Flower Kings Appreciation Thread

Originally posted by Horizons The vocals are terrible, even when they're compared to The Tangent. Plus the whole atmosphere just puts me off, and slightly cringe.

For which album? Unfold the Future has Daniel Gildenlow on vocals for a few songs (on disc 2), you don't like his vocals? There's also a lot of jazz improv on that album.

That's funny because I think Hasse Froberg's vocals are superior to Andy Tillison's. I understand Roine's vocals can be an acquired taste, but Hasse is featured prominently on UtF.

When it comes to the vocals (for most bands anyway), I let the music do the talking, and I sort out my problems with the vocals later (unless they're really friggin bad, which I don't believe TFK's vocals are).

Originally posted by Horizons Originally posted by darkshade Originally posted by Horizons The vocals are terrible, even when they're compared to The Tangent. Plus the whole atmosphere just puts me off, and slightly cringe.  For which album? Unfold the Future has Daniel Gildenlow on vocals for a few songs (on disc 2), you don't like his vocals? There's also a lot of jazz improv on that album. That's funny because I think Hasse Froberg's vocals are superior to Andy Tillison's. I understand Roine's vocals can be an acquired taste, but Hasse is featured prominently on UtF. When it comes to the vocals (for most bands anyway), I let the music do the talking, and I sort out my problems with the vocals later (unless they're really friggin bad, which I don't believe TFK's vocals are). I'm not sure which vocalist i disliked, i didn't try to differentiate. I'm not sure, i'll take your advice and try the 2 albums again later on up the road.

Sounds good. It took me almost 5 years to get into TFK, but that's because every time I gave them a shot, I listened to a different album each time, thinking I may have heard the wrong one or something. When I finally decided to try an album I had already heard before, that's when I started to get into them. I also went into their material looking for the jazziest prog I could find, which is not a good idea as their sound is too eclectic for that; you have to just go in with an open mind, in my opinion.

Originally posted by dtguitarfan Originally posted by Horizons The vocals are terrible, even when they're compared to The Tangent. Plus the whole atmosphere just puts me off, and slightly cringe.  I find this humorous because I got into TFK before trying The Tangent, and I thought The Tangent's vocals were awful. Is it just me or are the vocals on their live album very pitchy?

While I like Andy Tillison's vocals, they can't hold a candle to any of the Flower Kings vocalists.......though he and Stolt are similar in a lot of ways, vocally.

For me, Tillison's vocals actually took quite a while to get into, and it was only the Peter Hammill similarities that drew me in.  He also reminds me of John Lennon, believe it or not.  As far as pitch, yeah, he tends to be flat quite a bit, especially live.  However, Roine does the same thing. In the end though, I really enjoy both of their vocals, because they both put emotion and conviction behind every word they sing.  I've mentioned before that Froberg can get on my nerves sometimes, which is something that has developed for me since sometime after Unfold was released.  To my ears, he can be a bit shrill at times.  However, when both he and Roine sing together, I think it works great.  I loved when Gildenlow was in the band, and wouldn't have been disappointed if he had replaced Froberg (though really, I don't think that would have worked in the long run, as it would have changed the dynamic too much........Gildenlow worked best in the guest capacity).

I liked Roine's vocals the first time I heard them (Rhythm of the Sea, from Retropolis), as they reminded me a lot of John Wetton.  He has a lot of character in his voice, and as I mentioned above, a lot of feeling and conviction.  I can, however, totally understand why someone might not enjoy them.


Edited by infandous - June 06 2012 at 13:12

Originally posted by Roland113 Originally posted by Horizons The vocals are terrible, even when they're compared to The Tangent. Plus the whole atmosphere just puts me off, and slightly cringe.  I know someone before shared a similar thought but The Tangent's vocals are the reason that I only own two of their albums and avoided them like the plague ever since.  'A Crisis in Midlife' is such a fantastic song . . . until the flat and somewhat off key vocals come in.   I strongly prefer the tandem from The Flower Kings.   I know you're not exactly giving The Tangent high props for their vocals but The Flower Kings at least stay in key.  :) (on a side note, I'm considering getting COMM and giving The Tangent another shot.  I like the instrumentation on the two that I have and COMM seems to be almost universally enjoyed by people on here that I share similar musical tastes with)

The best one is A Place in the Queue, as far as symphonic prog goes.  Easily my favorite, though COMM is a close second.  Probably the vocals are a bit better on COMM though.  But musically, I suspect Queue is more up your alley.  Either one though is a good choice.

Originally posted by infandous Originally posted by zumacraig Originally posted by darkshade My copy of Tomas Bodin - "Sonic Boulevard" came in today. Can't wait to hear it!!! where did you get it?  i'm trying to fill in some gaps in my TFK family collection and am finding some stuff is out of print and way overpriced used.  i've found some stuff, but bodin's albums are proving difficult. My only suggestion is Greg Walker, especially if you are in the US.  <span =""="">synphonic.8m.comHe often has stuff that is no longer available on the usual sites like Amazon or cduniverse.  His prices are reasonable, you get it in a couple days (I've had them in my mailbox the very next day sometimes......and he's 2/3 of the way across the country from me), and he's a very nice guy who's very knowledgeable about prog (he organized the first US prog festival ever, out in California......the Flower Kings performed at one of his festivals in 1997, and I have it on VHS tape somewhere...I think a lot of it is on youtube)</span>

Infaddous thank you!!!   That site is a gold mine. Oh man I'm gonna be broke. Glad to hear he's a cool dude. Much rather give him my money than some bozo on eBay asking ridiculous prices. Thanks again.

Edited by zumacraig - June 06 2012 at 20:09

Originally posted by zumacraig Originally posted by infandous Originally posted by zumacraig Originally posted by darkshade My copy of Tomas Bodin - "Sonic Boulevard" came in today. Can't wait to hear it!!! where did you get it?  i'm trying to fill in some gaps in my TFK family collection and am finding some stuff is out of print and way overpriced used.  i've found some stuff, but bodin's albums are proving difficult. My only suggestion is Greg Walker, especially if you are in the US.  <span =""="">synphonic.8m.comHe often has stuff that is no longer available on the usual sites like Amazon or cduniverse.  His prices are reasonable, you get it in a couple days (I've had them in my mailbox the very next day sometimes......and he's 2/3 of the way across the country from me), and he's a very nice guy who's very knowledgeable about prog (he organized the first US prog festival ever, out in California......the Flower Kings performed at one of his festivals in 1997, and I have it on VHS tape somewhere...I think a lot of it is on youtube)</span> Infaddous thank you!!!   That site is a gold mine. Oh man I'm gonna be broke. Glad to hear he's a cool dude. Much rather give him my money than some bozo on eBay asking ridiculous prices. Thanks again.

No problem.  Just email him.....he'll even give you suggestions based on what you like if you ask him.  Very knowledgeable guy for prog.

I've been recommending him ever since I first ordered from him................and my first order from him was my first two Flower Kings albums, Retropolis and Stardust We Are (which were only available as imports back then, since they were only on Roine's personal label).  There was no Paypal back then, so I had to send him a check.........even though he didn't know me and I'd never ordered from him before, the CD's were in my mailbox before he even got my check!




Edited by infandous - June 07 2012 at 07:53

Originally posted by darkshade I just realized who Don Azzaro is.

I remember back in 1999 thinking it was odd that someone with such an Italian sounding name was producing a Swedish band.  Then I found out from an interview that it was Stolt himself.  Hippyfied Art (listed as the booklet designer for most FK albums before Rainmaker) is also Roine.  Dexter Frank, Jr., listed as "Engineer", is also Roine.
Apparently he used all these pseudonyms because he felt it seemed a bit conceited to have his real name listed for al this work.



Edited by infandous - June 07 2012 at 12:18

Today i've been emailing with my new best buddy...Tomas Bodin!!!

Originally posted by Master of Time Originally posted by Horizons Some of Space Revolver and  Unfold the Future.  Originally posted by Horizons The vocals are terrible, even when they're compared to The Tangent. Plus the whole atmosphere just puts me off, and slightly cringe.  I'm not a big fan of those albums either, but I love The Sum of No Evil, perhaps you may like it as well. The vocals on that album almost reminded me of Bruce Springsteen in parts. I also agree that the others have a strange atmosphere but TSONE's I thought didn't put me off as much and I grew to love it. I've never been able to gget into The Tangent however (though I've never really tried that hard) so I can't comment on that, but try The Sum of No Evil as well, maybe you'll like it.

Originally posted by darkshade Originally posted by M27Barney Originally posted by Master of Time Originally posted by Horizons Some of Space Revolver and  Unfold the Future.  Originally posted by Horizons The vocals are terrible, even when they're compared to The Tangent. Plus the whole atmosphere just puts me off, and slightly cringe.  I'm not a big fan of those albums either, but I love The Sum of No Evil, perhaps you may like it as well. The vocals on that album almost reminded me of Bruce Springsteen in parts. I also agree that the others have a strange atmosphere but TSONE's I thought didn't put me off as much and I grew to love it. I've never been able to gget into The Tangent however (though I've never really tried that hard) so I can't comment on that, but try The Sum of No Evil as well, maybe you'll like it. I have 1 CD by "The Tangent" ITWTWDT - and it didn't impress me on one spin - so It's one of the many that I may go back to but when I get home from a hard day sorting out Audi's reporting suite etc - I usually want to play something I know will give me a buzz - thus it's hard to give a CD that didn't impress a lot on spin 1 to give it a second go...Who's with me on this ??? If it's any consolation, that Tangent album may be the least best or 2nd least best album by them. I say "least best" because I think all The Tangent albums are good.