Providence - GYBE vs Sonic Youth

Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic

has anyone noticed that these are similar tracks?

a) 

Band: Godspeed You Black Emperor
Where: F#A# 00 track 3
Length: 29:02
Description: a helicopter blade swirling sound opens the track. A man talks about a preacher who predicts the end of the world and the falling state of america. The rest is an epic journey...

b)

Band: Sonic Youth
Where: Daydream Nation track 8
Length: 2:41
Description: sounds of helicopter blades and a soft piano melody play, interrupted by a voice on a loudspeaker (much like the end of storm by GYBE)

Conclusion:

very similar pieces of music. The lengths are nothing near each other but the titles, feel of the tracks and use of helicopter blades are similar. Perhaps GYBE were inspirted by SY

Thoughts?

Author	Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic
frenchie Members Profile Send Private Message Find Members Posts Add to Buddy List Reviewer page Prog Reviewer Joined: July 30 2004 Location: United Kingdom Status: Offline Points: 2234	Topic: Providence - GYBE vs Sonic Youth Posted: June 06 2005 at 15:43
	has anyone noticed that these are similar tracks? a) Band: Godspeed You Black Emperor Where: F#A# 00 track 3 Length: 29:02 Description: a helicopter blade swirling sound opens the track. A man talks about a preacher who predicts the end of the world and the falling state of america. The rest is an epic journey... b) Band: Sonic Youth Where: Daydream Nation track 8 Length: 2:41 Description: sounds of helicopter blades and a soft piano melody play, interrupted by a voice on a loudspeaker (much like the end of storm by GYBE) Conclusion: very similar pieces of music. The lengths are nothing near each other but the titles, feel of the tracks and use of helicopter blades are similar. Perhaps GYBE were inspirted by SY Thoughts?
	The Worthless Recluse