Prog Music Lounge - Oh well.....Rate Mine Too

Print Page | Close Window

Oh well.....Rate Mine Too

Printed From: Progarchives.com
Category: Progressive Music Lounges
Forum Name: Prog Music Lounge
Forum Description: General progressive music discussions
URL: http://www.progarchives.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=9510
Printed Date: July 19 2025 at 02:58
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 11.01 - http://www.webwizforums.com

Topic: Oh well.....Rate Mine Too

Posted By: TheProgtologist
Subject: Oh well.....Rate Mine Too
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 03:35

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge

2.King Crimson-Red

3.PFM-Per Un Amico

4.Tool-Lateralus

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1

8.IQ-Subterranea

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone

12.Spock's Beard-Snow

-------------

Replies:

Posted By: Bryan
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 03:48

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 3/5

2.King Crimson-Red 5/5

3.PFM-Per Un Amico 4/5

4.Tool-Lateralus 4.5/5

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 3/5

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 2.5/5

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 3/5

8.IQ-Subterranea N/A

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park 5/5

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver N/A

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone N/A

12.Spock's Beard-Snow N/A

Posted By: Mategra
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 03:50

Yes-Close to the Edge 3.5/5 (Not my favourite Yes album)

King Crimson-Red 5/5

Transatlantic-SMPTe 4/5

The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone 4.5/5

Spock's Beard-Snow 3.5/5 (My least favourite SB album)

Posted By: stonebeard
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 04:00

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 32653874 / 736310`37

2.King Crimson-Red 67376`193 / 736310`37

3.PFM-Per Un Amico 7549647 / 736310`37

4.Tool-Lateralus 967467478 /736310`37

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 84645637 / 736310`37

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 0.000000009 / 736310`37

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 5555555.666 / 736310`37

8.IQ-Subterranea 4059267 / 736310`37

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park 8951695.AAAAA / 736310`37

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver / 736310`37

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone . 13878964 / 736310`37

12.Spock's Beard-Snow 5 / 5

-------------
http://soundcloud.com/drewagler" rel="nofollow - My soundcloud. Please give feedback if you want!

Posted By: TheProgtologist
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 04:12

stonebeard wrote:

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 32653874 / 736310`37

2.King Crimson-Red 67376`193 / 736310`37

3.PFM-Per Un Amico 7549647 / 736310`37

4.Tool-Lateralus 967467478 /736310`37

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 84645637 / 736310`37

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 0.000000009 / 736310`37

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 5555555.666 / 736310`37

8.IQ-Subterranea 4059267 / 736310`37

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park 8951695.AAAAA / 736310`37

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver / 736310`37

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone . 13878964 / 736310`37

12.Spock's Beard-Snow 5 / 5

]

-------------

Posted By: Cygnus
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 04:26

TheProgtologist wrote:

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 10/10

2.King Crimson-Red 10/10

3.PFM-Per Un Amico

4.Tool-Lateralus 9.5/10

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 8/10

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 10/10

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 9/10

8.IQ-Subterranea

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park 9/10

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone

12.Spock's Beard-Snow

Hey Iwas expecting a rush album here. What would Neil say???

Posted By: TheProgtologist
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 04:39

Cygnus wrote:

TheProgtologist wrote:

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 10/10

2.King Crimson-Red 10/10

3.PFM-Per Un Amico

4.Tool-Lateralus 9.5/10

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 8/10

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 10/10

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 9/10

8.IQ-Subterranea

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park 9/10

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone

12.Spock's Beard-Snow

Hey Iwas expecting a rush album here. What would Neil say???

Yeah,I thought that after submitting the list.It's hard to narrow down all your favorites to a list of 10 or so.Maybe a should have made a favorite 100

Here you go:

13.Rush-Hemispheres

-------------

Posted By: Soulman
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 04:43

1.Yes-Close to the Edge (5/5)

2.King Crimson-Red (6/5 )

3.PFM-Per Un Amico (HHY)

4.Tool-Lateralus (0/5 ...sorry)

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe (4/5)

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory (2.5/5 ...not my thing)

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 (HHY)

8.IQ-Subterranea (HHY)

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park (HHY...sounded interesting though even though I'm not really into metal)

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver (5/5)

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone (HHY...I would like to here this one)

12.Spock's Beard-Snow (HHY..argh I need to hear this one!)

Rush-Hemispheres (4.5/5...I liked it but other Rush albums were better imo)

* HHY = Haven't heard Yet

Posted By: Cygnus
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 04:49

TheProgtologist wrote:

Cygnus wrote:

TheProgtologist wrote:

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 10/10

2.King Crimson-Red 10/10

3.PFM-Per Un Amico

4.Tool-Lateralus 9.5/10

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 8/10

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 10/10

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 9/10

8.IQ-Subterranea

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park 9/10

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone

12.Spock's Beard-Snow

Hey Iwas expecting a rush album here. What would Neil say???

Yeah,I thought that after submitting the list.It's hard to narrow down all your favorites to a list of 10 or so.Maybe a should have made a favorite 100

Here you go:

13.Rush-Hemispheres 10/10

Ah, that´s more like it .

Posted By: Guests
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 04:53

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 9

2.King Crimson-Red 9

3.PFM-Per Un Amico 8

4.Tool-Lateralus ?

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe ?

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory ?

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 ?

8.IQ-Subterranea 8

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park ?

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver ?

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone ?

12.Spock's Beard-Snow ?

Posted By: Hangedman
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 11:25

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 4.5/5

2.King Crimson-Red 5/5

3.PFM-Per Un Amico ?

4.Tool-Lateralus 4/5

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe ?

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 2/5

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 ?

8.IQ-Subterranea ?

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park 3.5/5

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver ?

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone ?

12.Spock's Beard-Snow ?

13.Rush-Hemispheres 3/5

Posted By: Ed_The_Dead
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 12:23

TheProgtologist wrote:

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 4/5

2.King Crimson-Red 4/5

3.PFM-Per Un Amico ?

4.Tool-Lateralus 5/5

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 4/5

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 5/5

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 3/5

8.IQ-Subterranea ?

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park 4/5

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver ?

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone ?

12.Spock's Beard-Snow ?

13.Rush 1/5

-------------
http://www.last.fm/user/ed_the_dead/?chartstyle=asimpleblue5">

Posted By: dodaro
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 12:24

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 5/5
2.King Crimson-Red 5/5
3.PFM-Per Un Amico 5/5
4.Tool-Lateralus I dont know
5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 3/5
6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 3/5
7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 I don't know
8.IQ-Subterranea I don't know
9.Opeth-Blackwater Park I don't know
10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver I don't know
11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone I don't know
12.Spock's Beard-Snow I don't know

Posted By: King of Loss
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 12:47

TheProgtologist wrote:

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge *****

2.King Crimson-Red *** 1/2

3.PFM-Per Un Amico ****

4.Tool-Lateralus *

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe **** 1/2

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory *****

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 *****

8.IQ-Subterranea ***

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park **** 1/2

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver *** 1/2

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone ***

12.Spock's Beard-Snow **** 1/2

Yay! Very good, except for one album!

Posted By: Spanish
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 13:09

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 4.5/5

2.King Crimson-Red 4.5/5

3.PFM-Per Un Amico 4/5

4.Tool-Lateralus 1/5

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 4/5

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 2.5/5

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element 3/5

8.IQ-Subterranea 3/5

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park 5/5

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver 4/5

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone 3.5/5

12.Spock's Beard-Snow 2.5/5 (their worst)

Posted By: Ed_The_Dead
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 13:13

King of Loss wrote:

TheProgtologist wrote:

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge *****

2.King Crimson-Red *** 1/2

3.PFM-Per Un Amico ****

4.Tool-Lateralus *

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe **** 1/2

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory *****

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 *****

8.IQ-Subterranea ***

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park **** 1/2

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver *** 1/2

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone ***

12.Spock's Beard-Snow **** 1/2

Yay! Very good, except for one album!

hehe, The one album by His fav band

-------------
http://www.last.fm/user/ed_the_dead/?chartstyle=asimpleblue5">

Posted By: floyd68
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 13:31

Yes-Close to the Edge 4/5
Transatlantic-SMPTe 3.5/5
Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 5/5
IQ-Subterranea 3/5
The Flower Kings-Space Revolver 2.5/5
Spock's Beard-Snow (IMO the worst SB CD) 2/5

and the winner is: DT - however I don't like Octavairum ;-)

Posted By: Arsillus
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 13:38

TheProgtologist wrote:

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 5/5

2.King Crimson-Red 5/5

3.PFM-Per Un Amico 5/5

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 4/5

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 3.5/5

Just the ones I've heard enough of to form an opinion.

Posted By: limeyrob
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 15:23

Cygnus wrote:

TheProgtologist wrote:

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 10/10

2.King Crimson-Red 10/10

3.PFM-Per Un Amico

4.Tool-Lateralus 9.5/10

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 8/10

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 10/10

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 9/10

8.IQ-Subterranea

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park 9/10

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone

12.Spock's Beard-Snow

Hey Iwas expecting a rush album here. What would Niel say???

I would say 'about time we had a favourites without Rush' - Very overrated IMO

Posted By: Bj-1
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 16:49

Yes - CTTE (5/5)
King Crimson - Red (4/5)
Dream Theater - Scenes From a Memory (4.5/5)

-------------
RIO/AVANT/ZEUHL - The best thing you can get with yer pants on!

Posted By: King of Loss
Date Posted: August 03 2005 at 17:03

Ed_The_Dead wrote:

King of Loss wrote:

TheProgtologist wrote:

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge *****

2.King Crimson-Red *** 1/2

3.PFM-Per Un Amico ****

4.Tool-Lateralus *

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe **** 1/2

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory *****

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 *****

8.IQ-Subterranea ***

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park **** 1/2

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver *** 1/2

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone ***

12.Spock's Beard-Snow **** 1/2

Yay! Very good, except for one album!

hehe, The one album by His fav band

Yea, I don't Tool.

Posted By: The Miracle
Date Posted: August 15 2005 at 20:28

TheProgtologist wrote:

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

Yes-Close to the Edge

King Crimson-Red

Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory

Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1

Opeth-Blackwater Park

-------------
http://www.last.fm/user/ocellatedgod" rel="nofollow - last.fm

Posted By: NetsNJFan
Date Posted: August 16 2005 at 00:15

TheProgtologist wrote:

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 5

2.King Crimson-Red 4.5

3.PFM-Per Un Amico 5

4.Tool-Lateralus 2

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe -

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 2

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 -

8.IQ-Subterranea -

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park -

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver -

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone -

12.Spock's Beard-Snow 2.5

-------------

Posted By: Drew
Date Posted: August 16 2005 at 00:17

TheProgtologist wrote:

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 5.5

2.King Crimson-Red 6

3.PFM-Per Un Amico ?

4.Tool-Lateralus 6

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 7

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 10

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 9

8.IQ-Subterranea 6

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park 9.5

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver 7

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone 7.5

12.Spock's Beard-Snow 10

Posted By: Cygnus X-2
Date Posted: August 16 2005 at 00:19

TheProgtologist wrote:

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 4.5/5

2.King Crimson-Red 6/5

3.PFM-Per Un Amico 4/5

4.Tool-Lateralus 3.5/5

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 3.5/5

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 4.5/5

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 4/5

8.IQ-Subterranea 3.5/5

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park 4/5

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver 3.5/5

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone ?

12.Spock's Beard-Snow 3/5

Nice selection.

-------------

Posted By: transend
Date Posted: August 16 2005 at 00:33

ok..I will!

Hell,everyone is doing it so I might as well give it a shot.Rate some of my favorite cd's

1.Yes-Close to the Edge -9.5/10

2.King Crimson-Red - 7/10

3.PFM-Per Un Amico - 7.5/10

4.Tool-Lateralus - 5/10 (for music) -10/10 (for CD cover)

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe - 9/10 (incredible, considering the time they took to make it!)

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory - 8/10

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 - 5/10

8.IQ-Subterranea - 6.5/10 (but 9/10 if it had been a single CD and cut some of the crap)

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park - DONT KNOW THAT ONE

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver - 8.5/10 (one of their best, the BEST single CD by them)

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone - 7/10 (first song is GREAT , rest is just OK)

12.Spock's Beard-Snow - 6/10 (one of their weaker efforts, I think, just TOO much samey stuff)

Posted By: JedHead
Date Posted: August 16 2005 at 01:32

Now, I have always rated albums on a scale from -10 to +10. I mean, if an album sucks so much, even .5 is a positive number, right?

So, on with the list

1.Yes-Close to the Edge 7

2.King Crimson-Red 4

3.PFM-Per Un Amico 4

4.Tool-Lateralus 2

5.Transatlantic-SMPTe 6

6.Dream Theater-Scenes from a Memory 10

7.Pain of Salvation-The Perfect Element Part 1 8

8.IQ-Subterranea 7

9.Opeth-Blackwater Park 6

10.The Flower Kings-Space Revolver 7.5

11.The Tangent-The Music That Died Alone 5

12.Spock's Beard-Snow 8

So go ahead and scream at me! Bring it on!

-------------
The good cop and the bad cop left for the day. I'm a different kind of cop.