Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Public Foot The Roman - Public Foot The Roman CD (album) cover

PUBLIC FOOT THE ROMAN

Public Foot The Roman

Psychedelic/Space Rock


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
elsmallo@hotm
5 stars There is one good song and only that is good at the end. Nonetheless i an going to give it 5 stars because my dad was in it (dag small) and he was ultra cool. no seriously on the album sleeve there is a photo of him with cricket jumper, jacket and long long hair, actually the cover sleeve alone is worth 5 stars for its collection of vintage 1970's style, all looking like throwbacks to the neanderthal age. Actually 'Judas returns' is a cool song, but they are let down a little by the lead singer- if he had been good they would have been a good band as they were all very good individually. anyway now they have a review courtesy of me. Splendid.
Report this review (#32969)
Posted Sunday, February 20, 2005 | Review Permalink
camellos13@ao
4 stars Actually these guys just recorded one lp much to my dismay......Every song is just better than the previous one...well crafted vocal harmonies with nice guitar and keyboard riffs...I bought their Movies lps later on, but they never acchieved the PF the Roman sound...buy the lp if you find it...its just that good!!! p.s. dont think it has been released on cd yet....
Report this review (#32970)
Posted Wednesday, March 16, 2005 | Review Permalink
Progbear
PROG REVIEWER
3 stars Slightly obscure proto-prog band from Cambridge. There's little here to distinguish them from dozens of other similarly-intentioned acts from 1974, just another rock band with somewhat proggish leanings and a prominent organ player, but they do execute the style rather well.

"Decline and fall" and "Judas returns" are the tunes of greatest interest for prog listeners. Both are extended numbers with many changes, and strong organ work from Dag Small. Vocals by Sean Byrne are typically strong and melodic, and also very English. Some of the other tunes-like "When you lay it down" and "Don't bite the hand"-have slight proggish touches and "One (On my mind)" has a nice folkish feel, but for the most part this is straight, early 70's mainstream rock.

Report this review (#49888)
Posted Monday, October 3, 2005 | Review Permalink
bristolstc@ya
3 stars A little hard to review this one. They play with conviction, and the Wishbone Ash like twin guitar leads definitely catch the ear and are pleasant enough, but the end result is perhaps worthy of 3 and a half stars, but definitely not a great record. Nothing is bad here though, and if you like Pink Floyd and slight references to early Yes this is a pretty good attempt at spacey mainstream rock by good musicians who don't quite know how to write really great songs. And this is the dillema. Had the songs and lyrics been better on this album it would be a classic not just of the era, but of 70s prog tinged rock period. The problem is that the songs sound unfinished and the lyrics are not very good or intelligent, often too gloomy and derivative (especially of Floyd). Another set back is pleasant, but not great vocals. The harmonies are nice at times, a little grating at others because they start to sound like The Grateful Dead if they were Cambridge graduates instead of stoned hippies! The lead singer does a decent job, but hardly has a great voice. Even with these set backs, you can enjoy this album every once in awhile, but it isn't a knockout. Looking at the sleeve and intriguing titles you expect a prog classic, but instead you get a reasonably good rock album with some spacey progressive leanings. Theres's some great passages mixed in with the ones that take the easy way out, particularly the beginning and close of the album ("Land Owner" and "Decline And Fall"), but in between are some songs that don't quite work as well as they should. There is nothing bad here, and even though the singer isn't great he isn't bad very much of the time either. Perhaps if they'd been around longer or been able to devote more time to this album it would have been a minor classic. With a release both in the States and England perhaps things were expected to happen for Public Foot The Roman, but they didn't take off. If you can come across this for not too much money it's an enjoyable album and if you like Pink Floyd as I do some of it may be very enjoyable. I am not going to say this is a great record or a classic, but it's not bad at all either.
Report this review (#58565)
Posted Tuesday, November 29, 2005 | Review Permalink
5 stars I got this album by accident in the late 70's from my friend.He had found it in a locker room and gave it to me because he was not a friend of progressive music.Well, I loved it very much.Today I think this is the best record I've ever heard.Why?Great songs,great singing and playing.And I never get tired of it.It gets better and better the more I listen to it.I hope somebody would release a cd out of this.
Report this review (#93665)
Posted Saturday, October 7, 2006 | Review Permalink
Sean Trane
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR
Prog Folk
3 stars 3.5 stars really!!!

Sole album from this formation although their self-titled album bore a striking Hipgnosis artwork that could evoke Close encounter a few years before hand. This Cambridge combo derived their amusing name from road panels, much like a Canterbury band did that same year. A double guitar prog quintet where the vocals played a major role, and three member sang lead, while all of them contributed to choirs, PFTR had a fairly

Apart the atrocious radio-friendly opening track Land Owner (XXXX), , PFTR is still often sounding like those early 70?s UK proto-prog bands (not in PA?s definition or PR) and a prototype of future AOR that would overflow the airwaves later in the decade. Indeed the much superior When You Lay It Down is more in the organ driven hard prog mould (with a bit of Yes Album tinge) meeting Argus-like Wishbone Ash. While not quite as bad as the opener, King For A Day sounds like third rate Lynyrd (that country feel) meeting Wishbone, while the 6-mins Judas Return takes on a Yes turn, simply because the band takes its time to show more than basic song schemas.

The flipside is filled with more of the same (bat of course the opener) and the Yes and WA influences abound but are never overbearing either, because PFTR has its own sound as well. The organ-driven Don?t Bite The Hand is great moment of interplay, once past the fairly conventional song format. The following on My Mind might just be the catchiest track on the album, starting on acoustic arpeggios and remaining acoustic over triple vocal harmonies (Cressida?s better moments are also on my mind here). All is left is the 8-mins+ Decline And Fall, the Yesser track of the album and again plenty of time to mingle strings, keys and skins.

The band (half the band, actually) would then commit a strange suicide by getting rid of their original name and changing to a stupid one: the movies. They would go on to record a few albums under that moniker until the early 80?s, but I?ve never of the group or their albums. But getting back to PFTR, their album is certainly not anything essential or groundbreaking, but they stood in the pack of tens of dozens of valid bands that deserved more attention, but there was only so much space in the early 70?s sunlight. In other words if Wishbone ash had done Argus with keyboards and proggier and lesser D&D lyrics, it could?ve sounded like this

Report this review (#216524)
Posted Tuesday, May 19, 2009 | Review Permalink
b_olariu
PROG REVIEWER
3 stars 3.5 stars for sure

This british band with intresting and odd name in same time, must be considered one of the forgotten and unnoticed prog rock bands from first half of the '70. Nevertheless they were quite popular among students playing a lot in colleges in 71-73 when they even release their one and only album in 1973 selftitled. Well, what I heared here is pretty good from start to finish, imagine you listen to Wishbone Ash with keyboards, really good, twin guitar and melted with some fantastic keyboards passages. Aswell I like the voice of Dag Small, there were three vocalists singing in same time, but I thing Small's voice was the one who really impressed me. Pieces like When You Lay It Down or Judas return who really sounded to me like early Yes around The yes album combined with with Flash around In the can period 1972, maybe you can add Argus from Wishbone Ash aswell, really nice pieces for sure. Another goody is ending almost 9 min Decline And Fall with again yes flavour but in the end not a copy/paste band for sure. A worthy album in my opinion who didn't get the chance . 3.5 stars , I really kine it. Keyboards and guitars are working at full capacity here. Intresting as the name and odd aswell is the art work. They disbanded in 1975 and gone into oblivion but morphed a year later into The movies with a comercial pop rock sound who were aswell doomed for eternity when punk rock enterd on the scene and killed the chances of succes for countless bands from that period.

Report this review (#1706177)
Posted Thursday, March 30, 2017 | Review Permalink

PUBLIC FOOT THE ROMAN Public Foot The Roman ratings only


chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of PUBLIC FOOT THE ROMAN Public Foot The Roman


You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.