I lack here a kind of list of Prog bands, counted by their  albums´ actual ratings. I´ve took the trouble and done this chart:

 

Rank No.	Band/artist name	Albums´ weighted ratings							Average rating
1	Pink Floyd	4,5677	4,4989	4,4388	4,2100	3,9513			4,3333
2	Genesis	4,5965	4,5475	4,3603	4,2166	4,1917	4,0983	4,0003	4,2873
3	Supertramp	4,2842							4,2842
4	Van der Graaf Generator	4,4036	4,2974	4,2093	4,2008				4,2778
5	Yes	4,5898	4,3301	4,2792	4,1522	3,9775			4,2658
6	Bacamarte	4,2610							4,2610
7	Banco del Mutuo Soccorso	4,2944	4,2871	4,1655					4,2490
8	Mahavishnu Orchestra	4,2993	4,1117						4,2055
9	King Crimson	4,5105	4,4408	4,2971	4,0467	4,0181	3,9030		4,2027
10	Premiata Forneria Marconi	4,3916	4,2508	4,0579	4,0249				4,1813
11	Opeth	4,2603	4,1512	4,1171					4,1762
12	Al di Meola	4,1614							4,1614
13	Maudlin Of The Well	4,1974	4,1159						4,1567
14	Rush	4,3319	4,2751	4,2674	4,2105	3,9326	3,9018		4,1532
15	Dream Theater	4,2239	4,2224	4,1117	4,0279				4,1465
16	Jethro Tull	4,5959	4,2397	4,0183	3,9512	3,9267			4,1464
17	Mike Oldfield	4,2579	4,0216						4,1398
18	Le Orme	4,1792	4,0992						4,1392
19	Robert Wyatt	4,1385							4,1385
20	Harmonium	4,3408	3,9261						4,1335
21	Kayo Dot	4,1322							4,1322
22	Ayreon	4,1961	4,0672						4,1317
23	Anglagard	4,3552	3,9036						4,1294
24	Dün	4,1283							4,1283
25	Gentle Giant	4,2224	4,1602	4,1514	4,1289	4,0794	3,9982		4,1234
26	Queensrÿche	4,1210							4,1210
27	Camel	4,2794	4,2659	4,1720	3,9409	3,9344			4,1185
28	Riverside	4,2102	4,1108	4,0294					4,1168
29	Pain Of Salvation	4,2562	4,1569	4,0794	3,9533				4,1115
30	Museo Rosenbach	4,1109							4,1109
31	Gong	4,1833	4,0256						4,1045
32	Phideaux	4,1011							4,1011
33	Khan	4,0988							4,0988
34	Osanna	4,0902							4,0902
35	Santana	4,1545	4,0182						4,0864
36	The Soft Machine	4,0810							4,0810
37	Big Big Train	4,0803							4,0803
38	Birds And Buildings	4,0800							4,0800
39	Tangerine Dream	4,0934	4,0442						4,0688
40	The Mars Volta	4,1812	3,9534						4,0673
41	Marillion	4,1768	4,1711	3,9620	3,9489				4,0647
42	Neal Morse	4,0984	4,0271						4,0628
43	Arena	4,0910	4,0324						4,0617
44	Caravan	4,1460	4,0476	3,9831					4,0589
45	Area	4,1517	3,9553						4,0535
46	Devin Townsend	4,1679	4,0771	3,9107					4,0519
47	Steve Hackett	4,0981	3,9990						4,0486
48	Sigur Rós	4,0460							4,0460
49	Beardfish	4,0455							4,0455
50	Unexpect	4,0440							4,0440
51	Return To Forever	4,0418							4,0418
52	Magma	4,1536	4,1006	4,0570	3,9863	3,9067			4,0408
53	Hatfield And The North	4,0943	3,9821						4,0382
54	Liquid Tension Experiment	4,0376							4,0376
55	Bubu	4,0373							4,0373
56	Il Balleto di Bronzo	4,0364							4,0364
57	Disillusion	4,0350							4,0350
58	Sylvan	4,0348							4,0348
59	Death	4,0999	3,9612						4,0306
60	Los Jaivas	4,0297							4,0297
61	Kansas	4,0848	4,0032	3,9969					4,0283
62	Focus	4,1496	3,9048						4,0272
63	Renaissance	4,1642	3,9735	3,9415					4,0264
64	Porcupine Tree	4,1234	4,1044	4,0240	3,9656	3,9131			4,0261
65	Maneige	4,0261							4,0261
66	Billy Cobham	4,0240							4,0240
67	Frank Zappa	4,1453	4,0336	4,0180	3,9988	3,9236			4,0239
68	Yezda Urfa	4,0236							4,0236
69	Tool	4,1241	3,9203						4,0222
70	Emerson Lake and Palmer	4,1251	4,0510	3,9743	3,9372				4,0219
71	Anathema	4,0329	4,0103						4,0216
72	Miles Davis	4,0591	3,9828						4,0210
73	Peter Hammill	4,1094	3,9312						4,0203
74	Mind´s Eye	4,0193							4,0193
75	Gryphon	4,0189							4,0189
76	Eloy	4,0166							4,0166
77	Maxophone	4,0123							4,0123
78	Dredg	4,0100							4,0100
79	S.B.B.	4,0085							4,0085
80	Sieges Even	4,0043							4,0043
81	Sleepytime Gorilla Museum	4,0009							4,0009
82	Shadow Gallery	4,0441	3,9549						3,9995
83	Bill Bruford	3,9979							3,9979
84	José Cid	3,9962							3,9962
85	Cynic	4,0182	3,9689						3,9936
86	Hawkwind	3,9933							3,9933
87	Transatlantic	4,0254	3,9522						3,9888
88	Psychotic Waltz	3,9887							3,9887
89	The Moody Blues	3,9884							3,9884
90	Redemption	3,9819							3,9819
91	U.K.	3,9817							3,9817
92	Haken	3,9810							3,9810
93	Spock´s Beard	3,9792							3,9792
94	Green Carnation	3,9783							3,9783
95	Symphony X	4,0116	3,9446						3,9781
96	Gnidrolog	3,9772							3,9772
97	Asia Minor	3,9764							3,9764
98	Il Rovescio Della Medaglia	3,9752							3,9752
99	Il Baccio Della Medusa	3,9748							3,9748
100	Amaran´s Plight	3,9691							3,9691
101	Peter Gabriel	4,0608	3,9230	3,9223					3,9687
102	Kamelot	3,9686							3,9686
103	IQ	3,9656							3,9656
104	Gazpacho	3,9647							3,9647
105	Discipline	3,9624							3,9624
106	National Health	3,9564							3,9564
107	Atheist	3,9562							3,9562
108	Alan Parsons Project	3,9548							3,9548
109	Colosseum	3,9544							3,9544
110	Egg	3,9517							3,9517
111	Moon Safari	3,9509							3,9509
112	Uriah Heep	3,9507							3,9507
113	Nemo	3,9474							3,9474
114	Arcturus	3,9469							3,9469
115	Ash Ra Tempel	3,9453							3,9453
116	The Decembrists	3,9429							3,9429
117	Mastodon	3,9408							3,9408
118	Echolyn	3,9392							3,9392
119	Celeste	3,9367							3,9367
120	Radiohead	3,9364							3,9364
121	Solaris	3,9344							3,9344
122	Indukti	3,9328							3,9328
123	Fates Warning	3,9570	3,9058						3,9314
124	Mr. Bungle	3,9299							3,9299
125	Magenta	3,9282							3,9282
126	Collage	3,9269							3,9269
127	Godspeed You!Black Emperor	3,9283	3,9239						3,9261
128	Univers Zero	3,9240							3,9240
129	Pavlov´s Dog	3,9234							3,9234
130	Rick Wakeman	3,9127							3,9127
131	Quella Vecchcia Loccanda	3,9101							3,9101
132	Biglietto Per L´Inferno	3,9097							3,9097
133	Angra	3,9082							3,9082
134	Brand X	3,9077							3,9077
135	Anekdoten	3,9034							3,9034
136	Talk Talk	3,9015							3,9015
137	Strawbs	3,9009							3,9009
138	A.C.T.	3,8999							3,8999
139	Ark	3,8999							3,8999

 

 

It´s based on Top Prog albums list, with max. 250 results, filtered by min. 30 reviews of each album. Then I´ve  filtered this list by minimum 3 listed albums and get 25 all-time Top rated bands. I know, there are one of the weak points here: I made a simple average from weighted average ratings.

 

Is it possible to create something similar list in our site, with many filters to creating various interesting charts?

 

Thanks for your answers.

What I mean is its a little too high compared to other bands. imo...

Probably not.....if they are not being realistic.