Harrison vs Wright, vocals

silverpot wrote: jude111 wrote: Who was the keyboardist in the Beatles (besides session players)? McCartney? If we're going to be fair, shouldn't Wright be going up against McCartney as a keyboardist? :-) Anyway, I went with Harrison, I love his voice. If there's a poll about keyboard players, I'd go with Wright. I think George Martin did most of the keyboard playing actually. Either way, Wright would easily get my vote on that one.When it comes to singing though, I prefer Harrison.

I tried to pair each member from each band on every instrument, and on vocals I tried to pair the members from each band who felt to me that fulfilled the same roll. I would have liked to put Wright on keyboard vs someone from The Beatles... but I just didn't even know if there was a keyboard player as such on The Beatles that would suitably go against Wright (I guess keyboards for The Beatles was more of a "session player" thing). However, if anyone thinks there's a suitable keyboard player on The Beatles, I would be more than happy to see the poll done too. As well, I didn't find a suitable member on Pink Floyd to put as a vocalist against Ringo Starr.

^That's Gilmour, not Wright.