Kharmina Buranna (anticipating this Peruvian band)

I'm Peruvian, Khatmina Bhurana is Peruvian (Just say this to make a point, nobody wqnts them in PA more than me).

Cesar Inca wrote: SYMPHONIC PROG would be much more appropriate than HEAVY PROG for KHARMINA BURANNA.   I don't understand why the eclectic prog team should be reluctant about them, but the second best option is Symphonic Prog, no doubt about it.

reluctant is not the right word for Cesar... I haven't seen Greg's (logan's thoughts)

but if you'll allow me a second...let me elaborate on Eclectic and how it is applied  here.

eclectic is not merely the abundance of visible and distinct influences.   but simply Cesar... it is the the place where bands who lack a DISTINCT or predominant influence go.  You know as well as us.. that many... MANY of these groups were by their nature eclectic.  All taking many influences and putting them in the pot.  Those who could be identified by a defining characteristic... Yes being being a prime example... go to subs where we can identify prime influences.  I think so far.. we are seeing symphonic as the prime influence there.. it is what I hear.. and seems to be what Moris does.  It that all .. .is it 'pure' symphonic.. no.. it isn't.  Whether symho will take it.. .that is up to them... if they don't take them... we will find a place for them.  Heavy or eclectic.  They'll be added for sure though.

exactly... 

I'm on board with Moris  here...  think the symphos should have first crack at this one. Great stuff 

This is essential symphonic rock band to the very bone.

And one hell of a band at that...        

Music is in that box under Interests, for those with adblock who don't find it immediately.  My computer is having major siezure problems.  I wish such pages would simply the layout with less graphics and stuff (too media rich, and looks bad).

Late, but listening now (might have missed mention of this is the Eclectic Team thread by either of you). I guess we should wait until the album is out, but if you want them for heavy, and think they are appropriate enough, I'd say go ahead, we can always move them easily later.  Seems obviously fit for the archives.

I'm not sure at this time if Eclectic is best... Sometimes I catch that eclectic mix of prog styles with no one style dominating sufficiently so to scream ECLECTIC almost immediately without even having to think about it much.  Other times I can quickly say, hell no (and think of another category), then other times my concentration tends to waver and I have to try to listen many times while trying my best to analyze the music.  This falls more into the latter one (and because I'm tired too)..

no, but I've got Ubieda's God's Garden which I love

understood  

..neat little band, Cesar







Edited by Atavachron - April 06 2008 at 16:16

that footage doesn't do them justice, but if Eclectic Team pass, I 'll consider them for Heavy