Forum Home Forum Home > Other music related lounges > General Music Discussions
  New Posts New Posts
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Events   Register Register  Login Login

A New Topic to Share Our Music Reviews

 Post Reply Post Reply Page  123>
Author
Message
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Topic: A New Topic to Share Our Music Reviews
    Posted: October 23 2026 at 20:10
Often our reviews on the frontpage quickly get drowned out by other reviews. I think that it's sad that those might not even be seen, or barely seen, and reviews also can be a great way to give our favourites greater recognition. Feel free to share any of your music reviews written anywhere and on any genre.

I'll start with my Boards of Canada - Inferno review which I largely re-wrote a couple of times.

Boards of Canada - Inferno

Burn, baby, burn!

It was thirteen long years since Boards of Canada released an album, and for the last three I have been thinking "This might well be the year! Mightn't it? Maybe?" Well, while some say that patience is its own reward -- not me however -- in this case good things came to those who endured the wait. It began on Record Store Day with a single, unannounced vinyl copy of a teaser track turning up at a record shop in London. Over the following six weeks, the campaign expanded into a complex puzzle: a brief audio snippet broadcast at midnight on Cartoon Network, grainy VHS tapes with hidden numeric codes sent directly to specific music sites, and physical hexagon posters bearing geometric fragments appearing in cities like Tokyo and New York. I found out about the roll-out early on, right when those first tapes started surfacing, and following it all when no one was quite sure if it was real just made it more fun. Then "Tape 05" appeared online on April 16th, and Warp Records officially announced the eighteen-track double LP on April 22nd, setting the release date for May 29th.

The day before the official street date, I managed to sneak an early listen to the audio online at home. Doing so felt like a bit of a spoiler, but the anticipation was too strong to wait. During that first spin, the upfront, dry voice samples and spoken-word bits made me overthink the tracks instead of just experiencing them. They were too far forward, getting in the way of my appreciation, though that feeling changed later.

Going to Neptoon Records in Vancouver for the pre-release party later that same day made it a shared experience, much like a concert. The shop was busy, with people filtering through the bins and chatting while the album started. The room settled as the music went on. While "You Retreat in Time and Space" played, the room became quiet, transfixed by the melody. Experiencing the music in that environment cleared away the overthinking from my earlier solo listen. I became one with the music; one with the scene.

The double vinyl release gives the tracks plenty of room to breathe, with arrangements leaning into slow electro-acoustic developments that focus on texture and mood. The music itself moves between melodic warmth and a stark minimalism, where monotonous repetition makes the changes in mood feel more distinct.

This record combines the acoustic warmth of The Campfire Headphase with the bleak, grey skies of Tomorrow's Harvest. The approach to the voice samples and background noise slowly growing into the environment brings to mind how Swans handled tape loops and found speech on Soundtracks for the Blind or Swans Are Dead. It is easily my favourite album of the year. The production feels cleaner and more polished than their early material, but the emotional core is intact. The release week also left a notable footnote regarding the group's wider cultural reach when a snippet from the promotional teasers turned up in a White House broadcast, prompting a condemnation from Warp Records for its unauthorised use. Fortunately, "The Donald" did not insist that Boards of Canada be renamed Boards of the 51st State in retaliation.

Many hate the word transcendent, became an overused buzz word, yet that is how Inferno feels to me. I love it.

EDIT: Adding links much like Paul to aid in listening:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_lljmZxsklD_9bkwH1M08MpA5SqAFuMJI8
https://boardsofcanada.bandcamp.com/album/inferno

I love my special edition red vinyl of this which came with BoC swag from the listening party.

Edited by Logan - October 24 2026 at 11:14
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 23 2026 at 20:30
I'll share this review from last year because it such a special live album to me.

Fishmans - 98.12.28 Otokotachi no wakare

"Are you feeling good?"

98.12.28 Otokotachi no wakare is a momentous live recording. Recorded in Tokyo on December 28, 1998, the performance has a heavy and sombre history behind it. Frontman and primary composer Shinji Sato passed away less than three months later, followed by multi-instrumentalist Honzi in 2007. I was living and working in Japan as an English teacher during those late-90s years, which creates a strange personal connection for me. Yet, despite the related tragedy, or perhaps more so because of it, this is a deeply joyous, life-affirming, and celebratory concert.

Sato addresses the room throughout the performance -- giving his signature greeting early on, checking back in before the second set, and sharing a brief word right before the finale. These conversational interludes bring great warmth to the performance, highlighting the gentleness of Sato and his seemingly shy nature. At one point, he asks the audience if his guitar playing was any good, prompting an enthusiastic female fan to shout "You're the best!" His blushing response carries a quiet, fragile humanity and humility. It makes me smile, albeit bittersweet.

After the energetic run of the early tracks, the music stops playing before moving into the quieter material, leaving a long pause where he talks to the audience and introduces the guests. From there, the music moves effortlessly. The band slides into the sparse bass groove of "Oh! Slime," then shifts into the upbeat reggae-dub rhythms of "Nantettano" and "Thank You," pivots directly into the fast ska-punk energy of "Tayorinai Tenshi" and "Hikouki," and then eases into the quiet dream-pop of "Night Cruising."

They improvised during every tour, meaning they never played a song the same way twice. They used the stage to change and expand the original arrangements, so that each performance differs and grows. "In the Flight" (I adore it) starts as a loose folk canvas over a steady groove until Honzi's violin unleashes an electrifying, fiery sound. The track maintains a calm dynamic moving into a crescendo. Sato pushes his vocals into a high falsetto -- an approach that might split some listeners but gives the performance a raw edge. "Walking in the Rhythm" stretches out into a long-form blues-dub piece, building toward a psychedelic space in its final minutes. I hear that same fluid approach across "Smilin' days, Summer Holiday," "Melody," and the shifting moods of "Yurameki in the Air."

"Yurameki in the Air" stands stretched out to over sixteen minutes. It begins with more than a minute of pure ambient drone before the bass line and steady rhythm enter. Sato's vocals are delicate and fragile here, carrying the melody without relying on distinct words. The track slowly builds to a hushed climax where the music thins out to leave his voice floating alone. When it feels like it might dissolve, the heavy bass and drums return with a sharp reggae rhythm to ground the track.

The core of the recording is the continuous, 41-minute version of "Long Season." This version is a joyous piece of music that deeply moves me. The track starts simply, with a repetitive piano pattern and a relaxed, walking dub rhythm. They get a comfortable groove going by keeping the instrumentation sparse and predictable, giving the music an easy, open feel. Then, all the other instruments stop, leaving a quiet section held by just a single echoing drum beat. When the repeating keyboard comes back, it builds a patient Krautrock momentum that feels hypnotic. The guest vocals and Honzi's violin layer into the mix, carrying me along with the steady repetition until the band builds up to a crescendo. I love the dynamic range here, especially the way a cheerful musical groove carries a sad undercurrent.

While the band shares similarities with the patient repetition of Can and the massive, building momentum found on Boris's Flood, their heavy dub and reggae rhythms give them a distinct identity. For me, this is their masterpiece. It is tragic how their journey ended, but what an absolute joy of a concert for Shinji Sato and Honzi to go out on. Sato's creative output left a lasting impression. Thank you for the music!

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_kwa0-rpWytjK2F45KXj-Uw7CxIYHKwr9c

Edited by Logan - October 26 2026 at 23:14
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
Fercandio46 View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer
Avatar
Jazz Rock / Fusion Team

Joined: September 06 2023
Location: Argentina
Status: Online
Points: 5764
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Fercandio46 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 24 2026 at 09:00
I knew right away that I wanted to share something little-known—precisely so that it might move a bit beyond that status.
The French band Pryapisme took me by pleasant surprise:

On their debut, the French quartet Pryapisme surprises listeners with a whirlwind of technology harnessed for rock, yet maintains a delicate balance between modern influences and classic 70s sounds. With an unmistakably feline subtlety (hence the cover art), "Suppozitorium Granifujnikoi" uses classic metal-style guitar and organ to evoke an atmosphere akin to the opening of Steve Hackett's Defector, dark, yet updated for modern times. A cello here, a clavichord there, and suddenly a Minimoog, joined by percussion, adds a symphonic flair to an experience that began as something incredibly dense and heavy. Yet such is the nature of this French quartet: "Le doryphore de Kafka" proceeds in the vein of a classically unhinged Frank Zappa, while fellow French artists from Versailles also make their influence felt. There is a Latin-style piano and a guitar sound that straddles the line between Santana and Bill Frisell. Naked City is undoubtedly another influence, further multiplying the sonic possibilities.

It moves from reggae to jazz; then the guitar speeds up, introducing a Russian metal melody, reminiscent of a heavy balalaika, with the piano accompanying the guitar. Quenelle Quenelle Fourrure continues with cello and piano, creating a chamber-music atmosphere; at times, an exquisite trio of piano, cello, and clavichord (or sometimes just piano) takes center stage, evoking a passion worthy of Bach, before building to an almost electronic climax and a distinctly French accordion sound, all bombarded by heavy metal. And the best part? That strange fusion actually works!


The atonal keyboard work in Sanglié par un cornid is reminiscent of Van Der Graaf Generator's Godbluff era, before shifting into an electronic, almost industrial sound. The unifying presence of the cello reminds us that these elements are part of a cohesive whole, while the guitar and bass accelerate with the intensity of an industrial King Crimson; yet, despite the constant stylistic shifts, the sound remains consistent. Darkness Lobotomy Insurrection would be pure grindcore were it not for its progressive interludes, which lend it complexity and operatic depth. Following the classically influenced, video-game-esque interludes, such as Enfoiré une fois, enfoiré deux fois, the track Copaing, le fuligule miloin moves with a heavy, deliberate pace driven by the cello before accelerating in a manner akin to Naked City, straddling the line between hardcore and classical music; amidst this harmonic interplay, one even hears keyboards reminiscent of Hiromi Uehara alongside symphonic synthesizers. It ends with a jazz feel and even a religious chant.

En ce qui concerne le sinistrose de cette fin de siecle, on ne peut se passer de se remémorer chacune des problématique de bon sens has a progressive Italian atmosphere, even becoming circus-like and Fellini-esque, but then the guitars burst in and later the music hall piano...thus this rather sacred heavy rock, at times playing like Van Der Graaf in H to He who Am the only one...and Truffade ou plutôt j'te rappelle appeals to the remnant of calm and virtuosity, until atonality also colors everything...like Wigwam in Fairyport...like Van Der Graaf in Pawn Hearts, playing jazz rock and funk, like all the great classics, this French quartet proves to be brave in their debut, and guillotining the past with homage included, as it should be.

Fercandio46 | 5/5 | 2026-7-1
"A good beginning and a good ending make a good movie, as long as they are close together." Federico Fellini
Back to Top
Fercandio46 View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer
Avatar
Jazz Rock / Fusion Team

Joined: September 06 2023
Location: Argentina
Status: Online
Points: 5764
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Fercandio46 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 24 2026 at 09:08
The second one (there are several, in any case) is a recent discovery that I absolutely loved, as it served as a reunion of sorts with Stereolab—yet it’s something entirely different. While it shares one of the band’s creative leads, this trio heads in a completely new direction, as any good side project should.
It’s Cavern of Anti-Matter:

The name Tim Gane might sound familiar, he is the guitarist for Stereolab, but here, joined by drummer Joe Dilworth and Holger Zapf on synthesizers, he gives free rein to the more krautrock-oriented side of Stereolab, setting aside the baroque arrangements in favor of a sound infused with post-punk, techno, and jazz. However, as soon as "Tardis Cymbals" begins, I, too, was reminded of The Velvet Underground, as well as Kraftwerk, the sensibility of the former combined with the electronic mechanics of the latter. Not only is the rhythm infectious, but, happily, there are overlapping layers; much like clouds forming shapes, one can discern the presence of deliberate composition.

As the foundation progresses, solos emerge, first on keyboards, then on guitar, complemented by reverberations that add a sense of depth and floating space; it is here that points of connection to the parent band become apparent. But that is as far as it goes. The project stands on its own as a purely electronic, experimental, and progressive endeavor.

The funk philosophy inherent in techno makes Blowing My Nose Under Close Observation an irresistible groove, well-suited both for the dance floor and for a stylish, more intimate living room setting. The best part is that this isn't "inorganic" electronic music; the trio plays keyboards, synthesizers, drums, clavinet, guitar, and organ, alongside their use of sequencers and synthesizers. The systematic repetition in "Insect Fear", shifting from low to high, evokes a train climbing an incline, or perhaps something more sinister. There is a touch of surrealism and expressionism in the music composed by Gane, which leaves the nostalgia for the band that first made him known, by a wide margin, far, far behind.

It is a varied, heterogeneous, yet simultaneously homogeneous album. It is the former because it constantly shifts its sonic approach, colors, and textures; it is the latter because it never strays from its foundational premise, a blend of krautrock, post-rock, and progressive electrónica, and the tension never lets up. Melody in High Feedback Tones is ethereal, suspended, and symphonic.

"Hi-Hats Bring the Hiss", nestled between the synthesizer and the guitar strums, sounds experimental and dangerous; there's a touch of Brian Eno, a hint of LCD Soundsystem. It's a kind of dark electronic punk that sinks its teeth into its prey and won't let go. Ominous. Oppressive. It's a pleasure when electronic music can become just as dangerous as rock once was.

Bradford Cox, from the indie band Deerhunter, provides vocals on "Liquid Gate," contributing a touch of psychedelic pop that serves as an effective bridge leading into the techno-infused "Pantechnicon" and the dreamier, more emotive "Black Glass Actions", a track where the spirit of Mary Hansen emerges, channeled in the style of Vangelis.

The album was recorded entirely in Berlin at Bloody Hair studios, and that vibe permeates every track, most notably on "Planetary Folklore." Joe Dilworth, former drummer for Stereolab, was living there at the time, and Holger Zapf is also German.

From the disco-funk of "Echolalia" to the hypnotic, esoteric "Void Beat," the name "Cavern of Anti-Matter" could not be more evocative or fitting; it transports us into a science-fiction universo, drawing on psychedelia, surrealism, and a concept that has no basis in real life. This makes it a concept album, whether or not that was the band's original intention.

Fercandio46 | 4/5 | 2026-10-17
"A good beginning and a good ending make a good movie, as long as they are close together." Federico Fellini
Back to Top
Psychedelic Paul View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: September 16 2019
Location: Nottingham, U.K
Status: Offline
Points: 55182
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (1) Thanks(1)   Quote Psychedelic Paul Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 24 2026 at 09:36
The first album review on my Greek Prog: From Alpha to Omega blog.....

5 stars 2021: Forbidden Myth - Zantea Chronicles: The Dream Dominator - http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLaBU4nHamOnWwcRWn5vOWeV-H2dmxxL_E

FORBIDDEN MYTH       The finest export from Greece since the Elgin Marbles first rolled up onto British shores at the turn of the 19th century - for which the Greeks have never quite forgiven us. Forbidden Myth is the brainchild of Antonis Adelfidis - Greece's answer to Rick Wakeman - ably assisted by multi-instrumentalist George Katsanos, playing together on just about every keyboard instrument they could lay their hands on, and with a cast list of supporting players almost as long as Ben Hur. It's also worth mentioning that Katsanos is a mighty fine singer too. This is the greatest partnership since Burton & Taylor, Bogey & Bacall, or Marks & Spencer. There's an old saying that you should beware of Greeks bearing gifts, but when those same Greeks come bearing gifts of prog albums, then you should welcome them with open arms and with love and kisses too. In the vast pantheon of prog, Adelfidis & Katsanos joins that long list of Greek heroes including, Theseus, Perseus, Odysseus, Vangelis, Roussos & Sideras. Okay, so the first three Greek heroes never formed a prog band as far as I'm aware, but the last three names were all in the same band. You won't find an Achilles Heel in the astounding sounds and amazing music of Forbidden Myth though, as this stunning album is a pure 100% masterpiece from beginning to end. In fact, you won't have heard such masterful keyboard wizardry as this since caped crusader Rick Wakeman first stunned us all with his acclaimed Myths & Legends album. Forbidden Myth target the listener with rip-roaring power chords with the unerring accuracy of a laser-guided Paveway missile. Zantea Chronicles: The Dream Dominator is the towering Acropolis on the Mount in terms of epic prog albums, which even surpasses all of Ayreon's magnificent masterworks. You'll find Forbidden Myth listed under Heavy Prog on ProgArchives, although they almost found their way into the Progressive Metal category, which really wouldn't have done them justice. After all, Zantea Chronicles is far better than any album I've ever heard by Dream Theater, although I can now hear howls of derision coming from DT fans. It's truly an epic album too, running at over 100 minutes long, in the true tradition of Ayreon's epic productions, making it excellent value for money. If you have the good fortune to buy this fine album, then it'll be the best 4,000 drachmas you ever spent. In the vast progosphere, Forbidden Myth are as good as it gets and Zantea Chronicles joins some of the finest European prog albums from Holland, Italy and Germany. And so, for any German prog fans out there, "Das ist Verboten Mythos. Danke schoen und gute nacht."



Edited by Psychedelic Paul - October 24 2026 at 09:36
Back to Top
Fercandio46 View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer
Avatar
Jazz Rock / Fusion Team

Joined: September 06 2023
Location: Argentina
Status: Online
Points: 5764
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (1) Thanks(1)   Quote Fercandio46 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 24 2026 at 09:51
^Fabulous review, Paul! It’s instructive, revealing, and entertainingly funny—it bears your signature style.


I need to learn how to export those gold stars... and it’s a good idea to include the listening link this time.
"A good beginning and a good ending make a good movie, as long as they are close together." Federico Fellini
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 24 2026 at 09:57
^ Thanks guys, I appreciate it. Here is my latest review. It's for an artist I added to Prog Related recently. It's cool to see each others reviews and different styles/approaches for me. As I have been getting into reviewing more (not nearly as much as many others), I have been all the more interested in seeing the different takes and modes of expression.

Glenn Branca - The Ascension (1981).

Glenn Branca's 1981 release The Ascension, issued on the independent label 99 Records, carries a joyous, celebratory energy despite its abrasive sound textures. Recorded by engineer James Farber in Hell's Kitchen and produced by Ed Bahlman, the album moves away from loose No Wave performance groups toward structured pieces written for specific guitar line-ups. The line-up here features four electric guitarists -- including Lee Ranaldo, Ned Sublette, and David Rosenbloom -- alongside Jeffrey Glenn on bass and Stephan Wischerth on drums. The record demonstrates how late-1970s noise rock started to combine with structured, classical arrangements.

The different guitar tunings clash on the recording, and the tracks move forward by steadily picking up speed and volume. The raw sound of the instruments during the sparser movements leaves the production unpolished. While the recording sounds thin and sharp rather than warm, that quality highlights the percussive nature of the guitars.

Branca's arrangements bypass standard rock riffs and focus on volume and tension. The guitars do not play standard melodies, focusing instead on sharp bursts and continuous, droning chords that do not pause, revealing new details upon repeated listens. While I often look for a slow, patient burn in long-form music, the performance here works differently because the musicians play with a lot of direct, shared energy. The shorter compositions, like "Lesson No. 2" and the 5/4 march of "Structure", speed up the pace to build anxiety.

Drummer Stephan Wischerth keeps the beat steady through a series of abrupt chord changes while the guitar work builds into thick feedback loops. When the ensemble plays at high volume, the strings feed back and build into loud crescendos. Without any vocals, these extra tones act like a main melody line and keep the tracks moving forward without breaks.

"The Spectacular Commodity" builds a steady, clanking momentum that mimics a loud machine, moving between harsh noise and sudden bits of melody. While the texture is dense and abrasive, the interlocking rhythms and those melodic phrases breaking through give the piece a joyous energy. It is a lot like later post-rock arrangements, focusing on a slow development instead of quick changes. "The Ascension" finishes the album by delivering a wide contrast, moving from quiet guitar movements into a dense, metallic roar that reverberates as a wall of feedback until the track ends.

The shorter tracks are strong, and the forty-two-minute runtime gives the music the space it needs to develop. The extra ringing notes do not muddy up the main rhythm. The album sits as a solid five-star favourite for me.

Several of the longer pieces sustain notes over long stretches to build toward loud crescendos. This approach is like later bands like Godspeed You! Black Emperor when making long tracks. This focus on heavy volume and repetitive arrangements also mirrors the style Michael Gira developed with Swans, following his time performing in Branca's 1983 Symphony No. 3 line-up. This is music ahead of its time.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLH9ilsHsT1RsdrCNTIZI9PucbDcXhU55V

Edited by Logan - October 24 2026 at 11:12
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
Fercandio46 View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer
Avatar
Jazz Rock / Fusion Team

Joined: September 06 2023
Location: Argentina
Status: Online
Points: 5764
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Fercandio46 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 24 2026 at 10:11
^After reading it, I went to listen to the album, and it largely matched the impression I had formed from the text. The phrase "focusing instead on sharp bursts and continuous, droning chords that do not pause, revealing new details upon repeated listens" is an absolutely accurate description of how it sounds.
In any case, I had imagined something along the lines of Join Hands by Siouxsie and the Banshees—and that’s exactly what it was! I really enjoyed it, too. It felt like an immersive experience of the album.
"A good beginning and a good ending make a good movie, as long as they are close together." Federico Fellini
Back to Top
Psychedelic Paul View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: September 16 2019
Location: Nottingham, U.K
Status: Offline
Points: 55182
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (1) Thanks(1)   Quote Psychedelic Paul Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 24 2026 at 10:25
Originally posted by Fercandio46 Fercandio46 wrote:

^Fabulous review, Paul! It’s instructive, revealing, and entertainingly funny—it bears your signature style.


I need to learn how to export those gold stars... and it’s a good idea to include the listening link this time.


Many thanks Fernando. To export the gold stars, just click on "Quote" to see the five forum codes listed below.

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 stars

Edited by Psychedelic Paul - October 24 2026 at 10:30
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 24 2026 at 10:30
^ Do you guys also have your reviews up on Rate Your Music?

Originally posted by Fercandio46 Fercandio46 wrote:

^After reading it, I went to listen to the album, and it largely matched the impression I had formed from the text. The phrase "focusing instead on sharp bursts and continuous, droning chords that do not pause, revealing new details upon repeated listens" is an absolutely accurate description of how it sounds.

In any case, I had imagined something along the lines of Join Hands by Siouxsie and the Banshees—and that’s exactly what it was! I really enjoyed it, too. It felt like an immersive experience of the album.


That such a great comparison with Siouxsie and the Banshees, a favourite of mine. Thanks. Also Joy Division in there. I like that review of Cavern of Anti-Matter, an album I am going to put on now. Something related to Stereolab, joy! My next reviews might be for Stereolab, although I might do one for Matt Berry first having added him recently.

One more review for me for now:

Boards of Canada - Hi Scores (1996, EP)

The 1996 EP Hi Scores captures the Sandison brothers when their tracking methods were transparent, prior to their focus on heavy tape degradation on later mid-career records. The EP occupies a distinct place in their discography, bypassing the fragile sentimentality of their subsequent releases to present a raw, intense environment, organised in a way that matches how I feel structure.

The title track opens with a cold electro-funk groove -- released on Manchester's Skam label, it uses a simple electronic bassline typical of mid-nineties electronic music and shows their basic programming choices before they began hiding tracks under heavy tape grime. "Turquoise Hexagon Sun" introduces the repetitive shapes and synth patterns they used for years, though despite the melody, it has a tense quality. It remains a track I turn off when the kids are around due to the distinct, adult vocal samples woven into the arrangement.

The flat tuning and detuned synth melody of "Nlogax" warps the sound to induce a literal vertigo. The physical response connects directly through the nervous system -- the unstable pitch shifts trigger a physical reaction in my stomach by travelling from the brain down to the enteric nervous system, making the electronic patterns a physical intrusion. "June 9th" carries that same unsteady, claustrophobic mode by putting fast percussion over a slow beat and low bass. This approach is a lot like The Future Sound of London's Lifeforms from 1994, leaving the tracking to physically affect my physiology. The tension comes from the actual pitch warps caused by the tape machines, building an environment that feels suffocating. "Seeya Later" uses long synth notes to link the early grooves to the end of the record, creating a heavy, slow mood that moves into the final track. "Everything You Do Is a Balloon" offers little comfort, carrying an unease that leaves me unnerved within the context of this album.

Listening to Hi Scores causes my sensory issues and synesthesia to flare up, drawing a fine line between pleasure and pain as the textures collide. The raw programming does not settle my nervous system, triggering an internal friction that makes the entire EP both brilliant and unpleasant to endure. The record is a five-star favourite for me now, acting as a template for psychological disruption. Going back through their catalogue reinforces how essential this early blueprint is.

Note: As it turns out I had an abscess, needs a root canal, and that infection likely helped to cause such a visceral, physical reaction.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_k2WTo4lNY5rcjwshdirUpmHpm8q8xZy_U

Edited by Logan - October 24 2026 at 11:13
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
Psychedelic Paul View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: September 16 2019
Location: Nottingham, U.K
Status: Offline
Points: 55182
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Psychedelic Paul Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 24 2026 at 10:48
No, I've never posted any reviews on Rate Your Music or anywhere else for that matter. ProgArchives is the only prog site I'll ever need, seeing as it's the ultimate resource for progheads like me.

I felt lucky when I found the following album in a charity shop recently for just 99p, which really made my day.

5 stars 1968: The Gun - Gun - https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLxf3X2Xi9rcLFuVbmaO8vr2NNYeA1sB-u

THE GUN        The Gun were an English Hard Rock band consisting of Mr Smith & Mr Wesson, otherwise known as Paul & Adrian Gurvitz, with Louie Farrell providing covering fire on percussion. Gun were previously known as The Knack, with no relation to the band who later had a hit with "My Sharona". Gun were one of the most powerful bands in the land at the time, with a proto- metal sound that could blow your hat clean off. Gun are perhaps best-known for their hit song "Race with the Devil", which went racing like a bullet up the U.K singles chart to No. 8 in November 1968. The high calibre locked and loaded sound of Gun were a Magnum Force to reckon with, opening fire with two Sudden Impact albums in a row:- "Gun" (1968) and "Gunsight" (1969). Brothers Paul & Adrian Gurvitz later went on to deliver another storming Gurvitz Blitz in the early 1970's with their platoon of Three Man Army, which subsequently became the Baker Gurvitz Army, featuring Ginger Baker of Cream. Gun's fired-up debut album has the distinction of being the first album cover designed by album art supremo Roger Dean. Gun will really make your day, but in all the excitement, it's hard to remember whether they fired off seven or eight chambered rounds (or songs) on their debut, or eleven or twelve songs with CD bonus tracks added from The Dead Pool of unused songs. Do you feel lucky?

You're very lucky indeed if you're the proud owner of the original vinyl Gun album, and what better way to open the album than with "Race with the Devil". It's a devilishly good song featuring a killer riff which is arguably one of the best-known speed riffs in the world of Rock. There's no mistaking the dual guitar blitzkrieg of the Gurvitz brothers on "Race with the Devil" and the song also features some marvellously over-the-top manic vocals. It's one of those timeless Rock classics: once heard, never forgotten. The sonic power and speed of the music hits the listener straight between the eyes when combined with the stunning simplicity of the lyrics:- "You better run from the devil's gun, He'll seek you here, He'll seek you there, The devil will seek you everywhere" ...... "Race with the Devil" was a hit song here, there and virtually everywhere. Jimi Hendrix paid tribute to it on his song "Machine Gun" at the Isle of Wight festival in 1970, and it was later famously covered by Heavy Metal band Girlschool on their 1980 "Demolition" debut. Now that we're all fired up from the storming opener, it's time for "The Sad Saga of the Boy and the Bee". You can put the Kleenex tissues away though, because this is a tremendously uplifting song and not remotely sad at all. It's a psychedelic phantasmagorical delight, featuring a grand orchestral opening, the familiar thunderous sound of the Gurvitz brothers twin blitzing guitar attacks, and not forgetting drummer Louie Farrell pounding away ferociously in the background at a frenzied pace. This magnificent epic even includes a wild and demonic version of Rimsky- Korsakov's "Flight of the Bumble Bee" for good measure too. Our third piece of music "Rupert's Travels" takes us on a brief semi-classical instrumental journey of flamenco guitars and full orchestra, which has obvious parallels with Mason Williams "Classical Gas", released in the same flower-power year of 1968. If your eardrums haven't yet been pounded into submission, then try "Yellow Cab Man". Get ready to be taken on a wild psychedelic taxi ride from hell with blood-crazed psychopath Travis Bickle (Robert De Niro), in a song that's all about a Taxi Driver struggling to make a living in the Mean Streets of The Big Apple (circa 1968). "You talking to me!??" ...... "Yellow Cab Man" murderously rampages its way through a Purple Haze of four unrelenting minutes of freaky acid guitar licks and pummelling percussion. The music is just as wild and fuzzy as the Gurvitz brothers frizzy 1960's afro-hairdos. Having blazed a trail through four romping, stomping songs, we now arrive at one of the most bizarre songs on the album: "It Won't Be Long (Heartbeat)". This song is as barmy as an army of weirdy-beardy vegetarians working at a meat-packing plant. The song opens to a cacophony of discordant sounds before emerging into a typical plodding blues riff, sounding like the heartbeat of the title. It's the echoing off-kilter vocals which really sets this freaky song apart though, and listen out for the very strange ending when the "heartbeat" slows..right...down....to.....a......crawl.......and........then.........comes..........to..........a...........complete............Stop.

The Gurvitz power trio are gunning for glory with the opening number on Side Two, so Pop the champagne cork and get ready to celebrate with the Beatle-esque sound of "Sunshine" - a warm and radiant burst of glorious Sunshine Pop. This bright and bubbly fizzy Pop concoction is overflowing with triumphant hope and optimism, and features a rousing chorus that's positively bursting with joy and love:- "Sun shines brightly every day, Let it shine, Let it shine." ..... It's a song which inevitably brings to mind the equally joyous sound of "Sunshine of Your Love" by Cream. It's Poptastic! We're entering moody and magnificent territory now with the stupendous sound of "Rat Race" - a celestial song which has all of the anthemic majesty and splendour of "Nights in White Satin", complete with lush strings and heavenly harmonies to die for. It's an epic ballad which proudly displays its pompous prog colours in a richly orchestrated symphonic soundscape. And now for something completely different as we arrive at the eighth and final song on the album: "Take Off!" This is where Gun really get to fly high and trip the light fantastic by throwing caution to the wind in an 11-minute long psychedelic freak out. The storming closing number is a booming and bombastic show of force where the band are going out with all guns blazing in this supersonic blast from the past.

Gun's stunning debut has all the unstoppable power and force of Dirty Harry's Smith & Wesson fifty calibre Magnum revolver. Gun is one of the highest rated albums on ProgArchives, and deservedly so too. The album comes pre-loaded with eight high calibre, full metal jacketed songs, with extra ammo provided on the CD reissue. Go out and buy the album from your local Gun dealer. It'll make your day!
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (1) Thanks(1)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 24 2026 at 11:22
^ Like me, you like more than just prog and more than just music in PA. I added The Gun to Proto-Prog and there's lot of relevant to PA material missing from the 'chives. But for me it's also about duplication, because at any time the data could be lost from a site or the site could go down. For that matter the whole internet could be shot to hell, so good not to keep all your bullets in the same revolver.

Anyway, I like The Gun, The Gun is good!



EDIT: I will add in another Fishmans review. It's not a concert i would recommend to people not already a fan of Fishmans, but I found it to be a moving tribute.

Fishmans - Live 2011/5.3 at Hibiya Open-Air Concert Hall "A Piece of Future"

A Piece of Future The Resilient Joy of Fishmans

This is a joyous and life-affirming concert despite the related tragedy, or perhaps more so because of it. People can be incredibly resilient, paying fond homage to that which has been while moving forward with joy and pride. The entire event is a celebration.

In 1999, the Fishmans frontman, singer, primary songwriter, and guitarist Shinji Sato passed away. This effectively put an end to the original group, but the tribute project Fishmans+ formed later for live performances, bringing together surviving members and various guest musicians. Only the longest composition, "A Piece of Future," is performed under the Fishmans+ name, while the core band and an array of guests deliver the rest of the setlist. This concert acts as a tribute to Shinji Sato, whose father was involved in organising the event not long before he also passed away. It stands too as a tribute to the collaborator Honzi, the violinist and keyboardist who died in 2007. This performance took place two months after the 2011 Tohoku earthquake and tsunami, adding a layer of communal healing to the atmosphere.

This concert is an experience best seen rather than merely heard. Watching the crowd standing in the rain adds to the atmosphere, it makes me connect with the event on more of an emotional level. And witnessing the genuine smiles and enthusiasm makes the performance feel extra special. The audible sound of the rain falling during the quieter moments provides a quiet delicacy. While having a grasp of the Japanese language or access to subtitles helps to follow the band's interactions with the crowd, the overarching emotion requires no translation. Because I have worked and travelled extensively in Japan -- a place that changed the course of my life -- this happening carries a deeply personal resonance for me. An existing familiarity with the Fishmans discography deepens this appreciation, as I am an ardent fan of their work.

One of the traits of Fishmans was their consistent desire to improvise and evolve their studio compositions for live stages. Every live iteration of a song reveals differences. The music in this set shifts and moves, revealing new details upon repeated listens. While I tend to favour their late-1990s output, the collaborative nature of this lineup injects new creative perspectives into the classic material. Sato's final composition, "A Piece of Future," which originally clocked in around eight minutes, is transformed here into a sprawling twenty-six-minute epic. The spoken-word opening bears a resemblance to the approach of Swans, taking on distinct post-rock qualities.

Instrumentally, the performance holds heavy weight. Drummer Kin-ichi Motegi, a very significant member of the original band and a driving force behind this reunion, guides the rhythm effectively. His vocal contributions are fitting, and he steps into the frontman role with an infectious warmth that translates directly to the listener. The guitar work throughout is prominent, and the addition of the guest vocalists and a choir expands the emotional scale of the music. In the absence of Honzi's violin and accordion textures, the guest instrumentalists fill those roles with grace.

The dub and reggae influence remains a core element of this performance. Fishmans operated primarily as a dub outfit in their early years before mutating into dream-pop and neo-psychedelia, and this set balances those worlds. Tracks like "In the Flight" and "Weather Report", two of my personal favourites, receive live treatments here alongside "Walking in the Rhythm" and "Night Cruising". The performance of "I Dub Fish" demonstrates how the band's instrumental interludes lift the compositions. The inclusion of hip-hop elements demonstrates the varied style of this collective. Fishmans possesses the unique ability to make me appreciate genres that typically fall outside my core wheelhouse; they are the band that ultimately taught me to love dub.

While the performance of "Season" is strong, the inclusion of "Long Season" could have extended the evening further. Even within an already lengthy setlist, a forty-minute iteration of that piece would have been a welcome addition. While omitting it leaves a minor sense of regret, the concert sits as a highly valuable record of the group for me. With persistent rumours of further reunion dates, this recording stands as a historically vital document of one of modern music's most unique ensembles.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LM3q6fBOK_c

------------------------------------

Note, unlike Paul's very humorous reviews, I have got much more serious over the years in the way I write. I still throw in some absurdist humour now and then. I said in my father's eulogy that he often made puns that were clever, but rarely funny (that got a laugh). I have been told much the same, minus the clever bit.

Edited by Logan - October 24 2026 at 12:01
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 24 2026 at 12:31
One more for me for now. I posted this topic in part as response to the frontpage being flooded by singular user reviews, and so it would problematic for me in turn to flood this venue with mine. But when would that ever stop me? ;) Ed O'Brien, who was in Radiohead, is an artist I was very happy to add to PA earlier this year due to his second album Blue Morpho. It is currently my second favourite album of 2026.

Ed O'Brien - Blue Morpho (2026)

Blue Morpho has grown on me with repeated spins. A few tracks resonated immediately, while the rest took some time to love. A Moon Shaped Pool was the first Radiohead album that I connected with, and this record carries a similar lush, melancholic weight. It feels warmer and more emotionally grounded than recent side projects on the whole, even though I love The Smile.

"Incantations" blends acoustic patterns and backing vocals reminiscent of Popol Vuh or David Bowie's Blackstar, while the title track features acoustic lines and string textures that recall Nick Drake's debut. "Sweet Spot" carries this melancholic quality, using a violin melody similar to Ramin Djawadi's Westworld score alongside the production style of later AIR.

On "Teachers," the record turns toward driving Krautrock and cold ambient sounds. The track evokes a motorik rhythm inspired by NEU! and Can's "Vitamin C" underneath a gritty electronica energy, carrying a raw vinyl dis-polish that brings Portishead to mind, providing a stark contrast to the ambient space of "Solfeggio" and "Thin Places." This material veers toward classic Warp Records, capturing a cosmic desolation like Cluster and Brian Eno alongside Shabaka Hutchings' flutes and Oneohtrix Point Never-style tape manipulations.

The album concludes with "Obrigado," opening with a dub atmosphere indebted to Fishmans' "Thank You" before moving into a bluesy guitar direction that feels heavily influenced by Funkadelic's "Maggot Brain" and shares the ambitious scale of Sufjan Stevens' "Djohariah."

Over time, Blue Morpho has realised its full potential as a five-star record. Its atmospheric mix of folk, Krautrock, and post-rock suits my tastes. While O'Brien's reputation as a guitarist precedes him, the record functions less as a conventional performance showcase and more as a deliberate exercise in nuance, atmosphere, and textural depth.

https://edobrien.bandcamp.com/album/blue-morpho
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLS4jAfE9d3aLlXX6C9ixmGLG3gcGiEqx5

Edited by Logan - October 24 2026 at 12:32
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 25 2026 at 15:06
While I appreciate very much that Fernando and Paul took the time to post their reviews and the comments on people's reviews, I had hoped that more of the reviewers would take part. I only have about 35 music reviews (I wrote film reviews long ago) so may not be as locked into a style as some others, but I do repeat the same kinds of themes in my reviews as with my posts. We all have a voice, but some are more distinct than others. I have spent hours trying to rework my Stereolab review, and I got it to a point where I am quite happy. I wanted to say more about ideology. I tend not to go for the track-by-track analysis that many like and am more overall thematic in approach perhaps, if that makes sense. I feel like I want to hone in on one or two major aspects to me with each album for a review, and use that as an anchor-point. I probably am overthinking it all. A friend told me about my stories that I ruin them by over-editing, over polishing, over-thinking them and they lose their immediacy.

Stereolab - Instant Holograms on Metal Film (2025)

Instant Holograms on Metal Film became my most cherished album of the year. While the band has been important to me for years, catching them live on the supporting tour later in the year connected me with the expression more profoundly.

People complain that the album echoes the same old Stereolab instead of offering something innovative, and when listening to much of their music, the approach can feel formulaic. Their stereotypical sound relies on a continuous, unbroken Krautrock groove. Laetitia Sadier’s vocal delivery gives the arrangement a jumpy, fragmented feel. Her singing is staccato, rhythmic, and measured, separating vocal syllables into a flat, monotonous "Da-da-da-da" pattern. Breaking up the syllables means the voice stops acting like a front-and-centre pop melody and instead meshes directly with the rhythm section, becoming another part of the beat.

This material presents a distinct dichotomy. While it is joyous on the surface, it has a revolutionary thrust. The music presents a sharp clash, where the lyrics on songs like "Aerial Troubles" confront an "insatiable state of consumption (systemic)" and an "assigned trajectory (extortion)". Sadier uses this bright avant-pop format to challenge political apathy, explaining that her desire is "to elevate above the crass(ness) that we are dictated to absorb day in day out". The tracks lean into signature motorik patterns and systemic resistance, driven by Sadier’s consistent ideology and her desire to fight the system. I am socialist leaning myself, yet her fierce idealism now feels quaint and nostalgic in today's bleak and all too apathetic age. When confronted with so many existential risks, it can be easy to resign oneself to that dire inevitability, or just ignore it.

Providing a strange sort of shelter from that heavy modern exhaustion, the music loops together sounds from an earlier era that we might see through rose-tinted glasses -- a time standing at its own anxious crossroads. The future still felt open and uncertain, leaving significant space for optimism. The driving rhythms of NEU!, vintage space-age pop, retro library music, and 1960s French chanson styled after Serge Gainsbourg and Jean-Claude Vannier create a familiar, protective space. Lounge psychedelia a la David Axelrod melds into their classic indie-pop aesthetic, wrapping the listener in rich layers of sound that feed directly into that comforting, nostalgic escape.

Various of my favourite tracks are "Melodie is a Wound", "Immortal Hands", "Electrified Teenybop!", "Vermona F Transistor", "Aerial Troubles", "Le coeur et la force", "Transmuted Matter", and "Esemplastic Creeping Eruption".

Stereolab may not be the most radically varied band across their thirty-five-year career, but they are easily one of the grooviest bands alive -- and for anyone exhausted by the current state of things, this familiar, unwavering groove is why this return is a sanctuary worth holding onto.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_n4hTfmpLAvMvSJA8XESgafs66sDEdZGEA
https://stereolab.bandcamp.com/album/instant-holograms-on-metal-film


Edited by Logan - October 25 2026 at 15:15
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
verslibre View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: July 01 2004
Location: CA
Status: Offline
Points: 24328
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote verslibre Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 25 2026 at 17:04
Originally posted by Logan Logan wrote:

Glenn Branca - The Ascension (1981).

Glenn Branca's 1981 release The Ascension, issued on the independent label 99 Records, carries a joyous, celebratory energy despite its abrasive sound textures. Recorded by engineer James Farber in Hell's Kitchen and produced by Ed Bahlman, the album moves away from loose No Wave performance groups toward structured pieces written for specific guitar line-ups. The line-up here features four electric guitarists -- including Lee Ranaldo, Ned Sublette, and David Rosenbloom -- alongside Jeffrey Glenn on bass and Stephan Wischerth on drums. The record demonstrates how late-1970s noise rock started to combine with structured, classical arrangements.


Excellent review, LoG! If I were unfamiliar with Branca, I'd want to hear him based just on your insights.
Back to Top
Atavachron View Drop Down
Special Collaborator
Special Collaborator
Avatar
Honorary Collaborator

Joined: September 30 2006
Location: Pearland
Status: Offline
Points: 67577
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Atavachron Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 25 2026 at 17:06
One of my personal favorite albums and reviews --



Morgan Fisher is a genius.

There, I said it. I mean, how else could he make some of the most inventive and interesting prog rock on the planet and end up in his late 50s writing music for commercials in Japan, and getting a pretty penny for it I would hope. Sounds like a good gig to me, and a good life lived for this king of B-list prog, master of the sideshow and winner of countless Best Music No One Really Cares About awards. I don't know, maybe Fisher's playfulness appeals to me (something often missing from today's prog). Or maybe his truly impressive musical range and compositional gifts are just too hard to ignore despite the funhouse feeling on this debut from 1972. And then there's the spectacle. All I know is Nova Solis is spilling over with atmosphere and imagery, and the fact is that Morgan Fisher gave more on his records than many of the bigger names of the time. It's an album wherein, as John Lennon said of Mr. Kite; "You should be able to smell the sawdust".

Nova Solis is an extravaganza of what had become possible with the rock format, a parade of idea after idea passing like giant floats, each eagerly waiting in line to be revealed. This is prog when things were closer to the wild west, with as many snakeoil salesmen and roaming criminals as reliable merchants and ranchers. But among the scoundrels, Morgan Fisher and songwriting partner Tim Staffell were legit. Simply put, this LP was the sh*t-- the absolutely real thing, authentic, strong as aged goat cheese and stinking of a far off place where no good things were happening. It's what the guys who have heard it all and know classic era prog inside & out quietly listen to when no one else is around. Every aging, coffee-swilling cigarette smoker with a bad hankerin' for prog and a tragically steady paycheck who's collection from Britain between 1969 and 1979 is larger than that thing they launched the space shuttle from will deny to their death this is the godsmack of second tier symphonic prog. But it is.

Similarities are hard to peg for these guys, it was such an original group. Certainly the brilliant descriptive and incidental work of Raymond Scott is apparent in Fisher's material, as well as Syd Barrett's sense of adventure, the circuses of Dave Greenslade and maybe a whiff of Zappa. 'Samarkhand the Golden' is wonderful vintage stuff enhanced liberally by Fisher's VCS 3 synth, Hohner & DK 1, Mo Bacon's eager drums and bassist Rob Sapsed doing a heroic job enhancing Fisher and Staffell's arrangement. Derivative 'Alone' is a miss but 'War Games' rocks, Bacon tearing up his drums, Staffell's vaguely biblical lyric and giddy vocal, and Fisher terrific on all number of keys from a Steinway Grand to a Hammond to a Spinet as he knits up the background, always sure to never let a good moment go to waste. Holst's 'Jupiter' from The Planets starts the second half, the nine part title piece. It's not long before things start melting apart into sound effects and space sickness but Morgan picks it up and pumps out the prog; mean organ flurries, unexpected jazzplay, piano lines merging into squealing synths, descriptive mood-setting, carousels, calliopes, histrionic dramaturgy, and more Holst at the end.

A one of a kind release by a band that epitomised the working prog musician and what a few inspired guys could do with some good equipment. Someday along your listening journey, Morgan Fisher's work deserves your attention. Maybe not today, maybe not tomorrow. But soon, and for the rest of your life.



"Too often we enjoy the comfort of opinion without the discomfort of thought."   -- John F. Kennedy
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 25 2026 at 18:50
^^ Thanks Verslibre, I appreciate that very much.

When Worlds Collide

^ David, adding that Casablanca line in at the end is a nice touch, and the whole write-up has a lively flow to it where your enthusiasm shines, in fact it almost blinded me! (I really like the positivity).

"Of all the pirate signals in all the towns in all the world, she has to crawl out of my television screen and ask if I've got any porno." And with that awkward movie mash-up, I'll share a review of mine that also has a line of dialogue at the end -- this time from Cronenberg's Videodrome:

Boards of Canada - Boc Maxima

Boc Maxima started as a private 1996 cassette distributed to a small inner circle of family and friends before leaking into the early-2000s file-sharing ether. Rather than a collection of loose bedroom demos, the tape serves as the blueprint of what Boards of Canada would become. A sound wave does not change its geometry, but its impact shifts based on the order of the sequence. Sandwiched between dark sketches and deliberate, haunting fade-ins, these familiar melodies lose their polished studio insulation. The timeline operates less like a passive playlist and more like a continuous midnight broadcast.

Taken as a whole, the tape has a rougher, more immediate edge than the official albums that followed. The melodies and rhythms sound direct and unadorned, lacking the spacious depth of their debut. Familiar musical ideas show up here in a basic form, frequently interrupted by tape hiss or sudden silences that take away the comfort of the later versions. Without a smooth mix, these repetitive tunes and brief acoustic moments feel less like deliberate album tracks and more like fragments caught on a fading radio signal.

The tracklist mixes exclusive material with altered versions of songs that later became famous. Tracks like "Niagara," "Red Moss," and "Whitewater" remain trapped on this cassette, never appearing on any official retail release. Other pieces underwent noticeable changes before their wider distribution; "Chinook" appears here in a short form before it was extended into a heavy vinyl single, Boc Maxima was later renamed "Bocuma" for their debut album, and several core songs feature alternate stereo panning or different background layers. Even the tracks that remained unaltered, like "Roygbiv" or "Nlogax," carry a different weight here simply because they are sequenced next to these raw rarities.

The movement of this tape operates similarly to entering the uncanny dimensions of The Twilight Zone, where science meets superstition, alongside the OBLIVION signal in Cronenberg's Videodrome, and the unrepeatable frequency of the 1977 Wow! signal. The bleeding transitions carry a distinct Blue Jam late-night radio logic. The continuous flow warps this familiar pastoral nostalgia, where childhood memory and cold, apocalyptic dread exist in an uneasy harmony. Long live the new flesh!

Edited by Logan - October 25 2026 at 19:30
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 26 2026 at 22:35
Earlier today I wrote a short "review" for Blackstar, and wanted to write a long-form review. I don't usually do full track-by-track reviews but this time I felt it suited the album well.

David Bowie - Blackstar (2016)

David Bowie's Blackstar serves not just as the culmination of a career, but a life. Created during terminal illness, the album confronts mortality without defeat. It stands as a definitive final statement within art rock, where the tragic reality of his physical decline coexists with his musical evolution. The music draws on the distinct textures of his past -- from the acoustic whimsy of the late 1960s and the aggressive art-rock of his Berlin period, to nineties industrial textures and the reflections of Heathen and The Next Day -- to reshape them into a final, unified statement. His condition deepens the work, creating a human and deeply vital record that evokes profound grief while remaining fiercely life-affirming. The emotional core shows how a life's journey transformed the art.

Listening through the record is less about witnessing a departure and more about experiencing a complete life cycle. The arrangements reflect a man reviewing his own past work, using his past musical identities not as simple nostalgia, but as tools to navigate his current reality. By balancing a heavy, looming finality with a persistent sense of play and exploration, the music avoids becoming a grim dirge, carrying instead a quality of stoic joy.

"Blackstar" opens with an unsettled, minor-key rhythm and low woodwinds, creating a heavy atmosphere of occult paranoia. The lyrics centre on a dark ritual in the town of Ormen, where a dead astronaut's jewelled skull is recovered to make way for a new, nameless figure. But this opening structure splinters and dissolves into a soaring melody for the line "Something happened on the day he died," dropping into a funky groove where he asserts, "I'm a blackstar, way up, on money, I've got game." This unexpected warmth holds a joyous space before the music shifts back to the opening motif.

Live acoustic drumming drives the breathless pace of "'Tis a Pity She Was a Whore." The saxophone lines echo the sharp, staccato accents of the rhythm section, creating a tight unison. Lyrically, the song pulls from seventeenth-century tragedy to explore themes of violence and vanity, using a blunt vocal style that connects to the ragged rhythms of his nineties work. The abrasive delivery of lines like "Man, she punched me like a dude" underscores this energy, shaping a harsh, chaotic performance.

"Lazarus" functions as a monologue on confinement and liberation, built on a slow, heavy bassline and a bleak post-punk guitar line reminiscent of his late-seventies Berlin period. The opening declaration -- "Look up here, I'm in heaven" -- carries a detached poise that confronts bodily decline directly. The vocal delivery carries an echo of "Sweet Thing" from Diamond Dogs, connecting his illness directly to his mid-seventies peak.

"Sue (Or in a Season of Crime)" invokes a sense of madness in the face of death. Its bleak narrative has a ragged rhythm, making the experience visceral. The desperation of the line "Endless faith in hopeless deeds" echoes the psychological collapse shown through the music itself, providing a sharp structural contrast to the vulnerability of "Lazarus."

"Girl Loves Me" uses a stark, echoing drum beat that leaves the vocals prominent in a hollow space. The lyrics use an abrasive, invented vocabulary of Nadsat and Polari slang to map out a disorienting sense of slipping time -- centred around the repeating question "Where the [%*!#] did Monday go?" This line delivers a gritty confusion that connects to his mid-nineties industrial work with Trent Reznor rather than fitting under a generic art-rock label.

"Dollar Days" features a nostalgic sound, carrying a melodic atmosphere similar to Nick Drake's "River Man." The arrangement has warm strings and fluid acoustic guitar, softening the earlier abrasive edges. The recurring realization -- "I'm dying to" -- stands out as a quiet confession against the smooth orchestration. Lyrically, the song processes memory, landscape, and departure, with the horn lines wandering loose through the melody before the final track.

"I Can't Give Everything Away" sets a buoyant, life-affirming rhythm against a guarded set of lyrics. The track opens on a familiar harmonica loop from "A New Career in a New Town," linking this final piece to that 1977 Berlin atmosphere. Lines like "Seeing more and feeling less" carry a distinct defiance, showing a man pushing back against the grain even as things draw to a close.

But after the music has finished playing, that resistance stops. The final fade leaves a sense of quiet resignation and a fading light, moving past the defiance into a frail, personal grace that accepts the inevitable end.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_k9zz5HH6wfeoWzK5VnHRd68UrIzKr3frI

Please keep your reviews coming! I find them very interesting to read.

Edited by Logan - November 05 2026 at 19:50
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
Lewian View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer
Avatar
Avant/Zeuhl, Post Rock/Math Rock Teams

Joined: August 09 2015
Location: Italy
Status: Offline
Points: 17737
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (1) Thanks(1)   Quote Lewian Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 27 2026 at 10:07
Blackstar is a masterpiece, I love it and have played it lots of times, but other than superficially I haven't engaged with the lyrics, allusions and connections to past work. Your review is the kind of review that can give even somebody who knows the albums quite well something new to reflect on, and so it adds to the experience that is Blackstar, at least for me.
I make typos so you see I'm not a machine, but I may be a machine pretending to not be a machine.
Back to Top
Logan View Drop Down
Forum & Site Admin Group
Forum & Site Admin Group
Avatar
Site Admin

Joined: April 05 2006
Location: Vancouver, BC
Status: Offline
Points: 43931
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Logan Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: October 28 2026 at 10:08
^ Thanks Christian; much appreciated. I wanted to do a deeper dive, but chose to be fairly economical. That and Rock Bottom are the two albums, when framing them with their surrounding context, that I would most like to write long-form essays on. They are both deeply poignant to me.

I liked your Blackstar review -- you have written quite a few of my favourite reviews on the site. The emotion in your I a Moon review really resonates with me, and you write with fantastic economy. It's great to connect with someone over the same music.

I appreciate reviews that express genuine emotion and seem to feel the music. Too many, IMO, end up reading like hype pieces, show an unfamiliarity with the material, or follow a formula that deadens the text. The great thing with such writing spaces can be the variety, though -- different perspectives and different approaches.

On another note, I enjoyed Fernando's review of Marius Popp's Panoramic JazzRock that followed mine on the front page. It's an album I've treasured for years after a PA poster recommended it to me -- "Inscriptie" in particular is an all-time favourite track. It's wonderful to see it in the archives. The Breaking the Waves mention was great too -- I love that film and saw it in the cinema.

Coincidentally, in a recent review I wrote a whole paragraph comparing the music to Lars von Trier's Melancholia (a film that profoundly affected me), but I ended up cutting it when I realised it didn't quite jibe with the main point I wanted to focus on. Paul sure has managed to fit in a lot of references in his reviews with humorous intent. Go ahead, make my play... on words. :)

Anna von Hausswolff - The Miraculous (2015)

In a 2018 interview with Laura Snapes for the Guardian, organist Anna von Hausswolff noted that women working in extreme, male-dominated genres are routinely forced to defend their art under a hyper-focused gender lens rather than a structural one. She observed that there is more focus on them being female than on their work, adding that it is still weird for people to see someone screaming and playing loud music. The past decade produced a surge of self-made art-pop and avant-rock figures. While some, like Kristin Hayter (Lingua Ignota), Chelsea Wolfe, Otay:onii, and Xandra Metcalfe (Uboa), built reputations on raw, confrontational soundscapes, others, like Susanne Sundfør, Jenny Hval, Melody Prochet (Melody's Echo Chamber), Pan Daijing, and Julia Holter, navigate intricate, delicate arrangements. Within this spectrum, von Hausswolff's work pairs melodic vocal lines with darkwave tones.

As her third album, The Miraculous acts as a transitional bridge between the atmospheric darkwave of Ceremony and the sound of Dead Magic. Her earlier reliance on ecclesiastical organ drones shifts here toward prominent, overdriven guitars. The music adopts a gothic, occult aesthetic, flirting with black metal textures -- a style von Hausswolff showed an early interest in, having sung in a Black Sabbath cover band at age sixteen. "The Discovery" opens the album with a sharp, cinematic tension.

The extended frameworks share an aesthetic kinship with the slow-burning post-rock of Swans, an ensemble von Hausswolff toured with and joined on Leaving Meaning. The pieces occupy distinct physical spaces built on deep neoclassical drones and gradual dynamic shifts. The driving, hypnotic movement of "Pomperipossa" and the swirling space of "Evocation" define the core of the record. The album closes with "Stranger", ending on a quiet, poignant resolution.

Listeners familiar with the layout of Dead Can Dance or Julia Holter, particularly her album Aviary, will find common ground here. The incremental builds achieve depth without sacrificing melodic sophistication.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_mLRHBWRboLesFShTWh_mweBf7KEC5uKCk

Edited by Logan - November 06 2026 at 18:47
Music is a living, emotional relationship meant to be experienced, not just dissected.
Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  123>

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down



This page was generated in 0.172 seconds.
Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.