look

sularetal wrote: stonebeard wrote: Well it's just other prople's opinions. Top 10/25/50/100 and all other lists are pointless and silly I think. You like what you like. But still...Nick Mason over Mike Portnoy??? I think not!!! For some reason I agree with that list in the drummers section. Never liked portnoy, not that he's not good or something. He's extreamly creative and genious in his playing not to mention his techinique but he never made me belive he is feeling the song. His drums never made me feel anything....

Nick Mason made me believe he is feeling the song...

Damn ok his technique is very limited, but he has a lot of feeling , just look Live at pompeii or hear Atom Heart...

He has a unique style of playing...

nice list!!!!!!

though mr. portnoy landed a bit far (top 11)....

I believe one or twi years ago I recieved a mail asking me to vote for my favorite Prog musicians and the name Arrakis (The owner of this page) was in the adress.

I usually delete this kind of mails but I voted because it was Prog related (of course I used a hotmail adress to avoid spam).

The voters are mostly from Latin America where Yes is the most popular Prog band by far, but great to see they are still doing this.

Iván

Genesisprog wrote: http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.arrakis.es /~quicios/votos/wakeman.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.arrakis .es/~quicios/votos/resultad.htm&h=150&w=150&sz=9 &tbnid=5kNZQWBUatwJ:&tbnh=90&tbnw=90&hl=et&a mp;a mp;start=284&prev=/images%3Fq%3DRick%2BWakeman%26start%3 D280%26svnum%3D10%26hl%3Det%26lr%3D%26sa%3DN

#  Vocalista:                                 Nº VOT  SUM VOT PORCEN
1  Anderson, Jon (Yes)                          52      123    20,23
2  Gabriel, Peter (Genesis, solo)               47       99    16,28
3  Plant, Robert (Led Zeppelin)                 23       42     6,91
4  Hammill, Peter (V.D.G.G.)                    16       41     6,74
5  Lake, Greg (ELP, K.C.)                       18       38     6,25
6  Anderson, Ian (Jethro Tull)                  15       31     5,10
7  Fish Dick, Derek W. (Marillion)              15       28     4,61
8  Gillan, Ian (Deep Purple)                    9        20     3,29
9  LaBrie, James (Dream Thater)                 8        19     3,13
10 Lee, Geedy (Rush)                            8        17     2,80
11 Collins Phil (Genesis, solo)                 7        15     2,47
12 Hogarth, Steve (Marillion)                   9        14     2,30
13 Waters, Roger (Pink Floyd)                   8        12     1,97
14 Wetton, John (King Crimson)                  6        10     1,64
15 Haslam, Annie (Renaissance)                  5        9      1,48
16 Barret, Syd (Pink Floyd)                     3        6      0,99
17 Hayward, Justin (Moody blues)                4        6      0,99
18 Coverdale, David (Deep Purple, Whitesnake    4        4      0,66
19 Di Cioccio, Franz (P.F.M.)                   2        4      0,66
20 Dio, Ronie James (Rainbow)                   3        4      0,66
21 Hagberg, Magdalena (Pär Lindh Proy.)         2        4      0,66
22 Boz Burrell, Raymond (K.C.)                  1        3      0,49
23 Brown, Arthur (Kingdom Come)                 1        3      0,49
24 Chapman, Roger (Family)                      1        3      0,49
25 Giersbergen, Anneke van (The Gathering)      1        3      0,49
26 Hodgson, Roger (Supertramp)                  1        3      0,49
27 Krause, Dagmar (Henry Cow)                   1        3      0,49
28 Mercury, Freddie (Queen)                     1        3      0,49
29 Sinclair, Richard (Caravan)                  2        3      0,49
30 Stratos, Demetrios (Area, Solo)              1        3      0,49
31 Tagliapietra, Aldo (Le Orme)                 1        3      0,49
32 Tate, Geoff (Queensryche)                    1        3      0,49
33 Walms, Steve (Kansas)                        1        3      0,49
34 Wilson, Ray (Genesis)                        1        3      0,49
35 Wyatt, Robert (Solo, S. Machine, M.M.)       1        3      0,49
36 Bacon, Max (Gtr)                             1        2      0,33
37 Byron, David (Uriah Heep)                    1        2      0,33
38 Di Giacomo, Francesco (Banco...)             1        2      0,33
39 Gilmour, David (Pink Floyd)                  1        2      0,33
40 Perry, Steve (Journey)                       1        2      0,33
41 Basquiz, Klaus (Magma)                       1        1      0,16
42 Belew, Adrian (King Crimson)                 1        1      0,16
43 Carrack, Paul (Ace, Mike&Mechanics)          1        1      0,16
44 Douglas, Bret (Cairo)                        1        1      0,16
45 Glenn, Hughes (Trapeze)                      1        1      0,16
46 Hastings, Pye (Caravan)                      1        1      0,16
47 Lanzetti, Bernardo (P.F.M.)                  1        1      0,16
48 Mann, Geoff (Twelfht Night)                  1        1      0,16
49 Roussos, Demis (Aphrodite's Child)           1        1      0,16
50 Shulman, Derek (Gentle Giant)                1        1      0,16

Good one, Genesisprog! 

NutterAlert wrote: I agree with STG (stonebeard the Great) about polls. But its fascinating to see the sublime Steve Hillage is only slightly ahead of the adequate (ish) guitar of Daevid Allen.   Stonie, change your last name to Divine, then we can call you STD

Glad to see I've been upgraded!!!!

Soon I will reach legendary status.

Well it's just other prople's opinions. Top 10/25/50/100 and all other lists are pointless and silly I think. You like what you like.

But still...Nick Mason over Mike Portnoy??? I think not!!!

   Nice list of musicians who play flute ,drums,keyboards,bass,guitars

   Its obvious that this page is interesting for everyone here.