tuxon wrote: Snow Dog wrote: tuxon wrote: Snow Dog wrote:     LED ZEPPELIN — The Song Remains The Same (Soundtrack) Review by Chris Stacey (Chris Stacey) Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator There is not much more to add than already mentioned on the DVD/Video release. This is an incredibly good live album. It would have perhaps been even better had it shown more of the Physical Graffiti material but nevertheless there are some splendid renditions of the originals. Highlights would have to be the 26 minute ' Dazed and Confused', a 14 minute rendition of ' Whole lotta Love', ' No Quarter' and one my persoanl favourites ' Celebration Day' off Led Zeppelin III. A solid four stars. Posted Tuesday, December 12, 2006, 17:33 EST | Permanent link How can It have Physical Graffiti material Chris? This concert was before that album.        well several songs from Physical graffiti were written before the concert, so it isn't an impossibility. True Tux, but absolutely unlikely!   The movie has Bron-Yr-Aur

Because the movie and album were released after PG, but the concert was before, in fact its part of the Houses Of The Holy Tour.

tuxon wrote: Snow Dog wrote:     LED ZEPPELIN — The Song Remains The Same (Soundtrack) Review by Chris Stacey (Chris Stacey) Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator There is not much more to add than already mentioned on the DVD/Video release. This is an incredibly good live album. It would have perhaps been even better had it shown more of the Physical Graffiti material but nevertheless there are some splendid renditions of the originals. Highlights would have to be the 26 minute ' Dazed and Confused', a 14 minute rendition of ' Whole lotta Love', ' No Quarter' and one my persoanl favourites ' Celebration Day' off Led Zeppelin III. A solid four stars. Posted Tuesday, December 12, 2006, 17:33 EST | Permanent link How can It have Physical Graffiti material Chris? This concert was before that album.        well several songs from Physical graffiti were written before the concert, so it isn't an impossibility.

True Tux, but absolutely unlikely!

    LED ZEPPELIN — The Song Remains The Same (Soundtrack)
Review by Chris Stacey (Chris Stacey)
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator
There is not much more to add than already mentioned on the DVD/Video release. This is an incredibly good live album. It would have perhaps been even better had it shown more of the Physical Graffiti material but nevertheless there are some splendid renditions of the originals. Highlights would have to be the 26 minute ' Dazed and Confused', a 14 minute rendition of ' Whole lotta Love', ' No Quarter' and one my persoanl favourites ' Celebration Day' off Led Zeppelin III. A solid four stars.

Posted Tuesday, December 12, 2006, 17:33 EST | Permanent link


How can It have Physical Graffiti material Chris? This concert was before that album.


    

Edited by Snow Dog - December 12 2006 at 18:11

I don't know about this, but how come there are reviews of an album that isn't out yet? I know maybe you can listen to it in a website or something, but the thing is, we have a lot of very short reviews of POS Scarsick coming from guests who I think are just trying to be the "first" to review an album even before it is available to most of us. Besides, shouldn't reviews be made only from actually released records so that sound quality, and every last minute addition by the band or the label or whatver change it may happen will be heard? Today we have three consecutive reviews of that album, all of them short, don't say anything with a real meaning, just trying to "show off" how quick they were to listen to POS' new. I have yet to read a review by a collaborator, then I would trust. But in the case of an album not-yet-released, with no collaborator-reviews available, I just don't trust those short, weak-content reviews.

(I had this post on the "report abuse" thread but someone pointed me in this direction)

Atkingani wrote: Mayhem's review is frozen presently and text was also deleted. The reviewer did that single review in Jan, 2005 and never returned. Chances are it'll be removed permanently.

I think it's just a bad review, if what you posted is the whole thing, then he said nothing about the instrumentality or songs. He simply said buy this, "it r awesome" The only postive trait is that he said "if you like __, then you'll like these guys", but that's what we're arguing about now. Personally I think that's the most credible part of his review.

Tony R wrote: Trickster F. wrote: (how exactly do you do "anti-Christian activity on stage" by the way?) you're too young to have been to a lapdancing club Ivan. I dont think that the reviewer has broken any guidleines though(?)

^mock crucifixions, though Mayhem's anti-Christian activities involced crurch burnings. Plus one member blew his head off and the members made necklaces of pieces of his skull. At least musicmaniac failed to point that out

Melomaniac wrote: Check more of this guy's reviews...  Still nothing about the album.  He has the right not to like Saga, but reviews like this have no point to them.

It would help if you actually read the replies to your posts (stonebeard's in this case)...

mystic fred wrote: i thought Accountants were supposed to be boring? this man knows a good album when he hears it!   (but can't spell)