Pink Floyd 20+ Minute Epics

'Shine On...', the rest is crap, sorry...

Shine on, my favorite song ever, though I love them all.

Floydoid wrote: A very close call for me but Echoes just edges it over SOYCD. Whereas AHM is pretty much garbage IMO.

I find such negativity, and "trash" talk, from a topic starter disheartening. Disliking it is fine. If AHM is pretty garbage in your opinion, then one might infer that in your opinion (of course it's your opinion) the people who voted for it and mentioned liking it in your topic have pretty much a taste for garbage. I thought it was horrible when Waters and/or Gilmour would make such claims and I thought it very disrespectful of Ron Geesin, who I think, did a fantastic job with the material (and I love Aldiss involvement). It's one of the first things I heard from Pink Floyd and have loved it since I was a child, and as someone long into choral type vocals, "Breast Milky" is beautiful. I love the whole thing.

Edited by Logan - 22 hours 24 minutes ago at 10:53

Hi,

ATM deserves more love. It is magnificent, and if you don't believe me, go listen to the classical version done by Ron Geesin on the net. It is unreally good, and makes great sense of classical music, instead of some quasi-hip stuff done by some folks that ended up trashing the whole piece, unfairly so ... they got too rich to admit they were kids at one time, and did some far out things.