Another 4's: 1974, 1984 and 1994 albums

Mellotron Storm wrote: Logan wrote: ^ It is incredible. By the way, dates do matter to me and for archives it is significant. On a side-note, commonly recorded dates are much more important to me than released dates with many archival releases (not released until much later). I wish we could easily search PA's albums by recorded date (and searching PA albums by year too could be easier and improved too with broader scope -- and I would like to be able to search PA by month of release, or even month and day if that info is available). It's an interesting topic. Do you go by release date or recording date? Gnosis is a site you probably have been on. All their dates are recording dates. So archival stuff goes where it should.

I usually go by released date other than with archival releases, often I try to recognise both. I would like both things to be very visible (like on the main artist discography page) and searchable. I have visited Gnosis, but not for many years except very briefly. I will check it out, thanks.

This site would be incredibly complicated if it was mine with so many features and a lot of redunancy. It might be very ugly. It might be rather like the Homer Simpson designed automobile of music sites.

^ It is incredible.

By the way, dates do matter to me and for archives it is significant. On a side-note, commonly recorded dates are much more important to me than released dates with many archival releases (not released until much later). I wish we could easily search PA's albums by recorded date (and searching PA albums by year too could be easier and improved too with broader scope -- and I would like to be able to search PA by month of release, or even month and day if that info is available).

Edited by Logan - May 26 2025 at 08:03

Regarding Masal, thanks John, I was using the Awesome Prog date since I made my list there. By the way, that was one of my favourite additions I was involved with on the Eclectic team when it was myself and Ricochet. Avestin suggested it as I recall. I used to listen to that album a lot. Anyway, I do have editing rights at AP so I might change the year there later when I can research and firmly establish the date (I have changed quite a few). I would rather it be more wrong at that site by someone else's hands than more right (i.e. closer to the proper date but still wrong) by my hands. The years that matter more still to me are earlier ones like the 60s. Like imagine if we all got it wrong somehow and instead of In the Court of the Crimson King being released in 1969 it was released years earlier... :) What often is more interesting to me than release date is recording date and form looking it up now, Masal was recorded in July of 1982 (that year I do recall for when it was recorded).

I knew you were going outside of your favourites. And like me, we both tend to like to list that which we care about, and with you, what often was in rotation as I recall (an interesting and systematic approach to listening). I sometimes like to do ones not based on my favourites, it can be interesting to figure out how one is going to determine which ones to cover. I have done ones based on charts, or based on the first names to spring to my mind whether I like them or not. I find it fun to come up with different approaches, and experiment a bit, and hopefully do something bit different from any others who have made polls. And it can be nice to know I am not just doing many of the same old names I've covered in polls here many times over the years. I like Yog Sothoth, Bondage Fruit (of course as it's in my list) and Gunesh Emsemble (listened to them the other day) a lot.

Edited by Logan - May 25 2025 at 21:57

On my polls I have been including albums I haven't even heard. This is something I've never done before, always including my favourites only for the most part.
So for 1984 I didn't include my favourites like Yog Sothoth, Rascal Reporters, Gunesh Ensemble, Uppsala and Bandhada. For 1994 Landberk, Par Lindh Project, Bondage Fruit, Psychotic Waltz and Purple Overdose.

Lewian wrote: Saperlipopette! wrote: ^No one's gonna shoot you down for not enjoying Hatfield. You never struck me as someone who was into the Jazz Rock-fusion sound from the Canterbury Scene anyway, so its hardly surprising. I'm actually into this kind of thing, yet find Hatfield strangely unappealing (given how much I love for example National Health).

That's ok too:). I love them, but I do prefer The Rotter's Club.

Saperlipopette! wrote: ^No one's gonna shoot you down for not enjoying Hatfield. You never struck me as someone who was into the Jazz Rock-fusion sound from the Canterbury Scene anyway, so its hardly surprising.

I'm actually into this kind of thing, yet find Hatfield strangely unappealing (given how much I love for example National Health).

Red

TD > KC > Hamill is all I can really vote for here...

I know I'm going to be shot down when I say this, but I really have tried Hatfield, I've really wanted to like it, but it doesn't do much for me...

I appreciate the inclusion of Janko Nilović. His output is often criminally overlooked.

King Crimson: Red

Greg, much to like in 1974 in both the Fusion and Prog world, but obviously our tastes diverge on what those are.


Edited by Big Sky - May 24 2025 at 17:50