Reviews discussion - Progressive Rock Music Forum

if David ever smokes ... he might take Supergrass Smile

I think it was brilliant! Also made sense to me coming in the wake of his other Schulze reviews, all of em with a distinct esoteric, and slightly tongue-in-cheek, writing style. Hell my own review of Blackdance is weird, maybe it's just the album itself that leads to madness?

Btw I moved your post to 'reviews discussion' instead. Didn't seem like you were looking for an admin to ban his ass for being momentarily crazy and verbose

“The Guide says there is an art to flying or rather a knack. The knack lies in learning how to throw yourself at the ground and miss.”

- Douglas Adams

- And do your research; the other reviewer may be wrong, or they may know something you don't.

"Too often we enjoy the comfort of opinion without the discomfort of thought." -- John F. Kennedy

Thanks for the replies.

I didn't reference the song or disc as I don't want to raise a stink or rock the boat,

as I tried to convey. I will try a private message but, of course, I have no idea if that

could have a similar, negative effect.

Forgive me. Only other similar type of forum I've posted out was a sports gambling one

(15-year membership, and this site--much more appropriate--is only my second, as

mentioned). This other site sometimes gets mud-slinging nonsense going and I'm trying

to avoid the same. I'm a rookie.

Don't worry...my skin isn't that thin.

Love the site and want to make it even better, if possible.

Reason I love it is because some of the reviews have encouraged me to hear some

previously unknown great music. If I can do similar reviews that provide other people

with the same then maybe the world will become slightly better because of it.

InstrupsychedeMelodramatic, perhaps.

Hi.

Recent newcomer.

I hope to do some reviews but have a question about what one should do when another

review, of the same disc, has some bad information. This particular case simply involves

stating a track was recorded live when it is a studio track. This may seem mundane but it

is one of those tracks that I will make sure is stashed with my cryogenically frozen head once

I shuffle off, If you know what I mean (this track is immaculate, in my opinion).

I actually (just now) checked the reviewer info and I see that they are still active. Review is

7 years old so I wasn't sure...

There is a "social review comments" option but I am considering a personal correspondence,

however those work, to find out if I'm greatly mistaken or to suggest a very minor edit to the

review; I assume edits can be done but I'm not certain.

This may sound unimportant--in the scheme of things it probably is (what isn't?)

I will hopefully review the disc and said song will be big focus; I want to clarify that it is a

studio track but don't want to mention other reviews or step on anyone else's toes.

I'll leave it at that as brain cramp has set it.

Wrong forum, maybe.

Crazy cookie-bomb for my first post.

Klose, but no "Cigar".

Trust me. I know what I'm doing.

I checked on my copy and he is credited there.

Hi there Luca and Steve Smile

I took the liberty of moving your posts to the 'reviews discussion' - a thread we don't use enough imo......and this is certainly where Luca's question belongs.

“The Guide says there is an art to flying or rather a knack. The knack lies in learning how to throw yourself at the ground and miss.”

- Douglas Adams

More than reporting anything wrong, this is a curiosity: the reviewer says that Bob Klose is featured on the new David Gilmour's album, but the lineup on PA doesn't mention him. Does he really play on it?

http://www.progarchives.com/Review.asp?id=1467282

I stand with Roger Waters, I stand with Joan Baez, I stand with Victor Jara, I stand with Woody Guthrie. Music is revolution

tszirmay wrote:

I met a business man whose name was Richard Head, and he asked not to be ever called Dick. LOL

Priceless!

I also remember an Italian American contact called Mike Raffone. He was loud! Clown

Hey Thomas, I met a Drew Peacock once. That Sent me over the edge.

Gimmie my headphones now!!! 🎧🤣