Author |
Topic Search Topic Options
|
bucka001
Forum Senior Member
Joined: November 16 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 864
|
Topic: NearFest X reviews Posted: June 23 2008 at 10:56 |
Did anyone go? Any reports? (I'm especially curious to know how a completely solo Hammill went over with the crowd)
|
jc
|
 |
King of Loss
Prog Reviewer
Joined: April 21 2005
Location: Boston, MA
Status: Offline
Points: 17059
|
Posted: June 23 2008 at 12:01 |
It was awesome.
Banco was fantastic and Hammill was pretty good. Watch for a more detailed review later.
|
 |
Mikerinos
Forum Senior Member
Joined: August 11 2005
Location: Planet Gong
Status: Offline
Points: 8890
|
Posted: June 23 2008 at 12:09 |
Hammill performed great, I would say his voice sounded just as good if not better than on Trisector or Present. Most people enjoyed it, but the LTE fans/family members dragged along might not have so much. I can't remember all the songs he played, many I'm unfamiliar with since it's mostly more modern solo stuff, but I recognized Still Life, In the Black Room / The Tower, A Way Out, Amnesiac, Central Hotel, and maybe another one or two.
I'd have to rank it:
1. Banco, they were really stunning and played everything beautifully, awesome way to end NEARfest. 2/3. Hammill / Koenjihyakkei. Already described Hammill a bit, got to talk with him for a few minutes and it was just awesome, he's really friendly and vibrant. Koenjihyakkei were really intense live, even compared to the already intense studio albums, the most avant-garde band there by far. 4. Radio Massacre International. I only knew they were an electronic band coming in so I figured it would be okay, but I was really blown away. Definitely the biggest surprise for me, they were a good break after LTE and Morglbl the next day. 5. Echolyn. They played a nice variety of material from different albums and moods, flowed together nicely with some humorous interludes. 6. Liquid Tension Experiment. Played stuff from their first two albums flawlessly, incl. When the Water Breaks, plus two new songs which seemed great. 7. Morglbl. Definitely the biggest surprise this year, really talented musicians and nice/funny guys (notice a pattern?). 8. Discipline. I'm not really into them, but people who were seemed to love it.
I couldn't get tickets to the preshow, unfortunately.
|
|
 |
Fight Club
Prog Reviewer
Joined: May 21 2006
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 572
|
Posted: June 23 2008 at 14:59 |
I was there and it was just amazing. It was nice meeting some cool people there (Hello Bluesaga and KingofLoss). Show was awesome.
Banco - I couldn't believe how good these guys were. Just a plain fantastic performance. They completely blew away my expectations.
Echolyn - They were pretty good, but didn't deviate much from what you would expect based on their studio recordings.
Radio Massacre International - were just incredible. I had chills down my spine through their entire set.
Morglbl - Biggest surprise of the show. I wasn't familiar with them prior to their performance and they were great. They were really comical, great musicians, and awesome people.
LTE - It's LTE, what do you expect? They were great.
Peter Hammill - The long time VDGG fans seemed to dig this. I haven't been into VDGG that long and am not familiar with Hammill's solo work, so I couldn't get into it as easily. He still performed well though.
Discipline - Biggest disappoint. I had heard these guys were good and bought their cd prior to their performance. I kind of wish I didn't now. They played very lazily and seemed very uninspired. I saw a lot of people falling asleep during this one.
Koenjihyakkei - Just an awesome band and performance. Was jaw was agape the entire time. This group is just insane and really cool people as well.
|
|
 |
CaincelaOreinim
Forum Senior Member
Joined: April 21 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 395
|
Posted: June 23 2008 at 16:08 |
NEARfest Review of mine from PE, apologize for wacky font sizes; cut and pasted from a word document:
Well I'm back, at ahem 01:54AMhundred East-coast time,
at the start of this entry (and now ending at ~3:43AMhundred East-coast time)
documenting NEARfest X's Zoellner Arts Center (apparently) "For Stoned
People" performances - anyone ELSE catch that somewhat fading graffiti
outside the entrance?! Stoned People I thought…isn't that the very…least? Being
stoned is even too much in my case…hah.
First off let me commend/preach to the choir those whom are amongst the only
people on Earth it seems these days who can actually still listen attentively,
assiduously to music (except for obnoxious solipsistic balconite who like a
fool would do, thought it commendable to share his feelings outright on a
continuously insufferable level to my immediate and seahound-scented right; you
know who you are amidst PE - 'nuff said and I will not continue with the
singling out…)like it's an art.
Secondly, if I can make some absolutely miniscule criticism of the venue
itself, NEARfest needs new mics as it is poorly miced AND easy, easy with the
lights man...goddamn! Why/blasphemy w/r/t sound?! One would be quick to blame
the bands/players/soundmen etc. but when you strain (and sometimes straining
won't do it) to hear a) snare hits, b) low end, c) acoustic guitars, and d) any
singled out instrument whilst the band plays simultaneously through most if not
every band, you know something is definitely not set accordingly…if anyone can
clear up whether it's just a matter of individual soundmen for every band or
the venue itself or some other particular feel free to put me in my place! Bands:
Observe: I didn't catch Synergy or Fish as my ride couldn't make Friday
night…would've liked to BUT if it's of any consolation I saw Steely Dan that
night instead who were fannntastic!
Koenjihyakkai - Arriving in from NY (and with a ride to boot this time hurrah!,
no more 6-9 hour bus-trips…next year might not be so lucky as ride wasn't
exactly thrilled with bulk of NF) I happened to hasten into K's set perhaps
during the middle of their first number. Knowing they'd probably be the most
extreme of all the bands I was prepped yet not unfamiliar. I'm not so sure
these guys should be witnessed after a decent 2 hour plus car-trip and on an
empty stomach…at times I sufficiently felt like I had left the world and the
over the top rainbow lights really augmented my projection too; although, this
might not have been a bad thing. Really excellent vocalist, rhythm section
(tight, shifty, and slinky) and sax (loved the females' freak-out solos and
dance moves heh)…Magma-esque but this goes with the territory. Can't say I
remember any of the track titles off-hand and eventually all their material
seems to blur together. B+
Discipline - Was mostly impressed with their guitarist who I feel on record
doesn't come off as strong/competent in a live setting: very serpentine body
language and aural equivalent; sometimes, especially in the new song they
debuted/tested, he was very Starless Bible Black era Fripp like...there was
even a Fractured bit therein. I recognized the majority of their songs however
I find the problem with their material is that it tends to just overstay its
welcome dragging and plodding along. Two songs within a forty minute time-frame
and 5 overall can do that I suppose but I think it would've been more
accommodating had they implemented the shorter pieces they've written into
their set somewhere. Parmenter was in good form although I somehow expected
antics/theatricality? Was he known to do more stuff like this a la old Genesis?
The rhythm section was alright but I thought the bass was a bit too muddy and
indistinct…again, would've liked to have heard The Nursery Year, The Reasoning
Wall, and/or Faces of the Petty just to get a little diversity. B
Peter Hammill - Again kudos to those with ears…honestly the hush that befell
the auditorium was palpable throughout his set. When the iconic Hammill stepped
to his piano I knew the divide was going to form and up top in the balcony many
walked out through the fury. While I listened to his set a thought that ran
through my head: PH is the vocal epitome of Death. Death can be utterly
graceful, graceless, raw, uninhibited, merciless, merciful, anxious, anguished,
etc.…all qualities I feel very much serve his modus operandi/performance and
how others view/are jarred by him…there were times when I felt like I was sitting
in a funeral parlor, holy-white smocked wraith-like Hammill in the corner our
aha, 'house music', and yet other times extremely soothed as if about to be let
go…let me know if this is weird guys aha! I'm not familiar with all 40+ (or
some such…) of his solo albums but am a paretty big VdGG fan. Some
highlights/songs I recognized include Amnesiac, a song where he kept repeating
the words "Out____" in a list-poem fashion (to which someone behind
me heaved an "oh man" at its end - agreed!), and Still Life which
absolutely slayed me, bringing me to tears. A
LTE - I'll preface this by saying I'm continuously on the fence with these
musicians (mostly the DT guys, Levin is always quality; alas more on him
later). But honestly, what the helll happened here? I can go on a looong ass
rant about how miserably disappointed I was with LTE but to make things
erhm...short (like the rest of this review so far hah?): a botched intro (of
aggrandized classical-culled stupidity to which I'm not even sure the band KNEW
was short-circuited/left us suspending in purple-tinted darkness), Portnoy's
speeches in which he compared When The Water Breaks to Supper's Ready; you
can't be serious! and said something to the effect of "we don't have much
to work with here guys…so bear with us" (oh really!?), the kind of
tailor-made 'musicianship' these DT guys masquerade under (does anyone actually
think outside of Levin who as it is has a proven track record that these guys
are GOOD improvisationalists? They play like clockwork, someone winds them up,
they march. Feel or grove is not a necessity: how fast and how well we stick to
what we wrote (because after all :bites nails: how/why change things?) seems to
be their reasoning…how do we make our vapid etudes really RIP and how much can we
fit within them is essential…especially when it comes to LTE it seems). IMO,
IMO! You might have loved them, good, I didn't; hell someone fell asleep during
their set! The majority of their set didn't breathe, stretch, or grove; being
strictly by the books: add in a heavy dose of speed to our studio albums guys
annnd see my above formula/reasoning! That long-ass 15 minute+ sh*tstorm which
I erroneously thought was an intro to Chewbacca was just hoo…no comment. And le
sigh, Tony Levin, where were you/WAS that you!? Now I know it wasn't his fault
potentially but his work was mostly inaudible especially on stick…is it just me
or does this instrument have a grueling time being LOUD/discernible at shows to
begin with? His solo bits were cool but only because no one else was playing
and you could focus in on him. I also don't feel like getting into the bass
player sounding like feedback dilemma of being heard amidst the metal genre's
knack for loudness and lack of melody but I wanted soo much more out of this set!
Osmosis, When the Water Breaks, and Paradigm Shift were I think the best songs
they played that night. In my opinion they did NOT deserve to be headlining
with a performance such as this. C
Morglbl Trio - NOW, HERE was perhaps THE surprise of NFX. I went in
dreading/not knowing much about these guys and quite frankly expected the
worst. They didn't sell me the first song they played but as they continued I
was extremely impressed…really a lot of fun hilarity (who would've thought?),
tasteful, Zappa-zany, and tight…you got the sense that here was a trio who
really came together nicely and played/communicated as an ensemble excellently.
Their guitarist definitely gave Petrucci a run for his money: like what would
happen if you combined Vai, Holdsworth, and Fiuczynski. They were reminiscent
of Primus if Primus actually took considerable time to practice and expand on
their chops and not stick to A-B vamps. Bassist wins MVP for me hands down and
ones who play with no effects usually always impress me; seem to recall
something about Fripp saying if you want sustain, physically give it
sustain…you don't need extortionately priced/high-end gear to sound good, it's
in your hands...sometimes…I suppose heh. He also, the bassist that is, ahah,
reminded me and my friend of Mr. Bean. When I spoke to their guitarist
afterwards (who weirdly enough looks like he's related to Jordan Rudess) I told
them they should've headlined last night. In my opinion they totally upstaged
LTE in sheer diversity of musicianship that worked and fit conducively without
feeling tacky, on speed, and/or rushed. C'mon, they played two-three encores
for a second morning opening band!..even though I still find Smoke On The Water
painfully cheesy, good thing their's smoked. They're I mean, not exactly subtle
work (although here and there there were nigh-Holdsworthian synth-axeish
melodic moments) but again I felt very pleased with these guys who definitely
deserve some attention in their…should we say fusion (?)…genre. A
Radio Massacre International - Here was another band in which the great divide
fell. They were very Tangerine Dream-esque (just to make this catch-all of
alleged 'electronica' and for the sake of brevity) with an emphasis on texture
rather than actual playing which became a nice albeit somnolent change of pace.
A bit too spacey (droning, warbling voice samples, keyboard loops, lackluster
'for the song' physical drum, guitar, and bass work) and I thought: if there
was a band, now granted IF I were a drug-user, to take something to, it would
probably have been this one, but of course I ask why do anything if what's
deemed 'trippy', 'strange', etc. already can be experienced/engrained within
oneself without the aid of chemical enhancement? Eh, you be the judge. Here
again was the problem of audibility in their sax/flute and violin guests, more
the sax/flute guy as there were points where he was playing but nothing was
coming through. They played roughly 4 through-composed pieces and ended with a
blues-ish number. Perhaps inappropriately I felt like Acid Mother's Temple would be a good
choice to look into for next time around? B-
echolyn - Not going to lie, them, LTE, PH, and Banco brought me back this time
around. I thought they put on an overall great performance although I feel like
the guys in echolyn aren't too confident with themselves…they talk/preface
material A LOT; it's almost like those guys/girls at poetry/anything creative
readings who tell you everything you need to know about it before it's read.
Let your work "stand on its own" guys, you can choose to explain or
not afterwards! It almost got to the point where Ray Weston's - who I thought
was in TOP form and who I consider to be one of the most underrated vocalists
out there today - frustration (although in jest) at points became my own: if
you hand four mics to five of your band members…things can get cluttered to say
the least. Funny that Brett and I agree on track selections The Great Men and
The End Is Beautiful...the former being his least favorite, the later his favorite.
Really thought the added/different/jam bits to As The World, the duet of
Lovesick Morning into the actual song, and Those Who Want To Buy were
treats…it's just some of it felt a little rough around the edges/not so sure it
worked for the best, but again, I think this just might be the ubiquitous sound
issue. TEIB, the abbreviated versions of Mei and SFTEM's Those Who Want to Buy
were definitely the highlights. I also wish they wouldn't play some of the more
sappy acoustic material, if there's anything I can criticize with these guys in
general it's that: they can get very maudlin/histrionic in their vocal
deliveries/lyrics. Overall good job, must say! A-
Banco De Mutuo Soccorso - About what I expected from the Italian legends
although I thought they would be a bit more straight-forward…didn't expect them
to be MORE airy, different than albums, and synth led/heavy. Francesco's stage
performance was in some ways hilarious and yet in others ponderous. Was he
feeling ok…I seem to recall a surgery of some kind? Ahah, he looked downright
bashful, about to hurl, and/or lugubrious at points; not to mention his
wandering/just-woke-up stumbles to the mic whenever he came in…but when he came
in, very moving and loaded with powerful pathos. Symptoms of the elusive guitar/aerophone
audibility prevailed. Last three songs (including the encores) were the ones I
definitely wanted to hear and they delivered in spades…also unexpectedly they
had a much slower and darker vibe to all the songs they played. A song even
with a tiny horn, can't remember its name! Either way they were greatly
enjoyable. They DESERVED to be headlining. A
Overall I thought this year was MUCH, MUCH better than last year's by far.
Looking forward to more good times musically in the future.
|
 |
Fight Club
Prog Reviewer
Joined: May 21 2006
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 572
|
Posted: June 23 2008 at 16:49 |
I would probably rank:
Banco - A+ Liquid Tension - A Radio Massacre - A- Morglbl - A- Koenji - A- Echolyn - B Peter Hammill - B- Discipline - C
|
|
 |
Mikerinos
Forum Senior Member
Joined: August 11 2005
Location: Planet Gong
Status: Offline
Points: 8890
|
Posted: June 23 2008 at 21:58 |
Hi Fight Club, I'm already starting to miss talking to random people about prog... it rarely happens elsewhere and there many of those guys knew more than even I. :P
I'll rank to the nearest letter grade just to simplify it:
1. Banco: A, even more emotional than Hammill (although if it were VdGG I probably wouldn't say that) 2. Hammill: A, really amazing to talk to him, even if it was only for a few minutes and then we bumped into him a bit later. About half the songs I never heard prior, since I don't have Singularity. 3. Koenjihyakkei: A, I talked to the saxophone chick later on, she was buying Henry Cow - In Praise of Learning and other awesome stuff, I think only her and the bassist could somewhat understand me. :P 4. Radio Massacre International: B, probably higher if I got familiar with them before, I really loved the first song and the one with ViolinCyndee and the saxophone guy. Bummed out that their merch guy left after I withdrew cash though, but I can eBay it. 5. Echolyn: B, those guys are really nice, too bad they didn't play any new songs I really enjoyed stuff from The End is Beautiful especially. 6. Liquid Tension Experiment: B, new stuff sounded good, awesome meeting Tony Levin 7: Morglbl: B, I really enjoyed them a lot more than I expected, even though that morning I was pretty out of it. 8: Discipline: C, sounded good but didn't really strike me for some reason.
Ended up with 9 CDs (2 Magma, Univers Zero, Present - which I got signed, Space Ritual - wanted to get a vinyl some day but I gave in, Faust BBC Tapes, Area, Popol Vuh, Slapp Happy/Henry Cow), a Magma single (for free :D), and a Koenjihyakkei DVD... definitely got to save up a bunch of money if I go next year and probably leave the debit card at home.
Edited by Bluesaga - June 23 2008 at 22:00
|
|
 |
Fight Club
Prog Reviewer
Joined: May 21 2006
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 572
|
Posted: June 23 2008 at 22:27 |
sh*t I didn't realize there was a Koenji DVD, I probably would have gotten that. I am satisfied with Angher Shisspa though  I know I didn't enjoy Hammill quite as much as most people did. If I had been a huge long time VDGG fan like a lot of people here I'm pretty sure I would have. I've only been into VDGG for about a year though and haven't followed them a great deal. I am very familiar with Pawn Hearts and Godbluff and also like H to He and Still Life, but haven't heard any of their other albums. Btw, during Banco my friends and I crept down to the grand tier and found a few empty seats. I believe you were sitting, Mike, a row or two in front of us on the left. And DAMN, the show sure was louder than I recall it being on the balcony. Banco's performance was incredible. I still can't believe they were that good. I didn't want the show to end!
|
|
 |
Fight Club
Prog Reviewer
Joined: May 21 2006
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 572
|
Posted: June 23 2008 at 22:42 |
P.S. - They also announced that P.F.M. would be one of the headliners next year. I absolutely MUST see that.
|
|
 |
Mikerinos
Forum Senior Member
Joined: August 11 2005
Location: Planet Gong
Status: Offline
Points: 8890
|
Posted: June 24 2008 at 00:20 |
I was 3-4 rows up from the back of the tier, on the left, so that was me probably.
I'm looking forward to PFM too, Stati di Immaginazone (sp) is really cool even though I miss the vocals, that and material from the first three albums should be incredibly awesome. Maybe I'll spend my Xmas money on patron tickets next year. :)
|
|
 |
Fight Club
Prog Reviewer
Joined: May 21 2006
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 572
|
Posted: June 24 2008 at 01:01 |
Bluesaga wrote:
I was 3-4 rows up from the back of the tier, on the left, so that was me probably.
I'm looking forward to PFM too, Stati di Immaginazone (sp) is really cool even though I miss the vocals, that and material from the first three albums should be incredibly awesome. Maybe I'll spend my Xmas money on patron tickets next year. :)
|
Ditto, Per un Amico blew me away the first time I listened to it. I can't wait to see who else is playing next year as well. Should be good!
|
|
 |
CaincelaOreinim
Forum Senior Member
Joined: April 21 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 395
|
Posted: June 24 2008 at 10:26 |
By the way, LTE didn't play ANY new material. What I mistakenly thought was a horrid epic/improv which I hoped would've erupted into Chewbacca but didn't, was Gershwin's Rhapsody in Blue.
|
 |
Mikerinos
Forum Senior Member
Joined: August 11 2005
Location: Planet Gong
Status: Offline
Points: 8890
|
Posted: June 24 2008 at 10:45 |
I saw a set list online, they played two "improv" songs, one of which led to Rhapsody in Blue.
If I can go next year (family might be moving, not sure where but that makes it difficult), I'm definitely going to shoot for patron program (late xmas present maybe :P) even though I could see everything well from my seat.
|
|
 |
King of Loss
Prog Reviewer
Joined: April 21 2005
Location: Boston, MA
Status: Offline
Points: 17059
|
Posted: June 24 2008 at 15:09 |
ANyways, heres my ratings
Synergy- B
Fish- B+
Koenji Hyakkei- A
Discipline- C
Peter Hammill- A+
Liquid Tension Experiment- A
Morglbl- A-
Radio Massacre International- A
Echolyn- A-
Banco Del Mutuo Soccorso- A+++
Basically, as awesome a band as Echolyn was, they failed to be in my top 5 of bands that played there, maybe even my top 6. Banco was AMAZING and Hammill played Still Life. The only real problem with the concert was that Discipline put a very mediocre performance. A band that talented should have perhaps rehearsed more or done with a bit more chemistry. Other than them, it was an enjoyable festival and I got to meet Peter Hammill. And.... PFM is next year. About 100% I'm going next year and probably 90% sure I'm doing patron again.
And yes, the cds:
2 Magma
1 One Shot
1 Koenji Hyakkei
1 Banco del Mutuo Soccorso
1 Christian Vander
1 Present (SIGNED BY THE PRESENT GUYS!! woot)
1 Univers Zero
2 Pure Reason Revolution
1 Morglbl
1 Transvallen Presdentti (Spelled wrong)
1 Zao
So Yeah... I had a good festival (spent about $700 not counting the plane ticket, but worth every penny)
|
 |
Mikerinos
Forum Senior Member
Joined: August 11 2005
Location: Planet Gong
Status: Offline
Points: 8890
|
Posted: June 24 2008 at 19:47 |
Yeah, I spent about $350 total ($160 on tickets, $150 on music, $50 on food, gas, misc) still had a lot more fun than I thought, and I had high expectations. Definitely will go next year.
|
|
 |
Garion81
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: May 22 2004
Location: So Cal, USA
Status: Offline
Points: 4338
|
Posted: June 25 2008 at 17:37 |
I wasn't able to attend this year if fact I only made it to one pre-show in 2005 that featured PFM and Proto-Kaw so I am a bit envious of those of you who can go. Being in the west I support Calprog and its mini events throughout the year. It is just a one day fest but a good one none the less but Nearfest is the standard. I was looking through their ten year history for a post in the SC section and wow what a list of bands that have graced the stage in Trenton, NJ and Bethlehem, PA over the last ten years. Zollener center is beautiful and the acoustics are great. This is just a partial list
IQ
Spock's Beard (with Neal Morse)
Happy the Man
Transatlantic
Echolyn
Porcupine Tree
Banco Del Mutuo Soccorso
Nektar
Steve Hackett
Magma
The Flower Kings
Anglagard
Glass Hammer
IZZ
Univers Zero
Strawbs
Le Orme
PFM
Proto-Kaw
The Kieth Emerson Band
Ozric Tentacles
Hatfield and the North
Tony Levin Band
Hawkwind
Magenta
Pure Reason Revolution
Alan Holdsworth
|
"What are you going to do when that damn thing rusts?"
|
 |
CaincelaOreinim
Forum Senior Member
Joined: April 21 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 395
|
Posted: June 25 2008 at 17:55 |
Yup, they even had a video montage commemorating everyone who played there at one point.
|
 |
King of Loss
Prog Reviewer
Joined: April 21 2005
Location: Boston, MA
Status: Offline
Points: 17059
|
Posted: July 02 2008 at 01:35 |
Heres my really long review:
I'd like to thank Chad and Rob for making my first NEARfest a very enjoyable one and for all the great vendors that made me spend way too much money.... Also for all the cool 40 something prog nerds that kept me company during those epic 1 hour waits. Thanks to our elder prog statesmen for recognizing someone so young at NEARfest.
So here we go:
1. Banco- Were easily one of the best bands I've ever seen. I saw Yes a couple of years ago and this definitely matched up with that. And when they played 750,000 Anni Fa... L'amore?, it was just amazing.. One of the moments of NEARfest X for me. 2. Peter Hammill- One of my favorite vocalists/musicians of all time played here and I must say, this was one that really convinced me to put out the money for the Patron and see him up close. Still Life, Way Out, Black Room blew me away, so did the encore and meeting him. Awesome, awesome performance, definitely one of my favorite live performances definitely. A 3. Koenjihyakkei- I'm a big of Zeuhl/Avant-garde/RIO and this performance definitely blew me away. Great vocals, great winds, great drums, great keyboards, great bass and of course, probably the second best performance of NEARfest in Yoshi's drumming. He's frigging awesome and I'm really looking forward to seeing Samla Mammas Manna play with him, Lars Hollmer and co. on stage. Should be friggin' awesome. A 4. Liquid Tension Experiment- They were frigging awesome. Portnoy, Rudess, Petrucci and Levin blew our minds and our ears. Great live performance from them. I could understand how typical prog guys can be annoyed with their metal, but it was amazing anyways. The jams throughout were great and When the Water Breaks was great, even though it wasn't as good as Supper's ready or Close to the edge. A 5. Radio Massacre International- Heres for me probably the most interesting band at NEARfest. Since I'm a sucker for good electronic music (Klaus Schulze, Tangerine Dream, Popol Vuh and all that good stuff), I was really blown away by their performance. Amazing, awesome show they put up, despite them being as "excitable" as the band that played before them, Morglbl, but it was for me, better than Morglbl. Definitely have to check them out in more detail later on. A 6. Morglbl- I really enjoyed Morglbl and they were not even on my radar before NEARfest. I knew who Christopher Godin was and how he was amazing at guitar, but never checked out Morglbl before and let's say I was pleased. Being in 6th place in my rankings is an understatement, but bands 3-6 could be placed anywhere and be fine! A- 7. Echolyn- I've been listening to Echolyn for quite a few years from now and I consider myself a somewhat big Echolyn fan, but they did not even make my top 5... They were great, just that the two bands before them blew me away, since I've never heard them. Still a great performance, fairly "normal" I'd say B+ 8. Fish- Ahh.. Fish.. Marillion.. Not a big fan of both Marillion and solo stuff, but it was still enjoyable. I thought his performance was amazing the first day, but compared to 7/8 bands on the weekend, it didn't have the effect for me.. Still, Clutching at Straws was great and his comedy was hilarious. B 9. Synergy- Larry Fast's performance here was good I'd say. It was a really good opener, but compared to the bands that were opening Nearfest before: One Shot, Tony Levin Band, Proto-Kaw, it was just not as good as those years, but I still enjoyed it. Great scenery in the background. For what it was, I enjoyed it a lot. B 10. Discipline- This band, Discipline, which I've never really officially checked out much (heard great things from people), and I finally heard their material for more than a couple of samples and I can say, this was the only band at my first NEARfest that I was really underwhelmed by.... I mean the band were technically great, BUT it seemed the performance was rather weak compared to the other bands. Parameter seemed to be a bit weak in his delivery. Really underwhelmed by this band after I had just seen the awesomeness that was Koenjihyakkei. C-
I had a great week overall and um... 5 or 6 bands at Nearfest were among the best 95% of the bands I've ever seen live and I've seen a lot of them, so definitely a great week for me!
|
 |
Lionheart
Forum Senior Member
Joined: December 27 2005
Status: Offline
Points: 106
|
Posted: September 28 2008 at 08:37 |
(I may say some things here that others may strongly disagree with)
Fish - Good show, although I arrived late for that one. Fish himself seems like a very nice guy and very warm.
Good songs, good time.
Discipline - Nothing really grabbed me about them. They seemed to take themselves a little too seriously, without any real musical reason. They came off as silly.
Morglbl - Great music, and a great stage set (palm trees if I remember correctly). A big surprise for me, and they had a great sense of humor. Like the type of guys you could have a drink with and share some laughs. Good stuff. I remember everyone scrambling to get their CD after the performance from the vendors.
Liquid Tension Experiment - Great *technical* execution, but musically redundant and uninspiring. They all seem like great guys personally, but the music had no real center to it, and they need to seriously work on their melodies (or lack thereof).
Echolyn - I missed this performance, because I wound up talking to a guy from New Jersey outside on the patio about why the New York Yankees suck so much.
Radio Massacre International - A *huge* and pleasant surprise for me. A really nice mix of Tangerine Dream with a big smacking of chaos. Wonderfully artistic, very cerebral, and a great head trip.
Koenjihyakkei - My biggest pleasant surprise of the whole show. Absolutely chaotic, absolutely loud and holds nothing back. I haven't seen such a "raw" band in a long time. I met them right after their set outside, and they were extremely kind and very happy to be there.
Peter Hammill - Didn't really leave me with any impression.
Banco Del Mutuo Soccorso - Well, this is the reason that I wound up going in the first place. They were great. Very warm, very musical, and a real treat.
|
 |
Norbert
Forum Senior Member
Joined: October 20 2005
Location: Hungary
Status: Offline
Points: 2506
|
Posted: September 30 2008 at 13:22 |
Banco, Koenji, PH, LTE- we'll never have a festival like this.  However, VdGG will come in January, and I'm glad that you all had a great time at NearFest.
|
 |