Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
PROG ARCHIVES intends to be the most complete and powerful progressive rock resource. You can find the progressive rock music discographies from 12,746 bands & artists, 80,676 albums (LP, CD and DVD), 2,159,448 ratings and reviews from 71,313 members who also participate in our active forum. You can also read the new visitors guide (forum page).

Latest Progressive Rock Music Reviews


Last 50 reviews
 Guruh Gipsy by GURUH GIPSY album cover Studio Album, 1977
4.14 | 53 ratings

BUY
Guruh Gipsy
Guruh Gipsy Eclectic Prog

Review by DetectiveDoom

4 stars What an unusual album this is! It is a mixture of ELP-inspired progressive rock and Balinese traditional music. Sometimes the blend is clumsy but most of the time it's excellent and worth your time.

The album was put together in the mid 1970s by Guruh Sukarnoputra, the son of Indonesia's first president Sukarno. He teamed up with members of the group Gipsy to do this one-off album.

It features vocalist/bassist Chrisye and brothers Gaury (guitar) and Keenan (drums) Nasution as well as the talented keyboardists Abadi Soesman and Roni Harahap. Chrisye became a solo star in Indonesia a few years after this album came out.,

The first track Indonesia Mahardikka blends the pomp of nationalist sentiments along with loads of Keith Emerson like synth leads! Gamelan and angklong surface from time to time but mainly it's the Western music that dominates the fusion on this 15 minute track. The guitar solo reminds me of Mick Rogers' playing on MMEB albums.

Another high point is Chopin Larung with its haunting mixture of Western classical piano and Eastern themes.

I also like the frenzied, often hard-rocking Geger Gelgel and Barong Gundah which sees the music get really complex as a deep bass groove interlocks with dynamic, almost confusing gamelan runs.

Indeed it's not easy listening and I get a bit bored when the Balinese orchestra dominates on Janger 1897 Saka and Smaradhana.

All told a fantastic album that should intrigue anyone with prog curiosity. It seems a pity Guruh gave up on music to focus on dance. He then entered parliament and served for over 20 years!

I rate it alongside Giant's Giant On The Move as Indonesia's best prog album.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Second Time Around by GHOST album cover Studio Album, 1992
4.00 | 13 ratings

BUY
Second Time Around
Ghost Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars 3.5 stars. GHOST were a six piece psychedelic/folk band from Japan who officially broke up in 2014. Their final live and studio albums were both released in 2007. An eight album run starting in 1990 with a consistent six piece lineup. While this is my least favourite of the four records I own by them, It's basically because this is the most straight up folk record of the four. It's almost like on this sophomore release they decided to get more serious and mature and as a result dropped the krautrock vibe from the debut, along with some of the gimmicks.

A 48 minute album, this was released in 1992 and features ten tracks. Vocals are male and in english. The song titles reveal that psychedelic spirit like "A Day Of Stoned Sunshine In The Union Zoo" which is where the album cover comes in. My favourite track is the longest "Orange Sunshine" at over 7 1/2 minutes. "Mind Hill" the closer is another psyche title. The opener "People Get Freedom" is the shortest at under 2 minutes and it's ethnic sounding and sparse before we get the title track and music that is more to my liking.

I just like their "sound" and spirit. A "live and let live" attitude embracing the spiritual. Psychedelic sunshine my friends. I'm bumping this one up as I truly enjoyed this one, despite feeling they did much better later on. While it never seems like I'm listening to a six piece band, I appreciate the flavours that are brought to the table, especially the flute. Great band!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Illuminate the Path by AN ABSTRACT ILLUSION album cover Studio Album, 2016
4.86 | 5 ratings

BUY
Illuminate the Path
An Abstract Illusion Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by Prog/Land

5 stars Breathe Create Beauty - This is a strong introductory track, definitely sets the vibe for the album to come. It's an excellent opener as a short but well written piece. It feels triumphant and reflective, ducking me in and making me want to hear more.

Abode of a God - The intro riff is awesome, and that bass line is super cool. Throughout the song, the orchestration and piano feels very tasteful. They add to the riffs without taking up too much space. Additionally, the vocals are on point; they are a perfect mix of understandable and gravely. All of the arpeggio riffs are well composed, not feeling needlessly complex with interesting harmonies happening underneath. The clean vocals are pretty good as well. My only nitpick is that the whole song is constructed around almost exclusively arpeggio riffs, and although they're good I found myself somewhat wishing there was more variety.

Drop This Planet of Dust - I really appreciate the super heavy opening riff, and the keyboard solo shortly after is really fun. I think this whole intro shows that An Abstract Illusion knows exactly what kind of sound they want to cultivate. This whole song just feels good. I appreciate how concise it is; the sections flow together very well. It is all complemented nicely by a great vocal performance, both growls and cleans. I think the song is a great mix of heaviness and atmosphere.

Illuminate the Path - It has a pretty slow intro, but I enjoy it. It builds into a great verse section. I think it isn't quite as immediately compelling as the other two full tracks so far, but its riffs are still very strong. I am surprised how unique each riff feels. I mean, all the riffs feel distinct enough that I think I could easily identify which one came from what song. I'm a big fan of the use of keyboards on this song. Finally, this song has a perfectly proggy outro, one worthy of the progressive death metal label. Also, I can't get over that bass tone, it fits so well.

Vakuum - I think the intro to this track has the first real guitar solo of the album, and it shreds. I think this one feels like the best demonstration so far of just how skilled all these musicians are. They are clearly putting a lot of intention into the structures of their songs. Almost every section hits perfectly and never sounds exactly like how you would expect it to, in the best way. The slow break in the middle wasn't my favorite, but I do appreciate as a whole how they are balancing the intensity of the album. As with the rest of the album so far, I did not predict where it was going. The epic outro with orchestra hits also caught me completely by surprise.

Talvatis - Definitely a major vibe shift. This song sounds like it could be off of a Porcupine Tree record, but I think it is very effective as an interlude track before the real epic comes next.

Skeletons of Light - Once again, a great use of keyboards on the intro. The trading solos about a third of the way through the song are all incredible. It doesn't feel like soloing just for the sake of it, but rather like each solo and ensuing section was really vital to the larger narrative of the piece. I've said it about other songs on this album, but it just flows together very well. It sounds like we're walking through a dark forest, on our way off to war, but with our loved ones at our sides. Or something. This to me feels like the true end of the album, and the final bits of this song support this idea. It is just so triumphant, there is really no better way to describe the final riffs.

That's the album, plus the fun cover at the end. Overall, this was a real treat to listen to. There was not a single dull moment, and every scream, solo, and breakdown felt completely earned. Ultimately, this is really good music, not much beyond that I can say. 8.5/10

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 This Room Has No Doors by I HEARD FROM LAVINIA album cover Studio Album, 2022
4.02 | 9 ratings

BUY
This Room Has No Doors
I Heard From Lavinia Crossover Prog

Review by Finnforest
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars Hugely Promising Debut

I Heard From Lavinia is the unusual moniker of a young singer-songwriter from Milan by name of Lavinia Giancaspero. Milan certainly seems a vibrant scene these days! The debut album is described by the artist as follows: "This Room Has No Doors is a concept album that sees love addiction as its central theme, that emotional state on the border between love and obsession that can lead one person to love the other in a totally unconditional and toxic way, regardless of any kind of abuse suffered on the part of the partner, establishing a real addiction to them. In the course of the songs we find moments in which the protagonist recognizes the harmfulness of the relationship and others in which she expresses her feelings towards her beloved. On the one hand there is a great craving for closeness, and on the other there's fear and desire of detachment from a clearly destructive situation. The empty room, with no way out, therefore becomes a metaphor for the mind and obsessive thoughts that cannot be controlled and from which it's impossible to escape." Heavy stuff.

When I first heard Lavinia, I was initially most reminded of Fiona Apple. Vocally, somewhat, but also in terms of her eclectic songwriting, the attitude, the mix of playing styles, and the darker shade of emotional atmospheres. Like Apple, she has a truly unique style and range with songs that leave you feeling slightly off-kilter or ungrounded, uneasy. "Prelude" is a haunting opener to the album with a cinematic sparseness that cues you to be ready for something big coming. It drops into "Funny" and, again, I'm reminded of the early tracks from Apple with similar lyrical notions ("It's so funny, but I'm not laughing at all") to high-end technical grooves as we heard from the likes of Jon Brion and Matt Chamberlain on Tidal. Here I believe it is Santi Banks who is Lavinia's primary sound collaborator. "Funny" is slow and sultry and just a bit of jazziness, and everyone in the band just smokes in a most tasteful manner. The arrangements and sound quality are similarly top notch.

"If we're going to drown in the abyss, shall we dance anyway?"

"Persistence" is a straight-up perfect piece of poetry delivered beautifully against competing sinewy, vibrant guitar leads and then swelling strings, an emotional powerhouse of a song. "Oblivion" is no less lyrically dramatic, but the music shifts to a catchy, almost Garbage/Shirley Manson type hard electronica vibe. The final three tracks shift down a gear. "Skeletons" and "Old Pictures" both feature slow-burn piano storytelling, gorgeous and always a tug on my heart. She stacks her vocal atop each other on "Old Pictures," self-harmonies that are truly ear candy. "Sinewave" also features slow piano but with a big wave of Insurgentes sounding swell rushing up the middle. (I believe she is a Wilson fan.) Sometimes debut albums have a hard-to-define flavor that comes from that indescribable springtime of youth, with its limitless artistic enthusiasms, and/or from just old-fashioned beginner's luck. Tidal was one. The Kick Inside. Song to a Seagull. This album may or may not be as good as such classics---I would say not quite, frankly, but that's for your taste to decide---and yet it is very much a great debut that enchants in a way that will make you sit up and notice. As of this writing, a CD version is still available on her Bandcamp page, and it features lovely artwork to boot.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Welcome to the Planet by BIG BIG TRAIN album cover Studio Album, 2022
4.02 | 229 ratings

BUY
Welcome to the Planet
Big Big Train Crossover Prog

Review by fuxi
Prog Reviewer

3 stars When this album first appeared, its cover art filled me with trepidation. COMMON GROUND had looked bad enough, and now Big Big Train seemed to have gone the whole hog, using pure mid-1970s Jehovah's Witnesses ('The Watchtower') style.

As for the music... I still have mixed feelings about it. If anything, WELCOME TO THE PLANET reminds me of such latter-day Caravan albums as BETTER BY FAR, by which I mean: the band's most innovative soloists having flown the coop, there still is space for one or two haunting and quite a few inconsequential songs (in Caravan's case, I consider 'Nightmare' first-rate), and there may even be one or two instrumentals (once again, with Caravan I really appreciated 'The Last Unicorn').

So what have we here, exactly? 'Made from Sunshine' seems to be BBT's equivalent of Stevie Wonder's 'Isn't She Lovely', while 'The Connection Plan' sounds like angst-ridden, violin-driven, mid-seventies 10cc-style 'soft rock'. Matters improve with 'Lanterna', which is a charming ballad with splendid vocal harmonies, and with the touching 'Capitoline Venus', which mainly consists of acoustic 12-string, mellotron and David Longdon's lead vocal. 'A Room With No Ceiling' isn't bad either: a quirky, bass-driven instrumental which turns into a little march that reminds me of National Health. On 'Proper Jack Foster', Longdon's voice sound warmer and more soothing than I'd ever heard before - which makes it all the more sad that this was to be his last studio recording with the band. 'Bats in the Belfry' is a lively instrumental that somehow reminds me of the Who's 'Sparks' (a.k.a. 'Underture'). 'Oak and Stone' is yet another nostalgic ballad with lovely vocal harmonies and very lush mellotron - but then - my goodness what just happened? - Carly Bryant's title track is an out-and-out scary song (about childlessness, it seems); it ends the album on a deep sigh.

Taken all together, I'd say WELCOME TO THE PLANET is an O.K. product which can't hold a candle to earlier and far more ambitious BBT albums like ENGLISH ELECTRIC (parts 1 & 2) or FOLKLORE. One wonders what direction the band might have taken if only David Longdon (and perhaps Carly Bryant as well) had been available for future releases...

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Omni by KARFAGEN album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.24 | 98 ratings

BUY
Omni
Karfagen Symphonic Prog

Review by Benny-Ptaha

5 stars KARFAGEN - OMNI (2025)

Review by Roman Gorielov (https://linktr.ee/romangorielov)

What can I say... Here is Antony Kalugin's new album, OMNI (2025). Let's listen - and think.

The album cover sets the mood instantly. Its central triangular figure evokes classic prog imagery - clean, symbolic, and unmistakably rooted in the genre's visual heritage. A simple yet effective design that prepares the listener for a conceptually rich experience.

Track-by-Track Impressions:

1. Omni Overture

The album opens with a grand overture that establishes the mood and outlines the journey ahead. It's cinematic and purposeful - an invitation into the world of OMNI.

2. Storyteller (Part 1)

And then - Richard Sinclair starts singing. Yes, that Richard Sinclair (Caravan, Camel). His voice is instantly recognizable, warm, and melodic, creating a powerful link between the golden age of prog and the modern scene. A wonderful, unexpected gift to longtime fans.

3. Whispers from the Past

Antony and Olha share vocal duties here. The chorus is emotionally profound - what I like to call "global music" - music that resonates deeply and universally. A strong and memorable piece.

4. The Spark

Per Malmberg brings a fresh dynamic to the album's progression. The arrangement is detailed yet clear, with excellent instrumental interplay and precise mixing. A vibrant track full of musical "events", yet never overwhelming.

5. Masterplan

No pause - this track flows directly from the last. Antony sings in his signature "conversational" style. The refrain - "Masterplan? Masterplan?" - is hypnotic. A sharp guitar riff gives way to soft chords and a delicate keyboard solo. The slower section is smooth, melodic, and memorable.

6. Mirror of Souls

A majestic instrumental that begins with a piercing, melodic grace. And yes - that's John Hackett on flute. A gift of a performance.

7. Unchained

A solemn opening gives way to Jean Pageau's rich vocals. The dramatic guitar lines are measured and impactful. The track builds into something monumental before transitioning, surprisingly and beautifully, into a lush melodic section. A highlight of the album.

8. The Cards We Play

Things only get better. The melody soars, and Marco Glühmann's voice enters - instantly gripping. The verse builds intensity, supported by expressive basslines, and then comes the chorus: unforgettable, catchy, and emotionally resonant. You'll find yourself humming it in the kitchen :) One of Antony's finest compositional achievements, and Marco delivers it with brilliance!

9. You and I

Bartosz Kossowicz adds a new emotional color with his distinctive vocals. A sleek, stylish track that adds depth and dimension to the album's soundscape.

10. Storyteller (Part 2)

The finale. Richard Sinclair and Antony Kalugin return for a beautifully lyrical duet that feels like a warm farewell. It's optimistic, reflective, and forward-looking - a calm and confident closing chapter. The mood is elevated, encouraging thoughts of discovery and new horizons.

Final Thoughts:

At just 45 minutes, OMNI manages to take listeners on a remarkably expansive journey. Its blend of rich melodies, conceptual depth, and diverse vocal talent creates something both classic and contemporary.

Antony Kalugin has crafted more than an album - he's built a bridge. OMNI connects the art rock traditions of the 1970s with the textures and sensibilities of modern neo-prog, without remaining static in either realm. It flows, shifts, and evolves - showing all the beauty of prog and the enduring power of music to move and inspire.

Rating: 5/5

A must-listen for prog fans old and new. If you love melody, craftsmanship, and thoughtful arrangements - this is for you.

P.S. A round of applause for all the instrumentalists - professional, driving, and tasteful throughout. A phenomenal collective effort.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Maestro by MAGIC PIE album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.18 | 30 ratings

BUY
Maestro
Magic Pie Symphonic Prog

Review by yarstruly

5 stars I am excited by the album I am about to listen to for the first time today, Magic Pie's new album "Maestro". Kim Stenberg and company last released an album back in 2019, so we are quite ready to delve into some new musical adventures from them.

Disclosure for transparency. After posting my Spotlight on Magic Pie 2 months ago in March of 2025 (Which I will post below the review), Anne-Claire of BadDog productions reached out to me to review and feature some of her artists, but there is no compensation outside of digital files of the music for review purposes, and I choose what I want to write about, and express my opinions freely. I am free to post about any artist, regardless of whether they are represented by her or not.

With that out of the way, let's get a taste of some new Magic Pie! (As usual, this is a cold listen, with the exception of Everyday Hero, which I have heard once.)

Here is the line-up for this outing:

- Kim Stenberg / guitars, vocals - Lars Petter Holstad / bass, vocals - Eirikur Hauksson / lead vocals - Martin Utby / drums - Eirik Hanssen / vocals - Erling Henanger / keyboards, vocals

This is the same lineup as the 2019 album, with the exception of Utby taking over on drums from Jan Johannessen.

Track 1 - Opus Imperfectus Pt. 1, The Missing Chord

Yay! We jump right in with an 18:29 epic. (The album ends with the much shorter Part 2 of this song.) We begin with a low drone, and brass instruments and some subtle cymbal taps. Do we have a full orchestra here? String sounds join in as well, joined by harmony vocals in a choir like manner. A crescendo brings the full band in shortly after the one-minute mark. They play a glorious introduction with some great drum fills from Martin Utby. I believe they are establishing a theme that we will return to throughout the track. There is an amazing unison run on guitar and keys at around the two minute mark. A cool odd-meter groove begins around 2:15. Great piano at around 3 minutes. We go back to a moderately slow 4-4 at around 3:30. Some more lovely piano playing at around 4:00 leads in the vocals for the first time which begin at around 4:15. I love how prog intros often outlast entire standard songs! The first verse has acoustic strumming with 4 on the floor bass drumbeats. Gradually more instruments enter, along with vocal harmonies. The style is best described as such: if Dream Theater, Spock's Beard and the Flower Kings each represent points of a triangle, Magic Pie is in the center of the triangle. There is a nice instrumental turn around between verses at around 5:30. At about the 7-minute point, the tempo slows down and there is a brief instrumental feature. That leads to a very quiet section with vocals and string sounds (perhaps mellotron). The keys continue as Stenberg's guitar takes the spotlight with long sustained chords. The band kicks in heavier at around 8:45. There is a cool siren effect that brings the vocals back in. Eirikur Hauksson has a powerful and slightly gruff tone; he carries the melody well. I like the heavy riff in this section. Cool accent at around 10:10. A new groove begins around 10:45. It gets a bit jazzy, with an electric piano solo. Utby and Holstad keep a tight rhythm for the soloists, as Stenberg returns on guitar. Nice shredding at 13:30 as the groove begins to rock out again. By 14:50 we are getting seriously proggy, and getting a bit more into the DT part of the triangle. Don't get me wrong, everything is pure Magic Pie magic, but I am just providing a point of comparison. In the section around 16 minutes and beyond, there are deep, rich, harmony vocals that remind me of a men's choir. The key changes on the final vocal harmony chord, and synth tones fade out, bringing the amazing opening epic to a close.

Track 2 - By the Smoker's Pole

A few sustained guitar notes begin the song, and the lead vocals soon join in with accompaniment from electric guitar and electric piano each making use of a tremolo effect. Very bluesy at the beginning. More instruments, including bass enter at around 1 minute for the second verse. Nice harmonies around 1:20. They return around 1:50. The drums kick in around the 2-minute mark, but only briefly. They kick back in heavier at 2:45. A melodic guitar solo follows. Nice choir-like effect on the keys! Amazing scale runs at around 3:45. Sustained notes close out this relatively short track. Nice song!

Track 3- Name It to Tame It

This one is a bit longer at 7:10. This starts right out with the full band rockin'! Excellent solo from Stenberg. This one is giving me Deep Purple vibes. Great guitar fills between phrases. Henanger also gives us some fill on the keys. This one rocks hard! Until about 2:40 when it suddenly gets quieter and the keys are featured over a tricky groove. Harmony vocals take over on top of the same groove. We get heavy again at around 3:25. A keyboard solo happens around 3:45, followed by a shredding guitar solo from Stenberg. The riff at 4:20 is awesome! Lots of energy in this one! After a bridge, Stenberg continues his guitar masterclass. What a rocker! Great track!! File this one under heavy prog!

Track 4 - Kiddo?

This is by far the shortest track at only 2:12. It begins with a slow fade-in of wind effects. Keys join, then an acoustic guitar starts strumming along with flute-like sounds. The vocals enter at around the 1-minute mark asking, "Who are you kiddo?". Beautiful harmonies around 1:25. This seems to be warning young people to be wary of "multi- media influencers". Nice short track that leads to?

Track 5 - Someone Else's Wannabe

This is the second longest track at around seven and a half minutes. We begin with a power chord then a swirling keyboard part. More power chords lead to harmony vocals. A very complex run at around 20 seconds leads to a new section. What a dynamic intro! Around the 1-minute mark the first verse begins. Cool groove at around 1:30! Then amazing, panned left and right backing vocals that seem to float above the music somehow! I love the turnaround parts between verses. This is another high-energy song! I am loving this. There is a quieter bridge to give some contrast. This is followed by a smokin' organ solo! Then he switches to synth for some odd-meter prog- tastic playing with Stenberg on guitar. Another quiet section follows as we approach the 5-minute mark. There is a spoken voice saying something I can't make out in the background. Maybe a band member might be kind enough to shed a little light on that? Another spectacular guitar solo follows. Then a closing chorus followed by a keyboard part that fades the song to a close.

Track 6 - Everyday Hero

As the lead-off single, this is the one track I have previously heard. The intro reminds me of "Desperate Times" from Kansas' "Freaks of Nature" album. The vocals come in soon after. This one has a feel somewhere between classic hard rock and 80s commercial metal. Fantastic, stacked harmonies in the pre-chorus. The vocals at 2:10 have a new-wave vibe. I can pick-up some Styx in there too! Stenberg continues to dazzle on guitar as does Henanger on the keys. I just figured out why I keep getting Deep Purple vibes too?Hauksson's voice reminds me a little of Ian Gillan. Superb guitar tag at the end! Another great track!

Track 7 - Opus Imperfectus Pt. 2?Maestro

And we close the album by returning to the last 4:17 of the opening epic. Echoey sustained guitar notes lead the vocals in. More great harmony singing at around 30 seconds and a drum fill leads the rest of the band in. The lyrics "Maestro, your masterpiece remains your legacy for future generations, for all time!" seem quite appropriate here, as Magic Pie have delivered an amazing album, that might even be their best one yet! And I have enjoyed every album they have put out up to this point. The arrangement of this song is incredible. Stenberg needs more recognition as a top-notch guitarist! He continues to impress, as does the rest of the band. I love the harmonized guitar parts with the big half time feel as we reach the close, they land on a minor chord after the triumphant major key segment, and keyboard parts close the album out. Wow, what an amazing finale to an incredible album.

OVERALL IMPRESSIONS:

As I mentioned above, Magic Pie have delivered a masterpiece that shows them worthy of being mentioned alongside fellow Scandinavians The Flower Kings, as one of the great modern prog bands! I loved every moment of this album. I would be remiss if I did not mention Jacob Holm-Lupo's masterful mix-job, well done! If you enjoy a hard rock edge to your prog, I recommend checking this album out without reservation; I'll even encourage it. 2025 is a great year so far to be a prog fan, with so many major releases. But definitely make sure this one is on your list to buy or stream! This is an easy 5 out of 5 stars.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Electric Light Orchestra [Aka: No Answer] by ELECTRIC LIGHT ORCHESTRA album cover Studio Album, 1971
3.64 | 324 ratings

BUY
Electric Light Orchestra [Aka: No Answer]
Electric Light Orchestra Crossover Prog

Review by Lobster77

4 stars The Electric Light Orchestra found much success in the seventies with their unique combination of pop and classical music, augmented by a dominant string section. Jeff Lynne soon became the driving force of the band, but ELO actually started as Lynne and Roy Wood's creation an offshoot of The Move (which was still in action at the time); the latter left soon after this debut.

Wood, who seems to be able to play every instrument available, and Lynne, share credits and singing here, while the strings are very raw, the cellos constantly chopping and hacking, giving the impression of string-laden lumberjacks, but they have quite a dramatic and fascinating presence, and it also helps that some of the material, particularly Wood's, is very melodious; his "Look At Me Now" and the wonderful instrumental "1st Movement" are two of ELO's best songs of all, while Lynne's opening "10538 Overture" is also a classic. However, it does have uneven moments - "Battle Of Marston Moor" works in places, but not as a whole, and the record loses its unique flavour a bit on side two, which is somewhat more perfunctionary, although Wood's concluding "Whisper In The Night" is quite lovely.

All the same, this is one of the more fascinating and revolutionary debuts around, and well worth pursuing, but from here on in, Lynne took control, and with a few more changes to come, found much fame with many successful releases, featuring a much more streamlined approach, and none sound quite like this.

4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Mirage by SCHULZE, KLAUS album cover Studio Album, 1977
4.27 | 391 ratings

BUY
Mirage
Klaus Schulze Progressive Electronic

Review by Lobster77

4 stars Considering I associate mirages with blistering hot climates (deserts etc.), it was a surprise to me that the second album I tried from Klaus Schulze ended up being one of the coldest albums I've ever heard. Composed of just two tracks - both nearly thirty minutes long - "Mirage" feels like the soundtrack to a journey through some sort of digitalized winter landscape, and not one of those happy 'Winter Wonderland' types either. These soundscapes are the polar (ha) opposite of inviting. Instead, they're chilling and ruthless, and despite being texturally dense, still evoke a sense of desolation in all of their mechanical glory.

While I do want to summarize the overall atmosphere of "Mirage" as I've just done, I should also point out that it is not just an hour long trudge through unpleasant synthesizer passages. The first six minutes of the second track consist of little more than several layers of cascading synthesizers, but are they gorgeous. The track evolves further from there, but this first movement, entitled 'Xylotones', truly captivated me and is easily the album's best moment.

It feels like a bit of a boneheaded move to listen to this as the winter fades and spring approaches, but I still felt enveloped by the wintry mood that "Mirage" creates despite listening in the midst a shift away from the season it's meant to portray. I probably would have gotten more out of the experience had I given it a try at a more fitting time of year. Still, if it can make me feel like there's 3 feet snow on the ground when in reality there isn't even a puddle, then it's certainly accomplished something.

4.5 Klause Shulze was definitely one of the fathers of electronic prog.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ghede Chokra's by SHARKMOVE album cover Studio Album, 1970
3.54 | 24 ratings

BUY
Ghede Chokra's
Sharkmove Symphonic Prog

Review by DetectiveDoom

2 stars The Indonesian prog scene of the 1970s does have some bands and albums worth checking out. I think Giant Step's Giant On The Move and Guruh Gipsy's self-titled album are probably the best, and there are also some other good albums by Abbhama and God Bless.

Before all that came Shark Move, who released this record in 1970. Its main songwriter Benny Soebardja was also to lead Giant Step later.

Shark Move's sole album is very raw and unique, yet I think it's a fantastic time capsule. The category may say symphonic prog, but this is clearly heavy psychedelic rock with a lot of fuzz guitar from Benny and great organ playing from Soman Loebis.

It does take some patience though. The downside is that the album was poorly recorded and has a demo feel. It sounds poorly mixed at times and there are issues with the drum sound and other things like broken English and occasionally offkey vocals. It also has three songs in English and four more straightforward ballads in Bahasa Indonesia.

Despite all this, it begins with a wonderful song called My Life. Careening along for nearly nine minutes through guitar freakouts and organ breaks and some tasteful flute, it has a lovely melody and plaintive existential lyrics.

The next best song is Evil War, which captures the anti-Vietnam War feel, and has some great keyboard. However the second half of the album is a bit dull because it has three ballads in a row.

Aside from the album being in two languages, another thing that makes it schizophrenic is that there are five different lead singers on the seven songs, as Benny and Soman alternate with bassist/flute player Janto Diablo, drummer Sammy Zakaria and manager Bhagu Ramchand!

So I don't quite know what to say. It sounds like I am not recommending it highly, but I really do think the high points are worth an investigation.

Maybe you should listen to the more polished Giant Step first and then come for this. Or at least track down just the song My Life to get an idea of what's in store.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Shazam by MOVE, THE album cover Studio Album, 1970
3.65 | 70 ratings

BUY
Shazam
The Move Proto-Prog

Review by Lobster77

4 stars This album has some really fantastic moments when it flirts with other genres, like the rising proto-metal opening riff of "Hello Susie", the classically influenced, quasi-Genesis-esque second half of "Cherry Blossom Clinic Revisited" and the sublime raga rock that overtakes the final few minutes of "Fields of People" (which bears a slight resemblance to the coda of "Baba O'Riley" to my ears). I also like the idea of the little snatches of conversation that punctuate the album, since they give the album a semblance of self-awareness that differentiates it from how most progressive rock bands of this era approached their music. All that said, there's just not quite goodness here for me to consider it a classic - more specifically, there are two real clunkers here in the form of "Beautiful Daughter", which is half as long as the second shortest song here yet somehow feels longer than every other song except the disc's other misfire, the shambling blues of "Don't Make My Baby Blue", which at times sounds like the vocals were imported from a completely different song.

4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Move by MOVE, THE album cover Studio Album, 1968
3.21 | 42 ratings

BUY
Move
The Move Proto-Prog

Review by Lobster77

3 stars The Move are well known for having had Jeff Lynne in their ranks but he would not join the band until after their second album. In fact, they would get considerably heavier and more rock oriented moving forward, which I wouldn't expect from Mr. Lynne due to his more pop oriented work with ELO after he left The Move. Anyway, this is good. I find it to be slightly overrated though, especially considering the people who have decided to call this a lost psych pop classic. It is mostly in a pop/rock vein with some psych and baroque influences, especially in the B-side. The A-side is decidedly less psychedelic and sounds a lot more like beat music to my ears, a sound that was about 2 years past it's sell by date at this point. Some of the A-side reminds me of what the Who were doing in 66/67. Anyway, I like most of this but I think it would be woeful to call this a psych pop masterpiece.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Dark Side of the Moon by DREAM THEATER album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2006
3.35 | 145 ratings

BUY
Dark Side of the Moon
Dream Theater Progressive Metal

Review by VianaProghead
Prog Reviewer

3 stars Review Nē 894

"Dark Side Of The Moon" is an EP of Dream Theater and was released in 2006. It's a cover album made by Dream Theater about the original album, "Dark Side Of The Moon" by Pink Floyd that was released in 1973. As with many Dream Theater's releases, some extras have been packed into this album to add value to it. So, a selection of bonus live performances has been added to it. All are Pink Floyd's covers that the band has performed in several live shows.

As we know it's usual Dream Theater perform on their live shows many songs from many of their favourite prog rock bands. As a way of providing something different and special to their fans, Dream Theater began a series of live covers shows in 2002. Usually, the band performed two nights in the same city, and dedicated part of their second show to cover entirely classic albums. With the advent of their official bootleg label, some of these live performances have been immortalized on albums, like "The Number Of The Beast" of Iron Maiden, "Master Of Puppets" of Metallica, "Dark Side Of The Moon" of Pink Floyd, "Made In Japan" of Deep Purple and "Larks Tongues In Aspic, Pt. 2" of King Crimson.

The EP "Dark Side Of The Moon" is divided into CD 1 and CD 2. CD 1 has the entire live version of the original album. It showcases the band's 25 October 2005 Pink Floyd's "Dark Side Of The Moon" album, performed in its entirety at the Hammersmith Apollo in London, England. CD 2 has seven tracks: "Echoes Pt. 1", "One Of These Days", "Sheep", "In The Flesh", "Rune Like Hell", "Hey You" and "Comfortably Numb". "Echoes Pt. 1" is from "Meddle". It was recorded at the Tower Theater in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania on 2 April 2004. "One Of These Days" is also from "Meddle". It was recorded in Rotterdam, Nederlands on 18 January 2004. "Sheep" is from "Animals". It was recorded in Los Angeles, California on 9 March 2006. "In The Flesh" is from "The Wall". It was recorded in Berlin on 26 February 1995. "Rune Like Hell" is also from "The Wall". It was recorded in Poughkeepsie, New York on 30 December 1998. "Hey You" is also from "The Wall". It was recorded in Paris, France on 25 June 1998. "Comfortably Numb" is also from "The Wall". It's a special version because it was performed with Queensryche. In 2003 Dream Theater worked with Queensryche on a lengthy summer tour. So, this is a version with two singers, three guitarists, a keyboardist, two bass players and two drummers.

Not much needs to be said about "Dark Side Of The Moon". It's a landmark album of Pink Floyd and a landmark of the progressive rock music too. It's one of the best prog selling releases of all time and it's also one of the most influential albums of one of the most influential progressive rock bands in the world. It belongs to the famous trilogy of Pink Floyd albums with "Dark Side Of The Moon", "Wish You Were Here" and "Animals" which are generally recognised as some of the best progressive albums ever made. It's also because Pink Floyd is one of the most famous and respected progressive rock bands in the world beyond the universe of the progressive rock music. Everybody has heard of them.

This is probably the best album of their official bootleg cover series. The band seamlessly and almost effortlessly transitioned from track to track as if they had written the album themselves, and no less, in a real live setting. It truly showcases the band's appreciation and admiration for such a classic album of one of the best prog classic bands ever. They do not foist the solos, tempos, or intricacies that made this album what it really is. The band restrains and plays the album virtually note by note, fill for fill, tempo for tempo. Labrie does a surprisingly stellar job. The vocal lines seem to be perfect for his range. However, Labrie's performance ultimately is what keeps this from being a perfect cover, although it's more than enough, as his overall performance is one of his best I've ever heard. The slide guitar parts in "Speak To Me/Breathe" are provided by Jordan Rudess on his keyboards, maintaining their original luster. His solos in "Any Colour You Like" are also phenomenal. The vocal solo for "The Great Gig In The Sky", as well as backing vocal parts for other songs, was perfectly done by Theresa Thomason. Her stunning replication of this powerful aria sends shivers down my spine, as will the crowd's response to her. She received, literally, the loudest ovation on the entire show. On "Money" and in other parts, the saxophone of Norbert Stachel adds a bit of nostalgia to the final mix.

Conclusion: This Dream Theater's version of "Dark Side Of The Moon" is amazing. The band is faithful to Pink Floyd's original vision, holding back from the kind of instrumental virtuosity that typifies their original material. The band is joined by the guest vocalist Theresa Thomason on "The Great Gig In The Sky" and the saxophone of Norbert Stachel on "Money" and "Us And Them", who substituted Clare Torry and Dick Parry on the original version. Additionally, the extra live performances on CD 2 are also excellent and complete this album. Dream Theater can't be accused of never giving their fans as much as possible. As an official bootleg, the sound quality is excellent and proves that Dream Theater has ensured that their fans are able to witness some of the most unique performances the band had to offer. So, this is an enjoyable release that should be interesting to Pink Floyd's fans and as well Dream Theater's fan base.

Prog is my Ferrari. Jem Godfrey (Frost*)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Pink Floyd at Pompeii - MCMLXXII (2025 Mix) by PINK FLOYD album cover Live, 2025
4.42 | 17 ratings

BUY
Pink Floyd at Pompeii - MCMLXXII (2025 Mix)
Pink Floyd Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by alainPP

4 stars Pink Floyd mixed by Steven Wilson, the prog mastermind who reveres them as much as his own musical DNA. The ultimate version of unbridled experimental rock from Floyd's psychedelic heyday. Dialogue and other interviews have been removed to delve deeper into the musical crater. The film's restoration is handled by Lana Topham, resulting in a striking visual.

'Pompeii Intro' with a stronger, Wilsonian vibe, I would say, is definitely a Steven mix. 'Echoes - Part 1' from 1971, the two-part 'meddle' with its nightclub vibe around the 8-minute mark, and a souvenir from my cousin, Pink, is also a memory box. 'Careful With That Axe, Eugene' for the ultimate apocalyptic psychedelic surge, the clear, pervasive sound; purists will feel like they're hearing a new album, while fans will note the perfection of the original sound. 'A Saucerful of Secrets' for the famous views of the volcano, the flow of living lava against a backdrop of Nick's eruptive pads, with the piano seeming out of tune and the guitar mimicking a plane in distress. The final Olympian, Pompeian ascent.

'One of These Days' and the check of the mix work with the drums in front, behind, and on the sides, accompanying the keyboard above and below, the perfect omniphonic joy. 'Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun' and the second personal memory, my essay in French with a teacher who let loose a bit by revealing herself, proposing the album as a dissertation topic. The opportunity to regress to Atmos 45 years later with this track as oriental as possible. 'Mademoiselle Nobs' as an interlude ā la 'Seamus' with canine blues to settle down before returning to 'Echoes - Part 2' and its crows and sinister atmosphere; It's on these more psychedelic, soaring tracks that we truly appreciate the instrumental purity.

Note three alternative and unedited tracks on the CD and vinyl editions: 'Careful With That Axe, Eugene' in a more explosive mode, 'A Saucerful of Secrets' in an experimental extension mode, and 'Echoes - Part 1' in a potential radio edit, just to dream a little more.

A pure moment of regressive nostalgia that would make you want to upgrade to a proper stereo system to appreciate current musical technologies, erasing the blur and the breath of recording to retain only the spirit of the musicians in action. A testament to today's youth.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Rogue by GLASS HAMMER album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.89 | 27 ratings

BUY
Rogue
Glass Hammer Symphonic Prog

Review by Rysiek P.

5 stars

I assume that you were waiting for the latest album by Glass Hammer in some way. Why do I assume? Although sometimes we say sarcastically that what can old hands do, what can they surprise us with, that it will probably be the same again... however (and please admit it to yourself) when such an album appears, we reach for it somewhere in the privacy of our homes to really convince ourselves whether it is as we expected, or whether there is something exceptional, surprising, some breathtaking novelty among the new songs.

You can like Glass Hammer, you can dislike them, but one statement cannot be disputed: they are, without a doubt, a legend of progressive rock in the American version. Although, in fact, a better description would be to say that they are an icon of American progressive rock. If someone asks about the most distinguished progressive rock bands from the New World, Glass Hammer will undoubtedly be among such aces as Rush, Styx, Spock's Beard, Dream Theater, Tool, Echolyn, Kansas. There is probably nothing else that can be said about a band that has twenty-two full-length albums to its credit, including: "Perelandra" (1995), "Chronometree" (2000), "Lex Rex" (2002), "Culture of Ascent" (2007), "One" (2010), "Valkyrie" (2016) and a trilogy consisting of the albums: "Dreaming City" (2020), "Skallagrim: Into the Breach" (2011) and "At The Gate" (2022). The albums listed above do not claim to be the best in any general summary, but in my personal collection they have their deserved place.

Let's consider another "myth" related to Glass Hammer. The band does not present its symphonic and strongly prog-rock face on all of its productions. It cannot be pigeonholed as a band playing symphonic rock. Although one could come to such a conclusion after listening to the Skallagrim trilogy, where strong, almost metal riffs intertwine with keyboard playing, right after the release of the trilogy, their portfolio includes, for example, the album "Arise" (2023), which is an excellent example of "musical exercises" carried out within the style that is usually called space rock. Over the years of its existence (the band's beginnings date back to 1992), Glass Hammer has presented songs on its releases that can be pigeonholed in many ways. And on the latest album - "Rogue" it returns to... melodic songs. I will risk saying (of course, only for the purposes of this description) that on the album we are dealing with a "new" musical genre - synth-prog. In the case of this release, synth-prog is a "mixture" of the styles of Mike Oldfield, Tangerine Dream, symphonic rock, neo-prog and music from the eighties (like new romantic and the like). And I can already feel the breath of ardent fans of progressive music in its "pure" form on my back.

Rogue tells the story of one man's fateful journey. "He leaves everything he knows behind him," explains songwriter and band founder Steve Babb, "?and thinks he's coming back to a place where he once knew happiness, but in reality his odyssey takes him somewhere completely unexpected." Babb explains that the ten-track album explores themes of regret and the mortal clarity that comes with age. "?It's a heavy subject for an album, but the music isn't as heavy as our recent releases. Rogue is much more like the Glass Hammer albums that our fans call 'classics.'" That's as much as the band's description of the album goes. And it's probably the music that's the most absorbing element on this record. It surprises with its stylistic combinations, unusual sound and a certain simplicity of arrangement, which (at least in my case) brings the intended effect ? delight in the melodic softness, simplicity of the message and melodic nature of the song.

And what happens if the first track on the album, "What If," sounds like something from the good, classic days of Mike Oldfield combined with the first Glass Hammer albums? The answer is very easy. We get a very cheerful song (with an almost one-minute instrumental introduction), which in its atmosphere resembles romantic synthpop compositions from the eighties. Just don't think that this is taking the proverbial easy way out. Just wait until the third minute for the guitar solo breaking through the delicate, electronic melody to make us, whether we want it or not, immediately let ourselves be seduced by the murmurando lurking in the background and the polyphonic vocals.

And please do not adjust any players because "The Road South" does not allow for even a moment of break. It captivates with the calm sound of synthesizers, which in some way bring us closer to what can be described as a symphony of spheres, and whose apogee is a half-minute guitar solo and the following delicate development of this vocal-guitar story. Maybe it's Alan Parsons, maybe someone else... or maybe it's a somehow changed Glass Hammer...

If you like clear bass guitar passages, then the third track is just for you. "Tommorow" will certainly delight lovers of clear organ lines and... bass, which plays almost its own solo fragments. The organ and bass occupy the entire space of this composition and pull it towards endless contemplation of heavenly beauty.

The song "Pretty Ghost" is a certain breakthrough. Drum rolls and booming bass, electronics, Olivia Tharpe's voice, synthpop rhythms from the eighties. Carefreeness, penetrating rays of sunlight, some subcutaneous joy. And when it seems that we are dealing with some ordinary pop song, in the middle of the song keyboards appear, which from something thoroughly pop create a slightly symphonic mix combined with an unusual, pop vocal.

It is similar with the song "Sunshine". Thanks to the guitar playing in the background, the ballad-pop song gains some drama, which contrasts with Olivia's "innocent" vocals. We are again in music from the eighties, but the guitar solo smoldering in the background is disturbing and absorbing, waiting for the finale, which is a flowing calm.

"I Will Follow" ? this is, in my opinion, the biggest hit from this album. It is proof that the band is still able to write a very catchy song, which, thanks to the balanced combination of two vocals and music, will find its place on every radio station in every music band. And while you're at it, please listen to the band's first albums, I think you'll find a few references.

I hope you haven't even had time to move, frozen in your listening, because it's time for "The Wonder Of It All". It's over seven minutes of travel in space and time filled with wonderful musical passages. I'm not kidding. A slightly cosmic atmosphere, mystery and? the desire to break away, to take off into the world of countless images and associations, into the world of contemplation and amazement at the harmony of the universe. This song simply overwhelms the listener with its majesty.

Please don't stop dreaming... "One Last Sunrise" not only creates an opportunity for this, but is simply a musical dream played. A three-minute, synthesizer, instrumental dream or a sweet dream if you prefer.

Another composition from the album "Rogue" - "Terminal Lucidity" - begins with electronics from the eighties. In several interviews, the band's leader Steve Babb said that his dream on the previous album ("Arise") was to create a composition in the style of Ozric Tentacles. And this is exactly how "Terminal Lucidity" begins - spacey, cosmic, psychedelic. The middle of the song is already "a different story" - heavier, guitar, krautrock. Distorted keyboard sounds, solos in high keys, a load of almost experimental music - as if a tribute to the group Tangerine Dream. The incredible atmosphere is complemented by the words that appear only in the eighth minute: "(...) I had a dream / My life, it seems, is the setting course of the sun / I know it began in brightness / and now the ashes and dust I hear calling me". Please listen carefully to this piece in its entirety - it is almost a musical space odyssey.

The album ends with the song "All Good Things" - a treatise on things past, on the past itself, on everything that will never come back. And at the same time an expression of hope that comes with another sunrise. It is a very optimistic song to end with. One would like to say... to leave. And when you finally think... about halfway through this eight-minute song, that this is the end, the synthesizers begin their story. They destroy this original atmosphere of the ending, and after a moment of anxiety, they lead the listener back to a land where everything seems possible, so real and easy to do, to achieve. Just follow this path... you will surely succeed.

If you now demand that I write a few words to sum it up, I would like to say that I am angry. Angry? because I can't tear myself away from it. Angry because it destroys my previous image of Glass Hammer as a symphonic rock band. Angry because I keep hearing new sounds. Angry because I don't have time for other records. Angry because this record caught my ear. Angry? because angry.

From a formal perspective, it must be added that Glass Hammer is currently a solo project of Steve Babb. On the album "Rogue" he is accompanied by his old collaborators: Fred Schendel, Reese Boyd and David Wallimann (guitarist in the years 2006-2010). Two new vocalists appear: Thomas Jakob and Olivia Tharpe. Oliver Day also plays guitar parts, Argentinian Ariel Perchuck plays keyboards, and Evgeni Obruchkov (who currently lives in Poland, by the way) plays drums. In a word, we are dealing with an international project (vocalists are from the Netherlands and the USA). "It is no secret that Glass Hammer is reborn every few albums," says its leader.

This does not change the fact that I am angry. Angry because... angry.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ligament by PAATOS album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.77 | 14 ratings

BUY
Ligament
Paatos Crossover Prog

Review by Rysiek P.

5 stars

As I begin to write this review, it is still light outside the windows. The "day shift" is still ongoing. People are still bustling about, taking advantage of the improving, warmer weather. You can see the first leaves on the trees, tulip-like flowers are blooming somewhere there, and the neighbors are wondering whether it is time to start gardening or whether it is too early. After all, "winter" may come, because "darkness" may come. External life begins to balance along the border between day and dark, moving towards "light," bright mornings and the evening grayness that sets in later and later. And internal life?? It seems to be gaining momentum after the long, cold, and sometimes snowy months. The winter barrier of grayness, melancholy, and sadness is breaking through more and more. An annually renewable new life is beginning. The exit from the darkness of winter and turning one's face towards the sunny warmth is beginning. The time of thaw from the darkness of short days is beginning.

And at that moment, after a thirteen-year break, we get a new album by the Paatos group entitled "Ligament". This is the sixth album in the portfolio of this band, which, existing since 2000, describes its musical work as: "(...) Cinematic rock with influences of heavy rock, jazz & electronic grooves". However, compared to their previous albums (e.g. "Timeloss" and "Kallocain"), we get a dark release, full of syncopated rhythms, melodies that are half gothic, half arabesque. The next compositions are full of gigantic bass lines and the very experimental voice of Petronella Nettermalm transmitted through a megaphone. The album does not lack what the band has already accustomed us to: a captivating atmosphere, refined electronic textures and organic rhythms. However, the special feature of this release is the rampant sadness, darkness, anxiety and the aforementioned emphasis on experimental creativity.

Ricard Huxflux Nettermalm ? the drummer of the band ? in one of the interviews cites the time we live in as the reason for this state of affairs, which is full of anxiety, instability and fear: "(...) Yes, there is a lot of anxiety in the world right now (...) Both lyrically and musically, Ligament reflects the anxiety that seemed obvious to convey". It is also worth mentioning here that some of the songs were recorded live without any editing - "(...) Some of the songs were recorded entirely live, which is why we were extremely sparing in using the "copy-paste" techniques (i.e. we limited editing to a minimum) in order to offer listeners the most honest and lively musical journey possible. A lot of the music we hear today is too processed and arranged, and its life cycle is very short. We have to breathe life into it, introduce some typography, otherwise we will get bored with it too quickly. I think we just wanted to get back to something organic." Maybe that's why you can hear some understatement in them, some positive awkwardness and? sincerity.

The very first composition on this album, which seems inappropriate for the current season, "Chemical Escape" is a perfect example of this. It is an incredible trip-hop journey with psychedelic-hallucinogenic accents, supported by Ulf Rockis Ivarsson's hypnotic bass line and nervous drum rhythm. Against such a background, Petronella's voice is delicate, almost weightless, balancing the instrumental tension. The aforementioned "sincerity" meets in the following songs with an introspective journey into the interior of one's own "self".

The slow, disturbing track "Who Am I" with its very restrained vocal line evokes the mood of David Bowie. "Svart" introduces a strong charge of internal anxiety and fear, sounding like the voice of someone calling for help in a situation of being abandoned. If, while listening to this composition, you think of one of the most important vocal and musical experimenters, Björk, then this association is completely acceptable. It is Björk and? Kate Bush that seem to be the closest associations that can be heard in Petronella Nettermalm's vocals.

The association with Björk's voice can also be heard in the song "I Deny", which mixes the gentleness of the musical line with the incredible timbre of the vocal line, making the whole thing sound like a breath of saving brightness in the heart of darkness. There is also no shortage of melancholy and mood on the album.

"Beyond The Forest" is such a very emotional and melancholic composition at the same time, the mood of which is built by the cello line performed by Petronella. An important "addition" here is also the singing of Mikael Åkerfeldt (Opeth), who in a duet with Petronella creates an incredible atmosphere of some kind of joy through proverbial tears in the middle part of the song.

The bass line and trip-hop vocals build the composition "I'm Letting Go" by drawing the listener into the world of a percussion-driven journey. As a result of this "mixing", we get a seemingly melodic composition, which however irritates and every now and then throws you out of listening and some contemplation.

The only description that comes to my mind while listening to the song "November" is "spectacular". This composition is one over four-minute musical passage with gentle melancholy that breaks through the moody haziness. And the unsettling vocals, seemingly gentle, innocent, yet full of absorbing melancholy and breaking through sadness, are intriguing, order you to listen and do not allow for a moment of pause.

"Can You see it? The sick pallor of reflection in Your mirror You still smell it The rotten stench of Your own bitterness Now You don´t even feel anymore Believe anymore And all my dreams were dust, after all... Unjust after all..."

This is a fragment of the lyrics of the title composition from the album ? "Ligament". This composition is the most experimental part of the album. Petronella's vocals processed by a megaphone on the one hand reject, and on the other hand create an atmosphere of total confusion of everything with everything. A mix of fear, chaos, total improvisation, almost punk chaos and synthesizer sounds. And as if to counterbalance, there is an instrumental, very short piece entitled "Post War Limina", which, through its simplicity of arrangement, is a quieting of the previous "musical mess". It is a break between the world of fear and chaos, and the world of harmony and mood.

It is impossible to describe this album in a traditional way. It is impossible to summarize it, it is impossible to "pull out" all the inspirations and associations from it. Without a doubt, it is a perfectly realized album, showing a huge palette of moods and colors. It is similar with the musical inspirations that can be heard. Definitely Björk, Kate Bush, David Bovie. Definitely... a number of other artists and musical styles. However, all of this is processed in a way worthy of attention by Paatos, who returns with a proverbial shield after years of absence. And returning to external and internal life, I must say that this is not a "spring" album. With its melancholy, subcutaneous anxiety, predatory mixed with sadness and gentleness, it stands in complete opposition to the brightness, life born in spring, to bright mornings and long days. Finally, to the ordinary, down-to-earth joy of every moment, of every moment. But at the same time it is a necessary "supplement" to this nascent, unbridled joy. Its yang element, because its ying element... just look out the window... a new day has dawned and things will happen, oh yes they will...

As I finish writing this review it is still light, almost warm, no clouds. And I am very happy about that because I have finished listening to one of the most atmospheric albums of this year and now I am going out into the sun.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Disaster / Lüüd Noma  by AMON DÜÜL album cover Studio Album, 1972
1.75 | 32 ratings

BUY
Disaster / Lüüd Noma
Amon Düül Krautrock

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

2 stars AMON DUUL were one of the first Krautrock bands to come out of late sixties Germany. They were like this commune of drugged out hippies who also tried to make some music along the way. Of their five studio albums, four came from the same sessions including this one. You talk about milking a session to death. These sessions were from late 1968 or early 1969. No one remembers. The guys and some girlfriends are all banging on something, with acoustic guitar and vocals also being part of the sound and not much else

If the music itself wasn't bad enough, the sound quality only makes things worse. And naming this "Disaster" could not have been more appropriate. And while I had a glimmer of hope during that very first spin with the opener. That glimmer vanished quickly as this played out for a painful 67 minutes. It's just gets annoying very quickly to hear all this banging and not much else.

This is one of those purchases that I really regret. I'm still kicking myself for not just being content with the one good record they did make in "Paradieswarts Duul" with a different lineup and three significant guests. Two from AMON DUUL II and Hansi from XOHL CARAVAN and later with EMBRYO and more.

Barely 2 stars for this one and a waste of time and money.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Weed Tree by ESPERS album cover Studio Album, 2005
3.42 | 17 ratings

BUY
The Weed Tree
Espers Prog Folk

Review by Novalarke

5 stars One of my favourite albums of all time. I discovered it in October 2005 as I was driving on US1 in New Brunswick NJ. I tuned in to the Rutgers Radio station, and this moody folky song was playing. It grew in intensity and an electric guitar came in howling. It got louder and more avant garde with a squealing cello, strong but dusty drums, solid bass - I was hooked. When the song was over I was stuck at a light and called the station asking what song with that wild scary guitar work. The DJ was "huh"? I described it more and he asked what the vocals were, and I said I didn't remember any vocals, just this long noisy crescendo that started folky and creepy and turned into this psychedelic proggy howlfest. He recognised it and said "Yeah - that was Espers. They're from Philly. That song is called "Flaming Telepaths". I thanked him and bought the CD the next day.

It's brilliant. It's mostly an album of covers, but a very imaginative collection of covers. Normally, people will cover things that are roughly in their wheelhouse of sound. Not this bunch. The singer and acoustic guitarist, Meg Baird, sings like an angel. A very depressed angel. She's also a fine guitarist, and studied with Burt Jansch. Greg Weeks plays electric guitar and synth and sings. Brooke Sietinsons played acoustic rhythm guitar, and is also very good. The cello is played by Helena Espvall who has done a lot of avant garde music since then, including with free jazz people like Alan Sondheim.

"Rosemary Lane" (traditional; arrangement influenced by Bert Jansch) Excellent version of a trad folk song, as it restores some of the darker lyrics that are often left out in more sanitised versions. Meg Baird's vocals shine through this bringing a delicacy to this profoundly sad and bleak trad folk tale of power imbalance, sex, and resignation to a horrible fate.

"Tomorrow" (Vini Reilly; originally by The Durutti Column) The Durutti Column are a whole thing unto themselves and to cover them in this raw folky way is remarkable. Again, Meg's voice is a beautiful thing. A song of longing for different outcomes and alienation of affections.

"Black Is the Color" (traditional; arrangement influenced by The Famous Jug Band) Another trad folk song. This one was covered by Nina Simone decades ago, and is the version I was most familiar. No shade to Nina's genius, but I rather prefer this version. There's something deeply spiritual and yet utterly disquieting about this. Brilliant. Weeks sings some fine and oddly complex harmony here.

"Afraid" (Nico) So, it was trad folk, Durutti Column, trad folk - how do you follow that? With a gloomy goth tune by Nico OF COURSE. The song sounds like a toy - gentle guitars, xylophone, cello - sweet, and yet: Nico's lyrics are just open despair. A wonderful counter to the arrangement.

"Blue Mountain" (Michael Hurley) This song by Michael Hurley is from 1965, and is a classic singer songwriter folk song from that time. Only in the hands of the Espers it is vastly more psychedelic and richer. Weeks sings the lead in this and his vocals are OK, certainly no worse than Hurley's, and Baird's harmonies really make this swing.

"Flaming Telepaths" (originally by Blue Öyster Cult) The centrepiece of the album. Stunning. especially as the original is about as unfolky as a song can get, being a brassy loud track from the Hard Rock band Blue Oyster Cult. Love it. 10 out of 10.

"Dead King" (Espers original) This is the only original on the album, and another version was released on Espers 2. Frankly, I think this version is better - it's a bit more open and direct.

This (and Espers 2) while not technically Prog Rock, is a Top Album in my world - required listening, period.

Band members: Greg Weeks Meg Baird Brooke Sietinsons Otto Hauser Helena Espvall Chris Smith.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Carta Malabarica by CLESSIDRA album cover Studio Album, 2013
3.46 | 3 ratings

BUY
Carta Malabarica
Clessidra Post Rock/Math rock

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

3 stars With only one studio album released in 2013, CLESSIDRA might already be relegated to Italian post rock history. Luckily this is a fascinating artifact, an all instrumental album with many influences from its principal sub-genre, but subtly incorporating mysterious and temptingly foreboding aspects of world music, chiefly from the middle and far east, as befits the real place names in the tracklist.

The rhythms are consistently the drivers here, accompanied by generally scant, almost minimalist guitar and keyboard touches best acquitted in "Gobekle Tepi", with "Baghdad's Battery" ,"Tunguska Part 1", and "Giza" being nearly of comparable standard. The keys often serve as another base instrument in that sense. Sound effects include canines, insects and human voices sans substrate, which form and dissolve as phantoms. Unfortunately one track ("The Kadath") is essentially a drum solo with equally atonal diversions, and "Ek Balam" is a failed attempt at weaving Frippian lead guitar into the end product.

While its legend is modest, I still recommended "Carta.." for those who enjoy post rock and world music and are tired of being force fed clumsy takes of both.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Circus of Wire Dolls by ROCKING HORSE MUSIC CLUB album cover Studio Album, 2022
4.79 | 6 ratings

BUY
Circus of Wire Dolls
Rocking Horse Music Club Crossover Prog

Review by BBKron

5 stars A sprawling concept double album, or more appropriately, a prog rock opera featuring a wide variety of musical styles. Never heard of them? Well, not many have. Rocking Horse Music Club is a music collective/collaboration based out of Rocking Horse Recording Studios in Pittsfield, New Hampshire, USA. The primary contributors are singer/songwriter Brian Coombes, a veteran prog musician/producer and owner of the Recording Studio; Justin Cohn, singer/songwriter/guitarist, and singer/songwriter/multi-instrumentalist Patrick Gochez, and supported by Brendan Harrisiades (bass), Myron Kibbee and Mike McAdam (guitars), and Eric Wagley (drums), as well as numerous other local, regional, and guest musicians to fill out the instrumentation and sound. The music tells the story of a man who has spent a good portion of his life creating a miniature circus of figurines made of wire, string, and cloth. As he nears the end of his life, he imagines the dolls each telling their own stories, with human thoughts and emotions, which actually reflect aspects of his own life. Thus, the story is told from several different voices (and featuring a series of guest vocalists). On the surface, it is the story of a miniature circus, but it's really about a man looking back on his life, his work, the people, his successes, his failures, his regrets. The different voices also provides the opportunity for many different musical styles. But whether or not you follow or are moved by the compelling story, it is the music that is the show here, and it is quite wonderful and breathtaking throughout. This expansive collection features 22 songs, ranging in length from 1 and a half to 8 and a half minutes each, for a total of over 95 minutes of music (which really doesn't even seem long at all because the songs are so good throughout). Guest artists include: Amy Birks, Tim Bowness, Caroline Carter, Evelyn Cormier (American Idol), David Cross (King Crimson), Kenwood Dennard (Brand X), Chris Difford (Squeeze), John Hackett, Greg Hawkes (the Cars), Noel McCalla (Mike Rutherford/Manfred Mann), Kate St John (Dream Academy), and Rob Townsend (Steve Hackett). Overall, because of the variety of styles, it is a bit hard to categorize or compare to other works (genre-defying?), but the closest may be somewhat along the lines of a concept album by the Alan Parsons Project, featuring light melodic progressive rock, with much pop, rock, and symphonic influences, as well as musical theater, chamber pop, and aspects of jazz and blues, and even a taste of glam rock thrown in. Although it has an original sound, there are brief glimpses of many other bands that pop up, including Genesis, Pink Floyd, Coldplay, Queen, Supertramp, The Pretenders, John Lennon, among others. Overall, the songs are touching and beautiful, with great melodies, themes, and recurring motifs. Of particular note is the impeccable production, arrangements, and attention to detail, always with the seemingly best combination of instrumentation and musical flourishes that are just right for each song, whether that might be strings, horns, clarinet, or whatever, and always most tastefully done. This is not an album that will hit you over the head, but in so many subtle and emotional ways just works immensely well, with just wonderful, beautiful songs throughout. All the songs work here, whether it is a tender duet ballad, such as Would You Be My Downfall, or the more raucous shot of glam rock in It's Not About You. Thus the list of best songs could go on and on, but I have narrowed it down to those I love the most. A truly wonderful album, that needs more love and respect.

Best tracks: Animate in 5/8, So Little Left, Cut From a Different Cloth, It's Not About You, 0300, SY22, Burn, All Shall Be Well, Every Show Must End, To Reach the Other Side, Flowers in November, and really all the rest. Rating: 5 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 On the Eve of a Goodbye by RETICENT, THE album cover Studio Album, 2016
4.48 | 12 ratings

BUY
On the Eve of a Goodbye
The Reticent Experimental/Post Metal

Review by Prog/Land

5 stars This is quite possibly one of the most beautiful albums I have ever listened to. It had me in tears by the end. It tackles an incredibly dark subject with grace, allowing everyone to connect with the depressing material. It perfectly weaves super heavy moments with beautiful vocals and instrumentation. This album stands as proof that concept albums are an incredibly effective way to tell a story. I highly recommend everyone to listen to this with the lyrics pulled up, and see if you won't start crying.

I think my only nitpick would be that a lot of the riffs don't really stand out too much, they kind of just add more texture. This isn't to say that the music isn't great, it just isn't incredibly iconic. If you played me some of these riffs and told me Opeth wrote it I would probably believe you. Still, I think this doesn't take away from the overall experience at all. It's a crime how underrated these guys are.

9/10

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Nightfall by BAUMANN, PETER album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.91 | 2 ratings

BUY
Nightfall
Peter Baumann Progressive Electronic

Review by Heart of the Matter

4 stars A reputed figure in the Berlin Schule of electronic/kosmische Musik, Peter Baumann was also a member of the classic trio line-up of Tangerine Dream from 1971 to 1977, the same golden period in which they released their seminal albums Zeit (1972), Phaedra (1974), Ricochet (1975) and Stratosfear (1976).

He's now back to recording studios, making his first solo instalment since Machines Of Desire, nine years ago. Baumann never followed the path of progressive rock based in virtuosity and energy, but rather that particular "tangerine" blend of cerebral design with cinematic soundscapes. And this is even more misteriously atmospheric an album than their previous efforts. Nevertheless, and in spite of all the astoundingly rational structure sustaining this music, its flow never stops, always impulsed by human emotion, the more conspicuous by contrast against the ever shifting sonic background. The cover of Nightfall with a sand dune, symbolizes the fleeting nature of our lives and experiences, our existence, according to Baumann himself, but also brings the last Klaus Schulze's album to memory, a non trivial association, since both seem to breathe and float in the same extatic universe.

"The track titles, as with much of my work, reflect the ephemeral, ungraspable nature of our existence", also says the artist. Of course, a strong sense of predictability also emerges from such an existentialist premise. But, in my case, that is not a complaint. In minimalistic affairs like this one, every minor shift in nuance or mood counts. The opener, No One Knows, convoys through the most hieratic desert, guided by sparse woodblocks under a laconic guitar dome. After that, there comes an impressively omnipresent, yet impenetrable choir in Track 2, Lost In A Pale Blue Sky. Perhaps the more dynamic (to say a lot) moments come to fruition in Tracks 3, 4 and 5, On The Long Road, A World Apart and From A Far Land, which, even being sustained by a still very circumspect percussive and harmonic scheme, assume a sort of narrative tension, in a fashion similar to a movie score when the trip procedes through an uncharted land of unmeasurable desolation.

"I love instrumental music because it bypasses any concepts, it is an expression that words can never capture," the artist reflects. "We can't hear music exactly the same way twice, it's always experienced differently, sometimes slightly sometimes substantially. Like a river, never exactly the same". So, it seems like this album extends an invitation to immerse and collaborate in the construction of that unfinished world of agonizing beauty.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 This Dark Earth by MOON LETTERS album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
This Dark Earth
Moon Letters Heavy Prog

Review by tszirmay
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

— First review of this album —
4 stars This Seattle Washington collective began their story with the 2019 "Until They Feel the Sun" album, an excellent debut that was followed up by the equally interesting "Thank you from the Future" in 2022. The veteran crew has remained solidly stable, composed of vocalist Michael Trew, guitarist Dave Webb, John Allday on keyboards, Mike Murphy and Kelly Mynes on bass and drum kit respectively. I am the proud owner of all three, though this will be the first review. It should not come as a surprise to any music fan, but Seattle certainly has a rather legendary musical heritage from Jimi Hendrix, via Heart to all the obvious grunge groups. There must be something in the air, or in Seattle's case in the rainwater. The psychedelic tendency probably stems from the turbulent weather that stretch of land is famous for. One of the main characteristics of Moon Letters is their insistence on originality, though obviously wearing storied influences on their sleeves. They also possess that wonderful prog ability to transition on a dime into sonic variations that defy the laws of gravity, infuse vocal harmonies at the most opportune moment (generally, smack in the middle of a storm) and sprinkle occasional doses of rawness, technical groove, snippet soloing , Zappa- esque controlled insanity as well as various implements around the kitchen sink. Prepare yourself for the unexpected yet very attractive!

This is expertly described on the eventually tumultuous "Energy of the Heart", an opening piece that navigates the various corridors of experimentation, emitting some lighter tangents and then, others more cavernous and harrowing. The quintet has no qualms of showing their mettle but just like with Uncle Frank, it's all about precise teamwork (like the Mariners, Seahawks, Kraken and Supersonics), no one hogging the spotlight, tight like a lid of marmalade. Trew can scream, Webb tortures his fretboard with splintering riffs, Allday doing his octopus thingy, and the rhythmic duo in a tandem turbocharged frenzy. Halfway through, the shift occurs towards a more Gong-like atmosphere, sweeping towards distant stars, waving to the long gone 'pot head pixies', in restrained admiration. On "Silver Dream", the shade becomes vastly different than on the previous piece, a somewhat pastoral sheen, with a more melodic concentration from Webb's slithering leads , the rolling bass fluttering along, wooing synths ululating and a flower-power vocal that reeks sunshine and beads. The pace gradually picks up steam and then gets catapulted momentarily into profound melancholia, a dejected piano accentuating the sorrow, before returning into the previous maelstrom. Through in a clamoring trumpet blast from Allday and Murphy's shepherding bass furrow, the guitar rasping furiously and tingling when exhausted, choir strings adding a touch of symphonics.

'Full speed ahead' bellowed the captain on "Island of Magic Mirrors", a castaway hymn for the Wilsons of this world, with an endless series of sharp reflections, at times blurred by haste, bullied by ramshackle gusto and then comforted by synthesized panacea. The track raises the urgency to unprecedented levels.

After a brief and much-needed rest period on the delicate and brief "Lonely Moon", the band decides to dive bomb screeching into the deepest abyss of angst and insanity, displaying a technical prowess that will require finding one's jaw on the carpeted floor. "In the Catacombs" is nothing short of a blitzkrieg onslaught on the senses, a raging, fulminating bulldozer that shows no mercy and offers no penitence for its actions.

Capping off this entertaining album, the marathon arrives in the form of a 17 minute+ extravaganza that, like most quality epics, integrates all the intrinsic characteristics that make up the mind set of this collective. "Dawn of the Winterbird" is a tectonic plate shift that will test anyone's balance, so it is recommended to sit comfortably and hopefully numb, and embrace the sounds, like one would visiting the gorgeous state's coastline. To say that the arrangement seeks to take one on a mesmerizing voyage is quite the understatement, as the variations are expertly fused together, introducing from the get-go a drop-dead gorgeous melody, with Trew and the backing vocal bench hitting all the pleasure nodes. Webb adds an intricately woven sizzle just to illuminate the sunrise appearing on the horizon. The unexpected somber retreat into a sorrowful stupor is heartbreaking and majestic, skillfully rebooting the celestial melody espoused previously, 'I would never try to hurt you?' and its warm continuance, the fluid electric guitar embracing the transcendence and in complete harmony with the divine vocal expression. Elegance in the shape of a brief piano etude that serves to ultimately enhance the power and the culminating effect of all the passion displayed! This is a masterful composition that deserves a podium finish on the altar of 2025 prog epics and alone is worth the expense to hunt down and treasure this release.

To paraphrase my great grandmother's idol Barry Manilow: 'Looks like you made it'! LOL . A wonderfully conceived and performed musical adventure, certainly worthy of immediate consideration among the other lunar modules in 2025 orbit, around this dark Earth.

4.5 Tired planets

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 YWNTS by PHLOX album cover Studio Album, 2013
2.97 | 6 ratings

BUY
YWNTS
Phlox Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by DetectiveDoom

3 stars This is the second of two albums by Malaysian psych rock quartet Phlox.

It continues in the same vein from the first album Quiver although I think it has slightly more direction in terms of compositions.

Rain and What Comes After, The Unknown and Pale Blue China are among the best songs by the group which features Hakim Tahar (vocals/keyboards/guitars), Hanafi Rahman (guitar), Syazwan Sazali (bass) and Ahmad Zulikhwan (drums).

I do have to say that the 25 minute title track has great moments but is also quite a drag to listen to. Maybe cos of the stoner-shoegaze vibe.

It will remind you of The Verve and Explosions Of The Sky at times, occasionally turning dense or dark or even progressive but rarely straying from the established laid back mood.

I think we may not hear from them again as this album came out in 2013 and appears to be their last.

Phlox's two albums rank alongside The Strollers' Waiting Is, Damn Dirty Apes' Valve State Dreams. Capt'n Trips And The Kids' The Paraverse, Golden Mammoth's Skycraper Towards The Sun and Martin Vengadesan & The Stalemate Factor's The Knight's Flight as the best of Malaysian psychedelic music.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Time Silent Radio vii by ECHOLYN album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.11 | 77 ratings

BUY
Time Silent Radio vii
Echolyn Symphonic Prog

Review by alainPP

5 stars "Radio Waves" with an ominous off-key sound, definitely a US series; we find the catchy charm of ELO, the Beatles, Barclay James Harvest, Bowie, Kansas, and Jethro Tull for the progressive soaring on the carefree spirit of youth. "Silent Years" with its piano and spaghetti western guitar, vintage sound and lush harmony, the finale with the phrase from the previous track making the connection. "Cul-de-Sacs and Tunnels" is a mawkish pop love song, meaning simple-minded in appearance; the melody is reminiscent of Inspector Gadget and the voice of Tears For Fears with a tune catching up with ELO in overdrive prog. "Boulders on Hills" changes style, aggressive with the syncopated riff worthy of Jethro Tull and the nervous vocals; a tonic tune that changes the game with a solemn piano outro.

"Our Brilliant Next" is a piano-driven track for the soft ballad, swelling with vocal lament, moving from acoustic to frenzy before the captivating jazzy finale; a beautiful progressive exercise. "On We Blur" is a rock ballad with Joe Jackson-esque melodic piano in the background and ELO's backing vocals, repeat; from serene we move to bucolic Charisma, inventive hints of XTC, a zest of Supertramp then a nod to Genesis, you'll recognize it. The exuberant track typical of Albion, enjoyable until its prog-like finale. "Tiny Star" ends the album; besides Big Big Train and ELO as reminiscences, knowing that BBT is much younger than them, this track is simply Echolyn. The musicality, Katie's fresh, catchy, feminine refrain "All you need," a true melodic delight enhanced by a stellar progressive drift. The musical diamond shines even after the finale; a final solo in Pink Floyd style for the split double album of the month.

Echolyn has recorded a very good progressive double album with two great singers; a musical breath of intertwined songs, polyphonic vocals, and chiseled Beatles and Steely Dan choruses; Yes, Haken, and Opeth also manage to create harmony that is both simple and complex. Progcensor origin.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Time Silent Radio II by ECHOLYN album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.96 | 88 ratings

BUY
Time Silent Radio II
Echolyn Symphonic Prog

Review by alainPP

4 stars "Time Has No Place": a symphonic, cinematic intro, a train station feel, a melody based on Big Big Train, the Flower Kings, and Gentle Giant, a touch jazzy. The vocals appear with Brett and Ray, a touch of XTC, fresh and varied. The lively piano for the second of the four parts, harmony, an invading Mellotron, a marshmallowy return with the melting sound of ELO. The instrumental, the return of the vocals, the choirs, and the air sinking into a divine space with Ray at the helm. The nostalgic, yet not soporific, vintage prog moment; the intermission and the Beatles-esque vocals all at once, somewhere between pop and prog rock with a hint of Canterbury. The sound of King Crimson, the heavy riff supporting the choirs; a musical festival, a fusion of opera, nursery rhymes, and pastoral sequences, bordering on the styles of prog rock.

Ģ'Water in Our Hands, Pts. 1-4ģ singular, fruity intro; the sound of the 70s for the voice and the musical structure; already lost in this musical maelstrom where we feel the deconstructed prog of Jethro Tull, technical, invasive. The vocal and instrumental mix makes us lose track of time; a compendium of rock with a captivating jazzy tessitura with bewitching voices; an entertaining space that seems to burst with discoveries in every drawer, like this rapped section, this passage on Genesis with the organ making the hairs stand on end. An acoustic piano interlude ā la Joe Jackson with the tenacious guitar riff that flirts with ĢThe Lambģ. The six parts go from the epic to the moving for an adventure that took ten years, with many nods to Yes, Genesis above all, on Big Big Train narrating the inevitable passage of time. The Beatlesian finale, fruity and enjoyable xtcian and thirty minutes out of this time. The album that recalls "mei" for its impromptu continuation. Origin progcensor.(4.5)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Focus by SOFT FFOG album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.05 | 21 ratings

BUY
Focus
Soft Ffog Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by tszirmay
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars Sophomore album from this talented Norwegian quartet, formed by two members of Krokofant, the recent 'enfant terrible' of the Norse scene, guitarist extraordinaire Tom Hasslan aka Zappa Finger and Axel Skalstad aka Pheel the Collins on the drum kit. They are complemented by Wizrd keyboardist Vegard Lien Bjerkan aka Wake(up the)man and finally from the band Red Kite, Trond Frones aka Geezer Jeezus playing the bass only on the sabbath. And who dares to say that Scandinavians have no sense of humour, have you not heard of the Finn funny man Ismo? Their eponymous 2022 debut caused a stir, but this latest release has a distinguishing inclination veering towards a Focus influence that shows up between all four players at times, as well as collectively. This band lets loose in intense jam mode, a yearning to have fun in the studio and let the chips fall where they may. The gorgeous cover art certainly satisfies the visual senses.

Hinting humbly at the legendary British band led by Andy Latimer "Camel" certainly underlines the melodic spirit behind that band, the pearly keys and bustling rhythm section settling into a robust groove, the idyllic platform for the electric guitar to begin soaring across the sonic dunes. Whereas the master was famous for long sustained emotional notes, here Hasslan lets it rip with a blistering array of rapid-fire salvos, leaning towards the more focused (sic) standard that will make up the album. The e-piano section is a glittering oasis of sun-drenched streaks, a mirror in the desert showing the way to liquid salvation.

Channeling his innermost Jan Akkerman fantasy on "Pocus", Hasslan goes properly berserk on his 6-string implement with a tour de force homage (two French words creeping into the verbiage-another Gallicism!), though Bjerkan chooses a decidedly jazzier piano and e-piano route on his ivories, while the rhythm section perfectly salutes the Ruiter-Van der Linden attack. Starting out in a breezy lilt with a clavinet introduction, the build-up gradually goes tornado (Happy Birthday Bill Bruford) with a blizzard of peaks and valleys, playfully gathering steam with some patented flurries that recall the finer moments of the Focus 3 album.

"Focus" keeps the foot on the cyclist pedal with a gentler foray into more bucolic workings, that swoon unashamedly into Metheny territory, the finger technique is bewilderingly accurate, mastering both leads, riffs, and flicks of the wrist, just like Jan did and still does today in his golden years. The comprehensive synth solo is quite the skidding workout, with enough shape and bend to thrill the most passive listener. It becomes apparent that the main underlying attribute of this quartet is plain old fun, jamming like there is no care in the world.

Written like this "Oh Jimi", it can only refer to Hendrix , as the spelling 'Jimi' has been permanently retired to the rafters, after he died on September 18, 1970. Kicking into a medieval tinged Jon Lord sounding organ surely ruffles the feathers, injecting the electric guitar with bluesy dexterity, as the pace slows to a grind, and the steady groove is set as the ideal gliding platform on which Hasslan can stretch, steal and borrow those characteristic moaning lines that made Jimi such a legend. A ten-minute rocking roller coaster ride is set in motion with just enough personality to dismiss any overt copycat urges, the keyboard spotlight doing wonders for the atmosphere as well as transitioning into varied mood swings that augur well for the explosive finale, where a Mahavishnu Orchestra - like feel shatters all the illusions.

I enjoyed the debut, but this is a much higher raised bar, easily reached without steroid enhancers or blood packing, just a more focused (oops!) approach that had the courage to add another iconic figure as a final coup de grace. Well played and totally unpretentious.

4.5 concentrations

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Gamle Mester by FRØISLIE, LARS FREDRIK album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.48 | 58 ratings

BUY
Gamle Mester
Lars Fredrik Frøislie Symphonic Prog

Review by ProgRockCanuck

5 stars Prog Rock Canuck (Canadian) Review Lars Fredrik Frøislie album Gamle Mester

The much anticipated follow up to Lar's last album, Fire Fortellinger has finally arrived and it starts off with a bang. An instrumental opener, Demring, that has all the elements of classic 70s prog but with a overall sound that is unique to the composer. In other words, you can hear other influences from the keyboard greats of yesteryear, think Emerson, Wakeman but still distinctively Lar's in the end. It starts off light with the organ, gets heavy and ends light with piano. Plus several twists and turns along the way in this short track. It sets the stage for where the rest of this album is going. A great introduction to this composer's music for anyone new.

The second track is heavy right out of the gate. And the first longer track of the album, its called Jakten Pa Kalydonske Villsvin. Also the first track to have vocals and what a pleasant surprise, the vocals sound so much more confident here than on the previous album. Also fits in better in the overall mix. Many of the instrumental sections in the first two thirds of this track harkens back to an ELP like sound but the last third of the track is my favorite. Much slower and atmospheric. Featuring some beautiful flute work over repeated piano lines.

Next we have the Title track. I must say that this instrumental piece, Gamle Mester could have been the opener and swapped places with Demring. Either track would make a great introduction to this composer's music. Very accessible. I played it for a 'non prog rock fan' and she really enjoyed it. All the elements of traditonal prog are here, odd time signatures (7/8 for the win!) and time shifts along the way with punchy drums and Ricky bass, and of course, Lar's multi layered keyboard tracks.

The fourth track, Medusa Flate really hits hard at the start (think ELP/Anglagard) but by the time we get in to the sung verses it surprisingly shifts into a YES like, prog popper. I actually felt like dancing. Half way through we''re back to heavy again and closer to ELP, (Think Trilogy album).

The fifth track, De Tre Gratier is the longest track on the album, and most interesting, start to finish. It opens soft with harpsichord and perhaps electric piano (not sure). Very beautiful start. Next we get heavy and although this sounds like pure Lars, I also hear an underlining framework of something that Yes might have produced. Then we are back to the beautiful harpsichord, and at this point I must beg Mr. Froislie to produce a future album of Harpsichord music. His playing of this instrument is exquisite. We also hear some lovely organ and mellotron through this section. Speaking of the mellotron, this album is certainly for lovers of this instrument. The final instrumental moments is a mixed bag, full of multiple instrument switching as to which is the lead instrument until the piece is over. There's also a slight Jethro Tull sound in spots. Like I mentioned at the beginning of talking about this piece, it truly is the most interesting on the whole album and will be great for repeat listens.

The final track and we're back to a full instrumental. Skumring starts off real soft with very atmospheric piano. It picks up a bit in the middle but never really gets heavy. It's a nice gentle way to close the album. It also leaves you with the urging to start from the beginning again.

Gamle Mester is truly an almost perfect album. I'm really tempted to give it 5/5. And I am delighted to see that in just a couple of days since its official release, it has already topped the Prog Archives chart for 2025. Congrats Lars, you knocked this one out of the park (baseball reference, home run).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Gathering of Souls by GUILDMASTER, THE album cover Studio Album, 2025
5.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Gathering of Souls
The Guildmaster Prog Folk

Review by Matti
Prog Reviewer

— First review of this album —
5 stars The Guildmaster could be seen as a folk-spirited little sibling of The Samurai Of Prog, likewise an international progressive rock project by mostly the same production team, but (unlike TSOP) relying on the original compositions of its core members. They are, since the second album Liber de Dictis (2022), Spanish folk expert Rafael Pacha, Finnish drummer Kimmo Pörsti, Italian-livng-in-Finland bassist Marco Bernard and Italian keyboardist Alessandro Di Benedetti.

With the preceding albums I occasionally felt that the Medieval/folk elements and the modern prog rock production were having a tug of war, making me wish for a purer folk approach on some pieces. Now everything is more coherent and unified, rooted on the symphonic prog -- with the blessing of the rich, folky sonic pallette due to the various folk instruments played by Pacha. But what really makes this album my fave of the three is the excellent level of compositions. Being almost as lengthy (64:20) as the 12-track Liber de Dictis, Gathering of Souls has eight tracks, four of them a bit longer.

Pörsti's opening instrumental 'The Crusade of Earl Birger' is inspired by the historic events that took place in the Finnish soil in the mid-13th century and it has a wonderfully dynamic and colourful arrangement. Pacha's long instrumental 'Where Are You?' still improves from that. One moment you may think of Ommadawn-era Oldfield, the next moment has a Wakemanesque synth run, and the cherry on the top is the beautiful wordless singing of Paula Pörsti. Also the third piece is a colourful folk prog instrumental, composed by Pacha.

Di Benedetti's sole composition, epic 'Blood and Oblivion' is an outstanding emotional highlight sung by Yogi Lang of RPWL. Then one more fine Pacha instrumental, after which the album takes a bit more vocal oriented course. Nick Markham (neverheard) sings with his smoky voice the ambitiously proggy 'Mary the Jewess' which however is not among my highlights. Also composed by Pacha is 'Luonto puhuu' where Paula sings in Finnish. This piece has a peculiar atmosphere. Pörsti's second composition 'Sea and Sky' features the mid-70's Phil Collins reminding vocals of John Wilkinson, and a lovely flute contribution of Giovanni Mazzotti.

Now I only need to decide how to round my 4,5 stars. Ok, let's round it up because, as I said, this is the most solid and symphonic Guildmaster album this far. Hats of especially to Rafael Pacha who's at his strongest here.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Long Season '96-7 - 96.12.26 Akasaka Blitz赤坂 by FISHMANS album cover Live, 2016
4.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Long Season '96-7 - 96.12.26 Akasaka Blitz赤坂
Fishmans Crossover Prog

Review by Logan
Forum & Site Admin Group Site Admin

— First review of this album —
4 stars "Me Fish bring" (some cool people will get that). "We got the funk" (more cool people will get that).

Full disclosure: I love Fishmans! And hearing them play live, even if recorded is a wonderful thing, and I so wish I knew the band while in Japan in the 90s.

Fishmans has made several great live albums, and I do count its "98.12.28 Otokotachi no wakare" as my favourite live album of all, but hot dang, this has serious highs too and I would absolutely recommend this to not just fans of Fishmans but many fans of funky and groovy music. It's a wonderful hour and 52 minutes spent, well, for me anyway.

I love the rendition of "Long Season" (I do prefer to return to this live version, and especially the one on 98.12.28, than to the studio album), "Oh Slime" is great and this is a terrific version of "Go Go Round This World!". Like on "Sunny Blue", this can be a really bluesy rockin' album, and it is a very funky release from Fishmans. It is less dreamy than later releases and more in your face, I might say. While I tend to veer towards more atmospheric music, I love this for what it is.

And Honzi (RIP), the violinist and keyboardist shines. She is electrifying. And I really like this drummer's work and the guitars. By the way, the drummer, and chorus contributor Kin-ichi Motegi proves how good he is as a front-man, drummer and vocalist when Fishmans reforms later with surviving members and others (Fishmans+).

This album has groove, and it also plays looser than other Fishmans releases. I like its less obviously structured and controlled dynamics.

An issue I do have seems to be the mastering/mixing. Honzi and other instrumental parts shine, and the chorus is wonderful in "Long Season", but Sato's (RIP)'s vocals are too prominent in the mix. It sounds too forward. It can take away from the instrumental parts. Of course Sato is dearly missed by many... but so is Honzi, which is not to say that Sato was put more forward in the mix due to his status among many fans. And while this is a very energetic performance by Fishmans, I don't feel Sato's vocals were at their best -- I am particularly comparing the vocals here to a live performance from earlier in the same year that also was released much later. "Long Season" off this live has significant sonic quality differences to my ears, and does sound recorded at a different time or times. It sounds later and I find the mixing/mastering better in that, and maybe it was how the equipment was set up. Again, it's a different and wonderful version of "Long Season". than the studio album version or the 1998 live.

Also, while I should take this album on its on merits, fun though this is, it is not as emotionally resonant to me as the December of 1998 concert. That feels more heartfelt, and also bittersweet since Sato's life was so short at the time. There is a kind of weariness and fragility and sensitivity in the 1998 album that I don't find here. But being lively/ energetic is of course not a bad thing commonly.

This album is very lively, very funky, and a good listen. I am giving it four stars because while very good in its own right and having some superb renditions and moments, the mixing could work better to my ear, and it is not as emotionally resonant to me (and lacks the atmosphere) of the 98.12.28 concert, a concert that takes place in the same venue. If you're looking for a harder funking Fishmans than you might know, this album could be the Fishmans album for you. The falsetto vocals, which can be very screechy, seem to be the main impediment some have in enjoying Fishmans. Your ears have been warned.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Pre-Flight by ROOM album cover Studio Album, 1970
3.74 | 49 ratings

BUY
Pre-Flight
Room Heavy Prog

Review by SliprKC70

3 stars Room was another one of those short-lived progressive rock bands from the seventies, with their album, Pre-Flight, being the only thing they left us. Looking at the generally positive reviews, along with how the personnel looked as if there was essentially an orchestra playing on this album, I had high expectations. What I received, however, was between a mediocre and simply good album. While this didn't reach my expectations, it still had some charm within it. The players on this album have a very strong sense of musicianship, and they manage to mix heavy blues and symphonic/progressive rock elements in a one-of- a-kind way. The main negative elements come when listening to the actual music, as it isn't bad, but it's also not that good. It lacks true originality at points and get quite bland in some of the tracks. For example, some of the music leans a lot more toward the blues aspects, and while I still like the genre, it's just kind of lackluster when played out compared to the parts of the album.

Moving on to the music, I liked the opening title track, which is a nearly nine-minute-long suite, with the orchestral and dramatic vibes mixing in exceptionally well with heavy prog, creating a solidly great song of ever-changing rhythms and evolving structures that turn and twist into this sort of "hype song" so to speak, as to what I thought would be on the rest of the album. Cemetery Junction also has a very similar thing going on, this time with a bigger focus on the symphonic side. Like I mentioned up above in the first paragraph, the album finds difficulty finding a true direction and sort of slithers in between Jefferson Airplane formulas and a sound that was similar to what Chicago was doing at the time. Where Did I Go Wrong is a bit of a drop-off, being mostly bland and nothing really interesting happening. The same goes for the shortest song on the record, Big John Blues. The rest of the songs bring their own quirky twists and are all around good songs. Some of my favorites include the jazz-rock leanings of No Warmth In My Life and the poetic lyrics of War. However, these are all just good songs, and the title track and Cemetery Junction are the only numbers I would truly consider to be great songs.

In conclusion, it's an alright record that could use some improvement. The title track is a real gem and worth checking out, but the whole album is far from being essential. I will admit, I really enjoyed some of the musicianship on this thing, so that brings my rating up. Overall I would argue a 3/5 is most fitting for this record.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Gamle Mester by FRØISLIE, LARS FREDRIK album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.48 | 58 ratings

BUY
Gamle Mester
Lars Fredrik Frøislie Symphonic Prog

Review by Progfan97402
Prog Reviewer

5 stars I wasn't expecting a second solo album from Lars Fredrik Frøislie so fast, given the tediously long waits between Wobbler albums (look at the wait between Rites at Dawn and From Silence to Somewhere, literally six years, so the big shock of the three years for Dwellers of the Deep). COVID hits, so slowing down the already slow process for a new Wobbler release (better than being overran by releases like Ayreon or the Flower Kings), so Lars records a solo album in the form of Fire Fortellinger. That one took me by surprise because I was wondering what a solo effort might be like from him. Wonder no more. I was expecting maybe he'd get Martin Nordrum Kneppen of Wobber to do the drum parts, but instead Lars did it, and he even did the vocals. In fact, he did it all aside from the bass parts. I was amazed with Fire Fortellinger, but looking back I felt there was room for improvement but improved he did. I felt on Fire Fortellinger maybe he wasn't completely confident going on a solo venture, but with Gamle Mester he certain has. Once again it doesn't take any rocket scientist to figure out how important Lars is to the Wobbler sound, it's obvious. To me, it sounds like if Tusmørke made full-on symphonic prog in the vein of Wobber with a bit of Jordsjø thrown in. Lars's vocals sound like Benediktator of Tusmørke. Instead of four cuts, here it's six, and it's full of everything you want, lots of authentic vintage keyboards, including Mellotron and even the Chamberlin M1 (I remembered back in 2009 seeing him purchase that Chamberlin from an American seller on YouTube and Wobbler was starting to record Rites at Dawn then, to be released in 2011) and lots of great arrangements. To me the highlights are "Jakten På Det Kalydonske Villsvin", the title track, and "De Tre Gratier". To me, this is some of the finest prog to have come out in recent years, and if you love Fire Fortellinger, get Gamle Mester right away, it's deserving a classic!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Outer Space by HAEKA album cover Studio Album, 2020
3.91 | 8 ratings

BUY
Outer Space
Haeka Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Finnforest
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars The spaces between shimmering

Haeka are a four-piece from Milan featuring Vitorio Zambon, Alberto Guglielmo, Jacopo Scibilia, and Marta Ceccarini. Their debut is entitled "Outer Space" and it was released in 2020, just four tracks in the six-to-ten minute range each. Thus a short album, but that seems to be a badge of honor for Italian bands. Going all the way back to the early '70s, they seemed to realize that less is more. In an era of 75 minute albums, I love the whole short album thing that many of the classics had. Haeka is an interesting variant of modern space rock that carves out its own sound. While I suspect Porcupine Tree may be an influence to some in the band, they don't mention it, and it's not particularly obvious. As of 2025, they are currently working on their second album.

Their debut sound is heavy and augmented with plenty of textural nuance and pauses for breezy escapades. The wildcard of Ceccarini's ethereal vocal and the echo and harmony applied to it create a mesmerizing effect. (The lyrics I could make out were pretty cool too, though I'm not a big lyrics guy.) I was reminded at times of Lagartija, although that band veers more jazzy while Haeka stay more in the spacey rock realm. When the shimmering harmonies near the beginning of "Stable as Change" kicked in, I immediately felt deja vu like I had heard them before but can't say where. But it is so beautiful. Indeed it is the detailed, stellar vocal arrangements more so than even the chops of the instrumentalists that knocked me out---so well sung and recorded. That's not to say the jamming is anything less than impressive. During the instrumental sections of the title track, it was almost like something from The Sky Moves Sideways. The album at different times exudes gorgeous formlessness and other times a sense of fluidity more structured. Heavy, lighter, intoxicating ventures and melodies. Great stuff.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Scarsick by PAIN OF SALVATION album cover Studio Album, 2007
3.23 | 669 ratings

BUY
Scarsick
Pain Of Salvation Progressive Metal

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

3 stars When it comes to talent and ideas in Prog Metal is there a band more adventerous than PoS? Daniel Gildenlow and the boys always bring the goods, but with this 2007 release called "Scarsick" their fans for the most part turned on them. This is one of the most controversial albums on this site, and for good reason. Clocking in at a long 68 minutes and being very wordy(concept album) this was a challenge. The challenge being the disco and rap excursions. Man, they do it so well though.

When I first got into Prog this band was an early discovery as Prog Metal was my gateway into our music. I really enjoyed those first four studio albums but when it came to 2004's "Be" I just couldn't handle it. I mentioned at the time that if I actually had the time "Be" might work for me, but man, so ambitious to a fault. I do feel that Gildenlow is a brilliant composer and lyricist. And that seemed like his "Black Page" album but in a different way. So I gave that one 3 stars and decided to pass on "Scarsick" with the first five collaborators giving this record 1 to 2 stars reviews!

I came back to this band with 2015's "In The Passing Light Of Day" and what a great record. So great I decided to go back and get "Scarsick" and "Road Salt Pt.1", along with a couple of live records. I was back. This isn't labelled as such, but this is "The Perfect Element Pt.2" as that concept is continued here with the same character spewing his venom. Or is that Daniel? I agree with a lot of the lyrics, but also disagree strongly with others. While the music may not be as complex as the earlier records, with more of a focus on the words, this is one entertaining album!

I really don't like the album cover. I felt at first it didn't represent the music very well, as this is upbeat and fun much of the time. Later I realized that the cover represents the title track and "Cribcaged" quite well. The world is sick my friends. And the words here deal with a lot of the greed that seems to run most people's lives. Status is the goal, making a name for yourself, being wealthy. "The best things in life aren't things" is a sign I'll always appreciate that was on a school bill board during the covid lockdowns when I was running around from town to town unvaccinated. Can't believe I'm still alive(yawn).

My favourite track, and others have mentioned it as theirs too, is "Kingdom Of Loss". Some nice contrasts throughout between the fragile vocals and spoken words. Love the guitar after 5 minutes. "Idiocracy" is another standout piece and it reminds me of a Steven Wilson track with the high pitched vocals. The synths are a nice touch, and this is heavy. "Flame To The Moth" continues that heaviness but this one has extreme vocals that I'm not into. Talk about spitting the lyrics!

Controvery? How about the opener "Scarsick" with the first word we hear being "Sick!" then rapping follows. I'm reminded of ALICE IN CHAINS around 2 minutes. Controvery? How about "Spitfall" the second track which brings to mind LINCOLN PARK big time. Such negative and angry lyrics here. But I can relate. Controversy? How about "Cribcaged" with the "f" bombs and ranting. Controversy? How about "America" and while the music is fun and catchy, the lyrics are biting and unfair in my opinion. I like America.

Lastly. Controversy? "Disco Queen" track five. So the first five songs are all controversial for one reason or another. I find the second half much stronger and it brings it up to 3 stars in my world. Oh, that "Disco Queen" song is also the longest for you disco fans out there. A plus. The creativity that Gildenlow brings to the table is astonishing. "Be" and "Scarsick" are not 4 star records in my world, but I am so impressed with all that goes into the lyrics and music. A band that is not afraid to take risks, and they are not worried about offending their fan base. They did it their way. Thanks Frank.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Phantom Island by KING GIZZARD & THE LIZARD WIZARD album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.75 | 3 ratings

BUY
Phantom Island
King Gizzard & The Lizard Wizard Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Fercandio46

4 stars The story picks up where Flight b741 left off, because Phantom Island is nothing less than its sequel. From the cover art, where the flight with the eight little pigs collided, an orchestra of lizards and fish greets them with strings and wind instruments. As Stu Mackenzie and Ambrose Kenny-Smith themselves explained, the songs on Flight b741 were more "outrageous," while those on Phantom Island were more "laid-back." However, they are more compositionally ambitious, once again entering the microtonal world, where multiple notes are used per octave. However, KWLG manages to make one listen and enjoy the music as a festive breath of fresh air, a characteristic they haven't lost since their beginnings.

The inclusion of the orchestra, along with their cocktail of psychedelia, at times recalls the band Love, but there are also progressive, funk, krautrock, and space rock. The title track introduces us to the mood, accelerating toward the end, with a very appropriate coda, which leads seamlessly into the next track, as it gives the impression of listening to an entire recording session without a break, without giving a moment to breathe.

Both Lonely Cosmos and Silent Spirit have flamenco reminiscences; Panpsych, Spacesick, and Aerodynamic reach soaring peaks of deliberately chopped rhythms, woven together in a way that makes you want to see them play them live on the 2025 tour!

Ambrose Kenny-Smith's solo album, In Times, had already foreshadowed the wonderful period they were entering with a fusion of synth-pop, blues, glam rock, and psychedelia that was as Australian as it was thrilling. As usual, KWLG, with their multiple songwriting minds, accustoms us to expecting the unexpected; as King Crimson's Robert Fripp said, it's always the same, always different.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Omni by KARFAGEN album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.24 | 98 ratings

BUY
Omni
Karfagen Symphonic Prog

Review by Circuito_Prog

4 stars All Is One, and One Is Kalugin

If anyone was still unsure about Antony Kalugin's place in modern symphonic prog, OMNI lands as a direct and elegant answer. There are no empty gimmicks or pretentious concept-dressing here. What you get is a solid, inspired, and — most importantly — cohesive album from start to finish. And yes, it's made up of just two tracks. Want a two-song album done right? This is how you do it: two long suites where every section breathes, evolves, connects, and moves you. No filler, no awkward pauses.

Kalugin remains a creative machine — releasing music at an insane pace, and still keeping the quality consistently high. Actually, he keeps getting better. OMNI isn't just another good record from him — it's probably his best so far. It's got that vintage symphonic prog flavor, but with modern production that feels clean, warm, and alive. Nothing sounds artificial — everything feels organic.

One of the album's biggest strengths is its guest lineup. Richard Sinclair (Camel, Caravan) brings his classic and unmistakable touch. John Hackett adds that pastoral breeze so typical of old-school British prog. And the musicians from Mystery (yes, the Canadians) bring emotional depth and melodic weight right when it's needed. The vocals overall are packed with real feeling — no cookie-cutter singers or cold studio polish here. It's sung from the heart, and you can tell.

As for the musicianship — no complaints. The guitar work shines with tasteful, melodic lines that never overstay their welcome. Every note feels intentional. And the way the album builds its climax is just masterful. It all flows naturally — no clunky shifts or forced transitions. This is an album meant to be heard as a whole — and it earns that.

The "all is one, and one is all" concept isn't just some abstract idea thrown into the lyrics. It's reflected in how the different parts of the album speak to each other — like separate stories from the same shared consciousness. The music carries that message without pushing it too hard. That's its real strength: yes, it's progressive — but it's also human, honest, and full of emotion.

OMNI is a modern gem of symphonic prog. As classic as it is fresh, as technical as it is heartfelt. And once again, Kalugin absolutely delivers.

Music: ★★★★

Lyrics: ★★★★

Execution: ★★★★

Emotion: ★★★★

Production: ★★★★

Artwork: ★★★★

Average: ★★★★

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Out Of The Blue by ELECTRIC LIGHT ORCHESTRA album cover Studio Album, 1977
3.67 | 389 ratings

BUY
Out Of The Blue
Electric Light Orchestra Crossover Prog

Review by Lobster77

5 stars "Out of the Blue" would be ELO's double-platter it is thee piece-de-resistance of the ELO oeuvre. Standouts: the whole thing. The first side is graced with three potential #1's, namely the harmonic myriad "Turn to Stone', the windy rush of "Across the Border" and the delectable melodic curves of "Sweet Talking Woman". Side two moves through jungles and starlight with cyclic cohesion, juiced with a little Theremin tweaking from the Tandy hand ("Steppin' Out") and rowed upstream in a raft of Kongos-like percussion from the Bevan brigade. The second record unveils the wondrous "Concerto For A Rainy Day", a four part triumph launched in the key trills and string twills of "Standin' In The Rain", guided through the corridors of the space age greenhouse effects in "Thunder and Lightning" and relieved in the angular music hall glide of "Mr. Blue Sky". Finally, side four has the band pulling out their wildcards, with an ace in each hand: "Birmingham Blues" is all the latter needed in pop lovers accoutrements, "The Whale" is perfect adjunct to the Intergalactic Touring Band, and "Wild West Hero" is a consummate happy ending of cinematic proportions.

5.0 I recommend for Prog and Pop rock fans. One of my favorites.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Parasomnia by DREAM THEATER album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.02 | 276 ratings

BUY
Parasomnia
Dream Theater Progressive Metal

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars "Parasomnia" is the fifteenth full-length studio album by US progressive metal act Dream Theater. The album was released through InsideOut Music in February 2025. It´s the successor to "A View from the Top of the World" from 2021. There´s been one lineup change since the predecessor as original drummer Mike Portnoy has returned to the fold replacing Mike Mangini, who had held Portnoy´s seat warm since 2011, where Portoy left to concentrate on other projects. Although the split with Mangini was amicable, he was in fact fired to make room for Portnoy´s return.

Portnoy was always much more than "just" the drummer in Dream Theater as an integral part of the songwriting team and the production team, and also as one of the most active band members when it came to media interviews, and his return to Dream Theater has made huge waves on the progressive metal scene. "Parasomnia" has as a result been an even more highly anticipated new release from Dream Theater than usual (and it´s not like every Dream Theater album before this one haven´t been met with almost hysterical level fan expectations and media attention). They are indeed the most well known and respected progressive metal band in the world...

Stylistically "Parasomnia" is one of the darker and heavier releases in Dream Theater´s discography along with albums like "Awake" (1994) and "Train of Thought" (2003). But albums like "Metropolis, Part 2: Scenes From a Memory" (1999) and "Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence" (2002) are valid references too if you want something from the band´s past to compare "Parasomnia" to. It´s like the band have consciously looked back at their turn-of-the-century albums and have found inspiration there for this album. At this point James LaBrie doesn´t sing that many really high notes though and it´s probably a good idea that Dream Theater have composed the material to accommodate LaBrie´s voice. He can still sing and he has a distinct sounding voice, which suits Dream Theater´s sound well, but age and years of touring the world have taken a toll on his ability to hit the high notes (which is audible when you attend a Dream Theater concert these days). While it´s not LaBrie´s fault, it doesn´t help make the vocal part of "Parasomnia" more interesting and varied if you compare it to some of the band´s earlier releases, but of course that´s been a tendency for now many albums, so it shouldn´t come as a surprise to anyone.

Other than that Dream Theater are as well playing as ever. Four virtuoso instrumentalists in the same band writing and playing complex progressive metal is always worth the price of admission, but honestly the incredible musicianship doesn´t mask the fact that the songwriting could need some focus and attention. Even better an outside producer would be nice at this point (guitarist John Petrucci is again credited for producing), weeding out some of the less interesting parts and making the band focus on and develop upon some of the amazing songwriting ideas this album also features. While songs like "Night Terror" and "Midnight Messiah" are immediately catchy and memorable, it takes quite some time to get familiar with the remaining material, because it´s either not as hook laden or sometimes have a tendency to wander off into noodly territory, which of course is what we expect from Dream Theater, but it often feels like the technical playing isn´t a means to an end (read: an integral part of the composition), but just there because the band knows that this is what the fans expect.

The sound production is overall well sounding, heavy, and detailed, and it´s not surprising to learn that Andy Sneap is responsible for mixing and mastering "Parasomnia". There´s a heavy metallic tone to the album, which suits the material well. Upon conclusion "Parasomnia" is an album which leaves me biased when rating it. On one hand it´s probably exactly what most Dream Theater fans expected and wanted, but as a more casual fan it would have been nice if Portnoy´s return had brought some of the 1990s Dream Theater greatness with it...but it really doesn´t. This is just another high quality progressive metal release from Dream Theater in a long line of relatively similar sounding but still high quality post-2000 releases from the band. The only time they´ve truly challenged themselves since the early 2000s was with the release of "The Astonishing" (2016), but I guess the fan reactions (mine included) to that album made them think twice about ever experimenting with their core sound again.

While my review may come off as a bit harsh and negative, it should not be misunderstood as if I don´t think "Parasomnia" is a high quality release, because it certainly is. The dream/nightmare lyrical themes which grace all tracks on the album is also well thought out and implemented, and when all is said and done "Parasomnia" is overall a strong release from Dream Theater. A 4 star (80%) rating is deserved.

(Originally posted on Metal Music Archives).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Campana di Legno + Trappola per Topi by ZIO CROCIFISSO album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.83 | 3 ratings

BUY
Campana di Legno + Trappola per Topi
Zio Crocifisso Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Stoneburner

5 stars Another great project from Italy this time from Milan. Zio Crocifisso is a young and promising band leaning toward the avant-garde side of progressive music. Their sound is clearly influenced by bands like Sleepytime Gorilla Museum, yet they maintain a distinct and experimental identity of their own.

Their 2024 debut EP initially left me with mixed feelings. It felt somewhat unfinished, and I was left wanting more. However, with this 2025 release, I've come to better understand and appreciate their approach. While the core of the album still revolves around the material from the previous EP, the reordering of the tracks, the addition of new compositions, and the overall cohesion give it a new meaning and a much stronger impact.

Yes, part of me would have preferred a completely new release but the way they've recontextualized their earlier work, complemented by new pieces like Campana di Legno and Trappola per Topi, makes for a compelling and unique listening experience.

Musically, the album moves seamlessly between heavy doom metal passages, intense dissonance, and the sharp clarity of math metal. It's an impressive balancing act that demonstrates creativity and technical skill.

Zio Crocifisso has delivered a fascinating and bold album another strong entry in what's shaping up to be an extraordinary 2025 for progressive music.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 K.A (Köhntarkösz Anteria) by MAGMA album cover Studio Album, 2004
4.26 | 805 ratings

BUY
K.A (Köhntarkösz Anteria)
Magma Zeuhl

Review by Lobster77

4 stars Having practically invented a new genre, Christian Vander's Magma went on a 20 year hiatus back in 1984 after having released some of the most original pieces of music in their early years. K.A. was their triumphant return to the new millennium with an album that sounded fresh and modern without any significant innovations but focusing on retaining their characteristic sound and slowly pushing it forward. Magma's music, while loosely based on jazz rhythm patterns seeks to create a grandiose futuristic atmosphere that can sometimes feel rather cinematic. In order to achieve that they employ a choir of female singers to accompany the mostly baritone male vocals, creating an epic sounding wall of chanting in an incomprehensible yet strangely satisfying language. Their blend of jazz and rock borrows pieces from many other genres like prog and krautrock and incorporates them into a well organized structure, like on the closing track K.A.

The relative ease with which Magma seem to be able to create an epic atmosphere which is both highly energetic and seemingly varied is something that has kept them on the forefront of what avant-garde rock is all about. The twenty year pause did not seem to affect them, since their return shows a band that is very mature and knows exactly what to do, the transition into a new musical age though had been a rather steep one when it comes to their general aesthetic. Without losing their aforementioned epic sound, it seems as though the warmth and straightforwardness of their early material is replaced by a colder much more calculated sound which can be disheartening at times. Regardless of that K.A. is still a strong addition to their lengthy discography and a fine entry point precisely as an effect of that modern sound.

4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Our Road to Dust by EDENSONG album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.48 | 14 ratings

BUY
Our Road to Dust
Edensong Eclectic Prog

Review by alainPP

5 stars "Of Ascents" with a vintage folk intro, acoustic guitar notes rippling out and opening for "The Illusion of Permanence" flirting between energetic rock and crazy heavy rock, bordering on occult djent with a jerky riff; an intoxicating choir, a fiery growl, the chorus leering at the great PAIN OF SALVATION. A zest of tulle flute before the chopped return of the colorful prog metal sound. The outro between bass and clear percussions of the ambient drums delivers the fatal note. "These Old Wounds" follows with a rumble of the pad and the flute, covering the musical sky on the dark gray. A light flute swing and aerial vocals from the 70s and the modern heavy return on top, just to avoid getting bogged down in regressive nostalgia. The bass break and martial drums before the dynamite folk solo of the 60s and the bouncing guitar, the swelling air of musical lava before the return of this frenetic flute surfing the wild rhythms of the GILDENLOW brothers; regression and innovation. "Black Crow" for the captivating vocal harmony, Josh, Emily and Alana coming to support TD and James by launching into a warm chorus; it fits well with this typical folk sound that follows, a mixture of MEER and psychedelic JETHRO TULL, disconcerting and nostalgic flirting with the 60s. Great art based on vintage keyboards, electronics and wild vocals; a tribal acoustic fade comes to rest our senses before "Hall of Statues" with its melodic Mandarin air, tambourine in front. The vocal is whispered with dark heavy waves on the flute and Barry's bass duo. Decadent prog rock with a nasty atmosphere leading to a pleasant waking nightmare.

"Book of Complaints" for its dark rock feel worthy of GHOST; a track surfing on grunge alternative rock with an expressive undertone, an explosion of sounds bordering on noise, musical chaos, a parable about their turbulent professional and artistic relationships, a touch schizoid. The sound demonstrates their vitality in a short piece; it moves everywhere, as catchy as can be. "Of Ascents (Reprise)" where everything is written to take a break from the previous Book of Complaints and its paradoxical creative madness. "Wykkr Bäsct" for its instrumental slap with bass and violins; a frenetic, playful, folky tune with Barry's extraordinary flute. From the Balkans or Romania, this track is stunning thanks to its big riff, held in the style of Robert's SUICIDAL TENDENCIES. Explosive rock before the finale and "Our Road to Dust" as an epic title, the vocals phrasing over the invasive organ and its Genesis-like undertones, the addictive Tulle flute. Traces on OVERHEAD, between grandiloquence and the air of a fishing port tavern, between steady rhythm and tenderness, distilling to the world this unique sound that is a pleasure to hear. The guitar break is plaintive then scintillating, chopping and going solo with Barry on GENESIS again. Innovative, modern, energetic, and not at all soporific.

EDENSONG has released a little progressive bomb with a strange sound, with the flute as a bonus, and choruses of buccaneering sailors. This second-rate band explodes in your face, offering a concentrated blend combining the power of hard rock with devastating melancholy. Originally on profilprog. (4.75)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ghost in the Old Tape by STRANGE POP album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.38 | 7 ratings

BUY
Ghost in the Old Tape
Strange Pop Crossover Prog

Review by alainPP

3 stars "In the Garden" in electro mode, mid-tempo, synths in front with an acoustic guitar pounding out its notes, a sound that directly looks at the 80s atmosphere like 'Subway' with the heavy bass. We move forward calmly with Mike with his captivating, languid voice; the hushed outro on VANGELIS synths. "Dempsey and Makepeace" his obvious 80s; between new wave and the synths used in Z-series films like John CARPENTER, who has become a reference. The chorus is danceable, on DEPECHE MODE, I give leads, or OMD; in short the ghosts of the old tracks have an effect. "Old Mansions" electro, hip hop, ethereal, indie, an ambient synthetic sound with progressive, addictive notes, a touch spatial, cinematic, twisting in the room. A minimalist piano and the electronic hum for this simple but devilishly effective instrumental. 'In Your Eyes (School Love)' is a groovy track based on Sean's funky-sexy vocals and bass for the sober nursery rhyme, in the radio edit tradition, yes, but that of the 80s.

'The Longest Night' with electro keyboards reminiscent of ULTRAVOX, a focused atmosphere; a minimalist, laid- back vibe reminiscent of the work of JAPAN, the reminiscences are flowing. Cloudy choirs ā la 10CC, a nostalgic atmosphere, the solemn synth solo taking the lead, captivating before drifting into psychedelic tinkering. The beautiful finale with a distant Gregorian choir, ERA for me. Time contracts for these diffuse and persistent memories. 'VHS Ninja' with its muffled, dark, strange atmosphere, a cartoon turtle? The electronic pad slams, leaving the keyboard notes reverberating, a fitting resemblance to a track on GENESIS's 'Duke'. The spatial, contemplative atmosphere, the talking synth on this second instrumental reminiscent of those of suspense master John CARPENTER. 'Halley's Comet' as an interlude or film finale, the crystalline, metallic, foreshadowing, and divinatory keyboard sound. 'Requiem for My Childhood' is a case in point; the long, ethereal, icy, and gentle piece, ambient and prophetic, about a vanished world, and a slow crescendo creating a dreamlike vintage atmosphere; the keyboard reminiscent of those used on MANFRED MANN'S EARTH BAND. The outro, two-thirds of the way through the planned breakup, resembles a (re)awakening, and the fade-out, like a subliminal message, on the fifth album.

STRANGE POP releases a tribute to the '80s, resisting cold digital with its warm and organic analog sound. An easy- listening album without much pretension that makes you dream and revisit our world of yesterday, yet interesting today. Originally released on Profilprog.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Solar Maximum  by MAJEURE album cover Studio Album, 2012
3.53 | 7 ratings

BUY
Solar Maximum
Majeure Progressive Electronic

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

3 stars 3.5 stars. MAJEURE is the solo project of drummer and electronics musician Anthony Pattera. He is one half of the duo known as ZOMBI and I believe he took the name MAJEURE from that TANGERINE DREAM album "Force Majeure". And that would make sense considering that drums and electronics dominate that record and this project. "Solar Maximum" is his second release from 2012 and Anthony does it all, the the instruments, the production and the composing.

I have his debut "Timespan" from 2009 and feel it's the better record. It's all subjective of course but that one really impressed me with how inventive he was with his use of the electronics, and the way he combined these electronic/synth sounds. It was fun and catchy and a breath of fresh air. This one feels more mature, more level headed. It seems like each track is arranged in a similar way. But I really like his sound. This one is more melancholic and there's less drums compared to his debut.

We get six tracks worth 44 minutes. Plenty of sequencers here along with spacey synths. The latter are just gorgeous on the closer "Solar Maximum 2" as well as on "Extreme Northern Lights". Just beautiful. The song with the most energy is the title track which is also the longest one at 11 1/2 minutes. I quite enjoyed my time with this one but it will be "Timespan" that will be my "go to" MAJEURE album in the future.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Later That Evening by WEBER, EBERHARD album cover Studio Album, 1982
3.88 | 24 ratings

BUY
Later That Evening
Eberhard Weber Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Intorikata

4 stars To begin, I gave this only 4 stars because...is it really prog? Rock? Neither fits well. Jazz doesn't fit well as a descriptor, either.

I'm writing this review as a realization just struck me, regarding this album: it may be Eberhard's best in terms of artistry, composition, and realization of a vision. There is a conversation to be had at the least. Previously I would have ranked it (except for "Death in the Carwash," strange creature that it is) just below the entire Colours (and THE FOLLOWING MORNING) catalogue, but its consistent level of achievement and integrity struck me tonight. He has albums I like more (though not by much), albums with certainly better tracks (again, however, the margin is narrow), but as an Artistic Statement...the coherence of the group, the individual tracks, the compositions and arrangements, the FEEL of the album...it is only surpassed by perhaps THE COLOURS OF CHLOË and PENDULUM. Perhaps.

It is mysterious and challenging, clear and direct, accessible and welcoming. I feel the lineup are all playing on the same wavelength to a degree we didn't get since the best moments of YELLOW FIELDS, and because of that, Eberhard's compositions -among his best, by the way- truly shine.

Enough gushing - perhaps it is the accompaniment by Two- Hearted Ale, but... consider my 4 stars a hot take and "rage bait" - LATER THAT EVENING deserves 5 stars, but I'm not sure it belongs to prog.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Les cygnes et les corbeaux by VANDER, CHRISTIAN album cover Studio Album, 2002
3.77 | 19 ratings

BUY
Les cygnes et les corbeaux
Christian Vander Zeuhl

Review by bartymj

3 stars Apparently this took a decade to put together: An hour-long eerie orchestral piece, operatic, celestial, and unmistakably Vander. Although understandably filed under Zeuhl, with the falsetto and chanting vocals, slow repetition and ominous mood, it's a classical and choral piece in its own right. Vander is a multi-instrumental talent, here ditching the drums for piano trills and synthesised classical instruments, and doing it brilliantly. Classical music is a long way from my comfort zone though so my mind eventually drifted elsewhere while listening through it, getting slightly bored despite the often complex nature of it, but there's absolutely no doubting it is brilliantly well crafted.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Troubled Mind by DEREV album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.75 | 11 ratings

BUY
Troubled Mind
Derev Progressive Metal

Review by alainPP

4 stars Derev combines old-school metal and progressive rock with Arab-Armenian sounds. "Buried Voice" opens with a dark alternative, a melody that changes tempo, the vocals flirting with the sounds of Katatonia and Antimatter. The immaculate softness is accentuated by the bass, with Adel amplifying it; a synth break from The Who takes hold, the sound takes off again, captivating, between gray autumn skies and the plains of Kazakhstan. "Cyclone" begins with a cyclical riff, the redundant note both hypnotic and languorous. A classic evolution through the instrumentation bringing musical tension, the lyrics about imposter syndrome. Between doubt and regret, a velvety, melancholic guitar solo to crush any feeling of rebellion. A beautiful progressive exercise, the final fade-out with "Crawl Space" links the cinematic moment filled with a feeling of melancholy, violin, and latent atmosphere. The piano comes from a stressful spatial limbo. "Room 9" explodes, dark prog metal, raw energy, punchy rhythms, a captivating atmosphere with this machine-gun drumming. The riff ticks by, the velvety synth, Armando's sharp guitar solo on a Balkan air; a heavy outro to nod along to.

"Paracusia" with a porcupine riff, velvety synth, and chatty bass, a proven funky instrumental. A true auditory hallucination bringing the guitar to a dynamite jazzy-progressive side. "Tides of Time" is an alternative melancholic ballad with a time signature shifting from 7/8 to 4/4 and a sound reminiscent of the desperate melodic hard rock of the 90s. The guitar solo disarms with its captivating spleen. "Darker Self" with an oriental drum pad, a disarming riff, acoustic with a cajon, everything to send you into a musical trance. A track reminiscent of Soundgarden, Spock's Beard, Rush, and the Von Hertzen Brothers, very varied. The staccato, captivating tune, a sublime guitar solo, further enhances the intoxicating atmosphere. "Trace Within" is ethereal with its Floydian keyboard and gravelly vocals; an atmospheric piece with its airy guitar, a languid vocal duet worthy of Anathema with Hiske as a guest, supported by bursts of piano and a warm darbuka.

Introspective retro prog with a captivating, innovative melancholy. A charming, contemplative, progressive, melodic, and alternative opus, a stunning album oozing with a progressive vibe; a new sound that refers solely to their ideas and pushes back the prog trend. An avant-garde album to keep an eye on. Originally released on Progcensor.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Love by FLOWER KINGS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.69 | 64 ratings

BUY
Love
The Flower Kings Symphonic Prog

Review by yarstruly

4 stars This week has an album that I have been looking forward to for a couple of months, since Hasse Fröberg put up a video of the pre-release single "How Can You Leave Us Now". The full album was released 5 days ago (as I type this? it'll be 10 days when I publish it). The album is called "Love". Please see my Spotlight on the band's long and complex history (Scott Rich on Facebook). The line-up for this album is mostly consistent with the previous album "Look at You Now" from 2023. (That album has one of my earliest, much more informal reviews on Facebook.) The only exception being that keyboardist Lalle Larson is now listed as a full member. The full line up is as follows:

- Roine Stolt / vocals, electric, acoustic, 6- & 12-string guitars, ukulele - Hasse Fröberg / vocals - Lalle Larsson / grand piano, Rhodes piano, Hammond B3, synthesizers - Michael Stolt / bass, moogbass, vocals - Mirko DeMaio / drums & percussion

With: - Hasse Bruniusson / percussion - Jannica Lund / vocals - Aliaksandr Yasinski / accordion - Jacob Collier / "world choirs"

There are two tracks over 10 minutes in length, while the rest range between 2 and 8 minutes in length. This is a mostly cold listen, having only heard "We Claim the Moon" and "How Can You Leave Us Now" previously. Without further ado, let's listen!

Track 1- We Claim the Moon

This begins with some sound effects fading in, then some marimba (I think), before a cut time beat and a cool riff with a 60's vibe kicks in. Great organ sound at around 40 seconds. The vocals from Hasse Fröberg begin at around 1 minute, before the riff takes back over. Beautiful arranging as we get ready for the first verse. There is more marimba or whichever similar percussion instrument that is prior to the vocals coming in fully. This is a high energy track! Nice harmonies around 2:30. The dynamic level comes down around the 3 minute mark, and Hasse sings with a jazzy backdrop. I love all of the dynamic shifts. The rhythm goes to a halftime beat before 4 minutes. Lots of full, lush chords there. It comes way down at around 5:15 and there is a very cool keyboard feature from Lalle Larson. There is a big finish at around 6:10, but then some sequenced synth sounds keep going that take us to the fade-out. Great, high-energy opening track!

Track 2 - The Elder

This is the longest one at 11:10. The title reminds me of 1981's "(Music From) The Elder" by KISS, the closest they ever got to prog, but I digress?

A glockenspiel melody starts us off here, establishing the melody that is soon repeated by vocals in harmony. I believe Hasse & Roine are alternating on vocals here. This one has an inspirational ballad vibe to it. After a verse/chorus, there is a pause then a drum fill leads us to a melodic guitar solo. There is a new melody following, starting with Roine's voice, then Hasse's. Things begin to build up at around the 4 minute mark. But then mellow out with a keyboard feature. The next verse is slightly more up-tempo. Another guitar solo follows. A sustained power chord takes us to ethereal keyboards, then a variation of the chorus, before an instrumental section begins in true FK's style. The instrumental brings us to a quieter vocal section sung by Roine. Then there is another keyboard feature. The music gets "big" at 10 minutes. This is a quintessential Flower Kings track. After a few guitar flourishes, the track fades out on sustained synth chords. A good solid FK track; I enjoyed it, even if it didn't blow me away.

Track 3 - How Can You Leave Us Now!?

Piano chords start us off, and Michal Stolt joins on fretless bass. Roine's vocals begin at around 40 seconds in. After a verse, there are classically influenced flourishes, joined by guitar, then synth. A harmony vocal section joins next. The drums have been limited to cymbal rolls and occasional accents so far. The drums become steady around 3:30 or so. Lead guitar joins in at just before the 5 minute point. A quieter section resolves the song. Good ballad. I can see why that was the lead off single.

Track 4 - World Spinning

This is one of the two tracks that are sub-3-minutes, and the shortest overall at 2:10. A nice amalgam of keyboard tones starts this off. Lalle Larson's presence is really felt on this album. There is a neat "hopping" tone before one minute. This seems to be a keyboard solo. I like it. I get some Wakeman influences. I wouldn't have minded a bit more of that.

Track 5- Burning Both Edges

This is the third longest track at 7:50. Foreboding sounds start this off, but they are softened by the keyboard sounds. Hasse is singing in a dreamy high-register tone. Nice key change at 1:45! I like the arrangement at around 2:15 with the layers of sound there. There are occasional panned synth flourishes over the vocals. This is a mid- tempo so far. The instrumental break around 3:40 is quite nice. Vocals return by 4:10. A guitar solo begins at around 4:35, that gives me Carlos Santana vibes. Synth takes back over around 5:15. Great run at 5:38. Excellent FK's BIG moment around 6:15! I think this one is my favorite so far! The ending has a nice crescendo. Great track!

Track 6 - The Rubble

This one has a bluesy vibe. I like the contrasting vocal and instrumental sections. Cool groove at 1:50. I like the conga drums. The chorus has a catchy hook "walking in the rubble, getting into trouble". At about 2:40 we have a guitar solo, followed by keyboard/guitar harmonies. We begin leading up to the finish at around the 4 minute mark, but it kind of just fizzles out. Pretty good, but I would have liked a more defined ending.

Track 7- Kaiser Razor

This is the other one that clocks in below 3 minutes at 2:32. An organ chord fades in and we get a big dramatic FK intro. Following that the piano takes the lead, with a nice drum pattern from Mirko. I like the rhythms in this. Excellent guitar run just before 1:30. This seems to be a nice little instrumental. It would make a good intro to an epic. Roine's guitar playing is on fire here. Great track, but I want more of it! I'm wondering if Kaiser Razor is the guy on the album cover?

Track 8 - The Phoenix

A slow fade in leads to a big strummed acoustic chord, then a slow tempo is established with bass & keys joining in. The vocals begin for a verse, then the drums join in. This seems to be a bit of a duet between Roine & Hasse. Roine takes a nice melodic guitar solo at around the 2 minute mark. Awesome harmonies around 3:10. The instruments fade out to bring us to a close. Beautiful ballad.

Track 9 - The Promise

A slow organ melody starts us off, then Roine begins singing with acoustic guitar and organ. There are some wonderful harmonies as we progress. There is accordion at around 1:20, then the band kicks in with a faster tempo. The sound is very charming. The drums drop out and the others play some call & response type melodies. Another verse follows. As we approach the ending there is a moment where they sing the word "celebrations" over and over in harmony. The instruments bring us to the conclusion of the song.

Track 10 - Love Is

Clean electric and unique vocals begin the song. The synths and other instruments play a few figures, then we get another BIG FKs moment, before the first full verse begins. Roine and Hasse are sharing vocal duties on this. Nice drum fill from Mirko at 2 minutes. That leads us into a transitional part, followed by what I can best describe as a "circus band march". Vocals join that beat. By 3 minutes we have returned to a more rock tone. Great accents at around 3:15. Lots of various melodies and tempo changes are happening here. Mirko gets a moment of unaccompanied drumming at around 5 minutes. This one has a very classic FKs sound. Great track!

Track 11 - Walls of Shame

This begins softly with some free time sound effects and guitar licks. The verse begins to give us some rhythm. The beat gets stronger as we proceed. Hasse seems to be taking the lead in the vocals on this one but Roine's voice is present too. This one is more mid-tempo. Nice wah-wah guitar solo around the 3 minute mark. This song is also signature FKs in sound. Roine and Hasse may be the only constants for the FK career, and Roine's brother Michael (an early member of the line-up) returned a couple of albums back, but Lalle and Mirko are doing a great job at creating the classic FKs tone. Hasse is giving a top-notch vocal performance as the song reaches its climax. Fantastic track!

Track 12 - Considerations

The final track is the second longest at 10:15. A drum fill leads us in, with what sounds like a mellotron in the prominent role. Roine's lead guitar takes over and by 1 minute he is using a slide. I love the piano and guitar flourishes during the transition from the intro to the next section. Things get quiet and dreamy keys and glockenspiel make a bed for the vocals, which are in a low register. I believe that this is Michal Stolt on lead vocals here; he sounds like a lower range version of his brother. There are some question and answer vocal harmonies as we proceed. Nice tempo change after 3 minutes. The instrumental sound is pure FKs, but Michael's vocal sound brings a new color to the palette. Roine takes a guitar solo around 5:30. Lalle follows with a fantastic synth solo. The music pauses briefly at 7 minutes, and there is a flute sound and harpsichord in a very classical sounding section, with Michael's vocals resuming. Then we get a big FKs guitar-led melodic instrumental section. Things seem to be building to a climax as the mellotron returns. There was a nice sweep picking arpeggio from Roine right around 9 minutes. Things quiet down before a crescendo brings us to the closing. Harmony vocals sort of float by in the final seconds. Amazing track!!

OVERALL IMPRESSIONS:

This is a solid album overall, even though some of the songs along the way do seem a bit mellow and not as energetic as I might have preferred. That said, the songs are all well-written, arranged, and produced. It kicks off energetically on track 1, then eases off for a bit on tracks 2 and 3, before picking up again on tracks 4-7. It eases off again on tracks 8 and 9 then finishes strong on the final three tracks. 2, 3, 8, and 9 aren't bad, just not as strong as the others to me. I'll give this a 4.5 out of 5 stars. Roine and company are still a force to be reckoned with in the prog world!

Clicked 4 but really 4.5!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Njene oci, usne, ruke by INDEXI album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 1980
2.00 | 5 ratings

BUY
Njene oci, usne, ruke
Indexi Crossover Prog

Review by Seyo
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

2 stars The twenty-fifth 7-inch record by Indexi was released at the end of 1980. At the same time, this was the 11th single released by Jugoton. Graphic designer Ivan Ivezic prepared a multicolored combination (blue, green, red, and yellow) for the cover, which seems to evoke a modernist artistic image of a setting sun on the horizon. Consciously or not, the image also indicates that Indexi were at the twilight of their career at this point, at least when it came to their recording and concert activities. They were acting less and less like a cohesive band, and would gather only occasionally for performances at popular music festivals. They had long since ceased to be considered a rock group worthy of attention, and during the year of the fierce breakthrough of the new wave in Yugoslavia (in 1980, notable records were released by Azra, Pankrti, Prljavo kazaliste, Paraf, while the Belgrade trio - Sarlo akrobata, Elektricni orgazam, and Idoli recorded material for the "Paket aranzman" LP, which soon dominated the radio waves and charts), they were almost not mentioned at all in the media and music press. Consequently, this single went largely unnoticed. Although not stated anywhere on the record itself, these are two songs that Indexi performed at festival events, two years apart. The recording studio is unknown to me, although records from the RTV Sarajevo phonotheque indicate that it was likely the Sarajevo studio. At this time, the band still consisted of: Slobodan A. Kovacevic - guitar, Davorin Popovic - vocals, Fadil Redzic - bass guitar, Nenad Jurin - keyboards, and Djordje Kisic - drums.

The hit track on the A-side, "Njene oci, usne, ruke" ("Her Eyes, Lips, Hands"), represents another compositional contribution by the Belgrade schlager maestro Aleksandar Korac, with lyrics by the little-known Ivica Vidric. Indexi performed it on June 28th at the "Vas slager sezone" festival in Sarajevo, and according to phonotheque data, it was recorded in the studio on March 20th, 1980. As I have already pointed out in reviews of earlier singles, Korac's name was not a guarantee of the musical quality we were accustomed to from Indexi, and his works too often approached the border of good taste. Music critic Ognjen Tvrtkovic shared a similar opinion, writing in Oslobodjenje daily on July 1st, 1980, immediately after the festival: "Indexi continue to profane themselves by performing sloppy schlagers by A. Korac, which even a high standard of interpretation does not save from swift oblivion." However, listening to this track today, after several decades, reveals some interesting musical details. The arrangers Kovacevic and Ismet Arnautalic, a former member of the band, were certainly responsible for the "high standard of interpretation" of this song. It has a strong, almost danceable rhythm with a bass guitar featuring a pronounced disco groove. The drums are somewhat muffled, and a particularly interesting detail is that the rhythm of the song is maintained throughout, almost metronomically without pause, by small hand percussion instruments - maracas and a ratchet. The guitar occasionally interjects with its melodic riff, supported by synthesizers whose tones sometimes venture into rhythmic electropop. Popovic frequently uses his famous vocal vibrato, and backing vocals also appear in certain places, making it difficult to say whether it's his multitracking or if Redzic joins in with his well- known falsetto. Despite justified criticism of Korac's "signature," the song still sounds solid today, although it is certainly not a great achievement, and indeed, as time would show, it was quickly forgotten. At the time of its release, "Njene oci..." was nevertheless a minor hit, as evidenced by a video clip from the Sarajevo studio that can be found on YouTube.

The B-side features a song that was not released for the first time here. "Oj, Neretvo" ("Oh, Neretva") is a patriotic song with lyrics by Miso Maric, evoking memories of the Partisans and their battles from World War II. The phonotheque records the recording date as October 29th, 1978, and it was performed in November of the same year at the "Festival of Patriotic and Revolutionary Songs" in Zagreb. It first appeared on a festival "cocktail" album in December 1978. Indexi had tried their hand at this genre before ("Jugoslavija" and "Zivjela Jugoslavija"), which was a common practice for many popular performers at the time, especially in the period immediately following the death of Yugoslav President Josip Broz Tito (he died in May 1980). Since Indexi did not have enough new material at the time, Jugoton's editors decided to re-release this older composition for the commemorative occasion. As for the song itself, let's first set aside the heart-rending and for-the-moment "commissioned" lyrics. The musical texture is quite impressive and falls within the framework of a somewhat "lighter" intoned symphonic prog rock, typical of Indexi. A somber and serious atmosphere is emphasized by the striking of (tubular?) bells, while the guitar sobs a mournful melody. The drums and bass enter powerfully into the sonic picture, accompanied by an acoustic guitar. Kovacevic embellishes the track with a beautiful guitar solo, but the part of the chorus where they sing "Sutjeska, Neretva" is not very good, both due to poor intonation and awkward rhymes in the lyrics. Nevertheless, this song, at least in its basic musical part composed and arranged by Kovacevic, deserves a passing grade.

PA rating: 2/5 Personal rating: 3/5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Even in Arcadia by SLEEP TOKEN album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.16 | 14 ratings

BUY
Even in Arcadia
Sleep Token Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Circuito_Prog

2 stars

Well-Produced Emptiness

Even In Arcadia is one of those albums that, on paper, should be huge ? a mix of hip hop, R&B, trap, pop, djent, atmospheric textures, and a vocalist with a super distinctive voice. It all sounds ambitious, but the execution ends up feeling like a mash-up of the most overused elements from each genre, without that "something" to make it stand out.

From the start, the album shows its cards: smooth beats, tightly processed guitars, familiar melodies and vocal tricks. But as it goes on, the whole thing starts to drag. I honestly struggled to finish it. Not because it's "bad", but because it just feels empty. There's a constant emotional disconnect, a lack of soul ? especially compared to the last record, where every song felt like a personal confession.

Vessel is still a talented performer, no doubt, but here his vocals fall into the same patterns ? melodically and lyrically. The autotune and heavy vocal processing don't help either. Instead of adding emotion, they end up hiding it. And it's not like autotune is the enemy ? when used intentionally, it can actually work ? but here it feels more like a stylistic crutch than a creative choice that gives weight to the music.

There are moments ? some instrumental bits, cool harmonies, nice vocal lines ? where you feel like something great could happen. But it doesn't. The ideas just float there, unresolved and undeveloped. They get lost in predictable song structures or get buried under layers of production that don't let the music breathe.

The lyrics, meanwhile, aim for something honest and personal, but too often end up sounding like a string of social-media-ready one-liners. It feels more preachy than cathartic, and doesn't really connect with the music in a meaningful way.

Even In Arcadia isn't a trainwreck, but it is a letdown. A collection of nice little fragments with no clear direction, watered down. It tried to do too much, but in the end, it leaves you with almost nothing.

Music: ★

Lyrics: ★★

Execution: ★★★

Emotion: ★

Production: ★★★★

Artwork: ★

Average: ★★

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Live in Nottingham by SKY album cover Live, 2002
3.05 | 13 ratings

BUY
Live in Nottingham
Sky Eclectic Prog

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

3 stars Pleasant but not world-shaking live album from Sky, available in various editions - the most complete being the one included in the Studio Albums 1979-1987 boxed set from Esoteric, despite the fact that it's not a studio album and isn't from that time period. In fact, it hails from 1990 and captures the last lineup of the band as they headed towards a dignified but not spectacular fade-out to their career; despite playing live at this time they didn't feel they had the material to knock out another studio album and decided to put the project to bed. The material here tends towards the gentler "easy listening jazz fusion" side of their sound, so don't expect pyrotechnics, but then again they were never that pyrotechnic of a group to begin with.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Natasha by OLDFIELD, SALLY album cover Studio Album, 1990
3.38 | 11 ratings

BUY
Natasha
Sally Oldfield Crossover Prog

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

3 stars It's been said by at least one person whose insights I value that artists who lost their way in the 1980s often found the plot again in the 1990s. Unfortunately, once the audience skedaddles it's hard to recover their trust. For SALLY OLDFIELD, "Natasha" seems self aware in its circling back to matching generally mystical lyrics with more suitable arrangements and production, including the return to her hypnotic repetitive figures best exemplified in "In the Presence of the Spring", her best track in a decade.

Even on the opener, with all its technological flare, the percussion and shout-chanted vocals seem to correct the errors of the prior two or three releases, with even her silky voice on the rise. The dreamy ballad "Natasha" is by several accounts an ode to herself as she is sometimes known by this name, perhaps a clever alteration of her middle name "Patricia". "Clear Light" is a trance like brief incantation, so by the time we get to the ripoff of a tune from her first album, it's obvious that at least some of what's here is in the same league.

Slipping in at just under 3.5 stars, "Natasha" is a mature effort that suggests this experienced singer, songwriter and musician has found inspiration in sincere self reflection.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Orphan Epoch by COSMOGRAF album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.90 | 2 ratings

BUY
The Orphan Epoch
Cosmograf Neo-Prog

Review by Second Life Syndrome
Prog Reviewer

5 stars Cosmograf is a very consistent project, but I noticed recently that I tend to love an album, then just enjoy the next, then love the following one, and so on. So, starting with the first one I heard, The Man Left in Space, I loved it, then only partially connected with Capacitor, then adored The Unreasonable Silence, and on and on. That trend has stopped, however. I absolutely loved 2022's Heroic Materials, and now Robin is launching The Orphan Epoch on May 23rd, and it is close to tying with Mind Over Depth as my favorite from him.

Robin Armstrong of the UK is the brains behind the project. When I say "brains", I really do mean that since Cosmograf is lyrically heady and precisely composed in a way that only a perfectionist could produce. He brings with him fantastic drummer Kyle Fenton, and Peter Jones guests on saxophone on one track.

This album represents some changes in Cosmograf. I mean, the sound is basically the same: progressive rock with some edge. But I sense something different, not so much an evolution as a full realization of the project's style. Robin doesn't seem shy about flexing his guitarist muscles anymore, and the keys, too, are gorgeous and played with aplomb. With the excellent rhythm section, towering saxophone spot, and continued strong lyrics, this album feels more completely Cosmograf.

The album addresses the divide that society wants to place between groups of people. This choice is most often binary, never nuanced or accounting for other ideas. They want to herd us into one of two labels, which I suppose would make it easier to control. The Orphan Epoch sets this as a foundation but then discusses young people and the disconnection and disinformation that is fed to them as they grow to become the next generation. What future awaits? Can the world handle such toxicity and lies?

The album has seven songs and they are all terrific. The singles "Kings and Lords" and "You Didn't See the Thief" are both outstanding; I love how hard the former rocks, and how the backing vocals add a sense of sobriety and history. Robin's guitar solo near the end is pure fire. The latter is even better, though, with its reserved character, electronic tone, and robust instrumental. What a great song!

But, you know, those aren't even my favorites. I love the opener "Division Warning", a pumping and powerful track with celestial keys and a sense of urgency. "We Are the Young" follows with more of an acoustic sound, but that marches into a whirling organ atmosphere of choices and confusion and melody.

My favorite track on the album is "Seraphim Reels", feeling a bit like a 2000s Porcupine Tree song with an injection of saxophone. I absolutely adore how Peter is featured throughout; Robin's voice is perhaps the most vulnerable and expressive that it's ever been. It's honestly a quieter track for the most part, but Peter lays down a thrilling, gritty sax solo that blows me away every time. I love how Robin's guitar takes its lead, ending the track in a deeply satisfying way.

The last two tracks on the album are both winners, too. "Empty Box" is a softer song that mostly floats in dark spaces with Robin's vocals. I like how it briefly erupts near the end, but the song works very well as an introspective break in the music. The closer "The Road of Endless Miles" doesn't try to impress with fancy tricks; no, this piece is pure and golden rock with fantastic guitar work, a memorable rhythmic hook, and an ambience that makes me want to listen forever. Between the gorgeous piano and melodic guitar work, the song easily becomes a favorite even if just because it sounds so damn attractive.

Cosmograf's albums are always worth the time, and it feels like Robin is only getting better at what he does. This album is quintessential Cosmograf, more so than anything else he's produced. Combine that with some of the feelings of Porcupine Tree's Fear of a Blank Planet, and you have a potent record that prog rock fans absolutely must hear.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Curious Ruminant by JETHRO TULL album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.40 | 100 ratings

BUY
Curious Ruminant
Jethro Tull Prog Folk

Review by Etherea

3 stars 'Curious Ruminant' finds Jethro Tull's Ian Anderson yet again floating on a cloud of neo-classical massage parlour music. This one however is a solid set of melodic, flute-tinged rock in the style of the group's late 70s Folk-themed albums like 'Heavy Horses' and 'Songs From the Wood'. In slight contrast to the previous two studio releases, this 9 track album is somewhat more concise and accessible- the only cons being Anderson's failing stage whispers and the lightweight production which undermine the muscularity of the band- particularly the guitars. This sameness of approach does not serve Ian Anderson well and I strongly believe that a different producer with a younger set of ears would energise the Tull sound next time. Having said that, this third album in as many years is a step above the previous two.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Tranceportation - Volume 1 (with David Torn) by SONAR album cover Studio Album, 2019
4.23 | 28 ratings

BUY
Tranceportation - Volume 1 (with David Torn)
Sonar RIO/Avant-Prog

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars SONAR invited David Torn back for the second straight studio album after the success of 2018's "Vortex". Here we are a year later with "Tranceportation-Volume 1" but this time the music has been composed with David Torn in mind. Despite this fact I still prefer "Vortex" to this one. I was really hoping this album might crack my top three SONAR related albums, but no. A solid 4 stars but this one doesn't move out of it's comfort zone, being quite uniform sounding throughout, to the point each track sounds very similar.

I still have "Vortex" and "Three Movements" as my favourite SONAR records then add Stephan Thelen's "Fractal Guitar" and you have my top three. Love the tritone guitars and bass on this one. A five piece lineup including Torn as we have three guitarists with both Stephan Thelen and Bernhard Wagner playing tritone guitars. Torn doesn't. He has his electric plus adds live looping. Christian Kuntner on bass is a big improvement with his tritone bass to the FRACTAL SEXTET bass sound. And I found that band to be too minimalistic.

It is pretty cool the atmosphere and spacey sounds that are created through the guitars. No keyboards here. Manuel Pasquinelli is like a Swiss clock on drums and percussion. This album sounds amazing clocking in at a tidy 39 minutes over four tracks. I won't describe the tracks as I will be repeating myself constantly. A top ten for 2019 but I will take Stephan Thelen's "Fractal Guitar" also from 2019 over this in a heartbeat. This music is incredible to listen to when driving I might add.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Instincts by OLDFIELD, SALLY album cover Studio Album, 1988
2.16 | 11 ratings

BUY
Instincts
Sally Oldfield Crossover Prog

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

2 stars The general lyrical theme on this 1988 album seems to relate to how much better the world would be if we were just honest with one another, as people and entities, and relied on our instincts. Well...if this didn't work in 1968, it wasn't going to work 20 years later. If only that were the biggest problem here.

"Instinct" isn't a whole lot different from its predecessor "Femme" in its polished production and arrangements, though perhaps with a tad less backbone, a possible consequence of Oldfield ceding many of the songwriting credits to others. The very good but hardly a near classic "House of Silence" is a credible cross between CHRIS DE BURGH and LOREENA MCKENNITT, while "Oleanders" reflects a path she might have followed to greater recognition. Most of the rest is forgettable synth pop blessed with a voice that deserves better, even on the collaboration with JUSTIN HAYWARD. If Sally had only trusted her instincts, which works better in art than in real life, what might have been?

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Colosseum Live by COLOSSEUM album cover Live, 1971
4.20 | 151 ratings

BUY
Colosseum Live
Colosseum Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Colosseum's boisterous prog-jazz-blues blend really shines in a live context, and whilst I wouldn't say this is enormously better than their top-grade studio albums (Valentyne Suite and Daughter of Time), it's a decent summation of the best aspects of their sound. It's particularly good that Chris Farlowe got this opportunity to further showcase his vocal contributions, because he'd only joined on Daughter of Time and it would have been a shame if that had been the only outing for him as frontman of the first incarnation of the group. Lost Angeles is a particular highlight, with Farlowe wringing genuine emotion out of the track as the band play like the world is ending (which for them, in a way, it kind of was).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Lumpy Gravy by ZAPPA, FRANK album cover Studio Album, 1968
3.24 | 476 ratings

BUY
Lumpy Gravy
Frank Zappa RIO/Avant-Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

3 stars 'Lumpy Gravy' is a very interesting Zappa album for several reasons. First of all, it is the first album credited to Zappa's name alone, and is a very fascinating example of complex in-studio editing of tapes; then, the 1968 version actually follows an orchestral release that was commissioned to the extravagant leader of the MOI the previous year, a mini-album on which Zappa was not actually allowed to perform due to his contractual obligations to Verve, and a work that had to be re-arranged for similar reasons, leading the avant-garde rock composer to use bits and pieces of it for the reimagined work, the one we know as the '68 version of 'Lumpy Gravy'. Finally, this is a very unnerving and fastidious sound collage concept-record that despite some obvious flaws, carries important characteristics of Zappa's distinctive, dense style, replete with comically cynical snippets of spoken word, and surreal musical passages that touch upon some of his earlier work, yet anticipate several experiments of the near future. The laborious editing of the countless tapes and the fact that an "orchestra" of hired musicians performed the entire work makes it an even more bizarre Zappa album than it already is!

Is this contemporary classical, the work of a genius, or the master tape of a madman? In any case, 'Lumpy Gravy' is a demanding, intense listen that carries the listener throughout numerous shorter pieces of music, orchestral arrangements, spoken word interludes, and blatant musique concrčte intrusions. There is a patchiness to the two big pieces, a general discontinuity between all the different elements making up the re-arranged version of the album. And while the dialogues might seem hilarious and wittily sarcastic, there are some seriously good musical motifs, especially on side one, yet not always sitting perfectly well with the hazardous arrangement (or lack thereof) of all the other disparate sonic experiments. As impressive and curious as this album may seem, it is also a fragmented work that lacks the coherence of preceding releases of Zappa, which hinders its listening to an extent - nevertheless, it has to be one of the strangely "essential" avant-garde albums of the late 1960s.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 If I Could Do It All Over Again, I'd Do It All Over You by CARAVAN album cover Studio Album, 1970
4.25 | 1237 ratings

BUY
If I Could Do It All Over Again, I'd Do It All Over You
Caravan Canterbury Scene

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars With a compositional sophistication on full display and an array of compelling tunes, right after being signed by a new label, Caravan released their second studio album 'If I Could Do It All Over Again...' in September of 1970, with the record becoming one of the all-time classics of the Canterbury scene. Following up on the band's playful psychedelic-pop debut, this release seems much more like an ode to innocence and boyhood perhaps, yet it exhibits a much more progressive approach to the various pieces of music on here, ranging from minute-long interludes to long and winding jazz-rock instrumental bonanzas. Of course, there is an eclecticism and an ingenuity to this album, as it all seems quite experimental, daring and somewhat provisional, with the music here paving the way for future recordings like 'Nine Feet Underground' or 'L'Auberge du Sanglier'. Narrowing down the psychedelic elements and expanding their musical vocabulary with jazzy tropes, Caravan had delivered a promising and expansive work very early on in their career.

The lineup featured here is the same as on the band's debut album, yet the musicianship and the chemistry between the band members seems ameliorated by far, as one could tell while inhabiting the headspace of the gorgeous arrangements here, always sufficiently elaborate but never really technically pretentious or overindulgent. There are also several catchier tunes, the "remnants" of that brilliant debut album - just breathe in the laid-back euphemisms of the opening title track. An interesting song lulls gently for eight good minutes in the face of 'And I Wish I Were Stoned', while the organ-heavy 'As I Feel I Die' works excellently and still sounds quite cerebral, as opposed to the outdated soundscapes of the preceding song. A 10-minute mini-suite closes off side one, this one is a less successful patchwork of sounds. 'Hello Hello' by Richard Sinclair is a fairly good pop number, while the centerpiece here is the gargantuan 14-minute jazz-rock suite 'Can't Be Long Now', simply capturing the band at their most extravagant and forward-thinking. Needless to say, 'Limits' is a lovely little closing piece, on an album that sounds impressive and adventurous for 1970, with its jazzy swindles and carefree pop tunes, just a fantastic LP.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Universe by PLANET X album cover Studio Album, 2000
3.69 | 118 ratings

BUY
Universe
Planet X Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by sgtpepper

3 stars Planet X indeed felt like they created music out of the Planet Earth (at that time). Heavy music with three virtuoso players, each getting the needed spotlight and the metal meets prog meets jazz approach was a novelty back then. Metal is present by the dense drumming and heavy riffing. prog is mainly represented by complex rhythms and keyboard wizardry while jazz isn't to be found in the pure form, however some Holdsworth inspired playing (last track) can be heart; also there plenty of soloing.

My two complaints are: riffing seems to be intentionally really heavy (unnecessarily) and half of the compositions aren't that memorable (Moonbabies will improve that). Tracks are extremely diverse with constant changes and challenging the listener to find the binding chain. Fortunately, after a few listens, you're going to find a motive or two in every track. The most demanding track is the ultra complex "King of the universe" joined by the likely fretless bass in the slow middle section between the frenetic start and ending. The "Chocalate" - not Chocolate is actually the most accessible track bordering on fusion similar to the action packed exhibition on "2116". 3.5 stars are guaranteed from me.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Mozart by SKY album cover Studio Album, 1987
2.87 | 31 ratings

BUY
Mozart
Sky Eclectic Prog

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

3 stars Sky's final studio album seems them taking a 1980s take on one of the earliest brands of progressive rock endeavour - adding rock instrumentation to classical music. This feels like a step down compared to The Great Balloon Race, which had been something of a return to form - here we're either dealing with a fairly standard take on Mozart with band contributions too subtle to be transformative, or the band jamming away with the orchestral guests pushed into the background.

It's a fun whistle-stop tour of some of the highlights of Mozart's discography, and I guess doing the whole "rocking the classics" thing which was popular in the early days of prog with updated 1980s instrumentation is original, but it feels unambitious - not in terms of the musical presentation, because that at least is doing something new by setting the band against a full orchestra (though isn't the point of their rock-classical blend that they can achieve orchestral sounds without resorting to that?), but in compositional terms, since it feels like you don't take this path unless you're well and truly out of original songwriting ideas and want to resort to something perennially popular.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Radio Gnome Invisible Vol. 3 - You by GONG album cover Studio Album, 1974
4.27 | 1191 ratings

BUY
Radio Gnome Invisible Vol. 3 - You
Gong Canterbury Scene

Review by Lobster77

5 stars The finale of the Radio Gnome Invisible concept and practically the dissolution of the classic Gong line-up comes in 1974 with the third part of the trilogy ''You''.Pierre Moerlen's younger brother Benoit joined the band on percussion and Daevid Allen decided that this would be more of a team effort.He recalls: ''...I was contributing a lot of the material, that it was too much my original creation. It was time we created something completely together, so we booked up a cottage in England...we connected so strongly together out of the improvisations, we just improvised and recorded it...''.The album was recorded at the Manor Studios in London in July 1974 and was released on Virgin in October.Simon Heyworth, who had collaborated with Mike Oldfield and Clearlight, helped with the production of the album

This was denitely the most intense of all Gong albums, extremely dense in sounds and sights and an amalgam of jazzy improvisations, spaced out experiments and psychedelic weirdness. Tim Blake offers some of his best synthesizer work to be delivered in a Gong album, very cosmic and cinematic with some nice guitar parts by Hillage and the occasional jazzy tastes as proposed by Didier Malherbe's elegant flute lines and powerful sax assaults.''Master builder'' is a masterpiece of the style with great sax work over the guitar and synth moves, while ''A sprinkling of clouds'' may sound a bit hypnotic with its extended synth soundscapes, but ends up to be another Gong weirdness with a full jazzy background and the flute/sax prevailing in the second half.Additionally the sweet vocal parts and the light interplays connect the band for the first time with the delicacy of the Canterbury scene.''The Isle of everywhere'' and ''You never blow yr trip forever'' are the two long cuts (over 10 minutes each) dominating the flipside of the original LP.You cannot blame Daevid Allen for carrying ''...some wonderful acid and we took this acid together as a group...'' back at the time, the result was a pair of cosmic, trippy and deeply psychedelic Jazz-oriented pieces with narcotic rhythms, some funky injections and excellent guitar work by Hillage, while the second cut contains some of the most complex themes executed by Gong in a combination of Heavy/Psych Rock, Fusion and Space Rock with ethereal female voices, flute-led soloing and intricate guitar/sax moves.

Epitomizing what Space Fusion is all about (along with Clearlight).Propably the best part of the Radio Gnome Invisible trilogy, the team effort had done good to the final result, which contains all of the Gong familiar elements: Psychedelic colors, jazzy interventions, poppy vocals and spacious landscapes.Strongly recommended.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Original Soundtrack by 10CC album cover Studio Album, 1975
3.74 | 170 ratings

BUY
The Original Soundtrack
10cc Prog Related

Review by Lobster77

4 stars 10cc set the stage with the opener "Une Nuit a Paris", an 8 minute multi-part track, sophisticated musically yet silly in it's ultimate delivery, taking inspiration from the cabaret/cafe sounds of it's title's city. And so it goes for aptly titled The Original Soundtrack, much of its contents on one hand riveting, on the other hand disposable, sort of the musical equivalent of a brilliantly filmed comedy. No doubt this is a release that will reveal more with each listen, 10cc showing themselves as intelligent musicians with a tongue in cheek agenda. Other highlights for me so far have to be the danceable "Blackmail", rockish "The Second Sitting for the Last Supper", and of course the hit soft-rock ballad "I'm Not In Love" - with it's synthesized vocals and disembodied middle section, a gloomy departure from the rest of the album.

3.78 rounded to 4 its iconic

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Sheet Music by 10CC album cover Studio Album, 1974
3.67 | 147 ratings

BUY
Sheet Music
10cc Prog Related

Review by Lobster77

3 stars A collection of eccentric pop rock tunes sandwiched between a mediocre yet seemingly popular opener and, to a lesser extent, closer. Every track from A2 to B4 is this odd Beach Boys/Frank Zappa crossover where you can't quite tell how seriously the band is taking it, but in that aspect it rivals Sparks (my favorite band) in its eclectic take on pop music, not to the levels of parody where 10cc feel like they're better than the music on the radio, but rather, are so appreciatory of the music that they were built upon, that the jabs feel more in good fun. Those Beach Boys harmonies and manic bridges are not laughing at, but with, the 60s, and I think that's not only intriguing, but 10cc does it very well here. Clockwork Creep keeps me moving, and Somewhere in Hollywood should be one of the great progressive pop songs. Alas, it is not, and that's a shame, because it and many other songs here are amazing. Sure, it is sort of the same shtick as The Mothers of Invention, but the 70s sensibilities add a lot to the sound, and give it that extra kick to be something grand. Add in a hint of glam, and you have something that really is a hit with me. I find that opening track too "hard rock" to get the feeling I desire, so it is a shame that's considered the hit here, and there are certainly some lyrics that haven't aged the best (Hotel, in particular, has some eyebrow raises in it) but it tends to be so fun I can't help but enjoy it all. Just a great record, I love their voices. Eric Stewart, Kevin Godley and Lol Creme are all fantastic vocalists.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Femme by OLDFIELD, SALLY album cover Studio Album, 1987
2.02 | 13 ratings

BUY
Femme
Sally Oldfield Crossover Prog

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

2 stars While she is to be commended for resisting the typecasting that overshadowed the surprise success of her 1978 debut "Water Bearer" and hit smash "Mirrors", like so many others during the mid to late 1980s, SALLY OLDFIELD did so by conceding to the mainstream to her own detriment. While a few well turned lyrics and compositions can compensate for oozy production and arrangements, as in "Silver Dagger", "Marlene" and "Two Different Drummers", and she does offer one minor classic in "Andromeda Rising", even her perennially sweet and versatile voice make most of this femme fatale a bit of a turn off.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 10cc by 10CC album cover Studio Album, 1973
3.60 | 112 ratings

BUY
10cc
10cc Prog Related

Review by Lobster77

4 stars 10cc's debut album is a much forgotten art pop gem from the early 70's, now considered faintly uncool a listen to this album is a timely reminder of the bands obvious genius with melody and witty wordplay, this LP is pop at it's best, up there with the very best, for critics who dubbed them too clever their debut is for the most part incredibly lean and focused and eschews the overtly artsy leanings of later efforts, "The Dean And I", Johnny Don't Do It", "Sand In My Face", "Donna" and of course "Rubber Bullets" are pop perfection whilst the band show a fine understanding of the rock/blues genre on both "Ships Don't Dissapear" and "Headline Hustler", the influences are for the main part American and in particular The Beach Boys yet it still sounds resolutely English (mostly thanks to the lyrics which owe more than a passing debt to the dry wit of Noel Coward amongst others), Recorded in 1972 this album sounds as fresh now as it did then, a joy from start to finish, all lovers of great pop music should check this little gem out, its an art rock classic.

3.99

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Presa di Coscienza by I GIULLARI DI CORTE album cover Studio Album, 2020
3.04 | 7 ratings

BUY
Presa di Coscienza
I Giullari Di Corte Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by Finnforest
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars No jest - pure time travel

Legend goes that I Giullari Di Corte (The Court Jesters) were born on a stormy night in distant 2002. After many years of inactivity, they came together again in 2017. What a revelation to hear this album released on the eve of the COVID years. For when the trippy opening subsides and "Nautilus" leaps from your speakers, it feels like you're experiencing some vintage RPI from the dawn of the '70s. While it may be symphonic prog, this is old school RPI of the gritty, slightly garage variety delivered by just three men, Alessio De Angelis, Matteo "Divac" Ballestrazzi, and Paolo Zacchi. This is not highly refined, "pretty" bench RPI with soft pillowy background, violin, and angelic harmonies. This is sweaty jamming with a hearty appreciation for hard rock along with the symphonic swirl.

When drawing parallels to who these guys reminded me of, my brain first flashed to Exploit's very rare Crisi album (where an original vinyl will cost you thousands if you believe Discog). Like Exploit, this is three-piece that thrives on an inventive and workmanlike approach to jamming to get where they're going, although Exploit used no guitar and these guys do. Other sound comparisons could be Capitolo 6 and Osage Tribe. I saw someone mention Le Orme, but I feel that is a more distant comparison. Not too many albums these days will eschew the myriad modern influences of the last few decades such as prog-metal and PT-type stuff, but the largely vintage instrumental Presi di Coscienza took me on a mind-trip to the fall of 1970, imagining a couple of barefoot teens sitting in an upstairs room cranking out the latest metamorphosis of rock, drifting into what we now call RPI. This is a unique and special album that frankly easily exceeds what Exploit did even if it falls a bit short of the Orme tag some give it.

I love the melancholic lilt in the many melodic adventures they undertake, so many beautiful piano/keyboard runs backed by fiercely belted-out bass lines and lively drumming. Vocals are used sparingly but effectively throughout. It is the large middle section of this album (from "Sherlock Holmes" through "Il Messicano") that shines the most, a truly excellent run of music. I found the second track and the last two tracks somewhat less convincing, but that's just me. I appreciated the symphonic/keyboard-led material more than the hard rock/guitar-led stuff. In any case, there is great potential here. The production could be criticized I suppose as there are times I feel the sound is too thin, and yet the compositional creativity and obvious passion for authenticity surpass all concerns about sound. This album brings the sauce, and we shall blast it down the halls of the villa. Really in the 7/10 range for me, but a whisker shy of getting to 4 stars. A second album is in the works, so keep your ears to the ground for that one.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Sweet Freedom by URIAH HEEP album cover Studio Album, 1973
3.44 | 431 ratings

BUY
Sweet Freedom
Uriah Heep Heavy Prog

Review by Etherea

3 stars Perhaps the last truly consistent album in the Dave Byron era of the band. The band have scaled down their compositions somewhat but some of the material such as 'Seven Stars' can clearly be heard in the DNA of the British metal bands of the 80s- Iron Maiden in particular. Highlights include 'Pilgrim' and the soaring 'If I had the Time' which finds vocalist Byron in full peacock-like flight on the word 'siiiinggggg!'. Truly one of his best vocal performances. 'Stealin'' is a catchy, rollicking road trip of a hit single which displays the trademark sonic Heep casserole of swirling organs, wah-wah guitar, operatic vocals and the censorship worthy line 'I done the ranchers daughter' which allegedly prevented the band's natural ascendancy in puritanical America.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Rio by RABIN, TREVOR album cover Studio Album, 2023
3.71 | 46 ratings

BUY
Rio
Trevor Rabin Crossover Prog

Review by Etherea

4 stars Fans of Trevor and his tenure in Yes would welcome this album. It has all the hallmarks of his time in the band- the big choruses, high-octane guitar playing, cinematic keyboards and multi-layered vocal harmonies. All of this would be somewhat meaningless if the songwriting wasn't up to scratch but Rabin delivers on that front as well ('Big Mistake' has more than a few echoes of 'The Calling' from the Yes 'Talk' album). 'Goodbye' even feels like a cheeky nod to the style of guitar rag associated with Steve Howe. The playing throughout is excellent and this album could easily be a successor to the heavily under-rated Yes 'Talk' album or an indication of what an album with Jon Anderson and Rick Wakeman might have sounded like had that window not closed so quickly.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Serpent Rings by MAGNUM album cover Studio Album, 2020
3.62 | 24 ratings

BUY
The Serpent Rings
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

4 stars Nearly 50 years into their career, British rockers Magnum sound more invigorated than they have ever been. Blasting out of the gates, the opener 'Where Are You Eden?' sets the tone for the album with 'Kashmir' style strings, serpentine guitar shredding and an urgency that is palpable. 'You Can't Run Faster Than Bullets' is another highlight while the title track is vintage Magnum with an atmospheric middle 8 worthy of Marillion or Rick Wakeman. Continuing this thoroughly consistent album are ballsy, 'in your face' rockers like 'House of Kings' which slips into an impressive display of Chick Corea jazz piano and even features a burst of saxophone in the out-tro worthy of Ornette Coleman. Elsewhere, 'Man' has an atmospheric synth intro before launching into the snarling riff. This is an exceptionally energised version of Magnum with some old stalwarts having moved on and replaced by younger blood. 'The Serpent Rings' is full of fist-pumping anthems from start to finish.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Sacred Blood Divine Lies by MAGNUM album cover Studio Album, 2016
3.17 | 28 ratings

BUY
Sacred Blood Divine Lies
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

3 stars Were Magnum ever strictly speaking, a Prog band? Well, no. The influences of Queen, Yes, and Jethro Tull were self- evident as was and still is the unmitigated knack for Beatle-esque melody. This band however, always enjoyed rocking! From the debut album 'Kingdom of Madness' to their decidedly playful hard rock album 'Rock Art', Heavy Rock was the backbone to their music. So while we always get a consistent album from Magnum- and this is a strong one- We never know just which way the dynamics will tilt towards Prog or Metal.

With a handful of lighter moments to break up the bombast, this British warhorse have delivered another consistent later period release. Continuing from the progress of the previous album, songwriter Tony Clarkin has proven adroit at crafting great bridges and pre-chorus sections even if they are housed in a formula Rock structure. The songwriting overall does suffer a little with this recent bout of Prince-like prolificism because there are only so many riffs and chord progressions that can be used in a hard rock context. Having said that, the formula is shaken up a bit with different tempos and feels and there is a strong sense that this era of the band is building up some serious momentum.

Merit points here particularly at the business end of the album which features two decidedly foot-stomping numbers 'Crazy Old Mothers' and the Uriah Heep-ish 'Gypsey Queen' and one thing that you cannot accuse this band of is lacking conviction. Elsewhere 'Afraid Of The Night' captures a classic Magnum vibe from the band's early period. 'Your Dreams Won't Die' is likewise a memorable track with poignant lyrics and an uplifting melody.

Magnum do share similarities with the aforementioned trailblazers Uriah Heep in that they continue to crank out albums regardless of whether they make the charts or not. I just wish they would use more shade and colour in the arrangements like the best Prog Rock bands do but I am picky because I have been a fan for 27 years!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Escape From The Shadow Garden by MAGNUM album cover Studio Album, 2014
3.08 | 39 ratings

BUY
Escape From The Shadow Garden
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

3 stars 'We're hopelessly confused/Wisdom's had its day' sings Bob Catley in one of the album's more balladic moments. This lyric seems to tie in visually with the cynical air of confusion which is also visually evident in the Rodney Mathews cover art and has been somewhat of a through-line for this prolific yet darker incarnation of Magnum since the band reformed in 2001.

There is nothing wrong with the music of course, it is solid and reliable as always. This is perhaps part of the problem. This is a band after all which honed a very unique stadium rock sound with gutsy, bravura vocals, smart lyrics and hooks abundant enough to cloak Tony Clarkin's entire collection of hats. The Magnum of old had a very positive, life-affirming quality to their music and while some of the themes were dark it was never overwhelmingly so. For the most part however, this album is a little bit leaner and less bludgeoning than the previous one (2012's 'On the 13th Day') and the occasional regurgitation of stock AOR riffery is broken up with a fresh integration of bubbling electronic synth passages and uplifting middle 8's ('Falling For the Big Plan' features some truly impassioned vocals from singer Bob Catley). 'Too Many Clowns' taps into the playful heavy rock found on the 1994 'Rock Art' album and offers some much needed respite from the themes of mortality and despair while 'Midnight Angel' treats its dark lyrical matter with subtle, ambient keyboard textures which sounds refreshing.

'Don't Fall Asleep' conversely seems to herald the album's second half which slides back into comfortable heavy rock and lament-filled ballad territory.

For the most part, this album from Magnum continues along the same path mapped out from the punchy rock sound of 'Brand New Morning' but delivers a handful of surprises in the arrangements to energise the tried and tested formula.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Visitation by MAGNUM album cover Studio Album, 2011
3.24 | 45 ratings

BUY
The Visitation
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

3 stars Some Magnum albums can be hard to evaluate when there are a lot of commercial rock cliches onboard. The influence of bands like Journey and Foreigner seem to be worn on the sleeve as such with the heavy pomp rock posturing on display. This is solid and expertly crafted as expected, following very hot on the heels of 2009's 'Into the Valley of the Moonking'. The material this time is predominantly hard rock lightly peppered with power balladry and despite having just 10 tracks, it feels somewhat flabbier than the previous album. The title track has tension and drama while 'Freedom Day' continues the dark undercurrent of cynicism and world- weariness but most surprising this time is the track 'The Last Frontier'- a mellow track with a great melody and anthemic strings which delivers some much needed variety amid the doom and gloom. Thematically, this album dwells in lament and mortality, often wallowing in the passing of time as evidenced visually by the memento mori in the Rodney Mathews cover art. It is this sense of artistry that sets Magnum apart from the aforementioned North American AOR supergroups- The lyrics are smart, measured, insightful and prose-worthy. The music is therefore elevated by this and not just relegated to FM radio playlists.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Into The Valley Of The Moonking by MAGNUM album cover Studio Album, 2009
3.11 | 43 ratings

BUY
Into The Valley Of The Moonking
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

3 stars Magnum's fourth new album since reforming has a sharper focus than the impressive but overwrought 'Princess Alice and the Broken Arrow'. There is more space and variety in the arrangements and an air of mysticism which is also reflected in the excellent cover art by Rodney Mathews. Lyrically, songwriter Tony Clarkin is still reflecting on mortality and bittersweet reminisces but sometimes this is at odds with the music (such as the songs 'All my Bridges' and 'Time To Cross That River' which does feature a beautiful acoustic guitar solo), while 'Take Me To the Edge' is a sure-fire Magnum rocker in the finest tradition. The title track is an interesting excursion into blues-rock which never feels forced or inauthentic for a band known for Pomp Rock anthems. 'Cry To Yourself' is decidedly melodic and Beatle-esque while 'If I Ever Lose My Mind' should please fans of early Magnum with its escalating sense of drama and heavy riffing. Elsewhere the shuffling 'No-one Knows His Name' is another highlight while some tracks follow the tried and tested hard rock approach like the AC/DC-ish closer 'Blood On Your Barbed Wire Thorns'. This is a Magnum album for the uninitiated and the faithful alike.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Princess Alice And The Broken Arrow by MAGNUM album cover Studio Album, 2007
3.50 | 58 ratings

BUY
Princess Alice And The Broken Arrow
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

3 stars Continuing the punchy heavy rock sound of 'Brand New Morning', Magnum deliver an album which is heavy in a cynical rather than playful way but is not lacking in the hooks that this band are known for. 'When We Were Younger' is an introspective opener which sets the mood for the rest of this 11 track album. 'Eyes Wide Open' has an urgency belying a band of this vintage. Other highlights include 'Be Strong' with its use of funky clavichord reminiscent of Stevie Wonder's 'Superstition' and the wonderfully anthemic 'Desperate Times' with its cascading vocal harmonising. This album does start a trend somewhat for the band. A tendency to follow the 'more is more' approach in the arrangements but songwriter Tony Clarkin has never been one for self-indulgence at the expense of the song and the album outstays its welcome only by two or three songs.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Sleepwalking by MAGNUM album cover Studio Album, 1992
2.71 | 40 ratings

BUY
Sleepwalking
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

2 stars Magnum appear to be somnambulating through tepid pop songs and half-baked efforts at restoring their Prog credentials here and the results are inconclusive. Uncharacteristically but perhaps fitting for the concept, the album opens with the slow burning brooding pop of 'Stormy Weather' (not the jazz standard) followed by some lightweight rockers before stumbling on one of its few highlights 'The Flood'- a song that builds into a crescendo of thudding drums and heavy guitar. 'Broken Wheel' is another ballad but has some charm about it while 'Just One More Heartbreak' perhaps not consciously channels a riff from the Midnight Oil song 'Brave Faces' (was Clarkin an Oils fan at that point I wonder?).

Elsewhere 'Only In America' offers a cynical view of the band's time trying to court the coveted US market and it does all this with a reasonable funk groove and a chorus that sounds like Asia.

Where is Magnum in all of this you may ask? The title track is one of the few songs that comes to life before it falls to sleep again in a haze of keyboard ambience, leaving only the catchy, melodic 'Prayer For A Stranger' and the lukewarm but agreeable groove of 'The Long Ride' where singer Bob Catley deepens his range to a chilled Bowie or Icehouse warble.

Perhaps most significantly for this album, Rodney Mathews has been commissioned for the cover art again for the first time since 1985. I dare say however, that more depth can be found in the artwork than most of the music contained therein.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Goodnight L.A. by MAGNUM album cover Studio Album, 1990
2.41 | 45 ratings

BUY
Goodnight L.A.
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

2 stars Magnum tunesmith Tony Clarkin is no novice when it comes to delivering great hooks and melodies. It therefore made little sense for their record company to hire a crack team of hot LA songwriters to would make the band more accessible.

The previous album 'Wings Of Heaven' broke into the UK Top 5 and the band did this on their own terms with a set of songs that were catchy yet retaining the British quirks that made them unique.

This follow-up squeezes the band dry with saccharine production and lacklustre material. There is however a handful of catchy songs ('Rockin Chair','Heartbroke and Busted', 'Mama') and some cuts that demand re-appraisal ('Only a Memory', 'Reckless Man', 'Born To be King') but the approach to my ears at least, never seems to gel. Magnum were better off being Magnum.

There are many parallels between Magnum and Uriah Heep. Both bands dabbled in a fantasy world of escapist album covers and Proggy arrangements that augmented their desire to rock. Both bands also enjoyed low-key to moderate success on the world stage while grazing the Top 20 in their home territories with seminal album releases. With Heep it was the 'Demons and Wizards' era, Magnum the late '80s 'Wings of Heaven' era where the band cracked the Top 10!

Despite Tony Clarkin's ability to mine the AOR sheen of Kansas/Boston/Foreigner/Toto/Survivor/REO Speedwagon, this is as popular as the band would get commercially.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Collection by MAGNUM album cover Boxset/Compilation, 1990
3.60 | 6 ratings

BUY
The Collection
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

4 stars This compilation of the Birmingham band's 1978-1983 output was my first introduction to Magnum via a record club purchase. I was trying to find a 'mystical metal' band to listen to and take under my wing. Upon receiving this item and putting it on, I was immediately struck by how diverse the material was. It wasn't consistently heavy enough to be called metal yet it wasn't total sellout AOR like Boston or Foreigner either. The band were sufficiently interesting and quirky but a little frustrating for a 17 year old pair of ears. I was obviously impressed with heavy rock anthems like 'The Spirit' and 'Soldier Of the Line', equally intrigued by Jethro Tull-esque 'Firebird' and the dirty riffing and operatic vocals of 'Kingdom Of Madness'. The opener 'Great Adventure' culled from the Magnum II album was also hard to define with its Queen vocal operatics and fiddly arrangement more in line with early '70s prog rock. Magnum have always straddled this wall between good-natured AOR hooks and snarling yet controlled guitar licks. This compilation is a great place to dip your toes into the Tolkein-esque fantasy world of the band before their 1985 breakthrough album 'On a Storyteller's Night'. The best cuts from each album are included and rare singles like the heavy AOR gallop of 'Back To Earth' make it all the more worthwhile.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Wings Of Heaven by MAGNUM album cover Studio Album, 1988
3.65 | 81 ratings

BUY
Wings Of Heaven
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

3 stars In Australia, finding a Magnum album was like the proverbial needle in the haystack, although I occasionally got lucky (I found 'Sleepwalking' in a CD store on a such a day!).

This album (despite being a Top 5 hit in the UK) was nowhere to be found on antipodean shores but I procured it second hand for $2 on cassette somewhere and couldn't wait to hear it.

Expecting hard hitting metal to blast from the speakers, I was immediately let down by the perfectly manicured AOR politely filling the room. This presented a quandary. How could I bang my head and pump my fist to music that sounded like John Farnham or Michael Bolton?

However, I played it again and realised the subtlety of the approach was actually a good thing and yes, I could still mime holding a lighter to inspiring romantic ditties like 'It Must Have been Love' and enjoy the guilty pleasure moments like when the guitar chimes in on 'I'm never gonna give you up...DA DA DA DA' in 'Start Talking Love'. The keyboards on this album too are more atmospheric and economical and usually soar in at key emotional moments in the song. The varied and prose-worthy lyrical content also elevates the music above the conceptually banal bands such as Asia who by this stage had dissolved into a fog of riff-laden AOR drivel.

This brand of punchy AOR with catchy melodies and impassioned vocals is worth the investment especially if you are a fan of this band. Aside from the solid hit singles including 'Days of No Trust', 'Wild Swan' and the excellent momentum of the closing track, the World War themed epic 'Don't Wake the Lion', it's a lean yet muscular album with dynamics and bombast in equal measure.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Vigilante by MAGNUM album cover Studio Album, 1986
2.82 | 69 ratings

BUY
Vigilante
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

3 stars Vigilante is in general more pop-rock oriented and made for FM radio playlists to schedule alongside Starship or Mr Mister. Smack bang in its time and preening the band for success.

Produced within an inch of its dated '80s life by Queen drummer Roger Taylor, this is a peculiar follow-up to the fan favourite 'On A Storyteller's Night'. Addressing the unicorn in the room, the cover packaging is hideous and looks like it was designed for a Mattell toy promotion. Rodney Mathews was sadly not on hand for this one and the kowtowing to record company demands has clearly undermined the band's music and visual image. Next item on the agenda: The songs. Some of them are very good ('Midnight You Won't Be Sleeping' and 'Lonely Night' in particular.)

Others are drenched in the syrupy production and at best come off like '80s TV show themes by Mike Post ('Sometime Love') while rockers like 'Holy Rider' and 'Red On The Highway' fair slightly better and at least offer some guilty pleasure for the listener. Magnum would improve on this approach for their next album (the Top 5 breakthrough 'Wings Of Heaven') but this was probably the necessary step to get them up the stairwell.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Chase the Dragon by MAGNUM album cover Studio Album, 1982
3.71 | 97 ratings

BUY
Chase the Dragon
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

4 stars From the fantasy cover art by Rodney Mathews to the bigger production (Kansas producer Jeff Glixman) and focused songwriting, 'Chase The Dragon' is an album that deservedly put Magnum on the map. Songs such as the medieval war-themed opener 'Soldier Of The Line', 'The Spirit' and 'Sacred Hour' would become live staples for decades to come while uplifting rockers like 'On the Edge of the World' struck a perfect balance between the guitar and keyboard histrionics. The album cracked the UK Top 20 but it would be a slightly bumpy road to the bigger success they enjoyed in the late '80s.

While songwriter Tony Clarkin is somewhat still wearing the Prog and AOR influences on his sleeve, the British quirks that set the band apart from the obscenely commercial US bands were well and truly in place here. The expanded edition is worth investing in as it includes the excellent galloping heavy rock song 'Back To Earth', 'Hold Back Your Love' and live versions of some of the songs- although the guitar appears to be somewhat thin in the mix. Also, the original release of this album contained 8 songs and clocked in under 40 minutes making it more emphatic than some of the group's current releases which-while solid- would not be hurt by some self-editing and fresh production choices.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Magnum II by MAGNUM album cover Studio Album, 1979
2.85 | 72 ratings

BUY
Magnum II
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

3 stars Magnum II is a slicker, more polished album than the band's debut but it is also a mixed bag and somewhat lacks the energy and spontaneity. Despite this, some of these songs are classics in the group's cannon; 'Great Adventure', 'So Cold the Night', and 'Firebird' reflect a Jethro Tull and Queen influence in the acoustic and electric contrasts, vocal operatics and tongue- tripping flute workouts while the intro to 'If I Could Live Forever' conjures up images of knights on a misty battlefield before the song proper gives way to a more prosaic song structure better suited to Journey, Styx or Boston.

Other songs like 'Foolish Heart' lapse into an indistinct and not overly memorable rock shuffle, the likes of which had already been well-worn by bands like Kansas. The album's closer 'All of My Life' tells a story and builds up quite a head of steam with Tony Clarkin's guitar gallops and Bob Catley's explicit Robert Plant yelps of 'push, push, puuuush!' letting prog fans off the hook.

Magnum II is essentially half Prog/half commercial fare but despite the obvious potential of the band, fans were not won over either way.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Kingdom Of Madness by MAGNUM album cover Studio Album, 1978
3.33 | 76 ratings

BUY
Kingdom Of Madness
Magnum Prog Related

Review by Etherea

4 stars Released in 1978 when Punk and New Wave had well and truly usurped the '70s rock dinosaurs, this is somewhat of an oddity. A Prog style hard rock album occupying its own existence outside of time and fashion. As such, it's an exemplary debut despite its slightly dated production. Songs like cracking opener 'In the Beginning' and the title track are bursting with energy and a purpose that would drive Magnum's best material. 'All That Is Real' is a beautiful ballad that comes of age suddenly before returning to its beginning sentiment. 'Invasion' sounds like the grandiose pomp rock lovechild of Queen and Rainbow. 'The Bringer' is another cracking track that perfectly blends the Prog Rock fantasy and atmosphere with the hard rock thrust and bombast. An impressive debut from one of the most consistent yet often overlooked rock bands. Vintage Magnum.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Book Of Souls by IRON MAIDEN album cover Studio Album, 2015
3.81 | 327 ratings

BUY
The Book Of Souls
Iron Maiden Prog Related

Review by Etherea

3 stars It has become apparent on the last two Maiden offerings that the band is at the very least, trying to find some new tricks to spruce up its bombastic prog-metal approach. On this double disc, there is a respectful display of bluesier guitar solos and other musical interludes and motifs which certainly help keep things fresh. The continuing problem since 2006's 'matter of life and death' however, seems to be the lack of self-editing in the music itself. On classic albums like 'Powerslave', and 'Seventh Son', short, punchy numbers would dominate proceedings, making the listener appreciate the 2 or 3 epics on display. This balance was lost somewhat with a 'back to basics' approach in the early 90s. Fortunately, the approach was found again on 'Dance of Death' (Not coincidentally the group's finest album since 'Seventh Son'). While there is much to recommend on this double album, particularly Bruce's triumphant vocals, it appears that the band has al but lost it's ability to craft trailblazing 3-4 minute anthems in the 'Piece of Mind' tradition and is now in somewhat of a rut of excess despite it's commendable efforts to deviate from the formula.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 A Matter Of Life And Death by IRON MAIDEN album cover Studio Album, 2006
3.65 | 499 ratings

BUY
A Matter Of Life And Death
Iron Maiden Prog Related

Review by Etherea

3 stars This would probably be the greatest metal album ever made...for a fresh pair of ears. Unfortunately we live in a generation now where things are forgotten not much sooner than they arrive. Iron Maiden hit the jackpot with the near excellent previous album 'Dance of Death', which can quite easily be ranked among the group's best but this follow-up has darkened the tone a little and retreated back to the sheer tedium of protracted concept songs, with little variation. Having said that, there is certainly much to recommend. 'Brighter Than a Thousand Suns' is one of the heaviest songs the group has recorded and recalls the aggression and dynamics of Piece of Mind. Elsewhere it is business as usual and that business has become bogged down a little.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Calling All Stations by GENESIS album cover Studio Album, 1997
2.45 | 1204 ratings

BUY
Calling All Stations
Genesis Symphonic Prog

Review by Etherea

2 stars Upon its release, I genuinely hoped that this would be a brave stab at the slightly darker, edgier sound and themes of the Peter Gabriel era- all foxes in dresses and games of croquet with human heads! The new singer Ray Wilson certainly has Gabriel's croaky warmth but aside from a cracking burst of guitar riffery on the title track, musically this is a very static album. Weirder still, it is an album distinctly lacking in direction. Not quite a pop album because the hyper-famous Phil Collins has left the band and taken all the catchy hooks with him (Perhaps only 'Congo' but little else) and it's not quite Prog either. The song 'The Dividing Line' feels like a call to arms for the old fans but it arrives out of a fog of string pads and nondescript melodies a bit too late in the album to provide hope. The drummers sound like Phil Collins, the vocals sound like Peter Gabriel but the music is a pea-souper of vagueness and if you manage to get through its interminable running time, you kind of wish you'd just listened to Foxtrot or Duke.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 In The Hot Seat by EMERSON LAKE & PALMER album cover Studio Album, 1994
1.80 | 483 ratings

BUY
In The Hot Seat
Emerson Lake & Palmer Symphonic Prog

Review by Etherea

2 stars What became the final studio album by this '70s prog trio was an album more shamelessly commercial than 'Love Beach' but better than that album by a whisker due to 'Hand Of Truth', 'One By One', 'Street War' and the studio re- recording of 'Pictures At An Exhibition' (which itself was a bonus track recorded in 1993 for a box set).

All of the aforementioned tracks are ELP songs in spirit and performance. The rest of the album however, is sketchier. Greg Lake's heartbreaking ballad about a lost- presumably murdered little girl- called 'Daddy' feels too heavy to be on an ELP album and as effective as it is, seriously disrupts the momentum. 'Heart On Ice' is syrupy, lame AOR which also feels like fodder for a Greg Lake solo project while 'Give Me A Reason To Stay', 'Change', and 'Gone Too Soon' don't fare much better- the latter being particularly devoid of character. ' 'Thin Line' does offer Palmer a chance to show some chops but as a song, is more reminiscent of 'The Gambler' from 'Love Beach' in its use of female backing vocalists. 'The Man with the long black coat' is a cinematic take on a Bob Dylan song and if nothing else, it does suit Lake's darkly nicotine affected voice. A very sad ending whimper for a once restlessly energetic supergroup.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Black Moon by EMERSON LAKE & PALMER album cover Studio Album, 1992
2.77 | 570 ratings

BUY
Black Moon
Emerson Lake & Palmer Symphonic Prog

Review by Etherea

3 stars Black Moon is by no means 'classic ELP' but it does contain elements of the trio's classic sound in the cinematic title track, funky Hammond workout 'Paper Blood', the Prokofiev appropriation 'Romeo And Juliet' and some pleasant, acoustic numbers from Greg Lake- 'Affairs Of The Heart' being the most memorable. The instrumental 'Changing States' has its moments too but is diminished somewhat by Palmer's over-reliance on electronic drumming while 'Better Days' feels like an attempt to modernise the band-with mixed results. The album is slickly produced and the material is largely streamlined AOR infused with liberal dollops of Hammond and String synth pad but Palmer's watered-down percussion and Lake's darkly broken voice may spoil enjoyment for some of the older fans.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Power Windows by RUSH album cover Studio Album, 1985
3.58 | 1171 ratings

BUY
Power Windows
Rush Heavy Prog

Review by Etherea

3 stars This album finds the Canadian power trio honing their synth-laden sound and masterfully pulling off some excellent tracks like the massive capitalist statement 'The Big Money', Cold War mini-epic 'The Manhattan Project' and the musically athletic 'Marathon' which features some career best playing from Geddy and Neil. Why I haven't mentioned Alex is because his guitar lines blend into the synthetic sounds making it increasingly difficult to know where he is. Despite the superb opening act, side two is comparatively indistinct and lacking in memorable hooks? 'Mystic Rhythms' with its dark timbres arrives too late to save the album from being a winning home run and the clinical, precise production does leave the listener a little bit cold.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Senjutsu by IRON MAIDEN album cover Studio Album, 2021
3.65 | 155 ratings

BUY
Senjutsu
Iron Maiden Prog Related

Review by Etherea

3 stars This latest Sun Tzu-themed blockbuster (albeit loosely themed) doesn't reach the peaks of their 82-88 glory era (except for perhaps 'The Time Machine' which is one of the highlights of the album's 82 minute record-shattering running time).

Elsewhere, 'Death Of The Celts' aims for an 'Infinite Dreams' level of epic grandeur and bombast while the 8 minute title track (a quickie for Maiden) is an uplifting, minimal fuss anthem that oddly doesn't seem to outstay its welcome. Traces of epics like 'To Tame a Land' can be heard in 'The Parchment' and there is a somewhat mid-tempo plodding to the proceedings which can test the patience a little- although this charge can be laid at ANY millennial Maiden release.

Overall, what you get is the same as always since their reformation with Bruce- a solid, sprawling experience where the motto seems to be 'more is more'. Some self-editing wouldn't exactly harm them next time because (and this should be noted) this music doesn't do anything that the band haven't done in a much shorter, more concise format anyway. Why waste the format if there is nothing new happening? Perhaps it's their age or the mileage but I do wish Iron Maiden would get to the point quicker like they used to!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Quest by YES album cover Studio Album, 2021
2.87 | 348 ratings

BUY
The Quest
Yes Symphonic Prog

Review by Etherea

2 stars The current incarnation of Yes has come some way (including through a global pandemic) in restoring some artistic credibility following the tepid 'Heaven And Earth' album from 2014. The production on this album is somewhat generic but warmer and most of the songs have the high standard of musicianship we expect from this 50 year old Prog institution.

Torch-holder and founding member Chris Squire has passed away since the last album and Jon Anderson is now a man in his late '70s who is clearly not interested in gruelling touring schedules. Instead of the mystical Yes brand of enlightenment, we are given songs about climate change such as the opener 'The Ice Bridge' which features a very decent demonstration of guitar and synth interplay from Steve Howe and Geoff Downes who seems to channel his inner '70s Prog synth wizard with class and precision.

Following tracks 'Dare To Know' and 'Leave Well Alone' aim for the sublime beauty that was on ample display in the band's '70s material- the latter only occasionally falling flat thanks to a stiff groove made worse by stabs of stodgy '80s synth brass. Keyboardist Geoff Downes, after a great start seems to become more diminished in his role as the album progresses (reminding me somewhat of Keith Emerson on ELP's 'Love Beach').

As this is now Steve Howe's legacy version of the band, the guitarist suitably rises to the occasion and his soloing and acoustic work is exquisite throughout. No complaints there. Less convincing though are the vocal melodies and hooks- of which very few take hold ('Future Memories' and 'Leave Well Alone' are exceptions). Less compelling still are the bonus tracks on Disc 2 which would scarcely make Asia B-side fodder- The ill-advised Beatles paen 'Mystery Tour' gets the 'Circus of Heaven' award for irritating fluff but even 'Circus of Heaven' can't compete with some of the woeful, cringeworthy lyrics here.

Singer/Lyricist Jon Davidson has shown no true personality again and I honestly wish that he would forget about trying to sound like Jon Anderson (listen to the ersatz way he enunciates words like 'heart' and 'fu-u-uture' if you need proof of this approach). So once again, this functions like a coffeehouse version of Yes despite the fact that the band are trying a bit this time. Davidson doesn't help matters either with his plaintive lack of expression- even Jon Anderson's voice had something resembling grit when the music called for it (remember when he was pissed off with the music business and formed ABWH?!)

The elaborate packaging for this album too- it must be said- smacks of desperation as if Steve Howe is saying "Look! This is the real Yes". If only that were true... It is more of a Beach Boys album without any Wilson brothers...

Despite these complaints from a long-time fan who got off on 'Talk' and even 'Union', it is nonetheless a pleasant, competent effort but Yes at their best, were always much more than that.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Union by YES album cover Studio Album, 1991
2.54 | 1273 ratings

BUY
Union
Yes Symphonic Prog

Review by Etherea

3 stars Following Anderson Bruford Wakeman Howe's impressive eponymous debut and successful tour of 1989, it was decided to cut losses and join the 'Yes West' line-up for an album and tour.

In perhaps, the most gargantuan event in the group's history.. Anderson, Bruford, Howe, Kaye, Rabin, Squire, Wakeman & White embarked on the massive Yesshows 91' World Tour which by most accounts- was massively enjoyable and successful.

The album they toured on however, was a little less functional...although it does hold the distinction of being the last Yes studio album to make the Top 10 in the UK- proving that the venture was well promoted and received.

Most of its tracks were by the ABWH line-up (some spruced up with Squire's distinct, articulate backing vocals) and the rest were by the Anderson, Kaye, Rabin, Squire, White team- of which 'The Miracle Of Life' fairs best.

This was the first Yes album I ever bought and I liked most of the ABWH tracks. The musicians seemed to be firing on all cylinders- especially Bruford with his sophisticated metric drumming and use of electronic percussion hardware. 'I Would've Waited Forever', 'Shock To The System', and 'Silent Talking' are all great tracks musically.

Here's the rub though- Steve Howe's prodigious guitar playing is great on its own but Bruford really does pull the music in exciting directions at times which only hinted at the direction the ABWH lineup could have taken on their second album were it not for the corporate suits and 'Yes-men' getting involved...Talk about creative 'Coitus Interruptus'! But that's Yes for you...

For a more consistent example of how these two musicians excel when working together, listen to Howe's solo album 'Turbulence' released the same year (1991).

Another problem here is Rick Wakeman's keyboards. Where are they? There are so many session players on this album, it is sometimes hard to know who is playing what and no less than 14 people are listed as playing keyboards and synths.

Mostly, the ABWH tracks sound somewhat sabotaged by prototype trance loops and synth presets at the expense of good playing...a fact that has clearly incurred Wakeman's wrath over the years. It is worth mentioning also that there is no point on this album where all 8 Yes members play together. So Union therefore is quite a farrago of Yes styles- some successful, others not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Talk by YES album cover Studio Album, 1994
3.09 | 1186 ratings

BUY
Talk
Yes Symphonic Prog

Review by Etherea

4 stars This was the latest Yes album when I first became a fan! To this day, it still holds up and I think it is an energetic, spirited take on the Yes sound for the '90s.

From the opening track 'The Calling', the band are in fine foot-stomping form with great melody and knotty interludes to spare. White's drums are higher in the mix than usual which re-inforces the band's backbone after some lightweight albums.

The beautiful vocal harmonies of 'I Am Waiting' send shivers down the spine, while 'Real Love' and 'State Of Play' have a welcome splash of metal riffing, electronic percussion and funky drum loops.

'Walls' (co-written by Supertramp's Roger Hodgson) feels like the only true concession to a commercial pop format while 'Where Will You Be' is polished and cinematic.

Last but not least we have the 15 minute suite 'Endless Dream' which begins dauntingly with knotty keyboard and guitar passages before moving through an escalating melody and climax.

This album neatly closes the Trevor Rabin era of Yes (although the guitarist would tour with Anderson and Wakeman some years later) and it is arguably his finest album with the band and certainly the last time Yes dared to look forward artistically rather than backwards.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Anderson Bruford Wakeman Howe by ANDERSON - BRUFORD - WAKEMAN - HOWE album cover Studio Album, 1989
3.21 | 433 ratings

BUY
Anderson Bruford Wakeman Howe
Anderson - Bruford - Wakeman - Howe Symphonic Prog

Review by Etherea

3 stars This is Yes in all but name. We have here an explosion of ideas-some lengthy and suite-like- performed by 4/5ths of the classic Yes line-up that recorded 'Fragile' and 'Close To The Edge'.

Jon Anderson seems particularly fired up by a disdain for the capitalist mechanisms of the music industry on the opening track 'Themes' which features lyrics like 'Be gone you ever-piercing power play machine!' and 'I am out at thee with a vengeance!'.

After years of amassing solo projects under their collective belts, Bruford, Howe and Wakeman sound inspired and driven playing in the same room. Wakeman's keyboard wizardry then blasts through the speakers on the cinematic 'Fist Of Fire' like a long lost friend!

Next is the multi-part 'Brother Of Mine' which is fine but doesn't do quite enough to justify its running time. This is followed by 'Birthright', a song where Jon Anderson waxes lyrical about the nuclear testing in South Australia in the 1950s.

Musically, the band are in top form here with Howe's stinging guitar lines matched with Bruford's tribal polyrhythms against a backdrop of Wakeman's painterly keyboard layering.

As with a lot of Yes albums since the glory era, things become a bit inconsistent after this point and the middle sags considerably with some decorative, feathery material. The latin-infused 'Teakbois' picks up the pace a bit but feels more like a Jon Anderson solo venture than a true group effort.

Things are salvaged though with the hard-rocking suite 'Order Of The Universe' which hammers things home with a big drum sound, kitchen sink percussive clangs, hard-rock guitar and cheesy but epic synth brass. This track is also the closest Anderson's choirboy vocals have come to sounding 'gritty'!

The closing track 'Let's Pretend' rounds things off nicely with a spare arrangement of vocals and acoustic guitar and the whole production is packaged in a fantastic canyon fantasy landscape sleeve by Roger Dean. What more could a Yes fan ask for at this point?

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Open Your Eyes by YES album cover Studio Album, 1997
2.06 | 1030 ratings

BUY
Open Your Eyes
Yes Symphonic Prog

Review by Etherea

3 stars This 1997 release is surprisingly not the album its bland cover and obvious rushed packaging suggested... Oddly enough its promotional sticker claimed it to be the first Yes studio album since Talk- In his intrinsic, erratic relationship with Yes, Wakeman left the group half way through the 1996 reunion tour and is replaced by Billy Sherwood.

Fortunately, Howe stayed on and once again contributed some fine guitar work, in a seemingly deliberate reaction against the last two live/studio Keys To Ascension albums.

The accent on songs and not epics this time is what makes this for the most part- an enjoyable listen. The opening track 'New State Of Mind' stomps in with a big riff and lushly blended vocal harmonies and is followed by the title track which succeeds in blending the Progressive and commercial elements of the band in more compact form.

This approach continues with 'Universal Garden' which feels like an updated version of 'It Can Happen' from 90125 a decade earlier, an impressive song in its own right. 'Fortune Seller' is the killer deep cut for me- great playing from Squire and White, richly layered Beach Boy-esque vocal harmonies and some gorgeously tasteful jazz picking from Steve Howe. This is a fun album in many ways and perhaps deliberately eschews the trappings of the band's Prog Rock excesses in favour of more concise songwriting.

In this respect, both Squire and Billy Sherwood deserve credit for re-inventing the wheel and not following the well- worn path- this beginning as a songwriting project between the two of them. As with most Yes albums since the 70s, it is nowhere near perfect and there is also a handful of trite filler material like 'No Way We Can Lose', "Man In The Moon', and 'Loveshine'.

The better moments ('Open Your Eyes', 'Universal Garden', 'Fortune Seller', 'Wonderlove','From the Balcony', 'The Solution') certainly make up for it and make it worth investigating for any fan of Yes. NB: My version of the album also included an extra 10-15 minutes of tropical rainforest sounds with occasional bursts of isolated vocal harmonies. Was this just music for a CD ROM or DVD menu, does anyone know??

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 An Hour Before It's Dark by MARILLION album cover Studio Album, 2022
3.95 | 280 ratings

BUY
An Hour Before It's Dark
Marillion Neo-Prog

Review by Etherea

3 stars Call me a cynic, but this whole Steve Hogarth style of Marillion music seems to be on auto-pilot where cinematic keyboards and lyrics about humans not engaging with one another (the sightly annoying 'I put my arms around her' refrain in 'Murder Machines') have taking precedent over memorable hooks and melodies.

I find some of Hogarth's lyrics to be pretentiously outré such as the aforementioned 'I put my arms around her/and killed her with love' but in earlier times, the melody and arrangement was king so the lyrics and even Hogarth's nasally delivery were tolerable (1995's excellent 'Afraid Of Sunlight').

This is not to say that some of the material lacks merit. This is a seasoned progressive rock band and 'Sierra Leone' for example, has some charm and warmth (at least the first parts).

The album opener 'Be Hard On Yourself' also surprises a little with the use of a choir- although its remaining segmented parts are less distinct and merely re-iterate the first part (a problem with most of the song suites).

'Murder Machines' has a light funky groove but it takes a back seat to the lyrics. So as with the group's previous album FEAR and most of SOUNDS THAT CAN'T BE MADE (apart from the extraordinary 'Gaza'), the most dangerous thing about Marillion's brand of airy, synth-laden Prog Rock is the lyrics.

Musically they are still of a very high pedigree as this album demonstrates, but if you are a bit too familiar with this incarnation of Marillion, you may want to skip this one.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Rage For Order by QUEENSRYCHE album cover Studio Album, 1986
4.01 | 422 ratings

BUY
Rage For Order
Queensr˙che Progressive Metal

Review by Etherea

3 stars Bombast and studio trickery are all very good but what about the songs? Well, the songs on Queensryche's second album-while not all winners-certainly reach some emotional and artistic peaks. 'Walk In the Shadows' is a terrific opening rocker with some truly stratospheric vocals from Geoff Tate but then we are treated with the Proggish power ballad 'I Dream In Infrared' followed by a flashy polyrhythmic drum groove that anchors the riff heavy 'The Whisper'. 'Gonna Get Close To You' is a voyeuristic cover complete with earth-shattering Phil Collins drums and a sleazy Geoff Tate vocal but it is after this point in the album that the songwriting quality dips a little.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Even in Arcadia by SLEEP TOKEN album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.16 | 14 ratings

BUY
Even in Arcadia
Sleep Token Post Rock/Math rock

Review by arcane-beautiful

4 stars Even In Arcadia by Sleep Token is a great move into more mainstream territory for the mysterious project. The rollout of singles on this album and the campaigning was perfect, but when it comes to the finished project, it does start to verve into predictable song formats. But while the ending does show more experimenting promise, the real clincher of this album is the production, performances and lyrics. While not overall being a thrill ride, the quality of material is fantastic with great creative choices throughout with pristine glimmer. On this album Vessel is more comfortable with his own voice, possibly linking to the concepts and themes, overall creating a great almost cinematic narrative. Great mix of styles proving that these guys deserve the attention that they have been currently getting. Lyrically the album is perfect, with great use of language and imagery. While not as grabbing as their previous album, this is still a great follow up and by far no slouch. I'd give this a low to mid 8 out of 10.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Roadburn Live 2008 by DIAGONAL album cover Live, 2022
4.00 | 4 ratings

BUY
Roadburn Live 2008
Diagonal Eclectic Prog

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars DIAGONAL released their self titled album back in 2008 and followed that up with a lot of live gigging. This "Roadburn Live" album is an important document as to how incredible this band was in a live setting. Recorded in April of 2008 this seven piece band was on fire. Sax player Nick Whittaker commented "I remember that was one of the shows where everything just clicked. We were playing live a lot at that time and you can really hear how tight we were in both the written and improvised sections. We'd recorded the debut a few months earlier and we were so confident with the songs and how to get the most out of them on stage."

If you don't have their first two albums you really need to check them out. They are very different from each other though. This is such a talented band with Alex Crispin leading the way on keyboards and vocals. Essentially we have two guitarists, two keyboardists, bass, drums and sax. As far as the keyboards go, Crispin plays farfisa organ while Ross Hasek adds synths. This is a 43 minute album that contains the whole debut album less the over 7 minute "Deathwatch" which was replaced with the previously unreleased "Heavy Language" at almost 7 minutes. This recording is archival, not being released until 2022 and it was mixed and mastered by Alex Crispin.

The love for this one was immediate, not so surprisingly given my appreciation for their debut. They combined the first two songs from that debut "Semi Permeable Menbrain" and "Child Of The Thundercloud" for an awesome 20 minute ride to get us started. Man, I am so into the vocals and sound here. The closer "Pact" at almost 11 minutes is just about as good. If the two shorter pieces were more my thing I'm going 5 stars. But they aren't. They are both shorter at 7 and 5 minutes but both are also fairly abrasive with that guitar style. I even thought of Italians GARDEN WALL when I first heard "Cannon Misfire". Both are good, but not great.

Luke Foster needs to be mentioned on drums along with his rhythm partner Daniel Pomlett on bass. I'm sure this show would have been talked about for months. The added sax along with the farfisa and vocals would have made this band's sound somewhat unique at the Roadburn festival. And this is a very 70's sounding performance. Easily 4 stars.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Great Balloon Race  by SKY album cover Studio Album, 1985
3.49 | 35 ratings

BUY
The Great Balloon Race
Sky Eclectic Prog

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Sky lost another co-founder between Cadmium and this, John Williams electing to step away from the group, and rather than simply replace him the remaining four members decided to take the empty seat as an opportunity to experiment, working in a range of guest musicians here and there as the compositions demand. This actually ends up working quite well! There's an extra injection of energy that comes in here, a sense of the unexpected which hasn't really been around since Sky 2, and whilst it wouldn't endure, it did at least refresh the group's sound enough to make The Great Balloon Race decidedly worth it.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Love by FLOWER KINGS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.69 | 64 ratings

BUY
Love
The Flower Kings Symphonic Prog

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Love, the latest Flower Kings album, finds the band in a gentle and low-key mood. Whereas the band's back catalogue is full of energetic, rambunctious, extremely busy and intricate music, Love finds Roine Stolt and company not averse to kicking back, calming down, and keeping it simple. That isn't to say they've stopped being prog by any stretch of the imagination - after all, think of how Yes, one of the Kings' major influences, wove moments of gentle beauty into their music in between the outbursts of technical wizardry, something which has always been something of a factor in the Kings' music.

Just because the pendulum's swung towards a quieter and more introspective approach doesn't mean this has become easy listening, mind - this is an album of melancholic contemplation of the state of the world, shot through with a strong vein of optimism and hope which is just the message we need to hear in the present moment. It's not a top-flight classic, but it surprised me at a point in the band's career when I wasn't expecting to be surprised, and that counts for something.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Daughter of Time by COLOSSEUM album cover Studio Album, 1970
3.72 | 194 ratings

BUY
Daughter of Time
Colosseum Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Chris Farlowe's turbocharged lungs drive Colosseum's music to the next level on Daughter of Time, the last studio album of their original run. Joining on lead vocals, Farlowe comes across like a more sombre, less excitable Arthur Brown, which I suppose makes sense since both Colosseum and the Crazy World of Arthur Brown had a somewhat similar approach to taking the blues and, rather than trying to reproduce it directly and appropriate it, instead inject a good dose of psychedelia and make it good and weird. It's overlooked next to Valentyne Suite, perhaps because it doesn't have an epic track comparable to the title track of that one, but that seems unfair, since I reckon it's about on a par.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Gamle Mester by FRØISLIE, LARS FREDRIK album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.48 | 58 ratings

BUY
Gamle Mester
Lars Fredrik Frøislie Symphonic Prog

Review by hugo1995

5 stars Frøislie has long been celebrated as the PROG MESTER, a true master of vintage keyboard arts, known for his work with Wobbler and his reverence for the classic sounds of the 70s prog scene. with his latest solo release, Gamle Mester, Frøislie steps into darker, more introspective territory, drawing deeply from the well of Scandinavian prog that flourished in the 90s ? one of the greatest eras in the genre's history.

Opening with the epic "Demring," Frøislie immediately establishes a more brooding, atmospheric tone that feels like a spiritual successor to the foreboding passages of Änglagård and Landberk. This track, in particular, evokes the same cold, melancholic textures that defined the Swedish masters of that era ? in my opinion it's a significant shift from the more jubilant, folk-tinged brightness of many Wobbler compositions. Yet, this change feels entirely organic, as if Frøislie is tapping into a long-simmering creative reservoir, rich with vintage Mellotron, searing Hammond organ, and haunting flute lines that echo through the icy Nordic mist.

Previously released tracks like "Gamle Mester", "Kalydonske" showcasing Frøislie's unparalleled ability to weave complex, adventurous compositions that blend the warmth of analog synths with the sharp bite of raw, Scandinavian atmosphere. It's hard to describe in words what the scandi prog sound is. It's this fusion that sets him apart, making him one of the few artists today, if not the only, who truly capture the spirit of classic prog while pushing its boundaries into a completely new, shadow-laden territory.

For fans of adventurous, keyboard-heavy prog with a taste for the darker side of the genre, Gamle Mester is a triumphant return to form. Frøislie has crafted an album that not only stands tall alongside his past work but also pushes the boundaries of what modern prog can be. It's the kind of record that demands repeat listens, revealing new layers of complexity and emotion with each spin ? a true contender for album of the year in the progsphere.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 A Sonication by OBSCURA album cover Studio Album, 2025
2.96 | 7 ratings

BUY
A Sonication
Obscura Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars "A Sonication" is the seventh full-length studio album by German death metal act Obscura. The album was released through Nuclear Blast in February 2025. It´s the successor to "A Valediction" from 2021. Only lead vocalist/guitarist (and band founder) Steffen Kummerer remains from the lineup who recorded the predecessor. "A Sonication" was released in the midst of a storm of controversy regarding the songwriting credits, as some former members of the band accused Kummerer of using parts they had written. Parts which according to them, Kummerer had promised to remove from the compositions.

Songwriting controversy or not, Obscura sound more or less like they have done since the release of their second album "Cosmogenesis" (2009). Technical death metal with a progressive edge, influenced by 80s/90s death metal acts like Death and Pestilence (the technical death metal albums by those artists) albeit appearing in a more contemporary skin and sound. Obscura have lifted the foot from the technical playing pedal though, and "A Sonication" overall sounds a bit more straight forward than what Obscura have released since "Cosmogenesis", although "A Valediction" also leaned that way. There are a lot of melodic death metal tendencies here too, and although Obscura have always been quite a melodic inclined technical/progressive metal act, they have increased the melodic death metal elements on "A Sonication". The vocals as usual vary between snarling raw vocals and deeper growling. There are occasionally some raw shouting and slightly more melodic tinged singing on the album too.

Although the material on the 8 tracks, 39:07 minutes long album is overall well written and the album features high level musicianship and a crisp, sharp, and detailed sound production, it´s still like something isn´t right. Obscura sound a bit tame and uninspired and "A Sonication" is an album lacking fire and passion. For a death metal release this is pretty limb, and although no one should ever expect to hear Suffocation or Cannibal Corpse brutality on an Obscura album, a bit more bite and intensity wouldn´t have hurt. It´s not a bad quality release, but it does sound a little sterile and lacking in energy. A 3.5 star (70%) rating is still deserved, but this seems like a crossroads for Obscura, and It´ll be interesting to see where they go from here.

(Originally posted on Metal Music Archives).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Grave New World by STRAWBS album cover Studio Album, 1972
4.15 | 402 ratings

BUY
Grave New World
Strawbs Prog Folk

Review by Lobster77

4 stars On their fourth album the band heads towards a more progressive rock direction. Their first three albums all had progressive elements but most of the material was just folk rock kind of stuff. I like their style change even if their previous albums all include some very nice material as well. Grave New World still has a bit of their original folk style left which is nice. But mostly this record is a prog rock disc from the start to the end.

Some of the highlights include "New World", "The Flower and the Young Man" and "Tomorrow" for example. Fantastic songs and those aren't the only great songs this album has to offer. Several very good songs are found from this LP. On the other hand there are still some tracks that don't have anything special to offer but luckily most of the material is solid.

This is slightly better than 3,5 stars so I guess I'll give this album four stars. Grave New World is a very nice progressive rock album even if it's definitely not one of the true diamonds of the genre. A solid listen however.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Radio Gnome Invisible Vol. 2 - Angel's Egg by GONG album cover Studio Album, 1973
4.14 | 806 ratings

BUY
Radio Gnome Invisible Vol. 2 - Angel's Egg
Gong Canterbury Scene

Review by Lobster77

4 stars I love Flying Teapot to death and I think it's a great starting point into Gong, but Angel's Egg seems to take what Flying Teapot did, compacted it, and made it more complete. There are plenty more shorter excursions here, but they work so well and many songs perfectly flow right into each other. The perks I notice here are Steve Hillage's guitar work (quite fascinating if you ask me), the percussion fest on "Love is How Y Make It", and the overall silliness of everything which is retained from their previous work. With titles like "Sold to the Highest Buddha" and "Eat That Phone Book Coda", you can tell this group aren't taking themselves too seriously, and I love them for it.

Pretty much everything from "Flute Salad" and onward is where I really start to get into Angel's Egg. Even the bonus track on the CD version I have ("The Ooby-Scooby Doomsday...") doesn't slow the album down a bit. "Prostitute Poem" might be my lone gripe, but that gets quickly drowned out by everything else on Angel's Egg. This is a lighter, goofier, way-less-serious side of progressive rock that is worth checking out.

4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 S&M 2 by METALLICA album cover DVD/Video, 2020
3.62 | 14 ratings

BUY
S&M 2
Metallica Prog Related

Review by martindavey87

4 stars Twenty years after the first 'S&M' concerts, and Metallica team up once more with the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra for a musical extravaganza, as metal meets classical in the ultimate musical collaboration.

Containing two CD's and a DVD of the concert, 'S&M2' lives up to its predecessor, but is as different as it is similar. Besides advancements in technology allowing for much, much better sound and picture (on the DVD), the band have this time, taken the performance from a concert hall to a huge arena, and with thousands of Metallica fans in attendance, the audience participation really enhances the experience, especially on the ending of 'The Memory Remains'.

The differences don't stop there. What's noticeable on the DVD, is that, unlike the first 'S&M', where Metallica were in their late 30's, battling shifting musical trends, addictions, and personal strife, and "taking a risk" with the whole endeavour, this time the band are now all in their late 50's. They're sober, a cohesive unit, and they've done this before, and you can see how they seem so much more relaxed this time around. Conductor Edwin Outwater's visual energy is infectious, and the orchestra musicians are no doubt, absolute professionals, but I can't help but feel like the pep talk backstage was something like "hey, don't worry, just have fun".

If any risks are taken this time around, it's the middle segment which sees the orchestra given time to shine. With classical pieces, a double bass tribute to Cliff Burton, as well as an orchestral version of 'The Unforgiven III', which sees James Hetfield go guitar-less. I don't think this has happened since he burnt his arm in the early 90's?

While sentimentality and nostalgia will always make me prefer the first 'S&M' over this one, the reality is that 'S&M2' is every part it's equal. Featuring classics such as 'One', 'Enter Sandman' 'For Whom the Bell Tolls' and 'Master of Puppets', as well as newer songs, 'The Day That Never Comes', 'Moth Into Flame', and 'Halo On Fire' (which sounds incredible with the orchestra), the CD's and DVD make for a fantastic audio and visual experience, and this is as essential a part of any Metallica collection as the first. Will the band still be around in their 70's for part three? Let the waiting begin!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Afraid Of Sunlight by MARILLION album cover Studio Album, 1995
3.83 | 836 ratings

BUY
Afraid Of Sunlight
Marillion Neo-Prog

Review by VianaProghead
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Review Nē 893

Marillion is a progressive rock band that was formed in 1979 in UK. Marillion had its origins in the early 80's presenting itself as the main representative of the new generation of the English progressive rock, as it was in decline since the appearance of the Punk Rock Movement and the New Wave, in addition to the abandonment of the style made by many of the classic prog bands, such as Genesis, Yes and Emerson, Lake & Palmer. They're one of the founders of neo-prog.

"Afraid Of Sunlight" is the eighth studio album of Marillion and that was released in 1995. Here again the band was faced with the challenge of continuing after the release of a very well finished album, "Brave". Although in its own way, Marillion remained within an excellent quality level. All tracks here are melodic, well written and beautifully produced, although on "Afraid Of Sunlight" the sound is much softer than in the Fish's era and even in the early Hogarth's era albums. Containing beautiful soundscapes, the songs are beautifully harmonized and are simply transposed into one another with organic textures, taking the listener in a musical ride that eventually erupts with good emotional intensity. So, all in all, "Afraid Of Sunlight" is an album that has emotions, complexity, excellent lyrics ad good instrumentation.

The line up on "Afraid Of Sunlight" is Steve Hogarth (lead and backing vocals, keyboards and percussion), Steve Rothery (guitars), Mark Kelly (keyboards), Pete Trewavas (backing vocals and basses) and Ian Mosley (drums and percussion). "Afraid Of Sunlight" is an album that had also de participation of Barbara Lezmy, Wendy Page and Hannah Stobart (backing vocals), as three guest artists.

"Afraid Of Sunlight" has eight tracks. The first track "Gazpacho" opens with the Rothery's chiming guitar figure and Trewavas' hyperactive bass line, as Hogarth introduces the themes that will emerge over the next seven tracks. This seemingly jaunty tune with its chiming guitars floats along on a deceptively cheery melody and with some great hooks. The second track "Cannibal Surf Babe" is a fun and silly stomp that recalls the 60's surf music and features some pretty awesome Beach Boys. While this could seem the album's throwaway track, there's nothing wrong with a bit of fun on the album. It has good lyrics with highly unconventional music for Marillion. The third track "Beautiful" was chosen to be released as a single. This is a melodic ballad which might not be to everyone's taste, since it's quite sentimental. It's a nice pop song with good melody and a simple naive text with few extremely broken treatments of the chosen meter. It would have fit in well on "Holidays In Eden". The fourth track "Afraid Of Sunrise" is a true gorgeous track. This is a completely atmospheric song, which is particularly noticeable with the lively bass from Trewavas and the broom drums from Mosley. It's one of the best tracks on the album and features some really enjoyable fretless bass work. This is probably one of the highlights on the album. The fifth track "Out Of This World" is another huge highlight. The lyrics get really personal and in the midst of this calm, cascading soundscapes of songs hides one of the most beautiful guitar solos that Rothery has ever played. The final consists of a carpet of keyboard sounds with all sorts of samples and around it, nothing for the impatient, but absolutely great for the intensity of the mood. The sixth track is the title track "Afraid Of Sunlight". This is another highlight, possibly one of my favourite tracks on the album. It's again a slow ballad, but this time tranquil and reflective, with some great evocative imagery. The track is further distinguished by a sprawling, grand chorus and a stupendously beautiful middle section. This is pure sonic nirvana music. The seventh track "Beyond You" is another heart on sleeve song, I think this time on the subject of love. This is almost a personal piece for the band, and especially for Hogarth himself, for a long time. According to Hogarth own statements, he simply couldn't sing it live. The lyrics are top notch with a haunting melancholy. The eighth track "King" closes the album bringing all the threads together in rumination on the attention seeking. It forms the massive conclusion, the dangers of fame, Kurt Cobain and Elvis form the thematic framework, along which we can see the claustrophobia. It concludes with a gloriously oceanic, noisy, a soaring build up. This is perhaps the strongest single track on the album.

Conclusion: Despite a disappointing commercial performance, the album was critically acclaimed as one of the band's best ever. From the opening track to the closing one, the album is an authentic musical journey, a perfect blend of different musical approaches that goes from progressive rock to pop. "Afraid Of Sunlight" has no weak points and it's the final proof that Marillion are meanwhile in a class of their own. It has a timeless quality and an effortless melody, not to mention that beautiful all around glow. In retrospect, "Afraid Of Sunlight" will proves to be a perfect divider between the first Marillion with their strong purely progressive atmospheres, and the futures projected towards a genre closer to rock than prog. The still unbroken courage to take risks against the too narrow die hard supporters ennobles the five.

Prog is my Ferrari. Jem Godfrey (Frost*)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Quiver by PHLOX album cover Studio Album, 2011
3.23 | 8 ratings

BUY
Quiver
Phlox Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by DetectiveDoom

3 stars Phlox is a Malaysian psych rock quartet featuring Hakim Tahar (vocals/keyboards/guitars), Hanafi Rahman (guitar), Syazwan Sazali (bass) and Ahmad Zulikhwan (drums).

Their first full length album Quiver shows them finding a middle ground between Pink Floyd, Ozric Tentacles and some Britpop bands like The Verve (themselves very PF-influenced).

The recurring Quiver (in three parts) offers a darker twist to the trippy motifs, while Speak To Me soars unexpectedly. Where You Go and Inside Outside continue in the same vein.

I also find Morning Dreams and Everything Kills You to be charmingly deranged acoustic guitar excursions.

Although I prefer the follow up album YWNTS, this is still a good place to start.

The Malaysian psych scene is very poorly documented but there are interesting albums.

Phlox's two albums rank alongside The Strollers' Waiting Is, Damn Dirty Apes' Valve State Dreams. Capt'n Trips And The Kids' The Paraverse, Golden Mammoth's Skyscraper Towards The Sun and Martin Vengadesan & The Stalemate Factor's The Knight's Flight as the best of Malaysian psychedelic music.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Queen's Gambit by MARTIN VENGADESAN & THE STALEMATE FACTOR album cover Studio Album, 2018
2.00 | 2 ratings

BUY
The Queen's Gambit
Martin Vengadesan & The Stalemate Factor Crossover Prog

Review by DetectiveDoom

2 stars This is the first Stalemate Factor album and while it's enjoyable, very little of it is progressive rock. Rather it's more of a singer-songwriter folk and blues rock album that doesn't give much indication of the prog direction that would be showcased on later songs like The Battle Of Emerald Skye and The Horizon Myth.

That said, I still have a lot of time for the songwriting here. Of interest is Across The Moors which rolls along for more than 7 minutes which no sign of percussion. Instead it relies on classical guitar, harpsichord, violin, viola and organ. Another highlight is Wisdom Of A Lie which gets very psychedelic towards the end.

Aside from that there is socially conscious material like the blues-tinged Affirmative and the heartbreaking Song For An Abused Child. Snow Sculpture is an engaging ballad and the Beatles influences are clear on Petunia and Baby Doll.

The Stalemate Factor always stood out on the Malaysian rock scene, and one listen to the album will show you why.

It's also noticeable that this album has a lot of guest performers behind the core trio that make up the band. I have to say that one or two songs seem to suffer from weak production but overall I really enjoy this album. Just that it's not very prog at all. That comes later.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Higher Dimensions by MYSTERIA NOCTIS album cover Studio Album, 2015
2.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Higher Dimensions
Mysteria Noctis Progressive Metal

Review by andrea
Prog Reviewer

— First review of this album —
2 stars Mysteria Noctis came to life in Como in 2011 on the initiative of Alessio Negretti, Alberto Negretti and Giacomo Piccinini, inspired by bands such as Opeth, Porcupine Tree and Dream Theater. After a long time spent in the rehearsal room and a good live activity on the local scene, in 2015 they self-produced and released a debut full length album entitled "Higher Dimensions" with a line up featuring Alberto Negretti (vocals), Alessio Negretti (guitars), Matteo Menafro (keyboards), Pietro Francoli (bass) and Giacomo Piccinini (drums).

It's a still immature work where death and black metal sounds prevail although the band try to blend them with many other different influences, from jazz to prog. Wild, raw sections characterized by growl and screamed voices alternate with calmer acoustic passages and symphonic digressions throughout the five long tracks of the album. "Decadence", "Cry Of The Ocean", "Iter Mentis In Deum", "Logos" and "Of Flames And Eternity" give life to a kind of suite full of interesting ideas, although not always musically coherent. Nonetheless, for the band this was just the starting point...

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Quid Est Veritas? by MYSTERIA NOCTIS album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2017
3.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Quid Est Veritas?
Mysteria Noctis Progressive Metal

Review by andrea
Prog Reviewer

— First review of this album —
3 stars The follow up of Mysteria Noctis' debut album is "Quid est veritas?", an EP that was released in 2017. It represents a step forward and an important change of direction in the style of the band when compared with the previous work from 2015. It was released on the independent Areasonica Records label with a confirmed line up featuring Alberto Negretti (vocals), Alessio Negretti (guitars), Matteo Menafro (keyboards), Pietro Francoli (bass) and Giacomo Piccinini (drums). Here the musicians leave back most of their death and black metal influences in the search for a more personal style. According to the band, this work is "focused on the search for Truth, in the deepest and most absolute sense of the term. It's the human journey towards the light that drives away the unknown, a path that tries to get closer to knowledge but is strewn with obstacles and rarely reaches a definitive conclusion in the span of a single lifetime".

The title track is a long suite sung in Italian (despite the title being in Latin) for which the band also shot a video directed by Simone Sacchi. It depicts the regrets that emerge from foggy memories and from the ashes of an arrogant ego obsessed with knowledge and blinded by greed. But the truth is that a man will never understand the nature of what lies behind the veil of the senses...

The second and last track, the lively "Swinging Mind", is shorter and is sung in English. In the own words of the band, "two progressive rock songs with two different perspectives, different styles that manage to complete a story by making the most of the combination of the tension and restlessness that form the background to the first song and the pinch of madness and instability that unfold during the second"...

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Live: Waves From The Underground by DAAL album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.44 | 16 ratings

BUY
Live: Waves From The Underground
Daal Eclectic Prog

Review by Stoneburner

5 stars Daal's from the Underground

This happens from time to time: when a band we like releases two albums at once. This year, DAAL did just that, and unlike Echolyn, whose double release didn't entirely convince me, DAAL delivered two powerful and contrasting works.

DAAL has been one of the most consistent progressive bands of recent years. Since 2018's "Decalogue of Darkness," perhaps their masterpiece, they have maintained a high standard, with previous works like "Dodecahedron" (2012) also standing out. Their music is hard to define: dark, immersive, and primarily instrumental, built around the sonic vision of keyboardist Alfio Costa, with support from Davide Guidoni, Ettore Salati, and Bobo Aiolfi.

Live: "Waves from the Underground" was recorded in 2023 at Studiosette in Rome and consists of improvised sessions. It includes reinterpretations of older tracks like "Brain Melody" and "Decalogue Part I," but in this live jam format, they take on a new life. The tracks on "W.F.T.U.," each referencing a specific historical date and geographic coordinate, add a conceptual layer, making the album more than just a typical live album.

Musically, this album explores a rawer, more experimental side of DAAL. It leans toward late-'60s German electro-prog, space rock vibes reminiscent of Hawkwind, and the avant-garde tension of bands like Art Zoyd. It's the perfect counterpoint to the dense and claustrophobic Decoding the Emptiness. Where that album plunges you into darkness, this one offers energy, risk, and freedom.

In a year in which DAAL has already released one of their best studio efforts, Live: Waves from the Underground arrives not as an afterthought, but as an essential accompaniment: an expansion of their sound and spirit. Personally, I've been listening to it more often. I enjoy the exploratory, improvisational side of progressive music, and this album fills that need perfectly.

I really enjoyed this record even more than Decoding the Emptiness, I'm more into the experimental side but both records are truly outstanding.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Decoding The Emptiness by DAAL album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.31 | 21 ratings

BUY
Decoding The Emptiness
Daal Eclectic Prog

Review by Stoneburner

4 stars Decoding Daal

These things happen from time to time: when a band we like releases two albums at once. Well, this year Echolyn did it? and in my opinion, it wasn't a good decision. But I'm not here to judge them, because I want to talk about Daal, the Italian band, another of my favorites.

Daal has been releasing excellent albums for years. Since 2018's "Decalogue of Darkness"?perhaps their best work?they've demonstrated remarkable consistency. That doesn't mean their earlier material is weak; on the contrary, their discography has virtually no low points. One of them is 2012's Dodecahedron, another magnificent album.

Immersing yourself in Daal's sound is like immersing yourself in a dark and gloomy world of impressive sonic quality. Their musical skill takes you through shadowy realms, occasionally opening up to brighter or denser spaces. The band uses their instrumental prowess to create a kind of sonic exploration: an interplay of light and darkness. Their music is difficult to define.

Led by keyboardist Alfio Costa, who creates the tones and atmospheres, Daal's sound is primarily instrumental. He is accompanied by Davide Guidoni on drums, Ettore Salati on guitar, and Bobo Aiolfi on bass. While vocals are rare, this time they feature contributions from Joe Sal and Alphabeard, who provide texture on two tracks instead of taking center stage.

Decoding the Emptiness is a complex and diverse album, particularly claustrophobic, but that's part of the experience Daal seeks to offer. It sometimes offers no respite with its dark, disjointed cadences, but musically it is extraordinary: a journey of the mind and spirit to those corners we often avoid, but somehow find strangely comforting. The performance is masterful and, as I said, constantly surprises you. It transports you through changing landscapes, creating a deep and unique connection, like discovering a hidden secret in each track.

Decoding the Emptiness undoubtedly sits on the darker side of progressive rock, but in a way that is highly rewarding for those who appreciate the genre's more cinematic and experimental nuances.

This album doesn't strive for catchy melodies or traditional structures. Instead, it builds dense soundscapes with vintage synthesizers, layers of mellotron, percussive textures, and melancholic atmospheres. It leans toward avant-prog and symphonic dark prog, referencing bands like Goblin, Univers Zero, and the more haunting side of King Crimson. Despite being primarily instrumental, it tells a compelling story, almost like the soundtrack to a psychological thriller or an art film.

Decoding the Emptiness might be Daal's best album to date: its layers of density and darkness are so well realized that the album stands as a true milestone in the genre.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Califas Del Rock by MEZQUITA album cover Studio Album, 1981
2.73 | 23 ratings

BUY
Califas Del Rock
Mezquita Symphonic Prog

Review by glaceoncheesecake

3 stars This is the second and last, more "pop rock" oriented album by Mezquita. They've bumped up their arabic influences but've dropped the progressiveness that the first album had almost entirely, with average lyrics and "easier" vocals, so if you're looking for progressive rock, check out the first album.

Their closing track, "La montaņa, La Ciudad" is very reminiscent of their first album, with long instrumental breaks and the return of the original poetic lyrics and vocals, and is about as progressive as this album gets.

The opening "Cuento Árabe" isn't really progressive, but it's very catchy and Arabic, and one of my favorites of the album.

"La Última Juerga" is probably nothing too special, but it reminds me of Mana, specifically their song "Oye Mi Amor". That's all.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Mirage by CAMEL album cover Studio Album, 1974
4.42 | 3190 ratings

BUY
Mirage
Camel Symphonic Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Camel followed up their eponymous debut album with the brilliant 'Mirage', released in March of 1974 by the classic lineup of Andrew Latimer, Peter Bardens, Andy Ward, and Doug Ferguson. This second studio album seems to be following closely in the footsteps of the band's melodic and moody first album from one side, but from another it also introduces an array of new and exciting sounds, this time with an even greater influence from the Canterbury scene, especially Caravan and their jazz-tinted explorations. Composed of just five tracks, two of which are multi-part suites, 'Mirage' is naturally one of the more accessible and successful Camel albums, with its strong melodies and chiseled arrangements, through which the listener could appreciate the majestic interplay between the guitar work and the organs; just wonderful musicianship from a band that tends to focus more on melody, structure and mood, rather than technicality and flamboyancy, which might also be the reason why this recording lacks some of the bombastic and cathartic qualities associated with the progressive rock genre.

The entire album flows evenly and is a rather enjoyable listen, starting off with the up-tempo rocking opener 'Freefall', one of the more straightforward Camel songs, definitely carrying great commercial potential. Yet the musicianship and the prudent playing on this track are never compromised. This one is followed by the first instrumental on the album called 'Supertwister', a song that sees Andy Latimer's enchanting flute playing, a nice addition to the sound palette of the album and a really mellow piece. The three-part suite 'The White Rider', closing off side one, might as well be the most exciting number on here, the instrumental work on this track is relentless and the gorgeous melodies seem to be in-tune with the aim of the song, simply an excellent work of prog. 'Earthrise' is the second instrumental off the album, a more ambitious and more complex arrangement here, that showcases the more experimental side of Camel's music. Finally, there is the iconic epic 'Lady Fantasy', seen by many as one of the hymns of 70s prog rock. A worthy piece of music, this three-part song carries some excellent and memorable sections as well as some of the most relentless Andrew Latimer playing yet. The entire 'Mirage' album is a very eclectic Camel release and an excellent one, too, but it also seems to be a bit one-dimensional and safe, always moody and never overly flamboyant - its strengths lie in the excellent songwriting and tremendous instrumental work, and despite the lack of experimentation, 'Mirage' remains not only a Camel essential but also a 70s prog gem.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Paragon Circus by ALTESIA album cover Studio Album, 2019
4.08 | 32 ratings

BUY
Paragon Circus
Altesia Progressive Metal

Review by Dapper~Blueberries
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Altesia is a fairly newer band within the prog mythos, forming in 2017 in Bordeaux, Nouvelle-Aquitaine, France. Now the reason I am reviewing an album from this fairly obscure prog metal act is simple?I just felt like it. Also because their next album, The Somnambulist, is coming out next month, and I kinda wanna review their first two albums before then.

Altesia's debut album sets the status quo for what the band's sound is gonna be. In a way, they're as if you took some of the more rocking songs from Dream Theater or Haken, and put that as a focus, creating a prog metal sound that's easier to get into on the spectrum. I don't have a problem with this, especially since I like the sound they got going on. It may not be mind blowing, super intense, or any of the in-between, but it's still fun to listen to in my personal opinion.

The band also shows a good willingness to be eclectic, trying some new things with each song to see what sticks. After all, a debut doesn't always have the right sound right away, and a band should always experiment to see what sticks. Some of the best bands out there, especially in prog rock, don't always have the right sound off the bat. Look at Renaissance, or Genesis, or Pink Floyd, or hell even Dream Theater. This band draws quite a bit from Dream Theater (a bit heavily I might add but I'll get into that later), and that band didn't have their sound down pact, having their first album be more in-line with symphonic metal and AOR than what they're known for now.

I also really like the keyboard work on here. They work very nicely in tandem to the guitars, and give the album a more unique style. I especially like the organs at the beginning of Amidst the Smoke, which give the song a pretty haunting intro.

The longer tracks are also really nice, especially Reminiscence and the epic of Cassandra's Prophecy. Cassandra's Prophecy is a 17 minute epic, so it was bound to be a favorite of mine, but Reminiscence is also a highlight here. It changes quite a lot, and over the course of its runtime, you can go from fairly great prog metal jams to jazzy synth works, to even a moment that feels like it came out of a funk metal song. It's symphonic, eclectic, and pretty fun. Easily the best track on the album for me.

Though, while listening to this album, I start to realize how much it kinda just sounds like Dream Theater, or any of those other fairly standard prog metal bands out there. Obviously I am fine with some derivatives, I mean, I like retro prog a lot, and that sound draws heavily from symphonic prog bands of old. But also MAN does this debut make Altesia kinda sound like Haken copycats, which they aren't, but still there is definitely some overlap in sound, which I think kinda harms the album.

Also, while I do like that they're more softer in their metal approach, I kinda wish they got a bit heavier. They kinda do it on Hex Reverse, with some harsh backing vocals, which are pretty awesome all things considered, but I kinda wish they really delve into some heavier sounds here and there for some surprise factor. At least it seems like, with their single of Her Ghost In Limbo, their up and coming album will go full throttle into the heavy metal aspects of the band, so that'll be exciting to see.

Despite being derivative and not all that intense, Altesia does prove on their debut they're a capable band creating great progressive metal. Not an amazing record, but I'd be damned if I said I didn't like what I heard from it.

Best tracks: Reminiscence, Amidst the Smoke, Hex Reverse, Cassandra's Prophecy

Worst track: Pandora

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Frances the Mute by MARS VOLTA, THE album cover Studio Album, 2005
4.08 | 1041 ratings

BUY
Frances the Mute
The Mars Volta Heavy Prog

Review by arunalu

4 stars I didn't think I'd be into newer progressive rock, as I was obstinately stuck in the '70s. And the fact that Dream Theater's Metropolis Pt. 2 didn't impress me that much didn't help, as I was put off by heavier, newer prog works. I now realise how much I've been missing out on.

Conceptually, Frances the Mute is a complex, fascinating and engaging tale that's supposed to be 'learned' - what I mean by this is that its story isn't quite clear with only a few listens. In this way, it maintains a great replay value, like Pink Floyd's The Wall, for example, which is the golden standard for concept albums in my opinion. This may be recency bias, but Frances the Mute's story is almost as beautiful and memorable as The Wall (even though it doesn't match the songwriting of Roger Waters), which is quite high praise. I look forward to further listens, as I'm pretty enthralled by this album that I've listened to it around three times already.

But the aspect of it that truly mesmerised me is the soundscape and the musicianship of the members. It blends some of my favourite things to be heard in a prog rock album, like free jazz elements, use of synthesisers, excellent guitar work and the liberal use of avant-garde sounds. However, I usually dislike it when prog music is on the heavier side. But, while I didn't enjoy it to the fullest, this heavier album was enjoyable to listen to. Undeniably, this album was very ambitious in using elements that are not often heard in most mainstream prog albums. This makes Frances the Mute a difficult album, which is a good thing when it comes to prog. However, the maximalist approach to the album's musical features also includes a few things I dislike. I found most conclusions of the songs that featured extended sound effects to be a drag to listen to. I felt that these parts made the songs a bit too long. This is one of the reasons I'm giving the album four out of five stars.

My favourite part of Frances the Mute is the amazing prog epic Cassandra Gemini, which I think is the best song on the album. It might be one of the best prog epics I've heard.

In summary, while it (unsurprisingly) fails to reach the heights of albums such as Close to the Edge by Yes or In the Court of the Crimson King by King Crimson - albums that set the bar very high, it's still an amazing record that most prog fans will enjoy, if they tolerate heavier, lengthier compositions.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ian Carr with Nucleus: Solar Plexus by NUCLEUS album cover Studio Album, 1971
3.94 | 101 ratings

BUY
Ian Carr with Nucleus: Solar Plexus
Nucleus Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Recorded in December of 1970, this was Ian Carr's relatively-new "jazz-rock fusion" project's third album release (though many cite Chris Spedding's Ian-Carr-less album from 1970, Songs Without Words as another Nucleus album, which would make Solar Plexus the band's fourth release). Here we see the final appearance on Nucleus/Ian Carr albums of Karl Jenkins, Chris Spedding, Jeff Clyne, and drummer John Marshall while at the same time we see the significant contributions of a number of hired guests to thicken and give variety to Ian's band's sound.

1. Elements I & II (2:12) full-on experimentation with the latest advances/offerings from the world of electronics: here a VCS3 synthesizer, courtesy of Keith Winter, joined by bowed double bass, flanged electric guitar notes, and metallic percussion noises. Interesting and, actually, rather structured! (4.5/5)

2. Changing Times (4:44) so many elements here that refer to other songs, other artists--like HERB ALPERT, OLATUNDE BABATUNJI, HUGH MASAKELA, BURT BACHARACH, and so many others An absolutely brilliant blend of so many styles and sounds: like a brief history of Jazz-Rock music! I'm glad! If anyone in the early Fusion world had a grip on where Jazz-Rock Fusion was coming from and the many, many arms and tentacles it could reach into, it was Ian Carr. A complete visionary! (9/10)

3. Bedrock Deadlock (6:52) opens sounding like a song from mediæval church music with oboe and bowed double bass dancing around one another in a kind of pre-tango pairs dance. Quite lovely--and brilliant! At 1:49, then, the classical music intro ends, there is a pause, and then a full band jumps into a weird motif that forces enters the listener to enter into a mish-mash of early-Beatles psychedelia. At 3:48 a horn section of saxes starts up a new expression of the main melodies--which is then countered by Ian Carr's own competing melody presentation from a horn section that he leads. Mix into the weave Chris Spedding and Jeff Clyne's own competing thread and we have a really cool, really beautiful weave of doubled up melodies--all supported by the rhythm play of John Marshall's drums paired up with Chris Karan's conga play. Cool mathematical exercise! (9.5/10)

4. Spirit Level (9:20) opening with another anachronistic weave of multiple "old" instruments that lasts about 60 seconds before turning into a little sprite-like dance between guests Tony Roberts' bass clarinet and Ron Matthewson's bass--which goes on for about two and a half minutes while late-night jazz brushed drums eventually join in as well as harmonically-arranged horn section. The bass clarinet and bass continue on well into the sixth minute before the band slides into a slightly more substantial jazz motif with sticks being used on the drum kit and Ian stepping up into the lead position while Chris Spedding, Ron Matthewson, Chris Karan, and the other horn players all fall into interestingly creative support roles. Another interesting song that sounds and feels like a journey through several time periods and styles. (18/20)

5. Torso (6:12) a song that feels somewhat rooted in the popular "beach rock" that became popular in the 1960s. There is also a Spanish hue to the song--quite like the Animals version of the classic tune, "Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood" (and the later version by Santa Esmeralda) as well as The Mamas And The Papas' chords from "California Dreamin'" and future [June of 1971] hit, "One Fine Morning" by Canadian band Skylark. A real rousing, rollicking, and engaging tune that makes you want to get up and move! (9.5/10)

6. Snakehips Dream (15:16) a song that starts out as if borrowing an old James Brown R&B motif to ge t started: bass, drums, two rhythm guitar tracks (on the left: more rhythm-oriented with lots of strumming of fast-changing chords; on the right with more jazz sounds and intonations. I'm guessing that Eumir Deodato and his guitarist John Tropea had this in mind when playing/recording for "Also Sprach Zarathustra (2001)"). Weird to just be noticing how there are virtually no keyboards on this album! The first four minutes of this are just as described: all R&B exploration of a theme, but then horns enter and start to fill some spaces and accent others until Brian Smith branches off into the sunlight to posit a smooth tenor sax solo over the hep R&B jam. At the 8:00 mark two different horn groups break off to perform a call-and-response passage that serves as a bridge to Ian's turn to solo--this time on a flugelhorn. Meanwhile, Chris Spedding's two guitar tracks continue to improvise, exploring and entertaining just beneath the lead and rhythm sections. (27/30) Total Time: 44:36

As suggested above, Ian Carr's vision for Jazz-Rock Fusion's potential is about as complete as anyone's that I've encountered: where others are imitators or simply jumping on a bandwagon with the other "cool kids" (like Miles, Freddie Hubbard, Art Farmer, Sonny Rollins, Herbie Mann, Jack DeJohnette, Donald Byrd and even Herbie Hancock (who was really more into exploring the latest and greatest technologies), Ian is actually totally committed, invested, and immersed in the movement--which I really admire. On Solar Plexus one can see Ian growing: spanning two worlds at the same time, with one foot still drawing from all that was fresh and innovative in the pop-jazz world of the 1960s while the other is in the forward-thinking, potential-realizing of his own imagination.

A-/five stars; another minor masterpiece of cutting-edge, exploratory Jazz-Rock Fusion from one of the true leaders and apostles of the movement.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Laplacian by FLUCTUS QUADRATUM album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.07 | 29 ratings

BUY
Laplacian
Fluctus Quadratum Symphonic Prog

Review by tszirmay
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars This is an intriguing instrumental line-up, a father and son team are not exactly a common occurrence, Jopheus Burtonshaw being a 20-year-old keyboards/synthesizer prodigy, who also holds down bass and guitar duties , while his dad Rick operates the drum kit. They are joined by vocalist Curtis Adamczyk. While clearly imbued by the progressive tradition that encompasses the golden years as well as the modern school, the focus here is heavily synthesizer-centric but not the robotic mechanical version, preferring the effervescence of past giants like Emerson, Wakeman and Banks. There is plenty of piano, organ and mellotron as well as an arsenal of synths, just in case the symphonic side needs some support. The father holds down the rhythm section with experience garnered over a long career in music yet surely buoyed by his young offspring's exuberance. The opening piece as well as title track of this debut album stamps the credentials on their style, a surprisingly mature form of symphonic/neo prog of the highest order, propelled by not only overt passion but an ability to handle all kinds of challenging twists and turns, lively contrasts filled with mini solo spotlights that frankly are astounding. The piano work is virtuosic and defiant, remindful of a teenage Eddie Jobson with Curved Air, while his mastery of the various synths is mind boggling, both in accuracy and fury. Vocals and electric lead guitars emerge on "Dawn of Acquiescence III", shining a different light on Jopheus' compositional skills by creating a lyrical opus with enthusiastic singing that hits the mark on multiple levels. There is an obvious layering of keyboards, with solemn contrasts that include fluid piano playing. "Inertia" tips towards a more acoustic tangent, a desperate lament that shimmers in a pool of gentle torpor, loaded with tons of string mellotrons, the vocals despondent and apathetic, perhaps mirroring the title's full meaning.

The epic is a definite highlight as "Where the Lack of Logic Lies", runs eleven minutes plus of unrushed lavishness, a slowly blossoming symphonic arrangement that shows no haste or waste, building up a gradual frenzy that will eventually lead to endless horizons of discovery. The elder Burtonshaw marshals the rhythmic pace, with percussive detailing as well as hard thumping, slipping unexpectedly into a robust bass-led jazz groove, where the organ and the e-piano get to shine brightly in the spotlight. Not to be benched for too long, the synths and the mellotron enter the fray with little restraint. The alternating contrasts between ambient and bombastic make this arrangement a winning proposition. The vocal finale is appropriately forsaken, underlining the subject matter but blends well with the instrumentation as it fades into the mists of time. "The Grey Room' is a brief piano etude that impresses once again, the kid can play, of that there is no doubt. Targeting a more neo angle, "The House Within Itself" maintains the sorrowful lament that still reveals a fair amount of instrumental pace and shows off the ability to veer into variations that remain consistent with the arrangement. The synth solo edges towards virtuosity on a grandiose and bombastic scale, the ornate piano once gain appears to soothe the senses with some romantic interventions that settle the score.

Combining a total of nearly 14 minutes, "Consequences", the intermezzo "Bridge to Suffering" and "Suffering in Serenity" is a 3-part suite that runs the gamut of stylistics this band is capable of achieving, initially carving out a reflective ambiance, laden with sensitive orchestrations that are impressive for such a young musician. The sentimental concentration of piano and mellotron is certainly nothing new in the prog universe but when played with such melodic bravado, it can only be admired for its continued reverence to style. This may just be my favorite section on this extensive album, the melancholic nature certainly appeals to me, a flashback to Mike Rutherford's debut solos album, the vastly underrated "Smallcreep's Day".

This is where a tiny caveat comes into play, the 72 minutes of playing time is perhaps just too much for a debut album, in my humble opinion and would have been better served with a shortened version. The final three excellent tracks, "Alone", the ambient "Mistwell" and "Direlight" came across as overkill , though I must be stated for the record that the latter piece is an absolutely excellent finale, a daring and courageous synthesizer symphony, with tingling medieval acoustic decorations that impress, to say the least. It gets pretty intense in the final stretch, a masterful finishing touch. A band that needs to be ardently followed, rarely have I been so impressed by a debutant prog band with as much raw potential as this.

4.5 square waves

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Enigme by ETRANGE album cover Studio Album, 2022
3.18 | 2 ratings

BUY
Enigme
Etrange Progressive Metal

Review by alainPP

3 stars 1. Entity, with its impeccable technique, blends modern DJent breakdowns with sounds from Dream Theater and Symphony X with classical orchestration; it seems limited by the lack of vocals, and then the flood of notes makes you forget all that. The barrage of guitar riffs combined with the triple pedal has something to do with it. 2. Nexus, like a flash, with a brutal blastbeat for a prog metal sound based on edgy Olympian lyricism, driving the point home and sending it into space. 3. Irradiance, for the slowing tempo, shows neo-classical symphonic sounds with disconcerting brass; a funky undertone for vitality and the quick passage of time, a catchy track that's easier to play for the prog.

4. Gemini for the Symphony X atmosphere again with the guitar boost plunging into a much stronger sound, bordering on djent, power metal and heavy prog rock with the heavy passages of the fat and catchy riffs, amen. The Egyptian atmosphere is very present; mid-course interlude of fusion/flamenco. 5. Möbius for the title reminding me the most of neo-classical fusion with the crystalline piano and its NASA voices, at the start then the guitar ravages worthy of a Patrick Rondat; another atmospheric break before the final melted with the intoxicating keyboards. 6. Eclipse follows on the conventional prog metal and bam, this Van Halen air, yes I can't help but write it; a little groovy from et al croisiere has fun to disturb a little more and you have the summary of this last title pulling on the 80s between nostalgia and grandiloquence; Again, the mid-track break is dark, cinematic, a Mars Attack tune to leave and then come back... or be completely disintegrated; a symphonic touch and the finale by Eddie, who also played synth.

ETRANGE, cinematic instrumental French progressive metal. VELHON and DEADALE, whose real names I won't mention, offer a unique album that's among the stars with touches of nostalgia. (3.25)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ian Carr: Belladonna by NUCLEUS album cover Studio Album, 1972
3.95 | 75 ratings

BUY
Ian Carr: Belladonna
Nucleus Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars In effect a NUCLEUS album, I can see, however, how/why Ian Carr dropped that moniker for this album in that only one musician (other than himself) remains from the original Nucleus albums (Elastic Rock and We'll Talk about it Later). (Brian Smith.)

1. "Belladonna" (13:42) an album that sounds very much as if it is taking its cues and inspiration from the post-Bitches Brew work of Joe Zawinul & Wayne Shorter (who had just launched their WEATHER REPORT project with both the self- titles debut and 1972 release, I Sing the Body Electric, both having been released prior to Belladonna's July recording sessions) and especially, Herbie Hancock, whose Mwandishi and Crossings albums had also both been released prior to Belladonna's recording sessions. (In case you were wondering, Chick Corea's Return to Forever album had its European release in September of 1972, two months after, Belladonna came out.) While Brian Smith's soprano sax is the real start of this show, Gordon Beck's peaceful Hohner electric piano is a key component to its success. While Brian's play and melodies are quite pleasing, even enjoyable, the song never gets elevated into anything but a long late night contemplative--and, perhaps a fitting inspiration for Vangelis Papathanassiou for the spacey "New Age" music that would occupy his attention for the rest of his life. (26.333/30)

2. "Summer Rain" (6:13) after a 90-second slow and deliberated intro in which Ian's trumpet and Brian's tenor sax set the melodic groundwork, this song is blessed by a dynamic breakout performance on the "dirty" Fender Rhodes by a Kiwi age-mate of Ian's, Dave MacRae (who would stay with Ian for the next three Ian Carr/Nucleus albums). I find myself not only absolutely mesmerized by this piece, but actually loving both the sound and melodies created by Dave and his Fender Rhodes. (It's the same sound that French downtempo chillout band AIR used so successfully on their massively-popular 1998 debut album, Moon Safari.) Bass, jazz guitar (mixed far-left into the background) and chill drums progress throughout the length of the song. Weird to hear Allan Holdsworth--the Allan Holdsworth--relegated to playing rhythm/background jazz guitar using neither his own trademark scales nor his own "trademark" sound. (9.6667/10)

3. "Remadione" (3:48) flutes take up a full two minutes of this song's opening while dirty Fender Rhodes electric piano (L) and more rock/proggy lead electric guitar gently support. The third and fourth minutes see the full band engage in another AIR-like downtempo motif while Dave and Allan ramp up considerably their "duel." (9/10)

4. "Mayday" (5:41) opening with the "Shaft"-like cymbal play and over all sound of Bitches Brew and Mwandishi/Crossings, Allan is strumming away wildly in the background while Dave MacRae and Gordon Beck. At 3:35 the band's rhythm section feels as if it finally "falls into" the song's main motif--which is an awesome jazz-rock groove while Brian continues soloing. The finish is tailed off with a coordinated horn section riff and poof! It's over! I'm not so great a fan of Brian's sax solo (most of the time I don't even hear it) but the bass and double keyboard play are awesome. (9.125/10)

5. "Suspension" (6:15) opening tracks dedicated to bamboo flutes, electric pianos, and percussion sounds is kind of cool--definitely evoking garden and/or Japanese/Asian images/feelings. Roy Babbington's bass enters around 1:15, soloing on its own as if trying to find its place in the mix, but then suddenly at 1:55 he "falls into" a steady riff that becomes the foundation for the rest of the song--and which Allan Holdsworth doubles up with his own lowest octave strings. Meanwhile the bamboo flute and Gordon Beck's dreamy Hohner electric piano continue to explore the background but now we add Ian's trumpet up front left and, soon, Dave MacRae's dirty Fender Rhodes in the right channel. The bamboo flutes disappear as Ian and the two electric pianos continue to explore their passions on their own tracks with their own separately effected instruments (Dave's Rhodes getting particularly wild--sounding like a wile organ or heavily-treated lead guitar). Despite a rather mundane and pastoral opening, this one became something quite interesting--especially with that cool Fender Rhodes sound flailing aggressively away in the final third. (9.125/10)

6. "Hector's House" (4:33) though definitely firmly rooted in the rock traditions, this one has one of the more convincing jazz-rock feels to it--all built on a riff and motif that is not so far from the opening song, "Song for the Bearded Lady" from We'll Talk about it Later. Brian Smith really tears an awesomely-smooth high-speed performance on his soprano sax in the second and third minutes while Allan Holdworth really rips up the soundwaves in the fourth with his jazz-rock guitar shredding. Once again there are such highs in this song to offset the lows/deficiencies. (9.125/10)

Total Time: 40:12

One of the most significant outcomes of the making of this album is the meeting of young Allan Holdsworth and elder statesman Gordon Beck as the two would forge a life-long friendship that would result in their collaboration on no less than four albums over the next few decades.

A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of highly-creative First or Second Wave Jazz-Rock Fusion.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Vulnera by MYSTERIA NOCTIS album cover Studio Album, 2020
3.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Vulnera
Mysteria Noctis Progressive Metal

Review by andrea
Prog Reviewer

— First review of this album —
3 stars "Vulnera", the second full length album by Mysteria Noctis, was released in 2020 with a renewed line up featuring Alberto Negretti (vocals), Alessio Negretti (guitars), Giacomo Piccinini (drums), Gioele D'Adda (bass) and Mattia Di Lorenzo (keyboards) plus the guest vocalists Eleonora Ferrari, Vittorio Iannaco and KDone. It confirms the departure from the decidedly black metal sound of the debut work offering a music style difficult to pigeonhole. Throughout the album you can find metal passages alternating with melodic sections and a prog rock veined with touches of electronic music and classical influences. The music and lyrics try to reflect anxiety and restlessness: in fact, according to the band, the protagonist of this work is "the man, caught in an intimate and at times desperate search for himself who inevitably clashes with his fragility and helplessness"...

The opener "Am I Here?" refers to the art cover and evokes bees all around and inside the head of the protagonist. It's a piece expressing a strong sense of bewilderment... Then it's the turn of "Thoughts", a piece that expresses an inner search that remains unsatisfied. Next comes the nightmarish "A Supplication", a long, complex track where the protagonist is on his knees in front of a jury, put on a hopeless trial leading him to the death penalty...

On "Ultimo canto" (Last singing) the rhythm slackens and the vocals turn from English to Italian. It's a touching ballad about love and death featuring a guest female vocalist who duets with the band's singer. The music and lyrics conjure up a spectral atmosphere as the protagonist answers the irresistible call of the Grim Reaper without fear...

On the following "Night Light" the rhythm rises again bringing demons and fears for an infernal ride into the night. This song is sung in English while for the next one, the melodic "Nell'anima" (In the soul), the band chose again their mother language to express the heat of an inner fire that burns inside the soul and makes the protagonist look up at the sky to overcome a sense of obscure, thundering solitude and uneasiness...

The last track, "Red Sea", is the most ambitious of the album and the most accomplished of the lot. According to the band, this composition was inspired by the classical form of the sonata and features some guest vocalists. Eventually it brings a pinch of optimism and some rays of light after the previous dark atmospheres. The journey comes to an end as the protagonist wakes up under a new sun...

On the whole, an interesting work that deserves a try.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Monster Movie by CAN album cover Studio Album, 1969
3.81 | 436 ratings

BUY
Monster Movie
Can Krautrock

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Unique, expressive and visionary, Can's debut album (credited to The Can on the animated album cover) is one of the truly fascinating rock releases of 1969, the sole early album by the band with original vocalist Malcolm Mooney, and one of the earliest examples of what the British media would go on to define as krautrock - in reality, a branch of experimental music with repetitive rhythms that might go on for a few minutes or for a good twenty-something or so, with various vocal, guitar-based experiments and effects playing over them, resulting in an indulgent, challenging and crafty amalgamation of psychedelic patterns and unusual soundscapes, always utilizing the traditional rock instrumentation, with the occasional use of more unorthodox instruments. It seems like 'Monster Movie' by Can is all about that delightful, frivolous and smirky experimentation, wherein the Hamburg-based band and its members come off as bold innovators, carrying the progressive spirit all throughout.

All four tracks appearing on the album have their distinctive characteristics, which all add up to the eclectic nature of 'Monster Movie', an album for which it would be more difficult to trace the influences of, rather than go on and understand how much of popular music has been influenced by it and by Can's trippy, expressive, and mechanically repetitive music. Opener 'Father Cannot Yell' is an accomplished krautrock staple, with its avant-garde psych-experiments and lightweight references to the Velvet Underground, as we see how Can would use tape experiments, improv and sound layering to create pieces of music that work in an almost-monolithic way. The use of reverb and various other guitar effects is prominent on the album, and the second track is a good example of that, with the elegiac tones of Michael Karoli's playing swaying in-between the sounds of the song. A more upbeat and shorter third piece 'Outside My Door' redirects the listener to the pomp of psychedelia, leading you towards the final, 20-minute-long closing track 'You Doo Right', the epitome of the entire album, a musical monolith of experimentation and tape editing, with wailing screams and stomping guitar flares, this is a gorgeous, startling and eerie piece of music that could have only appeared on a Can album. And with all this in mind, how could one oversee the gritty debut album of this rather unconventional German band, blending a variety of genres and techniques, and offering music that is nothing short of achingly compelling.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 If We Were Live by ODD LOGIC album cover Studio Album, 2013
4.00 | 5 ratings

BUY
If We Were Live
Odd Logic Progressive Metal

Review by arymenezes

4 stars Yep, this is a studio album. And this is your cue to request, "Please explain this better."

I transcribe here the words on their website, in this regard: By the release of Over the Underworld [the previous album], the discography had grown well, and yet no real possibility of playing live was in the near future. Combining his infatuation for non-traditional album concepts and the then very present desire to release a nice-sounding live album, Sean decided to create a "fake show", complete with pre-show banter, dialogue and audience participation. ​ "It was a lot of fun to make," Sean reminisces. "I believe it included the most voiceover guests for any album we've done.

Now for my review: starts as if they were recording someone entering an establishment where a show is about to begin. You can clearly hear the door been opened, the individual passing through the peanut/soda seller, and sneaking into the crowd. Just when the instruments are being prepared. That's the opening track.

Rhythmic sections are very robust and consistent on the second track, with well developed changes of harmonies. Full-bodied vocals, with interesting nuances in textures, volume and combination of long and short notes. There's a point where an excellent guitar solo comes along, and a bit after that, the "audience" applauds. The frontman, on the end, says "Hello everybody, welcome to the illusory palace, and welcome to the show".

When they open the next song, the bass delivers a simple but effective rhythym, before the entrance of the full cuisine, which is a bit heavier now, specially on the bass itself. Synthesizers economically but effectively stitch together the composition. Otherwise, there are moments when this instrument backs up, in order to give more space for the dialogues between the drums and guitar. Right on the middle of this track occurs an abrupt change, with a gorgeous erudit piano carrying alone the song. But quickly been accompanied by synths emulating strings, gentle and sweet. A little after that the drums accelerate a lot, during a short period. A bit henceforth, a variety of cadences and key signatures are performed. Well, the composition here is a bit confusing and lost, but nonetheless it's still a good effort.

A fingered guitar and soft touches on the piano are the start of the fourth track. The music grows some steps, before fabulous vocal harmonies, on a more melodic mood, are executed by two musicians. The drums keeps up with this proposal. A nice guitar solo, with clean and inspired notes, appears. The vocal timbres are velvety. Great music! On the end there are applauses, what happens on all tracks. I think it would be strange if there wasn't, 'cause it's included by the musicians themself. Well, here, on the end of the cheers, the frontman thanks "them" and says that the next song is a tribute to a friend. I can't help myself of thinking playfully: "is it an immaginary or a real friend?"

The cadence is almost a march on the entrance of the next song. The turning points on the harmonies are well constructed and grow firmly. Suddenly they shut this enterprise down and jump to a melancholic and quite diggy playing on the acoustic guitar. The lyrics are about poisoning, death and other mournful content. The sound mass gets higher, but not enough to distance them from that lugubrious mood. On its half they speed up, centralizing the composition on the magnific vocals. On the other hand, they soon present very inventive instrumental key signatures. That's before the synth brings back the dismal framing. It's a pity their are moments when they don't explore more of this hipnotizing enterprise. Anyway, the chant and the instrumental are always creative and diversified. Onn the end bass and the emulation of a half-harpsichord-half-synth make a solid tenebrous partnership. High level on practically all it's near 12min.

The beginning of the 6th track has a metal-oriented guitar. Bass seems to be competing with him, making them get tangled up. The drums doesn't find its place, this time. They all get better from the guitar solo henceforth, and when the synth assumes the main role.

Vocals reach high notes on the next song, and this is a good entrance. Both bass and guitar are heavy, but none of them are making a speedy execution, resulting in a superb partnership. Drums play some simple, sober, nice turnovers, with elegant cadences. Almost on the end they blend amazing harmonies. The frontman seems excited when he says "Alright, thank you so much. We're gonna leave you with some more, it's called The Great March".

What a start on this one! A chorus backwards precedes a perfect combination between the cymbals, guitar and a "dark" synth. Some seconds later, the chorus rises its dramaticity. Impactful chant switch with grandiose instrumental. This is really stunning! And a superb choice as the "closing" of the show. How impressive are the subtle and rich changes on bass and drums from one moment to another. When everything is already magnific, a delicate and charming piano enters. Spectacular! Guitar, more melodic here, is also on a high standard. Some moments later, there's this snippet somewhat more simple, but it's very short, and they return to awesome changes of harmonies and arrangements. On the 10th minute the arrangements low down a bit on creativity, the key signatures get mixed up without cohesion. With 12min the group gets more prog metal, the bass and drums together result in an odd musicality. So, these ups and not-so-ups (I'd write 'downs', but it would be unfair) make this track at least a little too long. When they reach the 15th minute there's an acoustic section, and a very different chant is improved, with a metallic tone. Now the band is delivering a very beatiful and hopeful song, I even want to sing along. The already expected applause follows, and the frontman is affected: "Wow... you guys are unreal!" And after a short pause amends: "Alright, let's do one more".

The last one has an exciting and stimulating AOR musicality, very vocal-oriented. With 1min the singer calls the audience to sing along. And what an amazing tone they reach, hehe! They make a duet, with the frontman performing the refrains, and the audience assumes the chorus.

Smart and original album. For this part I'll give'em a 4,8. Musically, I choose a 4 stars rate. Final rating 4.2.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Caravan by CARAVAN album cover Studio Album, 1968
3.71 | 637 ratings

BUY
Caravan
Caravan Canterbury Scene

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars A vastly mature psychedelic pop-prog graces the two sides of the self-titled debut album by English band Caravan, with the Canterbury scene innovators releasing their very first work as early as September of 1968, which is rather incredible to think about, as this timing is right around the dawn of the progressive movement and the steady, gentle fade of the psychedelic rock craze. With a strong, ostensible inspiration coming from Pink Floyd's 'Piper' without a doubt, as well as throwing in a couple of references to The Doors, 'Caravan' is a delightful treasure of an album and a great precursor to the excellent fusion-y music the band would go on to explore during the 70s, and while this rather short (and imperfect) studio recording only gives us frail traits of the mighty Canterbury scene, it remains an interesting glimpse into that transitional period of the late 60s, for its proto-progressive blueprints.

With the songs centered around the protruding Hammond organ sounds as well as the strong melodies and vocal harmonies, 'Caravan' is a record that is much in the style of the early Soft Machine 'Volumes' as well as some of those Cream and Floyd-ish exploratory pop tunes. The band's very own debut album already positions Caravan as a band aware of their fine songwriting capabilities, as they explore them quite interestingly and present a lush collection of moods and tones, with some songs being whimsical and uplifting, while others are being more pensive and even gloomy. Album opener 'Place of My Own' is melancholic and distantly menacing, a great song, while 'Ride' might turn out to be too trippy for some tastes. A string of three absolutely excellent numbers follow on side one, and the already impression of the album is of a very consistent, well-organized work. Just three songs on side two, among which the 9-minute closing suite 'Where but for Caravan Would I?' stands out as the first really impressive piece with more complex, challenging arrangements from Caravan. And as poor as the mixing is, and as distracting as this can be, 'Caravan' is a worthy anticipator of the Canterbury scene and a fine late 60s work that still echoes the tastes of The Wilde Flowers and the entire psychedelic rock ooze.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Pictures from Sierra Morena by ADEKAEM, THE album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.66 | 13 ratings

BUY
Pictures from Sierra Morena
The Adekaem Neo-Prog

Review by alainPP

3 stars The Adekaem, a Polish duo founded in 2013, features synths accompanied by guitar solos reminiscent of Camel, Aragon, and Marillion, creating a distinctive neo-prog sound. Their music takes them to the grandiloquent territories of Pink Floyd psychedelia and the atmospheric electronic music of Kitaro, creating a cinematic fusion.

"Pictures from Sierra Morena" features a solemn symphonic instrumental attack, featuring piano, keyboards, and emotive guitar; a Wallian phrasing explains the story of Potocki's novel in seven layers where the music clings to different cinematic waves, one of which features reverberating bass and Hang. Andalusian and Asian airs follow one another on a mysterious melodic foundation, with a finale composed of slightly overly dry pad rumbles and a tearful guitar. "Sea" is a vibrant, mystical, Olympian, and long intro, setting the mood with metallic, electronic neo- prog, featuring Daniel's distinctive vocals. The finale features a solo guitar and melodic keyboard duet. "Wrath" is a basic piano ballad; evolving into edgy prog metal with an 80s sax contribution, Krzysztof's guitar supporting a melancholic style, adding more depth and offering new neo-prog. "Lady of the Glade" is a lacy Genesis-esque arpeggio; a consensual pop-rock tune enhanced by its orchestral country-style variation, led by trumpet for a solemn feel. The orchestral part with violin and flute harks back to the prog rudiments of yesteryear with 10cc-style choruses; a beautiful, conventional fresco that unfolds and never ends with final bells. "By the Barrow" features approaching electro pads, a guitar screaming with melancholy, bucolic keyboards, a fitting sweetness, the disconcerting flute for the haunting melody, Daniel following the folkloric line.

The Adekaem draws closer to the bands Genesis, Camel, and ELP, which they cherish; melodic, melancholic, musical emotions, and world music atmospheres are the highlights of this melancholic album, which occasionally reeks of Anglagard. Origin on progcensor (3.5)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Monolith by KANSAS album cover Studio Album, 1979
3.26 | 477 ratings

BUY
Monolith
Kansas Symphonic Prog

Review by Alxrm

3 stars After five albums, which I believe is not just my opinion but generally are regarded as some of the best in our beloved music, it was time for their first bum note (or should I say album), or, to be more precise, half-bum. The band had released two years ago the monumental Point of Know Return which contains the monster-hit Dust in the Wind that literally everybody has heard once in their life even if they live at the most remoted place in the world. This time the band decided to produce the album themselves and I don't know if the lack of an experienced producer played a role, although I would bet that it was more the pressure of coming up with a song that would draw about an equal response as Dust... did. On this album there are some typical Kansas songs like the opener On the Other Side, A Glimpse of Home, Away From You and Angels Have Fallen (which are also my favourite ones), How My Soul Cries Out For You and Stay Out of Trouble that rock harder but aren't something remarkable, especially the latter which features mainly one and only riff responsing to every line Walsh sings and it becomes somewhat wearisome whereas the former features some interesting theme and time changes and finally the radio-friendly People of the South Wind and Reason to Be which were actually the two singles of the album. People... was the first one, it didn't make an impact and the label figured that Reason to Be (which due to the acoustic guitar drew some parallels with Dust in the Wind although, to my ears, it's closer to The More Fool Me by Genesis - which doesn't belong to their best moments). Strangely enough, I don't consider People... as a bad choice because it balances finely between commerciality and quality, I can clearly see hear it in my mind's ear even at summer night clubs blasting through the speakers, it's so upbeat but still not your every-day radio single. Anyway, the album falls short due to the massive quality of their first five albums or else it isn't that bad and it deserved something better. In restrospect, it was a transitional album to the most commercial and less inspired 80s era that the band would follow.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Chasing an Illusion by GRIMM, LARKIN album cover Studio Album, 2017
4.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Chasing an Illusion
Larkin Grimm Prog Folk

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

— First review of this album —
4 stars Among certain artists in one's genres of choice and among most artists in the genres whose company one does not choose, can be a tendency to produce seemingly impenetrable opuses, leaving one wondering what one is missing that presumably makes other listeners kvell as if they composed, arranged, produced and performed it themselves. Such disks can jettison us into unrecognizable worlds in which one must find food, shelter, and a modicum of the pleasures that one can only seek when both food and shelter are present, without any idea of how to go about it. LARKIN GRIMM's first couple of albums were like that for me, amorphous thought bubbles of either very low or very high sentience from which wails would escape via the wrong, or perhaps, no filter at all. Then there are the ones to which, with the effort affordable on a lengthy road trip courtesy of spotify on repeat, one adapts to the few originally obscure clues and is rewarded many times over. "Chasing an Illusion" worked in this manner for me.

With the early acoustic days behind her, and a generally warmer and more controlled voice and style reminiscent of SALLY OLDFIELD among others, Grimm again engages a band of master musicians, who elevate each and every track. The sprinkling jazz tinged harps of "Fear Transforms into Love" and "I Don't Believe You", companion pieces that highlight her expanding vocal skills; the joyous should-have-been-a-hitness of "Beautifully Alone" that resonates among the perennially single on yet another solo journey; the ambient ballad "A Perfect World"; and the closer and title track with its heaving sax and anguished screams which seem to have brought Grimm full circle all epitomize the secrets herein, revealed with gracious subtlety or hurling impact as needed.

Given that "Chasing an Illusion" is still Grimm's latest as of this writing, eight long years later, one can be both simultaneously optimistic and concerned for her future, but hopefully she will yet return with a work that is just as fantastically real.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Transformation by AURORA CLARA album cover Studio Album, 2019
4.03 | 11 ratings

BUY
Transformation
Aurora Clara Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars I finally got a chance to spend some time with an AURORA CLARA record. "Transformation" was released in 2019 and is in fact their debut. They have since released three more albums, pretty much on a yearly basis after their sophomore release. They are a five piece band based in Spain, but they are truly a multi-national band with all five musicians being from different countries. They are led by virtuoso guitarist Raul Mannola who was born in Brazil but has spent his life living in Finland before recently moving to Spain. And it's so cool he got to spend some time playing with the legendary jazz guitarist Jukka Tolonen who also hails from Finland.

Raul released a solo album back in 2002 called "Aurora Clara" which of course is where the band's name came from. He is a major John McLaughlin fan which comes through in his style but this man is a diverse player. Many of these musicians have a flamenco background and have accompanied various dancers before arriving in this band. The biggest surprise for me is the abundance of flute on here. I'm not big on his style. Very fluttering and dancing. I prefer it when the keyboards or guitar are soloing. Just my tastes.

It must have been a dream come true for Raul that violinist Jerry Goodman guests on the opener here. The band's very first song actually has the incredible talents of a MAHAVISHNU ORCHESTRA member! Raul adds in the liner notes "My gratitude to the Master of masters, John McLaughlin-to whom "Song To John" is dedicated-for giving me joy and inspiration for so many years." This is a 56 minute album with six tracks. And the opener "Aktur" certainly has a different flavour with the added violin from Goodman.

This is an extremely melodic recording that is very well played. My favourite musician on here is drummer Marco Anderson from England. The man has been around, playing in various musical styles. All I know is that he is incredible at what he does. The joy of this album is the playing of it's five members. I can just focus on any one of them and be impressed. Even the flautist, who isn't always dancing around with his flute. This is a mature release to say the least. In fact that closer is maybe too mature as they end the album with a ballad, my least favourite song on here. Lots of piano and acoustic guitar on it.

I really enjoy the keyboardist on here. He plays mainly piano and synths and does both extremely well. That electric piano especially. According to RYM this debut here is by far their highest rated of their four albums, with the next three dropping in value with each release. So yes get this one if you can. My favourite track is probably the opener with Goodman on it, but this is a fairly consistent recording other than the closer. If you're into jazz fusion this really needs to be heard. A solid 4 stars.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Secret by SERGE RAMSES album cover Studio Album, 1978
3.79 | 9 ratings

BUY
Secret
Serge Ramses Progressive Electronic

Review by SliprKC70

3 stars I can't exactly remember how I discovered this highly obscure and unknown artist by the name of Serge Ramses, but I do know that I became interested in it from the very captivating and interesting art on the album cover. For starters, I just want to quickly say that (for me at least), I never really understood progressive electronics. Unless something truly stands out or is revolutionary, most albums in this genre rely on the atmosphere and experience. So it came as no surprise to me that when I did get around to listening to this album, I was generally unimpressed by it. Sure, it had its interesting moments and had some fascinating passages woven into the music, but most of it lacks originality, and it generally brings little to no remarkably different material to the table. Most of it can be described as a less polished and in-depth work by Tangerine Dream or Klaus Schulze. I did enjoy the cold and hypnotic feel of the opening minutes of When The Birds Die Away, but Ramses doesn't seem to change this and continues the basic structure of the song throughout most of the album. 

In conclusion, the album could've used something to spice it up, but it's an alright album in the end. I would like it more if the songs were longer and more textures were added in, but I'm assuming Ramses' life after this has been lost to time and there will most likely never be a remastered version to add these factors. This is a high 3/5 to a low 3.25/5 for me. If you like the more popular progressive electronic music out there, or if you want progressive electronic music that is a bit more concrete in the overall audio itself, you'll probably enjoy this, but it's far from being an essential. 

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Bishop's Sacrifice by MARTIN VENGADESAN & THE STALEMATE FACTOR album cover Studio Album, 2018
2.91 | 2 ratings

BUY
The Bishop's Sacrifice
Martin Vengadesan & The Stalemate Factor Crossover Prog

Review by DetectiveDoom

3 stars The Bishop's Sacrifice is the second album by this band, and with one notable exception, it's not really very prog rock at all.

While the first album is folky, the third one psychedelic and the fourth the most consistently progressive, this one is generally a hard rock album with songs that are largely about politics, philosophy or religion.

The core band for this record is Martin Vengadesan on vocals/acoustic guitar/bass/keyboards, Joshua Rayan on electric guitar and Andrew Sagayam on drums.

So I gotta say, everything really rests on the 22 minute long song called The Battle Of Emerald Skye. It begins with a solo acoustic guitar performance, and has several notable subsections as an anti-war tale unfolds.

You will be able to spot the influence of Pink Floyd in its more melancholic moments, as well as bits of Led Zeppelin and maybe even Iron Maiden. It's got loads of Hammond organ, some Moog synths and a fantastic sitar guest appearance from Kumar Karthigesu. It all ends in an epic chaotic garage punk like jam!!!

It's got its flaws too. Parts of it feels draggy and not all of it sounds well recorded or mixed. So full marks for ambition, but not all there for execution.

Elsewhere you have a funk rocker called Hazard A Guess with some nice electric piano and an excellent double tracked guitar outro. Thirty Pieces Of Silver and Stained Glass are catchy rockers that deal with religious/agnostic themes. Both songs also have Eastern-sounding guitar solos from Joshua. I guess that makes sense for a band that has ethnic Indians from Malaysia!

Then there are a string of in-your-face socialist songs like Call To Arms which has some heavy organ that owes a debt to Jon Lord's sound. The Peasants' Revolt is set in 1381 when the farmers and workers of England rebelled against the authority of teenage king Richard II and his oppressive nobility. It begins with a bass solo but does send up sounding increasingly frenzied and slightly ackward.

The Revolution Will Devour Its Children is another historical tale, specifically about how the French Revolution fell apart with different factions like the Girondists and Jacobins taking turns to fall to the guillotine. Musically the song has classical motifs and a duelling electric piano/electric organ solo, as well as more prominent drums.

And then there is a subtle ballad called The Final Hours Of Salvador Allende which was written in memory of the late democratically elected Marxist president of Chile. It's quite moving although it's yet another song that makes you think the band could do with a stronger vocalist.

Overall it continues the pattern of gradual improvement, although I would always ask newcomers to start with The Rook's Siege album before wandering this way.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Decoding The Emptiness by DAAL album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.31 | 21 ratings

BUY
Decoding The Emptiness
Daal Eclectic Prog

Review by tszirmay
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars One of my favorite bands is back with another patented one-two punch of releases, a tradition they have mastered once before in 2018. By the way, the second 2025 release is a "Live :Waves from the Underground", performed at the Studiosette in Rome in October 2023. Their previous 2022 release "Daedalus" was a universally praised masterpiece, garnering high marks for technical merit as well as artistic Impression. The great news is the line-up remains the same, : the amazing Alfio Costa on a variety of keyboards, drummer extraordinaire Davide Guidoni, scintillating guitarist Ettore Salati and Bobo Aiolfi on the thunderous bass guitar. The 8 tracks also include 2 vocal guests but is really an instrumentally centric opus of the highest order. The title track catapults immediately into a musical path that is anchored on the symphonic side of things, but in a soundtrack-like manner, with dense atmospherics that show neither haste nor hysterics, though the mood can be quite surly and despairing, driven, as it is by tectonic drum fills and colossal torrents of blazing mellotron. There is a distinct aroma of the Crimson King and Italian stalwarts Goblin in the emanations presented here, in that a sense of trepidation and doom perseveres like a dense fog that seeps into the pores of the unforgiving. Ettore even peels of a glistening guitar line that sears the mind and even persists on the next piece "Attic Clouds" , a rhythmically oblique thrashing of confusion and looming dread that would fuel any horror flick known to man. The gruesome mood is mechanical yet greasy as if rolling on well-oiled lubrication, a reptilian motion that remains methodical until the ideal moment is ready and the release coiled to strike. Briefly only echo and resonance, Bobo marshals the drum parade, Davide clanging in the distance, as the feisty mellotron appears out of the darkened skies, pouncing mercilessly on the defenceless senses.

Complete change of pace on the opening vocal of "Twilight", a tenebrous requiem of glinting piano and harrowing voice, with subtle synthesized orchestrations, that metamorphoses into a pyrotechnic guitar meteor amid the trembling stars. There is a tranquility in the serene bass ruffle that seeks only to reassure, fomenting an eventual entrance for Ettore to display some dexterous picking, crystalline and awe-inspiring in its subtlety. I did mention a notion of scary movie earlier, didn't I ? Well, "Horror Vacui" certainly fits the bill, a mellotron- infested cascade, shoved along by a suitable bass trough, suddenly exploding into a fiery storm of Crimsonian vehemence and immediately dismissed by a romantic piano interlude, only to reignite another round of volatile destruction. Obdurate, erratic and teasingly serene , you never have any clue where this may be going, like Charon on the river Styx, destination and destiny unknown.

The cavernous "Simulacra" offers bombast in a variety of exploratory directions, as if offering another red nightmare, adorned with spooky synth pools of perspiration and slashes of incisive blades of sound carving into the brain. Images of somber reptiles slithering along Roman mosaic tiles, heading towards the roar of the arena nearby, where the starving lions await their next lunch. Gruesome effigies crucified along the road to freedom, impudent crows cawing with disdain.

The sultry femininity of "Mademoiselle X" comes as a most welcome distraction, the curving bass highlighting the softness of skin, the aroused mellotron caressing like a silky veil, building up into a glowing sonic image of beauty incarnate. Then the seductive lead guitar joins in on the flattery, the atmosphere veers into carnal exuberance. An extraordinary track that deserves the gift of eternal love, devotion and surrender.

The next 13 minute onslaught has a title that leaves no room for questioning ,"D.O.O.M" diabolically smashes into the soul with a searing display of pyrotechnics that unexplainably (but not really surprisingly) comes to a grinding halt, enough time for a forlorn piano to exalt gently, and then reignite into a magnificent melody, a pattern that will be repeated until the very end. From eloquence to eruption we go, back and forth in a domineering and deranged gait, a roller coaster of emotions from the two polar extremes, a challenging exercise in contrasts. Toss in a variety of sonic effects and noises to further confuse and numb the mind into subservience, the rash guitar takes over the pace, rambling along with the bruising mellotron, nasty bass currents and demonic drumming outro from Guidoni that fades into the sunset.

There is a bonus track , "Return from the Spiral Mind" , a variation of the previous album's mainstay, the 2-part epic "Journey through the Spiral Mind" which spanned a chunky 22 minutes. Here , the onus is closer to Floydian investigations, albeit in a more biting setting, with Alfio displaying his talent on a variety of keyboard instruments. There is less 'sturm und drang' fright than on the main album, hence coming across as a calming exit, a warmer touch and a guarantee of more future music from this impeccable Italian powerhouse.

5 Decrypted voids

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Garden by UNITOPIA album cover Studio Album, 2008
3.61 | 215 ratings

BUY
The Garden
Unitopia Crossover Prog

Review by TenYearsAfter

4 stars Australian formation Unitopia was founded in 1996 by Mark Trueack (vocals) and Sean Timms (keyboard and guitar) after they were introduced by a mutual friend who noticed that the two had similar tastes in music. The story goes that as soon as Timms heard Trueack sing, he knew they had to do something together. In 2005 Unitopia released their first album entitled More Than A Dream, followed by The Garden (2008), Artificial (2010), One Night In Europe (2011), Covered Mirror Vol 1: Smooth As Silk (2012) and recently Seven Chambers (2023).

This review is about the The Garden 3-CD remaster digipack, including a live disc and a new song entitled Tears From The Garden.

Disc-1 : My highlights.

The Garden (22:29) The first part contains a percussive climate with vibraphone that reminds me of Peter Gabriel solo. Then a swinging rhythm featuring heavy guitar riffs and powerful vocals, embellished with fiery saxophone, powerful vocals, Hammond, steel-guitar solo and sparkling piano. The interplay between rock guitar and Hammond is exciting rock. The second part of this epic composition delivers lots of shifting moods, from dreamy to bombastic, tastefully coloured with a soft bass solo, a swinging piano solo and a powerful saxophone solo. In the end intense vocals and Mellotron choirs in the vein of 76-77 Genesis, wow! The great dynamics, fiery guitar, Hammond and sparkling piano often evokes Spock's Beard, also due to the inspired vocals of Mark Trueack.

Angeliqua (9:50) This mid-long track starts with a sultry saxophone and a angelic female voice in an Arabesca climate, pretty hypnotizing. Then a swinging rhythm with Hammond and fat rock guitar riffs, followed by a mellow part with dreamy vocals, in a Neo-prog atmosphere. Next again rock guitar and Hammond, turning into dreamy with classical orchestrations, jazzy acoustic guitar solo and saxophone. Finally a heavy eruption with swirling Hammond solo and biting rock guitar, how exciting! . Amelia's Dream (3:22) First a voice, then a mellow climate with tender classical guitar, classical orchestrations and flute, wonderful, another musical face of this amazing band.

Disc 2 : My highlights.

Journey's Friend (6:29) A tight mid-tempo with fiery guitar and flashy synthesizer flights, wah-wah guitar and Hammond, and powerful saxophone, in a Neo-Prog atmosphere. Then dreamy piano and vocals, again Spock's Beard comes to my mind.

When I'm Down (5:41) After a spoken voice intro the mood shifts to bombastic with powerful vocals and spectacular synthesizer solo, the undertone is melancholical.

In the short track This Life (4:45) the focus is on a biting wah-wah solo, another wow!

Don't Give Up Love (7:48) is a varied and dynamic song with beautiful classical orchestrations (Mellotron-like soaring strings), a swinging break with distorted voice and spectacular synthesizer soli.

Disc 3: live + new track Tears From The Garden.

Unitopia is an excellent band on stage, in my opinion even more impressive than on the studio-albums, and the crowd loves it! Highlights are the two versions of The Garden (USA and The Netherlands), the band in its full splendor.

Tears From The Garden (New 2020 Recording, 3:54). A wonderful mellow piece featuring tender classical guitar, sounds of nature and romantic vocals, embellished with sparking piano runs, soaring strings and flute.

Conclusion about CD 1-2-3 : To me Unitopia sounds as a good and experienced band, the accessible sound is often close to Neo-Prog but in between room for lots of more complex musical ideas, dynamics and variety, topped with strong vocals. And live this band rises to the occasion, CD-3 is in fact a kind of 'best of' on stage. Highly recommended!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Vespro by MYSTERIA NOCTIS album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Vespro
Mysteria Noctis Progressive Metal

Review by andrea
Prog Reviewer

— First review of this album —
4 stars "Vespro" is the third full length album by Mysteria Noctis and was self-released in 2025 with a confirmed line up featuring Alberto Negretti (vocals), Alessio Negretti (guitars), Giacomo Piccinini (drums), Gioele D'Adda (bass) and Mattia Di Lorenzo (keyboards). It marks another step forward for the band, the musical fabric is very rich and variegated blending progressive rock with touches of electronica, synthwave, rap and black metal. According to an interview with the band, "Vespro is a concept album that tells the story of a man who, driven by an anonymous letter, sets out to find the sender. along the way, he embarks on a journey that forces him to confront his past. The central theme driving the entire story is that of choices and their consequences?". The art cover by Giacomo Tagnin gives a visual form to the atmospheres of the album...

The opener "Ombre dal passato" (Shadows from the past) sets the atmosphere. An acoustic guitar intro and a tormented voice open the album evoking a trembling hand writing a letter full of poisonous questions, addressed to a man who has changed over the years and seems to have forgotten his past. When the rhythm increases the image and perspective change. Night falls and the voice of the person who received the letter can be heard. The evil evoked by the sender envelops the protagonist like a shadow that takes his breath away. The journey in search of the mysterious sender begins, and the departure is described by the following short instrumental "Discesa" (Descent)...

"Anatema" (Anathema), on an apparently cheerful rhythm with echoes of eighties synthwave, describes the torment of the protagonist, visibly shaken by the mysterious call from his past and the shadows it evokes. The protagonist questions himself and questions his glass muse (a sort of woman-city metaphor of his present) on the opportunity to leave and begin a dangerous journey. The need to leave becomes more and more pressing, even if the response of the glass muse is extremely disturbing, a dark omen of perpetual damnation where the synth-wave echoes veer towards black metal hints...

"Ritorno" (Return) paints in music and words the protagonist who, alone and lost, travels along the traces of his past. Faces hidden in the fog watch him and hide the identity of the mysterious author of the letter. Afflicted by too many unanswered questions, by the memory of broken dreams, sacrifices and abandonments on the roads of his past, the protagonist goes on and on with many doubts but without fear...

A delicate piano passage introduces the following "Valzer d'inverno" (Winter waltz), a piece that describes the passion of a brief and intense relationship, a romance with a woman soon forgotten by the protagonist, a woman among many. What remains of that love story? The flames of passion have now given way to ashes and disenchantment, to broken dreams and broken promises, deceptions and betrayal. What remains is just a face that fades into the fog and perhaps a veil of nostalgia and regret...

"Ricordi?" (Do you remember?) begins with a short drum passage. It is a caustic piece that evokes the anger of a forgotten friend and rival of the protagonist in the race for success. A friend that the protagonist has ruined and humiliated. A sacrificial victim who has developed a deep hatred towards him. The meeting with his shadow is another ominous omen about the end of the journey that the protagonist has undertaken...

"Il processo" (The trial) opens with a slow and mournful marching pace. A hostile voice introduces the trial and invites the accused to face the charges. A rapped vocal part summarizes the accusations and invites the protagonist to look at that betrayed and forgotten woman who now takes care of her (and his) son and at the trampled and humiliated rival. The price of success is damnation, the verdict is one of condemnation. But the author of the letter is not among the jurors. He is still waiting for the protagonist at the pass...

The long, complex "La villa" (The villa) tells of the end of the journey. In fact, the journey ends in a dark and remote villa, the tomb of an unforgiving past. The piece opens with strong classical influences and then turns to threatening, heavy atmospheres. Growling, rap, operatic and theatrical voices combine to describe the scenes of an inner hell where you can find resentment and repentance. The protagonist feels that he is not alone in the villa but is welcomed only by dark presences. Four rooms are open. In one he sees the woman he left pregnant with his child, the woman he abandoned, in another room there's an innocent man who ended up in jail because of him, in the third a neglected friend who hanged himself while he was having fun at a party. In each room screams and damnation. In the last one the author of the letter awaits him...

The disquieting "L'ultima porta" (The last door) describes the protagonist ready to cross the last door and meet his fate. Of all the shadows, that of the author of the letter is the most feared. In the end, the most feared shadow turns out to be that of his soul. Now the protagonist understands that he is the monster who caused so much pain and inside a mirror he sees his soul dying. All the lights go out, between fear and remorse. It is his soul that wrote the letter, it is his hand. The man the protagonist was looking for is none other than himself. But when the final credits roll, the protagonist can still choose between forgiveness and oblivion...

The last track, "L'ombra" (The shadow), opens with powerful electric guitar riffs and a fast pace. The protagonist's hand still trembles as he writes the final words of a farewell to himself. He realizes he is the monster and condemns himself to death. Perhaps there is another path of penance and forgiveness, but will forgiveness be enough to save him from himself? The conclusion is left to the listener. The night falls among the shadows of the past and an ink-stained letter...

On the whole, a very good work that deserves a try.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 New World by LOCKWOOD, DIDIER album cover Studio Album, 1979
4.50 | 9 ratings

BUY
New World
Didier Lockwood Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars French violinist records an album for MPS in the Netherlands with an international all-star cast. Here we find Didier deciding to reach backward toward a more classic acoustic-oriented jazz, sounding very much like the music Stéphane Grappelli and the great European jazz violinists of the 1950s and 60s. Didier even goes so far as to cover several jazz "classics"--as if he feels he has to prove himself to the Jazz community.

1. "Vieux Pape" (5:19) opening with a sound palette and style that sounds completely acoustic Sixties, this Didier composition is highly melodic and richly-full with the busy, virtuosic jazz musicianship of pianist Gordon Beck, bassist Niels-Henning Orsted-Pedersen, and drummer extraordinaire, Tony Williams while Didier puts in a performance that would make him worthy for competition with the great Jean-Luc Ponty. Beck's wonderful piano play is capped by a solo that finds me thinking of the late, great Chick Corea. Lovely! Then Niels-Henning Orsted-Pedersen takes a turn in the spotlight and he's also quite wonderful--projecting lovely melody despite moving along the fretboard of his stand- up double bass at breakneck speeds. (9.25/10)

2. "Autumn Leaves" (5:24) a fully-jazz expression of the jazz classic (which was originally composed by Frenchmen Joseph Kosma and lyricist Jacques Prévoert when titled "Les feiulles mortes"--meaning "dead leaves"). Great performances--especially if you like high quality jazz musicianship. Also, I never really realized how wonderfully this song's main melody lends itself to expression on the acoustic violin. A kind of revelation! Gordon Beck's pristine solo in the second minute is so clean, crisp and yet beautiful. And Niels-Henning Orsted-Pedersen's walking bass line so perfect for holding it all together. (9.3333/10)

3. "La Manufacture De Sucre Engloutie" (3:50) gorgeous piano chord play opens this song--a composition credited to both Gordon Beck and Didier. Listening to this song truly is like being in the presence of humans possessed with a direct line to otherworldly beauty. I can definitely see how anomolous music mathematician Allan Holdsworth forged such a deep and lasting bond with Mr. Beck. (9.75/10)

4. "New World" (5:04) composed by Didier's brother, Francis, the ensemble really has fun with this one--especially, methinks, Didier and Tony. A great listen of impressive musicianship. (9.25/10)

5. "The Last Blade Of Grass" (4:26) the first song to sound a little like J-R Fusion with electrified violin, electric guitars, this song is attributed to guest fusion guitarist Jean-Michel Kajdan. Jean-Michel's performance is particularly impressive for its fiery dexterity as well as emotional expressiveness. Matter of fact, the rest of the band seem rather sleepy when set beside J-M's play: as if they're all stunned, standing in jaw-on-the-floor shock, as they go through their motions perfunctorily while Jean-Michel plays. In fact, it takes a full 20-to-30 seconds after Jean-Michel pauses for the others to re-focus and put some passion back into their own play--including the next soloist himself (Didier)! In the end, everybody gets up to speed and the song finishes well, but those first two minutes were extraordinary! (9.3333/10)

6. "My Memories Of You" (5:40) interesting that this Francis Lockwood-penned song title and sound, chord progressions all sound like a song of a similar name that would find its way onto Vangelis Pappathanassiou's soundtrack for the 1982 sci-fi film Blade Runner. This duet between the Lockwood brothers finds the one using electrified violin, the other using a standard grand piano. (8.875/10)

7. "Giant Steps" (2:10) an interesting sprint through one of the giants of jazz history. (4.5/5)

8. "Pent-up House" (2:31) a Sonny Rollins song that Django Reinhardt and Stéphane Grappelli made their own on which guitarist John Etheridge quite capably takes the role of Django, while Didier, of course, takes that of Stéphane. Quite a respectful and faithful rendering. (9.125/10)

9. "Zbiggy" (6:55) a tribute to the recently-deceased Polish-born jazz violinist Zbigniew Seifert. Perishing of cancer at the age of 32, "Zbiggy" had been an early pioneer of electrified violin sounds and an active member of the "free jazz" movement though he contributed significantly to the J-R Fusion albums of Volker Kriegel, Jan "Ptaszyn" Wrķbleweski, Jasper van 't Hof, Joachim Kühn, Hans Koller, Charlie Mariano, and Glenn Moore's Oregon. Didier's song here allows his collaborators (Tony Williams, John Etheridge, Gordon Beck, and Niels-Henning Orsted-Pedersen) to also pay tribute to their lost compatriot. Kind of a two-chord high-speed, dynamic vamp that allows for lots of soloing. (13.375/15)

Total Time: 41:19

It's all great acoustic jazz--maybe "rock" can be tagged onto the descriptive referents, but it's really just jazz. To me, this album is more of a retrospective tribute to Jazz history than a step forward in the evolution of Jazz-Rock Fusion. At the same time, after repeated listens I've come to appreciate the absolute genius of the performances of these jazz stalwarts. Beautiful!

A/five stars; while not what I would consider an expression or full-fledged Jazz-Rock Fusion, this is without a doubt a wonderful expression of music, musicianship, and jazz of the absolute highest quality and must, therefore, be extolled as a masterpiece of music--general Götterdämerung-ed music--no matter what genre or category you choose to assign it to. It's challenging for me to label this "essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music" when it's not progressive rock music--it's jazz--but, since it's here on PA and we're all in the business of exposing one another to great music in general (not just progressive rock) I cannot let this incredible album go unadvocated.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Mothers Of Invention: Absolutely Free by ZAPPA, FRANK album cover Studio Album, 1967
4.01 | 646 ratings

BUY
The Mothers Of Invention: Absolutely Free
Frank Zappa RIO/Avant-Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Soon after the release of their debut album in 1966, the Mothers of Invention followed that up with the brilliantly weird and often undecipherable 'Absolutely Free', an early staple of experimental rock that once again displayed the originality of the band and their effortless and satirical approach towards rock music, all while playing some of the most fascinating music to have come out of the late 1960s. Much like 'Freak Out!', the music on here is adventurously avant-garde and offers several completely unorthodox pieces of rock and pop music, with the MOI drawing in influences from all over the place (blues, psychedelia, garage rock, classical and fusion references grace the two sides of the original LP). Besides, this time we have an eight-piece band working itself around, plus a ton of guest musicians, with virtually every single member of this wicked art collective contributing to the bedazzling and disturbingly surreal passages of music and their corresponding sceneries, since the earliest music of Zappa and the Mothers is incredibly vivid and resembling what we could refer to as "a film for listening".

Herein, many of the shorter pieces actually make up for longer suites, led by a certain musical motif around which the rest of the compositions are developed, which in many regards works as the anticipation of the progressive rock style and what the bands associated with it would go on to experiment with later on. Not an easy album to dissect or digest, similarly to the debut, 'Absolutely Free' still has some really fine pieces like the great suites 'The Duke of Prunes' and 'Call Any Vegetables' on side one, with a strong display of Zappa's improvisational style of play, and the garage-prog collage of sounds found on side two ('Brown Shoes Don't Make It') with all of its quirky accompanying shorter tracks. The strengths of this album overshadow its downsides for sure, which is very likely why this release is well-respected and seen as a significant part of the classic MOI catalogue, and despite its obvious but cheerfully chaotic and patchy flaws, 'Absolutely Free' indicates a desire for rebellion as well as a vision of ominous quirkiness that we just cannot ignore.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Jazz Rock (aka Volkor) by VOLKOR album cover Studio Album, 1976
3.50 | 6 ratings

BUY
Jazz Rock (aka Volkor)
Volkor Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars The Lockwood brothers--20-year old violinist, Didier, and his older keyboard-playing brother, Francis--team up with monster bass player Bunny Brunel and recent Zeuhl artist Patrick Gauthier to produce an album that was inspired by Jean-Luc Ponty's work (especially his collaboration with Frank Zappa for King Kong: Jean-Luc Ponty Plays the Music of Frank Zappa) and probably that of Michal Urbaniak, and perhaps even Italian fusion artists Arti E Mestieri, David Cross (King Crimson, Clearlight), and Darryl Way (Curved Air). Though this album's original vinyl release was listed under Didier and Francis' surname, "Lockwood," later reissues (as early as 1980) tend to list the band as "VOLKOR"--though I know not why.

1. "To-Morrow" (2:15) opens with some super funky bass from Bunny Brunel--deep water bass, I have to call it. With the establishment of the main motif dueling solos ensue between Didier's electrified violin and Patrick Gauthier's Moog. This felt like a complete song despite being only two minutes long! (9.375/10)

2. "Astral Trip" (5:30) a great foundation presents fecund ground for Didier and to fly--while drummer Kirt Rust and, to a slightly lesser extent, Bunny Brunel also seem to fly underneath. Francis gets the next solo on his electric piano in the fourth minute and then Bunny in the fifth (which merely magnifies the prowess of power drummer Rust's extraordinary skill). Cool song with some great things accomplished with tempo changes over just two chords rotating over and over! (9.25/10)

3. "Elbow" (7:00) opening with some super-funky effected-bass establishing both the melody and pace before distorted Moog synthesizer starts to squawk its way into the groove. Drums and echo- and delay-treated-electric violin are next, the former playing a straight-time near-Disco beat while Didier provides melodies to counter Patrick's squawking synth. In the fifth minute Bunny and Kirt slow things down as Francis' Fender Rhodes stabilizes things with regular chords played in a Zeuhlish progression while Didier really goes to Jean-Luc Ponty town with his screaling violin. Cool shift--which allows Kirt to show more of his skills and creativity on the batterie. Patrick re-enters with that saw-squawk Moog for the final 30 seconds as the engineers give the song a slow fade. (13.75/15)

4. "What's The Matter" (2:15) multiple tracks given to Francis' distorted Fender Rhodes while Patrick puts on display another of the highly-unusual sounds that he's discovered on the Moog--this one sounding as if a calypso steel drum were filtered through a garbage disposal. An unique little novelty piece. (4.375/5)

5. "Volkor" (6:05) a Jazz-Rock Fusion piece that is structured and paletted like a Zeuhl song with a fairly constant/rigid Fender Rhodes four-chord progression and deep bass line towing the line while Kirt's drums race frenetically-along and Patrick's Moog and Didier's reverb-violin trade barb's up top. A shift in motif (but not sound palette) occurs at 5:30 but this just leads to a slow fade-out from the production crew. Cool song with great play from Bunny, Kirt, Patrick, and Didier. (9.125/10)

6. "Yellow Faces" (3:35) sonosphere-dominating underwater bass and spacious time-keeping rock drums provide the fertile medium for Didier to solo on his ever-increasingly-reverberated electric violin. It's cool, with a great sound palette, but ultimately a little monotonous in its one dimensionality: like another experimentation or étude. (8.75/10)

7. "Green" (3:50) another cute, quaint, and yet interesting little sound experiment (more in palette--due to another one of Patrick's sonic discoveries on his Moog) that ends up never changing, never developing into a full song, always feeling like another étude. (8.875/10)

8. "Naita" (4:20) the Lockwood brothers performing a spacious duet: Francis' dirty Fender Rhodes more supporting and reactive to his brother's wonderful soaring, plaintive work on the heavily-treated electric violin. In the fourth minute Francis picks up his involvement--almost sounding as if he's providing structure and pace for the rhythm section to join in--but it never happens. The song dies with Didier's last sad note as Francis' last echoed-chords filling the sonosphere. (8.75/10)

Total Time 34:50

Some amazing experimentations with sound and sound textures are occurring throughout this exciting, inventive album but there are two tendencies that render my overall impression one of words that are not all superlatives: 1) the clear Jean-Luc Ponty-ness of Didier's sound and stylistic approach to his violin play and 2) the fact that so many of the songs (three of them) feel incomplete--as if the brothers were so enamored of their sound creations that they figured a little blurb of these rather unique (and entertaining) sonic experiences was deserving of public preservation.

A-/4.5 stars; a near-masterpiece of innovative and experimental Jazz-Rock Fusion that never seems to reach its fullest potential.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Lockwood: Jazz-Rock by LOCKWOOD, DIDIER album cover Studio Album, 1976
3.88 | 7 ratings

BUY
Lockwood: Jazz-Rock
Didier Lockwood Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars The Lockwood brothers--20-year old violinist, Didier, and his older keyboard-playing brother, Francis--team up with monster bass player Bunny Brunel and recent Zeuhl artist Patrick Gauthier to produce an album that was inspired by Jean-Luc Ponty's work (especially his collaboration with Frank Zappa for King Kong: Jean-Luc Ponty Plays the Music of Frank Zappa) and probably that of Michal Urbaniak, and perhaps even Italian fusion artists Arti E Mestieri, David Cross (King Crimson, Clearlight), and Darryl Way (Curved Air). Though this album's original vinyl release was listed under Didier and Francis' surname, "Lockwood," later reissues (as early as 1980) tend to list the band as "VOLKOR"--though I know not why.

1. "To-Morrow" (2:15) opens with some super funky bass from Bunny Brunel--deep water bass, I have to call it. With the establishment of the main motif dueling solos ensue between Didier's electrified violin and Patrick Gauthier's Moog. This felt like a complete song despite being only two minutes long! (9.375/10)

2. "Astral Trip" (5:30) a great foundation presents fecund ground for Didier and to fly--while drummer Kirt Rust and, to a slightly lesser extent, Bunny Brunel also seem to fly underneath. Francis gets the next solo on his electric piano in the fourth minute and then Bunny in the fifth (which merely magnifies the prowess of power drummer Rust's extraordinary skill). Cool song with some great things accomplished with tempo changes over just two chords rotating over and over! (9.25/10)

3. "Elbow" (7:00) opening with some super-funky effected-bass establishing both the melody and pace before distorted Moog synthesizer starts to squawk its way into the groove. Drums and echo- and delay-treated-electric violin are next, the former playing a straight-time near-Disco beat while Didier provides melodies to counter Patrick's squawking synth. In the fifth minute Bunny and Kirt slow things down as Francis' Fender Rhodes stabilizes things with regular chords played in a Zeuhlish progression while Didier really goes to Jean-Luc Ponty town with his screaling violin. Cool shift--which allows Kirt to show more of his skills and creativity on the batterie. Patrick re-enters with that saw-squawk Moog for the final 30 seconds as the engineers give the song a slow fade. (13.75/15)

4. "What's The Matter" (2:15) multiple tracks given to Francis' distorted Fender Rhodes while Patrick puts on display another of the highly-unusual sounds that he's discovered on the Moog--this one sounding as if a calypso steel drum were filtered through a garbage disposal. An unique little novelty piece. (4.375/5)

5. "Volkor" (6:05) a Jazz-Rock Fusion piece that is structured and paletted like a Zeuhl song with a fairly constant/rigid Fender Rhodes four-chord progression and deep bass line towing the line while Kirt's drums race frenetically-along and Patrick's Moog and Didier's reverb-violin trade barb's up top. A shift in motif (but not sound palette) occurs at 5:30 but this just leads to a slow fade-out from the production crew. Cool song with great play from Bunny, Kirt, Patrick, and Didier. (9.125/10)

6. "Yellow Faces" (3:35) sonosphere-dominating underwater bass and spacious time-keeping rock drums provide the fertile medium for Didier to solo on his ever-increasingly-reverberated electric violin. It's cool, with a great sound palette, but ultimately a little monotonous in its one dimensionality: like another experimentation or étude. (8.75/10)

7. "Green" (3:50) another cute, quaint, and yet interesting little sound experiment (more in palette--due to another one of Patrick's sonic discoveries on his Moog) that ends up never changing, never developing into a full song, always feeling like another étude. (8.875/10)

8. "Naita" (4:20) the Lockwood brothers performing a spacious duet: Francis' dirty Fender Rhodes more supporting and reactive to his brother's wonderful soaring, plaintive work on the heavily-treated electric violin. In the fourth minute Francis picks up his involvement--almost sounding as if he's providing structure and pace for the rhythm section to join in--but it never happens. The song dies with Didier's last sad note as Francis' last echoed-chords filling the sonosphere. (8.75/10)

Total Time 34:50

Some amazing experimentations with sound and sound textures are occurring throughout this exciting, inventive album but there are two tendencies that render my overall impression one of words that are not all superlatives: 1) the clear Jean-Luc Ponty-ness of Didier's sound and stylistic approach to his violin play and 2) the fact that so many of the songs (three of them) feel incomplete--as if the brothers were so enamored of their sound creations that they figured a little blurb of these rather unique (and entertaining) sonic experiences was deserving of public preservation.

A-/4.5 stars; a near-masterpiece of innovative and experimental Jazz-Rock Fusion that never seems to reach its fullest potential.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Gamle Mester by FRØISLIE, LARS FREDRIK album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.48 | 58 ratings

BUY
Gamle Mester
Lars Fredrik Frøislie Symphonic Prog

Review by Stoneburner

5 stars Lars Fredrik Frøislie is the keyboardist for iconic bands like Wobbler, Tusmørke, White Willow, and projects like The Chronicles of Father Robin. Lars never stops?he's always creating something interesting. He owns an impressive collection of analog keyboards, including a Chamberlin Mellotron, which is almost impossible to find. Well, he's got one.

This is his second solo album in two years. The first, Fire Fortellinger, received very positive reviews. Frøislie, a lover of '70s prog?especially Italian prog?decided to sing in his native Norwegian, which gives the music a unique touch.

Once again, as with the previous album, Frøislie plays all the instruments, including vocals, and he does it remarkably well. He shares duties again with bassist Nikolai Hængsle and flutist Ketil Einarsen.

Gamle Mester is a bit stronger than Frøislie's previous album. The music is now more complex and slightly less folk-oriented. The keyboards take on a new dimension, and the compositions are inspired by mythology?the power of the gods over mere mortals.

The album feels warm and shares many similarities with Wobbler?except this time, Andreas Prestmo is missing. For fans of that band still waiting for something new, this record helps fill the void, but at the same time, it stands strong on its own. Personally, I think this album is changing certain parameters more than simply repeating what's already been done. I don't know how, but there's a lot of originality here, even though it clearly carries many influences. Lars Fredrik Frøislie, despite wearing his inspirations on his sleeve, manages to stand out and carve out a world entirely his own.

A great record to keep in mind in this extraordinary 2025.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Synkretiko by FUCCI, CLAUDIO album cover Studio Album, 2006
3.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Synkretiko
Claudio Fucci Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by Finnforest
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

— First review of this album —
3 stars A Wonderful Nightcap

Claudio Fucci was born circa 1952 in the town of Carosino near Taranto, later living in Milan. He started writings songs in the late 1960s, and by the '70s he was collaborating with the likes of Come Le Foglie and Banco. After the release of his own 1974 self-titled work produced by Eugenio Finardi, he would work with keyboardist Dario Piana again on the Le Mani project. But aside from a soundtrack project, it would be over 30 years before Fucci followed up his 1974 debut. The resulting Synkretiko is a country mile from anything resembling 21st century progressive rock, but it is a surprisingly warm and engaging return for Fucci nonetheless. This is not a progressive rock album even to the extent of his earlier work, but it is a good pop/rock album with a heavy dose of that wonderful Italian touch. It's very well decorated with two dozen great musicians including his old buddies, Eugenio Finardi and Dario Piana.

Synkretiko is an album for people who already know they like stuff like Battisti, Stephano Testa, Mario Barbaja, Gigi Pascal, or Gianni D'errico. The songs run the typical pop song template and length, but they are catchy, fun, and colorful. "Graffiti Italiani" is a festive opener with a bouncy folk feel adorned with fiddle. "Il Silenzio E Il Tuono" is another with a folky-country rock vibe that sounds great with Fucci's gregarious voice. "Sebastiano" is more bluesy with raucous electric guitar and organ that reminded me of Faces "Stay with Me." "Come Un Poeta" veers into a light and melodic jazz groove. And "Via C. Baroni" is a grand, romantic-sounding ballad. As you can see, the album's style is free and engaging, but the quality is very high. These songs will stick in your ears for days after. For such a late entry in the game, Fucci succeeds here. If this is to be his nightcap, it is sweet on the lips indeed. La musica della vita!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Typhareth by ZAO album cover Studio Album, 1977
3.67 | 37 ratings

BUY
Typhareth
Zao Zeuhl

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars Gone are both founder Yochok'o Seffer and recent acquisition Didier Lockwood, here come percussionist Michel Séguin, wind player Franįois Debricon, trombonist Hamid Belhocine, and a young Manu Katché on drums (the first recorded presentation of the future superstar).

1. "Merci Jacky" (7:20) opens with a Smooth Jazz-like feeling before Jaco Pastorius-like bass joins the percussion and steady one-chord electric piano motif. Key change at 0:50 continues the one-chord foundation approach while Gérard Prévost and Michel Séguin continue to impress (especially the former). 2:00 the reins are handed over to "Faton" for a solo that could come from lighter J-R Fusion players like Donald Fagen, Michael Omartian, or Greg Phillinganese. chord progression sequence in the fourth minute leads into a much more developed motif (though it feels the same because the drum and percussion lines are much unchanged) but trombone and saxophone now join in while the keyboard/synth and bass lines are now more sophisticated, melodic, and, frankly, interesting. Fuzz synth mirrors bass play for a score of seconds before circus-like sounds and chord progression take us into the dismantling finish. Nice, fun and light. Good opener. (13.25/15)

2. "Typhareth (Beauté)" (12:44) I love the presence, prominence of trombone coming from unconventional trombonist Hamid Belhocine. The flanged bass (with its great solo in the eleventh minute) is cool, too--especially due to the loving support that Faton's hypnotic keyboards play below him. This is a very easy-going, gentle and melodic tune which lulls the mind into perhaps failing to notice all of the lovely subtleties going on in the soil and underbrush. Truly a lovely song. (23.75/25)

3. "Troupeau De Bisons Sous Un Crane" (3:32) Hand claps and congas! A light, fun, and upbeat tune that seems to reflect a carefree, fearless Cajun-like attitude. Nice! A little Weather Report feel to this--and so nice to hear a lower- register saxophone for a change! (8.875/10)

4. "Binah / Comprehension Feminine" (5:04) dreamy ethereal combination of piano, flute, and EBERHARD WEBER-like flanged electric bass start this one out as cymbals and metal percussives add to the effect while flutes, percussives, change, trombone enters. At 3:00 there feels like a shift in temperament: as if the sun has come out and there's a reassurance that everything will be okay. But then it goes back to the more dreamy, less settling motif for the final minute. Nice! Interesting! Creative. (8.875/10)

5. "Les Temps Changent" (8:44) keyboard, congas, and café chatter open this for about 30 seconds before bass, drums and horn section enter to move the song forward--but slowly, with lots of stutter steps and shifting, twisting dance moves--before finally letting Faton lead us into the pedestrian lanes of the cobblestone shopping area of la vieille ville. As we walk the troupe gets more stylish, more swaggy and cocky with its self-assured, attention-getting footwork and audaciousness. I love it: These were the Seventies! This is a perfect representation of the Black-positive attitudes that styles, clothing, and music were expressing at the time--and Franįois Debricon's expressive tenor saxophone solo in the seventh minute is the perfect cherry on top! This is followed by an ensemble finale which feels as if it were choreographed by Mandy Moore for a street scene in La La Land. (18/20)

Total Time: 37:24

Like reviewer/friend John Davies, I find much more hiding in this music than what might appear at first listen: besides eminently-impressive musicianship from all involved, there are plenty of compositional and improvisational intricacies that might be masked by the easy-on-the-ears melodic sensibilities that Franįois offers the listener.

A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of Third-moving-into-Fourth Wave Jazz-Rock Fusion. Very engaging and upbeat while being deceptively intricate and sophisticated.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Tormato by YES album cover Studio Album, 1978
3.02 | 1854 ratings

BUY
Tormato
Yes Symphonic Prog

Review by Stoneburner

5 stars Yes -Tor -Mato

Tormato is the album with which Yes closed out the extraordinary decade that saw them reach the peak of progressive music and become the legendary group they are today. Tormato is an album I have a special affection for, as it was my entrance into this great band. Although many consider it mediocre, I've always found it extraordinary?not quite on the level of Close to the Edge or Fragile, but far better than what the band would go on to produce in the mid-eighties.

Tormato came after a glorious period for the band. They had just recorded an incredible album Going For The One and completed an extremely successful tour. By then, Yes was already considered one of the best bands in the world, almost on the same level as giants like Led Zeppelin and Black Sabbath. That's why, when they entered the studio to record Tormato, Yes had carte blanche to do whatever they wanted.

It's important to place ourselves in the historical context of 1978. The musical landscape had changed drastically. It wasn't just disco anymore?punk and new wave were now dominating the market and leaving a strong impression. Yes wasn't punk or new wave, but people still liked them. The Police were the band of the moment?everyone liked them, and many wanted to be like them.

After Going for the One, which featured the return of the band's prodigal son Rick Wakeman, things seemed to remain stable?at least on the surface. The problem was that the band had no new music composed. Everything they had was discarded, as the members couldn't agree on the sound they wanted for this new record, which already had a working title: Yes Tor, named after some hills near Dartmoor, Devon, close to where Steve Howe lived.

The cards were on the table, and the players were ready. Wakeman arrived at the studio with a range of new polyphonic keyboards, which significantly reduced the amount of gear he needed. The Polymoog and the Birotron would come to define the album's sonic character. Meanwhile, Chris Squire had discovered the Mu-Tron pedal, which gave his bass a distinctive, more modern effect?closer in line with the evolving sounds of the time. Steve Howe opted for single-coil guitars to create a sound that was softer yet more piercing.

Production duties were handed back to Eddie Offord, who hadn't worked with Yes since Relayer in 1974. This album wasn't just another record?it felt more like a reunion of old friends, eager to show off their new toys but lacking a clear direction. As the days passed and ideas floated in and out, the sessions turned increasingly frustrating. Chris wanted to sound like The Police, Alan White was pushing for a heavier rock vibe, Steve aimed for something more experimental, Rick wanted to explore his new keyboards, and Jon Anderson?curiously?didn't even want to sound like himself. He was trying for a deeper tone, searching for something different.

After those endless sessions, very little could be salvaged. The material was taken to Eddie Offord, who ended up abandoning the project because he found it dull and uninspired. Eventually, the band had to take over the production themselves. Slowly, out of that chaos, Tormato began to take shape. But why Tormato, if the album was supposed to be called Yes Tor?

Although the original plan was to have Roger Dean design the cover, he never really connected with the band's vision this time. Instead, as with Going for the One, Yes contacted Hipgnosis again. The final concept came from a photo featuring a smashed tomato, which immediately struck a chord with the band. It symbolized their frustration, mockery, and protest toward the whole recording process. For years, it was believed that the band members themselves had thrown tomatoes at the photo in anger. In truth, it was Aubrey Powell from Hipgnosis who hurled tomatoes at his own creation, frustrated after it was rejected by other bands. Yes empathized with that gesture, and Yes Tor becoming on Tormato.

The music on Side one opens with "Future Times / Rejoice", composed entirely by Anderson, whose lyrics here are unusually direct. The track features Chris Squire using the Mu-Tron pedal, adding that now-iconic touch to his bass tone.

"Don't Kill the Whale" originated from a bass line and acoustic guitar part created by Squire, which Anderson developed further using a poem he had written. The lyrics were inspired by a TV program about saving tigers, which led him to write about whale conservation. Their friend Terry Doran also played a role in sparking the theme. Wakeman added a Polymoog sound resembling whale calls, which shaped the track's unique identity. The song was an instant hit and it was the first major hit for the band since Roundabout.

"Madrigal" is a short, delicate piece driven by Wakeman's harpsichord, written at Anderson's suggestion to explore the madrigal form of English evening song.

"Release, Release", originally titled The Anti-Campaign, was co-developed by Anderson and White and reflected the social and political unrest of the time. The song features automatic double tracking on drums and a live crowd sample?allegedly from a football match?to energize the instrumental break. It caught the attention of Atlantic Records president Ahmet Ertegun, who even suggested the whole album follow its more straightforward rock sound. Anderson later admitted the song was difficult to perform live due to the vocal range it demanded.

On the other side starts with "Arriving UFO", a sci-fi-inspired track based on a theme Anderson developed after watching Close Encounters of the Third Kind. Wakeman composed the instrumental midsection.

"Circus of Heaven" tells a whimsical story aimed at children, complete with unicorns, elves, and a circus arriving in a quiet Midwestern town. The story was inspired by Ray Bradbury and was something Anderson shared with his son Damion, who voices the child at the end. Musically, the song is notable for Squire's reggae-style bass line.

"Onward" is a lush ballad written entirely by Squire, featuring orchestral arrangements by Andrew Pryce Jackman. Squire considered it one of his best compositions, and it was later revived on stage in 1996 with a new acoustic intro by Steve Howe called "Unity".

Finally, "On the Silent Wings of Freedom" closes the album on a high note, built around Squire's bass with a distinctive Mu-Tron Envelope Shaper effect, giving it a driving, pulsating energy.

As a side note, some original cassette and 8-track editions included a hidden track called "Richard", written by Anderson. Though it was omitted from later reissues.

In the end, Tormato it is a fascinating record in the Yes story. It's an album born from frustration, and experimentation, but it still carries moments of brilliance musical extremes hated by many and loved for others. While it may not reach the heights of their masterpieces, it reflects a band trying to adapt, to evolve, and to remain true to themselves in a rapidly changing musical world. For some, it's a misstep. For others? like me?it's a misunderstood gem, full of character, tension, and charm. And above all, it marked the last time this classic lineup would record together until much later, making Tormato both an ending and a turning point in the history of Yes. I still believe that this record needs more love from the fans.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Cadmium  by SKY album cover Studio Album, 1983
2.54 | 38 ratings

BUY
Cadmium
Sky Eclectic Prog

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

3 stars The fifth album from Sky is in similar "easy listening classical ditties for rock group" territory to their previous album, Forthcoming. The major difference appears to be that whilst Forthcoming was fairly placid, this is positively jaunty - why, on Telex From Peru there's threats to actually creep back towards rock, to the extent that Sky ever rocked, though there's still gentler moments like Then and Now. As with the previous album, it's a collection of entirely acceptable background music, but isn't much more than that. Individual listeners will have to decide whether the crisp production and pleasing musicianship saves it from being muzak or pushes it into that category.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Countdown to Ecstasy by STEELY DAN album cover Studio Album, 1973
4.08 | 279 ratings

BUY
Countdown to Ecstasy
Steely Dan Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Lobster77

5 stars Steely Dan a great American band, truly talented individuals, Becker and Fagan are geniuses with that unique immediately identifiable sound. I must admit in my formative years they absolutely blew me away, so I'm not sure how this album avoided my clutches. Was it worth the wait, I think it was, although I'm still a fan, that thrill of the new all those years ago has receded, become comfortingly familiar to the extent that it's hard to to disconnect oneself and give an objective view. What I will say that certain Steely Dan songs have a strong emotional pull on me, Do It Again, Rikki, Haitian Divorce, Dr Wu and on this album Razor Boy, ( I love that vibraphone/marimba and the pedal steel ) falls into this category not to mean it's best, I just get that similar kick from it, others like Bodhisattva, Boston Rag and My Old School are perhaps to well known to me from compilations. What I will say is while I may feel a little short changed on an immediately classic number this is still an intoxicationg listen, every track is a winner and a grower, listen closely and be overwhelmed by the musicianship, unadulterated class, the fresh sounds to me like Your Gold Teeth, with it's stabbing piano and funky rhythm overlayed with loose jazz guitar runs and King of the World are my big hitters.

Donald and Walt and their session musicians do a swell job at jazz fusion and this is just the second step of their discography.

5.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 La Danza De La Luna by MARTÍNEZ, JULIÁN album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2025
3.65 | 4 ratings

BUY
La Danza De La Luna
Julián Martínez Symphonic Prog

Review by Heart of the Matter

4 stars Romanticism made a well-known path through the classical music legacy. Beethoven, Schubert, Chopin, to name only a few of them, were names firmly associated with that particular sort of pathos, which may be hard to define, but definitely seems to include a strong association linking the purity of the human soul with the majestic harmony implicit in the many levels of order found in Nature. Society is essentially a corrupted affair, but man is more than a mindless part of that sad state of things, and can steer away from it, seeking redemption in a pure contemplation of Nature's own wonders.

Like the precise ballet taking place in the skies every blessed night. And that is the subject matter of this short, but at the same time ambitious little work. A spiritual endeavour fed by clasical influences, as mentioned above, but taking finally the form of a Symphonic Rock suite in several movements, primorously put together by the multi-instrumentalist talent of the composer Julián Martínez.

The mind behind the proceedings clearly seems to be that of a pianist, rendering a pleasant starscape made of interweaving scales embellished with all sorts of trills, and likely minded resources taken from the baroque and romantic palette. But the tonal color is also enriched by resort to the sound of harpsichord, flute and some hints of mellotron, mainly in the background.

The articulation of the work follows also the traditional alternation between the more rapid, dense, and heavily orchestrated movements, like the opener, El Canto Del Bosque, with other relatively slower, transparent, and sparingly orchestrated ones, like the second track, Caminos De Cristal, to put some example.

Anyway, what comes out triumphant in the end is the strong sense of relaxed flow, and thoroughly achieved continuity that prevails from the first note, right to the last one of them, an accomplished result of flawless conception and execution that the listener cannot but be thankful for.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Mahal by HENDERSON, EDDIE album cover Studio Album, 1978
4.00 | 7 ratings

BUY
Mahal
Eddie Henderson Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars Here we find Dr. Eddie teaming up with several of his previous collaborators from both the Mwandishi days but even a Headhunter or two--including the one and only Herbie Hancock.

1. "Butterfly" [Herbie Hancock] (8:05) a remake of the Herbie Hancock "classic" (even though it's only four years old) with its creator taking part in the modernized version (as well as several Mwandishi alumni and Bennie Maupin who was one of the original Headhunters, too!) I love all of the innovative sounds Herbie, synth specialist John Bowen, and guitarist Ray Obiedo are employing to funk-up and "modernize" the song. So funny to have these songs re-covered A) so soon after their initial entry into pop consciousness and B) by members of the original lineup now four years "older"! LOL! It's even been discofied a bit! Though it is definitely different than the original, it's still a great song. (Perhaps its just one of those songs that you can never ruin no matter how you choose to approach it.) (14/15)

2. "Cyclops" [James Mtume] (5:18) Eddie and his record company felt good enough about this song to have released it as a 45-single! It's definitely catchy--like the instrumental ear candy that many jazz fusion artists were turning toward at this time--before Jazz-Rock Fusion was being spilled over into Smooth Jazz, Disco Funk, Adult Contemporary, Yacht Rock, 80s R&B and Hip-Hop, and even New Age. It feels as if the piano chords in this song were lifted directly off of the master tapes for the 1984 Soul/R&B hit song "Hey DJ" by The World Famous Supreme Team. It is a great, fun, highly enjoyable listen. (9.333/10)

3. "Emotions" [Eddie Henderson] (4:59) gentle yet sophisticated with Paul Jackson's bass notes and bass harmonics forming much of the foundation with percussive drum play turning to full kit use in the second minute. Eddie's flugelhorn lead is quite melodic--quite like hearing a human voice pronounce its words quite intentionally. The involvement of the rest of the band seems minimal, other than Herbie's Fender Rhodes. (9/10)

4. "Prance On" [James Mtume] (5:16) another Mtume song that falls right into the Disco world that James would stick with throughout the 80s, there are CHIC-like clavinet, rhythm guitar strains, and background synth "strings" accents and flourishes that would become absorbed and exploited fully by Michael Jackson's songwriting/production crew from here (Off the Wall) through Thriller, but the bass is all disco and novelty Funk-Soul/R&B. Overall, it's a little too drawn out and monotonous. (8.875/10)

5. "Amoroso" [Bennie Maupin] (5:38) interesting funk R&B with some novelty sounds covered by some great percussion and trumpet play. Using a fairly dull, straightforward drum "program" the syncopation comes complete from the horns and bass teaming up to carry the melodic rhythm track while Herbie and muted Eddie solo among the flurries of other contributors sneaking in their inputs. (8.875/10)

6. "Mahal" [Eddie Henderson] (4:27) I'm not sure where Eddie was at this time in his life but I find it interesting that the three compositions credited to him on this album are all rather slow, gentle, and tender. Love? Loss? Sadness? Transition? How does the doctor use his music for therapy? There are wonderfully tender inputs from Herbie (muted clavinet), John Bowen (Oberheim strings), Julian Priester, and Paul Jackson on this lovely little tune. (9/10)

7. "Ecstasy" [Eddie Henderson] (3:25) dreamy Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood-like fairy dust coming from Herbie's JOHNNY COSTA-like Fender Rhodes is the only support Eddie uses to express his ruminative mood--like something from FRANK SINATRA's masterpiece of late-night regret, In the Wee Small Hours, or Freddie Hubbard on several of his song remakes on next year's The Love Connection. I really like contemplative songs like this: makes me think that some humans (without the aide of alcohol) are really thinking about their lives. A rather beautiful duet but not really anything contributing to the expansion of the Jazz-Rock Fusion idiom. (8.75/10)

Total Time: 37:08

A-/4.5 stars; a near-masterpiece of Third-entering-upon-Fourth Wave Jazz-Rock Fusion that illustrates that Eddie (and Herbie) are still committed to continuing to push the boundaries of that which is possible for the movement.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Bosses Låt by FANTASIA album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2017
3.10 | 2 ratings

BUY
Bosses Låt
Fantasia Eclectic Prog

Review by Matti
Prog Reviewer

3 stars The Finnish prog band FANTASIA are known from their eponymous sole album (1975), one of the definitive classics of the 'smaller' Finnish prog acts of the seventies. The album line-up already changed in 1976 but the group disbanded in 1979 without further releases at the time. In the early 2010's guitarist-vocalist Hannu Lindblom gathered a new line-up under the name Fantasia, after the album had seen its first CD reissue. In 2017 was released this three-track EP of new material.

The instrumental 'Bosses låt' is a cover of a piece by the Swedish prog band Fläsket Brinner, featured on their 1971 album and composed by the band's organist Bo[sse] Hansson -- yes, the Sagan om Ringen guy. This version is sonically tighter and more emphasized on guitar whereas the original has also flute plus some sax in the end. Although the composition per se doesn't much progress, it is easy to recognize as an early 70's prog instrumental.

'Desert Storm' is composed by Lindblom to the English lyrics by Pirkko Hautamäki. Also this one is very 70's in style, slightly resembling the Meddle era Pink Floyd, or rather, A Tab in the Ocean era Nektar for the hard- rocking psychedelic atmosphere. Lindblom's vocals have aged and roughened but they're still ok. The playing is powerful especially for the organ and electric guitar.

'Tämä uni' (= This dream) turns out to be the same piece in different Finnish lyrics by Kari Ilmonen who had also written the lyrics for the album in 1975. "Good, but non-essential" three stars. The fourth star would need a little more material than one cover and one new tune in two langauages.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Carnival of Lost Souls by CEN-PROJEKT album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.51 | 18 ratings

BUY
Carnival of Lost Souls
Cen-ProjekT Symphonic Prog

Review by rdtprog
Special Collaborator Heavy, RPI, Symph, JR/F Canterbury Teams

5 stars This is the project of one man with only one guest on bass. The music is rooted in the symphonic prog of the 1970s. The melodies are developed around lush keyboards and emotional vocal harmonies. Some acoustic passages bring Genesis and Hackett's style of playing. The flute passage adds to the retro prog feel that we have throughout the album. The guitars are never as heavy as some Neo-Prog bands, and the prominent use of acoustic guitar and flute provided an almost pastoral atmosphere. I am impressed by the quality of the songs from start to finish. For now, this album seems to be a step ahead of other albums from this project, because the songs have the edge that was missing. This could be in my top 10 albums this year!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Timespan  by MAJEURE album cover Studio Album, 2009
3.96 | 5 ratings

BUY
Timespan
Majeure Progressive Electronic

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars MAJEURE is the solo project of Anthony Pattera, who is in fact a drummer and an electronics musician. If that name is familiar you might be a fan of ZOMBI, as Pattera and Steve Moore are the duo who make up that band. "Timespan" is his debut from 2009, the same year ZOMBI released "Spirit Animal". His choice of the name MAJEURE has to come from TANGERINE DREAM's "Force Majeure" record. An album where electronics and drums figured prominently, like here.

There are three long tracks over 43 minutes. The music is quite catchy and melodic, not that far from the parent band. There's a host of electronic sounds here, plus the real drums are a bonus in my opinion. This is catchy and fun, but also really well done with that adventerous spirit. "The Dresden Codex" is the 14 1/2 minute opener. We get sequencers right out of the gate followed by synths and drums. This is great! Check out the bass synths before 3 minutes. I much prefer the first half of this track. It's a little mellow on the second half.

"Teleforce" is my favourite and the shortest at 9 1/2 minutes. Again sequencers hit us first followed by drums and this is rocking pretty good. Woo hoo! Synths sweep in after 3 1/2 minutes. So good. There's even more going on over those final 3 minutes.

"Timespan" the title track clocks in at 18 1/2 minutes. Love the start with the windy atmosphere as sounds pulse. The atmosphere turns more dense, then synths drop like rain as the atmosphere subsides and another wave of sounds arrives and takes over. No rain. Sequencers after 4 1/2 minutes along with drums before the synths come in like a cold front after 6 minutes. The tempo picks up before 11 minutes before it all settles around 15 1/2 minutes but sequencers, drums and spacey synths continue.

I have "Solar Maximum" from 2012 lined up next, his sophomore record. "Timespan" is entertaining yet adventerous. It's a cd I looked forward to popping in the stereo every time. A solid 4 stars for this one.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Drama by YES album cover Studio Album, 1980
3.77 | 2041 ratings

BUY
Drama
Yes Symphonic Prog

Review by Stoneburner

4 stars A Good Drama

I don't think I need to write an introduction for this album on Prog Archives, since it already has 190 reviews and comes from a classic progressive rock band. But a little history never hurts. After a long, two-year tour, Yes closed out a successful decade during which they released several landmark albums. However, the recording of Tormato was a complete disaster, and the resulting album left not only the band but also many fans?and especially the label?deeply dissatisfied.

That's why the band, with its classic lineup and taking advantage of Rick Wakeman's return, planned a tour covering their entire 1970s discography. Each show lasted between two hours and 45 minutes to well over three hours. Despite the length, the tour was a success, and Yes re-established itself. Perhaps it marked the end of an era for the band?or even the band itself. The dilemma, along with the failure of Tormato, put Yes in a difficult position. In fact, none of the classic members responded when Chris Squire and Alan White reached out to discuss the band's future.

At that point, Squire, Howe and White began rehearsing on their own. despite everyone's hopes, it didn't work out. Each time Squire headed to rehearsals, "Video Killed the Radio Star" by The Buggles played on the radio. He thought it was terrible?but there was something about the song that stuck with him. Howe left, and Squire and White were jamming alone.

One day, Squire began playing the hit song of the moment. White followed, laughing. In the middle of the jam, they stopped to talk. White said he liked the middle section and thought it had something. Squire felt it too and that's when he realized it might be a good idea to talk to Atco Records.

Squire, accompanied by Brian Lane his dude close friend, manager, and owner of the studio where Yes used to rehearse arranged a meeting with The Buggles. It turned out that Trevor Horn already knew Squire quite well, and they agreed to start working together, bringing in Horn's counterpart, keyboardist Geoff Downes. However, Horn made one thing clear: if it was going to be a Yes album, it had to include Steve Howe, whom Horn saw as the key member responsible for the classic Yes sound. Squire contacted Howe, who was finishing a short tour for his latest solo album. Howe agreed, but with one condition: that the album be produced by Eddie Offord the classic producer who hadn't worked with Yes since Relayer in 1974.

What Horn didn't know at that point was that Jon Anderson, the other fundamental piece of Yes, would not be part of the lineup.

And so, Squire convinced him that he would be the vocalist on the project, and Horn finally accepted. The band began working in New York, but they were broke, so Lane approached Atco Records to request a $200,000 advance. Initially denied, after some tough negotiation he managed to secure a better deal?$400,000. It was the first Yes album that started with a cash advance.

The album consisted of several Squire,Howe and White songs, along with others they had been rehearsing on studio, for a few weeks. Horn suggested including a Buggles song, "Into the Lens," as a potential promotional single. Although the Yes version was less commercial, it had the potential to bridge the prog world with the pop world.

Unfortunately, Offord's return as producer proved to be a disaster. He was going through a difficult emotional period, and his erratic behavior led the band to keep him on only as co-producer. His most valuable contribution came specifically on "Into the Lens." The production was eventually taken over by Hugh Padgham, then a young and relatively unknown figure who would later work with Sting, XTC, Genesis, and Phil Collins. As soon as work began under Padgham, everything started to feel easier and more relaxed than expected.

For example, Machine Messiah was rehearsed and recorded in just one day. The next day, inspired by Trevor Horn, they began work on White Car. Does It Really Happen? was a track originally rejected by Yes during the Going for the One sessions, but it was a personal favorite of Alan White. Side two opens with the masterful version of Into the Lens. Run Through the Light was one of the songs from the Squire and White era, but reworked in the studio?especially by Howe. Finally, Tempus Fugit was a song that originated in 1979 from a kind of Squire-Howe-White project.

Yes also worked on additional material during the recording sessions, though much of it remained incomplete. This included "We Can Fly from Here" and "Go Through This," which were later performed during the 1980 tour and eventually released on the live compilation The Word Is Live. "We Can Fly from Here" was later expanded into a 20-minute suite on Yes's 2011 studio album Fly from Here. A third track, "Crossfire," was also later released on another compilation.

The album's sleeve was designed by Roger Dean his first artwork for a Yes album since Relayer in 1974. When Dean was commissioned for the project, he already knew the album's title and approached the design with what he described as "an intuitive approach" to match the tone and spirit of the music. The title Drama was not chosen at random. It reflected the turbulent period the band went through before and during the making of the album the internal tensions, lineup changes, financial struggles, and the emotional weight of trying to rebuild Yes without Jon Anderson. It was, quite literally, a drama both musically and personally.

And yet, despite the odds, Drama stands as one of the most unique and underrated records in the Yes discography. It may lack the spiritual voice of Anderson, but it compensates with a renewed energy, tighter arrangements, and a bold fusion of progressive complexity with new wave flair. Horn and Downes brought fresh textures, and the core of Squire, White, and Howe delivered powerful performances. Songs like Machine Messiah and Tempus Fugit are now considered essential by many fans.

Over time, the album has gained respect, especially as listeners have re-evaluated it without the burden of its original context. It marked both an end and a new beginning?an experimental chapter that captured a band in transformation. Drama may have started in crisis, but it emerged as a reinvention.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Soul Retrieval by GRIMM, LARKIN album cover Studio Album, 2012
3.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Soul Retrieval
Larkin Grimm Prog Folk

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

— First review of this album —
3 stars The cover photo here reflects GRIMM's newish urban sophistication at the time, having come off the excellent "Parplar" release a few years prior, and inspires some fear that she may have gone abjectly mainstream. Luckily, "Soul Retrieval" is but an extension of its predecessor's aspirations. The ensemble now includes the legendary TONY VISCONTI which can't hurt. The opening number and the wonderful "Without a Body.." (perhaps her best song to this point) do flirt with pop, but an off kilter version nonetheless, epitomized by the latter's fanciful whistle-like synths. "Be a Great Burglar" is the third highlight with its haunting and eerily familiar tune and approach. Unfortunately the rest lacks the consistency, exceptionality and variety of "Parplar", ranging from the buzzkill blues of "The Road is Paved with Blues" to the decent but lightly uninspired "Flash and Thunder Came to Earth", so this isn't quite the album that might lead to Grimm's ascension, even if you might be singing along in spots.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Cotex, Volume 2 by CORTEX album cover Studio Album, 1977
3.95 | 2 ratings

BUY
Cotex, Volume 2
Cortex Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars The infectious popularity of Alain Mion's first CORTEX album obviously called for a follow up. The problem was in keeping his original band mates interested (and, I suppose, paid). Aside from drummer Alain Gandolfi (who, with Mion, would remain the core-constant throughout the Cortex career), an entire cast of newcomers has had to have been recruited in order to record an publish (and tour) with Alain's new songs.

A1. "Devil's Dance" (2:30) a great upbeat, piano & guitar-based Disco tune to open the album. Nice! New bassist Nicolas Mirkov and guitarist Philippe Vautin prove their worth from the opening minute. Even though it's short, it could easily (and happily) have been extended as a long jam (with perhaps some saxes or more solo work from Alain or Nicolas). (9.3333/10)

A2. "Funk Around The Punk" (3:18) definitely funk with the whole band--bass, drums, keys, and rhythm guitar--all participating in the wholeness of a 70s funk song. Guitarist Philippe Vautrin does some pretty cool things with his guitar: partly rhythmic, partly lead (small chords and both plucked and strummed strings). Alain Mion is active on several keyboard tracks indicating multiple over dubs. No horns or winds (that I can detect) on this one. Cute and peppy--very much like a BOB JAMES song. (8.875/10)

A3. "Hurluberlu" (5:10) two chord blues-based funk-rock/R&B with a rolling bass line and driving drum beat so that Alain and Philippe can play around on top. Nice, interesting work from Philippe's fuzzy-flanged lead guitar over this awesome cruisin' song. Excellent work from bassist Nicolas Mirkov (who, by the way, is the sole composer credited for this song) as well as from drummer Gandolfi. (9/10)

A4. "Soul" (2:50) three-chord keyboard entry leads into a funky Disco song with cool clavinet, rhythm guitar, and K.C. & The Sunshine Band "Get Down Tonight" lead guitar work, plus saxophone solos in the second half. Actually a pretty cool and creative song! (9/10)

A5. "Datura" (2:30) bass and guitar provide the most important inputs on this song. Though it has two motifs, it is another song that feels simple, one-dimensional, like a warm-up song or étude/practice/audition tune. One of the few songs not totally credited to Alain Mion, the guitar work of Philippe Vautrin is purely rhythm guitar but co-composer Nicolas Mirkov's bass (and sax) are plenty funky. (4.625/5)

B1. "Poxa" (3:25) this one sounds sappy enough to be a cover--like something that would likely end up as elevator music--but when the female background singers enter and start their "la-la-la-la-las" it kind of eliminates it from elevator heaven and renders it more of a soundtrack to some low-budget film. It's not bad--the musicians' performances are all fine--it's just a bit hokey. (8.75/10)

B2. "Mister J." (3:36) funky and perky little composition by drummer Alain Gandolfi that sounds like an American advertizing song. Female background vocalists enter in the second minute intermittently injecting the word some word that sounds perhaps more like "raina" than "régina." (8.875/10)

B3. "Régina" (5:00) the lone composition of guitarist Philippe Vautrin opens with guitar setting the chord progression, key, and pace. Funky bass, straightforward drums, keys, and clavinet "horns" plus real horns join in (the real horns gaining more traction the further into the song we go). (8.875/10)

B4. "Efficace Swing" (2:58) a nice little flute-led dittie that feels unfinished, more like an étude or practice song that never received the attention needed to finish it. Why is there no credit given to the flutist? (8.875/10)

B5. "Oh. Lord" (6:20) I love the etheric female vocalese singing like an angel over the church-like Hammond organ chords throughout the first half of this song. The little Hammond flurries in-between the two rounds of Alice Prévost's vocals is a little corny, but overall it's very cool. And then it ends. There is a rather long pause as if there is a whole new song starting, but I do recognize the same chords/key in the opening Fender Rhodes display. And then the bass, drums, and rhythm guitar-like chord play of Alain's left hand join in and provide a lovely funk-lite love song. (9.5/10)

Total Time: 37:52

The overall impression I have of this album is that it is a collection of interesting and fun ideas that the two Alains and their band mates were using for practice/workout sessions, most of which never really got fully developed or "polished." There are plenty of nice melodies and pleasant funk-lite grooves throughout, just nothing as amazing as the first album.

A-/five stars; though I really would not consider this a true masterpiece of top tier Jazz-Rock Fusion, the album is filled with brilliant, sometimes innovative ideas, excellent performances by all musicians involved and some great earworm- like ditties and hooks--and, of course, a core of silky-smooth funk! I sure miss the dreamy voice of Mireille Dalbray!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Perfect Strangers by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1984
3.55 | 696 ratings

BUY
Perfect Strangers
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by Hector Enrique
Prog Reviewer

4 stars As fate would have it, the members of Deep Purple's famous Mark II, immersed and scattered in different projects (Ritchie Blackmore and Roger Glover with Rainbow, Jon Lord with Whitesnake, Ian Gillan with his solo project and the failed attempt of 'Born Again' with Black Sabbath, and Ian Paice with Gary Moore's band), agreed that it was time to iron out their differences and give a second life to the band's most emblematic line-up. And what seemed impossible happened eleven years after 1973's "Who Do We Think We Are", the last joint work, with the release of "Perfect Strangers" (1984), the Englishmen's eleventh album.

A proposal that, although it no longer has the power and carefree nature of musicians with more than a decade of experience behind them, follows a balanced and well-balanced line, in which two of the singles that supported its release stand out: the intriguing and lascivious "Knocking At Your Back Door" with the tense introductory atmosphere that Lord creates with his Hammonds, and the thick and mysterious half-time of the orientalised "Perfect Strangers" and its nods to Zeppelin's 'Kashmir'; and the melancholic power ballad "Wasted Sunsets" with Blackmore's hurtful guitar solo and Gillan's best vocal performance on the album.

The rest of the songs, oriented towards an agile hard rock adapted to the demands of the convulsive and changing decade of the eighties, maintain a very good level, in which the sound base built from Glover's bass and Paice's spirited drums full of cymbals sustain the riffs and guitar solos that Blackmore intersperses with Lord's arresting keyboard playing on the lively "Under the Gun", "Nobody's Home", "Mean Streak" and "A Gypsy's Kiss".

Finally, "Hungry Daze", with its dancing riffs of Arabic airs and an experimental sci-fi interlude, provides the differentiating touch to an album as unexpected as it was celebrated, which reached fifth place in the UK and seventeenth in the US charts and revived Deep Purple's career.

P.S. The remastered 1999 version includes "Not Responsible" and Blackmore's very interesting and extended experimental jam "Son of Alerik" (B-side of the single 'Perfect Strangers'), which is well worth a listen.

3.5/4 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Breathless by CAMEL album cover Studio Album, 1978
3.18 | 1004 ratings

BUY
Breathless
Camel Symphonic Prog

Review by jayjayl48

3 stars Breathless us the sixth studio album released by Camel. This album was released in 1978 and is considered by a lot of people to be less progressive than some of their previous albums (Moonmadness, Mirage, etc.) but it still is a solid album in my opinion. Andrew Latimer is a fantastic guitarist and composer, and you can hear his brilliance all over the album.

I also really enjoyed all the songs that Richard Sinclair sang on and his bass work on some of the tracks especially "Echoes" and "The Sleeper" are beautiful. "Breathless" the title track is great. I really like the mellowness of the whole album. "Echoes" by far is my favorite song on the album and a great prog song. "Wing and a Prayer" is a solid pop sounding song. "Down on the Farm" is a fun whimsical track as well and I also really enjoyed the last song on the album "Rainbows End". The lyrics invoke a sense of sadness but like a happy sadness. The synthesizer on this track is what I love the most. It's warm and I love the overall tone and vibe of this song. It makes you feel like you are floating on a cloud and with no worries or stress.

Overall, I enjoyed the album. If you want a nice mix of some mellow songs with some complex prog elements you will enjoy the album. Even the more pop sounding songs are fun to listen to. Camel is a great band, and I think everything they do is great. They are passionate musicians who know how to write great songs no matter the style or complexity. I would give this album 3/5 stars. If you are a fan of Camel, I think you should listen to and own this album. If you are just getting into Camel or not really a fan, I would say this album is not essential to listen to or to own.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 310 poljubaca by INDEXI album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 1979
3.00 | 2 ratings

BUY
310 poljubaca
Indexi Crossover Prog

Review by Seyo
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars After participating in the Sarajevo festival "Vas slager sezone 79", Indexi soon had another festival appearance. At the beginning of May 1979, they went to Belgrade where they played at "Beogradsko prolece 79", which was only their third appearance at this festival. For this occasion, they collaborated again with Aleksandar Korac, performing his composition "310 poljubaca" (310 Kisses). Soon after, they released a new single record for Jugoton (the master disc was cut on May 9th), which, in addition to the festival hit, would also feature the lesser-known track "Bilo je lijepo" (It Was Beautiful). This was Indexi's twenty-third 7" record in total, or the tenth issued on Jugoton label. The single's cover shows the band in the lineup: Djordje Kisic, Nenad Jurin, Slobodan A. Kovacevic, Davorin Popovic, and Fadil Redzic, and the photograph is actually just a version of the same picture taken by Dragan S. Stefanovic (uncredited on the single's cover) that appeared on the inner sleeve of the album "Modra rijeka" (Blue River) a year earlier.

Indexi's previous collaboration with Korac had not always yielded the best results. Besides several commercially successful tracks (e.g., "Predaj se srce" - Surrender Your Heart), Korac was also the author of some of, in my humble opinion, the weakest compositions in Indexi's oeuvre (e.g., "Stani malo zlato moje" - Wait a Little, My Dear). However, it seems that this time things fell into place, and we got an excellent composition, which was also a big hit. Behind the not very promising title "310 poljubaca" lies a track with a very interesting and complex arrangement and instrumental details. The opening sequence with an atmospheric synthesizer, acoustic guitar, and a powerful bass solo (which is why Redzic was often called a four-string soloist) brings something of the atmosphere of progressive rock bands Yes or Camel. The verses introduce a somewhat lighter melodic pop expression with Popovic's standard quality vocals and Kovacevic's exceptional flamenco-style acoustic guitar playing. The chorus is in a somewhat more expressive danceable quasi-disco rhythm, with funky electric guitar riffs and discreet electronic drum effects. A couple more solo passages on the acoustic and bass guitars bring the track back to the main theme from the verses. This excellent composition, which we could conditionally label as "progressive schlager", was recorded, according to data from the RTV Sarajevo phonotheque, on May 6, 1979.

The flipside of the single features the song "Bilo je lijepo", whose complete author is Redzic. There is no data from the master tape in the Sarajevo phonotheque, so it can be assumed that it was probably recorded in a Jugoton studio in Zagreb. This track is also instrumentally rich and unfolds at a somewhat slower soft rock tempo. The performance alternates between acoustic and electric guitar (the latter occasionally treated with somewhat psychedelic flageolets and pedal effects), synthesizer, piano, and organ, while the tambourine stands out among the percussion. It is a very interesting and pleasant song, which for some reason did not catch on and remained lesser known.

All in all, this is one of Indexi's best singles from the second half of the seventies. The hit "310 poljubaca" reached the top 10 chart of domestic singles of "Politikin zabavnik" youth magazine for June 1979, and was also frequently played on Radio Sarajevo programs.

PA rating: 3/5, Personal rating: 4/5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Dopo Il Buio La Luce by SALIS album cover Studio Album, 1979
4.05 | 44 ratings

BUY
Dopo Il Buio La Luce
Salis Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by Stoneburner

5 stars One of the forgotten gems of the vast Italian progressive scene of the 1970s.

The Salis brothers, Antonio and Francesco, from Santa Giusta, Oristano (Sardinia), began their musical career in the early 1960s under the name Barrittas. They released several singles throughout that decade. With the help of their older cousin, Lucio, who produced them, they changed their name to Salis'n'Salis in 1969. By the time their first album was released, they were simply Salis.

Their debut, Sa vida ita est (1971), is a charming blend of 1960s-inspired pop and psychedelia, with subtle hints of progressive rock. It's a good album, but sadly it went unnoticed and didn't receive the attention it deserved.

By this time, the band had moved to northern Italy, near Cremona, in Lombardy. Their lineup also changed, with the addition of two musicians from Brescia: Pier Paderni and Paolo Gerardini. Both had played in JB Club, a group that once included Mauro Pagani. They replaced Mariano Tunerini and Nino Scalas, who had decided to return to Sardinia. This version of the band lasted until 1972. Briefly, in 1973, back in Sardinia, the lineup included bassist Pino Martini and drummer Salvatore Garau, who would later become the rhythm section of Stormy Six.

In 1974, a second album was released. This was more of a solo album by Antonio Salis than a complete band effort.

One of the first quadraphonic albums released in Italy, it was released on EMI's CiPiTi label and was later reissued by La Strega, a small label run by Lucio, who also wrote the lyrics for all of their songs. Musically, the album leans more toward pop/progressive than their debut and shares some similarities with another Sardinian band, Gruppo 2001. Antonio was accompanied by his brother Francesco, guitarist Gianni Serra, keyboardist Dario Baldan Bembo, and drummers Andy Suray and Furio Bozzetti.

Five years later, a new version of Salis returned with a revamped lineup and released Dopo il buio la luce, their third album. This is a completely different record: more focused, more progressive, and mostly instrumental. It's a keyboard-driven record that shows a completely different side of the band's potential.

The album is cleaner than the band's previous albums. The instruments flow and blend into a solid sound, guided by beautiful guitar and keyboard arpeggios. Dopo il buio la luce reminds me a bit of Arti e Mestieri and their 1974 album, Tilt, but with a more melancholic tone.

Dopo il buio la luce is another hidden gem of the great Italian progressive scene. Can you imagine? I've been listening to Italian progressive for almost 40 years and I'd never heard of this band. There are so many, and most of them are incredible. Nowadays, getting a physical copy of the album is almost impossible, but luckily there are digital versions so you can enjoy this wonderful record.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 If I Could Do It All Over Again, I'd Do It All Over You by CARAVAN album cover Studio Album, 1970
4.25 | 1237 ratings

BUY
If I Could Do It All Over Again, I'd Do It All Over You
Caravan Canterbury Scene

Review by Lobster77

4 stars I wonder why I like this class album so much. Maybe it's because all the tracks sound like 1 track as a whole, like a concept album. Or because it's simply a lovely progressive effort: very cleverly structured, elegant "Canterbury", performed in a loose, groovy manner. Delicate vocals, perfectly timed guitar, swirling organ throughout and exactly there we have THE Caravan characteristic: the organ weaves it into a woolen hip(pie) sweater, worn on a moisturized early morning walk through an ancient British forest in midsummer...then, all of a sudden, you stumble upon 4 lads, not quite sure whether it's the '60 or the '70 they're living in. You are grasped by music reaching your ears and rolling along with David, Pye, Richard & Richard within the timeless Caravan capsule. They would then roll all the way to the Land of Grey and Pink.

4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Days of Future Passed by MOODY BLUES, THE album cover Studio Album, 1967
4.21 | 1011 ratings

BUY
Days of Future Passed
The Moody Blues Crossover Prog

Review by Lobster77

5 stars This album is often labeled as the first true 'Progressive Rock' album (though it's also debated that Vanilla Fudge's debut album was actually the first). It's hard to say whether this album is a true prog album or not. This album clearly was influential on what would later become prog (King Crimson, in particular, would take the orchestral aspects of this album and carry it to new heights by combining it with jazz on In the Court of the Crimson King), and the fact that there was nothing else like it in rock music at the time should go a long way in defending it's progginess. Regardless of whether it's truly prog or not, this is a pretty cool album. It's not as good overall as what prog bands would eventually start doing, but there are moments on this album that are downright beautiful. All of the influences in one place like Procol Harum and this band establish what we know as prog. This is an absolute essential for any collection .

5.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Knight's Flight by MARTIN VENGADESAN & THE STALEMATE FACTOR album cover Studio Album, 2020
3.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
The Knight's Flight
Martin Vengadesan & The Stalemate Factor Crossover Prog

Review by DetectiveDoom

— First review of this album —
3 stars The third Stalemate Factor album is The Knight's Flight and it is unabashed psychedelic rock, from a most unexpected source - a Malaysian band full of journalists.

The album is very influenced by the trippy music of the late 1960. Obviously there the The Beatles's Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band and less obviously Pink Floyd's Atom Heart Mother and Traffic's self-title albums are influences.

While the previous album was hard rock and the next album is more directly progressive, this one stands out for the way it pays homage to the sixties!

Lyrically there is a fair amount of exploration of hedonism, enlightenment, daily realities and the good and bad of hallucinogenic drugs. The core band is Martin Vengadesan on vocals/keyboards, NR Lohan on electric guitar/vocals, Edward Gomez on bass/vocals and Andrew Sagayam on drums, the latter being replaced by producer Ashwin Gobinath on half the tracks.

Highlights are many and they include the opener The Doors Of Perception (Lost Weekend) which depicts the chaotic beginning of a psychedelic trip with a lot of surreal detours.

There are massed vocal harmonies and a blistering organ solo to round things off.

There's also the electric piano/Moog combo of Groggy Doggy and a bunch of other Beatles-influenced tracks like Shanny On A Sunday Morning, A Cafe in TTDI Park and Fragrant Hills, which adds Chinese and Indian influences to what is clearly a hallucinogenic adventure!

There is Crystal Meth & The One-Eyed Man with an incendiary guitar solo from Lohan over the massed chorus and Firewater Blues which touches on the impact of alcohol on Native American populations.

Your Runaway Mind (Syd Barrett, Peter Green & Me) is the longest track on the album and my personal favourite. It has a number of sub-sections and is a tribute to the men who were at the heart of the early success of Pink Floyd and Fleetwood Mac respectively but had very high-profile drug-related breakdowns and left their groups ? and the world - behind. This song has classic keyboard moments like a rollicking Moog solo and mellotron overload towards the end. And that's alongside harpsichord, piano and organ, as well as a lyrical guitar solo and great melodic bass work.

Another song A Thousand Moons has some stellar performances from backing vocalist Joanne Timbuong, Carnatic flute from Sridhar and violin by Karolina Sustova.

Scream In Pleasure is a grinding psychedelic blues stomper, with a mid section organ solo that is graced by a percussion orchestra from Balamurugan, while Opium Den is another rollicking trippy psych tune. Finally Grass Cutter Jam is an excursion into a little psychedelic jazz, and To The Carmine Sea is a beautiful folk song that turns into a twin lead guitar extravaganza that would make Wishbone Ash proud.

Not the most progressive album by The Stalemate Factor, but quite possibly it's best.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Inner Conflicts by COBHAM, BILLY album cover Studio Album, 1978
4.06 | 30 ratings

BUY
Inner Conflicts
Billy Cobham Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars This time incorporating the talents of some old favorites along with the continued promotion of some of his new collaborators (including the Escovedo family), Billy continues to remain staunchly loyal to the principles of sophistication and quality of "peak era" Jazz-Rock Fusion even if this is his most Latin-heavy production to date.

A1. "Inner Conflicts" (10:49) Instead of one of Billy's stark drum solos that he occasionally enjoys placing on his albums, we have here an experiment with drums, programmed drums, and synthesizers all woven together. I do not have a problem with this--especially in light of the album's title. I do, however, find myself a little annoyed at the effects placed upon the drum sounds (like I did on the last song of the Billy's previous album. I find the flange effect particularly cool when the drummer is keeping time or when the song is fading in or out, but when the drummer is this active and nuanced it feels diminishing.) The manual synthesizer work is not very melodic nor is it sophisticated-- not unlike Larry Fast's work on his Synergy albums or Patrick Moraz's The Story of I album. (17.625/20) A2. "The Muffin Talks Back" (9:52) opening with quite an interesting (and somewhat distracting) combination of synths, rhythm guitar, and percussive creating a kind of funky Star Wars "Cantina" sound world, the music soon launches into a before smoothing out a bit in the second minute into a kind of Latin-Disco true Jazz-Rock Fusion song. The electric guitar solos (and rhythm play) seal the deal--bringing a two guitar "Prince of the Sea" feel to it like Lenny White's final song from Venusian Summer. (This marks the nth number of times my brain has noted similarities to Lenny's 1975-76 production in Billy's albums from the period soon after.) The performances from everyone involved are quite dynamic, especially the three percussionists and keyboard maestro Don Grolnick. The vocal interjections are a bit odd, as are Al[ph]onso Johnson's bass chords in the seventh and eighth minutes as well. The final two minutes feature an awesome electric guitar solo riding on top (or within the percussion weave) that I'm guessing is Steve Kahn's guitar. If you're a lover of wildly-full percussion work, this would be a great song for you to enjoy! (18.5/20)

B1. "Nickels And Dimes" (7:21) a very interesting and engaging song with multiple motifs each with its own tempo and melodies--the second one really putting Ruth Underwood (Zappa)'s xylophone and the amazing horn section to the paces. A highly complex funk weave. Wonderful stuff! The music smooths out a bit in the fourth minute with a nearly- straight-tempo pattern over which George Duke is given copious time and room to perform a nice Fender Rhodes solo. Then we turn to more percussion based section with bass, winds, and "distant" horns backing John Scofield's extended guitar solo. At 6:10 we return to the "Can't Get Next to You" Discofied motif for some excellent work from the horn section and some prime Billy Cobham drumming. (14.25/15)

B2. "El Barrio" (6:30) another Latin percussion-dominated intro weave that finally gives way at 3:00 to a very pleasant Cubano-feeling motif in which whistles, timbales, bells, and bass are woven into a cheery, upbeat sound reminiscent of stereotypic Latin carnival. The welcome sound of Julian Priester's trombone is given the song's first solo, followed by a somewhat quieter guitar (mixed within the weave of the horn section) from Steve Kahn. Julian gets some shine again as the song ends. I would very much have preferred if this song had been extended! Too bad! (9.25/10)

B3. "Arroyo" (4:15) a slower almost SANTANA-like song with more great interplay between the percussionists (including Billy) while Alphonso maintain's a steady melodic groove over the top within which George Duke's keys and John Scofield's acoustic guitar take turns offering smooth, steady solos (almost in deference to the awesome groove being maintained by the rhythmatists). Nice finish if a slight comedown from the highs of the other four songs. (9/10)

Total Time: 38:51

Once again I feel ever-so grateful that Billy Cobham remains firm and true in his commitment to the high principles of "peak era" Jazz-Rock Fusion: refusing to slide into the easy job of creating Easy Listening Smooth Jazz (which we know he is capable of). The man was and still remains a staunch promoter of high-class Jazz-Rock Fusion.

A-/five stars; another minor masterpiece of "peak era" Third Wave Jazz-Rock Fusion from one of the "true believers" of the movement.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Sky 4: Forthcoming by SKY album cover Studio Album, 1982
2.64 | 51 ratings

BUY
Sky 4: Forthcoming
Sky Eclectic Prog

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

3 stars Whereas Sky 3 saw the group shift in a jazzier direction, Sky 4 found the band turning around and going straight back to their comfort zone of classical arrangements. In this case, this sees them overshoot the "smooth prog" approach of their debut album and land squarely in easy listening territory; it's good easy listening, mind you, the sort of gentle, laid-back music where I'm glad I have some of it in my collection for when the correct mood strikes, but it's not exactly the sort of material anyone who came to the band on the basis of the members' prog credentials in past projects would be at all likely to prioritise. The lack of Francis Monkman is especially acutely felt.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Magic by COBHAM, BILLY album cover Studio Album, 1977
3.94 | 40 ratings

BUY
Magic
Billy Cobham Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Another new lineup of collaborators does not mean Billy Cobham will sacrifice any of his integrity: he remains firmly committed to the high-fallutin' principles of high-quality, sophisticated Jazz-Rock Fusion.

1. "On A Magic Carpet Ride" (5:08) despite the impressive RETURN TO FOREVER opening 20 seconds, this songdemonstrates that Billy has now climbed on board the popular Disco train. At the same time, this song shows off his new international ensemble and the fact that they can pull together an impressive yet accessible (and melodic) display of group cohesion and virtuosity. New bassist Randy Jackson is much more oriented to accents, melodies, and syncopation than his predecessor (Gattling Gun Doug Rauch) and much more comfortable within the newer Disco parameters. 23-year old guitarist Peter Maunu had only been present on a few recordings at this point in his storied career and Billy, always a quick study of fresh young talent, knew what a find he had here: letting him take the lead for a good chunk of the song. Really impressive piano play from Joachim Kühn (and/or Mark Soskin). Too bad they felt that they had to fade out after five minutes--right in the middle of some fine soloing by Peter Maunu. (9.333/10)

2. "AC/DC" (5:27) spacious Latinized funk with the Escovedo family well-engaged (sister Sheila ["E"] having only burst onto the music scene in the previous year), it's bassist Randy Jackson who, as on the previous song, seems to dictate the pace, space, and melodies! After 90 seconds of spacious syncopation, the electric keys enter and smooth things out--over which Peter Maunu lets loose with a pretty awesome NEAL SCHON-like guitar solo while Randy funks things up below with some slap and pluck bass playing. Then Joachim Kühn takes a turn on the MiniMoog play provding us with an awesome and even rather amazing solo. Then things kind of let us down gently to the full stop finish. (9.25/10)

3. "Leaward Winds" (3:39) a melodic and Easy Listening tune on a par with those of Bob JAMES in that the musicianship is still top notch and subtly sophisticated. A little Steely Dan feel in the keyboards and chord progressions while Peter provides another super-engaging guitar solo up top. Mark Soskin is next with his piano solo while also sassing things up beneath with some Oberheim synth stuff. (9.25/10)

4. "Puffnstuff" (6:23) more peppy, bouncy, almost "light" Easy Listening Burt Bacharach-like Jazz-Rock Fusion; the Day of the Melody is here: all that showy-offy speed racing may be in the past. The performances in the weave above the rhythm track are still amply sophisticated but they are also fun and enjoyably melodic. I love the piano chord play and clarinet solo in the first two minutes. Then, in the third minute, there is a sudden and drastic shift in both mood, energy, and tempo as the band launches into a Discofied power J-R Fusion passage that presents/contains a Public service call to quit/desist from the use of marijuana! Funny! Then the band equally comically switches back to the opening "lite" and carefree melody and mood. Brilliant--both parts! Definitely a top three song--probably my favorite just for its quirky oddness and light-heartedness. (9.75/10)

5. "'Antares' - The Star" (5:11) another great tune with lots of carnival-esque Latin flavor (grâce ā the Escovedo family, again) with some equally great drum play from Billy, instinctual bass play from Randy Jackson, guitar and clarinet play. (I am unexpectedly loving the presence of the clarinet on these songs!) (9.125/10)

6. "Magic/Reflection In The Clouds/Magic Recapitulation" (13:33) opens like a response to the previous year's RETURN TO FOREVER release, Romantic Warrior, but then turn a bit more toward a George Duke-like sound. I'm not liking the flanged, compressed-muted effect imposed upon Billy's drums but ti's fine on Randy Jackson's fretless bass. The presence of the Oberheim synth is also a bit odd--bridging Billy's work more into the world of progressive rock than ever before. Add the male and female jazz/Broadway vocals in the middle of the song (performed by Pete Escovedo and Kathleen Kaan) also give this more of a Chick Corea aspect. This is followed by a gorgeous piano solo from Joachim Kühn and then some nice electric guitar from Peter Maunu that is paired nicely with the Gayle Moran-like voice of Kathleen Kaan. The aggressive/abrasive final minute is just weird--and meant to reinforce the fact that this is Billy's music, Billy's band, Billy's album. A pretty cool, pretty eclectic suite that is, unfortunately, engineered rather strangely. (26.75/30)

Total Time 39:21

Hello and welcome, Randy Jackson! Peter Maunu! Welcome to American audiences, Joachim Kühn!

A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of high quality Third Wave Jazz-Rock Fusion. I really am impressed by Billy's unwillingness to concede to the contemporary pressures to "sell out" and simplify for the masses: he stands staunchly-committed to the skillful and sophisticated (jazzy) side of Jazz-Rock Fusion. This is close to being my favorite Billy Cobham album from the 1970s.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Kalahen by DRAGON album cover Studio Album, 1977
3.49 | 36 ratings

BUY
Kalahen
Dragon Heavy Prog

Review by Lobster77

3 stars Impressive and gloomy proggy Psychedelia, like the band heading to the past instead of walking into the future, which was propably a good reason to never release their album and force them to disband. The material ranged from Kraut-spiced Folk Rock with flute, acoustic guitar, something like a Farfisa organ and raw vocals, accompanied by a mysterious mood, to keyboard-laden Psych/Prog grooves with some shaped Klause shulze like electric moves and occasional sax, sometimes recalling of Van der Graaf Generator.The eponymous suite is quite fascinating Heavy Rock with tons of Mellotron, organ and split Classical/Jazz influences it almost reminds me of Jon Lords Hammond organ from his work with Deep Purple.Close to a classic, seems this was released for the first time in 1986 in a limited run of vinyls. I also love the medieval theme on the cover as well.

3.5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Life & Times by COBHAM, BILLY album cover Studio Album, 1976
3.95 | 47 ratings

BUY
Life & Times
Billy Cobham Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Bulgarian keyboard virtuoso/composer Milcho Leviev is gone but Billy's demands of his support crew remain incredibly high, his compositions still quite sophisticated. I was really looking forward to hearing this album after seeing Doug Rauch and Allan Zavod on the call sheet--and for the sake of wanting to give John Scofield and George Duke yet more chances to win me over. (Their skills are always impressive but their styles and melodic sensibilities don't seem to align with my own.)

1. "Life & Times" (6:58) Nice racing song that puts on full display all of the principles, with very impressive solos from Scofield, Duke, and, dream of dreams, Doug Rauch. (Weird that I never really heard an "organ"!) Billy is, of course, ridiculously impressive. (13.75/15)

2. "29" (2:28) another song in which the musicians are asked to sprint from point A to B, the musicianship is quite impressive, and there are some nice melodies worked into the mayhem as well as some impressive solos, but it's just not, overall, a song that one can easily "get into." (8.875/10)

3a. "Siesta" (3:36) as if hearing my "complaint" from the first two songs, Billy has the band slow things down and finally use space as an additional band member. Also, as if taking a cue from former compatriot John McLaughlin and recent Return To Forever albums, the musicians are asked to perform on acoustic instruments--including some strings players to replace the bass. (9/10)

- b. "Wake Up!!!!!! That's What You Said" (0:04) just what the title says. All four seconds of it.

4. "East Bay" (6:08) this one sounds like a piece that could've been generated from the former conglomerate band of New York City-based future Hall of Famers that called themselves DREAMS for the three or four year duration of their association (back in 1968 into 1971). The funk is present but slowed down to a swaggering pace while John Scofield is given the bulk of the lead instrumental play as the rest of the band just strut around the rhythm tracks. Kind of cool! (9/10)

5. "Earthlings" (5:04) the only non-Cobham composition (attributed to John Scofield). John plays lead over active keyboard play from George's Fender Rhodes, Dougie's gattling gun bass note production, and Billy's impeccable swingtime. George gets some extended solo time in the fourth and fifth minutes to display his keyboard ideas and then mirrors/harmonizes with John's guitar play for a nice final section--my favorite part of the song. (9/10)

6. "Song For A Friend (Part I)" (5:03) a rather unique opening with slowed-down Cowboy-Western theme over which an odd synth slowly soars and falls as if a rocket being launched into the sky and then descending to the Earth--all the while the Fender Rhodes and gently picked guitar and bass and Billy's rim shots and hi-hat work keep Rancher's time. A highly unusual song: for Billy, for Jazz-Rock Fusion, for recorded music. I really like this! Again, it's nice to have songs in which space and airiness are explored to balance out the frenetic music of those other barn-burners. (9.25/10)

7. "On A Natural High" (5:17) a funky drive through town in the convertible (with the top down, of course) cruisin' all the hot spots (probably running into the Fonze, Spike Lee, and the Fresh Prince at various points along the way). Doug Rauch's very active bass play, I think, makes a nice complement to Billy's steady-yet-nuanced drum play--and George Duke seems to bridge the territory between John Scofield's squawking guitar play and the rhythmatists quite well. For me, this might be the song that works the best: melding rather perfectly on all levels. (9.25/10)

8. "Song For A Friend (Part II)" (4:43) a repeat/revisitation to the previous "Song for a Friend"'s Western cowboy motif with a different approach from John Scofield--using miked-up acoustic guitar instead of gentle electric--and from George Duke with richer, more sustained chord play from his Fender Rhodes. Nice melodies from John with excellent supportive chord play from George (while pushing that weird Prophet 5 synth portamento space note play a little more into the background). Another favorite. (9.25/10)

Total Time 39:21

I can see how the excessive number of notes demanded of the musicians on these highly-complex songs might fatigue and/or put off some listeners but at least there are more melodies to connect with. At the same time, Billy has considerately tried to balance out the fare offered on this album with several less-than-breakneck-speed songs for the listener to settle into. And, if you're at all interested in hearing basss sensation Doug Rauch in all his glory, this might be the absolute best album in which to do so--especially as his drug addiction issues would, sadly, render him pretty much unreliable and unemployable in the next year or two. (He would be dead in three years--at the unfortunate age of 28.)

A-/five stars; a most excellent full-spectrum presentation of Jazz-Rock Fusion at its finest if not most melodic. Highly recommended to anyone who has not heard it.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Big Red Dragon (William Blake's Visions) by BACCINI, SOPHYA album cover Studio Album, 2013
3.91 | 33 ratings

BUY
Big Red Dragon (William Blake's Visions)
Sophya Baccini Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by Migrainosaurus

4 stars This is a really interesting record, and it's fair to say I didn't expect it to be one. I'm not a fan of 'symphonic' at all ? like, AT ALL ? because of how it tends to swamp any music it touches in on-the-nail-obvious classical motifs and syrupy strings, so I approached this with a fair degree of cynicism.

To my surprise, it's far, far more a hybrid of experimental x chamber-music x prog rock x avant-garde opera than all the Nightwishy stuff out there ? and all the better for it. At its best, there are bits of what you might get if Diamanda Galas collaborated with Marillion and 'Worlds Apart'-era ...And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead on a soundtrack to 18th century London's dark side. Yeah, that interesting!

I'm a massive fan of William Blake's poetry, art and other writings too, so I'm always a bit doubtful when someone announces a conceptual rock work based on him - but this is mostly dark, incantatory and GREAT.

There are still some occasional stray elements of twinkly-eurosymphonic in there... but honesty, if you were expecting twee, you came to the wrong place.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Long Season by FISHMANS album cover Studio Album, 1996
4.21 | 12 ratings

BUY
Long Season
Fishmans Crossover Prog

Review by Captain Midnight

4 stars The Fishmans are a neat band and it's about time they were added to the archives, I'm not super familiar with this band other then a few songs here and there but everything I've heard from them is good, I decided to check out this album after I saw someone say something along the lines of this being the 90s equivalent to Pink Floyd's Echoes, now whether or not that's true it intrigued me. The album is a 36 minute song spanning multiple sections like a classic prog album but with modern influences. The song is very psychedelic but lush, it sort of has a Post Minimalism thing going on here, sort of reminds me of Steve Reich's Music for 18 Musicians especially with the keys and little sounds that add detail to the song like sounds of water dripping and chimes. The song has a noisy (almost LoFi) section, it's sprinkled with sounds of chimes and lazer? Sounds, it's amazing really. Around the 26 minute mark the song goes full Steve Reich and I love it, it's probably my favorite section of the song. The song has a little reprise and a grand finale that finishes it off overall an amazing song/album that definitely should be recognized by prog fans more often

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ghost by GHOST album cover Studio Album, 1990
3.76 | 14 ratings

BUY
Ghost
Ghost Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars GHOST are a six piece band out of Japan playing a psychedelic/folk brand of music. That krautrock spirit is here as well with those drugged out vocals on the second half of the album. The music is not in a hurry. Plenty of flute and percussion with vocals in english. They had a pretty good run releasing eight studio albums from 1990 to 2007. I am fortunate to own four of those. My first was way back in 2007 with "Lama Rabi Rabi" but it would be nine years before I would visit them again with their "Hypnotic Underworld" record. Both strong albums, so the search was on for more resulting in the acquisitions of this the debut and the followup "Second Time Around".

While there is electric guitar, sax, piano and electronics I feel they are buried or sparse. This album really is dominated by percussion, flute, acoustic guitar and vocals. The standout track for me is "Ballad Of Summer Rounder" an almost 11 minute trip my friends. I should mention as well that there are some inventive moments on this record. This isn't all trippy all the time. The vocal arrangements on "Moungod Te Deum" are interesting. Almost an "aummm" style to them but different.

And how about the opening of this record on "Sun Is Tangging" where we hear this soft distant flute. Do not be fooled into either turning up the volume, or putting your ear next to the speaker. They want you to do that! There is an explosion of sound that goes on for a while and it's the loudest section on the record. Like a blast of yells, beats and more blended together and then turned up a notch hoping to scare the naive listener. Yeah it worked! Thanks a lot.

This is a special record that even triggers emotion like early on my favourite track "Ballad Of Summer Rounder". I'm looking forward to spending time with the followup next week. As for this one, it's easily a four star record in my world, and it was great to hear their beginnings, where it all started.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Something in the Air [空中キャンプ] by FISHMANS album cover Studio Album, 1996
3.14 | 3 ratings

BUY
Something in the Air [空中キャンプ]
Fishmans Crossover Prog

Review by Logan
Forum & Site Admin Group Site Admin

3 stars Just a pretty short commentary lacking as much detail and not nearly as lengthy as my other FIshmans reviews: it's not nearly as essential as the live 98.12.28 Otokotachi no wakare (my favourite live album) to me, or the final studio album, Uchu Nippon Setagaya, nor is it as seminal as Long Season, but it is a lighter, chill and breezy album. It is not as complex as later albums, it is more pop. The dub aspect is strong, but so is the the dream pop and I like the psychedelic qualities. It has shoegaze qualities. It doesn't have the lusher arrangement or dynamic qualities of later albums, especially the live release I mentioned, but I find it to be a lovely and delightful album. I do prefer live versions of music. This still has moments that stand out and make me stand up and take notice like with the other albums I mentioned, and I really like the opening number, "Sunny Blue" I love, "Slow Days' is quite wonderful, "ナイトクルージング" is a great track to my ears, very dreamy, I really like "Nice Choice". Sad that I have to consider rating it. While it's something like a four for me, I'm giving it a three for PA. I would at least give it 3.5 if we had half stars. it's not a very "progressive album", it doesn't have the longer tracks, it is simpler, it is lighter on the whole and less dynamic as I said. I really like it, but unlike some other albums, it has not screamed at my OCD brain to play it again and again and again, but sometimes I don't want that. It's a very nice album. Note: this is still essential to me, and would be for many others depending on interests. I love Fishmans.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 A Funky Thide Of Sings by COBHAM, BILLY album cover Studio Album, 1975
3.90 | 55 ratings

BUY
A Funky Thide Of Sings
Billy Cobham Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars The first of a series of albums that Billy Cobham uses (with the inspiration of Bulgarian classically-oriented pianist/composer Milcho Leviev) to expose his commitment to seriously sophisticated musical composition.

1. "Panhandler" (3:50) a funk song that demands a lot of its players--especially the horn section, but these professionals are at the absolute highest echelon in music's talent pool. The song is okay but more fascinating to listen to the horn section. (9/10)

2. "Sorcery" (2:26) another great groove, this one a little less funky, on which Billy once again places rigorous demands on his horn players. I think I'm catching on to Billy's focus on this album: to show off his skills as an arranger. (9.125/10)

3. "A Funky Thide Of Sings" (3:40) a steady bass line with rich percussion contributions that sounds a lot like a blend of the DAVE SANBORN and KOOL AND THE GANG approaches to funk is complemented by a slightly less star-studded horn section. Sax player Larry Schneider is asked to lead throughout a lot of it. (8.75/10)

4. "Thinking Of You" (4:12) exploring the smoother, Disco-er side of jazz-rock fusion with a rotating crew of individuals stepping up to lead, including, synth player Milcho Leviev, trombonist Glenn Ferris, sax player Michael Brecker, trumpeter Randy Brecker, and guitarist John Scofield all getting a little time up front. (8.75/10)

5. "Some Skunk Funk" (5:07) a great song (attributed to trumpeter Randy Brecker), demanding tremendous skill to pull off, that once again lacks that special ingredient that makes one want to hum along: you want to dance, you want to study and marvel at the individual musicians, but there's nothing you'll be haunted by in the hours or days afterward. (9/10)

6. "Light At The End Of The Tunnel" (3:37) stealing the melodic rhythm track from Motown Temptation's "Can't Get Next to You" and then trying to make it different with interesting horn and lead guitar play over the top is like stealing a car and then spray painting it a different color. The solo voce drum play at the very end is the highlight for me. (8.875/10)

7. "A Funky Kind Of Thing" (9:24) solo drum play over the entire ten minutes! It always amazes me how Billy Cobham can create mood and funk with only himself and a drum set (and an engineering console). I can not think of many drummers who have this talent. (17.5/20)

8. "Moody Modes" (12:16) cymbals, electric piano, electric bass, and synths open up to create a nice dreamy "late night" motif--which is joined (bubbly slightly burst) at the 90-second mark by the horns. Piano takes over in the middle of the third minute. The pianist. Milcho Leviev is, you might recall, an incredibly talented pianist, composer, and band leader with quite a pedigree and c.v. back in Bulgaria before Don Ellis lured him across the pond to co-lead his orchestra from 1970-75. Though Ellis was quite the promoter, molder, and mentor to young and foreign talent, Don's relationship with Milcho was prompted by his tremendous respect and admiration for the Bulgarian music traditions and compositional (and piano) prowess he exuded. Billy began associating with Milcho in 1971 with the artist appearing on Billy's albums Total Eclipse (1974), this one, and Shabazz, a live album which would appear later in the same year as this one. Overall this long song plays out more like a soundtrack or classically-tinged suite than anything resembling anything else on Side One of this album. A marvellous song, though still lacking in melodic hooks and definitely lacking in infectious grooves. This one is for the intellectual music lover. (23.5/25)

Total time 44:32

A collection of demanding, sophisticated songs that all take considerable skill to perform but which somehow lack that special something that makes for a catchy earworm--a song that you want to push "repeat" for. Again, it feels obvious to me that Billy's focus on this album was most surely the task of proving he could write and arrange uber- sophisticated songs and then get the right team of musicians that he could then motivate to top-notch performances.

A-/4.5 stars; even though this isn't a favorite album--does not contain enough whistle-and-dancd along songs for my tastes--it is an album I have to rate up for the astounding skill level of the musical collaborators.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Frippada Andaluza by MALABRIEGA album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.26 | 70 ratings

BUY
Frippada Andaluza
Malabriega Prog Folk

Review by TenYearsAfter

4 stars ANOTHER GEM FROM THE OFTEN OVERLOOKED CURRENT SPANISH PROG!

In 2016 new Spanish prog band Malabriega released their first EP entitled El Duda, in 2017 followed by the album Fiebre featuring 12 tracks (11 + 1 bonus track from their previous EP). The national press and radio picked up their captivating eclectic sound (elements from prog, flamenco, Rock Andaluz, rock, jazz and postrock) and Malabriega started to perform live, along Spanish bands and artists like Tabletom (Nuevo Flamenco), Randy Lķpez (bass player/singer from Rock Andaluz legend Mezquita), Storm (The 'Spanish Deep Purple') and Zaguán (tribute to early Triana sound). Anno 2025 Malabriega released their new album named Frippada Andaluza, after stumbling upon tons of positive reviews on the Internet about this new Spanish 5-piece formation from Seville I could hardly wait to listen to it!

Frippada Andaluza (La Mar Limpia) (10:05) : The epic titletrack features a dreamy start with twanging acoustic guitar, in a slow rhythm, the atmosphere is pretty hypnotizing. Then a sensitive electric guitar solo with howling runs, in a build up to a compelling climate, somewhere between Porcupine Tree and post rock. Back to dreamy with twanging acoustic guitar, inspired Spanish vocals and rock guitar riffs join, culminating into a powerful sound. Again back to dreamy with twanging acoustic guitars and subtle electric guitar runs, topped with strong Spanish vocals. After pleasant acoustic rhythm guitar play, blended with a wonderful sensitive electric guitar solo, the music turns into a more lush sound with powerful drum beats. Finally a dreamy climate featuring acoustic - and subtle electric guitar, and inspired Spanish vocals. What a tension between the mellow and more lush parts, a promising start.

Pelo (4:30): This is a short but very dynamic track, with the focus on strong and emotional Spanish vocals, topped with a moving electric guitar solo and a harder edged guitar solo, and backed by an inventive rhythm-section.

El Duelo (4:19) : First the distinctive flamenco guitar, blended with intense Spanish vocals. Gradually the sound turns into more lush with rock guitar riffs, and a Paco de Lucia inspired flamenco guitar solo. Halfway an exciting break with powerful rock guitar, emotional vocals, and a heavy guitar solo, with echoes from Rock Andaluz legend Medina Azahara.

ŋQué Será? (5:30) : More Rock Andaluz atmospheres, what a captivating musical encounter between rock and flamenco, from pure flamenco guitar to a rock explosion with exciting harder-edged guitar and a propulsive rhythm- section, topped with Spanish vocals featuring that typical wailing flamenco undertone, wow!

Reencuentro (1:36) This is a very short but tasteful instrumental that contains folky acoustic - and electric guitar, in a slow rhythm, the final part delivers shortly a rock guitar.

La Levedad Del Ser (4:10) : Lots of flowing shifting moods, embellished with rock guitar riffs, a sparkling flamenco guitar solo and a moving electric guitar solo, and powerful vocals. The melodic rock sound reminds me of 80s Rush.

La Libertad (4:19) : A cheerful atmosphere in a mid-tempo, with catchy flamenco rhythm guitar (the vocals and catchy flamenco guitar reminds me of the Gypsy Kings) and a sensitive electric guitar solo. Halfway the sound turns into a more lush sound with howling guitar and powerful vocals. Then a mellow part with rhythm flamenco guitar, and subtle electric guitar, evoking 60s Shadows. Finally again the sound turns into more lush sound with powerful vocals and a strong rhythm-section, what a dynamic composition.

Reflejo Vacío (7:05) : This is the most early Triana inspired composition, due to the inspired, a bit wailing Spanish vocals, and the captivating blend of rock and flamenco, topped with lots of interesting musical ideas. First a slow rhythm, with powerful emotional vocals, rock guitar, a spacey guitar solo with echo, culminating in a mid-tempo beat and an exciting heavy guitar solo, wow! Halfway back to dreamy with twanging guitar and sensitive electric guitar, then a strong build- up and climax with a howling guitar solo and a strong rhythm-section, and in the end a rock guitar explosion.

Calamidad (5:17) : And finally more Rock Andaluz inspiration, I love it. First a flamenco guitar intro, then spoken words, and fat rock guitar riffs, to me it sounds as an early Medina Azahara atmosphere, how compelling and exciting! Then back to mellow, with subtle acoustic guitar work, followed by a propulsive rhythm with rock guitar and flamenco guitar (often the known piece Malaguenas comes to my mind in this track), powerful Rock Andaluz vocals, and a blistering guitar solo and thunderous rhythm-section, wow, what an awesome conclusion of this album, goose bumps!

This is what interesting and genuine prog is about: tension, dynamics, variety, skills, adventure, musical ideas, and topped by Malabriega with exciting Rock Andaluz atmospheres and great Spanish vocals (the one moment reminding me of the rumba flamenco inspired Gypsy Kings, the other moment of Rock Andaluz legend Triana), highly recommended!

P.s.: Other interesting current Spanish prog and Rock Andaluz bands: Qamar and Sherish (two favorites of mine), Randy Lopez, Arabiga, Taifa, Anairt, the awesome Periplo project by Juan Antonio Vergara (the mastermind behind the Spanish prog label 5Lunas), The Flying Caravan, and the amazing Derby Motoreta's Burrito Kachimba!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Love by FLOWER KINGS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.69 | 64 ratings

BUY
Love
The Flower Kings Symphonic Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars We have a pretty good new album by The Flower Kings, their seventeenth studio release, to be precise, the aptly titled 'Love'; and with this rather plain and broadly-suggestive title, together with the gorgeous album art, this new TFK offering is definitely a mellower, harmonious and swiftly developing work, with the band turning their backs on their more explosive and instrumentally intense side, prioritizing songwriting, feel and melody above anything else, as it seems. The addition of Lalle Larsson as a full-time band member pays off rather brilliantly, as the experienced keyboard player brings a flavor of fusion to the mix and displays an overall classy performance with his vast array of keys and synths gracing the songs on the album. Michael Stolt, one of the founding members of the band continues to handle all bass duties, while relative newcomer Mirko DeMaio appears on his fifth TFK album, making him one of the longer-lasting drummers of the band. Hasse Fröberg provides some excellent vocals, while band leader Roine Stolt covers all other aspects of this work.

Musically, there is perhaps nothing incrementally different from the rest of the more recent Flower Kings albums, after the band's 2018 reincarnation, yet 'Love' seems to be a more consistent release with a decent flow and a good balance between shorter and longer entries. The album's pace is kept all within the lower registers here, with the music being really atmospheric and hypnotic at times, with some soulful guitar and keyboard solos. The vocal harmonies between Stolt and Fröberg are gorgeous and represent one of the key elements making up the swaying emotionality of 'Love'. And with a bit of blues, bit of influence from classical music, fusion and classic 70s prog, what the listener is in for here is a solid work by a band of veterans who are trying out to work on some more laid-back stuff.

Opening track 'We Claim the Moon' is among the highlights, it is a pacey and uplifting piece with that typical Flower Kings flamboyancy. 11-minute epic 'The Elder' is excellent, a moody and reflective piece, as is the third track 'How Can You Leave Us Now?'. 'Burning Both Edges' once again very melodic, some tremendous vocals are to be enjoyed here. Towards the end we get the fine pieces 'Walls of Shame' and the 10-minute album closer 'Considerations', a more typically-structured TFK song that works very well and has Michael Stolt doing the lead vocals. It is only in the middle that this album seems to be more uneventful, but overall, 'Love' is enjoyable and plentiful, if you are ready to embrace its oceanic sways.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Psicomagia by PSICOMAGIA album cover Studio Album, 2013
3.57 | 19 ratings

BUY
Psicomagia
Psicomagia Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Stoneburner

4 stars Psicomagia

This is an incredible album. Everything I love is here. Psychomagic is a therapeutic technique created by Chilean mystic Alejandro Jodorowsky, which combines shamanic rituals, theater, and psychoanalysis to provoke catharsis in the patient and unlock trauma.

On this album, the avant-garde San Diego free jazz band creates an atmosphere of musical freedom with a flair for bombast, including spoken word in Spanish. You are immersed in the world of Psychomagic and all it represents, giving new meaning to the work of the Chilean visionary.

Psychomagic is more than a new band: it's a musical project that includes members of the psych-blues band Radio Moscow and the great progressive band Astra. The lineup includes Tyler Daughn (organs, synthesizers), Brian Ellis (tenor saxophone), Paul Marrone (drums), Trevor Mast (bass), and Bernardo Nuņez (poetry and recitation). The band revolves around music where improvisations and brilliant keyboard solos merge with Núņez's poetic storytelling.

In the end, the album is fascinating, and the band achieves truly brilliant moments with this blend of psychedelic jazz and avant-garde. The only drawback is the mixing of Núņez's vocals. At times, they feel buried; perhaps a moment of silence, or simply turning up the volume, would have helped us better understand his words. As it stands, the vocals are somewhat lost and end up being more of a distraction than an impact.

Still, it's a great album, very original, and definitely worth a listen.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Entheogenic Frequencies by AGHORA album cover Studio Album, 2019
3.07 | 9 ratings

BUY
Entheogenic Frequencies
Aghora Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars "Entheogenic Frequencies" is the third full-length studio album by US progressive metal act Aghora. The album was independently released in December 2019. It´s the successor to "Formless" from 2006, so it´s been quite a few years since we´ve last heard from Aghora. Guitarist Santiago Dobles and bassist Alan Goldstein remain from the lineup who recorded the predecessor, while drummer Giann Rubio has been replaced by Matt Thompson (King Diamond, Imagika...etc.). Lead vocalist Diana Serra has left and has not been replaced, and as a result the music on "Entheogenic Frequencies" is fully instrumental.

Changing from an act featuring a vocalist to playing fully instrumental music would be a major change for most artists but Aghora already played a music style on their previous releases, which could well have worked without the vocals. In fact the vocals were often a distraction and felt like an afterthought on the preceding albums, so the lack of vocals on "Entheogenic Frequencies" is to my ears a bit of a blessing.

The jazz/fusion/world music influenced technical/progressive metal style of the preceding releases is continued in all other departments, and Aghora are still an incredibly well playing band. Thompson surprises me here, as I´m only familiar with his playing from the King Diamond albums he plays on and the King Diamond concerts I´ve attended through the years, and I´ve always felt that he had a stiff, unimaginative, and sligthly tedious playing style which held King Diamond´s music back, but his playing on "Entheogenic Frequencies" has given me another view on his abilities and the dynamics of King Diamond as a band (clearly Thomson just plays what he is told, and is not allowed much imput and creative playing), because this guy can play and there´s nothing wrong with the creativity and power of his playing. In fact the playing from all involved is amazing.

"Entheogenic Frequencies" features a detailed and well sounding production job too, so upon conclusion it´s a good quality release from Aghora and fans of artists like Cynic and the related Portal should find lots to appreciate here. A 3.5 star (70%) rating is deserved.

(Originally posted on Metal Music Archives).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Paper Mâché Dream Balloon by KING GIZZARD & THE LIZARD WIZARD album cover Studio Album, 2015
3.66 | 100 ratings

BUY
Paper Mâché Dream Balloon
King Gizzard & The Lizard Wizard Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Lobster77

3 stars This album is probably where we first see the truly unexpected gizz experiments. Any album previously has been kinda hinted at in prior work (Like Sam Cherry's Last Shot being an Eyes Like The Sky type track), but this truly feels like a left turn in their discography, especially with what comes after. But as a left turn it's about as successful as it could be. This is on the surface a really charming acoustic pop record perfect for the summer or the like, but I'd also argue that this is some of the best songwriting king gizzard has to offer. They're really tapping into their 60s and 70s bag with lots of interesting chord progressions and lush arrangements which is really unlike them up to this point. They also manage to keep most of the tracks pretty short while still packing in so many different ideas.

While most of the tracks kinda embody the same vibe I'd say there are a few that divert from the rest and while it diminishes them a bit I still like them for what they are. I am of course talking the spooky Trapdoor and the two bluesier tracks The Bitter Boogie and N.G.R.I (Bloodstain). To a certain degree one could also add in the closer but it's more of an extended outro medley than a full track. When it comes to the rest though I'd say my favorites would probably be Bone, Dirt and Most of What I Like. They just have that sort of extra oomph and variety in their arrangements

This is pretty good 3.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Shine On Brightly by PROCOL HARUM album cover Studio Album, 1968
4.06 | 402 ratings

BUY
Shine On Brightly
Procol Harum Crossover Prog

Review by Lobster77

4 stars Procol Harum reminds me of The Moody Blues in a way; not in terms of their sound but in terms of their place in the history of progressive rock, and how it evolved. Both bands got in on the ground floor, which makes them pioneers, at the very least. But both also got in before progressive rock really became its own thing, and so their music sounds incredibly traditional and conventional compared to much (if not most) '70s prog.

That's true of Procol Harum's second record, which sounds pretty far from the "progressive rock" that I have listened to all my adult life. The songs on side one are pretty conventional pop rock songs, for the most part, with clear art music influences, but only to the extent that I would call them "art rock" rather than prog rock. These songs are catchy enough, with above average lyrics, but which feel like very tentative steps to a new music, if you could even call it that. (In fact, it's only with the benefit of hindsight that we can see the tentative steps to some form of new music, as these are pretty conventional.)

But all that changes on side 2, when the prog rock band's favourite test of mettle appears to have been invented (to the best of my knowledge). I'm talking about "In Held Twas In I," a nearly 18 minute long, five song suite, which predates all the major prog side-long suites by at least two years, the second side of Abbey Road by a year, and whose only precedents I know of are the considerably less ambitious and "A Quick One While He's Away" and "Real" by the Who, and "A Saucerful of Secrets" by Pink Floyd. I am inclined to overrate such pathbreaking, but I can't really help myself.

The track itself - or collection of tracks - is not necessarily as successful as I'd like to be, as I'm not sure it really coheres together quite as well as subsequent efforts in the genre (or the above mentioned early stabs at long rock suites). But it's still an absolute landmark in the evolution of progressive rock, creating a new standard in rock ambition that would not be matched for a few years.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Live in Aston 1977 by CAN album cover Live, 2024
3.36 | 9 ratings

BUY
Live in Aston 1977
Can Krautrock

Review by Syzygy
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars Live in Aston is the first of a pair of releases that capture Can circa Saw Delight playing at universities in the English midlands. On these dates the core quartet was joined by Rosko Gee on bass (Rebop Kwaku Baah wasn't with them for the UK tour), with Holger Czukay in a proto sampling role on short wave receivers and special sounds. This particular release would have more or less fitted onto one side of a C90, and appears to be the first half of the gig.

Eins is a strong opener, just under 14 minutes of the trademark open ended musical exploration that Can did so well. It may not have the manic intensity of the free form freak outs that can be heard on earlier concert recordings, but Schmidt and Karoli weave fascinating patterns over an ever evolving groove laid down by Gee and Liebezeit and it demonstrates that Can could still conjure beguiling music out of thin air. Zwei is based on Vitamin C from Ege Bamyesi, beginning with Irmin Schmidt's keyboard arpeggio and exploring the theme from there. We stay with Ege Bamyesi for Drei, which uses Pinch as its jumping off point and which is where they really cut loose and let fly. It's also where Holger Czukay's contributions are most audible. Vier is a heavily deconstructed Dizzy Dizzy and brings proceedings to a satisfying conclusion.

Although they were touring Saw Delight at the time, this release leans heavily into Ege Bamyesi and Soon Over Babaluma in terms of both musical themes and overall feel. Rosko Gee's bass is busier than Holger Czukay's and both he and Czukay are relatively low in the mix most of the time. It's an interesting document of a frequently overlooked and under appreciated phase of Can's career, but is a solid rather than inspired addition to the archive live recordings.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Come Taste the Band by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1975
3.24 | 599 ratings

BUY
Come Taste the Band
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by Hector Enrique
Prog Reviewer

4 stars The departure of Ian Gillan and Roger Glover in 1973 had struck at the inner core of Deep Purple, and when Ritchie Blackmore also stepped aside after the release of "Stormbringer" to form Rainbow, it looked like the end of the band. However, the surviving members decide that there are still more battles to fight, and they call upon the talented Tommy Bolin, an overflowing and overwrought American guitarist, who at only 24 years of age gets involved in the new and risky adventure of the English band, "Come Taste the Band" (1975), Deep Purple's tenth album and the only one of the Mark IV.

An injection of vitality is what Bolin brings with him to a very tired band at that time, differentiating himself from Blackmore's corrosive and toxic guitar playing for more versatile and uninhibited ones, as in the explosive "Comin' Home", in the aggressive "Dealer" (great slide guitar) and "Drifter", and in the Zeppelin-like "Love Child", songs full of refreshing hard rock where the young guitarist displays his virtuosity in a carefree way, and shows a surprising point of maturity in the powerful "You Keep On Moving" accompanied by the melancholic hammonds of a Jon Lord, strangely relegated, and the marked bass of Glen Hughes in an apt duet singing with David Coverdale, surely the best song on the album.

On the other hand, the influences that Hughes and Coverdale shared from long ago, are manifested in the extremely funky "Gettin' Tighter", in the motown sonorities of "I Need Love", and in the soul of "This Time Around", songs that, in spite of having a solvent performance by the band and an excellent production work, move away from the characteristic sound of the glorious Purplelian hours.

And precisely because of that and the reluctance to accept a guitarist different from the iconic 'man in black', "Come Taste the Band" failed to transcend and faded away, undeservedly in my opinion, amidst fan disinterest. Discouraged, the band split up in mid-1976 and sadly, towards the end of the same year, Bolin died under the effects of an overdose of drugs and alcohol.

Deep Purple thus enters a long and uncertain hiatus, only interrupted in 1984 with the reunion of Mark II for "Perfect Strangers".

3.5 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Blacker by RADIO MASSACRE INTERNATIONAL album cover Studio Album, 2007
4.47 | 19 ratings

BUY
Blacker
Radio Massacre International Progressive Electronic

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

5 stars 4.5 stars. I haven't been surprised like this for quite a long time. "Blacker" released in 2007 shows the band playing some of their more experimental music. This is dark and minimalistic for long stretches. Plenty of guitar from Houghton, but less of those sequencers, even though they are present here and used well. Lots of mellotron though. I just didn't at this point think I'd come across an album of theirs that suddenly is a top three from their huge discography. We are missing a boat load of their albums on this site.

"Knutsford In May" is still my favourite from 1996, but "Blacker" came out of nowhere. I own a lot of their music. They have mainly been on three record labels. Centaur Discs, Cuneiform Records and Northern Echo Records. This is on the latter and is shown as being their 17th on that label. The disc itself has NE017 under the name "Blackler", yes there's an extra "L" in there, clearly a typo. The only info related in this package is "Recorded at the Greenhouse in Stockport, where cups of tea cost 20p but check if there's some milk before paying." An incident that won't be forgotten.

So we get four tracks over 58 minutes. From the short 4 minute "No Bones" where we get these repeated guitar lines over and over in atmosphere. To the 28 minute "This Is Scenery?" where the band stretches out so far that the tea needs to be warmed up. All three guys are on electronics and caffeine, while Dinsdale adds drums and Goddard bass. I love these guys, I really do. And it's interesting to me that this was released the same year as "Rain Falls In Grey" two of their best right there. That opener is amazing. "Dubly" is a 9 minute trip of dark atmosphere with the guitar crying out. The bass gets us started as those sounds pulse in the darkness. Headphone music.

The closer "Enormodome" opens with haunting mellotron as spacey sounds twitter. A voice desperately cries out over and over in the atmosphere until a change around 5 minutes in. This is where the soundscape starts to move. This sounds incredible with the guitar expressions and deep sounds. So much going on. More guitar after 9 minutes, then sequencers after 11 minutes before the guitar returns to end it.

I like how each track blends into the next. I was going to describe that 28 minute beast but lets just say the time flies by. It's just such an interesting piece of music where we get it all from them. Sequencers, synth melodies, guitar expressions, percussion, dark atmosphere etc. Experimental, and how about those growly sounds? Just an epic track that will go down as one of my favourites from this band. I'm bumping this one up. And for sure this will be on of my "best of" electronic list.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Giro Di Valzer Per Domani by ARTI E MESTIERI album cover Studio Album, 1975
3.89 | 145 ratings

BUY
Giro Di Valzer Per Domani
Arti E Mestieri Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars After producing one of the best proggy instrumental Jazz-Rock Fusion albums of all-time in Tilt, they decide to add vocals and try more melodic, and more funky tune constructions along with their usual Mahavishnu-like Power Fusion.

1. "Valzer Per Domani" (2:12) swinging a bit like some hap-sappy melody-laden Broadway overture (sounding a bit like a variation on "My Favorite Things"). It's pretty and very catchy but something feels a bit off: as if the band is a bit off, a bit out of sync (especially the drummer) and as if they're having to dig into other people's ideas and melodies for material. (4.375/5)

2. "Mirafiori" (5:55) the drummer is way too busy: as if he's either coked up or really feeling Ego-full of himself. Nice to hear that Gigi Venegoni and Giovanni Vigliar are still very much in sync with one another (on guitar and violin, respectively). Giovanni impresses in the second and third minutes while Furio Chirico's frantic KEITH MOON-like busy- ness almost fits in! Gigi Venegoni's following John McLAUGHLIN-like solo is also impressive. The ensuing section with its rather crazy effected-soprano sax solo makes the band sound like the upcoming NOVA albums with Corrado Rustici and Elio D'Anna. Obviously Mahavishnu Orchestra is the inspiration for both bands, so no use arguing about which came first. (8.875/10)

3. "Saper Sentire" (4:40) another really odd mélange of seemingly disparate styles (and sounds)--with vocals! Singer Gianfranco Gaza sounds like a 1970s version of LA COSCIENZO DI ZENO/NOT A GOOD SIGN lead singer Alessio Calendriello. (8.6667/10)

4. "Nove Lune Prima" (0:55) with this and the next three songs the band seem to be trying to reach back to a couple of years into the history of power Jazz-Rock Fusion. (4.5/5) 5. "Mescal" (5:16) as if right from The Inner Mounting Flame, we get to see/hear this band return to the realm of serious Jazz-Rock Fusion--with drummer Furio Chirico finally feeling as if he is in his comfort zone: channeling his inner Billy Cobham. (9.333/10) 6. "Mescalero" (0:35) a pretty, poignant bridge between "Mescal" and "Nove Lune Dopo". (4.75/5) 7. "Nove Lune Dopo" (2:39) great J-R Fusion using Jean-Luc Ponty-like melodies over Mahavishnu-like fire. Great drumming and bass play. (9.25/10) 8. "Dimensione Terra" (1:30) What sounds like the completion to the Mahavishnu-like suite of "Nove Lune Prima" through "Nove Lune Dopo". (4.5/5)

9. "Aria Pesante" (3:53) a vocal-centric song that has components that remind me of Wayne Shorter-led Weather Report as well as Broadway stage hippie music (the bouncing piano chord progressions). The instrumentalists on top are still performing as if they're a jazz rock ensemble--though here more in the Jean-Luc Ponty vein than the earlier Mahavishnu styles. (8.875/10)

10. "Consapevolezza Parte 1a" (3:22) more melodic JEAN-LUC PONTY-like Jazz-Rock Fusion; very high quality but also very melodic. Furio Chirico is a madman! (9.3333/10)

11. "Sagra" (3:06) this one sounds like a jazzified variation on the orchestral part of "MacArthur Park" or Caravan's "L'auberge du Sanglier/A hunting we shall go/Pengola/Backwards/A hunting we shall go (reprise)". Towards the end of the song, Luigi "Gigi" Venegoni goes JAN AKKERMAN/TODD RUNDGREN bat [&*!#]-crazy: spitting watermelon seeds from his machine gun axe over the high-speed race of the band beneath him. Impressive if a little odd and disjointed in its mix and stylistic commitments. (9.125/10)

12. "Consapevolezza Parte 2a" (1:12) drums, bass, and vibraphone make a light, airy little ditty that guitar, keys, and violin join. Beautiful! (5/5)

13. "Rinuncia" (2:48) another pop-oriented tune that sounds quite Americanophilic, even crossing over into Southern Rock (and pop RPI)-like territory with the second half. Odd assortment of vocal performances scattered throughout. Nice bouncy bass and clavinet work supporting the Southern-Rock guitar soloing. (9.25/10)

14. "Marilyn" (2:40) contemplative piano play that sounds as if Beppe Crovella is just playing around are eventually give way to frenetic drums, smooth clavinet chord play, and jazzy-Elio D'Anna/Jan Garbarek-like soprano sax play. An interesting étude-like mélange. I really like Beppe's piano instincts. (4.5/5)

15. "Terminal" (2:20) sustained vibraphone chords joined by bass and drums before Mahavishnu-like guitar and violin burst in with piano chord support. The two motifs alternate three times before the engineer executes the big fade. (4.625/5)

Total time 38:16

This album is so scattered--and it panders more to the pop/radio friendly world than the previous album but the ideas, sounds, performances, and experiments are all top notch/of the highest quality.

A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of more broad-spectrum pop-considerate Jazz-Rock Fusion. Not as good as Tilt but nothing to be ashamed of.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Sky 3 by SKY album cover Studio Album, 1981
3.23 | 74 ratings

BUY
Sky 3
Sky Eclectic Prog

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Sky's third album sees Steve Gray joining the lineup in place of a departing Francis Monkman. This seems to have prompted a backing away from the somewhat rockier and more energetic sides of the band displayed on Sky 2, focusing more on the sort of mellow, gentle sound of their first album, albeit with the classical aspects dialled back (but far from absent) and the jazz side of things dialled up just a tad. This will bore anyone who insists that their prog rock, well, ROCKS, but if the idea of taking early 1980s Camel and making it even more gentle appeals to you, then Sky 3 might be just the ticket.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Rook's Siege by MARTIN VENGADESAN & THE STALEMATE FACTOR album cover Studio Album, 2023
4.00 | 3 ratings

BUY
The Rook's Siege
Martin Vengadesan & The Stalemate Factor Crossover Prog

Review by lawnmower

4 stars Interesting effort from this chess-themed prog band from Malaysia. Behind the dark and brooding album cover of Martin Vengadesan & The Stalemate Factor's "The Rook Siege", the fourth album in their catalog, its opening track "The Horizon Myth" shows off the best of Vengadesan's talents, taking us on a sonic journey that is explorative in nature in this playful 11-minute-50-second suite. A fun lengthy song by Stalemate Factor.

I was particularly taken by the acid-soaked track "The Heretic" told from the perspective of a person struggling with late night depression. Its beauty is in its darkness, as is much of this album. The mood of the song flickers like a light switch between verse and chorus, brilliantly depicting the violent throes of manic depression in its lyricism and arrangement.

Its chorus stood out. Anyone who has identified as an outsider at some point of their lives would be able to see themselves in the lines:

Am I a heretic if I do not think like you? Or just a broken man who knows not what to do? All trace of this life I guess will soon be gone No one needs to know that I never belonged

This eventually builds up to a spirited jam between sitar, keys and electric guitar.

Check out "The Forest Of Thieves" for its Ian Anderson-reminiscent flute lines and blistering guitar solo, and "Ashes" - a charming piano-forward song, heavily backed by mellotron, telling a tale of betrayal.

Another piano-forward track is "The Tomb Of Osiris", which reminds me of Iron Maiden at its best, rocking and rolling with soulful backing vocals supplied by I-Shan Esther. Notable mentions are tracks "Citadel Of Twenty-Six" for its fantastic outro and medieval imagery and "Death Comes As The End", which I believe is a nod to Agatha Christie's work of the same name.

A very pleasing hour spent on "The Rook's Siege" indeed.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Mr. Gone by WEATHER REPORT album cover Studio Album, 1978
2.79 | 148 ratings

BUY
Mr. Gone
Weather Report Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars The peak Weather Report lineup PLUS guest appearances from Tony Williams, Steve Gadd, Maurice Williams, Deniece Williams, John Lucien, and Manolo Badrena. Needless to say: Expectations are high!

1. "The Pursuit of the Woman With the Feathered Hat" (5:00) the Zawinul sound parade begins. They could do so much better than this! (8.6667/10)

2. "River People" (4:49) live or not, this just sounds like another of the band's endlessly-protracted themes to allow Joe to show off his keyboards' sound possibilities. Throw in the handclaps and disco drums and you get one boring song. (Can't imagine why Jaco would put up with this!) (8.6667/10)

3. "Young and Fine" (6:54) very repetitive, melodic in the quirky, upbeat way that only Weather Report (and maybe Jay Beckenstein's SPYRO GYRA) can be. At least the musicianship of the instrumentalists keep it interesting--on multiple levels. (13.5/15)

4. "The Elders" (4:20) another surprisingly insipid and bare-bones song construct on which the band's parade of "fresh" sounds gets put on display. (This song would seem to support the theory that by now all of the band members have caught M. Zawinul's "look at me" bug.) (8.6667/10)

5. "Mr. Gone" (5:20) the opening minute of this song sounds like something from the soundtrack of a 1970s Italian horror film. Then it turns to "bizarre circus environment" for the second and third minutes, using lots of "old" sounds and 1960s "robotic" sounds and noises to make their music. Interesting, entertaining, and laughable. (8.6667/10)

6. "Punk Jazz" (5:07) Finally! Jaco breaks free of his master's chains, leading Tony Williams on a journey worthy of his talents. But that's only the first minute, after that they break into an odd organ-backed sax solo like the femme fatale's theme in an old Guy Noir 1960s "Whodunnit?" film. The circus plodding that follows in the third and fourth minutes is unfortunate despite some nice play from Wayne and Jaco, but they've only gone and wasted the talents of one of the most skilled and dynamic drummers of all-time. (Twice in a row: two consecutive songs!) Still, it's kind of likable. (8.875/10)

7. "Pinocchio" (2:25) fade in fade out = a scrap of music from an extended jam that was deemed "worthy" of being included (to fill space). Steve Gadd's performance is amazing! (4.5/5)

8. "And Then" (3:20) like a gentle "good-bye" song--or even a lullaby. The contributions of EW&F's Maurice White and newcomer Deniece ("I've Just Got to Be Free") Williams seems totally wasted. (8.75/10)

Total Time: 37:15

Yeah, the fade in, fade out tactic only shows me that the band was just jamming, most likely exploring without structure, goals, or end in sight. Also, I fin myself annoyed and saddened that band-leader Joe Zawinul is still stuck in his "see what I can do" mode of changing the sound programs on his synthesizer keyboard every 20 seconds, trying to cram as many "new" and "unusual" sounds that he can into each and every song (without ever repeating them!) This tactic often serves only to make each song--or each section of a song--ridiculously drawn out. Two good songs in a band's prime years does not make for a great album. Making it through this album is like 37 minutes of waiting for a plane that's only later found out to have been cancelled. Mr. Gone! Too bad!

B-/3.5 stars; a disappointing collection of song offerings from a lineup of many Jazz-Rock Fusion all-stars--a lineup that seemed to promise something wonderful, could've been so much better.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Mothers Of Invention: Freak Out! by ZAPPA, FRANK album cover Studio Album, 1966
3.93 | 783 ratings

BUY
The Mothers Of Invention: Freak Out!
Frank Zappa RIO/Avant-Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars A revolutionary rock album for 1966, without a doubt, 'Freak Out!' is the debut studio album of The Mothers of Invention, a Frank Zappa-led quintet that completely shackled the idea of a rock band, and the extent to which the standard blues format might be experimented with. Released precisely a week after 'Blonde on Blonde', it is quite likely that this is the first debut double album to be released by a rock band, a work so unhinged and far-reaching that it crosses genres with ease, drawing in influences from psychedelic rock, blues, doo-wop, experimental music, and R&B, to create a vivid satire of American culture that would go on to influence the entire progressive scene as well as provide a fascinating new idea of an artistic take on the rock genre, limited strongly (yet not exclusively) by the artist's creativity.

You can call it challenging and entertaining, and whatever this album may be, the four sides of this LP assault the listener with the vicious and humorous patchwork of sounds, effects, vocal trips, and occasional use of some ridiculous instruments, at least for what concerns our idea of rock music. Vehemently experimental, 'Freak Out!' is interestingly enough a concept album, too, wherein each song depicts a particular scene, it inhibits an idea and explores it so that the whole of the work is tied together by the vision of its creator. There are absolutely bizarre arrangements, some wackily constructed pieces made up of different movements, catchy and quirky pop-sided blues numbers, and kazoo-laden jams; in a word, a tiny bit of everything. A world of its own, this debut album already anticipates a lot of the musical vocabulary that would become synonymous with Zappa's name, and the most daring part of it has to be the blatant experimentation and anecdotal musical parodies, as heard on some of the classics like 'Hungry Freaks, Daddy', 'Motherly Love', 'Any Way the Wind Blows', 'Trouble Every Day', the 'Help I'm a Rock' absurd suite in three movements, or the closing side-long and provocative collage of sounds and tapes, the 12-minute-long 'The Return of the Son of Monster Magnet', perhaps the essential antidote to all the Bob-Dylans out there. A massive album that introduced a new sensitivity in rock, it showed a comical manner and an avant-garde approach that transcends genre, and eventually, would influence a whole bunch of later movements and styles.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Monster Movie by CAN album cover Studio Album, 1969
3.81 | 436 ratings

BUY
Monster Movie
Can Krautrock

Review by Lobster77

3 stars in their earliest incarnation, Can still sound very rough, proto-krautrock ā la early Amon Düül more than their later selves. This is more a matter of sound than of essence though, because the basic ingredients are all here already: the lock grooves, the repetition, the occasional hypnotic quality. Musically, it's like an unfinished draft for the real thing, but it's nevertheless very accomplished.

Most Can fans maintain that it took Damo Suzuki to take the vocals to the right level, and I kind of agree, but it's really hard to argue with Malcolm Mooney's vocals either: his indistinct mumbling before he spouts out some understandable bits and pieces, and certainly his ability to be a lot more repetitive than his successor have a compelling quality. Listening to this, it makes sense that only a few months later, he would suffer a nervous breakdown on stage, being unable to stop singing "upstairs downstairs". He feels quite on the edge on this record too, and it's precisely this somewhat morbid aspect that adds an interesting dimension to this music.

4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Rook's Siege by MARTIN VENGADESAN & THE STALEMATE FACTOR album cover Studio Album, 2023
4.00 | 3 ratings

BUY
The Rook's Siege
Martin Vengadesan & The Stalemate Factor Crossover Prog

Review by DetectiveDoom

4 stars The Rook's Siege is the most recent album by The Stalemate Factor, which is a rare progressive rock band from South East Asia. I have all four albums but this is the most progressive overall and by far the best place to start.

The obvious draw is the opener - a great track called The Horizon Myth. A 12 minute piece that ends with a superb Moog solo it also has some fine guitar work by LK Wong and outstanding drumming from Ashwin. There are bits of the song that remind me of Rush, King Crimson and even The Beatles and Traffic. The lyrics are all about warriors and wizards, poisoned blades and a half-prince in the shadows!

Another highlight is the blistering Ashes which has some fantastic piano and organ interchanges by keyboardist/singer Vengadesan. I would also recommend The Tomb Of Osiris which blends heavy metal and jazz while ruminating on the fate of the last priest of an ancient religion. Similarly The Forest Of Thieves touches on Jain mythology, and has a captivating midsection on flute and another great outro solo by Wong.

Then there's The Heretic which is an all out brooding jam featuring electric piano, guitar and sitar by guest performer Kumar. It also has a schizophrenic Beatles-like chorus.

The album is full of hidden moments like the violin solo in The Ballad Of The Latter Day Saint and the maudlin string and flute exchanges in Death Comes As The End. I also like the vocal duet on Citadel of Twenty Six, and there are great female vocal contributions from Joanne, Alena and I-Shan Esther.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ei noi muut by VIMMA album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.93 | 6 ratings

BUY
Ei noi muut
Vimma Prog Folk

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

4 stars I wonder if prog folk historians of the future will fly over the indefatigable VIMMA or recognize the innovation they bring/brought to a sometimes staid genre. Set apart from the English axis that bust out in the 1960s and 1970s and the neo/wyrd movement of the 80s/90s and beyond, VIMMA incorporates not just standard pop but the forbidden fruit of punk and hip hop among others. In a breathless 32 minutes they string one fiddle fronted mini masterpiece after another, not so much mocking what came before as paying homage while truly signposting a potentially new as yet unnamed genre if others could only discern the flashing lights in their faces. My nearest comparisons to the past might be a more rooted MECANO or a less anarchic and smarmy CHUMBAWUMBA. Even allowing for a bit of mid tempo weakness towards the end, particularly the album closer, VIMMA's third is by far their most accomplished and a viable candidate for prog folk royalty in 2025.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 A Complex of Cages by BARREN EARTH album cover Studio Album, 2018
3.86 | 25 ratings

BUY
A Complex of Cages
Barren Earth Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars "A Complex Of Cages" is the fourth full-length studio album by death/doom metal act Barren Earth. The album was released through Century Media Records in March 2018, almost to the day three years down the line from the release of Barren Earth´s third full-length studio album "On Lonely Towers" from March 2015. There has been one lineup change since "On Lonely Towers" as keyboard player and founding member Kasper Mårtenson has left and has been replaced by Antti Myllynen.

Stylistically the change on the keyboard player position hasn´t meant much for the overall sound of Barren Earth (and that´s despite Mårtenson being one of the main composers of the band on the past releases), as the material on "A Complex Of Cages" is a continuation of the progressive death/doom metal sound of the band´s past releases. Opeth is the most valid and immediate reference point, as Barren Earth have a similar love for 70s progressive rock and the occasional nod or two towards ethnic Scandinavian folk, but Barren Earth still have a sound of their own with more melodic death metal leanings and more use of keyboards. Faroe Island born lead vocalist Jķn Aldará has a commanding brutal growl but he also sings a lot of semi-operatic clean vocals throughout the album, and to my ears his vocals are now a much more integrated part of the band´s sound, compared to the way they worked with the music on "On Lonely Towers". This probabaly has something to do with the fact that Aldará wrote almost all lyrics on "A Complex Of Cages" and also contributed vocal melodies to a lot of the material.

So, this more collaborative approach to the songwriting (while bassist Olli-Pekka Laine is still the main composer, some of the other band members picked up the torch after Mårtenson left, and has also contributed material) has paid off and "A Complex Of Cages" features memorable and effective songwriting which is both heavy and brutal, but also sophisticated and clever. Add to that a powerful, organic, and detailed sound production, and some high quality musicianship, and "A Complex Of Cages" is as a result a high quality progressive death/doom metal release. A 4 star (80%) rating is fully deserved.

(Originally posted on Metal Music Archives).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Parplar by GRIMM, LARKIN album cover Studio Album, 2008
3.51 | 5 ratings

BUY
Parplar
Larkin Grimm Prog Folk

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

4 stars I was starting to wonder if LARKIN GRIMM would ever see her art as more than personal therapy but as a means to connect with an audience beyond the double digits, and along came 2008's "Parplar". Same voice but a poppier, more relatable weirdness. The full band helps coax a variety of Appalachian and celtic influences out of their long hibernation. The juxtaposition of styles and arrangements makes for an engrossing listen from start to finish, with nary a misstep, be it the arrestingly lively "Ride that Cyclone", "Mino Minou", and "Fall on my Knees", the more balladic but lyrically fascinating "Blond and Gold Johns" and "Anger in My Liver", the country ish "Be my Host", or the unsettling chants of "Durge". If you heard her earlier work and threw up your arms in defeat, give this one a chance.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Chicago Transit Authority by CHICAGO album cover Studio Album, 1969
4.10 | 281 ratings

BUY
The Chicago Transit Authority
Chicago Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Lobster77

5 stars Welcome to Chicago, the home of amazing brass arrangements, a stellar rhythm section, a mastermind guitarist and an impressive debut album. For those who thought Chicago was just a commercial pop band that produced radio hits in the 70s and 80s, this ambitious double album will prove you wrong. A solid mix of rock, jazz, soul and blues, Chicago Transit Authority is especially unique compared to other albums of the era by including an entire horn section in their lineup. This gives the band a fresh jazz-rock style that feels original.

We start with the self-explanatory 'Introduction' where the band goes through a bunch of movements in 6 minutes; it ebbs and flows in dynamics as smoothly as the brass section plays. A fantastic way to begin the album. The next track, 'Does Anybody Really Know What Time It Is?', starts off with a piano solo before moving straight into the hummable verses that snappy chorus that garnered much deserved radio play. 'Beginnings' opens with acoustic guitar as drums, bass then horns come in. Vocals follow in this uplifting track. Everything seems to get more passionate halfway through. Peter Cetera plays some really good bass on this track especially after 4 minutes and a great percussion outro to end it.

'Questions 67 and 68' is a powerful track with a ton of heavy brass, fast guitars, strong drums and of course Cetera's soulful vocals. 'Listen' follows; what I really like is the onset built around Terry Kath's single feedback note. It's more of a true rock song in that they emphasize the guitar, organ and rhythm and the horns are only there to embellish. 'Poem 58' is a great highlight, a guitar-driven rock jam in which Kath shows off his prowess. Not to mention, the guitars with Cetera's bass and Seraphine's remarkable drumming are an essential driving force to this song.

Kath gets his own piece with 'Free Form Guitar', a 7-minute experimental piece of guitar improvisation similar to the riveting solos of Jimi Hendrix (Hendrix once mentioned Kath as his favourite guitarist). Keep in mind that no pedals or effects were used on this track, only a guitar and an amp. Whether this fits in with the album or not, it's an intriguing piece. 'South California Purples' is a long bluesy rocker with some backing horns thrown in. Saving a slightly weak third side is a cover of the Spencer Davis Group's 'I'm a Man' which does not pale in comparison; the organ of Robert Lamm, the bass and guitar are on point and I like how driving the hook gets at times. The drums add a completely new flavour to the song too.

The last side begins with 'Prologue', a one minute introduction of what may be an actual recording of the controversial 1968 Democratic Convention in Chicago featuring the crowd chanting the infamous phrase 'the whole world is watching'. This segues to the next track 'Someday', filled with splashy horns, pounding piano chords and politically-charged lyrics. The album ends with a 14-minute jam, 'Liberation'. A brilliant but lengthy demonstration of musicianship and virtuosity from the performers.

'Chicago Transit Authority' still feels as fresh as ever. A strange and daring double debut album, and a mighty successful one at that. For what it serves, it's hard to ask for much more and the production is satisfactory. I recommend this to fans of classic 60s rock who don't mind a tad more brass and if you like progressive rock with more accessible and bluesier roots.

5.0 essential for jazz fusion fans. I had this review saved for a while.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Love by FLOWER KINGS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.69 | 64 ratings

BUY
Love
The Flower Kings Symphonic Prog

Review by alainPP

3 stars 1. We Claim the Moon, a FLOWER KINGS-style debut, that's for sure; Hans still sings so well; the atmosphere reminds me of The Love Boat, in fact, the jazzy escapade at the end of the race is hard to digest, too focused, this track is a blast. 2. The Elder goes into symphonic territory bordering on elegiac, reminiscent of the great YES; the development is worth it for its marshmallow arrangements that make you want to sit down in the evening and stop thinking; symphony in the style of themselves and the youngsters of BIG BIG TRAIN; one of the current prog signatures of the last of the 70s dinosaurs. 3. How Can You Leave Us Now!? for its SERRA-like base from the 80s, for the AOR air of BOSTON from the love song era, for the bucolic and flowery side of GENESIS, for the bewitching ballad. Beautiful but overdone, bombastic and demonstrative. 4. World Spinning for Lalle's keyboard interlude leading to a soaring, invigorating orchestral prog. 5. Burning Both Edges for the epic track, a long progressive build-up oozing with overly sweet candy. For Roine's guitar solo, revealing his delicate and melting touch, yes, it's enticing; the Genesis-esque atmosphere I adored almost 50 years ago is still as beautiful but dries up with time; in short, a musical slap in the face for anyone who didn't know this band before. 6. The Rubble for the bluesy sound it exudes, a fruity mid-tempo that makes you want to invite your future partner to this slow jam reminiscent of SANTANA, with its atmosphere and guitar solo; very rhythmic, very fresh, groovy, inviting you to snap your fingers. The melting Hammond behind it.

7. Kaiser Razor for the second interlude, which makes your ears prick up even more. An expressive interlude reminding me of TOTO's 'Childs Anthem'; a short but intense moment, navigating between jazz, bossa, South American ambiance, and Scandinavian symphony. 8. The Phoenix for my favorite track, short and to the point, for its airy Yessian intro, a beautiful solemn track that doesn't just leave its nest. 9. The Promise for its country side with folk arpeggios, for its accordion, also settling down and showing that progressive rock comes from classical and popular music in fact; a beautiful ballad. 10. Love Is returns after these few short and remarkable tracks to the lands of Albion, eyeing GENESIS; a country sound, like a funfair, a small village clique. In short, a break after a flight, the symphonic melody joins the progressive, forgetting how well-crafted it is, superb. 11. Walls of Shame for the Gilmourian guitar intro, for the progressive twist; the FLOWER KINGS showed what they could do with a good copy/paste. Then they let loose; a bluesy solo with the organ of the time behind, Hans giving his gravelly voice, the synths and keyboard dripping their octaves, then the crystalline piano. 12. Considerations with the intro smelling good of KING CRIMSON, yes from afar but still; well, an intro that makes you dream, the crescendic rise to a castle, a pyramid, in short, an Olympian mount. Hans modulates his voice, the tone is more solemn before heading off into the territory of SPOCK'S BEARD from Neal's time. The track that connects you and connects you to symphonic prog with its clarity, much more refined than the last PATTERN SEEKING ANIMALS in comparison. A symphonic track that showcases Mirko accompanying Roine for a high-note finale.

A FLOWER KINGS with a FLOWER KINGS twist, in fact. Well, without more, it would be another band, one could call very good, disconcerting. (3.5)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Retropolis by FLOWER KINGS, THE album cover Studio Album, 1996
3.73 | 644 ratings

BUY
Retropolis
The Flower Kings Symphonic Prog

Review by Lobster77

4 stars The Flower Kings were on good track when they first made Back in the World of Adventures. All they had to do was improve their sound and add some much darker and moodier elements into the equation. Without their own knowing that mission, they took one step further to success a year after their first album with their second studio album, Retropolis.

The material that was delivered in this album had already begun to sound a little darker and prophetic, taking more of a concept approach to the album. Some of the songs began to take to the futuristic device, which worked exceptionally well with King Crimson's In the Court of the Crimson King. The new question would be this: would it work with this album? It certainly didn't hurt the album much. In fact, it benefited the content of the album quite a bit. It gave the darker material more flavor, mood, and uncertainty while it uplifted the brighter tracks even higher in attitude. However, there was a little less traditional content in this album than their 1st effort, which could have helped Retropolis be a little more interesting.

4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Low Spark Of High Heeled Boys by TRAFFIC album cover Studio Album, 1971
4.12 | 397 ratings

BUY
The Low Spark Of High Heeled Boys
Traffic Eclectic Prog

Review by Lobster77

4 stars Folky, jazzy psychedelic-tinged classic rock, like Jethro Tull and early Genesis mixed with the English blues-rock tradition, these guys are a bit hippie-trippy for me, but there's still something that keeps drawing me back to them. Winwood's voice is brilliant, and the music is full of quirky little elements that make it uniquely Traffic-y... The title track is the centerpiece of the album, and also the band's entire career, I'd say, a twelve-minute masterpiece of jamming, but there's also Rainmaker, the bouncy flute-laden Hidden Treasure, and the irreverant concert favorite Light Up Or Leave Me Alone... This remastered edition sounds great, and adds the bonus elongated single version of Rock & Roll Stew, so that's a bit of a plus for bigger Traffic-ers than me, I guess... Either way, this is still a great record, even if not one I throw on all the time. I would call this an essential for its blend of multiple genres.

4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Watching Worlds Collide by ESTHESIS album cover Studio Album, 2022
4.07 | 39 ratings

BUY
Watching Worlds Collide
Esthesis Neo-Prog

Review by Prog Dog

4 stars This band is new to me, even though they've released previous albums. As someone who's video-reacted to over 1,300 songs on YouTube, I've noticed that hearing a band for the first time naturally leads to comparisons with familiar sounds. So who comes to mind here? Talk Talk, Tears for Fears, David Sylvian, Steven Wilson (especially in the vocals), the Alan Parsons Project... and for some reason, the X-Files TV series!

Right away, I was drawn to Arnaud Nicolau's drumming. With all the modern advances in in-the-box drum production (which I have nothing against), it's refreshing and energizing to hear the tasteful flourishes of a real drummer on a properly mic'd kit. He's joined by Marc Anguill on bass, laying down great grooves throughout much of the album, not with a plectrum, but with what sounds like strong, two-finger plucking that firmly grounds the band.

The band is firmly rooted in sophisticated prog pop rock. Aurélien Goude's vocals are laid-back yet constantly reaching ?not in a strained way, but with a searching, introspective quality, as if he's a singer in pursuit of answers. Mathilde Collet adds beautifully complementary vocals on several tracks, helping to shape the band's distinct and nuanced sound.

Compositionally, the album is broad and expansive, with little repetition and a willingness to wander down long, winding corridors of sound. While it does rock out at times for emphasis, the overall vibe is laid-back in a cool, deliberate way. That's where I draw the connection between prog and noir: the music often feels wrapped in a smoky mystery, like it's unfolding in shadows.

There's some truly mature and memorable songwriting on display here, supported by superb arrangements and rich jazz-influenced chord progressions. The band isn't bound by predictable verse-chorus structures; instead, the songs unfold in expansive, often unexpected ways. Much of the music is piano-centric, with tasteful and layered use of synths and textures that complement the core beautifully. Trevor Horn would absolutely love this band?in fact, he'd be the perfect producer for them.

The album carries an introspective tone -relaxed, unhurried, and never trying too hard to impress. No one's breaking a sweat here, and that restraint adds to its charm. There's some lovely violin work on track 3, and a horn section makes welcome appearances throughout several songs. The atmospheric touches are especially notable -some tracks would fit seamlessly as background in a modern crime noir TV series.

A solid 4 out of 5 stars. Esthesis exude a smoky ambience I'd describe as prog noir?a sound steeped in jazz influences that creates a rich, atmospheric sense of mystery. While the tone leans toward the darker side, there's enough uplift to keep it moving forward with some optimism.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Aphelion by LEPROUS album cover Studio Album, 2021
3.70 | 183 ratings

BUY
Aphelion
Leprous Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars In concordance with the stylistic lineage of recent Leprous albums, 'Aphelion' from 2021 eventually represents an exercise in mastery of the musical musings of preceding studio effort 'Pitfalls' - an experimental, moody post-progressive sound that dares to invoke an electronic pop sensibility and render the Norwegian band's very own branch of "slow storm build-up" heavy rock into a fascinating and eclectic experience of music that only seemingly utilizes the means of expression of the metal genre, but in reality takes the material a step further, veering into some uncharted territories, that is without a doubt the case here. One might as well make the point that there is little variation in the band's output since their fifth album 'Malina' came out in 2017, but each LP feels like a fervorous step forward in the exploration of previously unheard of before soundscapes, with the band melting together a myriad of styles and tropes within their pot.

'Aphelion' is no exception from the rule, yet it is one of the most consistent and coherent listens out of the entire recent catalogue, with its cinematic soundscape and moody passageways, there is a smoothness to the album that is perhaps counteracted by its labyrinthian instrumentation, giving way to the impressive vocal work of band leader Einar Solberg, as we observe him getting better with each new Leprous album. There is a familiar feel to 'Aphelion' but also a warmth that makes it immediately appealing. Starting off rather impressively with explosive and miraculously beautiful tracks like 'Running Low', 'Out of Here', and 'All the Moments', there is a clear tone of pensive melancholy to this work, all while the band provides the soundtrack to a rather exploratory musical odyssey, from the sweeping guitars and the pitch-perfect drum patterns to the orchestral bits and the ambient waves of synthesizer sounds. It seems like Leprous are still stronger when it comes to the heavier department of their music ('The Silent Revelation', 'Nighttime Disguise'), with the gorgeous crossover pop-metal numbers on this album, while the more forgettable pieces of music are represented by these structure-less and ghostly songs in the second half, 'The Shadow Side', 'On Hold', and to an extent 'Castaway Angels'. Still, a really solid work, 'Aphelion' is yet another excellently-crafted album by Leprous.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Redemption by CHEAT THE PROPHET album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.83 | 14 ratings

BUY
Redemption
Cheat the Prophet Neo-Prog

Review by alainPP

4 stars "Chaos" starts with piano before the sumptuous direct air on a Wallace poem as a base, expressive pad on the velvety keyboard, the laid-back vocal eyeing the phrasing of Nick from PENDRAGON. The heavy riff arrives, surprising prog metal, allowing a beautiful drift at the end of the chorus; its sound flirting with SAGA in the distance and RUSH closer. Final arpeggio soaring then nervous for an abrupt end. "Bad Bitch" changes direction by offering a catchy rock, with an alternative reminiscence, a zest of Steven WILSON and the colorful rock of Franck CARDUCCI. The latent break with the dull riff, the sound searching and an atmospheric keyboard solo then another guitar making the title fly. Prog metal takes shape with this redundant riff, these spatial notes. A finale in the great prog rock tradition bordering on heavy on the typical rhythm of ENCHANT, to signify the symbolic hatred of the singer. "Marvelous World (Losing Season)" crystalline piano, acoustic arpeggio leading to the marshmallow ballad swelling like a distant wave, an easily accessible crescendo with the haunting solo at the end, a touch simplistic.

"Paper White" with an assertive arpeggio worthy of YES, crystalline guitar notes; simple and addictive, the urge to pick up your guitar and mime; delicate like a rural interlude. "Whisper" closes with a marked prog intro, sound effects; the Mellotron and vocals hit the heartstrings, the heavy riff suddenly breaking the melodic aspect before launching into a Kashmiri air. A piece in eight musical tableaux, an intoxicating musical fresco featuring vocal highlights, a text on politics since the 1980s, the end of the USSR, apartheid, Ukraine, and a beloved film, mantra- like rises, and the languid sound of the guitar used as a weapon of spleen. The break reminds me of Steven Wilson, then Barclay James Harvest for the vocals and keyboards. The progression to religious choirs, the symphonic prog metal rhythm, the velvety keyboard with Dan as a guest amplifying the symphonic space, pricking up the ears very favorably. A childish cinematic outro nostalgic for our memories, have you found the eggs?

"Zaff's Fez" is a bonus track, a short track that starts off with a bang, with Derek Sherinian-style keyboards ending with a languid jazzy piano fade-out and a nod to a friend.

Cheat The Prophet is reborn after 20 years, offering a distinctive prog rock sound that moves them away from their original style, progressing towards a captivating, modern sound, all to their credit. Some reminiscences and complex arrangements for a genre that amalgamates ambient, metal, alt-rock and compulsive synths. (3.5) Originally on Progcensor.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Platinum Collection by GENESIS album cover Boxset/Compilation, 2004
3.16 | 115 ratings

BUY
The Platinum Collection
Genesis Symphonic Prog

Review by fuxi
Prog Reviewer

2 stars Call me a fool, but I actually bought this set (at a firmly reduced price, of course) because I wanted the best tunes from the 1980s/1990s Phil Collins era. As a great admirer (since 1975!) of Gabriel-era Genesis, I never used to listen to the radio and only occasionally saw a clip or two on MTV, but of course some of those Collins-led tunes are inescapable, and I have to admit I even like a couple. So let's forget about Bret Easton Ellis, I ended up with this PLATINUM COLLECTION, what did I make of it?

Well, ladies and gentlemen, some of the tunes were as good as I'd hoped for and perhaps (when you don't hear them pouring out of a speaker in a noisy bar) even better. Songs like 'No Son Of Mine', 'Abacab' and 'Turn It On Again' can only be described as superior pop. 'Jesus He Knows Me' is as delightful as anything Peter Gabriel ever did, and 'Mama' actually starts out like one of PG's early solo tracks - what a shame it had to end on a 'screaming skull shrieking' fest. Yes, I'll admit that right from the start I had problems with Mr. Collins' insistent emoting, but that doesn't mean he can't sound deeply affecting as well: tracks like 'Many Too Many' and 'Undertow' actually bring a tear to my eye. And much to my surprise, 'That's All' strongly reminds me of the Dutch prog band Kayak, and of Genesis anno 1971 ('Harold the Barrel', to be precise).

Alas, I also found that discs 1 and 2 contain a number of tunes I didn't enjoy at all ('In Too Deep' for example, and that horrible little thing from CALLING ALL STATIONS), while one or two of Genesis' earworm songs (like 'Invisible Touch' and 'Tonight Tonight Tonight') proved deeply irritating. When the second disc reached WIND AND WUTHERING and A TRICK OF THE TAIL, I was disappointed that the most ambitious songs from those albums ('One For The Vine' and 'Robbery, Assault and Battery', for example) were nowhere to be found. Instead, I got offered relatively bland fare such as 'Afterglow' (I just can't stand Phil Collins singing falsetto) and (Lord help us) 'Your Own Special Way'. Couldn't they have picked 'Blood on the Rooftops' instead? It's at least twenty times better... Anything to avoid giving Steve Hackett his due, I suppose... Well, at least the compilers had the guts to include both 'In That Quiet Earth' and 'Los Endos', which are the closest Genesis ever got to 'progressive jazz rock' ā la Brand X.

With Disc 3 we enter a different universe, and the great news is that the best track is included from each of Genesis' classic 1970s albums. (I would also have loved to see 'Dancing With The Moonlit Knight' instead of 'I Know What I Like', but I guess you can't have everything.) As soon as the disc begins, we hear a new voice which has the kind of dignity Phil Collins - for all his virtues - never possessed. I wonder how that third disc will go down with unsuspecting non-proggers if they pick up this collection in a thrift store, just like me...

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 ReEvolution by CYNTHESIS album cover Studio Album, 2013
3.82 | 38 ratings

BUY
ReEvolution
Cynthesis Progressive Metal

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

3 stars 3.5 stars. CYNTHESIS rose out of the ashes of ZERO HOUR who disbanded in 2008, after their "Dark Deceiver" album. Three of the four members here were in ZERO HOUR with drummer Mike Flanegan coming from ENCHANT. This project was originally to be a three album run, a trilogy about a dystopian society set in the future. Sadly, this band only released two of the three records about this concept before disappearing on us. Singer Eric Rosvold and guitarist Jasun Tipton would return to the music scene once again with a comeback album from ZERO HOUR in 2022, but minus Troy Tipton on bass and Mike Guy on drums.

The possibility of this trilogy getting completed at this point seems remote. I do feel that this followup release is a definite step down from the debut. The lyrics/concept have taken over. I prefer the instrumental part of the debut much more. There were songs and sections I looked forward to, while here, other than the epic 13 1/2 minute closer I just feel we get so much atmosphere and sad vocals. Again, another concept album where the concept overrules everything else. I just find that those "moments" are few and far between on "ReEvolution".

A 43 minute record released in 2013, it's been a while hasn't it? That closer is called "Release The Diety" and like the short intro track that opens this record this starts with some beautiful sounding guitar melodies in atmosphere before the vocals arrive pretty much speaking the lyrics. A lot of that on here, telling the story. I just get tired of this vocal style, despite being a big Rosvold fan. I live for those heavy outbreaks on this record. They are a rare thing. That first long song "The Grand Facade" which is track 3 does the trick after 6 minutes. Some heaviness on "Persistence Of Visions" a 9 minute piece. And later on on that long closer as well. I'm all for contrasting sounds but this dwells in the atmosphere with spoken words far too often for my tastes.

I'll stick with their debut "DeEvolution" from 2011 thankyou. And fingers crossed that this trilogy gets done one day.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Epic Forest by RARE BIRD album cover Studio Album, 1972
3.48 | 95 ratings

BUY
Epic Forest
Rare Bird Crossover Prog

Review by BradJShaw

5 stars I would have to disagree with some reviewers here regarding Epic Forest. I have several Rare Bird albums, and my opinion is that this is their best. Back in the 70's a member of one of the bands I was in discovered this album and shared it with all of us. We loved it so much that we ended up playing two of the songs off this album several times live. That is actually saying a lot, in that at that time we were mostly covering southern rock...no progressive songs. I remember wearing the album out basically, even though I had a pretty great sound system at the time. I would have to go to my local music store and sift through an immense record catalog to find it and special order it. Nowadays it's pretty easy to find on eBay. Unlike their other albums, I find this to be a cover to cover album. I can start one side and listen all the way to the end of the other side. Being a guitarist, I can appreciate the licks. Also having an appreciation for melodic things, I can appreciate the intricate melodies and harmonies. I'm thinking that maybe some reviewers are put off by some of the sentimentality of a few of the tracks. Personally, I just enjoy the melodic nature of them. Some listeners may be put off by a few lyrics that seem nonsensical, but nearly every progressive rock band has a few of those. (Yes comes to mind specifically) In closing, I am quite serious about my rating. I have never purchased as many copies of a single album as much as this one...mostly due to the vinyl wearing out!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Argus by WISHBONE ASH album cover Studio Album, 1972
4.23 | 834 ratings

BUY
Argus
Wishbone Ash Prog Related

Review by PapaPork

1 stars This is one of those albums that has no reason at all getting the amount of praise that it does. I've tried it a few times and its just very average music. There isn't anything that is remarkable or even good. This is not Wishbone's best album, or even top five material. I've tormented myself with "Locked In" and this one is closer to that one than it is to "Four" or "Pilgrimage". I am trying to remember a melody or passage from this album, but I just can't seem to do so. Its just so uninspired and really doesn't go anywhere. If you were to pick up this album and had no idea who this band is, I would wager that most would turn it off by the end of track two.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Perspective by MILLER, RICK album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.93 | 21 ratings

BUY
Perspective
Rick Miller Crossover Prog

Review by tszirmay
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars My fellow Canadian is quite the prolific musician, presenting releases since 1984, kicking off with "Starsong" but his finest trait remains his consistently adamant and rebelliously unapologetic desire to maintain his stylistic preference and not bend to any outside pressure in having to forge bold new horizons. A rogue prog composer who sticks to his roots is fine with me! Personally , I am completely addicted to his art, just as I continue to enjoy consuming large doses of longtime favorites like cheese, chocolate and wine. Why should I deny my tastes buds more pleasure ? "Perspective" is his 19 album and is just another brilliant sonic adventure with all his usual collaborators on board for the ride. Rick has proffered a darker complexion to his craft, perhaps a sign of the current angst-laden times, where media-fueled truth is just another unresearched opinion begging for followers and maybe even a few likes, desperate for some sense of control . This narrative is clearly enunciated on the rhythmically dystopic "False Prophets", a mesmerizing thumper that takes its sweet time in developing a long line of cling-clang percolations, ominously close to imprinting a sense of doom or ,at the very least, disbelief in any form of conventional 'leadership', where nothing is explained properly or even researched, just platitudes bandied about like internet candy. The Barry Haggarty lead guitar shines like a crazy diamond, unafraid to cry in despair as Rick ruminates on the human condition. Will pounds his skins with indomitable impunity, urging on 'the piety on bended knee' evoked on the microphone.

"My Avalon" searches for the inner lantern that flickers albeit gingerly, the guide towards an inevitable fate that shows no preference towards rich or poor, powerful or weak. The gorgeous melody is stirring, a forlorn lament that seemingly has never faded since the dawn of time. What finer instrument than the Mateusz Swoboda cello to underline the plight of every birth , the lead guitar taking over with its usual extemporaneous euphoria, a gloriously effective track.

A moment of reverential simplicity in song, "The Path" displays a Moody Blues-like serenity, lead and backing choir describing 'a destiny lost, a lifetime too late' , the swirling lead guitar engraved on the tombstone that awaits further along the way, patiently awaiting the inevitable outcome of a life well lived, though with many regrets , the cello holding the hand of fate until the final silence.

The majestic centrepiece on this album is "An Ordinary Man", a typical Miller epic that fluctuates gently with immense restraint, choir orchestrations and flute being a perfect combination as it encapsulates the symphonic quality of the arrangement. Kane Miller's acoustic guitar and Rick's heartfelt vocal combine to roll out the red velvet synth carpet, infusing the ardent theme with profound intensity. An instrumental section portrays the shadow filled dreams expressed , a blistering fretboard salvo scouring the sky above, before returning to the thematic melody once again, for good measure. Voice effects, urban chaos, tingling threads of light, all the creature comforts for those who fear solitude and who believe they will inherit the earth. The extended bluesy solo contains a fair amount of grieving sizzle, a welcome expression of the turbulent nature of life , unrelenting and obsessive , occasionally deeply unjust but so is fate. A classic in the Miller canon for eternity.

Exploring Middle Eastern influences is also a Miller trait, the instrumental "The Prisoner of Uqbar" evoking the sweeping grandeur of forever shifting dunes, distant sandstorms, a yearning for some mirage-induced oasis, the slow-gait of the caravanserai as it leads seemingly nowhere, the obligatory cobra-exciting flute amid hand drums and sundry percussives that enhance the aura of the souk.

A more conventional ballad with the slightest hint of the Crimson King's Epitaph , "When Night Meets Day" is similarly crushingly attractive, heartfelt and ornate piece that seeks only to appease the senses, delighting in harmony and expression. 'In the twilight, choices are made' is a revelation of a truism that escapes those who sleep through the night, unaware and untroubled.

Like being held captive "Inside the Dream", the reverie-like lilt takes on a glittering variety of impressions that have no rhyme or reason (or so we are led to believe ) when in fact, the truth often lies there in complete isolation from the daily routine. The elegant piano joins in with the sombre cello in peaceful bliss, flirting with past memories and envisioning future expectations, a torrid electric guitar stretching the envelope of time and space, until the next reality checkpoint is reached.

Offering a tongue in cheek finale as a pseudo-horror movie mini soundtrack, a murky insanity creeps in with "She's Alive!" , with as clever lyrics as one will encounter in 2025 , : 'her skin is made out of plastic, her bones are made out of clay . Her brain I bought on Ebay'. Evoking the classic " The Bride of Frankenstein" with Gene Wilder (1974) but with a modern soundtrack of clicking licks, hostile beats, whispering vocals, and yet an accessible main theme, this quirky piece comes as a novelty to the unexpectant listener. I would be inclined to add this to some Bauhaus/Peter Murphy track on an imaginary radio show , as a spooky attempt to offer trick instead of treat for a change. She is definitely alive.

Another utterly enjoyable chapter in an illustrious career, to go with the creamy Camembert, the impeccable Amarone and some Leonidas Belgian chocolats .

4.5 Viewpoints

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Sum of No Evil by FLOWER KINGS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2007
3.83 | 648 ratings

BUY
The Sum of No Evil
The Flower Kings Symphonic Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars The Flower Kings' tenth studio album happens to be one of their most adventurous, captivating, dynamic and front-to-back relentless works of theirs, a 75-minute-long album contained just within six tracks, 'The Sum of No Evil' from 2007 is a gorgeous and expansive symphonic prog record full of bold and unexpected turns, strong melodies and overall excellent, soulful playing; briefly put, here are all the elements of a TFK album delivering all the goods, in spades. Narrowing things down to a single-disc set (in contemporary terms) seems to have allowed the band to organize a rather focused work, and a surprisingly accessible one, too, thanks to the myriad of fantastic and highly memorable hooks and melodies. Needless to say, Stolt's guitar work here is driven and flamboyant, with the experienced Swedish axe-man delivering some of the most delightful and appealing riffs of the entire back catalogue of the The Flower Kings.

The opening scene here is the uplifting and "flowery" 'One More Time', a longer piece that features prominent lush instrumentation all over, some really fine singing, and beautiful build-ups, definitely a nod to good ol' Genesis. This is followed by the centerpiece of the album, the 24-minute suite 'Love is the Only Answer', a virtually perfect long epic from The Flower Kings, a multi-part song with tons of unexpected twists and turns, incredible arrangements, strong licks and some emotive playing. This might as well be the perfect representation of the vivid symphonic rock style of the band, it has both the pace, the grit and the atmosphere of some of the most inspiring prog epics of the genre's classic era. A trippy and elegiac shorter piece comes up next in the face of 'Trading My Soul', after which we get another very powerful longer song, 'The Sum of No Reason', a slightly darker but no less impressive piece that definitely hints at a possible future itinerary for the band (thinking of 'Banks of Eden' and 'Desolation Rose'). An excellent and avant-garde instrumental gives way to the sixth and final song off the album, 'Life in Motion', a more upbeat and pastoral trip that dares to close off the work on a high note. The entire album is nothing short of excellent, and while one might "devise" minute flaws here and there, with the song lengths and some of the arrangements coming up as challenging, this is an eclectic and rewarding listen that keeps you acutely interested in what's going on all throughout.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 GAPVIS by BUHLMANN, ROLAND album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.00 | 3 ratings

BUY
GAPVIS
Roland Buhlmann Crossover Prog

Review by tszirmay
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars Looking up into the prog galaxy, there are so many shining stars to marvel at, some are blazing comets, here today and gone the next, amid colossal planets that majestically maintain their orbit and on occasion, we discover a scintillating pulsar that emits radio waves at regular intervals, transmitting pulsating messages for all to contemplate. That is how I envision this unique artist from that enchanted alpine land, who is now up to his seventh album, each one a marvel of distinctive experimental content that still proposes lush melodic explorations that pleases the ear, challenges the senses and ultimately, soothes the soul. "Gapvis" is the anagram of the first letter of each track, clever!

The scene is set with a reflective sonic mirror of legitimacy on "Genuine", an absorbing incursion into gentle collisions, nothing too strident, yet nevertheless audacious, galvanized by a blazing solo that sears one moment and soars the next. Delving into the deepest form of introspective exploration, the nearly 11-minute-long expanse on "Autistic" comes across as a boundary challenging exercise, where mechanical electric threads are garnished with Middle Eastern acoustic accoutrements, sliding in brief clusters of buzzsaw tactics, a bellicose bass rumble and a definite impression of beyond the norm intensity that rewards the inquisitive listener. At times resolutely illuminating as well as veering into cacophonic domains that boggle the mind, nothing is ever gratuitous or perfunctory. Relaxed horizons appear on the diaphanous "Perception", a subtle track that imposes an elusive sense of hypnosis, inexorably expanding in intensity when required. There is a crystalline, almost Kraftwerk-like mechanism at play, perhaps within all the clanging percussion and twanging guitar motifs, a soldering lead guitar solo that caps the seal.

Another epic piece that stretches beyond the 10-minute mark, "Views" is harder-edged, at times infected and unwavering, much like the rabidly opinionated world we currently live in. The layered guitar incision is like one more red nightmare to deal with, a wake-up call that shows a wide variety of shifting moods, namely the brilliantly plucked acoustic section. The thrill deviates into quite an agitated sonic cataclysm, a whirlwind of colliding notes and collapsing shifts that keep the listener on its toes. This really pushes the envelope further into the unheard and unknown.

Clattering along the internal pathway that leads to the "Inside", the inspiration stretches beyond the pale, with a dedication to softly aggressive meditation, echoing deeply into the caverns of one's soul. Shimmering flurries, glittering sprinkles and simmering soundscapes combine to fling the piece into an inner world that each person will interpret as they wish. A corkscrew guitar vortex ends the process.

Kalimba and oblique guitar ruminations unite on "Secrets", an obsessive journey shrouded in complex rhythmic interjections, percussive percolations in abundance, and a resounding sense of controlled desperation that impresses beyond mere words. There is zero predictability displayed , nothing leisurely vapid or ambient, relentless enticing , created and played by a most original artist who defies comparisons.

Roland dedicates this album to the Swiss diplomat Carl Lutz, who saved 62,000 Hungarian Jewish lives during WW2 in Budapest where he was serving at the time, in concert with the famous Raoul Wallenberg.

4.5 daunting encounters

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Sky 2 by SKY album cover Studio Album, 1980
3.84 | 119 ratings

BUY
Sky 2
Sky Eclectic Prog

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Of the two Sky albums featuring co-founder Francis Monkman, Sky 2 has the edge - there's a few moments of additional bite which help maintain at least some connection to rock music, and the compositional approach is a touch more varied, with moments ranging from an update of "Vivaldi" (a classical adaptation from Monkman's former berth in Curved Air) to a touch of instrumental comedy in the form of Tuba Smarties to the accomplished side-long piece Fifo. Most of all, there's a bit more emotion on display. The band would take a different trajectory after Monkman left, but as a capstone to his era with the group it's very good.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Drum 'N' Voice Vol. 3 by COBHAM, BILLY album cover Studio Album, 2010
3.82 | 12 ratings

BUY
Drum 'N' Voice Vol. 3
Billy Cobham Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Another go at the Milano-based collaborations with Nicolosi family and a whole bunch of all-star guests. Fasten your seat belts: Billy is on fire; a funk rampage!

1. "Electric Man" (7:06) great Jazz-Rock Fusion led by Rossana and Billy's hard-driving rhythm track while Lino and Pino provide rich support (with some awesome Jan Hammer-like synth riffing from Pino), but it's Brian Auger's spirited performance on Hammond and Fender Rhodes throughout that provides many of the song's highlights. Nice to hear Brian still at the top of his game (Billy, too!)! (13.75/15) 2. "Alive" (5:14) Chaka Khan and Dora Nicolosi singing together, side-by-side! Pinch me cuz I must be dreaming. Both ladies are given multiple tracks to form a pretty awesome choir effect to the vocals, start to finish, but it's really Chaka's song: her voices and stylings given far more prominence than those of Dora. The foundational music is pretty basic Jazzy-R&B with some truly excellent rhythm guitar work from Lino and some awesome keyboard support (and soloing) from Pino on both Fender Rhodes and Hammond. Such great sound engineering from the Nicolosi Brothers! (9/10)

3. "Roller" (8:24) George Duke and Bob Mintzer are the featured artists on this truly funky ride on which Billy really lays down some extraordinary chops! Matter of fact, this is one of the few songs I've ever heard on which Rossana's bass playing doesn't seem to "fit": it's really 100% Billy creating and holding down the funk! George and Bob pretty much spend the first two minutes repeating and reinforcing the same melodies, playing in tandem without even creating any harmonies. George's Nord synth soars and dives like a firecracker in his solo in the fourth minute while Pino holds down the mid-range with his Fender Rhodes. Bob finally gets a nice, long solo in the fifth and sixth minutes--with the band transitioning into a kind of cool bounce-rhythm in that sixth minute--which serves to amplify attention to Billy's amazing drumming (and give Rosanna a little space in which to inject some of her own creative flourishes). Not annoying, but I'm not really much of a fan of this sax soloist's style--nor of the "bounce-rhythm"--especially when they're both extended over four minutes! With only a fadeout saving us from having to endure more. Were it not for the light it gives to hear/study Billy's playing, it would be a real yawner. (17.5/20)

4. "We The People" (5:34) Gino Vannelli! (One of my all-time favorite vocalists and music creators.) At first his voice sounds more like Simply Red's Mick Hucknal, but then, with the arrival of the first chorus, we finally find Gino breaking into his disctinctively forceful and exclusively unique sound. Solid song on which one of Jazz-Rock Fusion's great vocal masters shows why he is revered the way he is--and should be! (8.875/10)

5. "Destiny" (6:47) with Alex Acuņa stepping in to help out in the percussion department, and guest John Scofield generating the odd lead sounds from his electric guitar, we're off to another great start to another great funky jazz track. Billy and Rossana are back in true sync--with additional help from a percussive synth bass and some of Pino and Lino's other tricks as well another awesome contribution from Brian Auger. The tit-for-tat duel of Scofield and Auger is without doubt the highlight feature here but one cannot (should never) discount the allure and magical properties of the rest of the music being created by Billy and the Nicolosi family. (13.5/15)

6. "I'd Like To Change" (5:04) Dora Nicolosi on the lead vocal, people! Given a great tune by her brothers, great groove from Billy, Rossana, and Pino, the performances are all supendous--especially Lino's surprise jazz guitar flourishes in the third minutes--but neither the basic chord progression nor the melodies given/offered by Dora are A-list "hookers." As a matter of fact, my absolute favorite parts of the song are A) Lino's afore-mentioned solo, B) the Vannelli Brothers-like "C" sectino in the instrumental fourth minute, and C) Pino's wonderful Hammond play throughout. (8.875/10)

7. "Dreamer" (4:24) another song that makes me fear that the Nicolosi Brothers are losing their magical grip on earworms: that they're choosing to employ more cerebral chord and melody progressions, inadvertantly sacrificing the pleasant hooks for the sake of funkiness. Plus, the presence of another innocuous sax lead just gives me DAVE SANBORN heebeejeebees. (I got so burned out on the David Sanborn, Najee, Kenny G sax sound phenomena back in the 80s!) Still, this song offers more GREAT performances from Billy and Pino. (8.875/10)

8. "Route" (4:48) a hard-driving synth-led tune that reminds me of Boney M and Rick Braun's "Chain Reaction." The lead/solo keyboard, bass, and electric guitar performances on this song are so high-quality that I find myself constantly checking and re-checking to see which guests are providing which instruments, but IT'S ENTIRELY DUE TO THE NICOLOSI's! (and Billy). (9.5/10)

9. "Stratus" (6:30) from the opening bass and drum line the listener is reminded of why this song is one of Jazz-Rock Fusion's greatest/most iconic songs ever. Anyone who gets to play on this one must feel the goosebumps of feeling "I'm playing 'Stratus'! with THE Billy Cobham!" GREAT bass play (and sound) from Rossana. GREAT synth contributions from Bob Mintzer. PERFECT keyboard playing from Pino Nicolosi and absolutely STUNNING/amazing lead guitar work from Lino. It's almost like you can't go wrong playing any version of this amazing song! And then, of course, you get the Master, the song's composer, breaking loose at the very end to remind us why this song, this drummer, and this man is considered one of THE absolute greatest of the Greats. (10/10)

Total time 53:51

Overall, the impression Vol. 3 of the Drum 'N' Voice collaborations is slightly disappointing to me. This is due, as pointed out above, to the Nicolosi Brothers' abandonment of easy/smooth melodies and chord structures for the sake of funking up the funk to the absolute funkiest funk they can mathematically conceive. Call me a sap, but I prefer the pleasing smooth side of Jazz-Funk: that's the music I can put on speakers to loop over and over all day long.

A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of Jazz-Funk that gets it's high marks from three great songs--one of which is a cover/remake of one of Billy's iconic classic tunes.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Drum 'N' Voice 2 by COBHAM, BILLY album cover Studio Album, 2006
4.69 | 7 ratings

BUY
Drum 'N' Voice 2
Billy Cobham Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars The collaboration between one of Jazz-Rock Fusion's most loyal and iconic founders and Milano's Nicolosi family continues. The list of guests appearing here arouse high expectations of more serious Jazz-Rock Fusion.

1. "Waveform" (5:04) all synth work, including the bass and programming, reminding me of the spirit of late 70s-early 80s techno-devourer Herbie Hancock. (8.875/10)

2. "Real Funk" (4:36) actually, funked up blues. Excellent blues-jazz guitar from Frank Gambale. Buddy Miles' vocal is okay--nothing extraordinary. (8.75/10)

3. "Running" (7:45) rich Fender Rhodes play from Pino with yet another amazing bass line from sister Rossana. Drums join in opening up the way for Lino's excellent electric guitar work. Billy's just holding time with rock solid tenacity. Great jam; feels a bit like a cross between music behind Al Jarreau and Narada Michael Walden though a step or two up in term of funkiness. Pino's keyboard synth work in the second half is as extraordinary as his brother is on guitar. What a perfect pair! No wonder they're such amazing songwriters! And their prowess only seems to grow the longer the song goes on (even when guitarist Lino Nicolosi shows off his rather exceptional percussion chops in the final minute)! (13.625/15)

4. "Final Destination" (6:53) not quite up to the level of the previous tunes, it takes the arrival of the horns in the second half of the second minute to really get things off the ground, then the interplay between Billy, Rossana and Marco Fadda really begins to shine. (13.375/15)

5. "One More Day To Live" (5:13) virtuoso acoustic guitarist Dominic Miller opens this song before the Nicolosi family join in, setting up a nice bed for vocalist Mike Lindup to lay his vocal in. He's got a nice voice--one that reminds me of Hall & Oates and England Dan & John Ford Coley--but not quite top tier material. Still a nice tune--not disappointing or detracting from the overall vibe of the album. Dominic doesn't really get much spotlight, but I guess that's okay. (8.875/10)

6. "Ozone Part. 1" (2:12) Billy attacks this song (a drum solo) with some new ideas and continued fervor. I am impressed. (5/5) 7. "Ozone Part. 2" (6:28) taking the previous song's ideas and putting it to music with the help of Novecento, Jeff Berlin, Jan Hammer, Dominic Miller (on gorgeous electric guitar), and Airto Moriera. Incredible Jazz-Rock Fusion of the old style! The presence of these old pals really pushes Billy to reach for heights we don't hear from him as often as we did in 1971-73. (9.667/10)

8. "Take Seven" (6:01) again Billy showing much more than time keeping, this bouncy rondo of Jazz-Rock Fusion turns a little smoother when the intro ends and Pino's Fender Rhodes gets singled out for the lead, but then it wavers back into J-R F territory. Rossana's thick bass sound is awesome at the very lowest end of the scale, and the horn accents are trčs important. Solos from guitar and, of course, John Patucci's bass are great, neither lasting too long before the band returns to the main riff. Michele Carrabba gets the next solo--one of the longest ones (with Patucci)--while Pino's Fender and the funk rhythm section holds full and solid from beneath. And then, sadly, the song is faded out. Too bad! Great groove with some truly stellar drumming exhibited from the Master. Dora Nicolosi is listed as a vocalist on this one (which is something I've grown to look forward to very much) but it's, unfortunately, only in a capacity as a melody supporter with her wordless vocalese. (9.25/10)

9. "Let Me Breathe" (4:23) great groove setting up a wonderful song for the exquisite voice and vocal performance of Dora Nicolosi. Awesome bass, drum, keys, and rhythm guitar accents, but also Guy Barker's flugelhorn solo in the fourth minute. Another song that fades out far too early for my liking. So smooth and enjoyable! A real earworm that carries on long after the song has ended. (9.25/10)

10. "Amazon" (2:11) a drum and percussion duet between Billy and Airto, two long-time buds. Airto's percussive wordless vocalese is like another percussionist in the conversation. (4.625/5)

Total time 51:03

The difference in this album from the previous Drum 'N' Voice collaboration with the Nicolosi family and other friends is in the display of much more of Billy's extraordinary skills--and far more ventures into the more sophisticated and complex realms of peak era Jazz-Rock Fusion--whereas the first Drum 'N' Voice seemed far more oriented toward melodic pop Jazz-Funk on which Billy was primarily a rock-solid time keeper.

A-/five stars; another minor masterpiece of melodic, often grooving Jazz-Rock Fusion.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Metropolis Part 2 - Scenes from a Memory by DREAM THEATER album cover Studio Album, 1999
4.32 | 3337 ratings

BUY
Metropolis Part 2 - Scenes from a Memory
Dream Theater Progressive Metal

Review by Alxrm

4 stars Once again a member change: Derek Sherinian out, Jordan Rudess in, although this time I don't think many people wondered who this guy was because most of us were already familiar with the Liquid Tension Experiment project. Aside that, we had already read at interviews that there was a second part for Metropolis - "The Miracle and the Sleeper" somewhere lying around and it would see the light of day soon. That day had come and I don't think I am exaggerating in the slightest by saying that all Dream Theater fans were scratching puzzled our head when we were reading statements where the band members were informing us that they had to put in a lot of practice to deliver their parts - honestly, how much more technical could they get? We had our answers when we took hold of our copy of the new album.

Pretty much like Awake and Falling Into Infinity I wasn't immediately won over and also pretty much like the aforementioned albums I came to love it, too. Nevertheless, to my personal taste it isn't as perfect as the other two because on Beyond This Life Petrucci and Rudess solo way too long and also I always skip The Spirit Carries On, I find it boring no end, whereas on Images... and Awake there isn't a single note to spare. Other than that, Metropolis pt.2 has won deservedly a place in the pantheon of the best prog metal albums ever, with Home/The Dance of Eternity as the pick of the bunch. It would be interesting to know if this album was mainly responsible for bringing Prog Metal to the fore, but the only certainty is that it sent all budding musicians practicing endless hours honing their chops (most of the times at the expense of quality music, I might add). Personally, after this album my interest for the band began to decline until it disappeared completely. Jordan Rudess is a formidable and out-of-this-world keybordist, but musically he never captivated me as Kevin Moore or Derek Sherinian did. Also the sound of the band became significantly heavier, a fact that contributed generously to the rising of Dream Theater as a prime force since the audience there is wider compared to that of progrssive rock.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Daughter of Darkness by NATURAL SNOW BUILDINGS album cover Studio Album, 2009
4.27 | 6 ratings

BUY
Daughter of Darkness
Natural Snow Buildings Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Captain Midnight

4 stars I can't believe I ignored this for so long. This album is as beautiful as it is weird but don't go into this with the mindset being this is "just another Post Rock album" maybe lie down and close your eyes and imagine your own imagery while the music plays. I should also mention to listen to this album in multiple sessions as the runtime is seven hours with songs spanning from ten to thirty minutes. But who is this album for? There's elements of Post Rock here but I'd say this is more adjacent to an Indo/Raga Rock album with Post Rock like soundscapes, and I should mention this is more like....Post Folk? I've definitely seen it labeled as Avant Folk but this here is something else. One could argue the album can get "samey" but there's some tracks on here that i can only just admire in awe. Devil's Fork and Curare are two highlights for me, I feel like they exemplify the albums acid folk and even psychedelic sound. Its hard to pinpoint this album so I definitely recommend it for anyone who wants music that not only breaks boundaries but also plays by its own rules

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Trust Us by MOTORPSYCHO album cover Studio Album, 1998
3.98 | 125 ratings

BUY
Trust Us
Motorpsycho Eclectic Prog

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars "Trust Us" is the sixth full-length studio album by Norwegian alternative/psychedelic rock act Motorpsycho. The album was released through Stickman Records (Europe)/Sony Music (Norway) in March 1998. It´s the successor to "Angels and Daemons at Play" from February 1997, so there is just over a year between the two album releases. Despite the relatively short time between the two albums, Motorpsycho have had time to write and record material enough to release a double album, featuring over 80 minutes of music. Trygve Seim (reindeer antler, flutes, saxophone, clarophone) has been added to the list of guest/sesson musicians, but the core of the band is still Bent Sæther ( vocals, bass, guitars, piano, percussion, harmonium, marimba, vibraphone, trident, mellotron, sitar, taurus, drums), Hans Magnus Ryan (guitars, vocals, mandolin, harmonium, rhodes piano, taurus, mellotron, piano, bells), and Håkon Gebhardt (drums, acoustic guitar, glockenspiel, mellotron, harmonium, percussion).

Stylistically the material on "Trust Us" pretty much continues the alternative rock/psychedelic rock style of "Angels and Daemons at Play (1997)". Sometimes a little more psychedelic and jam oriented than other moments which are more structured. Motorpsycho are a well playing unit and they obviously master both the improvised jamming and the more conscise songwriting parts. But when that is established the vocals have always been the weak link of Motorpsycho and they continue to be that on "Trust Us". Not in a manner which destroys the listening experience, but they do sound weak and it often feels like they are just there singing without a recognisable vocal melody. So maybe it´s not just that the voices of the two vocalists aren´t that strong or distinct sounding, but maybe also that the band just don´t write that great vocal melodies.

With that out of the way, Motorpsycho should still be praised for their organinic and powerful instrumental performances. "Trust Us" is also a well produced release, so it´s in the songwriting department that Motorpsycho are still lacking something at this point in their career. Six albums into a music career and I expect more, but I understand why others enjoy it more than I do. The combination of 90s alternative/indie rock with 70s psychedelia has been done by many other contemporary artists (The Flaming Lips, Mercury Rev, and some of Radioheads early recordings are valid references) and it´s just a hard sound to nail.

"Vortex Surfer" is the most well known track from "Trust Us" and I agree that it´s slow layer building is effective, but the weak vocals almost ruin the track. Upon conclusion "Trust Us" is a good quality rock album from Motorpsycho if you (unlike me) are able to appreciate the vocals. I´ll play nice and give this a 3 star (60%) rating, but but you can add 0,5 star ekstra if you imagine that I could enjoy the vocals.

(Originally posted on Metal Music Archives).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Dawn of Oberon by TUSMØRKE album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.89 | 27 ratings

BUY
Dawn of Oberon
Tusmørke Prog Folk

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars TUSMORKE are back with their eleventh studio album called "Dawn Of Oberon". Released in 2024 they are essentially a four piece of bass/vocals, flute, drums and keyboards on this one. The leader Benediktator besides playing bass and singing is credited with a list of instruments as long as my left leg. There are so many flavours of sound on this record. And of course the lyrics are about fairies and their king Oberon. Lots of mellotron and chirping birds. The organ is very active as well, and upfront bass. Yes! And there's plenty of flute and piano.

This was released by Karisma Records. That fourth track on the back of the cd is shown as being 7:78 long. Norway time is longer? Okay an error. They thank a lot of other bands including ACTIONFREDAG, CHRONICLES OF FATHER ROBIN, JORDSJO, WOBBLER and NEEDLEPOINT. I have their debut and this their latest and that's it! I do prefer the debut from 2012, it's more folky and uniform. It will be part of my "best of" Folk list when I get to that.

This 2024 release has it all if your a Prog fan. It's adventerous and fun. Lots of wordless vocals too. They don't take themselves very seriously. I mean to sing "Born to be mild" to that same melody as "Born to be wild" is something. They make children's albums and I feel that comes through here at times. And again keep in mind this is a concept album about the king of the fairies. Funny, my favourite track is the one that is 7:78 in length. Okay 7:58 is what my stereo shows when it ends. That opening bass line as the organ comes in dancing along with vocals is a great start. The birds are chirping and the mellotron is flowing on this one.

I have to mention the opening title track at almost 18 minutes. It embodies so much that we all love about prog. The repeated themes and the instrumental excursions are well done. Lots of flute and organ as well here. I like the vocals a lot on this one. Reminds me of their debut. We get synths standing out on the closer along with those wordless vocals I like. You can almost smell the forests of Norway when listening to this record. A very brown and green recording that creates a woodsy atmosphere.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Anima Animus by CELESTE album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.82 | 3 ratings

BUY
Anima Animus
Celeste Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by tszirmay
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars This group from San Remo has a great story to tell, formed in 1972 and releasing the legendary classic Il Principe del Giorno, with its effusive mellotron-painted landscapes, garnering rave reviews and cult status in the process. They disbanded in 1977, reformed briefly in 1991-1992 for two middling albums that fared poorly in comparison to their debut and promptly vanished from the scene. Drummer and keyboardist Ciro Perrino went on to reboot Celeste in 2019 with "Il Risveglio del Principe", a well-received return to past glories that kickstarted a series of releases such as "Il Principe del Regno Perduto" a year later. With the stunning 2022 album "Celestial Symphony Orchestra" , this stellar band kept raising the bar until achieving the impossible, surpassing their debut with the thundering beauty of last year's "Echi di Un Futuro Passato", one of my top choices for that year. It must be stated that the solid new crew of deft drummer Enzo Cioffi, Francesco Bertone on athletic bass and Mauro Vero on assorted guitars keep the pace tightly majestic but where the biggest 'leap forward' is to be found, lies in the important addition of flutes, recorders and saxophones , courtesy of Marco Moro, thus daubing a jazzier element that is simply, well, celestial! Throughout their career, the explosive mellotron reigned supreme and thankfully, it still shines brightly throughout all the arrangements on this new album "Anima Animus", the jazzier component further elevated with add brass guests on trombone, bass tuba, clarinet and , yes, more sax! Ciro mans the keyboard arsenal, not only the fabled white monster but also mythical instruments like the Solina string Ensemble and Eminent synths, made famous among countless others by Pink Floyd. Throw in an ARP 2600, Oberheim OBA and EMS AKS synthesizers and the deal is done.

The title track ignites the shimmering mellotron lantern, as if to remind us that what began once long ago has never left. Acoustic guitar, piano, bass and drums all playfully gather around the brisk atmosphere, where the delicately pastoral flute expands the aura with an elegant buildup towards a gigantic melody, symphonic prog at its finest. This wealth of serenity is the ideal platform for extended solos from the elegant piano (Marco Canepa) and delirious saxophone forays from Mirco Rebaudo and Paolo Maffei. The outro reaches into experimental realms where a vaporous tone shows the door to heaven.

Technically robust, the bold and brazen delivery on "Roots and Leaves" has an incredible pulse, with a slight hint of that Jason Bourne soundtrack melody, the bouncy piano careening delicately with the choppy percussives, the rolling bass keeping the tires adhering to the tarmac, steered by the vivid flute racing into the twilight, like a prancing black horse on a speed mission. The turbo charged sax backfiring until the mellotron sweeps in to take the checkered flag.

Percolating syncopation introduces the next chapter, the appropriately titled "Cosmic Carnival", an intoxicating festival of beats, guided by an up-front and to die for elastic bass line, twinkling piano and the airy brass and flute needed to keep the groove going. The piano takes the center stage as it carves the main melody with razor sharp precision, in alliance with the delirious flute for a brief interlude, before reverting to the previous shuffle. That bewitching bass is just pure sorcery and when the clarinet makes its appearance, what a sound to behold! Prog jazz symphonic prog, a new label is born.

The 9 minutes of "De Rerum Natura" harkens back to more orchestral backdrops, a carefully crafted pastoral composition that sits clearly in a more keyboard-centric classical vein, the bucolic main theme emerging after a long gestation period. The rhythmic sidebar is stately, there only to punctuate and underline, with a flurry of crashing cymbals. The theme returns for another reminder, a soothing piece of music that relocates the mind to another level.

Singer Ines Aliprandi takes out the microphone on the seductive "Lilith", an impressive scat-vocal that interferes perfectly with the space warble of colliding synthesizer cascades, a cosmic voyage that is sliced open with a thunderous lead guitar solo from Mauro Vero, and an equally abundant brass interplay that reaches back in time to some garden in Eden.

Back to the land of percussive puzzlement on "El Mundo Perdido", a rhythmic world of exotic sounds and lush soundscapes, featuring delicate 12 string guitars (Davide Mocini) and more vocalizations from Ines, a sublime bass interference with 'mellotronic' backdrop that adds intensity as well as beauty to the sound palette, and an overall sense of a tranquil journey in a lost world. The echoing choir effects are dazzling. 'Doobie-doobie-do' vocal on "Secret Crime" is nothing short of tongue in cheek humour in lieu of the title, a trait that characterizes the Italian culture, as it was never a country but rather will always be a grand theatre, as my grandfather once taught me. The Bertone bass highlights the lighthearted dolce vita mindset, the Cioffi drums roll like an Aperol Spritz down the gullet on a hot day.

Closing out with a marathon piece is always the right way to go, "Moon and Cloud Dancing" will take the listener on a dozen minutes of seriously pretty music, starting off as a flute and piano duet, all delicacy and flutter, the core theme leaping out and caressing the soul, acoustic guitars adding to the mellifluous luxuriance. The piano highlights the positive vibe, a most welcome delight, a serene lullaby to reflect on the beautiful things that life has to offer. Halfway through, the torrential string mellotron waves enter the fray, raising the atmosphere to heavenly heights, the operatic vocalizations appear once again and the flute signifies the eventual farewell as the night arrives, both the stars and the vapours enlaced in a tight and loving embrace, waiting for the sun to rise again.

Another fascinating chapter in this storied career, unafraid to endlessly evolve into new sonic regions, while maintaining their dedication to elegant symphonic prog undertakings. Intelligent, thoughtful, and eternally pleasing panacea for the tired 21st century mind , just plain gorgeous music.

5 peaceful souls

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Dominion by IQ album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.15 | 172 ratings

BUY
Dominion
IQ Neo-Prog

Review by alainPP

3 stars IQ, one of the founding fathers of the neo-prog movement, combines different styles and continues to fuel the '80s neo flame.

"The Unknown Door" opens symphonically, like "2001," with solemn trumpets; a typical Chamberlain narrative on the neo keyboard. Four minutes of takeoff on typical IQ before the first cinematic deluge leans toward "Flash Gordon" at eight minutes, with its Olympian air and heavy riff evolving their sound. A blend of electro, Peter's soft voice, and Michael's sharp guitar make for this track with a Genesis-like metallic prog sound, rather well crafted. The ambient, cinematic, dark, muffled break, distant trumpets, the opening fanfare, the apocalyptic icy cold, and the Floydian acoustics create a meditative calm. The synth has a hint of animalistic Pink Floyd before the cathedral keyboard explosion, in the style of Yes. Michael intervenes again, launching the fourth part, Peter as an angel, Neil as a liberator, and Neil as a Riverside-esque frontman. We feel Marillion for the dithyrambic melancholic finale of this unknown door.

"One of Us" features a folk arpeggio with acoustic guitar for the interlude and Peter's lyrics about a painful relationship. "No Dominion" follows with a symphonic intro drifting through Peter's signature phrasing, a melancholic Welsh poem about the persistence of life. A deep crescendo with Neil in the spotlight, piano and keyboards leading the way, the solemn air with Paul banging as best he can and Michael delivering a monstrous solo, velvety and deep. The outro features a clock ticking back in time, stunning. "Far from Here" with its lullaby, Peter narrating on a somber keyboard and bells in the background; The choruses vibrate, the drums create a menacing air, the crescendo begins with the orchestral part, the keyboards, and the smashing of the pads. It flirts with prog metal, surpassing it with a bloody riff; the electro break sounds modern, rhythmic, and groovy. The Rothery-esque guitar solo and the energetic Banks-esque keyboard burst forth before the angelic return of Peter Anderson for the nostalgic coda. A personal evocation of a dear loss. "Never Land" continues with a shimmering atmospheric keyboard, with Peter and his warm voice guiding the track in two parts; calm, ethereal, bringing us back to a flight to an imaginary island where weightlessness reigns supreme, even though the title is written in two words. The track is full of emotion for the nostalgic finale filled with hope, with rays of sunlight in the distance. The rise stops with the return of the velvety keyboard oozing with melancholy.

IQ made IQ by adding electronic sounds and heavier riffs to surf the 2020s. Powerful atmospheres weaving intense emotional sounds, a distinctive sound keeping the fan on his musical base with a little more keyboards. A follow-up album is already planned, hoping for a small musical advancement because we only have IQ here. Originally on Progcensor. (3.5)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Down to Earth by RAINBOW album cover Studio Album, 1979
2.83 | 227 ratings

BUY
Down to Earth
Rainbow Prog Related

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

3 stars Rainbow's last studio album of the 70s, the generally successful and hard-rocking 'Down to Earth', is an eighth-track LP displaying a more "approachable" and stripped-down sound, compared to the charmingly epic musical world of the Dio era. This August 1979 album also sees the sole appearance of vocalis Graham Bonnet and marks the last work of the band to include Cozy Powell as the main behind the drums. Further shifting the lineup, Blackmore had invited ex-Deep Purple bandmate Roger Clover to take are of all production duties, ultimately playing all the bass parts on the album, with the lineup further completed by the addition of keyboard player Don Airey, currently of Deep Purple. The commercial edge of this then-new Rainbow album takes its toll and unfortunately comes at the expense of the unbridled and epic creativity that had defined the music of the previous iterations of the Blackmore-led group.

What we have here is a guitar- and keyboard-heavy rock with strong melodies and catchy choruses, and despite the overall radio-friendly dimensions of the LP, 'Down to Earth' remains a really solid collection of songs, on which Blackmore shines through as an ingenious riff-craftsman, giving us several of his most recognizable and sharp-edged licks. At the same time, Graham Bonnet's performance is satisfactory, and he impresses as a fine vocalist, nailing all of the hooks this record has to deliver. What this work really misses is the progressive edge that had prevailed on 'Rising' and the debut album, for example; Nevertheless, the music is decent enough and most of the songs do a pretty good job of "delivering the goods" - opener 'All Night Long' is an energetic rocker that sets the tone for the record, 'Eyes of the World' is interesting and somewhat daring, while other songs like 'Makin' Love', 'Love's No Friend' and 'Danger Zone' impress with the gritty Blackmore riffs. Ubiquitous radio hit 'Since You Been Gone' if the fifth track off the album, while 'No Time to Lose' and 'Lost in Hollywood' are pure rubbish, but this, of course, is not a flawless album. Just a fine hard-rocking collection of songs with excellent guitar playing, ballsy vocals, and an enjoyable production style, which renders 'Down to Earth' as lively and organic, as much as it can be.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Clann by SOLSTICE album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.04 | 42 ratings

BUY
Clann
Solstice Neo-Prog

Review by alainPP

3 stars 1 Firefly opens and puts the SOLSTICE sound in the spotlight, soft and marshmallowy with the violin and the female vocals, flirting with South American jazzy sounds; good but lacking in soul. The guitar solo saves the appearance a bit, but I don't see anything new or innovative for this band I had so much hope for. 2 Life Suit, more jazzy soft melodic fusion; a beautiful ballad like in the 80s or 90s, or even the 70s. Yes, I'm thinking of FLEETWOOD MAC; I'm waiting to find that pearl drop to get going. The mid-tempo variation that follows, with the rise of the reverberating guitar solo, saves the notes; I'm starting to doubt the appeal of the novelty. 3 Plunk, with this synth sampled on a trumpet, becomes repetitive before really getting going, bordering on annoying. The heavy guitar solo, yes, I insist, saves the appearance, but you really have to love this nostalgic atmosphere to take off; Redundant and soporific

4 Frippa for its cinematic intro, its energetic vintage keyboard; we repeat the same pattern and the same flaws afterwards, unfortunately; too bluesy-jazzy and the neo-prog I'm still looking for. The folky violin ambiance to melt, yes, but it lacks the momentum. A neo-keyboard solo contradicts me, voiceover again launching the... guitar solo always enjoyable, Andy hasn't lost any of his energy; go for the violin full of Albion. 5 Twin Peaks for the nostalgic vintage moment, where I dive back into their 1992 album! Sweetness, the bucolic enchantment of this genre apart, flirting between folklore and neo-ambience with the best guitar solo on the album, rich, gripping, a bit like IONA in fact. The vocal, with the marshmallowy hints of FLEETWOOD MAC of yesteryear, is interesting but not stimulating enough. The mid-track break is clearly neo, perhaps Matrix-esque. Yes, I want to escape; in short, from hypnotic psychedelic synth to ethereal vocals, I'm finally taking off. It starts again with a light, buzzing pad, a trendy bolero launching the final, overwhelming chorus. Phew, finally, the synth outro really reassures me.

6 Earthsong (Bonus CD) for the rehash of the track "Silent Dance" from the first album. The title track is too sugary and sticks, preventing me from taking off; a consensual tune without spark, far too melodic and predictable, a shame.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Your Wilderness by PINEAPPLE THIEF, THE album cover Studio Album, 2016
3.95 | 359 ratings

BUY
Your Wilderness
The Pineapple Thief Crossover Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars 'Your Wilderness' from 2016 marks a general shift in the musical vocabulary of The Pineapple Thief, with the band experimenting with a silky-smooth production style and a rather minimalist alt-rock approach, developing a recognizable sound that borders on the acoustic, and centers around that elegiac, melancholic atmosphere that we have come to recognize the band for recently. This album also marks the first appearance of Gavin Harrison behind the drum kit, here only as a session musician, with other guests coming from Supertramp and Caravan and working on the clarinet and string arrangement parts of the album. This is an interesting album because it becomes so difficult to categorize it - the prevailing feel is that of melancholy, and the record is quite pensive and monotonous, gentle and atmospheric, almost to the point of having no recognizable or memorable melodies.

Undoubtedly the focus here is on the guitars, the drums and the vocals, and while some of the singing and the arrangements might seem infectious, beautiful and moving (don't forget about the scarce but acute use of the string arrangements as well as the punctuating Mellotron, which is to be heard on several occasions here), 'Your Wilderness' doesn't really deviate at all from the well-known formula of The Pineapple Thief, which kind of renders it less characteristic and less memorable. Yet this remains one of the band's more consistent and accessible albums, objectively considering its strengths, which is arguably why it has been seen as a general success. Notwithstanding, this record has given us some really fine songs, like the desperately astounding opener 'In Exile', the cryptic and semi-acoustic 'No Man's Land', the more eclectic and moodier 'Tear You Up' as well as the enjoyable numbers 'Take Your Shot' and 'Fend for Yourself'. All in all, an improvements in terms of songwriting, production and coherence compared to some of the preceding releases of the band is at place, which makes this an important step towards the magnificent work that is the near-perfect album 'Dissolution'.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Zivjela Jugoslavija by INDEXI album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 1979
2.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Zivjela Jugoslavija
Indexi Crossover Prog

Review by Seyo
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

— First review of this album —
2 stars Starting from 1967, the year it was established, Indexi were regular guests of the Sarajevo pop music festival "Vas slager sezone" (Your Hit of the Season), which they never missed until the release of this single, except in 1974 when Slobodan Bodo Kovacevic and Davorin Popovic were in the army. Therefore, "Vas slager sezone 79" was their 12th appearance at this "light music" event. It was held on April 7, 1979, in the KSC Skenderija hall in Sarajevo, and Indexi performed two compositions that would soon be found on their 24th 7" record overall, or their 11th single released by Diskoton record label. The lineup of Indexi at that time had stabilized with drummer Djordje Kisic and keyboardist Nenad Jurin, along with the standard bass guitarist Fadil Redzic, and the aforementioned duo. When talking about Indexi, the terms disco or punk rarely appear in the same sentence. Yet, although extremely opposed to each other, these two musical styles were very popular during 1979, both abroad and in Yugoslavia (albeit the former declining and the latter just emerging), which certainly did not bypass Indexi, who always listened to what new was happening on the world scene.

The A-side of the single featured a patriotic pop song with a slogan-like title, "Zivjela Jugoslavija" (Long Live Yugoslavia), for which Kemal Monteno wrote the music and lyrics, and Redzic made the arrangement. It was recorded on March 24, 1979. It begins with the strumming rhythms of an acoustic guitar, gradually joined by orchestral strings, vocals, and the rhythm section. Playful keyboards further embellish the sonic picture, and subtle influences of disco music can be felt in the beat pattern and the treatment of the electric guitar, bass, and drums. The lyrics are quite weak and banal, and seem as if they were "commissioned" by the country's political leadership for the purpose of promoting the policy of non-alignment ("Just come, just come/Black brother, white brother/Here a white dove flies to every heart/With a branch of peace"). To avoid any misunderstanding, Indexi were no exception in occasionally performing patriotic songs. On the contrary, it was standard practice during the seventies, and it would be much easier to list the performers of pop and rock music who did not engage in this. However, such songs were too often short-lived, and their artistic reach was usually minimal. Such is the case with this song too. Despite a solid musical performance - with which Indexi won fourth place at the festival - which also featured former band member Ranko Rihtman as the conductor of the RTV Sarajevo Revue Orchestra, "Zivjela Jugoslavija" remains only as an interesting historical reminder of the time in which it was created.

A much better track, however, is on the B-side, which was often the case in Indexi's singles discography. The music and arrangement for "Prazne noci, a beskrajni dani" (Empty Nights, and Endless Days) are the work of Bodo Kovacevic, while the lyrics were written by another former member, Ismet Arnautalic. It was recorded in a Sarajevo studio on March 9th. The instrumental introduction is characterized by a fierce riff on the electric guitar that Bodo employs in a hard rock manner. This extremely catchy and effective sequence was used in the early eighties as the opening theme of a popular music show on Radio Sarajevo. The boogie/rock and roll pattern is also enhanced by the electric organ, which gives the track the "old style" of classic Indexi, while the chorus also shows influences of punk in the way the guitar is played. Bodo's acrobatics with a pick scratch, on the other hand, also evoke the style of "guitar heroes" in the heavy metal genre. Only the funny and long-outdated electronic drum effects, with their high- pitched tones like those from arcade video games, clearly date the track to 1979, when these sound effects, thanks to the market availability of Simmons instruments, were very popular and often used without measure or taste. In any case, it is one of Indexi's rockiest songs in the second half of the seventies, at a time when they were gradually moving away from rock and inevitably falling into oblivion by their previously loyal audience. It is indicative, for example, that in the text summarizing the domestic scene for 1979, published in "Hit strana" of "Politikin zabavnik" youth magazine at the end of December of that year, Indexi were not even mentioned, nor did any of their songs enter the selection of 20 domestic hits. However, in the same magazine, "Prazne noci" managed to enter the top 10 chart of domestic singles during September and October, peaking at the 4th position.

The record was released during the summer of 1979 (the vinyl matrix was cut on July 16th) in a standardized graphic design of the cover, which Diskoton used for a series of single records with hits performed at "Vas slager sezone 79". On a blue background, a photograph of the band is framed to resemble a TV screen, and it shows the current lineup of Indexi. However, the image was taken from an earlier photo session done for the cover of the album "Modra rijeka" (The Blue River), which can be concluded from the somewhat Elton John-esque extravagant dark glasses worn by drummer Kisic. All in all, this single is not among the Indexi's more significant releases, although the B-side song has enough interesting moments, which remind us that even in their most pop mainstream phase, Indexi knew how to dust off energetic rock and roll when they wanted to.

PA rating: 2/5 Personal rating: 3/5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 L'étrange Mr. Whinster by HORRIFIC CHILD album cover Studio Album, 1976
2.58 | 25 ratings

BUY
L'étrange Mr. Whinster
Horrific Child RIO/Avant-Prog

Review by SliprKC70

2 stars This sole studio album by Horrific Child, which was essentially just the French artist Jean-Pierre Massiera going under an alias, originally caught my eye with the awful album cover, and I just had to investigate what it was. After repeated listens, I can say, without a doubt, the album cover isn't the worst thing about this album. It has a generally good idea in terms of where the album wants to go, but it doesn't live up to how it goes there. Normally I would be ok with experimental music, but this album just doesn't do it right. The entire time the record can't decide whether it wants to be avant-prog, a sound collage, or an experimental world album. It goes in so many directions, but the execution is horrible. The inconsistency of how much of each of these varying genres is implemented into the actual passages is also very noticeable. I understand that this was under Massiera's creative freedom, and he wanted to make an experimental record, but there's not much originality on the album because artists had already experimented in these fields and pushed these boundaries decades before this was released. Also, from what I heard, the production was mediocre at best and annoyingly lackluster at worst.

In conclusion, the rating this album already has on Progarchives is pretty good at representing what this album is like. It's truly a shame because Massiera worked on a really impressive album, Atlantide's one and only album (which I reviewed a couple of months ago), and this is the next piece of music I hear that he had a more active role in writing. And so combined with all these factors, this is a 2/5 for me, and a lot of aspects could've been improved on Horrific Child's only testament to time. I would absolutely not recommend this album.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Sunrise by HADEON album cover Studio Album, 2018
3.11 | 9 ratings

BUY
Sunrise
Hadeon Progressive Metal

Review by Finnforest
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars Sunrise, Sunset...

Hadeon was formed in 2014 by Alessandro Floreani, Fabio Flumiani, Federico Driutti, Gianluca Somma, and Lorenzo Blasutti. They released their sole full length work in December 2017. The band claimed as their influences all of the usual classic '70s prog giants as well as neo-prog bands like Pendragon, Moon Safari, IQ, and prog and metal bands Dream Theater, Porcupine Tree, Threshold. On the album's concept, per the band website, "the album Sunrise bases its roots in the nature of the human being. By using music as a communicative element, Hadeon identify some of the disorders and illnesses that affect the modern man. Such dramas are manifested as characters that tell their stories to the listener through the songs. Throughout the listening, the songs becomes increasingly gloomy and sad examining the most desperate cases. The intent of Sunrise focuses on the search of oneself through sorrow, on the need and the will to always find the remedy, even in the most extreme cases, to end the distress and return to the light."

Hadeon plays an accessible, melodic prog metal that balances complexity with an ability to be pleasing on the ears. It is not overly heavy, crushing, or mechanical, although they can and do rock. When I first played the album, I didn't really hear any of the bands they listed as influences. To me, they sounded more like a slightly less-heavy, more melodic Pain of Salvation. Those tiptoeing, sustained guitar notes in pattern building up to the full powerful chords and chugs. Even the vocals are not too different from Daniel Gildenlöw though a bit softer perhaps, generally. The songwriting is adventurous, occasionally intense, but more often melodic and soaring in nature. I like how they incorporate softer touches. "Chaotic Picture" begins with gorgeous piano lines before blending them with guitar. "Never Thought" has a cool folk vibe with acoustic guitars and tablas, quite a departure. The 10-minute title track closes the album by opening with up-front fluid basslines and gentle piano before developing through several different motifs and some great lead guitar work. On February 19, 2019, Hadeon announced on social media that the band had ended. It is unfortunate because this was a pretty solid debut. Check it out if you're into Perfect Element-Remedy Lane era Pain of Salvation.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ligament by PAATOS album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.77 | 14 ratings

BUY
Ligament
Paatos Crossover Prog

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars A band I will always find the time to listen to (more for the hope of hearing the magically-nuanced performances of my favorite drummer of the Naughties). After 13 years (probably focused on raising children), the band returns with a highly-creative effort that would seem to deny that any time has passed at all.

1. "Chemical Escape" (5:53) Huxflux is back! He and Ulf Ivarsson present with an impressively complex high-speed weave from the opening note to the end while Petronella's calming voice characteristically (and magically) counters from the top. Keyboards are also almost always present within the mix as well, sometimes (especially at the end) providing Petronella's only support. (8.875/10)

2. "Beyond The Forest" (5:52) an eery folkish song that feels as if the music is built around the vocals: Petronella and guest Mikael Akerfelt alternating in a duet during the verses and then the faerie-like female choir vocals in the first part of the choruses (full band choir for the second part of the chorus). Drum, bass, synth, and guitar helps drive the song (especially in the fourth minute's drum-and-bass-less instrumental passage) but, again, it feels as if the song could exist as an all vocal a cappella pagan folk song. Interesting but not as engaging as one would have hoped. (8.75/10)

3. "I Deny" (5:02) opening with a beautiful Harold Budd-like arpeggio which is gradually joined by bass, harp, synth strings, and light percussion play. Petronella doesn't enter until the 90-second mark, here singing with an unusually airy-whispery upper-register voice. Gorgeous chords and melodies! Petronella's voice gets a little more forceful for the brief "chorus" recitation of the song title. (9.125/10)

4. "Ligament" (2:09) weird little busy thing that defies categorization--except forthe fact that just about every track, instrument, voice sounds heavily-treated/processed. (4.375/5)

5. "Post War Limina" (2:23) interesting machine/robotic drone-like keyboard and bowed bass piece. (4.375/5)

6. "I'm Letting Go" (5:12) nice rolling tom play with snare hits on "The One" with Peter's droning electric guitar chords and notes and Ulf's active bass play beneath Petronella's strong (invested) vocal. The ambient guitar and/or synth sounds injected between and within the vocal lines are quite cool--as is the multi-voiced chorus near the very end. Cool, effective, and different sounding song. (9/10)

7. "Who Am I" (4:37) jazzy drums open this sounding a lot like some kind of Buddy Rich show from the 1960s or 70s while bass, guitar, and piano inject their long-sustaining minimalistic offerings here and there, providing some kind of chordal cushion for Petronella to sing over. Once again her vocal feels invested, she uses delicacy and power to equal effect--even holding some impressively-long notes with the exposition of the song title. Another song that just flies by and then evaporates as if into thin air! Masterful! (9.25/10)

8. "November" (4:26) guitar, bass, cymbals, all playing with Mark Hollis-like extreme delicacy and sparse dispersal of their offerings--which happens to be just enough for Petronella to deliver one of her signature delicate, vulnerable-yet- elegant vocals. Such impressive skill! (8.875/10)

9. "Last Ones Of Our Kind" (6:10) another solid, masterful song whose weak point, in my estimation, comes in its lyric (which is, unfortunately, lost to me). The music is unusual in its choppy flow but the consistency of this delivery makes it possible to get used to it. Not my favorite song but I cannot deny it's creative strength. (8.75/10)

10. "Svart" (3:59) an unusual song for being build over heavy (almost stark) music that is bass dominated--fully fulling out the low en--while Petronella sings in her light, airy voice over the top. It could have been better had the melodies-- both vocal and instrumental--offered more engaging "hooks" for the listener to sink its teeth into. (I've always had this feeling--especially from the music of this band--that there is something quite foreign, something quite obtuse and inaccessible in the Swedish soul that we Americans cannot ever truly fathom or understand. Paatos is definitely one of the principle bands to leave me with this feeling time after time. I'm not judging [either Swedes or Americans]: just pointing out the consistent trend of my inability to comprehend, much less "like," some of these songs--this despite my understanding and appreciation for their creativity and maturity. They remain . . . "foreign" to me!) (8.75/10)

Total time: 45:43

Wow! After 13 years this is quite an impressive "renaissance" (comeback?) The band's propensity to deliver creative, highly-nuanced and unusual music with lots of unique sound and structural experimentation is as pronounced as ever! It's as if each and every one of the band members has been working super hard each and every day since their last album/tour to improve their skills, to nurture their creativity, to develop and let mature their ideas. I love that Ricard "Huxflux" Nettermalm returns with as impressive (and jazzy) drum work as ever--and that his wife seems as inspired and fully-committed to her performances--to the music--as ever. Yes, Ms. Nettermalm's talents are all on full display: her exquisite skills as honed as ever.

B/four stars; an excellent addition of unusual, often-experimental prog from a highly-skilled ensemble working at the absolute peak of their creative powers.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ligament by PAATOS album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.77 | 14 ratings

BUY
Ligament
Paatos Crossover Prog

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars "Ligament" is the sixth full-length studio album by Swedish alternative/progressive rock act Paatos. The album was released through Timeloss Records in April 2025. It´s the successor to "V" from 2012, so it´s been 13 long years since we´ve last heard to Paatos and personally I thought they had called it quits. Especially considering that "V" was half new original tracks and half re-arranged versions of older material. It spelled the end for Paatos, but I´m glad to be proven wrong.

Rising from the ashes of progressive rock act Landberk (and also featuring members of Agg) in 2000, who released a couple of solid Swedish progressive rock albums in the early- to mid-1990s, Paatos have released quite a few interesting releases through the years featuring influences from musical genres like progressive rock, jazz/fusion, trip-hop, and alternative rock/hard rock. They are not a high profile act (at least in terms of mainstream success), but they have consistently released good quality material throughout their career.

Stylistically "Ligament" is pretty much the melting pot of all the genres mentioned above and it´s like Paatos never went away. They still produce a melancholic atmosphere with organich (and sometimes busy) drum and bass work, beautiful dark guitar melodies, atmosphere enhancing keyboards/orchestration, and Petronella Nettermalm´s strong voice in front. One of the great strengths of Paatos music is that they never become too nice and polished. This is melodic vers/chorus structured music and you can sing along to the choruses, but Paatos always add a sense of unease and a layer of unpredictability to the songs, which keep the listener on his/her toes and make the songs interesting to return to.

To springle a bit of stardust on your album isn´t a bad idea either and Mikael Åkerfeldt from Opeth guests on the darkly atmospheric/almost cinematic and slightly progressive/neo-folky "Beyond The Forest" singing a duet with Nettermalm. It´s great to hear Paatos exploring a sound like that, and with great success I might add. Paatos can go from performing subtle mellow songs to performing busy, almost aggessive, and hard hitting tracks like they do between tracks number three and four on the tracklist "I Deny" and "Ligament". It´s a pretty big contrast, but it´s great for the variation of the album, and Paatos pull off playing both styles with the same natural ease. I´d say there are more mellow atmospheric songs featured on the album than the busy ones, so it´s not a 50/50 dynamic. Among the highlights of the album are tracks like "Chemical Escape", "Beyond The Forest", "Last Ones Of Our Kind", and "Who Am I", but "Ligament" is a consistent release in terms of the quality of the songwriting.

The sound production has to be mentioned as "Ligament" features an organic, dynamic, and detailed sound production, which provides all instruments and vocals with room to breathe and to be heard. The many layers of the music are heard clearly in the mix, and "Ligament" overall features a high level production job. Upon conclusion "Ligament" is a good quality comeback for Paatos, and fans of the band´s earlier work can safely push the purchase button. To my ears Paatos are slightly more experimental (and maybe a bit darker too) on this album than they´ve been for a while, and that´s a strength. Not catering to a mainstream audience often brings out the best in a band, and at this point it´s obvious that Paatos aren´t expecting one of their songs to suddenly become a hit, and they therefore write exactly what they feel like writing. A 3.5 star (70%) rating is deserved.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Bohemian Rhapsody / I'm in Love With My Car by QUEEN album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 1975
4.39 | 38 ratings

BUY
Bohemian Rhapsody / I'm in Love With My Car
Queen Prog Related

Review by Captain Midnight

5 stars While Queen is not (primarily) a Prog band, Bohemian Rhapsody is undoubtedly the most iconic Progressive Rock song ever made beating songs like ELO's Mr Blue Sky and Pink Floyd's Comfortably Numb. The song is epic and over the top in the greatest way possible starting off as this slow Glam/Opera/Piano Rock intro, amd has a couple more sections each one more iconic then the last, untill the climax. My only problem with this song is the ending it's probably just a personal peeve but i never really cared for it. The B Side here is also really good, Roger takes the vocals here in this funny yet hard rocking song, overall a great single from a great album

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 War of Being by TESSERACT album cover Studio Album, 2023
4.11 | 63 ratings

BUY
War of Being
TesseracT Progressive Metal

Review by Bashir

5 stars An album brimming with strength, vitality, and originality. Tesseract is a band I discovered several years ago with their album ALTERED STATE, and since then I haven't been able to shake my addiction to their complex and syncopated riffs, the stunning voice of their singers Daniel Tompkins and previously Ash O'Hara, plus an extraordinary drummer (Jay Postones). This album is an epic journey through the human soul. It requires at least a dozen listens to begin to understand and appreciate the richness, the variety, the mathematical precision of each of its compositions, which together form an album that, after a while, becomes a pleasure to listen to again and again. All of their works seem excellent to me: ONE, ALTERED STATE, POLARIS, and SONDER. A tremendous band, very underrated. Creators of ethereal, surreal atmospheres, compositions that are simultaneously violent and delicate, these musicians are a true pleasure to listen to.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Drum 'N' Voice - All That Groove by COBHAM, BILLY album cover Studio Album, 2001
4.79 | 5 ratings

BUY
Drum 'N' Voice - All That Groove
Billy Cobham Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Billy and friends are in Milano. They're game to jam with local legends like the Nicolosi Family who comprised the pop- R&B band Novecento back in the day. This is the result of those sessions.

1. "Africa's Sounds" (4:32) great opener of smooth jazz. Billy still has it! (9.3333/10)

2. "Shadow" (4:46) a cool jazzy pop/R&B song with great organ play from Pino Nicolosi and awesome bass and guitar from the other two Nicolosi brothers, Rossana and Lino, respectively. Sister Dora Nicolosi also makes an apearance as Gregg Brown's foil and backup singer. (8.875/10)

3. "Red Baron" (7:44) Troy Parrish speaking the lyrics over the funky music (of a Billy classic?) Never a huge fan of the original (off of Spectrum) but this one is groovin/dance-worthy. (13.5/15) 4. "Okky Dokky" (4:41) great melodic smooth jazz with a 90s Soul II Soul-like Acid Jazz feel. Excellent horn contributions, but such a great groove played by Billy, Rossana, and Marco Fadda. I love this tune! (9.375/10)

5. "Jah Spirit" (5:02) great Acid Jazz music with Gregg Brown's Rastafarian vocal, Lino Nicolosi's excellent rhythm and smooth lead jazz guitar work over Rossana and Billy's killer collaboration. Great double bass solo from Riccardo Fioravanti in the mid-section as well and trumpeter Fabrizio Bosso in the final third. (9.25/10)

6. "I Want You Back" (4:57) great cruisin groove established by Rossana, Pino and Billy while vocalist Rick Baily provides a satisfactory R&B vocal over the top. The Rick's multi-voiced b vox are fun. Rossana Nicolosi is the real deal! Brother Lino provides a fun blast-from the past Eddie Van Halen "Beat It" like guitar shredding in the final 90 seconds. (9.125/10) 7. "Sensations" (5:32) more cool grooving: sounding like a cross between Barry White's old LOVE UNLIMITED ORCHESTRA and some of the 90s' best Acid Jazz grooves (even Swing Out Sister). AWesome trumpet solo from either Amik Guerra or Fabrizio Bosso in the second half of the song. Great, hypnotic groove! (Rossana: you go girl!) (9.25/10)

8. "Leaving Now" (6:26) Smooth Jazz set up for Manhattan Transfer-like pop-jazz vocal from Gayle Moran-sound-alike Dora Nicolosi. Eddie Gomez' always welcome double bass sounds a bit weird. Great smooth jazz "lounge" piano from brother Pino Nicolosi. A tough, complicated vocal is performed admirable but not quite as perfectly as a Barbra Streisand or Celine Dionne (or even Corinne Drewery) would have done. (9/10)

9. "Hands Up!" (5:11) 1980s Smooth Jazz/Soul/R&B heaven! Love the strings arrangement and performance, Pino's organ and electric piano play, the Italian horn section, and, of course, Rossana's awesome bass! No more cowbell! (9.25/10)

10. "Now That You've Gone" (5:07) more stellar Smooth Jazz with nice group vocals and awesome jazz electric guitar over the amazing Pino, Rossana, Billy, Marco Fadda rhythm section. (9/10)

Total time 53:58

I can't think of a 21st Century Jazz-Rock Fusion album that feeds my 1970s-Motown-raised soul better than this one!

A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of Acid Jazz-tinged funky Smooth Jazz.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Dominion by IQ album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.15 | 172 ratings

BUY
Dominion
IQ Neo-Prog

Review by ComaEcliptic

5 stars "𝗗𝗼𝗺𝗶𝗻𝗶𝗼𝗻 = 𝗟𝗶𝗴𝗵𝘁 𝗠𝗮𝘁𝘁𝗲𝗿"

1. The Unknown Door (22:33) (25/25)

The opening is soft, reminiscent of the Fanfare for the Common Man cover by ELP. The WWII radio in the back, the war-like horn section. This will take fans back to Harvest of Souls and The Seventh House, War Tale vibes like on a few other IQ epics. The opening section ends with a bit of a world music vibe too. Really cool!

The following section takes normal IQ songwriting while adding something totally different for them. Still the same soaring hammonds and mellotrons, guitar riffing, tambourine. This section tied together by an industrial sequencer led chorus. Weird part, a bit of a mess but doesn't hinder the listening excerience.

The next part is a bit heavier, what some call 'The Battle' section. Even compared to recent IQ works like 'The Road of Bones' and 'Resistance'... this is heavy. It has a really nice chorus-esque piece that really ties this heavy section together. Good hammonds, great mellotrons, chunky guitars sound really good too.

A little instrumental section, has some really silky basslines, really feels like 80s Neo-Prog. Has some Pendragon elements, but I feel like this section can be summed up into ... an 80s Neo-Prog bit with 2000's IQ flare.

The acoustic section next up reminds me HEAVILY of 'Dogs' acoustic sections by Pink Floyd, even 'Meddle'-esque. The Prog Folk elements are strong here. Plus these chords are very Floydian as well. Strong section, love the vocals, chords, instruments used... chef's kiss.

Now onto a slightly more typical IQ part, nice keyboard solo, well structured, proggy, but nothing new really. Just fits well in an IQ epic. Gives the average fan something to remind of the band they've always known.

The ending section is typical, a reprisal of the opening in a slower, more emotional, all instrumentalists involved. Is it unwelcome because of how predictable it is? Absolutely not. It's what you expect of a strong IQ epic.

Overall, this epic is a great alternative to Harvest of Souls. You want something just as well structured, has moments that are just as strong, and something a bit different? This is it. Each section feels like it's own song (which is the hallmark of a strong epic). Wonderful. The best epic since "Without Walls" and "Harvest of Souls" for sure (and it's not particularly close to me).

2. One of Us (3:10) (5/5)

Gorgeous acoustic track, beautiful. The vocals are soft, pleasant, and well mixed. The keys add a nice amount of atmosphere to this soft track. It's a song like Wintertell (off of 'The Lost Attic' by IQ). The song can even be compared musically to "I Believe in Father Christmas" by ELP (Greg Lake). Such a beautiful song, glad a song like that made it onto the final cut of an IQ album. Could make a grown man cry with how beautiful this is.

3. No Dominion (6:25) (9/10)

The single from the album. Of all the tracks, this is the one that retreads the most old IQ ground. Is that a bad thing? Absolutely not! This song, unlike the other singles, is a keyboard dominant track. I love how ominous and thick the keys are. The musical box like keyboard melody and sound is noted here, seems to be a theme. It's a typical IQ song structurally speaking, it shows the band's Genesis influence, while keeping it's darker side. Weird telephone like sound effect, followed by a wound-up musical box sound effect. Cool way to transition to the next song, sad there was a fade out. Good, strong, not groundbreaking, just good IQ.

4. Far From Here (12:44) (14/15)

The opening is very dark, atmospheric, love the opening a ton. Typical of a 2000's IQ mini-epic. A haunting musical box opening, very cool. Creepy, love it.

The next section shows off a bit more of Paul Cook's drumming skill. A bit heavier and more chaotic. Keyboard dense section with nice vocals from Peter Nicholls.

Definitely picks up a bit in the heaviness department, more straightforward, definitely just a bit more of a heavy chugging section. Probably the heaviest section of any IQ track ever released.

Sequencer to transition into the next bit, a bit like Nine Inch Nails or even Rammstein. Kinda returns back to the second sections theme. Nice reprise, ties the mini-epic together in a circular-esque structure. Beautiful chorus-like piece here too, love the mellotrons, sticks around in your head.

Soft, gentle end to this more chaotic mini-epic. Keyboard and guitar with a bit of vocals. Pleasant, it really fits on this album. Plus the end itself is just... so pretty.

This Mini-Epic overall does everything a solid IQ mini-epic ought to do. It's got good dynamics, heavy moments work well, gentler moments shine nicely, it's a more chaotic one than normal... but I think it works really well! It's a grower!

5. Never Land (8:16) (10/10)

The opening of this track is so beautiful. The lyrics are emotional, the mood is angelic, the production, silky basslines, piano in the back. This song is like a reworked, expanded, and restyled 'Oceans'. Amazing. One of the best album closers in their entire discography.

______________________________

Overall Rating: (63/65) Rating Percentage: 97% Favourite Track: The Unknown Door Final Grade: A+ ______________________________

I couldn't be more impressed with how the big boy's in Prog have released some of the best albums they've released in 2025. Steven Wilson's "The Overview" and IQ's "Dominion" have been borderline 'ten-out-of-ten' rcords!

This album takes tropes that this band is known for and adds completely new moods and sounds, effectively refreshing IQ's sound. It's impressive that over 40 years after their debut, they can still deliver high quality records. They haven't lost their identity, they only expanded on it. Incredibly confident album from IQ. It's concise, structured, well produced, and contains some of their best songwriting of the 21st Century. The second album this year to come close to my 10/10 score. 2025 truly has been one of the best years for Prog Rock in a while.

PA Rating: 5 stars - Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Sky Full of Hope (as Fractal Sextet) by THELEN, STEPHAN album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.95 | 2 ratings

BUY
Sky Full of Hope (as Fractal Sextet)
Stephan Thelen RIO/Avant-Prog

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars I have become such a fanboy of all things related to SONAR and Stephan Thelen. That all instrumental music coming out of Switzerland that is complex and interlocking. The sound of the tri-tone instruments is amazing, as is guitarist David Torn when he involved. So the expectations are high when it comes to this 6 piece band called FRACTAL SEXTET. This is their second studio album released in 2024, and it clocks in around 55 minutes with six tracks, not counting the bonus song.

The story goes that Stephan Thelen and fellow guitarist Jon Durant were asked by an individual as to why they don't have a permanent band to play this complex and interlocking style of music. So the seed was planted and eventually Stephan and Jon sat down and talked about who would be part of this group. Adding four members isn't an easy thing when you do not want to step on any toes as it were with fellow collaborators from SONAR and Stephan Thelen solo. So they did the smart thing and went outside the usual cast of musicians who are involved.

The exception is Andi Pupato a percussionist who is one of the usual suspects and previously part of Nik Bartsch's Ronin'. So that leaves drums, bass and keyboards. Man, I would have liked to have had an ear to these conversations about who they considered. The surprising pick to me was Colin Edwin formerly of PORCUPINE TREE. Really surprising until I saw he and Durant are in the same band called BURNT RELIEF. So that was a Durant suggestion no doubt. Keyboards? Fabio Anile, who is a classical pianist and keyboardist. On the kit we get drum phenom Yogev Gabay from Israel.

On their debut it was Stephan Thelen composing just about everything, while here it is shared between him and Fabio Anile. I have to say that this is surprisingly minimalistic. The breakouts are few, to a fault in my opinion. And understand I adore this style of music, but this certainly doesn't matchup to many SONAR or solo Stephan Thelen albums. I would also argue that while I appreciate all the music that they can give us, I don't think this permanent band idea was necessary when you have that large cast of musicians that have played live and in studio together for years at your disposal.

One thing this record did though was bring to my attention drummer Yogev Gabay. Thelen says that this is a very polyrhythmic album but with Yogev in the driver's seat, there's nothing to worry about. Still, they have almost doubled down on the metric pensions of their debut to the point that even Gabay had to do a few takes at times before he nailed it. They call him the major lynchpin to the proceedings, as well as one of the group's prime catalysts.

When I think of this album I'm reminded of drums, piano and guitar expressions. And that it's minimalistic of course. So much of this just seems to trip along. Of course the attention is in the details here but it's hard to know from song to song which one I'm listening to. All are similar in sound and style but I'd probably pick the closer "Four Hands" if I was to pick just one song. I was disappointed with this one but the expectations were sky high(haha). I pretty much assumed this would be my album of the year for 2024. No, it is not, but a solid 4 stars regardless.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Last Concert in Japan by DEEP PURPLE album cover Live, 1977
2.16 | 90 ratings

BUY
Last Concert in Japan
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

2 stars The dedication to Tommy Bolin does not, unfortunately, change the fact that 'Last Concert in Japan' is one of the weakest releases of the entire Deep Puprle canon, a 1977 live album capturing the last gig of the Mark IV lineup in Tokyo, is a muddy recording that does not really present any of the appeal of this particular iteration of the band, and if their then-last studio album had been a fine exercise in funk-rocking, this live release seems to have almost nothing to do with 'Come Taste the Band', the album supposedly supported on that tour. The final product here is a dreadful recording of an obviously poor concert, with Bolin virtually missing, his playing is by far one of the most abysmal guitar recording to have ever appeared on a Purple album, with Glenn Hughes later claiming that the band's axe-man had been "out of shape" that very evening, confirmed by the really bad recording. He is, of course, covered up excellently by Jon Lord, who seems to steal the show in Tokyo, even getting a solo spot that goes under the name of 'Woman from Tokyo' on the official tracklist.

And this is where the other major source of confusion comes from as half the selected setlist is made up of songs that were not recorded by this lineup of the band. The hefty but unsuccessful trials of 'Smoke on the Water' (which is relatively acceptable here) and the really tasteless playthrough of 'Highway Star' prove why such recordings should not have been included on the live album. Below-par performances of other classic tracks recorded by the MKIII lineup grace the setlist, like 'Burn' and 'You Keep On Moving', while Bolin even gets to play a song off of one of his solo albums, completely irrelevant here. The only decent recordings seem to be the ones of 'Love Child' and 'Lady Luck', quite expectedly. Just a very poor and confusing live album, far off the excellence and liveliness of 'Made in Europe', for example, released some years prior; perhaps this project should have been abandoned by Deep Purple as it hardly serves them any favour in documenting them as a solid and exciting live force.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Live At Wembley '86 by QUEEN album cover Live, 1992
4.08 | 148 ratings

BUY
Live At Wembley '86
Queen Prog Related

Review by Hector Enrique
Prog Reviewer

4 stars The monumental and brief performance at the Live Aid in 1985, of a Queen submerged at that time in a deep internal crisis that sowed doubts about their continuity, brought them back to life and revitalized their career in such a way that less than a year later they released "A Kind of Magic" with a promotional tour (called "Magic Tour") included. There were 26 shows in Europe exclusively (they were banned in North America mainly because of the satirical and misunderstood video of the single "I Want to Break Free"). Of that tour, the presentations of July 11/12, 1986 in the mythical London stadium Wembley were collected by the double album "Live at Wembley '86" (1992). A work that repairs, six years after the publication of the failed and stunted "Live Magic" of 1986, and ends up being a posthumous tribute to Freddie Mercury in one of the last live performances of Queen.

More than 140,000 people over the two days packed the venue, guided and surrendered to Mercury's swagger in a setlist that included the band's worldwide mega-hits such as "Under Pressure", "Another One Bites The Dust", "I Want To Break Free", "Crazy Little Thing Called Love" and "Bohemian Rapsody", songs from the album that motivated the tour such as the homonymous "A Kind of Magic" followed by the legendary vocal game of the singer replicated by the audience, memories of the early days with "Seven Seas of Rhye" and the chorable "In the Lap of the Gods", the hard rock of "Tie Your Mother Down", "Now I'm Here" and "Hammer to Fall", the emotional moment with "Love Of My Life" and "Is This The World We Created? " linked with the late 50's rock and roll tribute of "(You're So Square) Baby I Don't Care", "Hello Mary Lou Goodbye Heart" and "Tutti Frutti", and a final full steam ahead segment with the stadium rock mobilizer that the band handled so well: the energized "Radio Gaga" and the unbeatable duet "We Will Rock and "We Are the Champions".

The infallible and pre-recorded English hymn "God Save the Queen", the last song of the setlist, was the backdrop for the farewell of Queen and a Mercury dressed in a cape and crown emulating the Queen of England, perhaps the most memorable image of one of the best frontman in the history of rock.

3.5/4 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Those Who Are About to Die Salute You by COLOSSEUM album cover Studio Album, 1969
3.63 | 171 ratings

BUY
Those Who Are About to Die Salute You
Colosseum Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

3 stars Early prog tended to veer away from blues - after all, part of the point was to broaden and deepen the range of stylistic influences rock music took on, and rock had already borrowed plenty from the blues by the time the late 1960s rolled around. There were, however, exceptions - Jethro Tull were on their first couple of albums, and so too were Colosseum on this debut release, which leads off with the bluesy rave-up Walking In the Park. The blues influences snakes through the album as touches of other genres emerge here and there.

By the time you get to Beware the Ides of March, you get more classical influences, with Dave Greenslade on keyboards and Dick Heckstall-Smith on sax in particular showing that anything Procol Harum were doing at this time, Colosseum could match. On the other hand, By the Road She Walked Before ends up being fairly conventional light psych-tinged pop, and perhaps the shortcoming of the album is the sheer range of styles it tries to incorporate, not all of which are created equal and some of which taste decidedly like filler.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 There Is No Space For Us by HAWKWIND album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.88 | 20 ratings

BUY
There Is No Space For Us
Hawkwind Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Condor7

4 stars This album follows in similar vein to the recent output and that is no bad thing. You could almost call this an instrumental album, although in actual fact only a very few tracks are totally instrumental. However vocals are in general brief and occasional and perhaps slightly too far in the mix although that seems to be their style these days. The closing song A Long Long Way From Home is the gentlest track on the album leaving us in a more calm mood and you could be fooled into thinking it is an instrumental when in fact the song title is just sung once right at the end. Space Continues (Lifeform) is totally instrumental over its 8 minute journey and my favourite track on the album, play it loud and try and tell me there is not a hint of Pink Floyd's One Of These Days.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Attack Of The Grey Lantern by MANSUN album cover Studio Album, 1997
4.02 | 43 ratings

BUY
Attack Of The Grey Lantern
Mansun Crossover Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Paul Draper definitely had a healthy and vigorous fascination with the Beatles, which is a dominant influence on alternative Britpop rockers Mansun's debut studio album titled 'Attack of the Grey Lantern', a semi-conceptual album with a complex storyline and a cast of enigmatic and eccentric characters, as it had been argued that the concept had never really been finished in its entirety, which adds up to the oozing pretention and appeal of the album and the band itself. Now, Mansun seem to be all about that alternative edge in British pop music, with an alluring sound that borders on progressive, with Draper & Co. never really setting for the standard verse-chorus song structure, as their music is replete with interesting movements, moods and playful melodies, appearing all over that excellent first album, a work of a somewhat capricious and ingenious songwriter (Draper), whose oeuvre works as an antidote to the corny grunge and post-punk rock from the nineties.

In terms of the genre within which this record might fall into, we could speak of a crafty mixture of alternative rock, Britpop, and 60s psychedelia (ā la Beatles), all vibrant and cynical, with memorable choruses and unpredictable twists as well as a great use of keyboards and effects, only when necessary, topped by the soothing vocals of Draper, sufficiently quirky to keep you aware of what he's singing about. The lyrics and the (loose) storyline make up a great deal of what 'Attack of the Grey Lantern' works best as, where the songwriting gets the best of each and every song, on an album that has such a rich stylistic diversity that should be found appealing by the most demanding of prog fans. Spacey single 'Wide Open Space' is obviously one of the remarkable entries on the album, but the same amount of praise has to go to 'Mansun's Only Love Song', an infectious art-rocker, the 7-minute trippy pop suite 'Taxloss', or the comically quirky tune 'Stripper Vicar', with the record closing off with strong numbers like 'Egg Shaped Fred' and the orchestral and cathartic 'Dark Mavis', ultimately working as the resolution of the story. Mansun's debut album is a fascinating piece of British alt-pop that continues to impress and sound relevant even today, with the band setting a high standard for other alternative acts to come, with their complex arrangements, excellent songwriting, and overall witty humour.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Quásar by QUÁSAR album cover Studio Album, 2023
4.83 | 3 ratings

BUY
Quásar
Quásar Symphonic Prog

Review by Heart of the Matter

5 stars Quásar bring out a bold proposition with this debut of theirs, and not in spite of, but rather because of its being so classic sounding. You have to dare, and they did. No production design specifically aiming to render a "vintage" feel. Just the guys and their instruments projecting an unmasked, authentic vibe made of moogs, axes, bass & cymbals through the pristine clarity of a modern studio. And melodies not only flow unstopably, but they are truly memorable. After a couple of minutes, or so, the next thing you know is that you are embarked in their cosmic journey, together with birds singing, synth washes, and who knows what else.

For starters, we are treated with the sweetness of a classical nylon-string guitar styling discret figures on the synths increasing density. After that, almost everything one can desire from a Symphonic rock album takes place in turn. First come the vocals, insinuated by a repetitive syncopated entry, giving way to a marvellous cadence made of strategically robbed beats, and accents showing up where one doesn't expect, but they always had to be. That first track is rounded with more deliciously dreamy classical guitar and full-blown synths retrieving the initial figures of the vocal cadence.

Track 2 features prominently the melodic power of the electric guitar. Trust me, no matter how much you can turn up the volume, it will never be enough. Track 4, El Rumor del Bosque, probably reaches the most perfect blend of every element in the band, all given to an accordingly perfect melody.

Approaching the middle of the album, I was thinking of a rating surpasing the four stars, but, for how much? Then I had my encounter with Track 5, Código Quásar, and that sent me all the way through to reach the masterpiece status. Simple in principle, indescribable in the end. Starting up from an elementary telegraphic beat, they go for an astonishing number of variations in metrics, and in every possible sense you may think for the word "texture", pushing things from quiet to extra-loud, from simple to ultra-complex, and from utterly transparent to impenetrably dense. My favorite track, no doubt in my mind about it.

And from there on, one cannot stop listening with wide open eyes, even for a minute. Don't miss it.

More info: https://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=134853

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Erotic Cakes by GOVAN, GUTHRIE album cover Studio Album, 2006
4.20 | 151 ratings

BUY
Erotic Cakes
Guthrie Govan Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars After over 15 years of study and practice, guitarist extraordinaire Guthrie Govan comes out of the closet as a blues- rock-educated and -grounded composer!

1. "Waves" (5:09) opening with a fully-fleshed out motif in which Guthrie introduces the main melodies over a fairly straightforward rock rhythm track but then begins to dance around the fretboard in wildly unpredictable ways from 0:50 to 1:15 when he settles back in among the band to reinforce the opening melody. Another foray into solo expression begins at 1:50 but this time evolves rather protractedly and more within the domains of previously- heard/attempted rock guitar solos (using his own unusual scales to perform his runs). A doubled-up flourish at the three-minute mark signals a bridge to a more blues-rock/classic rock solo. This man has so many faces! And such amazing dexterity! Impressive but also enjoyable. And I love the unusual ending: it feels like an homage to Roy Buchanan. (9.125/10)

2. "Erotic Cakes" (3:51) stoccato chugging music displaying some very odd time signatures and polyrhythms between the three musicians. Guthrie never really seems to be traveling in the same universe and Seth and Pete: it's more like he's rocketing around the rhythmists as if looking for an entrance, looking for a way to join into the groove they're in. His maneouvering makes me think of a heat-seeking predatory bird like a crow (or trio of crows) with hummingbird- like quickness. Interesting and rather enjoyable. (9/10)

3. "Wonderful Slippery Thing" (3:21) another solid rock/blues-rock motif over which Guthrie takes Wes Montgomery and Django Reinhardt to The School of Rock. Uber-impressive and almost humorously-creative but not my favorite, the song had existed since the early 1990s when Guthrie used it to compete in a guitar-playing competition for Guitar magazine in 1993--which he won. (9/10)

4. "Ner Ner" (8:05) another fairly straightforward (and familiar) (Southern) rock motif that presents engaging/alluring melodies over which Guthrie impresses with more flash and fireworks on both electric and acoustic guitars (one of which might very well be the guest guitar soloist Richie Kotzen). This song reminds me a lot of the solo work of STEVE VAI. Nice accessible music. (13.5/15)

5. "Fives" (4:36) sounding very much like a cross between the work of ALLAN HOLDSWORTH, STEVE VAI, and KING CRIMSON, this song starts out heavy-technical but then starts to cruise and fly in the third minute as Steve flits and spits over the top. At 4:00 the music cuts down to bare bones for the quiet support of a nice bass guitar solo from brother Seth Govan. (8.875/10)

6. "Uncle Skunk" (5:29) an interesting song that seems to draw inspiration from a combination of the old blues masters (like Buddy Guy and Roy Buchanan) and modern sound-technicians like Adrian Belew and Robert Fripp. I like the creative energy, engaging (almost "Yacht Rock") melodies, and laid back feel of this one. A top three song for me. (9.3333/10)

7. "Sevens" (5:57) this one opens sounding very much like the palette, construct, and melodies of the SCORPIONS' "Rock You Like a Hurricane," but then things change. A ChapmanStick-like bass chord playing style provides much of the foundation beneath Guthrie's amazing SATRIANI-VAI-like shredding runs. The intermittent softer flying arpeggio sections feel a lot like some of Devin Townsend's more amazing beauty passages whereas the ramped up fourth minute feels more like the work of 1980s heavy metal bands like I love the return to the more melodic and then more delicate stuff for the song's final 90 seconds. (9.125/10)

8. "Eric" (5:06) opening with a slow, spacious, more delicate and melody-rich motif over which Guthrie solos with a slide-like sound not unlike something from Roy Buchanan or even a more blues-oriented Adrian Belew. Nice. Interesting weave of micro-fast arpeggi in the fifth minute. Overall, there is a very comforting, connectable feel to this song that helps render it among my three favorites on the album. (9.125/10)

9. "Slidey Boy" (4:35) a brooding jazz flavor opens this song as Seth solos over Pete's mostly-cymbals and snare drumming for the first minute. His impressive bass play continues as Guthrie joins in with some low end piccolo-bass- like note play that intertwines with his brother's bass play but then separates and begins occupying the middle and upper ranges in a very AL DI MEOLA-like sound and style. As a matter of fact, the music and performances on this song could easily fit on Al's 2002 release, Flesh on Flesh: sounds just like Al and Anthony Jackson working together. My other top three song. (9.375/10)

10. "Rhode Island Shred" (2:18) just like Guthrie's project The Aristocrats, he must feel a need to represent as many separate styles as possible: here the Country-Western Bluegrass scene--with the help of fellow guitar wiz Bumblefoot. Impressive but neither the prog rock or Jazz-Rock Fusion that I'm seeking. (4.5/5)

11. "Hangover" (6:32) a slow, plodding blues-rock bass over which a wide variety of STEVE VAI and JOHN PETRUCCI-like guitar solos flourish--and within which brother Seth shines once again in his Anthony Jackson-like way. Solid if not my favorite. (9/10)

Total Time: 53:39

My only beef with the music on this album is the non-proggyness of a lot of it; the music here belongs more in the realm of Rock Power Trio stuff--most of it quite anchored in blues-rock traditions (very much like the music of The Aristocrats' album releases).

A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of post-graduate-level blues-rock based Guitar School expression. There may not be a guitarist as talented as Guthrie, it's just a little disappointing to me how much of his music is firmly founded in the blues and blues-rock traditions.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Of Queues and Cures by NATIONAL HEALTH album cover Studio Album, 1978
4.28 | 552 ratings

BUY
Of Queues and Cures
National Health Canterbury Scene

Review by Kaiba

5 stars National Health's Of Queues and Cures still holds up as a smart yet accessible prog rock album. The playing is intricate?think jazz-flavored rhythms and layered melodies?but avoids feeling overly calculated. Take The Bryden 2-Step: the guitar and keyboard trade sharp, interlocking phrases without losing the track's drive. Binoculars stands out with its raw emotional tone, offering a directness that contrasts with the album's more abstract moments (which makes it one of my favourite songs among all the works of National Health). What works in this album is how they balance complexity with groove; even the busiest sections feel grounded. It demands attention, but the payoff comes through repeated listens. A good gateway into 70s Canterbury Scene, whether you're a seasoned prog listener or just curious. 4.5 rounding up to 5.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Waterloo Lily by CARAVAN album cover Studio Album, 1972
3.77 | 687 ratings

BUY
Waterloo Lily
Caravan Canterbury Scene

Review by Kaiba

4 stars While this album offers moments of undeniable charm, it struggles to fully commit to a cohesive identity. The album starts strong with Waterloo Lily?catchy guitar riffs and bright melodies prove it's a solid opener. The second track isn't bad either: it takes a sharp turn into jazz-rock territory with bold experimental shifts. The issue begins later: from the third track onward, the band retreats to their comfort zone. The melodies grow repetitive, the rhythms turn predictable, and while their playful charm remains, it lacks freshness. Yet amidst these inconsistencies shines "The Love in Your Eye," a sprawling epic whose emotional resonance arguably ranks among Caravan's finest compositions. All in all, this isn't a disappointing album. In fact, its bold fusion-jazz experimentation?ironically?even overshadows the remaining tracks, which, while still pleasant, feel comparatively ordinary. Its high standard overall, along with the fragmented brilliance still justifies a solid four-star rating. For listeners open to jazz, this remains to be a album that's worth a listen.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Macchie di inchiostro su carta sensibile by HABELARD2 album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.20 | 6 ratings

BUY
Macchie di inchiostro su carta sensibile
Habelard2 Crossover Prog

Review by Finnforest
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars Lush Instrumental Storytelling

Sergio Caleca from Milan is another of the many one-man, multi-instrumentalist phenoms who inhabit our lovely ProgArchives halls. These guys and gals compose everything and play all the instruments themselves, and they tend to be prolific, an understatement for Sergio who has cranked out about a dozen albums in the past decade. While he favors the instrumental, he will occasionally bring in a guest vocalists or other guests. During the 2010s, Sergio was keyboardist for the RPI band Ad Maiora from Milan, and he now works under the moniker Habelard2. His latest album, Macchie d'inchiostro su carta sensibile, continues fleshing out his growing symphonic prog catalog. The title refers to a project of poems and photographs he had been working on but which never came to fruition.

One of my favorite things about this material is the huge, up-front bass sound that runs through several tracks and the almost funky vibe, an interesting element on a largely symphonic album. I was reminded of Alan Parsons or maybe Duke era Genesis sans vocals. Despite the lack of vocals and lyrics, the songs very much have a feel of complex storytelling due to the great care taken in musical development, arrangements, and superb keyboard work. The expected lush elements are here in all their magnificence: lovely piano runs, flute, strings, choirs (or perhaps just samples of these, but the effect is the same.) It's beautiful stuff, and I really enjoyed the dreamy nature and dissolving into the songs. "La polvere sotto il tappeto" was another standout, an excellent mix of classical guitar to bass and flute with bucolic imagery.

My only criticism is the same one I have with most of these artists who are one-person projects. There is an inherent wholeness and depth of personality that comes from the essence of a rock band: the varying creativity styles, the collaboration, the arguments, the friendships, the intertwining histories of, often, youthful adventures together. A band brings a lot of additional fuel and compelling emotional diversity to an album of music. Almost always I will notice that part missing when listening to lone multi-instrumentalists regardless of how talented they may be. It's subtle, for sure, but it's a thing. Despite that reservation, this is a good album, and I encourage anyone who enjoys traditional symphonic prog recorded with modern technology to check out any of his many albums. There is much here to appreciate.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Illusive Golden Age by AUGURY album cover Studio Album, 2018
3.48 | 12 ratings

BUY
Illusive Golden Age
Augury Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars "Illusive Golden Age" is the third full-length studio album by Canadian, Quebec based technical/progressive death metal act Augury. The album was released through The Artisan Era in March 2018. It´s the successor to "Fragmentary Evidence" from 2009. There has been one lineup change since "Fragmentary Evidence" as drummer Étienne Gallo has been replaced by Antoine Baril.

Stylistically the material on "Illusive Golden Age" is a continuation of the technical/progressive death metal style of "Fragmentary Evidence". Augury are still an incredibly well playing unit and they pull out one powerful technical death metal riff and drum part after another, and Dominic "Forest" Lapointe´s fretless bass playing also gets the occasional spotlight. The vocals are quite brutal, shifting between deep unintelligible growling and higher pitched blackened screaming, and there are occasionally other types of vocals used in the music too. The opening title track for example features some semi-melodic shouting raw vocals.

Although "Illusive Golden Age" features a lot of challenging and sophisticated parts, one of the great assets of Augury is that they never loose their extreme metal credibility or brutality. They are arguably in the more polished end of the death metal spectrum, but there is still an aggressive and brutal edge to their music (as well as unpredictable chaotic atmospheres), which prevent "Illusive Golden Age" from becoming a sterile and powerless exercise in technical/progressive wankery. So, this is an album where you can simoultaniously drop your jaw and bang your head. An achievement Lapointe´s former bandmates in Beyond Creation for example didn´t pull off on the contemporary "Algorythm" (2018) album.

Augury have been among the elite technical/progressive death metal artists since the release of their debut full-length studio album "Concealed" in 2004, and just as they did on "Fragmentary Evidence", they continue that trend on "Illusive Golden Age", which is another powerful, sophisticated, but still brutal and intense death metal release. A 4 - 4.5 star (85%) rating is deserved.

(Originally posted on Metal Music Archives).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 St. Radigunds by SPIROGYRA album cover Studio Album, 1971
4.25 | 251 ratings

BUY
St. Radigunds
Spirogyra Prog Folk

Review by Lobster77

4 stars Likely to be their most consistent album, Spirogyra's debut from 1971, has proved its timeless quality. The male, Dylanesque vocals might be something for an acquired taste, however you might allow it some time to flourish. Barbara Gaskin's voice on the other hand is top of the bill and about the finest of its kind. A very diverse album of staggering beauty and intense, heart-felt musicianship. The viola sounds particularly sinister; the acoustic guitar exceptionally driven. The VCS-3 synth(!) is used very cleverly by Tony Cox. At times the music reflects an atmosphere akin to the Comus "First Utterance" album, not as dark & utterly strange, though. An important progressive/folk disc that deserves to stand in the spotlight.

4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Night After Night by DUKE,GEORGE album cover Studio Album, 1989
4.54 | 4 ratings

BUY
Night After Night
George Duke Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by NadirBigChance

5 stars Underrated Gem

This one is absolutely classic George Duke style of presenting Jazz Funk. At the mid 70s Duke's efforts were hardly influenced by his earlier work with Frank Zappa. "Feel", "Faces In Reflectin" and "I Love The Blues, She Heard my Cry" were definitely brilliant. But The KING OF JAZZ FUNK FUSION was established later on. Each his release from 1976 to 2013 (untill his death) were good and could me marked no less than 3 stars. Night After Night is a quintessence of his legacy IMOO. The tracks flow one into another consistently and naturally. The composition of the performers as usual at the highest level.On my CD version ther are 3 bonus tracks which conclude the hole album perfectly. Especially the instrumental "Fuzzion" with Stanley Clarke, Jean-Luc Ponty and Lee Ritenour as collaborators.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Vitamin F by FONTANELLE album cover Studio Album, 2012
4.91 | 3 ratings

BUY
Vitamin F
Fontanelle Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

5 stars When I think of Oregon, I picture a state of endless forests that I feel is represented well by AGALLOCH, with their woodsy, folk-metal sound, and the lyrics to match. FONTANELLE who are from Portland, Oregon are a completely different cat though when it comes to the music. Formed by bassist/guitarist Rex Ritter and keyboardist Andy Brown, they released three straight albums to start the 00's(00-02) then silence for a decade before returning with this record called "Vitamin F" from 2012. And this is the last we have heard from them.

Those first three album were birthed out of the "in studio" jams they did where everything was recorded like CAN used to do, then they would pick out what they felt was the best material to go on their records. TORTOISE gets mentioned a lot in regards to those first three albums. Sort of a Post Rock/Jazz thing happening on those early recordings. The album art work for those first three albums is similar, while the art work on "Vitamin F" is completely different, suggesting a change. Oh, is there ever a change. Rex Ritter had been playing and touring with his other band SUNN 0))) over that decade, and he returned here with a new mission.

One big change is the addition of six guest horn players to their sound. There are no horns on those first three records. Then as their inspiration they have channelled that early 70's Miles Davis sound along with that Mwandishi spirit that Herbie Hancock and the boys were doing, also in the 70's. Take out that final track and this is as close to perfection as I have heard when it comes to jazz Fusion and my tastes. That closer "Reassimilated" is a six minute ballad-like piece that is different from the rest. And not a good different.

"Vitamin F" was released by Southern Lord Recordings, and I like their little blurb on this album. I should mention as well that Randall Dunn is the producer, engineer and mixer of this record. He has worked with SUNN O))), WOLVES IN THE THRONE ROOM, BLACK MOUNTAIN and many others. Randall's mission was to go back in time to 1973 into Patrick Gleeson's Different Fur Trading Company Studio, and replicate that sound. Mission accomplished! The biggest kick I get out of this album is hearing guest trumpeter Dave Carter doing his Miles Davis impersonation. I am surprised there hasn't been more of this hero worship as it were by other trumpet players. I mean you think of Miles instantly when Carter comes in with those short bursts of trumpet runs out of the atmosphere, like on "Bitches Brew". So incredibly good.

The overall sound is dominated by that rhythm section where the drumming and bass work really are outstanding and upfront. But just as important is the keyboard work. Lots of clavinet, rhodes, wurlitzer, farfisa and synths on here. And man, those keyboards are tripped out and distorted, and with echo. This really is a dream come true in my music world. A six piece with six guests. And we have some amazing players on this all instrumental record. Seven tracks over 43 minutes, and those first six tracks are untouchable. A lot of repetitive stuff here which I like, and repeated themes and contrasts. It's hard to even pick out one of the six as a favourite, it's all so consistently good.

It's fair to say that this album might be my overall favourite from 2012, at least a top three. I first spent time with it four years ago and it has to be a top ten when it comes to my Jazz and related music. That is saying something.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 If I Could Do It All Over Again, I'd Do It All Over You by CARAVAN album cover Studio Album, 1970
4.25 | 1237 ratings

BUY
If I Could Do It All Over Again, I'd Do It All Over You
Caravan Canterbury Scene

Review by Kaiba

5 stars Pure 1970s gold for anyone who loves rock that's smart but never stuffy. Caravan mixes jazzy basslines, trippy guitar riffs, and flutes that sound like they're dancing (Hello Hello is a straight-up joyride). As I Feel I Die shows their magic?crazy sax solos crash into gentle melodies without missing a beat, like a garage band that accidentally wrote a symphony. The whole album feels raw in the best way: fuzzy recordings, loose jams, and playful lyrics. Sure, it's "prog-rock," but forget the fancy labels?this is just great music that's aged like a weird vintage wine. Fifty years later, it's still the kind of album you'll want to play "all over again". 4.5 rounding up to 5.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 For Long Tomorrow by TOE album cover Studio Album, 2009
4.04 | 74 ratings

BUY
For Long Tomorrow
Toe Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Kaiba

5 stars As a math-rock masterpiece that weaves precision into raw emotion, For Long Tomorrow thrives not just on drummer's hypnotic rhythmic webs or guitarists' needlepoint melodies, but on how these elements serve feeling over flash. While the entire album captivates, its second half glows brightest: Two Moons pairs classical guitar clarity with tactile, human-paced grooves, while the Can't Hear Mosquitone twins feel like finding beauty in cracks. Yet it's Goodbye that stuns?vocalist Toki Asako's tender delivery melts the band's precise rhythms into raw, human warmth. No cold technicality here; every odd rhythm bends to human warmth, every note a bridge between head and heart. Proof that complexity can whisper, not shout.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Red by KING CRIMSON album cover Studio Album, 1974
4.57 | 3909 ratings

BUY
Red
King Crimson Eclectic Prog

Review by Lobster77

5 stars As far as the John Wetton period of King Crimson goes, Red and Starless & Bible Black were always overshadowed by my love for Larks' Tongues in Aspic and In the Court of the Crimson King. I decided to go back and check out those two albums again, this time give them a little more time to sink in. I'm glad I did too, because I've become quite addicted to Red. Things kick off with the heavy sinister title track, which just sets the perfect mood for the album. Next track is Fallen Angel, possibly my favorite KC ballad. One More Red Nightmare brings back to the heavy sound of the title track but now with vocals and horns. Next up is Providence, which is kind of the "Moonchild" of the album. It's another one of those KC improv pieces; definitely not something everyone is going to dig. I must say though, the song at least doesn't ruin the dark mood of the album. And of course you have the classic Starless right at the end, which is definitely a KC fan-favorite. This album might be a little challenging to listen to if you're new to King Crimson, but it definitely grows on you in the end. Phenomenal talent surrounds this album all three members put out transcending melodies and this is a essential for a King crimson fan.

5.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ants from Up There by BLACK COUNTRY; NEW ROAD album cover Studio Album, 2022
3.97 | 80 ratings

BUY
Ants from Up There
Black Country; New Road Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Lobster77

4 stars A few years ago, Black Country, New Road released their album For the First Time, a record that almost managed to live up to the immense hype, but also an album that never grew on me, it always felt like despite the obvious greatness at display, something was missing. Ants From Up There explores completely different territory, sonically, and it appeals to me more than their debut, it feels like a much more complete album that leaves little to be desired.

Lyrically, they're probably not among my favourite bands yet, but the music here is incredible. The opener Chaos Space Marine would probably give you the wrong idea of what you're in for, but it's a fantastic indie rock anthem. Good Will Hunting seems to put off a lot of people with its "Billie Eilish" lyric, but I don't mind it much and adore the riffs and melodies on the track. Isaac Wood's vocals are possibly my favourite thing about the album, fragile yet passionate and distinctive.

I'm always wondering what makes BC,NR stand out from other similar acts, but since I heard this, I had little doubt that it's a modern classic. Maybe it's how incredibly cathartic the build-ups and climaxes feel on this record, maybe the outstanding arrangements with saxophones and strings. Either way, it's one of the best albums of the decade yet, and the last three tracks are unbelievably good. The moment when the drums stop on Snow Globes might be the most beautiful moment in 2022 music next to Richard Dawson's The Hermit, The Place Where He Inserted the Blade is one of the most addictive tracks of the year. Basketball Shoes is a perfect closer to a stunning record.

4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Stratus Luna by STRATUS LUNA album cover Studio Album, 2019
3.84 | 76 ratings

BUY
Stratus Luna
Stratus Luna Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Alxrm

4 stars Fans of instrumental prog rock, may I have your attention please. Four young guys from Brasil offer on this release seven compositions which I would never believe they could go hand-in-hand with their age. They are too mature, balancing in a very elegant way between the prototype prog sound and the modern one with some occasional fusion and even jazz touches thrown in. More than that, they don't sound derivative in the slightest. Although entirely instrumental, forget about endless soloing, these are actual compositions where the lack of vocals goes by unnoticed since the listener is always engaged into humming a melody. Aside the core instruments, their pallette includes the flute and the sitar, although not widely used. Excluding NREM-1 which, to my ears, isn't a fully fledged composition but a bridge between Pandas Voadores and On'rica, all other six compositions are replete with wonderful melodies and time changes which keep the interest, most of the times, intact and I'm saying this because just occasionaly, to my ears, some parts don't flow too naturally and that's the reason why I don't rate it any higher. It is an album that for six years now is a regular companion of mine and I would heartily recommend it not only, as I said at the beginning, to the fans of instrumental music, but to all progressive listeners.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Sky by SKY album cover Studio Album, 1979
3.45 | 107 ratings

BUY
Sky
Sky Eclectic Prog

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

4 stars What if prog rock simply wasn't very rock? The answer is that it would end up something like the debut album from Sky - a supergroup of musicians from a variety of backgrounds (John Williams from the world of jazz and classical, Francis Monkman from Curved Air, Herbie Flowers from numerous glam albums of yesteryear). On the one hand, if the basis of prog is to take a rock band lineup and let them perform virtuosic music informed by a broad range of musical genres, then this is undeniably prog - but it's prog as you'd implement it in 1979 by middle-aged musicians who seem to have decided to leave the harder-rocking stuff to the punk kids, set aside the psychedelic weirdness of prog's earlier days, and opted to turn out something reminiscent of the sort of fare Mike Oldfield, Camel, or the Alan Parsons Project were putting out at the time.

For some, this will no doubt seem unacceptably saccharine - but the power of music in part resides in its ability to touch a broad range of emotions and moods, and if you're in the mood for music which is often gentle, never aggressive, always thougthful, and generally quite light in approach, Sky aren't half bad. And it would be a flat-out mistake to regard this as some sort of commercial sell-out affair - unlike, say, Asia, it would be wrong to accuse this of being pop-prog, not least because if you were going to go pop in 1979 you'd never put out an all-instrumental album to begin with. Where Opposites Meet, the side-long epic that rounds it off, likewise demonstrates that these chaps can take a more overtly proggy approach when they decide it's merited - the trick is that these are all knowledgeable musicians who make excellent calls as to when it's good to go textured and complex, and where a touch of simplicity is needed. Hardly a world-changingly innovative work, but a slickly executed and seriously enjoyable one for that.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Chronicles by JON & VANGELIS album cover Boxset/Compilation, 1994
2.65 | 16 ratings

BUY
Chronicles
Jon & Vangelis Prog Related

Review by VianaProghead
Prog Reviewer

3 stars Review Nē 892

"Chronicles" is the second compilation of Jon & Vangelis that was released in 1994. It was released ten years after the release of their debut compilation "The Best Of Jon & Vangelis". As many of we know, Jon & Vangelis was a musical project formed by vocalist of the band Yes, Jon Anderson, and the Greek musician Vangelis Papathanassiou in the 80's.

The first meeting of both has happened in London in the 70's. Vangelis would be the replacement of Rick Wakeman on keyboards after the departure of him from the band after the release of the sixth studio album of Yes "Tales From Topographic Oceans". That would never happened, because Rick Wakeman was substituted by the Swiss keyboardist Patrick Moraz, the keyboardist of Refugee. Still, Anderson participated as a vocalist on some solo albums of Vangelis like "Heaven And Hell" released in 1975, "Opera Sauvage" released in 1979 and "See You Later" released in 1980.

The duo worked together from 1980 to 1991 and recorded four albums "Short Stories" released in 1980, "The Friends Of Mr. Cairo" released in 1981, "Private Collection" released in 1983 and "Page Of Life" released in 1991. The music was written by both and Anderson was the author of the lyrics. Jon sang all the songs and Vangelis played all instruments.

"Chronicles" has fourteen tracks. The tracks were taken from their first three studio albums. "I Hear You Now" is from "Short Stories". It's a love song, beautiful, melodic, delicate and vibrant at the same time. This is a song that represents the perfect harmony between the two musicians, the main hallmark on "Short Stories". "He Is Sailing" is from "Private Collection". It's a good song with nice rhythm, more in the vein of their album "Short Stories". Here we can see some effort and some complexity on the structure of the composition of the song. "Thunder" is from "Short Stories". It's the shortest song on "Short Stories" but it has some beautiful and interesting musical moments. It's very short but very nice . "Beside" is from "The Friends Of Mr. Cairo". It's a very good and beautiful love song with some fantastic classical musical arrangements and where the voice of Anderson and the music of Vangelis marry beautifully. "Birdsong" is from "Short Stories". It's more a coda of "Each And Everyday" than a filler. This is a short beautiful love song with the music of Vangelis providing the ambient to Anderson's voice. "A Play Within A Play" is from "Short Stories". It's a sublime dreamy song that is, for me, with "Curious Electric" and "Far Away In Baagad" one of the three best moments on "Short Stories". It starts slow and grows up until reaches the climax and in the end it returns and dissipates slowly again. "And When The Night Comes" is from "Private Collection". It's a nice and pleasant song clearly focused on Anderson. It's an electronic melodic song typical of the 80's but it has unfortunately bad lyrics. The lyrics are awful, lame, trivial and almost laughable. "Deborah" is from "Private Collection". It's a song in the same vein of "And When The Night Comes". It's dedicated to Anderson's eldest daughter and fortunately the lyrics are better than on "And When The Night Comes". It's a nice and mellow song where once more we can hear a good orchestral arrangement. "Curious Electric" is from "Short Stories". It's a superb and brilliant song that begins to create the perfect atmosphere along the entire "Short Stories". On this track Vangelis is simply brilliant. In my opinion, this is one of the best compositions ever written by him. "The Friends Of Mr. Cairo" is from "The Friends Of Mr. Cairo". It's a funny fine piece, worthy of being part of a soundtrack for a "B" class American film noir of the 30's and 40's. Despite be a bit a commercial song it has enough to be considered a good piece. "Back To School" is from "The Friends Of Mr. Cairo". It's a funny rock'n'roll song played with keyboards, a nice and pure synth pop song of the 80's with good rhythm and nothing boring. Still, this is a vulgar song without anything of special on it to offer. "Italian Song" is from "Private Collection". It's a beautiful and celestial song with an absolutely perfect and majestic combination between Anderson's magical voice and the beautiful and floating Vangelis' keyboard sound. "Polonaise" is from "Private Collection". This is an intense, catchy, mellow and beautiful love song with plenty of sugar. Beware with your CD player. If Jon & Vangelis would have competed on the European Song Contest, they probably would win it. "Love Is" is from "Short Stories". It's a nice and mellow love song but is at the same time too much sentimental and bore. This song represents for me the lower point on "Short Stories".

Conclusion: As I wrote when I reviewed "The Best Of Jon & Vangelis", "Chronicles" is a better compilation album than "The Best Of Jon & Vangelis" is. It has more five songs and it's probably most representative of the musical career of Jon & Vangelis. All tracks are in general good and it has also some great tracks like "Beside", "The Friends Of Mr. Cairo" and "He Is Sailing". By the other hand, all six tracks chosen from "Short Stories" are great but I left out them purposely. As I mentioned on my review about "The Best Of Jon & Vangelis", "Short Stories" always was my favourite part of the project. And, it displeases me a little bit that "Short Stories" was separated into several parts. I always saw "Short Stories" as a whole and solid piece of music. However, "Chronicles" remains for me a good compilation album.

Prog is my Ferrari. Jem Godfrey (Frost*)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Distance over Time by DREAM THEATER album cover Studio Album, 2019
3.62 | 544 ratings

BUY
Distance over Time
Dream Theater Progressive Metal

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars After the rampant backlash of fans against the double album 'The Astonishing', Dream Theater returned with a concise yet focused album that could only be seen as a "back to basics" effort - 2019's 'Distance over Time' is the fourteenth studio album by American progressive metal headliners and is a creative offering that eventually sees the band at their most appealing and accessible in years. This album seems to be all about the songs, the feel and the sound that comes out of a band playing together in a cabin, which is exactly the location at which the album was recorded. Taking less than three weeks to record 'Distance over Time', we have a Dream Theater focused on their hard-rocking influences as well as occasional glimpses of a glam flamboyancy. Of course, this comes at the premise that none of the complexity or intricacy of the usual DT sound gets compromised; instead, there is a flaring, well-executed amalgamation between accessible and progressive.

Full of memorable riffs and vibrant guitar and keyboard solos, this album is crafty and focused, there is a generally uplifting feel to it and a recognizable swagger that definitely makes it a more universally appealing work. No big suites, no mind-blowing twists, no excessive point, just a more straightforward and organic playing, which also allows James LaBrie to shine on with one of his better performances in recent years. Each song kind of lives a life of its own and what might amaze you about this release is the fact that there are no weak entries on here - from the melodramatic opener 'Untethered Angel' and the elegiac 7-minute 'Fall Into the Light', to the sharp-edged and mechanical 'S2N' or the more complex arrangements of 'Pale Blue Dot', one might as well be drawn towards catchier numbers like 'Barstool Warrior' and the Van Halen-esque bonus track 'Viper King', this entire album is all about the songs, which are of pretty damn good quality all throughout. 'Distance over Time' is a welcome return to a more familiar but brilliantly-executed rocking sound for Dream Theater, with each band member showcasing why this is one of the most celebrated technical bands worldwide.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Deep Purple by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1969
3.65 | 730 ratings

BUY
Deep Purple
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by Lobster77

5 stars The third and final album from Deep Purple mark 1 lineup was different from the first two in that it was virtually all original material. The only cover being a slow Donovan track Lalena. The original material had a more progressive rock feel as on Taliesyn than the poppy sound of Shades. The opening cut Chasing Shadows is a Lord/Paice composition and not only showcases Ian Paice's undoubted claims to be one of rocks premier drummers but also makes you wonder why Jon Lord never contibuted more to the lyric writing department. The second track Blind, a Lord solo composition, adds strength to this argument and is in my opinion hugely underrated. Why Didn't Rosemary is quite possibly Rod Evans finest contribution to Purple with both interesting lyrics and a good delivery. Bird Has Flown is another interesting composition, a different version was recorded as a B side and is possibly better than the album version. There is also a version with an Ian Gillan vocal recorded sometime later which is also worth tracking down. The main cut on the album though is the epic closer April. A spectacular rock opera track with orchestra and a particularly pleasing vocal it serves as a perfect appetiser to the Concerto.

During the recording of this album Blackmore/Lord and Paice decided that Rod Evans was struggling with the heavier material and needed replacing. Nick Simper too was declared surplus to requirements and they were subsequently replaced by Ian Gillan and Roger Glover, thus giving birth to one of the greatest ever band in the history of rock. In fact Gillan and Glover were already on board before this album was officially released in the UK.

Rod Evans is often given a bit of a rough deal by fans and press alike presumably because of the so called Deep Purple scam of 1980. However, it is worth pointing out that he was a vital member of the legend that is Deep Purple and his part in the building of that legend should not be forgotten. The early success of Hush in US was due more to his 60's pop crooner delivery than the musical talents of Blackmore and Lord. Without that early success there is no guarantee that Blackmore/Lord/paice would have stuck at it through three commercially unsuccessful albums. It was unfortunate for Evans that whilst Blackmore Lord and Paice were waiting to embrace the heavier sound with open arms he was much more at home with the soon to be outdated sixties sound. It is somewhat ironic that his final Purple album was probably his best individual performance and that his next musical project "Captain Beyond" is still regarded by many as a prog classic. The same can be said of Simper and "Warhorse". With regard to the 80's scam looking back at it now it is difficult to see what the fuss was about. He was after all an original member of the band and there was no other Deep Purple around at the time. I am being purely mischevious here but you would think that a good lawyer would be able to argue that there is as much validity in a Deep Purple which features Rod Evans as the only original member as one which features only Ian Paice from the original line up. As if that would ever happen...

4.99

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 For Your Pleasure by ROXY MUSIC album cover Studio Album, 1973
4.17 | 390 ratings

BUY
For Your Pleasure
Roxy Music Crossover Prog

Review by Lobster77

4 stars A darker more nocturnal album from glam / art rockers Roxy Music. Before I listened to this, I thought Roxy Music was sweet, edgeless 80s pop, 'cos I only knew the song Avalon. But this album definately does have an edge (as well as its older brother, which was simply titled Roxy Music), or has even gone over it, with dark lyrics and weird atmospheres, best showing in "In every Dream Home a Heartache", which sets off with a (musically) minimalistic poem like sequence to continue with a really hardrockin' solo. Another paranoid song like this is "The Bogus Man", a static drumbeat with the instruments used to create an atmosphere rather than really play melodies, though it still is music. Other stand out tracks are "Do the Strand" and "Editions of You", which are glamhardrock at its best. The fragile vocals and groovy keyboards of Bryan Ferry, the dirty saxophone of Andy Macay, the screamy but controlled guitar of Phil Manzera and the drumming of Paul Thompson are all excellent and the album is spiced up with the spaced out electronic sounds of Ambientmusicinventor to be Brian Eno.

4.5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 World Citizen (with Ryuichi Sakamoto) by SYLVIAN, DAVID album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2003
4.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
World Citizen (with Ryuichi Sakamoto)
David Sylvian Crossover Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

— First review of this album —
4 stars 'World Citizen' is a 2003 collaborative EP released by Japanese sound designer Ryuichi Sakamoto and ex-Japan frontman and moody crooner David Sylvian, containing two distinct versions of a song that was supposed to be part of a series of projects developed by the two musicians upon the instigation of the former. Of course, the collaborative efforts between these well-known figures in the world of art rock/pop date back to the 1983 single 'Forbidden Colors', a fairly well-known piece of music that has surfaced the discographies of both ever since. Now, on 'World Citizen' two distinct compositions appear - the self-titled one, which is a more traditionally-structured piece of art rock with acoustic guitars, gentle melodies and soft synth sounds in the background, reflecting upon the superpowers' fowl play, so to say. The EP offers a shorter version, a longer one (with slightly extended instrumentals), and a Ryoji Ikeda remixed versions, quite an interesting addition to the release, more pertinent to glitch pop and electronica, patchy but really effective.

The other version is the 'I Won't Be Disappointed' one, and this is where the influence of Sakamoto is more prevalent as we hear a more electronic and beat-driven piece within which the vocals fit perfectly well the collage of piano samples and static sounds purveying the piece with ambient qualities. The longer version here works in a really sublime way and perhaps overshadows the other number on the EP. Interestingly enough, a re-arranged version of this song appears on a compilation album released recently by Sylvian, adding up to the appeal of this track. Overall, this is an excellent release replete with emotive sounds, comforting and smooth, sufficiently avant-garde but never really overdone, a strong work that combines two complementary musical forces.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Parasomnia by DREAM THEATER album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.02 | 276 ratings

BUY
Parasomnia
Dream Theater Progressive Metal

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

3 stars Unanimously seen as a reunion album for Dream Theater (despite the band never really going away), 2025's 'Parasomnia' marks the surprising and exciting return of original drummer and founding member Mike Portnoy, restoring the lineup that had been responsible for all of the fantastic albums released between 1999 and 2009. This new album by the kings of progressive metal is the sixteenth overall in their studio catalogue, expanding upon the material released in the last fifteen years, with the band loading up on their darker riff-heavy compositions that encapsulate both the melodic and the more technical aspects of their sound. Not a concept album, but a thematically cohesive work centered around the consequences and impacts of sleep disruption, intertwining this thread into their diverse and intriguing stories, as told on 'Parasomnia', this album generally seems to have something stylistically in common with both the self-titled album from 2013 and 'Train of Thought', both darker and heavier albums from the past.

Of course, the return of Mike Portnoy does not necessarily imply a return to the band's state prior to the 2010s, since the inventive and eccentric drummer did not redeem any of his production duties (handled exclusively by Petrucci) and it is not directly discernible how involved he has been with the songwriting process here, the direction of the music, or the conceptual side of it all (credited with writing the lyrics of just one of the six non-instrumental songs), which have more recently been dominated by the ideas and vision of John Petrucci and Jordan Rudess. With this in mind, 'Parasomnia' seems to be a direct continuation of the rather fine thread of albums released by Dream Theater between 2011 and 2021, and the similarities are quite tangible. This new work introduces nothing unheard of before - the cathartic and sophisticated songwriting dominates most of the songs on 'Parasomnia', which are quite effective and exhibit some really excellent riffs, mind-boggling guitar solos as well as well-written and memorable melodies, many of which can in reality be traced back to past works. The intricacy is here, the depth and the texture of the music are here, together with the signature dramatic delivery of James LaBrie. With the sole exceptions of 'Bend the Clock' and the big closing epic, 'Parasomnia' is incredibly consistent, enjoyable and generally uplifting, there is a sense of rejuvenation brought along by Portnoy's return, even if the album closely follows the well-known DT template, making it a fine listen and a more guitar-driven offering that probably lacks some of that characteristic flair, ever so poignant on some of the classic albums from the 2000s era of the band.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Agony by FLESHGOD APOCALYPSE album cover Studio Album, 2011
3.82 | 29 ratings

BUY
Agony
Fleshgod Apocalypse Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

2 stars 'Agony' is the second studio album by Italian symphonic death metal band Fleshgod Apocalypse, released in 2011 through fames German record label Nuclear Blast, and generally expanding upon the stylistic pursuits of earlier releases by the band originally coming from the city of Perugia. Bookmarked by shorter instrumental opening and closing pieces, there are eight songs in total making up the contents of this rather messy work, blending together the two seemingly opposite worlds of symphonic music and brutal death metal, an amalgamation of genres that is incredibly difficult to pull off, with some bands succeeding at it being Greek act Septicflesh and Finnish band Children of Bodom. Unfortunately, 'Agony', amidst all of the praise received over the years, is an album that is as unlistenable as it is bold and ambitious.

Generally consisting of fast-paced death metal songs with orchestral samples running in the background, the guitar riffs are hardly discernible in the final mix, and the listener might have severe difficulty in unearthing any of them, completely lost among the unnecessary and overblown use of symphonic elements and the scorchingly fast drumming (the overusing of blast beats does not help either), mechanical and all over the place, completely lacking any liveliness or musicality. Just crass and insensitive heaviness prevailing all over the place, hardly working together with the orchestral samples, ultimately hindered even further by the weak vocals, and this goes both for the harsh death metal growls (not particularly noteworthy in the context of the genre), and for the high-pitched semi-operatic clean vocals, entirely below par and uninteresting. Don't get me wrong, all the elements of a fine symphonic death metal album seem to be there, it is just that the execution of it all that is really poor, with most of the songs being virtually buried under the overtones of tremolo-picked guitars strumming that one chord, the indulgent use of orchestration and the extremely fast-paced drums, produced rather artificially. Still, among all the critical aspects, songs like 'The Deceit', 'The Egoism', and the title track, manage to present a better view of the aims of this record, butchered by the overall approach of the band and their production team.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Killers by IRON MAIDEN album cover Studio Album, 1981
3.61 | 653 ratings

BUY
Killers
Iron Maiden Prog Related

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

3 stars Iron Maiden quickly followed-up their self-titled debut album with 1981's 'Killers', an album compiled of various recordings either left over from the previous sessions of the band or songs already performed live and further honed in the studio. Not only this but this is a record that, above all else, explores more in depth the group's punk rock influences, which definitely help in rendering this LP a catchy, rough and hook-driven one. Famously, this is the final studio recording with vocalist Paul Di'Anno and the first appearance of guitarist Adrian Smith, although this minute lineup change is yet to become effective stylistically for what concerns Maiden's very own brand of heavy metal. 'Killers' is generally in line with the debut album and is quite similar to it in terms of scope, production, and songwriting, and while 'Iron Maiden' had several really melodic (and even softer) spots, this album is a more combatant and upbeat one.

Once again the music is riff- and hook-driven, with occasional glimpses of more technical playing, despite the fact that Maiden seem to have focused exclusively on writing shorter songs here. There is a sense of tension within the music and a broad lack of incredibly exciting ideas, and to put it plainly, 'Killers' does not even dare to overachieve what the debut album had already achieved and introduced as a stylistic trope, as musical vision and as a general progression within the world of heavy rock. Just a pretty good album that is rather similar to its predecessor, giving us interesting songs like the opening instrumental 'The Ides of March', the extremely catchy (and overly punky) 'Wrathchild' and 'Murders in the Rue Morgue', as well as the strong title track with its fine riffs and generous bass sounds. 'Prodigal Son' offers a counterforce to the overall heaviness but then come putrid songs like 'Purgatory' and 'Drifter', completely ruining the ending of an otherwise imperfect studio album. Perhaps 'Killers' was never meant to be as good, despite the occasional glimpses of fine writing and inspired playing, this is the album showing the signs of why this iteration of Maiden could not have lived on.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 For Girls Who Grow Plump in the Night by CARAVAN album cover Studio Album, 1973
4.19 | 923 ratings

BUY
For Girls Who Grow Plump in the Night
Caravan Canterbury Scene

Review by Kaiba

5 stars Definitely one of the best albums of Caravan. Mostly constituted by instrumental pieces, this album lays less stress on vocal parts, which may be the reason why it is sometimes eclipsed by former albums like "the land...". But it's still an indeed masterpiece that may even reach new heights in the essence of being a Canterbury Scene with all the superb performances made mainly by keyboard or drum. In particular, "memory lain"features truly uplifting passages and "surprise, surprise"is a real surprise as well. The combination of viola and strings also add a distinctive texture to this album, which can be highlighted the most in "a hunting...".

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Deep Purple by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1969
3.65 | 730 ratings

BUY
Deep Purple
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by Hector Enrique
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Using as cover a section of the triptych painted in oil on boards "The Garden of Earthly Delights" by the Dutch artist Hieronymus Bosch of the XV century, Deep Purple published in the epilogue of the sixties the last chapter of the trilogy that marked the point and apart of their first stage, simply titled "Deep Purple" (1969).

An album that maintains that explorer and psychedelic spirit sprinkled with traces of classical music of its predecessor "The Book of Taliesyn", in themes that include African percussive elements by the hand of Ian Paice in the tribal "Chasing Shadows", Jon Lord's warm harpsichord notes on the baroque "Blind", Rod Evans' Greg Lake-esque Crimsonian singing on the delicate cover of the Scottish Donovan "Lalena", and schizoid studio tricks using reverse tapes on the brief instrumental "Fault Line"; and also shows Ritchie Blackmore very involved in the composition with a rich display of riffs and distorted guitar solos interspersed with Lord's hammonds, especially in the funky "The Painter", in the bluesy "Why Didn't Rosemary? " (with an alternative thematic approach to Roman Polasky's creepy film "The Rosemary's Baby"), and in the thick, lingering cadence of the narcotized "The Bird Has Flown".

And if there is a song that could summarize the first stage of the band, that would be the mini-suite "April": the interest in experimental atmospheres in the medieval and beautiful introduction of church organs and acoustic guitars, Lord's persistent concern for incorporating classical components with the arrangement of violins in between, and the incipient hard rock still to take off that appeared in the final stretch of the long track.

Given the scarce commercial repercussion of the album and convinced that the band would not have much more future in the cloudy paths of psychedelia and sixties sonorities, Blackmore and Lord then incorporated Ian Gillan and Roger Glover, dispensing with Rod Evans and Nick Simper in the search of hardening their sound, more in accordance with the powerful style piloted by the overwhelming Led Zeppelin. Thus ended the appreciable formative stage of Deep Purple.

3.5/4 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Lucro Sucio: Los Ojos del Vacío by MARS VOLTA, THE album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.58 | 39 ratings

BUY
Lucro Sucio: Los Ojos del Vacío
The Mars Volta Heavy Prog

Review by Dapper~Blueberries
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Well this is unexpected. I had a feeling that they would make a new album, but I didn't expect them to just?drop something out of the blue. I expected at least a few singles, but honestly the only shred of advertisement that the band had done for Lucro sucio; los ojos del vacio was that tour they held with Deftones and Fleshwater, which I actually went to a show during said tour. That was when I got a taste of what the album would be like, and in turn, got quite hyped since the live version of these songs were really good!

Though, what about the actual studio output? Well with the band going pop in their last album, I figured they'd continue that streak, but instead Lucro sucio; los ojos del vacio changed things up dramatically, and honestly it took a bit to grow on me. In a way this is probably their most psychedelic venture yet since Noctourniquet, hell probably more.

If I had to describe the sound on this album, it'd probably be if Spiritualized made an album that was a lot more pop focused and had Latino elements.

It's very much a mix of ambient pop, art rock, and neo-psychedelia, rolled in a blanket that is not too dissimilar to some of Omar Rodriguez Lopez's solo works. It's honestly such a weird, but cool sound for the band to do. Cedric's voice is more of a focus here too, giving out very beautiful performances that are a stark contrast to the hard edged stuff he had made in the past. Not only that, but the fact the band is changing things up, even under a pop context, shows their progginess thoroughly even when they moved away from prog. Would I consider Lucro sucio; los ojos del vacio prog rock? No. Maybe prog pop at most, but this is definitely not under the same threshold as The Bedlam Of Goliath. But even still, this is such a different direction to go compared to what one would expect coming off of their last album.

However, I can definitely see why a lot of people are kind of coming into it very confused and lost, because?this album is just weird? It has the beats of a modern day Mars Volta album, but it never really presents itself as one? I don't know how to describe it, but at least initially it doesn't feel like a Mars Volta album. Sure you could say that about their self-titled too, but that one I'd say would still be recognizable as a Mars Volta album, even to the most casual of fans. This album, though, feels so out of left field even for a band such as this, that it ends up being kind of hard to get into, at least for me.

This album's biggest weakness is that while every song is good, even some really great ones like The Iron Rose or Morgana, the aforementioned confusion still persists, and I end up having more questions than answers. I have gotten more accustomed to it with each relisten, and now see it as another album by The Mars Volta, but even if I may have the pieces to the puzzle, organizing the picture is still quite hard.

I also think a weakness this album has is, while this may be more personal, I feel like the live versions I had heard in that Deftones concert sounded better, and thus I am just a tiny bit disappointed in the studio output. Now, no duh, of course songs sound better live, but like?if you listen to old live recordings from the band, it's clear that their studio and live sessions had a similar quality to both. Like, there are some differences, like the live material being far more jammier and wild, but at the end of the day the studio version of say, Tetragrammaton, sounds just as good as the live version of it. Lucro sucio; los ojos del vacio, though, sounds kind of empty on occasion in the studio compared to what I had heard live. It's not an awful emptiness, but it's very apparent these songs are more meant to be played live.

But, perhaps this direction ends up making this one of the most interesting Mars Volta albums ever. I mean, sure it may not be conceptually as interesting as Frances The Mute, but musically it's very?anti-Mars Volta. It's as if the very band itself went into an opposite world, and recorded an album with their mirrored counterparts. It's a bizarro Mars Volta, having beats and melodies that feel like something the band would make, but just off enough for it to be quite the head turner. And honestly, in this context, the album just becomes 10x cooler! It's so Mars Volta to make a Mars Volta album that doesn't vibe like a Mars Volta album.

Initially this album was a 3.5/5, but with each new listen I end up raising the bar a tad higher. Now, at a 4.5/5, I think I now know what to say. The Mars Volta NEVER misses. Sure, some of their releases are better than others, but if you ever ask me if they have any bad albums, I'd tell you no. They have unique, strange, and off putting material, but they do not make bad music EVER. Anyways, listen to Lucro sucio; los ojos del vacio, it's great.

Best tracks: The Iron Rose, Cue the Sun, Celaje, Morgana, Cue the Sun (Reprise)

Worst tracks: Mito de los trece cielos, Detrás de la puerta dorada

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Algorythm by BEYOND CREATION album cover Studio Album, 2018
3.64 | 17 ratings

BUY
Algorythm
Beyond Creation Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars "Algorythm" is the third full-length studio album by Canadian, Quebec based technical/progressive death metal act Beyond Creation. The album was released through Season of Mist in October 2018. It´s the successor to "Earthborn Evolution" from 2014. There´s been one lineup change since the release of "Earthborn Evolution" as bassist Dominic Lapointe has left and has been replaced by Hugo Doyon-Karout. Lapointe is a pretty prolific musician on the Quebec music scene having been a member of/or is still a member of acts like Atheretic, Augury, and First Fragment, making an audible impact with his fretless bass playing, so it´s big shoes Doyon-Karout has to fill.

Stylistically Beyond Creation continues the high energy technical death metal style with progressive songwriting ideas of the last couple of albums. The fretless bass provides the music with an audible bass presence and a fluid organic flow. "Algorythm" is in most other ways not organic at all. It´s actually a pretty sterile sounding release and the mellow excursions into jazz/fusion and progressive rock/metal territories do nothing to change that perception of the music. Beyond Creation are incredibly well playing and perform many virtuosic guitar riffs- and leads, the above mentioned technical fretless bass playing, a technical drumming attack, and vocals which shift between deep growling and higher pitched screaming/snarling. To my ears the most valid reference is Obscura, but the aforementioned Augury is another.

The sound production is massive, layered, and detailed, but I´m not blown away by the sound, which for all its well sounding qualities ends up presenting the music in a slightly powerless fashion. So upon conclusion "Algorythm" is a bit more shallow in the songwriting- and in the performance deparments than the band´s earlier releases and paired with a sound production which doesn´t provide the music with the needed boost of power, "Algorythm" ultimately comes off a less accomplished release than the preceding albums from Beyond Creation. It´s still a good quality technical/progressive death metal release, but it´s not exactly among the elite albums of the genre. A 3.5 star (70%) rating is deserved.

(Originally posted on Metal Music Archives).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Garden Electric by JUPITER FUNGUS album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.19 | 34 ratings

BUY
Garden Electric
Jupiter Fungus Eclectic Prog

Review by TenYearsAfter

4 stars After Methexis, Verbal Delirium, Naxatras, Residuos Mentales and Forbidden Myth, here's another interesting current prog band from Greece named Jupiter Fungus, a studio project featuring Papatriantafillou (keyboards, guitar and vocals) and Fotis Xenikoudakis (flute and tin whistle), it was set up to pay homage to the legendary bands associated with the progressive and classic rock scene of the 1970s, from Jethro Tull and Focus to Pink Floyd and Deep Purple, and other. Band info. "Although essentially just a duo, selected studio musicians were also recruited to enable them to create their debut album Garden Electric: George Papageorgiou (bass, acoustic guitar and glockenspiel), George Emmanuel (electric guitar) and Nick Vell (drums). With the liberal use of a variety of keyboards and flute, augmented by some powerful guitars and a solid drum and bass foundation, the four-track album of just under 50 minutes is brimming with vibrant arrangements and unexpected shifts."

Underdog: The powerful and dynamic foundation in this long composition is a swinging mid-tempo beat, the bass even sounds pretty funky. The music is embellished with swirling work on the distinctive Hammond organ (reminding me of Booker T.), heavy guitar runs, frequent eruptions with flute and rock guitar, some spoken words in English, a dual- guitar sound with Hammond, a sparkling flute - and fiery guitar solo and a spectacular Minimoog solo with pitchbend, wow, what an exciting start by this new band on this debut album!

Circles: In the first part a catchy beat with a powerful bass and sparkling flute and Hammond layers, soon joined by the cheerful tin whistle. Then a swirling Hammond solo, sparkling flute work, fueled by awesome rhythm-section, (like 70s Camel with Peter Bardens). Halfway a nice break with spacey synthesizers, a hypnotizing rhythm-section, soaring flute work (the bass work reminds me of In A Gadda Da Vida from Iron Butterfly), subtle electric piano runs and a spacey slightly distorted guitar solo. The final part contains a more lush sound with flute traverse and a moving guitar solo.

Past Ground: First a dreamy intro with Andean flute-like sound, beautiful. Then a swinging rhythm with powerful flute work in the vein of Ian Anderson. Back to dreamy with soaring flute and Hammond, distorted vocals in a catchy beat. Next a short, more experimental part. Then a sumptuous eruption with Hammond, in a catchy beat with heavy guitar sound and sparkling flute, powerful vocals, and a fiery guitar solo, topped with an exciting Hammond solo. The band succeeds to blend obvious 70s prog echoes with a fresh and modern sound and strong musical ideas.

Thoughts of Revenge: This epic final composition is the most eclectic and dynamic one featuring lots of surprising changing atmospheres, the band in its full splendor. From a spacey intro synthesizer and soaring flute to a more polished sound with soulful vocals. From a rock guitar explosion with heavy Hammond and powerful vocals (evoking Pink Floyd) to a flashy synthesizer solo with pitchbend. And from a mellow climate with flute to halfway a slow swinging rhythm with omnipresent flute play. The final part delivers a compelling atmosphere with a strongly built up David Gilmour kind of guitar solo, this is Symphonic Rock Heaven!

What an excellent debut by this new Greek formation, loaded with dynamics, tension, strong musical ideas and exciting soli, and performed by skilled musicians, highly recommended!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Still the Orchestra Plays - Greatest Hits Volume 1 & 2 by SAVATAGE album cover Boxset/Compilation, 2010
3.95 | 12 ratings

BUY
Still the Orchestra Plays - Greatest Hits Volume 1 & 2
Savatage Progressive Metal

Review by martindavey87

4 stars 'Still the Orchestra Plays' is a 2010 compilation album by legendary cult metal band Savatage. After years of inactivity, this CD package just randomly popped up from nowhere and probably left most fans wondering if it was a sign that anything new was coming. Sadly, that was not the case, as it would be another three years until the band would once more pop up out of the blue with a re-released narrated version of their rock opera, 'Streets'.

But back to this one, and yeah, as you'd expect, this is a fantastic compilation! Two discs full of absolutely top quality music. Sure, there's a few omissions that I feel should have been included, but overall, it's a nice career retrospective, perfect for newcomers to the band, or long-time fans who need a reminder of how brilliant these guys are.

From 'Power of the Night', 'Hall of the Mountain King', 'Gutter Ballet' and 'Edge of Thorns', to the likes of 'Morphine Child', 'The Wake of Magellan', 'Chance' and 'One Child', there's no shortage of Savatage classics here. And three newly-recorded acoustic versions of previous hits are a welcome sign that the band were still trying to somewhat maintain active.

This CD package comes with a bonus DVD, which has the classic 'Japan Live '94' concert on it. Originally released on VHS, it was nice to finally be able to own a copy of this. Granted, the sound and picture are quite dated, but the performances are excellent, and it's just great to be able to see a full concert video of the band.

Overall, this is, quite simply, a fantastic compilation. It's definitely a great starting point for newcomers, but also has plenty of value for fans too. A worthy addition to any rock or metal collection!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Abacab by GENESIS album cover Studio Album, 1981
2.62 | 1518 ratings

BUY
Abacab
Genesis Symphonic Prog

Review by Lobster77

3 stars While I do understand that this Genesis is not a past Genesis, that's not why I think that Abacab lacked a lot of quality compositions, or consistency for that matter. After the outstanding Duke, there is a drop-off, but it's not the worst album ever. One big difference is the solo works, which this time are limited to one by each; that turns out to be a good thing. Tony Banks' "Me and Sarah Jane" is a rather uneven piece, with some great moments but some rather overdone ones. Meanwhile Phil Collins' "Man on the Corner" (a minor hit), and Mike Rutherford's "Like it or Not" seem routine and somewhat boring, let alone generic; the former two pieces also further Collins' obsession with drum machines.

The rest of the album? The title track is a great composition, but Banks tends to overdo the synths and drown out everything else, a sign of what you'll hear for the entire album. "No Reply at All" is one of the couple gems here, a pop radio staple augmented by the same horn section from Earth, Wind & Fire and great bass work by Rutherford. "Keep it Dark" is not a bad song, but again I fault Banks for being too heavy with the keys. "Dodo/Lurker," the other long track here, is the other truly good piece; it likely has the best lyrics on the entire album, and Rutherford gets a chance to shine some on the six-string. I don't need to comment on one of the worst Genesis pieces ever, "Who Dunnit?" for every other review echoes my comments on that song. "Another Record" closes, which is somewhat bland, but at least Banks' piano is near its best for this album.

The eponymous follow-up would be a nice rebound for me (if that proves that my problems aren't because of Genesis' identity), but I found Abacab to seem rather run-of-the-mill and not easy to get into.

3.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Fauna by HAKEN album cover Studio Album, 2023
3.90 | 225 ratings

BUY
Fauna
Haken Heavy Prog

Review by arcane-beautiful

5 stars The band's most recent album, it saw them take what they have previously achieved and take it to it's absolute zenith. Being their 7th album out of a mostly flawless discography, on this it is very much a diverse palette showing off everything that makes the band brilliant, with great detail to every aspect of their sound. While each song has its own unique characteristics, the album showcases the bands secret weapon, guitarist and songwriter Charlie Griffiths who contributed a large amount to this album, especially with the epic penultimate song Elephants Never Forget, which possibly may be the finest track they've ever produced. A real gem in the age of current progressive metal.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 All Rights Removed by AIRBAG album cover Studio Album, 2011
4.01 | 553 ratings

BUY
All Rights Removed
Airbag Neo-Prog

Review by ironman2002

4 stars Great album perfectly recorded

That was the first work of the band I had a chance to listen to after being very impressed with Bjorn Riis' solo album Fimbulvinter. Right from the start, All Rights Removed gave me clear vibes of Porcupine Tree, with passionate, crying- like solo guitar work reminiscent of David Gilmour. The vocals sound strikingly similar to Steven Wilson, adding to that haunting, melancholic atmosphere.

The lyrical themes revolve around inner struggles, heavy emotions, and a sense of loss, which is perfectly complemented by the introspective nature of the band's music. While the chord progressions stay in the realm of classic rock or post-rock simplicity, the long, immersive song structures shift the album closer to epic progressive territory.

The production is nothing short of stunning. Every chord, every cymbal hit is rendered with pristine clarity, showing the engineer's meticulous attention to detail. There's a cinematic feel throughout the album, as if each track tells a slow-burning emotional story.

All Rights Removed is a sad, but incredibly beautiful work. It's a deeply immersive experience that fans of atmospheric progressive rock will truly appreciate. This album has certainly made me want to explore more of Airbag's discography. 4/5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Fimbulvinter by RIIS, BJØRN album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.93 | 50 ratings

BUY
Fimbulvinter
Bjørn Riis Crossover Prog

Review by ironman2002

4 stars High quality

Fimbulvinter by Bjorn Riis is a deep, haunting, and melancholic album that showcases his signature atmospheric soundscapes. Tastefully composed and performed effectively with both acoustic and electric instruments, the album draws listeners into an introspective journey. The track "She" stands out for its sincerity and emotional depth, highlighting Riis's ability to convey raw feelings through subtle arrangements and heartfelt melodies.

The title track, "Fimbulvinter," is probably the proggiest piece on the album. It starts off with heavy prog rock energy, transitions into a melodic passage, and then masterfully combines both elements. This progression expands into other musical forms reminiscent of Pink Floyd's ambient textures and late Opeth's emotional dynamics. Riis's skill in blending these influences while maintaining a unique voice is impressive.

Overall, Fimbulvinter is a very satisfying listen for fans of progressive and atmospheric rock, offering both emotional weight and musical sophistication.

4.4/5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Solar Fire by MANN'S EARTH BAND, MANFRED album cover Studio Album, 1973
4.01 | 424 ratings

BUY
Solar Fire
Manfred Mann's Earth Band Eclectic Prog

Review by iliya

4 stars Released in 1973, Solar Fire stands as one of Manfred Mann's Earth Band's most daring and cohesive works, merging progressive rock with cosmic themes and electronic experimentation. The album opens powerfully with "Father of Day, Father of Night"?a haunting rework of a Bob Dylan tune?setting the tone for a journey through mythology, astronomy, and human evolution.

Highlights include the hypnotic title track, a swirling Moog-driven instrumental, and "Saturn, Lord of the Ring / Mercury, the Winged Messenger", an epic prog suite blending classical influences with rock energy. While less commercially successful than later hits like "Blinded by the Light," Solar Fire remains a fan favorite for its ambition, atmosphere, and musicianship.

A must-listen for prog enthusiasts and 70s rock fans, this album proves Manfred Mann's Earth Band was far ahead of its time.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Omni by KARFAGEN album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.24 | 98 ratings

BUY
Omni
Karfagen Symphonic Prog

Review by ironman2002

4 stars Antony Kalugin created another beauty

Karfagen's OMNI is a breathtaking progressive rock album that showcases the band's signature blend of rich melodies, dynamic instrumentation, and thoughtful composition. From the very first track, the album feels incredibly accessible ? a rare feat in the world of complex prog music. Whether you're a seasoned prog fan or a newcomer, OMNI draws you in with its uplifting spirit and emotional depth.

The arrangements are lush and intricate without ever feeling overwhelming. There's a clear sense of purpose behind every musical transition, and the band's chemistry shines throughout. The album is brilliantly recorded, with a warm, polished sound that brings out every nuance of the performances. From soaring guitar solos to expressive keyboards and vibrant acoustic textures, OMNI is a sonic journey that leaves a lasting impression.

Karfagen has created a work of art that's both sophisticated and soul-stirring ? an absolute gem in modern prog.

4.3/5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Un'Altra Mano Di Carte by LIMITE ACQUE SICURE album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.02 | 67 ratings

BUY
Un'Altra Mano Di Carte
Limite Acque Sicure Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by ironman2002

4 stars RPI gem

Un'altra Mano Di Carta by Limite Acque Sicure is a stunning album that showcases the band's ability to blend emotional storytelling with refined musicianship. The album is very accessible, drawing listeners in with its warm sound and heartfelt performances. It's also incredibly melodic and beautiful, offering a lush listening experience that's both comforting and thought-provoking.

The first track is solid and sets the tone well, but it's the remaining five songs that really shine. Each of them brings something special?whether it's a soaring chorus, a delicate instrumental moment, or a powerful vocal delivery. The album is dramatically performed, with real intensity and feeling in every note, and it's all nicely recorded, with clear, rich sound that highlights the emotional depth of the music.

This is the kind of album that grows on you with each listen, revealing new details and resonances. A truly rewarding release from a very talented band.

4.4/5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Remnants of Light by NEEDLEPOINT album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.86 | 28 ratings

BUY
Remnants of Light
Needlepoint Crossover Prog

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars After three straight albums with the same four piece lineup, we get some major changes for "Remnants Of Light" NEEDLEPOINT's most recent endeavour. This 2024 release saw half the band leave, but I'm thankful that the singer/guitarist and bass player remain. The new drummer is Ola Overby, as the previous drummer left and joined MOTORPSYCHO. The new keyboardist is Erlend Slettevoll who has played with Ola Kvernberg and Kjetil Moster, but more importantly to myself, he also was on that GRAND GENERAL record I adore.

The greatest strength of this band is their story telling. I used to roll my eyes when I'd open their liner notes and see a black page full of lyrics. The thing is, they tell stories of simple, everyday life, that we can all relate to. The album cover art is an example of this. And there's emotion in these simple stories about life. I feel like there's a shift happening here with their latest, as we get more of a GENESIS vibe with the vocals and sound. I'm talking about those mellow GENESIS tunes from the seventies, with those relaxed vocals that tugged at our emotions back in the day. Yes, GENESIS is brought into one of the stories here which is so cool, more on that later.

We get nine tracks and all but one are between 4 and 5 minutes in length. A more stream lined sound, and as a result more accessible than ever. Those distorted organ sounds are still here, bringing to mind that Canterbury flavour, but this album is a little different. I will still maintain that "Aimless Mary" and "Walking Up That Valley" are two of the greatest recordings to ever come out of Norway. I would rate "Remnants Of Light" and "The Diary Of Robert Reverie" as definite steps down from those, but these two are still essential in my musical world.

I have a top five with the first being track three called "While Our World Is Still Revolving". This one stands out for the bass playing and active drumming. Some flute and fiddle too, but I like the organ and clavinet over those. "Another Inch Towards You" brings back memories. And the melodies on here are so inviting. So uplifting this one. The closer "Blank Sheet" is surprisingly experimental to start but that is over quickly as 12 string guitar and vocals come out of that. The singing is in the GENESIS style. Active drumming once again and distorted organ too. Nice. The drumming is relentless on this one, to the point I'm thinking Ola's arms must be tired before it ends.

My top two are left, and these two tracks are among my favourites of 2024. The back to back "Where You Two Once Held hands" and "Large As Lakes". The first of those being the longest on the album at over 6 1/2 minutes(gasp). "Where You two Once Held Hands" is surprising for the vocal style and also who is singing. And that would be the bass player Nikolai Haengsle. There's some distorted organ and repeated themes. The drumming once again stands out. This could be a single. And it was stuck in my head often this past week.

My final top two is "Large As Lakes" and this is all about the words, but I feel that Bjorn Klakegg is one of the finest when it comes to writing lyrics these days. It opens with "Selling England By The Pound. Is from a song I heard a long time ago..." Mellow with reserved vocals, there is so much emotion on this track. It's the lyrics! Some guest clarinet as well.

Yes, this one is a little different from the previous three studio albums. A new lineup and sound you could say. This is a top ten for me for 2024.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Periphery IV: Hail Stan by PERIPHERY album cover Studio Album, 2019
4.06 | 70 ratings

BUY
Periphery IV: Hail Stan
Periphery Progressive Metal

Review by arcane-beautiful

5 stars When it comes to each aspect of the band's style and sound, this album is the perfect example of a band taking each of their qualities and using each song to microscope in detail what it is they are good at. Material wise, this showcases their strongest batch of songs, each being a unique gem to showcase their abilities and approach to their wide sonic palette. Spencer Sotelo gives the performance of his career, while the band are at their zenith when it comes to technical ability. Very epic throughout, whether that be on scope, power or drama, it is one of the most underlooked and greatest modern metal albums, especially within their own niche genre.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Deep Water by COSMIC CATHEDRAL album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.86 | 52 ratings

BUY
Deep Water
Cosmic Cathedral Symphonic Prog

Review by James007

5 stars Cosmic Cathedral - Deep Water Another Neal Morse group?. This time with Genesis live member Chester Thompson, long time CCM guitarist Phil Keaggy, and versatile session bassist Byron House. The result is Cosmic Cathedral. The album follows a familiar setup that Morse has followed on several projects: Two epics bookending some shorter pieces. In this case, leading off is a 14 minute epic "The Heart of Life", followed by three very different middle pieces then finishing with a 38 minute epic. Being a Neal Morse homer, I was probably going to like this album regardless. However, what I wasn't prepared for was how excellent the performances are by Thompson, Keaggy, and House. Chester is a much different drummer than Mike Portnoy and his style adds more of a jazz or funk feel to many passages on this record. I was concerned about him going into the record because he's 76 years old. I should have learned my lesson after recently seeing Ian Paice with Deep Purple who is the same age. He's still got it. I have been a fan of Phil Keaggy's since his days with Glass Harp in the early 70s. There's an urban legend that Hendrix referred to Keaggy as the world's greatest guitarist. Keaggy points out that they did record the first Glass Harp album at Hendrix's studio but this was only a couple of weeks before Hendrix died so it's unlikely he could have said this in an interview. In any event, Keaggy is a monster and has been for a long time. On "Deep Water", Keaggy is excellent. His solos are spot on and his vocals match very well with Neal's. The biggest surprise for on this album is Byron House. I had to look him up. As it turns out, he's got around 300 album credits to his name; many well known, and many in my collection. His playing on this record is just terrific. The concept for the album comes from Neal's autobiography where he describes his Christian conversion as a vision of standing at the top of a waterfall and being encouraged to jump into the water below. The Deep Water Suite goes back to the "launch out into the deep water" as a central theme of the epic. I am thoroughly enjoying this album and am regretting that I didn't get the signed copy. If you're a prog fan, you need this. If you're a Christian, it's a must have.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Libero Arbitrio by GHIRARDELLI, AMOS album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.00 | 2 ratings

BUY
Libero Arbitrio
Amos Ghirardelli Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by andrea
Prog Reviewer

4 stars "Libero arbitrio" is the first solo album by Amos Ghirardelli, a keyboard player and composer from Sassuolo, now based in the province of Venice, with years of experience behind him. It was released in 2024 on the independent Velut Luna label and recorded with the contribute of a group of talented musicians who help highlight the compositional value of the pieces, mostly inspired by the symphonic progressive rock of the seventies. In fact, the line-up includes Amos Ghiradelli himself (keyboards), Andrea Valfrč (keyboards), Filippo Ghirardelli (piano), Andrea Ghion (bass - from Egonon and Aldo Tagliapietra Band), Roberto Parolin (drums - from Egonon), Matteo Ballarin (guitar - from The Former Life and Aldo Tagliapietra Band) and Massimo Bellio (vocals). The recording sessions took place at Magister Recording Area, in Preganziol, Treviso on August and September 2024 and I'm sure that the final result will please many prog fans...

The title track, "Libero arbitrio" (Free will), is a sort of declaration of intent that opens the album. It's a long suite that starts by rarefied and dreamy atmospheres. The rhythm is slow but gradually grows while the melodic lines evoke strange trajectories in space and time. Then a short funky section followed by a marching beat introduces the sung part. The title refers to the capacity to choose between different possible courses of action, an ability that is connected to the concepts of moral responsibility, praise, culpability, advice, persuasion, deliberation and prohibition. But do not worry, this is not a boring philosophical treatise. The music and lyrics are meant to give a stern warning: it is better to take the time to listen and carefully consider the advice of interested benefactors who could do you a lot of harm. They are like beasts that hunt you, black crows that do not help you, they are like a pack of wicked children who do not know the limit of fear and who seek you... You've better get rid of those people! Think twice and make your own choices...

The long instrumental "Oltre la nebbia" (Beyond the fog) begins by a slow keyboard intro that paints in black the musical canvas. Then dark organ sounds set a mystical atmosphere and a sense of bewilderment and restlessness. The central section with a delicate piano theme could make one think of a boat searching for its way through the fog, illuminated by soft night lights, among the narrow canals of Venice, while the final part, more decisive and jazzy, seems to suggest the exit from the strange lagoon web made of fog, doubts and nostalgia and the beginning of a new journey towards the unknown...

"Frammento di me" (Fragment of me) is an introspective and melodic song that speaks of the awareness of one's choices with hermetic verses and fragmentary images. Without scruples the protagonist rearranges and finds new words that he then interprets. Shivers of fantasy flow and the colours of May offer us images and destinations without tomorrow where you can get lost. Try to surrender to dreams while the mind leads you to secret places where you can find new songs. Don't let yourself get down, choose and what you have chosen will become possible and will make you see the deception of your freedom...

Then comes another long instrumental piece, "Dreaming Sanremo". The organ introduction evokes an almost liturgical atmosphere, then the rhythm increases and the music takes you on unexpected paths, where relaxed and nocturnal moments alternate with sunny and majestic passages. The sky is a wonder and flowers are everywhere. Maybe it's not for nothing that Sanremo, the city of the title, is also known as the city of flowers. By the way, Sanremo is also famous for the Italian song festival, an event that fortunately has very little to do with this track...

The short instrumental "Malinconia" (Melancholy) closes the album with a soft and relaxed atmosphere. Here you can find a hint of nostalgia and a touch of regret while the notes are used as pastel colours to paint an expressionist picture...

On the whole, a very interesting album that is worth listening to.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Per Un Amico by PREMIATA FORNERIA MARCONI (PFM) album cover Studio Album, 1972
4.40 | 1982 ratings

BUY
Per Un Amico
Premiata Forneria Marconi (PFM) Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars The Italian progressive rock scene is one of the fascinating underground movements of the early 70s - the sounds developed by the likes of Genesis, Gentle Giant, ELP and King Crimson had obviously resonated strongly with several bands of this country, and among the pioneering ones of this era we shall necessarily discover Premiata Forneria Marconi, otherwise referred to as PFM. Releasing two albums in 1972, their second one titled 'Per Un Amico' ('For a Friend') is often seen as their definitive work, drawing heavily upon the stylistic pursuits of the aforementioned British bands, and with a particular taste for the pastoral and moody dreamscapes of Genesis. This five-song album was written by legendary guitar player Franco Mussida, keyboardist Flavio Premoli, and the band's flautist Mauro Pagani, also playing the violin on several tracks here, a lineup completed by percussionist Franz di Cioccio and bassist Giorgio Piazza, and continues the sound the band had presented on their debut album, released earlier that same year.

The music on 'Per Un Amico' seems to be quite mellow and atmospheric at first, later revealing many interesting and diverse layers and passages, as the listener understands that PFM were trying out a variety of different things musically, and very often to tremendous results, with the music being rather eclectic and intelligent. Relying on strong melodies and a sound that reminisces the crossover classical tropes of ELP, the Milan-founded group indicate a clear direction, a symphonic rock tendency that utilizes the expressive force of instruments like the flute, the violin, the piccolo, the Mellotron, and the harpsichord, giving the music a sense of ethereality and space, never really compromising the more technically acute and sophisticated sections on here, achieving a fine balance between texture, expression and experimentation. Opener 'Appena un Po'' might as well be the finest example of this melodic style that defines PFM, the dreamy interludes and the gentle vocal delivery seem to be among the cornerstones of the band's sound. This is later confirmed through the quirky title track and the moody piece 'Il Banchetto', replete with rich keyboard sounds. The instrumental 'Generale' offers a more upbeat approach, while the closing track 'Geranio' touches upon that avant-garde side of early prog, with miscellaneous instrumental twiddles at the end of the song.

The overall impression is of a dreamy and melodic symphonic rock album, heavily inspired by the music of the British originators of the progressive rock movement, and while 'Per Un Amico' offers an eclectic array of pastoral soundscapes, it generally seems to lack the grit and mysterious darkness of the music coming from the UK. Nevertheless, this is a classic album of the 70s that seems to be a must in every prog collection, and we could perhaps conclude that it is deservedly placed among the greatest releases of its time.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Rising by RAINBOW album cover Studio Album, 1976
4.22 | 646 ratings

BUY
Rising
Rainbow Prog Related

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

5 stars Ritchie Blackmore's Rainbow definitely consolidated themselves as a hard rock powerhouse with second album 'Rising', released in 1976 and featuring an updated lineup with newcoming drummer Cozy Powell, bassist Jimmy Bain and keyboard player Tony Carey, arguably forming (alongside Blackmore and Dio) the most solid and successful lineup of the British band. 'Rising' eventually takes up where the debut album had left off, but this Rainbow effort seems to be more focused on the rock aspects of the band's music, developing even further Blackmore's neo-classical guitar experiments and capturing a significantly more epic, towering and impeccable sound, which could have only rendered this album more elusive in its heaviness. Dropping off early attempts at writing boogie rock numbers, this LP is a more consistent, more focused work that is definitely progressive at its core in terms of approaching the traditional rock sound of the 70s and stretching it out to an early form of heavy metal.

Just six tracks appear on the two sides of the original release, and one immediately understands that this album is all about that sonic onslaught, fast-paced riffing, a groovy and rock-solid rhythm section, the occasional appearances of fascinating keyboard sections or solos, all topped by the monstrous vocal performance of Ronnie James Dio, an immaculate singer who had set a solid standard for all rock vocalists to come. Blackmore's guitar is quite upfront on 'Rising', as he offers several virtuosic solos along the way, together with numerous iconic, chunky riffs, unlike his more melodic, soulful and medieval-esque approach on the debut album. It becomes quite difficult to pick a favorite track off this album, a virtually perfect collection, since the menacing march-like opener 'Tarot Woman' delivers that signature classic Rainbow sound in spades, while 'Run With the Wolf' is a groovier number offering the excellent and beautiful musical phrasing of Dio. Then come the hard-rocking 'Starstruck' and 'Do You Close Your Eyes', and what is there to say about the two epic 8-minute pieces on side two, 'Stargazer' and 'A Light in the Black', capturing Rainbow at their most adventurous, introspective and grandiose - a fantastic album that has undoubtedly withstood the test of time.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Last Tree by GRIMM, LARKIN album cover Studio Album, 2006
2.54 | 3 ratings

BUY
The Last Tree
Larkin Grimm Prog Folk

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

2 stars While I understand that writing and performing might be cathartic for many if not most artists, I am not in favor if it necessitates behavioral health intervention for the listener. On this, her third album, LARKIN GRIMM takes a few strides forward in imparting her wacky wisdom in a more musical fashion but too many tracks remain impenetrable except for a certain unpleasant sensation in the cervical vertebrae. Luckily, the more "conventional" title track, the atypically joyous "Link in Your Chain", and the geographically proximal "Rocky Tap" all hit the mark and hint at future directions. Along with a few near misses, they don't quite compensate for the likes of 4 or 5 others of scream therapy, most egregious is the aptly titled but otherwise best dismissed "The Most Excruciating Vibe". Still hoping for an elusive 3 star sapling to sprout.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Curious Ruminant by JETHRO TULL album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.40 | 100 ratings

BUY
Curious Ruminant
Jethro Tull Prog Folk

Review by yarstruly

4 stars I'm sure today's artist needs absolutely no introduction. Jethro Tull, led by Ian Anderson has been a hallmark of prog from the 60s onward. After nearly two decades of no releases under the Tull moniker, Anderson resurrected the name in 2022 with the album "The Zealot Game", albeit without longtime guitarist Martin Barre, who had been onboard since Tull's second album, "Stand Up" in 1969. In 2023, Tull released "RökFlöte" and today's review is the third since the band resumed, called "Curious Ruminant". By all accounts, this album is very much in the style of their 70's classics. Here is the line-up for this outing, which is the 25th studio album under the Jethro Tull name:

- Ian Anderson / flutes, vocals, acoustic guitar & tenor guitars, mandolin, odds & sods, bits & bobs - David Goodier / bass - John O'Hara / piano, keyboards, accordion - Scott Hammond / drums - Jack Clark / electric guitar

With: - James Duncan / drums, cajķn, percussion - Andrew Giddings / piano, keyboards, accordion

Let's check out this Curious Ruminant, shall we?

Track 1 - Puppet and the Puppet Master

The track begins with a minor key piano melody, but soon after, a jaunty beat takes over with Anderson's famous flute work out front. Anderson then begins singing and telling a tale. Just before one minute an almost funky rhythm takes over. After a second verse in 6-8 the flute is featured again. The third verse follows and is in turn followed by a guitar solo. As we proceed, we have another flute section, then the organ is featured. All the while the rhythm section is tight. The verses are short, punctuated by flute leads after the main instrumental break. The song concludes on a minor chord after having been in a major key following the piano intro. A lively and entertaining track.

Track 2 - Curious Ruminant

Once again, melancholy piano starts us off. A few acoustic chords join in, before unaccompanied flute takes over. The groove sets in around 30 seconds in, with a chugging rhythm. Ian Anderson has always taken the storyteller role in his music, but it somehow even seems more so here, as his voice is definitely singing a melody, but it's almost spoken. There is a wonderful guitar solo as we cross the three-minute mark. The next verse is quieter than the ones before the solo. Jack Clark's guitar tone is remarkably similar to Martin Barre's, but his playing is more fluid than his legendary predecessor. There is another wonderful guitar solo as we cross the 4-minute point, then a call and response with flute. I like the moving guitar parts behind the vocals. There is a staccato unison rhythm pattern from the band as the song reaches its conclusion. Good track.

Track 3 - Dunsinane Hill

This one begins with a flute, backed by accordion. It has a 3-4 feel like Brahms' Lullaby. The flute parts become layered prior to the verse. At a bit after 1:30 the rhythm changes as the agile flute takes over. He then returns to 3- 4, although the beat picks up. The drums are playing a subtle tom-tom pattern. By 3 minutes he is fully speaking the lyrics, before returning to singing. A well-arranged song, and Anderson's voice is engaging.

Track 4 - The Tipu House

This one begins with a bit more excitement. This one is upbeat with more energy in the flute. I am feeling a bit more of the Tull that I expect to hear. There is a lot going on lyrically here, that I will need more time to digest. Lots of things are happening in the Tipu House, for sure. The song ends somewhat abruptly. Kind of a fun track though.

Track 5 - Savannah of Paddington Green

Birds chirping and other nature sounds are quickly joined by a staccato acoustic guitar part. This one harkens back to the 70s folky acoustic strumming Tull songs. We are in 6-8 here. After a verse and chorus, the staccato acoustic riff leads us back to another verse and chorus. Anderson's voice range may be a bit more limited these days, but he makes it work well by writing within his range. Good track.

Track 6 - Stygian Hand

Stygian seems to be the word of the year among classic proggers, as Alex Lifeson's new band Envy of None's second album which I recently reviewed is called Stygian Wavz. This one has a very fun riff. I like the mandolin on this. Excellent swirling parts between vocal phrases. I love the guitar run just prior to the 2-minute mark. This one reminds me the most of classic Tull, so far. I like the pause in the instruments at around 3:20. Great track, my favorite one to this point.

Track 7 - Over Jerusalem

Flute, Acoustic guitar and some sort of bell-like keyboard or percussion, then vocals soon join in. Other instruments begin making appearances as the verse proceeds. This one is very folky and melodic. In the bridge there are some nice clean electric guitar fills. At around 2:35, the acoustic guitar establishes an odd-metered rhythm. As the band joins back in, the flute takes a solo, then there is a new verse in that rhythm. We are in 5-8, I believe. We then get a brief guitar solo before the flute takes the spotlight back. I like the rhythm section bed in this part. After a short unaccompanied flute bit, the guitar solo resumes, and he continues playing lead lines when Anderson begins singing again. At 4:23, the music mellows out again. There is a stronger section before Anderson closes out the song by saying "Jerusalem" twice in a very distinct way. Strong track.

Track 8 - Drink from the Same Well

This is by far the longest song on the album at 16.42, with the second longest being the title track at an even 6 minutes. After a quick check it seems that the last time there was a song of this length (and it's exactly the same length at that!) on a Tull album was "Baker Street Muse", going back 50 years to 1975's "The Minstrel in the Gallery"! In fact, as far as I can tell the only song over 10 minutes between that one and this one is "Budapest" which was just above that threshold at 10:05 on 1987's Grammy winner (for best metal album, lol) "Crest of a Knave". So, let's see what Ian and company have in store for us.

High-pitched melodic flute and piano start this one off, and then the bass joins in. After around 1:15, some synth strings subtly join in. At the 2:00 mark, an acoustic guitar strum announces a new, more rhythmic section, with the flute still firmly in the lead role. The band provides some rhythmic twists along the way, but the percussion is still subtle. At 5 minutes, the beat pauses, then the flute gives us a new tune. Jazzy drums join in at around 5:35. The piano takes over after the six-minute point, but only briefly as the flute takes back over quickly. Piano gets another brief spotlight around 7 minutes in. After another short pause in the action at around 7:45, piano and acoustic guitar give us a new melodic foundation. After a bit more flute, the first vocals begin at around the 8-minute point on a low note. Ian the storyteller is in fine spirits on this one. There is an effective vocal effect at around 9 minutes in. At 9:45 there is another flute feature. Vocals return at 11:52. At 13:30 there is another distinct pause after an accented note, then we get some rhythms from the intro that return and the flute solo resumes. Ian is, of course, one of the finest flautists in rock history, which is a small but distinguished lot, and he really felt like stretching out on the instrument here. This feels less like a prog epic, however, and more like an extended Ian Anderson flute solo with a short, but intriguing song in the middle of it. That isn't necessarily a bad thing, but the only thing it shares with "Baker Street Muse" is its length. It's not a bad track, but I am a bit disappointed, as I was hoping for something a bit more exciting when I saw the run time of this one.

Track 9 - Interim Sleep

The album closes out with the shortest track, at just over 2 and a half minutes. It begins with a nice slowly strummed acoustic guitar chord. This time he actually is talking instead of singing. The acoustic guitar and flute flourishes accompany a droning note as he waxes poetically. I interpret this as a metaphor for dying and being reborn. This is just a little punctuation on the album, to me.

OVERALL IMPRESSIONS:

It's not bad, not great. It's an enjoyable listen overall. The playing on it is quite good, if lacking a little in energy. But when you consider that the Jethro Tull 'brand" has been around for 57 years this year, it's impressive that there still are Jethro Tull releases to be had. Tracks 6 and 7 are my favorites. Ian Anderson still has stories to tell, and this is how he does it. Maybe it's not quite as good as the 70s glory days, but it's still worth listening to. I'll give it a 4 out of 5 stars.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Forever Howlong by BLACK COUNTRY; NEW ROAD album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.92 | 31 ratings

BUY
Forever Howlong
Black Country; New Road Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Dapper~Blueberries
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Now, if you've ever known me, you would know that my relationship with Black Country, New Road is?rocky at best. I cannot deny they do have some talent, but they never wowed me unlike other bands in the Windmill Scene, and, in fact, I would go so far as to say I don't get why people seemed to love them in the past, especially in regards to Ants From Up There. I don't like Ants From Up There, I'm sorry, but it just feels like such a basic post rock album to me that I'd rather listen to This Will Destroy You or Explosions In The Sky.

However, it seems like we got the glow up of the century with their recent studio workout of Forever Howlong, and honestly?yeah this is a massive improvement compared to their last two records for me.

The line-up changed quite a bit, specifically with the new lead singers of Georgia Ellery, Tyler Hyde, and May Kershaw. They have been in the band before as backing vocalists, but now they're in the forefront, and honestly they really brighten this album up. They're all really amazing vocalists to me, and they capture the energy and spirit of this new direction for BCNR so well. I don't quite know who's who, so I cannot really say who my favorite is, but they all do a really great job so even if I did know who's voice is who's, I'd still have a hard time deciding.

But obviously the real meat and potatoes is the musical change, as they basically moved far, far away from post rock, and head dive straight into chamber and baroque pop.

If there is something I could commend the band for in the past, it would be that they could make really stellar pop music when they did get poppy. So, honestly, when I first heard Besties and realized they would go into a pop direction, I was honestly excited, though cautious because of my dislike of Ants From Up There. Luckily, they focus primarily on pop, and in doing so create a very rich and jovial sound that I really adore. This might be probably the strongest pop record I heard this year. The mix of pop and folk music create an energy that's uniquely theirs, with a great baroque sensibility that's not too far off from classic bands of the 60s like The Moody Blues and Sagittarius.

It all culminates in a sound that is certainly new, but doesn't take away the feelings that BCNR has carried since For The First Time. In fact, I'd say this direction is probably a healthy one, as they sound much happier and freeform compared to the past, but they still keep what made them special for so many people alive in some shape or form. Everything in the music, especially on tracks like Besties, Two Horses, Happy Birthday, For the Cold Country, and Goodbye (Don't Tell Me), has this energy that cannot compare to their older works, yet has the spirit of them, and such makes me so happy that they decided to go in this direction.

I do have one complaint though, and that's, while I may have not liked their post rock sound in the past, I do think it would be kind of neat if they had at least one post rock moment on here, like make one of the tracks a bit longer and have a moment that's kinda reminiscent of some songs off of For The First Time or Ants From Up There. In this new pop direction, I bet they could really make it work well. It might make this album the quintessential BCNR record-I mean it is for me but it would be more so for the diehard fans. Just feel like it's one missed opportunity in a sea of great opportunities.

I was super, super surprised with how much I loved this album. I thought BCNR would just be one of those bands I would never get into, but they clearly proved me wrong in the best ways possible. While Forever Howlong isn't perfect by any means, I think it has so many great moments and songs that it's hard for me to at least not find it pretty good at worst, and at best, an amazing baroque and chamber pop journey through the English countryside. Most certainly a must listen in my humble opinion, and I really do hope they keep up this direction in the future. They finally did it, they made an album I like!

Best tracks: Besties, Two Horses, Happy Birthday, For the Cold Country, Goodbye (Don't Tell Me)

Worst track: N/A

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Two Against Nature by STEELY DAN album cover Studio Album, 2000
3.35 | 130 ratings

BUY
Two Against Nature
Steely Dan Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by sgtpepper

3 stars Steely Dan releasing a new album after 20 years was one of the jazz-rock most anticipated albums of 2000. Long- term band hiatus did not take away any of the tandem trademarks: - Meticulously produced music with sharp sound, meaty instrumentation and precise playing. - Sound rooted in accessible jazz-rock without sounding dated. It is mainly thanks to the rhythm section that the album sounds contemporary. - Focus on motives rather than melodies. Instruments make up for lack of commercial abilities (fine for me).

The first three tracks and the last upbeat largely instrumental saxophone supported numbers are as convincing as any other Steely Dan highlights. This is the last truly impacting Steely Dan to me as the next one would lose the magic of perfection and creativity.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Recontinue by ALARUM album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.95 | 2 ratings

BUY
Recontinue
Alarum Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars "Recontinue" is the fifth full-length studio album by Australian technical/progressive metal act Alarum. The album was independently released in November 2024. It´s the successor to "Circle's End" from 2020 and the trio lineup who recorded "Circle's End" have now been joined by drummer Jared Roberts, making Alarum a quartet on "Recontinue". Session guitarist Ryan Williams (Aeon of Horus) performs leads on the songs "Introspective", "Imperative", and "Zero Nine Thirty".

Opening with a melodic jazz/fusion influenced progressive metal instrumental in "Introspective" and then segueing into a technical/progressive death/thrash metal track like "Imperative"...yup it´s Alarum alright. Powerful, melodic, and intriguing technical/progressive metal with death/thrash metal brutality. Alarum still excel in the dynamics of shifting between melodic jazz/fusion influenced progressive sections and more staight forward technical death/thrash metal. It´s one of the great strengths of Alarum how well they make the different elements of their sound naturally flow together. You don´t question the relevance of a an atmospheric jazzy fusion part in the middle of a death/thrash metal dominated song (or visa versa). Alarum combine the two styles in a seamless manner.

If I have to compare "Recontinue" to "Circle's End" I´d say that the death/thrash metal parts of the band´s music have become slightly more punchy and straight forward, but then again Alarum have lost none of their progressive mindset, so in many ways "Recontinue" is just the natural continuation of the music style found on "Circle's End". The quality of the songwriting, the performances, and the sound production values are just as high as on the preceding album, so upon conclusion "Recontinue" is yet another high quality release from Alarum and a 4 star (80%) rating is deserved.

(Originally posted on Metal Music Archives).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Africa Speaks by SANTANA album cover Studio Album, 2019
3.58 | 45 ratings

BUY
Africa Speaks
Santana Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Fercandio46

4 stars After the classic period of Woodstock and the fusion of the '70s, where he marked his mark of psychedelic rock with Latin rhythms plus a lot of funk and soul, he entered the path of so many great musicians, and as hybrid albums of such dissimilar duos are not to my liking, I do not think his spirit is there, I will emphasize from Shape Shifter, from 2012, the reunion with his old friend Jhon McLaughlin in Montreux, Santana IV (his project with the 1973 band), the album with the Isley Brothers of covers, and finally the album in question, Africa Speaks, from 2019.

Inspired by African music and with the Spanish singer Buika, he puts together a series of deeply inspired songs, revisiting the spirituality present in his greatest works, and that curved saber that makes the incision where it should be, echoing the sound of his guitar. Buika truly creates hypnotic atmospheres, such as "Oye este mi canto" (Hear this my song). "Yo me lo merezco" (I deserve it) is an anthem that rivals his older songs; the color of his voice brings a lot of feeling, and he manages to sound modern at the same time. There's soul and funk, like in "Paraísos quemados," "Breaking down the door" includes wind instruments very appropriately, while "Los invisibles" and "Luna hechicera" seem to explore a new sound, more modern but true to itself at the same time. That's one of the greatest virtues of this album, rescuing the sound of the '70s (like in Santana IV) but venturing into new territory, not only in African tradition but also in fusion with other climates, as heterogeneous as they are earthly.

With "Bembele," Africa not only sings but also dances, albeit in a sophisticated way, and "Candombe Cumbele" reunites us with the furious, catchy funk that stirs the soul. Teaming up with new musicians always renews and revitalizes influences, sounds, and feelings, but in the service of a cohesive and almost conceptual work, even if that wasn't the intention, because it tells us, in many ways, a story of resilience, love, and courage, of course with oceans of rhythm.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Dinamo by FONDERIA album cover Studio Album, 2023
3.14 | 10 ratings

BUY
Dinamo
Fonderia Eclectic Prog

Review by Finnforest
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars Instrumental "Dynamo"

Fonderia is a Rome-based instrumental band now three decades into their career. They released three albums in the first decade of the century and are now back after a 13-year release hiatus with Dinamo. The line-up has remained mostly consistent for their albums save, with the new album, bassist Paolo Pecorelli replaces Claudio Mosconi. I've not had the chance to hear their earlier work, so I can only speak about the new album without making comparisons to their first three albums. Yet just yesterday I reviewed an instrumental band called Forsqueak, and the two albums are actually pretty similar. Thus my immediate sound references to Dinamo were the same.

This album reminds me of those '80s albums from Fripp-Summers and to a lesser extent bands like early Police, '80s Crimson, and even '80s Rush. Yet Fonderia lacks vocals and are more experimental for sure. We're talking here about post rock, math rock, neo-psych, and some fusion tendencies. Beyond the great guitar work and super-tight rhythm section, the buffet of keyboard models and sounds is a veritable feast. Without vocals, each of these tracks would make great soundtrack to short film or conceptual videos. However, I end up in the same place I did yesterday with Forsqueak. This is a good album. These guys have fantastic chops. Yet, as an album, it doesn't move me a great deal emotionally. I appreciate it. I respect it. But I didn't fall in love with it.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Harpoon by GRIMM, LARKIN album cover Studio Album, 2005
2.46 | 5 ratings

BUY
Harpoon
Larkin Grimm Prog Folk

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

2 stars While the journey of 1000 - insert your preferred measure of distance - begins with a single step, at least if you're walking, it's often those first steps that pile on the bunions, plantar fasciitis, and sundry aches migrating up the impacted appendages. We sometimes witness similar in developing artists, and the early works of LARKIN GRIMM loosely approximate this tendency on the few fitful lines of a budding bell curve.

If her dreadful debut is thankfully underexposed, the far better known "Harpoon" does mark her tentative steps towards a more coherent and, yes, listenable, model. It's still beyond strident in parts and, as if her voice doesn't go to those teetering and bat-infested eaves often enough, she has added equally shrill whistles to fill in the moments when she has to catch her breath, but hasn't figured out that things don't work that way. Still, for all its overly weird philosophy, "Harpoon" clearly emanates the soul of Appalachia at its core, epitomized by the rhythmic "Going Out" (which recalls the experimental SORNE), the playful "Pigeon Food", and the hypnotic and obsessive "One Hundred Men", while the sole epic "Future Friend" is better than most of what follows.

While understandably immature, "Harpoon" spearheads the evolution in Grimm's sound enough to motivate me forward.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Psy-Ko by HALLOWEEN album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.93 | 23 ratings

BUY
Psy-Ko
Halloween Symphonic Prog

Review by tszirmay
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars Nothing is truly over and done with, as the phoenix rising from the ashes of time can always rise once again and soar into the mainstream. Call it rebirth (or its better-known French label 'la Renaissance') perhaps even artistic freedom after 24 years of immaculate silence, this veteran group reignites its muse for a return to the progressive community in 2025. Around the original core trio of vocalist/violinist Jean-Philippe Brun, Gilles Coppin on keyboards,(both class of 1988) and drum stool director Philippe di Faustino (in 1989) , as well as adding Geraldine LeCoq on the vocals (1994), Psy-KO showcases their ongoing legacy of intricate symphonic-prog but adding impregnable jazz-rock elements that eschew a mature sensibility in proposing challenging colorations to their discography. Newcomers Romain Troly on bass and the exciting guitarist Cédric Monjour raise the complexity bar, last exposed on their previous album "Le Festin" (2001). A sprawling 72-minute extravaganza that comes across as a genre-bending foray into an even more psychotic introspection into the human condition, always a great subject to find artistic inspiration.

Maintaining their patented sombre approach to symphonic prog, it is therefore fitting that the violin takes the lead on the whirlwind "Transe", first emerging from a distant point of darkness, the bass shuffling immediately the arrangement into a driving, harsh guitar rant that is unafraid to rock, raunch and roll with the punches provided by the throttling rhythmic section. Géraldine sings in French, and she certainly knows how to stretch the pulmonary attributes she richly possesses. Monjour wastes little time in demonstrating his glittering technique, bending as well as torturing his six-strings with raging abandon. A jazzy pool of e-piano and high-pitched wailing settles the mellow mid-section into a reflective mode that is most inspiring. The lead guitar sets a sizzling solo into the mix, quickly elevating the mood into a torrid frenzy, which after all, is what psychosis is all about. A rambunctious opening track that has Géraldine doing her finest Robert Plant homage! Bonjour, we are back!

The haunting "Crise de Foi" offers a mechanical take on sonic weirdness, a trait that is a hallmark of this band, where burping synths amid bass gurgles, tick-tock polyrhythmic gymnastics and buzz-saw axe flickers rule the roost, a complexity driven arrangement that needs a ton of concentration to follow the breakneck pace, richly adorned with everything the kitchen has to offer, including tinkling bells and vocal whispers. Cranky and eerie, verging on hypnotic hysterics, the cavernous bass/drum guitar pounding permits the savage violin to take a bow (sorry, I had to) and soar mightily into a chaotic maelstrom of blister and bluster. Where are my pills!

After such a cavalcade of insanity, "Plume de Plomb" reverts to more spectral realms, the violin playing its part to perfection, as the hushed and exhausted voice seeks some kind of solace, as it hiccups along to the cat-gut ramble. Certainly not accessible or radio friendly to start, the bopping bass brings this scat wailing manifesto back to some sense of normalcy, with an actual melody taking hold amid the commotion. Incredible piece.

Epic time, as "Nostalgie" encompasses the core of this album with its 15 minutes of reverberating oddity, with voice and sonic influences that scour the shadows of past memories, before evolving into a full-force sonic hurricane, where merciless syncopations dictate the tempo and the cacophonic atmosphere. A heartbeat away from experimental soundscapes that boldly seek out adventurous boundaries, as surprises lurk at every corner, a universe where the harsh collides with the serene, the whispered voice taking the spotlight in the most theatrical manner possible, a particular trait of French progressive rock, might I add. There is no urgency, but a lot of despair in the tragic tone of the arrangement, especially when the colossal chorus kicks in, in full symphonic regalia, as it seeks out an inexorable apotheosis of feeling and emotion. Her obsessive laughter section is theatre of the highest order, perfectly underling the madness of a mind that has lost focus , where paranoia, hysteria and hallucination combine to force surrender. Impressive and demanding progressive rock that needs to be heard and enjoyed.

Transitioning into a livelier expanse though maintaining a sense of dread , "Frustration" is a thrilling mellotron- laden spread that bursts and explodes into sheer raucous disturbance, the voice hopscotching with agility one moment and swooning serenely the next, expressing the title with disturbing correctness, as if a less Teutonic sounding form of Magma. The whispering flutter is off the charts. The blow-out is a combined effort from the spiraling violin, swerving between the rough guitar edgings and the booming pulse. Surely the definition of monstrous creepiness, "Gnomes" is the second epic, latching onto a 10 minute+ frame and wasting little (oops) time in establishing a violin/bass duet that will soon let in the cruel guitar and spooky tubular bells announcing the arrival of hideous creatures. The vocalist climbs up and down the scales like gargoyles on parapets of ancient cathedrals, the synthesizer looping madly in apparent uncertainty, Romain Troly trolling (second oops) with an athletic bass furrow, cacophony and folly compounding to stretch the pain even further. The choral work is hectic and disturbed, again a la Magma, the violin returning to set things back to melodious and I daresay , ear friendly. Challenging musical interpretation that will test your ability to fall asleep.

Two 7 minutes tracks conclude this glorious return to form, "Cochon de Laid" first offering an overt Zappa-esque conflagration of sonic argy-bargy, a stretch of hypersonic and turbo-charged lunacy, proving surely a mastery of their respective instruments. She enters with soothing panacea, sweetly offering a reprieve, but its short lived, as the wild aural cluster bombs return with a vengeance, burly organ front and center. This would cause mass panic as an opening piece to a Taylor Swift concert, as the prissy fans search for their precious seats, phones in hand. Bates Motel music.

Surely an ode to Stravinsky, "Igor S." settles the score with not French but Russian language lyrics and interpretation, combing massive male choirs (reminiscent of the Red Army choir) and the usual fatalistic mood that permeates that richly appointed culture, where bombast and desolation live in apparent harmony, part of that genetic make-up that cannot be shaken or stirred. Monjour peels off a thunder and lightning guitar solo that screeches, cavorts, plunges and soars like a bird of prey. The elegant piano takes over the storm with a heartfelt etude, where voice, bass and drum beat signal the end of the therapy session.

A challenging , grippingly intense and convincing return to the stage for this celebrated band, may they continue to thrive and prosper. Not for the faint of heart or those who seek instant gratification.

4.5 goblin asylums

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Napoli Centrale by NAPOLI CENTRALE album cover Studio Album, 1975
3.83 | 67 ratings

BUY
Napoli Centrale
Napoli Centrale Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars High quality Jazz-Rock Fusion coming out of Naples, Italy but they're not even half Italian! They're made up of one-and- a-half Americans (Mark Harris and American-fathered "James" Senese), a Brit (Anthony "Toni" Walmsley), and only one- and-a-half Italians (Franco Del Prete and the maternal half of Gaetano "James" Senese). This was the lineup that produced their wonderful debut album whereas successive studio releases in the 1970s would only be able to retain songwriter and band leader James and Franco.

1. "Campagna" (7:56) most excellent Jazz-Rock Fusion, very current/up-to-date with the music coming out of America at the same time, spiced up quite nicely by James Senese's vocals and the MANDRILL, OSIBISA, and CYMANDE-like African-like group/choir vocal chants. James' sax and vocals even have a little of DEMITRIO STRATOS and JAMES BROWN's swaggy confidence. The rhythm section of Franco Del Prete and Toni Walmsley are so tight, so in sync, that it gives Fender Rhodes/synth player Mark Harris a lot of confidence to do his own shining thing. A most excellent, even anthemic opener. (14.25/15)

2. "'A gente 'e bucciano" (8:42) despite the smooth, gentle opening, this one breaks into some great, dynamic music in the third minute--after James' brief introductory vocal spurt--that is well rendered but is slightly diminished by James Senese's fair but not great vocal. (Why are the vocals on this song recorded so differently and more inconsistently than the other songs on the album? It's almost as if they were only added as an afterthought in the final production but never polished or processed with any care.) Toni's bass play is awesome--and I love how it's mixed so far forward in the sonicsphere. And Franco's drumming is right up there with Toni's as is Mark Harris's Fender Rhodes play. (17.625/20)

3. "Pensione floridiana" (3:32) horn section blow followed by repeated Fender Rhodes chord arpeggi open this before drums and bass join in and settle into a bluesy jazz-rock motif that sounds as if it should be the soundtrack theme for an American radio sitcom. Pleasant but almost innocuous. (8.875/10)

4. "Viecchie, mugliere, muorte e criature" (10:02) James Senese's raspy/gritty voice once again takes the forefront over this very solid Herbie Hancock music only, this time, it's quite fitting and winning--kind of in the same way that LE ORME's Aldo Tagliopietra and AREA's Dimitri could command the stage. I love his ballsy duel between his voice and his own saxophone in the fifth and sixth minutes. The band certainly does a great job of using multiple tracks to fill their sonic field. The ad nauseum repetition of the music tends to stagnate a little over time despite Mark Harris' excellent Fender Rhodes play and James' sax solos, spirited vocals, and multiple sax "horn section" track--most of which becomes more interesting in the song's wonderful final third. (17.75/20)

5. "Vico primo parisee n°8" (7:37) quite the dynamic bass lines on this Headhunters-like funk track! Everybody is playing at the top of their game: putting together a spirited Jazz-Rock Fusion tune that could mix right in there on any of Herbie's Headhunters albums. Mark and James also impress with their equally dynamic keyboard, sax, and whistle performances. In the second half they even manage to harken back to the earliest J-R Fusion masterpieces--like Bitches Brew! It's just such a great galloping groove--one that definitely puts on full display the talents/skills of all four of the musicians. (14.125/15)

6. "'O lupo s'ha mangiato 'a pecurella" (6:49) synth and sax play the melody-leading solos in the first minute of this more laid-back, spacious tune that reminds me of something from the earliest Weather Report albums. The melodies and weaves here are much simpler, sparse, and less familiar/pleasing to the radio/pop-trained Western ear. Even James' sax play is more similar to that of Wayne Shorter while the sparse note play from the independent musicians is constructed more harmonically, instead of melodically, like Weather Report. Then we run into the final two minutes with its percussion-supported street party "drunken" celebration before the band pulls back inside, into the studio, for a more tightly-performed closing. Interesting but, like the music of Weather Report, not my favorite expression of the panoply of idioms that make up Jazz-Rock Fusion. (13.25/15)

Total Time 44:38

There is a quality and style in the sound and music of this album that places me firmly in the 1972-74 period of ever- transitional Jazz-Rock Fusion being created by American Herbie Hancock and his late Mwandishi and early Headhunters periods.

A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of mature, more-than-competent Jazz-Rock Fusion. Recommended to all lovers of Peak Era (Third Wave) Jazz-Rock Fusion.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Deep Water by COSMIC CATHEDRAL album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.86 | 52 ratings

BUY
Deep Water
Cosmic Cathedral Symphonic Prog

Review by AlanB

4 stars Cosmic Cathedral is a new band featuring Neal Morse with guitarist Phil Keaggy and bassist Byron House (both people Neal had worked with before) plus former Genesis live drummer Chester Thompson, who Neal met at a Steve Hackett gig in November 2023. The four of them got together to jam and the album Deep Water is the result. It consists of five songs, the first of which is a 13 minute mini-epic and the last a 38 minute, multi part piece, with three shorter songs in between. This seems like a favourite pattern for Morse, off the top of my head I can think of The Grand Experiment, No Hill For A Climber, and Transatlantic's Kaleidoscope using the same formula.

Speaking of formula, this album is pretty similar to any other Morse prog album, albeit with some jazzy elements added, probably courtesy of Thompson's drumming style. Also, the Christian lyrics that Morse is renowned for are pretty prominent here. Hardly surprising having read the liner notes I see that all the band members are Christians. So if you don't like Morse's more direct Christian references, it's maybe not the album for you. If you do, however, Deep Water is as good as many other albums he's made, and better than some.

So, let's dive in track by track:

1. The Heart Of Life - written solely by Neal and it could be on any prog album by him really. It starts with an extended instrumental section followed by a pause before the vocals come in. Very familiar Morse territory. It's an excellent start 8/10

2. Time To Fly - A decent tune, very catchy, less proggy than some of the other tracks. Nice use of saxophone and female backing vocals 7/10

3. I Won't Make It - another Morse-only composition and quite honestly I don't think it belongs on this album. It's very much in the vein of his singer/songwriter stuff. Not a bad song though. 6/10

4. Walking In Daylight - Phil Keaggy takes lead vocal on this one (and he shares the writing credit for the lyrics with Neal). It's the most jazzy song on the album, a funky intro, some jazz piano, and even a bass solo. I like it a lot. 9/10

5. Deep Water Suite - so we come to the centre piece of the album, a 38 minute song divided into 9 sections. And what a journey it is! Beginning with the lyric "Launch out into the deep water," a phrase that recurs throughout, not just in the three sections labelled Launch Out parts one, two and three, but also midway through Fires Of The Sunrise and at the very end of the piece, the phrase refers to trusting God. In Neal's autobiography Testimony he describes his conversion as a vision of standing at the top of a waterfall and being encouraged to jump into the water below. Clearly he is referencing this here. Following the initial "Launch Out" lyric (sung through a vocoder) there follows a typical Morse overture. The vocals come in with launch Out Part One, and following this is a more acoustic section, Fires Of The Sunrise. Storm Surface is an instrumental interlude which reprises one of the riffs from Launch Out Part One and highlights Keaggy's tasteful lead guitar style. Then we have Nightmare In Paradise which is a bit different to Morse's usual style. Following the brief Launch Out Part Two, New Revelation is another upbeat track. Then we revisit the Launch Out theme again before the closing section, The Door To Heaven, which sounds like any other Neal Morse closing track with lots of build-up to a climactic ending. The whole piece is a masterpiece. 10/10

To summarise, these are four excellent musicians. I was familiar with Morse, Keaggy and Thompson before but Byron House is a phenomenal bassist. Chester Thompson brings a more jazzy feel to the music than Mike Portnoy would have done, but all in all this is a typical Neal Morse project and if you like his music you will like this.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Kornelyans: Not an Ordinary Life by KORNI GRUPA (KORNELYANS) album cover Studio Album, 1974
4.16 | 55 ratings

BUY
Kornelyans: Not an Ordinary Life
Korni Grupa (Kornelyans) Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Sophisticated prog rock from the Serbian portion of the former Yugoslavia. I can see why this band is considered one of, if note the, greatest rock/prog bands ever to come out of that nation state.

1. "Rising" (2:14) quite lovely, well produced, keyboard-led instrumental proggy Jazz-Rock. (4.625/5)

2. "Not an Ordinary Life" (10:16) sounding very much like a cross between early QUEEN, RARE EARTH, and early URIAH HEEP. I'm quite surprised to hear the excellent command of English spoken/sung throughout this song. Great change to an adventurous, theatric RARE EARTH-like motif around the three-minute mark. Some truly excellent drumming, guitar, and keyboard play during the extended solo patch in the middle. In the seventh minute the music switches into a very prog-rock focus with its CHRIS SQUIRE "Close to the Edge" bass line and dynamic (if also circus-like) keyboard play. A rather surprisingly mature and sophisticated composition pulled off with excellent musicianship and excellent sound quality! At 8:45 the music then moves into a grooving Jazz-Rock motif over which guitarist Josip Bocek shreds (in two tracks!) while lead singer Zlatko Pejakovic takes us out with his theatric vocal performance. (19.125/20)

3. "Generation 1942" (6:32) here exhibiting a style more similar to bands like CHICAGO and STYX (and Starcastle and, yes, Yes), the music is so pleasant, well-composed, and creatively rendered I find in total shock. I don't particularly like this style of music (it's now rather dated) but I definitely appreciate the skill and creative genius that went into its creation and production. (9/10)

4. "Fall of the Land of Women" (5:30) employing a distortion-making effect to Zlatko's voice gives this heavy prog song an Arthur Brown-like quality--but it's also in the forcefulness of his vocal delivery. The hard-driving MUSEO ROSENBACH/LE ORME-like music is quite complex with high-quality rock solos from multiple keys and electric guitar as well as solid tracks contributed by bass, drums, percussion, and acoustic guitars. Bassist Bojan Hreljac and keyboard wiz Kornelije Kovac are particularly awesome. (8.875/10)

5. "Temporary Parting" (3:58) solo piano and organ play from Kornelije opens this one before the arrival of a Jon Camp-like bass and syncopated drumming from Vladimir Furduj expose what is obviously a RENAISSANCE-like effort. Even the motif change at 3:00 is in full compliance with the Renaissance approach to making prog out of classically- inspired pieces. (9/10)

6. "Man with a White Flag" (11:43) another heavy rock motif opens this (sounding like a heavier GRAND FUNK RAILROAD or maybe URIAH HEEP) while Zlatko and his background singers sing in quite the GRAND FUNK style. There's a little Gentle Giant and Thin Lizzy in the instrumental passage between the first vocal section and the second. The vocal excellence really rises to the top in the second vocal section, even successfully transforming to monastery- like male choir in the fifth minute. Nice doubled-up synth solo in the sixth minute. The stylistic switch at the end of the seventh minute into a more high-powered-blues-rock motif--for Kornelije's piano solo--is awesome. Then the softer synth and organ-founded motif over which Zltako's voice sings so tenderly is equally impressive. Pulsing bass at the austere nine-minute mark gradually form into another dramatic motif: where Zlatko's URIAH HEEP-like treated voice performs as if from a cage. This culminates in a rising pitch bridge to a more cruising rock motif over which Kornelije returns to his bluesy piano soloing--during which the music is slowly faded out over the course of about 25 seconds. Though, again, this is not particularly my favorite kind of musical style--even in the prog rock form it is in--I cannot help but admire and appreciate the skill and maturity it took to put this together and perform it so flawlessly. (18/20)

Total Time 40:13

Considering that this band's 1972 debut album was only the fourth full-length studio album released in Yugoslavia of a rock band, the production here (in 1974) is incredible. The band had had six or seven years to work together before the recording of this album and it shows in both the skill level of the musicians but also in the sophistication of the compositions. The fact of the band's desire to make its mark in both the radio-friendly pop culture and the more instrumentally-lauded world of progressive rock music is also markedly present here.

A-/five stars; though I would never call this music "Jazz-Rock Fusion" I am over-the-moon impressed with every aspect of it. Quite entertaining (theatric) and excellent progressive rock music. Highly recommended for any and all progheads--especially if you like the spirit and styles of prog's "Classic Era" best.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Jaco Pastorius by PASTORIUS, JACO album cover Studio Album, 1976
3.77 | 91 ratings

BUY
Jaco Pastorius
Jaco Pastorius Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars The first solo studio album produced of the legendary bass innovator's performances of his own compositions. When one takes into consideration the young master's "tender" age of 25 on this record, one can begin to contemplate what the world was being exposed to.

1. "Donna Lee" (2:26) Jaco takes on this Charlie Parker song with solo bass and Don Alias' congas acting as his lone support instrument! The man was a genius! What imagination! What even flow! (4.625/5)

2. "Come On, Come Over" (3:50) full R&B funk: complete with vocals (from no less than Sam & Dave!), active multi-part horn section, and bouncy rhythm guitar-sounding clavinets and other electronic keybaords from no less than the one and only Herbie Hancock. A great tune! I'm very surprised I'd never heard this one before. (9.25/10)

3. "Continuum" (4:31) using Stevie Wonder's melody lines from his 1972 hit "Superwoman" as well as similar Fender Rhodes support from Alex Darqui, Jaco expresses himself quite eloquently, even romantically. Lenny White's drums are suspiciously muted/compressed on the high end--maybe to let the harmonics of Jaco's play stand out or to let Herbie Hancock's electric piano sound shine. (9/10)

4. "Kuru / Speak Like A Child" (7:38) strings open this announcing a dynamic adventure into James-Bond-like cinematic music. Herbie Hancock's piano play is given the first solo while Jaco, Don Alias, and Bobby Economou hold down the rhythm track. Strings only make appearances in the first two minutes as minor accents or breaks between solos, but then in the third minute they're given a rather central place for over a minute with Herbie performing the role of providing accents. At the very end of the fourth minute there is an exciting sped up bridge with Jaco and Herbie momentarily displaying something extra, but then this moves into a more lounge-jazz-like section in which Herbie's piano performs At 5:20 the music speeds up again as the strings re-enter and take over the lead again: slowing and smoothing things out until the next sped up section (which starts at 6:10 and lasts for over a minute). Weird to hear Jaco serving only as a rhythmatist and Herbie and the strings occupying 100% of the solo/front time! (13.5/15)

5. "Portrait Of Tracy" (2:20) gorgeous and mind-blowing solo electric bass. The man was a mind-blowing genius! How can a bass create such a lovely melody by using only harmonics? (4.75/5)

6. "Opus Pocus" (5:25) two steel drums players performing with Jaco, Don Alias and Lenny White holding down a spacious low end while Wayne Shorter takes on the lead with his soprano saxophone. In the third minute Lenny and the steel drummers finally regulate themselves with a forward moving albeit still rather slow groove as Jaco, Wayne, Herbie Hancock's Fender Rhodes, and the steel drums take off each in their own directions. I love how well they five play off of each other while still remaining loyal to the foundational groove and melody line. (9/10)

7. "Okonkole'y Trompa" (4:21) A song co-composed with percussionist Don Alias, the two take off on a hypnotic journey into African rhythmic minimalism (with Jaco only using bass harmonics for his contribution to the weave)--all the while French horn player Peter Gordon provides a kind of distant future-MARK ISHAM-like dirge. Brilliant! Maybe I've been giving too much credit to KING CRIMSON for their "ground-breaking" polyrhythmic song "Discipline"--which won't reach the public's ears until 1981! (9.75/10)

8. "Used To Be A Cha-cha" (8:52) this Latin groove comes across as something light and upbeat--like a Chick Corea song--as the acoustic jazz instrumentalists contribute more traditional-sounding (albeit, Latin-infused) jazz structure and solos to the top. Hubert Laws' piccolo flute, Herbie Hancock's impeccable piano play, Lenny White's masterful drum play, and Don Alias' fearless percussion play all serve immeasurably to help Jaco express this one: a song for the ages. I'm sure this one has been studied and copied and practiced with by anyone who wants to be anything. Just, Wow! They're all working so hard, I hope they were having fun, too! (19/20)

9. "Forgotten Love" (2:12) just Herbie's piano chord play with support of full strings and Jaco's simple support on bass. Very surprising to see that Jaco is the sole author of this composition. A beautiful study in odd chord progressions. (4.75/5)

Total time 41:35

I remember picking this album up while I was in college (late 1970s) and having great trouble connecting with anything in it. (My young and inexperienced ears and brain were not yet able to comprehend what I was hearing.) Now I finally am able to appreciate--with gratitude--(some) of the genius being put on display for the world to see/hear with this album. It's a humbling yet inspiring. We are so fortunate to have had this man and his talents on the planet--and to have some of his performances and compositions preserved for posterity!

A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of stunning performances rendered of ground-breaking compositions and ideation. Highly recommended: but only when you're ready to receive ideas and performances well out of the basket of comfort and "normalcy."

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Common Ground by BIG BIG TRAIN album cover Studio Album, 2021
3.85 | 208 ratings

BUY
Common Ground
Big Big Train Crossover Prog

Review by fuxi
Prog Reviewer

4 stars After GRAND TOUR, which I found disappointing, BBT are back in a big way. The band's idealism is marked even more strongly than on their previous album. Three of the first four tracks feature lines such as: 'Together / is the way we'll survive', 'Opened up to freely share / Everyone and everywhere / All the love we can give' and: 'We see the same stars / Walk the same ground / Lit by the same sun / We can be one.' Were Greg Spawton and David Longdon still reacting against Britain's fateful decision to leave the EU?

Musically speaking, the album shows an interesting evolution. Three of BBT's greatest soloists (Rachel Hall on violin, Andy Manners on keyboards and Dave Gregory on guitar) having left, the most exciting solos are now provided by Rikard Sjöblom, who does amazing things on Hammond organ and various synths. Dave Gregory's absence also means the final track's brass quintet apotheosis is almost devoid of ecstatic lead guitar. At the same time, the band have worked hard on their harmony vocals: D'Virgilio, Sjöblom, Longdon and - a newcomer - Carly Bryant now take care of these together, and the result is highly pleasing to the ear.

'Part One' of the album (which encompasses the first four tracks) is more lightweight than 'Part Two', which seems more closely related to 'classic' BBT. 'The Strangest Times', a fun opener, feels like the band's homage to Elton John's interpretation of 'Pinball Wizard'. 'All the Love We Can Give' and 'Black With Ink' almost veer into run-of-the-mill AOR, but 'Dandelion Clock' (another uptempo piece) is sung with such conviction that the listener perks up.

'Part Two' clearly deserves four stars. 'Apollo' is a delightful instrumental with a great bass line and remarkable solo contributions on flute, violin (played by Aidan O'Rourke), brass and Hammond organ. The title track is wonderfully catchy as well, and the 15 minute 'Atlantic Cable' is as good as anything on earlier BBT albums such as FOLKLORE or ENGLISH ELECTRIC.

While two or three of the tracks on COMMON GROUND are probably 'non-essential', most of the material is so uplifting that the album as a whole will form an 'excellent addition' to any prog rock music collection.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Io Uomo by RICORDI D'INFANZIA album cover Studio Album, 1973
3.32 | 53 ratings

BUY
Io Uomo
Ricordi d'Infanzia Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by Andis

3 stars Ricordi d'infanzia plays a melodic hard rock, primarily featuring straightforward, catchy rock tunes. It's not until the last two tracks that the band really lets loose, giving a nod to progressive rock. Otherwise, you'd have to be quite generous to see it that way. They remind me of many other Italian bands from that era, with heavy guitar, organ, and melodic, romantic vocals.

The main issue, as I see it, is that most of the songs are just melodic rock tracks. They're good, but they don't particularly grab my interest. The sound is somewhat gritty, with hints of the '60s, which isn't a bad thing - in fact, it almost works in the band's favor. The lead singer is excellent, and I suspect there are multiple vocalists in the band.

Most of the tracks are solid 3+ songs - good, but not spectacular. The penultimate track is clearly the best, and the final track also pushes the boundaries a bit. The overall sound is decent, but the album doesn't hold up particularly well compared to others from that time. While it's entertaining and sounds good on a first listen, repeated plays reveal its limitations. It's competent but rather unremarkable.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Circle's End by ALARUM album cover Studio Album, 2020
4.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Circle's End
Alarum Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

— First review of this album —
4 stars "Circle's End" is the fourth full-length studio album by Australian technical/progressive metal act Alarum. The album was released through Dinner for Wolves in June 2020. It´s the successor to "Natural Causes" from 2011. Only lead vocalist/bassist Mark Palfreyman remains from the lineup who recorded "Natural Causes" and new in the lineup are Scott Young (guitars, backing vocals keyboards) and John Sanders (guitars, vocals, backing vocals, keyboards). The drums are performed by session musician Ben Hocking (The Levitation Hex, Aeon of Horus).

Stylistically the material on the 10 tracks, 46:08 minutes long album is a continuation of the technical/progressive death/thrash metal style of "Natural Causes". The difference between the two albums are that Palfreyman delivers his vocals in a slightly more aggressive shouting manner (there are also sporadic male clean vocals on the album and very shortly a female clean vocal section on "Crystals") and that the sound production on "Circle's End" is more powerful, heavy, and massive than the slightly less effectful sound production found on "Natural Causes". It´s a big plus in my book to hear Alarum´s music presented like this. To my ears the semi-jazzy death/thrash/progressive metal of Cynic is a big influence on Alarum, but Alarum generally go for a more straight forward and easily accessible sound.

So, although this is certainly a both technically well played and progressive tinged metal release, the song structures are predominantly relatively simple and easy to follow, and there is an almost instant gratification listening to the music. "Simple to follow" shouldn´t be misunderstood as if the music is primitive though, as it´s still quite intriguing and technically well played music. It´s also quite as eclectic in style and "Circle's End" is overall pretty varied and the tracklist is well thought out.

Upon conclusion "Circle's End" is a high quality release from Alarum and to my ears an improvement over the already great "Natural Causes". Alarum deserve much more attention than they probably receive, and I can highly recommend fans of Cynic and other similar melodic semi-jazz/fusion influenced death/thrash metal acts to check out "Circle's End" as a starting place to get to know Alarum. A 4 star (80%) rating is deserved.

(Originally posted on Metal Music Archives).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 North Country by GRIMM, LARKIN album cover Studio Album, 2002
1.00 | 2 ratings

BUY
North Country
Larkin Grimm Prog Folk

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

1 stars I'm not sure how many fans of LARKIN GRIMM are even aware of this obscure debut. On her bandcamp pages she practically disavows it as too raw and squalid, but some of our prized contributions by our favourites are similarly mocked, while their "picks" can leave us just as nonplussed. Right? Well, less so in this case, as "North Country" seems just the sort of album that the Christian/new age cult under which she received all manner of early tutelage might have played at their ceremonies to thin the herd. The title track in particular is a shrine to the Wail Gods, but it doesn't improve all that much from there, a low budget, likely single tracked single minded series of rants, with the longest track's best part being sound effects that sound far less offensive but last longer. Don't let this dissuade you from giving Larkin a chance, but wait until if and when you love her voice for itself through her better known albums.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Tarot, Part II by MAGICK BROTHER & MYSTIC SISTER album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.57 | 23 ratings

BUY
Tarot, Part II
Magick Brother & Mystic Sister Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

3 stars 3.5 stars. MAGICK BROTHER & MYSTIC SISTER are from Spain and released their debut in 2020 as a four piece. In 2024 they returned with a vengeance as a trio, releasing two studio albums, and both based on Tarot cards. And just for your information Walter Wegmuller released an album called "Tarot" back in 1973, with a who's who of Krautrock musicians.

I have to admit that this album isn't sticking to my little brain. It's bizarre that other than one track, I feel like this is a lot of spacey soundscape music. Mellotron and synths rule. "Part II was released 7 or 8 months after "Part I" and this latest comes across as being the left overs from the "Part I" sessions. I don't know this, I'm just saying what it sounds like. The guest flute is missing from "Part I" as well, but essentially this is the same trio with the same guests.

In the liner notes they show track 1 "Strength" as being track 11, so a continuation from "Part I". Except that there were eleven tracks on "Part I" so "Strength" should be track 12. Regardless, this "Part II" just feels mailed in to me, or the left overs. I like it, and I'm not sure why I am just not connecting to it at all. Keep in mind I know several fans who prefer "Part II" by a wide margin. I feel the exact opposite. The one song that did standout was "Sun". It feels energetic even though it's mid-paced, because the music on here really does feel like soundscapes that just don't move much.

I'll keep this review short as I'm just not absorbing the music enough. "Part I" is in my top 10 for 2024, while this one I will remember as being a disappointment.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 FSK by FORSQUEAK album cover Studio Album, 2017
3.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
FSK
Forsqueak Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Finnforest
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

— First review of this album —
3 stars Eclectic Post/Math Jams

Forsqueak is an instrumental post rock group from Palermo featuring Bruno Pitruzzella, Sergio Schifano, Luca La Russa and Simon Sfameli. They released their debut in 2013 and their follow-up FSK in 2017, both on Almendra Records, an artist-run label also from Palermo. They mention influences as diverse as Battles, Mogwai, and Robert Wyatt. Forsqueak is a unique and modern improvisational group that reminded me at first of stuff like '80s Crimson and Summers-Fripp, mathematical and exploratory for sure, but also with a streak of jamming alt-pop/rock elements one might expect from The Police or even The Pixies. They also have an edge of avant-jazz at times.

It's very interesting how their repetitive guitar lines unfold back and forth over each other, different lines going different places, but then eventually the rhythms and melodies meet back up, seemingly by chance. The guitar lines dance with each other. This band is more direct and to-the-point than many of those dreamier post rock bands who float along serenely, but there are some lighthearted, quirky passages. So as you can see, they're a bit all-over-the-map with their sound, which is the point! This is a good album and they have excellent chops, but I'm afraid I appreciate their sound more than I love it.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Selling England by the Pound by GENESIS album cover Studio Album, 1973
4.65 | 4821 ratings

BUY
Selling England by the Pound
Genesis Symphonic Prog

Review by Benjaminq

5 stars This album is perfect from start to finish. A perfect, extremely melodic opening, with zany lyrics that reflect the current state of England in the early 1970s, where America was just beginning to make a killing with its economic siren. From lines like "There's a fat old lady outside the saloon" that guide you through imaginary passages where you truly feel the reality of the lyrics. It's not Collins' best drumming. It might have been his best on ATOTT or LLDOB. But with Hackett at his best, Rutherford bringing the soul he always gave to Genesis, Banks perfectly crafting the most beautiful melodies I've ever heard, and Gabriel at his most creative. Surpassing Foxtrot was only possible with this album. It continues the socioeconomic narrative but leaves a bit of a gap, or rather the religious theme that hadn't been fully addressed since the first album. For me, In the Court is only better for what it means to the history of rock in general, but this album is the most divine delicacy the genre has ever created. If I had to choose just one album to save, it would surely be this one. A beautiful cover, referencing the second track, which is super progressive in its lyrics, although it had pop and radio leanings, but it encouraged young people to do something that's still being done 50 years later: Doing what you love.

{Note this was Google translated and then edited for accuracy by admin. Only reviews in English are allowed.}

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Blazing Revelations by SANDERSON, DOMINIC album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.21 | 111 ratings

BUY
Blazing Revelations
Dominic Sanderson Eclectic Prog

Review by Benjaminq

3 stars Honestly, I'm starting to get used to this formula, which has been gaining traction for the past two or three years, leaning heavily toward Avant or Zeuhl, or occasionally just making noise that starts to give me a headache after about 20 minutes. I think this album has everything in terms of instrumental complexity, but it lacks a bit of melodic beauty. I say this as a die-hard symphonic fan. It's a very good album, but it gives me a headache. I think mixing all the bands from the '70s isn't the formula. We should reconsider creating our own new sound. That's the essence of prog.

{Note: translated by admin to English. Reviews should be published in English for this site.}

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Frippada Andaluza by MALABRIEGA album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.26 | 70 ratings

BUY
Frippada Andaluza
Malabriega Prog Folk

Review by Benjaminq

5 stars It's great to see how Spanish prog is beginning to take hold on the global scene. Frippada Andaluza, which sounds like (Revoltijo de Fripp Andaluz), does it perfectly. With an album that only came out on CD and has a two-sided format with everything in between when listened to on CD. With perfect themes of love and the melancholy of being alive in an economic system that's stretched thin and squeezes us as much as it can. Very similar in parts to PF's Animals in the second half of the album. With death metal scenes included and in Spanish, haha. Without a doubt, along with Naxsatras, the best I've heard this year.

{Note: This was translated by Admin. Only reviews in English are allowed.}

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Comin' Through by HENDERSON, EDDIE album cover Studio Album, 1977
4.08 | 6 ratings

BUY
Comin' Through
Eddie Henderson Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars Recorded in Eddie's "backyard"--in San Francisco--at Wally Heider Studios--sometime in 1977--the album is reputed to have had a July release from Capitol Records.

1. "Say You Will" (4:28) so this is how it's going to be: Disco Jazz-Funk! There is the skillfully-played musicianship coupled with repetitive dance grooves with their instrumental riff "hooks" and engageable melodies. The main melody as presented by Eddie on his trumpet prepares us for Debbie Harry's awesome 1980 hit, "Rapture," while the mesmerizing bass 'n' drum line beneath feels as if it came straight out of The ISLEY BROTHERS' 1975 release, The Heat Is On (like a slightly less bass-heavy "Fight the Power"). (8.875/10)

2. "Open Eyes" (3:53) slow it down to Bob James pace, Paul Jackson's funky note-sliding bass line is so cool! Active horn section, Patrice Rushen's clavinet, and choir sultry background vocals make for a great cocky-urban groove to fall into. Here the effect of the percussion ensemble is felt and Eddie really lets us hear his trumpet talents. Nice--though it is faded out to end it (indicating, of course, that the original jam went on for some time longer). (9/10)

3. "Morning Song" (5:38) discarding the Disco and R&B stylings for a song is a good thing. Here they are reaching back into the soulful early 70s with a Bob James/Steely Dan kind of spacious style. I like this very much as it reminds me much more of the true essence of some of those original pioneers of Jazz-Rock Fusion--the ones who were seeking to catch listeners with melody, comfort, and ease. Eddie's lead trumpet play is quite smooth and modest, rarely showing his skills, settling more for the engaging melodies of the classic soul singers of the 1960s. (8.875/10)

4. "Movin' On" (5:54) I'm wondering if the "dirty" production on George Cables' electric piano intro was intentional or not. No matter. After 30 seconds of solo electric piano, the band appears with a Disco-lite motif that predicts HERB ALPERT's 1980 hit, "Rise." George's clavinet play above Paul Jackson's centering bass line is great while the electric piano strays and spices things up beneath the steady beat provided by the Locksmith. The long reverbed trumpet notes are pretty cool even if they are mixed a little further back than I would have expected (or liked). With so many percussionists employed for this song I would have expected more noticeable action coming from that department, but no. My favorite part of the song (beside the clavinet and Fender Rhodes play) is Manny Boyd's excellent sax solo in the third and fourth minute. Again, like Herb Alpert in "Rise," Dr. Eddie stays the course pretty firmly with his long- sustained reverb note playing throughout. (9/10)

5. "Return to the Source" (4:32) a song that sounds like a slow-motion version of one of The Isley Brother's popular uptempo funk songs from their Heat Is On-Harvest For the World-Go for Your Guns period (1975-1977). Eddie's muted trumpet play is awesome, the pace a little discombobulating because it's slower than you would want or expect, but it does allow for plenty of chances to observe the talents of band members like the rhythm guitarists and vocal choir. Great rhythm guitar work from Lee Ritenour and some of the album's best trumpet playing by Eddie. (9/10)

6. "The Funk Surgeon" (4:59) fully committed to the Disco era: multiple rhythm guitars, slap and pluck bass, bass- and hi-hat-centered drums, EWF-like horn section, Patrice Rushen's novelty sound of duck-like Mini-Moog--it's all here for a dance-floor novelty song. Which is sad for the way in which Eddie's trumpet becomes so secondary (or tertiary) to the music--even going so far as getting buried within the mix instead of up front. (8.75/10)

7. "Beyond Forever" (4:38) one of the most interesting songs on the album--mostly due to its mid-song tempo increase and the remarkable instrumental performances that come with that. NOt only are the performances of Paul Jackson, George Cables, and Locksmith off the charts impressive, the composition (by George Cables) displays a songwriter who is anything but complacent--someone who wants to continue to keep the exciting, exploratory nature of jazz alive within the music industry. Great song! (Too bad they faded it out again: I would love to hear what else they had to say!) (9.375/10)

8. "Connie" (3:05) an Eddie Henderson composition that finds the flugelhorn player expressing from a tradition that feels closest to that of Miles Davis and/or Freddie Hubbard. George Cables is Eddie's lone accompanist--on a sparkling Fender Rhodes. Very reflective and introspective. I love Eddie's emotional side. (9.25/10)

Total Time: 37:07

Though full of plenty of funk and creativity, this album definitely presents a full commitment to the sounds and styles that were dominating the world of radio- (and sales-) friendly pop music at the time.

A-/4.5 stars; a collection of masterful songs that perfectly reflect so much all that was going on in the dance, radio, and Jazz-Rock Fusion world at the time (mid-1977).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Grass Is Greener by COLOSSEUM album cover Studio Album, 1970
3.84 | 129 ratings

BUY
The Grass Is Greener
Colosseum Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars This album is apparently quite the anomaly in that most of these songs have appeared on previous Colosseum albums but here they employ a different lineup of musicians. Plus, this was an album that was released only in North America- -which seems to indicate that the band (or record company) was trying to gain a foothold across The Pond--one that they had obviously failed to gain with their previous releases. The offerings here are jazz-tinged psychedelic rock album that predicts the music of GENTLE GIANT while reaching back to familiar West Coast psychedelic power rock bands like like The Doors, Spirit, as well as taking advantage of the way paved by more successful British Invaders like The SPENDER DAVIS GROUP, PROCUL HARUM, and LED ZEPPELIN.

1. "Jumping Off the Sun" (3:00) psych rock in a GENTLE GIANT vocal form. The music is a bit closer to the psych rock bands of the late 1960s--like SPIRIT but those vocals sound just Derek Shulman. The musicianship is very high, very tight. (8.75/10)

2. "Lost Angeles" (5:30) this one sounds like a sophisticated THE WHO song with Paul Weller singing the vocal. Drummer Jon Hiseman is so good that you can tell that the rest of the band feeds off of (or is driven by) his powerful skill. Great Jimmy Page-like guitar solo from David Clempson in the third minute. The rest of the band around him (including a second guitar track) are equally great: all focused on delivering the unmitigated CREAM-like power that Hiseman and the spirit of this song seem to demand/require. I can finally hear Dick Heckstall-Smith's sax in the final minutes of this one. Excellent song. (9.3333/10)

3. "Elegy" (3:26) a famous song that brings to mind both SPENCER DAVIS and BRIAN AUGER. Guest vocalist James Litherland has a great, soulful voice. The song's basic chord progression and melodic hooks work very well: a very memorable song. The role of the soprano sax and Neil Ardley's strings is noticeable but not a major contributor. (9.66667/10)

4. "Butty's Blues" (6:45) yes, full on organ-lead blues: the first song on which Dave Greenslade gets to really shine. He's very good--with an excellent horn arrangement behind him from Neil Ardley and excellent bass and drum play from Tony Reeves and Jon Hiseman. Once the amazing "big band" intro is over at 1:28, the song turns into a very typical blues/blues-rock tune--like something JOHN MAYALL or ROBIN TROWER would do. But then the horns return to remind us of the modern juxtaposition and Dick's tenor sax takes a solo in place of the second vocal verse. The dynamic whole-band finish is awesome! I normally don't like blues/blues rock but the participation of the horns makes this very dynamic and exciting. (13.5/15)

5. "Rope Ladder to the Moon" (3:42) an outlier in that this song had not appeared on any previous Colosseum releases, the song was picked up Jack Bruce and made more famous as one of his anthemic concert favorites. It is a very cool song with great vocal, lyrics, melodies, and full-band support music. Rated up purely on the vocal performance & clever lyrics (and delivery). I have the feeling that this song may also have been influential to Derek Shulman and his brothers. (9/10)

6. "Bolero" (5:28) one might laugh upon seeing this title on the page but the band actually do Ravel's original quite some justice with this heavy, full power-rock version. Nice keyboard and sax play over Jon's impeccable drumming, but it's David Clempson's fiery, bold-like-TERRY KATH electric guitar solo that really gives it its unique identity. It is one of those great, truly original and, therefore, iconic guitar solos. As a matter of fact, it's so good (and the rest of the bands' performance on his coattails) that you are actually transported into forgetting that this is Ravel's "Bolero"!! (9.125/10)

7. "The Machine Demands a Sacrifice" (2:48) another song lifted off of the previous year's Valentyne Suite album, this one has a psychedelic feel not unlike that of Iron Butterfly's "In-a-gadda-da-vida"--especially in the drum-and-bass- centered music. (8.75/10)

8. "The Grass Is Greener" (7:31) one of the pieces lifted from the actual "Valentyne Suite," this one is gentler and more prog-tempered than the album's other tunes--probably because it's an instrumental on which the band hope to show off their skills as musicians. I'm surprised at the uncredited full-horn ensemble opening as well as the slower TRAFFIC/Southern Rock tempo. It seems as if all of the band's instruments gain some showing here with full-spotlight solos from Hammond organ, bass, volume-pedal-controlled electric guitar, even sax and drums. The tempo shift into high speed for final three minutes (as well as the long, protracted dénouement at the end) will become such a template for so many Southern Rock bands like LYNYRD SKYNYRD, MOLLY HATCHET, CHARLIE DANIELS, and THE OUTLAWS. (The Allman Brothers were already doing it--so maybe Colosseum picked up the idea from them.) (13.125/15)

Total Time 38:10

I very much like this album: it has great musicianship--feeling as if each member of the band is fully committed to and engaged with each song. At the same time, despite the presence of horn sections on several songs and despite the excellent (probably virtuosic) musicianship, I could probably never be convinced that this music is Jazz-Rock Fusion. It's just progressive blues-rock psychedelia dressed up in some jazz fittings.

B/four stars; though I find the skillful and tight musicianship on this album to be exceptional, the songs are not always aligned with my own personal preferences. At the same time, I can definitely imagine the success and popularity that an album like this would have created in 1970/71.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Sing to God by CARDIACS album cover Studio Album, 1996
4.27 | 410 ratings

BUY
Sing to God
Cardiacs RIO/Avant-Prog

Review by SliprKC70

3 stars I will admit, this album took me a while to get into. And it makes perfect sense (to me at least) for me, someone who is critically negative towards punk as a genre, to not enjoy the Cardiacs. However, after multiple listens over a long period of time and expanding on their discography, I've found some good in their music. First of all, the album never rests. It's always moving, transforming, and changing while staying consistent on the amount of energy the band puts into each song and always staying aggressive to help keep that motion going. The only problem is that after over an hour and a half, it can get quite overwhelming, annoying, and sometimes even bland. Speaking of annoying, Tim Smith's vocals made me want to just take a break from the album overall. He has a good vocal range and guitar skill, but he is constantly forcing his singing into every song, and that just doesn't go well with a guy (me) who mainly prefers instrumental music.

Moving on, all the songs carry at least something to be appreciated by. They all sound like the same song, not in structure, but in style. Some of my favorites include Eat It Up Worm Hero, Fiery Gun Hand, A Horse's Tail, and Wireless. These songs are some of the most complex and interesting songs on the album and can be enjoyable to dissect and discover little details in each of them. Wireless specifically explores many different aspects, seeing how it is one of the longest songs on the album. The reason my rating is 3/5, however, is because this album is essentially just a modern expansion on the band's previous albums and isn't really that new because of it. Also, I wish the songs were longer and went into further territory other than just making the same song over and over again (as I mentioned above).

In conclusion, maybe if this had come out a decade earlier, it would have been more original in my eyes, and maybe if the band had more meat on the bones of the tracks and the different sections instead of making the same thing every time, my rating would be higher. I am settling on a 3.25/5 for this album because I understand why it is loved and why it might be an important record for progressive rock enjoyers to listen to, but I wouldn't label it as an absolute essential piece. It also isn't even the band's best album (in my opinion).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Moondragore by BUKWALD, ARNAUD  album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.31 | 5 ratings

BUY
Moondragore
Arnaud Bukwald Eclectic Prog

Review by kev rowland
Special Collaborator Prog Reviewer / Special Collaborator

4 stars Over the years Arnaud has released albums under his own name and under the bandname Moon Dragore, and here he combines both with his latest album which also includes Gong co-founder Didier Malherbe. Arnaud provides vocals, guitar, weissenborn, sitar, keyboards, Didier suling, flute, bawu, ocarina and the line-up is completed by Cherry Pob with vocals, bongos, frame drum, tongue drum and drummer Cloudy Myster. The result is something which truly stands out among the dross of the modern world as Arnaud has taken his influences from world folk and then brought it to life with musicians who truly understand the vision. Didier is in his eighties now, but still as vibrant and important as he was when he was playing on classics like 'Camembert Electrique', 'Flying Teapot' and 'Angel's Egg' and there are times when he and Arnaud combine to create music which is refusing to be bound by any boundaries or preconceived ideas and the listener can just revel in what is going on between their ears.

However, it is not all ethnic, and Arnaud is happy to allow Cherry Pob to provide her vocals on songs like "Looking Across" where he strums acoustic guitar on material which is far more Americana, but then he follows that with a guitar workout which is different yet again. This really does feel like a journey of discovery switching through different origins so one never knows what is going to come next, just that it will be enjoyed. It is an album which moves all over the place, but whereas many releases that attempt this simply fall by the wayside, here there is mastery at play, so we enjoy the myriad explorations and opposed to be confused by it. It is majestic and vibrant, powerful and passionate, thoroughly enjoyable from beginning to end.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Uchu Nippon Setagaya [宇宙 日本 世田谷] by FISHMANS album cover Studio Album, 1997
4.48 | 6 ratings

BUY
Uchu Nippon Setagaya [宇宙 日本 世田谷]
Fishmans Crossover Prog

Review by Dapper~Blueberries
Prog Reviewer

4 stars (This review was written in Apr 07 2023)

While I may not have been all that fond of Long Seasons, it did introduce me to Fishmans and I am grateful for it as they definitely do have a great dream pop and dub sound. I think after I listened to their live album of 98.12.28, I became a bit more interested in Fishmans as a whole, and with my recent endeavors of their 1997, and last album of Uchu Nippon Setagaya, they really cemented themselves within my brain.

Unlike making a repeat of Long Seasons and releasing a big song, Fishmans went back to a multi-song structure for this album, but they do dabble a bit more in song structure, clearly as a refinement from Long Seasons. I think the best thing about this album, for me, is how lively, yet very laid back these songs feel. I think it is mostly due to the downtempo and reggae inspired sound found here, but I never feel like these songs ever grow into something super intense, or increasing into tempo, most songs here stay a relative and smooth tempo that are quite slow, but I think it works out in the group's favor as it makes their dream pop and psych rock sounds feel all the more buoyant, and a little nostalgic for me. I don't know why, or how, but these tracks make me feel like I lived in late 90s Japan a long time ago, even though I was born long after the 90s, and I am not even Japanese. Maybe it is some past life deja vu, but the fact this album can make me feel nostalgia for a time and place I never even been in makes this quite a powerful trip.

I also have to take praise where it is due with the long track of Walking The Rhythm. Man, this song is so good, with its first minute consisting of this beautiful piano and rhythm movement and then shifts into this very sweet ambient dream pop soundscape that I just adore. I personally believe, compared to their other long song of Long Season, this track beats it out of the water in terms of consistency and power.

I do have one problem with this record and it is the fact most of the stand out moments on here just seem to be relegated to the last 3 tracks. I mean I really enjoy all the songs on here, but I think if you compared Pokka Pokka or In The Flight with バックビートにのっかって or Daydream, it just ain't no contest to me on which is better. I think if the band spread these last three songs throughout the album and try to make all the other songs into something also truly special, I think we might have a masterpiece on our hands.

A very great record from this little trio from Japan. Sad this is the last album they made, but I am glad they have left us with some great music. Definitely will look into more of their stuff, and who knows, maybe review more. They definitely piqued my interest here, and I think one day, I might find my absolute favorite from them.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Long Season by FISHMANS album cover Studio Album, 1996
4.21 | 12 ratings

BUY
Long Season
Fishmans Crossover Prog

Review by Dapper~Blueberries
Prog Reviewer

3 stars (This review was written in Sep 12 2022)

For many, obscurity and popularity are two things that never cross paths. For them, it's either you never heard of them, or you've heard everything from them. I would like to break this process away from the status quo, since I fully believe that an album can be both obscure and very popular, as long as you know where to go. In online music communities, people can find and hear albums they never knew existed before, and that is generally how I discover most of my music. Music circles share albums from one hand to the next like two cars passing by each day. In that sharing of two separate, but equally musical things, people grow attachments and love for some albums, some of which they never heard of before. There are communities built up from the groundwork for finding new and interesting music, such as Rate Your Music, Album Of The Year, a lot of music-focused Discord communities, and even my little darling that is ProgArchives. The internet, while being a bit of a dumpster fire in most places, helped a lot in terms of finding new joys in life that no one in the history of time could comprehend. So in that context, it is safe to say that without the internet, not many people would know about the Japanese band, Fishmans, and their album, Long Season.

Formed in 1987 in Minato, Tokyo, Fishmans was formed by the founding members of the late Shinji Sato (Vocals, Guitar, Trumpet), Kin-Ichi Motegi (Drums, Sampler), and Kensuke Ojima (Guitar, Vocals). Kensuke would leave the band in 1994. Two more members joined the group in the later years of 1988 and 1990, that being Yuzuru Kashiwabara (Bass), and Hakase-Sun (Keyboards). Their music often falls in the same boat as The Flaming Lips, being a blend of dreamy pop music with Neo Psychedelic Rock, however, they have done more ambient pop, and progressive pop music as well, especially found on this album. In recent decades, they have gotten a good following over the years, especially on sites like Rate Your Music, where this album is considered the #1 album of all time in 1996 with a rating of 4.19/5.0 from over 20 thousand ratings. It is clear that this album or more accurately song is one that many people fell in love with, and to be honest, I really do get the hype and care surrounding this entire album, because it is really good, however, I would be remiss to not point on something I do not particularly find that great on this album.

This album is one big 35-minute epic that goes through this abstract valley of sound and noise. Sometimes you get flavors of very dreamy keyboard and drum playing skills, mixed in with a wide array of varying instruments, from violins, to sound effects, bells, and some tribal beats as well. This whole song feels very much like waking up from a dream and having that dazed confusion while hearing your alarm clock blaring in your ears. Everything here feels very abstracted, and I think in some, mostly good areas, it works. I think the best thing about this song is that I always come out of it fairly good, and while that goes for most epics I listen to, hearing this more surreal type of music being pushed to half an hour in length and getting out of it does surprise me a lot. Usually, I would only ever truly love it if it was something like Tangerine Dream or Jean Michel Jarre where you can get very loose and experimental forms of longer music, but here in a more rock/pop context, it makes me surprised to see it come through so well. Every bit and part of this song is very airy, and I think the band was aware of the space they were given for this song since you get a ton out of it while still keeping up with what the intended sound should be. Everything is consistent in its direction, so props have been given. Oh, and also the singing is very well done. I do dig how soft the vocals here are, they feel very in line with the music being played here.

However, the song also can suffer from that abstract sound that I praised in the last paragraph. Like trying to remember a dream, some parts I have trouble trying to remember because sometimes this song can feel very boring at times, or just too Avant Garde to where it gets lost in the weirdness. It seems like a lot of times they get lost in trying to find a new but consistent direction for the song to take, and sometimes they can find their way to a new place that'd improve things, sometimes it feels as though they cannot seem to know how to get through the thicket and end up scraping and bumping into things that do not go well with this epic. Honestly, I feel like they could've made this song even better if they reworked the parts at 14:35 through 27:00, especially that part where it's tribal drumming with a weird repetitive sound effect looping a bit, and that violin part. Honestly, that violin is the worst part of the song, it is so ear-grating that when I hear it I most often than not turn my volume down to be much quieter so I cannot hear it. Honestly, this song would be one of my favorites if it didn't seem like they get lost in their direction and focus on those middle pieces.

I get why this album is very beloved, and I do enjoy a good deal of parts on here, heck I'd say most of the good elements on here outway the bad, but I cannot in good faith say this is a must-listen, or would recommend it to anyone due to those middle parts. It's still a perfectly good album, but not one that I can really adore. If you want some other more dreamy psychedelic or more atmospheric psychedelic rock music then this could be a good place, but I'd suggest being acquainted with other types of bands or projects before hearing this one.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Jordsjo & Breidablik: Kontraster by JORDSJØ album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.16 | 39 ratings

BUY
Jordsjo & Breidablik: Kontraster
Jordsjø Symphonic Prog

Review by Stoneburner

4 stars 10 years of Prog

If you're into classic modern progressive rock, chances are you already know Jordsjø. But fewer may be familiar with Breidablik, a project that, until recently, flew under my radar. I've been a huge fan of Jordsjø for a while, but I only listened to Breidablik for the first time yesterday?and I was genuinely impressed. Think Tangerine Dream, Mike Oldfield, or Jean-Michel Jarre. It's techno-ambient, old-school, beautifully crafted, and with a distinctly vintage sound. In short: a very good band that deserves more attention.

Now, these two Norwegian acts have come together to release a split album celebrating their 10th anniversaries. One side is Jordsjø, the other is Breidablik. Despite coming from different corners of the prog universe, the combination works surprisingly well. Jordsjø already stands as a major name in the current Norwegian scene, but paired with the atmospheric touch of Breidablik, the result is something even more immersive.

Jordsjø contributes a nearly 20-minute epic titled "Kontraster", and Breidablik answers with a piece of similar length. Both tracks explore the same central theme, but in their own signature styles?Jordsjø through organic, symphonic prog textures, and Breidablik through layered electronic ambiance. It's like hearing two different languages express the same thought, and it works beautifully.

What's most striking is that these two bands have almost nothing in common musically?except that they both come from Norway. Yet this split is a powerful example of the diversity within the prog scene, especially when approached with this level of professionalism and creativity.

I loved the record from the very first listen. It's one of those rare collaborations where both artists elevate each other. Without a doubt, this album deserves to be high on any end-of-year list.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Tempora Mutantur by LUNAR album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.39 | 5 ratings

BUY
Tempora Mutantur
Lunar Progressive Metal

Review by kev rowland
Special Collaborator Prog Reviewer / Special Collaborator

3 stars This is the first time I have come across Sacramento-based progressive metal collective Lunar, but apparently, they were formed all the way back in 2013 by drummer Alex Bosson (Helion Prime, Planeswalker) and Ryan Erwin who passed in 2018. This is their fourth album, following on from 2023's 'The Illusionist', which has seen a few line-up changes so on this recording the band was Chandler Mogel (clean vocals), Brian Lewis (growl vocals), Carlos Alvarez (rhythm guitar), Connor McCray (lead guitar), Ryan Price (bass), Alex Bosson (drums) and Anthony Stahl (keyboards). There are many guest guitarists providing solos, while I note cellist Raphael Weinroth-Browne (Leprous) is also on one number.

Lyrically, what we have here is a concept album dealing with the passing of time and the effects it has on us physically and mentally. Bosson said, "This album deals with something everyone can relate to, and no one can escape: the passing of time. We get older, our perspective changes, and we gain some things, and lose others? sometimes the things and ones we love. And we struggle and fight along the way. This album deals with some of the highs and lows we deal with along this journey we all share." Musically, there is a lot going on as here we have a band who can be prog metal, mathcore, pronk, often in the same song and sometimes at the same time. It means the listener can never really relax as they have no idea what is going to happen as the band progresses through the songs. In some ways I am somewhat surprised there are not more longer songs on this set, as only one is above 10 minutes, and only three more above six, as this is music designed to extend and stretch both the listeners and players. It will be no surprise to anyone that this will appeal to fans of Tool, Opeth, Caligula's Horse, Haken, and Porcupine Tree, and if you want music which can be highly melodic and almost laid back at one minute and insanely complex and heavy the next, then this is for you.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The White Death by FLEURETY album cover Studio Album, 2017
3.00 | 2 ratings

BUY
The White Death
Fleurety Experimental/Post Metal

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars "The White Death" is the third full-length studio album by Norwegian avant-garde/black metal act Fleurety. The album was released through Peaceville Records in October 2017. It´s the successor to "Department of Apocalyptic Affairs" from 2000, so it´s been quite a few years since the last album. Fleurety haven´t been completely inactive though releasing no less than four EPs in the years between 2009 and 2017. Fleurety formed in 1991 and initially played black metal, but eventually drifted towards an avant-garde metal style in the late 90s/early 00s.

The duo lineup of Svein Egil Hatlevik (vocals, drums, percussion, Keyboards) and Alexander Nordgaren (guitars) is still intact from the last album. Fleurety is helped be several session musicians who perform bass, backing vocals, female vocals, keyboards, and flute.

While the musical direction of "The White Death" can still be labelled avant-garde metal, there is a huge difference between the abstract melancholic/often eerie sounding blackened avant-garde rock/metal style of "The White Death" and the all-over-the-place odd avant-garde metal style of "Department of Apocalyptic Affairs". If you didn´t know it you wouldn´t have guessed that it´s the same band releasing the two albums, but you can of course also add Fleurety´s debut full-length studio album "Min tid skal komme" to that pile as it´s a full-on black metal release, which sounds nothing like either "Department of Apocalyptic Affairs" nor "The White Death". So, Fleurity is indeed a shape-shifting creature.

There are a few nods here and there to the band´s black metal past ("Lament of the Optimist" for example features blast beating black metal sections) but "The White Death" is predominantly not a black metal release (a track like "Future Day" for example sounds like a combination of Comus and Dead Can Dance). It´s dark, abstract, and melancholic/eerie sounding avant-garde rock/metal which often consists of just a simple beat, some dissonant guitar riffs/keyboards, and some vocals. Other times there are more musical layers, and it´s definitely an interesting and challenging release. The album is not easily compared to other contemporary releases and Fleurity don´t sound like any other artist either, but artists like Virus, Dødheimsgard, Ved Buens Ende, and Code can maybe at least lead you in the direction of what to expect on "The White Death".

The album features a dusty, raw, organic, and somewhat stripped-down production style, and it suits the material well. To my ears "The White Death" isn´t a perfect release, but it´s much more consistent in style than the eclectic sounding "Department of Apocalyptic Affairs". For avant-garde metal fans eclectic sounding releases usually aren´t an issue and I´m sure there are many who find "Department of Apocalyptic Affairs" a more accomplished and challenging affair than "The White Death", but the more consistent and accessible sound of "The White Death" has other qualities, which make it appealing. A 3.5 star (70%) rating is deserved.

(Originally posted on Metal Music Archives).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Jordsjo & Breidablik: Kontraster by JORDSJØ album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.16 | 39 ratings

BUY
Jordsjo & Breidablik: Kontraster
Jordsjø Symphonic Prog

Review by Progfan97402
Prog Reviewer

5 stars Ever since I discovered Jordsjø in 2017, there were two things I wished for and one was to record a side-length piece, another was to get Lars Fredrik Frøislie to make a guest appearance. Well, it looks like one of my wishes came true, and that's to record a side-length piece. As for Lars appearing, that hasn't happened. Probably because he wishes to record in his own home studio (the fact much of his gear is of authentic vintage, he probably doesn't want to move them around due to reliability issues, especially because much of it is at least 50 years old now). Kontraster is the second split release by Jordsjø with Breidablik, after Songs from the Northern Wasteland back in 2016. Kontraster is Norwegian for "Contrasts", which could have been easily guessed by me. And that aptly describes this. First side is Jorsdjø's piece. No surprise it's all Håkon Oftung on vocals, guitar, flute, and assorted keyboards, and Kristian Frøland on drums. It sounds like what you expect from these two guys, great retro-prog with lots of great vintage keys, vocals in Norwegian, and flute, and it's great to see them pull off an almost 20-minute piece. I knew they could pull that off, so I can't imagine that stopping them on a proper full-on Jordsjø release. I imagine Håkon wasn't confident he could pull off a 20-minute piece, as no Jordsjø piece ever went much beyond 10 minutes. Either that, or he was fearing a Tales from Topographic Oceans type of album from them (I couldn't imagine that. Jordsjø has always been too modest for that). Breidablik's contribution is, unsurprisingly much more electronic, with lots of eerie ambient passages and sequencer-dominated passages as well. He gets Håkon to play guitar and flute, as well as a real drummer, not Kristian Frøland, but Trond Gjellum, a drummer that's not familiar to me. That's the first time I ever heard real drums on a Breidablik recording, as usually it's a drum machine (but only used occasionally), as most of the time, Breidablik recordings is entirely by Morten Birkeland Nielsen himself. This is incredible stuff, and it shows how Jordsjø is some of the greatest prog going these days as Breidablik is for electronic music.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Book of Taliesyn by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1968
3.22 | 634 ratings

BUY
The Book of Taliesyn
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by Hector Enrique
Prog Reviewer

3 stars "The Book of Taliesyn" (1968), a title whose origin comes from a medieval manuscript attributed to the Welsh poet Taliesyn (6th century), is the second chapter of Deep Purple's formative trilogy, and where, despite its still very rudimentary production, the great potential of the duo Ritchie Blackmore and Jon Lord, protagonists of this work, can be glimpsed, after the primitive and agitated pounding rock of "Listen, Learn, Read On", spirited and generous virtuoso displays as in the instrumental "Wring That Neck", a combination of jazz and blues marked by the incontinent interplay of guitars and keyboards, and replicated in the middle section in the country pop of the festive cover of Neil Diamond's "Kentucky Woman".

On the other hand, "The Book of Taliesyn" also has an important experimental component taken from the psychedelic sixties aesthetics, in tracks like "Exposition", the hyperventilating instrumental intro of the interesting adaptation of the Beatles' classic "We Can Work It Out", in the intriguing "Shield" with Ian Paice incorporating percussive world music sounds, and ventures even further combining it with baroque renaissance elements so admired by Lord who explores with mellotrons, church organs and a violin arrangement in the relaxed "Anthem", and where the robust voice of Rod Evans hits with an Elvis-style imposition, surely the best and most progressive track of the album.

And the cover composed by Phil Spector, Jeff Barry and Ellie Greenwich for Ike & Tina Turner, "River Deep, Mountain High", is the band's excuse to indulge in another experimental lysergic dalliance based on a tenebrous wind blowing and with some nods to The Doors, concluding an album that has few intersections with Deep Purple's seventies works, but is nonetheless extremely interesting.

3/3.5 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Monobody by MONOBODY album cover Studio Album, 2015
4.72 | 8 ratings

BUY
Monobody
Monobody Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Precisely performed jazzy Math Rock from some youth from Chicago. Gutsy, intelligent, complex and intricate yet delivered tight and with great melodic sense.

1. "Lifeguard of a Helpless Body" (4:15) with the same fast pace and upbeat nature of a TOE (Japan) jam, this sets the tone for the album with some fast-picking (and tapping) guitar work. Such a refreshing sound! (10/10)

2. "I Heard them on the Harbor" (5:56) takes its time in establishing patterns as it opens with several instruments taking turns appearing and disappearing. It is only into the third minute that a rhythm and structure is established and played over--but then is challenged and discarded in lieu of some spacey and then jazzy keyboard. The spacey, spacious soundscape reappears for a while until at 4:18 an entirely new and soft-beat rhythmicity is established and built around. And exquisitely so, I might add! Cool and unusual song. (9/10)

3. "Curry Courier Career" (8:11) opens sounding like an intricate, upbeat WES MONTGOMERY song. It then diverts into I kind of étude in sharp time changes and collective band discipline. Things shift and progress in this song so quickly and suddenly--totally unpredictably. There is, however, a pattern to the song structure here (as opposed to song #2). A song that displays some seriously talented and skilled musicians and some seriously well-rehearsed execution of some seriously well-thought out song composition. Definitely the most jazzy song on the album. (13.5/15)

4. "Exformation" (5:21) opens with some intricate and frenetic guitar tapping leading the band into a stop-and-go kind of rush hour traffic pace. The guitarists melody lines here are seriously (and continuously) fast! Even in the mid-song lull the keyboard and guitar lines are intricate and speedy. STANLEY JORDAN would be impressed! (9/10)

5. "Gilgamesh (R-Texas)" (6:18) lots of interplay between instruments off doing their own thing: staccato rhtymic hits from drums and rhythm instruments, polyrhythmic arpeggi from piano, guitars and synths. It is an amazing display of artistry, vision, discipline and restraint. There's even quite a liteel MUFFINS-like Canterbury play in the chord and melody structures of the third and fourth minutes (and the horns in the fifth minute). Everything drops off at the end of the fifth minute save for an electric piano chord sequence--over which the delicate play of other instruments is added to the end. Another outstanding gem of a song! (10/10)

6. "Country Doctor" (5:25) opens with a simple little piano arpeggio repeated over before countrified big band joins in. The pace is atypically slow for this band until the one minute mark when a wall of KAYO DOT-like electrified sound enters and swallows us. The music vacillates back and forth for a while between the MAUDLIN OF THE WELL like beauty of intricately woven soft-picked instruments and the occasional wake-up call of a blast of heavy metal dynamo then settles into a long section of soft but intricately woven multiple instruments. The final 35 seconds allows instruments final flourishes over a fast piano arpeggio. Beautiful song! My favorite on the album. (10/10)

Every once in a while an album comes out of nowhere to shock and surprise me--and this is one of those. I only wish I had heard it in the year it was released so that I could have had more say in helping to bring attention to it. This is an AMAZING album that is truly worth the while of any prog lover's time and attention. Check it out!

A veritable five star album; a true masterpiece of progressive rock music! But what is it? Post Rock/Math Rock like TOE or ALGERNON? Eclectic Jazz Rock ā la FROGG CAFE or UNAKA PRONG? Canterbury jazz like MANNA/MIRAGE/THE MUFFINS? It's a mystery! They're chameleon's! I can't wait to watch their future unfold for the skies are not too high for these talented musicians!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Unending Ascending Special Edition-Live by GONG album cover Live, 2024
2.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Unending Ascending Special Edition-Live
Gong Canterbury Scene

Review by alainPP

— First review of this album —
2 stars This Special Edition album features all eight tracks from 2023's 'Unending Ascending' and incorporates five live tracks to make it seem like a live production, available digitally until the time of writing; no doubt, die-hard fans of this unclassifiable band will have gotten their hands on it under their 80s raincoat, the era of innovative ska. The bonus track 'Musica Per Aprire La Mente, Musica Per Aprire Il Cuore' is the best live track on this album. For the eight tracks, the spotlight goes to the languid Crimsonian 'Ship of Ishtar,' magnified by the bewitching voice of Saskia Maxwell, in fact the vocal engine inspired by the DEAD CAN DANCE or even COCTEAU TWINS. An album that has brought nothing since the death of its founding father, which maintains the legend of a band apart for many fans who remained attached to their sound of the 70s and who will die with an epitaph of said band on their tombstone for sure. An album with an Indian atmosphere, psychedelic above all and quite far from the Canterbury movement that it is supposed to represent. The most 'painful' pieces are those with wind instruments which upset by assaulting the ear.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Lies to Live By by SPIRIT OF CHRISTMAS, THE album cover Studio Album, 1974
4.33 | 17 ratings

BUY
Lies to Live By
The Spirit of Christmas Eclectic Prog

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

5 stars 4.5 stars. Guitarist and vocalist Bob Bryden is from Oshawa, Ontario and he was part of several bands in the sixties. He formed CHRISTMAS in 1969, a four piece with Bob singing and adding guitar, plus there was bass, drums and lead guitar. They released two albums in the early seventies. When it came to that third record Bob recruited vocalist and keyboardist Preston Wynn. He felt the change in the band's sound with this new singer and the added piano and mellotron required a change in the band's name, so it was altered to THE SPIRIT OF CHRISTMAS.

Preston can sing! He has such character in his voice. I mean it sounds dated, sounding like he's from the late sixties. but man he can let it rip. There's a folk vibe to his voice, sort of similar at times to the singer from COMUS. The band would then get signed to Capitol Records but when Capitol heard the final result they weren't happy. They wanted a more commercial styled music than what was created on "Lies To Live By". The band stood their ground, and a lawsuit resulted. The album would finally get it's release a year later in 1974, but not on Capitol, and a much smaller release as a result. Sadly this album barely caused a ripple. You gotta love these clueless record executives.

We get six tracks over 41 minutes. The first three songs really bring that folk vibe out with the vocals and stories. Even though the music isn't folk. "All The Wrong Roads" opens with slide guitar as acoustic guitar then vocals join in. It picks up quickly with drums and bass joining the party. And talk about folky, check it out at 1 1/2 minutes. "Stay Dead Lazarus" and the next tune "Voice In The Wilderness" reference the Bible which is interesting since Bob would eventually become a Pastor. The first of those is like a dark, folk inspired piece where the bass leads much of the time. Nice. The latter is quite uplifting to my ears. The bass again is upfront. Some piano later. We're having fun 2 minutes in. Such a feel good tune.

Those first three songs are all under 4 1/2 minutes. The next three are 9 to 11 minutes in length, and no doubt of great interest to Prog fans. "War Story" is an anti-war tune that opens with heavy gun fire that had me looking in confusion at my stereo. I had just spent time with BLISTERING MOMENTS "Therapeutic Dreams" where we get this heavy gun fire on a couple of tracks. I was briefly confused(haha). This is one of two songs with mellotron on it. Love when it kicks in at 3 minutes. The wordless vocals, the ripping guitar solos. An earlier theme returns at 5 minutes. Mellotron and piano follow.

"Factory" is my favourite. Those vocals really shine on this one. Lots of energy right out of the gate. A calm with piano follows. This all changes before 2 minutes as the guitar lights it up and we get those repeated lines "Down at the factory." The guitar gets a little crazy after this then a welcomed calm at 4 minutes. Another calm at 5 1/2 minutes where it's almost silent. Then those words "Everything's under control" over and over. This reminds me of THE LEGENDARY PINK DOTS and their "Chemical Playschool 10" record, and in particular the song "Saucers #1" where Ed Ka-Spel announces over and over "We do not have everything under control."

Finally we get the closer "Beyond The Fields We Know" which is the longest at over 11 minutes. Mellotron on here along with some inventive instrumental work. Whispered vocals at one point before it builds before 8 minutes with emotion. Wordless vocals follow. An adventerous way to end this record. I read that a young Alex Lifeson would go and see Bob and his bands many times, while Bob in return would eventually do the same with RUSH. This album and RUSH's debut were released the same year. Bob was on his way of getting out of music while Alex was just getting started. Passing the torch as it were. This album is a monster and it's part of my "best of" Eclectic list.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Orgone Unicorn by ØRESUND SPACE COLLECTIVE album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.73 | 9 ratings

BUY
Orgone Unicorn
Øresund Space Collective Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by alainPP

3 stars 1. Skin Walker drums by Innuendo, right at the start; 23 minutes later, we wake up from the OSC trance, time has moved, but our limbs haven't, they're stiff, proof that this music affects time and space; in short, simply captivating. 2. Enos Donut for the tinkering around close encounters of the third kind, before and after the famous encounter and the mountain climb; A sound that spins, that comes and goes 3. Orgone Unicorn for its atmospheres combining oriental sounds, reverberating bells with the typical sounds of TANGERINE DREAM, captivating and heady 4. Kraut Toe Trip for its typical OSC signature, indecipherable with dark, cursed guitar sounds, from the era of the Mandarin dream of the early 70s 5. Omnia Magnifico for its syncopal musical impulses, its electronic drums, its violin, in short, OSC jamming with, again and again, the oriental atmosphere in the distance 6. Red Panda in Rhodes for the adjustment of the different keyboards or the short interlude, for the bathroom break? 7. David Graham's Wormhole Ride for this sound reminding me of the metronomic tunes of PIL, yes, PUBLIC IMAGE LIMITED also knew how to be repetitive; after that, TANGERINE DREAM returns at a gallop, radically changing the atmosphere; After 5G acceleration into hyperspace! In short, 130 minutes strapped to the seat for a free round trip into space?amazing! (3.5)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Singles by CAN album cover Boxset/Compilation, 2017
4.00 | 14 ratings

BUY
The Singles
Can Krautrock

Review by Syzygy
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars Your one stop shop for Can.

On the face of it, this is not an obvious choice for a Can compilation. In their heyday they were famous for thirty minutes plus freakouts on stage and wildly experimental studio albums, neither of which are obvious contenders for chart toppers. They did, however, release a steady stream of singles throughout their career and even enjoyed some success; Spoon was a sizeable hit in Germany, and I Want More got into the UK top 30 and earned them a Top of the Pops appearance.

This collection covers all their studio albums from Soundtracks to Rite Time, with the exception of Out of Reach, and there are several non album tracks and a similar number of edited down versions of their more extended pieces. The editing was mainly done by Holger Czukay, who generally managed to distill the essence of a longer track onto one side of a 7" single. The collection kicks off with Malcolm Mooney's two lead vocals on Soundtracks and then heads into the Damo Suzuki era. There are two non album tracks here, Turtles Have Short Legs and Shikako Maru Ten, both enjoyable slices of eccentricity that would have slotted nicely into Unlimited Edition. Two Tago Mago tracks were used as b sides, including a drastically edited Halleluwah, and Future Days is similarly slimmed down. Then we're into the quartet era, with edited highlights from Soon Over Babaluma, Landed and Flow Motion; the pairing of I Want More / ...and More may not be to everybody's taste, but it works surprisingly well. Silent Night is the first bump in the road - Can's version of the classic German Christmas carol has not aged well, and it is followed by the full version of Cascade Waltz. We then briefly dip into the Rosco and Rebop line up with an edited version of Don't Say No and the non album b side Return, which is like a slightly funkier reboot of I Want More / ...and More. Can Can, the famous Offenbach tune, was performed by the three remaining founders Karoli, Schmidt and Liebezeit, and while it might have seemed like a good idea at the time it is the one total dud in this collection. In the 1980s Malcolm Mooney joined the core quartet for a one off reunion album, Rite Time, and Hoolah Hoolah was picked as the single. Both the single and the album were better than expected, even if they're not exactly vintage quality.

Four stars for this collection. It's the only single disc collection that covers every Can line up, and which traces their development almost from the beginning. It's also the only place to get all the non album tracks in one compilation; none can be considered essential, but aside from Silent Night they are all worth having for completists. The edited versions of longer tracks are sufficiently different from the originals to be of interest, although some are more successful than others. The sleeve notes warn that not all the original tapes were available. so the sound quality is a little inconsistent, but I didn't notice anything particularly jarring. If you're a Can newbie this is a good place to start; if you're an established fan it's pretty good to listen to while driving or exercising.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ei noi muut by VIMMA album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.93 | 6 ratings

BUY
Ei noi muut
Vimma Prog Folk

Review by Matti
Prog Reviewer

4 stars This is the brand new third album by the young Finnish group -- whose name means Frenzy -- that features violins and carries a strong message about the climate change in their lyrics. The debut from 2019 really impressed me as an eclectic fusion of folk, classical, rock and hip hop elements. The second album from 2023 sounded much poppier, and also enjoyably fresh for that matter. The group's musical direction continues to change further towards tighter, more energetic, in a way more youthful and more passionate/aggressive about the message delivery. What's eventually losing in this progress is the wider, prog-natured musical variety, especially the classical chamber music flavour. The entire brief album is extremely loaded with high-speed, rap-like and often very repetitive vocals of the female vocalist Eeva Rajakangas. Strangely though, my initial listening last Friday ended up being quite positive. I guess I was in the right mood for some real kick-ass attitude. What an energy and passion, who's not to appreciate them?

'Bensa 95' is rather similar to the second album's lead single 'Antrasiitille'. The beginning's punchy riff of violins + hand-clapping is joined by rap-flavoured verses and the beautifully melodic and airy chorus. The arrangement combines pop, rap and folk elements truly deliciously and harmonically, making this track one of the obvious highlights. 'Pestään kädet' (= Let's wash our hands) and 'Kuolematon' (= Immortal) are more rap-oriented as compositions, but the sound full of violins is interesting.

'Tarviin' (= I need) is a charming, electrified, fast-paced pop song with a toy-like synth sound and a melodic, catchy chorus. Reminds me of the British band PRAM. 'Kapina on kuumaa' (= Rebellion is hot) and the album's title track (= Not those others) are hectic, high-speed songs that could be labeled as punk!

Gracefully the 7th and 9th pieces (= You can't change anything; Broken) are calm, slow, spatial and moody, both indeed beautiful. 'Punainen aurinko' (= Red sun) is also relatively slow and has a gorgeous, dynamic arrangement. After the continuity of these three calmer tracks the closing song 'Kuningas Gnu' charms with its poppy brightness and energy.

Well, as I started this review I thought I couldn't give more than three stars, for all the punk and rap, but the highlights are after all forming a majority of the ten tracks. VIMMA remains to be a unique band and now they're more powerful than ever before, there's no denying of that.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ici Est Ailleurs by RAISON DE PLUS album cover Studio Album, 2001
3.85 | 25 ratings

BUY
Ici Est Ailleurs
Raison De Plus Symphonic Prog

Review by alainPP

4 stars 1. 'Renaissance' for the cinematic intro before its time, with this beach narration, quickly erased for a layer of synths that gives into neo-symphonic and the song that lasts, lasts and goes on nostalgic lands, 6 years to release a better-made album!! 2. 'Jamais j'aurais faut grandir' with the introduction of the French vocal in the lyrics, ouch that has aged well there, I find SHELLER in the intonation, the flute not helping matters by flirting with the ANGE of yesteryear; a slow, well-crafted drift, but with old-fashioned markers that take me back to the date, ah yes 2001 like for the film, a sidereal space; in short, the flute is eyeing JETHRO TULL now, hey, a little reggae where are we going? It's a bit disparate 3. 'Le roi du temps gris' (The King of Gray Weather) with a preamble, it's beautiful, explanatory, a sound that looks to MAGNESIS or vice versa, for the distinctive vocals that can be disturbing because they're put too much forward, like in a vulgar French song, the Achilles heel of French prog; a touch of ANGEL again, we're right in it with the operetta voices, like in the epic of General Machin; the outro with violin makes us forget these details that the prog fundamentalist of the 70s can't stand; well, a journey to the dark French forests of the Vosges 4. 'Vagues a l'ame' (Waves to the Soul) with its waves, narrates the story of the meditating king; Seagulls, the synth, ah, we're going for the 80s new-wave sound, interesting, hey, a hint of SAGA again, the sound evolves, the flute minstrel, medieval, Scottish... folkloric for the moment, a well-crafted instrumental, which confirms that sometimes music is enough without the vocals. 5. 'Une autre chance' for the title track on side 1 with the melodic importance of the gently reverberating guitar, on the flute of MOODY BLUES, yes, the nostalgic memory has an effect; it's soft, it takes us far away from the prog of yesteryear, the narrated vocal explaining for those who want to know everything.

6. 'La cle' reminds me of the band's adulation for SAGA, hence the immersion in the album; Fresh keyboard layers, the nervous side on MINIMUM VITAL too, the tenacious guitar reminiscent of Ian and the flute more on OVERHEAD infusing the rhythm, a very good musical moment and it rises in quality 7. 'Dans la cite des incredules' with the theatrical vocal return worthy of Christian from the ANGE 70s era; the voice that channels the music and guides it on bucolic tracks; the pleasure of traveling with a majestic finale so as not to take itself seriously; long and well done, to wander on it 8. 'La rumeur' with a wink, whether proven or not on purpose at all, on the magnificent 'Fou' by ANGE, yes we are really on it and the voice integrates again flawlessly with the diabolical orchestration; The sound of MORE REASON is here, not elsewhere. 9. 'Enterre vivant' and its clock, time, the cinematic space of a time when it didn't exist yet; sirens, key sounds, a vague synth in the distance, and then the song gets going; the SHELLER-esque voice again, it's rather pleasant given the compositions of this outstanding singer and composer; a space with the GENESIS-esque keyboard, not bad either; the well-integrated vocals prove it's possible; the guitar even dares to flirt with the melancholic notes of HACHETT, yes, Steve Hackett himself. Come on, a little martial military drumming, yes, I repeat myself, and a few birds in the distance for the album's track, and it's not the frog that will croak at me otherwise. 10. 'Entre reel et imaginaire' concludes this concept album, the slow and long story of man, always a child, loving to lose himself in his imaginary meanders, or the child sleeping precisely in each of us; A playful tune where the lyrics blend in with the notes of this sad melody, because even the prog knows they no longer have a place in today's world; think a quarter of a century later, it's even worse. In short, go get the ball and keep dreaming.

MONA LISA, ATOLL, PULSAR, HALLOWEEN, and especially SHELLER, SAGA, and ANGE as the spearheads, the initiators of this album of yesterday.(3.75)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ritchie Blackmore's Rainbow by RAINBOW album cover Studio Album, 1975
3.77 | 377 ratings

BUY
Ritchie Blackmore's Rainbow
Rainbow Prog Related

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Medieval dreamscapes and remote castles guarded by dragons - leaving Deep Purple had allowed eccentric guitarist Ritchie Blackmore to explore his visions of high lore and to examine the possibilities of melodic rock with strong progressive leanings, constructing a band of unknowns at the time, in what would become the first iteration (of many to come) of the band Rainbow. The debut album of this new musical outlet had been recorded over in Munich during the spring months of 1975, and later released in September of that year. The music on 'Ritchie Blackmore's Rainbow' features prominent melodic licks and powerful, monolithic riffs, occasionally criticized by some who would've expected a greater touch of Purple in the guitar work, but unlike the majority of his work with his former band, Blackmore seems to have been much more invested in the sound and development of the songs rather than gripping guitar pyrotechnics. The result is an album that is quite hard-rocking and melodic, replete with images of fantasy world and the stunning vocal work of Ronnie James Dio, formerly of the band Elf.

The debut Rainbow album, of course, has several emblematic pieces of classic rock, including the sharp-edged 'Man on the Silver Mountain', a song that is quite omnipresent in the world of the band, with a fantastic main riff from Blackmore and tremendous singing from Dio, the prog-ballad 'Catch the Rainbow', one of the band's finest moments, together with the fabulous piece 'The Temple of the King', a song bolstering beautiful vocals from Dio once again, and the frequent live number 'Sixteenth Century Greensleeves'. Apart from these all-time classics, this debut album also features the lesser known but really catchy 'Self Portrait', a well-constructed rock number, the fast-paced 'Snake Charmer', giving us some excellent Blackmore soloing, and the closing instrumental cover of a song by The Yardbirds. One shall also find the mediocre boogie rock numbers 'Black Sheep of the Family' and 'If You Don't Like Rock 'n' Roll', two Rainbow songs we might prefer not to talk about... Yet this album has remained definitive for its era and has given us a number of classic tracks so there are no reasons not to love it, a great work of hard rock and perhaps early heavy metal.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Dominion by IQ album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.15 | 172 ratings

BUY
Dominion
IQ Neo-Prog

Review by kev rowland
Special Collaborator Prog Reviewer / Special Collaborator

5 stars IQ are back with their third studio album in just over a decade, with the same line-up for all three, four of whom who played on 'Tales From The Lush Attic' all the way back in 1983. Michael Holmes has been the only constant through the band's career, but there was a stable line-up from 'Ever' to 'Dark Matter', and it is only the one album after that period, 'Frequency', which truly failed to shine, not bad for a band with the longevity of this one. Peter Nicholls (lead & backing vocals), Michael Holmes (guitars), Tim Esau (bass, bass pedals), and Paul Cook (drums, percussion) along with "newbie" Neil Durant (keyboards) may not be the most prolific, but arguably their output has been the most dynamic and consistent of the band's career. This is not a group who are going through the motions but instead are releasing some of their most important and fascinating music yet.

When I reviewed their last album, 2019's 'Resistance' I said that one of the things that truly stood out for me was the confidence of the band, particularly that of Paul Cook, and here we see that being taken to yet another level. Opener "The Unknown Door", which is the longest song on the album (and one of their longest ever) at 22 minutes, tells you everything you need to know about this IQ. Paul can be hard-hitting, blasting around the kit, or providing emphasis by sitting on his hands and doing nothing, Tim provides complexity with his hands and stability with his feet, Neil has long ago moved away from being compared to Martin Orford and has created his own niche in the band with banks of sounds and a happy understanding of the relationship between overplaying and providing support, while Michael can be bombastic and loud or picking an acoustic. There are multiple layers, the threads interweaving and combining the sounds into a majestic whole, and then at the front is the irrepressible Peter Nicholls. To me he has always been as important to IQ as Geoff Mann was to Twelfth Night, or Fish to Marillion. Yes, each band has released highly enjoyable albums without those frontmen, but were they true to the essence? I think not.

This is not an album from people heading gently into older age but instead is a band who still have something to prove, proudly progressive, moving forward. It is a band working together, with little in the way of flashiness as instead this feels like a collective release with everyone knowing their place in the pantheon and what they need to achieve. Consequently, it is a release which I loved the very first time I played it, and it has grown on me even more with the repeated listenings. There is a presence, a dynamic here which is difficult to explain, a majesty which only comes from a band still on the top of their game after more than four decades.

This may well be their finest release since 'Subterranea', not something I say lightly at all. Essential.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Trail by HOLLINGSHEAD album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.00 | 3 ratings

BUY
Trail
Hollingshead Heavy Prog

Review by kev rowland
Special Collaborator Prog Reviewer / Special Collaborator

4 stars When I recently reviewed 'Asleep or Insane' by Bakelit I explained that I have known Swedish multi-instrumentalist Carl Westholm for years through Carptree and Jupiter Society, although others will probably recognise his name more for his time with Avatarium and Candlemass. After I sent out my normal Christmas update email last December Carl asked if I would like to hear the latest releases from his two new projects, Bakelit was the first and Hollingshead is the second. Carl is the only constant between the two bands, and he again provides organ, electric piano, synthesizers, theremin, backing vocals while this time the band is completed by Tony Naima (lead vocals), Johan Niemann (bass, from Evergrey, Therion and Mind's Eye), and Fredrik Haake (drums, Meldrum, Sideburn, God Is My Co-Pilot). There has been a four-year gap between this album and the debut, during which time original singer Gidon Tannenbaum departed.

I have not heard the debut, and a new vocalist often changes things quite dramatically, so I have no idea if this is should be viewed as a continuation or a new direction, but I am aware it is very dark and deep indeed. Is there such a thing as doom prog? If not, then these guys may have invented a new musical form. Imagine if you will, a cross between Atomic Rooster and Candlemass and you may get some understanding of just how heavy this is, with Niemann playing a bass which sounds as if Lemmy and Chris Squire have come together and produced a sound as filthy as possible, yet somehow the music is wonderfully melodic. There is no guitar here, as there is no room for it whatsoever as the bass, drums and keyboards are so tight and all rammed together at the bottom end, but I can almost guarantee the average punter will not realise that as so few listen carefully these days. Then over the top are wonderful vocals which contain emotion when the time is right, not too high in the scale so it all gels together as opposed to clashing.

There will be quite a few progheads who will find this release way too heavy for their tastes, or the organ just too dated, but if ever someone wants some darkness on a bright sunny day, yet not too much to totally overpower the senses then this is it. Carl asked me to give this some time, but I enjoyed it the first time of playing and it just gets better with repeats. Not for the fainthearted though.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Wildflower by FINDLAY, HEATHER album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Wildflower
Heather Findlay Crossover Prog

Review by kev rowland
Special Collaborator Prog Reviewer / Special Collaborator

— First review of this album —
4 stars A post from Heather appeared in one of the groups I am a member of on Facebook, and the computer in my head started whirring and I immediately thought of a band I haven't listened to in years, Mostly Autumn. Originally signed to Cyclops, I reviewed the first three albums when they were released, but the last I had heard of theirs was the wonderful 'Passengers' from 2003. I was not aware that Heather had left the band after 13 years and eight studio albums to follow a solo career, nor that she had formed Mantra Vega and released albums in different group formats and styles, as well as books, poetry and art. What I did know, though, was that I always loved Heather's vocals and was intrigued to hear what she was doing more than 20 years after I last reviewed her.

I was soon playing 'Wildflower' and fell into a world where all that mattered was the voice, and the voice was all that mattered. This is mostly a true solo album, with Heather accompanying herself on acoustic guitar and occasional piano and percussion with just Troy Donockley (yes, I know he is in Nightwish, but for me he will always be the guy from Iona), providing a wonderfully emotional vocal and Portuguese Mandola to the lilting duet, "Still Burning". This is an acoustic album, containing a few elements of folk, quite a bit of Americana, a touch of Country and Western, and a ton of beauty. The album is bookended by Heather leaving a message on voicemail, welcoming us and reminding us we are all loved, and although there may be some who will not like this element, it works well to both bring us into the album and leave us with a positive message.

Positivity is a common element throughout this release, as while there are times when it wants us to think, it is never negative or mournful. This is particularly true of the last song, "Love Is All", which is a capella with just a few bird sounds to provide backing. It is uplifting, all-encompassing and incredibly powerful. It is if Heather is in a warm summer's glade, the birds in the trees, and we are sat entranced at her feet, caught in her spell. Although I have found myself enjoying this in the car, there is no doubt the best way to listen to this is on headphones when one has the time to immerse oneself in the world she is creating with her voice.

Having not heard any of Heather's releases in more than twenty years I can see from this that I have been missing out and will have to investigate her Bandcamp page further. For those to whom the name Heather Findlay is new I can assure you this is an album very much worth investigating. If you enjoy acoustic music with wonderful female vocals and lyrics with meaning, then this is simply essential.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Transmutation by KARMAKANIC album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.13 | 113 ratings

BUY
Transmutation
Karmakanic Symphonic Prog

Review by alainPP

4 stars 1. Bracing for Impact for the prog metal intro that's searching for itself, that DEEP PURPLE-esque rhythm made me listen, it's like ZZ TOP in the distance and that divine keyboard, well, everything is in place to produce typical prog rock. 2. End of the Road for the beautiful long melodic track that lacks creativity; yes, I feel like I'm on the latest FLOWER KINGS; well, no more, it's like Neal MORSE, yes, on familiar ground. The guitar solo is heartwarming, thanks to Luke for adding some pep. 3. Cosmic Love for its latent, progressive intro, quickly erased by the new-wave electro keyboard, yes, very invigorating; with Randy and John, we get our money's worth. 4. We Got the World in Our Hands, beautiful intro and consensual track, damn! It's going around in circles, it's beautiful, but it lacks the spark to captivate, because my ears still remind me of the sound of the Albion bigwigs who had a lot of fun jamming together on consensual prog rock, ideal for prog fans not looking for new sounds.

5. All That Glitters Is Not Gold for the accordion and the captivating chorus that you'd think you'd already heard elsewhere; the best track for the crescendo that deviates into the proven prog metal side, finally showcasing Göran's voice and the guitar solos that really enjoy themselves; the sax ā la 'West Side'; in short, I did well to resist. 6. Gotta Lose This Ball and Chain for the calibrated ballad that reignites the debate on the sound of yesteryear; it's beautiful but conventional, we've already heard that, and what's new? It's clean, without any smudges, but I don't find the air that would make me swoon, or rather, I can't find a sound that would distinguish them from the FLOWER KINGS or BIG BIG TRAIN, pillars of a movement losing creativity. 7. Transmutation (The Constant Change of Everything) with its intro, yes, I'll leave you with that; after that, it's the trap track that seeks to melt the listener with numerous guests... and it works. Between Steve HACKETT's guitar and Andy's Hammond, I thought I heard a GENESIS tune, with Dina's vocals and Amanda's help, Nick's pad parts, how can you remain unmoved? Yes, but too much can kill too, so let's be careful! The velvety, melting, melting mid-track disappointed me, repeating the clichés of symphonic prog; The very beautiful jazzy-ethno-crazy jam suite can be shocking to have such a diversion on ZAPPA, PATTERN, MORSE again. The finale is worth its weight and captivates, bewitches the listener. (3.75)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Emancipés du vide? by M'Z album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.00 | 5 ratings

BUY
Emancipés du vide?
M'Z Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by alainPP

4 stars An album by musician Mathieu Torres, who also performs under the name String Theory, recounting the crash of a passenger plane in the Alps, a code name for a harrowing moment. Okay, let's get back to M'Z and his "Emancipés du vide?" for a musical melting pot of pop, rock, jazz, hard rock, and music shaped by genres ranging from Canterbury to Drum 'n' Bass, Rock in Opposition?in short, a diverse, ambient blend bordering on rock, pure and simple. A melancholic fusion with touches of progressive metal, a juxtaposition of complex sounds, layers of fat, invasive synths bringing a dark side, energetic, eclectic crescendi, all accompanied by guitar that is happy, sad, or both at the same time.

Ideas of emotional themes, freedom in a sick world?this is what his music takes us to; a violent and acerbic critique of our world, of our Kleenex society, translated into these singular pieces. Colorful art rock without real drawers, original and captivating compositions, an uncompromising sound, overflowing with creativity with its heroes bearing the signature of Steve VAI and Joe SATRIANI, no coincidence given the riffs and tunes offered. A sound allowing one to dream or meditate at low cost on these different instrumental pieces but brought together in a conceptual way. (3.5).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Profondo Rosso [Aka: Deep Red]  (OST) by GOBLIN album cover Studio Album, 1975
3.87 | 189 ratings

BUY
Profondo Rosso [Aka: Deep Red] (OST)
Goblin Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars 'Profondo Rosso' is a soundtrack album to the Dario Argento movie of the same name, arranged and performed by the Italian progressive rock band Goblin, a musical act led by organist Claudio Simonetti, also featuring the talents of well-known Italian musicians Fabio Pignatelli, the band's bassist, and Massimo Morante, the guitar player of the collective. This 1975 release is the first official release under this band's name and has since become one of the obscure but rather intriguing places of the Italian prog rock scene; the genre indeed has a rich history of movie soundtracks, and this happens to be one of the most ingenious and original ones to have even graced the Continent. Being a psychological horror movie, the music to 'Deep Red', as would go the translation, is quirky, intense and spooky, bringing in a variety of influences like progressive rock, fusion and even proto-metal, all making up for an eclectic work of great scope.

The original album release lasts for just about thirty minutes and features seven separate tracks, the first one of which is the title track with its menacing organ work and solid but minimal rhythm section working its way through in the background. 'Death Dies' comes second here and is a suspenseful piece that takes advantage of various percussive instruments until the main riff gets introduced, a really effective song. 'Mad Puppet' with its unusual and rather haunting opening actually develops into a trippy krautrock-inspired instrumental, unlike 'Wild Session', which is precisely where the prog rock pedigree of Goblin is completely prevalent, from the wicked introductory section to the quirky interplay between the keys and the bass, to the unhinged sax solo at the final section of this instrumental. 'Deep Shadows' is then the most experimental number on here, technical but haunting, leading to the two shorter closing pieces 'School at Night' and 'Gianna', both of which have this classical crossover feel and provide an excellent ending to this gorgeous soundtrack album from the mid-70s.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Iron Maiden by IRON MAIDEN album cover Studio Album, 1980
3.85 | 717 ratings

BUY
Iron Maiden
Iron Maiden Prog Related

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

3 stars 'Iron Maiden' is the 1980 eponymous debut album by the legendary British heavy metal band, a record that proclaims the initiation of the NWOBHM movement in many ways, and displaying the ferocity and aggressive approach of those very early metal albums from the beginning of the decade, being informed by and combining elements of both punk and progressive rock, it has since been received as a critical success, having also brought significant amounts of attention to the then-young metal band upon its release, lauded by both fans and critics as a "cult classic". The music on this very first Maiden album is indeed quite heavy but also very rough and unpolished, with difficult-to-appreciate production values, occasional muddy riffs and silly choruses, it is an imperfectly perfect debut album, if that makes any sense. Featuring a unique early lineup with Steve Harris, Dave Murray, and vocalist Paul Di'Anno, Maiden was also then-composed of Dennis Stratton, a guitar player who would leave the band afterwards, and drummer Clive Burr.

What is there to say about the music on here except the fact that this is an early heavy metal music that introduces a variety of interesting influences to the world of heavy rock, serving as somewhat of a blueprint for an entire movement to come. Still, as influential as 'Iron Maiden' may be, this album is definitely not universally appealing, having significant problems in the production and songwriting departments. It opens with 'Prowler', a ballsy and fast-paced number, one of the better songs off the album, followed by the catchy 'Sanctuary', a fine homage to Judas Priest (or even Motorhead) and just a tad bit banal for what concerns its contents. 'Remember Tomorrow' is where we hear the Rainbow lesson on full display, a decent number with great guitar work that anticipates a lot of what the band would go on to explore in the future. 'Running Free', or the revved up R'n'B song of Iron Maiden, is followed by the most far-reaching piece on the album, the 7-minute 'Phantom of the Opera', a more complex and dramatic entry, still played live by the band. 'Transylvania' is a great instrumental arranged by Harris, 'Strange World' is the album's ballad, a good piece of metal music. 'Charlotte the Harlot' is indeed a bit silly, also the riffs here are not as pungent as on other places of the album, and the closing title track is more forgettable than it is impressive, despite the fabulous and ferocious bass playing. A really fine and important metal album from the early 80s that has not necessarily aged too well, 'Iron Maiden' is the first step towards the crafting of the band's signature style of heavy and technical arena rock.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Motorpsycho by MOTORPSYCHO album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.14 | 92 ratings

BUY
Motorpsycho
Motorpsycho Eclectic Prog

Review by Lobster77

5 stars It's always great to hear of a new release from veteran prog rockers (I'm two months late to say this). coming back in action with their own brand of returning to form but with only two of the original three. After having two pandemically conditioned albums in the can from Yay! (2023) to Neigh!! (2024), it's time for them to get back in their spaceship once more and return flight with their latest sole self-titled release.

From prog, cabaret, krautrock, pop-orientated, alternative rock, freak-out sessions, and psychedelic adventures, the band have gone back through the adventures once more to prove themselves that they can kick plenty of butts with mesmerising punches that come out of thin air

When I mention the krautrock genre, I could possibly tell Motorpsycho were listening to bands such as AMON DUUL CAN on 'Balthazaar'. They take listeners aboard the cosmic train into halogenic improvisations that bring to mind the two Michael's; Karoli and Rother. They combine the compositions between 'Mother Sky' and 'Hero' into one. Plus, adding in a bit of Hawkwind's curricular into the bees' knees of a heavy jam session.Then, a touch of the alternative rock vibes of the 1990s and going into a sing-along gem for 'Stanley (Tonight's The Night)' and 'Core Memory Corrupt'. You can just imagine these two songs being played during that time frame in the 90's.

The starting track kicks things off with a bang as they make the jump to light speed returning back to who they were years ago. Bent's revved-up bass sets up the course to light speed as they return to the Heavy Metal Fruit-era during their Rune Grammofon years, making sure that everything in our solar system is going according to plan as Ingvald and Hans lead the way to add in elements of flaming fire inside their hearts and minds to carry on more missions that awaits them.

But, wait a minute! What's going on? Do I sense a tip of the hat towards the geniuses of Led Zeppelin's heavy riffs that come into mind when it comes to 'The Comeback?' oh hell yeah! Reine Fiske leads the charge with Olaf Olsen in hot pursuit. Boy, do they know their source materials or what? Then, everything becomes a surreal nightmare when it comes to the ominous dark, clouds that are about to come in. From the haunting, folky lullaby on the 'Bed of Roses' to the 21-minute apocalypse 'Neotzar (The Second Coming)'. Oh, they got the machine guns all revved up and ready to attack.When Thea Grant channels her Lotte Lenya approach in the Cabaret textures, she imagines herself, singing this song during the events of The Threepenny Opera by Bertolt Brecht and composed by Lotte's husband Kurt Weill. You feel as if Pirate Jenny walking alone in the streets of Germany in 1928, singing alone in a brothel, knowing that things are going to be different for the first two minutes of corruption to take over.The band switches gears as Motorpsycho gets back into their space shuttle as they ride off into massive solar power. Bent's mellotron, Hans' heavy guitar riffs, and Ingvald coming back into the forefront, this is no jam session folks, this is as heavy as far as the eye can see. Somehow, the heaviness moves into a gentle, classical, and ambient under watery effect as if you're in a dream.

Like something out of David Lynch's movies, Motorpsycho imagine themselves doing a film score inside their minds, creating this dark, surreal, yet almost nightmarish terror that's unveiling in front of your eyes. It then reaches a volcanic eruption, waiting to explode at any second as all hell is about to break loose in this rumbling effect the band walk into.I can't tell if its Bent or Hans playing the lead section on the guitar. If its one of them, they are taking it to the nth degree, going on this hypnotic mode as if they're not making a stop signal by returning home to Earth whilst channeling the arrangements of America's 'A Horse with No Name' for 'Three Frightened Monkeys' that come into shape but making it a mid-fast shuffle that'll burn your brain cells, nonstop.

This is a very engaging listen the whole way through, these guys create eclectic masterpieces, lengthy compositions and overall great music. These guys produce a piece that resemble some of their earlier work while bringing in new energy.

5.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Tale Spinnin' by WEATHER REPORT album cover Studio Album, 1975
3.67 | 143 ratings

BUY
Tale Spinnin'
Weather Report Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars Following the ground-breaking Mysterious Traveller--many prog and jazz-rock fusion lover's all-time favorite Weather Report studio release--was no small challenge.

1. "Man in the Green Shirt" (6:28) I really love the interplay of drumming, percussion, bass, and electric piano in this song. The horns are nice, and the weird synthesized Nature sounds entertaining, but it's the great coordination of high speed play from the rhythmatists that impresses and engages me the most. (9.375/10)

2. "Lusitanos" (7:24) opening with quirky comi-funk before synth, keys, and horns present a WR-type of melodic/chordal statement. Between regular repetitions of this chorded theme Wayne and Joe take turns adding their respective solos but the sonic field is so layered that it's almost full: practically burying any soloist's attempts. But then the band thins it out, keeping only the bare bones, so that Wayne and Joe can trade solos on soprano sax and piano, respectively--Joe even going so far as to solo twice: as if duelling with himself! Then Wayne takes a turn on his tenor sax: first within the full band weave, then with the open field laid out for him. No matter who's soloing, Joe is always adding quirky little sound injections from his circus collection of synth and hand tools. Alphonso Johnson's bass is creatively effected but it seems to handcuff him into playing some rather simple lines and a lot of single tone repetitions. (13.125/15)

3. "Between the Thighs" (9:33) the Weather Report circus show continues as Joe seems pretty set/obsessed with incorporating as many unusual quirky sounds and instruments into his songs as possible. So far in three songs, almost 24 minutes of music, there has really never a minute passed without some randomly fresh sound being injected haphazardly into the mix. It's almost like he's going for a citation in the Guinness Book of World Records for the most instruments played (or included) in a single song (or album). (Being a big fan of Andreas' Vollenweider's "busiest multi- instrumentalist I've ever encountered," Pedro Haldemann, as well as Pat Metheny's legion of upper-stage multi- instrumentalists, Mr. Zawinul may find that he has a little competition.) So many times on this album I'm hearing riffs and samples that predict the cumulative breakout that 1977's "Birdland" will be for them. The best funk and groove in this song is, for me, in the song's final minute. (17.75/20)

4. "Badia" (5:20) reaching into the orient for inspiration. (It's okay: the band had now been there--on their tours-- several times.) Odd percussion, reeds, sqealy synth, pregnant bass couplets, cymbal play, and treated horn and mzuthra make for an interesting and very spacious weave. Melodica and oud are also prominent. How confusing it must have been for dynamic creatives like Alphonso Johnson and Leon Ndugu Chancler to have been so shackled like this. (8.75/10)

5. "Freezing Fire" (7:29) funk that finally taps the tremendous skill and potentialities of the relatively untested and untried bass funk master. A song that grooves and flows, feeling a little more like a Jazz-Rock Fusion tune, despite the continued barrage of incidentals injected as accents throughout the length of the song. Again, it's the drum 'n' bass unity that interests and impresses me, not the parade of creative sound injections that Joe (and Alyrio?) can muster. Just give me Alphonso and Ndugu and I'd be a happy camper! Great foundation; weird and "novelty" level entertainment. (But, Joe: I don't come to your albums for surprise and novelty: I come for the grooves and weaves!) (13.3333/15)

6. "Five Short Stories" (6:56) one of those interesting-but-ultimately-off-putting musical equations (or masturbatory exercises) that Joe and Wayne like to work through with their band. Slow and methodic, sometimes melodic; definitely cerebral and mathematical. Quite the challenge to stay engaged/interested--especially over seven minutes. (13/15)

Total Time: 43:10

The smooth, careful, and calculated side of Jazz-Rock Fusion, here presenting a lot of interesting ideas (many of which will be more fully developed on future albums). With Joe and Wayne monopolizing all of the compositional duties I think they still had not realized what they had on their hands with the recent acquisition of 24-year old bass genius Alphonso Johnson. As demonstrated on Eddie Henderson's Sunburst album that was recorded and released at about the same time as this one, the kid is nothing short of a creative genius; he has ideas, he has the chops to star--to lead-- and he has a bag of his own compositions bursting at the seams (two of which ended up on that Sunburst album). Don't get me wrong: the compositions on Tale Spinnin' are all fine, mature, presenting ground for a lot of great performances and some rather memorable songs and riffs, they're just not quite as dynamic and powerful as those on Sunburst. I think it a terrible thing that Joe and Wayne "wasted" so much talent that came their way (though many would look at it as "mentored," "groomed," or "developed"). There is some great music here, just too much entertainment-oriented circus noise.

B/four stars; an album of sophisticated, busy, multi-layered music that is often overly-gilded in what amounts to circus entertainment tricks. Too bad! as I LOVE the bones and richly constructed first layers of a lot of this music.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Vortex by AMON DÜÜL II album cover Studio Album, 1981
2.94 | 53 ratings

BUY
Vortex
Amon Düül II Krautrock

Review by Lobster77

4 stars Beginning around "Pyragony X", Amon Düül II began embarking on a more streamlined prog sound - more accessible, less weird, and generally less interesting, if still quite good. By the end of the '70's, however, this lineup pretty much petered out, leading to the far more intriguing version known as Amon Düül (UK). But II still had one more album to do, and "Vortex" was the result. And you know what...a lot of fans dislike this one (as they do all the '80's Amon Düül releases), but forget all of that. "Vortex" is a fantastic album, easily the best one Düül II had made since "Hijack". It is still more (cough) commercial (cough) than that one, but what on earth. It is really one outstanding work and a great way for Düül II to go out. Of course, Amon Düül II would return in the '90's, but this was a fine swansong for them and a fitting signpost for what Amon Düül (UK) would go on to achieve.

4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Department of Apocalyptic Affairs  by FLEURETY album cover Studio Album, 2000
3.23 | 12 ratings

BUY
Department of Apocalyptic Affairs
Fleurety Experimental/Post Metal

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars "Department of Apocalyptic Affairs" is the second full-length studio album by Norwegian black/avant-garde metal act Fleurety. The album was released through Supernal Music in 2000. It´s the successor to "Min tid skal komme" from 1995, although the two full-length studio albums are bridged by the 1999 "Last-minute Lies" EP. Fleurety consists of the duo of Alexander Nordgaren (guitars), Svein Egil Hatlevik (drums, synths, vocals), but in addition to the core duo "Department of Apocalyptic Affairs" also features a host of prolific guest appearances from artists like Maniac (Mayhem, Gravetemple, Sinsaenum, Tormentor), Garm (Ulver, Borknagar, Arcturus), Einar Sjursø (Virus, InfernÃļ), and Hellhammer (Mayhem, Shining, Arcturus, The Kovenant), among others.

"Department of Apocalyptic Affairs" opens with "Exterminators" and right off the bat it´s audible that Fleurety have completely changed since the black metal days of "Min tid skal komme". If you´re familiar with the musical direction of the "Last-minute Lies" EP, the avant-garde metal style of "Department of Apocalyptic Affairs" probably won´t come as a surprise, but if you come to "Department of Apocalyptic Affairs" directly from listening to "Min tid skal komme" and expect that "Department of Apocalyptic Affairs" will sound anything like the debut album you will as a minimum be very surprised and in some instances (depending on your tastes and open mindedness) very disappointed by the highly experimental and ever changing avant-garde metal style of "Department of Apocalyptic Affairs".

The vocals vary between semi-jazzy female clean vocals, male clean vocals (of many different types), and more aggressive snarling male vocals. In that respect Fleurety have brought back a few of the extreme metal elements they had otherwise left behind on "Last-minute Lies", but other than a few heavy riffs and punchy rhythms here and there and the aggressive raw vocals, there isn´t much here which reveals that only 5 years before Fleurety were a black metal playing unit. It´s fellow contemporary countrymen Ulver, Atrox, and to a lesser extent Manes that Fleurety have something in common with. The bass, guitars, drums, and vocals are complimented by programmed drums and effects, keyboards, and saxophone, making "Department of Apocalyptic Affairs" quite the interesting affair in terms of instrumentation.

"Department of Apocalyptic Affairs" features a decent quality production job, but the distorted guitars at times sound a bit powerless. I´m not sure they are meant to be massive and heavy, but it would have been nice with a bit more punch and power when the music occasionally features heavy riffs. Heavy riffs aren´t the dominant musical element of the album though. That´s instead dissonant lead- and (dis)harmony themes, odd jazzy interludes, and all sorts of other weirdness and abrupt musical shifts. To my ears most tracks have a musical red thread, but there are moments where the avant-garde nature of the compositions almost overpower the songwriting and become weird for the sake of it. Upon conclusion "Department of Apocalyptic Affairs" is a bold sophomore studio album from Fleurety. They certainly don´t cater to their original fanbase with this one, but I respect that this was their musical statement at that point in their career. A 3.5 star (70%) rating is deserved.

(Originally posted on Metal Music Archives).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 No Man's Sky - Music For An Infinite Universe by 65DAYSOFSTATIC album cover Studio Album, 2016
4.35 | 14 ratings

BUY
No Man's Sky - Music For An Infinite Universe
65DaysOfStatic Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Lobster77

5 stars Fantastic OST for a fantastic video game where you explore an infinite universe, the first disc here is prime 65dos, bringing a full set of their trademark post-rock with some electronics. There is no compromise here, this plays like a 65dos album. The 2nd disc is called Soundscapes and is what it says it is; ambient/electronic sound textures (but still featuring some of their trademark post-rock). I imagine this disc is more of what the music in the actual game might sound like. Altogether, this is a great set. It is incredibly long, running almost 2 hrs long (both discs combined) but fans and newcomers alike will find something worthwhile here. Disc 1 is the better of the two but I like Soundscapes as well, especially "Borealis/Contrastellar" which could have fit on disc 1 easily. It's one of the best songs on the entire set. I'm very pleased with this and I think most people will be as well. It is very well written and you can tell the band was really inspired by the game to make this music. This is extraordinary and it matches perfectly with the theme it tries to capture.

5.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 You Go Now by CHROMA KEY album cover Studio Album, 2000
3.57 | 106 ratings

BUY
You Go Now
Chroma Key Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars 'You Go Now' is the second solo studio album released by Dream Theater founding member and original keyboard player Kevin Moore, under his Chroma Key moniker. It is well-known that Moore had left DT to pursue his personal musical interests, which unlike the branch of progressive metal developed by the US-based band, had inclined much more towards the world of electronic music, and this 2000 release is precisely about Moore's exploration of this style, blending elements of ambient, lo-fi, lounge music, rock and psychedelia, the fascinating underground prog pioneer brings a collection of finely-tuned and mellow pieces, with half of the album being instrumental, and another half focusing on the vocal tracks. 'You Go Now' is quite similar to what Moore had done previously on the first Chroma Key album, although this time there is a greater focus on programming, effects, and production, while his first album was more piano-based and song-oriented.

The music is incredibly moody and mellow, kind of like a contemporary electronic rock rendition of Alan Parsons, but significantly more elegiac and occasionally desperate. Moore proves to be a master of feel and texture as he explores both of these elements in depth on 'You Go Now', as the album offers some of his most memorable songs (the opening track 'Get Back in the Car', 'Another Permanent Address', and 'Astronaut Down', all of which have an incredibly elusive ambient texture to them, yet manage to remain faithful to the structure and expressive force of rock music, with Moore punctuating the atmosphere with bits of psychedelia). On the other hand, this record also goes into some instrumental ventures, and these turn out to be rather enjoyable more often than not - 'Lunar' is quite laid back, while 'When You Drive' introduces some lounge soundscapes. 'Subway' and the title track seem to be a bit muddy, but this does not undermine the quality of an album that is rather unusual. Kevin Moore can be sufficiently eclectic to keep you interested in what comes next and his emotive approach to composing music is what renders his work so potent and evocative.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Lunar Mistake by LUNAR MISTAKE album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Lunar Mistake
Lunar Mistake Eclectic Prog

Review by kev rowland
Special Collaborator Prog Reviewer / Special Collaborator

— First review of this album —
4 stars Somehow I came across the band Lunar Mistake and when I asked them for more information I was sent this, "Lunar Mistake is a prog/post-punk/new wave band from Oakland. It features long-time members of the Bay Area music scene, including Matt Lebofsky (Secret Chiefs 3, miRthkon, MoeTar) on keyboards, Steve Lew (New Zombies, Eskimo, Ebola Soup) on bass, David Shamrock (Sleepytime Gorilla Museum, Free Salamander Exhibit, Slombis) on drums, Drew Wheeler (Free Salamander Exhibit, Young Has Beens) on guitar, and Jackie Wheeler on vocals and percussion. Points of reference may include: Devo, Thinking Plague, Danny Elfman, Rush."

The more observant of you may have seen a couple of musical genres listed which surely could only mean one thing, and you would be right, as here is a pronk band which Tim Smith would surely be proud of. I cannot believe I don't see a mention of Cardiacs in their influences (is it really more than a quarter of a century since "Sing To God"?) as here is a band who have taken pronk and run with it to make something which is RIO, Avant, yet somehow commercial at the same time. Jackie may not have a great deal of experience in bands but she is happy with everything the band is throwing at her, whether it is the Devo-style punk of "Infinite Loop" or the more comical "Fishies". This is a load of fun which could have come from the stable of either Cardiacs or Poisoned Electrick head and is a blast of punk prog fun which is so very different indeed to what is in the current scene where prog often seems to be quite involved at gazing at one's navel.

What we have here is a band producing music which was underground thirty years, and now is even more so as they are so very different indeed, yet their jagged angular melodies and guitar riffs are literally music to my ears.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Dalla Citta al Cielo by FOSCHIA album cover Studio Album, 2019
3.88 | 6 ratings

BUY
Dalla Citta al Cielo
Foschia Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by Finnforest
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars From the City to the Sky

Foschia (Mist) is the perfect name for this young band from the Bologna area of Northern Italy. It describes their conflicted---sometimes mysterious, sometimes hopeful---sound pretty well. All band members were born around 2000, making them about 19 years old when they released this debut, Dalla Citta al Cielo (From City to Sky). I found that remarkable because, while there is a youthful perspective in the passion and sense of wonder, there is also a real maturity and patience in the pacing. This is an album for prog rock fans who appreciate the pacing of "Echoes" more than, say, "Blackest Eyes." While there are no 20-minute tracks herein, the first three songs do sort of melt together into one long piece in my own head.

In fact, as tiring as Pink Floyd comparisons can be, I do feel these guys bring a bit of '69 to '71-era Floyd to mind, as well as a bit of "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" to mention a later song. In many of the songs, there are sections of slow development built around distant-sounding guitar leads---lone notes, soft bends, and space between each---with the same being true of the keyboards and piano that build around thoughtful, sometimes brooding chords. This approach brings an unhurried, contemplative approach that used to be more valued in progressive rock circles. The emotional release and payoffs will come, but they are in no hurry to give you a quick sugar high to sing along with. That space between the somber moods and the hopeful ones play out over the course of the album. The psych and sometimes bluesy feel of the electric guitars overshadow a "typical RPI" vibe generally, but the heartfelt Italian vocals help retain the experience. This debut reminded me most specifically of a 2011 album called Hanblecheya by Labirinto di Specchi, which was roundly enjoyed my many PA regulars at the time. I would say that Dalla Citta al Cielo is similar though less experimental, but perhaps even a better balance.

Love the trippy opening to "Il Viaggio" (The Journey). The wind sound effect is perfect behind the clean guitar, and it acts as a de facto intro to the 10-minute "Entrance." More environmental sound (rain, birds) augment the dreamy guitar opening. Drums enter and eventually a long synth section and electric lead. A beautiful piano solo closes what is perhaps the most Floyd-inspired track. "Il Delirio" (Delirium) continues the hazy guitar and piano meditation style, and it became my favorite track. The haunting romanticism of "Vite appese ad un filo" (Lives Hanging by a Thread) changes gears a bit, modern RPI and yet somehow it could've been written by Jackson Browne or Conor Oberst. Go figure. "Dio Della Morale" has a bit of a Doors or perhaps Traffic vibe. I heard a Mazzy Star vibe in a few corners of the room. I love that there is so much space in these songs; this is Exhibit A that great music need not be overly complex, overly dense, or overly loud. The pure emotion of a standalone voice, guitar note, or soft piano chord are given the space to be nakedly heard, which is powerful. I think that philosophy is now so rare that it truly stands out when a band does it, and it's part of what makes this album so great.

A few minor quibbles: the distorted rhythm guitar tone lacks presence, lacks oomph. It's just a bit thin, and it's more noticeable with the rhythm guitars than the leads. Everything else sounds great, including the drums, which I almost always have issues with when listening to modern bands. Also, I'd say that the album could have ended with "Il paroliere" and been stronger for it. The tracks that follow, a bit more pop and ballad, are fine songs indeed, but they feel unnecessary as they deviate from the sound style of the rest. Being a fan of shorter "vinyl length" albums, I appreciate a tight tracklist. That said, this is without question a compelling and appealing debut, simply luxurious listening. I loved it. I do hope there will be another album someday. The cover artwork could not be more appropriate. It perfectly captures the mood and personality of the music you will hear.

Miss this album and you are missing out.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Long Lost Relatives by SYRINX album cover Studio Album, 1971
4.00 | 38 ratings

BUY
Long Lost Relatives
Syrinx Progressive Electronic

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

3 stars This is the second and final album by this Canadian trio based in Toronto. And what an unusual setup of electric sax, keyboards and hand percussion. The self-titled debut was released in 1970 and was dominated by synths. The electric sax and hand percussion certainly weren't given equal billing by a long shot. They were more like guests on that one. No dynamics either, and as we know the result is no nose bone. A 2 star record in my world.

This followup from 1971 sounds more like I thought that trio would sound like. Everyone is getting their moment in the sun, very much an equal billing thing happening. We have nose bone as well. Now I must admit that I really don't like the tone of the electric sax. So it becomes be careful what you wish for at this point. We get eight tracks over almost 38 minutes. They brought in an orchestral string section which is heard briefly on "Syren" but in a much greater way on "December Angel". Strings later on "Ibistix" as well, and it's the second longest song at 8 minutes.

The opener and closer feature a memorable melody, but that's it. We do get some experimental sections that I like. And I like that eerie start to the longest tune "December Angel" which is 9 minutes long. The 3 1/2 minute closer called "Aurora Spinray" might be my favourite. It's just nice to have some warmth in the form of those organ sounds. And there's some vocals very late. I should mention the short "Tillicum" which was recorded for CTV and the TV show "Here Come The Seventies". It does sound slightly familiar as I no doubt as a kid heard this opening theme for that show. We were only able to get two TV channels back then, so the odds are pretty good I heard it and saw that show.

So a much better album than their debut, but this just fails to do much for me at all. This just isn't a band that I was able to get into unfortunately. Maybe I still have a bad taste in my mouth from my recent time sent with their debut. I like that other trio from Toronto though that would arrive a few years after this release.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 La Brea by HESSE KASSEL album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.21 | 25 ratings

BUY
La Brea
Hesse Kassel Post Rock/Math rock

Review by Stoneburner

5 stars Hard to Love

Hesse Kassel is another Chilean band that released its debut in 2025, alongside Chercan. They bring a splash of color to the often repetitive sounds of some progressive bands, offering freshness and a high level of musicianship. Hesse Kassel is a hard-to-classify group and a source of pride for Diego Portales University. Formed in Santiago in late 2022, the band consists of six members: Renatto Olivares (guitar, saxophone, vocals), Luca Cosignani (guitar, vocals), Mauricio Rosas (guitar), Matthew Hopper (bass), Eduardo Padilla (drums), and Joaqu'n Gonz'lez (keyboards, backing vocals).

A big part of what makes this band special is Renatto Olivares. His vocals are stunning'emotional, raw, and dynamic'often shifting between tenderness and intensity with natural ease. His guitar work is just as vital, cutting through or weaving into the mix exactly when needed. And when the saxophone appears, it's not just a novelty'it's perfectly placed and tastefully arranged, adding texture and depth without ever feeling forced. His versatility gives the band much of its emotional and sonic range, and his presence is felt on nearly every track.

Their debut album, La Brea, has received critical acclaim for its ambitious and emotionally charged compositions. It features eight expansive tracks'including 'Postparto,' 'Anova,' and 'Yo La Tengo'' marked by dynamic structures that move from discordant tension to euphoric release. The lyrics use a present, direct tone and explore sensitive themes like sexuality, adolescence, love, poverty, and identity. The production isn't perfect, but it fits the music well and contributes to the album's overall feel. The cover art is intriguing, beautiful, and mysterious'much like the music itself.

I never expected a clash of two Chilean bands at such a high level, much less that I'd be writing about them. Chile is a complicated country when it comes to music. It's not hard to record an album here'but it's hard to get noticed, especially if you're not making urban music, trap, cumbia, or reggaet'n. That's why I think what these guys are doing is truly commendable and deserves more exposure and recognition.

La Brea is a weird album, in the best sense of the word. It never lets you get fully comfortable, even in its most comforting moments. And that's a strength. It achieves something rare: it moves from lament to rage to peace, evoking a wide range of sensations through intricate musical work. It reminds me of many things, but I don't feel the need to classify or categorize it. If I had to name a reference, I'd point to 'Viva Chile! (1986), the debut masterpiece by Chilean legends Electrodom'sticos'just to give you a rough idea. At times, the band also approaches the monumental scale of Swans' The Seer (2012). That comparison isn't made lightly'it's just to help you imagine the intensity and ambition at play.

The album opens with 'Postparto,' a tense, mantra-like piece that sets the emotional tone. 'Anova' follows with ambient textures and sharp social commentary. 'Americana' stands out for its improvisation and shifting intensity. 'En Tiempo Muerto' leans toward jazz, with brilliant guitar work. 'Moussa' showcases the band's full power, moving between chaos and calm. 'Vida en Terranova' is cryptic and emotional, ending with an open wound. 'A. Latur' blends jazz fusion and folk, while 'Yo La Tengo' closes the album with raw emotional weight'it's the loosest track structurally, but also one of the most powerful.

This is an amazing record. Not perfect, but great. Possibly one of the best albums released this year. It's not for everyone'it's challenging, complex, and deeply emotional. But if you're into avant-garde, post-metal, dissonance, or just music that pushes boundaries, this is worth your time. I may be biased, but even so, La Brea stands out as an extremely interesting and important addition to any serious music collection.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Blackfield V by BLACKFIELD album cover Studio Album, 2017
3.79 | 168 ratings

BUY
Blackfield V
Blackfield Prog Related

Review by maxsmusic

5 stars For me this is the best Blackfield album. The first two set the bar but this one went far above it and has more emotion and great ideas. This whole album needs to be listened to as a complete concept and it is very beautiful in its execution. The essence of the ideas is everything is based on water and we are just prisoners of a world that we swim in. The air is water, the earth is water and water is water. Water is the base and we are just people who try to live and start families and become useful in the world. However, the world is not a very forgiving place and we may find happiness but more likely we will suffer. Blackfield may now be over but they put out some really great music. Aviv is a great songwriter and his collaboration with Mr. Wilson really gave the two of them a marvelous symphony of beauty. This album is 4.5 stars.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Weatherman Is Wrong by GADADU album cover Studio Album, 2022
5.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
The Weatherman Is Wrong
Gadadu Crossover Prog

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

— First review of this album —
5 stars Sophisticated, smart neo-soul jazz-pop from NYC. Like hearing KOOP 20 years after the fact: Koop 2.022! (I love the band's own descriptor of "kaleidoscopic sense of time and texture"!) A big shout out to Progzilla's Epileptic Gibbon for making me aware of these amazing artists and their stunningly beautiful album!

1. "Cicadas" (5:08) strings--multiple tracks filtered through delay and echo and then woven together. So cool! (And so Jean-Luc Ponty like!) Synth pop keys and drums join in as do dreamy horns, vocalize and bass. When Hannah Selin begins to sing with verbal articulation at 2:10 her breathy ingenue voice comes in with such a sexy innocence. Totally reminiscent of 2001 KOOP with the vocal talents of the great contributions of chanteuses Cecilia Stalin Yakumi Nagano. What a refreshing, incredible start! (9/10)

2. "Bear" (1:53) opening as a very folkie tune reminding me of both HANDS OF THE HERON and A FORMAL HORSE, the music soon expands to become a more happy-go-lucky pop song with some jazzy nuances. (5/5)

3. "Dreamhouse" (5:46) a song whose complex rhythms only gain in sophistication and complexity as the song goes. Absolutely brilliant! What a great vocal performance. My favorite song on an album of great songs. (10/10)

4. "At Play" (4:05) representing more of the pure torch singing jazz vocalist, beautiful music/accompaniment certainly helps. The creative Burt Bacharach-like contributions of the horn section really change things; this is not the song I was expecting to unfold from those opening bars. I am very much reminded of the compositional skills and creativity of Philadelphia band iNFiNiEN as I listen to this. (9.5/10)

5. "Makeup" (4:16) a very pleasant jazz torch song. Hannah's breathy voice is so perfect set against the piano-based spacious jazz instrumental accompaniment. (8.875/10)

6. "Ocean's Children" (4:41) this one reminds me of JULIA HOLTER. Such creative genius coming from this vocalist! Another song that benefits so much from the horns, solid rhythm section and wobbly Herbie Hancock-like Fender Rhodes. (9.25/10)

7. "Tides" (4:42) the plodding rhythm line is a bit confusing, but then Hannah's DIANA KRALL-like vocal performance starts and I'm in a totally different universe. (What rhythm line?) I love the way the band/horns swell with the end of Hannah's vocal lines! Absolutely brilliant! Then there's a dramatic switch to a new jazzier blues motif at the three- minute mark, but things seem to settle back a bit for the final minute. (9.25/10)

8. "Prove to You" (4:44) despite Hannah's rock-like core vocal performance, I have to admit that the contribution of the Xanthoria (string) Quartet here is incredible--especially around that gorgeous chorus. (9.25/10)

9. "City Lights" (3:53) on this song Hannah's vocal performance is "hidden" somewhat within/behind the horns and piano. A pretty song, it doesn't quite live up to the amazing effectiveness of the others. (8.75/10)

Lead vocalist Hannah Selin's voice (and the effects the band & engineers have chosen to soak it with) reminds of the singers the Swedish duo calling themselves KOOP used on their 2003 album Waltz for Koop--though more Yakumi Nagano than Cecilia Stalin, though, in actual fact, more like a blend of the two. Gadadu's music is similar, as well, but much more sophisticated.

For as much as this band has excelled at eclectically gathering and blending from pop, jazz, folk, fusion, and avant garde musical traditions, I feel as this is the first album on which the band has most adventurously and confidently expressed their own musical style(s)--as if they have finally begun to express musics of the future more than syntheses of the past.

A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of jazz-rock fusion and definitely a wonderful addition to any prog lover's music collection.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Kinship by IOTUNN album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.17 | 17 ratings

BUY
Kinship
Iotunn Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars "Kinship" is the second full-length studio album by Danish metal act Iotunn. The album was released through Metal Blade Records in October 2024. It´s the successor to "Access All Worlds" from 2021. There have been no lineup changes since the predecessor. Iotunn formed in Copenhagen in 2015 and released the promising "The Wizard Falls" EP in 2016 and with the release of "Access All Worlds" they started making headlines.

Stylistically the material on "Kinship" is a natural successor to the material featured on "Access All Worlds". Progressive/power metal combined with both death, black, folk, and even doom metal elements, and all delivered in an epic and atmospheric package (it´s one of the better combinations of melodic tinged metal and extreme metal I´ve heard in a while). Lead vocalist Jķn Aldará (Barren Earth, Hamferđ) performs both epic clean semi-operatic vocals (both low end and high end cleans), death metal growling, and black metal snarling, and as a result the vocal part of the album is quite varied. The material on the 8 tracks, 68:23 minutes long album is both eclectic in style, epic in sound, but also powerful, heavy, and massive. It´s relatively polished, but still with enough rawness to pack a punch when that is needed. Other than the paatos filled and skilled vocal performance, one of the other great assets of "Kinship" is the harmony- and lead guitar work of the two Gräs brothers, Jens and Jesper. The album is loaded with soaring epic leads that´ll have you picture great mountains and beautiful valleys, fantasy castles and dark wizards. The scope of the music is almost cinematic in nature.

"Kinship" features a high quality production job courtesy of prolific Danish producer Jacob Hansen. This is a perfect sound production for this type of music. As mentioned above the sound is relatively polished and you can hear all details clearly in the mix, but there is still bite and rawness enough for this never to become a sterile listening experience. Combined with the intriguing, sophisticated, and powerful songwriting, and the high level musical performances, this results in a high quality sophomore studio album from Iotunn. A 4 - 4.5 star (85%) rating is deserved.

(Originally posted on Metal Music Archives).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Deep Purple in Rock by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1970
4.36 | 1390 ratings

BUY
Deep Purple in Rock
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by Lobster77

5 stars This may be Deep Purple's greatest album, and if not it still certainly has their masterpiece on it: the brilliant epic Child in Time, a ten-minute musical journey featuring my favorite guitar solo of all time. Blackmore plays with such emotion on this track, not to mention speed and technicality, it just amazes me. Gillan's vocals are so awe-inspiring it is hard to believe. It is not natural how well he sings here. The dueling guitar/organ solo in Speed King is quite fine too. My second favorite track, however, would have to be Hard Lovin' Man, which also includes a brilliant solo by Blackmore.

Rightfully proclaimed one of the first true heavy metal albums, In Rock is one heavy mother. Blackmore moves to the front of the mix, while Lord creeps further below (but still with a strong presence). Let us not forget Gillan's first (and one of his best) appearances. Another must get.

All in all, one of the greatest hard rock albums of all times. It is a landmark of rock 'n roll music. 5.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Emperor Tomato Ketchup by STEREOLAB album cover Studio Album, 1996
4.04 | 10 ratings

BUY
Emperor Tomato Ketchup
Stereolab Crossover Prog

Review by Lobster77

4 stars I saw two other PA users review Stereolab albums so I decided to review one of my favorites by this art pop six-piece.

This is where all those consolidated sounds and styles in Stereolab's earlier albums suddenly splintered, separated and were given their own space (they hinted at it in Mars Audiac Quintet, but here it sounds charged). They still approach each song with the heavy hand of a rock sensibility (as opposed to their later smoother electro-jazzy- groovy-esoteric stuff), and cram it with experimental and inventive arrangements. A grab bag of unpolished gems. Equal parts orchestral pop, proto-punk, moog rock and funk, without actually adhering to any prefab formula. Yet to a lot of people in a lot of ways, it's the only Stereolab LP where you don't have to develop a whole new philosophy about the structure of popular music in order to appreciate it. But your parameters are challenged and broadened anyway. Take "Spark Plug", a funky number with meat, its groove offset by the robotic chant "auto production / auto organization". Or the buzzing Suicide pulse of "OLV 26", given a melodic warmth. Or the odd rhythm coupled with a Steve Reich-like vibraphone trance in "Tomorrow is Already Here". Like I said, it's heavy-handed. This ain't EZ listening. Even forays into schmaltz like "Monstre Sucre" have a weighted off-kilter quality. While tunes like "Metronomic Underground" and "Emperor Tomato Ketchup" are so catchy, so instantaneously addictive, you'd never guess they were built around riffs lifted from Yoko Ono songs. Everyone should own this, even to see just how influential they were. Subversive in its intelligent sense of fun.

4.5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Circa: 2007 by CIRCA: album cover Studio Album, 2007
3.14 | 56 ratings

BUY
Circa: 2007
Circa: Crossover Prog

Review by Lobster77

3 stars Most of this CD is great, reminds me very much of the better works the band Yes put out in the 90's which isn`t surprising since three (that I know of) members have worked with Yes in the past.

The big concern for me wasn't about what the music was going to sound like as I expected it to be great, more so I was concerned what the vocals will sound like would they attempt to try and clone the Jon Andersons style (I hoped not) They only sound like Anderson a bit in the harmony vocals, but the lead voice is more like a mixture of Rabin and Anderson in its application with a slight Peter Gabriel sound to his voice (hard to explain what I mean you need to hear it)

There's the odd "throw away" song that to me wasn`t adding to the rest of the collection of well written pieces "INFORMATION OVERLOAD" went over my head I`m afraid .. but the rest of the CD is well played well executed prog rock which sounds very experienced yet fresh and not too overly ambitious. I especially liked "Look inside" and 'Brotherhood of Man".

This is not the Next "Close To The Edge" but it certainly is a pleasant surprise 4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Deceptive Bends by 10CC album cover Studio Album, 1977
3.29 | 133 ratings

BUY
Deceptive Bends
10cc Prog Related

Review by Lobster77

5 stars Godley and Creme left 10cc at the beginning of the sessions and Eric Stewart, Greg Gouldman and Paul Burgess would give us Deceptive Bends. Obviously, they gave the world a great gift by doing so. I am quite sure that the annoying musical trickery that ruined Sheet Music (excluding "The Wall Street Shuffle") and most of The Original Soundtrack (definitely excluding "I'm Not in Love") was a Godley & Creme thing. Instead, Graham Gouldman and Eric Stewart were excellent songwriters who, at this point, needed to lose the shadow of the trickery to stick with the real thing. The result, Deceptive Bends, features the good sides and has lost the bad sides of the 'old' 10cc. This brings it closer to Supertramp, Wings, or ELO with a witty sense of humour.

The opening track "Good Morning Judge" is not very special, but the following three ? "The Things We Do for Love" (the wonderful hit single, a classic), "Marriage Bureau Rendezvous" and "People in Love" ? are all pure gold. "Modern Man Blues" is very different, more rocking, less harmonious, but its rhythmic changes stay within the limits of good taste. The lyrics of "Honeymoon With B Troop" turn annoying now and then but the music is very good. It is followed by a hilarious piece called "I Bought a Flat Guitar Tutor", a more ordinary (but still good) number titled "You've Got a Cold", and finally the magnum opus of the album, "Feel the Benefit" which sure is overlengthy, but sounds good enough to carry the listener through all the way.

Despite not having heard each of those so far, I am very sure that Deceptive Bends is one of he best 10cc albums in my opinion. The quality of the music on this album is very high. Recommended for everyone who likes Breakfast in America, A New World Record, or Band on the Run. It also helps if you like "I'm Not in Love." Stay away if you are looking for a '70s British Mothers of Invention album. At this point that band no longer existed. If you play this you will feel the benefits. 5.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The LAB Experience by LAB EXPERIENCE, THE album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.88 | 22 ratings

BUY
The LAB Experience
The LAB Experience Symphonic Prog

Review by TenYearsAfter

4 stars IN BRAZIL THEY CAN PLAY FOOTBALL, AND THEY CAN MAKE MUSIC, WOW!

Luiz Alvim is a Brazilian keyboardist and composer with a background in classical piano. He has performed live and recorded with a diverse range of artists. Progressive rock is often defined by intricate compositions, virtuosic performances, and a willingness to push boundaries. The LAB Experience, led by Luiz Alvim, takes this philosophy to a new level by completely omitting guitars, one of the genre's most fundamental instruments. The result is an album that challenges conventions while maintaining the depth and complexity that fans of progressive music crave. The album consists of a mix of original compositions and reinterpretations of previous works, enriched by contributions from various guest musicians.

Well, as a huge vintage keyboards aficionado it took very little time to get excited about this instrumental first album by The LAB Experience (only keyboards, bass and drums), what a great sound, and what a skilled musicians.

The first 3 tracks A Long Time Ago, m.a.r.i.k. and Parallel Dimensions deliver bombastic mid-tempo beats featuring dazzling synthesizer runs and swirling Hammond organ, backed by a powerful and dynamic rhythm-section, the interplay is awesome, often Japanese Gerard (the era as a trio) comes to my mind.

The fourth composition The Mind starts with a fat synthesizer sound, then the music delivers more variety, with several breaks, including Mellotron violins, blended with a fat bass sound and propulsive drums, and a short but swinging bass solo.

Next Future Dreaminess, first an ominous spacey climate, like horror soundtrack, then accellaration with Hammond, followed by soaring strings and slow rhythm, spacey synthesizer flights. Halfway a mid-tempo beat and lots of keyboard pyrotechnics, fuelled by a powerful bass. In the second part a break with Mellotron violins and a growling bass and propulsive drums, how exciting.

Then the epic composition Astral Zenith. It opens with a majestic Hammond organ and tremolo Leslie sound and concludes with tender piano runs, in between lots of shifting moods (from dreamy to bombastic) featuring Vintage Keyboard Heaven: Mellotron violins eruptions and soaring Mellotron flutes, dazzling pitchbend driven Minimoog synthesizer flights and spectacular Hammond organ soli, topped with amazing work on bass and drums, wow!

And finally the short The End, a beautiful piece built around tender Grand piano, tastefully blended with soaring Mellotron violins, dreamy bass work, and a churchy Hammond sound.

What a stunning debut album, highly recommended to all keyboard aficionados!

For me this kind of new bands is the reason that I stil write about prog since 1992, obrigado Luiz!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Solstice by TOWNER,RALPH album cover Studio Album, 1975
4.42 | 52 ratings

BUY
Solstice
Ralph Towner Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Recorded in December of 1974 in Oslo's Arne Bendiksen Studio with Jan Erik Kongshaug sitting behind the engineering console, it was released during the following year by ECM--perhaps as late as September. Many consider this album as a defining moment--even one the crowning achievements--of Manfred Eicher's ECM label.

A1. "Oceanus" (10:58) a very cool, very fresh sound with Jon Christensen and Ralph Towner keeping busy on their respective instruments while Eberhard Weber almost drones away on his bowed electric bass (or cello) and Jan Garbarek fills the front with periodic exhalations from his sonorous tenor sax. The quartet amps up the intensity and volume a bit in the fifth minute before Ralph enters into a jazzy 12-string solo. I'm hard pressed to tell you whether or not the syncopated rhythm 12-string work is the same track with Ralph playing it all at once or whether there is a completely separate track dedicated explicitly to each (lead and rhythm). Jon Christensen's infinitely-nuanced cymbal and snare work is so patiently deployed, responding to Ralph's guitar work that it almost feels as if the two were joined at the brain. And Jan and Eberhard's contributions are so respectful, so reactive and ego-less. (I think that would be the quality I can claim to like best with regards to Jan's saxophone playing: his patient response to both external and internal "calls to action.") Brilliant and enjoyable song despite lacking much in the way of melody. (Weird to think that Eberhard's drone-like bass notes may have been the most melodic in the song--at least in terms of a Western sensibility of what is "melodic.") (18/20)

A2. "Visitation" (2:32) an exercise in Nature and primordial recreation. (4.333/5) A3. "Drifting Petals" (6:56) Ralph on solo piano playing a playful, gentle, introspective pastoral tune is joined in the second minute by Jan's flute. In the third minute, drums, reverberated fretless electrified bass, and Ralph's 12-string guitar step forward to creepy-crawl an exercise in hypervigilance--one that each of these ECM masters are completely up to task. The whole-band dynamic interplay in the fifth minute--both loud and soft--provides a real emotional peak. And the return to gentle piano arpeggi and guitar flute for the final minute is a display of sheer perfection in symmetry. (13.75/15)

B1. "Nimbus" (6:25) here is where I see fodder and inspiration for Pat Metheny's own solo acoustic guitar work. My favorite song on the album: it's absolutely gorgeous music. After 2:30 of exquisite solo acoustic guitar work the band is slowly coaxed into joining Ralph: first Jan's flute, then a slow entry of Jon' beautifully nuanced drumming, along with more tracks of Ralph's guitars and two tracks of Eberhard: one on bowed cello and one on upright double bass. Once full speed has been reached Ralph's awesome 12-string play is met face-to-face with Eberhard's dynamic double bass play and the entry of Jan's perfectly-balancing tenor sax. I don't always like Jan's work (or that of any saxophonist) but this is amazing--and powerful! Great, rousing band interplay over the course of those final couple minutes. Wonderful music even acoustic musicians can make thanks to the magic of multi-tracking! (10/10)

B2. "Winter Solstice" (3:58) Ralph playing near-Spanish style classical guitar with Jan meeting and matching him all along the way with his soprano sax. Man! These two are so in sync--so attuned! And both are definitely putting their full virtuosity on full display. Though I'm not such a fan of the melodies chosen/played by the two, I am so incredibly impressed by their astonishing timing in conveying them that I can't help but be won over. Standing ovations for this one! (9.75/10)

B3. "Piscean Dance" (3:33) funk in acoustic jazz?!? Jon Christensen and Ralph are definitely trying their best to demonstrate its possibility! Definitely a song that both impresses and endears both artists to me even more. (9.3333/10)

B4. "Red And Black" (1:12) electric guitar, volume-controlled whale sounds from Eberhard's electrified bass, and Ralph's acoustic guitar explorations--all coming together as if purely intended as an exploration of a certain sound possibility. (4.375/5)

B5. "Sand" (4:07) droning (and, probably, heavily-effected) sustained bowed cello notes joined by double bass notes with soprano sax splatterings and, eventually, Jon's funky drum play and effected 12-string guitar strums and gentle pickings all come together to create a sound palette that sounds remarkably similar to that which Corrado Rustici, Elio D'Anna, Percy Jones, Renato Rosset, and Narada Michael Walden will be creating for their 1976 NOVA album, Vimana. (9.33333/10)

Total Time: 40:57

I am emotionally and mentally blown away by the music Ralph and his virtuosic friends (and Manfred Eicher's production crew at ECM) have created for this album!

A/five stars; a masterpiece of some of the finest, most creative guitar-centered acoustic jazz you are likely to ever hear.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Guardians by CYAN album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.87 | 23 ratings

BUY
The Guardians
Cyan Neo-Prog

Review by sussexbowler

3 stars Much of what I think here is similar to what I said in my 'Pictures from the other side' review. No matter how much I listen to the main track I fail to find it 'Proggy' enough. Yes, there are the subtleties, but given 24 minutes one expects more of an memorable journey with a grand finale. I mean, it's all very listenable, but it doesn't really grab you. 'All around the World' seems to end up being blues number, which just leaves me cold. 'Cyan' is an instrumental which developes into a Steve & John Hackett type of song, which is good. Ultimately, despite the musicianship and production being superb, they can't hide what is ultimately a weak primary track.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Pictures from the Other Side by CYAN album cover Studio Album, 2023
3.89 | 20 ratings

BUY
Pictures from the Other Side
Cyan Neo-Prog

Review by sussexbowler

3 stars It's difficult to know what to say really. The overriding thing for me is that much of it isn't strictly Prog, but then what is Prog? If the sound is too familiar then we'll criticise it for not being new, but the vehicle here seems to provide the basis for Love songs/Ballards, which surely isn't Prog. Whatever, if you listen to the album a lot then you'll find plenty of Prog subtleties to enjoy, as both the production and the musicianship are first class. The real winner here, and perhaps the most important musical instrument being used here is Peter Jones's voice, which never fails given the tasks thrown at it. These are heightened with the accompaniment of the female voice of Anghared Brinn, and when the pair of them sing together it's absolutely faultless. Overall, it's a pleasant enough listen, but probably not what you are expecting. Sadly, I feel that I can only award it 3 stars because I don't feel that there's enough of what I define as 'Prog' music to justify giving it more.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Stormbringer by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1974
3.12 | 698 ratings

BUY
Stormbringer
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by Hector Enrique
Prog Reviewer

3 stars With the auspicious and revitalizing "Burn", it seemed that the winds were blowing again in Deep Purple's favor but, as in other occasions in the band's history, particular situations ended up influencing the final result of the following album, "Stormbringer" (1974), the ninth of their discography. The personal problems of Ritchie Blackmore immersed in a hard divorce process derived in his little implication in the creative process of the album, assumed mainly by David Coverdale and Glenn Hughes, inclined towards more Funky and soulful sonorities in demedro of the hardrock rispidness.

Although, as in "Burn", the auspicious beginning with Blackmore's guitar deployment in the homonymous and robust "Stormbringer" (the best song of the album), the proposal is nevertheless heading towards more accessible harmonies, as with the cloying "Love Don't Mean A Thing", the innocuous "Hold On", or the inconsequential "You Can't Do It Right", accompanied by the lightened boogie rock of the agitated "Lady Double Dealer" and "High Ball Shooter", the latter featuring one of the sporadic appearances of Jon Lord's hammond on the album.

And both the peaceful semi-ballad "Holy Man" with Hughes' spirited vocals, the misty half-time of "The Gypsy", and the melancholic "Soldier of Fortune" with Blackmore's delicate acoustic arpeggios and the best Coverdale on vocals, balance a little more a work that Blackmore belittled with insulting terms.

A few months after the recording of "Stormbringer", whose imposing cover is a colored adaptation of a photograph of a tornado in Minnesota (USA) in July 1927 complemented by the winged horse 'Pegasus' from Greek mythology, the irascible man in black would leave Deep Purple for the first time to form Rainbow.

2.5/3 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Live Nassau Coliseum '76 by BOWIE, DAVID album cover Live, 2017
4.49 | 15 ratings

BUY
Live Nassau Coliseum '76
David Bowie Prog Related

Review by fuxi
Prog Reviewer

4 stars What a fun album! The most exciting DB live collection you can find, in my opinion. The man himself is in great voice & in an even better mood, and his band simply smoke. Thanks to master drummer Dennis Davis (who does wonders throughout) the climactic third part of 'Station to Station' sounds incredibly funky, and let's not forget lead guitarist Stacey Heydon, who joined Bowie just for this tour and was never heard of thereafter. Who needs Earl Slick when you can have Heydon? In the hands of this particular band, 'Stay' sounds about three times as exciting as the original studio version, and Bowie's performance of 'Word on a Wing' (which I always skip when listening to STATION TO STATION) finally acquires the depth it so sorely needed. It's a pity the 1976 live band never attempted 'Wild is the Wind'; I would have loved to hear Carlos Alomar's elegant guitar stylistics, which also dominated the delightful 'Golden Years' - another '75/'76 tune that's missing here... Alomar seems to be taking a back seat; during the set's highlights (such as 'Queen Bitch', 'Panic in Detroit' and 'Diamond Dogs') it's Stacey Heydon's heavily distorted guitar that stands out. Tony Kaye gets to play the piano part that was devised for 'Life on Mars?' by his eventual successor in Yes - wonder how he felt about that? As you can imagine, he leaves out most of Rick Wakeman's rococo flourishes, and generally speaking his keyboard accompaniments are subtle but highly effective.

Are there any problems with this collection? Well, I guess you could claim that 'TVC15' goes on for a little too long (though it features a splendid little bass solo by George Murray) and the same probably goes for 'The Jean Genie', the final number... (And if I have to be perfectly honest, I should add I could never stand 'Rebel Rebel'.) But let's be grateful for what we've got! Was Bowie still in the throes of addiction when this was recorded? If so, you just can't tell; he sounds like a man who's fully in his element.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Dots and Loops by STEREOLAB album cover Studio Album, 1997
4.13 | 10 ratings

BUY
Dots and Loops
Stereolab Crossover Prog

Review by Dapper~Blueberries
Prog Reviewer

3 stars (Originally written in 2022)

It seems like I am starting to make a trend of sorts where I review albums with a very similar sound, Yoshimi, Long Season, and now Dots and Loops. A trifecta of sorts of more dreamy psych rock with mixes of experimentation it's sort of funny to review three albums from three of the biggest continents, America, Europe, and Asia. Kinda unique how things manage to work out like that. Anyways, I was recommended to check this album out, so thanks.

So, about Stereolab. They are an English French band formed in the 90s with Tim Gane (Guitar, keyboards), and Lætitia Sadier (lead vocals, keyboard, guitar, percussion), both of whom were involved in the 80s pop group, McCarthy. Members throughout the band's history would come and go, some of which were from bands before, sort of and sort of not making Stereolab a supergroup. The band is considered to be one of the early post-rock bands, mostly from the first wave of post-rock, before the likes of Godspeed You! Black Emperor and modern-day Swans took the world by storm. They, Slint, Talk Talk, and Cul De Sac are considered to be forefathers in post-rock in a way, and while I could argue bands like Faust or Neu (or any krautrock group in general if you really think about it), generally speaking, the late 80s through early 90s is when post-rock was born, and bands like Stereolab are rather popular in small internet circles for this reason alone. However, do I like this record? Yeah, but not entirely.

The album begins with Brakhage, and this is when we have to get familiar with this sound right from the get-go, because the entire album is very closely similar to this one song. It is very easy to listen to, and when I say that I do not mean it's bad, I just say that in general, it is probably one of the most pop-sounding post songs to be conceived. The guitars are lush, the vocals are smooth, and the general vibe of this song is very soft and fuzzy. You can feel that this song is meant to be comfortable in a good way. It is relaxing, never too complex, and very easy to settle into. Not a bad start to the album, though I wish they did experiment a bit more.

Miss Modular, the next track on the album, is sort of the same. It is very easy to listen to and get a hang of, and while I like the song, this shows one of the faults this album has. Every song here doesn't change all that much, they do add new elements to slightly spice things up, but they never experiment with their sound. Each song feels the same, with no new emotions or thoughts and feelings, almost cookie-cutter-like. It feels weird to never see this, especially for an album that is very artsy and is considered one of the early examples of a genre that loves to bend and experiment with each passing song. I cannot say I entirely dislike it. I feel like they knew what they wanted to achieve, and with that, they have achieved their main goal of creating a very easy listening experience, so I do applaud them for that, however, their main goal should have a little more weight. It frustrates me to hear talent not being utilized to create something that could bend and shape rock or pop music, but instead never actually try to be unique or different.

This is an example of the 17-minute long song, Refractions in the Plastic Pulse. When I think of 17-minute songs I think of some big names that are very experimental, very groundbreaking, or very sonically enriched. Stuff like In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida by Iron Butterfly or Ocean Cloud by Marillion comes to mind in which both songs try new stuff throughout, experimenting with the band's sounds to create a new sonic experience like never before in music. That is why I generally call 15+ minute songs epics because they break the mold, they try new things that previous songs might've not had the chance to do before in the album. Here with this song though it all just continues what the album did before, the only difference is that it has elongated itself into the double digits. Due to this reason, I felt immensely disappointed with this one track. It feels almost cheap to not have a long song that has at least some kind of new sound or something along those notes. It is clear they still can create good music with songs before and after this, with Diagonals being my favorite example with it adding horns to the mix. If this track did stuff like that and tried new things more often then I would say it's a great track, but as it stands it doesn't stand well in the face of so many other long tracks.

The rest of the album is again still very solid. Lush and harmonic sounds galore here. However, I have to say I find it odd this album is so popular with its very apparent and needless flaws. Quite frankly, the reception garnered feels undeserved. I do not hate this album, but it doesn't do much for me to love it. I'd say skip this one since for the first wave of post-rock there are much better, much more ground molding and much more diverse albums out there than this one.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Instant 0 In The Universe by STEREOLAB album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2003
3.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Instant 0 In The Universe
Stereolab Crossover Prog

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

— First review of this album —
3 stars 3.5 stars. STEREOLAB have an interesting sound where we get this stew of percussions, drums, fake beats, electronic beats, bass, and intricate guitar. It's enough to make you dizzy, but then the female vocals come in which are warm and soothing. She will sing words, but she will also add a lot of wordless vocals as well. The music is uplifting, positive and catchy.

This Ep is a nice companion to their 2004 album "Margerine Eclipse", with them sounding very similar since they were from the same sessions. Underneath the information about who engineered it and mixed it etc. it says "Mary, thinking about you." Former band member Mary Hansen had only very recently passed. This Ep is over 20 minutes and five tracks. And my description in the opening of this review applies to these songs as well.

I do like "Microclimate" for the way sounds echo at the start. It's just a little different early on before the beats take over with vocals. A lot of electronics early on during "Mass Riff" but we have at least two themes being contrasted. A driving track that is the longest at 6 1/2 minutes. "Good Is Me" is an interesting mid-paced tune with contrasting themes. Bass, synths and guitar standout on this one.

This Ep along with a second Ep form the bonus disc for the recent re-issue of "Margeine Eclipse". And it's such a great package as it gives us everything associated with the "Margenine Eclipse" sessions.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Omni by KARFAGEN album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.24 | 98 ratings

BUY
Omni
Karfagen Symphonic Prog

Review by ValeriyK

5 stars Karfagen's "OMNI" is not just an album it's a journey. A radiant, multi-layered voyage through soundscapes that feel both timeless and refreshingly new. From the very first notes, it's clear that this is a labor of love and vision, meticulously crafted by Antony Kalugin and the brilliant musicians involved.

What strikes me most about OMNI is its balance it manages to be both complex and accessible, grand yet intimate. The compositions weave in and out of symphonic prog, jazz-fusion, folk, and ambient textures, all while maintaining that unmistakable Karfagen identity.

Melodies soar with emotion, rhythms evolve organically, and the instrumental interplay is just stunning. There's a story in every track sometimes meditative, sometimes playful, often uplifting. The transitions are seamless, and the dynamics flow like a well-told narrative. It's cinematic, but never overwhelming. It breathes.

The production is crystal clear, giving every instrument its space. It feels like you're inside the music, not just listening from the outside. That's a rare thing.

And while I'm grateful for the YouTube upload (thank you again, Antony!), this is one of those albums that deserves to be held in your hands. The artwork, the liner notes, the tangible presence of the CD or vinyl it completes the experience.

In short: OMNI is a triumph. A modern prog gem that pays homage to the classics while boldly forging its own path. I'm already on my third listen and discovering new layers each time.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Safe Journey by TIBBETTS, STEVE album cover Studio Album, 1983
3.56 | 11 ratings

BUY
Safe Journey
Steve Tibbetts Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by maxsmusic

4 stars The mood of this album is contemplative and relaxed. It is instrumental percussion, as the guitar is really percussive and fits nicely with all the beats from the drums. Now over 40 years old but it sounds very fresh as it doesn't really fit in any genre, outside of world fusion or whatever you call alternative music. This is not rock or jazz, it's a lot of acoustic guitar and effects on the electric guitar. The theme is a journey and the cover shows the entrance or the exit. Steve Tibbets is an experimental musician who takes the guitar to interesting places. With this release he has three great percussionists and a bass player making up atmospheric tracks that seem to flow together. A very strong effort and quite nice.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Omni by KARFAGEN album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.24 | 98 ratings

BUY
Omni
Karfagen Symphonic Prog

Review by alainPP

4 stars KARFAGEN was initially noted for his MINIMUM VITAL and TRANSATLANTIC sounds, which brought a playful folk touch to his work. GENESIS, Mike OLDFIELD, UK, CAMEL, YES, GLASS HAMMER, and THE FLOWER KINGS are among his musical references, not to mention PROKOFIEV, GRIEG, and KORSAKOV for classical music.

"OMNI Part 1" on the first side features "Omni Overture," a clean synth from the GENESIS era, with thumping drums; a thunderous, airy intro that adds energy; it's sure to get people talking with its telltale brass. "Storyteller (Part 1)" follows, with Richard from CARAVAN and CAMEL singing with his suave voice on a marshmallowy track, aka melting, velvety, "Canterburyen." Softness and rhythm for new prog rather than symphonic prog: the important thing is to be carried. Michel ST-PČRE (MYSTERY) and John HACKETT come to throw their notes to inflate the piece in modern mode. "Whispers from the Past" in folk variation with female voices and romantic choir; a flute, an air, a melody from medieval times. The interlude to settle down, in the vein of SUNCHILD. "The Spark" with Per MALMBERG (SALVA) as guest vocal, sound of ELO and again of GENESIS 3rd version. The brass amplifies the funky-groovy period of certain groups of the 80s, TOTO and the AOR which shines through, EARTH, WIND & FIRE on the other. The instrumental finale with Antony's keyboards shows his dexterity, his creation; FLOWER KINGS for the finale. "Masterplan" continues, keyboards in front; Soapy, cottony, apparently like Bodin, and Antony for me, singing too, in short, SUNCHILD with a rather common sound. The drift and the finale are worth much more, the nervous guitar setting this track alight before the flavor of the melting keyboard. "Mirror of Souls" concludes, a cinematic symphonic soundtrack with a grandiloquent baroque air; unrestrained prog with John's bucolic flute.

"OMNI Part 2" opens with "Unchained," marking the beginning of the second side, like in the days of CDs, LPs, and cassettes. Jean Pageau (Mystery) adds his voice, a moment of latency over a piano coulis; a slow drift and the melting solo arrives; it's very bucolic, very culinary, very neo-prog too. This solo is just perfect, rising in intensity and emotion; from reliable sources, it's definitely Max Velichko (Inside the Sound) who's having a blast on it. Jean takes control for a while but the solo explodes the song musically; melancholic outro piano and keyboard calmly bringing "The Cards We Play" with a new change, flute from John, singer Marco GLÜHMANN (SYLVAN) with his stamped prog voice, Richard for his bass and Michel coming to deposit their progressive doses. Antony amalgamates everything as a conductor to make this title the central spearhead of this side worthy of a baroque rock opera without naming it. Dark outro flute, guitar, keyboard and "You and I" appears, Bartosz KOSSOVICZ (COLLAGE) working his voice between that of Steven WILSON and FISH; an intimate, spleen, captivating new prog. The guitar solo returns to the emotions of English neo prog, more languid, sweeping away the question of having so many beautiful voices on this side; very warm. "Storyteller (Part 2)" ends the album with a chorus of velvety voices for the bucolic, rustic track; Richard radiates the most, as does Antony; the tune seems to have come straight from a Robert Wyatt album.

KARFAGEN releases OMNI, a musical journey that takes Antony's personal work far back with this blend of symphonic, aesthetic, and fantastical rock. Originally on profilprog (4.5).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Rogue by GLASS HAMMER album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.89 | 27 ratings

BUY
Rogue
Glass Hammer Symphonic Prog

Review by alainPP

4 stars GLASS HAMMER's 23rd album, loaded with melodies, from space rock from the 70s to today, a beautiful progressive spectrum. A return to the roots with the story of a man's final journey, a temporal parable.

"What If?" shakes my ears, a return to the GLASS HAMMER of the past, more melodic, less heavy, sung with the fruity sounds of Yes, acoustic guitar, and electronic keyboard worthy of 80s BOSTON. The vibes of Mike OLDFIELD are compelling for this bright, airy, symphonic track with a bucolic guitar solo. "The Road South" opens with a tune by BARCLAY JAMES HARVEST, RADIOHEAD, and a soaring atmosphere of ALAN PARSONS; gone is the prog-metal sound that boosted me, back to the keyboard-laden sounds of 70s-80s YES and ELP. "Tomorrow" is a text oozing with religious hope, a tune leaning towards pop love song with velvety synths and a pervasive bass. A hint of Jon Anderson on the holiday air of these bucolic, marshmallow bells. "Pretty Ghost" continues, a few notes from the cruise s'amuse to emphasize the cheerful tune. Olivia takes the stage accompanied by the Yessian bass, a languid 80s pop tune and her Genesis-esque keyboards like in the band's early days. Fresh without overthinking it, but so far from the sound of the last two albums. "Sunshine" continues with Olivia, YES exploding into reminiscence with the pad and plaintive lap-steel guitar. A languid vocal ballad for 80s regression with this thoughtful keyboard smelling good of THE CARS. A progressive finale on a marshmallow slope hurtling down the notes of a country meadow. "I Will Follow" is a classic organ intro. YES, yes again, although U2 fans will have been listening for a while. The punchy rhythm, velvety keyboards, and diverse hooks give this track a measured power. Layers of vocals, Oliver's vibrant melancholic guitar solo, and Steve's keyboards amplify the progressive side.

"The Wonder of it All" is an 80s-style intro, reminiscent of The Cars; I insist on the fresh use of the keyboard. The cinematic intro lets the velvety vocals unfold on the slopes of Alan Parson's, oozing melting marshmallow over a serious lyric. The keyboards bring the AOR-oriented, alternative, nostalgic break, harking back to the original Glass Hammer, sumptuous even if it lacks pep for me; the final keyboard is redundant and hypnotic. "One Last Sunrise" with the interlude, YES-style, coming from the Centaur star; electronic atmosphere, which is moreover, easy to access, bordering on new age. The unfolding of the air in fade on a vulgar drum machine embellished with bewitching keyboards, chiming with the dark outro. "Terminal Lucidity" matrix-like intro, soaring, obvious on OZRIC TENTACLES. A title winking at 'The Return Of Daedalus' by Arise, with the spaceship coming out of a black hole... In short, space rock full of electronics bordering on krautrock where the sounds of TANGERINE DREAM come to light. Velvety, distorted, on 'Tron'. The heavy guitar solo spurts from this black hole precisely, immense; Ariel's keyboard solo a tad hypnotico-oriental, bluffing. A little space-time later it's a bewitching alien western. The piano sets the scene after 8 minutes, introducing a solemn symphonic aria where vocals were not required. A grandiloquent moment with choirs, bells, and piano blending into the space of our psychedelic memory. "All Good Things" closes the album, with Alan Parson's vocal phrasing, ELO, and The Beatles. A sad, languid aria that evolves with the instrumental parts of Ariel on keyboards and Oliver on guitars. The solemn piece, a testament to the hero's journey, is effectively brought to life by this divine, captivating, psychedelic break. Prog like the good old days, with melancholic sequences that make you cry with joy and realize that beautiful music is still present today.

GLASS HAMMER returns to this gentle sound after their heavy trilogy, which had so much to talk about. A melodic album with a nod to the 80s, new wave to regress without getting too lost in the twists and turns of the Dinos. Original profilprog (4.5).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Angel Station by MANN'S EARTH BAND, MANFRED album cover Studio Album, 1979
3.53 | 195 ratings

BUY
Angel Station
Manfred Mann's Earth Band Eclectic Prog

Review by Lobster77

4 stars Here we have an album that finds the different sides of MMEB at their most balanced; and of course this means, Angel Station is not MMEB at their proggiest. But still, from the 6 minutes and 15 seconds of "Don't Kill It Carol" on, it is clear that the listener is not listening to a light pop album. There is a certain depth to the package, perhaps even underlined by the strange fact that possibly the best new and self-penned MMEB song here, "You Are ' I Am", is virtually derived from "Hollywood Town", a Harriet Schock cover that can be found earlier on this album. Also only two of the golden era MMEB members are here (Chris H Thompson and Manfred Mann himself).

Well, the covers. Manfred Mann's Earth Band always liked to cover either Bob Dylan ("It's All Over Now, Baby Blue", "Father of Day, Father of Night") or Bruce Springsteen ("Spirits in the Night", "Blinded by the Light"). So there is Dylan's "You Angel You" on Angel Station, and of course it sounds like anything but Dylan but its great how they did it nonetheless.. On the other hand, MMEB's famous covers have tended to be quite prog rock, but this one is mainly pop rock and can be considered a bridge towards the forthcoming Chance album in a way. There is also a Billy Falcon cover, "Waiting for the Rain", which is one of the several Angel Station tracks that simply sound great ' those include "'Belle' of the Earth" and "Resurrection" as well.

So, it is evident that Angel Station is a great album. And still it is just as natural that it is not an actual masterpiece. There never was one in the Manfred Mann's Earth Band catalogue. Amongst the late 1970s albums, I can place it beside Octave (The Moody Blues) and XII (Barclay James Harvest). I like all these three, I would mention each of these if having a longer discussion about the late 1970s prog pop, but not in the first sentence. 4.5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Crime of the Century by SUPERTRAMP album cover Studio Album, 1974
4.32 | 1907 ratings

BUY
Crime of the Century
Supertramp Crossover Prog

Review by Lobster77

4 stars Unambiguously the best Supertamp record along with/after Breakfast In America. A lot of real progressive masterpieces can be found here. The opener 'School', 'Hide In Your Shell', the epic 'Rudy', 'If Everyone Was Listening', especially the closing 'Crime Of The Century' are among the best pieces of progressive music ever. The album's two most accessible tracks, 'Bloody Well Right' and 'Dreamer' are somewhat less inspiring in musical terms but it doesn't deduct from the quality of this record.

Supertramp's brand of prog rock always tended towards the slicker, more commercial, less idiosyncratic end of the pool, akin to post-Dark Side Pink Floyd, or the Alan Parsons Project, or Kayak. I don't think this is a bad thing by any means- but I think it means that Supertramp does better commercially in a progressive pop mold than when they're trying to do more ambitious prog stuff. The best songs on this album (Bloody Well Right, Dreamer) are, probably not coincidentally, the poppiest; and the most forgotten about(Hide in Your Shell, Rudy) are the most ambitious: big sweeping structurally ambitious mini-suites which come across to some as dull mid-tempo ballads at heart. 4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 PowerNerd by TOWNSEND, DEVIN album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.87 | 36 ratings

BUY
PowerNerd
Devin Townsend Experimental/Post Metal

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Well, Devin Townsend is surely one of the most impeccable composers of complex and quirky metal music that transcends genre and categorizations, and his latest work, 2024's 'PowerNerd' is yet another fascinating installment in the Canadian musician and prog maestro's enviably eclectic and unpredictable discography. The album is pretty tight and relatively straightforward, a stunning collection of songs that virtually celebrates the complete musical palette of the Devin Townsend microcosm. There are pacy and aggressive riffs as well as raging, rattling vocals all over, there are also some incredibly melodic and ambient-like washes of sound, intertwined with equal amounts of silliness or serious reflection upon the state of the world. Townsend does not shy away from adopting his usual "wall of sound" style of production here, which serves this powerful and manic album rather fittingly, so to say.

Confining himself to just eleven standard-length songs, Townsend has allowed himself to craft a cohesive and meticulous album that offers both an energizing and a somewhat nostalgic feel as his more recent albums have been leaning towards this lighter presentation and highlighting texture and nuance more. 'PowerNerd', on the other hand, is absolutely riff-heavy, blasting collection of well-structured songs with memorable, and occasionally anthemic, choruses - definitely some of the most sing-along material on a Devin Townsend album ever. An uplifting album that drags you in through the fast-paced opening track, allowing us to understand just how much Mr Townsend likes petting the cats (among other deeds), after which the album goes through the massive-sounding 'Falling Apart', the heavy rocker 'Knuckledragger', the prog metal hymn that is 'Gratitude' as well as the tricky and intricate heavy number 'Jainism'. 'Ubelia' and 'Glacier' once again bolster that rich and vibrant production style, where each instrument plays a part in the large wash of sound that serves as the song's backbone. Of course, closing track 'Ruby Quaker' should sum up brilliantly what this entire record is all about, that itchy Devin Townsend-ness that has compelled music fans for decades now.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 In Den Gärten Pharaos by POPOL VUH album cover Studio Album, 1971
3.98 | 237 ratings

BUY
In Den Gärten Pharaos
Popol Vuh Krautrock

Review by Lobster77

4 stars German krautrock/ambient group Popol Vuh's second album possesses strong ethereal & cerebral qualities that slowly envelope the listener until you find yourself inside a huge pulsating wall of ambience that threatens to cave in on you with the tribal element leading you into an almost trance-like state. The title track takes a few different directions from Eno-style ambience to a more trippy, tribal feel before settling into a jazzier vibe towards the end. Both tracks are very spacey but "Vuh" is the stronger of the two & is seriously dark for something released in 1971. Don't expect to sit back & chill to this. Expect to find yourself engaged on a physical & emotional level that most music is not capable of. This is BIG music! I actually really enjoy the two bonus tracks on the re-release. An Eastern influence is very prevalent on "Kha-White Structures 1". It reminds me a lot of the more ambient works of modern minimal techno artists like Plastikman with it's use of subtlety & repetition. "Kha-White Structures 2" is a total headcase of the highest order & again hints at modern techno as well as dark ambient. "In den Garten Pharaos" is a timeless classic of epic proportions. I honestly feel that I would've reviewed this album exactly the same way had it been released yesterday.

The album misses any rocking attitude this is not a straightforward rocker. The first two tracks, which made up one side of the original LP each, are Ambient and Drone, partly with a thick carpet of percussion lying underneath. In particular the quality of the title track shines. Both bonus tracks are more in the direction of experimental electronic. The percussion is nearly completely missing here. Nevertheless they are an absolute enrichment of the original album. In total a very strong recording. 4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Quadrophenia by WHO, THE album cover Studio Album, 1973
4.50 | 718 ratings

BUY
Quadrophenia
The Who Proto-Prog

Review by Lobster77

5 stars It didn't hit you as quickly as "Who's Next", "Leeds" or even "Tommy".But eventually, if you were a Who acolyte you got it. And make no mistake, this was a record meant for the true believers.Hardcore Who fans stood apart as torch bearers for a shared promise that took on an almost missionary zeal. There was a bond between The Who and their audience that was never equalled by any other top ranked group of that era. Back then two years between studio albums was an eternity, so when "Quad" finally arrived it was an event.

At least it was an event for Who fans. The casual Who fan would never really warm to this one, and even many older followers dismissed it as being impenetrable and overcooked. It wasn't radio friendly, the short US tour was poorly recieved, so why did this eventually succeed in scaling the heights?

It happened because their audience was willing to take the time required to fully understand this epic. I don't know if "Quad'" can still mean the same to fresh ears as it would have 35 years ago. Mods were a distant social movement even in 1973. But even in the parochial "Englishness" of it all there was still a spot on understanding what it was to be young, confused, angry and ectastic. Actually, the entire Mod backstory somehow made it more plausible because of its exotic nature.

Don't pick this one up first if you're new to The Who with fresh ears. But whenever you do encounter "Quad", you'll soon find it to be indispensable. 5.0 one of my favorites.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Hiromi's Sonicwonder: Out There by UEHARA, HIROMI album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.27 | 44 ratings

BUY
Hiromi's Sonicwonder: Out There
Hiromi Uehara Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars I have resisted listening to any Hiromi studio album releases since she abandoned her Sonicbloom format (for the trios). Isn't that crazy?! What the heck was I thinking?!!! This is Hiromi's second studio release with her new quartet. All of the same collaborators return from the 2023 eponymously-titled album.

1. "XYZ" (6:56) this opener certainly does a great job announcing the serious skills and chemistry of Hiromi's new band. This very complex and least-melody-friendly song on the album still manages to impress because of the display of talent necessary to play these sophisticated and fast-shifting chord, rhythm, and melody changes. Impressive--though not my favorite. (13.625/15)

2. "Yes! Ramen!!" (8:14) so much fun, quirk, stylistic soup (kind of like the ramen itself!): more from Hiromi's incredibly free-flowing playfulness. (14.5/15)

3. "Pendulum" (5:57) the spirit of my late beloved Ryuichi Sakamoto seems to be flowing through Hiromi's fingers and piano on this but more, the stunningly exquisite vocal performance of Michelle Willis is somehow perfectly matched to Hiromi's beautiful music. Even the poetic lyrics are a welcome, fitting, and, again, perfect enhancement--precisely because of the musical quality of the poetry. Hadrien, Gene, and, later, Adam's contributions in the second half are equally respectful of Hiromi's Sakamoto-like gift to the cosmos. (10/10)

4. "Out There: Takin' Off" (6:33) too much fun, too much joy gushing from these performers to not love this song! (9.125/10)

5. "Out There: Strollin'" (6:43) a little more grounded in a blend of both traditional, "classic" melodic jazz as well as the Pat Metheny approach to music-making, this song has again so many nostalgic references: from all three of Hiromi's collaborators as well as the bandleader herself. This feels to me like a walk through New York City circa 1965. I love it. Adam O'Farrill's trumpet play is so fun and playful! How could someone not just fall in love with this music. Makes me want to go watch old Woody Allen movies. (9.25/10) 6. "Out There: Orion" (8:10) on this song it feels as if we are stepping down another floor into more traditional jazz sounds and styles--especially in the melody-making department: I feel as if the main melodies and variations on the main melodies are more akin to that which supported Frank Sinatra and Nancy Wilson in the 1950s. Don't get me wrong: I LOVE it, but it's just a feeling I get. Especially when each of the four "Out There" suite members is compared to each other. (13.75/15) 7. "Out There: The Quest" (8:11) the spirit of Weather Report/Manahattan Transfer "Birdland" comes through quite strongly here, that is, the 1980s. Man! I sure love the sounds and playing styles of both trumpeter Adam O'Farrill and bassist Hadrien Feraud! The way Gene's drums are presented in the mix (separation and sound spectrum) bug me a little. Not as big of a fan of this song as the others. (I've never been much of a Weather Report or "Birdland" fan.) (8.875/10)

8. "Pendulum" (6:19) the instrumental, all-piano version of song #3. It's just as beautiful without the great vocal performance and lyrics of the other version: mostly because Hiromi's music is so damned perfect. I love the different liberties Hiromi takes with the main melody in the fourth and fifth minutes--just before she begins gently working some low end bass notes into the background (from 3:44 to the song's end). (9.75/10)

9. "Balloon Pop" (6:18) a lot of fun syncopated staccato interplay between Hiromi (more her left hand), Gene and Hadrien. Adam gets a few passages to inject his own ten cents--and they're lovely (if mixed a little too far back into the sonicsphere)--but it's Hadrien's Anthony Jackson-like solo in fourth minute that really blows me away! I'm an absolute sucker for this kind of disciplined staccato syncopation--especially when it's performed at such a high precision level as this is. Fun whistle-like synth solo around the five minute mark with nice background trumpet accents, then it's off to the land of duelling anjos for the final minute: everybody trading barbs and challenges around the circle, one after the other until the finish. (9.125/10)

Total Time 63:21

I am so surprised (and overwhelmed) to find my inner being exuding such joy and elation as I listen to and review this album. I feel so very privileged to be able to know and have this kind of joyful music in my life. If I have any complaints/criticisms of this album, they are very minor--and they have nothing to do with the compositions or performances. I find myself ever so slightly put off by the way Gene Coye's drums are recorded. At times all of the four instruments feel rather subtly separated, that is, the tracks devoted to Gene, Hadrien, Adam and even (sometimes) Hiromi feel as if they have plexiglass walls between them: as if they were recorded in separate rooms, separate cities, at separate times and then the engineers tried to make them feel together. I've been quite resistant to listening to much of Hiromi's discography since she fell into my life with her first Sonicbloom album back in 2007: I just was afraid that nothing else could ever be better much less compare to that. A few live performance videos with Anthony Jackson have recently softened my stubborn stance, and then, today, this album popped into my awareness! Am SO GLAD it did! Also, I've been so focused on "Classic Era" Jazz-Rock Fusion and 1960s Jazz that I'd completely ignored (like a righteous little snob) any modern Jazz-Rock Fusion. Okay: I now see the error of my ways. I'm going to open myself back up to 21st Century Jazz-Rock Fusion. Hiromi, Antoine Fafard, Kamasi Washington, Meshell Ngegeocello: watch out: I'm comin' for y'all!

P.S. I ADORE the album art of this album! Now that's what I'm talkin' about! A/five stars; a certifiable masterpiece of joy-filled upbeat Jazz-Rock Fusion. All hail the Queen! Highly, highly recommended. For anyone who professes to love music.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Live Killers by QUEEN album cover Live, 1979
3.54 | 203 ratings

BUY
Live Killers
Queen Prog Related

Review by sgtpepper

3 stars "Live killers" was a live album which Queen fans have long been waiting for. With arguably greatest traditional and rocking repertoire up to that date, the players in a great shape, all the scene was set for an exceptional live album. In the end, though, my feelings are mixed. The band is on fire; the upbeat tracks prove it with no denying whether it's Mercury's powerful voice (sometimes with Taylor's needed intense contribution), May's rocketing guitar or Taylor's well audible and sometimes playful drumming. The stylistic variety on the studio albums is a double edged sword on the stage with trade-offs taken, especially when the songs are trimmed. Recorded at the end of the 70's, the former vocal decoration and layers are stripped from the live setting, naturally, highlighting the rocking abilities by the band to their artistic variety. The playlist is pretty decent and not focused on the hits only. Production is a big disappointment to me, the band sounds thin and distant. With the lack of similar live material from that era, this is still the preferred live testament by the band, with all its pros and cons.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Fusion III by URBANIAK, MICHAL album cover Studio Album, 1975
3.97 | 21 ratings

BUY
Fusion III
Michal Urbaniak Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars I spent time with this record, and the previous one called "Fusion" six years ago, about a month apart. This time around I wanted to compare the two recordings since they are related, both with "Fusion" in their titles. The similarities are Michal's violin playing, and Urszula his partner's wordless vocals. These two albums "sound" very different from one another. Released a year apart, and also a continent apart.

Michal and his partner would move to the USA leaving his band behind. Urbaniak was such a fan of American Jazz, and on "Fusion III" he gets his wish to play with some American greats. So it's somewhat ironic that his keyboardist on "Fusion III" is Wlodek Gulgowski from Poland. He hadn't played with Urbaniak previously, as he had moved to Sweden in 1965. He would join MADE IN SWEDEN for their final release the following year in 1976.

For my tastes in Fusion Urbaniak's previous four albums blow this one away. All in that 73/74 time period with the live "In Concert" being part of that plus their studio records "Inactin", "Atma" and "Fusion". "Fusion III" on paper might look better, but the results do not agree with this. Unless you like funky music that is. I prefer the more European Jazz style that he played in Poland with those experimental passages. "Fusion III" is more accessible, melodic and softer. I feel that his Polish band is on another level, but honestly it's more the style of music they are playing.

So besides Michal, Urszula and Wlodek, all born in Poland, we get John Abercrombie on guitar, Anthony Jackson on bass and Steve Gadd on drums. Larry Coryell guests on one track, plus we get some other guests on here adding some vocals, extra guitar and drums. It's kind of crazy that the previous record "Fusion" didn't have bass or guitar on it, yet I adore that record. There was no guitar on "Atma" or "Inactin" either, but both had electric bass. My favourite tracks are the opener and closer which are the two parts of "Chinatown". And my favourite bits are what the keyboarder is doing playing synths and clavinet along with an abundance of electric piano.

A lighter and more commercial sound to this record over his previous stuff, but this is still a solid 4 star record in my world. I'll just stick to his Polish records from that '73/'74 period. Urbaniak's best!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Chercán by CHERCÁN album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.08 | 37 ratings

BUY
Chercán
Chercán Eclectic Prog

Review by Stoneburner

4 stars The flight of the Chercan

The chercán is a very popular bird in Chile. It nests near houses and can always be seen around them, forming a kind of symbiosis with humans.

Chercán is also the name of a band here in my country, Chile, an experimental group with a very prog- influenced sound. Their influences include jazz fusion and avant-garde styles. They resemble many bands, but here I'm going to focus more on their chilean influences than the foreign ones. I can detect touches of Fulano, Fractal, and Akinetķn Retard, along with a set of influences leaning more toward pop especially in the vocals, which sometimes remind me of Lucibel.

Chercán was formed in 2019 in Valdivia, Chile. Through their lyrics, the band aims to express the various concerns of its members: vocalist Martín Peņa (guitar in 7 Colores), bassist Simķn Catalán, guitarist Roberto Faúndez, saxophonist Matías Bahamondes, and drummer/percussionist Rodrigo González Mera. Their themes revolve around personal experiences, their relationship with nature and the environment, and the challenges of today's society.

It's hard to be a fellow countryman and criticize art especially progressive music in a country where there isn't much raw material, and few dare to attempt something like this. Not to mention how difficult it is to make music in Chile, where reggaeton and urban music are venerated. Rock let alone progressive rock feels like it comes from another planet. And if we do choose to listen to something, we often prefer it not to come from our own backyard. It's something idiosyncratic, and there's no time here to get into a deep social critique of Chile, which could easily fill several pages and multiple theses. The reality is that in Chile, this kind of music doesn't reach a popular level, and getting a project like this off the ground is extremely difficult.

That said, I hope I can say this without hurting any feelings: Chercán has made a very good and complex record, full of interesting passages. Unfortunately, it sometimes falls into repetition as if the album loops at certain points. In the middle of some songs, it can feel like the music is going in circles. But overall, it's a solid album. The fact that it's sung in Spanish and still sounds natural and fitting is an accomplishment in itself something rarely achieved outside of Argentine progressive rock, where the Spanish language doesn't clash with the musicality.

The album has wonderful production. Every instrument has its place, and the vocals are very well recorded and well delivered. Guest musicians like Benjamín Ruz on string arrangements and violins, Javiera González on viola, and Ariadna Kordovero on cello add extra color and beauty to the final result.

Behind the scenes, the work is equally impressive. Drums, guitars, and vocals were recorded at Estudio LeRock in Santiago by José Tomás Molina. The saxophone parts were recorded by Pueblo Obsoleto in Valdivia, while the bass was recorded by Simķn Catalán himself in Valdivia. The string quartet was recorded by Benjamín Ruz and Eduardo Padilla at Estudios ZUR in Santiago, and the percussion by Rodrigo González Mera at Estudio El Pequén in Valdivia. Mixing was handled by Jorge Fortune at Telúrica Estudio in Coyhaique, and mastering was done by both Carlos Barros (known for work with Kalimba, Las Mentiras del Muro, Tiempos Paralelos, and 7 Colores) and Jorge Fortune (La Culpa, Quimera, Orate, Caen las hojas blancas).

The cover art deserves special recognition too, with its play of colors that seem to symbolize the plumage of the friendly chercán. The artwork was done by the artist Paulina Rosso.

In the end, Chercán is a great debut album. Despite its flaws, the record achieves what it set out to do. In my opinion, it may not be a masterpiece but it's certainly a strong ķpera prima.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ensemble Havadiā by ENSEMBLE HAVADIĀ album cover Studio Album, 1981
4.02 | 8 ratings

BUY
Ensemble Havadiā
Ensemble Havadiā RIO/Avant-Prog

Review by Finnforest
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars An Avant-Folk Vocal Feast

Attention fellow RPI fans. Here is another deep (and crazy) RPI album in the same wing of the villa as Stormy Six, Opus Avantra, Gruppo D'alternativa and some of the other wilder titles that I'm struggling to recall from my out-of-the-loop-for-too-long brain. It's a difficult spin that may drive you batsh-t crazy the first couple times you play it, but it will alter your synapse connections eventually and suck you in. Think of an avant-garde chamber collective blending neoclassical music with Italian folk music and literally all manner of highly creative and over-the-top vocal arrangements, strings, and horns. As cool and disorienting as the music is, it is the vocals and the vocal arrangements that make this a classic for me. How do the vocals present? Throw a dart. Operatic, folksy, theatrical spoken word, beautiful and calming, laughter, children singing, various types of choir harmonies, nonlyrical mouth noises, on and on.

As a great lover of the Traditional Latin Mass and the sacred music offered by some at the beautiful High Masses, it is the hymn-like vocals on "I benandanti" that grabbed my attention initially. The sound quality of the album is just fantastic. There are no rock guitars or loud rock drums involved, so all attention could be placed on micing and capturing and mixing the strings and intricate vocals in the best possible manner for the early '80s. I also appreciated that, while there is certainly weirdness here, they don't do the deep dive into cacophonous "noise" that makes some albums land like a migraine. There is a lot of melodic beauty here in between the strangeness, and the balance of the two makes for a great listen. These guys weren't around long, but when you birth a piece of work like this one, maybe it's for the better. It's happened a few times in rock history. Sometimes you make such a unique work that you're unlikely to top it. Just a hunch.

Highly recommended for fans of avant-garde, anti-rock Italian weirdness. As I don't believe they have a website, I've linked to their music on YouTube via the "Website" button on their artist page---this album is the first nine tracks of that compilation. It is followed by five tracks (10-14) from their later EP, which is not as compelling. There were also vinyl and CD releases.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Burn by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1974
3.88 | 958 ratings

BUY
Burn
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by Hector Enrique
Prog Reviewer

4 stars The entry of Glenn Hughes (ex - Trapeze) on bass and vocals and the little known David Coverdale on vocals (chosen after Paul Rodgers declined the invitation) to replace Roger Glover and Ian Gillan respectively, helped not only to bring harmony back to the heart of Deep Purple, but also added new nuances to the band's sound universe with the release of "Burn" (1974), their eighth album and first of their second reincarnation (Mark III).

A mixture of influences and styles inhabit the album, which oscillates between the elaborate hard rock of the homonymous "Burn" with the baroque keyboards of Jon Lord and the guitar exhalations of Ritchie Blackmore in the frequency of "Highway Star", the festive boogie of "Lay Down, Stay Down" and "What's Goin' On Here", the groove- heavy funk of the sludgy "Sail Away" with Lord's hypnotic keyboards, and the witty "You Fool No One" with a great solo by Blackmore over Ian Paice's dynamic percussive base, and the meditative blues of the mournful "Mistreated" with another very good solo by Blackmore and Coverdale's most accomplished vocal participation in the work.

And to complete the palette of colors, the instrumental "'A' 200" (name taken from antiparasitic disinfectants), starred in good measure by the keyboards and especially Lord's lysergic moog and Paice's percussive evocation of Maurice Ravel's 'Bolero', adds the experimental and progressive touch to "Burn" in its final stretch.

Commercially "Burn" did well (#3 on the UK charts and #9 in the US), and while it doesn't reach the heights of "Deep Purple in Rock" or "Machine Head", it's a few notches above "Fireball" and several more above "Who Do We Think We Are".

3.5/4 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Made In Europe by DEEP PURPLE album cover Live, 1976
3.50 | 252 ratings

BUY
Made In Europe
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars As far as Deep Purple live albums go, their third one 'Made in Europe' attempted to be as commercially successful is its 1972 predecessor and semi-namesake, featuring recordings from the band's European tour from 1975, with the fantastic MK 3 lineup with David Coverdale and Glenn Hughes in the front. While the scope of this live release might generally seem more limited compared to that of 'Made in Japan', the album absolutely manages to present the power and ambition of the band during their 1974-75 period, featuring just five songs from their incredibly strong pair of 1974 albums 'Burn' and 'Stormbringer'. Some of tracks are faithful to the album versions, while others see the extended jamming sections that Purple had become quite notorious for, and the overall impression is of a very solid and recognizable live sound, full of great playing and mesmerizing vocal performances.

Opening up the album with a killer version of their iconic track 'Burn', Purple set an explosive tone for the rest of this rather short release (purposely omitting songs from the previous lineup with Gillan and Glover) - the live version here is an invigorated rendition of the classic track, generally respectful of the original sound and structure of the song. Next up on the tracklist is a recording of the heavy blues number 'Mistreated', the version here is really powerful, with the performance of Coverdale being particularly noteworthy. Glenn Hughes' bass parts are also incredibly animated and upfront, which is a very welcome treat to the audiophile here, his playing shall be lauded for its technicality, precision and energy. The track gets extended by a fine Blackmore solo moment and an interpolation with classic blues number 'Rock Me Baby', here playing an interesting role in the context of the wallowing tones of 'Mistreated'. 'Lady Double Dealer' is excellent, while 'You Fool No One' gets an improvised extension through a Jon Lord solo opening spot, a Ritchie Blackmore string of guitar pyrotechnics, and the inclusion of Ian Paice's drum solo from 'The Mule', concluding the 16-minute-long version. A gorgeous 'Stormbringer' run-through closes off the overall excellent live album, eventually passed through extensive studio editing that had in any case failed to harm the recording's grit and liveliness, indicative of the powerhouse that Deep Purple is as a live act.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Cavalcade by BLACK MIDI album cover Studio Album, 2021
3.99 | 173 ratings

BUY
Cavalcade
black midi RIO/Avant-Prog

Review by Dapper~Blueberries
Prog Reviewer

5 stars OH BOY I HAVE BEEN WAITING TO REVIEW THIS! Ever since I reviewed Hellfire in 2022, I have been waiting patiently for the chance to look at the other two albums on black midi's studio catalog, and now that I will absolutely review more of them, I can now tell everyone about my favorite album of 2021, Cavalcade!

Cavalcade is where I believe the Windmill scene, as well as black midi as a whole, peaked. In a way, it perfectly encaptures the ideals and musical thoughts within the scene that started in The Windmill pub of Brixton. It is an eclectic mixture of brutally crazy avant-prog, dark and brooding post-punk, noisy jazz rock, and even some slices of post rock, just for good measure.

I think this mix is really where black midi shines, as no matter the song they end up always sounding so forward thinking, from the chaotic mess of John L, to the slow and methodical Diamond Stuff, I always feel so surprised with how they made this album the way they did. Every song exudes personality and character to the point where the songs themselves do not actually feel like music, but rather feel like people, and every strained sax playing is their conversation with me.

And by god do these songs TALK.

Admittedly though, if there is one thing that I dislike about the album is more so the fact that the first listen of it will always feel like a trip. This is obviously more of a mental thing, and clearly won't reflect in the final grade, but I honestly wish I could forget I ever listened to Cavalcade so I can listen to it freshly again, because the first time I listened to it was probably the craziest I have ever felt, even more so than all the other black midi releases.

I think I was in my junior year of high school when I first heard this album. I knew the song of John L first through Spotify, probably recommending the track, and I most certainly liked it. I figured the band would be like a modern day King Crimson. I was wrong, dead wrong. black midi is not even close to being a modern day King Crimson, they're their own beast. But I didn't realize this, and in that moment when I finally finished listening to Ascending Forth, it hit me like a brick on what black midi was.

Cavalcade's biggest strength and weakness is, if you've never heard of black midi before, or know very little of them, the album will hit you like a semi truck, and when it hit me, I grew to instantly love it. However, once you get familiar enough with black midi by listening to Schlagenheim and Hellfire, Cavalcade ends up having a softer blow. Still with immaculate music, but the feral beast had been considerably tamed.

It's like, say, a horror game that you love. At the first playthrough, you are tense, confused, shocked, and even maybe a little anxious by what could be around the corner. Could it be another monster? A healthpack? Maybe a puzzle? All three? The only way to know is to check.

But after a replay or two, that corner becomes very less scary because you know what's around it. You're more prepared and even feeling a little nostalgic when you were afraid. In a way, Cavalcade is a horror game, a really fun horror game, and like all horror games the fear of it wanes into nothing. But perhaps that's the point? After a while, an album can grow a little boring after so many listens, and one might need a bit of a break from it to truly appreciate it again. Cavalcade is an exception for me though, as while the impact it once had most certainly is gone, the love and level of fun music to be had on here just brings me back for more.

Perhaps Cavalcade hasn't changed since my first listen. A domesticated dog can still bite as hard as a wolf can.

Cavalcade really is just a special album. There is just something so satisfying about it that no other album has reached. It's music from an abnormal world, where notes are conscious and where sound has eyes and teeth, but no mouth. It's everything and nothing all at once, and for that, it's beautiful.

Best tracks: John L, Slow, Diamond Stuff, Dethroned, Ascending Forth

Worst track: N/A

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Tarot, Part I by MAGICK BROTHER & MYSTIC SISTER album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.24 | 80 ratings

BUY
Tarot, Part I
Magick Brother & Mystic Sister Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Stoneburner

5 stars Spain give us another gift in music Magick Brother & Mystic Sister formed in Barcelona in 2013, and its members have participated in multiple musical projects, among which I'd like to highlight Akron, a Magic Pop favorite. The original project was called Fungus Mungus, where they set the Tarot to music. The band is made up of Eva Muntada (vocals, piano, organ, synthesizers, and mellotron), Xavi Sandoval (guitar, sitar, and bass, as well as mixing), Maya Fernández (flute), and Marc Tena (vocals and drums). The project began to take shape in the early 2000s when the first two met Daevid Allen at the Canterbury Festival. They even released a DVD of the documentary about Gong's performance in Montserrat, entitled "Gong Montserrat 1973 and Other Stories." Maya and Marc joined the project in 2013, forming the band. They began performing live covers of Soft Machine, Skin Alley, and Jethro Tull, before later focusing on their own creations. There's also Krautrock influence?think Guru Guru, early Eloy, or Can?and the Canterbury sound of Gong. You can also hear early Hawkwind and the psych side of Pink Floyd's first records. Right from the first track, "The Fool," you know you're stepping into something special. The band doesn't rush anything. The music unfolds slowly, naturally?like incense smoke swirling in a candlelit room. This is pure, analog-feeling psychedelic prog with deep roots in late-'60s and early-'70s sounds, but it never comes off as copycat. Think early Gong, some Amon Düül II, or even the quieter parts of Pink Floyd's Obscured by Clouds?but more colorful, more melodic.

The instrumentation is full of vintage keyboards (mellotron, organ, Moog), hypnotic basslines, soft female vocals that drift in and out like a ghost in a dream, and guitars that shimmer rather than shred. There's no rush to get anywhere, and that's the beauty of it. The songs feel like Tarot cards being turned one by one? each one opening a new scene, a new feeling.

1. The Fool The perfect opening. Light, mysterious, and playful?just like the Tarot card itself. The melody feels like a character stepping into the unknown, wide-eyed and curious. The drums are soft, the organ dreamy. It's a gentle invitation into the band's world, with that hazy, late-'60s vibe already in full effect.

2. The Magician More grounded than the opener, this one brings a subtle groove and more focused arrangements. You can feel the intention behind the music?like something's being conjured. The synth lines swirl around like smoke, and the bassline really drives the spell forward. You start to sense that this album is not just a collection of moods?it's telling a story.

3. The High Priestess Mysterious and slow-burning. A standout. The vocals are ethereal, almost whispered, and the keys paint this misty, sacred space. The atmosphere is everything here?beautifully restrained, but layered with meaning. You don't just hear this track, you feel it on your skin.

4. The Empress Here things start to bloom. There's a warm, almost pastoral energy?like walking through a garden at sunrise. Flutes and soft guitar lines give it a folky touch, very early Gong or maybe even something out of the Italian prog scene. The rhythm flows naturally, almost womb-like. A nurturing, enveloping piece.

5. The Emperor The contrast to "The Empress" is perfect. This one's more structured, heavier. There's a quiet authority in the rhythm section and more pronounced organ work. It's not aggressive?but it stands firm, grounded. You can feel the Tarot card in the music: power, presence, control.

6. The Hierophant One of the more esoteric pieces. Echoes of Krautrock here?slow, ritualistic pacing, lots of space between the notes. The textures are deep, almost meditative. If the Hierophant is about spiritual tradition, this track sounds like it's channeling some cosmic church service in another dimension.

7. The Lovers Probably the most melodic track on the album. It has a dreamy romanticism to it?tender vocals, gentle guitar arpeggios, and a real sense of connection between the instruments. There's no drama, no big climax. Just two musical forces intertwining. It's beautiful.

8. The Chariot More movement here. The drums pick up, the tempo shifts, and things start to push forward. It's not explosive, but it's clearly going somewhere. Feels like a cosmic road trip?lots of swirling keys and that classic '70s psych-prog momentum.

9. Strength A slower, deeper cut. It doesn't show off?just holds its own. The bass is heavy and grounding, while the organ creates a kind of floating contrast. There's emotional weight here, but no melodrama. It's subtle strength, just like the Tarot card.

10. The Hermit A quiet moment of reflection. Sparse arrangement, more ambient textures. You can hear the solitude in the music. It's not sad, though?it's thoughtful, inward-looking. Like watching the stars alone from a mountaintop.

11. Wheel of Fortune The closer ties it all together. It has ups and downs, changes in tempo, shifting dynamics?just like the ever- turning wheel. There's a sense of motion and resolution. It doesn't end with a bang, but with a kind of knowing exhale. The journey pauses here? until Part II.

Tracks like "The High Priestess" and "The Lovers" are standout moments?not because they try to blow you away, but because they invite you in. This is headphone music. Room-dark, incense-lit, eyes-closed kind of stuff. There's also a strong cinematic vibe?like a forgotten European film soundtrack from 1972.

As an album, Tarot Pt. I is a space to get lost in. It flows beautifully and builds a dream world that continues in Tarot Pt. II. But this first part stands solid on its own. It's patient, immersive, and incredibly well-crafted.

For lovers of cosmic prog, mellow psych, and vintage sound textures. Magick Brother & Mystic Sister aren't just looking backward?they're reaching across time, channeling something old and making it new again. This record is slightly better than their sequel Both are great

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Tarot, Part II by MAGICK BROTHER & MYSTIC SISTER album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.57 | 23 ratings

BUY
Tarot, Part II
Magick Brother & Mystic Sister Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Stoneburner

5 stars A Magick and Mystic Tarot

I don't know how many times I've written this, but Spain is experiencing a rebirth, a revival, a new wave of great music?especially in the progressive scene. Just a few days ago, I was listening to a band that I swore was from the late '60s. But no?it's from the 2020s.

Magick Brother & Mystic Sister is a band from Barcelona, Spain, and they feel like a reincarnation of those great psychedelic bands from the late '60s to mid-'70s. There's Krautrock influence?think Guru Guru, early Eloy, or Can?and the Canterbury sound of Gong. You can also hear early Hawkwind and the psych side of Pink Floyd's first records. But what's amazing is that the band still sounds original. They don't just imitate their influences?they use them to create something fresh.

This is the band's third album, and it moves between different atmospheres and textures: layered keyboards, dreamy vocals, hypnotic drums and bass, and long, expressive guitar solos.

Tarot Part II is the counterpart to Tarot I. It's less adventurous than Part I, but it met my expectations as a continuation of the band's journey. It opens with "Strength," and from there the album flows like a long meditation?spacey, atmospheric, and textured. It breaks at times with voices, guitar solos, or delicate arpeggios. It's really beautiful. The music feels organic?it grows and retracts like a living thing.

It's almost impossible to do a track-by-track breakdown because the album feels like one cohesive whole that evolves as it goes. That said, track 9, "The Sun," stands out as something a little different?a kind of refreshing American bossa nova touch. In the end, Tarot Part II confirms that Magick Brother & Mystic Sister are not just another retro band. They've taken the spirit of an era and shaped it into something personal, sincere, and timeless. The album doesn't try to impress with technical showmanship or big climaxes?it pulls you in with atmosphere, feeling, and flow. It's the kind of record you sit with, close your eyes, and let it take you somewhere else.

Spain keeps giving us these hidden gems, and this band is right up there with the best of the new progressive wave. Highly recommended for anyone into psychedelic prog, cosmic vibes, and albums that feel like a journey rather than just a collection of tracks.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Made in Japan by DEEP PURPLE album cover Live, 1972
4.53 | 774 ratings

BUY
Made in Japan
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

5 stars 1972's 'Made In Japan' is undeniably an iconic live album that captures Deep Purple in their prime, unhinging their full potential live while playing and improvising over some of the best cuts from their string of classic albums released in the early 70s, this is a fantastic document of its era indicative of just how manic, heavy and experimental Purple really were in their finest days. Recorded at their Japanese tour, this second live album from the legendary British band presents a selection of material recorded at three particular shows - at the Budokan in Tokyo and at Festival Hall in Osaka. The compositions featured here are not necessarily run-throughs of the album tracks but instead go into a guitar and keyboard-heavy jam session-kind of playing, with the band playing extended instrumental improvisations within the framework of their songs, and with just seven tracks spread over the two sides of an LP, one can imagine the rattling ambition of this live album, vivid, powerful and really, really loud.

A thumping version of 'Highway Star' opens up the album, this is a fantastic way to kick off the show on a high note, the energy is excellent, the playing is excellent, and the dominant wailing screams of Ian Gillan impress all throughout. Lord and Blackmore are quite generous with their soloing, and the entire band locks in for a classic night of heavy rock. This is followed by a triumphant and rather exhilarating performance of 'Child in Time', graced by the frantic banshee wails of Gillan once again, all performances are beyond description here. The mandatory inclusion of 'Smoke on the Water' brings a rampant playthrough of the iconic rock anthem, while the following track 'The Mule' features the six-minute-long drum solo of Ian Paice, really entertaining and impressive to hear. The next tracks feature long and improvisational instrumental sections, with wide, stabbing solos from both Blackmore and Lord, working brilliantly within the jam-based setting here. The final and most expansive piece on the album is the 20-minute recording of 'Space Truckin', definitely a fantastic and explosive rendition of the otherwise tremendous song from the 'Fireball' album. The entire 'Made In Japan' set is perfect, from the inclusion of iconic tracks from the DP catalog to the incredible performances of each band member, to the degree of experimentation and flamboyant energy with which each song is tackled, and finally, because of the fact that this is arguably the most significant live recording of the Mark II lineup of the band.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Come Taste the Band by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1975
3.24 | 599 ratings

BUY
Come Taste the Band
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

3 stars The last studio album released by Deep Purple in the 1970s is 'Come Taste the Band', an LP that is still an odd occurrence within the catalogue of the band, featuring a rather disjointed and unique lineup of Ian Paice, Jon Lord, Glenn Hughes, David Coverdale and the mysterious, exotic guitar player Tommy Bolin, a guy previously known for recording guitars for Billy Cobham's 'Spectrum' album. Perhaps the two most notorious musical aspects regarding this album are the absence of Blackmore and his signature playing as well as the much stronger leaning towards funk rock (as we eventually get its proto-version here), a stylistic lineage that had been propelled by Bolin and Hughes, the two most troublesome personalities of the band by 1975. The entire record is this intertwining between the funk-infused style of rock that the band had been exploring recently, and an attempted resonance with their previous works.

'Comin' Home' and 'Lady Luck', positioned at the beginning of the album, are upbeat and fast-paced rockers that have a more ostensible classic rock sound, with Bolin's fiery riffs making their way through the tight rhythm section, while Coverdale's vocals definitely impress. 'Getting' Tighter' is a generally enjoyable funk-ride, yet an odd entry on a Deep Purple album, while the much more improvisational track 'Dealer' features some of the more exciting and unpredictable playing of both Bolin and Lord on 'Come Taste the Band'. This is one of the tracks indicative of the possible direction this iteration of the band could have taken had it continued its existence - the song, however, is followed by the slightly tedious and once again very funky 'I Need Love' and the forgettable song 'Drifter', both of which offer nothing overly exciting. 'Love Child' is a classic from this album, while the mini-suite 'This Time Around/Owed to 'G'' is the most unusual entry on the album but also a very welcome experiment on a generally stale and one-dimensional studio album. Closing track 'You Keep On Moving' is another one of the better-known Purple songs from that period, which is closed off by an album that is somewhat confusing, but also never really as bad as people say it is. It just a pretty good rock album but not necessarily an incredible DP album.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Box Man by NOVA CASCADE album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.18 | 20 ratings

BUY
Box Man
Nova Cascade Neo-Prog

Review by tszirmay
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars There are those rare moments when words are hard to come by for someone who feels so much at ease in expressing emotions, thoughts and impressions . Over the course of a quarter of a century writing reviews, I have on occasion published posthumous reviews of bands that have broken up or retired , a reverential look back at a past accomplishment worthy of praise or at the very least, analysis of what made them special. It's altogether a different kettle of fish when a band's final release is announced well ahead of time and the dread of your review becoming an obituary column is unbearably difficult. The only way to soothe that sadness is to contemplate the final opus as a legacy move by an artist well-deserving of putting a punctuation mark to a storied career. "Above All Else" in 2018 was the first instalment of Nova Cascade's prog path, where I instantly fell in love at first hearing that amazing voice and the lush musicianship that elevated it to such grandiose heights. Then came 2019's "A Dictionary of Obscure Sorrows" (now that is a prog title!) , a masterful sophomore release. Raising the bar even further on "Back from the Brink" that came out in 2021, it sealed my loyalty in crimson wax. When the stunning "the Navigator" emerged from the post-Covid fiasco, the key word became outright veneration. Leader Dave Hilborne has a voice of crushing poignancy that cannot leave anyone indifferent, his keyboard skills are equally magnificent, yet the spirit behind the man remains his greatest heritage! His final work is fully dedicated to former universally beloved bandmate Eric Bouillette, who sadly passed way in the summer of 2023, and the personal proceeds from "Boxman' are entirely passed on to the Pancreatic Cancer UK. That is what I call legacy! With long-time companions bassist Dave Fick, Colin Powell shining on both keyboards and guitars ( A Multitude of Two) , and finally newcomer Niko Chikviladze on the violin. Dave takes the Nova Cascade navigation to a mythical Norse ritual sending off! "Boxman" becomes a musical longship (Drakkar) laden with grave goods and tributes and sent adrift where seven blazing arrows are aimed at the huge sails and the pyre illuminates the stars.

Spanning a colossal 28 minutes+ instrumental , "The Choice" is the spark that will engulf the listener into a spectral voyage of profound emotional release, ambient keyboard colorations orchestrate a canvas of vivid sonic imaginary, pierced by the magical serenity of the violin , pools of piano providing occasional stability but the ethereal qualities exhibited are soothing comfort that sets the mood from the outset. When Fick settles into the appropriate deferential pace, time seems to vanish from the focus, unneeded and unwanted, as the anesthesia takes gently effect. The evolution of the piece swerves into symphonic bliss, Niko exuding a strong classical presence, as the transition arrives to a universe of absolute gorgeous melodies. With a shift in the drumbeat, the tingling transition to an elevated electronic atmosphere gives Colin Powell the opportunity to make his electric guitar glitter like molten strands of gold, helped along by choir mellotrons in the distance. The rhythmic pulse deliberately expands in vigor, as if wispy clouds ahead announce a change of weather, rivulets of restrained piano announcing the upcoming gale and ultimately unleashing a furtive guitar barrage. Bubbling synthesizers keeps the arrangement on unending periphery, always proposing a slight hint of expectation, various voice effects entering the fray, and the tempestuous guitar raging, thoroughly engaged, as the epic reaches a level of paroxysm that does not overstay its welcome, always offering new choices. This roller-coaster ride mimics the bouncy waves, a river of constant change. The final section is loveliness incarnate, a melody so exquisite, words are difficult to come by. The heavily stringed and choired outro is grandiose and wholehearted. If this is not the epic of the year, I surrender.

When Dave reaches for the microphone on "Smoking Gun", that incredibly hushed and frail voice hits your soul, causing profound tinges of legendary Strawbs frontman Dave Cousins, a voice anchored in romantic expression of the highest order, and though perceived as sensitive, it exudes immense authority. Tick-tock drumming, a looping and elastic bass and an echoing piano unite in a conspiracy to never surrender (like I did on "the Choice") on "If You Don't Succeed", a brooding patchwork of endless beginnings, searching for the proper outcome, resolute in their craft and succeeding one final time. Footsteps that lead to another realm.

The scourge of inhumanity is to be found on "Sentry", as any discourse on the futility of war finds a scholarly home in my realm, as an eternal student of conflict and the reasons behind it, proprietor of a colossal library right next to my enormous prog collection. As a hopeless romantic fool, I find nothing glorious in bloodshed, a wasteful exercise that became evident in visiting various military cemeteries as well as interviewing a long list of veterans over the decades. A song of mourning that affected me greatly.

The instrumental anguish on "As It Was & Is" serves as a perfect post-scriptum to the above carnage, the sorrowful violin from Chikviladze and the desolate piano expressing wordless agony. Another drop dead (excuse the bad pun) melody that gets just retribution with a whiplash guitar salvo from Colin, and some synthesized confusion from Dave, the orchestral backdrop raising the curtain on the proceedings.

The title track is where reverence seeks to impose its dominion and what better instrument that the mighty pipe organ, a personal favorite ever since "the Six Wives of Henry VII" was purchased so long ago. This is where that old tradition of looking at the LP artwork helps in defining the music within becomes apparent. The inspirational artwork is not only visually beautiful but also very a propos, as it contains all the clever hints needed to comprehend the story (oh so, 70s prog!) of how each life is a colliding enigma of potential opposites , depending on which cards are dealt, as well as which one you choose to play. The extremes go from a wooden box to a spectral palace beyond the suspended bridge on the horizon. The human condition is an endless maze of comfort and agony.

The French (RIP Eric) say "terminer en beauté" (finish in style but the Gauls are so much more expressive) and how appropriate to finalize the album and a career with "The End of the Line", a stirring and positive exit ramp instrumental that shines ever so brightly, a brisk percussive pace, glitter riffs, swooning bass support and an applauding piano, with Colin polishing off a masterful 'merci beaucoup'.

Nothing to look forward to more in the future than to regularly revisit all the Nova Cascade albums, as these works offer not only aural satisfaction but a much-needed artistic form of panacea for a constantly troubled world. 5 Deck of cards

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Nevergreen! by MISSING LINK album cover Studio Album, 1972
3.98 | 56 ratings

BUY
Nevergreen!
Missing Link Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Proggy Jazz-Rock Fusion from Deutschland--produced and engineered by Dieter Dierks. Sadly, this is the band's one and only album.

1. "Spoiled love" (5:19) opens with heavy rock chords and sound palette that sounds just like it comes from the kind of Black Sabbath or albums that SPINAL TAP made their name on for their parodies. Getting into the meat of the song there are some ELP-like sounds and chord progressions (and skill displays) before the organ and bass fall into line for the support of Gabriel Dominik Mueller's excellent voice to sing over. Great song established with stellar performances from all of the instrumentalists though especially Markus Sing's amazing lead guitar solo in the third and fourth minutes. I love how it goes soft for Dieter Miekautsch's electric piano solo (with added Mellotron later) for the final motif as bassist Dave Schratzenstaller's Greg Lake-like lines remind the listener of KING CRIMSON's In the Court of the Crimson King. Saxophone joins in with a little over a minute to go before Gabriel returns in the final minute; here he reminds me a lot of Roye Albrighton's voice for NEKTAR. (9.5/10)

2. "Song for Ann" (2:49) a great Keith Emerson-like piano solo. Gorgeous! (4.75/5)

3. "Time will change" (5:31) very disciplined almost-mathematical Jazz-Rock that is built a little like Paul Desmond's "Take Five" while sporting some "I'm a Man" descnding chords to regularly bridge the band into a reset. Nice piano, electric guitar, and saxophone. A new blues-rockin' motif starts around 2:45 which eventually supports the TRAFFIC/VAN MORRISON-like vocals that arrive in the fourth minute. (How much this reminds me of the 1990s HAPPY MONDAYS!) Awesome bass and rhythm guitar play along with Gabriel's excellent blues-rock vocal. Not my favorite style of music but definitely a great construct with quite excellent and creative performances from everybody in the band. (9.125/10)

4. "Only me" (5:07) more power psychedelic blues-rock that seems quite inspired by bands from a few years earlier like Traffic, Blood, Sweat & Tears, and even Santana. (8.875/10)

5. "Sorcery" (5:23) a blues-rock vamp over which sax, electric guitar, and keys elicit some impressive solos--especially Markus searing wah-wah guitar. The sound palette drifts into some really nice ALLMAN BROTHERS territory in the fourth and fifth minutes just before everybody throws any restraint to the ground for a free-for-all race to the finish. (8.875/10)

6. "Filled up" (6:26) More interestingly-constructed music that seems to have its hands in several pies: rockabilly, Baroque, and even the angular, anachronistic quirk of Gentle Giant. The vocal section in the fourth and fifth minutes is like GG being performed by Peter Hammill's VAN DER GRAAF GENERATOR or The Netherlands' FOCUS. Interesting-- and definitely way more proggy than jazzy. Too bad Gabriel's vocal track is recorded/processed rather poorly. (8.875/10)

7. "Kids hunting" (6:11) on this one I hear a 60s rock start turn VDGG with some AREA injected into the music in the second minute. Vocals enter at the three-minute mark with a kind of DEREK SHULMAN style of singing used in the first vocal motif. But then the band switches to a more rapid-paced rock motif in which Gabriel's voice sounds more like Sabbath's Ozzie Osborne. The vocal performance is nice but, again, it's recorded/rendered rather poorly--like Grand Funk Railroad's early renderings of Mark Farner's lead vocals. (9/10)

Total Time: 36:46

Too bad these talented musicians (and songwriters) didn't stay together: there is some very high-quality musicianship as well as highly-creative song construction going on here. Only guitarist Markus Sing and keyboardist Dieter Miekautsch went on to contribute to any other successful bands (Konstantin Wecker and Missus Beastly/Embryo, respectively).

A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of creative, skillfully-rendered progressive rock music.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Tarot, Part I by MAGICK BROTHER & MYSTIC SISTER album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.24 | 80 ratings

BUY
Tarot, Part I
Magick Brother & Mystic Sister Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Pascaline.ha

5 stars Chronique Magick Brother and Mystic Sister.

Quelle belle découverte psychédélique ! De surcroît accessible. Je fus comme suspendue, devant cette effervescence sonore. D'oų émerge une atmosphčre spatiale aux concomitances "floydiennes". Mon ouīe fut embarquée par ces effluves vintage rappelant un tant soit peu les beaux jours du groupe GONG dans des sonorités en moins excentriques, plus somptueuses, et voluptueuses de la scčne Canterbury's proche également de CARAVAN, plus précisément de l'époque "If I Could Do it all Over again?" Mais, dčs le début du répertoire des saccades enivrantes, combinées avec une basse envoûtante, hypnotique, convergent vers des notes radieuses, virevoltantes ā souhait. L'ambiance y est "psyché", surréaliste, tribale. Ā cela, j'ajoute des couches électros pour parfaire l'aspect cosmique. Įa.."vocode" ā tout va ! si je puis m'exprimer ainsi. En veux-tu en voilā ! Le combo accentue la prosodie en juxtaposant des réverbérations de voix féminine. Sans ętre pour autant prosaīque ni cartomancienne, le mystique a certains attraits qui me sied. J'en conclus lā, inopinément, pour la premičre carte du tarot de Marseille " The Fool" l'une des vingt-deux arcanes majeurs du tarot divinatoire. Voilā, ā brûle pourpoint, un petit cliché éphémčre de la thématique de l'album. Si, je vous ai donné l'eau ā la bouche, j'en serais fort aise ! Toutefois, il serait opportun désormais d'apporter de l'eau au moulin concernant nos deux lascars catalans tout droit venus de Barcelone, si j'en crois les infos recueillies. Une anecdote aurait été rendue publique par le duo. Elle évoque l'épisode impliquant DAEVID ALLEN (cofondateur de Soft Machine et créateur de Gong). Cela remonte en 2000 lorsque EVA MUNTADA (piano, synthé, orgue, Mellotron, vocals) et XAVI SANDOVAL(basse, guitares, mandoline, voix , sitar, backing vocals basse/ guitare) l'ont rencontré lors d'un festival ā Canterbury oų se produisaient GONG, CARAVAN et ARTHUR BROWN. Quelques décennies plus tard, le binôme se lance avec brio dans leur premier projet créatif. Ils choisissent, comme nom du groupe " Magick Brother & Mystic Sister ", en référence au premier titre du premier album de GONG. Cet événement fut source d'inspiration pour le combo puisqu'il s'enrichit de MARC TENA (batterie et chant) et de MAYA FERNĀNDEZ (flûte). Afin de donner vie au projet, Ils publient en 2020 leur premier album éponyme. Le quatuor sort de l'ombre, ā la lumičre d'une presse dithyrambique. Il aura fallu néanmoins quatre années de gestation pour que les espagnols de "MB&MS" accouchent d'un nouveau projet. Il a vu le jour sous le label grec "Sound Effect Record" le 29 mars 2024 titré "Tarot Part 1". Ce sera le premier volet d'une série en deux parties. Ils s'inspirent notamment des cartes du tarot divinatoire des arcanes majeurs. Pour cette premičre partie onze cartes seront tirées. Auxquels sont associés onze morceaux plutôt ramassés représentant les cartes du tarot. Mais, avant de me lancer dans la narration des divines cartes. Je souhaite vous faire partager une sensation controversée qui m'amčne ā cette réflexion. Certes, via ces quelques lignes vous y avez sûrement décelé un élan d'enthousiasme et d'euphorie. Une sensation tout ā fait justifiée ā l'égard de cette formation. Cependant, que ce fut difficile d'y plonger sans décrocher puis, d'en extraire matičre ā écrire. Pataugeant dans mon marasme linguistique, il a fallu ętre assidu, concentré. Il m'aura fallu énormément d'écoute. Est-ce une aphasie, une sorte de catharsis liée ā l'extase de ces notes radieuses, virevoltantes, aériennes, cosmiques, relaxantes, oniriques, qui ont traversé mon lob frontal ? Ainsi inoculé, je fus perplexe, confuse, divergente, sans pouvoir y aligner le moindre mot. Aurai-je été plongée dans un songe ? Bref, un autre point m'interpelle. Est-ce une coīncidence, l'alignement des étoiles, une intervention divine ? aurait-elle guidé mon choix pour cette nouvelle découverte ? Quelle qu'en soit la raison, je suis heureuse d'avoir fait ce choix, ô combien judicieux. Cela m'a permis de me délecter d'un kaléidoscope sonore en tout point remarquable de la formation sis Catalogne. Un son rétro futuriste, folk, avec des accointances néo Canterbury psychédélique. Estampillé rock psychédélique/ Space Rock. Avec autant de marqueurs seventies, j'espčre sincčrement que vous n'imaginez pas que nos loustics seraient une pâle copie, un prog rétrograde de GONG ? Il n'en est rien, je vous en conjure ! Seul le nom du groupe est un indicatif et un hommage ā leur aîné. Ils ont su au travers leurs influences musicales, leurs appétences, trouver leurs propres identités. Et qui plus est, leur empreinte sonore ne laissera personne indifférent. Mais, voyons les cartes que nos hôtes ont tirées pour les convives. La premičre carte " The Fool" il faut se l'avouer, les jalons avait bien été posés dčs l'album éponyme. On retrouve ici, ces sonorités psychédéliques moins déjantées certes, que leur aîné avec une touche cosmique, hypnotique, envoûtante, une orchestration conįue aux petits oignons de derričre les fagots. Wouah ! įa titille les esgourdes vers un voyage onirique. La seconde carte montre le magicien "The Wizard". S'ouvre alors, un narratif et, ā l'instar de "The Fool" emporte l'auditeur au pays des songes. La magie opčre, l'ambiance psychédélique demeure. Subrepticement se dévoile ā l'ouīe des phases éphémčres, évanescentes, au piano, ā la guitare, au mellotron trois minutes de ręve instantané. Le ręve se poursuit ā l'écoute du troisičme tirage "The High Priestess" Les réverbérations des voix féminines se superposent sur des séquences folk/médiévales de toute beauté. S'ensuit la quatričme carte "The Empress" les envoûtantes vocalises féminines se déclinent dans l'apaisement et la sérénité. Un moment de nostalgie captivant. S'enchaînent allčgrement "The Emperor" trois minutes Canterbury's , cinématographique aux réminiscences de CARAVAN. Quant ā "The Hierophant" , les notes mystiques du sitar transcendées par les accords magiques de TONY JAGWAR dans un rythme effréné, apportent l'orient ā portée de l'ouīe. "The Lover", les douces harmonies de la sitar évoquent ā nouveau les sonorités sino -orientales. "The Chariot", une fioriture de sonorités prog psyché, émerge le long de mon lob auditif. Ne serait ce pas des réminiscences ā "Sweet Smoke just a poke" combiné ā la magie de la flûte de MAYA FERNĀNDEZ ? Une merveille d'exotisme. "The Justice" Un dream prog Canterbury associé aux harmonies de la flûte et de la voix d'Eva. Épique ! "The Hermit", l'immersion dans un espace sonore méditatif, obscur et futuriste. Intrigant ! L'opus se conclut avec : "The Wheel of Fortune". Un final qui męle sons et pulsations charnelles. Les combinaisons sonores évoquent une impression d'apesanteur, les voix masculines y sont feutrées et se réverbčrent ā l'unisson. Nous sommes dans un tempo plutôt lent, les saccades derričre les fûts fluctuent. L'alchimie agit. La beauté des notes s'enchevętrent avec légčreté dans une atmosphčre psyché cosmique. Une composition ā la beauté formelle, comme le sont, l'ensemble des onze compositions merveilleusement orchestrées pour charmer vôtre ouīe et jouir de ses parements sensoriels. Puis, arrive le moment fatidique de la conclusion. Oų demeurent sans réponse les sempiternelles supputations, interrogations ? Pourquoi n'ont-ils pas fait un double album part 1 et part 2 ? Est-ce le temps de digérer le premier ? Ou peut- ętre de faire grimper au rideau l'auditeur d'impatience ? Outre ces questions sans réponse, il me semble également avoir omis d'évoquer la virtuosité du combo, la symbiose qui en émane, condition sine qua none d'une bonne d'orchestration. Puis, le charme des vocalises d'Eva. J'en conclus lā mes omissions. Enfin, pour l'avenir, sans l'ombre d'un doute, j'envisage un avenir prometteur pour les Catalans de MB&MS.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Dust And Dreams by CAMEL album cover Studio Album, 1991
3.65 | 631 ratings

BUY
Dust And Dreams
Camel Symphonic Prog

Review by Alxrm

4 stars The contract with Decca was over. Andy Latimer knocked some major or less-known label doors which all of them deemed Camel as used-up and they had nothing to offer anymore. That turned out to be a blessing in disguise since Andy Latimer and Suzan Hoover decided to go DIY, they founded Camel Productions and they did a come-back which I don't know how many fans would have faith in. But it seems having shaken off the shackles of a label (consider a hit- single) was the catalyst for Andy Latimer to follow his heart. The first album that emerged from this setup was Dust and Dreams which was based on the widely known book The Grapes of Wrath. It was in the making since 1985 but it saw the light of day six years later. Musically, there is a return to Camel's core sound, but it isn't a case of reheating old stuff, actually some elements of their 80s body of work are present (Stationary Traveller mostly). The music flows continuously, only between Milk n' Honey and End of the Line there is an actual pause. That was a wise thing to do since there are eight songs that range from 0:35 to 2:34 minutes and it would make no sense at all if they were separated. Most of the shorter tracks are on the ambient side which means they are mostly keyboard-driven, in other words although half the album is entirely instrumental, the guitar of Andy Latimer remains silent quite often. I do love the album, but this the reason why I don't rate it higher since I miss the fully-fledged instrumental songs of Camel (where they are unbeatable) as Hopeless Anger is. Then again, Andy aimed to write music to serve the concept and went for wider instrumentations including the harmonica, oboe, French horns and also Mae McKenna on vocals (who would be recruited once again on the follow-up album) and some melodies on these instruments are meant to conjure up scenes from the book. It is of no use to mention some songs as highlights since the album, in my opinion, should be regarded as one single piece of work. And, personally, every time I hit the play button, it goes by in flash and I feel totally elevated.

Occasionally, I have given it some thought if I should regard it as an excellent addition to any prog music collection or as good but not essential. My mind can't reach any conclusion, so I left this task to my heart.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Funky Snakefoot by MOUZON, ALPHONSE album cover Studio Album, 1974
2.40 | 11 ratings

BUY
Funky Snakefoot
Alphonse Mouzon Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

2 stars After breaking out on his own solo career the previous year with the fairly-successful The Essence of Mystery the respected Jazz-Rock Fusion drummer strives for more of the Soul/R&B market.

A1. "I've Given You My Love" (4:43) opens up like an ABBA dance tune before quickly veering into the funkier pre-Disco realm. Alphonze's synth solo takes the first extended solo, then pianos, rhythm guitar, and horn blasts punctuate a bridge after the chorus to return to the verse and start over--with the lame synthesizer continuing to solo/announce the melodies (as if it were a human voice delivering lyrics). It's good, solid, definitely danceable and melodic, just not as interesting as--more like the music a TV talk show band would use between guests or to introduce a guest. It's definitely better in the final two minutes when organ and horns are more prominent. (8.875/10)

A2. "You Don't Know How Much I Love You" (4:40) opens with a drum beat like Barry White's "I'm Gonna Love You Just a Little More, Baby" but then blends in some Marvin Gaye What's Going On before turning into something more like "Love's Theme" (with lyrics). This is definitely Al's poorest vocal performance on the album: there are way too many moments in which his pitch fails to stay in key. (8.375/10)

A3. "I Gotta Have You" (2:46) a song that plays out as a kind of humorous cheeky Stevie Wonder-like song. Very simple chord and rhythm structure over which Al sings the title lyric with a few add ons for emphasis. The dude is feeling sex- deprived. Same drum sound, same voice sound issues, and same synth drilling teeth from behind. (8.5/10)

A4. "My Life Is So Blue" (4:37) a song that is set up to be a little more classy, even elegant, with both it's construction, sound palette, and Gino Vannelli-like vocal styling. High marks for effort, demerits for coming across with too much schlock. (8.875/10)

A5. "Funky Snakefoot" (3:45) great drumming, great bass playing from Gary King, and great clavinet play from Harry Whitaker open this one, quickly establishing a very refreshing groove. Trumpet, piano, and trombone solos from Randy Brecker and Barry Rogers, respectively, in the second minute are brief but powerful. Andy Gadsden's saxophone in the fourth, also before the song fades out. Very high-spirited and fun! Easily the best song on the album (perhaps the only one). (9.3333/10)

A6. "My Little Rosebud" (2:02) a very openly tongue-in-cheek Country-Western parody. Mark Horowitz' pedal steel guitar and banjo play are actually quite impressive. (4.25/5)

B1. "A Permanent Love" (4:20) more upbeat, uptempo soulful dance music over which Alphonze sings. The dude shows a little passion and feeling for this lyric; with the addition of the horn sections accents, the music sounds a little like contemporary Stevie Wonder. The lyrics are definitely meant to be the focal point of this one but the horn section is fun (would be fun to be a part of). (8.875/10)

B2. "The Beggar" (4:35) funky synth bass line opens this before cool, solid drum beat joins in. Electric piano, synth, organ, and Alphonze's voice join in. Too bad A's Eddie Murphy-like voice is recorded, engineered and mixed so oddly throughout this album (far into the back--almost muted). Again, the lyrics are meant to be the star of this song--much in the vein of popular social commentarist Gil Scott-Evans, methinks. The song is faded out right in the thick of A's rather impassioned delivery of lyrics. How odd!(8.75/10)

B3. "Oh Yes I Do" (4:35) bluesy-R&B that sounds a bit like The Temptations "Can't Get Next to You." Al starts singing right from the start: once again sounding very much like the voices Eddie Murphy would make popular on his Saturday Night Live musical skits, only, I don't think Al is trying to be comical. The Steohen Winwood blues organ chord progression keeps things organized as Al uses his drums and favorite synth sound to rouse a little more energy over the final two minute's instrumental passage. (8.75/10)

B4. "Tara, Tara" (3:35) nice drumming and keyboard work over this song that mimics Billy Preston, Stevie Wonder and predicts K.C. and the Sunshine Band a little. The drumming is impressive, I just wish it had been recorded and mixed a little better. (8.875/10)

B5. "Where I'm Drumming From" (1:20) sounds like someone fooling around on an early drum machine: rapid fire here, there, everywhere! (Is this where the sound was recorded from to make my first drum machine's programmed sounds?) It's as if a guitarist turned on the record button and just proceeded to spit out 90 seconds of runs. (4/5)

B6. "Ism" (3:08) opens with drums as if to impress--and they're flanged! Then big bombastic jazz chords are played over the continued impressive drumming with synth banks, horns, synth bass chords. I actually like these angular chord progressions though the drumming gets a little pompous and over-zealous from time to time. The man is all Animal tom- and cymbal-crashing--not even the cool flange effect can keep me from feeling embarrassed for Al's apparent need to impress. (9/10)

Total Time: 43:16

A jazzed-up Soul/R&B album with each and every song intended to have possible pop radio play (if only the Soul/R&B charts). It's fun, with no real low/deficiencies it's just not top tier production. Also, Alphonze just doesn't have the voice or vocal talent to pull of radio-quality hits and his drumming is quite often embarrassingly over the top: as if the 25- year old feels some overwhelming drive to prove his skillfulness. (Was he dissed by the critics early on in his career?)

C+/3.25 stars; an interesting and often enjoyable display of Soul/R&B wannabe from a supposed upper-level Jazz-Rock Fusion. I had much higher expectations than this was able to deliver. In terms of relevance to a prog or J-RFuse database, this must, unfortunately, be relegated to the collector/fans only bin.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Caravanserai by SANTANA album cover Studio Album, 1972
4.22 | 792 ratings

BUY
Caravanserai
Santana Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Lobster77

4 stars A Santana album that does not sound at all like the 3 first ones. It's even better, the chirping in the beginning gives you a very clear idea of what it is you're getting yourself into. Then the weird jazzy sax introduction, shamanesque! Introspective, reflective, explosive at times, this is by far my most favorite Santana album (although Lotus is a close second but 6 sides of Santana can get a little overbearing sometimes). Neal Schon at his best too by the way. Man, i wish they would record something together with that much inspiration again. Carlos Santana is a masterful guitarist and this is a staple of the Santana discography. 4.5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Convivencia Sagrada by PEZ album cover Studio Album, 2001
3.84 | 25 ratings

BUY
Convivencia Sagrada
Pez Crossover Prog

Review by Fercandio46

4 stars There are bands that seem tied to the destiny of the land that gave them birth, and just as human beings can detach themselves from their family and achieve their own flight, only to then, over the years, involuntarily return to their genesis, Pez, the band of Ariel Minimal and friends, follows the winding paths of Argentina, changing, contradictory, sometimes of great quality and complexity... and others that are better forgotten. Not in vain, their most recent albums have not been reviewed here. But on this occasion we are talking about the first great album, where all the influences finally converged in a work with an author's signature. Although Quemado (1996) and Fragilinvencible (2000) already had progressive elements, airs of King Crimson along with touches of Astor Piazzolla (the great maestro who revolutionized and changed tango forever), it is in Convivencia sagrada that the world of Minimal, with its own poetry, metrics and sounds, is revealed. A powerful and distinctive guitarist who conveys ideas as well as complex feelings through both music and lyrics. Along with Gustavo Fķsforo García on bass and Franco Salvador on drums, Pablo Puntoriero joins the band on saxophone and flute, and Juan Salese on electric keyboard and synthesizers. The blend of voice and instruments adds Minimal as an additional instrument, in addition to his work as a guitarist. The counterpoints and changing rhythms also leave room for melodies, progressive rock, jazz, and occasionally free jazz with bossa nova, tango, and psychedelia, with influences such as Luis Alberto Spinetta, who paved the way with his group Invisible, and another Argentine legend, Litto Nebbia, a personal friend of Ariel Minimal, who has included him on several of his albums and is his mentor. Tango is present in El Cantor, as well as orchestral progressive and free jazz in ĄQueseyo! A cornerstone that would cement a promising career in the years to come, with a progression of several albums in this direction and even more variations, until a certain stylistic stagnation and a return to their punk and hard rock origins... from which they seem to be emerging now. Because if there's one thing that characterizes Minimal and his band, it's honesty to what their heart dictates, as well as constant change. In this quest, there are successes and failures, as in life, but the alchemy is renewed by adding new members who revitalize it with their influences.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Rose, My Rocket Brain! by STEREOLAB album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2004
4.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Rose, My Rocket Brain!
Stereolab Crossover Prog

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

— First review of this album —
4 stars "Rose, My Rocket Brain!" was the three song, 14 minute cd they sold on the "Margerine Eclipse" tour. The most recent reissue of the "Margerine Eclipse" recording comes with a second disc that includes "Rose, My Rocket Brain!" and the Ep "Instant O In The Universe". And as band leader Tim Gane relates in the liner notes, this reissue contains everything they recorded during the "Margerine Eclipse" sessions.

The biggest difference in my opinion between the three songs here and the main album is the lack of electronics on these 3 tracks. And it hasn't been given the Tim Gane makeover after the fact, like the main record. And I would put these three tracks over any from the main album. That's what makes this extra disc so special, and I'll talk about the Ep "Instant O In The Universe" soon. I should mention too that the song "University Microfilms International" is the unedited version, so it's actually 1 1/2 minutes longer than the original.

All three tracks are fairly subdued yet uplifting. Relaxed happy songs. I can't help but feel good listening to this music. "Banana Monster Ne Repond Plus" features lots of percussion and organ. Of course the vocals lead the way, including some wordless singing. I'm surprised at the experimental sections on this one. "University Microfilms International" is another feel good tune but a little different with all those intricate sounds, the guitar and keyboards too. Vocals and wordless vocals again. The closing title track opens with bass which is very satisfying as relaxed vocals join in. Catchy but laid back. Organ then guitar as it builds. Active drums and the vocals come and go. They go off on a detour after 2 minutes then back to happy.

It's perfect that this is included with the other Ep giving us over 36 minutes of bonus material on that second disc, all from the "Margerine Eclipse" sessions. Nice.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Journey To Love by CLARKE, STANLEY album cover Studio Album, 1975
3.67 | 54 ratings

BUY
Journey To Love
Stanley Clarke Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Though virtuoso bass player Stanley Clarke was already a household name in the circles of those who knew jazz and Jazz-Rock Fusion, with this, his third "solo" album, we find him still under the influence of some of his more- established mentors and idols (like Chick Corea and John McLaughlin). At the same time, there are plenty of signs of his "coming into his own" as he leads many of the tunes on this album with his considerable (perhaps unequaled) soloing skills.

1. "Silly Putty" (4:52) an interesting song that borders on the funky R&B that was all the rage in 1975 but really has its roots in the Blues-Rock that pre-dates the 1970s. Between Stanley, George Duke, and David Sancious the band has every weird funky chicken sound possible covered in this playful novelty tune. Not my favorite style, it still manages to entertain and, of course, display incredible musicianship. (Just wondering: Which came first: Lenny White's "Chicken- Fried Steak" or this?) (9.125/10)

2. "Journey to Love" (4:52) spacious southern rock that starts out with some high-pitched vocals (apparently as provided by Stanley and George) and then develops into something that sounds like a slowed down Mahavishnu Orchestra song. Horn section adds punctuating accents at the end of the singers' second verse signaling the start of the instrumental jam session that would unfold for the final two minutes of the song. I think the reason George Duke and David Sancious rarely get mentioned with the great sound-pioneers of the 1970s (like Jan Hammer, Chick Corea, or Herbie Hancock) is their tendency to explore/choose really odd sounds for their keys and guitars. (8.75/10)

3. "Hello Jeff" (5:16) this one definitely has both the JEFF BECK and RETURN TO FOREVER sound with Stanley in particular using those heavy, thick bass chords he became known for with Chick's band. The guitar shreding here (from Mr. Beck and recent discovery David Sancious [from Bruce Springsteen]) is other-wordly! I'm not a fan, however, of the sound rendering of Lenny White's drums--nor of the Al DI MEOLA-like main melody. The best parts of the tune are Jeff's solos and Stanley's finish. (8.875/10)

4. "Song to John, Part 1" (4:22) Chick Corea on piano, Stanley on his bowed double bass, and Mahavishnu John McLaughlin working his magic on an acoustic guitar. (Stanley must have received an "only if it's all acoustic" answer from the Mahavishnu when he asked for John's participation on this album's recording sessions--which would be in character for the Shakti-inspired guitarist at this time.) The song plays out like any/every John McLaughlin or Chick Corea song on acoustic instruments: virtuosic performances, great melodic sensibilities, and each artist inspiring the others to their highest levels of creativity. I just love all three of these artists when they're in acoustic mode! Chick's sense of melody is really so sublime--but so are those of Stanley and John--especially when supporting Chick in that fourth and fifth minute! (9.25/10)

5. "Song to John, Part 2" (6:09) the "lively" half of the suite--feels like a precursor to RTF's "The Romantic Warrior" (one of my ALL-TIME favorite songs!) from their upcoming album of the same name--though the second minute to the fourth has quite a little Django Reinhardt-Stéphane Grappelli energy and feel to it as well. How much fun must these guys have been having! Great jam! You will not find songs like these very often in the real world! (10/10)

6. "Concerto for Jazz/Rock Orchestra, Parts 1-4" (14:25) Messrs. Clarke, Duke, Sancious, and Gadd back for a gorgeous fifteen-minute suite--with the support of the full horn section in the (minutes). The opening three minutes is just synth, piano, and bass weaving a beautiful, contemplative atmosphere together to get the listener ready for . . . the "launch." At the three minute mark the full band jumps into electric world with bass, synth strings washes, Fender Rhodes, and drums creating a dynamic power motif within which David Sancious adds some searing lead guitar riffs in mini- crescendo moments. Things smooth out a bit in the sixth minute before George and Steve fall into support of a multi- sectional bass solo. (By multi-sectional I mean low end bass notes offset by high-end piccolo bass riffing.) This turns into more sustained searing electric guitar from David for about a minute in the ninth minute, culminating in a horn- section thickened section to fill the tenth minute--which leads to an odd break at 10:15 after which an AL DI MEOLA- like guitar-led Chick Corea patch ensues within which Stanley's machine gun bass play keeps up note for note with the same from David Sancious. The melody first exploded into the sonic field by the raging guitar-and-electric-bass duo is quite familiar but I can't place from where. The drumming in this "break out" passage are quite straight time rock 'n' roll as opposed to the rather funky, syncopated forms Steve was playing before the ten minute mark. The horns help amplify and multiply the fiery melody being ejaculated by David and Stanley until a crescendo and crashing trumpet scream at 12:15 re-opens the door for a very peaceful George Duke synth and electric piano after-the-storm section takes over to lead Stanley and the "strings" to a fadeout exit. A wild ride! Not so much a concerto as a RTF-like power suite! (27/30)

Total Time 39:21

Multi-instrumentalist David Sancious is quite a find! His guitar skills are virtuosic (as are his keyboard skills--as will be proved in near-future solo and collaborative albums) yet I've always felt that his sounds and melody choices are either too imitative of other greats of the era (like, here, Al Di Meola) or that they're too sweet, dense, or obtuse for me to ever be drawn into. However, here with Stanley he has found a partner who at least drives him to heights of the greats. George Duke feels too much the support mule on his three songs: rarely given the flashy solo time that David or Stanley himself take--which seems a waste. And Steve Gadd is great though sometimes feeling a bit the odd man out in terms of gelling perfectly within the weaves and styles set up by Stanley. For me, the Chick Corea-John McLaughlin- Stanley suite "Song for John" is the album's highlight with the opening song, as virtuosic and erudite as it is, proving to illustrate for me the fact that funk (my beloved funk) can be taken to outlandish extremes--barnyard, bawdy, or adolescent extremes.

A-/five stars; a display of creative song-making commensurate with the virtuosity of its participants. Perhaps not on quite as high or memorable of a level as some of the iconic themes and songs from the other Jazz-Rock Fusion classics of the time, but definitely fitting and deserving of the attention of any lover of virtuoso musicianship.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Dominion by IQ album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.15 | 172 ratings

BUY
Dominion
IQ Neo-Prog

Review by roelgrif

5 stars IQ's Dominion isn't just another entry in their storied discography?it's a declaration. A bold, emotionally charged, and musically expansive journey that might just be their finest hour. Or at least, their finest 53 minutes. It's rare for a band decades into their career to sound this vital, six long years after the previous album 'Resistance', but IQ have always played the long game, and with Dominion, they're playing it on their own terms.

The album opens with the monumental "The Unknown Door," and in doing so, throws down the gauntlet from the very first note. A 20-minute-plus tour de force, it might well be the band's greatest epic ever?a bold statement, but one that stands up under repeat listens. The beautiful horn intro, followed by Neville Chamberlain's unnerving war declaration speech, sets a tone of mystery and grandeur, like a curtain lifting on something vast and unknowable. After a 'rubato' vocal section, reminding me of the beginning of 'the road of Bones', the piece really lifts off at 5:00 with heavy rhythms and great guitar/synth work. Another escalation around 9:00 where the band moves into even heavier territory. Twelve minutes in, the track plunges into a breathtakingly intricate rhythmic section, a whirlwind of precision and tension that showcases the band at the height of their compositional powers. After a climax the horns return, announcing a more intimate section with vocals accompanied by accoustic guitar only, gradually building up to a more rhyhtmic section with Nicholls once again singing his favourite(?) lyric line consisting of just one word: 'Now', around 19:00 finally creating room for a wonderful symphonic and majestic ending, with a solemn, cathedral-sized church organ arriving to bring the piece to its emotionally towering conclusion, although the final seconds are again reserved for just the voice of Nicholls and the accoustic guitar of Holmes. This isn't just a song?it's a universe, and stepping through The Unknown Door changes how you hear the rest of the album.

"One of Us" follows with a more introspective, human-scale focus. Wrapped in melancholic melodies and Peter Nicholls' aching vocal delivery, it explores themes of belonging, exclusion, and quiet resilience. There's a sense of emotional gravity in its simplicity, making it one of the most quietly affecting moments on the record.

The mood turns sharper and more assertive in "No Dominion," a track that bristles with energy and defiance. As the title suggests, it plays like a direct counterpoint to the album's name?questioning power, identity, and legacy in a compact, driven burst. Neil Durant's synth textures shine here, adding a restless undercurrent that pushes the song into darker, edgier terrain without ever losing IQ's unmistakable melodic sensibility.

On "Far From Here," the band shifts into lyrical high gear, weaving wordplay and socio-political commentary into another haunting prog epic (stretching nearly 13 minutes). The standout line?"What if the right had nothing left, would the left get nothing right?"?crackles with ambiguity, wit, and relevance. Directional, ideological, and emotional meanings twist together, reflecting the confusion and contradiction of modern life. It's IQ at their smartest and most subtly confrontational.

The album closes with the sprawling, cinematic beauty of "Never Land." Part elegy, part promise, it builds slowly and confidently toward a shimmering, hopeful conclusion. It's the kind of song that doesn't just finish an album?it stays with you long after the final note. Glowing with layered instrumentation and emotional heft, it's a fitting final chapter to an album that feels like a journey, both outward and inward.

Musically, Dominion finds IQ in peak form. Mike Holmes' guitar work is expressive and precise, switching effortlessly between soaring leads and atmospheric textures. Neil Durant's keyboards are lush, intelligent, and emotionally attuned, while the rhythm section of Tim Esau and Paul Cook is as tight and inventive as ever. And at the center of it all, Peter Nicholls remains a singular presence?part narrator, part guide, always compelling.

Dominion is everything you would want from a modern progressive rock album: ambitious, intelligent, beautifully constructed, and emotionally resonant. IQ haven't just crafted a collection of songs?they've built a world. One with doors both known and unknown. And it all begins the moment you step through the first one.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Right On by BURNIN' RED IVANHOE album cover Studio Album, 1974
3.85 | 20 ratings

BUY
Right On
Burnin' Red Ivanhoe Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars The Danish band's fifth and final album before migrating over to the more-Jazz-Rock-oriented Secret Oyster.

1. "August Suicidal" (4:32) sounds like a slightly more sophisticated 1960s Eric Burdon with The Animals or Arthur Brown's Crazy World. Organ, racing drums, guitar, and bass with pompous male vocalist singing and screaming over the top. Interesting bass guitar solo in the third minute. (8.875/10)

2. "When I Look Into Your Eyes" (3:40) slow, polished 1960s psychedelic rock. They musicians are skilled and very disciplined, but I hear absolutely no elements in this song that would lead me to think, "Jazz-Rock Fusion." However, I greatly admire the control and maturity the band displays on this musical expression. (9/10)

3. "La BeautÊ Du Buste" (4:50) soprano saxophone, bass, and wah-wah-ed Fender Rhodes electric piano each soloing at the same time, forming an interesting and surprisingly palatable weave. Now, this could qualify for significant J-RF points--though there is nothing here that doesn't sound like it was inspired by Yes Fragile shorts or The Doors' L.A. Woman. (8.875/10)

4. "Make Me Look Away" (5:40) this one feels almost straight out of the American South: like a Doors venture into Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young; Arthur Lee's LOVE; The Eagles and Joe Walsh before they became one. The earliest Lynyrd Skynyrd. Very solid, great Southern Rock with one heck of a lead guitar sound (and, for that matter, that of the rhythm guitars, too) and skilled and passionate guitar soloing (from multiple guitars!). This could easily have been a major hit on FM radio stations in America! (10/10)

5. "Rockin' Rambler" (11:42) a cross between Creedence Clearwater Revival, Grand Funk Railroad, and Uriah Heep. More stellar sound production and mixing that fully and clearly captures the work of these talented musicians. The song itself is really just a 12-minute two-chord vamp within which Ole Fick sings (and talks) in his VAN MORRISON/JIM MORRISON/MICK JAGGER blended style while Karsten Vogel toots his alto sax along-side. The palette thins in the seventh minute while Ole and Karsten continue vamping. Kenneth Knudsen gets some shine on his Fender Rhodes in the tenth minute before a major slow down, space out takes over (though I can still feel/hear the "absent" two-chord vamp right up to Karsten's final squeak. (17.625/20)

6. "Tell Me" (5:20) back to the Eric Burdon & The Animals (or War) style and sound with Ole following the bass and sax's seven note rising scale melody line exactly during the verses. The choruses are a little more free and interesting, but those repeating verses get pretty irritating. Nice professional ROBIN TROWER-like guitar solo in the third and fourth minutes. A fine, polished performance of a somewhat weak composition. (8.75/10)

7. "Accident" (0:15) bloody nothing. Is the 15-second gap between songs the "accident."

8. "After The Carcrash" (3:00) treated electric guitars slowly weave their picked melodies with one another for the first 1:15. Then Karsten joins in with his plaintive sax. It's like a funereal dirge. Multiple sax tracks woven together are what take us out over the final minute. Kind of magical, that ending. (8.875/10)

Total time 38:59

No matter how finely crafted, performed, recorded, and produced these songs are (and there is a LOT of finery here) this album is in no way, shape, or form a Jazz-Rock Fusion album.

B/four stars; an excellent collection of finely rendered Southern Blues-Rock songs. Would have been great to play in rotation with my Rolling Stones, Doors, Uriah Heep, Crosby, Stills, Nash, Lynyrd Skynyrd, and Eric Burdon albums.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Lost Horizon by EYE 2 EYE album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.88 | 16 ratings

BUY
Lost Horizon
Eye 2 Eye Neo-Prog

Review by alainPP

4 stars "Garden of Eden" is a family breakup with a fierce vocal, and a rock rhythm behind it. The grating violin break is disorienting before the solo, followed by a religious vocal rise, reminiscent of Klaus NOMI, mantra-like and depressive. A striking heavy suite, interesting with its colorful dark prog side. "The Letter" has a nervous riff, a basic monolithic keyboard, a quest for an impossible love before the electronic musical space surfing ARAGON; a prog- metal rock mode with the depressive violin. "Meadows of Silence" with its metronomic title, punchy rock for the vocals and electro; a classical, religious break, a Dantesque explosion with the inhuman bombardment. Bruno's guitar solo amplifies the drama by letting the song drift into the dark finale, into a latent atmosphere.

"Lost Horizon (Ghosts Endgame)" in three parts; A chilling violin with the disappointment of the lonely hero ending his life and throwing his writings into the sea. A solemn, depressive air, the piano then the gravelly voice over a stern progressive rock; a neo-break with an expressive, narrated, Wallian, melancholic vocal. The variation with the martial percussion lets out a final languid guitar solo flirting with an excellent ANGE. "Tempest" as an instrumental interlude explains the opening of the lyrics and a beautiful velvety keyboard solo. A passing siren enhances the languid violin solo before the melting organ and then the nervous guitar. Will she decide to read these lyrics? The choirs arrive, the piano becomes austere, will it be read?

Eye 2 Eye did the job, a good job with a conceptual album on long cinematic, captivating passages, alternating softness and explosion reminiscent of PULSAR, PINK FLOYD, LACRIMOSA, with a unique and singular sound very endearing over the course of listening. origin on progcensor.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Sistema by EGO album cover Studio Album, 2014
3.53 | 19 ratings

BUY
Sistema
Ego Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by Finnforest
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars System Soundtrack

Ego is an instrumental trio from Varese who have now been around for two decades. Their fifth album Sistema (System) came out in 2014, and it is not a sound one might expect from the RPI bench. While there are occasional traces of RPI coming mostly from the romantic and melodic piano gracing several tracks, much of the album is almost like retro electronica that would not sound out of place blasted at a rave nor as the background soundtrack for a video game, making the album cover a perfect visual token for what you should expect. The synths are so brilliantly robust and layered and rich, complete and total ear candy. The bass is massive and forceful. The drumming is very much about propelling the vehicle forward, almost sounding like programmed beats sometimes, though I believe it is live drumming.

The songs can sound like pop music one moment but completely veer into the unknown at the drop of a hat. As mentioned, there is that sense that this could be soundtrack music to a video game, and it is music as constant movement and energy. The lack of vocals is so perfect for this album because it allows you to immerse more fully into the experiment. There are excursions from the pulsing synth-rock such as the brass-laden "Via Del Cairo," the gorgeous piano solo "Distrazione," and the 10-minute symphonic, cinematic "Petit Prince," very much the payoff pitch here, meticulously crafted and dreamy and dynamic. As our superb reviewer and friend Thomas wrote, this album "stretches the boundaries" of RPI. While not entirely my cup of tea, this album is sure to please fans of both retro and modern synth/key-heavy instrumental rock not straddled by the too-common jazz-fusion slant of other instrumental bands.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Esyllt by CHILDREN IN PARADISE album cover Studio Album, 2011
4.27 | 30 ratings

BUY
Esyllt
Children in Paradise Crossover Prog

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars The debut release of heavy, Gothic Celtic-oriented music from this French ensemble from Brétagne.

1. "Little Butterfly" (4:19) indescribably, deliciously seductive. Almost from the opening notes I am completely under their spell: both Dam Kat's voice and diction as well as the deeply-engaging music. What an opener! (10/10)

2. "King Arthur's Death" (7:37) both PORTISHEAD and RADIOHEAD come to mind with the opening of this song, but the power chords of the chorus and instrumental sections and smoldering hot electric guitar work on Pat O'May's solo belie a different, deeper element that cannot be compared with anyone that I can think of! (14/15)

3. "My Son" (6:05) with this song my comparisons of the dangerous, Siren-like singing talents of Ms. Millot are growing closer to those of Elizabeth Heaton (which is about as high praise as I can muster from the group of artists this 21st Century has to offer). A piano-founded song with more sultry-seductive vocals and fiery guitar pyrotechnics. The music, however, is a little too blues-rooted for my preferences. I love the injection of Uilleann pipes. Too bad it was saved only for the end. (8.875/10)

4. "The Battle" (7:44) the music here is a little more unpolished with several sound choices that seem to reach back to the 1980s and some questionable compositional and sound engineering choices. At times it feels as if Dam Kat's vocal track is getting buried by the levels and thickness of instruments. I find myself excited by the transition after Kat's "O happy" lyric to a fast-paced "Heavy Celtic Rock" motif--where the Uilleann pipes get a chance to shine again. Unfortunately, the section (including the vocal) play out as if something from a beginning garage band who've only learned a few simple early Black Sabbath chords.(13/15)

5. "Esyllt" (5:50) tender and ominous singing accompanied by piano play that sounds as if it comes from a dated computer-generated piano. When bass, drums, rhythm guitar chords, and harp join in at the end of the second minute things improve. I love the mix and presence of the harp. The music starts to ramp up, get heavier, while Kat's singing seems to sink its teeth into one's neck with increasing courage and conviction. Has the bite from a vampiress ever felt so welcome?! Incredible vocal performance! (8.875/10)

6. "Silent Agony" (6:02) another opening that reminds me of PORTISHEAD, the presence of harp from the very start is even more welcome and suggestive than on the previous song. On this song Kat's voice seems to lilt and flutter around the room like a butterfly. Or a bat. She is so talented! The music is rather simple rock but offering a nice palette of instrumental sound choices, which helps. Then you get another pretty nice guitar solo from Pat O'May to smooth things over in the third and fourth minutes. (8.875/10)

7. "Don't Forget Me" (6:58) though this song starts out rather unremarkably at the end of the third minute the band moves into a very cool, completely different and nuance-loaded motif--one that puts on display the more creative talents of the band's musicians. Kat begins singing again in the sixth minute in a rather conspiratorial kind of voice that reminds me of some of Rickie Lee Jones' early tender vocals. It ends up being one of the album's stronger songs. (13.75/15)

8. "I'm Not Scared" (5:08) Uilleann pipes and low organ chord notes introduce this palette just before Kat enters singing in what is almost an a cappella stage musical style. Early Robin Guthrie guitar chords begin keeping time while Kat switches to her upper registers. Metal power chords enter with drums and active deep bass while Kat oscillates from airy upper voice to lower sultry. Another pretty unique yet engaging song. (8.875/10)

9. "Look Around You" (7:26) the highlights of this rather sedate almost-Americana-like song are 1) the parts where Kat provides her own angelic, k.d. lang-like harmony background vocals, 2) Pat's Steve Vai-like guitar solo in the fifth minute, and 3) Kat's clear investment in her vocal's delivery of the song's message in the sixth minute. Enchanting. (13.375/15)

10. "I'm Alive" (7:06) Unfortunately, there is nothing very special, inventive, or engrossing about this song (except for maybe the dreamy keyboard work). Even Kat's vocal fails to engage or hook me (and I can't really figure out why). Nice bass-and-drum rhythm pattern created in the fifth minute. (13.25/15)

Total Time 64:15

A-/4.5 stars; a very intriguing and promising debut album--one whose emotional music is very difficult to categorize. Highly recommended for all you other progheads to judge for yourselves.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 3000 Miles Away by GRANCHER, PHILIPPE album cover Studio Album, 1975
3.75 | 15 ratings

BUY
3000 Miles Away
Philippe Grancher Crossover Prog

Review by SliprKC70

4 stars Philippe Grancher's sole piece of work, 3000 Miles Away, caught my attention when I saw the album's unique artwork. I had it under my radar since late 2024, but only recently did I get around to listening to it. This album has such a fantastical approach to progressive rock, and it overall expands mainly on minimalist and electronic ideas. The first half of this album is the side that exercises these approaches. The three compositions found on side one feel like multi-sectioned pieces that switch between ambience and classical harmonies that are full of depth, emotion, and a strangely satisfying and pleasing feel and sound. Each of the tracks feels as if they connect into this mythical world of a lost art Philippe created on this record, and each number, while remaining consistent in the original sound he made, always brings a different perspective on what was found in the passages before it. It's a real shame he never expanded on this form of music again after his career, because he had real potential, as shown here.

Side two also has incredibly good points on here. It brings in more rock themes and introduces dynamics between the low and moody characteristics found on side one and this new jazzy, folk, and conventional work on side two. The progressive nature of some sections feels otherworldly at points, and in combination with the climate, it makes for some great sections. However, throughout the album, I felt some of the sections were a bit too disconnected and short. Because I don't have a physical copy, I had to go off online platforms, and it was hard for me to tell when one song ended and one song began because each song has at least one shift of musical direction midway through. And unlike side one (which would shift in terms of the material being played but never too far from the past passages), it feels to me that these parts could've stayed more consistent. Ignoring this problem, though, side two is also pretty strong.

In conclusion, I don't think there is a single album out there that is quite like this one. It is legitimately 3000 miles away from any other work! I was fascinated by the authentic music Phillipe made for his testament to time. It has its flaws here and there, but overall this is an exceptionally excellent album that has many positive aspects to it. While this is far from an essential progressive rock album, I still recommend listening to it for the experience. This is in between a 3.75/5 and a straightforward 4/5 for me.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Transmutation by KARMAKANIC album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.13 | 113 ratings

BUY
Transmutation
Karmakanic Symphonic Prog

Review by tszirmay
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Jonas Reingold I have seen perform with the Flower Kings as well as with Steve Hackett and he had me shivering with delight, as he is without any doubt among the top bassists in music today. While I did review the Karmakanic debut and quite enjoyed that one, I only paid slight attention to the follow ups , the tasty 'Who is the Boss in the Factory' and 'Dot' (with which I could not connect -pun intended) . On this stellar release, the material seems to be much stronger , with some memorable pieces and the usual splendid playing and highly enjoyable vocals. The only average detail is the perfunctory cover art which reveals little of the pleasures inside, but Jonas does have a nice face .

With a perfect title like "Bracing for Impact", do not expect an ambient xylophone lullaby , but rather a volatile onslaught of gruesome Andy Tillison organ surges, assassin-based bass guitar meanderings from the maestro and incessant drum bashing of the highest order that last 2 and a half minutes and gets all the juices flowing. Keyboardist Lalle Larsson and Krister Jonsson add impressive details to the opening salvo.

Next up is not only a masterpiece track , on the verge of becoming a classic with more airplay, the mesmerizing beauty of "End of the Road" possesses all the ingredients to be a gourmet prog epic. Absolutely every second has staying power, seduction, and melodic content. Geri Schuller defines the ravishing theme on piano (which will take a bow at the end as well), the platform for Simon Phillips to decorate his syncopating technique, Luke Machin showcasing both acoustic and electric guitars, and a vocal barrage of the highest order : Randy McStine and John Mitchell trading the microphone, expressing the 'days of wonder' of 'the end of the road' with succinct passion. Jonas keeps everything nice and tidy as befits a musician of his stature (the images of his red Rickenbacker will remain forever imprinted on my soul). The acoustic guitar reprise with the piano is two steps from heaven genius as the theme detonates for another, more tectonic recap, Machin swerving madly on his lead guitar showcase. I have been humming this melody even in my sleep. You will too. One of the finest tracks for 2025 and beyond.

Craig Blundell takes over the kit on stunning "Cosmic Love", with John on the vocal, Randy on the guitar with Jonas handling the pulse, layering a great harmony chorus to boot, as once again the melody is immediately engrained into the mind of the listener. A slight hint of Spooky Tooth's classic oldie "The Mirror", which is a major compliment. The next trio of pieces could have been a suite loosely put together , as the overall style is similar. "We Got the World in our Hands" has Simon back on the drum stool, John playing a sensational 12 string acoustic and singing, with Jonas twirling in the background. Easy to follow with a few twists into creative sidebars, an inspirational chorus that sounds most comfortable and Krister peeling off an oblique run on his fretboard.

"All That Glitters Is Not Gold" incorporates old pal Tomas Bodin on keyboards, with addition of guest flute, saxophone and accordion, Jonas whipping out his fretless bass for our pleasure. Another crushingly attractive melody solidifies the chorus , that sonically widens with powerful riffs courtesy of Jonsson's axe technique that give off a darker atmosphere that is most welcome. Rob Townsend plays the sax part with his usual aplomb, with Blundell propelling like a turbo charged speedboat.

Original Karmakanic vocalist Goran Edman handles the bluesy "Gotta Lose this Ball and Chain" with his intricate growly voice supported with plenty of backing vocalisms, the molten riffs and athletic drums (Phillips) verging on Led Zeppelin and once again, lest I repeat myself, a theme that sticks the landing immediately! Guest guitarist Sven Cirnski rips a solo that hits the mark, and the finale is a showstopper. Another delicious chapter of this amazing release.

The title track is the coup de grace (please, it's a French word, its pronounced 'coo de grass') takes the exalted listener on a magical 23-minute progressive rock exploration that seeks the raise even further a most lofty bar. Throughout its length, many guests get to shine: Lalle Larsson, Andy Tillison, Geri Schuler, Tomas Bodin and Roger King show their keyboard skills, Steve Hackett shows up on his patented nylon acoustic for a brief spot, along with Jan-Olof Jonsson on acoustic and Krister taking another lead solo flight, Nick D'Virgilio manning the drum side of things , Rob on sax, and the amazing Dina Hoblinger trading the lead vocal with John, with backing help from Amanda Lehmann. Jonas does his reputation proud with some scintillating interventions on his instrument. Do not worry, this mammoth track flows like a majestic iceberg in glacial waters, at times gleaming, then shimmering, always glimmering, unafraid to boldly veer from prog to symphonics on a dime and a jazzy piano spotlight from Schuler this side of Herbie Hancock. The vocals are spectacular, the lyrics deep and the overall tempo is next level genius. Roine, this is a modern epic!

An extraordinary addition to this year's top of the podium finalists for 2025, one of easiest five-star attributions ever. This finely-tuned Prog automobile needs zero repairs or maintenance.

5 conversions

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Second Thoughts by BROERS + KLAZINGA album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.01 | 22 ratings

BUY
Second Thoughts
Broers + Klazinga Neo-Prog

Review by bartymj

1 stars I usually wouldn't take the time to write bad reviews but I feel compelled to here. Track 7 describes accurately my humble opinion of those that have gushed about this album so far.

The album is built around overly simplistic synth passages which can mostly be played with a single finger, and a rinse- and-repeat composition where every track is an attempt at building an atmosphere around a basic ballad and including one of the aforementioned synth passages and a final bit of Floydian (in style but not in likeability) guitar. The worst part is the lyrics. I commend anyone willing to have a go at writing lyrics not in their native tongue, but it often results in an incredibly simplistic and often not scanning result - no different to me attempting to write an intricate and passionate love song with my C in GSCE German and the help of google translate. At times the lyricism makes you physically cringe - see The Mirror for one of the most sickening ballads I've ever heard.

The end result is an incredibly derivative attempt at a neo-prog rock opera. Even for fans of neo-prog, 80s synth, or the symphonic pomp, there are dozens and dozens of far better modern efforts out there.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Breakfast in Biarritz by ARENA album cover Live, 2001
3.80 | 99 ratings

BUY
Breakfast in Biarritz
Arena Neo-Prog

Review by VianaProghead
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Review Nē 891

"Breakfast In Biarritz" is the second live album of Arena and that was released in 2001. While their previous debut live album "Welcome To The Stage", which was released in 1997, was totally focused on their first two studio albums "Songs From The Lion's Cage" and "Pride", this their new live release was essentially focused on their newest two studio albums, their third and fourth, "The Visitor" released in 1998 and "Immortal?" released in 2000, respectively.

The name of the album "Breakfast In Biarritz", might be slightly a bit confused because this live album was recorded at the Paradiso, Amsterdam, Holland on Tuesday 17th October 2000, during the European of their "Immortal?" live tour, and not in France. The title of the album refers the place where the band had a day of during the "Immortal?" live tour.

"Breakfast In Biarritz" has ten tracks plus four bonus tracks. The second track "Crack In The Ice", the third track "Double Vision", the fifth track "Serenity", the seventh track "The Hanging Tree", the eighth track "A State Of Grace" and the ninth track "Enemy Without", are all live versions of tracks recorded on their third studio album "The Visitor" that was released in 1998. The first track "Moviedrome" and the sixth track "The Butterfly Man" are two live versions of tracks recorded on "Immortal?" that was released in 2000. The fourth track "Midas Vision" is a live version of a track recorded on their debut studio album "Songs From The Lion's Cage" that was released in 1995. The tenth track "Crying For Help VII" is a live version of a track recorded on their second studio album "Pride" that was released in 1996.

So, as I mentioned above, with the exception of "Midas Vision" and "Crying For Help VII", all tracks on "Breakfast In Biarritz" are from their albums "The Visitor" and "Immortal?", which are in general considered two of their best studio albums, in what I also agree. About the performance on the album, and as happened with their debut live album "Welcome To The Stage", there's no real live atmosphere because the pieces are interpreted very closely to the studio original. There are hardly any variations, either in terms of content or sound. But, the performance is good and some of the pieces are really fun, such as "Crack In The Ice", "Midas Vision" and the rocked version of "Crying For Help VII".

"Breakfast In Biarritz" has two CD's. The CD 1 has the ordinary tracks. The CD 2 has the four bonus tracks, three live versions of three studio songs plus an Arena's documentary. The first track "Chosen" and the third track "Friday's Dream" are live versions of two tracks recorded on "Immortal?". The second track "Elea" is a live version of a track released on "The Visitor". The fourth track is a multimedia section with over thirty minutes of live footage, the history of Arena and interviews with all band's members. It was originally made for French Television and its quality is very good.

When inserting the second bonus CD into your computer, it will automatically start the Internet Explorer, play an intro tune and will offer you several options. You can visit the Verglas and Arena sites or the site of Legend Productions, the company who produced the interactive section, or you can drop to these companies an e-mail. However, the most interesting thing on this part of the second CD is the fact that you can start the documentary about the group instantly.

The documentary is nicely designed with lots of floating images, flipping collages and even an animated version of the "Immortal?" CD covers. In this documentary, the band's members, mainly the two founding members Clive and Mick, take you through the history of the group, the writing process, portraits of the band's members and speak about their new album "Immortal?". These interviews are shot backstage at a concert, in a pub and in what I think is Clive's Thin Ice Studio. The story is alternated with footage of the band live on stage or sound checking. Although, some of the music is completely unrelated to the period or albums discussed, and therefore it's somehow a bit out of context with the real historical perspective, which is a shame. Unfortunately, all the footage also features the new line up, which is comprehensive, but I preferred to see some film material with the right lines up, because as it's a documentary about all group's history, I would like to see some film material with the right lines up. Anyway, this is an interesting thing to see.

Conclusion: The second live offering from Arena is as good as the first one is. Like with their debut live album, the track selection for this live set is also excellent. All their studio albums, until that moment, are represented here with one track from "Songs From The Lion's Cage" and one track from "Pride", and where their greatest masterpiece "The Visitor" is amply represented with six out of ten tracks from that album, besides the two excellent tracks from "Immortal?". So, "Breakfast In Biarritz" is like "Welcome To The Stage" an excellent album, despite the changes on the line up of the group. Both new band's members Rob Sowden and John Mitchell are perfectly well on it. Mitchell is truly an amazing guitarist and together with Nolan, he is the brightest star in the band. Sowden made a great job especially when he had to sing songs originally performed by Paul Wrightson and John Carson. This is highly recommended.

Prog is my Ferrari. Jem Godfrey (Frost*)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Who Do We Think We Are by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1973
3.04 | 657 ratings

BUY
Who Do We Think We Are
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by Hector Enrique
Prog Reviewer

3 stars By the end of 1972 and with worldwide recognition on their shoulders after the hugely successful 'Machine Head' and the stratospheric live album 'Made in Japan', the pressure from Deep Purple's managers to continue taking advantage of the band's state of grace did nothing but add fuel to the fire to the already deteriorated relationship between its members and it seemed to matter little that Ritchie Blackmore barely exchanged a word with Ian Gillan. And it was in the midst of this critical and forced situation that the band released 'We Do We Think We Are' (1973), their seventh album.

A proposal that, although it doesn't have as memorable and forceful pieces as 'Machine Head', has some rescuable moments of unquestionable value, such as the rocking 'Woman From Tokyo', the tribute to the great receptivity that the British had on their excursions to Japan, and the only single from the album, Blackmore's zeppelin-like riffs combined with Lord's huge keyboard display in the powerful 'Rat But Blue', and the great guitar solo of the man in black over Roger Glover's bass lines in the robust blues 'Place in Line'.

A step below are the agile and lilting developments of 'Mary Long', 'Super Trouper' and 'Smooth Dancer', which move towards a more conventional classic rock, and the grandiloquent and intoned 'Our Lady', which does not seem to be part of the sound frequency of the purple universe recognisable at that time.

Once the recording of the album was finished and in the middle of the umpteenth promotional tour, Gillan resigned in writing (that's how difficult things were) from the band, accompanied in the decision by Glover. This was the end of Deep Purple's most successful line-up (Mark II) until their reunion eleven years later on 1984's 'Perfect Strangers'.

3/3.5 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Lucro Sucio: Los Ojos del Vacío by MARS VOLTA, THE album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.58 | 39 ratings

BUY
Lucro Sucio: Los Ojos del Vacío
The Mars Volta Heavy Prog

Review by Prog/Land

3 stars As a big fan of The Mars Volta's old work, and having paid little attention to their newer stuff, I really didn't know what to expect going into this record. To get straight to the point, I thought it was pretty good. Nothing felt revolutionary like Frances the Mute, but that doesn't mean the album was bad. I really enjoyed a large portion of it. I also appreciate the album writing style of a bunch of shorter songs that flow together smoothly. It's not talked about a lot, but the way prog bands choose to divide up songs on their releases directly affects the listener's experience with that release. It tells a story when one half of a complete song is titled differently from the second half, and the only way to know they are two halves of a whole is to listen to them back-to-back. That being said, I didn't find a ton on the album to grab onto. It was really just a lot of nice moments that flowed well, and not much more. I think I have to give this a 6.5 or 7 out of 10.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Väistyy Mielen Yö by VIIMA album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.20 | 80 ratings

BUY
Väistyy Mielen Yö
Viima Prog Folk

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars It's been 15 years since we last heard from Finland's own VIIMA. Yet this latest album has a lot in common with the previous release from 2009. One lineup change, but it's a big one as the original keyboardist has left, although he guests on one track here. He was replaced with the new male vocalist who also adds keyboards and mellotron. The previous male singer is still here, he's just sticking to his flute and adds some keyboards, backing vocals and the spoken words on the closer. These last two albums have much less to do with folk than the debut. And these both are more symphonic and rocking at times. But that folk element is still here mainly with the style of those reserved Finnish male vocals which I'm not all in on.

That 2006 debut is one of my favourite releases out of Finland, and an automatic entry into my "best of" folk list when I do that. It has female vocals and more of a nordic vibe to my ears. I just love it. These last two aren't in that league in my opinion, but most feel they are better, so there's that. Depends on your musical taste. This most recent record is worth over 44 minutes, over five tracks.

We get the mammoth, almost 19 minute second track that is the centrepiece. The opener did bring back memories of the debut in the sense that it starts out folky with the flute, then reserved vocals. So it's a surprise when we get an electric guitar solo after 3 1/2 minutes. That's what I remember from the debut. Those folky female vocals and flute before out of nowhere electric guitar. That is where the similarities end between the debut and the two that follow. "Perhonen" is one of my favourite songs on here. How good does this sound at 3 minutes. Vocals join in quickly though. A nice sounding rhythm section with vocals over top. A guitar solo too before 5 minutes.

That third track "Pitkat Jaahyvaiset" is perhaps my favourite for the mellotron and surprising heaviness. It actually gets dark on this one, plus I like the synths as well. The closer is where the former keyboardist returns with some keyboard work plus the opening and closing wind sounds. Apparently viima means wind. An appropriate way to end the album. Mellotron on this one as well. I won't say much about that epic track other than it has it's highs and lows, a mixed bag, but an interesting ride for sure. Overall I like it, just like I like this recording. Nice comeback guys! A solid 4 stars.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Clann by SOLSTICE album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.04 | 42 ratings

BUY
Clann
Solstice Neo-Prog

Review by tszirmay
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars Proud owner of all eight studio albums, this veteran band proves the famous adage that time waits for no one, having launched their career in 1984 (hi, George!) with the still lovely after all these years "Silent Dance" release. Then came "New Life" in 1992 and "Circles" in 1997. With guitarist Andy Glass leading the band through a bevy of altering lineups, including the brief presence of the celebrated Clive Bunker on that final recording, the band suddenly found itself at a crossroads , unable or unwilling to fight o, desperately in need of a reflective pause and resource some creativity. Thirteen years went by in quiet anonymity, Andy gathering around him players that still form the band today: sensational violin and viola player Jenny Newman, Steve McDaniel on keyboards as well as the perennial rhythmic duo of Robin Phillips on bass and drummer Pete Hemsley. The album "Spirit" not only reignited their career but was a wonderfully solid progressive album that excited the prog world immensely. From the whopping opening tune in "Salomon's Bridge", to the epic title track, their redefined sound lit quite the fire, that continues to this day. Four more gloriously tasty albums followed, the stupendous "Prophecy" in 2013, the lush 2020 "Sia", the luminous "Light Up" in 2022 and now "Clann" in 2025. The latter three albums feature the lovely and talented Jess Holland on lead vocals and complete the Sia trilogy. All that patience and hard work has paid off handsomely, as Solstice reigns supreme in the prog world, love by critics and fans alike for their resolute courage in believing in their craft! Their concerts are ebullient affairs full of positive feelings , a trait desperately in need of today.

"Firefly" spirals like glittering insects in the early evening darkness, providing electric excitement, a smooth 'light up' groove that would embolden even the dourest of souls, Jenny' violin fluttering mightily, the vocals from Jess Holland this side of gently seductive , a solid bass and drum foundation, colored by McDaniel's keyboard pastels . And here is what makes this band so special, everything displayed is deliriously smooth and velvety , until Glass enters the fray boldly, very much like Carlos Santana in his heyday, taking over the arrangement and making his guitar soar and emote like no tomorrow. A folkier side of Camel, mixed with some incisive axe manipulations.

Keeping the upbeat positive vibe, the shuffling and breezy "Life" comes across as a complex simplicity, interwoven grooves that eventually build up into more atmospheric pools of reflection, learning to breathe and enjoy the ride. When the symphonics kick in with the violin/viola led orchestrations, it is clear to anyone that this piece is exceptional. Glass launches this into a restrained shadow with a slow-paced crescendo before reverting to the original expansive pace. The harmony vocals from Ebony Buckle and Dyanne Crutcher only adds to the joy.

Deciding that having fun is always a good thing, the brassy funk-rock of "Plunk" comes as a bit of surprise, very addictive with clever lyrics and a very urban American style, sunshine warming the air. Glass delivers an almost Holdsworthian flurry of notes from his screeching guitar , backing vocals in full tow, including some chanting choruses at the end. Surely fun in a live setting !

From Funky town to Bluesville, "Frippa" is not an homage to the Crimson King but a rock song full of choppy riffs, stop and start pacing, rippling Hammond bursts , a swirling violin and impressive vocalizations from Jess and the girls. A synthesizer solo a la Foss Patterson (Camel) takes briefly over, before Glass goes ballistic on his fretboard with a blistering fireball of notes, another violin spot for Jenny to shine on , and all converge to the fold for the finale.

"Twin Peaks" is not only the final piece but also an epic 14-minute jewel that crowns this album with high marks, as it's a stunner! The first three minutes are an introduction to a shimmering celestial portal, where acoustic guitars, exquisite violin and divine vocals coexist in complete adoration. A breathtaking melody helps the cause. The repeated 'come away' chorus from the feminine trio is a soothing balm of panacea that seduces profoundly, taking this second level even higher. Andy kicks it further up the ladder, with an emotive display, all sense and sensibilities. With a third variation being an electronic transition that defies expectations, the dreamy echo of a pained voice amid the bubbly synths becomes another moment of bliss. The fourth level introduces a nearly Oldfieldian vocal feel, genuinely intoxicating and hypnotic, taking the listener to another galaxy, with drums beating in the valley below. The circle is complete with the glowing reprise of the main 'come away' melody, and I must say, if this leaves anyone indifferent, and ear doctor (or in proggy terms, an otolaryngologist) would be of great benefit. Fluffy synthesizer clouds put this incredible piece to bed. I am on my knees, in reverent fulfillment! This final track will surely go down as one of the most intriguing and beguiling pieces of 2025, hands down. 4.5 tribes

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Alive and Kicking by UNITOPIA album cover Live, 2025
4.91 | 3 ratings

BUY
Alive and Kicking
Unitopia Crossover Prog

Review by tszirmay
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Well, I guess the presence of legendary drummer Chester Thompson explains away the title, as it immediately shines light on that Simple Minds tune, whose powerhouse drumming from Mel Gaynor really made a huge difference in forging that band's sound. Combine the equally heralded Don Schiff's tremulous stick and you wind up with a rhythm section for the gods , propelling a sprawling cavalcade of progressive epics. With members from around the globe , this incredible 2 CD album comes with a Blu-ray DVD , the ideal tool to enjoy a live experience, whereby the listener is visually stimulated as well, in the comfort of their own home. Recorded at the Boerderij in Zoetermeer in the Netherlands on September 12, 2023. By watching this event, you can almost say you were there!

Their latest studio album ,2023's "Seven Chambers" was a hugely successful release, universally anointed as a 'chef oeuvre' for the genre, espousing all the attributes that make progressive rock so compelling: passion, atmosphere and melodies galore. Shepherded by a cast of stellar instrumentalists that form the Unitopian core , namely surgical guitarist Dr. John Greenwood, Sean Timms on the keyboards as well as Steve Unruh's soaring violin sorties , Mark Trueack's impressive vocal delivery seals the deal. Five songs were played from that 'heartstoppingly' gorgeous album, as well as pieces from their past discography, namely the epics "Mania" and the sprawling "the Uncertain" on the first CD . On the second one, "Tesla" (the scientist not the car) is a highlight , as well as the magnificent masterpiece "The Garden ", that takes you into a dense 24-minute botanical voyage into celestial realms, a definite highlight of this concert. And what better title that "the Great Reward" to close off the concert in classy style. This writer usually chooses to elaborate on each track specifically, in order to diver into the creative specifics but as a rule, live albums should be written about in terms that highlight the event and not qualities that were surely dissected in the original studio creation.

What makes Unitopia so special is their lovingly crafted talent in combining solid progressive rock foundational elements that we all know and love ,with sprinklings of jazz-fusion (namely that wicked Jean-Luc Ponty-esque violin from Unruh) , world music tinges and some of the finest vocals anywhere on the globe, sung with unabashed power and passion. Lyrics have always been a strong addition to their music, covering that perennial labyrinth of insanity known as the human condition, with a current critique of our opinion-fueled 'modern reality' that still espouses harmony and hope for a better future.

In closing , no mincing of words or pussyfooting (as Fripp and Eno once clamored), "Alive and Kicking" is hands down one of the finest live albums ever foisted on the prog community. A mantle worthy addition to any collection, do yourself a favor and get a copy ! 5 simple minds

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Heritage by HENDERSON, EDDIE album cover Studio Album, 1976
4.50 | 8 ratings

BUY
Heritage
Eddie Henderson Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Co-opting the "Oakland sound" of Paul Jackson-Mike Clark--the rhythm section that Herbie Hancock had been using on his post Head Hunters Headhunters albums (Thrust and Man-Child)--is an indisputably brilliant idea. Add Patrice Rushen, Julian Priester, and Mtume and you have the formula for instant magic.

1. "Inside You" (4:49) reminds me quite a little of FREDDIE HUBBARD's wonderful version of The Stylistics' "People Make the World Go Round" from Polar AC, his final album for Creed Taylor's CTI production team. Like Hubbard's song, this is soothingly hypnotic with some nice ARP synth strings work from Patrice Rushen throughout. (8.875/10)

2. "Acuphuncture" (3:42) there is no mistaking the Smooth Jazz influence of GEORGE BENSON's recent MONSTER hit, Breezin' on this one. Nicely melodic and funky in an early Smooth Jazz kind of way. (8.875/10)

3. "Time & Space" (5:16) a beautiful and contemplative opening to this one opens the door for some great play from Eddie and Patrice. I feel a bit sad for the constrictive restraints spirited bass player Paul Jackson finds himself under. Great soprano sax work from Hadley Caliman. Still, this is an eminently enjoyable Smooth Jazz tune. A top three song for me. Patrice Rushen's multiple instrument contributions should not go without appropriate praise. (9.3333/10)

4. "Nostalgia" (4:10) Yes, sometimes you just can't help but go back to reminisce--which, of course, conjures up inspiration for new songs from the spirit of 1917-73 and the Mwandishi-Crossroads-Sextant-Realization sessions with Herbie and the gang. I love this though it's not very dynamic or fresh. (8.875/10)

5. "Kudu" (6:07) a slow sustained intro leading into a very funky motif started by Paul Jackson's bass at the one-minute mark reveals a song that is very fitting to the Miles Davis school of jazz-rock fusion. Nice clavinet and trumpet accents and flourishes during the next 90 seconds before there is a James Brown-like R&B bridge that shifts the band into support for an even-wilder Miles-like performace from Eddie. Patrice Rushen's electric piano work beneath is so lively that it threatens to distract from Eddie's superlative outbursts. Then Paul Jackson seems to take over at the end of the fifth minute with Patrice amplifying her rhythm guitar-like clavinet play to take us out. Despite the similarities in sound and style to those of 1970s Miles Davis, this is a great Jazz-Funk tune! (9.75/10)

6. "Dr. Mganga" (7:29) the Swahili name that Eddie self-adopted while living in the Mwandishi world, the band pull together a very full, very active, very funky motif that feels as if it's incorporating a variation on Eumir Deodato's "Also Sprach Zarathustra (2001)" My other top three song. (14/15)

7. "Dark Shadow" (6:54) opens with Hadley Caliman playing bass clarinet sounding like a cross between Herbie's "Hidden Shadows" and Weather Report's "Birdland." Eddie throws in a "Nature Boy"-like melody with his muted trumpet to add to the mut-like mélange feeling of this tune. Julian Priester's contributions on trombone in the second and third minutes is awesome. (I've always loved trumpet and trombone way more than that of any saxophone or clarinet.) Patrice Rushen is also doing some very clever and interesting things beneath the horn soloists. The main bass-and-bass clarinet "Birdland" melody playing beneath it all, however, begins to feel a bit worn out: by the time we're approaching the end (which is, thankfully, quite dynamic) I've about had enough of it. Even Patrice and drummer Billy Hart seem to go to sleep around this point--and then, in the middle of the sixth minute, they do! They crash! Everything falls apart: rubbernecks before popping back to action. Unfortunately, they choose to just pick up the same parts they were all playing--the very ones that brought on the group narcoleptic fit! Not my favorite--and a sad way to close an album (cuz it leaves me with a sour feeling of disappointment). (13/15)

Total Time 38:27

Despite Eddie's tendency to "borrow" themes from other songs/artists in order to start/build his own songs, I cannot ignore the contributions to the progression of Jazz-Rock Fusion that Eddie Henderson and his collaborators have made.

A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of Jazz-Rock Fusion that falls into the category of early Smooth Jazz.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Exposed by OLDFIELD, MIKE album cover Live, 1979
3.91 | 122 ratings

BUY
Exposed
Mike Oldfield Crossover Prog

Review by martindavey87

3 stars 'Exposed' is the first live album by British musician and composer Mike Oldfield (or second if you count 'The Orchestral Tubular Bells' as a live album). It was released in 1979, and features 'Incantations' and 'Tubular Bells' in their entirety.

And that, essentially, is this album in a nutshell. The musical performances are of an excellent standard, as would be expected, and the sound is incredible. In fact, the sound is so clear, I often forget this is a live album, mistakenly thinking I'm listening to their studio counterparts.

But in all honesty, I'm not really that keen on the 'Incantations' album, and while I do like 'Tubular Bells', it's very rarely, if ever, a record I choose to listen to. And if I'm going to listen to either, it's going to be the studio album. There's an additional track, of Mike's foray into disco music with the awesome 'Guilty', but that's not enough to win me over either.

Therefore I can't really give this release more than a three-star rating. It's good, but it's not an album I'm likely to ever play again. There are just so many other Mike Oldfield albums I'd rather listen to.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Svitanie by BLUE EFFECT (MODRŨ EFEKT) album cover Studio Album, 1977
4.36 | 206 ratings

BUY
Svitanie
Blue Effect (Modrũ Efekt) Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Despite carrying forward only two of the band's founding members, this is the sixth studio album using the "Blue Effect / Modry Efekt" monikers.

1. "Vysoká Stolička, Dlhũ Popol / High Chair, Long Ashes" (10:12) sounds like a cross between early (pre-Wakeman) Yes and early Emerson, Lake and Palmer with some strains of Focus, Eloy, Hawkwind, Nektar, and Camel (and even a little Gentle Giant and Colosseum) thrown in there in equal parts. A song that seems to have thoughtful construction but at times may not express a cohesive, coherent purpose--often feels incomplete or unfinished--as if they were waiting for the arrival of one more band member who might provide the "missing piece" that would/could make this feel complete. Nice sound--with great engineering--of nice performances; it just feels as if it's lacking . . . a purpose, a raison d'ętre. (17.875/20)

2. "Ej, Padá, Padá Rosenka / Dew Is Falling, Falling" (6:36) a FOCUS-like opening with some searing Steve Howe-like guitar flurries turns even more FOCUS-like when the band settles into a church-like organ-based vocal section at the end of the first minute. The sound and styles of Radim Hladík's guitar wavers between those of 1972 Robert Fripp and 1972 Jan Akkerman. The singer's voice sounds a bit strained. All in all it is still an impressive and enjoyable song. (9/10)

3. "V Sobotu Popoludní / On Saturday Afternoon" (4:15) the band starts off in third gear and then proceeds to build a cool BILLY COBHAM-like tune. The insistence of the tandem bass-and-drum lines is clear and undeniable. The next motif sounds a lot like some of Italian band AREA's driving music from Crac! or even some of the peak J-RF from the likes of Lenny White or Tony Williams circa 1975-6. My favorite song on the album (probably because it is really the one that is the most genuinely founded in Jazz-Rock Fusion). (10/10)

4. "Svitanie / Dawning" (19:35) long, prolonged spacious organ and bass guitar intro is supported by electric guitar, synth, and cymbal incidentals. I like this! It's like a church processional. Radim's volume-controlled guitar notes are quite Jan Akkerman-like. The vocals and synth work that arrives in the fourth minute and builds into some YES-and- JON ANDERSON-like sounds is pretty cool--especially if you don't mind such blatant imitation of the great Brits. Here one can recognize that those volume-controlled guitar notes are really more akin to Steve Howe's work. At the end of the sixth minute there is a spacious bridge to a new variation of the organ-and-bass motif, with more gentle and sporadic cymbal support before Fedor leads the song into a different direction--one that become more blues-rock based. The blues rock motif provides Radim the impetus and inspiration for a pretty awesome bottleneck solo on his guitar (though it could be a pedal steel guitar). Then there is a patch with some chunky bass and drum soloing. The sound quality throughout is impeccable even if this is not my favorite style or sound of music (and not even close to what I consider "Jazz-Rock Fusion"). The guitar soloing turns full-on rock 'n' roll. At the 11-minute mark acoustic guitar takes over the lead play over bass chords and new church organ sounds. Nice play from Radim. The next solo (in the thirteenth minute) still feels like guitar, only one that is very uniquely effected. Then, in the fourteenth minute, Radim bursts out with his loudest Jan Akkerman sound to try to outrun the master. In the fifteenth minute there are multiple instruments all soloing against, with, and off of one another for very short bursts of time, with Radim switching from sound to sound until settling onto a trumpet-like volume-controlled sound for the rest of that minute, and then moving back to some sounds that are quite familiar to us lovers of JAN AKKERMAN's work on "Answers? Questions! Questions? Answers!" I like Radim's ballsy inspiration. He's obviously quite talented. Even though very pleasant group vocals enter in the 19th minute to help bookend and guide the song to an end, the song seems too blatantly set up for Radim to rather-conceitedly show off his skills (and toys). (17.75/40)

Total Time 40:38

I just have to say that if this is Jazz-Rock Fusion then so is Focus, Yes, Lark's Tongues in Aspic, and Änglagård.

A/five stars; though not necessarily fresh or unique music, I cannot deny the masterpiece quality of the performances and skills displayed on this album. The bulk of this music, however, feels more like skilled progressive rock music than Jazz-Rock Music.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Omni by KARFAGEN album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.24 | 98 ratings

BUY
Omni
Karfagen Symphonic Prog

Review by MalenaRoss

5 stars Wow? just wow. OMNI completely blew me away. From the very first notes, I felt like I was being taken on a journey through space, time, and memory. This album is melody in its purest form ? beautiful, rich, layered ? and every song feels like a chapter in some epic musical story.

The vocals? Absolutely stellar. With Marco Glühmann and Jean Pageau lending their voices to this project, the emotional depth reaches a whole new level. They bring so much feeling and character, it's impossible not to get goosebumps. There are moments on this album that literally touched my soul ? those quiet, emotional passages that stretch into infinity. You just close your eyes and feel.

At the same time, OMNI is such a loving tribute to the roots of progressive rock. You can hear the spirit of the classics, but it never sounds dated ? it's alive, inspired, and full of heart. Karfagen have created something truly special here.

If you love prog, melody, emotion, or just great music ? do yourself a favor and listen to this masterpiece. Then listen again.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Los Elementales by ARCO IRIS album cover Studio Album, 1977
4.36 | 76 ratings

BUY
Los Elementales
Arco Iris Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars The seventh studio album released by this amazing band of virtuosic musicians from Buenos Aires.

- "Elemental De Tierra" : 1. "Gob (Maestro-Mago De Los Gnomos)" (5:58) awesome opeing with some very impressive drums-and-percussion interplay with distant saxophone and Fender Rhodes adding accents in the backgrround. At the very end of the first minute the band shifts into a punctuated Mahavishnu/RTF-like performance of electronic instruments. Man! This drummer is so good! (And his drums are recorded so perfectly for this kind of dynamic power Jazz-Rock Fusion!) Surprisingly, Ara Tokatllian's tenor saxophone takes the first significant solo--really flying off into near-Coltrane free jazz realms with his reckless abandon! But the support crew keeps me well engaged--and makes Ara's craziness quite tolerable. Bass player Guillermo Bordarampé is also quite impressive, but the work of percussionist Jose Luis Perez may rival that of both Ara's sax and his own drumming! It's really hard to imagine Third Wave Power Jazz-Rock Fusion being any better than this! (10/10) 2. "Destilando El Perfume De Los Minerale"s (4:58) with the gentle piano and flute opening to this it's hard to fathom its supposed-connection to the previous song (within the umbrella of the "Elemental de tierra" suite title). Vocals and soaring saw-synth enter with Guillermo's melodic bass as Ara's piano and synths expand their involvement beneath the singing. There is some feeling of RPI bands like PFM and Maxophone as well as Chick Corea in this as well as some KHAN! Pretty but nothing as Earth-shattering as the opener. (8.875/10)

- "Elemental Del Fuego" : 3. "Cristalizando Los Rayos Del Sol" (4:26) the heavier side of Jazz-Rock Fusion, bordering on Jazz-Rock or straight-up Prog. Complex with plenty of magical individual performances from all of the musicians (though the drums are a little poor in their volume levels), the multi-voice vocal enters around the two minute mark, delivering a round of lyrics before giving way to folk flute and then a powerful section with some great chord progessions supporting both electric guitar and synth solos. Then we're back to the group lyrics for another round of the same, this time with synth, sax, organ and then guitar offering the harmonized "solos" till the end. (9.5/10)

4. "Djin (Maestro-Mago De Los Salamandras)" (3:52) metronomic piano chords support a rather bombastic intro with drums, bass, and multiple searing guitars exposing the power this band is capable of. But, this only lasts about 50 seconds before the storm passes and we're left with piano and soprano sax (and, soon, flute) to deliver some gentle pastoral beauty for about a minute before the drums-and-duo-guitars explode onto the scene again. This cycle continues until the pastoral and main theme combine to softly take us out. (9.25/10)

- "Elemental De Agua" : 5. "Despertar De Los Hijos De La Maņana" (3:45) electric piano playing two chords opens this before the rest of the band crashes the party with some quite bombastic play: everybody but the bass (and piano) seeming to scurry off into their own soloing. By the arrival of the second minute things are calming down, eventually leaving just the piano and flute to play for us, but then--just as with the previous song--the cycle of pastoral beauty being broken by 20-to-30- second bursts of bombast continue--until a bass and cymbal crash at 3:26 signals the intro to the next song of the suite. Wonderful stuff! (9.25/10)

6. "Necksa (Maestro-Mago De Las Ondinas)" (8:07) opens to quickly establish a cool Jazz-Rock Fusion bass and drum groove, funky yet well-steeped in rock, before tenor saxophone presents the main melody. The bass player's style sounds like Stanley Clarke with the thick bass lines mixed with heavy bass chords. So cool! An extended "pause" or "repeat" in which no real soloing is going on is then followed by another explosion of sax melody-making before the music shifts into a different motif--one that seems to combine a 1960s spy-theme with the big RTF sound palette. At 5:45 things thin out, making way for the arrival of vocals: first all female choir, then male. By 6:30 the music turns back to all-instrumental with a more Latin rock sound and feel while a spacey synth and flute fly above the rhythm guitar and heavy bass work. Excellent! (14/15) - "Elemental De Aire" : 7. "Los Nacidos Del Viento" (3:57) a gentler, more spacious soundscape is created over which breathy, gentle male vocalist (doubled up?) joins in sounding like a cross between something between classic NEKTAR, CAMEL, CELESTE, PFM, and modern DEVIN TOWNSEND. Sax and odd synth sounds take the lead in the fourth minute before volume- pedal-controlled electric guitar notes and flute provide bird-like sounds to take us out--while the gently-arpeggiated electric guitar chords that started it all continue throughout and right to the end. Very pretty. Almost more prog folky than JRFuse. (9.125/10)

8. "Paralda (Maestro-Mago De Los Silfos)" (8:09) a rock-heavy Jazz-Rock Fusion song built around a variation of Henry Mancini's "Peter Gunn" while deploying a heaviness that well-emulates the peak music of VAN DER GRAAF GENERATOR: this is truly remarkable! At 4:45 the band takes a detour down a JAN HAMMER-like road so that Ara Tokatlian can show off his synth prowess--in two channels--in opposition to his guitarist, Ignacio Elisavetsky. An extraordinary duel (triel?)--one that is right up there with anything Mahavishnu or RTF or their numerous offshoots and imitators ever did. (14.25/15)

Total time 39:20

After starting with the band's early releases, and now skipping ahead to this full-fledged Jazz-Rock Fusion-bordering- on-Proggy album, I have to admit my astonishment at the growth and progress the band has achieved. They were always good--with great musicianship top to bottom--but to so wonderfully blended the sounds and styles of such high in such an impressive way is beyond all expectations.

A/five stars; a full-blown masterpiece of proggy Jazz-Rock Fusion: on the same level as the best from Fermáta, SBB, Jan Hammer, or any of the early RPI classics! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED--especially if you profess yourself a prog lover!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 John Abercrombie & Ralph Towner: Sargasso Sea by ABERCROMBIE, JOHN album cover Studio Album, 1976
4.37 | 35 ratings

BUY
John Abercrombie & Ralph Towner: Sargasso Sea
John Abercrombie Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Two guitar virtuosos blending their sensitive-yet-fluid styles for an album of duets. It's hard to imagine anything better.

1. "Fable" (8:41) like a stripped down "Blue in Green." Absolutely beautiful in every aspect imaginable. (19.5/20)

2. "Avenue" (5:19) veering into the Spanish/Flamenco traditions. (And these guys aren't even Spanish! That's what I'm talking about when I use the word "virtuoso": an artist's ability to easily morph into a variety of styles while convincing the listener that that style is the one and only/best style that he/she plays.) (9.5/10)

3. "Sargasso Sea" (4:01) opening with discordant chords doesn't faze me: the sounds are too good. (It's kind of hard to make a 12-string sound discordant--unless it's out of tune.) Ralph's piano tinkers away beneath both 12-string and volume-pedal-controlled electric guitar. The construct is what I imagine a song made in which the musicians only play half of what is on the song charts: skipping half of everything in each measure. The sounds being produced the electric guitar in the second half, coupled with the discordant chords being played on the 13-string, are a bit weird and, to me, nonsensical. (8.75/10)

4. "Over and Gone" (2:51) four tracks, four guitars, starting with a classical guitar soloing over the gentle support of a second strummed classical guitar, but then the duo are joined by two steel-stringed acoustic guitars playing with and within the melody lines that make up the weave of this brief but beautiful song. (9/10)

5. "Elbow Room" (5:11) strummed steel-string acoustic guitar supports a soloing twangy, echo-effected electric guitar. Not my favorite though I love listening to creative, reactive rhythm guitar play like this. (8.66667/10)

6. "Staircase" (6:25) the same instrumental sound palette as the previous song with much gentler playing styles to both the acoustic guitar support and the twangy-electric guitar soloing. The song definitely gets better in the second half when only acoustic guitars are being played (again deploying more of a Spanish chord and melody structure and style as in "Avenue"). (8.875/10)

7. "Romantic Descension" (3:17) as suggested by the title, this is a duet of stunning beauty, supple interaction; two musicians expressing while on the absolute same wavelength. Even prettier than anything on John McLaughlin's tribute to Bill Evans, Time Remembered. (10/10)

8. "Parasol" (5:24) a song that sounds like something that might come from Pat Metheny: brilliant, erudite chord phrasing from Ralph's gentle and respectful acoustic guitar while John solos up top with his slightly twangy electric guitar. Piano joins in around the half-way point while the support guitar continues, eventually moving to the front for some Chick Corea-like soloing while the two guitars support with uncommon elegance. I'm not as much a fan of the melodies in this one, but the structure and respectful interplay is gorgeous. (9.333/10)

Total Time 41:09

What I appreciate the most about this album is the way the artists seem to prize beauty over flash and flair: the egos never became more important than the emotional inputs and elegant results of every song. I feel as if this is such a rare achievement in the world of music. Perhaps this is one of the gifts that Manfred Eicher and his ECM label were able to bestow upon the world: a label that seemed to value the way their published product soared and resonated above money, time, and egos; where timeless beauty was prized over commerce and fame. The only negative of taking the time to get to know this album (and write its review) is the fact that I'm looking for Jazz-Rock Fusion, not so much straight folk-jazz like this.

A/five stars; an album displaying the stunning connection between two guitar masters. It DEFINITELY doesn't get any better than this!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 In the Can by FLASH album cover Studio Album, 1972
3.38 | 118 ratings

BUY
In the Can
Flash Eclectic Prog

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

3 stars 3.5 stars. It was guitarist Peter Banks the original guitarist for YES, and vocalist Colin Carter who started this band. They started writing some music together to begin with before adding the rhythm section. The self titled debut was released early in 1972, while "In The Can" the followup was released later that same year. Tony Kaye another YES alumni guested on keyboards on the debut, but is absent here. Banks does add some synths.

The vocals are harder to take on this one as he really sings with passion and with a warble throughout. I found he at least changed things up when singing on the debut, but it's like he was determined to sing in this upfront style on here. And of course he's the focus when he does sing. That's the negative.

The positive is that Ray Bennett on bass is sounding in "tone" closer to Chris Squire. His bass is at least upfront and I'm a fan. Mike Hough on drums is given a greater platform on here and comes out with a really nice performance. They even gave him a short track to do a drum solo. But he's more active overall than on the debut. In fact, I thought the rhythm section sounded pedestrian on that debut, which had me thinking maybe they just weren't that good. I was proven wrong here.

So I feel this is a half a star better than the debut mainly for the rhythm section, but also for the guitar work which is more of a focus with Kaye gone. The vocals keep me from going 4 stars though. Again like the debut they stretch things out with three songs on here going over the ten minute mark. The other two include "Stop That Banging" the under 2 minute drum solo, and the 5 minute "Monday Mourning Eyes". The latter is a busy piece with some Howe-like guitar.

Of the three longer tracks I prefer the opener "Lifetown". It's almost festive sounding early on. It was 4 1/2 minutes in on this one where i said to myself "Where did this bass player come from?" Because he didn't sound like this on the debut. I do like this record but that fourth star isn't going to happen. With a different singer yes, but like their album covers, you just cant undo that stuff.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Quantum Phase Transition by EKZILO album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.18 | 41 ratings

BUY
Quantum Phase Transition
Ekzilo Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Stoneburner

3 stars Another great spanish band

As I've said before, this is a good era for Spanish progressive music. In recent years, we've heard great bands like Malabriega, Noah Histeria, Cielo Drive, Vientos Moderados del Este, Jordi Farreras, Joan Villalonga, and Javier Miranda. The Astronomy Records label has been steadily guiding the genre's train, along with Rafa from the Amarxe label?another Spanish imprint leaving a strong mark on the global prog scene.

Now we have Eksilo, a very interesting band that bursts through the front door with a strong debut. Quantum Phase Transition blends extreme metal with jazz fusion and neo-progressive touches. When I heard the opening track, "Patibulum," I was caught off guard?in a good way. It's a devastating, powerful start. But from there, the album slowly moves away from that intensity and drifts into something more predictable. Not bad, just less gripping. The band clearly has chops?these are skilled, creative musicians? but as the album progresses, the surprise factor fades and things start to drag. Some tracks left me wanting more; others just wore me out.

Eksilo is a great band with a promising future. They're still finding their voice, and that's okay. If the album had a more defined concept or theme, it might've held together better. As it stands, I'd stick with "Patibulum" and "Evolution" as highlights. The rest, while well played, didn't quite land for me and at times slipped into boredom. Despite that Eksilo is a great band that deserves more stars but for now on it has to improve those moments and evolve.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 From Nothing by BENTHOS album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
From Nothing
Benthos Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by Prog/Land

— First review of this album —
3 stars This was my first experience with Benthos, and I was at times pleasantly surprised and mildly bored. It is clear this band has quite a bit of potential, as several songs on From Nothing are very original, but I think the band is still in an early stage of developing their sound.

The first half of this album passed me by without much of note. Songs like "Let Me Plunge" feel incredibly derivative of the progressive metalcore we've all heard a thousand times. "As a Cordyceps" was a little more interesting to me, but still nothing to write home about. I was tempted to give up and move on there, but I figured I would give them one more chance to grab me. The next song, "Fossil", is easily one of the highlights of the album. I think it best showcases what Benthos does really well: strange song structures, irregular breakdowns, and general chaos. I'm a big fan of the off-kilter but still somewhat familiar riffs, and I think Benthos is executing those as well as some of the greats (about half the time).

The second half of the album is leagues more memorable than the first, but that doesn't mean it is without the forgettable moments. I can confidently say that the last three true songs, "Athletic Worms", "Perpetual Drone Monkeys", and "To Everything" are the best three tracks on the whole record. All three paint a very odd picture, and it feels really exciting. It's almost as if an entirely new band wrote the three songs. I would love to see Benthos embrace their chaotic and original side more in the future. I could definitely see them combining their catchy metalcore choruses in a very effective way with the rest of their sound, but I did not hear this done very well on From Nothing.

Overall, I give this album a 6 or 6.5 out of 10.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Übercode Ouvre by PANZERBALLETT album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.00 | 9 ratings

BUY
Übercode Ouvre
Panzerballett Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Grumpyprogfan

4 stars Abstract and intense are the arrangements and sounds of "Übercode Ouvre", the latest from Panzerballett. Tis a very jazzy yet heavy album with jaw dropping musicianship, and I never thought I'd hear vocal growls on "Ode to Joy". Yes, the Beethoven song. The angelic vocals soar but, at the same time, the changing rhythms transform a song about joy into something more creative than you'd imagine. There is art above my comprehension happening on this release and I dig it! The killer drumming by Marco on this track is the ode to joy. Other faves... "Alien Hip Hop" is a fresh arrangement of Virgil's tune that shreds big time... how is this level of drumming possible? It seems drummers shine on this album. "Andromeda" is initially a mellow original tune of Jan's but, I should know better and always expect a menacing ending. "Pick Up The Pieces" is a funky upbeat mess that should have you groovin'. Another standout is "The Devil's Staircase"... it goes a long way through tricky changes and humorous steps. Hell, apparently I enjoy all this album.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Quantum Phase Transition by EKZILO album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.18 | 41 ratings

BUY
Quantum Phase Transition
Ekzilo Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Circuito_Prog

3 stars The particles shift their collective behavior.

'Quantum Phase Transition' is an album that confidently stands on that fine line where restraint is worth more than excess. This mostly instrumental work, with only two vocal tracks (the opener and the closer), dives into a state of carefully measured sonic contemplation.

I came into it without any prior knowledge of the band's earlier material, so I wasn't expecting that raspy voice in "Patibulum" It caught me off guard - in the best way. That intensity, that controlled frenzy, immediately brought Between the Buried and Me to mind, especially those sections where everything seems to break apart, yet never fully loses its shape. You're left wanting more vocals - there's a real curiosity about how that voice, somewhere between clean and shredded, might have blended into other moods across the album. Still, the decision to use it only at the beginning and ending has its own logic - and it works.

The interplay between the musicians feels intentional, but never stiff. There's a constant dialogue; they listen to each other, give space, push and pull. "Brujería" encapsulates that perfectly: tight rhythm, collective growth, and an outro with Spanish guitar that's not just for show or folklore - it closes with identity, with a sense of place.

What truly elevates this album above the average is the keyboard work. It's not background - it's foundation. It builds atmosphere without becoming dense, sustains tension without being predictable. There's a melodic sense always present, yet never obvious; piano, synthesizers, Rhodes, Hammonds... everything in its right place, delivered with impeccable taste. There are moments when a single texture or ambiance speaks louder than any virtuosic solo - and that's not easy to pull off.

This isn't an immediate album, and it doesn't need to be. It has layers, patience, intention. Once it pulls you in, there's no rush to leave - and when it's over, you feel the need to return, just to find something you missed the first time.

This band still has room to grow. Within their style, there are ideas and concepts that deserve deeper exploration. No doubt - their best record is still ahead.

Music: 4 stars

Lyrics: 3 stars

Execution: 5 stars

Emotion: 4 stars

Production: 4 stars

Artwork: 3 stars

Average: 3.83

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Firehose of Falsehoods by O.R.K. album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.48 | 12 ratings

BUY
Firehose of Falsehoods
O.R.K. Progressive Metal

Review by alainPP

3 stars O.R.K., a voice and a sound reminiscent of PAIN OF SALVATION, SOUNDGARDEN, SYSTEM OF A DOWN, KING CRIMSON, and PORCUPINE TREE, all supercharged. Incisive, metallic tunes.

"Blast of Silence" takes off with a heavy metal rock sound, with a powerful riff, gravelly vocals, and guitars as screaming as the Zeppelin-esque choruses; an alternative torrent of lava. "Hello Mother" for its ultra-bass rhythm and its heady, belching vocals, ā la ALICE IN CHAINS. "The Other Side" is a nervous intro, a repeat performance before moving into an ambient sound, returning to dirty rock worthy of SOUNDGARDEN with a touch of madness behind it. This alternation amplifies the raw, raw edge and gives surprise guest Giuseppe NEGRI's riff the power of percussive hard rock. "16,000 Days" follows, a spacey micro-intro before Lef's delicate phrasing and the track's catchy mid-tempo with a stratospheric chorus. The progressive sound suddenly arrives on the album, ideal for asking the question 'where are we going?' A beautiful, strong, expressive track that ends with an ethereal feel.

"PUTFP" returns to the punchy metal-rock energy with a relative melodic drift; it's in the break that the progressive resurgence suddenly emerges with a haunting, surprising tune that makes us forget the heavy side. "Seven Arms" is a heady southern rock tune, with prominent guitars and vocals reminiscent of Led Zeppelin; astonishing, astounding with rhythm, energy, and modern rock. "Beyond Reach" continues this dark atmosphere with a strident guitar exploration ā la RAGE AGAINST THE MACHINE contrasting with the passive vocals. A melancholic track where Pat's expressive pad break echoes PINEAPPLE THIEF with its haunting melodic variation. "Mask Becomes The Face" features guest vocals from PORCUPINE TREE's John Wesley on this rhythmic and captivating track, somewhere between haunting and contemplative, for a tearful rock sound with a sparkling solo and a progressively apocalyptic, Dantesque finale of the choir ā la 'Dark Side'. "Dive In" is available as a bonus track and is not to be missed, a long, captivating track, based on ambient alternative rock, with a syncopated rhythm and expressive percussion. Lef, languid and raw once again, supported by a melancholic trumpet, the guitars shearing the air with riffs make this the album to listen to.

O.R.K. continues to pour out a rock metal style full of tension, exploration of our desperate world, a schizoid sound enters it, hard with ambient swirls at times. If everything had been at the level of the bonus, this album would be a top of the month. Origin Profilprog.(3.5)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Streetnoise by AUGER, BRIAN album cover Studio Album, 1969
4.15 | 68 ratings

BUY
Streetnoise
Brian Auger Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Lobster77

5 stars Despite some future weak LP's or mainstream/cashing machine approximations, there's no way to ignore the fact that Brian Auger is a master groover and one of the first to have successfully plunged in Fusion (taken in its wider meaning) waters; on the other hand Julie Driscoll appears as having always functioned as a creative/inspirational muse for Auger, in that all their collaborations bore tasteful fruits; that said this album is in my opinion here to prove it! Backed by Clive Thacker on drums/percussion and Dave Ambrose on basses, guitars and vocal help, BA and JD lend their keyboards and vocals energetic, soulful and unmistakably personal skills to an interesting and varied batch of songs ] The four tracks written by B.A are pulsating Jazz infected grooves with a classic theme in an Emerson vein (Tropic?), full instrumentals with flashy organ work, Motown infected swinging Jazz (Ellis Is?) or Funky grooves (Finally found?), or have our man singing behind his acoustic piano in melancholic ways (Looking in the Eye?); On her own tracks J.D strums or plucks her acoustic guitar in a poignant, three parted, politically charged manifesto against "Czechoslovakia" invasion, in a piercing short solo piece (Word about colour) or with ravishing, long and complex vocal performances, either solely backed by the organ (on the traditional tune arranged by her, "When I was young") or by her acoustic guitar. A similar high level is obtained in the other half of the tracks, all very personalized covers ( a topic where they excel), of almost as many songwriters/artists: in short, there's a 2 speeds piano driven Gospel rendition of Nina Simone's "Take me to?", a peculiar, tension mounting version of the Doors "Light my Fire" with a classy, glassy organ work, a Jazz infected R&B cover of Richie Havens's "Indian?", which asserts it self as a template for much of the sound of bands like Affinity and Gospel and Soul tinged treatments, filled with stunning organ work, of the Rado/Ragni/mcDermot songwriters trio "Let the sunshine in" (yes the one from Woodstock) and "I've got Life; Written by Ambrose, who's in charge of the lead vocal too, "In search of the Sun" is fascinatingly reminiscent of Pete Brown's Piblokto style, where as the band and singer are strongly engaged on the mid tempo acoustic version of Miles's "All Blues" and close the album with an heartfelt, punchy rendition of Laura Nyro's "Save the Country" which is better than the original in my opinion. 5.0 this is one of Brian Auger and Julie Driscoll's best.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Hatfield and the North by HATFIELD AND THE NORTH album cover Studio Album, 1974
4.25 | 931 ratings

BUY
Hatfield and the North
Hatfield And The North Canterbury Scene

Review by alainPP

4 stars 1. The Stubbs Effect and Big Jobs (Poo Poo Extract) as canter openings, soft, jazzy soft pop; soft rock, experimentation, already. 3. Going Up to People and Tinkling follows, a muted pop air, a fusion of genres from a jazzy bar night, ah, it's becoming clearer, sound effects too, cinematic one would say today. 4. Calyx continues, trumpet and backing vocals or both at the same time, vocal rambling above all with the great Robert leading the way. 5. Son of "There's No Place Like Homerton," an epic track whose sequencing is once again noteworthy, hence the prog vein certification; a beautiful peregrination with wind instruments at the forefront, the melody flowing unrestrainedly on an avant-garde side of the time, combining classical, hushed ambiance and suave compositions, the moment when we can understand the progressive wanderings of Pink Floyd, Genesis, Magma, Robert Wyatt. A subdued bon mot for this purely progressive take on the early 70s. An atmosphere that flirts with the works of the great King Crimson in the final third, with sax and shrill backing vocals. 6. Aigrette, not sour but almost, with this more instrumental vocal for the pastoral, floral interlude. 7. Rifferama and Richard with his swirling bass, a Camel, Caravan, born in Canterbury. Phil uses his energetic guitar to flirt with free jazz-rock, harking back to the future of Return to Forever.

8. Fol De Rol follows with this mantra from another age, a moment where each note coming together becomes nostalgic, vibrant, or exasperating, depending on the listeners' tastes; perfection of the moment, soulless tinkering.

9. Shaving Is Boring follows with the typical Canterbury take; It starts out of nowhere, it's barely audible, and then, and then it transforms into a minimalist electronic musical mishmash that holds up, like the work of Tangerine Dream; confusing, astounding, gradually captivating; an open-door break, the sound of footsteps, and the finale, as if coming from elsewhere, for the organ-bass-guitar assault on Canterbury time, the one that melts time with notes. 10. Licks for the Ladies follows, as if there were no sides on LPs at the time; a rural atmosphere with a distant vocal on an acoustic guitar and its electric organ. 11. Bossa Nochance follows, just more energetic. 12. Big Jobs No 2 (by Poo and the Wee Wees) in the same vein, well, why separate tracks that are only the musical continuation? Soft vocals and guitar play the part with a honeyed undertone. 13. Lobster in Cleavage Probe arrives, electric organ on choirs of sirens or nuns in bloom, the bucolic scene is confirmed; a battle without weapons between two female choirs wandering in cloudy limbo before the powerful solo, launching 14. Gigantic Land-Crabs in Earth Takeover Bid and its unashamedly crimsonian solo into violent, archaic, heavy territory?yes, the word is out, which makes me smile at the look of my prog friends, impervious to the prog metal movement, in short; a little sweetness, clarinet, tweet, tweet, or almost, before the new deluge and 15. The Other Stubbs Effect closes the debate with the psychedelically disturbing outro.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Purification by ANUBIS GATE album cover Studio Album, 2004
2.98 | 32 ratings

BUY
Purification
Anubis Gate Progressive Metal

Review by martindavey87

2 stars Having heard a number of random tracks over the years, Anubis Gate are a band I've always held in pretty high regard. Typical of most European progressive metal bands, they're not very well known, but despite remaining mostly off the grid, they've put out an impressive array of high-quality albums. Keen to delve properly into their discography, 2004's debut, 'Purification', seemed like the best place to start.

Except it probably wasn't.

Sadly, to my surprise, I've found this a very hard album to get into. I've had it in my playlist for what feels like forever, and I just can't seem to really remember anything from it. Every time I play it I zone out. The playing is fantastic and there are a few rather tasty guitar riffs, likewise, vocalist Torben Askholm has a great voice that really suits the music and its themes. But the overall writing is just so dull, all the songs seem to mesh together and just plod along at the same pace, all sounding similar to each other and thus, making it impossible to really distinguish most of them.

If I had to pick out any highlights, 'In the Comfort of Darkness', 'Hypernosis' and 'Downward Spiral' are all decent enough, but even then, I don't think I could sit and listen to them all the way through without losing interest. And it's a shame, because I know this band are capable of much better than this. But overall, 'Purification' just does nothing for me, and it's fortunate that I'm already familiar with some of the bands later material, otherwise, had this been my first exposure to them, I probably wouldn't bother coming back.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Machine Head by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1972
4.35 | 1393 ratings

BUY
Machine Head
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by Hector Enrique
Prog Reviewer

5 stars Ritchie Blackmore and Ian Gillan, two complex personalities who permanently argued to impose their points of view on the musical direction of Deep Purple, with eventual interventions by the less belligerent Jon Lord, who also showed his interest in adding classical music elements to the purple proposal, paradoxically ended up generating the fundamental energetic spark for the creation of "Machine Head" (1972), the sixth album by the British band and one of the stellar works in the history of rock.

Lord's lush Hammonds and Blackmore's baroque-scented guitar solo on the thundering "Highway Star", the immortal, universal riffs of the timeless "Smoke on the Water" (which describes the cinematic fire that occurred during Frank Zappa and his band's performance at the Mountreux Casino Theatre on the shores of Lake Geneva, the very place Deep Purple chose to record "Machine Head"), Lord and Blackmore's virtuosic display on the robust blues rock "Lazy", and the thick riffs on the fantastical, galactic "Space Truckin'" with Gillan's vocal wailing, are carved into the foundations of hard rock and incipient heavy metal, and immortalised on the legendary live double "Made in Japan" released months later.

Just below the famous tetralogy, there is the mid-tempo bluesy riff of "Maybe I'm a Leo" and the determined and unstoppable keyboards of the vertiginous "Pictures of Home"' with a similar structure to "Highway Star"; And if the excellent and melancholic ballad "When a Blind Man Cries" (B-side of the simple and correct funky single "Never Before") had not been left out, partly because of the technical limitations of the vinyl and partly because Blackmore was not convinced by the song, the album would have been even more rounded.

The stupendous "Machine Head", which reached the first place in the music charts in the UK and several European countries, and in the top ten of the US Billboard with around 3 million copies sold, is an obligatory reference and source of inspiration for countless bands that emerged in the following years (Def Leppard, Iron Maiden, Metallica, and Alice in Chains, among others).

Essential

4.5 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 E = MC˛  by LASRY, TEDDY album cover Studio Album, 1976
3.53 | 13 ratings

BUY
E = MC˛
Teddy Lasry Progressive Electronic

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

3 stars 3.5 stars. Teddy Lasry came from France, and from a musical family. His parents were in an experimental band that released many albums, with the first being in 1960. In fact Teddy would play on some of those beginning in the late sixties. Lasry also was a horn/flute player for MAGMA. Playing on their first three records before quitting and going solo. This 1976 release is one of Teddy's solo records, and many are tagged with Library music by RYM, including this one.

While Lasry does it all pretty much, he did get a drummer and a bass player to help out. The drummer is on two tracks, and that bass player happens to be Janick Top and he also plays on two tracks. Neither guest really stands out, rather they are part of the sound. It's a 38 minute record with 8 tracks. The opener and closer are really the same song with minimal keyboard sounds over 1 1/2 minutes. The intro and outro you could say. So yes, Lasry is all over this record playing clavinet, marimba, soprano sax, clarinet and adding electronics and effects.

While this album did grow on me, I really am on the fence with it. I didn't even like it at first, but after 4 spins I was feeling like it was actually pretty good. Still, it's too inconsistent for me to go 4 stars. The one song that stands out is "Quasar". A dizzying array of sounds on this one, but it's the last 2 minutes where the we get the best section of the whole album. They just step it up a notch, and it's great. "Earth" is another good one with a fair amount of piano.

It's odd that on the song "Nebular", before the 5 minute mark, we get sax coming out both speakers but playing different melodies. This happened with the piano on "Earth" as well. I'm not big on a lot of the high pitched electronic sounds on this record, like to start "Birth Of Galaxy" for example. And then "Birds Of Space" features chirping birds for over 3 1/2 minutes. Way too long! And even when we do get soprano sax like to start "Nonsense" it just sounds so old school. It's brief, but the drum and percussion section that follows goes on for far too long.

There is this attention to detail here that I admire, but this is a recording that I have trouble enjoying.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Goldstar by IMPERIAL TRIUMPHANT album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.75 | 16 ratings

BUY
Goldstar
Imperial Triumphant Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by Dapper~Blueberries
Prog Reviewer

4 stars When I think of black metal, I never really picture cities as a visage point. Usually I imagine dark, gloomy forests, snowy mountain tops, maybe even the occasional medieval weaponry. But New York? Now that's something different in the black metal sphere I never thought of, though a city could theoretically work. A concrete forest oftentimes can hide the cruelties of man just as well as a forest can. In a way, that's where Imperial Triumphant's newest release of Goldstar comes into play.

I knew of Imperial Triumphant from their 2022 release of Spirit of Ecstasy. I liked that album, but not enough for me to revisit it over and over again. However, I was pleasantly surprised the moment I heard Goldstar, as not only was it really good comparatively, it made me more interested in checking this band out more in the future.

I've never been the most huge on dissonant black metal, but I have always been quite in favor towards avant-garde metal, and hearing them combined is always quite a treat admittedly. Imperial Triumphant creates a storm of chaos through each of their chords and percussion-lines that range from Gorguts-like technicalities, to old school Ulver blackness. It is honestly really enjoyable for what it's worth, and adds a lot of weight to a pretty short album.

I also really enjoy the concept here, being an album based around the quote unquote 'sounds of New York as we hear them'. They take the ideas of metropolitan United States, and mashes the commercialism and constant ads of the city's skyline as a sort of occult-like nature. In an offshoot way, this album did release at a perfect time when you consider American politics. I know, I know, we're all tired of political nonsense, but hear me out. With America politics becoming more and more in favor towards the rich and wealthy, especially when we have a bumbling rich idiot in office, with a fascist wealthy brat who cannot make a car for God knows what right by his side, viewing these aspects of American greed and consumerism as a sort of cult wouldn't be too far off. I mean, what's too different from a Satanic cult in comparison to the diehard bigots who support our current president's every move?

I do think sometimes the execution of this concept can be a bit too hamfisty, like with the 'hail satan my child' part, and the entirety of the title track. Kind of wish they did more subtlety within the lyrical aspects. It's a really good concept, again, but I don't think the lyrics are the best aspect here. In fact I do think they're kinda the worst aspect on the record. Great concept musically and conceptually, but written on paper'it could use some work.

Safe to say, Goldstar is a gold star of a black metal record. It has a lot of things one can love from a good ol' bm album, and many more. I definitely say check it out, cause it's not only a really fun time, but certainly an album for a modern day America happening right now.

Best tracks: Eye of Mars, Gomorrah Nouveaux, NEWYORKCITY, Industry of Misery

Worst track: Goldstar

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 UK by UK album cover Studio Album, 1978
4.11 | 756 ratings

BUY
UK
UK Eclectic Prog

Review by Lobster77

4 stars A line up that included John Wetton, Eddie Jobson, Bill Bruford and jazz guitarist Alan Holdsworth was never going to stay together long. Jobson and Wetton were rock and roll guys (having played with Roxy music, Uriah Heep, Zappa) while Bruford and Holdsworth were interested in jazz music. They did make some interesting music with this album, but it's no surprise that they soon broke up after this album was completed. The opening suite of "In the dead of night", "By the light of day" and "Presto vivace" is outstanding. "Thirty years" also has its moments, but is ruined by Wetton's loud bass during the instrumental bits. "Alaska" is mostly Jobson playing keyboards and "Time to kill" is the kind of boring AOR Wetton started to do on the later Asia albums and his 90s/00s solo albums. "Nevermore" is the album's highlight. It's full of Bruford and Holdsworth's jazz influences, yet Wetton and Jobson are in top form as well and for once the combination between jazz influences, Jobson's keyboards and Wetton's bass and vocals sounds exactly right. "Mental medication" is again a poor track. Overall the album's inconsistent, but with half of the tracks being that outstanding it is well worth getting for any fan of one of its members. Those who, like me, prefer Bruford and Holdsworth's contributions to the album should check out Bruford's "One of a kind". 4.5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Parallel World by FAR EAST FAMILY BAND album cover Studio Album, 1976
4.14 | 168 ratings

BUY
Parallel World
Far East Family Band Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Lobster77

5 stars While Germany or Britain are most known for being at the forefront of electronic psychedelic music, Japan certainly had its share of cosmic travelers. One of the best of these groups was Far East Family Band, a band who would gain some stature throughout the world during the latter part of the 1970s. These guys would frontier Japanese prog.

Klaus Schulze was one such luminary to be attracted by this six-piece Japanese ensemble. Helping produce their early albums (the first two albums are very similar, the latter of which was re-recorded and sung in English, and other slight variations), Schulze saw an opportunity to promote cosmic rock all over the globe. However, I always felt the debut album/successor tried too hard to be the next Dark Side of the Moon. The instrumental bits are great only to be ruined by sensitive pop ballads - not Far East Family Band's strong suit I'm afraid.

But it all came together on Parallel World. Focusing on their instrumental cosmic sound and pretty much foregoing the pop commercial-oriented songs, the six-piece Far East Family Band unleashed a gem that easily could have found itself on the Kosmische Kouriers label. In fact, the recording comes closest to sounding like the first Cosmic Jokers album with more focus given to the whooshing synthesizers than the guitars (Schulze's influence?). As one can guess, the two keyboard players are featured most prominently, and it's hard to imagine that Far East Family Band actually had two guitarists as well!

The album opens with 'Metempsychosis' which is a tribal drum and synthesizer atmospheric backdrop piece that sets the stage for 'Entering' which contains some intense fuzz bass and a ripping guitar sequence among the 12 minutes of keyboard ecstasy. Brilliant, and this is one of finest tracks Far East Family Band has ever recorded! 'Kokoro' is psychedelic ballad. This is the sort of piece their first albums featured, so one can get a whiff of this style, if not familiar. The side long closing title track sounds like a long-lost Galactic Supermarket recording and aptly finishes a masterwork of cosmic progressive space rock. 5.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Do They Hurt? by BRAND X album cover Studio Album, 1980
3.51 | 148 ratings

BUY
Do They Hurt?
Brand X Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by VianaProghead
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Review Nē 890

Brand X is a British progressive rock band that was founded in London in 1975. Brand X was a jazz fusion band that was active between 1975 and 1980 and that had a hiatus from 1980 to 1992. The band was disbanded in 1999 and was reformed in 2016. So, Brand X had a lifespan of about forty six years, and existed on and off between 1975 and 2019, though technically, their last studio creation as Brand X dates back to 1997. At the height of their success, the 70's, they were often considered a jazz-fusion act, but over the time, were rounded up into the progressive music label. That was due in part to their own gradual shape shifting. The fact that upwards of 25 separate and international session players appeared with them in studio or on stage, their frequent reputation of working as a revolving door musical experiment was erroneous. In reality, Brand X was only ever three British musicians who signed on and were defined as "the band", John Goodsall, Percy Jones and Robin Lumley. Brand X was lucky to have signed a recording contract with the Island Records. And as we all know, Island Records has been home to many reputable artists all over the years.

Brand X released four studio albums in the 70's. Their debut studio album "Unorthodox Behaviour" was released in 1976. Their debut live album "Livestock" and their second studio album "Moroccan Roll" were both released in 1977. Their third studio album "Masques" was released in 1978. Their fourth studio album "Product" was released in 1979. Finally, we have the subject of my review, their fifth studio album "Do They Hurt?" that was only released in 1980.

So, "Do They Hurt?" is the fifth studio album of Brand X and that was released in 1980. The line up on the album is John Goodsall (guitar), Peter Robinson (keyboards and tam-tam), Robin Lumley (piano and keyboards), Percy Jones (vocals and bass), John Giblin (bass), Michael Clark (drums), Phil Collins (drums) and Morris Pert (percussion).

"Do They Hurt?" contains material from what's left over from the multivalent sessions for their previous studio album "Product". Commercially, the album wasn't a huge success, but that was pretty much the norm in the Brand X's case. If Phil Collins hadn't been running the band as a kind of a side project as the drummer, the band might have remained even less known. That it would have been too bad, because the level of the band was good. Unfortunately, the rest of the band often got a little lost beside him. That is also too bad, because the musicians are all among the best in their field, guitarist John Goodsall, bassists Percy Jones and John Giblin, keyboardist Robin Lumley, percussionist Morris Pert and drummer Mike Clark. They were also the main musicians on this album. Collins basically played a guest role.

"Noddy Goes To Sweden" is a jazz fusion track that doesn't require a guitar. The dominant instrument is Jones' fretless bass. The song is sparsely instrumented, but grooves pleasantly and sneaks funky-casual. To hear it is a real joy to our ears. "Voidarama" is a very guitar-oriented track. It begins with a nice and catchy relaxed melody. In the middle section Goodsall dares to play somewhat more complex parts. This track is a reminiscent of the Mahavishnu Orchestra style. "Act Of Will" is a piece sung through the vocoder. It's probably catchier than its predecessor. Sometimes is rocky and sometimes is melancholic. I like it even if it sounds rather conservative and commercial by the Brand X's standards. "Fragile!" is probably a bit more complex than the previous track, mildly experimental. It's beautifully an intricate jazz-prog rock number with some bass guitar leads. It's a fine light funky jazz-rock, a reminiscent of the "Masques" album. "Cambodia" is another very guitar-oriented track that follows the Mahavishnu Orchestra path. It oscillates between rock and jazz rock. It's one of the highlights on the album with Goodsall's excellent guitar work and Jones' good bass parts. "Triumphant Limp" is a fusion piece with a very dense drumming. It leans more towards the jazz fusion style. The song lives less on big ideas and more on Jones' excellent bass work and Collins' impressive drum parts. It's a triumphant statement of a great jazz fusion/rock band. "D.M.Z." is typical of Brand X. It seems playful and varied that thrives on the humming singing bass of Jones. The track represents the highlight on the album with Goodsall's excellent guitar work and Jones' good bass parts. This composition is a very successful conclusion of a solid jazz rock/fusion album, really.

Conclusion: With "Do They Hurt?", Brand X continued in the path of simplifying the sound that they had embarked on with "Product". Overall, the album oscillates somewhat indecisively between the jazz rock and rock, between complex and catchy. For some, the album lacks the effervescence of its predecessor maybe because it feels like a collection of outtakes from the "Product" sessions. However and despite of that, it has become a solid album between the jazz rock, prog and rock. It has the typical Brand X signature, bubbling bass lines, weird guitar runs, cool drumming and colorful keyboards. Despite Brand X have created more accomplished music before, "Do They Hurt?" still stands a great album. Here you can hear a number of experts in their field jamming blithely without losing the structure of the band's music.

Prog is my Ferrari. Jem Godfrey (Frost*)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 There Is No Space For Us by HAWKWIND album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.88 | 20 ratings

BUY
There Is No Space For Us
Hawkwind Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Following the rather transitional Stories From Time and Space, There Is No Space For Us takes the sound of that album, tightens it up, and throws in a few curveballs for good measure - for instance, the title track takes us out of space rock and more into the realm of a sort of space folk, before transitioning into the soundscape territory of The Outer Regions of the Universe. Worry not, though, because heavier moments such as on Neutron Stars (Pulsating Light) have their place as well, and seem to be more prominent than on the previous album. Dave Brock's vocals seem a little distant - not quite buried in the mix, but not especially foregrounded either - and though this is hardly new in the Hawkwind discography (it's often part of their style) it seems to be dialled up somewhat here, but otherwise this will likely please anyone who enjoys recent Hawkwind.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Overview by WILSON, STEVEN album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.85 | 227 ratings

BUY
The Overview
Steven Wilson Crossover Prog

Review by The Crow
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Without completely abandoning the electronic influences of his recent albums, "The Overview" marks Steven Wilson's return to what he does best: outstanding progressive rock!

Here, we find only two unique and lengthy tracks, split into more standard-length songs on disc 2. While these may not represent the instrumental excellence of "The Raven That Refused to Sing" or "Hand. Cannot. Erase." (it's worth noting that the musician himself handles most of the instruments), they certainly bring us back to the most inspired Wilson from a compositional perspective.

Within this work, the most remarkable elements are the more acoustic and less experimental passages, present in both tracks, which might even remind us of the best moments of Porcupine Tree or albums where the British artist served as producer, such as "Damnation" by Opeth.

I hope this return to the right path continues over time and that Steven Wilson keeps delivering music of this quality, whether under his name or that of Porcupine Tree.

A true surprise, indeed!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Mindquake by EDERA album cover Studio Album, 2015
4.46 | 18 ratings

BUY
Mindquake
Edera Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by Finnforest
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Masterful

Edera were a Milan-based band formed in the mid-90s and who now have fallen silent for a decade in terms of new releases. This is truly a bummer because, based on the strength of this work, they should have made a larger splash than they did. Mindquake is their third full-length album, and it is on another level completely from that which came before. Their first two albums were good and had some very cool tracks, but Mindquake, coming a decade after their second album, really succeeded in reaching their full potential. If the idea was to make one final album before dissolving the band, they nailed it. Indeed, there is so much intensity packed into each track that it does feel like a band shooting for the moon as if they knew it was their last work. Of course, that's my speculation. Maybe they'll be back someday.

Everything about Mindquake ups the ante over what they've done before. Starting from simple presentation issues, the rather amateur-looking album covers are replaced by this cool sci-fi image expressing the emotional and/or physical pain of the protagonist, I'd presume. The messy 19-title tracklist of the previous album, some just a minute or so long, are replaced with solid, lengthier tracks with succinct titles, seemingly aiming for a tighter conceptual package. Ironically, as cool as their album design is here, this is their only release that didn't get a CD release. Tragic it is that this is only available digitally currently and only from a couple places. (Since the band's website is gone, I will link to a source for album via the 'Official Website' button on their artist page so all reading can find a place to listen.) If you love this album as much as I did, be sure to download a copy from one of the official sites in case this work disappears someday. I rarely bother with that, but this album is worth the trouble.

Getting to the music finally, I did not expect much going in, yet I was blown away by this album. Just to start: emotionally dark and heavy, tightly wound, constricting feelings balanced with release. Every track is akin to a dramatic, self-contained stage scene almost. Often described as a combination of symphonic and neo-prog and, while that's not wrong per se, there is more to it than that. There is almost a gothic modern rock vibe as well, almost a veil that a Cure album might possess. I think this album is a conceptual sibling-in-spirt to other stylish and somber works like Peter Gabriel's Up, Marillion's Brave, or Moongarden's Round Midnight. So much intensity and emotional fuel is packed into the tightly constructed compositions. The keyboards create both oppressive and serene backgrounds while layered guitar parts thrash back and forth. The drumming expertly walks the line of keeping the tracks taut while allowing some controlled turbulence. The vocalist is an intense, heart-on-sleeve guy like a Thom Yorke, Fish, or as others mentioned, Marco Gluhmann. His style could be off-putting to some, but I thought it was perfect for the material.

The songs can be very dense, impenetrable, and sometimes feel oppressive and claustrophobic, but they do have sections of relief and places to breathe, usually arriving in the form of a lovely piano run or some acoustic guitar or just a softer passage. While I didn't have lyrics to catch all the nuance, the songs musically feel very much like the running diary of someone dealing with immense pain, bouncing from crisis to crisis in the search for serenity. The fact that the music is able to impart such a journey on me with ease via the form of a unique progressive rock sound is what makes it a stylistic masterpiece to me. I also feel like the creativity of the songwriting and the performances of every individual player here are off-the-charts good. Everyone is hitting the sweet spots that allow you to feel the emotion and enjoy the "theater" of it.

If there is one flaw I'd mention, it might be that the production is not as crisp or clear as I typically like. However, given the solemn conceptual nature of the material, this might actually work to the benefit of the album by helping to create the rather unnerving, anxious vibe the songs require in places. Despite being a difficult album full of material some might call a little depressing, I found it a very satisfying album that likely would have made my best of 2015 list had I heard it then. It is tragic that there is no CD and that it garnered so little attention from progressive rock fans and prog writers. I highly recommend checking this out if you like the kind of emotionally heavy works I mentioned above.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Syrinx by SYRINX album cover Studio Album, 1970
3.24 | 22 ratings

BUY
Syrinx
Syrinx Progressive Electronic

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

2 stars SYRINX were a Canadian band who released two studio albums, one in '70 and the other in '71 before calling it a day. A unique trio of keyboards, hand percussion and electric sax. The leader was keyboarder John Mills-Cockell who had been in a number of bands prior to this. He was also one of the first Canadian musicians to purchase a moog. And this appears to be the album where he tries it out. Moog dominates this album, in fact, take away the hand percussion and electric sax and no one will notice.

It's beyond surprising how mundane and unexciting this 39 minute album is. Moog all the time, but John also adds organ a fair amount, and piano sparingly. It's almost as if John knows this album will be held up down the road as being one of the very first Canadian albums with moog on it, so lets not blow it. Lets not embarrass ourselves by doing anything out of the norm on this historical recording. Okay, maybe I'm wrong, but I just can't get over the discipline in play to make such a monotonous record. The hand percussion is heard a few times. The electric sax leads twice as a solo instrument. Otherwise the sax is buried amongst the moog and organ sounds, it's another layer.

For me the most interesting track is the opener "Melina's Torch" where we get three different sounds eventually being apart of this track. It's melancholic and repetitive and not that great, but not bad. Same with that 11 1/2 minute closer where we get some moments like that but not many. The hand percussion might be at it's most upfront on that closer. "Father Of Light" is slow moving to a fault. Some piano on "Hollywood Dream". The one song that kind of clicked with me was "Field Hymn". A melody that is moving.

Their second and final release "Long Lost Relatives" is so much better. It's kind of what you would expect with that unique trio. This one is a rare 2 star album for me.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Omni by KARFAGEN album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.24 | 98 ratings

BUY
Omni
Karfagen Symphonic Prog

Review by Trinity S

5 stars Congratulations, dear Antony!

I truly hope OMNI brings you the respect you so clearly deserve! It's been amazing to witness all the progress you've made over the past few years. Releasing such an outstanding statement like OMNI is, without a doubt, a major success. And with this album, you've undeniably stepped into the high league of progressive rock.

OMNI is a release that holds magical depth, filled with so many beautiful melodies ? something so rare in the modern prog genre. While many bands drift through chord sequences and layers of sound, I love when there's melody in music ? it's the heart, the core.

Speaking of the melodic core in OMNI, it almost feels like a musical. There are guiding themes, and all the excellent musicians involved feel like actors ? each one playing their role with meaning and precision.

I've listened to the album so many times that it's hard to pick a favorite track. They all work perfectly together, forming a cohesive suite. But if I had to choose just three, they would be:

"Whispers from the Past" ? A charming and hypnotic, almost medieval acoustic ballad. I especially want to highlight Olga Rostovska's voice ? absolutely beautiful!

"The Cards We Play" ? A true prog rock hit! It hooked me the moment it was released as a single. Marco Glühmann's vocals and Michel St-Pčre's guitar work bring magic to this 8-minute gem ? pure progressive rock delight.

"Storyteller (Parts 1 & 2)" ? I love both parts, but the second one brings tears to my eyes. A touching father-and-son story, full of emotional highs and lows? what a powerful acoustic piece.

"Dreams that broke, we turned to gold, Wounds that healed, stories told. Through the tears, through the strife, We penned the poems of this life."

I highly recommend this album. In my opinion, it will remain a bright chapter in prog rock history.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Brave by MARILLION album cover Studio Album, 1994
3.99 | 1231 ratings

BUY
Brave
Marillion Neo-Prog

Review by Lobster77

5 stars Brave has been one of the most acclaimed Marillion album from the start in fact, it used to be even more acclaimed back in the days when the 1980s Marillion sounded dated and this still didn't. Naturally, Brave has begun to sound a little dated itself, while the 1980s Marillion has almost turned kind of fresh. Anyway, this one was a brave album, as it introduced a new kind of Marillion that had left the 1980s and Fish's ghost behind, instead presenting us a new progressive rock hybrid that was recognisably 1990s.

The opening "Bridge" doesn't really get going, but the following "Living With the Big Lie" and "Runaway" are already better. Then there is the lengthy "Goodbye to All That", which features some nice fragments, but I quickly learned to skip it. "Hard as Love" is not actually my favourite either. Instead, "The Hollow Man" and the 8-minute "The Lap of Luxury" are high quality music, while "Paper Lies" is not much worse. but "The Great Escape" and "Made Again" close the package with a high note. This is a Magnum opus of progressive rock and music and general. Mariilion created this album with a narrative and created It perfectly. 5.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 More (OST) by PINK FLOYD album cover Studio Album, 1969
3.15 | 1597 ratings

BUY
More (OST)
Pink Floyd Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by Lobster77

4 stars "More" and "Obscured by Clouds" (Pink Floyd's other soundtrack album) are often regarded as side notes to the band's primary development as represented on their true studio albums - and consequently not worthy of the same consideration as the albums proper. I couldn't disagree More, no pun intended.

Obscured by Clouds and More represent a critical component of the Floyd sound that would emerge whole by the early seventies. Whereas the 1968-'71 albums proper are harder and more psychedelic/progressive in their orientation, the two soundtracks are largely acoustic (with some striking exceptions) with strong melodies and great singing (individually and in harmony). Importantly the material on More (and Obscured by Clouds) displays that subtly menacing edge that Floyd's peak work is known for. In fact that combination of a soft melodic veneer with a cold, menacing undercurrent is - I would argue - the essence of Pink Floyd and is demonstrated much better on the two soundtracks than on any of their pre-1973 or post-1975 albums.

The true songs and instrumentals here are all outstanding. The playing is great, the arrangements are really enjoyable and the whole album sounds like a live band recording - not as much like a studio recording. This also has quite a bit of great guitar work from Gilmour.

Strongly recommended for early and mid-seventies Floyd fans. Truthfully you can only listen to Wish You Were Here and Dark Side of the Moon so many times before getting tired of them - here are two albums that share many of those qualities that you've never heard once. 4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Rogue by GLASS HAMMER album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.89 | 27 ratings

BUY
Rogue
Glass Hammer Symphonic Prog

Review by emilkomonen

4 stars This is my first review ever, sorry if it's not very good.

1: What If: The album starts with a very melodic song, which reminds me a lot of older Glass Hammer albums. Very good song. 2: The Road South: This song is very melodic and symphonic and very peaceful, a lot more peaceful than the last song. A good song, however not as good as the last one. 3: Tomorrow: This song is very atmospheric and faster than the previous song. The song slows down after the beginning. I like this song more than the previous one. 4: Pretty Ghost: Not a bad song, however not my favorite either. 5: Sunshine: This song is again very peaceful and atmospheric. I like this song, however not as much as some of the others on this album. 6: I Will Follow: This song begins with organs and it begins very peacefully and when the drums come in, the song becomes faster. I like this song. 7: The Wonder of it All: This song is faster and very atmospheric. I like this song. 8: One Last Sunrise: A very peaceful and atmospheric song. I like it. 9: Terminal Lucidity: An atmospheric song. Really brings on a journey. I feel like there's some Tangerine Dream influence in it? I like it a lot. 10: All Good Things: This song is peaceful, it also seems to bring on a journey, very good song. Probably my favorite song on this album.

Conclusion: A very good album, with lots of great melodies and its a very atmospheric album. Rating: 4/5.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Rox by MIHRAX album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.84 | 10 ratings

BUY
Rox
Mihrax Crossover Prog

Review by yarstruly

4 stars Today we'll be checking out a fairly new German prog band from Berlin called Mihrax on their second album, titled Rox. The band was founded in 2016 by keyboardist/guitarist/songwriter Tobias Graef, who refers to himself as 'a musical alien of my generation,' as he is into prog rock over the modern pop sounds preferred by the masses these days (I feel ya, Tobias!). In that year Tobias wrote the songs for what was to be the first Mihrax album, recorded with Tobias' father Thomas Graef on bass and drummer/vocalist Frank Zibner. The band's name comes from a fictional drug name used in the story that the album is based on. The self-titled album was released in 2019 and has a very high 4.5 out of 5 star rating on Prog Archives, albeit only based on 2 ratings (one 5 and one 4).

In the interim, Frank Zibner exited the band and three other musicians joined: Thorsten Schl'ter on guitar, Andreas Wittwer on drums and vocalist Boris Elfert. This quintet recorded the album we are checking out today, just released on March 7, 2025. This review was requested by the band's promotion team at BadDog productions via Anne-Claire. I received no compensation for this review, and as always, 'I call it like I hear it.' As usual, this is a cold listen and my first impressions.

Track 1 - Black Star

We begin with an 11 minute + epic. Which shares a name with an early Yngwie Malmsteen track. A mid-tempo 4-4 drum beat starts us off and then a very 80s analog synth joins in. The bass provides a riff as well. The opening lyrics are spoken with an echo as the beat pauses, and is backed with guitar harmonics. The beat then resumes and a guitar riff leads to the first proper verse. Boris is singing in a narrative about a character known as Black Star, who is a rock star. I believe this may be a bit of a rock opera happening. The chorus is very catchy and the keyboard flourishes are well done. At around 3 minutes in, the guitar riffs take back over before the vocals resume. Boris sings with a slightly raspy baritone that fits the music well. At around 4:30 we begin a different section in an odd meter. I thought it was going to be an instrumental break, but we'll call it a bridge, as the vocals resumed. The guitar interludes in the song are quite nice. After 6 minutes, I do believe this is an instrumental feature. Nice keyboard riffs at 7 minutes. Then the beat pauses and the guitar plays unaccompanied. The vocals resume at around 8 minutes. The bass and drums in the rhythm section have been spot-on! Very cool odd-meter guitar break around 9:30. I like the drum pattern around 10:50. Excellent opening track!

Track 2 - Intoxication

A slightly shorter track (but hardly short) at 7 minutes. This begins with a hard-edged guitar riff with the rhythm section and keys supporting. The next section is very dramatic. Then the keys come front-and center briefly at a slower tempo, before the verse begins, back at the original tempo. There is a call and response style here between solo and harmonies. On the second verse, the groove stops on the response part of each phrase couplet. Just prior to the 3 minute mark, the bass takes center stage with a sinister riff. The keys then lead us into a new section with distant spoken dialog. The tone is very mysterious, and the ride cymbal keeps subtle time. The sounds include what sounds like announcements in a train station or some such thing. Then at around 4 minutes in the band kicks back into full gear for an instrumental break. The mysterious section returns at 5 minutes, before a chunky guitar part takes over. A guitar solo joins in and the way it builds is very engaging. The chorus returns following the solo, with some nice clean drum fills. I believe I hear mellotron as the song nears completion. Excellent track! I really enjoyed that!

Track 3 - What You Gonna Do?

Another longer track at 9:47. This begins with a foreboding synth drone. An odd meter drumbeat leads the bass and keys in, followed by the guitar at around 1 minute in. The vocals join in and the music gets a bit jazzy sounding, harmonically. The chorus is in a sinister rock style. Excellent wordless harmonies at around 2:30. A cool sudden guitar fill at 3:00 leads in the next verse. The next section has a heavy (but not-too-heavy) guitar riff, and it leads us to the well-played guitar solo. Andreas plays a sort of tribal beat in the next segment while the other instruments resume the riff from before the solo. The vocal harmonies then return, before the beat pauses and the keyboards lead in the next verse. Boris' voice is less raspy and cleaner on this one. I like the triplet rhythm at the end of the next harmony vocal section on the lyrics 'I'm your lover, your butterfly.' Cool keyboard tones blend with guitars next. Then we have another heavy guitar riff section with the rhythm section slamming the beat; kinda funky. The earlier riffs return, before a different section enters. The segments change faster than I can type them out, but trust me it all works. I like the Brian-May-style guitar layering from Thorsten as the song comes to a close. That was a very eventful ride!

Track 4 - Unknown Yet

This is the shortest track at 4:30. This begins with clean electric guitar, soon joined by the rhythm section and a shimmering acoustic. The vocals come in next. Nice harmonies, very clean and ringing in-tune. This is a bit of an introspective ballad. Slightly prior to 3 minutes a dreamy keyboard part, then (what sounds like) fretless bass take us to the guitar solo with a lot of 'right hand tapping'. Another chorus follows with a bit of lightly-distorted electric rhythm guitar. This track is a well-executed change of pace for the album.

Track 5 - Stench

One of the relatively shorter tracks at 5:24. This one starts off rockin'! Boris' raspy quality returns on this one. I like the keyboard part that comes in during the verse. There is a brief solo piano part before the chorus begins. Another verse and chorus cycles through, then we have an instrumental break led by organ and joined by guitar that leads to a short guitar solo. Another chorus follows. Unaccompanied piano happens around 3:45, then at 4 minutes a flute-like sound takes over on the keys. A nice bass line makes a counter-melody then some glorious mellotron enters. The rock returns with about 30 seconds to go. It's a good track, but I would have liked them to have extended the instrumental section some more. Again, it's a solid track, but maybe not quite as good as the rest so far.

Track 6 - Hang It Up!

A bit longer at 6:45. Whoo! A prog-tastic riff right from the get-go! I love it. Great odd-meter rhythm. At 15 seconds the keys take over unaccompanied, then the riff returns. This reminds me of the intro to 'Changes' by Yes on 90125. By around 50 seconds they begin a new tune. Then the music briefly calms down before the prog riff resumes. By 1:55, I believe we are building towards a new part. Yeah, around 2:25, the odd meters continue, but it's different. Not 100% sure, but this seems to be shaping up into a full instrumental, and a good one at that! Cool pulsing synth takes over at around 4 minutes and Thorsten plays melodic guitar over the top. The beat resumes around 4:40 and he takes a guitar solo, followed by a keyboard solo. The band-members are navigating time changes with ease as any good prog band should. They saved the best riff for last it seems at around 6:15. What a great prog instrumental! (My suspicions were confirmed.) Nothing against Boris' vocals as they have been great, but this one got my prog-fan blood pumping, and, and may be my favorite on the album so far. But, there are two tracks to go!

Track 7 - Stuck in a Maze

This is the second longest track at 10:20. It begins with a big rock riff from the full band. It's just a bit sinister. Boris begins singing with only keys and bass accompanying. At around 1:44, heavy guitar begins accenting then the band kicks back in at around 2 minutes. A chorus follows. I love the riff at 2:45. Another quiet verse follows. It builds in a similar manner to the first one. Boris is using the raspy tone again. Super cool riffs at 5:10. There is a mellow section at around 5:45. There are dissonant chords on the keys, jazzy guitar leads and a spoken part with effects on it. By 6:15 the full band resumes. Initially there is a short guitar solo, then the keys take over. There are some very unique keyboard tones here. The guitar returns next. A unison guitar and keyboard riff follows. The vocals return by 7:40. An ascending pattern takes over at around 8:30, then another chorus happens. Thorsten takes another solo as the song nears conclusion, followed by another keyboard solo. I love the big complex ending! Great prog!

Track 8 - If the Music Dies

The final track is relatively short at 5:30. This starts right out with vocals accompanied with clean guitar in an odd meter. Harmonies join in, giving me Gentle Giant vibes. Mellotron joins the soundscape at 1:00. Another verse resumes. I believe we are in 5 here. At around 2:40, the keys play a tune that I would call 'The Snake Charmer Tune' but made to fit in 5-4 time. The vocal arrangement gets even better at around 3:20, sounding like a men's choir. The bass & drums are taking a break on this song, but they aren't needed here. This is a truly unique and very engaging track! Well-done!

OVERALL IMPRESSIONS:

I had no idea what to expect when I began this review. But I am very impressed by Mihrax! I can't compare it to their first album, as I haven't heard it; but only the father and son team remain from that effort, making this is nearly a new band. Tobias is a talented young musician and writer, and it seems that he is surrounded by more seasoned musicians in the band. The playing is solid all around! Thomas and Andreas make a tight rhythm section, while Tobias and Thorston are terrific soloists. Boris is a strong and engaging lead vocalist. I loved all of the tracks with the exception of 'Stench,' but I still liked it, just not quite as much. For me, the star track of the album was 'Hang it Up!' as it was a phenomenal instrumental. Also, 'If the Music Dies,' was a very unique track that really got my attention. I would be remiss if I didn't mention that the cover artwork is fantastic! I hope that Mihrax keeps putting out music of this quality and builds a strong following. A solid 4.25 out of 5 stars! Definitely worth checking out! Fans of Neo-prog with a little bit of heavy rock guitar such as IQ and Marillion, as well as Spock's Beard will likely enjoy this.

Clicked 4 , but really slightly better than that at 4.25

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 La Danza De La Luna by MARTÍNEZ, JULIÁN album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2025
3.65 | 4 ratings

BUY
La Danza De La Luna
Julián Martínez Symphonic Prog

Review by alainPP

3 stars 1. 'El canto del bosque' for a musical journey between piano, a sonata diving into the distant past, those of BACH or CHOPIN and a languorous piece that will leave us stuck in musical space-time 2. 'Caminos de cristal' for the combination of keyboards from yesteryear and today; a sweet bucolic serenade, a touch solemn, for an enticing air 3. 'La danza de la luna' for this combination of harpsichord from times gone by and other, more contemporary keyboards; An energetic ballad with a velvety finale. 4. 'Refugio de sueņos' extends the solemn aria with an enchanting hint of marshmallow. 5. 'Viejas sombras' offers a more cheerful air, where the piano notes seem to come out in a jet, metronomized by the electric drums.

A composer who adores BACH, CHOPIN on one hand, PINK FLOYD, KING CRIMSON, and GENTLE GIANT on the other, for an original creation that showcases the progressive signature of the great classical composers who have bathed the ears of artists from the 1970s to today; a little regressive moment for those who adore keyboards above all and the classical golden age.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Where Ideal and Denial Collide by ODDLEAF album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.13 | 61 ratings

BUY
Where Ideal and Denial Collide
Oddleaf Symphonic Prog

Review by Prog Dog

5 stars by Dean Wolfe of prog dog media (

This has been a go-to CD for me... for months now.

If I had done a 2024's Best Albums of the Year List, Oddleaf would likely have topped it. Although there's no shortage of fresh new progrock hitting hot wax.

Oddleaf are likely inspired by some of the classic 70s prog rock bands- one in particular they do remind me of is the great female-singer led Rennaissance- and Oddleaf's lead vocalist Adeline Gurtner is on par with Annie Haslam in presence and substance.

This band has created prog rock epics without need to resort to modern prog metal vibes. The flute figures large in many parts of the album and transports me to the dense forests of Tolkien's Middle Earth at times, or the Dark Ages.

There is no lack of bass on the album- it is unmistakably present and integral to the band's sound- Olivier Orlando often (maybe always) picks the bass with a treble-inducing plectrum.

And did I mention the drummer? Highly energetic, sophisticated- but not sounding too 'technical'- Clément Cureaudau is playing in cool time 'sigs' all the time, but he's sneaky about it, makes it sound natural and easy- sort of like Yes' Alan White and less like Rush's Neil Peart.

Complexity abounds on this debut album "Where Ideal and Denial Collide" yet it manages to remain subtle. The production is balanced- not overly processed - very cohesive- clean-- it all sits perfectly - which is I think due in part to the band's skills of self-editing. There aren't 'too many notes' or too many instruments. All of Oddleaf's musical elements intertwine without clashing or competing- actually a remarkable feat. I liken it to watching a busy intersection in Vietnam that has no stoplights yet everyone manages to flow through without incident- it's mesmerizing.

Did I mention the keyboards? Lots of accomplished playing- great rock organ solos by main composer Carina Taurer...some great piano sections and cool Tony Banks and Keith Emerson-ish playful escapades. I need to check if she's won any awards yet- she sounds like a giant in the making. Lots of fantastic sections.

I'm a guitarist, so I noticed there is only a scattering of electric guitar across the album...several solos, but the album doesn't feel lacking in any way.

The 'Oddleaf' sound has been confidently nailed. Regardless of any comparisons made here, Oddleaf have their own unique sound.

The album opener- and closer- are epic and grandiose- graceful and hearkening to the days when an album was an album - capturing the entire album's vibe- which is often one of optimism. The lyrics throughout are cleverly woven at times reminding us to honour the planet, but also reassuring us that no matter what 'the Earth's core will remain warm'. 'Bring me back to a simple time..' Gurtner sings.

The songwriting is adventurous but mature- the music unfolds gracefully, effortlessly. A remarkable first effort by any standard. Strong melodies are spread throughout, haunting at times, surprisingly wide in scope. The album's tracks are often tied together, sometimes with windy desert sounds, and the album finishes off with what sounds like a whale swimming off into the distance, singing 'goodbye' and leaving the listener in a state of peaceful longing.

The latter part of the album departs a little bit from the tone it began with - a little less heavy-hitting on 'song'-ness, and is more experimental and noodle-y- perhaps hinting already that Oddleaf is not content without a little boundary- pushing playfulness.

The backup vocals are also noteworthy- tasteful and distinct. Everyone except the drummer is noted to have added their voices- which creates more distinction in the Oddleaf sound.

The flute work by Mathieu Rossi is refreshing. It's such an earthy and uplifting instrument- and is another link to a musical past of simpler ages (It reminds me more of Peter Gabriel with Genesis than Jethro Tull- but I don't know Tull too well yet. Others can chime in on the comparison).

I could go on, but let's leave it there. My score is 5 bones out of 5- partly because they just appeared out of nowhere with a super fresh unique sound. It's a spectacular album- full of nuance and well-thought-through passages and interludes, with both a serious and a fun-side without the slightest air of pretension or even ambition to be anything but a young band with a vision . Thank-you, Oddleaf.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Miracle by QUEEN album cover Studio Album, 1989
3.16 | 434 ratings

BUY
The Miracle
Queen Prog Related

Review by sgtpepper

3 stars The miracle was regarded as a return to the true Queen sound and principles - live rocking sound, focus on guitars. The band fulfilled the promise indeed, we could say they feel re-energized after a 3-year break. May is more audible than ever since 1980's keyboard input into the Queen sound. Deacon provides top contribution in particular to the dance or electronic inspired tracks like "Invisible man" and "Rain must fall". Mercury's vocal and showmanship shine through whereas Taylor's versatility ranges from pop, rock, metal to the 80's alternative. May feels very inspired, starting with the guitar instrumental on "Chinese torture" continuing to true hard rock/heavy metal riffing and distinguished soloing.

Though the sound will please most of older Queen fans, I think the material is weaker than on the previous 2 albums because of unusually high amount of filler. No denying the band was having fun but almost all of the 4- mark compositions were OK in the album's context but can't stand on their own (Party, Khashoggis ship, Scandal, My baby does me, Hang on there). These have their moments but ultimately feel either undeveloped or are overall not memorable. On the other end of the spectrum, we're faced with 3 incredibly strong compositions, crown jewels. "The miracle" has a fantastic melody, soothing chorus, moments of tension. Guitar solo is delicate and melancholic at the same time. The semi-hard-rock outro is ingeniously arranged if not very inventively played by May.

"I want it all" is another gem, a direct punched rocker. The studio version contains additional very 80's riffing. The mid section starting with the vocal tandem of May/Mercury invites into hard-rocking and then heavy metal territory. If you search of an anthem on this album, this is it.

The last standout is "Breakthrough", though more conventional in its composition, the muscular rhythm and Mercury section take the spotlight. Pay attention to the bass solo followed by the traditional guitar work.

Further tracks worth noting is the dance-friendly "The Invisible man" and the slightly epic "Was it all worth it" with sparse progressive elements in the structure and rhythmic parts. The most ambitious track, could be considered a premature "Innuendo".

Queen did an excellent job by tackling multiple (and some new) styles on this record. Not all exercises had a winning formula but fortunately, there are a couple of excellent tracks.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Quantum Phase Transition by EKZILO album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.18 | 41 ratings

BUY
Quantum Phase Transition
Ekzilo Psychedelic/Space Rock

Review by higgins

5 stars This second album by Ekzilo represents a radical evolution from their self-titled debut. It has a magic quality. It mixes a thousand surprising things, and they all fit together. The album never strays, even though he has plenty of opportunities, haha. It takes risks and excels. The instrumental level is very professional. And the composition. The production is a 10/10.

It's a magnificent album (and of Spanish origin). The suite, both in its title and style, demonstrates this absolutely wild evolution. On first listening, with those pauses and changes in key, it leaves you disoriented. But everything works perfectly together (as does the entire album). There are so many different influences here, but this "Quantum Phase Transition" is an album that doesn't deserve musical spoilers; it's better to let yourself be surprised by it. Few albums this year are as surprising and of higher quality.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Live in Cuxhaven 1976 by CAN album cover Live, 2022
3.31 | 13 ratings

BUY
Live in Cuxhaven 1976
Can Krautrock

Review by Syzygy
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars Live in Cuxhaven 1976 was the third archival Can live album to be released, following two epic 90 minute sets from Stuttgart and Brighton dating from 1975. This is a very different beast indeed, capturing 30 minutes of the core quartet in Lower Saxony shortly before the release of Flow Motion.

As usual the individual tracks are numbered, and all four last between six and a half and eight and a half minutes. Eins seems to start in mid flow - presumably the bootlegger forgot to press 'record' until the band had been playing for a couple of minutes - and the sound and feel very much point the way forward to Flow Motion. Zwei is a little more spacy and a little less funky, while Drei offers a somewhat deconstructed version of Dizzy Dizzy. Vier is the closest we get to the unfettered monster jams heard on previous concert recordings, with Karoli in particular cutting loose with some blistering axe work. There is then a brief announcement that the band will take a break. If there were any 20 minutes plus spontaneous compositions in the second set, either they weren't recorded or, for whatever reason, Irmin Schmidt and Mute have decided not to share them with us.

What we get on this album is a tighter, more focused iteration of Can; the interplay is dazzling, but in general the music feels more polished and less manic. The sound quality is excellent throughout, and it feels more like a budget official live album than a cleaned up bootleg; clearly, the recording technology available to bootleggers had improved in the mid to late 1970s. Vinyl aficionados will be pleased that it's an affordable single album pressed in blue; if you haven't got a turntable it's available as a reasonably priced download. It's a worthy addition to the ongoing series of live albums, and demonstrates that Can on stage still had the fire that was sometimes missing from their later releases, but it's distinctly non-essential.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Blow By Blow by BECK, JEFF album cover Studio Album, 1975
4.18 | 326 ratings

BUY
Blow By Blow
Jeff Beck Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by Lobster77

5 stars Mere words can't come close to capturing the incredible magic of the fusion-inspired work laid down by guitarist Jeff Beck in the mid-'70s. The George Martin produced Blow by Blow (Epic Records/March of 1975) must be heard to be believed.

Running on instrumental freewheeling innovation, the nine song album features the hyper "Scatterbrain", the bumper-to-bumper "Freeway Jam", the effects-laced "Constipated Duck", a cover of "She's a Woman", and the sobering "Cause We've Ended as Lovers", which Stevie Wonder penned specifically for Beck.An absolute legend on the guitar. None of these songs need anything else. They are orchestrated perfectly. The drums are killer too and I feel they might get overshadowed because of how heavily featured the guitar is.

The diverse and inspired Blow by Blow is pure genius from a legendary guitarist, which served as Beck's most popular LP release.5.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Neptune by CELLULOID album cover Studio Album, 1983
3.86 | 3 ratings

BUY
Neptune
Celluloid Progressive Electronic

Review by Progfan97402
Prog Reviewer

4 stars When Mellotron albums are talked about, we talk about the obvious ones like the Moody Blues, Yes, King Crimson, Tangerine Dream (and solo Edgar Froese), and Genesis, and the less obvious ones, but equally important and well loved, like Spring, Beggars Opera (Waters of Change, that is), Anglagard, Anekdoten, Museo Rosenbach, Celeste, Earth & Fire, Barclay James Harvest (mainly the 1974 Live album as most of their albums features much more real strings, and less tron than you imagine), and too many others. One artist completely missing is Chuck Minuto and his Celluloid project from the 1980s, not exactly tron friendly times. Mercury was the debut, and while it does feature some Mellotron, it mainly credits a computer, which was supposedly actually a rented Synclavier II. It's the next album Neptune that's a completely different story, and the reason it's barely discussed amongst tron lovers is because the album is very rare and hard to fine, and the only reissue is a dodgy 2-for-1 that includes Mercury. Neptune is created entirely on the Mellotron, and it truly is a Mellotron tour-de-force if there ever was one. I find it hard to believe he used only one tron, as it's clear he's using tons of tron FX as well as the tron standards like strings, flute, and choir. Also, where is he getting those synth sounds? Unless they were included as custom tron tapes, I simply believe he was using a synth that was hanging around his home. Regardless you'll never hear so much tron in your life. The music is often ambient and experiment, with all sorts of sound effects to stuff inspired by "Revolution 9", King Crimson, and Genesis. He does use a lot of reverb and echo boxes as well. It's clear this is a home-made affair so you're not getting a full professional production, but it's surprisingly well-down given Chuck Minuto was still a teenager. Hard to believe this was 1983. This was at a time when Duran Duran, A Flock of Seagulls, The Thompson Twins, and even Talk Talk (they were still a New Wave synth pop act then) were on the airwaves, with MTV airing their videos, and hair metal was just starting to hit the scene with Quiet Riot, the now-makeup-free KISS, and Def Leppard going that direction with Pyromania. Neptune sounds more like an album that belongs in the previous decade, and in this case, all for the better. The original LP is naturally rare and expensive, but it's really worth it for all tron nuts out there!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Empires Must Fall by GHOST OF THE MACHINE album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.75 | 25 ratings

BUY
Empires Must Fall
Ghost Of The Machine Neo-Prog

Review by BBKron

3 stars Second album from this UK Neo-Prog band. Guitar-heavy melodic progressive rock, with a definite leaning towards the sound and style of Rush (particularly the 80's version of Rush, with more keyboards, less proggy structure). Fine playing and musicianship, but the songs and style just didn't click with me. Single vocalist with no background or harmony vocals at all, so not a very full sound. Came across more as Rush wannabes without the needed songwriting skills. If that vibe and style is appealing, you will probably really like this, but it is not really for me. Not bad, just not that great. Rating 2.5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Of Queues and Cures by NATIONAL HEALTH album cover Studio Album, 1978
4.28 | 552 ratings

BUY
Of Queues and Cures
National Health Canterbury Scene

Review by Lobster77

5 stars National Health's second LP is generally similar to their first, but there are several points of difference: co-founder Alan Gowen is no longer involved, Amanda Parsons' lovely vocals are missing as well, and whereas all material on the debut was composed by Gowen and Dave Stewart, here the songwriting is more evenly distributed, with Stewart contributing three tracks ? "The Bryden 2-Step (for Amphibians)" Parts 1 and 2, and "The Collapso" ? and bassist John Greaves, guitarist Phil Miller, and drummer Pip Pyle one apiece ("Squarer for Maud", "Dreams Wide Awake", and "Binoculars").

Side A's first track, "The Bryden 2-Step (for Amphibians)" Part 1, begins with a hushed "dawn" introduction (complete with birdsong), which gives way to an energetic theme that might at first be mistaken for something by Emerson, Lake & Palmer before settling into a fusion-y interlude and concluding with a hypnotic passage featuring a bass solo. Regarding the next track, "The Collapso", suffice it to say that it bears no resemblance to calypso, even though Selwyn Baptiste appears briefly on steel drums; in fact, it sounds particularly ELP-ish. The final track on Side A, "Squarer for Maud", is rather more foreboding, sounding at times somewhat like some extended instrumental excursion by the Starless and Bible Black-period King Crimson, and incorporates a sudden spoken-word interjection that feels like it could have come from Robert Fripp's Exposure.

Opening side B is "Dreams Wide Awake", which starts out in a way that could put you momentarily in mind of Edgar Winter's "Frankenstein" and then goes back into the standard National Health solo-trading that's always enjoyable to listen to but would be a challenge to identify which track it came from if you were to hear a random segment of it. The next track, "Binoculars", features actual singing (by John Greaves), making it the most reminiscent of Hatfield and the North of anything on this LP; there's also some nice flute and clarinet by Jimmy Hastings. The album closes with "The Bryden 2-Step (for Amphibians)" Part 2, which starts with an almost bolero-like riff before breaking into the main theme from Part 1 and finally drifting off ethereally in typical Dave Stewart fashion. 4.99 a essential for the Canterbury section of a collection.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 David Gilmour by GILMOUR, DAVID album cover Studio Album, 1978
3.56 | 413 ratings

BUY
David Gilmour
David Gilmour Prog Related

Review by Lobster77

4 stars Pink Floyd guitarist/vocalist David Gilmour hasn't been extremely prolific as a solo artist, issuing only three studio albums in over thirty years. Given the large gaps in his discography, it isn't entirely surprising that all three of his records are significantly different in style. On this, his debut record, David opts for a harder rocking sound that falls a bit closer to the classic Floyd style of the 70's. The music here is slightly bluesier and more straightforward than most of classic Floyd, while most of the track clock in at a relatively meager (by Floyds standards) 5-6 minutes. Still, many of the individual passages here still wouldn't have sounded horribly out of place on the Gilmour-heavy Floyd album Animals, which was released the previous year.

David Gilmour is ultimately the only one of Gilmour's studio releases that I find particularly satisfying, not because it adheres more closely to 70's hard rock orthodoxy but because it offers what is easily Gilmour's strongest set of melodies. "There's No Way out of Here" and "I Can't Breathe Anymore" are vocal-based pieces that nicely anticipate the bands more song-based approach of The Wall, while "It's Deafinitely" (the proggiest thing here) is an engaging instrumental whose guitar/synth interplay favorably recalls Steve Hackett's solo work of the same period. In fact, there isn't a single track here that I'd label as sub-par, even if dreamier cuts like "Mihalis" and "Short and Sweet" merely float by without leaving much of an impression.

A very good release that every Pink Floyd fan should look to acquire. Fans of classic hard rock who were never particularly keen on Floyd's spacey progressive style may also be interested in this record as a relatively accessible entry point into the band's greater corpus of work. 4.5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Seawater by MOSTLY AUTUMN album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.73 | 63 ratings

BUY
Seawater
Mostly Autumn Prog Folk

Review by BBKron

3 stars This veteran U.S. Prog Folk band, releasing their 15th album, an expansive 76 min affair, and it is quite an enjoyable listen, if you are OK with its limitations. I would describe this as dramatic, atmospheric folk-rock with prog elements, and it is filled with simple but effective songs and engaging melodies that are given lush treatment. Great emotional vocal performances, and the contrasting styles, and interaction of the main female and male vocalists are the main highlights of the album. Unfortunately, several of the songs are stretched-out much longer than they should be through repetition rather than musical inventiveness. Even the mostly effective epic-length (19 min) Pink Floyd-inspired title track is much longer than needed. Good, but could have been much better. Rating: 3.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Curious Ruminant by JETHRO TULL album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.40 | 100 ratings

BUY
Curious Ruminant
Jethro Tull Prog Folk

Review by BBKron

3 stars Ian Anderson and his current assemblage as Jethro Tull are back with their 3rd album in the last 4 years, and this is the best of those three, as it has more elements reminiscent of the old Tull (more folk and rock elements, return of the acoustic guitar, etc.). It's a good listen, quite enjoyable. The instrumental sections, in particular, are quite good, with stellar flute work and a stronger guitar presence than other recent albums. However, it is still a far cry from classic Tull. Anderson's vocals have greatly deteriorated and are somewhat distracting (should do more instrumentals) and overall, the songs are just not as memorable. Thus, it's good, but not great, and not really something you will probably want to go back to again and again. Rating: 3.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Parasomnia by DREAM THEATER album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.02 | 276 ratings

BUY
Parasomnia
Dream Theater Progressive Metal

Review by BBKron

3 stars OK, I'm not a big fan of Dream Theater or Prog-Metal in general, so maybe it's not surprising that I was not very impressed with this new album, their first since drummer extraordinaire Mike Portnoy re-joined the band. There is no denying the excellent musicianship on display here and the sound is great, but there is just too much metal and not enough prog influences present here to work well for me. I think many were hoping that there would be more of a return to the old Dream Theater with Portnoy's return, but this sounds just like their last few albums, which I have tried to get into, but it just doesn't click for me. Not bad, just not that great. Rating 3.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Dominion by IQ album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.15 | 172 ratings

BUY
Dominion
IQ Neo-Prog

Review by BBKron

3 stars Another veteran prog band returning after an extended absence (6 years since last album) with this, their 13th album. It contains all the parts and pieces you expect from these professionals and all the components of a great Neo-Prog album: excellent musicianship and instrumental prowess, great range of dynamics and moods, emotive vocals and majestic themes, and wonderful sound and production. Unfortunately, it is still somewhat disappointing, as the songs themselves are just nothing special, and fail to create engaging melodies or compelling themes. They seem to be going through the motions of what has worked in the past, but the songs just fall somewhat flat. The opening 22-min epic is OK but doesn't really go anywhere, and despite fine individual efforts from all involved, it just seems quite ordinary. Best track is Far From Here, which almost reaches another level, but can't quite sustain it. There's nothing bad here, it is all fine, pleasant, and well-done, good, it just doesn't inspire or excite, and is thus underwhelming. Rating: 3.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Transmutation by KARMAKANIC album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.13 | 113 ratings

BUY
Transmutation
Karmakanic Symphonic Prog

Review by BBKron

5 stars What began as a side project for The Flower King's bassist, Jonas Reingold, in 2002, has developed over the years into one of the premier modern symphonic prog bands, and they are back again, after a 9-year absence with this, their 6th album, and Jonas and band have brought along many wonderful prog guest artists to help out, including Steve Hackett (and all the members of his touring band), Andy Tillison (The Tangent), John Mitchell (Frost, It Bites, Lonely Robot), Randy McStine, Nick D'Virgilio, and Simon Phillips, to produce one of the best albums of the year so far. It opens with a burst of energy in the brief, but powerful rockin' instrumental Bracing For Impact, and then continues to get better and better with each subsequent track, End of the World is a beautiful song (although goes on a bit too long), then Cosmic Love gives a somewhat throwback 80's single sound, like something from Yes' 90125 period. But they are just getting started, as each of the rest are great, such as the fantastic Gotta Lose This Ball and Chain, culminating with the sensational Prog epic title track (23 min), which is stunningly brilliant from beginning to end, with everything you could want in a prog epic, from tender acoustic sections to glorious majestic themes to incredible soloing and exciting instrumental passages, including a dazzling middle section that manages to channel Genesis as a jazz fusion band, then reprising earlier themes for an emotional and majestic finale. Just brilliant, and one of the best epic-length prog tracks in many years, and that can stand among the all-time greats. What I really love about this band and album is that they are extremely creative and inventive in their arrangements, production, and instrumentation, able to turn even fairly simple themes and melodies into wonderful, exciting pieces with their intricate, detailed handling. Just love this album, my absolute favorite of the year so far and sure to be in the running in the end for best album of the year. Best Tracks: Transmutation, Gotta Lose This Ball and Chain, All That Glitters is Not Gold, We Got The World in Our Hands. Rating: 5.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Motorpsycho by MOTORPSYCHO album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.14 | 92 ratings

BUY
Motorpsycho
Motorpsycho Eclectic Prog

Review by BBKron

4 stars You never quite know what you're going to get from this prolific (28 albums overall, and 16th album in the last 17 years) eclectic Norwegian prog band, with their ever-shifting styles that incorporate heavy doses of psychedelic, indie, and prog rock, along with forays into ambient, atmospheric, acoustic, pop, jazz, punk, metal, krautrock, space-rock, and so on. Although their last couple albums have had a lighter pop-oriented touch (I absolutely loved 2023's Yay!, whereas 2024's Neigh was just OK), this album gets back to heavier aspects and their psych, prog, and hard rock roots, but also contains bits of everything from their past and still maintains their melodic sensibilities and that Motorpsycho sound, in this expansive self-titled double album (11 tracks, >81 min.). This one has it all, and they pull out all the stops, in various moods and styles, from the dark psychedelia of the opener Lucifer, Bringer of Life, to the throwback pop feel of Stanley (Tonight's the Night) to the heavy guitar riffs (and Jimi Hendrix vibe) of The Comeback and the psych-prog journey of Balthazar. Then there is the epic-length (21 min) Neotzar, with its mix of jazz, prog, and psychedelia in a mesmerizing and a bit creepy blend. But there's still more with the lighter, brighter Core Memory Corrupt, and the driving groove of Three Frightened Monkeys, before the melancholy pop of Dead of Winter closes the album out. Another wonderful, eclectic album from Motorpsycho. Best Tracks: Balthazar, The Comeback, Stanley, Core Memory Corrupt, Dead of Winter, Neotzar. Rating: 4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Overview by WILSON, STEVEN album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.85 | 227 ratings

BUY
The Overview
Steven Wilson Crossover Prog

Review by BBKron

3 stars As one of the biggest names in modern Prog, it's always interesting to hear what Steven Wilson is up to, and this album had additional expectations as it was hyped as Steven's 'return to prog' after multiple albums experimenting with different musical forms, with mixed results. On this album, Steven tackles the concept of The Overview, which has to do with a state of awe and transcendence reported by astronauts while viewing Earth from Space. And if Steven was attempting a musical depiction of that experience, I don't think he succeeded. But for me, Steven Wilson has always been hit and miss, as he has produced some brilliant music, but also a lot of just OK stuff over the years. On this album Steven serves up a mixture of sounds and themes that span through his history, from the more atmospheric, spacey early work of Porcupine Tree through to the more experimental pop of recent years. As usual, the production and sound is impeccable, but for me at least, the results are similar to past work in that it is extremely up and down, equal parts good and disappointing. There are only 2 album side-long tracks here, but yet they don't really hold together as cohesive pieces, more as a collection of shorter pieces just placed together, some of which work and some that don't. It seems to be put together from various pieces and ideas he had lying around. The best parts are really good, with some great melodies, proggy elements, and pop-rock arrangements, whereas the weaker parts are somewhat dull or not very interesting. Overall, maybe about half of each full track was enjoyable for me, about 15-20 minutes out of the 41 min length. I know many consider Mr. Wilson to be a musical genius, and I'm glad that Steven is able to do whatever kind of music he wants to do, but once again, these musings strike me as being just pretty good, and a bit underwhelming. Rating: 3.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Father of Make Believe by COHEED AND CAMBRIA album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.68 | 16 ratings

BUY
The Father of Make Believe
Coheed And Cambria Crossover Prog

Review by BBKron

4 stars Coheed and Cambria is a U.S. rock band that has been around since 2002, but is hard to categorize due to the wide variety of styles they play. All of their albums are concept albums, or more accurately, part of an interrelated series of concept albums that tell a larger story. This is their 11th album overall and 3rd in the Vaxis Series. I can't begin to say just what the story entails (haven't heard the previous albums), but musically, it is all over the place, with a little bit of everything, and I really liked this one. It opens with a beautiful folk ditty (Yesterday Lost), then follows with a driving power pop rocker (Goodbye Sunshine), then a melodic hard rock gem (Searching For Tomorrow). Full-on heavy prog of the title track is next, followed by a sweet ballad which swells to an anthemic power ballad (Meri of Mercy). Then comes the fierce onslaught of metal and punk metal in Blind Side Sonny and Play the Poet. One Last Miracle is a fine hard rocker and Corner My Confidence tones things down with a lovely, folky, acoustic charmer, before a catchy 80's style pop-rock single (Someone Who Can). Then comes the powerful concluding suite, Continuum, which is broken into 4 parts, each with its own style and vibe, wrapping up with So It Goes, a wonderfully bouncy and catchy pop song. And surprisingly, it all works. The vocals from Claudio are wonderful throughout, whether dripping with honey on the pop-oriented songs or screaaming and growling on the heavier tracks, he is great. And the arrangements are also spot-on, covering many different styles, showing the versatility of the band. What is most impressive to me, though, is the melodic sense that runs through all the songs, with engaging, catchy melodies, whether gentle pop or hard rock, and even the heavy metal, that melodic sensibility shines through, creating a very satisfying collection of songs. The only musical comparison I can think of would be something like a much heavier The Dear Hunter, showing that kind of variety, versatility, outrageousness, and melodic sense. However, because of the range of types of songs, it may be that those who prefer the heavier aspects of the band may not appreciate the more pop-oriented tracks, and vice versa for those enjoy the more poppy tunes, so I don't know how this fits in with their other albums, but I am very impressed. Best Tracks: So It Goes, Father of Make Believe, Goodbye Sunshine, Corner My Confidence, Searching For Tomorrow. Rating: 4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Time Silent Radio II by ECHOLYN album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.96 | 88 ratings

BUY
Time Silent Radio II
Echolyn Symphonic Prog

Review by BBKron

4 stars Legendary U.S. Symphonic Prog band Echolyn has emerged after a ten-year absence with not one, but two new albums, their 10th and 11th (released not as a double album, but 2 separate albums), returning with their unique rockin' prog sound, mixing classic melodic rock and power pop with sumptuous symphonic prog for a wonderful set of albums. TSRii consists of 2 epic-length tracks (16 and 29 min.), whereas TSRvii has 7 shorter tracks (that's where the titles come from). The two lengthy tracks ebb and flow and take their time to develop through multiple musical sections and themes, but never lose focus, remaining consistently enjoyable and entertaining throughout their musical journeys. I prefer TSRVII over this disc, but this is still quite wonderful prog. It is just not quite as consistently brilliant throughout as the other disc is. Echolyn's music may have many varied influences throughout, but yet they have created their own unique style, as they don't sound quite like anyone else. I'm not all that familiar with the band's earlier catalog, but I really like these 2 albums, and will be returning to them often throughout the year. Best Tracks: Water in Our Hands. Rating: 4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Time Silent Radio vii by ECHOLYN album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.11 | 77 ratings

BUY
Time Silent Radio vii
Echolyn Symphonic Prog

Review by BBKron

5 stars Legendary U.S. Symphonic Prog band Echolyn has emerged after a ten-year absence with not one, but two new albums, their 10th and 11th (released not as a double album, but 2 separate albums), returning with their unique rockin' prog sound, mixing classic melodic rock and power pop with sumptuous symphonic prog for a wonderful set of albums. TSRvii has 7 shorter tracks (that's where the titles come from), and is the better of the two albums, as the songs are brighter, punchier, with more emphasis on melody and catchy rock tunes, but still with plenty of proggy goodness throughout, with great vocals, instrumental passages and arrangements. All the tracks are great (but my faves are listed below). Echolyn's music may have many varied influences throughout, but yet they have created their own unique style, as they don't sound quite like anyone else. I'm not all that familiar with the band's earlier catalog, but I love this album, and will be returning to it often throughout the year. Best Tracks: Tiny Star, On We Blur, Boulder on Hills, Radio Waves, Cul-de-Sacs and Tunnels. Rating: 4.5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Passing by ROBERGE, JACOB album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.96 | 45 ratings

BUY
The Passing
Jacob Roberge Symphonic Prog

Review by BBKron

4 stars A new voice in progressive rock, Canadian composer-vocalist-multi-instrumentalist Jacob Roberge has emerged with his 1st album, a grand excursion in the melodic symphonic prog tradition. The first half of the album features shorter songs and a more acoustic approach with prominent piano, acoustic guitar, winds, and strings, with soaring melodies and classical themes, but also some lulls and dull passages. The album picks up as it goes along, with Empty Traces, part 2 a highlight, but the album really soars with the epic-length (32 min.) title track, consisting of multiple sections, styles, and dynamics, encompassing the best of symphonic prog, embracing the styles of the classic bands (Yes, Genesis) as well as more modern influences (Big Big Train and especially Neal Morse) to produce a wonderful majestic track that satisfies on every level. It moves seamlessly from one section to the next, with beautiful melodies and rousing instrumental passages, and culminating with a grand majestic finale. This track is superb and more than makes up for some inconsistencies in the early tracks, producing a very good and satisfying album experience. It will be interesting to see what this rising artist does next. Best Tracks: The Passing, Empty Traces Part 2. Rating: 3.5

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Friend of All Creatures by PATTERN-SEEKING ANIMALS album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.89 | 96 ratings

BUY
Friend of All Creatures
Pattern-Seeking Animals Crossover Prog

Review by BBKron

4 stars Originally began as on offshoot of Spock's Beard (featuring current and former members Ted Leonard, Jimmy Keegan, Dave Meros, John Boegehold) in 2019, this band has forged their own way, creating their own sound and style, to become one of the premier modern melodic progressive rock bands. This is their 5th album (over just 6 years), and continues their reign of producing high quality 'music that's progressive and intricate while keeping things immediate and melodic' (in the band's own words). Another batch of wonderful songs that are a joy throughout, beautiful and well-played, with great vocals and musicianship, and the full range of emotions, dynamics, and instrumentation. Although not quite my favorite of theirs (that would be 2022's Only Passing Through), this is a great album nonetheless, and maintains the high bar established by each of the previous albums. Masterful melodic prog. Best Tracks: Down the Darkest Road, Words of Love Evermore, Days We'll Remember, Another Holy Grail. Rating: 4.0

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Man & Myth by HARPER, ROY album cover Studio Album, 2013
3.79 | 24 ratings

BUY
Man & Myth
Roy Harper Prog Folk

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

4 stars On what, in retrospect, appears to be ROY HARPER's final album of original, non outtake material, he has out guestlisted even his own prior records, enlisting, among others, PETE TOWNSHEND, Irish guitar session wizz BILL SHANLEY, and venerable folkie ANDY IRVINE. He exits the stage with one of his most accomplished collections, marred only by his increasing tendency to overreach on at least one track per disc, this one being the 15 minute 15 stone anchor of concrete galoshes "Heaven is Here".

Luckily the achievements overrule here. "The Enemy" is reminiscent of LINDISFARNE's best work right down to the ALAN HULLisms vocally and lyrically; the delicate gentility of "Time is Temporary" is even exceeded by the heartfelt ballad "January Man"; and "Cloud Cuckooland" is a send up of the race for failed modernity as nobody can express better.

By this point, Harper had little left to prove, but Man and Myth solidifies his legendary status. Few other artists have scaled multiple summits over the better part of a half century.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Robert Fripp & Andy Summers: Bewitched by FRIPP, ROBERT album cover Studio Album, 1984
2.87 | 61 ratings

BUY
Robert Fripp & Andy Summers: Bewitched
Robert Fripp Eclectic Prog

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars An album I picked up as soon as it came out (back when I was a daily frequenter of the local records stores). The idea of the album intrigued me--though I never expected Summers to hold his own against the Fripp-genius. Still, knowing the diversity of styles Seņor Robert had tried (and having been an avid fan of it all), and seeing Andy's ventures into the world of synthesized sounds, I had to give it a try. And I gave it far more attention than perhaps it even deserved. Don't get me wrong: it's all very likable--with a couple songs that even made regular rotations on my driving cassette tapes--and it does represent the technology of the times (what we thought might be the future of music, at the time)-- but there's really little here to demand shouting from the rooftops. Plus, it's predecessor, I Advance Masked, was fresh and refreshing; this one does little new.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Robert Fripp & Andy Summers: Bewitched by FRIPP, ROBERT album cover Studio Album, 1984
2.87 | 61 ratings

BUY
Robert Fripp & Andy Summers: Bewitched
Robert Fripp Eclectic Prog

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

3 stars The less beloved younger brother of I Advance Masked sees Robert Fripp and Andy Summers dial back on the improvisational, texture-based, ambient-oriented approach of that album and focus instead on more composed pieces which fit closer to a conventional art rock sound. The end result is inevitably somewhat less innovative, though since Fripp was coming down off the shuttering of the 1980s incarnation of King Crimson perhaps he was simply in a less experimental mood at the time. It's an enjoyable listen but it's not quite as eye-opening as the first collaboration between the duo, but if you're in the market for New Wave-inclined background music it's not so bad.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Therapeutic Dreams by BLISTERING MOMENTS album cover Studio Album, 1986
3.95 | 2 ratings

BUY
Therapeutic Dreams
Blistering Moments Progressive Electronic

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars I have never had so much paper work, cdrs, posters etc. spread all around me for a review in my almost 20 years of doing this! More on that in the post script. BLISTERING MOMENTS was the project of Jim Leggett and Rik Wilson who were based in Texas. Rikky had worked in a record store from 1970 to 1981. And it was 1981 that Rik was invited to Jim Leggett's house to jam. A musical match made in heaven as they say. Jim had a Robert Fripp styled reel-to-reel frippertronics set up and they played, and it sounded great. Both were music collectors as well.

BLISTERING MOMENTS ended in 1990, but Jim and Rik would continue to work together in various projects from 1996 to the present. They originally named themselves SURGICAL II LS and self released 9 or so cassettes under that name. "Therapeutic Dreams" would get the attention of the label boss for Dead Man's Curve Records in London, England. He suggested they change their name, feeling it was too industrial sounding. Hence the name change to BLISTERING MOMENTS. I think it's ironic then that RYM has them tagged as ambient, drone, sound collage, minimal synth, progressive electronic and... Industrial.

There is a lot of audio samples on this album, but let's look at what the boys were playing during this recording. Jim adds a variety of keyboards, synths, roland organ/strings, mini moog, solina string machine, 2 mellotrons, gibson sg guitar and more. Rik adds conrad bass, wurlitzer organ, roland juno 106, farfisa organ, mellotron, various percussions, samples, and yes, a vacuum. They had stuff. "Therapeutic Dreams" is just under 47 minutes over six tracks, and the compositions were created between 1983 and 1986.

And while the notes, distortion, effects and presentation are distinctly psychedelic, they would open for artists from the avant- garde world and beyond. It's so cool they shared the same stage as Fred Frith, Chris Cutler, Lindsay Cooper and the bands they were apart of at the time. From the humble beginnings of playing for 12 people at a record store to opening for some names including FAITH NO MORE, to being signed by a record label. And the liner notes were written by Dave Henderson, a significant voice in music from the UK at the time. They must have been proud.

Rik the artist designed posters for every upcoming show, more on that later. These two were so creative. A lot of experimenting for sure, to get to the final results. When a lot of people think of Texas, they think of religion and guns. And both are featured prominently on this record. "Night Prowler" opens with this sinister rhythm in a warm humid atmosphere. He's coming. Spacey synths will join in but man I really like that intense rhythm. "77Seven, I Guess" opens strangely with an audio sample before a preacher arrives followed by a heavy atmosphere and relentless gun fire. Reminds me of some of those early psychedelic PORCUPINE TREE albums, but this predates them.

"The Plat-Eyed Position" is an 11 minute tour de force. Spacey sounds to open as we hear footsteps and heavy breathing in atmosphere. This is powerful, almost overwhelming as far as the atmosphere goes. The sound will slightly change as this plays out leading to the preaching at 7 1/2 minutes which ends with "Will you listen to the crowing of the cock?" Next we get the sound of someone trying to start a car over and over. Just trying to get out of dodge. Back to previous sounds after 9 minutes.

"Bushwacker's Overture" opens with heavy gun fire and more as another preacher does his thing. Okay, this song had me giggling like a school girl many times. Usually when I played this at night while under the green spell. At first I found it annoying, but then the gun fire stopped and I just heard the preaching. It was when the gun fire returned the light went on. And I started laughing. And speaking of annoying the start of "Clean Thyself" where we get an official announcer declaring "R" words one after another. Then determined beats kick in. It all turns more powerful when the "R" words stop.

"Die Muther[%*!#]er" is the almost 15 minute closer. Fast paced percussion sounds and more before turning experimental. This is "out there" at 3 minutes. All kinds of banging sounds, keys, vocal expressions and more follow. My music! The creativity on this record is off the charts. It's not perfect by any means but I'm proud to own this.

P.S. I was contacted by Rik Wilson a couple of years ago asking if I'd be interested in hearing the music from some of the projects he was involved with over the years. I didn't know Rik prior to this, but gladly gave my address. I was not expecting such a large package of cdrs, posters and information that he sent. Rik was an art teacher at one point in his life, but before that he was responsible for the cover art of all of his and Jim's albums over the years. The man is creative. So many ideas with not only the various cover art he's done, but the posters really meant a lot as well to me. The inventive ideas to get people out to hear them. A lot of humour too.

Rik is now based in North Carolina and his present project is B. WILDERED. He has his own studio and many releases under his belt. I'm honoured and proud that he dedicated a song from one of those albums to myself. From his "Illiop" record from 2024, we have a song called "New Grange(For John Davie)", that's me!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Sub Rosa in Æternum by TRIBULATION album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.05 | 2 ratings

BUY
Sub Rosa in Æternum
Tribulation Tech/Extreme Prog Metal

Review by UMUR
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars "Sub Rosa in Æternum" is the sixth full-length studio album by Swedish gothic metal act Tribulation. The album was released through Century Media Records in November 2024. It´s the successor to "Where The Gloom Becomes Sound" from 2021. There has been one lineup change since the predecessor as guitarist Jonathan Hultén (a longtime member of the band) has been replaced by Joseph Tholl.

While Tribulation started out playing death/thrash metal oriented music on their first couple of releases, they started to incorporate gothic metal elements to their music on "The Children of the Night" (2015). Over the course of the next couple of albums ("Down Below" from 2018 and the above mentioned "Where The Gloom Becomes Sound" from 2021), the extreme metal elements of the band´s sound have descreased and the gothic metal/rock elements have increased. On "Sub Rosa in Æternum" we´ve now reached a point where this can be fully labelled a gothic metal release. The only extreme metal element left on the album is the sporadic and very rare use of raw snarling vocals (for example heard on "Tainted Skies"). The vocal style is otherwise now deep register clean vocals in typical gothic metal/rock style. It´s artists like Tiamat, Type O Negative, and Paradise Lost who Tribulation are now similar to (or at least share similar musical element with). The less known New Zealand based The House of Capricorn and the equally less known Finns in Babylon Whores are valid references too. Dark, melancholic, and ominous sounding gothic/heavy metal.

The material is effective and well composed, although a few more surprises wouldn´t have hurt. There is a predictability to the song structures which isn´t always a positive feature. Tribulation are a well playing band and lead vocalist/bassist Johannes Andersson has a powerful, emotional, and convincing delivery. The sound production is organic, detailed, and well sounding too, so upon conclusion "Sub Rosa in Æternum" is a high quality release from Tribulation. I personally think they´ve lost some of their uniqueness by cutting the extreme metal elements from their sound, but it´s obviously a conscious choice and there´s probably a better chance to reach a wider audience with a sound like this one compared to the sound of the last couple of releases (and definitely a better chance compared to their early releases). A 3.5 star (70%) rating is deserved.

(Originally posted on Metal Music Archives).

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Lucro Sucio: Los Ojos del Vacío by MARS VOLTA, THE album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.58 | 39 ratings

BUY
Lucro Sucio: Los Ojos del Vacío
The Mars Volta Heavy Prog

Review by TheEliteExtremophile

3 stars I was not super jazzed about this album in the period leading up to its release. The Mars Volta's 2022 self-titled was not a good record. I savaged it as being underbaked, half-assed, and overall un-Voltaic. Supposedly, the acoustic re-recording of that album from 2023 is better, but I haven't listened to it. I thought the underlying songwriting was weak enough that an aesthetic reshaping couldn't save it.

TMV's new album is Lucro sucio; Los ojos del vacio (Dirty Luck; the Eyes of Emptiness). It's 18 songs long, so that daunted me a bit at first glance. But the total runtime is under 50 minutes, so it's not as bad as I initially feared. I was dreading the prospect of something with the sound of their self-titled coupled with the length of Frances the Mute.

I'm happy to report my fears were largely misplaced. Lucro sucio is a huge improvement over The Mars Volta. The songs are relatively short, but they don't suffer from the same underdeveloped quality their reunion record had. Songs flow together smoothly, giving this a sense of cohesion the last album sorely lacked.

The album starts with a pair of songs that barely crack a minute: "Fin" is an airy, (mostly) a capella piece with a sweet atmosphere, and "Reina tormenta" features some interesting electronic elements. Despite these two songs adding up to less than two-and-a-half minutes, this is already showing a lot more promise than their self-titled. This proves you can write short songs without rushing things, which was a major issue on The Mars Volta.

Latin drumming, droning sax and eerie guitars give "Enlazan las tinieblas" an unsettling feeling. While distinct from the sounds of their heyday, this, unlike anything on TMV, actually feels like The Mars Volta. It's spooky and exciting, and everything feels meticulously crafted to feign chaos. Flowing directly from this song is "Mictlán", an eerie atmospheric piece.

"The Iron Rose" is a bit of a step back. Cedric's voice doesn't sound great here, and the writing feels a bit lazy. It's a slow and forlorn piece that doesn't do a ton. It's not awful, but after this album's strong opening, this was a noticeable downgrade.

"Cue the Sun" shows more promise with groaning guitars, throbbing synths, and hoarsely-muttered vocals giving this a tense and anxious aura. "Alba del orate" doesn't feel like a separate song, but more like the second half of "Cue the Sun". I love all the electronic touches, and even the relative simplicity of the indie rock flourishes feel like they belong.

Latin flavors are prominent in "Voice in My Knives". It especially reminds me of certain moments on Amputechture. This song slinks along, and I really like the percussion. The short runtime suits this side of Omar's songwriting well. "Poseedora de mi sombra" sees things start to veer off in a more experimental direction. Chords are slightly off-sounding, and it sees a sense of urgency build. Though, much like "Alba del orate", this feels more like the second half of the preceding song, rather than an independent composition.

The processed vocal effect that plagued Cedric on The Mars Volta returns on "Celaje", and it distracts from what is a pretty interesting composition. Jazz touches and rhythmic inventiveness hearken to some of this band's classic era works, especially on Frances the Mute and Amputechture. 

"Vociferķ" isn't my favorite song here. Moody synths, lo-fi-hip-hop-sounding drums, and Cedric giving a middling vocal performance do not really add up to much.

Following a pointless little interlude, the next real song is "Un disparo al vacío". This is another unfortunate miss. Cedric's vocal cadence is awkward, and the backing is rather minimal. "Maullidos" continues with the torpid mood, and I feel like I've already heard this song elsewhere on this album. "Morgana" doesn't do much to stand out, either. At least the Mellotron flutes add a nice bit of texture.

After that disappointing run, we're treated to a reprise of "Cue the Sun". It provides some good momentum after three consecutive slow songs. It's lush and exciting, and it reinvigorates the record.

The album ends on "Lucro sucio". It sticks with the understated mood this album has cultivated so far, but it's the most akin to classic TMV. It's sinister and foreboding, and this song features a vocal effect that I like. I do wish the percussion were a bit more muscular, though. Parts of this song can border on soupy or mushy, and a stronger rhythmic backing may have helped this ill.

Lucro sucio is the best Mars Volta album in a while. It far outshines their self-titled, and I'd place this above Noctourniquet, too. I would still probably put Octahedron over this, but that has more to do with the sheer strength of songs like "Cotopaxi" and "Luciforms" than any sort of overarching solidity. Lucro sucio is a chill take on the sound of this band, and I overall enjoyed it. I would like to see them put a bit more grit back into their sound in the future, but as it stands, this is a perfectly good release.

Review originally published here: theeliteextremophile.com/2025/04/14/album-review-the-mars-volta-lucro-sucio-los-ojos-del-vacio/

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Signals by RUSH album cover Studio Album, 1982
3.95 | 1558 ratings

BUY
Signals
Rush Heavy Prog

Review by VianaProghead
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Review Nē 889

"Signals" is the ninth studio album of Rush and was released in 1982. It was the follow up to their previous and very successful studio album "Moving Pictures". Stylistically, the album was a continuation of Rush's foray into the new oriented technology of the 80's, through the increased use of electronic instrumentation such as keyboards and electric violin. The synths really add another layer of sound to the album as a whole and clearly without them, the album would not have the charm it has. Other noticeable changes were the decreased average song length and lyrical compression.

"Signals" represents the first studio album released by the band that belongs to their third musical phase that ended with their twelfth studio album "Hold Your Fire" released in 1987. The other two studio albums released by the group between these two studio albums are "Grace Under Pressure" released in 1984 and "Power Windows" released in 1985.

The line up on the album is Geddy Lee (lead vocals, Rickenbacker 4001 and Fender jazz bass, Mini Moog, Obernheim OB-X and OB-Xa, OB-8, Roland Jupiter-8, Obernheim DSX, Roland TR-808 rhythm machine and Moog Taurus pedals), Alex Lifeson (Fender Stratocaster double neck and Moog Taurus pedals) and Neil Pearl (Tama drums, Avedis Zildjian cymbals, Wuhan China Type cymbals and percussion). The album had also the participation of Ben Mink (violin).

"Signals" has eight tracks. All lyrics were written by Neil Pearl, except "Chemistry" that was written by Lee, Lifeson and Pearl and all music was written by Geddy Lee and Alex Lifeson. The first track "Subdivisions" is my favourite song on the album. The keyboards are lush and gorgeous here, and Geddy's voice is in his top element here. Based on whether or not you like "Subdivisions", this is in a certain way the track that can basically decide whether or not you will like "Signals". The second track "The Analog Kid" is a very different song. This is a much more guitar oriented song and represents the hardest rocking song on the whole album. It features Lifeson at his best and with Lee flowing nicely. The guitar and the bass lines are very powerful and are very well supported by an incredible drumming by Pearl, as usual. The third track "Chemistry" represents one of those rare and fascinating occasions where all three band's members share lyrical work. This is another very interesting song with again the massive use of synthesizers. The guitar and the bass are also really powerful on this song. This is an incredible example of a perfect mix of guitars and keyboards. The fourth track "Digital Man" is a song that brings some musical elements of reggae. Sincerely this a track that in some parts reminds me the music of The Police and particularly Pearl sounds like Stuart Copeland. This is a very interesting, good and strong track from the album, even though that it isn't for sure one of their most popular songs. The fifth track "The Weapon" continues were "Witch Hunt" left off and will follow it as part two of the "Fear" trilogy, and is excellent with its explorations of how people, and societies, use fear against each other. It's the lengthiest track on the album and it has almost mechanical drumming and some electronic noises. This is another great track with very important lyrics. The sixth track "New World Man" is a song that reminds me of "Digital Man", because it has the same meaning and the musical influences of reggae. At a first place it sounds a little bit commercial like it was made to be passed on the radio. This is one of the weakest tracks on the album, but I sincerely think that it's a catchy song with great singing from Lee. The seventh track "Losing It" is a great ballad, reflecting on the waning years of one's life man. Lifeson has some great guitar work with his solo and Ben Mink's violin is simply and absolutely gorgeous on this song. It's a very different track and the most experimental of the album. This is also the only song on the whole album that uses acoustic guitars. The eighth and last track "Countdown" was designed for commercial and video play, but I sincerely like it. It's a song that musically and lyrically builds in symbolism and homage to the lunch of a space shuttle. It's a very well done and tasteful song with a great keyboard work for those who appreciate it. This is a very strong ending to a strong album.

Conclusion: "Signals" is another very good and fine album from Rush that certainly worthy of Rush's name. Fans of their older musical era from their progressive musical period might have an initial hang up, like me, but this album will certain grow to be a favourite of them. With "Signals", the band is still rocking and moving with a fluid grace. It soars with the kind of spirit only these veterans can produce or get way with on such a style change. Lee's bass is still great and his solos work very well, if anything his dominant here. Pearl's percussion is complex, at times subtle, but still dominating rhythm machine. Lifeson's leads are drowned out his solos are still great, his imprinting is still working its magic as a multi textured part of the whole. The musical arrangements are excellent, the group writing pieces of music that flow with grace, the production here melding the compositions into an artistic whole, sounds and textures ebbing and rising with a craftsman detail. So, we can say that the final result is another great studio album from Rush, indeed.

Prog is my Ferrari. Jem Godfrey (Frost*)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Fireball by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1971
3.80 | 968 ratings

BUY
Fireball
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by Hector Enrique
Prog Reviewer

3 stars After the huge commercial success and widespread acceptance of 'Deep Purple in Rock' and in the midst of a busy schedule of concerts and commitments, the pressures of the record label to seize the moment led Deep Purple to rush the release of "Fireball" (1971), the fifth album by the British band and the second with their most classic line- up, known as Mark II.

"Fireball" was recorded in the few spare moments the band had, suffering from the growing ego disputes between Ian Gillan and Richie Blackmore and even dealing with the discomfort of Jon Lord, who saw his desire to incorporate classical overtones losing more and more ground.

It is in this complicated context that the album's approach suffers and doesn't quite come together, despite the unbridled start of the rocking "Fireball", the driving and bluesy "Demon's Eye" with Gillan in Jim Morrison mode and some very good solos by the Lord/Blackmore duo, and the Arabic insinuations of "The Mule" with Ian Paice's persistent drumming, a sense of reduced revolutions and creative exhaustion envelops the work, and is glimpsed in the repetitive and simple "No No No", in the unexpected "Anyone's Daughter", a country song that would have been better suited to a collaboration with Bob Dylan, and in the experimental and lysergic "Fools", which is not bad, but at times becomes more monotonous than necessary, weighing it down.

The irregular "Fireball", which inexplicably did not include the hit single "Strange Kind of Woman" in its European edition and has an interesting Funky outburst at the end with Lord's consistent keyboard-led melody in "No One Came", is in my opinion, more than what it is said to be, but less than expected, perhaps because it is in the shadow and wedged between the band's two emblematic albums, "Deep Purple in Rock" and "Machine Head".

3/3.5 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Second Thoughts by BROERS + KLAZINGA album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.01 | 22 ratings

BUY
Second Thoughts
Broers + Klazinga Neo-Prog

Review by alainPP

4 stars Composed of Jacob Broers and Gerben Klazinga, founders of Knight Area, for good symphonic-classical neo-prog.

"Prelude - Sons of Gods" opens with a solemn Olympian sound, with trumpet and bells worthy of Waalsdorpervlakte; the devastating riff then a Brazilian samba feel. "Wait for Sleep" layers of velvety keyboards serving as an introduction; the guitar on ARENA melts the atmosphere; Mark, solemn on vocals, pours out a captivating symphonic rhyme; the uncompromising prog, easy to access with the killer melody. The MARILLION break for this warm guitar solo, the tone between softness and progressive soaring, the organ frolicking through its scales. "Countess Grief" is a bucolic rhyme, YES for the vocals, GENESIS for the flute, PENDRAGON for the acoustic guitar and keyboard. "The Mirror": Nadine's captivating vocals, an uptempo ballad with its guitar and synth solos; a captivating catchy chorus filled with delightful melancholy; superb vocal alternation. "Forgotten" is prog metal with the duet vocals; a plus that adds up, going from this shared track to the velvety break of fat, spatial, and swirling synth layers. A purely progressive track with this instrumental moment. "No One Left to Blame" is a sovereign piece, slow, plaintive tempo, melting melancholy. The guitar solo throws itself into this languid slow song; emotional notes to melt the prog.

"Delusional" is a romantic epic with captivating vocals; the keyboard part harks back to the mysterious sound of MILLENIUM for the sovereign air; the track evolves, moving into playful prog metal with Mark again on lead guitar, providing depth and passion, where the synths recall GENESIS for the Mellotron. A beautiful crescendo dripping from the sharp guitar. "The Test of Time," reminiscent of STYX; a slow, atmospheric rise filled with the symphonic sounds of GENESIS, ARENA, and MARILLION for the remarkable guitar solo. Another solemn track, boosted by the second solo, magnifying the divine air of the Mellotron. "Shame," with its zany neoclassical intro worthy of "A Clockwork Orange," a playful romantic-medieval aria, sharp notes from Monteverdi's cantata, bringing a solemn emphasis. "Read Me," a languid piece, a beautiful nursery rhyme with unstoppable vocals coupled with a bewitching melody, a slap in the face for this solo that never ends. "Iconoclast," a melodic suite featuring enlightened vocals, fluffy, Olympian keyboards, and a touching, melancholic guitar. A long finale with an explosive keyboard. Broers + Klazinga releases the opus smelling of the 80s with Genesis keyboards and KNIGHT AREA. Originally on progcensor. (4.5)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Third Sleep by OAK album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.85 | 24 ratings

BUY
The Third Sleep
Oak Crossover Prog

Review by alainPP

4 stars OAK, a dynamic and melancholic sound reminiscent of RIVERSIDE, PORCUPINE TREE, OSI, and ANATHEMA on the one hand, with the major psychedelic wanderings of AIRBAG and GAZPACHO on the other. Symphonic and neo- dark metal with soft, atmospheric, hypnotic rhythms bordering on pop from TEARS FOR FEARS and TALK TALK, heavy wanderings from ULVER and MASSIVE ATTACK, and finally, classy cinematics from CHOPIN, BACH, HORNER, and WILLIAMS.

"No Such Thing (Place)" kicks off with a crossover to anchor itself, an ethereal, alternative, and icy pop tune, a captivating melody with a melancholic trumpet, syncopated drum beats, and distant piano, like those NASA voiceovers. A hint of clarinet to stroll through a decidedly bucolic atmosphere. "London" and its electric reverberation, a purely Wilsonian feel in the writing; cold, cinematic rock, leaning towards the 80s for its dark wave and progressive spirit. Reminiscences of ANTIMATTER for its languorous side. "Run Into the Sun" delves even deeper into this coldness with a drift of piano and rock guitar, polyrhythms between the vocals and the instrumentation, a sound reminiscent of OPETH's progressive experiments drifting between progressive and melancholy. A bit of PINK FLOYD or even DREAM THEATER from their album 'Systematic Chaos'. "Shimmer" is a nod to the first album 'Stars Under Water', with the captivating, melancholic ostinato enhanced by traditional instruments, amplifying the austere, icy folk spirit that emanates from it. A sparkling, gloomy sound that ends with a new age coda and the captivating chorus.

"Shapeshifter" with the drum giving a little more intensity to the basic piano and Simen's desperate vocals. Electric piano for the break, rolling pads, the weighted intensity swells with a stereo effect like in the good old days. The guitar flirts a few notes with that of PINK FLOYD, ANATHEMA, bands inscribed in memories today. The final solo is almost heavy, violent, on another dreamlike coda with the haunting keyboard. "Borders" amplifies the basic sounds letting the guitar sound develop until then in the background, the air forming an osmosis between SOEN, KATATONIA, ANTIMATTER. A beautiful dark spleen rise on a languorous keyboard of time and an intimate fade before the nervous guitar riff tumbling on "Sensory Overload" with again this expressive martial pad; reminiscences of Steven WILSON for this confrontation sweetness and violence. This vocal romanticism with orchestral deluge, latent is truly captivating. The derivation seems simple, basic, and demonstrates a modern progressive exploration with the introduction of a hysterical sax followed by distant screamed vocals. The atmosphere builds to a final, explosive, Opethian growl, conducive to apoplectic trance. Originally on Profilprog.(4.5)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 La vie by VAN GIERSBERGEN, ANNEKE album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2025
3.13 | 4 ratings

BUY
La vie
Anneke Van Giersbergen Prog Related

Review by memowakeman
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

3 stars Review originally posted at www.therocktologist.com

Dutch singer Anneke van Giersbergen announced a couple of months ago that she will be releasing a new album entitled 'La vie, la mort, l'amour', a collection of quite personal songs she wrote after her parents' passing, finding inspiration from the ones she loves, in a surely not-so-easy mourning period. However, that full-length album will be divided in three parts, three different EPs in which she will be dropping some of the songs, being 'La vie' the first one, already released in February 2025.

Here, she has shared the first four songs of that upcoming album, and as I expected, we can find here personal and intimate lyrics with strong and touching music that can move anyone, of course, the power of her voice is always a lethal tool. 'La vie' features four tracks that make a total time of 18 minutes.

The first one is a beauty named 'One More Nanosecond', gives me chills, because I think we all have been there, wishing to spend more time with our loved ones, dying to give everything to see them again, and keeping our precious memories. Anneke has an impressive sensitivity to transmit emotions with her voice, we know that since her times at The Gathering, and though time has passed, her voice and her power remain intact. Here she offers a kind of alternative pop rock song, with a catchy sound and a chorus we all might learn and sing. Of course, there is an explosion in this song where all the emotions are spread by the artist and taken by us, the listeners. Love this song.

'When I Die' starts with some programmed drums that reminded me of a popular Phil Collins' song haha, but well, here she openly speaks about death and what happens when you are gone, or at least what you imagine it will happen. It is common that we find moments of introspection when a person we love transcends, and in some cases, moments of creativity and inspiration. This is a nice song that has a soft sound, calm and melancholic for the first three minutes, then it explodes and becomes a bit heavier, the rock element is more evident and, of course, her voice and all the emotions are spread.

Art is love, and we are made of love, Anneke is not an exception and a clear example of it is 'More than a Thousand Words', a pop song that comes from the bottom of her heart and that speaks about how well we know our people, that we are capable of knowing how they are by looking at their eyes, nothing more. Besides the "normal" instruments, here we can also find violin and winds, which made the experience richer.

The last track of this EP is 'Heal me', and I love it because in a mourning period it is normal to feel trapped in darkness, and normal to look for help in order to feel better. Yeah, death, just like life, has a seesaw of emotions and we must embrace them, then, relief will find us sooner than later.

Anneke and her voice will always touch me, and I am grateful for that. Now, let's wait for the upcoming bunch of songs, the upcoming EP.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Frippada Andaluza by MALABRIEGA album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.26 | 70 ratings

BUY
Frippada Andaluza
Malabriega Prog Folk

Review by memowakeman
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars Review originally posted at www.therocktologist.com

Oh yeah, this is so good!

Eight years after their debut album, Spanish band Malabriega has returned with a stunning release whose title 'Frippada Andaluza' suggests its connection to progressive rock or maybe a tribute to one of the genre's icons. This band had already satisfied my senses when I was introduced to their music, due to their great blend of prog rock, flamenco and jazz, with an evident Spanish sound mainly due to the vocals, however, while writing this review I feel really excited with this album, which I'd rank as one of my top prog albums from this still young 2025 so far.

Since the first self-titled track, 'Frippada Andaluza (La mar limpia)', I felt quite attracted to its sound, whose starts with acoustic guitar but with a kind of post-rock feeling that is being built-up while the seconds pass. It wonderfully flows, and then at minute three Juan Castro and his cantaor voice appear adding quite colorful textures and emotional sounds; at the same time, the music is really well-crafted, strings and drums all together taking us by the hand in a blend of prog, alt rock and, of course, a bit of flamenco. This song lasts ten minutes, so as you can imagine, there are some changes in mood and tempo, so in moments you will feel a vertiginous ride, and in others you will feel at ease.

'Tu pelo' starts again with acoustic guitar, then soft bass lines and voice join, later drums and after a minute there is a bridge that is quite attractive, with some lyrics that we Spanish-speakers would love to sing. I like when both acoustic and electric guitar interplay creating beautiful passages. There is also a kind of melancholic sound here, and with the vocals, the emotional side of Malabriega prevails. Joaquín Sáinz delight us with very nice guitar solos here and there.

A folkier sound closer to flamenco comes with 'El duelo', in which Manuel "Noly" Soto delights us with a really delicious spanish guitar performance, and though that Spanish sound is quite evident, I love how the band manages to produce a let's say "universal" sound when rock and prog take over, even with an amazing moment where Sergio Carmona's bass is a true highlight; and then in the ending part with a truly emotional passage.

'ŋQué será?' is divided in halves, the first part provides a soft rhythm, a charming sound, and then in the second one it becomes more attractive to my ears due to its increase of speed and emotions. I might be crazy, but I find in several Malabriega tracks some hints of popular prog rock bands such as Riverside or Porcupine Tree, but mixed with that Spanish sound, the result is amazing.

An interlude appears with 'Reencuentro', a short instrumental track with a charming sound led by strings, it will put a smile on your face. It leads to 'La levedad del ser' that has a darker sound, then that prog/alt rock sound begins and the song naturally flows, adding different figures and notes while the seconds pass, even with a very nice acoustic guitar solo. It's a powerful track, however I think it is easy to dig and enjoy.

'La libertad' brings indeed an atmosphere of freedom, I picture myself in an open air place enjoying life while listening to this with headphones and loving what my eyes see surrounding me. These guys know how to create a great balance of emotions, how to place the softer moments and the ones full of energy, and how to provide those feeling with and without vocals / lyrics.

Another great example of that balance comes with the amazing 'Reflejo Vacío', in which we can also appreciate a magnificent work by Raúl Gķmez on drums, and that beautiful blend of acoustic and electric guitars. It is also a kind of multi-cultural experience, because that flamenco essence worderfully merges with that modern prog rock sound that comes from different parts of Europe, I mainly remember the UK, for instance. There is an amazing change of direction here, in an amazing instrumental passage that lasts only for a while, however, it makes a big impact. This is a hell of a song, truly amazing. This great album finishes with 'Calamidad' which might be the most Spanish song of all, first with the flamenco sound and then with the metal oriented one, without leaving aside that prog rock soul this band has. For the first time they bring spoken words which, of course, produce different textures and emotions. At minute three there is even a kind of spacey / atmospheric sound that takes us to a brief journey until it becomes heavier with the bass and drums. Yeah, I will name again the popular Porcupine Tree, because any fan who likes that project might feel enchanted by what Malabriega offers here, with their distinctive Spanish sound.

Great, great album, I encourage my readers to listen to it, I bet you will find a positive surprise, quite different from your daily musical experiences.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Once by HARPER, ROY album cover Studio Album, 1990
3.42 | 17 ratings

BUY
Once
Roy Harper Prog Folk

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

3 stars Like many performers of 1960s vintage, ROY HARPER's productivity and popularity declined in the 1980s and 1990s, though less so among other artists, as demonstrated by the usual stellar guestlist on "Once". Harper's "formula" didn't vary a whole lot during this period, with grade A lyrics, musicianship and copasetic vocal, so his albums can mostly be judged based on the musical aspects of their songs. "Once" occupies a lower rung but is far from disposable.

The title track is consummate travail for ostensibly celebrating the miracle of our existence, and might have worked better in a poetry slam, or honestly any other format. The next couple of songs don't fare any better. Ultimately, the only true standouts here are the provocative protest folk "Black Cloud of Islam" and the tutorial that is "For Longer than it takes", but "Berlin" and "Ghost Dance" qualify as appealing enough near misses.

Given its appearance during a relatively quiescent era for Harper, "Once" serves as, at a minimum, a placeholder to be replaced by another a few years down the line, and at most a reminder of his dogged oneness and wholeness.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Trost by DANEFAE album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.91 | 15 ratings

BUY
Trost
Danefae Crossover Prog

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars Highly-texturized and mood-setting music from a group of Danes who claim to be rooted/oriented in metal traditions. If their band name offers any hints, I think of them more as the ambiguously-intentioned mischief makers who inhabit the hidden recesses of the woodland and swampland areas less likely to be populated by humans (because of their remoteness and/or tentative prospects for safe, sustainable living): the creepier, not-always-friendly faeries of Danmark.

1. "Fuglekongen" (5:23) some moody music whose wisp 'o wil female vocals belie the metal assertion. Though the hints of metal certainly arise as the song travels along (mostly in the bass and heavy toms and kick drums), it's not until the 3:55 mark that the music definitely falls into "threatening" territories of metal music--and even here the vocals (both lead and background) remain steadfastly grounded in more Mediæval Bæbes-like fairy-folk conventions. And I love the fact that the band chooses to have their stories sung in their native tongue. It certainly lends even more folk-faerie frost and shiver to the songs. (9/10)

2. "Vaetter" (5:04) butterfly-like electric piano arpeggi open this before drums and voice join in. Again, Anne Olesen's vocal performance sounds so creepy: beautiful like a mythological Siren, but we all know the ultimate design of those bloodthirsty beauties. Again the music beneath serves to convey the same creepy underlying garment of deceitful beauty, with passages ascending into full-on doom metal (despite the lilting vocals in and around it). The peak crescendo at 4:00 to 4:52 is amazing! It feels so rare that keyboard-sounding guitars deliver that kind of JEM GODFREY- like twisted threat! (9/10)

3. "Natsvaermer" (5:45) for 1:18 gentle piano and voice lull one into submission before the metal monsters explode into the soundscape to tell us otherwise. The melodies and vocal sounds don't grab me as much with this one, and the metal monsters are a little too aggressive and in-my-face on this one for me to really get into it. Another reviewer has commented how the volume/loudness of the "brickwalled sound in the louder parts" caused them some disturbance and I can see why: the volume of what I'm calling "the monsters" is a bit too much: too affronting, almost driving me back or away. (8.75/10)

4. "Vandskabt" (5:33) decibel levels of the monsters are again quite overwhelming on this one. It really does affect how much I can get into and enjoy the gorgeous vocals and melodies of the singers. The engineering is good enough that I can still distinguish each and every voice and instrument but the volume of the guitar/bass combination simply murks up the forefront too much, making me turn the volume down on my headphones, thus diminishing my immersion into the totality of the music. (8.875/10)

5. "P.S. Far er død" (12:40) two arpeggiated guitar chords open this one before Anne's delicate, vulnerable voice enters with spacious bass notes beneath. At 1:15 strummed acoustic guitar replaces the guitar and bass that were beneath as Anne reaches waif-like degrees of delicacy by reaching for the higher, breathier notes of her register. Enter gentle arpeggi from an electric piano and then we switch to a more folk rock palette of acoustic and gentle electric guitars, gentle bass and drums, and female-backed vocals. This carries forward until 3:30 when the band as a whole jumps into a heavier sound palette while Anne's vocal becomes more pleading and insistent (but still Prog Folk-ish). In the fifth minute a predominantly low-end drum and bass motif moves on as everybody else become incidental-only contributors while a mature male voice recites some lines in a spoken voice. The music slowly, gradually begins to thicken again as Anne returns again. (I'm very surprised how far into the mix her voice is buried. There are actually background and "side-" vocalists who are given louder presence in the mix than the lead!) This is still a very cool Prog Folk passage--until 7:07 when a heavier, more metal-threatening passage takes over--complete with heavily distorted vocals from Anne and "monster" background vocalists. But, 45 seconds later we are returned to the temporary safety of some alcove for a brief breather before venturing back out into the malevolent chaos and confusion of the hunt (where we're the prey). While I'm not exactly bowled over by this epic, I recognize and applaud the creative theatric storytelling aspect of this. Truly an epic in the traditions of the old Viking sagas. An electric guitar solo in the eleventh minute makes me realize how few (if any) other instrumental solos are present on this album! Interesting. The final 1:15 (after the guitar solo ends) plays out like a cacophonous mélange of all of the themes and melodies used in the course of the song piled and compiled one on top of the other for a bombastic finale. (22.75/25)

6. "Trøst" (2:17) gently-picked heavily-treated electric guitar works its solo way into a kind of variation on some famous jazz or classical music melodic chord progression. Nice. (4.5/5)

7. "Blind" (4:43) drums and chugging guitar and bass metal chords turn full-on metal at 0:30 for a brief repetition of a three-strum djent motif before backing out to allow a more atmospheric motif to take over for lead singer Anne Olesen to perform a vocal that is very much in the tradition of some of the great Prog Metal sirens of the Naughties and Teens (Simone Simons and Sharon den Andel come to mind first). I like the diversity and multiplicity of unexpected turns on this one. (9.125/10)

8. "Sang om Håb" (3:51) syncopated group clapping opens this one before Anne and some deep-background siren present the pagan folk-like melody and lyric. At 0:43 violin-like arpeggi and chugging metal bass 'n' guitar enter to give this a much more demonic palette. Anne continues singing, gaining force and power from her companions yet her voice never quite reaches the thickness and force of the above-mentioned queens of Prog Metal: her pipes only deliver a thinner, more folk-like lilt instead of the unquestioned power of regal malevolence. Still, a pretty good song despite Anne's shortcomings. (8.875/10)

Total Time 45:16

I love the duplicity of this band's music: very much like the Sirens reference, there is alluring beauty in every song-- often all the way through a song--while there are also the threats of monsters and malevolence lurking beneath, often jumping out from under the bridge or out of the dark woods.

89.86 on the Fishscales = B+/4.5 stars; a near-masterpiece of very interesting music from a band of young musicians whom I will look forward to following over their next few albums with high expectations for progress and improvement.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Green Man by HARPER, ROY album cover Studio Album, 2000
4.20 | 19 ratings

BUY
The Green Man
Roy Harper Prog Folk

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

4 stars One might be excused for surmising, based on the title of this 2000 release, that it would finally be ROY HARPER's answer to "Heavy Horses", but of course one ought to know better. While the themes of humanity's relationships to nature are pointedly strewn about, this is still a Harper album, hence he juxtaposes a veritable.chamber orchestra of earthy folk-adjacent instruments into his patentable style, courtesy of JEFF MARTIN and, to a lesser extent, PADDY KEANE, such that the feel is as organic as the Green Man himself. Even if the title track is stunningly unremarkable, the sumptuous ballad "The Wishing Well" , the ultra catchy "The Monster" and "New England", and the grower that is "Rushing Camelot" (his "spinning round the world" line might have launched a thousand SUFJAN STEVENS') help solidify the massive improvement over "Dream Society", which obliges me to plant this one firmly in the green belt of Harper's discography.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Guiding Ghost by EPHEMERAL album cover Studio Album, 2022
4.08 | 8 ratings

BUY
Guiding Ghost
Ephemeral Crossover Prog

Review by Finnforest
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

4 stars I Saw Your Shape in the Fog...

Ephemeral is a captivating recent presence on the modern prog rock horizon. Formed in Rome in 2021 from a band called Floating Minds, the new project Ephemeral consists of Arianna De Lucrezia, Gabriele Catania, Francesco Ciancio, and Matteo Morini. Their debut full-length album came out in 2022 for Elevate Records, an enthusiastic, energetic sound that is Guiding Ghost. When you first look at their CD cover, you might mistakenly think this is a downbeat, murky horror-type vibe, but in contrasting fashion, Guiding Ghost is actually quite the buoyant crossover sound. The album explores the concept of some kind of supernatural guiding spirit around us.

From the beginning moments of "Deep Blue," you know this is gonna be a real treat---no waiting for some delayed payoff. The first four tracks are all impressive, often ebullient prog rock with impressive chops, catchy-as-hell pop sensibilities at times, and a great sense for layering and dynamics. Grooving, bubbly bass lines paired with highly melodic electric guitar and nimble, superb drumming. I like how their heaviness comes from the playing itself rather than effects overload. While there is some distortion used, it is not relied on to create constant heaviness like a metal album might. Instead, they find heaviness through their prowess on the fretboard (guitar and bass are both killer). De Lucrezia has a unique voice that is difficult to describe, maybe a bit like Gwen Stefani, though the music here is so different from No Doubt that it's an odd comparison. Occasionally, she will double-track to harmonize with herself, and I always love that technique. The album is almost textbook crossover with both super catchy choruses and pop-prog presentations ("Lock 'em Out") but also sophisticated, original developments ("Inky Eyes"). That clean guitar solo on "Inky Eyes" is fantastic. These songs can rock hard, can relax, and can surprise. They can also groove!---check out "Freddy."

As cool as the first half is, the highlight probably comes with the second half, the "side-long" related tracks of "Into the Ether" (a short keyboard interlude) followed by "Guiding Ghost, Parts 1 and 2." The keyboard palette is one of the notable things about the album, mixing both imaginative modern soundscape with traditional-sounding symphonic grandeur. From the wonderful, mellow "Ether" opening, the title suite opens up into a full-on, grand, epic-style composition with nods to progressive rock past and present: ELO (minus strings), Echolyn, Moongarden all came to mind for me at various points in the album. Some serious and intense jamming develops in "Part 1" and eventually leads to this awesome clearing where the band falls away to showcase the standalone voice of De Lucrezia, quite a dramatic and beautiful moment, before a bit of piano rejoins. Just lovely, thoughtful development through this long track. It's ambitious and fun songwriting throughout---not one throwaway on this disc. Rather, you can hear how invested they all are in this material.

Beyond the album, I spent some time listening to their live and live-studio videos on YouTube, and these four are all amazing musicians able to just crush live covers of classic and modern prog rock giants with ease. Their passion for prog rock generally and for their own material is infectious to say the least. But beyond their musical talent playing, it really is the collection of interesting songs that draws me to Guiding Ghost more than anything. It's an album of great variety, twists, and turns, and I enjoyed returning to it each time. I also have to give a quick nod to the production and mix; everyone is heard clearly and well. I'm bummed out it took me three years to find this! I believe they are already working on their second album, but this was really a thoroughly engaging debut. Available on CD or digitally.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 El Silencio De Las Estrellas by MARTÍNEZ, JULIÁN album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2024
3.67 | 2 ratings

BUY
El Silencio De Las Estrellas
Julián Martínez Symphonic Prog

Review by TenYearsAfter

3 stars Julián Martínez was born in 1994, in Buenos Aires, Argentina. The legendary Argentine band Crusis was an important influence when Julian got interested in progressive rock as a kid, along with Pink Floyd. Later he also became a fan of progressive metal when he witnessed a Dream Theater gig in his hometown, in 2012. After becoming a musician, composer and producer, between 2017 and 2025 Julian released a variety of instrumental albums in symphonic rock, classical music and other genres. His influences range from J.S. Bach, Frédéric Chopin and Astor Piazzolla to Pink Floyd, King Crimson, Gentle Giant and Steven Wilson.

On the PA Forum Julian Martinez asked the reviewers to pay attention to his albums. The very positive words from Tszirmay about Julian Martinez his music inspired me to check out his albums, as a huge fan of more recent Latin- American prog, from Sergio Alvarez, Astralis, Caravela Escarlate, Supay, Flot De Loto and R-U Kaiser to Sagrado, Under Linden, Tarkus, Apocalypse, William Gray, Anima Mundi, Amagrama, Jaime Rosas and my favorite Nexus.

I have started with the (mini) album El Silencio De Las Estrallas, from 2024. The music on the 5 tracks (between 3 and 5 minutes) is built around wonderful work on the piano, from tender to sparkling, often blended with majestic Mellotron violins and mellow saxophone , it sounds very melodic and harmonic. The most dynamic and 70s symphonic rock sounding composition is La Danza Del Tempo featuring a mid-tempo with delicate Hammond runs, soaring Mellotron violins and Minimoog flights, topped with tasteful saxophone play. In the other tracks the music is more laidback, in my opinion Julian Martinez could have used a bit more variety in his musical ideas. Because at some moments the atmospheres featuring the 'piano-Mellotron violins-saxophone formula' sound a bit too similar. But in general this is a pleasant meeting between classical music and 70s symphonic rock, and Julian Martinez did a fine job with playing all the instruments himself.

My rating: 3,5 star.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Il Gioco Imperfetto by PLENILUNIO album cover Studio Album, 2021
3.47 | 10 ratings

BUY
Il Gioco Imperfetto
Plenilunio Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by KansasForEver4

3 stars No need to have studied Italian for years to translate PLENILUNIO; even a baby could do it! This is the third album for this transalpine quintet, which has existed since 1977. It was the final album for our musician friends, originally from ACQUI TERME in PIEDMONT, a town very close to ASTI for those who want a geographical and wine-growing reference.

1977 was also the swan song of the Golden Age of progressive music in Italy and elsewhere. ELP, GENESIS, PINK FLOYD, and others were at the height of their powers, while newer bands arrived at the wrong time and struggled to find their place, and that's saying something... The CAMPARO siblings, with the collaboration of Davide PRONZATO on guitar and Roberto MAGGIOTTO on drums, opted for the name PLENILUNIO to continue their dream, so to speak. Over time, after departures and returns, the Piedmontese band now seems to have stabilized. Not having heard PLENILUNIO's first two albums (2012 and 2017), I embarked on a listening journey to "Il Gioco Imperfetto" with chaste ears.

With PLENILUNIO, we're more on the progressive pop trail than on the often steep paths of transalpine symphonic progressive. To be clear and provide references, let's mention ASIA from the British and LE ORME from the mid- seventies ("Verita Nascoste"/"Storia o Leggenda"). Admit it, we could find much worse; closer to home, NATHAN's debut album can serve as a benchmark.

There's nothing to criticize on this record, which is less than forty-five minutes long (by a hair's breadth). Fortunately, you might say, in the words of today's youth, "it's a breeze."

What are the most recommendable pieces from this "Il Gioco Imperfetto"? In order of the opus, the opening track "L'Aquilone"; the fifth and somewhat folky (especially in its first two minutes) "Diariodi Bordo"; the next and very brilliant instrumental "Voci del Vento" (the highlight of the work); the reference to NATHAN's "Nebulosa" is strongly marked here; the seventh "Tutte le colpe che ho" is very LE ORME, as mentioned above. Roberto MAGGIOTTO sings as well as Aldo, albeit with a deeper voice (a welcome classical guitar part played by Riccardo PRONZATO); and finally, the eighth "Loro" (LE ORME too.....in all honesty, it feels like you're there; the structure of the piece is unmistakably reminiscent of him).

A small downside for the whole album, most of the pieces end too suddenly for my taste...Valter, some small instrumental developments for the next album ?

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Stormbringer by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1974
3.12 | 698 ratings

BUY
Stormbringer
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Funky Purple! 'Stormbringer' is the second studio album released by Deep Purple in 1974, following the acclaimed 'Burn'; this is also the last album recorded by the Mark III lineup with Blackmore, Lord, Paice, Coverdale and Hughes, and is the first seventies album by the band to exhibit a strong funk sound (and even if Blackmore was not keen on such a musical direction, his playing on here is pretty much superb, as is the playing of all other members of the band). From this point of view, this becomes a unique album that expands the possibilities of Purple's sound, and even if 'Stormbringer' has remained an underrated entry in their catalogue, it is undoubtedly one of the important albums that attempted to do something new and exciting.

The iconic and rather ominous title track has to be one of the best-written rock singles of the 70s, pure power and great playing, heading straight to the core, it is an excellent song. Some might be keen on the groovy blues-funk of 'Love Don't Mean a Thing' or the more elegiac but memorable 'Holy Man', with fine lead vocals from Hughes. This album also features the upbeat rocker 'Lady Double Dealer', the dazzling funk anthem 'You Can't Do It Right' as well as all-time Coverdale classics 'The Gypsy' and the melancholic 'Solider of Fortune'. The entire album is packed with great material from front to back as it captures an excellent-form variation of Deep Purple, with lovely playing from all members, masterful songwriting and an unmistakable energy. At the same time, songs like 'High Ball Shooter' and 'Hold On' eventually fail to hit the spot, but we can consider them as "expendable" given the overall quality, influence and significance of this 1974 Purple release.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Who Do We Think We Are by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1973
3.04 | 657 ratings

BUY
Who Do We Think We Are
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

3 stars 'Who Do We Think We Are' is the final Deep Purple album recorded in the seventies by the Mark II lineup of the legendary British band, and this is a record whose writing and production had been exhilarated by pressure from the label, having insisted that the band complete another studio recording, while Deep Purple themselves were simply in need of a short break. The result is an album that is difficult to appreciate as it can sometimes be fun, enjoyable and rocking, at times it can get pretty boring as the band was obviously uninspired, which is further proven by the fact that Gillan and Glover left the band afterwards. The music on here is very much in the same vein as the preceding albums recorded by the quintet, with blues-based rock compositions leading the way, occasionally drawing in influences like scat and prog rock, and while the overall quality of the recording is rather good, the general aftertaste of this album is of an incomplete and slightly strenuous work that lacks the character and grip of preceding albums, even if songs like 'Woman From Tokyo', 'Super Trouper' and 'Rat Bat Blue' work great. Jon Lord and Ian Paice deliver noteworthy performances, while Blackmore's riffs tend to be less exciting than usual - tracks like 'Place in Line' and 'Our Lady' depict a tedious side of Purple's music, which could have probably been avoided had their label not insisted on a new studio album.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Burn by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1974
3.88 | 958 ratings

BUY
Burn
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Deep Purple returned in 1974 with a renewed lineup and a reinvigorated sound, as the release of their classic album 'Burn' sees a welcome return to the hard-hitting and anthemic sound of albums like 'Machine Head' and 'Fireball, with the excellent inclusion of vocalist David Coverdale and legendary bass player and singer Glenn Hughes, completing what would become the Mark III lineup of Purple. This album is replete with classic songs, many of which are pretty ubiquitous radio hits or all-time hard rock masterpieces, like the frantic title track, 'Might Just Take Your Life', the funky 'Sail Away' as well as the bluesy 'Mistreated'. This record also features a prog-inspired closing instrumental, which does not necessarily sit perfectly well with the rest of the music but is still an interesting musical exercise for Jon Lord and Co.

The general success of 'Burn' is definitely due to the safe but well-executed return to a more ostensible heavy sound, with catchy riffs and strong melodies, impressive episodes of jamming and experimentation as well as rattling keyboard and organ solos, all topped by the flamboyant vocal duet of Coverdale and Hughes. Both voices are strong and recognizable and without a doubt a fantastic addition to the band, one that introduces another dimension to Deep Purple's hard rock trailblazing sound, and while this album remains in line with the heavy and blues-based style developed on previous albums, there is also an element of funk on 'Burn', which brings an interesting twist to the DP formula, a stylistic gag that would be developed more later on. All in all, this is one of the hard rock classics of the 70s, an album that has proven its worth as time has passed, and a record that has given us a sufficient number of memorable and iconic pieces of pure heavy rock joy.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Time Machine 2011: Live in Cleveland by RUSH album cover DVD/Video, 2011
3.95 | 117 ratings

BUY
Time Machine 2011: Live in Cleveland
Rush Heavy Prog

Review by fuxi
Prog Reviewer

4 stars The 2011 Cleveland concert has been heavily criticised by the most devoted Rush fans; just check out their reviews in our 'live album' section. I myself thoroughly enjoyed it, almost from start to finish. I'll admit it's not as perfect as R30, but for someone like me, who never attended a Rush gig, it almost makes me feel as if I were in Cleveland that night. Any deficiencies in the drum sound or in Geddy Lee's vocals don't bother me when I'm watching the blu-ray. The camera work is just fantastic, it makes me feel as if I were right there in the concert hall. The band's playing is as precise and exciting as ever, and the set list features not just one but THREE first-rate Rush instrumentals: 'YYZ', 'La Villa Strangiato' AND 'Leave That Thing Alone'. The latter is performed with great gusto; Geddy's bass solo is a wonder to behold. Best of all, this is the only live set where you'll find one of my favourite Rush numbers: 'The Camera Eye'. In my view, the 2011 live version far surpasses the studio original. The video show accompanying the tune (projected on huge screens) is spectacular (it carries me away every time) and Geddy opens the piece with his best Robert de Niro imitation. In other words, I can't escape from calling this an 'excellent addition to your personal prog rock music collection'!

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Omni by KARFAGEN album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.24 | 98 ratings

BUY
Omni
Karfagen Symphonic Prog

Review by Matti
Prog Reviewer

5 stars To put it into one word: BRAVO! Antony Kalugin has made one of his finest albums, and considering his excessive but always pretty inspired productivity that's amazing. In fact, I have, for some time, had a somewhat tired feeling for the endless flow of Kalugin/Karfagen/Sunchild releases in recent years, and I wasn't expecting to be truly impressed anymore. Gladly I was wrong. Omni has a unique identity among Kalugin's works, partly it's because of the international stellar cast of prog musicians, but also musically there's a breath of fresh air. Not that anything heard here wouldn't already be rather familiar from Kalugin's output. But the energy, dynamic balance, melodic power, indeed everything, has reached perfection on this symphonic and suitably pop-sensible and highly emotional neo prog album.

The whole flows extremely naturally and seamlessly. Two of the ten tracks, 1 and 6, are instrumentals that bookend the first suite (Omni Part 1 has six and Part 2 four pieces, and I'm glad they are separated on the CD display). The first guest vocalist is Richard Sinclair (Caravan, Hatfield and the North), the finest voice of Canterbury prog. Haven't heard of him in ages, so this is a very nice surprise.

On 'Whispers from the Past' Antony duets with Olha Rostovska, backed by Bartosz Kossowicz from the Polish neo prog scene (Collage, Quidam). This song reminds me of the atmospheric, calm songs of the later-day Steve Hackett. The more upbeat song 'The Spark' is sung (+ on guitars and bass) by Per Malmberg from Salva, unfamiliar to me. His tight voice has a shade of 80's pop, Tears For Fears and Midge Ure of Ultravox. The brief, moody second instrumental features Antony's keys, John Hackett's flute and Daniel Ilyin's electric violin.

The vocalist on the emotional 'Unchained' is Jean Pageau from the Canadian neo prog band Mystery. The flute opens the next passionate song sung by Marco Gluhmann from the German neo act Sylvan. Kossowicz offers lead vocals on 'You and I'. And on the final, serene piece Antony duets with Richard Sinclair.

Omni is a gorgeous, epic neo prog album that I believe a dedicated listener of the genre will greatly enjoy.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Ron Thal/The Adventures Of Bumblefoot by BUMBLEFOOT album cover Studio Album, 1995
4.38 | 12 ratings

BUY
Ron Thal/The Adventures Of Bumblefoot
Bumblefoot Progressive Metal

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Ronald Jay Blumenthal is one of the most inventive guitarists I know. He shortened his name to Ron Thal, and he also goes by Bumblefoot. The man is from NY and he is multi-talented. He almost does it all here on his 1995 debut. The cover art, the production, compositions, performance and drum programming. There is a guest adding timbales on "Ick", and some guest slap bass and narration on 'Bumblefoot". There is some keyboards offering horn-like sounds on 3 tracks, along with piano on "Blue Tongue".

But this really is about Ron's incredible performance on his guitars. No vocals other than grunts, groans and the odd shout out on the opener "Bumblefoot". The 12 song titles all represent an animal disease. And those 12 diseases are represented on the cover art by 12 different characters. This was recorded in Ron's basement on his digital 16-track from August to October 1994, except for three tracks which were recorded earlier. This clocks in at around 45 minutes, and I do have a top three to talk about.

I feel the album gets off on the wrong foot(haha) with "Bumblefoot". I mean it's a great song, but those silly shout outs of "Bumblefoot!" several times are annoying. Hey, he was a kid here. And Ron is about entertaining, and the man is funny. I just feel like this is the one track I'd skip if I did that. The rest is gravy. The top three include that second song "Orf" which would have been a great opener. It just sounds so much better, and keep in mind that "Bumblefoot" song was recorded earlier.

I find "Orf" so uplifting when Thal is soaring on that guitar. When it slows right down we get some complex guitar, and I love his tone here. Repeated themes, and I really like those guitar expressions around 3 1/2 minutes. "Strawberry Footrot" is another top three. Love the heavy sound, and again the guitar tone. Just a great guitar track really. Finally, "Rinderpest" rounds out my top three. The warmth! Deep sounds before the guitar arrives soaring. I really like this, then it reverts back to that opening theme.

I also want to mention the 1 1/2 minute "Mailgnant Carbuncle" for the amazing guitar show. Ron has so many ideas, but also the nerve to follow through on some of these insane musical thoughts. He truly thinks out side the box, or bucket if you will. A solid 4 stars for these adventerous tales of woe.

PS I had already reviewed Ron's second release "Hermit" back in 2016, and mentioned there that he had a real drummer on board, but not so on the debut. Well, I had forgotten all that. After a couple of spins I decided to look up who the drummer was. Haha, what drummer? Usually in a case like this, once I find out about the programmed drums, the next listen reveals that in spades. Not here. I swear it's a real drummer, even after reading this information. Again, the man is so talented, in so many ways.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Katharsi by DEEP LIMBIC SYSTEM album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.89 | 22 ratings

BUY
Katharsi
Deep Limbic System Crossover Prog

Review by kev rowland
Special Collaborator Prog Reviewer / Special Collaborator

3 stars Eight years on from their debut, Mexican progressive act DLS are back with their second album. Given the amount of time which has passed it is somewhat surprising to realise that only guitarist Efrain Fraire is no longer a member of the band, as he left during the recording of this album so provides some additional guitar on just three tracks. He has been replaced by Leonel Huerta while the rest of the band are still Sergio Sunga (vocals, guitars), Carlos Barcenas (keyboards), Angel Natividad (bass) and Jose Armengol (drums and percussion).

The result is an album which is very much middle of the road crossover, with some heavier touches here and there, and the initial reaction is that this is a band who will appeal to fans of Porcupine Tree, RPWL, modern Marillion and Big Big Train as well as the likes of Pineapple Thief. For me the album works best when they are punching the guitars, such as in sections of closing number "Ωmega", but when they are taking the music in a more modern and quieter direction, I feel my attention shifting. But I am also very aware that this is my personal taste (the last few times I have seen Marillion I have vowed never to do so again, I am a slow learner) and there are plenty of people out there who will find this a very interesting album indeed. The production is good, the arrangements very well structured and the vocals excellent, it is just not a style of progressive rock which I want to spend a lot of time listening to. This may not be for me, but if you like the bands above and enjoy your prog to be easy to listen to then this may well be for you.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Perpetual Motion Machines (Music for a Film) by DAYS BETWEEN STATIONS album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.10 | 13 ratings

BUY
Perpetual Motion Machines (Music for a Film)
Days Between Stations Eclectic Prog

Review by kev rowland
Special Collaborator Prog Reviewer / Special Collaborator

3 stars Here we have the fourth album by duo Oscar Fuentes Bills (keyboards) and Sepand Samzadeh (guitars). I was convinced this was the first time I had come across them until I realised they first came to attention after they sent some material to Bruce Soord who then used some of it as the basis for the song "Saturday" on The Pineapple Thief's '12 Stories Down' which I reviewed more than 20 years ago. This particular album has had a long gestation in that its' conception goes all the way back to the mid-2010s when Oscar and Sepand began working on music for a documentary film about artist Jean-Paul Bourdier with friend Alexandre Dorriz (who had shot the original footage). This is why the album is subtitled 'Music For A Film', and why there is just one song, "Being", with vocals (provided by Durga McBroom), which is also the only song to feature real drums (Scott Connor) as the rest of the album is just the duo. It also explains why the Hipgnosis-style cover is so striking, as the photograph was taken by Jean-Paul Bourdier himself.

However, while all of this is quite fascinating (at least to me), there is the strong impression while playing this that there is something missing, and I think this must be the visual element. The music was written to emphasise the imagery they were seeing in his pictures and existing films, but without that element being present this can at times drop too much into the ambient and lose interest for the listener. That the two musicians have a wonderful collaborative spirit which explains their more than 20 years of working together, but this does not feel like an album but rather a collection of pieces which are looking for a home. This is art which is not quite standing on its own, as although we get feelings of Tangerine Dream, Vangelis and JMJ, it is not enough to fully maintain interest and when the drum machine makes an appearance it is clunky and detracts from the overall.

While I would be interested in seeing the documentary, I think this will only make sense musically when one has the images to go with it.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Corvus Stone II by CORVUS STONE album cover Studio Album, 2014
4.03 | 340 ratings

BUY
Corvus Stone II
Corvus Stone Crossover Prog

Review by kev rowland
Special Collaborator Prog Reviewer / Special Collaborator

4 stars I reviewed the debut Corvus Stone album all the way back in 2013 but never came across 2014's follow-up until recently, possibly because the debut left me somewhat confused with its strange mix of material which did not seem to relate to each other. However, it has been more than a decade since then, my musical tastes have changed, plus guitarist Colin Tench has died way too soon, all of which is bound to have a bearing on how I listen to this now, so this review may be somewhat different to what I would have written if I had heard it when it was released.

Corvus Stone were somewhat unusual in that they were an instrumental quartet, who then used different guest singers to provide voice to the songs. Also, they were determined not to make an album containing material which could be considered as being in a similar vein and the CD includes the statement, "This album is extremely varied. It does not follow any imaginary rules. It is not genre safe!". The band comprised Colin Tench (guitars), Pasi Koivu (keyboards), Petri Lemmy Lindström (bass), Robert Wolff (drums & percussion) and they were joined by singers Stef Flaming, Sean Filkins, Phil Naro, German Vergara, Timo Rautiainen, Blake Carpenter, and Andres Guazzelli. When I reviewed the debut, I found the variety somewhat disconcerting, but I see this one as a wonderful musical adventure.

We can go from a classical guitar interlude (which has the great title, "A Stoned Crow Meets the Rusty Wolff Rat") to rock, while "Scandinavians In Mexico" is so Latin and off the wall that each time it comes up I find myself checking the player to see if Corvus Stone has ended, and it is the next album on my list. The four musicians are able to play anything they want, so they do, and if they want to play fusion why not? The way they change styles is so precise that it really does sound as if different players are involved on different songs: it is simply remarkable. There were some elements on the debut which made me smile, and we have the same here as "Purple Stone" is probably the finest Purple cover which never was. Everyone plays their role to the max, with the drums driving the song, the bass providing a melody which is different to the Hammond while Colin is all over the place doing his best Ritchie impersonation. Blake Carpenter may not sound like Gillan, but he somehow captures the feeling and vibe, and if anyone was unsure as to which song they had taken for their inspiration for this, there is no doubt whatsoever when we get the first two lines and melody of "Highway Star" towards the end.

This is not going to be everyone's cup of tea, just because the songs are so varied, in which case just think of it as a collection of great material by different artists in different genres, and then it makes much more sense. An absolute delight.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Another Country by GARDENING CLUB, THE album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.85 | 5 ratings

BUY
Another Country
The Gardening Club Crossover Prog

Review by Pascaline.ha

5 stars At the start of 2025, the release of new releases, which I find lacking in appeal, hardly inspires me to write letters. This is similar to the cohort of albums released last year, where, inevitably, a plethora of artists fall by the wayside. This is the case with "Another Country," the latest release from "The Gardening Club." Despite a label and a rich discography, "MARTIN SPRINGETT" and his project remain under-publicized, particularly in the French-language press. Why has this album, which subtly blends pastoral prog, folk, and cinematic ambiance, not received the kind of attention it deserves? Is it forgetfulness, a lack of curiosity? One thing is certain: "Another Country" deserves our attention.

For ages, "MARTIN SPRINGETT" has sculpted melodies in the silence of the media, bursting with a talent threatened by oblivion. Far from the spotlight, he plows his own furrow, a distinguished illustrator whose art flows through his veins. Born in the United Kingdom, the multidisciplinary artist emigrated to the west coast of Canada. Drawn, perhaps, by the gentle murmur of the king of rivers? Be that as it may, the poet of harmonic orchards founded the project: "The Gardening Club" in 1983. The self-titled debut album was released the same year. A few years of silence before the combo rose from its ashes in 2016 with a reissue, enriched with previously unreleased tracks and a graphic novel illustrated by "Springett" himself. Then, in search of new territory, he launched "A Gardening Club Project," a parallel initiative that broadened his palette while remaining faithful to his quintessence. From this essence, several albums were born, including "The Blue Door" in 2021 and "Mr. October And The Moon Of Madness" in 2022.

It took two years for the "Another Country" project to come to fruition. Originally, the title was supposed to be "The Enigma Of Arrival." Martin Springett has revealed that the title should have been "L'Énigme de l'arrivée," the painting by De Chirico, because, according to him, it allowed him to project himself into the disparate places he desired musically and thematically. "Another Country" is a project that reflects the artistic evolution of Martin Springett and his collaborators. Released on October 11, 2024, this 57-minute opus consists of nine tracks that explore varied themes, skillfully blending progressive rock, jazz, and neoclassical elements.

After an introduction to the artist, let's dive into the heart of "Another Country," the latest opus from "The Gardening Club," led by the talented Martin Springett. This album marks a new stage in the band's musical evolution.

From the opening notes of "A Zephyr of Sound," a delicate sonic breeze envelops us, setting the stage for "Small Town Boy," an introspective ballad that tells the odyssey of a young man leaving home in search of new horizons. The lyrics, written by Steve Bennett, resonate with touching sincerity, evoking the hopes and disappointments of adventure.

"Tricksters" draws us into a musical whirlwind where Wayne Kozak's soprano saxophone harmoniously interacts with the guitars of Springett and Laliberte. This composition explores the changing facets of the human personality, symbolized by the "trickster," that mischievous and polymorphous being.

The nostalgic atmosphere of "Hotel Nostalgia / Enigma 1" invites the listener into deep introspection, each room of this imaginary hotel containing memories and forgotten melodies. The soprano voice of "DANIE FRIEDEN" adds an ethereal dimension to the whole, reinforcing the feeling of an introspective journey.

The eponymous track, "Another Country," spans over sixteen minutes, offering a sonic odyssey rich in variation and emotion. The careful arrangements and impeccable production of "KEVIN LALIBERTE" and "NORM MACPHERSON" demonstrate a mature artistry, skillfully blending progressive influences with contemporary touches.

In short, "Another Country" is a masterful work that confirms "The Gardening Club"'s place in the modern progressive rock landscape. Each track is an invitation to escape, a sensory journey where music and poetry intertwine to create an unforgettable auditory experience.

{translated from French to English by admin as reviews should be submitted in English}

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Mobula by KOLYADIN, GLEB album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.75 | 23 ratings

BUY
Mobula
Gleb Kolyadin Crossover Prog

Review by Pascaline.ha

4 stars Sometimes I find myself making impulse purchases. This was the case with the latest project from the male half of "IAMTHEMORNING." Yes, "Gleb Kolyadin," the Russian pianist who graduated with acclaim from the St. Petersburg Classical Conservatory under the direction of Professor Vladimir Polyakov. I don't know the reasons; I can only imagine. A fleeting preview triggered this impulse: I had to have it. Modula will now be an integral part of my music collection. Just as his previous opus, "The Outland," had struck me.

A prerequisite, no doubt due to the man's virtuosity, especially since it combines with the organic warmth of the century-old "Broadwood" piano. That was all I needed. I was as if bewitched, captivated without being aware of its structure or its themes. "Gleb" has that ability? I would say? Immersive in his music, which oscillates between hypnotic repetition and harmonic soaring, where, moreover, the piano is the common thread. "Parallax," which instigated this unexpected acquisition, and "Glimmer," which confirmed to me that I had made the right choice. The influences of Philip Glass emerge, defined by the evolution of the hypnotic repetitive motifs. The feeling of immersion, almost cinematic. As if enveloped in a contemplative state, of escape. At times, I felt as if I were plunged into the oceanic abyss of the "Mobula" ray's habitat, a sensation further amplified by "Fractured," reinforcing this impression of abysmal immensity. I didn't know if I was in the ocean depths or in the interstellar. So much so that I had to learn more about this project.

Gleb Kolyadin's latest project, Modula, hit stores on February 28th. Above all, its strength lies in its ability to captivate even before we understand its structure or themes. I find his immersive signature, his virtuosity, and his capacity for exploration. I mentioned earlier the influences of Philip Glass, particularly in terms of motifs. I find a wealth of textures. His approach to minimalist jazz, ā la Tigran Hamasyan, or the progressive explorations of Keith Emerson. The addition of folk and jazz adds an additional richness, giving Modula a dizzying sense of sonic journey.

Before continuing the narrative of new sounds, the album consists of 14 short pieces from his approach to "new sounds," drawn from his vast musical archive inspired by "polonium cubes." This project represents evolution and change over time. As stated on his label's page: the idea of ​​an aquatic, science-fictional journey. As the album title and its artwork suggest: "Mobula," a graceful ocean creature. In this regard, this isn't the first time he's delved into his musical archives. This was already the case with his self-titled debut album in 2018.

Undeniably, "Gleb Kolyadin" surprises. Pleasantly, I should say! It certainly doesn't have the texture of "The Outland," which is more progressive, but not only that... However, the juxtaposition of sound fragments, the structure, remind me of short story collections or science fiction novellas, where each story explores a different facet of the same universe. Where each piece is like a short film or a sound vignette capturing a fragment of this imaginary planet evoked by the album. His cinematic approach to composition and the immersive atmosphere. The alternation between contemplative moments, electronic pulses, and folk textures gives the impression of traveling through different scenes, the emotions they arouse, and the landscapes that reinforce this idea. To this, I would add that with "Gleb Kolyadin," and particularly in the context of "Modula," we sense in certain transitions, in the crescendos, sudden, unexpected ruptures. As if he abandons all logic to follow an emotion or a spontaneous idea. A controlled abandonment, if I may say so. Ah! That's where I was going with this. I have this feeling that the opus is split into two parts, starting with "Transient." The modus operandi clearly changes. We move from an introspective, sometimes meditative space like "Parallax" and "Glimmer," to something more organic, unstable, alive, almost chaotic in places. It's at this moment that the magic happens. And the artist's intention doesn't matter. What matters is what I experienced. This awakening where the rhythms become more complex, the texture denser, the motifs less cyclical, the contrasts accentuated. We feel that something is blossoming or cracking. "Kolyadin" has this narrative genius of not creating pieces, but states of consciousness. And in Modula, this pivotal moment around "Transient" resonates like a body capture, a descent into a more concrete, rhythmic, textured material.

To conclude, I have the impression that "Gleb Kolyadin" pushes this even further: he retains the poetic essence of "IAMTHEMORING" but injects it with a rawer, more free, sometimes even more mathematical, even contemporary jazz.

{translated from French to English by admin -- reviews should be submitted in English}

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Atonement of a Former Sailor Turned Painter by SUBMARINE SILENCE album cover Studio Album, 2024
3.91 | 19 ratings

BUY
Atonement of a Former Sailor Turned Painter
Submarine Silence Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by Pascaline.ha

4 stars Submarine Silence, an offshoot of the band Moongarden, invites us on a musical odyssey with their fifth album, "Atonement of a Former Sailor Turned Painter." Released on February 21, 2025, this album stands out for its conceptual approach, narrating the quest for redemption of a sailor turned painter, exploring the twists and turns of his soul through art.

From the first notes of "Majestic Whales," the listener is immersed in a dreamlike atmosphere, where Cristiano Roversi's ethereal keyboards and Davide Cremoni's melodious guitars evoke the majesty of cetaceans. The participation of Roine Stolt (The Flower Kings) adds an extra dimension to this captivating instrumental opening.

"The Words You Don't Say" introduces a captivating vocal duality between Guillermo Gonzales and Manuela Milanese. The contrast between Gonzales's raspy voice and Milanese's crystalline sweetness creates a palpable emotional tension, reinforced by organic arrangements blending organ and mellotron.

"Limbo of the Rootless" continues this sonic exploration with an acoustic guitar introduction, followed by a vocal dialogue between the two singers. The composition evolves toward darker tones, incorporating inspired guitar solos reminiscent of IQ, and organ passages that add a mystical depth to the ensemble.

The album's highlight is undoubtedly the eponymous suite, which lasts over 20 minutes and is divided into eight movements. This centerpiece takes the listener on a journey through the Caribbean, each segment reflecting a different port of call, with lyrics in five languages ​​(English, French, Dutch, Haitian Creole, and Portuguese), illustrating the region's cultural richness. The fluid transitions between sections, blending pastoral acoustic passages with progressive soarings, demonstrate the band's mastery of musical storytelling.

The album closes with "Zena," an elegant instrumental piece showcasing Cremoni's guitar virtuosity, providing a soothing conclusion to this sonic adventure.

Ed Unitsky's artwork deserves special mention, his visual world enriching the listening experience by reflecting the album's themes.

In short, "Atonement of a Former Sailor Turned Painter" is a rich and immersive work that, despite notable influences from Genesis and The Flower Kings, manages to forge its own identity, offering progressive rock fans a deep and nuanced musical experience.

{google translated from French to English by admin. Reviews should be submitted in English}

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Fimbulvinter by RIIS, BJØRN album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.93 | 50 ratings

BUY
Fimbulvinter
Bjørn Riis Crossover Prog

Review by Pascaline.ha

4 stars Bjørn Riis? Fimbulvinter: Released April 11, 2025

An Odyssey in Two Acts

With Fimbulvinter, Bjørn Riis invites us on a sonic journey in two parts. The first half of the album surprises with a more rock, even hard, energy, where the more incisive rhythm guitars bring a new intensity to his usually subdued universe. We perceive hard-core notes that contrast with the melancholic softness to which the artist has accustomed us.

Then, as the album progresses, we rediscover Riis's characteristic atmospheric imprint. The second half opens with more ethereal soundscapes, where soaring layers and introspective melodies take over, bringing us back to the deep introspection that is the artist's signature.

Fimbulvinter thus stands out as a work of contrasts, where the initial tension gradually gives way to contemplation, offering a rich and nuanced emotional palette.

----------------------

Translated from:

Bjørn Riis ? Fimbulvinter : Sortie 11 avril 2025

une odyssée en deux actes

Avec Fimbulvinter, Bjørn Riis nous convie ā un voyage sonore en deux temps. La premičre partie de l'album surprend par une énergie plus rock, voire hard, oų les guitares rythmiques, plus incisives, apportent une intensité nouvelle ā son univers habituellement feutré. On y perįoit des effluves hard qui tranchent avec la douceur mélancolique ā laquelle l'artiste nous avait habitués.

Puis, ā mesure que l'album progresse, on retrouve l'empreinte atmosphérique caractéristique de Riis. La seconde moitié s'ouvre sur des paysages sonores plus éthérés, oų les nappes planantes et les mélodies introspectives reprennent le dessus, nous ramenant ā cette introspection profonde qui fait la signature de l'artiste.

Fimbulvinter s'impose ainsi comme une ?uvre contrastée, oų la tension initiale cčde progressivement la place ā la contemplation, offrant une palette émotionnelle riche et nuancée.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Nature by TETRAGON album cover Studio Album, 1971
3.94 | 58 ratings

BUY
Nature
Tetragon Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by SliprKC70

4 stars Tetragon was an obscure symphonic fusion from Germany that for the longest time had only one record in their catalogue. That record, being titled Nature, is a pretty strong one. Instead of making normal progressive rock, the album meticulously fuses classical music and jazz fusion into this more traditionally influenced and segregated album. The band members each have their own individual moments on the album, with plenty of room given for experimentation on their instruments. This is all woven together through bridges of the band joining together for exquisite moments of pure symphonic prog, balanced by a level of dynamics between low harmonic and loud yet minimalist dark playing. The main player on this album is their keyboardist, Hendrik Schaper, who leads most of the music on this album and has a clear high level of skill. While all this might sound good on paper, when actually played out, the band sort of lets me down. As much as I love some good keyboards, there's a little too much (especially on side one). On the other hand, though, it has some really good moments on side two.

The opening song, Fugue, has a much more classical influence, being around sixteen minutes long and being dominated by an organ. It's a very symphonic and melodic arrangement, and at points it sounds like something Maneige would make. I will admit, sometimes the rapid organ compositions and melodies can become a little too much, but they're still a charm to hear. You can hear influences in the keyboards mainly from Keith Emerson in terms of rock keyboardists, but classical pianists from old times can also be heard in here. For the most part, the rest of the song is composed of individual solos in varying quality. From these solos, I personally like the drum solo the best, mainly because it takes many technical directions and complex arrangements, but when the band is playing together, it becomes a lot better. There's a short interlude called Jokus, and the next song, Irgendwas, is just a repeat of Fugue but with more piano and keys. There is very little to say apart from the limited guitar work, but I think the band could've tried doing something at least a little different on this song.

Side two has more of the jazz fusion elements, especially when it comes to A Short Story. The relaxed yet powerfully focused and complex music creates a wonderful atmosphere that has arguably some of the best moments on the album. The passages played out here seriously seem like a legitimate and well-known progressive rock album rather than an obscure gem. I also really liked some of the sections on the title track, with it having more of a rock direction in its sound, including vocals and a strong and steady rhythm. This song also has the most influence from jazz fusion, which I really enjoyed. Now, I will say that I am not too sure why side one and side two have different directions in the tracks, but they each bring their own unique experiences to the table.

In conclusion, this album had a lot of potential. Unfortunately, most of it was sacrificed for extended keyboard solos. Some of Hendrik's solos go on for a little too long, and while they are still worth listening to, it can get a little bland. However, the other moments of actual rock music are actually really strong, and if the band had focused more on those elements, we could've seen a more structured and amazing progressive rock album. In the end, the website says it's 4/5, but my actual rating would probably be a 3.5/5.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Brief Encounter by MARILLION album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 1986
2.74 | 82 ratings

BUY
Brief Encounter
Marillion Neo-Prog

Review by martindavey87

3 stars Released in 1984, 'Brief Encounter' is a five-track EP by British progressive rock band, Marillion. Originally intended for American markets to coincide with their tour of the States and Canada, it would eventually be re-released on CD format as a bonus disc for a re-mastered 'Real to Reel' live album.

The EP features two studio tracks that were previously released as b-sides to various singles, 'Lady Nina' and 'Freaks', which have gone on to their own acclaim as Marillion classics, and the live tracks, although available elsewhere, are still good. In particular, 'Kayleigh' and 'Fugazi' deserve recognition for the excellent performances involved.

Overall, this is a good EP. While nothing remarkable, it's a cool collectable, especially if you have an original vinyl, and at barely 32 minutes in length, is a harmless keepsake for fans.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Cleaning Out The Closet by DREAM THEATER album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 1999
3.11 | 72 ratings

BUY
Cleaning Out The Closet
Dream Theater Progressive Metal

Review by martindavey87

3 stars 'Cleaning Out the Closet' is a compilation album by progressive metal legends Dream Theater, released in 1999, exclusively to fan club members. It features a variety of unreleased songs and singles b-sides, most of which were recorded and intended for 1997's 'Falling Into Infinity', but ended up not making the cut.

And that's probably a good thing, too, because some of these songs can be pretty average at times. That's not to say that they're bad, but they were clearly left unreleased for a reason! However, a number of these have gone on to garner almost classic status. 'To Live Forever' has been floating around the bands live set for years, and 'Raise the Knife' appeared on their 2006 live album 'Score: 20th Anniversary World Tour'.

Other notable highlights include 'The Way It Used to Be', 'Cover My Eyes' and 'Speak to Me'. Although, in all honesty, while this compilation is decent enough, I don't think I'd ever choose to listen to any of these songs over any of the bands official studio output. Still, if you can find it, this is worth owning if you're a die-hard Dream Theater fan.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Deep Purple in Rock by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1970
4.36 | 1390 ratings

BUY
Deep Purple in Rock
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by martindavey87

3 stars After three releases playing psychedelic rock, and one playing classical with an orchestra, it was time for Deep Purple to truly establish their identity and give us a taste of who they are. With a major line-up change and at the insistence of guitarist Ritchie Blackmore, the band would go down the route of a heavier, more hard rock style, and it would pay off in dividends.

Released in 1970, 'In Rock' would go on to become one of those classic, genre-defining albums. Along with Black Sabbath and Led Zeppelin, Deep Purple were laying down the foundations of heavy metal with a bigger guitar sound and a high standard of musicianship by everyone involved.

'In Rock' would also see the debut of vocalist Ian Gillan, who's banshee-like wailing set the bar for metal vocalists a decade before Bruce Dickinson and Rob Halford were screaming their hearts out. Giving the band a much broader and more versatile range to work with, the chemistry between Blackmore, Gillan and keyboard player Jon Lord (and everyone else, for that matter) really starts to shine through here. For the first time since their debut album, the band sound genuinely inspired and confident.

With that out of the way, I do think that perhaps you had to be there in 1970 to truly appreciate this album the most, because listening to it today, there are a number of songs I tend to skip. But the ones I don't skip, such as 'Black Night', 'Speed King', 'Child in Time' and 'Bloodsucker', are without a doubt, Deep Purple classics. And packaged with its iconic and instantly recognisable artwork, this album is a pivotal moment in rock and metal history, and thus, belongs in everyone's collection.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Martian Chronicles III: I Or A.I. by SOLARIS album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.35 | 104 ratings

BUY
Martian Chronicles III: I Or A.I.
Solaris Symphonic Prog

Review by alainPP

5 stars Solaris, the sixth album, is a triptych that delves into the 70s, seeking the atmosphere and sound, and bringing it back, toned down, boosted, and descaled, to 2024, to better confront the science fiction of tomorrow.

"ZOO Galactica" and its symphonic-cosmo-romantic intro; a solemn, classical beauty with a majestic flute- keyboard duo. "Shadows Of The Creators" follows, with the sound of muffled pads, fat synth with a guitar arpeggio, heavy beats, and a flute blast ā la Ian; a cinematic, contemplative space leading to bliss. "Guardians" continues with Rķbert's sharp riff and fiery keyboards. The melting pot of old and new revisited through the story of our robots taking power. "I or A.I.", a Serra-esque pad, an 80s pop melody reminiscent of Tears For Fears, all the delicacy of the atmospheric, medieval nursery rhyme ā la Candice Night; a classical beauty blown out all at once with the Purple keyboard, the much more edgy Overhead-esque flute, and Csaba's haunting guitar. "Inflection Point," with the piano, stands as a bulwark against electronics in this AI world. The rhythm navigates between the carnal, colorful, and rich air of a jazzy variation for a musical duel that passes like a spatial letter on this perfect first instrumental outburst.

"Ballad Of Deluge Suite" and the Olympian "Prologue" with trumpet, neo-classical with timpani and melting choirs; a consensual bucolic space ballad. A second Balkan choir creates confusion, sung with guitar commanding respect at the finale. "Island Of Survivors" takes us into a hot jungle with an old-fashioned slide and a dizzying keyboard-flute riff. Invigorating choirs, the flute scratching the ear, vintage noise boosted with this southern cacophony, cowboys against aliens. The church organ captivates before the thunderous guitar solo flirting with Oldfield, smelling of the old madness of Focus with the reverberating synth; we are ready for the duel. "The ARK" approaches jazz rock with the twirling piano and the captivating choirs. The guitar-flute battle is energetic, a modern rock with reminiscences. "Ballad Of Deluge" Dire Straits chords, Deep Purple-style timbale, King Crimson. Asian atmosphere, Hungarian vocals and tear-jerking guitar, the cello melting. This ballad moves into a dreamlike, overwhelming and grandiloquent Rondō Veneziano.

"Dream Valley Suite" with "Welcome To The Collapse" is an acoustic preamble and a couch potato duet, almost cloying, with the voices of the Corrs. "Nightmares" is a fitting nightmarish intro. The redundant, low keyboard, the Japanese air in return, setting off a Jethro Tull-Overhead musical melting pot. The drum stutters like a galloping horse, the church organ injecting emotion, and the agonizing bass for the instrumental, which sets the stage ablaze with Csaba's bewitching guitar firing like a sinister western. A cinematic soundtrack in a frenzied coda. "Future Memories" bursts forth, keyboards, synths, mezzo-soprano voice soaring with the electronics. The guitar arpeggio melts with scattered notes; a warm, hypnotic musical cinema. "Golden Raven" for the interlude with basic spatial sound effects, the vibrating synth, the heavy guitar in the distance, Bregovic's regressive Balkan flute; captivating. "Dream Valley" is more digital, electronic to the point of suddenly hearing Space, Daft Punk. A very serious fretless bass break, energetic percussions bring the atmosphere of traditional balls from the time when music was still beautiful. The electronic and gypsy air, a melting marshmallow romance. The incomprehensible chanted vocals with the metronomic violin continue the hypnotic effect. "Paradox" and the presence of Attila, a flautist disrupting musical codes, sprinkling here and there his elven notes; the series of belched sounds taken as instruments, the Hispanic melody prolonging the cinematic effect before the finale with the wah-wah guitars like in the good old days, idyllic. The musical madness is palpable, with the final vocoder vocals reminiscent of Tangerine Dream. "Monument" has a Vangelisian sound, a solemn aria for the Olympian march with celestial choirs. "The Last Poem" is the outro, a final clap, a Hungarian poem bathed in an ethereal stereo keyboard sound, while the flute seeks out those lost on this long, astonishing journey.

Solaris offers a personal soundtrack to an imaginary film that will replay in your mind.(4.75)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Odyssey by KWOON album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.95 | 11 ratings

BUY
Odyssey
Kwoon Post Rock/Math rock

Review by alainPP

4 stars Kwoon's fourth album after more than 10 years of absence marks their planned return from afar, high up on volcanoes and mountains, facing Mont Blanc, near the sea. They continue to combine ethereal and stratospheric atmospheres to encourage musical introspection.

"Leviathan" opens with expansive, explosive, and invasive post-rock; strong and heavy with a destructive drum pad. "King of Sea" offers an aquatic journey, an airy and ambient symbiosis reminiscent of the band's archaic early days. Jazzy piano and drums create an intimate, rising track, like a gentle, rogue wave. "White Angels" has an ambient crescendo with its solemn ascent to the Heavens. Warm choirs, pounding drums, and crystalline piano, reverberating, emphatic, and overwhelming. "Life" with cello, a nostalgic, Floyd-esque tune and its children's choirs, captivating with the final melancholic violin reinforcing the atmosphere. "Blackstar" is more intimate with its latent piano; spatial sounds to soar high and never return; with a final vibration worthy of a movie soundtrack ā la "Interstellar." "Last Paradise" with its Kwoon-esque rise, metronomic percussion over a captivating sound of an apocalyptic world.

"Jayne" with its very Pendragon-esque, Floyd-esque title and prominent vocals; the killer melody, fitting the story of a Wild West in decline. The memorable rise of a showcase concert with chills from the dreamlike side it emanates. "Wolves" stands out for its Daft Punk-esque electro, a soundtrack to "Tron" with melancholic strings reinforcing the irremediably sad air. "Youth" with its warm, catchy title, most closely resembling the classic Sigur Rķs universe for its relentless monolithic sound. A long and slow post-prog rise. "Fisherman" in the same framework, the same vein, the same post wave with more vocals. "Nestadio" for the long, haunting title, a worthy representation of what post can still be today: simple, dreamlike, hypnotic, easy, captivating, expansive like the Universe; long, fluid, perfect with the dark outro. "Keep on Dreaming" for the final flight with strings, choirs, percussion and typical post guitar. The captivating sound oozing emotion.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Grand Tour by BIG BIG TRAIN album cover Studio Album, 2019
3.97 | 472 ratings

BUY
Grand Tour
Big Big Train Crossover Prog

Review by fuxi
Prog Reviewer

2 stars There's quite a tradition in prog of dealing with Weighty Literary Themes: 'The Fountain of Salmacis' (based on Ovid's METAMORPHOSES), TALES OF MYSTERY AND IMAGINATION (based on Edgar Allan Poe) and 'Xanadu' (based on Coleridge's 'Kubla Khan') spring to mind. Big Big Train do a splendid job here with the 14 min. 28 sec. 'Ariel', which neatly combines allusions to THE TEMPEST with references to the life and poetry of Percy Bysshe Shelley. It's the highlight of the album, and it's a predominantly vocal track.

I've got decidedly mixed feelings about the remainder of the album. 'Alive' and 'The Florentine' are okay I guess, the former consisting of 'power pop' with the addition of some neat little mellotron, and the latter featuring pleasant solos on violin, Moog and electric guitar. 'Theodora in Green and Gold' is good too: catchy and touching, but with a chord progression that's perhaps a little too similar to 'Judas Unrepentant'. The main problem lies with the album's other 'mini-epics'. The 13 min. 33 sec. 'Roman Stone' has no tune worth speaking of and features boring, cliché-like lyrics. ('All things must pass / Dawn down to dusk / All stories have an ending / The first and the last': if that's all you can say about the Roman Empire, just SHUT UP!) The piece almost comes alive in the middle, where there's a fast interlude for rhythm section, brass and flute, but it soon falls flat again. Similarly, the 14 min. 'Voyager' is far too wordy and the words mean little ('Out into the open skies / To find out what we are / How far we've come / How far we can go' - oh pleeease!), there's a pleasant instrumental section with a bubbly synth solo that reminds me of Genesis' 'Riding The Scree', but the thing-as-a-whole fails to capture the imagination. 'Homesong' initially feels pleasant enough, but its Grand Finale (with added brass ensemble and Dave Gregory's guitar wailing away, more or less like in 'East Coast Racer') seems overcooked and undeserved; in my opinion it merely grates.

It seems likely that GRAND TOUR was Big Big Train's reaction to Britain's 'Brexit' vote of June 2016. While the band's intentions may have been good ('Let's just show how Britain used to CONNECT with the rest of Europe'), the album flounders disastrously. Which is no surprise, really, for in the preceding ten years BBT had delivered four or five true masterpieces, and inspiration can't last forever...

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Odyssey by JUPITER HOLLOW album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2017
4.00 | 1 ratings

BUY
Odyssey
Jupiter Hollow Progressive Metal

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

— First review of this album —
4 stars I was going through the pile of metal related albums I hadn't reviewed yet, when I discovered this Ep by JUPITER HOLLOW. I thought I probably had them in the wrong section given their name. So I looked them up here and almost fell off my seat as they are a local band. From Barrie, Ontario, a mere 30 minute drive from my place, and where my sister lives. They are a duo who formed in 2015, the same year as CROWN LANDS, and I mention them because they too are a duo from Ontario(Toronto) and both are greatly influenced by RUSH.

CROWN LANDS managed to get their first EP out the year before JUPITER HOLLOW, but I actually prefer this Barrie band. I can't get over how good this 23 1/2 minute recording is. It sounds amazing, as far as the production goes. The singer reminds me of Geddy on "Hemispheres", he can flat out sing in that higher register, and he gets extreme as well. Kenny on vocals is also the drummer and both add synths. Grant adds the guitar and bass. It's kind of crazy the similarities between these two Canadian bands who formed the same year. While COWN LANDS seems to talk about RUSH constantly, JUPITER HOLLOW is more into TOOL and TESSERACT.

This duo has released a couple of studio albums so far. Their 2018 release called "AHDOMN" features four of the five tracks from this EP but given a makeover apparently. And they released "Bereavement" in 2020. This "Odyssey" Ep is one I just am blown away by. The complexity and power, but also the melodic passages and atmospheric calms. The singer can get extreme but it all sounds amazing. The only song they didn't put on their debut from this EP is the title track. Kind of surprising considering how good it is. Its the closer here. The atmosphere over the final minute is breathtaking. Like thunder kind of but a little different. Of course I link it to it's title "Odyssey" and it's just such an epic way to end this recording.

This album gets very heavy at times. That opening number called "Deep In Space" reveals that. Kenny comes in screaming the vocals at first. So many repeated themes on this one. It's like the rhythm section after 4 1/2 minutes is trampling the soundscape to end it. What an opener! "Hades Heart" is brighter, more prog metal-like with the vocals and style. "Over 50 Years" has this abrasive guitar sound to start as drums roll in. This is the heaviest section yet. So much bottom end. The vocals growl and scream briefly around 2 minutes. A complex track. "Ascending" is all about the atmosphere and melancholy over it's almost 3 minutes.

What a start for this young duo. Five tracks all under 6 minutes, but enough time to truly showcase this band's incredible talents. I have no doubt they could stretch these songs out in a live situation, but man, what a great teaser this Ep is. Another 2017 release I didn't get to. This was worth the wait.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Good Man by CARPANI BAND, ALEX album cover Studio Album, 2024
4.09 | 51 ratings

BUY
The Good Man
Alex Carpani Band Symphonic Prog

Review by kev rowland
Special Collaborator Prog Reviewer / Special Collaborator

3 stars Alex Carpani is an Italian French composer, keyboard player, singer, producer, musicologist and artistic director who lives and works in Bologna. From the late 90's to the mid-2000's he wrote and self-produced a lot of instrumental music, ranging from new age, electronic, symphonic, music combined with poetry, DnB, electro-jazz and music for theatrical performances and documentaries. However, since the mid 2000's he has dedicated himself mainly to rock, releasing 8 albums with Italian and foreign labels, which has led him to collaborating with the likes of David Jackson, David Cross, Theo Travis, Jon Davison, Bernardo Lanzetti and others. For this album the core band again comprises drummer Bruno Farinelli, with whom he has worked on the last few albums, along with bassist Giambattista Giorgi and guitarist Emiliano Fantuzzi with guests Alessio Alberghini (soprano sax) and Valentina Vanini (mezzosoprano).

This album comprises two long suites and represents an uninterrupted story, an experience lived through the folds and fragilities of the human mind, through the infinite nuances of our emotions and feelings. This never sounds like a band headed by a keyboard player, as this is very much a rock album which while progressive switches through multiple sub-genres from hard rock through Neo, Crossover and rarely into Symphonic which is where he sits on PA (but having never heard any of his other material it is possible this is quite different to the rest). The two suites are very different in approach, with the first being instrumental, following more fragmented and diverse paths while the second contains far more guitars and is more melodic and straightforward in some ways. The nuances added by the classical female vocals and the sax are a really nice touch, and one is never really sure where the music is going to lead as it is never quite as straightforward as one imagines it is going to be. I can easily see the second suite being enjoyed by those into melodic rock as well as prog, as it straddles the line, and while Alex may not have the largest vocal range, he knows what he can do, and he does it well with the arrangements being set to maximise the emotion and passion. Overall, this is a very enjoyable album on the first time of playing, feeling homely and welcoming and does not take any hard work to get inside which is a pleasant change given much of the prog I am sent these days. I can certainly see me looking out for more from Alex in the future, and if you enjoy this then why not check out his substantial back catalogue.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 H2 Three by HYDROGEN BAND album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2024
4.00 | 2 ratings

BUY
H2 Three
Hydrogen Band Progressive Electronic

Review by kev rowland
Special Collaborator Prog Reviewer / Special Collaborator

4 stars Here is the third in a series of releases from Hydrogen Band, the name given to Barney Jones (guitar, bell tree, tape machine, metal clarinet), Dave Newhouse (e piano, organ, bass clarinet, flute) and Bev Stephenson (synth, bell tree, organ, penny whistle) who recorded these sessions in 1980. Barney and Bev are no longer with us by Dave has worked in Ian Beabout to bring to life these old recordings and make them into something new. This time we have just one long track, "3 Eye", which is actually four sections edited together from two separate sessions, with some overlaps/fades.

Given it is from the source, it is no surprise that this is a logical follow-on from the other two EPs in this series, with all three musicians heavily into experimental improvisation, going where the mood takes them. The different multi- instrumentalists switch between what they are playing with an almost hypnotic repetition on keyboards at times and is definitely one of those when if the listener is prepared to spend the time then they will be richly rewarded. It is not as immediate as the others, but Dave and Ian have worked hard on the tapes to create something which is cogent and with direction, as opposed to senseless meanderings ? working through music in this way reminds me a great deal of Robin Taylor and some of his works with Taylor's Free Universe (if you enjoy either act then I highly suggest you check out the other), although the output is quite different. I do not know how much more material is available from these sessions but let us hope there is still more to come as this is both experimental and essential.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 H2 One by HYDROGEN BAND album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2024
4.00 | 2 ratings

BUY
H2 One
Hydrogen Band Progressive Electronic

Review by kev rowland
Special Collaborator Prog Reviewer / Special Collaborator

4 stars In 1980, Dave Newhouse (keyboards), Barney Jones (guitar), and Bev Stephenson (synth) dragged their gear into the basement studio at the Mars Everywhere house (Barney was a member of Mars Everywhere at the time) and recorded a series of tapes straight through without stopping and no overdubs. This EP, which contains two tracks with a total playing time of more than 20 minutes, is the first in a series of three recordings which will be made available on Bandcamp, having been de-mixed and re-mastered by Ian Beabout at the Rec. Room.

Dave is these days often asked to provide his wonderful woodwind playing on multiple albums, but he has always been a keyboard player as well, but I think this is the first work of his I have come across where he is only playing keys, apart from possibly some live recordings in The Muffins. Consequently it seems quite strange, but there is never any doubt that he is in a room with kindred spirits as he and Bev combine to create some wonderful sounds while Barney carefully pays attention and adds nuances, or sits out of a section, or rides roughshod with distortion over the top. As well as being a fine musician in his own right, Ian Beabout is doing some wonderful work these days and he has managed to provide a clarity here which makes it sound as if this was recorded in the finest digital studio only a few days ago, as opposed to in a basement more than 40. This is wonderful improvised electronic jazz which has nods to ambient as well as Canterbury and I look forward to the next two with great interest.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 H2 Two by HYDROGEN BAND album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2024
4.00 | 2 ratings

BUY
H2 Two
Hydrogen Band Progressive Electronic

Review by kev rowland
Special Collaborator Prog Reviewer / Special Collaborator

4 stars Following on from 'H2 One' we have 'H2 Two', which will soon be followed by 'H2 Three'. Yet again what we have here are two lengthy tracks recorded live and without overdubs by Dave Newhouse (keyboards, flute), Barney Jones (guitar, metal clarinet), and Bev Stephenson (synth, bell tree). Recorded in 1980 the recordings have been de-mixed and remastered by Ian Beabout and are now being made available for our listening pleasure. Dave does make a confession that there are two one-minute sections on "The House on the Hill" where he accidentally combined two different sessions ? he was going to delete them but when he listened to what he had created he felt this was a happy accident and perfectly fitted with the ethos of the band.

I generally think of Dave as being primarily a woodwind player, but of course he did also play keyboards in The Muffins, and here he is combining with Bev to create layers and ideas while Barney can often be found moving in a quite different direction, yet somehow, they all combine together to make musical sense of what is taking place. In many ways this is a logical progression from what Dave had already been doing with The Muffins, while Barney was heavily into experimentation with Mars Everywhere (they released 'Industrial Sabotage' the same year this was recorded). Together the trio created music which is still exciting and taking us in new directions in 2024, some 44 years after they created it out of the thin air.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Deep Purple in Rock by DEEP PURPLE album cover Studio Album, 1970
4.36 | 1390 ratings

BUY
Deep Purple in Rock
Deep Purple Proto-Prog

Review by Hector Enrique
Prog Reviewer

5 stars Having failed to take off as expected after three albums focused on light pop with psychedelic touches and with their bank accounts in the red, Ritchie Blackmore and Jon Lord decided it was time for Deep Purple to make a change of direction, replacing singer Rod Evans with the portentous tenor Ian Gillan and bassist Nick Simper with the virtuoso Roger Glover, to align themselves on the same frequency of the deadly sound waves with which their contemporaries Led Zeppelin and Black Sabbath swept through the early 70s. And the result of that line-up change was "Deep Purple in Rock" (1970), the band's fourth album.

A powerful offering that contributes to further shape and style to the opulent Hard Rock still in the process of consolidation, with Blackmore unloading dense, distorted guitar riffs laced with Lord's timeless Hammond on the thunderous opener "Speed King", the very substantial bluesy riffs that ornament the lilting "Bloodsucker", and to a great extent with Lord's digitated and surgical keyboards and Gillan's incredible vocal register taking the high notes to unsuspected levels in the dramatic and intense "Child in Time", a huge and elaborate piece that borders on progressive rock structures, undoubtedly one of the best songs in Deep Purple's entire discography and in the genre.

And to reaffirm the band's rugged new approach, the Blackmore/Lord duo persist with their dynamic, symbiotic interplay on the supersonic "Flight of the Rat" which features influences from 'The Flight of The BumbleBee' (part of Russian Nikolai Rimsky-Korsakov's early 20th century opera 'The Tale of the Tsar Saltan'), and on the thick mid- tempo "Into the Fire"; and while Ian Paice's funky drumming and Glover's remarkable bass lines lend some warmth to Lord's sharp keyboards on "Living Wreck", it's only a brief pause for the galloping "Hard Lovin' Man" to pick up the rispidity with Lord's Keith Emerson-esque jam and Blackmore's dubbed out guitar plucking, in another remarkable hard rock essay and end to the work.

The unmistakable and iconic cover of "Deep Purple In Rock" is also a symbol of what the album represented, one of the cornerstones (not to say mountains...) in the history of rock.

Essential

4.5 stars

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Se Nos Lleva El Aire by ROBE album cover Studio Album, 2023
4.83 | 4 ratings

BUY
Se Nos Lleva El Aire
Robe Heavy Prog

Review by The Crow
Prog Reviewer

5 stars After listening to the masterpiece "Mayéutica" thousands of times, with its structure of a single song divided into movements like a symphony, the return of Robe to the traditional song format in "Se nos lleva el aire" initially felt almost strange to me. But nothing could be further from the truth!

What we find on this album is the most mature, confident version of Robe yet. He seamlessly blends the magic of "Mayéutica" with the spirit of his first two solo records to craft a collection of songs that is nothing short of impeccable, intoxicating, and already filled with anthems for lovers of modern Spanish rock.

Tracks like El Hombre Pájaro, Viajando desde el Interior, Nada que Perder, El Poder del Arte, and Ininteligible rank among the finest ever composed by the Plasencia-born artist. He's accompanied by a band capable of delivering a true sonic orgy, an explosion of textures, musical richness, and technical prowess that is hard to match in today's progressive rock scene.

An absolute phenomenon. A force of nature in the shape of a musician who, at over 60 years old, shows no signs of slowing down. While many artists see their talent fade with age, Robe's only continues to grow, delivering the best albums of his entire career at a time when most musicians are simply coasting on past glories.

Bravo, Robe! I can't wait to hear what you create next. We need more of this magnificent, electrifying drug you compose.

Best Tracks: El Hombre Pájaro (a full crescendoing symphony in itself, reminiscent of the masterpiece Un Suspiro Acompasado), Viajando desde el Interior (an absolutely overwhelming bassline unleashes one of the wildest and most intense songs Robe has written since Para Todos los Públicos), Nada Que Perder (this can already be considered a classic of Spanish rock, perfect in every sense, and incredibly catchy), A la Orilla del Río (a beautiful piece, pure poetry, with flawless musical accompaniment), El Poder del Arte (the centerpiece of the album, and its best track. opening with a Debussy-inspired melody and evolving into a stunning tribute to music itself, moving through jazz, heavy metal, hard rock, funk, pop... and even Apocalypse Now! A jaw-dropping musical achievement, topped off with what might be the best chorus Robe has ever written), and Ininteligible (a full-blown progressive rock bomb, intense, with phenomenal instrumental work)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Shells by EVERON album cover Studio Album, 2025
3.91 | 59 ratings

BUY
Shells
Everon Heavy Prog

Review by The Crow
Prog Reviewer

4 stars When, after a long 17-year hiatus, the incredible and criminally underrated German heavy prog band Everon announced their return with the magnificent single No Embrace, I could hardly believe it. Especially considering the heartbreaking passing of their drummer and founding member not long before.

And yet, in February, "Shells" arrived at my doorstep and after many, many listens, I can say with confidence: the magic of Oliver Phillips remains completely intact. His brilliance as a composer, singer, guitarist, keyboardist, and, of course, producer, hasn't faded one bit. In fact, "Shells" earns a spot among Everon's top five albums?and might even go toe-to-toe with titans like "Fantasma", Bridge, and "Flesh" for a place in the top three.

Stylistically, the album picks up some of the sonic identity of "North" (the album many of us believed would be Everon's last), but it's infused with a broader range of textures and ideas that also echo the eclecticism of "Fantasma" and the timeless elegance of "Bridge".

What we get is classic Everon: epic, emotionally charged tracks with sweeping orchestration and lush keyboard arrangements (No Embrace, Monster); darker, melancholic pieces that tug at the soul (Broken Angels, Shells, Guilty as Charged); tracks with a subtle pop sheen (Travels, Until We Meet Again); touches of experimentation including folk influences in the surprising Pinocchio's Nose, and even flashes of extreme metal in the final moments of Shells. There are also signature instrumentals reminiscent of classics like Meteor or Puppet Show (OCD), and some slightly cheesy but heartfelt ballads (Grace)?a staple of Everon's unmistakable charm.

In short, Shells is everything an Everon fan could have hoped for?and so much more. It's a dream come true, and without a doubt, one of the finest progressive rock albums 2025 is likely to deliver.

A spectacular return. Let's just hope they don't keep us waiting so long next time!

Best Tracks: honestly, there's not a single bad song on the album, but if I had to choose, I'd go with No Embrace (the chorus is wonderful, and the final solo is legendary), Pinocchio's Nose (those Celtic touches and the female vocals are just gorgeous), Monster (the best lyrics on the album?harsh and raw?paired with dreamlike melodies for a powerful contrast), Guilty as Charged (perhaps the most well-rounded track on the album, with an absolutely overwhelming ending), and the re-recording of Flesh (which somehow improves on a song that already seemed unbeatable)

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Dream Society by HARPER, ROY album cover Studio Album, 1998
2.66 | 13 ratings

BUY
The Dream Society
Roy Harper Prog Folk

Review by kenethlevine
Special Collaborator Prog-Folk Team

2 stars It seems about time, both chronologically and contextually, for my quasi annual nostalgic rant for the days of the 40 minute LP, particularly when the artist in question produced several of these low fat offerings during his creative peak. More is surely less on "The Dream Society", whose major accomplishment hides in the rockers strewn about, particularly "Psychopath" and "Angel of the Night", while the "Songs of Love" falls about as flat as his own romantic life at that time. The epic title track is adequate, if that is any sort of endorsement, "Broken Wing" foolishly espouses his excruciating vibrato and drags immeasurably, and the 15 minute closer is an overripe potpourri of the Dylan esque that sounds as if it might have been held back for 3 decades. The only ballad that resonates for me is "I Wanna be in Love". While not a full fledged nightmare, this dream is certainly one from which I am glad to emerge.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Margerine Eclipse by STEREOLAB album cover Studio Album, 2004
4.00 | 6 ratings

BUY
Margerine Eclipse
Stereolab Crossover Prog

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars Going into this album the band decided to get back to basics. In their earliest days they recorded live as a band, and so this would be the direction taken here. They added a second keyboardist, allowing leader Tim Gane to focus more on the guitar. The two Post Rock legends John McEntire and Jim O'Rourke who had been involved with the recording process and production were not invited back. McEntire(TORTOISE) had been involved on the previous four studio albums. So changes aplenty. I was glad to see the guest horns that were on "Sound-Dust" were not invited back as well.

To quote Tim Gane "The making of this LP was dominated by one tragic event; the death of a great friend and band member Mary Hansen, shortly before we were due to start recording." Tim related that all of the instrumental music had been written before Mary's passing, but not all the lyrics. So that explains why this album is so uplifting and happy. That part was already done. Gane continues to tell that it was at one of those live in studio rehearsals that Martin showed up unexpectedly to tell them the news of Mary's passing.

Tim goes on "You'll have to excuse me if I don't have a perfect memory of what happened after that except to say that we stopped, packed up and went home. I don't remember what I was thinking about or what my state of mind was. Weeks passed before we collectively agreed on continuing to make music as a group and to carry on with this record specifically. Obviously nothing would be the same and the original ideas we had for the recording were dropped."

It's interesting that they decided to add these electronic pieces they call the Carlton idents. They had done these back in 1992 for Carlton Television, a series of futuristic sounding idents for a new season of programming they had coming up. Tim stumbled upon the demos for these and decided to incorporate them in some of the intros, outros and mid sections of songs on here. So the original live in studio thing was dropped. Just before the recordings began Tim decided to pan the speakers extreme left and right with nothing in the middle. "This led to the idea of having one version of the song on the left speaker and a second on the right speaker and the third 'version' would be the two combined."

The packaging here is so much better than on "Sound-Dust. In fact it's beyond the call of duty how much detailed information we get concerning this album. Like the album's title which has no meaning in relation the music. Like all of their album titles. Tim just liked it. This is about a dozen minutes shorter than "Sound-Dust" which I like, as it clocks in at over 53 minutes. Like "Sound- Dust" I can't say I'm in love at all with their music, but with "Margerine Eclipse" I at least have no issues with what I'm hearing and I quite like the warm and uplifting attitude. This is fun when you would expect a dark pall to be over this album. Not so.

Their last great record and worth a low 4 stars.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 The Sea Within by SEA WITHIN, THE album cover Studio Album, 2018
3.55 | 120 ratings

BUY
The Sea Within
The Sea Within Eclectic Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

3 stars The Sea Within is a musical project/supergroup put together by German progressive rock label Inside Out Music in 2017, composed of an all-star lineup featuring members of The Flower Kings, Pain of Salvation, and Kansas, namely guitarist Roine Stolt, bass player Jonas Reingold, vocalist Gildenlöw, drummer Marco Minnemann, and keyboard player Tom Brislin, currently a member of Kansas. This collective is joined by Flying Colors singer Casey McPherson for their 2018 self-titled debut album (and as of 2025, sole release under this name), and while some might have expected a more flamboyant symphonic prog crossover, the music of The Sea Within is more of an eclectic mixture of mellow, dreamy and textured art rock, attempting to catch a somewhat "oceanic", floating feel, almost like a modern and livelier version of Pink Floyd.

The entire album exudes this cinematic and almost pop sensibility, which is quite a welcome experiment for the band members, considering their different backgrounds - the balance between the vocals of Gildenlöw and McPherson is nice and quite effective, all while the music remains tranquil and pensive, at times even tediously mellow, perhaps reflected in the lyrics and the peculiar but gorgeous album art. Among all that, Marco Minnemann's performance impresses as particularly outstanding, his fills and grooves become the essential drivers of many of the songs and he successfully manages to instill a liveliness to the band. The guitar playing is finely controlled and occasionally bluesy, nothing overly flashy and complex, while the keys are in that classic rock vein, which is definitely suitable for the music produced by this collective. Songs which ultimately end up as exemplary of the supergroup's style are the dramatic opener 'Ashes of Dawn', the melancholic tunes 'They Know My Name' and 'Time' (a touch of Floyd is inevitable here), the rather accessible and well-arranged songs 'The Void' and 'Goodbye', while the big 14-minute opus 'Broken Cord' lacks that edge and charisma that other entries on here exhibit. Closing track 'The Hiding of Truth' is forgettable, too, and the four-track bonus disc brings nothing overly exciting to the table - this record can be great at times, and can get boring at others.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Real to Reel by MARILLION album cover Live, 1984
3.88 | 373 ratings

BUY
Real to Reel
Marillion Neo-Prog

Review by martindavey87

3 stars 'Real to Reel' is the first live album by British progressive rock band, Marillion. Released in 1984 and featuring only seven tracks, it shows a band that are only two albums into their career, but already displaying the prowess of a tight-knit unit.

When writing about this album however, I don't really have too much to say. The sound is really good, and the performances are excellent, with particular praise to vocalist Fish, who bellows every note with passion and conviction. Sadly, as it is still early days for the prog rockers, the set list is a little dated by today's standards.

That's not to say that it's bad, but I'm just not likely to ever listen to this. With highlights including 'Assassing', 'Cinderella Search', and a fantastic rendition of 'Forgotten Sons', it's no doubt a nice memento for a time before Marillion would become huge worldwide superstars. But really, considering the absolute wealth of material the band has produced by now, this is nothing more than a nice collectable for fans.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Un'Altra Mano Di Carte by LIMITE ACQUE SICURE album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.02 | 67 ratings

BUY
Un'Altra Mano Di Carte
Limite Acque Sicure Rock Progressivo Italiano

Review by TenYearsAfter

4 stars GOOD NEWS FOR THE MANY ITALIAN PROG LOVERS!

The new Italian band Limite Acque Sicure was founded in 2005, in the northern part of Italy. In 2016 they turned into a six-piece formation, with members from different origins and horizons, from metal to fusion, from classical to rock, but this is precisely the secret of their formula. In 2022 I wrote about their eponymous debut album (see review) the following. "I am impressed by this new Italian prog band with their first album, these are excellent musicians, with interesting different musical backgrounds, what a chemistry, I am already looking forward to their next effort, highly recommended!"

Band info. "In this new work we have adopted a theme, the concept is telling of life experiences by characters. The record is a metaphor for the randomness of fate, which assigns each person a specific story, a particular path in life. It is different from our debut album, here on Un'Altra Mano Di Carte" we tell stories, of marginalisation, of distant (perhaps false) memories of a better life, of abuse. Stories of reflection on wickedness, stories of rebellion, of shots of pride."

Joker : The first composition on this new Limite Acque Sicure album contains a lot of shifting moods and a varied instrumentation. From a spacey synthesizer intro to a bombastic outburst with howling wah-wah guitar. From a slow rhythm with pleasant Italian vocals to dreamy with tender piano sensitive electric guitar and a celestial female voice. In the second part the sound gradually becomes more bombastic, culminating in a compelling climate with a church organ sound, a Minimoog solo and Mellotron choirs, backed by a dynamic rhythm-section, wow, what a start!

Il Racconto Di Juan Della Sua Terra : This track features the more pastoral side of the band featuring an Angelo Branduardi kind of folk sound with flute, acoustic guitar, tender piano and orchestrations. In between a sumptuous eruption with a synthesizer solo and fiery guitar solo, this adds dynamics and musical contrasts to the music, one of the trademarks of the band.

Natale 1914 : It starts with military drums and a tin-whistle sound, then a slow rhythm, in a dreamy climate with melancholic vocals and piano. Gradually the sound turns more lush featuring moving guitar, emotional vocals, another pleasant, very compelling atmosphere, topped with delicate synthesizer and guitar interplay. Halfway through is a a fiery guitar solo, then a mellow part with acoustic guitar and intense vocals, finally the unsurpassed Mellotron joins, what a tastefully arranged track.

Non Il Bergerac : The intro contains a wonderful classical piano solo, next tender vocals and piano, turning into a slow rhythm with sparkling piano, beautiful. Halfway through a mid-tempo with a flashy synthesizer solo. In the second part a mellow atmosphere with a moving electric guitar solo, gradually the mood shifts to a heavier sound. Finally sound effects and a melancholic accordion.

Chita : This long composition features excellent female vocals, she has a wide range and lots of power. The atmosphere alternates between mellow and bombastic, embellished with piano, guitar and accordion. In the final part a kind of Arabian singing, turning into an opera voice, pretty hypnotizing, but also adventurous.

Storie Perdute : The final composition delivers an awesome vintage keyboard sound with powerful Hammond organ and majestic Mellotron choirs, in a bombastic climate with propulsive drum beats, a sparkling piano interlude and a sumptuous outburst featuring heavy guitar with wah-wah. Often Le Orme comes to my mind, also due to the wonderful male Italian vocals.

WOW! What a wonderful second effort, highly recommended, especially to the fans of 70s Italian prog, like Banco and Le Orme.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Robert Fripp & Andy Summers: I Advance Masked by FRIPP, ROBERT album cover Studio Album, 1982
3.63 | 98 ratings

BUY
Robert Fripp & Andy Summers: I Advance Masked
Robert Fripp Eclectic Prog

Review by Warthur
Prog Reviewer

4 stars The product of a couple of stints of recording from just just before and a bit after the sessions for King Crimson's Beat, Andy Summers and Robert Fripp's I Advance Masked sees the Police and King Crimson guitarists going on a journey of ambient guitar exploration. Naturally, it's like nothing in the Police catalogue, and there's precious little in the King Crimson repertoire which resembles it, beyond some of the more ambient and outre instrumental passages on their 1980s albums, the resemblence largely coming from Fripp chewing over similar guitar ideas there as here.

The closest comparison, however, is to an even more guitar-oriented take on Fripp's collaborations with Eno or his solo work, with the dual lead approach here allowing Fripp to intertwine his guitar sound with Summers much as he would with Adrian Belew in King Crimson at the same time. The end result is more thoughtful, less intrusive, more ambiently inclined, and less tempestuous than Fripp or Summers' day jobs, and it's a solid piece of work provided you weren't expecting Elephant Talk or Every Breath You Take.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Miles Davis Quintet: Miles Smiles by DAVIS, MILES album cover Studio Album, 1966
4.21 | 164 ratings

BUY
Miles Davis Quintet: Miles Smiles
Miles Davis Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars Recorded at Columbia's 30th Street Studio, New York City, on October 24 and October 25, 1966. Whereas the previous studio album (recorded all the way back in January of 1965) showed the band experimenting with very subtle structural elements in what felt like very profound and skill-building ways, this one shows a return to more dynamic, loosely-constrained improvisational music. The band has had over a year and a half of almost continuous touring and live performing to hone their skills as well as play with and express their transcendent subliminal connections, and now they're ready to re-enter the studio not just as a machine but as a fully-fledged organic organism capable of fluid and united here-and-now morphing: something like the murmurations of a flock of starlings.

A1. "Orbits" (4:35) the first of three Wayne Shorter compostions, it opens with Miles, Wayne, and Tony bursting out some riffs before smoothing with Ron Carter's twinkle-toes support into a The nuances Tony is throwing at us from his sticks is extraordinary: it's as if he's playing multiple percussion instruments over there (in the right channel) all at the same time! Oddly, there is absolutely no presence of Herbie Hancock's piano until the 2:45 mark when he's given a solo slot. I like Herbie's lower octave piano phrasing here: it's very smooth and virtuosic--even understated--in its imitation/regurgitation and development of the main melodies offered by the horn players. (9.125/10)

A2. "Circle" (5:52) a song attributed to Miles, it harkens back to the softer, more subtly populated fare of old Miles' songs like Kind of Blue and Sketches of Spain. Miles' muted trumpet presents the melodies for the first 90-seconds and then Wayne comes in with one of his masterful melancholy solos--the kind that feel so simple and easy and yet contain untuold numbers of virtuosic touches that you and I could never duplicate. Then Herbie's solo starts and it's a beauty: so well proportioned with the play of Ron's bass and Tony's brushes. I'm glad to have Herbie's gentle phrasing bridge the rhythmatists and melody-makers for the full length of this song. Miles, Wayne, and Herbie each take second solos in the middle of the song: these being even more melodic and emotionally-charged than the first ones while Ron and Tony exude magical techniques that I've never heard before (from the double bass' upper registers and from Tony's hi-hat), and then Miles' muted trumpet takes us out--ever so gently--as everybody else also dials down their inputs. Wow! What a great song! (10/10)

A3. "Footprints" (9:44) the second Shorter composition, this one is overflowing with pleasing melodies! At the same time, the confidence exuding from the instrumental sounds played by all of the band members has grown in geometric proportions; it's as if previously Miles was tearing his young collaborators down in order to rebuild them better than before. The success shows commensurately. (18.5/20)

B1. "Dolores" (6:20) on Wayne's #3 contribution, it sounds like a slight variation on the previous track: slightly faster, slightly more dynamic, giving more open reins to Tony, in particular. It's not the dynamic, rock-muscling drumming of Lifetime, but it is virtuosic. The oddest thing about this song is that I hear absolutely no piano until 3:15! (9/10)

B2. "Freedom Jazz Dance" (7:11) something I see less frequently on Miles' studio albums: Miles covering someone else's composition--here a song by Eddie Harris. I love the interplay among the musicians--that includes Ron and Herbie as Wayne and Miles lead the way. In the meantime, underneath it all, Tony is again set free to play! And amazing is his exhibition! I have to keep going back to try to listen to the other musicians because I always seem to end up being drawn to Tony's drum play. Teo has Herbie mixed a little low in the mix--off in the left channel with Wayne and Ron, Miles right-center, while Tony is left pretty much alone in the right channel. (No wonder I can't stop listening to him: my right ear is my better ear!) The construct and play is a little more angular and less melodic in the solos, but as long as Tony is there to wow me, I don't really care. And then the song comes to a proper, natural end (as opposed to being faded out). (14/15)

B3. "Ginger Bread Boy" (7:40) another cover song, this one of a song by saxophonist Jimmy Heath. The band opens with Wayne and Miles riffing together while Tony drives his kit like he's weaving in and out of traffic on the Autbahn (while Ron tries to keep up with him by fast walking on his fretboard). Once again there is minimal (if any) piano play in the support sections. Miles gets an awesome solo in the second and third minutes in which he verily feeds off of the energy being issued by Tony. Then Wayne, too, offers up something lively and inspired--not quite as entwined with Tony's playing as Miles' solo (and mixed a little into the background) but still quite impressive. Herbie rather awkwardly gets the nod to jump in toward the end of the fifth minute. His choppy solo feels less connected to the rest- -more heady and experimental than loose and free-flowing. As Wayne and Miles duet to bring us back to the opening motif with a minute to go, you think it's going to fade out, but instead they give Ron a little spotlight time with which to bring the song to a close (with the additional rasp of Miles talking to Teo at the very end). Mr. Williams is incredible and it's Miles who does the best job of feeding off his drummer's phenomenal energy. (14/15)

Total Time 40:35

Boy! Have these guys come a long way! It's so amazing to actually hear and feel the tremendous growth they've achieved as a band. My only complaint with some of the songs is the choice to not have Herbie's piano act as an accompanist: he's given solos in the second half of these songs but allowed no presence in the opening or closing portions of three songs!

A/five stars; a masterpiece of wonderfully-cohesive quintet jazz. This band is not called "great" for no reason! Highly recommended to anyone wanting to experience a full album of really high-quality jazz music.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Miles Davis Quintet: E.S.P. by DAVIS, MILES album cover Studio Album, 1965
4.01 | 95 ratings

BUY
Miles Davis Quintet: E.S.P.
Miles Davis Jazz Rock/Fusion

Review by BrufordFreak
Collaborator Honorary Collaborator

5 stars After a couple of years of touring, testing out new lineups and new formats while trying to form a new quintet (and releasing several live albums in the interim), Miles has his new dream lineup--what will be remembered as his "Second Great Quintet"--as superstar Wayne Shorter has finally come aboard to join Miles and Ron Carter with wunderkinder Tony Williams and Herbie Hancock. The first studio album to feature the full lineup of the Second Great Quintet is recorded at Columbia Studios in Los Angeles on January 20-22, 1965. Producer Teo Macero has by now been exposed to the amazingly new and expanding possibilities of sound engineering (he's had lots of fun practicing with a couple of live albums released between this and 1963's Seven Steps to Heaven as well as the long process of finishing the classic Gil Evans big band collaboration, Quiet Nights, which had been recorded in 1962 and early 1963 but not released until December of 1963), thus the six months between recording sessions and the final Columbia Records release.

A1. "E.S.P." (5:29) there is a sense of comfort and ease from the very onset of this song: this band "clicks." Wayne Shorter leads on his tenor sax from the opening note with Ron Carter and Tony Williams running like mice beneath and Herbie accenting the mid-range on piano. When Miles takes over the lead in the second minute it feels like everybody kicks into hyper-focus: "Got to impress the boss" they're thinking. Herbie gets the next solo starting at 4:05. His melodies are impressive for how quickly things are moving along. At the advent of the sixth minute Ron slows down as Wayne and Miles recapitulate the main melody together, bringing the song to a close. Impressive jazz. (9.125/10)

A2. "Eighty-One" (6:14) Herbie leads on this one while Miles and Wayne inject a few interesting blasts before the reins are handed over to the bandleader. There is a definite fresh, innovative feeling to this song: I'm not sure if it's the odd structure or mix of changing motifs from partial elements of the group while the soloists play, but there is something very interesting here. It's like the band members are each allowed to change things up--to shift gears or styles-- whenever the mood or whim excites them. Tony, Herbie, and Ron all do it and a few times the whole band follows suit but sometimes they don't! I'm not sure what you call that which I'm listening to here but it's very different from the jazz I'm used to hearing. When Miles and Wayne join forces to play in tandem over Herbie's solo in the final minute, it is so cool! It's as if they're playing a game: trying to read each other's minds while not taking too much away from Herbie. A very cool jazz song that feels as if it's pushing boundaries. (10/10)

A3. "Little One" (7:21) soft, slow, and spacious piano-led (and Herbie-composed) jazz music over which Miles and Wayne each take turns soloing with pensive intent. Ron and Tony are there in the background, trying to feed off the leader's energy (Tony trying to hold back his penchant for more dynamic play) and Wayne's "thought trains" a little more active-preoccupied than Miles' reflective ones. Even Herbie in the background feels as if he's ready to exude more enthusiasm than his leaders have laid down, yet his turn in the spotlight is perhaps the most beautiful in its contemplative expression of all of them. (It's between he and Miles.) The support from the rhythm section backs way down in the seventh minute, giving the song a much more "finished" feeling to its end. Nice exercise in mental discipline. The boys did well! (14/15)

A4. "R.J." (3:56) back to a quicker pace with Tony keeping time while Ron runs through a two-measure sprint over and over with a brief piano-filled break in between each race. Wayne takes the first solo but I find myself so distracted by the intriguing little dance that Herbie and Ron are doing that I find it hard to pay attention to the soloists. Fascinating! (9.3333/10)

B1. "Agitation" (7:45) Tony, sticks on the skins, for the first two minutes of this before Miles' muted trumpet squeaks into the soundscape with Ron and Herbie tip-toeing beneath. Eventually, Ron, Tony, and Herbie fall into sync with one another creating what feels like a motif that is intended to mesmerize the listener; they're sneakily trying to brainwash us! Miles distracts us from "behind" with his muted trumpet while the other three go through their Marth Graham-like angular motions with the consistency of time pieces. Wayne steps in to give a gentle solo that continues to lull us while the scientists do their work underneath. Again: fascinating! Miles and his collaborators are definitely exploring the structural rules of jazz--testing the confining boundaries with these mathematical exercises. I find myself really enjoying this (and the process)! A Miles composition, I imagine he was quite exacting of his demands on the rhythmatists here. (14/15)

B2. "Iris" (8:31) opening like a late-night piece from Kind of Blue we are informed very early on by Herbie that this is in no way anything like anything from Bill Evans or Wynton Kelly. Ron and Tony stay pretty firm in their commitment to standard jazz support, but Miles and Wayne are definitely stretching the familiar routes of melody and dynamics on this Wayne Shorter composition. While I truly enjoy all of the solos, it is Herbie's humane piano solo in the seventh minute that I love the most. (It is actually quite a lot like something Bill Evans or Vince Guaraldi might do. Lovely!) Wayne, too has manifests some pretty awesome ideas here. One of the few songs on which it is the soloists/melody- makers that impress me the most! This might actually be my favorite song on the album! (19.25/20)

B3. "Mood" (8:49) once again we've got a set up in which Tony is keeping time while Ron and Herbie play off of one another to help create a kind of see-saw rhythm track. Then Miles, playing another muted trumpet, and Wayne, here playing a breathy (slightly muted?) sax, play off each other in a way that is similar to Ron and Herbie. In both duo's cases one of the members is being more steady (Ron and Wayne) while the other is spicing things up a bit (Herbie and Miles). But then, in the fourth minute, Wayne is given the spotlight while Miles sits back and watch/listens. Nice solo here, Wayne! For the sixth minute, Herbie gets the next solo. Again, I am so impressed by his discipline and presence: the way he takes time to let the next chord or phrase emerge out of him without ever seeming to press or rush. Amazing! Miles and Wayne return to their original binary star dance for the final minute. Interesting, lovely, though a bit soporific. (17.875/20)

Total Time: 48:23

I am rather surprised at the way the music on this album somehow manages to keep the band's usually-hyperactive drummer in a rather sedate state. The dynamic rock inputs of the previous album are totally absent. (Perhaps Tony is spent or distracted from the energy he is putting into his solo projects at the time. Or perhaps Miles put some heroin into Tony's chamomile tea.)

A/five stars; a masterpiece of jazz music that I hold up as one of the finest demonstrations of boundary-pushing jazz I've ever heard. Though there is little to no influence of rock music here, the mentality of mathematical experimentation with structure that is supremely present here is something that I find very essential to the "progressive" part of both high arts of Progressive Rock and Jazz-Rock Fusion. HIGHLY recommended--even essential to any music lover's album collection.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Adam & Eve by FLOWER KINGS, THE album cover Studio Album, 2004
3.49 | 578 ratings

BUY
Adam & Eve
The Flower Kings Symphonic Prog

Review by A Crimson Mellotron
Prog Reviewer

4 stars 'Adam & Eve' is still to this day one of the most entertaining albums by The Flower Kings, this is the Swedes' 2004 studio release and is one of the rare occasions of a 2000s single album, featuring ten new tracks, both traditional prog epics as well as short snippets of music connecting the major pieces. This also happens to be the second album with Pain of Salvation's Daniel Gildenlöw, who shares vocal duties with Stolt and Fröberg, as he had done on 'Unfold the Future'. His addition is a rather interesting one as well as surprising, knowing how "busy" the vocal department within TFK already was, but his strong and roaring wails add a tone of aggression and edge to the otherwise lush symphonic sounds explore by the band.

Not necessarily a concept album, 'Adam & Eve' deals extensively with the themes of religion, love and sexuality, all while remotely touching upon some Biblical topics as well. Music-wise the listener will experience the usual blend of symphonic and experimental rock with a strong retro feel that The Flower Kings mastered on their early releases, although this particular album has some unusual entries. The sound of 'Adam & Eve' is dense and complex, of course, but there is a general feel of harmony and textural richness that elevates the album, whose structure is quite interesting as well - enframed by the two exquisite epic pieces 'Love Supreme' and 'Drivers Seat', very strong offerings filled with great melodies, virtuosic playing and excellent vocals. In-between them, one shall discover the quirky 'A Vampire's View', with lead vocals by Gildenlöw, this song is not your typical TFK mini-opus, but it still contains some intriguing bits, the uplifting title track, another well-written song, and the crammed and chaotic 'Timelines', co-written by bassist Jonas Reingold. The transitional shorter tracks are no less enthusiastic in their soundscapes, while the album ultimately remains a very consistent and creatively-acute work that presents a familiar but slightly unusual side of the band.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Dominion by IQ album cover Studio Album, 2025
4.15 | 172 ratings

BUY
Dominion
IQ Neo-Prog

Review by James007

5 stars I was a bit late to the party on this one. I started listening to IQ when I picked up their 1993 album "Ever". I was struck by their very Genesis-like (Prog years) sound: including vocalist Peter Nicholls sounding almost like Peter Gabriel. That album was great so I immediately ordered their first 4 albums (the earliest released a decade earlier). Those albums were good but not on the level of "Ever" mainly because they were uneven. There were a lot of great tracks, but also some lesser ones. Since then, they have released 7 more albums through 2019. All were excellent from first to last, including 2014's "The Road of Bones"; rated by many as the best prog album of that year (although Opeth and Transatlantic fans would disagree). Covid hit and there was a gap before their next release, this year's "Dominion". These guys have been around for 40-something years now and you'd think they'd show their age, but that's not the case. Nicholls' voice is as great as ever. The rest of the band, very talented musicians, work as a cohesive unit (very Genesis-like) and I think this album may be their best. The main theme is taken from Dylan Thomas' poem "And Death Shall Have No Dominion". And each song addresses this theme from a different viewpoint. Perhaps it's because the band members are getting older and reflecting on their own mortality or somesuch? whatever, the album really works. This one is released on the heels of last year's 4 disc live set "The IQ Weekender" which is very well done. The new album starts out with the 23 minute "The Unknown Door" with its horn intro reminiscent of Aaron Copeland's "Fanfare for the Common Man" and invokes images of WWII and the bravery and tragedy therein. My favorite song (probably my favorite IQ song) is the last song on the record, "Never Land", dealing with someone who has lost the love of their life. It starts with a gorgeous intro with Nicholls voice carrying the wonderfully spacious melody and it builds and builds until all the stops are pulled as the album comes to an end. I highly recommend this album for Prog- era Genesis fans. "Dominion" and "The Road of Bones" are on equal footing in my mind, and I didn't think that was possible when "Bones" was released.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Queen II by QUEEN album cover Studio Album, 1974
4.35 | 986 ratings

BUY
Queen II
Queen Prog Related

Review by sgtpepper

3 stars Queen II has a legendary respect-awaking album cover. Interestingly, Queen II has songwriting split into the May's first side and Mercury's second. Since 1973, the band evolved in terms of sophistication, ambitions and songwriting. They slowly start going beyond conventional rock and explore other territories like folk, classical music, glam rock and prog. The start is on an elegant note with May's guitar layers. After that you would expect a hard-rock number by May but what comes is a soft-rock beginning with vocal harmonies which at 2:30 evolves into a hard-rock wilderness thanks to busy drumming and raw riffing. "White Queen" is a magnificent ballad with some mellow (acoustic and/or jazz guitar sounding) and loud instrumentation. Would be interesting to hear the author (May) sing it as it seems to be personal. Then comes a folk-rock tune which is a bit monotonous but suits May's vocal well. Taylor has an improved contribution (over their previous album) with a really memorable drum intro, modestly interesting melody and decent singing. Though it's a slow track, guitar riffing and decoration keeps it in the realm of hard rock. The first Mercury penned "Ogre Battle" has plenty of great riffing and a particularly well done instrumental intro with waves of guitar attacks. One of the heaviest tracks in the band's catalogue.

The first really eclectic almost ingenious track is a short "The Fairy Fellers Master-Stroke" with incredibly rich vocals, songwriting surprises and a masterful melody reminding me of classical music and it could have been connected to the following "Nevermore".

The flagship on this album is depicted in the "March of the black queen". It used to be my favourite album track but in the course of years I think it is not as creative as some other tracks here because it merely combines typical Queen licks like melodic guitar soloing, bombastic moments and crescendos. Either you've heard them before or you'll hear them on following Queen albums recycled (Bohemian Rhapsody, Killer Queen etc.). Despite that, it can be considered the first Queen mini-opera.

The last tracks are of average quality but won't bite you.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Queen by QUEEN album cover Studio Album, 1973
3.66 | 661 ratings

BUY
Queen
Queen Prog Related

Review by sgtpepper

2 stars The debut Queen album is their most straightforward and least eclectic work dominated by hard rock. Mercury could sing with great intensity and had a high vocal range. May uses mainly riffs and fewer soloing than later in the career. Naturally, because as music was becoming more mellow, there wasn't much space for heavy riffing. All May guitar ingredients are already here though including melodic playing, guitar harmonies and a distinguishable sound. After the first hard work workout, we face a ballad which turns into an intensive Zeppelin-like riffing like a short storm before the clouds disappear.

"Great king rat" has a march-like rhythm, quite a basic fundamental melody. The track is quite long and dominated by the guitar which plays quite refreshing licks. Mercury shows off his compositional skills, ornate singing and piano support on"My fairy king" which hints at their majestic mid 70's period. Taylor has provided his highly-pitched vocal well suitable for heavy metal however it's with "Liar" where his drumming becomes remarkable, I like his hi-hat work and sound here. Besides, he applies quite various beats throughout this lengthy song greatly supported by raw sounding May's guitar. "The night comes down" is a curious subdued guitar starting track which first sounds like an instrumental jam. The track is superbly constructed, one of its motives could classify it as the first potential Queen anthem.

Taylor unleashes his power on his penned "Modern times rock'n'roll" that could compete with any heavy metal output back then in terms of intensity. His vocal is distinguishable and yet emotional. Considering its lack of good melody, it still remains arguably the least memorable track here. The generic "Son and daughter" fares slightly better. I like guitar effects and vocal harmonies better than the generic riff motive.

"Jesus" is noteworthy for its lyrics, walking bridge and guitar madness in the second half of the song.

Overall this is a great rocking debut with a potential for more diversity and very little to be found for proggers.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Journey To The Vast Unknown by PYTHAGORAS album cover Studio Album, 1980
3.44 | 27 ratings

BUY
Journey To The Vast Unknown
Pythagoras Symphonic Prog

Review by Mellotron Storm
Prog Reviewer

4 stars I feel like I'm one of the few who is actually really into this album. Of course the Bio for this duo reveals a different story. And it's such a cool story where keyboardist Rene De Haan in his late teens and a regular visitor to Moonlight Records in The Hague, meets the owner Bob De Jong, and the rest is history. Rene, still living with his parents has a room full of keyboard equipment and is composing music. He has dreams, and Bob, a drummer who also knows his way around a studio, buys into Rene's dreams.

They would record this album in the second half of 1980 and release it in 1981. Bob of course has connections and ideas. He sends copies to many Djs who in turn after playing a tune would give the postal address for Moonlight Records for those interested in buying a copy. Soon Bob was getting hundreds of requests. Would you believe this sold over 5,000 copies! Well, if you heard this 42 minute album you might be surprised. I could see if this was 1971 but not 1981.

It's uniform sounding with Rene dominating. Lots of synths here and some sequencers. Piano as well, and some mellotron on the closer. Bob's drumming is rather sedate, but that's the sound they were looking for. Not a lot of breakouts, and it's melancholic. No vocals. There is some moving sections and variety within the style. What style? Well, electronic would be my choice for this album. Symphonic for their second release I understand, as I don't own it. Considering the duo call it a Symphonic poem, I guess answers that.

They released that second record in 1982 and that would be the end of their moment in the sun. They actually have a very young Arjen Luccasen playing guitar and bass pedals on that one, along with guest violin, flute and bass. Plus synths from a PLACKBAND member. Oh, and they thank PLACKBAND in the liner notes on the debut here as well. This album opens with the side long suite called "Journey To The Vast Unknown" which is divided into four parts. And the second side features two long tracks, just under 10 minutes each. I am a sucker for albums that take you places. I have that psychedelic mindset. This is a trip, or journey to the vast unknown indeed. And those two closing tracks are my favourites.

Easily 4 stars in my little cosmic music universe.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
 Old New Borrowed Blue by FAIRPORT CONVENTION album cover Studio Album, 1996
3.38 | 12 ratings

BUY
Old New Borrowed Blue
Fairport Convention Prog Related

Review by SteveG

4 stars Old. New. Borrowed. Blue. Is the follow up album to the stupendous Jewel In The Crown released just one year earlier. On again off again drummer Dave Mattacks stepped out to do session work so the remaining lads, Simon Nicol, Dave Pegg, Maartin Allcock and Ric Sanders, decided to record an album and tour as quartet without him. In many ways, this album is complementary to Jewel In The Crown as features more exceptional songs written by the writers who supplied the "Jewel" album with its best gems. Standout studio tracks are "Lalla Rookh", "Frozen Man" (written by James Taylor), "There Once Was Love/Innsbruck " and the fun instrumental "Woodworm Swing".

The album does an about face and features live performances of the next 7 songs, which is a treat as the acoustic Fairport was always more impressive live and the following songs are all the better for it. Excellently recorded and mixed, the standout songs are old throwbacks "Crazy Man Michael", "The Widow of Westmoreland's Daughter", another nod back to the early days with a great version of "Genesis Hall" (The Richard Thompson penned classic), and a wonderful version of Ralph McTell's "The Hiring Fair".

It would be another ten years before the band would produce albums as good as Jewel In The Crown and Old. New. Borrowed. Blue., but at least Fairport Convention left us two exceptional albums to hold us until then.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password
Reviews list is cached

Latest Prog News, Shows and Tours


Prog News & Press Releases (10) | More ...
Prog Gigs, Tours and Festivals (10) | More ...

Latest 3 Progressive Rock Videos


All videos
MOST POPULAR ALBUM (last 24h)
BUY PA T-SHIRTS & MORE
Arjen Lucassen (AYREON's mastermind) wearing the classic long sleeves PA t-shirt
Arjen Lucassen (AYREON's mastermind) wearing the classic long sleeves PA t-shirt.
To buy Progarchives.com custom items: t-shirts, beer steins, coffee mugs, mouse pads, bumper stickers, go to http://www.zazzle.com/progarchives, select the ones you like and checkout (PayPal support). All orders are handled by Zazzle from invoicing, printing to shipping.

Thanks in advance for supporting us and for spreading the purple prog !
FORUM NEW TOPICS

Prog Lounge

Prog Polls

Prog Interviews

TOP PROG ALBUMS
  1. Close to the Edge
    Yes
  2. Selling England by the Pound
    Genesis
  3. In the Court of the Crimson King
    King Crimson
  4. Wish You Were Here
    Pink Floyd
  5. Thick as a Brick
    Jethro Tull
  6. The Dark Side of the Moon
    Pink Floyd
  7. Foxtrot
    Genesis
  8. Red
    King Crimson
  9. Animals
    Pink Floyd
  10. Fragile
    Yes
  11. Godbluff
    Van Der Graaf Generator
  12. Pawn Hearts
    Van Der Graaf Generator
  13. Larks' Tongues in Aspic
    King Crimson
  14. Nursery Cryme
    Genesis
  15. Mirage
    Camel
  16. Moonmadness
    Camel
  17. Hemispheres
    Rush
  18. Per Un Amico
    Premiata Forneria Marconi (PFM)
  19. Moving Pictures
    Rush
  20. Relayer
    Yes
  21. Darwin!
    Banco Del Mutuo Soccorso
  22. Aqualung
    Jethro Tull
  23. Io Sono Nato Libero
    Banco Del Mutuo Soccorso
  24. Hot Rats
    Frank Zappa
  25. Kind of Blue
    Miles Davis
  26. In a Glass House
    Gentle Giant
  27. Si on avait besoin d'une cinquičme saison
    Harmonium
  28. A Farewell to Kings
    Rush
  29. Hybris
    Änglagård
  30. From Silence to Somewhere
    Wobbler
  31. Storia Di Un Minuto
    Premiata Forneria Marconi (PFM)
  32. The Yes Album
    Yes
  33. The Raven That Refused to Sing (and Other Stories)
    Steven Wilson
  34. Scheherazade and Other Stories
    Renaissance
  35. Metropolis Part 2 - Scenes from a Memory
    Dream Theater
  36. Octopus
    Gentle Giant
  37. H To He, Who Am The Only One
    Van Der Graaf Generator
  38. The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
    Genesis
  39. In the Land of Grey and Pink
    Caravan
  40. Crime of the Century
    Supertramp
  41. Images and Words
    Dream Theater
  42. The Power and the Glory
    Gentle Giant
  43. Birds of Fire
    Mahavishnu Orchestra
  44. The Snow Goose
    Camel
  45. Zarathustra
    Museo Rosenbach
  46. The Grand Wazoo
    Frank Zappa
  47. Meddle
    Pink Floyd
  48. Banco Del Mutuo Soccorso
    Banco Del Mutuo Soccorso
  49. The Mothers of Invention: One Size Fits All
    Frank Zappa
  50. Still Life
    Van Der Graaf Generator
  51. Free Hand
    Gentle Giant
  52. Still Life
    Opeth
  53. Hand. Cannot. Erase.
    Steven Wilson
  54. Fear of a Blank Planet
    Porcupine Tree
  55. Mekanīk Destruktīw Kommandöh
    Magma
  56. Permanent Waves
    Rush
  57. Blackwater Park
    Opeth
  58. A Trick of the Tail
    Genesis
  59. Ommadawn
    Mike Oldfield
  60. The Silent Corner And The Empty Stage
    Peter Hammill
  61. Acquiring the Taste
    Gentle Giant
  62. The Inner Mounting Flame
    Mahavishnu Orchestra
  63. Depois do Fim
    Bacamarte
  64. Ghost Reveries
    Opeth
  65. Misplaced Childhood
    Marillion
  66. Romantic Warrior
    Return To Forever
  67. Häxan
    Art Zoyd
  68. Space Shanty
    Khan
  69. In Absentia
    Porcupine Tree
  70. Szobel
    Hermann Szobel
  71. Dwellers of the Deep
    Wobbler
  72. In A Silent Way
    Miles Davis
  73. Ashes Are Burning
    Renaissance
  74. A Drop of Light
    All Traps On Earth
  75. Radio Gnome Invisible Vol. 3 - You
    Gong
  76. Script for a Jester's Tear
    Marillion
  77. Symbolic
    Death
  78. Bitches Brew
    Miles Davis
  79. Second Life Syndrome
    Riverside
  80. Arbeit Macht Frei
    Area
  81. The Road of Bones
    IQ
  82. 4 visions
    Eskaton
  83. Viljans Öga
    Änglagård
  84. Voyage of the Acolyte
    Steve Hackett
  85. Of Queues and Cures
    National Health
  86. Spectrum
    Billy Cobham
  87. Enigmatic Ocean
    Jean-Luc Ponty
  88. If I Could Do It All Over Again, I'd Do It All Over You
    Caravan
  89. Elegant Gypsy
    Al Di Meola
  90. Emerson Lake & Palmer
    Emerson Lake & Palmer
  91. Rock Bottom
    Robert Wyatt
  92. Hamburger Concerto
    Focus
  93. English Electric (Part One)
    Big Big Train
  94. K.A (Köhntarkösz Anteria)
    Magma
  95. Svitanie
    Blue Effect (Modrũ Efekt)
  96. Remedy Lane
    Pain Of Salvation
  97. Felona E Sorona
    Le Orme
  98. Hatfield and the North
    Hatfield And The North
  99. Operation: Mindcrime
    Queensr˙che
  100. Leftoverture
    Kansas

* Weighted Ratings (aka WR), used for ordering, is cached and re-calculated every 15 minutes.

More PA TOP LISTS
100 MOST PROLIFIC REVIEWERS

Collaborators Only

ratings only excluded in count
  1. Mellotron Storm (5421)
  2. Warthur (3528)
  3. Sean Trane (3161)
  4. ZowieZiggy (2931)
  5. siLLy puPPy (2917)
  6. apps79 (2629)
  7. kev rowland (2471)
  8. UMUR (2462)
  9. BrufordFreak (2450)
  10. b_olariu (2060)
  11. Easy Livin (1932)
  12. Gatot (1811)
  13. Windhawk (1700)
  14. Conor Fynes (1613)
  15. SouthSideoftheSky (1598)
  16. Matti (1541)
  17. kenethlevine (1518)
  18. Tarcisio Moura (1455)
  19. Evolver (1425)
  20. TCat (1407)
  21. AtomicCrimsonRush (1378)
  22. Bonnek (1334)
  23. tszirmay (1241)
  24. snobb (1237)
  25. Finnforest (1218)
  26. erik neuteboom (1201)
  27. Rivertree (1069)
  28. octopus-4 (1054)
  29. ClemofNazareth (1011)
  30. memowakeman (1003)
  31. Cesar Inca (928)
  32. loserboy (897)
  33. VianaProghead (894)
  34. Rune2000 (882)
  35. Marty McFly (841)
  36. Guillermo (794)
  37. DamoXt7942 (777)
  38. Neu!mann (759)
  39. Chris S (753)
  40. Eetu Pellonpaa (725)
  41. Aussie-Byrd-Brother (719)
  42. greenback (685)
  43. Seyo (678)
  44. progrules (666)
  45. admireArt (648)
  46. Prog-jester (624)
  47. Epignosis (624)
  48. friso (624)
  49. andrea (617)
  50. lor68 (601)
  51. Prog Leviathan (582)
  52. Ivan_Melgar_M (560)
  53. philippe (540)
  54. hdfisch (492)
  55. The Crow (490)
  56. stefro (486)
  57. Chicapah (486)
  58. Menswear (476)
  59. Dobermensch (464)
  60. zravkapt (460)
  61. colorofmoney91 (459)
  62. J-Man (449)
  63. ProgShine (445)
  64. russellk (440)
  65. Atavachron (429)
  66. A Crimson Mellotron (406)
  67. Sinusoid (403)
  68. Queen By-Tor (396)
  69. Progfan97402 (388)
  70. fuxi (380)
  71. rdtprog (370)
  72. tarkus1980 (369)
  73. Nightfly (365)
  74. Zitro (365)
  75. Greger (365)
  76. Modrigue (360)
  77. Cygnus X-2 (353)
  78. lazland (352)
  79. Andrea Cortese (348)
  80. Negoba (336)
  81. richardh (334)
  82. EatThatPhonebook (326)
  83. Hector Enrique (323)
  84. Guldbamsen (322)
  85. FragileKings (321)
  86. Tom Ozric (306)
  87. patrickq (302)
  88. Flucktrot (301)
  89. Kazuhiro (299)
  90. DangHeck (297)
  91. progaardvark (290)
  92. GruvanDahlman (290)
  93. Dapper~Blueberries (288)
  94. Proghead (288)
  95. OpethGuitarist (287)
  96. Second Life Syndrome (283)
  97. daveconn (266)
  98. Trotsky (264)
  99. Muzikman (263)
  100. Slartibartfast (261)

List of all PA collaborators

NEW RELEASES

Cheaper Than Cheep by Zappa, Frank album rcover
Cheaper Than Cheep

Frank Zappa

Bridges by Somewhere album rcover
Bridges

Somewhere

Nightfall by Baumann, Peter album rcover
Nightfall

Peter Baumann

Live At Club Goodman by Koenji Hyakkei album rcover
Live At Club Goodman

Koenji Hyakkei

Night Lamp (with Tungu) by Kaiser, Henry album rcover
Night Lamp (with Tungu)

Henry Kaiser

INTERACTIVE

RSS feeds

+ more syndication options

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.