MONSTERS FROM THE ID

Exceptional Symphonic Progressive Rock

Majestic, Grand, Epic, Profound

Australian mastermind Ben Craven hands us a masterful progressive rock tour de force with this, his third full-length release since 2005's debut, "Tunisia: Two False Idols".

I know, I know, there are various other albums in his discography- collections, single edits, live versions. However, these are his important artistic statements, and "Monsters From The Id" is outstanding. I think it'll stand up beside "Close to the Edge" for artistic merit, musicianship, scope, and composition.

Theologian

Ben may not appreciate this appellation, yet the icing on the cake of this mature, soaring, complex work, is the persistent impression he leaves that he is maneuvering in spiritual territory.

The two epic halves of "Monsters" suggest the epic and ferocious battle between Good and Evil, and the title itself draws us into contemplation of the creatures we humans are- the 'id', the unconscious boiling within urging us to go for what we want when we want it, consequences be damned.

Die Before You Wake

The first half of the album draws from cinematic music-making with opening industrial sounds, yet grows from this chaos into symphonic splendor. with mighty choral sounds, and featuring Ben's soaring, melodic guitar lines.

There are suggestions in the lyrics of that great spiritual battle, with ideas of darkness, hate, vengeance, and destruction. These are set within the framework of Ben's epic compositions, punchy bass guitar underneath, majestic keyboards and synths, subsiding into extended reveries with echoing reflective guitar work, and growing once again into grandeur.

There is imagery of baptismal waters, damnation, and salvation, never heavy-handed, and considered in fine poetic pictures.

Amnis Flows Aeternum

The second half of "Monsters From The Id" opens with clean acoustic guitar, brooding deep synth sounds and added keyboards, leading into a gentle symphonic passage.

I understand why his music is referred to as "cinematic" since it shows sparkle, drama, and depth. It underscores the gorgeous and graceful poetry of lyrics referring to the cry for aid in remaining open, not prejudiced; staying loving, not vengeful; joining the mighty flowing streams of Eternity rather than being selfishly bound to the id.

Here we have Ben's soaring, seething electric guitar leads over majestic symphonic grandeur, giving way to crisp, complex guitar/bass unison lines and developing into some sinuous twin-guitar melody.

There is a nightmarish passage that grows and develops into musical bedlam, which gives way to grand choral passages, which in turn devolve with tremolo guitar leading into a moody, ponderous passage.

Finale

The grand ending wraps up this exceptional work with a winding-down, that again gives way to re-emerging grand themes and Ben's sighing, soaring signature guitar work.

My Conclusion

There IS a way we die before we experience transcendence. Dying to self and self-seeking, then awakening. Ben's notes say he intends this work to suggest the transcendence, the hope, the vastness, and the grandeur that we humans too easily lose sight of in the day-to-day hurly-burly.

I appreciate the reminder, done so beautifully here by a surpassingly gifted composer/musician.

My rating- 5 Sparkling Stars, a masterpiece of progressive rock music.

Ben CRAVEN is this Australian composer who has been playing everything since 2005. Known thanks to Roger DEAN for the 2011 cover with a symphonic prog rock where he himself quotes FOCUS, Earth and Fire, GRYPHON, CARAVAN, NEKTAR, SOFT MACHINE, CAN, ELOY, Grobschnitt, YES, GENESIS and PINK FLOYD. This 5th album consists of two long vinyl tracks with modern cinematic orchestral arrangements punctuated by instant singing and emotional guitar sequences, pieces dealing with the age-old fight between Good and Evil of man vis-à-vis himself; epic, moving prog

'Die Before You Wake' for the 1st musical slap, 7 linked tracks flirting with the cinematic symphony very fashionable today, on a classic flight à la ORFF; an agreed tune with an aerial chorus with choirs, a riff reminiscent of the famous 'Kashmir', a break giving pride of place to the Hackettian guitar solo; windy, soaring art-rock progressive break, cloudy in its melodic design, Gilmourian solo; at 11mn it rises even higher before the return of the verse, a synth solo à la BANKS, reminiscences ooze from all sides. The last quarter starts on a floydian bluesy sound of 'The Dark Side' with a spleen, moving and warm guitar; we are far on the Creation, the sky, the temptation and we are well.

'Amnis Flows Aeternum' and 12 drawers for circulation around eternity, crystalline guitar intro worthy of an ASIA 'Aqua', disturbing 70's spy film style keyboards that plunge into this cinematic genre, between rock prog, music classic and BOF, new fusion. It descends suddenly on a Squirian bass, the sharp guitar solo, vintage and dynamic, then dark and spleen at the same time with a singular tremolo; an orchestral slows down time before starting again, a keyboard and the 2nd 'Amnis' sung appears; crescendo bringing the music to the state of art illuminating the symphonic emotion in depth, worthy of a great PINK FLOYD. The last third goes back to the choirs, the vibrating guitar, a majestic experience that makes you forget time by taking up here and there the themes discussed before. 4 bonuses featuring titles from each composition, 'Die Before You Wake' and 'Wicked Delights' on the one hand for the radio hit edit and the symphonic madness; 'Guiding Voice' and 'Amnis Flows Aeternum' for the recognizable melody and the desire to immerse yourself in the two compositions.

Ben CRAVEN releases a magnificent album, it is said. Notes of hope, of overcoming, of majestic epic, 6 years used to make a top album 2022 quite simply; mix of intoxicating atmospheres, cinematic passages and dithyrambic breaks to sublimate our subjective vision of music, to bring the psyche to the firmament, to escape from this world where everything is still possible. CD/DVD in 5.1 mix with the illustration of Freya, like daughter of the master of prog covers.

This is an outstanding album, refreshing and yet quite set in the aesthetics of the 70s. key elements from different influences ranging specially in Yes, but managing to nevertheless sound very set in the current times. The way the two pieces are built is speaking of the way in which Craven serves composition, arrangements and the use of a very well structured and creative way of organizing the ups and downs in both long epics.

In a way reminiscent of many albums of the 70s (think of Thick as a Brick or Tubular Bells), the album consists of only two major epics, both clocking the 20 minutes. Both take the listener in a complex and yet easy listening journey through the sound palette Craven provides so enthusiastic of the way instruments work together in the aim of arranging an atmosphere. Since there is only one performer, Craven himself, it is difficult to hear the sensibilities of other musicians, but still it feels highly emotional, coherent and strongly armed.

The second epic flows around more sub-parts, and still, it follows perfectly in the set of colors the first epic had built. It opens with a very nice acoustic introduction. Despite the fact of having a continuity of small pieces interconnected, the themes return several times to provide the feeling of unity so very important in any epic.

I strongly recommend this one, I think is one of the best albums 2022 will provide! 5 stars

A one man band made this?!! I wish he had trusted someone from the outside to give him some constructive criticism with regards to sound engineering and final mix.

CD: - Side 1: 1. "Die Before You Wake" (19:32) solid construct (in 7/8--all 20 minutes!) with rich sound and great melodies and singing. The sound production, however, suffers from muddiness and a few uneven levels--and maybe some clarity and use of some odd effects. Very nice performances on all instruments and tracks (though nothing extraordinary much less jaw dropping). As catchy as that main melody and construct is, it really shouldn't go on for nearly 20 minutes. Sounds like something that Tony Patterson & Brendan Eyre might have done (Nine Stones Close). Also, the Trans-Siberian Orchestra comparisons are not unwarranted--more for sound palette than pace and tech-metal twists and turns. (36/40): - a. Sleeping Spectre (2:19) - b. Ancient Majesty (1:31) - c. Die Before You Wake Part 1 (3:03) - d. Warming Glow (3:55) - e. Wicked Delights (2:40) - f. Die Before You Wake Part 2 (2:01) - g. Endless Night (4:03)

- Side 2: 2. "Amnis Flows Aeternum" (19:11) Unfortunately, much of this song sounds the same as the previous one; in my mind I literally cannot distinguish between the two: the music, melody, and singing from the previous one--as if it's a continuation or repeat. (There may be too many similarities to Hans Zimmer's Pirates of the Caribbean soundtracks for me, mate!) Still a fine song, with lots of engaging elements, melodies, and sonic candy. (36/40): - a. Amnis Flows Aeternum Part 1 (1:11) - b. Guiding Voice Part 1 (2:39) - c. Sound and Light (1:20) - d. Guiding Voice Part 2 (1:06) - e. Royal Rewards Part 1 (1:09) - f. Blessed Stream Part 1 (0:58) - g. Amnis Flows Aeternum Part 2 (2:26) - h. Earthly Dues (2:47) - i. Amnis Flows Aeternum Part 3 (3:04) - j. Blessed Stream Part 2 (0:51) - k. Royal Rewards Part 2 (1:02) - l. Guiding Voice Part 3 (0:38)

Total Time 38:43

It's a fine effort of solid, sophisticated, and melodic progressive rock, albeit NeoProg. Lush Yes-like soundscapes and instrumental choices with solid bass and quite good vocals, the sound engineering/mixing could have used some objective input. Nowhere near as sophisticated, virtuosic, or polished as the "classic era" masterpieces. If the sounds and styles weren't so dependent on (even directly copying) previous masers, I might be more generous with my final rating of this one--it is great music with serious compositional intention (I've watched all of his videos on YouTube regarding the making of this album, so I appreciate the effort and reasons for his constructs). Then there are my dissatisfaction with the sound engineering. As I said above, I wish Ben had had a few more critiques/inputs to help him create the best product for the public.

A-/4.5 stars; a near-masterpiece of progressive rock music. While many are claiming Ben's effort here to be a masterpiece for the ages, I look at it as more of a masterpiece of respectful, diligent synthesis and imitation of the aged. Great job ? but but not much here, in my opinion, to "progress" the art form (except perhaps in the engineering room).

Yes casts a very long shadow over progressive rock. Their influence isn't just obvious in the music, but also in the visuals frequently deployed on album covers. Roger Dean-style artwork has become a cliche of the genre, and I have developed something of an apprehension about acts that use this visual style. I've harped on about acts that just uncreatively wallow in the mid-70s, and flashy album covers do not make up for bland, uninspired music. Thankfully, this is not one of those albums.

Monsters of the Id is the fifth full-length release from Australian multi-instrumentalist Ben Craven. It follows in the long prog tradition of albums made up of just two long songs. (Though for all the obvious Yes-isms on this album, that band never released a record with fewer than three songs.)

"Die Before You Wake" kicks the album off on an ominous note. Strings and vocal arrangements swirl in a foreboding maelstrom. This introductory passage is reminiscent of some of the darker moments off Yes's Magnification with the way strings are utilized. The eventual main theme which emerges is bouncy, and the use of chimes helps the melody stand out above the dark backing.

The first verse consists of just piano and vocals at first, though it soon reincorporates that dark main theme in the chorus. It's dramatic and attention-grabbing. There's a strong sense of drama as this movement pushes forward, and the lyrics match the tone of the music excellently. This somewhat suddenly resolves into a gentler movement, consisting of looping synths and dreamy guitar accents.

What eventually emerges is a mellow, folky passage led by acoustic guitar and warm synth. This movement drifts along for a while with some pleasant instrumental moments, but it then turns back into something anxious. Strings and guitar duel each other in an exciting passage, and it smoothly transitions back to the earlier main theme.

There is a piano passage near the end of this suite that is distractingly similar to "The Great Gig in the Sky", and it's topped by a guitar solo that sounds like it's straight off The Division Bell. It's not a bad way to end the song, but the references to Pink Floyd are so starkly obvious that it took me out of it a bit.

The second epic here is "Amnis Flows Aeternum". Lush synths and gentle nylon guitar provide a sense of sonic continuity with "Die Before You Wake", though the mood is considerably less dire. As the opening passage progresses, twangy guitar, low brass, and vibraphone evoke film scores.

A jumpy, Steve Howe-esque guitar line helps propel this piece into its next movement. This is a great example of Craven's ability to artfully build up the momentum of his pieces.

Vocals finally enter around the song's midpoint. The atmosphere is cinematic and ritualistic, being nearly chanted. Swooping choral arrangements add a nice mystique. The melody isn't quite as striking as on the previous song, but it's enjoyable nonetheless.

The verse eventually transitions to another quite-Gilmourian instrumental passage. Though a synth solo is the focus of it, it strongly evokes later Pink Floyd. After a reprise of the verse, there's another guitar solo, and this one sounds a bit more distinctive. 

Craven's latest album does not stray too far from tried and true progressive rock tropes. The songs are epic, the playing is flashy, and the artwork is fantastical. There are some passages which crib from Yes and Pink Floyd to distracting degrees, but that is a relatively minor issue in the context of the whole.

Review originally posted here: theeliteextremophile.com/2022/06/27/album-review-ben-craven-monsters-from-the-id/

To be honest this new album by Ben Craven (autodidact, born in Brisbane, Australia), his fifth since 2006, is my first musical encounter with his music. But I am blown away, what an awesome Seventies Symphonic Rock inspired music, very tastefully arranged, with flowing shifting moods, strong work on guitar and keyboards, and despite the long running time of the two epic compositions "never a dull moment!".

Die Before You Wake (19:32) : The albums starts with a bombastic and slightly chaotic sound collage, the prelude of wonderful and impressive 24-carat symphonic rock, alternating and compelling, very melodic and harmonic, from start to finish this music succeeds to keep my full attention, wow! The one moment from a slow rhythm with a bombastic atmosphere and fiery guitar leads to mellow with tender piano and vocals, then turning into more lush and dramatic. Or from a bombastic outburst with compelling classical orchestrations, blended with harder-edged guitar and propulsive drum beats to sparkling piano and classical orchestrations with heavy guitar and tight drum beats. The other moment from a spacey guitar solo, or a sound collage featuring an electronic undertone to a slow rhythm with dreamy synthesizer flights, and another moving guitar solo with howling runs. Or from a flashy synthesizer solo with a majestic Mellotron choir sound, melancholical vocals to a Gilmourian slide guitar and tender piano, in slow rhythm. The final part delivers a long and moving Gilmourian guitar solo, topped with Mellotron choirs and militairy drum beats, goose bumps!

Amnis Flows Aeternum (19:11) : First a mellow atmosphere with dreamy acoustic guitar and piano, to me it sounds as a soundtrack, a bit ominous, the Floydian slide guitar rules. Then the music turns into a catchy beat (Eighties King Crimson come to my mind) with a sitar-like guitar. Gradually the sound becomes more lush and dynamic with strong guitar work and bombastic orchestral keyboard layers. Now back to mellow with tender piano, and halfway again that ominous atmosphere, like a horror movie. Then soft drum beats, with pleasant vocals and Mellotron choirs, followed by a mellow climate with Floydian slide guitar and a spacey synthesizer solo. The second part of this epic delivers a spectacular Minimoog solo with Mellotron choirs in the best tradition of Rick Wakeman, and then a sumptuous accellaration with a long and moving guitar solo, in the best tradition of David Gilmour, this is Symphonic Rock Heaven!

This album is concluded with 4 single edits: Die Before You Wake (4:57), Wicked Delights (2:400, Guiding Voice (3:31) and Amnis Flows Aeternum (4:51), incredible how inventive Ben Craven turns the epics moments into strong single edits.

Highly recommended, and especially symphomaniacs alert, this is top notch Seventies Symphonic Rock inspired music!