Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Syd Arthur - On An On CD (album) cover

ON AN ON

Syd Arthur

Crossover Prog


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
obiter
PROG REVIEWER
5 stars Welcome to a wonderful world which some of us may have thought was lost only to be re-visited through the vinyl recesses of our collections.

From the first bars of First Difference you are transported to and wrapped in the warm optimistic Canterbury Scene of yore. But you are in an altogether modern environment. This has a distinctly contemporary edge. There's an undercurrent of jazz.

Edge of the Earth was a song I'd already come across on youtube. My favourite, this has an impelling rhythm, an edge, but it is the effortless changes of mood, the unstrained vocal which has such an impact. Love the drums. This is a must listen to track.

Ode to Summer I've already reviewed as an EP. The same beautiful synthesis of vocal, violin, bass and drums. Love the bass.

Dorothy: (there's an EP with studio and live). A slow understated jazz with almost lazy vocal style that reminds me of Stina Nordenstam (not the pitch though!).

Truth Seeker has a harder edge. Not typical at the start but again the effortless shifts in mood and rhythm stamp an unmistakable Syd Arthur seal on the track. I suppose that is one of the striking things about this band. Having only listened to 3 EPs and this album their sound is instantly recognisable. Formulaic this isn't.

Night shaped light features a stronger violin part. Again the changes and tight bass + guitar runs. For me there is a bit much. I found the guitar sound too distorted and muddy at the end. But then again I'm pretty sure that's exactly what was being sought.

Promised Me has a similar mix. Again the guitar is muddier as the song drives on. Then there is a break, the quiet melody on a radio.

Black Wave returns to the cleaner more open sound. There is control and balance. One of my favourites.

For a second as Moving World started I thought Michael Buble was about to cut in. That jazzy undertone is to the fore. But there is a folk story telling, a prog shifting of timing and mood. One of my favourites.

Paradise Lost. This has it all. At one point we have a distorted slow heavy beat with bass Geezer might have played. How did we get here? It's like Sabbath! Then a total breakdown, an ethereal passage more reminiscent of spacerock before the clean guitar brings us back. The vocals return with a delayed echo. Then back into an up beat staccato passage. Then break to a smooth rolling. reminiscent of classic yes. Classic prog.

You know you're hooked when you've listened to an album a dozen or so times and yet when it ends you find yourself going "what? no more?" replay and search the web for a few new snippets.

Simply a must have. Many will wait eagerly for the next offering. The worry is in an X-factor world of pop pap it takes proggers to support bands as such as this.

No hesitation: must have.

Report this review (#1078892)
Posted Tuesday, November 19, 2013 | Review Permalink
5 stars What a lovely and elegant blend of so many different genres! Most songs have a warm and estival feel to them which is made even more interesting with the heavy jazz chords played in the background. Syd Arthur were not only able to mix genres but they did it in a very catchy way. They didn't trade beauty for complexity, everything flows naturally.

"First Difference" is one my favorite tracks on the album. From the first few bars, you are immersed in this bright Canterbury prog mood while the sound remains modern and fresh.

"Edge of the Earth" is a cool track but I think it lacks the catchiness and impressive background details of other tracks.

"Ode to the Summer", what a fabulous track! It will please prog lovers and their grandmas alike. The verse is a syncopated 3/4 riff. The chorus is incredibly catchy and I particularly love the contrast between the catchy vocal lines and the jazz chords.

"Dorothy" is a mellower, slow paced song which heavily relies on guitar jazz chords. The chorus is extremely catchy as well where quite a good part of the orchestration relies on background vocals in harmony.

"Truth Seeker" is one of the songs I liked the least. I find it a bit chaotic. Although it calms down half way through it. Give it a listen, you might like it!

"Night Shaped Light" is an instrumental. One recurring theme is played on guitar and is somehow reminiscent of Tosin Abasi's playing. The main theme is driven by Raven Bush's violin. A great tune!

"Promise Me" is a bit dull in my humble opinion. I won't elaborate since I'm not a big fan.

"Black Wave" is a cool song. A bit darker than other songs on the album. Won't elaborate either.

"Moving World" is also darker than most songs on the album. I like how the chorus emerges from the verse in a cresendo fashion. It suits the lyrics pretty well. The chorus is very well orchestrated.

"Paradise Lost" brings us back to the brighter mood of earlier tracks in the album. It is also considerably longer than those tracks. It does a perfect closing piece in my opinion. It starts with heavy distorted guitar than moves to one of the main themes where each and every member of the band plays a considerable part. This part is probably the one that will keep you coming. After that, we have a more chaotic section which serves as a transition to a peaceful and spacey part where lyrics kick in. This spacey part evolves into an additional section which is more syncopated, reminds me of Gentle Giant and Spock's beard. The song ends with the main theme.

Overall, an excellent album from a very promising band. In my opinion, highlights are: First difference, Ode to the summer, Dorothy, Night shaped light and Paradise lost.

Report this review (#1185078)
Posted Thursday, June 5, 2014 | Review Permalink
apps79
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
3 stars Coming from Canterbury, claiming to play Progressive Rock and not having 70's local influences in your sound is pretty much impossible.Syd Arthur hail from Kent, led by four musicians, brothers Liam Magill (lead vocals, guitar, percussion, flute) and Joel Magill (bass, percussion, vocals) along with Raven Bush (mandolin, violin, percussion, piano, vocals) and drummer Fred Rother.They slowly built a cult fame directed by the release of no less than 3 EP's, ''Kingdoms of experience'' (2008), ''Willow tree'' (2010) and ''Moving world'' (2011), before they launched their first full-length album ''On and on'' during the summer of 2012.The album was recorded at Syd Arthur's Wicker Studios and released on their own Dawn Chorus label, handed in CD and a limited number of vinyl editions.

They sound quite close to ANTIQUE SEEKING NUNS, developing short tracks with a dense musicianship, where Pop sensibilities finally find some space next to nervous, jazzy interludes of the Canterbury scool of Fusion.''On and on'' comes actually as a mix of Prog, Psychedelic Rock, Jazz, Pop and Blues, but the adventurous workouts of the classic Canterbury scene are more than any of Syd Arthur's other influences.CARAVAN is the most appropriate comparison for this modern group, which builds its sound on some cool electric piano, plenty of violin moves and a happy rhythm section.Even Liam Magill's vocals seem like coming from the 70's, while he occasionally throws in some nice guitar bits, but his best contribution appears to be the clever mandolin shades in the bulk of the album's tracks.The music rarely becomes powerful, but when it does some moments of prog majesty are waiting in the corner.These guys seem to be fond of elaborate, finesse-styled musical textures with a flexible Fusion palette and indeed the result is usually quirky with the impressive violin tricks and the sound of piano being complemented by some inventive electric textures and a touch of acoustic crescendos.Only attempt on a longer composition, the 8-min. ''Paradise lost'' sounds like an amalgam of CARAVAN's career with ethereal passages, jazzy textures, proggy twists and a Post Rock vibe during the ambiental sceneries.

The spirit of Canterbury Prog will never be lost with bands like these.Modern material with beautiful vintage acoustics of the local area, wrapped in a mix of Prog, Jazz and Pop.Recommended.

Report this review (#1191846)
Posted Friday, June 13, 2014 | Review Permalink
4 stars While I'm waiting for Syd Arthur's second album, I've decided to return to listen their brilliant and promising debut LP and I have to say that is a great pleasure for me to find again such an exquisite sound into the 10 tracks of this album.

Maybe there's not totally original compositions here. In fact, there are lots of 60's and early 70's inffluences, proggy psychedelic instrumental sections, some early Yes stuff and even drops of Canterbury sounds (specially on "Dorothy", "Night Speed Light" and "Promise Me") but Syd Arthur has their own particular style that includes the constant presence of violin and acid guitar riffs which provides the music of hypnotic and changing rhythms and textures.

If you are looking for all those sounds into just one album SA has to be in your colection. Into this album you'll find really great and sometimes complex compositions, such as "Promise Me" and "Truth Seeker"; melodic retro songs as "First Difference" and "Dorothy", and an acid fusion of styles (including some hard blues guitar riffs) such as in "Ode to the Summer" and "Moving World".

Definitively an album with no weaknesses that it'll be a pleasure to 70's rock and prog fans and for all those who are looking for a mixture of retro and new sounds... 4.0*

Report this review (#1360733)
Posted Monday, February 2, 2015 | Review Permalink

SYD ARTHUR On An On ratings only


chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of SYD ARTHUR On An On


You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.