Just bought The Who 3 DVD including Tommy, Quadrophenia and Live at Universal Anphitheatre, simply amazing.

A must have.

With guests as Elton John, Steve Winwood, Billy Idol (The perfect Cousin Kevin) Patti La Bell and Phil Collins (Who does a good version of Uncle Earnie,good but a bit over played, Keith Moon was amazing in the movie).

Iván

I've had this dvd since before Christmas, and it is a superb dvd that all fans of the band should own.

Which one do you prefer Ivan, Tommy or Quadrophenia?

Have it since 8:00 PM and haven't seen Quadrophenia yet (My sister is sleeping here because she's painting her apartment and my  nephew  used my room to see Barney ). Probably will sleep a couple of hours because from here to see the DVD  or I'll take it to my office, no job expected being Holy Weekend.

But Tommy is outstanding, probably the best I've seen it's a very solid performance,

The Live performance at Universal Anphitheatre is very good, still I miss listening Baba O'Rylley with violin instead of harmonica.

Iván

Jim Garten wrote: What year are the performances from?

Tommy is from the 1989 tour and Quadrophenia is from their 1996 tour.

Cygnus X-2 wrote: I've had this dvd since before Christmas, and it is a superb dvd that all fans of the band should own. Which one do you prefer Ivan, Tommy or Quadrophenia?

No clients today in the office, because of the problem with the elections (Still nobody knows the second candidate) and holy Week, so spent all day watvching the complete DVD.

Honestly can't choose, both concerts are outstanding, maybe I would stay with Quadrophenia, because it's not so common to see songs from this album on stage as in the case of Tommy.

But both are excellent.

Iván

Ivan_Melgar_M wrote: Cygnus X-2 wrote: I've had this dvd since before Christmas, and it is a superb dvd that all fans of the band should own. Which one do you prefer Ivan, Tommy or Quadrophenia? No clients today in the office, because of the problem with the elections (Still nobody knows the second candidate) and holy Week, so spent all day watvching the complete DVD. Honestly can't choose, both concerts are outstanding, maybe I would stay with Quadrophenia, because it's not so common to see songs from this album on stage as in the case of Tommy. But both are excellent. Iván

I agree. My only real gripe with Tommy is that they omitted the Underture (which while repetetive, was a really cool song). But Quadrophenia is spectacular, the bass solo from 5'15 stands out in my mind particularly.

stan the man wrote: I have it.  It is amazing.  Watch Quadraphenia and John Entwistle does a phenominal bass solo.  Truely one of my favorite bass players.  The Quadraphenia has less of an 80s influence then the Tommy show.  Quadraphenia was performed in 1996 and Tommy was performed some time in the late 80s.  I myself enjoy Quadraphenia as an album much more than Tommy but it is a matter of taste.  Zak Starkey who played on the Quadraphenia show (son of Ringo Starr) is almost a Keith Moon.

That's because Keith Moon taught Zak how to play and Zak was given Keith Moon's  1976 Drumkit, so he got to be Keith Moon without being Keith Moon.

Cygnus X-2 wrote: That's because Keith Moon taught Zak how to play and Zak was given Keith Moon's  1976 Drumkit, so he got to be Keith Moon without being Keith Moon.

I wa amazed to find the similarities, Zak is as strong as Keith but has more technique (Probably his father taught him some fundaments) but he's ten times more drummer than Ringo.

The kid mixes the best of Loony Moony and the best of Ringo,

Iván

Ivan_Melgar_M wrote: Cygnus X-2 wrote: That's because Keith Moon taught Zak how to play and Zak was given Keith Moon's  1976 Drumkit, so he got to be Keith Moon without being Keith Moon. I wa amazed to find the similarities, Zak is as strong as Keith but has more technique (Probably his father taught him some fundaments) but he's ten times more drummer than Ringo. The kid mixes the best of Loony Moony and the best of Ringo, Iván

I remember reading in the Keith Moon biography "Moon" last year, that it noted that Zak idolized Moon, and wanted to play just like him. But it would make perfect sense if Ringo at least taught him how to play a simple beat.