Forum Home Forum Home > Other music related lounges > General Music Discussions
  New Posts New Posts
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Events   Register Register  Login Login

A New Topic to Share Our Music Reviews

 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <123>
Author
Message
Fercandio46 View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer
Avatar
Jazz Rock / Fusion Team

Joined: September 06 2023
Location: Argentina
Status: Online
Points: 5764
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Fercandio46 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 28 2026 at 10:30
Originally posted by Logan Logan wrote:



On another note, I enjoyed Fernando's review of Marius Popp's Panoramic JazzRock that followed mine on the front page. It's an album I've treasured for years after a PA poster recommended it to me -- "Inscriptie" in particular is an all-time favourite track. It's wonderful to see it in the archives. The Breaking the Waves mention was great too -- I love that film and saw it in the cinema.




I’m glad you liked it, Greg! I noticed that you had added that particular album to AP years ago. Given the political turmoil Eastern Europe has experienced over the last few decades, the sacrifices made by its musicians are even greater—to the point where the very act of being able to record consistently takes on an almost epic, heroic quality.

That is why, for me, these albums are doubly valuable—not to mention the undeniable talent behind them. Many go unnoticed, yet they stand on par with the very best and possess great originality, as they are the product of different life experiences and cultural sensibilities.

As for Lars von Trier, that particular analogy fits perfectly with the album of Marius Popp. His films never leave anyone indifferent; they are quite an experience. I still remember Antichrist!

The story of the German pianist Klaus Lenz (who is already featured on Progarchives) is equally moving—not to mention his exciting approach to fusion, showcased alongside his powerful big band.

https://www.progarchives.com/artist.asp?id=13496

Edited by Fercandio46 - October 28 2026 at 10:37
"A good beginning and a good ending make a good movie, as long as they are close together." Federico Fellini
Back to Top
jamesbaldwin View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer
Avatar

Joined: September 25 2015
Location: Milano
Status: Offline
Points: 6531
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote jamesbaldwin Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 28 2026 at 16:07
Originally posted by Logan Logan wrote:

Earlier today I wrote a short "review" for Blackstar, and wanted to write a long-form review. I don't usually do full track-by-track reviews but this time I felt it suited the album well.

David Bowie - Blackstar (2016)

David Bowie's Blackstar serves as the culmination of not just a career, but a life. Created during terminal illness, the album exhibits a resilience that confronts mortality without defeat. It stands as a definitive final statement within art rock, where the tragic reality of his physical decline coexists with his musical evolution. The album acts as a summary of his entire artistic journey, drawing on the distinct textures of his past -- from the acoustic whimsy of the late 1960s and the aggressive art-rock of his Berlin period, to nineties industrial friction and the mature reflections of Heathen and The Next Day -- to reshape them into a final, unified statement. This terminal condition deepens the work, creating a human and deeply vital record that evokes profound grief while remaining fiercely life-affirming. The emotional core exhibits how a life's journey transformed the art.

Listening through the record is less about witnessing a departure and more about experiencing a complete life cycle. The structural choices across the album reflect a man reviewing his own past work, using his past musical identities not as simple nostalgia, but as tools to navigate his current reality. By balancing a heavy, looming finality with a persistent sense of play and exploration, the music avoids becoming a grim dirge, carrying instead a quality of stoic joy.

"Blackstar" opens with an unsettled, minor-key rhythm and low woodwinds, giving it a heavy atmosphere of occult paranoia. The lyrics centre on a dark ritual in the town of Ormen, where a dead astronaut's jewelled skull is recovered to make way for a new, nameless figure. But this opening structure splinters and dissolves into a soaring melody for the line "Something happened on the day he died," dropping into a funky groove where he asserts, "I'm a blackstar, way up, on money, I've got game." This unexpected warmth holds a joyous space before the music shifts back to the opening motif.

"'Tis a Pity She Was a Whore" has a breathless pace driven by live acoustic drumming. The saxophone lines echo the sharp, staccato accents of the rhythm section, creating a tight unison. Lyrically, the track pulls from seventeenth-century tragedy to explore themes of violence and vanity, using a blunt vocal style that connects to the ragged, industrial rhythms of his nineties work. The abrasive delivery of lines like "Man, she punched me like a dude" underscores this energy, shaping a harsh, chaotic performance.

"Lazarus" acts as a theatrical monologue on physical confinement and impending liberation. The music has a slow, heavy bassline and a bleak post-punk guitar line that mirrors his late-seventies Berlin period. The opening declaration -- "Look up here, I'm in heaven" -- sets up a detached poise that confronts bodily decline directly. The vocal delivery carries an echo of "Sweet Thing" from Diamond Dogs, connecting his terminal condition directly to his mid-seventies peak.

"Sue (Or in a Season of Crime)" invokes a sense of madness in the face of death. Its bleak narrative has a ragged rhythm, making the experience visceral. The dark desperation of the line "Endless faith in hopeless deeds" is a phrase that echoes the sense of psychological collapse exhibited through the music itself. This provides a sharp structural contrast to the vulnerability of "Lazarus."

"Girl Loves Me" has a stark, echoing drum beat that leaves the vocals prominent in a hollow space. The lyrics use an abrasive, invented vocabulary of Nadsat and Polari slang to map out a disorienting sense of slipping time -- centred around the repeating question "Where the f**k did Monday go?" This line delivers a gritty confusion that draws entirely on his mid-nineties industrial work with Trent Reznor rather than fitting under a generic art-rock label.

"Dollar Days" features a sadly nostalgic sound, carrying a melodic atmosphere similar to Nick Drake's "River Man." The arrangement has warm strings and fluid acoustic guitar, softening the earlier abrasive edges. The recurring realization -- "I'm dying to" -- stands out as a quiet confession against the smooth orchestration. Lyrically, the song processes memory, landscape, and departure, with the horn lines wandering loose through the melody before the final track.

"I Can't Give Everything Away" sets a buoyant, life-affirming rhythm against a guarded set of lyrics. The track opens on a familiar harmonica loop from "A New Career in a New Town," linking this final piece to that 1977 Berlin atmosphere. Lines like "Seeing more and feeling less" carry a distinct defiance, showing a man pushing back against the grain even as things draw to a close.

But after the music has finished playing, that resistance stops. The final fade leaves a sense of quiet resignation and a fading light, moving past the defiance into a frail, personal grace that accepts the inevitable end.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_k9zz5HH6wfeoWzK5VnHRd68UrIzKr3frI

Please keep your reviews coming! I find them very interesting to read.


Instead, for Piero Scaruffi, Blackstar is ranked 4/10 with these words.

"As usual with Bowie, Blackstar (RCA, 2016), produced again by Tony Visconti,, is mostly image and very little about the music. The ten-minute Blackstar, that was supposed to be the centerpiece, is little more than a funereal litany a` la Doors with jazz horns that goes on five minutes too many. Bowie crooning melodramatic in Lazarus (from his Broadway musical about an alien who falls in love) or romantic in Dollar Days is either delirious and pathetic, certainly not entertaining. His tedious voice interferes with the driving jazz jam of 'Tis a Pity She Was a Whore and with the frenzied and tense Sue (a 2014 single). Even when the voice is not a distraction, the rest is hardly intriguing: I Can't Give Everything Away boasts an awful distorted guitar against syncopated beats and layers of electronic drones: not exactly genius. This is trivial "music" that any amateur could make, except that most amateurs would be ashamed to release it."

There is a little difference with Greg... very interesting comparison...
"ART IS NOT A MIRROR, IT IS A HAMMER - John Grierson" (Henry Cow, In Praise of Learning). Taken from: "Art is not a mirror, but a hammer: it does not reflect, it shapes".
Back to Top
Atavachron View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: September 30 2006
Location: Pearland
Status: Offline
Points: 67577
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Atavachron Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 28 2026 at 16:25
An album many fans like, but for me and my friends in '84, it was a fairly dark moment for prog rock --




It was 1984 and a lot of bad things were happening. Orwell's vision seemed to be coming true in the guise of an increasingly tense international atmosphere and an American cowboy-turned-President. Music as well was in a deep freeze, with such luminaries as Kenny Rogers, Duran Duran, Billy Squire and Madonna in command of the publics' attention. And Rush, the last intact bastion of a thinking person's rock, was not immune to these events. What little we know of this period is that the band wanted to "make a change" and dropped their long-time producer/mentor Terry Brown in favor of Peter Henderson, a last minute replacement. But that wasn't the only shake-up: abandoned was the group's single-minded direction toward the fantastic, instead adopting a colder, regrettably sober image complete with bleeding cover art, bad 80s haircuts and decidedly dreary lyrical content. Of course little of that would've mattered if the music had been worth it.

This was all quite a shock, especially on the heels of the previous Signals, one of their best offerings. Had Grace Under Pressure been the soundtrack to a Karate Kid movie it would probably have worked. But this was a new Rush album, an event, and the first chance many young people would have to see the band on tour. What we got was a grey, wounded, emaciated record with little of the magic we all hoped for and needed in those tense times. As fans, we desperately sought out the few good moments among the new songs. But it soon became clear that something had happened, something terrible-- grace under pressure, indeed... but what pressure? And this was graceful?

In fact, the album reached number ten on the Billboard charts, so, from the band's perspective, perhaps it all worked out. Opener 'Distant Early Warning' was an inexplicable hit, securing mainstream status with, ironically, their most uninspired work in ten years. The cut is a bit of a plodder with a soggy bass and thin drum sound. Guitarist Alex Lifeson has some of the better moments on the album having fully developed his new minimal style, lightly decorating the material with tasteful chirps, trills, squeaks and neat noises. 'Afterimage' though is a prime example of the forgettable work here, not bad as much as empty, a song that seems to evaporate as it plays leaving no discernible taste. 'Red Sector A' pumps with some promise but Peart's lyrics only remind us of what peril were all in with none of his usual light, and 'The Enemy Within' sealed this deal with a dreadful ska beat. A bit of uplift on the C3P0-like 'The Body Electric' about a wayward and all too human robot, one of the few genuine and unexpected moments, and rather good 'Kid Gloves' was a touch of the old Rush power and enthusiasm. But 'Red Lenses' is cringe-causing, a simply horrifying example of how far this great trio had strayed from their muses. Worthy 'Between the Wheels' comes much too late to save this languid release. Awesome in its disappointment, almost masochistically so, GUP has somehow become a favorite for many and remains a symbol of one of the darkest periods in progressive rock.

"Too often we enjoy the comfort of opinion without the discomfort of thought."   -- John F. Kennedy
Back to Top
Fercandio46 View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer
Avatar
Jazz Rock / Fusion Team

Joined: September 06 2023
Location: Argentina
Status: Online
Points: 5764
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Fercandio46 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 28 2026 at 16:59
^In that sense, the 80s were a dark period for many bands, especially those that had been around from before. I never liked the tone that keyboards took on, nor how flat the drum sound became, which stripped away its depth.
I enjoyed the review. It has a solemn, almost elegiac tone, which fits the content well.

"Between the Wheels" sounds a bit like Genesis, before Geddy starts singing!
"A good beginning and a good ending make a good movie, as long as they are close together." Federico Fellini
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 28 2026 at 17:29
^ & ^^^ Thanks.

^^ Lorenzo, I find that review appalling and inhumane. Blackstar is about a man facing his own death and putting that reality into music. Calling that kind of raw vulnerability "pathetic" or "trivial" shows a total lack of empathy. When a critique strips away the human context of a record, the result is completely cold -- but then, that reviewer operates in a cold and calculating way, treating art like an equation. Music exists (not saying solely, but an aspect) to communicate real human emotion. Treating a final statement like this with detached disgust misses the point of the art, and worse, it shows a lack of empathy and humanity generally. He and I are viewing it from very contrary places indeed. I can see why so many really dislike that reviewer. Heartless -- but then the album does appeal to my sentimental soul and perhaps he lacks one (I use the term figuratively).

------------------------------------------------------------------

Boards of Canada - Music has the Right to Children (1998)

Knock knock ... Who's there? ... Orange ... Orange who? ... Yeah, that's right.

Music Has the Right to Children holds an uneasy balance. It evokes a sense of nostalgia that is rarely safe or comforting, landing instead in a bittersweet, haunted space where degraded educational samples and childhood imagery look displaced -- like a half-forgotten television broadcast left to decay on an old VHS tape.

A dusty, organic rhythm section shapes much of this atmosphere. On "Aquarius", a heavy, driving bassline and hip-hop breakbeat carry numeric counting games beneath an unsettling undertone. The Sandison brothers produced this frayed sound by design, bypassing pristine digital tools to run their synthesisers straight into old tape machines, combining the sub-bass of the Roland SH-101 with the character of the Ensoniq VFX-SD. Recording clean melodies onto consumer-grade Tascam and Grundig decks introduced natural pitch fluctuations, signal gaps, and a warm, distorted tape saturation.

This tactile quality defines "An Eagle in Your Mind", where a skittering rhythm and warped vocals sound as if they are dissolving on a sticking tape head. The track's low-end thunk and swirling synths owe their texture to low bit-depth Akai S1000 samplers, which naturally crush high frequencies and add a dusty grit to the breakbeat. By embracing the unpredictable quirks of old gear, the duo built a soundscape that mirrors the way human memory blurs over time. Even the brighter "Roygbiv" succeeds because the underlying production keeps its straightforward melodic hook from sounding cheap or saccharine, using a heavy, physical bass thrum to weight the drifting top melodies. Near the end, "Happy Cycling" shifts the energy into something far more relentless, driving forward on a cyclical, motorik rhythm that is both hypnotic and slightly ominous. Rather than tiring, the repetition induces a heavy trance that mimics the physical exhaustion of a long journey, bringing the record to a resolute close.

Tracing this debut through their later catalogue reveals the roots of their subsequent directions. The warm, electro-acoustic infrastructure and acoustic guitar textures that defined The Campfire Headphase clearly start here in brief transitions like "The Colour of the Fire" and "Olson" -- showing that the duo evoked nostalgia through a lighter, more organic palette well before their mid-career shift. Conversely, the early signs of the cold dread that eventually consumed Tomorrow's Harvest surface in the unsettling vocal mutations of "An Eagle in Your Mind". By balancing heavy hip-hop grooves against a haunted psychological undercurrent, the debut established a blueprint they spent the next two decades refining.

Nostalgia shapes this debut through hardware-driven audio decay -- the actual pitch wobble and signal loss caused by worn, mechanical tape machines. By matching these technical textures to the way human memory naturally blurs over time, this work transcends its era of production to remain both timeless and evocative of hazy times. Nearly three decades later, these physical grooves and fragmented childhood themes hold up seamlessly.

Now orange you glad I didn't say banana?

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_lcbBHZNY1YP-yJMLufIAuk6s1NXF0N_bU

Edited by Logan - October 29 2026 at 00:28
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
Atavachron View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: September 30 2006
Location: Pearland
Status: Offline
Points: 67577
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Atavachron Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 28 2026 at 17:38
^^ Thanks, Fernando.

Greg, I hope more members will post reviews here...seems like a natural.

"Too often we enjoy the comfort of opinion without the discomfort of thought."   -- John F. Kennedy
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (1) Thanks(1)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 28 2026 at 18:54
^ David, I really enjoyed reading your Grace Under Pressure review, an album my roommate would play incessantly -- well, he would play Rush incessantly. Your writing is sharp. Bringing up Orwell and the cold war anxiety of 1984 reflects that bleak, drained environment where the colour gets sucked out -- grey music, and saying "grey, wounded, emaciated record" captures the shock you described after Signals well. Listing the ska beat, losing Terry Brown, and the drop in power does clarify reasons why the album polarised its audience. I still like the album, but hearing it so much before kind of sucked out some of the band's joy for me. Still have lots of music I love. Good review! Thanks.
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
Atavachron View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: September 30 2006
Location: Pearland
Status: Offline
Points: 67577
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Atavachron Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 28 2026 at 20:37
^ Always nice to hear.
"Too often we enjoy the comfort of opinion without the discomfort of thought."   -- John F. Kennedy
Back to Top
Jared View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: May 06 2005
Location: Hereford, UK
Status: Offline
Points: 23914
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Jared Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 29 2026 at 00:18
I'd probably have been like Greg's flatmate... if I was being honest, it was Rush, Yes & Genesis on an almost incessant rotation during my 6th Form years.

Talking of GUP, I have always drawn my own parallels between it and Eloy's Metromania. Yes, Performance was a transitional album which had eventually sucked out the remainder of their 70's Space Rock style, but Metromania was similarly cold and harsh in its style, reflecting the emotionless individualism of the age.
Back to Top
Cosmiclawnmower View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: August 09 2010
Location: West Country,UK
Status: Offline
Points: 4311
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Cosmiclawnmower Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 29 2026 at 14:28
Ive been looking at my 'wall of vinyl' and my lack of playing it, particularly over the last couple of years. Ive never written a 'review' of an album before so i thought i'd start at the letter 'A' and work my way through as much of the collection as i can over this winter and try and write some reviews as i go- thus listening to more music (heck i can't even remember what ive got in there half the time!) and practicing my writing skills.

So, here goes, this is my FIRST effort and its NOT a prog lp but its the first disc out of the box. Be gentle with me.

Ace: ‘5-a-side’ 1974
Its not a prog, Jim, but it’s album number one, in unit number one of my (loosely.. ok very loosely) alphabetically arranged record collection. This one was still sealed in its original shrink wrap until a few years ago, came with batch of US imports I acquired many moons ago. Ace were a UK outfit fronted by the fantastic voice of Paul Carrack (who went on to work with Squeeze, Mike and the Mechanics and as a solo artist), he also played organ and piano on the album. The album was produced by well known prog-producer, John Anthony and engineered by Pat Moran at Rockfield studios so the slick and fairly polished sound on this lp is no surprise. Yet, at heart, this is an album of American influenced R & B rock, exceedingly well played yet much of it with a nod to the coming UK ‘Pub rock’ scene of Brinsley Schwatrz and Duck deluxe and a rootsy ‘The Band’ flavour plus hints of Tamla Motown. Of course, the standout song is the hit single ‘How Long?’ which really launched Carrack’s career and was, according to legend, played by Pink Floyd as a sound check during the tour of ‘Wish you were here’.. The album starts with the tight country boogie of ‘Sniffin’ about’ very much in the early Eagles vein with lots of vocal harmonies. ‘Rock n roll runaway’ is more throwaway in an almost Doctor Hook kind of way, pleasant enough and soon over. ‘How Long’ comes in with that iconic electric piano and soulful vocal harmonies and understated rhythm guitar, the middle section guitar solo and percussion recall Steely Dan and I can, in my minds eye, see David Gilmour et all belting this out as some light relief from the stress of their own material. ‘The real feeling’ and ’24 hours’ continue this mix of bluesy soul and harmony vocals, mixing a bit of funky organ and fender Rhodes ala Little Feat. Side two opens with ‘Why’ which rolls along in a similar mood to How Long, they could so easily be a band from across the pond; this sort of material is so radio friendly it hurts.. the album continues in that vein with the next two tracks, ‘Time ain’t long’ and ‘know how it feels’ with a slower soul feel. ‘Satellite’ has the ‘Little Feat boogie thang with some nice sax and brass. The lp ends with ‘So sorry Baby’ which oddly with the Hammond organ and vocal harmonies sounds like a cross between US Prog Starcastle and Brit pub rock Brinsley Schwartz!
These guys were so tight, obviously top notch musicians, and along with the production makes for a shining, if slightly sterile, performance. There were quite a few bands like this in the early mid 70’s- Stretch, Snafu, Andy Robert’s Homegrown, Sutherland brothers & Quiver.. accomplished as players yet stuck between touring a country rock sound and the requirements of pop radio; often barely moving beyond being support acts. Paul Carrack moved on and established himself as a bit of a minor ‘national treasure’, still singing some the songs he penned with Ace and has done very well thank you. Ive enjoyed revisiting this album though its not something I’d play often; it’s a shame they didn’t stretch out the album version of ‘How long’ and ‘Why’ for, say, 6 or 7 minutes and loose one or two of the shorter more throwaway tracks but as an lp of 10 radio friendly toons, its pretty good.
4 out of 5.
Ace: '5-a-Side' 1974

Edited by Cosmiclawnmower - October 30 2026 at 07:38

Back to Top
Heart of the Matter View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: September 01 2020
Location: Argentina
Status: Offline
Points: 4932
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Heart of the Matter Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 29 2026 at 15:59
^ It's Carrick, or Carrack?
Back to Top
Cosmiclawnmower View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: August 09 2010
Location: West Country,UK
Status: Offline
Points: 4311
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Cosmiclawnmower Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 30 2026 at 07:33
Originally posted by Heart of the Matter Heart of the Matter wrote:

^ It's Carrick, or Carrack?


You're correct, it is Carrack, not Carrick. Apologies for poor editing and spelling. I'll go back and amend. Thanks for pointing that out

Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (1) Thanks(1)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 30 2026 at 09:12
^^^ Hi John, methinks you've done a good job exploring the context with your review. Pointing out how John Anthony's Prog production and Pat Moran's engineering helps me to understand why a rootsy UK pub rock album can sound so polished in its way, and the part about Pink Floyd using "How Long" for a soundcheck adds colour. Mentioning how these players were caught between country rock and commercial radio seems a significant observation -- I like that kind of insight and contextualisation. I sincerely enjoyed the write-up and think it could be a good way to keep calm and carry on through the winter during these troubling times. I look forward to reading more! Thanks.

---------------------------------

On another note, I hope my response to that Piero Scaruffi review posted by Lorenzo to illustrate our differences on Blackstar did not seem well over-the-top, but that review definitely hit a bad nerve, and I should know, I just had a root canal yesterday.

-----------------------------

Many thanks to those who have shared their reviews and commented on others reviews. I hope to read more. An issue I have had with writing reviews is that usually one gets no feedback at all. While I enjoy isolated writing, I do like a forum for being able to discuss our writings and the kinds of ideas based discussions it can bring.

Edited by Logan - October 30 2026 at 09:20
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 30 2026 at 09:30
Here is a short review I wrote in 2023 after adding Chelsea Wolfe to PA.

Chelsea Wolfe - Pain Is Beauty (2013)

As Christina Amphlett of Divinyls intoned, "It's a fine line between pleasure and pain, you've done it once you can do it again." Wise words. Chelsea Wolfe demonstrates here that pain can be beauty. Her pain, my joy, my arms, your hearse. Of course, what is beautiful to one can be painful to another. I love the atmospheric gothic folk stylings of Chelsea Wolfe. Some might find Pain Is Beauty to be too dark, slow, and depressing, or even cheesy, but it has real beauty for me. This record, Abyss, Apokalypsis, and Hiss Spun are all very good albums, but this one is what made me fall for her music, even though I really love Abyss now. This album is a treat for me. Part of what hooked me is that the opening track reminded me of music from a favourite TV series of mine, Utopia, with music by Cristobal Tapia de Veer. Associations vary, and not based on what one has heard, but on other perceptions.

I would compare her music to Emma Ruth Rundle's solo albums -- Some Heavy Ocean, Marked for Death, On Dark Horses -- or her work with the post-rock band Red Sparowes. Wolfe collaborated with her on the single "Anhedonia" in 2021. At times there are significant similarities to Anna von Hausswolff's music. Fans of music by Dead Can Dance, Current 93, Coil, Nine Inch Nails, Susanne Sundfor, and Swans should find Wolfe's music appeals to them. Jarboe-sang tracks in Swans as well as her solo work are a goof reference point. I recommend this to people into darkwave, gothic music, and atmospheric folk-rock.

Every song is a highlight for me, but "Reins", "The Warden", "Lone", "Feral", "House of Metal", "Sick", and "The Waves Have Come" stand out as personal favourites.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_nMiKKPt1bRPsB7PAxDi-qfesP7owgKUVk



Edited by Logan - October 30 2026 at 09:37
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
Heart of the Matter View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: September 01 2020
Location: Argentina
Status: Offline
Points: 4932
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Heart of the Matter Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 30 2026 at 09:41
Originally posted by Cosmiclawnmower Cosmiclawnmower wrote:

Originally posted by Heart of the Matter Heart of the Matter wrote:

^ It's Carrick, or Carrack?


You're correct, it is Carrack, not Carrick. Apologies for poor editing and spelling. I'll go back and amend. Thanks for pointing that out

Thanks to you too, very interesting review, I didn't know that band.
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 01 2026 at 11:58
Boards of Canada - Tomorrow's Harvest (2013)

Here is one for Tomorrow's Harvest, I rewrote this a few times, well mostly hacking out stuff, but on finding my earlier draft I decided to reinstate it. I thought it was maybe too self-indulgent. I wrote the day after coming back from a trip To Whistler where I should not have been swimming far out into the lake after having multiple pints. Damn you happy hour specials! Big fan of happy hour both for alcohol and food.

Reaping what tomorrow sows...

Tomorrow's Harvest acts as a cold bridge of a sort to a spiritual trilogy. While the bookend albums were easier listening for me, on a recent spin I feel I really got it. That eureka moment. Unlike the others, it has felt like a bit of a slog, but this time at 49 minutes in I looked at the timer since I knew I had to prepare dinner. It felt like the quantum wave function had collapsed. Floating in a blur of endless, timeless possibilities, suddenly looking at the clock forced rigid reality to snap back into place. Time had collapsed for me and this had become a timeless classic, dimensionally transcendent as might be said in Doctor Who.

The album did require patience, but I was primed for it after getting into Inferno, because I feel that is the spiritual successor to Tomorrow's Harvest and The Campfire Headphase -- a glorious trilogy spanning 21 years. Music can take time to grok, and while there was instant gratification within the album, to appreciate it as a whole took some neuro-syncing. This isn't background noise. It has a deep, unbreakable connection to the Kosmische Musik and Berlin School pioneers, like early Tangerine Dream or Popol Vuh, with some Eno and Cluster for good measure. It has long-form, cyclical synthesiser desolation qualities. If The Campfire Headphase was a warm, sun-dazed tapestry of nostalgia, and Inferno an explosive electronic rebirth, then Tomorrow's Harvest feels like an icy tunnel connecting them, filled with warmer moments and contrast. The brilliance here isn't about showing off; it's about atmosphere and texturing. The Sandison brothers use unstable tape capstans to make their synthesisers sound like older machinery wearing down from a sticking tape head.

"Gemini" opens the album not with a big statement, but with a strange, distorted little b-movie audio tag bleeding into a lonely synthetic trumpet motif alerting the listener that the landscape has changed. This flows into "Reach for the Dead," which is the gravitational centre of the first half. It has a cold, heavy drum pulse feeling like a terminal heartbeat, with a melody that rises continuously. It seems to me to be like a bleak answer to "Dayvan Cowboy" where instead of launching toward the sun, it's more akin to watching the sun burn out. Then there is "White Cyclosa," which builds a quiet, flitting kind of anxiety with that icy bass-line.

The pacing is cinematic, evoking Ennio Morricone's vintage work with Edda Dell'Orso. Morricone understood that a melody can stand out if it follows uncomfortable, quiet spaces. On this album, those bleak mood pieces give the melodies their heft and presence. The off-kilter rhythm of "Jacquard Causeway" carries a boozy-woozy, unsteady quality -- reminiscent of my swim out to a lake raft at Whistler yesterday after two beers, trying to keep my balance on the boards with the music from an earlier play drifting through my head. Interludes like "Telepath" and "Transmisiones Ferox" use eerie countdowns reminiscent of a shortwave numbers station. Tracks like "Cold Earth" blend rigid electro-beats with mournful choral pads, while "Sick Times" delivers an isolated hip-hop groove evoking an end-of-the-world film.

The thin, sunny nostalgia of "Nothing Is Real" provides contrast, a window of sunlight before the colder elements take over the season. Its simple melody remains steady, grounding the arrangement before the cold returns. The loops shift into "Palace Posy" and "New Seeds," where the rhythmic repetition builds tension alongside radio static and vocal samples. At that 49-minute mark, the rhythm swells, transforming the record into a kind of manna that points forward to the dense electronic landscape of 2026's Inferno. The album concludes with the dense, cinematic presence of "Come to Dust" and the hollow drone of "Semena Mertvykh." It leaves the listener in a hollow limbo -- less of a definitive ending and more of a dark, "to be continued" Twin Peaks episode, leaving a cold uncertainty about whether there is warmth left for tomorrow's harvest.

They say one reaps what one sows. Sinking into this record took patience, but the payoffs were significant to me. When the clock was ignored, the music took hold and stayed over subsequent spins.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_kBIHneSc23tMiNaX68rurYceNxzwtBH84

EDIT: I had this at four stars, but after listening to it again yesterday twice while fixing the house up for a Halloween party, I had to bump it to five. By the way, I love all eras of Boards of Canada, looking at the ratings it is interesting how divisive BoC is (not that it got very many ratings). But at least for it to be divisive it must be known, which is better than just being ignored IMO.
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
Cosmiclawnmower View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: August 09 2010
Location: West Country,UK
Status: Offline
Points: 4311
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Cosmiclawnmower Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 02 2026 at 12:38
Here's record number two.. and ive realised just how NOT in alphabetical order my collection has got so please forgive. This is just an exercise in re-acquainting myself with a big, neglected chunk of my collection and getting some writing practice; a good project for me with winter on its way (for many reasons which i wont go into now). If this proves to be something i really pursue, should i start a new topic with it or can i continue to post here? And thanks for your supportive words, Greg, which are very appreciated.

Ain Soph: A Story of Mysterious Forest, 1980, Nexus records


I think this process of going through my record collection is going to produce many moments of ‘goodness gracious, I don’t remember owning this!’ or ‘I thought I got rid of this years ago!’ and other such statements, probably linked with considerably stronger expletives, I’ll mention it here, once, and you can just take it as read..
So, Ain Soph.. this album and their follow up which I will listen to next were a band which I had heard the existence of through an enlightened record shop owner in the 1990’s and also through some specialist prog cd supplier lists at the same time yet I didn’t invest in any of their music until around 2010 when I managed to get both albums, on vinyl, as Japanese import.
I love Japanese vinyl with its quality card sleeves, the OBI strip, the various inserts and of course the quality of pressing. I had literally not heard any of their music until the albums were on my turntable.. I must have had spare cash to flash then as these imports don’t come cheap; and if on rare occasion, they did, the shipping was alarming (though I have to say, always impeccably packed in extra strong boxes so all arrived safe and sound). Despite what I had read before, once the needle hit the vinyl I was happily re-assured that simple homage, it most certainly was not. Its obvious that the skill and virtuosity of the four musicians is impressive and their influences, wide ranging. From 1960’s pop and blues, through jazz and fusion, European progressive music of the 70’s and folk and ethnic music styles, much of this is reflected on one level or another on this entirely instrumental album. I would say that National Health, Isotope, Bruford, Brand X and later 70’s Camel and American Jazz fusion represent more of their influences than Caravan, earlier Soft Machine, Matching Mole or Hatfield and the North. There is also a good dash of European Progressive rock with nods to Atoll and Maxophone, even Focus and Eloy (at one point) along with hints of Scandinavian 70s Jazz rock outfits such as Kornet.
Side One starts in fine fashion with ‘Crossfire’, the kind of brisk, fast flowing, tight and twitchy jazz-fusion that I love! Very much 70’s Brand X, Return to Forever, almost Zappa at the end of ‘Inca roads’.. A great start! Why have I not listened to this album in years?? Interlude 1 is a lovely little acoustic piece but doesn’t really serve any function except as an introduction to the third track, ‘Natural selection’ which sedately slides into being mixing a Canterbury-esque theme with a slightly oriental sound, some nice piano and string synths which then picks up the pace, moving (briefly) into a Jan Akkerman guitar piece and jazzy piano alternating between a synth theme. I do love cheesy sounding String synths, particularly with nice echoey fender Rhodes piano.. a little bit ‘Jet Lag’ PFM there.. and back to that original theme and finishing with grand piano flourishes. ‘Variations on a theme by Brian Smith’ again returns to that Brand X style of fusion with some super tight percussion, lots of light and shade, moving from acoustic guitars and pianos to electric instruments and back. Some of this also reminds me of ‘Alive and well in Paris era Soft machine’ if Al Di Meola was playing with them! And the piece ends quite abruptly with some acoustic piano..
Side two encapsulates the epic 19 minute suite ‘A Story of Mysterious Forest’ made up of eleven sections, Starting with a piece that sounds like Focus ala Hamburger concerto it soon morphs into a section that has a taste of Eloy with spacey synths then morphs again in to a ‘Pink floyd/ Barclay james harvest’ slow section.. this is the real issue for me, it just seems to be many short musings, atmospheres and interludes, covering just about everything possible.. what’s this little Latin sounding bit with the annoying synth sound?? Then another reprise of the Focus theme.. now its definitely Camel ala ‘Snowgoose’.. Its all very oddly joined together too, some pieces merge into others, some just stop, with an awkward space before starting into the next. Rather disjointed for me. But, overall, not unpleasant, just a feeling of a loose concept not properly thought through or brought to fruition as some bits could have been expanded on and a few bits completely dispensed with. Shame.
I will certainly revisit this album and explore some of their later output as there is a lot to love here; yet on side two there is enough annoying disjointedness and distraction to stop me giving it 4 out of 5
3.5 out of 5


Edited by Cosmiclawnmower - November 02 2026 at 12:42

Back to Top
Atavachron View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: September 30 2006
Location: Pearland
Status: Offline
Points: 67577
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Atavachron Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 02 2026 at 13:52


Don Caballero   What Burns Never Returns

Damon Che is a monster.   This whole damned band is.   And led by the brilliant drummer, Don Caballero obnoxiously crashed the party with their third studio release, a relentless, unstoppable creation.   The group's mysterious writing process is only outdone by the sheer will and physicality brought to the performance of the music, a braver and more progressed follow-up to the spectacular Don Caballero 2 that has less to do with mathrock and more where this rare communion of players is able to go, and able to take us.   We oblige, of course, because not to would be to deny what these guys have offered the world of rock as art.   To say that the Dons have contributed a verse to rock history would be putting it lightly.

The album is dunked in a bath of motor oil and spits bits & pieces of machinery often.   It is industrial with a small "i", never letting us forget where Che, Morris, Williams and Banfield are from, the mercantile and warehouse habitat of iron, rubber, steel and concrete it so affectionately recreates.   What Burns Never Returns is truly like finding oneself lost in a huge and abandoned but active factory that you might, if you're lucky, find your way out of.   You can smell the rust and broken parts of the title track arriving with Che's continuous snare ruffle and the confused mingling of strings finding its way, warming-up the axles, wedges and pulleys of this perpetual motion machine.   Damon Che kicks the sh*t out of this baby but the band counters with contrasted lines creating the trade-off between force & distance, the friction these four utilize so well.   Lightly slapped guitars and anchor-heavy bass parts for 'In the Absence of Strong Evidence to the Contrary,One May Step Out of the Way of a Charging Bull' with havoc one minute and wonky rhythms the next, heavily flirting with ~ if not tongue-kissing ~ dissonance.   Thrash chords blow open 'Delivering the Groceries at 138 Beats per Minute' pumping with internal combustion, compressed air, elastic energy, and electrical discharge.   Man meets man-made in 'Slice Where You Live Like Pie', a protest piece and a point where some listeners will simply throw their hands up and hit the skip button like a junkie on his next fix.   And I wouldn't blame them.

'Room Temperature Suite' before brooding 'The World in Perforated Lines' take the hands off the throttle a bit, the latter trailing off into vacuum tube oblivion giving way to frustrating 'From the Desk of Elsewhere Go' showing Che's remarkable knack for leadership and group dynamics.   Those late, late shows at the ratty club downtown?   When the last band was winding down a decent but frankly tortured set that threatened to cripple anyone who was paying attention while trying to avoid the sizable puddle of beer & burrito vomit in the middle of the floor?   Apt imagery for these two cuts, but things are saved by almost melodic 'June is Finally Here'.

A near 5 stars if not for the small amount of less than inspired work, but in the end the boys gave us something that showed, simply by doing it, that true progressive rock was far from depleted, demonstrating how both the complex and the primal could come together to orbit and affect the other in ways not previously conceived.



"Too often we enjoy the comfort of opinion without the discomfort of thought."   -- John F. Kennedy
Back to Top
Psychedelic Paul View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: September 16 2019
Location: Nottingham, U.K
Status: Offline
Points: 55182
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Psychedelic Paul Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 03 2026 at 03:35
5 stars 1972: Steel Mill - Green-Eyed God - https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL_8ts-YOjKJ2Bioctkgzv8zlpLg2tjsmc

STEEL MILL were forged in the foundry in the industrial heart of London way back in 1969. The five-piece band recorded their one and only album "Green-Eyed God" with a sense of iron will and determination and the album first emerged from the steel works in 1972. Unfortunately, the album failed to set the music world alight in a blaze of fire and steel and the band quickly melted away into the suburbs of London just as suddenly as they'd appeared. And so, without further ado, let's have a listen to the eight heavy metal songs that Steel Mill hammered out on the anvil during their brief moment in the spotlight.

It's not quite heavy metal thunder and lightning with the opening number "Blood Runs Deep", but it's not far off. This is a storming Jazz-Rock song with a heart of iron, featuring a pounding and pulsating rhythm section and with a sassy saxophonist rampaging throughout in a blaze of pulverizing high-decibel fire and steel. The band Steel Mill have forged a powerful opening to "Green-Eyed God" which is sure to leave the Prog Gods green-eyed with envy. Although this record might play on the turntable at the rather sedate speed of 33 and a third - just like any other L.P. - there's enough latent power contained within the groove to send it spinning right off the turntable at 99 R.P.M.! As the much-missed D.J. legend Alan 'Fluff' Freeman would say, "Alright? Not 'arff!!" If "Blood Runs Deep" was a heavy dose of solid steel, then the second song "Summer's Child" is more like a lightweight aluminium siding. It's a beautiful ballad floating wistfully along on a delicate gentle breeze of woodwind and soothing electric guitar, which also features some gorgeous heavenly harmonies from the ethereal choir. The heartfelt lyrics from the impassioned singer deserve a brief mention too:- "Summer's child, Smiles and feeds me, Autumn loves try to please me, Older now, in your silence, Better day of less violence, Winter's child, says she needs me." ..... This is melancholy prog at its absolute best! We're off to meet "Majo and the Laying of the Witch" for our third encounter. This song Rocks! It's an 8-minute-long monster mash featuring a pounding and percussive sonic blast of Psychedelic Rock with wild vocals and a simply sensational saxophone solo adding to the raw energy of this storming rocker. This spooky song resembles that other supernatural Halloween favourite "Season of the Witch", only "Majo and the Laying of the Witch" is injected with a huge boost of extra adrenalin and frenetic energy. We're on the "Treadmill" for our fourth song, which opens as a typical prison chain-gang chant in the style of "We're working on the chain gang, Huh!" You get the picture. We don't stay on the "Treadmill" for long though as we're off on another wild ride aboard the crazy train for a psychedelic Jazz-Rock excursion, which resembles early Van der Graaf Generator in places, only without the over-wrought vocals of Peter Hammill.

We're off to meet the jolly green giant now for the title track "Green-Eyed God", which opens as a pastoral woodwind piece, sounding a bit like an Indian peace pipe. This song definitely has an eastern mystical air to it, at least to begin with, although that first impression is soon shattered by a very western outburst of heavy electric guitar riffing in powerful combination with a storming saxophonic solo and a solid punching rhythm section, which is then followed by a brief return to the Indian pipes of peace for the tranquil conclusion. The storming middle section is a chunk of solid iron ore and the song as a whole is a steel-eyed Rock Monster! "Green-Eyed God" represents an outstanding album highlight which is about as close to heavy metal as you can get without actually BEING Heavy Metal. It's time to "Turn the Page Over" now for our sixth song. It's a fairly laid- back number with a catchy melody, featuring some gorgeous guitar soloing and lovely harmonies to match. It's the most commercially appealing song on the album which is more of a good all-round Pop song than some of the earlier storming hard rockers on the album, and that's all for the better too, where variety is the spice that makes for a great album. After all, too much heavy metal thunder and lightning in one sitting can be like a sonic assault on the tender eardrums, but then again, the thought of unleashing a non-stop Sonic Attack never stopped Hawkwind in their tracks. In a solid steel album full of highlights, the seventh song "Black Jewel of the Forest" is a diamond gem. This primal and unearthly song is a real witches brew, featuring tribal drums, a pastoral flute and hauntingly atmospheric vocals throughout. The overall impression is of some sinister witches coven meeting somewhere deep in the dark woods, and so, in the immortal words of Sergeant Phil Esterhaus (Michael Conrad) of Hill Street Blues, "Let's be careful out there", because you just never know what might be lurking deep in the darkest recesses of the forest at midnight during a full moon on the night of Halloween. The album closes beautifully now with the charming "Har Fleur", a lovely, short and sweet instrumental woodwind piece which sounds as pretty as a French flower!

Steel Mill have produced a stainless steel rust-proof album of gleaming chrome with "Green-Eyed God". This rare solid state album of bright shining steel will be like a nugget of gold to prog collectors as it truly is a one-off album. It's really stood the test of time too at nearly half a century old and there's not a speck of rust to be seen anywhere!
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: November 03 2026 at 10:51
Thanks to all who have shared reviews. :)

Originally posted by Cosmiclawnmower Cosmiclawnmower wrote:

Here's record number two.. and ive realised just how NOT in alphabetical order my collection has got so please forgive. This is just an exercise in re-acquainting myself with a big, neglected chunk of my collection and getting some writing practice; a good project for me with winter on its way (for many reasons which i wont go into now). If this proves to be something i really pursue, should i start a new topic with it or can i continue to post here? And thanks for your supportive words, Greg, which are very appreciated...


Again, I very much like your review. This topic is open to all who want to share their music reviews, as many as they like, be it Prog or not, up at another site or not, short or long, and also to comment on any of the posted reviews if one should choose to.

-------------------------------------------------------------

Here's an embarrassingly juvenile and puerile one I wrote in 2010. The cover has a sexy naked Venusian lady and so I leaned into that imagery, and added the Uranus joke just to be extra crass.

Lenny White - Venusian Summer (1975)

Men are from Mars, sexy women are from Venus ... it being summer, they can leaves clothes off... I've always been interested in astronomy and have often trained my telescope on Venus, beats looking at Uranus, so I do know what I'm talking about, butt I digress. Speaking of Venusians, what a beautiful album cover. It's the kind of imagery that I would like to paint on the side of my van cum love-mobile. It has wall-to-wall carpeting by the way, unlike that Venusian beauty who looks silky smooth.

Lenny White is the drummer who played on the seminal album by Miles Davis, Bitches Brew, and also played on the most excellent, musically better than Bitches Brew in my opinion [NOTE, I would not claim this now] Red Clay by Freddie Hubbard. He also performed on Eddie Henderson's masterwork, and I believe one of the greatest albums in JRF, Realization -- which is what initially drew me to explore Lenny White albums. In fact, Lenny White has played with a great many of the jazz, and jazz fusion greats such as Freddie Hubbard, Miles Davis, Herbie Hancock, Buster Williams, Eddie Henderson, Billy Hart, Benny Maupin, Ron Carter, Joe Henderson, various Return to Forever guys obviously, but we forgive him ;), and Larry Coryell. This album and Adventures of Astral Pirates are my favourites under his name.

What particularly makes this album special is the "Venusian Summer Suite", and how sweet it is! It ranks amongst my favourite pieces of music in the jazz-rock universe, and this is the heart of the album. It starts off in an electronic, cosmic manner that is reminiscent of western art music composers such as Holst and Debussy -- in fact, I thought I recognised the specific theme, maybe not that original but still so wonderful. It is very much a Dr. Patrick Gleeson slice and it is his contribution that makes the opening so superb. It transitions into stirring, exciting, exhilarating -- now I'm being really exasperating -- jazz-funk. What a great track; one of the best in jazz-rock/electronic, and it should appeal to those who love music such as Herbie Hancock's Sextant and Crossings as well as Bennie Maupin albums. Adding this suite to a cosmic funk playlist with tracks such as Bennie Maupin's 'Quasar' (the version from Slow Traffic to the Right), Eddie Henderson's 'Galaxy' off Sunburst, 'Languidity' from Sun Ra, and similar funky cosmic excursions is an epic thing to do.

If the whole album was up to the standards of the "Venusian Summer Suite" this album would get a five from me. It's not, but there is more to get pretty excited about. "Chicken Fried Steak" and "Away Goes Trouble Down the Train" are good, fun and enjoyable, but nothing terribly remarkable. Pretty standard bluesy jazz-rock and rather boring for me. For those drawn to electric guitar-oriented music and bog-standard blues and rock-and-roll, this might hold considerable appeal. I still find it fun, but while these pieces have their moments, I have tended to skip them. Still, it presents another side to the music and gives contrast, so as part of the album package, it makes the album better. Erm, sort of. Still, not the greatest start for an album for me. Of course things soon improve with the 'suite' that follows.

"Prelude to a Rainbow Delta", another very Gleesonish work -- I'm pretty sure Gleeson composed it as well as performed -- is a wonderful and short ambient electronic piece. It's reminiscent of Tangerine Dream and ilk, and I hear similar forays with Art Zoyd and Patricia Dallio's electronic work.

"Mating Drive" is terrific, driving JRF which starts off in the electronic world like "Venusian Summer Suite" then picks up steam -- strong technical drumming by White if not terribly imaginative. His drumming, though good technically, does generally fail to particularly appeal as I don't find him to be a very creative drummer. Still, a fine "rockin" piece with enough jazz-funk to satisfy.

The final track, "Prince of the Sea" is also very good and rockin' jazz-rock, maybe a little too rockin' or electric guitar oriented for me. Hardly a favourite track in jazz-rock fusion, but well-done. I wish it had more of an experimental edge, but very good never-the-less for what it is. I do wish it had more subtlety; however, it is still an excellent piece of jazz-rock and enjoyable for me. I expect this would be the highlight of the album for quite a few. Those who love Al Di Meola's electric guitar style, or like shredding, will likely appreciate this. This is the track I'd recommend to those into power metal and guitar hero music since the guitar style is reminiscent of shredding with hints of Eddie van Halen et cetera. I love the way it ends with a gong and seagulls -- pretty Zen, and maybe a touch cliché.

I'm giving this album a four because I do think it's very well-executed and it has some great music on it. Just for the "Venusian Summer Suite" alone I think this is pretty essential. Lowlights for me include guitar-work which is just not altogether my style -- Coryell does good work on this, but I feel like Al Di Meola is not that 'elegant' here. The highlights include the electronics, great jazz-funk, and fine keyboard work. On the whole I prefer Astral Pirates, but this has such great music included that it stands as an essential work among Lenny White's self-named albums. However, it has too many "mainstream" moments for me to consider this whole work amazing and, as is the case with a lot of jazz-rock, the compositions can suffer from overdone instrumental showmanship.

It is one I'd recommend to many, but not so much, considering the bulk of the album, to those who prefer their jazz more experimental, as I often do. For those who are more mainstream-oriented, this could appeal hugely and open up new musical passions, but there's music here for most everyone to enjoy.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_m4LJe91koL0vGt16luM_vEytlAbebmYtg

Edited by Logan - November 03 2026 at 11:30
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <123>

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down



This page was generated in 0.180 seconds.
Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.