BENEFIT

This 1970 release, the band's third album, is the first of the early Tull recordings that, to my taste, merits a 5-star rating. By this time, the group's sound had jelled into what most fans would say typifies classic Tull: less blues-rooted than its (excellent) predecessor, with Anderson's unique flute and Martin Barre's hard-edged guitar to the fore. There's not a single weak track, and the absolutely essential "Inside" and "Teacher" (one of my all-time favourite Tull songs) appear here.

This disc is a must for followers of the early Jethro Tull!

It's like a second part of Stand Up, some songs make the album worth listening...With you there to help me, To Cry you a song, Son, Sossity..., this album is also a landmark is the sense of changing definetly the music direction of the band...Just listen to the next great album of the band...This one is a good buying, good songs, relax and enjoy

3,5 stars really!!!

After the resounding success of Stand Up and the non-album hit-singles surrounding it, proving that it was possible to have singles and still be a respected artist with intricate arrangements, Tull released in spring 70 their third album in 18 months. With an unchanged line-up (this rare enough to be mentioned), the quartet chose a hard direction, sometimes foraying in hard rock. The sound is definitely not as slick as on Stand Up, but this helps the album gain its own personality. The album sees the appearance of keyboardist John Evan for the first time, but still as a guest.

Unlike most JT fan, I find this one is not as nice as the sound is not as round (as on Stand Up) and is more aggressive and squarer (as in To Old... and Minstrel ITG). I have a tendency to think that Martin Barre was trying to get more implication with the creation and every time he did so, the overall sound gets tougher, rockier and harder. There are still many fine songs on the album such as "With You", "Play In Time" (with its scarily twisted distortions checking if the needle was not getting wrecked), the great folky "For MC, Jeffrey And Me", "Inside" (bringing us back to their debut) or "To Cry You A Song", but some tracks are relatively weaker (Nothing To Say, Son, Time For Everything?) and make repeated listenings of this album somewhat arduous! Thankfully it ends better than it started.

The remastered version boasts another four bonus tracks, three of which from a December 69 session, the exception being "Singing All Day" closer in time to Stand Up and sounds like it also. If it was not for Inside on the original Benefit album it might sound out of place. Witch's Promise is a delightful and maybe the best thing on the remastered album, while the short "Just Trying To Be" is a charming ditty and Teacher is another catchy track even if I find Anderson's singing very odd at time. All four tracks were previously available on the LITP collection, but add excellent value and quality to the original album. Still a classic Tull album, but I would recommend this album only after you have gotten past the essential albums such as Aqualung, Stand up and TAAB!

first one in their specific style, blues influences are still present but we have also lot of fantastic folk tunes here. That mixture of styles simply works and if you listen for example to song For Michael Collins... you'll find what I'm talking about, but my favorite of this album is blues/rock ballad Nothing To Say ... it's a must.

The beneficiary of a rich sonic contrast that brought elements of light (acoustic guitar, John EVAN's piano) and dark (Martin BARRE's guitars) into the mix. "Benefit" is a noisier, heavier record than anything the band had done to date and a harbinger of what would follow ("Aqualung" et al). Where Stand Up played up the band's acoustic side and thus had a bluesy gentility to it, "Benefit" bares its teeth in the distorted, drenched electric end of the musical spectrum. IAN ANDERSON had already shown a penchant for animalism in his flute solos; now taking a wider berth behind the boards, he was able to carry that style over to the other instruments, notably for the electric guitars. The folk sensibilities remain, but they're subordinated to rock riffs that suggest LED ZEPPELIN on a lighter scale, especially on the riff-driven "To Cry You A Song" and "With You There To Help Me". To the dismay of some, ANDERSON was also growing more indulgent in his lyric delivery, dripping with disdain on "Son", "Nothing To Say" and "Play In Time". In many ways he was becoming the FRANK ZAPPA of folk/rock, creating intricately knotted ribbons of music on which to hang his effigies. As a result, the pockets of youthful optimism ("Inside", "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey And Me") now sound disingenuous and out of place, the first casualties of the new TULL. To balance the darkness, ANDERSON would come to rely on humor to rise above the fray he'd made; "Teacher" (with its clockwork precision) is part of a select company of TULL songs that pokes fun at philosophizing ("Fat Man", "Thick As A Brick edit #1") for example. The album ends with the didactic, delicious "Sossity; You're A Woman", an acoustic wonder that holds its own with the best of them (including the first half of "Stairway To Heaven").

"Benefit" affords the listener their choice of the hot sun or cool shade; that is, without the inhospitable heat of a bright concept hanging over their heads. Some saw it as the end of the line, others the beginning, making it one of the few TULL albums most fans can agree to enjoy.

I've been always having a difficult time trying to review this album. Ten years ago (1992-93) I was in my JETHRO TULL phase, and I was often letting people know my likings for these guys. Ten years later, it turns out that "Benefit" remains one of my favorites. I find this album a more mature offering than "Stand Up", and the sound quality is definately much better. Yes, it's a more difficult album to get in to than its predecessor, that's why "Benefit" had received its share of criticisms. New member John Even provides piano and organ, making it easier for the keyboard parts (after all, the piano and organ on "Stand Up" was from ANDERSON himself), although he was credited as an official member yet. My favorite cuts include "With You There To Help Me", "Nothing to Say", "Inside", "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey, and Me", "Play in Time", and strangely, I also like the acoustic "Sossity, You're a Woman".

Many of the songs on this album point towards the direction of "Aqualung" (like "Nothing to Say"), especially from Martin Barre's guitar work. Also only half the songs features ANDERSON's flute work. The reason was that ANDERSON wanted to demonstrated that the band could still float without his flute on some of the cuts, and it works. In fact, on side one, only "With You There To Help Me" and "Inside" features his flute. As for "Teacher", the hit on the album, apparently it only appeared on the American version, and "Alive and Well and Living In" was on the British version ("Teacher" was released as a single there - the flip side being "Witches Promise", you get to hear all these songs, as well as "Alive and Well and Living In" on the double album set "Living in the Past"). "Benefit" sure makes me wish it was 1970 again (even though I wasn't alive in '70). Great stuff.

A new decade had started and Jethro Tull's evolution was almost defined, the blues oriented "This Was" and the still jazzy but more eclectic "Stand Up" were left in the past, the band had found the progressive folk sound that was going to be their trademark until today.

Ian is perfect with his characteristic vocals and unique flute but the most important feature is the way he blends the soft acoustic guitar with Martin Barre's electric and aggressive instrument, creating a mixture between the countryside and the city that gently merge into the same atmosphere, simply perfect and totally different to the previous albums where acoustic and electric guitar seemed to be playing different melodies.

Also important is the addition of a powerful pianist as John Evan who's style is much more technical than David Palmer. It's important to notice that John Evan had already played with Ian Anderson in The Blades and John Evan Band, so it was easier for them to join again in Jethro Tull.

Not in the level of Aqualung or Thick as a Brick but Benefit is a well balanced album with no fillers that includes some masterpieces and tracks that will be part of Jethro Tull's repertoire in later gigs. my favorites from this album are:

"With You There to Help Me": This is the song that would introduce me to the Jethro Tull's world, still can remember the impression that made on me the contrast between the acute flute, Ian's low vocal tone and Barre's breathtaking chords. Some drastic changes that are softened by the characteristic flute make of this song an underrated classic.

"Nothing to Say": The electric guitar introduction leads immediately to Ian's voice, a track that advances step by step to a peaceful development when the listener is expecting something more aggressive, but the beauty of the song is precisely that contradiction.

To Cry You a Song": Another track that became a classic in Tull's concerts, probably the most eclectic song, folksy and soft but with some echoes of their blues past that suddenly changes with a frenetic guitar solo that is a pleasure for those who love the harder edge of Tull.

"Teacher": A very beautiful song where Ian's voice and Glen Cornick's bass make the difference along with the psychedelic keyboards and ultra fast flute, a true masterpiece.

"Sossity, You're a Woman" is the perfect closer a song which proves that Jethro Tull has also a classical side, the acoustic guitar soft but complex is simply delightful and the melodic flute that blends with the tune completes the scene.

Not yet the peak of Jethro Tull's creativity but already fantastic Benefit is a very solid album that deserves a special place in every collection. I know that other releases are more mature, but in my book this outstanding album deserves no less than 5 stars

Without question one of the most underrated LPs of the 70;s it has it all. I love the , liner notes Ian wrote my new copy last fall , he explains the history and feeling well, in the era of the big ones stair way dark side who's next good stuff indeed , I thought Tull had to a back seat but now people do remember , as I do how great this lp is classic 5 stars to the members of tull 1970 , thank you you did well. Jlr

I`m not a fan of Jethro Tull, because I don`t like very much the "one-man bands", I mean, the "owner of the name-composer-producer-boss and his musicians-employees", which is what Jethro Tull is for me. I only have listened to some of their albums (a long time ago to: "Stand Up", "Thick as a Brick", "A Passion Play" (I remember that it is a good album), "War Child", "Too old to rock and roll...", "Songs fom the Wood", all of them because someone lent them to my older brothers) and I only have 3 of their albums: "Benefit" and "Aqualung" (recorded in a cassette from two of my brothers` record collections) and "A" (which I bought because I liked the band called "UK" and because former UK member Eddie Jobson appeared in this album as guest). This album "Benefit" is very good, better than "Aqualung", in my opinion. Is more a "Rock" album than a "Folk- Rock" album as there are a lot of guitars and drums. In this album, Ian Anderson wasn`t the only original member of the band so this is stiill more "an album made by a band called Jethro Tull", with a very good line-up and with very good guitars by Martin Barre (who was recording his second album with the band). My favourite songs from this album are: "With you there to help me", "Nothing to say", "To cry you a song" (with a melody which sounds similar to Bach`s music, I think; the best song of this album and the most Progressive), "A Time for Everything" and "Teacher". I also like the cover design: it was a very original idea for a cover.

While being a hugely succesful effort on its own, Benefit is slightly inconsistent, and weaker as a whole than Stand Up, if you don't mind me saying so. Nevertheless, it could be argued that this is where Anderson finally found the "classic" Tull sound, and the album is ultimately a bit less blues-oriented. This album has a few of my all time favorite tunes, namely "With You There To Help Me", "Nothing To Say" and "Teacher". That said, some of the songs are a bit forgettable -- it's been a while since I listened to this album, and I can't remember how the melody of "Play In Time" goes. The album is smoother than their earlier works (has a natural flow), and it sounds more professional, but at the same time, I miss the energy of Stand Up and the raw enthusiasm of This Was. A fine collection of songs, this one, and a safe bet for anyone wanting to look into Tull, but possibly not as essential as their future works would turn out to be.

To make a little break in this DT madness, I'll review Benefit. This was my first JT album. It took me a while to get into, but I found it a great album after a few listens. While not being quite a prog essential like Aqualung or Thick as a brick, It is a great Tull effort. There are some harder rocking songs here like To cry you a song or Nothing to say, and it also has some nice calm folk ballads, such as With you there to help me(the best song off of the album , I think). While Stand Up was more of a blues sounding album, with the exception of Bouree, Benefit has beautiful fluite on every composition. A great JT album, su go buy it when you shop for Octavarium:)

With each release Jethro Tull get's more progressive, and more edgy in the songwriting. Benefit is somewhat an intermediate between their previous blues folk rock albums and the more progressive folk of their later releases. Again the sound is mainly accoustic, with some flute (less than on previous and later recordings), with solid, highly rhythmic bass and drums, that remains the core of Tull's sound IMO. Some very interresting guitar parts, and Ian's voice gets better with each album (keeping in mind I don't really like his voice). Also the addition of John Evans on piano gives the music some more counterpoint.

1. With You There To Help Me (6:17) both soft and dark, as hard and edgy, great counterpoint, and lots of changes in tempo and atmosphere, fabulous song. 2. Nothing To Say (5:12) great opening, nice rhythm guitar, only Ian's singing is a bit out of focus. The music deserved better. 3. Inside (3:49) An intimate song, with soft intricate rhythms, and sweet flute playing. On this song Ian's voice works a lot better than on the previous song. slowely the song get's more dynamic, great song.

4. Son (2:50) More heavy song, with a great piano counterpointing the guitar. Some Beatles influence in the transition halfway, again a great build-up, leading to a full stop. 5. For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me (3:49) Nice, but a tad boring 6. To Cry You A Song (6:12) Great guitarplay, on a solid blues rock foundation. I love it, as usual the song builds to a climax and changes just before it hits it peak.

7. A Time For Everything (2:43) Whining vocals, not my thing. 8. Teacher (3:59) Great Bass play, great flute, solid rock, with good singing from Ian. The flute and the guitar complement each other wonderfully. 9. Play In Time (3:48) The first song of Tull I rate as five stars, with lots of changes, and agressive atmosphere, really awsome. 10. Sossity, You're A Woman (4:30) A soft folk song, with great playing from Barre. a nice last track of the album.

I don't rate this album as highly as the previous two albums, but that's mainly because I think they didn't really improved. Basicaly it is as good as the previous albums, with Play In Time as the stand out track. Their songs became more progressive, but not really better. On Aqualung there's the real change to progressive rock, with some real improvement. I rated the previous albums at four stars, averaging above 3,5, this one averages 3,25 therefor 3 stars is sufficient for this good, but not essential album.

One of Jethro Tull's most underrated albums,not least by the band themselves. I think it is a remarkable achievement, with fine musicianship by all of the group. Ian 's flute playing is to a very high standard, & Martin Barre's raunchy guitar work quite brilliant.More varied than Stand Up, and with hints of what was to come with Aqualung, Benefit just shines with superb songs. In particular, To Cry You a Song, A Time for Everything &, the cream of the crop, Nothing To Say; one of those songs that send shivers through you with its fine melody & vocal from Ian. The addition of Jon Evan 'guesting' on keyboards also gives the album greater depth. The acoustic final track, sometimes overlooked, is a great end to the proceedings. Indeed Sossity,Your're a Woman, is I believe one of Martin Barre's favourite songs. I love seeing the band live but I always think it is a pity that they rarely play anything from this album. I'm sure many fans would appreciate updated versions of some of these tracks.I'd like to give this 5 stars but I know that this rating should be used sparingly.I have rated it 4 stars,but it merits 4 3/4 stars, as it deserves to be up there with Aqualung,JT's most famous work.

Altought this is a good record I deemed non essential. Latter records are but not this. I like "With You there to Help Me" and "Nothing to Say" as good progressive songs but the rest of the album is folk "Sossity you a re a Woman", pop (many songs) and Hard Rock "To Cry you a Song" so this is absolutely not "Aqualung". You´ll enjoy it anyway.

That´s what it is: a masterpiece of progressive music.

My experience with listening to this album is unforgettable - it spoke directly to my soul. I can´t say merely "I liked this album" - its songs simply produced a major revolution inside myself. I was one before listening to it and I was another after!

It must be a deep spiritual thing - because the kind of feelings the flute melodies and the vocals generated on me were far away from ordinary. I don´t know if I listened to the album before, when I was inside my mother´s womb, or something like that (I was born in 1978), because the experience was like being brought to the deepest of the deepest of "myself" - in fact, I was absolutely unconscious of "myself" during the experience.

Well... all that happened to me and, so, this album is very, very special to me - because of what I really lived, and not because anything related to technic considerations or objective analysis.

Experience with Aqualung was very similar. I simply couldn´t believe that what I was hearing existed!

In Benefit Jethro Tull went to a harder and darker feel with a growing cynism in Ian's song- writing. The band is now joined by Mr John Evan, the keyboard player from that John evan Band from which Tull had metamorphosed two years previously. he made it clear he would only work with JT for a year or two a the most, but he remained (thanks God) for the next ten years. Sadly Benefit it's the last for Glenn Cornick, gone to form Wild Turkey. The best songs in my opinion are With You There To Help Me (with the famous back-played flute intro), To Cry You A Song (of which there's a great cover performed by Hughes in the tribute album Magna Charta-A Collection Of Tull Tales) and the powerful Nothing To Say. In the Chrysalis 2001 remastered edition are found the excellent 1970 singles Teacher and the acoustic The Witch's Promise coupled with the nice Just trying To Be and Singing All Day.

A great album, but not one to start with... It's better Stand up as a beginning... anyway 4 stars are the right pay to Ian Anderson and company!!

The third work announced in 1970 "Benefit". It is a work by which JETHRO TULL becomes a peculiar sound. I think that the recording is also lucid. It is a surprised album in the power of expression of the group. All tunes are due to the composition of Ian Anderson.Excellent addition to any prog music collection.

As Ian Anderson wanted the music of Tull had somewhat less blues influenced, the band did prove it through their follow-up album "Stand Up" (1969) which I already reviewed in this site couple of months ago. "Benefit", the band third album released in 1970, confirmed the band departure from blues to their own Jethro Tull Sound combining the heavy use of flute and acoustic guitar as rhythm section which anchored their music into what people mentioned later as progressive folk music. Even though it's hard to deny that there is a bit influence of blues in this album - as was the case with many classic rock music released during late sixties and early seventies. By the time this album was released there was no such term as progressive as a commonly used language by music critics at the time. Just to put things into perspective, by the time this album was released, The Beatles released "Sgt Peppers Lonely Heart Club Band" three years in advance (1967), King Crimson was releasing their second album "In The Wake of Poseidon" after the success of debut album "In The Court of The Crimson King" (1969) which most people reckon as the birth of prog rock. Genesis was releasing their second album "Trespass" and Yes "Close To The Edge" was not born yet. Looking at this perspective it's quite clear the "Benefit" has its own standing in their musical style.

The album kicks off with ambient flute work in "With You There To Help Me" followed with floating vocal line and rhythm section. The music style is a blues-rock with hard edged guitar work (melody) by Martin Barre. The flute demonstrates its role during short interlude. It's a warm opening track. Acoustic guitar plays as rhythm section and strengthens the "folk" image of the band's music. But if we observe the music in great detail, I can confirm that structurally and style-wise this track is a prog rock. "Nothing To Say" (please do not confuse with other Tull's track "Nothing's Easy") has a mellower in style but maintaining the floating singing style of Ian which later become his trademark. Very cool and very enjoyable - Martin Barre's soft riffs are stunning. "Alive And Well And Living In" continues the music with a styke that has become Tull's sound as you can find this with even later album of Tull like "Heavy Horses". Next tracks "Son" and "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey And Me" are excellent tracks as well with the latter uses acoustic guitar fills as main rhythm section.

The best favorite track out of this album is probably "To Cry You a Song" which also became a title of tribute album released by Magna Carta (see my review in this site under Various Artists). This song forms its style in heavy rock with soft guitar riffs as main rhythm section with dry singing style by Anderson. It's melodically very strong and it has a good composition with excellent variations of electric guitar work. I can hardly hear flute sound in this track but still this one still represents great Jethro Tull Sound! You can also enjoy the tribute version in To Cry You A Song performed by Glenn Hughes (formerly with Deep Purple). "A Time Foe Everything?" brings the flute back into music but Martin Barre's guitar is still dominating the music.

"Inside" has a different style than its previous tracks whereby flute is now floating, accompanying Ian's singing. It's really cool having this track presented after relatively rocking track. "Play In Time" bring the music into upbeat tempo with aggressive flute playing style and energetic singing augmented with soft guitar riffs - unique to Jethro Tull's music. The intertwining sounds of guitar and flute is stunning. "Sossity: You're A Woman" concludes the album with a mellow nuance with great acoustic guitar fills as main rhythm section accompanying voice line. This drum-less track is really powerful. As usual, flute provides great inserts throughout the song.

Overall, it's an excellent album with tight composition, powerful songwriting and flawless performance. This album has put a strong foundation for the future of Jethro Tull's music. Highly recommended. Keep on proggin' ..!

Peace on earth and mercy mild - GW

What to say about this great masterwork. "Nothing To Say" is one of the most wonderful tracks I listen, difficult to describe... "To Cry You a Song" (really hard, you don't want to finish) and " A Time for Everything" are also great tracks, some of the best JT's songs. 35 years ago and now are modern than ever...

Very good, probably as good as Aqualung

Felix From Spain

I made an unofficial research and discovered that Jethro Tull had their work released in Brazil before other giants like Pink Floyd, King Crimson and even Moody Blues... probably they were the first prog-band heard in this part of the World!

Reasons, well, I listed 2: first, their association with Rolling Stones through the Rock and Roll Circus - since Beatles were disbanded, the Stones were in the crest of the wave; second, they were considered initially a hard-rock or acid-rock band in the same line of Sabbath, Led or Deep Purple and these guys were a kind of fever here by 1970/1971.

The fact is that JT really benefited from these events and got an extreme popularity in Terra Brasilis that I guess that in the prog-scene they lose only for Pink Floyd and the difference is tiny. Ian Anderson is a usual visitor alone or with the band and he is an easy figure on our TV even going to talk-shows and similar stuffs. Also JT had a good start because while "Benefit" was their third work was truly their first prog piece and the first to be released here; new fans received more than they asked for!

And the album itself? A good one, well above the average. For a listener back in the 70s some sounds should have seem quaint, also the flute, the guitar riffs, the arrangements, certain tunes and passages, the singing act; the progressive ears were being educated.

Songs flow smoothly and even the weaker tracks run accordingly; opening track, 'With you there to help me' is one of the album highest points but there's that marvelous flute in the best track 'Inside' or the pleasant 'Sossity', 'Nothing to say' and 'Son'. A landmark and an excellent addition for a music collection. Total: 4.

After excellent 'Stand up' it had been hard to expect a follower of the same quality. However, 'Benefit' continued in the direction which has been taken on its predecessor, now with longer songs, more harder in structure and with piano and organ enriched tune. From A side of the record there are two titles to be specially highlighted, opener 'With you there to help me' with its impressive psychedelic effects and superb Glenn Cornick's bass guitar playing, a song which is one of my all time Jethro favourites, and the follower 'Nothing to say' where you can here full Jethro sound and all the group members at their best. On the B side 'To cry you a song' catches you with tainted guitar riff, and closing 'Sossity your'e a woman' brings wonderful acoustic guitar playing complemented with powerful flute and organ. I've always been in dilemma which among three Jethro albums- 'Stand up' , 'Benefit' and Aqualung' - I would rate as the best one.After three decades the dilemma has been solved.Five stars to all of them.

This album has received a lot of glowing reviews, almost invariably from people who say it's just as good as STAND UP and nearly as good as AQUALUNG. So let me add my halfpennyworth.

I simply love BENEFIT, and I believe there is not a single weak song on the entire album. Tracks like 'With you there to help me', 'Nothing to say', 'To cry you a Song' and 'Sossity; you're a woman' are as charming and tuneful as anything Jethro Tull have ever done. If the album has remained underexposed in Tull live shows or on compilation albums, there are several possible reasons I can think of. (1) Strange to say, none of the heavier tracks included have attained the (semi-)classic status of 'A new day yesterday', 'Locomotive breath' etc. (2) The album was recorded during a grim period in Ian Anderson's life. I enjoy the way he sings its mournful melodies, but apparently he was not yet capable of writing irresistibly jolly tunes like 'Mother Goose', or deeply felt acoustic songs like 'Wond'ring aloud'. (3) On many of the tracks, lead guitarist Martin Barre performs a surprisingly prominent role. (With double-tracked wah-wah solos and all!) BENEFIT is Martin's album as much as anyone's - something I find highly refreshing, since Martin was still using an old-fashioned blues-rock idiom. This doesn't mean BENEFIT is a guitars-only album: John Evan's keyboard contributions are tasteful and unforgettable.

Every Jethro Tull fan should have a copy of this album, which is far more enjoyable than the turgid THICK AS A BRICK. It's now available with four bonus tracks, all of them superb. For me, BENEFIT firmly belongs to the top five of Tull albums.

"Benefit" had been the last album by JT with Glenn Cornick on board and the first one with John Evans adding a new dimension to the band's sound with his piano and organ play. It might stand a bit in the shadow of its brilliant follow-up "Aqualung" and the very good previous one "Stand Up" but I wouldn't consider it that much inferior to those ones. This album has an overall darker and more hard-edged sound compared to its follow-up fitting quite well to my taste preferences and of course there aren't such staple hits here like "Aqualung" or "Locomotive Breath". The next one certainly would feature more elaborate lyrical work by Anderson and more of nice acoustic ballads but here we have just strong more powerful tracks instead. They started here as well experimenting with some production techniques like the backwards recorded flute on "With You There To Help Me" which would become a regular joke on stage by Anderson as he turned his back to the audience to play the opening notes. Two facts might be worth mentioning that is first the lyrics "flying so high" in "To Cry You a Song" which seamed to confirm the rumor that Anderson was a junkie what never been the case of course. The second one is the line "blues were my favourite colour until I looked 'round and found another song that I felt like singing" in "Play In Time" which had been a direct message by him to his critics supporting their earlier blues-orientated approach. "Teacher" became very popular in the US though the band considered it rather a throwaway song. Therefore it might have been put only as bonus in its original version featuring less flute on the CD reissue. We get the excellent track "Alive And Well And Living In" dominated by Evans' piano play instead. Other highlights are "Nothing To Say", "Inside", "For Michael Collins", "To Cry You A Song", "Play In Time" and the more acoustic one "Sossity, You're A Woman" but as said already there's not any flaw on here. Recommended as an essential Prog addition!!

Having gotten this as a Christmas gift, it has been a good 25 years since I've listened to it and I must admit every song came back to me instantaeously. Right from the start, "With You There To Help Me" it has that early bluesy Tull sound, but Barre's guitar is gutsy and jazzy at the same time. Bunker bashes the heck out of his drums throughout and Anderson's voice changes from song to song, raspy at times, hushed other and soars if needed. I can honestly say that this almost matches the classic Aqualung song for song. The only track that bogs down the disc is the last. It's not bad, but lyrically I'm not loving it, (I do believe Mr Anderson is one of the greatest lyricists ever). What I really care about this album is the darkness and cynicism. According to Ian's writing inside the CD sleeve for the re-mastered edition, they came back to England following an exhausting US tour for "Stand Up" tired and a bit ornery. There's not too many dark Tull album's, maybe "A Passion Play" but for the most part this one is darker. Now, how to judge it. From a progressive perspective, it's a three. From a hard rock perspective with a bit of English blues and pub boggie it's a hands down fiver. Going for the middle ground, and seeing as it's more adult brother comes next I'll give it a solid four stars. A must have early Tull album for those who played the more classic ones to death...give it a go!

Benefit is the real start of the Tull's great history (IMO). I could not quite appreciate their first two albums but this one is somewhat different. I remember passing by the same record shop for months around my school in 1973. They still displayed this LP sleeve (as well as most of the Genesis ones of the era) and maybe therefore, this album will always have a special place in my collection.

The opener "With You There to Help Me" is a fabulous song : hard rockind, great flute and wonderful guitar. Somehow complex : it is one of my fave and a highlight. "Nothing to Say" is a harmonious song : strong backing work from the band (bass and drumming) although the master's voice is dominent and noticeably trying (and achieving) to articulate as much as possible to ensure listeners understands what he says. Another great 5'14" piece of music (and the second highlight).

"Alive and Well and Living In" is a short but well balanced song : rocking / fluting / melody-ing (?). Not at all a weak track. The instrumentals here are very good. The band is really coping well together here.

"Son" is a weird song made of two parts (easily noticeable). The first one being somewhat hard rocky is right in tune with the first two songs. The second section, although it started folky, finishes like it started : a good Tull rocking tune. The end of the song though seems to be cut. Strange structure.

"For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me" starts like a mellow folk song. But with "Benefit" it must have been agreed that no song would be totally folk, so the track will balance between folk and rock. Not too bad.

The vocals for "To Cry You a Song" are quite bizarre. I am not really found of the "special" effects added here. The track though is great : hard rocking at times with great musicianship from Barre. I really would have liked to get the normal Ian's voice format to fully appreciate this song. Great bass playing again by Glenn Cornick.

"A Time for Everything" is again a good song. Same singing work from Ian than in "Nothing to Say". Abrupt end like in "Son". As the album flows, one has to acknowlege that there are no weak track on here. Barre's influence is huge : "Inside" could have been a folky/mellow tune but thanks to his input it turned to be a good rocking song. "Play In Time" really shows how powerful the band can be (even in a studio work). "Sossity" is the sole whole acoustic number. Maybe it is good to rest a bit after such a rocking album !

Four bonus tracks on the remastered edition : "Singing All Day" is a great song with very good keys and bass (again). Fluting is quite melodious. "Witch's Promise" is another track which could have easily fit on the album. Rocking but aerial. Tull. These two bonus tracks are also released on their compilation effort "Living In The Past". Absolutely no fillers. It is no the same with "Just Trying To Be" : quite average track (but it is the first one so far...) "Teacher" is almost a heavy track with a slow rythm. Glenn Cornick is again great (but I have mentioned him so much that he too should be credited for this quite rocking / hard sound of this album).

Although none of the tunes will turn into Tull classic it is a very well balanced effort.

IMO "Benefit" will pave the way for lots of Tull albums from ...the eighties. Like "Broadsword", "Crest" and "Rock Island" but I will have the opportunity to discuss these ones a little later). I would highly recommend the remastered version of "Benefit" to anyone willing to enter their catalogue because :

1. It is a very good album

2. It is really representative of several Tull albums (or individual tracks on later albums)

Four stars.

Filling the gap, the finest example.

One of the finest amalgams between good musicianship and high level of literacy; since it was released in 1970, it was wrapped with progressive overtones, but not because of occasional trends - it's more likely an emphasizing device for wide palette of Ian's ideas. It is true that the album is somewhat inconsistent, but I will stay in it's defence because all the aspects if that inconsistency are:

a) well above the average level of songwriting, b) album works perfectly as a whole, and c) the level of inconsistency is significantly decreased if you don't compare the album with other Ian's conceptual works.

Having said that, I'm defining this album as first yet very successful picture book of a skilled man who will become world-renowned rock pedagogue and methodologist in a years to come.

Are my comparisons too daring? I don't think that's the case, they're simply reflection of Ian's really intelligent work as a whole, and of his work in this particle called "Benefit" whose relevancy is not to be underestimated.

First of all - and that's probably the most important fact, musically-wise - this albums fills the gap between band's first period (of pushing the boundaries of blues) and the second period (progressive, (semi) conceptual works with social themes). It's clearly blues-influenced, but there's no straightforward blues tune on it, progressive elements are more evident in pseudo-baroque riffs ("To Cry You a Song", "Sossity; You're a Woman") than in multipart-compositions ("Son", For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me"), and last but not the least, the quality of production increased drastically.

Simply because of that fact this album deserves to be called an essential one, and we didn't scratched the surface yet.

As far as music goes, there's less flute and more piano, clashing the occasional hard-rock bursts and folkish tranquility.

Every track here is telling it's own story, and each one is augmented with excellent music - it's hard to say whether is music the background for the lyrics or vice versa. Whatever it is, it works perfectly. Ian's lyrics are emotional and clever in he same time, and the beauty of the lyrics and the music themselves is not buried under overaccentuated technicality, although this album is of high quality craftsmanship-wise. As any other Tull record.

The album is full of contemplative piano parts, which in correlation with unique Tull trademark - Ian's flute - create a perfect amalgam and pleasant listening experience. The other side of the musical diversity is armoured with barrage fire of hard-rock moments which are not raw or notorious at all; hard-rock presented here is crafted well, reasonably polished, with a spice of furiousness; there are some absolutely astonishing moments where guitar sounds like a snake in spasm lashing both sides of stereo field, an unbeatable trick that surprised even the band members, because apparently it happened in studio by a coincidence.

My point is that this album is monstrously well-balanced, focused, technical and emotional in the same time. It is not the best record that JETHRO TULL ever did simply because the band have half a dozen masterpieces up its sleeve, but as a standalone unit, this is a masterpiece in all possible contexts.

The last of the classic folk rock tinged albums that started with This Was, Benefit shows the band progressing towards a more refined and progressive sound, further leaving behind the bluesy tunes in exchange for harder more instrumentally focused work.

Same lineup as "Stand Up", Benefit is quite similar to that album in the way songs were written, and the same type of subjects they focused on. Yet another Jeffrey Hammond Hammond song! Unfortunately this would be the last album featuring the stylistic hippe bassist Glenn Cornick, who will be replaced by Ians old friend and namesake of three previous songs, Jeffry Hammond Hammond.

Benefit has a few of those early gems that are just completely essential, the best here are "Teacher", "With You There To Help Me" and my personal favourite "To Cry You a Song". The arrangements are effective yet simple, the perfect formula. Anderson's lyrical ability is also clearly progressing but far from it's peak which is two years away.

Great classic album, it won't disapoint.

Is it possible to make a classic album without including any classics songs? Why of course it is!

Jethro Tull's "Benefit", their 1970 release, was the third album by these rock n' roll giants. this album is really what got their career going, and for me it is the beginning stages of that epic Jethro Tull sound. Glenn Cornick is tight the whole way through, and Martin Barre's intense, sludgy guitar riffs are the perfect compliments to Ian's beautiful flute sounds.

The show kicks off with "With You There To Help Me", an amazing hard rock stunner that features some of the Tull's best early riffs. One of the highlights of the album, could not have picked a better song to start the vinyl. "Nothing to Say" features an excellent rhythm section, and the highly underrated Clive Bunker provides some great beats to match Cornick's bass. Anderson's voice overpowers most the band however, and it captivates you. The good songs just keep flowing! "Inside" is much slower than the first two, more comparable to the melodic, flute driven Tull that cam before this album. Although it is not a bad song, you as a listener will be expecting the heavy guitar riffs and loud singing instead of the atmospheric tones on Anderson's flute and "love-song voice". "Son" is my favorite A-side track by a good mile! From the high- intensity first seconds of the opening verse until the songs radical psychedelic switch, Martin Barre is on top of his game and the whole song just flies. Anderson is at his lyrical peak on the album, and even the slow half of the song is amazing because of the interesting guitar once again presented. "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey, and Me" is comparable to "Inside". Once again, not a bad song, but messing with the flow of the album. The slower opening takes away from all of the energy and action that "Son" created before it. Of course the song picks up in the middle and becomes an excellent song, but the flow is already gone and the intensity is gone.

The B-side starts out with "To Cry You A Song", which is another example of pure excellence! The opening music is intense without being overbearing and the singing is amazing. Can't tell if it is distorted or not, but it is heavily psychedelic. The music in the middle is once again, intense but not overbearing with Martin's amazing guitar solo coming into play. Mr. Barre is steadily becoming one of my favorite guitarists. More soloing leads to "A Time For Everything', the shortest song on the album. The guitar matches the flute every step of the way, which makes for quite an interesting concept. The pairing of the guitar and flute really brings out the good sense in the vocals as well. Another perfect song. "Teacher", the most recognizable song off of the album, is surprisingly one of the weaker songs here. Surely the fans could have picked a better song to represent the album, but this is still an excellent song nonetheless. Another heavy and rockin' guitar riff brings the song up, but the lyrics are a tad bit of a letdown compared with the amazing pen productions on the other songs here. Still an amazing song, don't get me wrong. The flute rave-ups are still a nice touch as well. Speaking of flute rave-ups, that is exactly how the next song, "Play In Time" starts. Barre picks up where Anderson leaves off, and then some more heavy vocals come out and this song is on par with the tone of the album still. I really find it hard to say a negative thing about this album! After the rock-hard outro on "Play In Time", the amazingly beautiful "Sossity, You're A Woman" beings. Very laid-back, this is an atmospheric musical piece that brings a nice ending to a perfect album.

Many have said it before, but I will echo the saying that "Benefit" was the arrow that pointed them to "Aqualung", even if I do prefer "Benefit" of the two. This is undoubtedly the early Tull masterpiece, and one of their career's best. Also, this is a highlight for anybody with ears, let alone progressive rock fans. The mixture of folk and heavy, hard rock brings an interesting concept that made a masterpiece. 5 stars.

So Stand Up was a good album, but it had two things against it: first, the sound quality was a little muddy, I'll never understand that. Secondly, the band wasn't always gelling as a unit. I don't know. With Benefit we clear up both those issues. The sound on Benefit is crisp, the nicest album until Passion Play in that sense. The band also plays as a unit pretty consistently. Unfortunately, something else is gone. Diversity.

Yep. All the songs on Benefit tend to follow a pattern: they blatantly mix gentle acoustics with sludgey guitar. It's also very dark within and throughout, the darkest album to date. However, I have nothing wrong with that pattern. In fact, there's almost nothing on the album that pisses me off, which makes for a fairly even listening.

The opening number is "With You There to Help Me," possibly the earliest song to enter my echelon of "just really, really good Tull numbers." It's an acid drenched ditty with spooky voice and flute and fuzzy guitar. And clapping. Listen closely for the laugh effects, and out of tune (purposely...I hope) piano under the main melody. I love the coda: an endless flute/guitar showdown. Yep. This is Tull's psychedelic album.

"Nothing to Say" is a really depressing number with fantastic vocal delivery. Ian really sounds like everyone is out to get him, and he doesn't give a crap. A little lighter is "Alive, Well and Living In," with the main tune being handed back and forth between Ian and Martin, and a nice acoustic bridge. Diehard Tullers often rave that "Son" is the first number to truly incorporate soft and hard parts, but they tend to forget "Back to the Family." Oh well, most diehards aren't thrilled with it anyway. I don't see why. It's the hardest thing on the album, with angry lyrics directed right at Ian's old man. Great to listen to right before listening to "Cheap Day Return," see what a year can do.

As I said, the best number is "With You There to Help Me," but the worst number is a little harder to define. However, "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me" is a pretty good candidate. I like the rockin' middle, the "I'm with you boys" part, but the acoustic buildup is just so...BORING.

The second side brings us back with "To Cry You a Song," the most famous and classy riff on the album. And it fades in! Ha! No one was doing that! It's the second of the psychedelic trio (in between "We Used to Know" and "My God"). It's really a great number for Barre, with fuzzy guitar tones layering themselves over and over again in during the instrumental breaks. "A Time For Everything" is a nice little tune, with the main melody once again being traded between flute and guitar. However, it also has a really irritating beep in the middle, which (unless my disc is faulty), kind of spoils it.

"Inside" is the most upbeat thing on the album, an amusing little pop rocker with light 'n catchy flute. "Play in Time" is the weirdest, most experimental of the lot. It's a driving rocker, with little flute parts popping up here and there. Sometimes the backwards chewed tape effect gets on my nerves, but other than that a decent song (I love the lyrics). "Sossity; You're a Woman" is some atmospheric organ and equally atmospheric acoustic guitar. It's a sufficient closer, but on the greatest.

So, as I've said, not the greatest, but good. Dark, but not the darkest. Dry, but not the driest (some have suggested a proto-Minstrel). There is not a single song that doesn't contain something I like, if sometimes you have to dig for it (or endure sound effects). The band sounds pretty good, but I'm also a little disappointed. Ian and Martin are great, and John Evan does pretty good on the 'boards, but my rhythm section (particualry Cornick) isn't nearly as strong as on Stand Up. Poor Glenn. Clever chap, jazzy basslines, but I do prefer Jeffrey.

Benefit is worth your dollars, if only for the two biggest numbers off the album. Both are pretty much classics. Yeah. Damn this is a bad ending to the review, but I can't think of anything better.

(There are four songs on the digital remaster, and you've probably heard them all! "Singing All Day" is one of the grooviest numbers Tull ever did. It's remarkably toe tappin'. "Witch's Promise," the best bonus, is a ghostly orchestral folk number with fantastic build and creepy flute that comes from...everywhere. "Just Trying to Be" is a short, sweet number with little acoustic/lullaby effects. "Teacher" is what Ian created when "they" told him "they" needed a pop rocker to help sell the band. No fear, it's still way too strange to be yer standard radio play. I am, however, with Ian on this one; I'm not a fan of this fan favorite. It's a nice enough tune, but it's played for way too long. Amazingly enough, no change in rating. I just...don't feel it. Sorry.)

BENEFIT is an overlooked entry in the Jethro Tull canon, perhaps because it was a transitional album. The band was going in the hard rock direction, maybe because that was the general trend of blues rock bands by the early 70s. The album has no more straightforward blues numbers as the THIS WAS and STAND UP had. Instead the band has that early proto-prog sound, where some rather classical harmonic sequences occur.

The first two tunes are "soft" hard rock tunes. Maybe the band was not sure about what direction they should take, but this is the beauty of this album! Out came songs that were pretty meek and not as "assertive" as "Bouree" and "Aqualung" for example. That is why there are no real hits on this album, they were too personal and dark to appeal to the audience. "Alive and Well and Living In" is a slightly more confident tune, previewing the long lasting collaboration of pianist John Evan, who was only a guest on BENEFIT. This is the first tune that has that full Jethro Tull sound! "Son" is another hard rock number but this time a lot more confidence is heard in Ian Anderson voicing. Yes this is the direction he wanted to take in the future! "For Micheal Collins, Jeffrey and Me" closes the first side in a subdued way. It is my least favorite on the album.

"Inside" was probably the best known song, but I never really liked it much, too poppy maybe? This is fixed with "Play in Time", another rocker with Anderson playing a flute riff in unison with Martin Barre. The backwards tape effect sounds pretty damn dated, but hey it's in the name of fun. Sgt. Pepper was built on such tricks and it still has great reputation - go figure... "Sossity; You're a Woman" is an overlooked folky ballad.

BONUS TRACKS: All these tunes were released on LIVING IN THE PAST, so there is nothing new here. The songs are all very poppy singles that weren't as great as the album, unless you were a normal person. "Teacher" is a hot jam though, and "Singing All Day" is a farewell to that early jazzy sound, their last jazzy number ever, complete with with brushes instead of sticks! "Just Trying to Be" is a charming folk number, and was this the first time Tull used a marimba? I think so.

This is the album on which Anderson's writing style started becoming more individual, and this is the prototype of future albums. On the next album they would perfect what they started here!

Benefit, Tull's darkest album to date. Not that the light doesn't shine through in various points, but this is the overall mood I get from this album. The guitar and sometimes the piano give this music a sinister feel and when combined with the lyrics and vocals, one can get a sarcastic feel. Being a lover of darker music, this is a plus for me. Before going into the core of this review, it is necessary to point out that the musicians are certainly coming into their own here and are even tighter than on previous releases. The songs are structured well, and when they fully get going its fantastic.

However, when they aren't "going" things can get a bit arduous. Especially in the middle of the album. The songs themselves are alright, but to me they lack the necessary materials to keep the interest up. Another thing, is the similar sound of these songs. A little more variation here would have certainly improved it. But of course, this has its upsides as well. If this sound (mostly a hard blues rock sound, with folky acusticness and a healthy dose of flute) is what you prefer about Jethro Tull, then you should enjoy it alot more. But the main reason for a three star rating, is that I feel this is a step backwards for the Tull. To my ears, Stand Up was progressive and varied (and the same could be argued for the debut). As I said eariler, this album is much more in the hard blues-rock vein. Thus, thinking strictly for a progressive collection this album is by no need essential.

Though there are high points with this album. With You There To Help Me, Nothing To Say, and Alive And Well And Living In are all classic JT songs. To Cry You A Song, Teacher, and Inside are all very good songs as well, although I wouldn't call them classics. There is also great guitar and solid flute work present throughout most of the album, and for fans of the hard blues age there are a few bluesy jams thrown in as well. But, overall, this falls a bit flat, especially comparatively.

All in all, Benefit is a decent album. This will appeal more to fans of early Tull then to fans of progressive Tull, folky tull, or late Tull. The Blues sound is certainly dominent here at the cost of the progressive side of things. Not a complete bust however, and I believe every fan of JT will find something enjoyable about this album. Also, not the best starting point in JT's extensive discography. Three stars, good, but not essential.

I'm feeling guilty because of my mean rating: four stars and a half. Well, I love this album. Not as much as Stand up, Aqualung or TAAB, but this was my first experience with Tull, and how do you want me to overlook it? Impossible. I love it. But, unfortunately, it was sandwiched by two masterpieces. It uses to happen; same with Yes' Fragile and KC's Island, among many other excellent albums released in between two dinosaurs, and they become a bit overlooked due to it. Benefit is (don't know if it was at the time, but actually is) a similar case. I'd give it five stars because I personally like it, but from an objetive point of view, in Benefit there are the first dull moments in Tull's discography.

First of all, in comparison to Stand Up (or even This Was), this album sounds less Tullish than before. It means, early Tull used to compose multi-directions albums, like Stand Up: jazzy, bluesy, rocker, folky, etc.... A masterpiece. Maybe Benefit is as versatile as its predeccessor, but clearly more lack of inspiration. Perhaps you just need to listen to the opening track and you'll get my idea: it's about six minutes long, when it could be less than four minutes. A great song, don't get me wrong, but it goes a bit long..... that's all. Exactly the same on 'To Cry You A Song', one of the well-known classics on this album, and it's quite heavy, has a great riff, but it could be much better if it were about four minutes instead of six or more.

Ok, there are no dull tracks, but there are dull passages, repetitive passages of music mostly on the tracks aforementioned. If you ask me for a low note, I'd say 'Play in Time', cause I can't get that agressive flute riff and that distorted guitar moments, but still a good song. 'For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me" pretends to be another memorable acoustic tune, but unfortunately it derives into a harder section... not suitable at all, but again, still a pretty good Tull song. The rocker 'Son' also has little weak moments.

My cup of tea? Well, every track deserves a mention, although my personal favourite is the closing track. It's also acoustic but a bit more medieval-esque and it has a beautiful organ at the intro. The flute along the chorus is also fine. This is THE acoustic song of the album, and for sure one of the acoustic Tull classics of all. Love the lyrics too. I also enjoy 'Nothing to Say' pretty much. I find both electric and acoustic guitar work fairly superb. Special mention to 'Inside' too, it contains one of the best lyrics I've ever heard.

Yep, the first uninspired passages begin to appear on this album; luckily, we'll have again other masterpieces in the next years, starting with Aqualung. But don't stay away from here: this is a nice album and truly essential for J-Tull fans. Enjoy it as I did when I was about twelve and it got me into this terrific band. Four stars and a half.

NOTE: ...Wait... Another half star! Because you gotta try to get it with the bonus tracks. 'Just Trying to Be' is easily one of the most beautiful short songs that I've heard, and both 'Witches Promise' & 'Singing All Day' are classics from the early days. Anyway, all those tracks will appear in the fantastic compilation 'Living in the Past', released one year later.

Try it!

A GOOD HARDER ROCKIN ALBUM.

After the commercial success of STAND UP and their no-less successful USA tour, JETHRO TULL was asked to go back in the studio to take advantage of all the last good developments in their carreer. And in 1970 came out BENEFIT! their 3rd album already in less than 2 years!

Often considered as a transitional album between the goodies of STAND UP and their biggest baby AQUALUNG, BENEFIT can stand alone on its own merits. It took me a long time to get into it, and to be frank, i didn't listen to it very often back then in the roaring 70s. Luckily , i tried again with the new remasterised CD i bought first just for collection purpose, but finally, something ''clicked'' after all those years. Just have to be patient, i guess!

BENEFiT benefits(!) of the same line -up that was on STAND UP. The only modification is the arrival of keyboardist JOHN EVAN, first as guest, then he would become a permanent member for the next 10 years.He will help a lot of course to add more diversity to the JETHRO TULL sound, but also will prove to be a great stage showman that will have the band noticed along with IAN ANDERSON.

This is a hard rockin album compared to the first two. The guitar of MARTIN BARRE is well mixed in the front with raging riffs like on TO CRY YOU A SONG or WITH YOU THERE TO HELP ME. This is definitely NOT prog again, but can JETHRO TULL be really catalogued as a prog band??? Not really, this is JETHRO TULL music. Don't forget we are in 1970, year of LED ZEPPELIN 2, BLACK SABBATH 1, DEEP PURPLE IN ROCK. This is the year hard rock took off the groud. I guess JETHRO TULL was not immune to the outside sounds of the time and IAN ANDERSON asked MARTIN BARRE to go for it. And MARTIN doesn't stop; listen to him again on TIME FOR EVERYTHING and SON. He really brings a lot energy to the album. The flute is secondary and sometimes mixed in the back like on TIME FOR EVERYTHING.

Also, it is noticeable that the voice of IAN ANDERSON got also better, he sings his heart out with a strong powerful clear voice.There were no hits on this album, no BOURREE or SWEET DREAM, just 10 compact hard-energised songs made to rock. No string quartets either, just listen to PLAY IN TIME; You will never hear MARTIN BARRE playing again like a crazy demon like on this song in particular.

Again, we are treated with 4 good extra tracks with the remasterised CD edition . That just makes the listening of this album a wonderful experience , the same way it was with TIME WAS and STAND UP.

So 3.5 stars + half a star for the bonus tracks=

4 STARS

You can't step into the same water twice - and this album really shows that. After the excellent "Stand Up", the band with the same line-up (Anderson-Barre-Bunker-Cornick) recorded "Benefit" which seemingly fails short in comparison. There are no obvious hits or songs that stand out, while the overall musical production is somewhat restrained. The material is equilised and consistent throughout the record, mixing nicely the electric and acoustic passages. However, what sounds and what may have sounded at the time like a drawback now shows "Benefit" as a necessary break before the storming sequence of masterpiece albums to come. "Benefit" is extremely listenable, unpretentious album, with several more than excellent songwriting examples, among which "With You There to Help Me", "To Cry You a Song", "Teacher" and "Sossity" are the best. It was never seriously considered among the fans but that's why you may re-discover its hidden treasures.

PERSONAL RATING: 3/5

P. A. RATING: 4/5

After leaving a firm imprint on progressive music history with their exquisite "Stand Up" album, Jethro Tull spent most of the following year touring the states. There they opened for loud rock and roll bands like Led Zeppelin, Grand Funk Railroad, Creedence Clearwater and even the proto-punk MC5 (imagine trying to play "Bouree" to THAT boisterous crowd!). This certainly affected Ian Anderson's mindset and the result was that "Benefit" has a much harder and slightly darker edge to it with many songs being geared to the rowdier audiences they had so recently faced. In the liner notes for the remastered CD Ian also relates that many of the tunes reflect his cynicism resulting from his disenchantment with the record industry as a whole.

One noticeable difference appears immediately as John Evan's piano is featured on the intro to "With You There to Help Me," a somewhat Gothic-sounding dirge that brightens considerably when they reach the uplifting chorus. There Anderson expresses his longing for a home life when he sings "I'm going back to the ones that I know/with whom I can be what I want to be/just one week for the feeling to go/and with you there to help me/then it probably will." The spirited, frenzied duel between Ian's flute and Martin Barre's slashing guitar lines at the end also belies a major 60s psychedelic influence that will appear often throughout the album. A military drum beat starts the riff-based "Nothing to Say," a wonderful song that contains one of Anderson's best melodies as he further narrates the trials of constant touring and record company demands and false promises. "Every morning/pressure forming/all around my eyes/ceilings crash/the walls collapse/broken by the lies," he laments. The tune features a surprisingly simple arrangement but it's one of their top numbers in my book. Continuing to evolve away from their basic flute/guitar roots, Evan's piano is again prominent in the next song, "Alive and Well and Living In," which plods a bit but doesn't hinder the overall momentum of the proceedings.

"Son" finds them delving into the heavier acid-rock genre to some extent and it gives Ian a chance to make a personal statement about his stifling upbringing as he sneers in his father's condescending voice "Oh, I feel sympathy/be grateful my son for what you get/expression and passion/ten days for watching the sunset" and "'permission to breathe, sir'/don't talk like that, I'm your old man." The cut has an odd little interlude halfway through and an abrupt ending as if someone had slammed a door. Things take an upswing on the following track, "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me" that has a folksy acoustic guitar feel on the verse that gives way to an almost southern boogie-like atmosphere on the chorus. The juxtaposition of these different styles is refreshing and the surreal, poetic lyrics are striking. "Watery eyes of the last sighing seconds/blue reflections mute and dim/beckon tearful child of wonder/to repentance of the sin," Anderson intones. Next up is one of the album's true gems, the riff- themed rocker "To Cry You a Song" in which Ian describes a short break from touring with descriptive lines like "closing my dream inside its paper bag/thought I saw angels/but I could have been wrong/search in my case/can't find what they're looking for/waving me through/to cry you a song." Barre provides a cool cosmic guitar lead and when he plays through the organ's Leslie speaker cabinet he puts an indelible stamp on the tune.

The piano reappears to lead them through the rather nondescript "A Time for Everything" but it does offer a glimpse of what the following album will sound like. I always smile when "Inside" begins because I love its captivating, rolling feel and Anderson's sprightly flutisms. Here he cheerfully describes the ecstasy of being back at home with his woman as he warbles happily "I'm sitting on the corner feeling glad/got no money coming in but I can't be sad/that was the best cup of coffee I ever had/and I won't worry about a thing/because we've got it made." It's a great, joyful song. Their trippy side is on display once again in "Play in Time," a barnburner of a tune with a memorable flute/guitar motif and hair-raising studio tricks to boot. Here the corporate suits' constant demands for more product are related when he sings "Got to take in what I can/there is no time to do what must be done." The acoustic guitar is prominent in the scintillating, involved structure of "Sossity, You're a Woman" and when the flute and organ intertwine in the middle the tune achieves sublimity. Anderson's ode to moving on from an older lover is tender and sweet as he croons "all of the tears you're wasting/are for yourself and not for me/it's sad to know that you're aging/sadder still to admit I'm free." The song's fascinating and complex musical arrangement is superb.

The four bonus tracks are not just discarded out-takes but a real treat. Recorded weeks earlier, the first three of these cuts (that obviously didn't make it onto the official UK "Benefit" release) plainly display how the band was downplaying their earlier eclectic influences and going in a more arena-rock direction that would culminate in "Aqualung." The delightfully jazzy groove of "Singing All Day" would have fit perfectly on "Stand Up" and Ian's excellent flute at the end is top notch. "Witch's Promise" meanders a trifle until the Mellotron enters and the song really takes off, morphing into another jazzy-ish ditty. "Just Trying to Be" is presented without drums and features a chiming piano playing in the high registers while an acoustic guitar strums underneath. It's a very short but sweet number that tragically fell to the wayside for decades. And, last but not least, the radio- friendly single that is "Teacher" ends things on a strong note. It's an immensely popular rocker that thoroughly displays all the Jethro Tull charms as Evan's Hammond organ growls underneath and Anderson's breathy flute mannerisms fly over the steady rhythm section provided by bassist Glenn Cornick and drummer Clive Bunker while Martin's fat electric guitar gives the song its necessary muscle. And here Ian replies to the record executives' demands that he should do more hob-nobbing and glad- handing with "Hey man, what's the plan/what was that you said?/sun-tanned, drink in hand/lying there in bed/I try to socialize but I can't seem to find/what I was looking for/got something on my mind." Something more fulfilling than self-promotion, I'm sure.

While not as consistent as the masterpiece album that preceded it, "Benefit" is still an outstanding effort that no fan of prog should be without. This was to be the last record from their unadulterated embryonic stage for Cornick was soon to leave and Evan was to come on board as a full-fledged member, altering their sound forevermore. The cover art satirically portrays them as cutout figures being moved arbitrarily around by their masters like paper dolls but artistically they were coyly learning the ropes and discovering the loopholes that would allow them to succeed in retaining their own identity despite those manipulations. 4.4 stars.

So, Benefit's a step up from Stand Up, but still an average album. There's simply not much here to distinguish it from dozens of other albums of the time. The best of it (With You There to Help Me, To Cry You a Song, Teacher, Sossity) is excellent, but the remainder is unremarkable and generic. The treats here are a couple of the tracks that originally appeared on the Living in the Past collection -- Singing All Day and Witch's Promise -- which are always welcome in remastered form. With the benefit of hindsight, it's clear Tull was still searching for an identity on Benefit and not really finding it. They'd take care of that soon enough. But for the most part there's very little here that is/was memorable, even back in the day. I recall buying this when it was released, listening to it incessantly for a week or two, then never really coming back to it save for the few songs mentioned. Having listened to it three or four times in the course of writing this review, I expect the same will happen now. Which, put in contemporary terms, means it's not going to be taking up a lot of space of my meager 30 GB IPod.

Docked 1/2 star for showing Ian on the cover in his one-legged 'stork' pose, which seems to have become the standard for any number of middle-aged, flute-playing street musicians.

From out of an ancient cave comes a cackle, a flute, and one of the best rock albums of 1970. While others were making huge strides in modern arrangements, elaborate productions and increasingly grand bombast, this group of battle-hardened travelers was rocking the halls with a more direct and now fully-realized style of heavy Celt-tinged art rock. The album is a successful transition between the breakthrough 'Stand Up' and landmark 'Aqualung', and early hints at the latter can be heard. Ian Anderson's self-harmony steadies 'With You There to Help Me', Martin Barre providing some drama on guitar, more cackling from a mad jester and a whooping flute. Things darken a bit for the brooding folk-metal of 'Nothing to Say', and John Evan's jazzy piano starts 'Alive and Well and Living In', the band's future starting to show with confident riffs and melodic acoustic treatments as the cut develops. More progression on 'For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me' and flat-out meanie 'To Cry You a Song', Tull's medieval metal at its early best. Anderson's unison voice tracks in 'A Time For Everything?', the flute parts now cutting rather than just part of the mix, and folk haunter 'Sossity;You're a Woman' closes a dynamite collection of songs from a band that would soon move well beyond these raw and real days. And though Jethro Tull would grow better with age, like a snapshot of a person in young adulthood this record shows a vibrant and enthusiastic group ready to do much more. Four good bonus tracks from the same period are included on the remaster.

Jethro Tull had a bumpy start to their career. First they made the average blues rock album This Was, then they made the fantastic rock album Stand Up which is a personal Jethro Tull favorite of mine, and then this their third album Benefit which I find a little below average. I always wondered how Jethro Tull could make an album like benefit after making such a strong album as Stand Up, but I guess it´s hard to follow up a succes like that one.

The music on Benefit is much more emotional and moody than on the rocking Stand Up. It almost seems like Ian Anderson is crying when singing some of the songs. It´s very suiting that one of the songs are called To Cry You a Song. It´s unfortunately not the best Jethro Tull album and I think the songwriting lacks a bit sometimes. The only real highlight for me is Sossity: You´re a Woman which I find beautiful. Clearly the best song here.

The musicians are good as always, but the flute which Ian Anderson used extensively on Stand Up is not as present here despite the picture on the front cover of Ian in his famous posture. I think I hear more piano bits on Benefit than on Stand Up.

The sound quality isn´t very good and it doesn´t really help the songs to come out.

I always though Benefit should have come after This Was and not after Stand Up as it is clearly a step down from the wonderful Stand Up and not a continuation of that style. Benefit is an ok album on it´s own premises but put up against Stand Up it don´t stand a chance. I´ll give it 3 small stars and maybe I´m even being too nice here. It´s one of the more forgettable Jethro Tull albums really. If you´re new to Jethro Tull don´t start here.

I consider this album to be the first of the Jethro Tull truly-greats. I enjoy this even more than 'Aqualung'. But before going on, I have to just mention the difficulty I have concerning the five- star rating system:

I think Jethro Tull have released several five star albums, quite a number of excellent, also more than a few very, very good ones and also one or two albums that are still good but not quite up to their usual standard. These last ones on the ProgArchives scale would have to have a two-star ranking, but by the rating definition (and in my ears) require tree stars. Oh dear, I haven't expressed myself too clearly, but in essence I think I would prefer a ten-star rating to avoid unfairness.

But moving on: This is the Jethro Tull heavy riff album. But not dumb riff, but great riff album. Something that should give Black Sabbath something to chew on. These riffs have melody, and tons of it! The foot taps and taps, and taps some more. Not to mention the head-bopping.

There is not a single uninteresting song or tune on here, something that I can't say for 'Aqualung' for instance, where I do have one or two slight reservations. I'll get to that in my next review.

It seems that Anderson must have said: OK, we're going to go heavy this time, and if we do that, we might as well do it properly, but let's not get carried away.'

This record kicks...things. Hardly any daintiness here, There are one or two acoustically based songs as well, and I'm still not quite clear about how Jethro Tull manage to get the heaviness across on these too.

I know that some of the reviews here give this album a bit of a bashing, but although I might understand that from a Prog point of view, I still disagree because this album demonstrates how a recording can be both straight and heavy, and progressive at the same time. There are chord sequences here that go straight to the testosterone and still are way ahead of what chord bashing bands were doing at the time (and now, come to think of it).

So as I have not even the slightest problem with this offering from yore, I give it the full works of five stars.

# 100!

For my one hundredth review I thought I would choose something special. I chose Jethro Tull's Benefit my absolute favorite Tull album. Released in 1969 this was a transition album moving Tull from the Blues band they were to the prog band they were about to become. That is very much in evidence in such tracks as With You There to Help Me, For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me and Sossity Your a Woman. There still is the blues band in songs such as To Cry You A Song and Nothing to Say. I like this variety of styles presented here. Classic Tull sounds are present in songs like Inside and Play in Time.

The production can be a bit sparse based on this is a 5 piece without the aid of keyboards. Still the flute fills in the cracks nicely throughout and Martin Barre sounds great on this one. The 2001 remaster adds a lot of clearness to the mix and there are things I can hear now that I wasn't able to on the original release.

The Remaster also includes 4 bonus tracks the best of which is Witches Promise are not really that strong additions to the album proper but not bad for collectors.

This is the first of Tull's golden age of the early 70's. I give this one a 5.

This is the weakest album until A Passion Play, in my opinion.

It's not terrible. I just find it thoroughly boring and not a very intriguing release from the band that usually knows how to pack intensity and excitement into albums like your grandma knows how to pack for a long vacation. Instead, here we find the band looking for melody without their wild side, which is not a bad aim, except the melodies are not strong enough to allow for such a gutless album. It's not all worthless, true, but I really can't bring myself to listen to it very often. Tull has been known for releasing a couple great albums and a great number of mediocre ones to fill the spaces in between. This falls into the mediocre category, though I think it might be a bit below par. On the whole, also, there seems to be a certain lack of much progression or progressive-minded music. The creativity seems to have vanished before recording started on this album.

On a song basis, there really are not any tracks that stand out to me. A Time for Everything? is a good song, but even so it is not a very exciting or memorable one. The melodies do work well, especially with the flute. However, there is an awful high pitched squeal for ten seconds or so in the middle that almost guarantees an instant headache. Play in Time and the simultaneously released single (available on the remaster) Teacher are both interesting tracks, with some good flute and popular vocal melodies. Aside from those three, however, none of the songs off of Benefit really do much in the way of standing out at all.

From my perspective, this album should be only for serious fans of the band. A casual listener would likely be pretty unimpressed.

Review I'vestoppedcountingbynow, Benefit, Jethro Tull, 1970

Even in the already quite unusual Tull catalogue, Benefit is an oddity. Unlike the following Aqualung and Thick As A Brick, it seems very uncertain as to where it wants to place the stress, which results in a slightly muddy recording full of good playing and good writing, but not a lot of focus. With You There To Help Me and To Cry You A Song are comfortably the most successful examples of this ambiguous, dark style, while the remaining ones took a lot longer to work their wat in. John Evan's additions on piano are interesting, but doesn't really come off in an obvious way yet. It's probably fair to say that this album is the start of a rather more progressive Tull, but still, I'd maybe say to leave it unless you're already a fan of more effective and quirkier efforts like A Passion Play and Minstrel In The Gallery (even if the rating seems to contradict me). Nonetheless, after a fair few (probably about ten or so, in my case) listens, the album suddenly sank in, striking back with all the little bits of emphasis, the quality arrangements and the subtler touches.

The superb With You There To Help Me kicks off the album in style, with a highly distorted flute, some acoustic strumming that seems to abandon the mould altogether and a sort of confusing block vocal that'll recur in the album. A great Martin Barre guitar tone supplements the rest of the band. The lyrics set an ambiguous mood, and Glenn Cornick's bass provides a touch of throbbing background the song can't do without. The Clive Bunker percussion is understated, effective and explosive. A very, very difficult song to describe, and somewhat intentionally so, at that, with a mood that somehow shifts between a desperate optimism and an assertive disillusion.

Nothing To Say is a bit more unusual, again featuring the everything-goes-on-at-once acoustics, guitar thrums, thick vocals and emphatic hammering piano lines. Cornick's swirling bass drives the song along from the bottom. Bunker's again perfectly good on the drums. The vocals/lyrics are weird as anything, but they somehow end up working for the piece, providing a greater contrast between the ironic 'I've got nothing to say' and the lushly arranged verses. A touch of piano-guitar-bass interplay works in the piece's favour. A surprisingly understated Barre solo off the piece.

Alive And Well And Living In The Present seems to move both further from and towards rock. A hard Barre part meets a rather folky rhythm and an Anderson-Evan dominated moment of real jazz. The lyrics are unusual, but good, and the combination of styles actually ends up working pretty well.

Son is built on a two-part conversation, perhaps extending the themes of For A Thousand Mothers, and including a rather unusual fade mid-song into another section. The piano-and-acoustic reply is particularly neatly done. The ending jumpy piano sort of disappears into midair. Unconventional, and I hated it at first, but now I'm getting fonder of it.

The absolutely lush For Michael Collins, Jeffrey And Me is amazing, with a piano, acoustic and careful bass reminiscent of the softer songs of Aqualung. The more rocking chorus is an oddity, but it works quite well once you listen out for what Barre is doing. The building acoustic is a treasure, and the little melodies make the song very moving. Again, an unusual mood, but it works. Finally, the vocals are extremely good here, which isn't something I'll say about much of Benefit.

To Cry You A Song is another of the pieces I loved at first listen. It featyres superb percussion, capable guitars, emphasis placed by delaying some of the anticipated guitar parts and a fluid bass which also seems to not quite relate to expectations. Some of the rocking solos are clear precursors to bits of Aqualung. I think an odd organ section takes place, but it could just be a manipulated guitar. Anyway, it thumps, rocks and wails away in an impressive fashion.

A Time For Everything features an obvious flute part, including a kettle-on-flute sound, as well as a good synthesis of guitars, percussion and piano, using a couple of low piano notes to contrast the fiery guitar. Barre takes a rather unusual guitar part in places, which I can't really even compare to anything adequately... perhaps the early VDGG guitar off Whatever Would Robert Have Said? is the best I can suggest. Anyway, I like it.

Inside is another of the folk-rhythm pieces, with a little bass part which adds a touch of colour, and an unusual percussion sound that sort of traps ideas. The flute again provides weird melodies in the background, and a couple of wordless vocal lines. The lyrics are good, and it's a much more successful merge of folk and rock than the later Songs From The Wood material in my opinion.

Play In Time is again weird, with a nice low-key-organ, some really odd guitar and a sort of bass-backed riff that is really simple, but quite effective. The bursts of instrumental grit are fantastic... the rest of the song at least has the appeal of being unusual and distinctive. Anyone who thinks Tull weren't really experimental... try this for size. A bit of characteristic yelping + flutes makes an appearance, and the piece as a whole is good.

The interesting Sossity; You're A Woman takes its place at the end of the album successfully. The unusual classically-inspired acoustic guitar and organ meets another block vocal and some surprisingly moving folk-based percussion and harmonies. The crystalline flute melodies provide an atmosphere, though I'm not 100% sure what it is. The lyrics are again excellent, and effective. The last note of the album, a standard classical flourish holds real potency.

Singing All Day is a rather fun and quirky little piece in 5/4 (if I'm not mistaken, though I could be... I'm not great on counting time signatures), with a neat vocal, some subdued flutes. A bit more of the Clapton-influenced guitar stylings we get on We Used To Know, and a couple of brief, darker and more unusual sections. The lyrics are naturally pretty good. Witch's Promise again draws a bit on the melodic folk side of Tull's writing, with either a mellotron or an actual string arrangement (more likely), along with a neat bass part and a load of fun little features.

Just Trying To Be is a brief, pretty and unusual acoustic piece, with a couple of really nice marimba additions. Teacher is a particularly good rocker, with a great bass part, harder guitar, complimented by a classy hammond tone and a couple of memorable melodies. So, really, a very good set of bonuses.

Anyway, a touch weird, but still commendable. My rating of the album seems to waver from listen to listen.... I'd certainly not call it a masterpiece, or even truly essential if you aren't a big fan of some later/earlier Tull, but it never strays below fun, and is an extremely interesting record. Very difficult to describe, and rather intentionally ambiguous at a lot of times, but still an interesting, experimental record, displaying a fusion of rock, folk, and even the occasional dab of jazz, classical and pop to good effect. Needs to be heard, and given a little time to grow, I think. Recommended for anyone who's very fond of some earlier or later Tull.

Rating: Four Stars, but it really is a pretty difficult one to rate. Favourite Track: Lots of good ones. I think Sossity; You're A Woman has grown on me the most, but then With You There To Help Me might still take it.

Firstly, let me mention that my track listing is slight different than that listed above. I believe the above list is from the original US vinyl, because the Remastered CD follows the original UK release. Anyway, the quality of music found on Benefit is extremely good at times, 'With You There to Help Me' and 'To Cry You a Song' being the obvious centerpieces of the album.

Overall, a lot darker and cynical than Stand Up- Ian even expresses this feeling in the liner notes of the remastered CD. To me this seems like something that would come before Stand Up, in reality it comes after. It is certainly a backwards step when one thinks of the diversity of their previous effort, but if anything it is a small step. Insert keyboardist John Evans who would provide Tull with great ideas for the entirety of the 1970's, and subtract the heavy doses of Ian's flute. Let me begin by discussing the highlights of this album, an excellent album to add to your Tull collection as it contains some hidden gems.

Firstly, 'With You There to Help'. Starting the album of with a flair for the dramatic- backwards flute and acoustic guitar building the piece (something we will see done with similar effect on 'Cross Eyed Mary') before the verse and chorus quite well. This is one of Tull's best pieces and a highly sophisticated piece that is an extension of Stand Up. Quite enjoyable.

'Nothing to Say' had a beautiful feel to it, Barre's guitar taking the listener to medieval pastures- his riffs working well with the peaceful acoustic nature of the piece. Throughout it seems as if there is something building beneath the surface of this piece, then Barre's haunting solo closes the piece; it sends chills down my spine.

'Alive and Well and Living in' is one of my favorites, Evans piano leads us to an incredible Barre riff, with Bunker giving an incredible foundation. After the second chorus, it descends into a piano and acoustic guitar solo section before Ian's flute takes the listener to the end. 'Son' builds upon the harsh tone of the album, an odd transition in the middle of piece provides an eccentric transition before returning to the main riff. A very harsh, and aggressive song.

'For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me' continues the trend of acoustic melodies balanced with heavier sections. It is at this point in time it is important to note the absence of Ian's flute throughout. Then we have the sludge masterpiece: 'To Cry You a Song'. Great riff, pounding drums, echoing and haunting lyrics ("Flying so high/trying to remember/how many cigarettes did I bring along? /when I get down/ I jump in a taxi/ riding through London to cry you a song").This is the song that captures the essence of this album's cynical and dark atmosphere. It is a guitar fan's dream, Martin's layered guitars are remarkable and his solos are tasteful, heavy and ubiquitous in this piece. ("I came down from the skies to cry you a song")

Ian's flute returns in 'A Time for Everything' , a piece that features some experimental noodling with ringing sound effects, aside from them the piece is good and a nice reflection of the type of music found on Aqualung. 'Inside' is very much like their work from Stand Up, not as heavy on Martin's guitar- he seems to approach the song much like he did 'Living in the Past' or 'Bouree' and Cornick's bass stands out and is in fine form. This song is a nice counterpoint to the rest of the album.

'Play in Time' features an energetic, belligerent and unforgiving riff, Ian playing this on flute and Martin following in line; more keyboard experimentation from John Evans and Ian's vocals are in excellent form. This is not the same band that release 'Look into the Sun' or 'Reason for Waiting'; a hardened and much more relentless sound, which is characteristic of the full album. And then the album closes with 'Sossity; You're a Woman'. John Evans' organ and Ian's acoustic guitar begin the piece with Ian coming in on vocals shortly thereafter; a very dark and somber acoustic number, the flute is reflective and much akin to the flute in other Prog bands, atmospheric and pastoral without the same youthful exuberance as 'Bouree'.

The bonus tracks are equally worthy, if you enjoy the album you are bound to like these as well. Personally this is the most consequential of Tull's classic period when looking at their sound, but it is highly entertaining and beats virtually all hard rock out there. Excellent sound quality and a great rock record. Enjoy!

Being for the benefit of Mr. Anderson

I think it is fair to say that Benefit is a transitional album. As such, it shares some of the weaknesses of the two 60's albums, but it also points humbly toward what was to come after it (on Aqualung). Unlike many others, I personally think that Benefit is better than the band's first two albums overall, even if it lacks clear standout tracks. But I still find it somewhat immature in relation to what was soon to come.

The straightforward Blues Rock of This Was and Stand Up is toned down here in favour of more Folk and even a bit of Beatles-like Pop. The production is better than on the former two albums. Mr. Anderson's distinctive flutes and vocals are again clearly recognizable here, and they sound better than before, but it was still not at all evident what a great band they would soon become.

Like I said in previous reviews, Prog fans should begin with Aqualung and ignore the first three albums at least until they have acquired most or all of the band's post-Aqualung output, most of which is better than these early albums.

Good, but still not essential

A folk treat for rainy evenings.

By now,Jethro Tull had developed their sound into a subtle and melodic folk workout.The band would move on and incorporate a wider range of influences in the following album as we all know it(and therefore evolve into a proper progressive rock band),but in Benefit their earliest sounding reached a remarkable peak,closer to perfection than ever before.It's interesting to notice that this one keeps the spontaniety found in This Was and Stand Up,and still manages to capture the listener's attention in the same way Aqualung would do.It's an extremely pleasant album with wonderfull tunes,although it's progressive relevance is questionable.

The band simply cannot be given enough credit for creating what is,alongside Thick As a Brick,the most consistent album of their career in what is all in all a predominatly acoustic recording.The strenght of each song and how well balanced they are,make a huge contribution to the album's joyfull,pastoral sound.Highlights include the wonderfull with You There To Help Me,one of the finest songs in the band's career,Sossity;You're a Woman and To Cry You a Song,but every piece(with the possible exception of Son)is a gem.A beloved moment of mine is the nostalgic melody of For Michael Collins,Jeffrey and Me,an acoustic ballad that grows in it's powerfull chorus.I've also heard throughout the years people mentioning Nothing To Say as there all-time favourite Jethro Tull song.

It's a shame that Benefit never received the attention it deserves,seeing as it doesn't contain any of the band's classics.So being,it's sophisticated folk approach,priceless spontaniety,and ultimately it's magical songs remain a well kept secret in Jethro Tull's rich discography.

This is JETHRO TULL's third album and the first where we can hear that classic TULL sound. The previous album "Stand Up" for me was a mixed bag, it was almost like Ian wanted to experiment with all these different musical influences he had in his life and it shows in the final result. I would call that a transition album. "Benefit" is darker and harder and I think it helped that John Evans came on board to play keyboards leaving Barre to concentrate on solos and riffs.

"With You There To Help Me" opens with flute that seems to echo as acoustic guitar then vocals come in. It kicks in before the chorus. Man the flute that follows is haunting. I really like the guitar 3 minutes in and later with the flute before 4 minutes. "Nothing To Say" just sounds so good with the guitar,bass and drums leading the way before the vocals arrive. That electric guitar sounds pretty amazing to me. Good song. "Alive And Well And Living In" opens with piano as lighter than usual vocals come in with flute and drums. Electric guitar makes some noise. Some good contrasts here.

"Son" has some attitude both with the vocals and the guitar. A lighter section before 1 1/2 minutes then it kicks back in after 2 minutes. I like the way it ends. "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey And Me" opens with acoustic guitar and reserved vocals, then piano joins in. It gets fuller after a minute as contrasts continue. "To Cry You A Song" builds until the vocals come in. Some nice guitar in this one. I like it ! "A Time For Everything ?" features flute, raw guitar and vocals. Piano comes and goes. "Inside" is such a great song. It's Ian's vocals and flute that make this so special. "Play In Time" is a cool track that's fairly aggressive. "Sossity, Your'e A Woman" opens with acoustic guitar and organ. Vocals join in this dark and melancholic song.

I like this album a lot. Oh and my version has "Teacher" as a bonus track, it was on the original UK version and was recorded a few weeks before the other songs on the album.

Benefit almost reaches the same heights as its predecessor. Less bluesy and opening up to more acoustic songs and folk influences, we get another inspired and passionate release, with excellent song writing and a top performance.

But for one or other reason it doesn't feel like a consistent album to me. It sounds like a compilation of songs they had lying around at that time. It lacks to coherence and unifying sound of Stand Up and there is a huge quality difference between the more accomplished longer tracks and the still adequate but less memorable short ones.

Anyway, Jethro Tull were enormously creative and inspired in their first years, especially if you also consider the amount of songs that were written in the same period but didn't make it onto one of the albums till the compilation Living in the Past was released.

With you there to help me it probably will.

Jethro Tull is a band that has really grown into me these recent days, and Benefit has been a big contributor in the procedure. This album is like Genesis Nursery Cryme, or Yes Fragile. You really can't decide is it a total masterpiece or just under the bar. For me a total masterpiece consists only of tracks i want to listen to all the time. This is so far the only reason i can come up with to not give Benefit 5 stars.

The album offers very very much. There is the opening track, which for me ranks amongst the Jethro Tull greatest. Then there's fantastic tracks like "Inside", "Son" and "Teacher". I also like "For Michael" and "To Cry You A Song". This album just lacks the consistency that would show on the next album, and this for me is the main reason to give it "only" 4 stars.

On Benefit, Tull had taken the highroad, and the 70s would now be taken by storm and flute. A great album and a great introduction into 70s Jethro Tull. 4 Stars.

Benefit - Jethro Tull (3.21 stars) Original Release: 04/20/1970

Songs:

With You There to Help Me (3 stars) This song has an ominous tone which peaks in an interesting pair of instrumental and vocal chorus'. I'm not able to discern the meaning of the lyrics. The song has good energy but doesn't interest me as much as I would like it to.

Nothing To Say (3 stars) This song first features that distinctive early Tull guitar sound which has a mildly baroque, staccato, hard rock anthem quality to it (for lack of a better description). The lyrics describe a negative mysticism, a wisdom of the rejection of the world. The guitar peaks with a exuberant melancholy that is evocative when the lyrics reach their brief chorus.

Alive and Well and Living In (4 stars) This song brings a slightly more richly textured instrumentation. The song moves from a bass and piano sectin to a flute and guitar section and back down (in intensity) again. The lyrics describe the unwitnessed choices of a woman who gives without expectation of return. Very enjoyable song that ends a little soon.

Son (3 stars) This song depicts a sarcastic conversation between father and son. The character of the father is painted with hypocracy. The song switches tone from hard rock to acoustic guitar in the middle presumably to change the perspective from father to son. Then it switches back again to complete this short song. This song and the previous one present some brief character sketches.

For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me (4 stars) This song starts with a sweet acoustic guitar and lilting vocals. I don't get the lyrics meaning. The sweet melancholy picks up a joyful pitch in the chorus. Interesting, beautiful song.

To Cry You a Song (3 stars) That early Tull guitar sound is back and after the chorus the guitar breaks out into a skywards fanfare. Then the instrumental section descends back down in stages to the vocals again. The lyrics speak of the travelling musician/singer flying to London to perform (cry = sing); he has his cigarettes and alcohol.

A Time for Everything? (3 stars) Piano, guitar, flute start off this song, then, without having realized it there is some of that great aggressive flute playing that until now hasn't been present or noticable anywhere earlier on this album. The song has a reflective and anticipatory feeling. I wanted this song to kick off into more aggressive flute playing. Somehow the song seemed poised to take off but it doesn't quite make it.

Inside (3 stars) Lyrics suggest an almost giddy man with nothing in his pockets now but success assured in the near future. A growing fame already presents privacy issues, perhaps, but the protagonist finds moments to be real with true friends. The music is also happy and breaks out into a higher joy/faster pace. A second pass at that higher joy is never made as the remainder of the song seems to stall at the song's initial level of reverie which is somewhat anti-climatic.

Play in Time (3 stars) An aggressive flute and guitar again! Interesting organ work as well. The lyrics seem to be about performing the music that is within the musician and some of the challenges in doing that. Interesting "edit room" effects wind up the energy in places in this song.

Sossity; You're a Woman (4 stars) Expose about an older woman who thought she was getting her kicks from a younger man but it seems such relationships only ends in bitter disappointment. The chorus suggests that this older woman and society are interchangable ideas. The organ and acoustic guitar make a melancholy joy and the serene chorus is haunting as is the final guitar chord.

Singing All Day (2 stars) Straight-forward song about the happy anticipation of seeing a particular woman; short dreamy mid-section adds only slight interest to this song.

Witch's Promise (4 stars) Acoustic guitar and flute instrument this anima song. The mood picks up a notch and mellotrons come in. The song builds as it goes forward more effectively than most of Tull's songs to date that I have reviewed.

Just Trying to Be (3 stars) A xylophone or well tuned toy piano and acoustic guitar play on this quiet and extremely short song with evocative lyrics about how personal identity is confused by parental over- guiding of the play of their children.

Teacher [Original UK Mix] (3 stars) Funky version of that early Tull guitar sound. The lyrics describe a "teacher" who recommends not getting stuck in things and getting out and experiencing the world while the listener humorously seems to miss the point. But this whole exchange seems to occur in the bright morning of a day inside the protagonist's head; a waking dream of inspiration soon lost.

Album:

That familiar guitar sound heard on some of Tull's most popular classic rock songs appears on this album for the first time. The album is a collection of songs with some more musically interesting that others. I wouldn't quite call them a progressive rock band at this point although they are widely appreciated by fans of the genre; Tull's songs are not slaves to the standard chorus, but they have only a few, well-developed instrumental sections.

MP3 recommendation:

Four stars (4 stars) 1. Alive and Well and Living In (4 stars) 2. For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me (4 stars) 3. Sossity; You're a Woman (4 stars) 4. Witch's Promise (4 stars)

Jethro Tull is taking shape on Benefit.

I will be brief....

This may be their first album with the now trademark Jethro Tull sound. Which means a mix of folk rock, symphonic prog and blues. There is not enough symphonic prog here to bother the ELP/Genesis fanatics, including myself, but the real Jethro Tull is coming through here.

I am not a fan of blues and there is too much blues here for my liking. The music is also pretty harsh on this album. This album is bordering to hard rock at times. This album seems a bit underdeveloped in my view. But the songs are good. They are not great in my view. Inside is a great song. The same can be said about Teacher. The rest is good and this is a solid Jethro Tull album where the band is taking shape. This is a good, but not a great Jethro Tull album. My interest in this band is focused more on their Thick As A Brick like work instead of their harsher songs like those on Benefit. Hence three stars.

3 stars

This album shows Jethro Tull almost fully evolved from the mostly bluesy folk rock band of their first album into the full fledge prog monster they became. In fact, the second half of the album is made up entirely of songs that would fit in very well with their later repertoire. To Cry You A Song and Teacher are both radio friendly and interesting enough for most prog fans.

None of the songs are bad. But some just seem to pass from memory an instant after listening to them. And what is up with Ian Anderson's obsession with that Jeffrey guy?

Easily three stars.

Given the sheer glut of Tull material out there, the band has a tendency to sound "samey" over time. However, even though their sound is not terribly different from Aqualung, there are some nice diamonds in the rough to be found on Benefit.

This was one of those random albums that I had on vinyl while growing up, so in full disclosure I admit that it does have a special place in my heart. Who knows why I had this and not Thick as a Brick, but I suppose sometimes it's OK to save the best for last, even if it happens unwittingly.

Highlights: With You There to Help Me, Nothing to Say, Teacher, Sossity. Although there are no bad moments on this album, I often get the feeling that I'm listening to some variations of a common theme. Not so with these select highlights, which each offer something interesting and rewarding. The opener is a real keeper, with a nice chanting verse punctuated by flute runs, leading to a good rocking chorus melody. Nothing to Say is not complex, but an effective bluesy rocker with plenty of guitar harmonies. Teacher is a very catchy "single" and even--rightfully so--gets decent airtime on the radio. Sossity works great as the album closer, and is a nice somber number. The organ and acoustic guitar are quite haunting, and the addition of flute and tambourine later is really done to nice effect.

Overall, a good number of very solid songs, yet the truly progressive aspects would need to percolate just a bit longer. I do often come back to this album, but in retrospect the band did need to evolve, because even a quality effort like Benefit can come to sound a bit bland in places.

'Blues were my favourite colour, until I looked around and found another song that I felt like singing...'

I found it hard to decide whether to give this 4 or 5 stars. When I first listened to it about a year ago, I found it to be one of the poorer jethro Tull records as I had high expectations after coming to terms with the likes of Aqualung, Minstrel and Stand Up etc. I always thought of Benefit as being a regression rather than a progression from Stand Up. This seemed to be more hard and bluesy than Stand Up which had many different styles incorporated into it.

Then upon listening to it more recently, I realised that those styles hadn't disappeared, they were just less obvious as they had been covered slightly by the hard rock atmosphere. Now, I really love the way that the hard rock and the progressive (and slightly folky) aspects interplay. This is maybe best shown in the opening track, 'With you there to help me'. This has got to be one of the best openers of any JT album. It starts with a backwards flute trill(which was actually achieved by reversing the recording, not as Ian says in the 'live in Montreaux' DVD , by him standing with his back to the microphone). The piano of John Evan and the acoustic guitar take us through the verse and then it builds up during the chorus into a VERY heavy electric guitar riff. So there you go, the juxtaposition of acoustic (folksy) and electric (rocky) is in fact better than it is on Stand Up.

There really aren't any weak points. The only songs that are slightly weaker are Nothing to Say and A time for everything which are more blues rock, but they are only weaker compared to the rest of the tracks, which isn't to say they are bad because the other tracks are astounding! My unusual choice for best track is Play in Time. I don't know why I like it so much it's just very catchy. There's some annoyingly high noises near the end but I can live with that. With the additions of the bonus tracks, Witchs Promise becomes the best track. It is probably their most folky track to date and the flute intro is amazing!

I'd just like to say that John Evan's keyboards are great throughout. I'm not surprised they let him join full time and it really BENEFITed them during the next 10 years!

I've decided to change my rating, perhaps I was a little too hasty after rediscovering this album. Don't get me wrong, it's still great brilliant, but Tull had still to progress quite a lot before reaching their masterpiece Thick as a Brick, so this is logically a 4 star album, but a high 4.

I was expecting the worst for this album, but much to my surprise it's hardly any worse than Stand Up. Just goes to show you can't trust critics. This is definitely a darker, more-depressed Tull, but it isn't any further in the throes of despair than a song like "We Used To Know". That one was my favorite song on Stand Up, and this is kind of like having an entire album of variations on that theme and mood. Which means that each and every song is excellent.

Unfortunately, it also means that it's hard to enjoy from start-to-finish. Every song can please you at one time or another, but there just isn't the kind of variety an album like Stand Up had to entice you to listen from beginning to end. However, on a song for song basis, I might actually say Benefit is BETTER - but I'd give both a 4, because the variety of Stand Up helps its weaker song list.

There are also stronger bonus tracks. The singles which apparently accompanied the album's release are all awesome, particularly the radio staple Teacher and Singing All Day. Like Heavy Horses and Stand Up, I can hardly even imagine Benefit without those bonus tracks. Maybe that makes the rating a little unfair - perhaps a 3.5 would be more accurate, with those tracks removed. But since they were recorded around the same time (the liner notes say 3 weeks before the rest of the album) and keep the vibe going just as if they were meant to be there, I don't feel too bad about using them to contribute to the album's overall higher score.

A really solid album, it isn't exactly quintessential Tull but there's too few weak spots to keep it from rating among their very best. Best song's got to be With You There to Help Me, or, if you want to count the bonus tracks, Teacher.

This third Tull album belongs to their early bluesy period along with This Was and Stand Up. This seems a more polished record than previous ones, with Martin Barre playing really crunchy licks and riffs all around, especially on With You There To Help Me, Nothing To Say (I love this one!) and To Cry You A Song (one of my favourites tunes from the band). There's not a lot of flute from Ian Anderson, but when he shines he really does it well on With You There To Help Me or Inside. This last song is really special, it has something magical on it and the bass lines are wondrous. The more folky tunes are great too, but I prefer the more edgy side of this album where Barre plays louder.

I think this is the best album from the early trilogy and a great place to discover the bluesy and rocking side of Tull.

Peace!

A fine collection of highpoints makes Benefit a worthy Tull release, but not without a few snags; when the band's blend of folk/blues/rock works-- it does so very well, though there are a few misfires in here as well.

The opener, "With You There to Help Me" is an amazing showcase of the classic Jethro Tull sound. A stellar arrangement shows off the group's energy and instrumental skills, with Anderson's dynamic flute effects and Barre's guitar jaming sounding excellent. In fact, Benefit works best when things are cranked up, as in the playful and rockin' "To Cry You a Song", and the killer guitar work on "Play in Time". These songs feature the band's tremendous style uniqueness very well.

Unfortunetly, the follow-up "Nothing to Say" is pretty much self-explanatory. This tune (as well as "Son", and "Time for Everyting") come across as somewhat bland and feel very "stand- alone", in that they don't seem to fit in to any context and tend to be over before ideas have fully developed. While not bad, they come and go with a distinct malaise when compared to the more outstanding tracks.

The good stuff in Benfit is very good, and even the filler is enjoyable. Even so, I didn't make quite as a connection with me as some of the band's other albums; I attribute it to Anderson's vocals and a sort of stand-offish feel to some of the songs. Very near the four star mark, but I was left wanting more.

Songwriting: 3 Instrumental Performances: 3 Lyrics/Vocals: 3 Style/Emotion/Replay: 3

This was the follow up to the album "Stand Up" and it sounds quite different. It's rockier and has more bluesy moments. A lot of proggers seem to love Benefit but I must say that even though I'm a huge JT fan, it's one of my least favourite of thier albums.

There's a new bit of organ and piano here which provide some nice touches to a lot of the songs. You may also notice a few interesting tape-manipulation techniques like backwards flute on the first song "With You There To Help Me" as well as some backward piano and sped up guitar effects on "Play In Time" which sound rather odd and psychedelic.

Highlights for me are probably the more tranquil tracks like "Inside", "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey And Me" and "Sossity You're A Woman".

It is a good album though maybe I'm missing something because it just does't deliver a punch to me as much as the good old previous album! I would rather recommend following albums like Aqualung, Thick As A Brick or most of the other Tull albums from the 70's than this one. 3 stars.

I like Jethro Anderson as well as Jethro Tull. Jethro Anderson was the band who replaced Tull after the first album. Ian Anderson always has a vision, and it's interesting to follow his mad pied piper routine wherever he goes. But Tull it isn't. Having said that, I like this album, Ian almost breaks into songwriting at a couple of points, Cry me a Song has a writer's certainty about it that you don't tend to hear in much else he does. Witches Promise has the structure of a song too, but it's a folk song rather than a pop or rock base.

For me, this was just about the last knockings of a band that echoed the original Tull, from here on in, they went on to other meanderings, sometimes to great effect, sometimes to no good purpose.

But let's face it, Ian Anderson is a National treasure, so let's not knock it all too much. 4 stars, would like to give 3.5 if I could, because it deserves more than a bare 3, but isn't quite an excellent addition.

Review #5 Jethro Tull's 1970 album Benefit.

Benefit was the 3rd album by Tull that I had heard. It was given to me as a present for my 16th birthday. At first it didn't grab me but I will admit after the 5th or 6th play I was hooked.

It is now up there in my top 4 Tull albums of all time and I put it in front of Aqualung (even though I think Aqualung is a five star album as well). You know (i.e. everyone in PA land) the best prog albums are the ones that take a number of listens; and Benefit belongs in that category.

"With You There to Help Me" brings tears to the eyes, a sublime track that introduces John Evan's piano to Tull. An instrument that was not evident on their first 2 albums and the outro dueling between Anderson's flute and Martin Barre's trashing guitar interspersed with rookie Evan's piano make this track an all time favourite. "Nothing to Say" is the most underrated Tull track ever but it's in my Tull top 10 ever....Barre shines.

The Australian release of Benefit, which I first owned omitted "Alive and Well and Living In" (which is found on the UK Benefit) and replaced it with "Teacher". I know Anderson is not too fond of Teacher but this is a Tull track that really demonstrates Anderson's emergence and an innovator of the flute in a rock setting. "Alive and Well and Living In" (was on the Australian "Living In The Past" double LP) is a superb tune.

All the other tracks on Benefit are winners. Just play them a number of times (obviously 5 or 6 times) and see what I mean ........."Son", "Inside", "Play In Time", "To Cry You a Song", "A Time For Everything" and the 2 acoustic numbers "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me" and "Sossity; You're A Woman". Hell, how could anyone give this less than 5 stars?

This is, for me, the best of Jethro Tull, or more accurately, Ian Anderson plus sidemen. Although the original band ended with This Was, that recording wasn't a good enough representation of an excellent band, so Benefit is, to my mind, a dash of the original Jethro laced with the future Anderson band. At times Ian almost breaks into song-writing, Cry me a Song being just about the best of anything he ever wrote (not a performance judgement, please note!). Cornick and Bunker give sterling support, but the guitar of Barre is glaringly competent while devoid of inspiration a la Abrahams. Any defects are quickly made void by Anderson's outstanding arrangements and performance, and the whole thing takes up where Stand Up left off. Thereafter, although interesting at times, the whole project became depressingly formulaic and Captain Anderson ran his ship with a tight helm and three strokes of the lash without the rum.

Less acoustic and less bluesy than the two previous albums, Jethro Tull´s third release shows the band in great form and, finally, reaching a pont where they were able to find their very own sound that we all know and loved. For years I kind of avoided this album because I read in an interview that Ian Anderson didn´t like the record. I really don´t know why he made this statement since I regard nowadays Benefit as one of their best. Ok, this is no Aqualung, Thick As A Brick or even A Passion Play. However, this is a great leap forward if you compare it to both Stand Up (good) and This Was (average).

The sound is definitly more rockier, with Martin Barre finally coming on its own and showing how good he is and how important he was into the making of the jethro Tull sound. This is the fisrt time too that keyboards player John Evans make an appearance on a JT CD, although here he was just a guest. Although the album does not have any epic like Aqualung, nor any really outstanding stuff in the same league as some of the classics they would eventually produce, it´s a great collection of Anderson´s songs and there is no weak track on the whole record, at least as far as I´m concerned. Some parts hint grater things to come (like Nothing To Say). Anderson was really gaining momentum here and his skills as songwriter were maturing fast. The band also was tighter than ever.

I´ve always liked To Cry You A Song, one of the few cuts in this album I´ve known for years, with its terrific riffing and simple, but clever, lyrics.But I really ewnjoyed this CD as a whole. I don´t have the remastered version with the additional bonus tracks, so I can´t comment them. But even my old Chrysalis version has an excellent sound.

Rating: something between 3,5 and 4 stars.

Benefit ? 1970 (3.6/5) 11 ? Best Song: With You There to Help Me As we grow ever closer to the progressive mentality of the early 1970's, we must first take into consideration the mindset which lead to these types of "innovations" ? namely the seriousness and lack of childish play that might?say?appear in your typical blues rock jamming-good album. What do the boys of JT do? The perforate their performances, sapping as much of the overt joviality and replacing it with a more serious, hard knocks stiffness. It doesn't make for a lesser experience, it's just a change, you see. They've gone through yet another guitar player (holy bajessus, it was Tony Iommi being replaced. Maybe he was so upset at losing out on the great Jethro Tull gravy train he decided to make really angry, aggressive music in Black Sabbath, or maybe he just liked that to begin with) and in came the mainstay Martin Barre, who is by all rights my favorite of the three. He turns your typical pseudo-serious thought rocker 'With You There to Help Me' into a minor epic. I do love how his ripping tone will crash in between the watery flute. You might ask yourself, this being the third 11 in a row, when will the band be picking things up and rocking the world? Well, it's a slow process god damn it. And, to be honest, this is a really high eleven. It's almost a 12, it's so damn fine. My only problem is how the songs don't retain either the energy or diversity of the two previous releases (remaining formally content with a softer pop 'march'). That may be true, which is why I say that Benefit is the third slice of 1960's pie they finally had to shake loose frm their system before moving forward ? that of lush pop (not that this music is LUSH, but it is moreso than Stand Up). That makes the album their prettiest so far. It's not bad!

Jethro Tull spent their first album ensnared in a conflict between Ian Anderson and original guitarist Mick Abrahams over the musical direction of the band, and then with Abrahams leaving and Martin Barre installed firmly in place spent their second album reacting against the Abrahams-inspired bluesy hard rock edge of their debut.

Benefit further tones down the blues influences, but feels able to crank the rock back up whilst keeping folk influences intact, as the band continue their meanderings and begin to hit on a new sense of purpose. The direction which would flower fully on Aqualung begins to become apparent here, on what is arguably the first album to really hit on the "classic" Jethro Tull sound. Benefit both closes the band's early chapter and sets the tone for what would follow, and is worth a listen for any Tull fan, even if some of the material here can sound a little straightforward if you are used to the Tull of Aqualung, Thick As a Brick, or A Passion Play.

Jethro Tull's first masterpiece and my personal favourite from them, 'Benefit' is a brilliantly written, performed and produced record. There isn't a single song here which stands out, meaning that this album alone could be a 'best of' compilation (similar to their next two records).

Great songwriting, Ian Anderson once again proving that his flute is much more than a gimmick (despite the fact that there is noticeably less fluting on this album than on 'Stand Up', one can hear much improvement in Ian's flute sound), Martin Barre's mind-blowing Les Paul tone (which is just waiting for 'Aqualung' so it can pulverise the casual ear-dropper), Glenn Cornick's melodic and soft-sounding bass (which is important enough to mention, as both Jeffrey Hammond-Hammond and John Glascock would play with a pick and sport a much harder sound), Clive Bunker's jazzy shuffling and, finally, the first appearance of John Evan on a Tull record, who perfectly fits his piano into the band's sound.

As I said before, the songs presented here are perfectly balanced and, in my opinion, feature some of Ian Anderson's best lyrics (which is indeed saying much, as I'm yet to hear him write a bad lyric). Also, my two favourite Tull songs are on this album, the mentioned being 'To Cry You A Song' and 'Inside', but, again, every track on this album is a classic.

Some bands would dream of having a record like this, but Jethro Tull went on to show that they can do just as well, if not better than this on following releases.

Few albums better encapsulate the sound of 1970 better than Benefit. Plenty of bands were embracing a folkish sound while others were veering towards harder edged rock at this time, and Jethro Tull at this point somehow managed to toe the line between both with this offering. It's darker and has more guitar oomph than previous releases, yet still retains plenty of folk melodies while moving away from their bluesier roots. And yes, some of these songs are just damn cool.

"With You There To Help Me" is a great opener that sets the mood; it's haunting at first and more on the acoustic side of things until that electric guitar kicks in to tell us the band means business. The crescendos utilizing the flute before quick angry guitar wails are memorable elements to this song as well. Definitely one of my favorites by the band in general.

There are plenty of other good tracks that vary between folk and rock such as the killer riffing in "To Cry You A Song" and "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me" with its 'sing-along with a beer stein' chorus after the more folky verses. I can't give it the masterpiece status because I have to admit that a couple of the tunes don't really work for me, basically "Son" which has an awkward shift that doesn't work and "A Time For Everything" which is ok but has this terrible feedback moment that screws things up.

As a whole though, despite Benefit not getting quite the same recognition as the two albums sandwiching it, I actually prefer it to either of them. Stand Up and Aqualung both have some of their best songs, but I find Benefit a more consistent record, and probably my go-to record when I'm in the mood for some classic era Jethro Tull. Thick As A Brick is their best, but I have to be in the right setting for that listening experience, whereas this puppy can be played at any time.

The beginning of greatness...

Ian Anderson was able to stretch his versatile creativity on "Benefit" and the production quality improved dramatically. He has an uproarious time on flute and acoustic guitar. Martin Barre is dynamic on lead guitar churning out one brilliant riff after another. Clive Bunker on percussion along with Glenn Cornick on bass provide the driving rhythm. This is perhaps the finest album with this line up. The guest musician John Evans provides a wonderful piano accompaniment. Anderson is excellent on flute and his vocals are full of theatricality and vigour.

Many of the tracks became part of Tull folklore and appeared frequently on concert set lists. Highlights include 'With You There to Help Me' with the flute and baritone vocals along with Barre's wizardry on guitar. 'To Cry You a Song' became a Tull classic over the years with its powerful guitar and strong melodies, it drips with folk nuances and blues guitar. The heavy guitar work of Barre is a key element and he really gives it a work out on this master work. 'Teacher' is a beautiful song with frenetic flute playing and soulful vocals. Once again the track became a favourite and can be found on most compilations.

"Benefit" is definitely the beginning of greatness for Tull when the magic came together and it paved the way for the classic masterpieces to come.

3.5 for sure

Benefit saw the light in april 1970 and is the third album of this famous band named Jethro Tull. While I prefer the previous effort Stand up, this is almost constructed on same attitude and characteristics as before, but aswell is more rockier the Stand up in places. This is a good JT album, no doubt , but to my ears is less convinceing then anything they release after untill 1982 and less exciting then Stand up. Some excellent pieces like With You There To Help Me and For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me, the rest are also good but not fantastic. The rhytmic section is solid as always on every JT album, but the arrangements suffers little bit of consistency IMO. Aswell this is the first album where appers as guest John Even, keybordist and organist, he will become full time member untill 1980. His contribution to the JT sound is importand, with each album JT sounded more progressive and less bluesy like on first three albums. This hard folk prog album has enough pleasent moments to say that is a fairly good JT album, but to me is not among their excellent albums. 3 stars rounded to 3.5 in places.

Benefit stands now and will always stand (up!) as one of my favorite albums of Jethro Tull. Its absolutely dark, sober and strangely escapist. Probably one of the best first songs that set the mood for the entire album may be found here. "With you there to help me", with introspective lyrics that are agravated by the reverted piano and flute, made you know exactly what will follow in the next 40min.

Benefit's flaw may be its lenght with the lack of variety, as Stand Up clearly has. But there are so great moments in individual songs that, by the time you get to "Socity you're a woman", you feel completely rewarded.

A good glass of wine or whisky, sitting alone somewhere watching the rain is probably the best way to hear this album. A good adition to anyones library.

Third JETHRO TULL album and their definitive affirmation as great progressive band ! While in " Stand Up" the Anderson's and company music still clearly influenced to jazz and the electric blues scenery and show a more heavy approach in their sound due to the introduction of Martin Barr''s guitars. In "Bennefit" they taken a more lyrical or bucolic direction. This become evident already in the First track " With You There To Help Me" (in my opinion one of the best Tull songs) the Anderson's flute sounds leading the audience to a "enchanted forest" where the flute seems imitates a "glow worm" flight. Another track with a special feature is the track 3 "Inside" with the Cornick's interesting bass arrangement which make the song "spins". The track 6 "To Cry You A Song " have a strong "riff" and is other classic Tull song. The album presents other grea tracks like, "Teacher" and "Nothing to Say" which are also detachable. In my vision in Tull's discography "Songs From The Wood" is the more close album in style in relationship with this one. My rate is 5 stars !!!

I really did not enjoy this album, way back when, when I first got hold of it. Today I still don't like the album opener "With you there to help me" at all - it rings very dischordantly on my eardrums and I don't like the way the flute is used through the track. "Nothing to Say" is mundane for me - the name of the track says it all for me and it gets very monotonous. "Inside" is a track that doesn't do anything for me whatsoever and for me it just goes on and on. "Son", to my ears is purely noise. "For Michael Collins.........." is the first track on the album that I enjoy and I like it a lot. "To Cry You a Song" doesn't send me screaming from the room however I wouldn't rush to put it on a compliation cd of my favorite tracks. "A Time for Everything" to me sounds like just about every other preceding track - that's my problem with this album I think, I find it too repetitive and too monotonous. "Teacher" is much much better - very good track for me and one that I would put into a self made Jethro Tull compilation. "Play in Time" is another that I enjoy. "Sossity......" is a good closer to the album. I enjoy four tracks from the album but I can't bring myself to want to listen to the others again. I know that there are many who love this album so I'm not going to insult it - it obviously has a lot of worth. From me a three star rating due to the tracks that I do enjoy and due to the fact that there must be something that I missed however I personally won't be looking for what that may have been.

Maybe not an abrupt turn of styles, but to follow STAND UP with the gut check of BENEFIT will feel a little weird to those following Jethro Tull in some chronological order. BENEFIT is very much a hard rock album nearing proto-metal many times, probably a byproduct of Martin Barre getting comfortable as the de facto electric guitarist of the band. Speaking of comfortable, the lineup of the band technically didn't change between STAND UP and BENEFIT; while long time organist John Evan first showed up here, I believe Evan's role here was mostly on a session basis.

You could call this a precursor to AQUALUNG in many ways as it has those album's characteristics without an overlapping narrative. To be honest, I get a lot more enjoyment from BENEFIT than AQUALUNG, maybe because the songs here are more unpolished of gems even if many Tull fans hold this album in high regard.

Other than bits and pieces scattered throughout the album, the acoustic bits are kept to slightly more than marginal. Granted ''Sossity'' and ''Michael Collins'' are very acoustic based, but the meat of the matter is in the harder rocking tracks and how it sounds like if Tony Iommi did rub off on Ian Anderson's composing style (Iommi was a brief member of the band in earlier days). ''Son'' is just face-tearing with a stomping riff, as is ''Inside''. It's also how well the riffs segue from one to the next that warrant a sense of stability in songs. ''Inside'' plays with the notion very well and can keep you guessing the whole song.

Other strong highlights come in many forms. We have rock songs beefed up with Anderson's signature flute playing that give a sense of unorthodoxy (''Alive and Well and Living In'', ''Play in Time''), songs with excellent solo opportunities (''Nothing to Say'', ''To Cry You a Song''), and the overall highlight in ''With You There to Help Me'', a song that keeps the listener on the edge of their seat with well-executed and quick dynamic shifts.

BENEFIT ''benefits'' (BOO!) from not having as much wear on it as some of its neighbouring albums. If you're a prog rock fan looking for more bite, BENEFIT is waiting.

Benefit was the hardest Jethro Tull album for me. Hardest to find, and hardest to get into the music. I have really never felt difficulty to understand Jethro Tull albums. But I haven't got anything from this album until "To Cry You A Song". After this amazing song, the remaining tracks sounded different and a way better. So I noticed that there was something more hided into this work. So I listened to the whole album again. And again. Finally I found the magic behind it. Jethro Tull (or maybe Ian Anderson?) was reaching the maturity, and the songwriting is brilliant. Almost a masterpiece.

This is one of the most interesting JT album for me. The genre involved is Prog Folk rock: they have such a typical guitar and keyboards sound which very few other bands can imitate. The Ian Anderson's lead vocals are really outstanding. The songs are catchy and rather loaded. Listen to the drums and bass: they are delightful! Martin Barre put various unforgetable moments in the album. The Flute and keyboards brilliantly embellish the overall sound and textures; everything form a solid ensemble which is often characterized by melodic & instrumental structures. If you like early Camel, then you'll like this record. It is not like Thick as a brick but it is something else... Rating: 3 stars

Jethro Tull, eh? The band that rose from blues origins and went through rapid change and progression, heading straight into legend with a string of mostly genial albums in the 70's? Yes, that's the one. Jethro Tull's debut was anything but classic blues, displaying a wide variety of influences and progression. What they created on This was was in fact an outstanding display of vision. A great album, really. Then the progression went even further on Stand up, in order to reach a sort of pre-progressive/proto-progressive zenith on Benefit.

For a long time I thought Benefit was the best of the lot, even surpassing Aqualung. This was before I discovered A passion play and Thick as a brick. Both of those surpassing Aqualung in quality. My stab at being controversial ends there. I think Aqualung comes in as number three in the ranking of Tull's albums. Anyway, I am rambling as usual. I thought Benefit was the greatest, yes. That's it. My mind has changed since then. Benefit is a marvellous album, really it is. It still is and probably always will. At least I hope so.

When i listen to it nowadays i think I am, in part, struck by nostalgia but foremost I find that this album displays a lot of what Tull stands for. Their standpoint is one of blues, hard rock, folk and classical elements, all poured into that great musical blender and served as a cocktail of unspeakable originality. However, I think that Benefit for the most part lingers back in the progressive blues territory, albeit with several feet in their progressive future. The songs are folky, hard rocking at times and we are served a slice or two of classical cake. That is all very well and the result is very nice. I do think, however, that the album is slightly less genial than I once perceived. If I was to suggest an album to start off with I would, most likely, recommend some later album. Aqualung, I guess.

As a Tull-head, and having been one for over 20 years, I find a lot to love on Benefit and I still think it is one of my favorite albums. Not because I think it is the best work they made, simply because it is a wonderfully charming album, conquering musical territory back in the day. If you are into Tull, this is a great album. If you are about to discover them, go for Aqualung or Thick as a brick.

Conclusion: 3 stars, given with love and affection.

Jethro Tull go (somewhat) mainstream and they produce gold! Let's see what they did track-by-track

With You There To Help Me: A sensitive song, with a desperate verse and a powerful chorus that convinces you our hero will finally make it, because he believes! A much better song than most people think, has layers to decode.

Nothing To Say: Fantastic pop-oriented ballad, with a great riff and unforgettable vocal lines by Anderson. Could have become a radio hit if times were different. Classic!

Alive And Well And Living In: Very versatile song, skillful and entertaining, with simple but meaningful lyrics. You wanna play it again to know it better, since it's only 2:47 long. They were on fire in this album!

Son: What an idea! Bombastic riff, unusual vocal lines, "calm" section in the middle... A father-son dialog with deep social messages, progressive and all, in under 3 minutes. Anderson's talent is hard to realize, even after all those 50 years. A true giant.

For Michael Collins, Jeffrey And Me: Progressive pop is the best term I can think of this one. A beautiful song, with a variety of melodies and personal lyrics. The acoustic guitar riff reminds me of the "Friends" main theme, as it's basically the same riff with some double notes. A very interesting song.

To Cry You A Song: My favorite song of the album. Instantly classic riff, hard rock core, the best guitar work by Martin Barre in the entire album, super radio-friendly even though it's 6 minutes long (they feel like 3).

A Time For Everything: My God, what an album this has been! This one is another song with a splendid riff, catchy vocals, and a perfect duration for air play. The lyrics are surprising, since they are written through the eyes of a middle aged man that sings about his lost opportunities. Anderson was only 23 y.o. at the time!

Inside: The first not-so-special song of the album. Kinda repetitive and uninspired, they should cut this out and put in "Teacher" instead (released as a single at the time, a great song).

Play In Time: An OK song, but nothing significant. Compared to the other superb songs of the album, it fades easily.

Sossity: You're A Woman: Poetry. Fantastic lyrics, sensitive melody, yet again very interesting vocal lines, and trippy folk music that would be fully explored some years later on Minstrel in the Gallery. A beautiful ending for a monumental album.

RATING: Maybe the most underrated JT album. It's quality is elusive, with only two songs out of ten being less than very good. 3 or 4 songs can be easily included to a Best Of JT compilation any given time. Totally 4,5 stars by me, have to go with 4.

For the first of JETHRO TULL's string of platinum selling albums, "Benefit" tends to be glossed over if not ignored outright, but this has as much to do with the impact of "Aqualung" and "Thick as a Brick" as anything. As those behemoths rocked the sales charts and their tours were greeted feverishly, it was easy to forget where their sound originated, in this collection of folk and psych influenced hard rock that seems to constitute Ian Anderson's only significant nod to the singer songwriter era. This is especially notable in the two brilliant opening numbers, with their idealism meets cynicism within Anderson's typically oblique subject matter. The lilting "Sossity you're a woman" is a template for the best that SHAWN PHILLIPS could muster, and the intriguing "Inside" lyrically and melodically slots in just to the cryptic side of GORDON LIGHTFOOT's socially conscious work of that period. Even the vocal style and placement in the mix seem orchestrated so that the words can be heard if not understood. I can't say I got this vibe from subsequent TULL releases, and I've never heard anyone mention this before, so I thought I would include it as justification for yet another review.

Musically, "Benefit" established the interplay of dreamy and aggressive woodwinds with riffs that defined the era, and keyboards and acoustic guitars that reinforced the often breathtaking melodic basis of the songs. "With you there to help me" and "Nothing to say" are too powerful a one two punch to set things up, and, while the rest may not quite measure up, "To Cry you a Song" comes close, its main guitar figure preparing us for "Cross Eyed Mary" and its ilk, and its lead solo presaging the more succinct phrasings of "Aqualung". "Teacher" is another master statement with an invigorating shift in the verse structure and more flute in a heavy rock setting.

Unfortunately, the album suffers from two weaknesses that would permeate most TULL releases: an over-reliance on Anderson's voice, one that should be savored in short sips rather than furtive gulps, and a tendency to include mediocre plod rock material, some probably in service of appealing to the straggling blues fans, but perhaps just as symptomatic as Anderson being too eclectic for his own good. I'm going to give them the benefit of the doubt and round up to 4 stars.

1970 marks a release of "Benefit" - one of the most important albums in Jethro Tull's catalog. "Why?" you might ask. Well, this is because of a crucial transition from blues rock based music to "braving the new world." The group found themselves a folk-inspired scenario. With a very English, Charles Dickens-esque element, even on pieces with strains of their original blues style, which obviously couldn't get rid of all at once. This creates a fascinating, fresh sound of a band finding its path. Furthermore, John Evan, a keyboard player guested on the album, introducing a strong classical music influence.

The highlights of the album are the moody "Teacher" and "With You There To Help Me." The last one in particular shows a strong folk music influence that would later be shaped into songs like "Cross-Eyed Mary". Martin Barre's bluesy guitar tone is still present and it definitely integrates well with the path taken by the band.

Albeit still not as exciting as the albums that are to in the following years, this album is a very important work and it is recommended to prog fans!

Coming off a 30 week tour of the US with bands like Led Zeppelin, Grand Funk Railroad, Creedence Clearwater and even Blood, Sweat & Tears and with constant pressures from the record company to engage in incessant radio interviews following the success of 'Stand Up,' Ian Anderson returned back to his native England and began writing new material for the third JETHRO TULL album BENEFIT. After the grueling touring schedule Anderson states that this album is much darker as a result of his cynicism with his frustration with the music industry. This album also develops the band's sound to the more classic period with the addition of classically trained keyboardist John Evan who added a new element to that band that kept the melody churning allowing Martin Barre the luxury to focus on his famous monophonic riffs and guitar solos instead of being limited to merely strumming chords and this is the point is where all the elements stack up side by side to create that instantly recognizable JETHRO TULL sound. While Evan's intent was to join on a temporary basis, things worked out so well that he stuck around for ten whole years.

BENEFIT continues the folk elements with strong songwriting, addictive melodic developments and the beautiful poetic adroit vocal suaveness of Ian Anderson's vocal style accompanied by his signature flute fills, however the addition of the keys and Barre's new freedom to expand his guitar duties make this a much harder rocking album than 'Stand Up.' A whole new layer has debuted here adding to an already rich tapestry of sounds. The band expands these elements with ease. They figured out right from the start how to meld all the folk and rock elements together in a seamless manner and alternate the soft passages with the harder edged ones. There is not a bad song on this one and this is actually one of my favorite JT albums. Starting with the very first echoing flute sounds that begin the album, Anderson kicks off the album with his saturnine singing style and the melodies unfold with addictive verses and chorus' that flow together so flawlessly with bridges and unexpected yet pleasing transitions. I have always considered Ian Anderson to be one of the best songwriters out there and on these early albums he just shines like the brightest supernova in the distant universe.

Because record companies were totally evil back then (or are they still?), they decided to complicate things and there were two versions of the album. The usual one for the UK and one for the US. While not as ridiculously complex as Beatles or Rolling Stones album, the UK version contains the track 'Alive And Well And Living In' whereas the US version doesn't but rather has the track 'Teacher' and vice versa. Luckily the remastered CD version has the whole kit and caboodle and bonus tracks to boot. BENEFIT is just bereft of any flaws in my opinion. Every track just hooks the listener and takes you to that special JT universe where you can escape into the seductive song structures where guitar riffs conjure up your inner rowdy rocker while the calming keys and flute solos take you on a folky sojourn through the pastoral lands of rural England. BENEFIT is a strong album that has been perhaps one of the most listened to on my playing list. This album may be written off by some as a mere practice session for the even better albums like 'Aqualung' and 'Thick As A Brick' which were just around the corner and true this doesn't quite hit high on the progometer quite yet, but the melodies, musicianship and strong performances make this one a very slick and savvy listen nonetheless. Just as enjoyable as the classics that follow IMHO. 4.5 rounded UP!

Before Jethro Tull had truly hit the mainstream with "Aqualung" and "Thick As A Brick", there came "Benefit".

There's really not a whole lot to say about this album, since not a whole lot goes in within. At its core, what we have here is a blues rock album with folky acoustic sections. No more, no less. This isn't a progressive rock album by any means. There are no virtuosic pyrotechnics, no elaborate song structures, no Khatrus or foxes on the rocks to be found. This isn't an inherently bad thing, of course.

That being said, there's more to my lackluster perception of "Benefit" than just its complexity. After all, some of my favourite albums are very minimalistic or compositionally simple. The thing with "Benefit" is that it just doesn't really gel into anything that flows. The music is very riff-based, with plenty of power chords chunking their way along, sometimes interspersed by uninspired flute flourishes. Ian Anderson's drab vocals don't help, failing to add any extra colour to an already dreary palette.

Having said that, the album isn't a total write-off. There are some really good songs on it, notably the dark, Whipping Post-like "With You There To Help Me" and the more spirited "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me". So while some of the songs are enjoyable to listen to in isolation, this isn't really an album to be experienced 40 minutes at a time.

As such, I'll give "Benefit" a 2 star rating, since I believe it's a record that established Jethro Tull fans will really dig. But if you have only a passing interest in their later works, there's no real reason to listen to this.

'Benefit' was the 3rd album by Jethro Tull, released between 'Stand Up' and 'Aqualung'. The band considered this one a lot easier to make than 'Stand Up' because it was more a product of the record company demanding an album and the band members didn't have the freedom they had with 'Stand Up'. Ian Anderson also said it was a dark album because of their frustration with the heavy schedule of touring and frustration with the music business. It also was the first album to feature John Evan on keyboard who Anderson said was so much better to work with and gave him more freedom to do what he wanted. Evan, at the time of recording, was only a session musician, but would become a regular member afterwards.

This is more of a hard rock oriented album than a progressive album as they hadn't quite established that sound yet. It was released at the same time that so many riff oriented artists were releasing albums, thus, to follow suit, Anderson also considers this a riff-oriented album. It definitely is more guitar oriented and based off simpler rock riff than what their later albums would be, but it also shows a natural movement towards the more folk and progressive side. It also shows a more natural progression towards the upcoming and ever popular 'Aqualung' album to come.

It starts out with 'With You There to Help Me' and with an echoing flute and a folk-ish lilt, you can hear the beginning of the sound that they would become famous for. There are also hints of the progressive music to come with non-standard chord changes aplenty. The song stays in the folk feel but with occasional bursts of guitar throughout. There is a nice call and answer section at the extended instrumental ending between flute and guitar that make things interesting.

'Nothing to Say' starts with a weaker guitar riff, but the vocal melody is decent enough. It's in this track that the weakness of the album starts to show through. The music just doesn't have the flair of the previous track and is not very memorable. 'Alive and Well and Living In' is more acoustical guitar and piano with bursts of flute and electric guitar. 'Son' is heavier with a more complex melody, but this fades strangely enough and is taken over by an acoustic section and then returns to the original heaviness. 'For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me' is also mostly acoustic with a softer and folkier feel and a meter that changes alternatively from one section to another.

'To Cry You a Song' returns to music based on a few heavy riffs. It features processed vocals. It is a little closer to a progressive song with some nice hooks, but it seems as if it's missing any soul or emotion, almost clinical. It could have been a much better song with a little more work, but it was probably rushed. 'A Time for Everything?' sounds too much like the track before it, except for a little more flute, but at least it's a bit shorter. 'Inside' is a bit better, based off of a repeating flute riff and a nice and memorable folk melody. 'Play in Time' is a toe tapping flute and electric guitar riff playing together with a great rock feel. There are some interesting textures that seem to be achieved by backward recording that gives it a psychedelic flavor.

Last of all, at least on the original release, is 'Sossity; You're a Woman'. It starts as a nice acoustic tune with a baroque feel. It's a perfect song to close the album with the nice acoustic feel all the way through.

The 2001 CD reissue added 4 more tracks that were b-sides and outtakes to this that help to flesh out the album a bit more. 'Singing All Day' is a great, yet simple song that I feel would have made the perfect single. 'Witch's Promise' is also acoustic with a flourishing flute and a more complex melody than the previous one. It utilizes a mellotron later on in the track. This was a non-album single. The third bonus track is a short little ditty called 'Just Trying To Be'. Last of all it the UK mix of 'Teacher' which was substituted (in a slightly different mix) for 'Alive and Well and Living In' on the US release of the original album. It is has a theme that is somewhat familiar in the states.

This album is good, with a few great highlights in 'Sossity' and 'With You There to Help Me', and it works well as a bridge between the albums that came before and after, and it has some echoes of where the band would go after this, but it still doesn't come close to the brilliance of 'Aqualung' and isn't quite as well thought out as 'Stand Up'. But it shows a band in flux and under the influence of the music industry. Fortunately, the next album 'Aqualung' would prove to be the first album to really put the band into the spotlight in a great way.

There is a tendency to underrate LPs sandwiched between two landmark, universally acclaimed albums. The most jarring example - as far as I'm concerned - is Deep Purple's "Fireball", often forgotten classic of Mark II lineup, mostly because it happened after "In Rock" (a truly groundbreaking affair) and was followed with "Machine Head" (no introduction is needed). "Fireball" contains lots of goodies as well, but they quickly disappeared from concert setlists, being replaced with "Lazy", "Space Truckin'", "Highway Star" and other hits.

"Benefit" suffers a similar fate, to a lesser degree.

Everyone and their mother loves accessibility, variety and fresh arrangements of "Stand Up", and I can see why. Then we have "Aqualung", album so good (and popular) that even casuals give it a spin on the regular. But "Benefit" is much darker. "Benefit" gets rid of the flute, in large part. "Benefit" comes forward with crunchy guitars, cloudy lyrics, stormy vocals and a pinch of psychedelia. And for some reason it's not clicking with all fans.

Or maybe there is no beef with the esthetics, but rather quality of particular songs?

I must admit some pieces aren't really 5-star material. But as I understand five stars on Progarchives - that should be reserved for uncanny masterpieces, music so good it gives you goosebumps and makes you wonder how a bunch of 20-year olds came up with such a marvel. "Benefit" has those moments, too, but often it's just a Very Good stuff. And neither "very good" or "great" are enough for the promised land of five star ratings.

There isn't much room for improvement though. "To Cry You a Song" has one of the hookiest riffs in Jethro's catalogue, prominent bassline and Ian's youthful, belligerent delivery. Bridge at 1:45 could pass as "Aqualung" sessions material, the same could be said about guitarwork at 4:00 minute mark - decent stuff, no doubts. But I think this particular song would benefit (heh) from cutting off the last minute and introducing edgier, more meaty distortion. When it comes to guitar sound, I think Martin could've done a better job on "Son", which is a bit fuzzy and incoherent. But I like how it changes moods from Cream-inspired, brash rocking to dreamy acoustic madrigal in the vein of George Harrison.

I consider these two songs the album's lowpoints. And they're still good. "Benefit" has a very high floor, let me tell you.

I delved into Ian's vocals before and must say I applaud how he sings with chagrin and a bit of angst. "With You There to Help Me" shifts back and forth between broody and rebellious vocal tones, beautifully enhancing the band's behind. Although it takes more than six minutes, I'm enjoying every second - the moody intro on piano, flute echoes (wandering somewhere in the woods, I feel), touches of acoustic guitar, intensifying hand clapping and escalating storm in coda - as if it was a rainmaking ritual. A terrific, progressive piece. "Nothing to Say" evokes similar moods - John Evan's inclusion works wonders, especially when the band's shooting for dramatic effect. Anderson's wailing fits like a glove here.

Don't get me wrong, "Benefit" isn't all doom and gloom. "Alive and Well and Living In" is more upbeat, utilising flutes in small doses, just to give it more carefree, airy attitude. If I were to find a comparison, I'd say this one sounds just like the woody album cover, instrumental outro at 1:50 in particular. So tasteful and relaxing. "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me" ends the 'Jeffrey Trilogy' on a joyful note, at least once the main theme kicks in. One of those tunes staying in your head all day long.

In my opinion "Benefit" truly shines on B side. "A Time for Everything" is so ballsy yet romantic, the flute sounds triumphant and very inspiring - I could listen to it twice in a row and stay pumped up. "Inside" is another short, but fantastic tune with great doses of "feelgood", enough to share with whole neighborhood. That's what Jethro Tull does to you with flowery arrangements and catchy melodies, cheers you up for good!

"Play in Time" might just be my favorite song here, starting with tight, bluesy riffing, but quickly branching into psychedelia with twisted tape loops from the Wonderland ("Tomorrow Never Knows" breed) and Mad Hatter fluting his brains off. Spiritual antecedent of "A Passion Play", if you will. Looking for analogies, "Sossity You're a Woman" is an acoustic ballad with emphatic storytelling and ardent, folksy chorus sung by an antihero... much like "My God" and parts of "Minstrel in the Gallery". Another win, in my book.

I think "Benefit" was a necessary stepping stone towards prog rock of the seventies. While it doesn't have the epic scope of "Thick as a Brick" or mind-boggling variety of "Aqualung", it introduces more advanced composition and changing moods within a song. Perhaps Jethro Tull wanted to prove they can write accomplished music without aid of mandolins and balalaika "trickery"? Anyhow, the band should be applauded for progressive approach, especially that recording sessions began in September 1969, even before ITCOTCK was released. There is no weak song here, and some of its highlights are ridiculously good (opener and B side come to mind). Plenty to choose from really, and I don't mind the darker mood at all - nobody bashes "Minstrel in the Gallery" or "Stormwatch" for ominous atmosphere, and "Benefit" was clearly a forefather of sombre ambience.

Even if we exclude "Teacher", "The Witch's Promise" and other bonus tracks - ALL of them brilliant - we have a surefire 4 star album here. Four and a half, on a good day. Jethro Tull was alive and well and getting ready for a masterpiece, and this album paves the way in a convincing fashion.

Review Nº 259

'Benefit' is the third studio album of Jethro Tull and was released in 1970. There are two versions of the album, the UK edition and the US edition. Both editions have ten tracks. However, the order of the tracks is different on both editions. But, the main difference is that the US version has the track 'Teacher' instead of the track 'Alive And Well And Living In'. 'Benefit' was the album where Jethro Tull solidified their sound around the folk and rock music, abandoning their more blues sound. The album is more hard and rock than their predecessor 'Stand Up'. This is also the album where the band uses tape-manipulation techniques in several tracks, which was unusual on their earlier two studio albums.

'Benefit' represents the second change on the line up of the group. It was the first album of the band including a keyboardist, John Evan. However, he wasn't yet a regular band's member. It was also the last album to include bassist Glenn Cornick, which would be replaced by Jeffrey Hammond-Hammond on their next fourth studio album 'Aqualung'.

So, the line up of the album is Ian Anderson (vocals, guitar and flute), Martin Barre (electric guitar), Glenn Cornick (bass guitar) and Clive Bunker (drums). As I wrote before, John Evans (piano and organ) appears as a guest musician. And as happened on the two previous studio albums, David Palmer made all the orchestral arrangements in 'Benefit', too.

'Benefit' has ten tracks. All songs were written and composed by Ian Anderson. My review is based on the UK version. The first track 'With You There To Help Me' is a very interesting song to open the album, which is at the same time soft and dark. It's also at the same time hard and melodic, making of it a great counterpoint. This is, without any doubt, one of the highest points on the album with many changes in tempo and atmosphere. The second track 'Nothing To Say' is a harmonious, calm and beautiful Jethro Tull's song with a mellow style and with a nice floating singing style by Ian Anderson. It has also a strong backing support of the bass and the drums. The final result is a very cool and enjoyable song to hear. The third track 'Alive And Well And Living In' is one of the three smallest songs on the album. It's a calm and well balanced song where the general instrumental performance is very good. This is a song with a superb tune that we could later hear on the more folk oriented albums of them. The fourth track 'Son' is the second smallest song on the album. It's a very interesting song that switches the tone from hard rock to a soft acoustic guitar tone. This happens because this song represents a sarcastic conversation between father and son. It's a very unconventional song, but we learn to like it after some time. The fifth track 'For Michael Collins, Jeffrey And Me' is really an amazing song. It's a song with great piano, nice acoustic guitar, good bass, beautiful chorus and great singing. This is a song that starts as a mellow folk song, but that suddenly, it rocks. So, this is a song that is balanced between the folk and the rock, which is probably, the main characteristic of the entire album. The sixth track 'To Cry You A Song' is one the best known songs from this musical period and that became a classic on Jethro Tull's live shows. It's an excellent rock song with a great guitar work. This is a must for those who love the harder side of the band. This was also the song who gave its name to the tribute album released by Magna Carta. If you are interested on it, you can read my review on this site, in Various Artists. The seventh track 'A Time For Everything?' is the third smallest song on the album and is a song that brings the flute back into the music and where Martin Barre's guitar dominates the music. This is another great folk tune, totally in the vein of what would be their future on their more folk oriented albums 'Songs From The Wood', 'Heavy Horses' and 'Stormwatch'. The eighth track 'Inside' is an intimate and soft song with some intricate rhythms, a sweet flute playing and a nice and warm voice. It's really a cool, very relaxing and a truly pleasant nice song to hear. The ninth track 'Play In Time' is the weirdest, the most strange and experimental song on the album. It's a song with lots of changes and a great aggressive musical atmosphere. It's a very energetic song with excellent singing and great guitar riffs. This is, in reality, a unique song on the entire album. The tenth and last track 'Sossity; You're A Woman' finishes the album with a beautiful and mellow tune. It's a song with great acoustic guitar playing, good rhythm section and a beautiful voice line. The flute provides also great inserts all over the song. This is a perfect closing to the album.

Conclusion: 'Benefit' is another excellent Jethro Tull's studio album. It's probably less considered because it was released between 'Stand Up' and 'Aqualung' and before the great masterpiece of the group, 'Thick As A Brick'. However, despite isn't as good as 'Stand Up' and 'Aqualung' are, and especially, it isn't as good as 'Thick As A Brick' is, 'Benefit' represents an excellent musical effort of Jethro Tull and is a very solid album. As happened with 'Stand Up', 'Benefit' is also a landmark for the band, because it confirms definitely and firmly the changing of the music direction of the band. It remains a classic Jethro Tull's album and an excellent addition to all decent musical collection.

Prog is my Ferrari. Jem Godfrey (Frost*)

There is no doubt that the first five TULL albums got incrementally better and truer to their strong suits which are melding the folk, rock, and prog elements into one tasty stew. The first proggier elements are evident on Benefit, namely With you there to help me and To cry you a song. While Inside and teacher were or should have been great radio staples. I think Teacher ranks up there with the three big hits from Aqualung. There's not really a weak song here, and Martin Barre's guitar work is much more essential to the overall sound than on Stand up. Even though this but doesn't quite stay with you like the next two, it was a great indication of what was to come in the next 2 years. For some reason it took a little while for me to warm up to this one, not its easily in my top 10. A strong four!

Review #60

JETHRO TULL's third album "Benefit" was the first one to feature John EVAN on piano and organ; of course, he wasn't an official member of the group yet but still, his performance gave the album a more harmonic sound. This was also the last album to feature Glenn CORNICK before he was replaced with Jeffrey HAMMOND.

The songs in this album are in the same vein as "Stand up" (hard rock guitar riffs, powerful drumming, and, of course, the indispensable flute of ANDERSON) but here the Jazz and Blues songs are completely gone and the band's music evolve into the Progressive Rock/Folk sound that they would keep developing in their 70's albums. Songs as "With you there to help me", "Inside", "To cry you a song" and "Nothing to say" had become classics in JETHRO TULL's repertoire.

This is definitely a before and after in their discography.

SONG RATING: With you there to help me, 5 Nothing to say, 5 Alive and well and living in, 4 Son, 4 For Michael Collins, Jeffrey, and me, 4 To cry you a song, 4 A time for everything, 4 Inside, 5 Play in time, 4 Sossity: you're a woman, 4

AVERAGE: 4.3

PERCENTAGE: 86

ALBUM RATING: 4 stars

A secret gem, remaining somewhat absent from some discussions, but a record that deserves rock and prog fanatics' full attention - this is Jethro Tull's third studio release, named 'Benefit' and released in mid-1970, after two really good albums, also continuing the band's streak of releasing something every year. Now, 'Benefit' comes after the pretty decent debut, and the quite solid but still not fully epic 'Stand Up', and it plays its role as a seriously important step in the band's development, but it has to be said that by itself this album is pretty damn excellent! I would even go on to say that there is no 'Aqualung' without 'Benefit' - the five-piece display a tremendous songwriting, more riff-oriented compositions, with sharp and sometimes corky wordsmith by Ian Anderson, all making up for a very well-structured and enjoyable album.

The mixture of their bluesy roots, with the hard rock leanings, is probably the main flavor of the album; the folky bits are also here, of course, as well as the medieval-like phrasing; So, one has all the elements that make up what is for many the essential Jethro Tull sound. This 1970 release is a very straight-to-the-point solid collection of songs, maybe a bit darker than its predecessors, but very elegant and impressive. The guitar playing is the thing that would probably remain in the memory of the listener after a few spins; Martin Barre is exploring more large-sound, heavier riffage, which results in some pretty iconic songs, in my humble opinion. The keyboards are still not very prominent, as 'Benefit' could be more fruitfully classified as a hard rock album, rather than a prog one. Glenn Cornick does some justice on the bass, and Clive Bunker impresses with his fine drumming. Anderson, as usual, is the multi-instrumentalist powerhouse leading Tull to its glorious moments - the man wrote the whole album, except for his vocal, lyrical, and musical contributions.

Several highlights can be found here (or rather, no bad songs are present!), among which one should point out the opening track 'With You There to Help Me', an exploration on friendship, and probably on the power and possibilities of human relationships; 'Alive and Well and Living In' is a shorter and very elegant poetic piece that leads to the crushingly good 'Son', with its almost obnoxious main riff; Then one would hardly miss out on praising 'To Cry You a Song' ? the first really epic J Tull song? Or the melancholic adventure of 'Inside', and the admiration that 'Sossity; You're a Woman' instills, a brilliant way to finish off an excellent album.

Jethro Tull certainly reached new heights with 'Benefit', despite some not so laudable commentaries from critics and fans. It is an album that has a personality, it is a coherent and enjoyable listen, and despite being somewhat of a transitory release for the band, it is a very well-written one, containing some of the most killer songs one will find in any early 70s rock album.

I know a lot of people love this album, but for me, it is somewhat of a step backward from the more unique and progressive Stand Up (1969), as the band has fallen back to a much more standard UK Blues-rock here, without the more innovative approaches and advances made on the previous album. Yes, they are very good at the blues-rock sound and style, but this does not best show their unique style and strengths that would make them a standout rock band. Also, some of the best songs from these sessions were not even included on the album, such as 'Teacher' (which was released as a standalone single) and 'Witch's Promise'. Thus, a very good album overall, but one that did not advance their sound and unique style beyond the blues-rock played by other bands. However, they would make tremendous leap into progressive rock with their next album. Best tracks: Nothing to Say, Alive and Well and Living In, Inside, Sossity You're a Woman. Weaker tracks: Son, A Time For Everything. Rating: 3.5 stars

Their next album, 1970's Benefit, saw Jethro Tull fully divorce themselves from their blues roots and establish the folk-prog/hard rock sound for which they would become best-known. John Evan (née Evans; he dropped the "s" after being told that made him sound more distinctive) sorta, kinda, unofficially joined the band as their keyboardist. He was billed as "guest" on the album sleeve and initially intended to play with Tull only for a year or two. He wound up sticking around for ten.

This is also the only Tull (non-compilation) album to feature different UK and US track listings. The (original) UK version featured "Alive and Well and Living In", a jazzy, piano-driven number. In contrast, the US version featured "Teacher" in its place, a hard-rocking piece which was a successful non-album single in the UK. For my money, I prefer the US track listing. "Teacher" is one of Tull's absolute best songs.

The rest of the album is impressive as well. "Inside" is a jazz-influenced song with a strong melody and striking, fuzzed-out bassline. "Son" is one of Jethro Tull's weirdest songs. It clocks in at under three minutes, but it wildly vacillates between melodic hard rock and strange folk rock led by plinking piano and acoustic guitar.

"For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me" and "Sossity; You're a Woman" see the band further exploring folk-rock. Both open with gentle, acoustic moments and are powered along by somber-yet-effective melodies. The band's hard rock influences also became clearer on this record. Songs like the riff-driven "To Cry You a Song" and the charging "Play in Time" showed Tull's willingness to lean into heavier sounds.

Following Benefit, bassist Glenn Cornick left the band and was replaced by Jeffrey Hammond. (This is the same Jeffrey as mentioned in the songs "A Song for Jeffrey", "Jeffrey Goes to Leicester Square", and "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me". He also occasionally went by Jeffrey Hammond-Hammond, as his mother's maiden name was Hammond.)

The addition of John Evan is what really allowed Jethro Tull to blossom creatively. Ian Anderson credits his joining the band to their continued success.

Review originally posted here: theeliteextremophile.com/2019/07/25/deep-dive-jethro-tull/

After the original and attractive "Stand Up", Jethro Tull releases "Benefit", their third album. Without leaving aside their successful troubadour vein and medieval reminiscences, the band led by Ian Anderson enriches their musical proposal by incorporating tonalities and structures that turn "Benefit" into one of the most hardened works of their discography.

From the initial and persistent "With You There to Help Me" with an acoustic melody that absorbs the guitar onslaught of the very active Martin Barre, engaged in a duel of sharp counterpoints with Anderson's delay flutes, "Benefit" shows the hardest rock side of the band, endorsed by the dense "To Cry You a Song", where the guitarist creates consistent riffs doubled by Glenn Cornick's bass and accompanied by Anderson's megaphonic vocals, and also by the agility of "Play in Time", where again guitar riffs and flutes play as a team and give space to a very interesting and challenging solo by Barre.

On the other hand, that thickened wall of sound that "Benefit" brought with it, is nuanced by the long-suffering "Nothing to Say" and its excellent chorus and acoustic development, but above all by the new textures that the keyboards of guest and later stable member John Evan bring, as in the reflective "Alive and Well and Living In". And both the recurring reference to the flautist's school friend and future band member Jeffrey Hammond on the descriptive and personal "For Michael Collins, Jeffrey and Me", and the neat and beautiful "Sossity: You're a Woman" dominated by Anderson's vocals, flutes and arpeggiated acoustic guitars, drawn from the band's purest and most recognisable folk style, complete the album's instrumental mosaic.

"Benefit" got a little caught and partially overshadowed in the middle of the successful "Stand Up" and the transcendental "Aqualung" and "Thick as a Brick" that followed one after the other, taking the shine off it. Over the years, fortunately, the album has gained value in general consideration until it is recognised today as the very good album that it is.

4 stars