Best Pink Floyd Singer

Roger Waters any day!... thats why Pulse and delicate sound of thunder aren't good, they lack Roger's singing. Of course, nothing beats Waters, Gilmore and Wright sharng vocals between them, like on DSOTM etc. but if any it should be Waters

I was always fond of Rick Wright's singing efforts.

Gilmour without any doubt, his calmed voice is perfect for the atmospheric music that Pink Floyd created.

Roger Waters did a great job also singing his parts.

The guys knew what they did, each one sings in the parts that are better for their voices, but check for example "In the Flesh Live" Roger has to hire Doyle Bramhall II that has a similar range to Dave, because he isn't able to replace Gilmour, but Dave sings most of Floyd songs in his solo albums and with Floyd when Roger left.

Iván

Edited by ivan_2068

What , how can it be that Gilmour has almost 80% of the votes, he has a 'pretty' voice I'll admit, but boring and uninspirering as hell!

Waters is the Pink Floyd vocalist, he suceeds in communicating feelings and emotions through his voice, for instance the way these lines are sung (from Pros and Cons of Hitchhiking) :

The kids caught bronchitis
The space heater ran out of diesel
One weekend a friend from the East
Rot his soul
Stole your heard
I said "f**k it then
Take the kids back to town
Maybe I'll see you around"

No vocalist could have done it better!

and these (from The Wall)

Hey you, out there on the road
Always doing what you're told
Can you help me
Hey you, out there beyond the wall
Breaking bottles in the hall
Can you help me
Hey you, don't tell me there's no hope at all
Together we stand, divided we fall

It sends shivers down my spine!

A vocalist should care very little about perfection and singing it correctly, and only care about deliver vocals with as much emotion and passion as possible!      
  

Syd Barrett

Gilmour is definetely the best.  He has such a great voice, one of the best of all time.  Waters and Wright are not too far behind, both are incredible singers too.  Barret was a decent singer, but just doesn't compare with the others.

Waters and Gilmour are both my favourite singers. I really can't choose between them.

  I voted for David Gilmour

No contest!Gilmour!

How can I vote in this poll if my prefered Floyd vocalist isn't here?

Well, i prefer the Rick Wright's voice... not so sweet-sugar like David, and not so acid-bitter like Roger...