Nodding God for Progressive Electronic

Bump. Hope I'm adhering to the new submission guidelines correctly.

Also I see they were added to Progfreak a couple years ago (and their sole album was labelled "Avant-Garde Prog Rock").

His albums have been reviewed by multiple prog websites that consider his music prog, and the House of Mythology label that’s released much of it is generally thought of as a prog record label.

Sometime you just have to accept that some bands and artists are thought of and accepted as prog outside this website, but not by his website.

Remember, what is or is not prog is always subjective, and PA tends to have a more narrow scope, or I guess it would be overwhelmed and overwhelming.

If it makes you feel better, I definitely consider Nodding God to be prog. 👍🏻

[EDIT] I had a look to see, and it would appear that Current 93 is in PA under prog folk( http://www.progarchives.com/artist.asp?id=7041 ); and the Current 93/Zu collaboration is included in PA as a Zu album ( http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=57788 ). Perhaps, Nodding God could be put forward for Progressive Electronic, and if it doesn’t meet the bill, come under Prog Related? If I understand correctly, for a band to be considered for Prog Related, it needs to be considered by a genre team first. I think it is prog, rather than prog related, but something is better than nothing...

@nick_h_nz: I appreciate your support. I'm trying to understand the dialectic of something being objectively "prog" but not prog enough for PA's standards. I would like to think my suggestions are not unreasonable. I believe Nurse With Wound belong here, for instance, and see no reason why their inclusion would open any floodgates or render PA illegitimate (the uniqueness of the project notwithstanding, they have direct material links to krautrock, are primarily inspired by progressive rock artists and sound like a synthesis of all their influences, making them progressive in the literal sense, too). There have been some fascinating and decidedly left-field projects that have been admitted over the past ten years, with the most outré being Crawl Unit, Allegory Chapel Ltd. and Aube, though I understand the latter's inclusion more than the former two. My understanding and appreciation for what is PE expanded with the inclusion of acts such as Zoviet France, Coil and Rapoon, all of whom have surreal, occult takes on Zeit- and Irrlicht-style dark ambient which I love. Keeping these expanded - but not yet unreasonable - parameters in mind, I thought Nodding God would be a safe suggestion, perhaps even a shoo-in, so I've still been surprised that it received such a tepid response.

Despite the discussion of the subjective nature of what is "prog," particularly prog electronic, I won't care what the outcome is, I simply hope the project can be given a proper judgement on Progfreak. From my limited understanding, I think a band has to be a special circumstance as well as influential to be designated Prog-Related, and Nodding God are too young to qualify (despite the credentials of Tibet and Liles).

@rushfan4: Thanks for clarifying. Haven't read that mag in years but I remember they'd uncover some really delightful gems. Wish I could've seen their review of this material.