Author
Topic Search Topic Options
N-sz
Forum Senior Member
Joined: May 28 2011
Location: NH
Status: Offline
Points: 344
Topic: The longest song you know Posted: April 27 2012 at 20:09
The longest song I know is Incantations by Mike Oldfield - 72:37 - which I think is all considered one song (just in four parts).
I like it, though I didn't find it super exciting until it got to the last part. Then again, I still haven't given it a full chance to grow on me.
TheLionOfPrague
Forum Senior Member
Joined: March 08 2011
Location: Argentina
Status: Offline
Points: 1060
Posted: April 25 2012 at 19:51
Tapfret wrote:
rod65 wrote: I'm inclined to stick with vocals as an integral component of a song. The word "song " means music that is sung as opposed to music that is exclusively instrumental. That said, the longest song I know is Galleon's "The Ocean," clocking in at 52:05. Though it is divided into parts in the notes, it is a single track on the CD. Not a huge fan of the lyrics, by the way--too heavy-handed for my taste--but instrumentally it is quite good.
Holy cow you are right. I had to look it up, but yep, its in the definition. I guess I have to start calling Canvas Solaris tracks "pieces" or "movements", neither of which are attractive terms.
Hahaha, great signature.
I shook my head and smiled a whisper knowing all about the place
ole-the-first
Forum Senior Member
Joined: January 03 2012
Location: Russia
Status: Offline
Points: 1534
Posted: April 24 2012 at 07:35
Queen's untitled instrumental from Made in Heaven is 22:34 in length, I think it should be mentioned.
This night wounds time.
AtomicCrimsonRush
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: July 02 2008
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 14256
Posted: April 24 2012 at 07:07
^^^^^^^^^^Brilliant song but link broken sadly
Edited by AtomicCrimsonRush - April 24 2012 at 07:08
PyramidMeetsTheEye
Forum Senior Member
Joined: April 02 2012
Location: Slovenia
Status: Offline
Points: 118
Posted: April 24 2012 at 07:01
rush 2112
VIDEO
AtomicCrimsonRush
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: July 02 2008
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 14256
Posted: April 24 2012 at 06:06
^^^ Yeah, I wont be ordering that monster anytime soon
Sagichim
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: November 29 2006
Location: Israel
Status: Offline
Points: 6632
Posted: April 24 2012 at 06:02
Rich Robert, 420??
AtomicCrimsonRush
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: July 02 2008
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 14256
Posted: April 24 2012 at 05:30
Oh and that is an awesome list with the longest songs ever that you will never hear:
Rich, Robert Somnium 420:00 2001 Somnium Schulze, Klaus Picasso Geht Spazieren 154:27 1993 - 70:00 - 79:59 Bongripper The Great Barrier Reefer 79:23 2006 The Great Barrier Reefer Schulze, Klaus opera trance 79:17 1997 jubilee edition Schulze, Klaus 'Nuff Said 79:06 1997 - Devil Doll The Sacrilege Of Fatal Arms 79:03 1992 The Sacrilege Of Fatal Arms Schulze, Klaus Tradition And Vision 78:45 1997 - Schulze, Klaus The Cello 78:38 2000 - Schulze, Klaus Into The Blue 78:25 1995 - Transatlantic The Whirlwind 77:54 2009 The Whirlwind Schulze, Klaus Borrowed Time 77:12 1997 Jubilee Edition AMM Newfoundland 76:41 1992 Newfoundland bongripper heroin 76:07 2007 heroin VONN Victim One: Agony 76:04 2006 Victim One: Agony Schulze, Klaus My Ty She 75:40 2000 - Fush*tsusha The Wisdom Prepared 74:55 1997 The Wisdom Prepared Fantomas Surgical Sound Specimens from the Museum of Skin 74:16 2004 Delirium Cordia Roach, Steve Darkest Before Dawn 74:00 2002 Darkest Before Dawn Rich, Robert Calling Down The Sky 73:59 2004 Calling Down The Sky Bass Communion / Jonathan Coleclough / Colin Potter Epidural 73:57 2003 Bass Communion / Jonathan Coleclough / Colin Potter Roach, Steve The Dream Circle 73:57 1994 The Dream Circle Schulze, Klaus The Music Box 73:56 1993 - Schulze, Klaus Machine De Plaisir 73:51 1993 - Cope, Julian Breath of Odin 73:45 1999 Odin Roach, Steve & Vidna Obmana Spirit Dome 73:28 2004 Spirit Dome 2350 Broadway Hands Of Light 72:50 1993 2350 Broadway mistigo varggoth darkestra the keys to the gates of apocalypse 72:05 1999 the keys to the gates of apocalypse Pat Metheny Group The Way Up 72:05 2005 The Way Up (japanese version) Corrupted El Mundo Frio 71:39 2005 El Mundo Frio TV Victor Agai 71:01 2000 Timeless Decceleration 2350 Broadway The Invisible Landscape 70:50 1994 2350 Broadway 2
AtomicCrimsonRush
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: July 02 2008
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 14256
Posted: April 24 2012 at 05:25
This part of the list is perhaps made up of many of the songs that took up one whole side of vinyl in the good old days.
Rich, Robert Seascape 29:59 1983 Drones Alec Empire 2641998 29:57 2001 Intelligence & Sacrifice Nadja The Bungled & the Botched 29:55 2008 The Bungled & the Botched Emerson, Lake & Palmer Karn Evil 9 29:53 1973 Brain Salad Surgery Magma Kohntarkosz, Version 2 29:50 1974 - Moonsorrow Tulimyrsky 29:45 2008 Tulimyrsky EP Adventure Seasons 29:37 2000 Adventure Schulze, Klaus Heinrich Von Kleist 29:32 1978 - Legend Triple Aspect 29:29 1996 Triple Aspect Extremoduro Pedrá 29:28 1995 Pedrá Wahnfried, Richard Midiaction 29:28 1986 Miditation Revelation A New Dawn 29:26 2005 The Colossus Of Rhodes 25 Yard Screamer Cassandra 29:25 2007 Cassandra Djam karet blue fred 29:25 1985 no commercial potential Guy LeBlanc Subversia 29:15 1999 Subversia Black Boned Angel The Sorrowful Mysteries 29:14 2006 Ashes Morse, Neal The Door 29:14 2007 Sola Scriptura Schulze, Klaus Crystal Lake 29:12 1977 - Coda Sounds Of Passion 29:06 1986 Sounds Of Passion Reverend Bizarre They Used Dark Forces / Teutonic Witch 29:05 2007 III: So Long Suckers Godspeed You Black Emperor! Providence 29:04 1998 F# A# OO Coheed and Cambria The Willing Well 29:03 2005 Good Apollo I'm Burning Star IV, Volume One: From Fear Through the Eyes of Madness Can Prehistoric Future 29:01 1974 Unopened (Volume Two) Nadja Radiance of Shadows 28:59 2007 Radiance of Shadows X Japan Art Of Life 28:59 1993 Art Of Life Djam Karet Strange Wine From A Twisted Fruit 28:54 1998 - Henry Cow Oslo 28:54 1976 Concerts Schulze, Klaus Nowhere - Now Here 28:53 1977 Body Love 2 Steve Roach Arc of passion (continued) 28:44 2007 Arc of Passion Morse, Neal So many roads 28:42 2008 Lifeline Orb, the feat. David Gilmour Metallic Side 28:42 2010 Metallic Spheres Schulze, Klaus Ludwich II Von Bayern 28:40 1978 - Michael Mantler Folly Seeing All This 28:39 1993 Folly Seeing All This Schulze, Klaus Wahnfried 1883 28:38 1975 Timewind Manowar Achilles, Agony And Ecstasy In Eight Parts 28:37 1992 Triumph Of Steel Fripp & Eno An Index Of Metals 28:36 1975 Evening Star Underworld Lovely Broken Thing 28:36 2006 The Riverrun Project Gathering, The How To Measure A Planet? 28:33 1998 How To Measure A Planet? Tangerine Dream Quinea 28:25 1992 Quinea Liquid Tension Experiment Three Minute Warning 28:22 1998 Liquid Tension Experiment Morse, Neal Part 4 28:19 2003 Testimony C.A.P. Suite Ali Del Sogno Odissea : Libir XIV, XV, XVI 28:16 2005 Odyssey - The Greatest Tale Schulze, Klaus Velvet Voyage 28:14 1977 Mirage Echolyn A Suite For Everyman 28:13 1992 Suffocating the bloom Rich, Robert Wheel of Earth 27:58 1983 Drones 2350 Broadway Raga 27:57 1993 2350 Broadway Coda Lament For Planet Earth 27:54 1996 What a Symphony Salem Hill Sweet Hope Suite 27:54 2000 Not everybody's gold Skepticism Aes 27:52 1998 Aes Weird Al Yankovic Peter And The Wolf 27:52 1988 Peter And The Wolf Bass Communion / Jonathan Coleclough / Colin Potter Pethidine 27:51 2003 Bass Communion / Jonathan Coleclough / Colin Potter Nexus El Regreso 27:50 2005 Odyssey - The Greatest Tale Roz Vitalis Potoki Sveta Trisolnechnogo 27:48 2004 Das Licht Der Menschen Wobbler Hinterland 27:46 2005 Hinterland The Rebel Wheel Christal rain suite 27:40 2004 The Rebel Wheel Pineapple Thief, The What Have We Sown? 27:33 2007 What We Have Sown Nadja I Have Tasted the Fire Inside Your Mouth 27:26 2007 Radiance of Shadows Steve Cochrane Songs For Spring 27:26 1998 - US Life in Progress 27:26 2003 Eamon's Day Schulze, Klaus Floating 27:15 1976 - Constance Demby Part Two 27:14 1986 Novus Magnificat: Thru the Stargate Greenwall The Secret Passage 27:13 2005 The Colossus Of Rhodes Schulze, Klaus P.T.O. 27:12 1977 Body Love Vander Trio, Christian Dear Mac 27:09 1990 - Malibram Le Porte Del Silenzio 27:08 1993 Le Porte Del Silenzio Earth Teeth of Lions Rule the Divine 27:04 1993 Earth 2: Special Low Frequency Version C.A.P. Alla Corte Degli Eroi - 1550 27:03 2006 The 7 Samurai Moongarden The Gates Of Omega 27:03 2001 The Gates Of Omega Spock's Beard The Great Nothing 27:02 2000 V Cathedral The Garden 26:59 2005 The Garden of Unearthly Delights Davis, Miles Bitches Brew 26:58 1970 Bitches Brew Jet Chamber Outer Rotation 26:56 1996 Jet Chamber 2 Mastermind Tragic Symphony 26:56 1995 Volume III: Tragic Symphony Simon Says Brother were you bound 26:56 2008 Tardigrade Tillion The Ugly 26:56 2007 The Spaghetti Epic 2: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly Deluge grander Inaugural bash 26:55 2006 August in the Urals Priam Initiatic Quotient Of The Monk 26:54 1997 - Schulze, Klaus Gringo Nero 26:54 1991 - hourglass The Journey Into 26:53 2002 The Journey into Shalabi, Sam Outside Chance (Dreamfangs) 26:53 2001 On Hashish Pär Lindh Project Mundus Incompertus 26:43 1998 Mundus Incompertus Transatlantic Duel With The Devil 26:43 2001 Bridge Across Forever Nil Acte 2 26:42 2003 Quarante Jours Sur Le Sinai Shalabi Effect Aural Florida 26:37 2000 Shalabi Effect Sinigaglia, Riccardo Evon 26:37 1990 - Frost* Milliontown 26:35 2006 Milliontown Inquire When Darkness Turns To Light 26:35 1999 - Leviathan Un Pensiero e Sempre Libero 26:34 2005 The Colossus Of Rhodes Anima Mundi Spring Knocks on the Door of Men 26:33 2010 The Way Ritual Dangerous Journey, A 26:32 2007 Hermulic Voluntary Band, The Ash Ra Tempel Friendship 26:30 2000 Friendship neurosis cleanse 26:30 1993 enemy of the sun UFO Flying 26:30 1971 Flying Lands End A new world order 26:29 2005 The Lower Depths Hammill, Peter Labyrinthine Dreams 26:25 1996 Sonix Constance Demby Part One 26:24 1986 Novus Magnificat: Thru the Stargate Ageness Sequels (The Feast Of Fools) 26:22 1998 Imageness Esoteric Awaiting My Death 26:20 1994 Epistemological Despondency Schulze, Klaus Shadows Of Ignorance 26:20 1979 Dune Focus Anonymous Two 26:19 1973 - Moonsorrow Tuleen Ajettu Maa 26:19 2007 Viides Luku-Hävitetty Beduinos a gasoleo Canto IV 26:18 2007 Beduinos a gasoleo Flander's Adventure, Jack Chapter #2 26:18 1992 - Yob The Illusion of Motion 26:10 2004 The Illusion of Motion Ezra Winston Ancient Afternoon Of An Unknown Town 26:05 1990 - Transatlantic Stranger In Your Soul 26:05 2001 Bridge Across Forever Introitus Fantasy 26:04 2007 Fantasy In The Woods... Omnio 26:02 1997 Omnio XII Alfonso From Ismarus To The Land Of Death 26:01 2005 Odyssey - The Greatest Tale Morse, Neal Seeds of Gold 25:59 2011 Testimony Two Schulze, Klaus Georg Trakl 25:59 1978 X (remaster) Morse Code Procréation 25:58 1976 - Manning Ragged Curtains 25:55 2002 The Ragged Curtain Nemo Barbares 25:53 2009 Barbares Steve Roach The origin of artifacts 25:48 1994 artifacts Kaipa Mindrevolutions 25:47 2005 Mindrevolutions Schulze, Klaus Conphära 25:42 1973 Cyborg Citizen Cain Somewhere But Yesterday 25:40 1994 Somewhere But Yesterday Simon Says Minds Of Mortal Men 25:40 2005 Odyssey - The Greatest Tale Velvet Desperados Gentlemen Of Fortune 25:39 2007 Treasure Island Lustmord Metastatic Resonance 25:34 1994 The Place Where The Black Stars Hang Wahnfried, Richard Miditation 25:33 1986 Miditation Reverend Bizarre Anywhere Out of This World 25:32 2007 III: So Long Suckers Fonya The Valley Of Lavon 25:31 1995 Earth Shaper Phish Union Federal 25:31 1988 - Domain Shadowhall 25:27 2006 Stardawn Ash Ra Tempel Traummaschine 25:24 1971 Ash Ra Tempel Quicksilver Messenger Service Who Do You Love Suite 25:22 1969 Happy Trails Schulze, Klaus Mindphaser 25:22 1976 - Reverend Bizarre Sorrow 25:20 2007 III: So Long Suckers Tangent, The A Place In The Queue 25:19 2006 A Place In The Queue Mangala Vallis Werewolf Suite 25:18 2005 Lyncanthrope Sunn o))) Decay2 (Nihils' Maw) 25:18 2004 White2 Univers Zero La Faux 25:18 1979 - After Tea Trial, Punishment, the End 25:17 1970 Jointhouse Blues Sunn o))) My Wall 25:16 2003 White1 Fish Plague Of Ghosts 25:13 1999 Raingods With Zippos Rich, Robert Hayagriva 25:13 1983 Trances Burzum Rundtgĺing Av Den Transcendentale Egenbetens Střtte 25:11 1996 Filosofem Lands End Dross 25:11 1996 An Older Land Harrison, George No Time Or Space 25:10 1969 Electronic Sound Floating State Suite dall'inconscio dell'Assassino 25:08 2008 Giallo! One Suite for the Murderer Randome The Good 25:08 2007 The Spaghetti Epic 2: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly Underworld Pizza For Eggs 25:08 2006 The Riverrun Project Dreamies Program 11 25:07 1973 - Mad Crayon Come Vento Tornero 25:05 2005 The Colossus Of Rhodes Parallel Or 90 Degrees An Autopsy In Artificial Light 25:05 2000 Unbranded Rich, Robert The Other Side Of Twilight 25:04 1987 Numena Flower Kings, The Stardust We Are 25:03 1997 Stardust We Are Schulze, Klaus Percussion Planante 25:01 1990 - Morse, Neal The Conflict 25:00 2007 Sola Scriptura Wereju The Darkness Goes on Forever 25:00 2008 Lost and Far From Home Trion Frank 24:59 2004 The Spaghetti Epic: Six Modern Prog Bands For Six Seventies Prog Suites Korpiklaani Korven Kuningas 24:58 2008 Korven Kuningas Rachel's Birthday Waves 24:58 1996 An Invitation to Rachel's Birthday Schulze, Klaus Neuronengesang 24:57 1973 Cyborg Lustmord Aldebaran of the Hyades 24:56 1994 The Place Where The Black Stars Hang Magenta Man The Machine 24:56 2001 Revolutions Bass Communion Drugged 24:55 1998 Bass Communion (I) Cliffhanger Ragnarök 24:54 1996 - Schulze, Klaus Sequenzer (from 70 to 07) 24:54 2007 Kontinuum Bass Communion Drugged 2 24:53 1998 Bass Communion Moon Safari We Spin The World 24:52 2005 A Doorway To Summer 2350 Broadway Heart The Light 24:51 1996 2350 Broadway 3 Velvet Desperados Lords And Knights 24:51 2005 The Colossus Of Rhodes Hancock, Herbie Sleeping Giant 24:50 1972 Crossings Oldfield, Mike Taurus II 24:49 1982 Five Miles Out Zappa, Frank Billy The Mountain 24:49 1971 Just Another Band From L.A. Schulze, Klaus Friedrich Nietzsche 24:47 1978 X (remaster) Devil Doll Eliogabalus 24:44 1990 Eliogabalus Nik Turner Original Sounds from the Great Pyramid 24:43 1993 Sphynx Floating State The Shore And The Breathing Night 24:40 2007 Treasure Island Hecenia Les Jardins "Ethernels" 24:40 1994 La Couleur Du Feu Rutherford, Mike Smallcreep's Day Suite 24:40 1980 Smallcreep's Day Glass Hammer The Knight Of The North 24:39 2005 The Inconsolable Secret Renaissance Scheherazade 24:39 1975 Scheherazade And Other Stories Flower Kings, The Devils Playground 24:30 2002 Unfold The Future IQ Harvest Of Souls 24:29 2004 Dark Matter Flower Kings Love Is The Only Answer 24:28 2007 The Sum of No Evil La Maschera Di Cera Enciclica 1168 24:27 2006 Lux Ade La Voce del Vento The Bad 24:27 2007 The Spaghetti Epic 2: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly Black Jester Paradiso 24:26 1997 The Divine Comedy Billy Thorpe & the Aztecs Ganster of Love 24:24 1971 the Hoax is Over Höstsonaten The Dream 24:21 1998 Mirror Games Jet Chamber Quite My Chords 24:19 1997 Jet Chamber 3 Ash Ra Tempel Jenseits 24:18 1973 Join Inn Episode Hesperates Rising 24:18 1993 Starlight Tales Magic Pie A Life`s Work Pts.1 - 4 24:17 2011 The Suffering Joy Frohmader, Peter Funebre 24:14 2002 Eismeer Tempano Chapter XII, XVII, XVIII, XIX 24:14 2005 Odyssey - The Greatest Tale Anyone's Daughter Adonis 24:13 1979 Adonis Bass Communion / Jonathan Coleclough / Colin Potter Yossaria 24:12 2003 Bass Communion / Jonathan Coleclough / Colin Potter Symphony X The Odyssee 24:09 2002 The Odyssee Adam Hurst Metamorphosis 24:07 2006 Passages Nathan Mahl Of Longings, Suitors, Deities And Quests… 24:07 2005 Odyssey - The Greatest Tale Bradsham Leather, Don Autumn Mist 24:06 1972 Distance Between Us Nuova Era Io E Il Tempo 24:06 1992 Domani Io Vecchio Roz Vitalis The Threesunny Light Power 24:05 2004 The Threesunny Light Power Discipline Rogue 24:04 2011 To shatter all accord Frohmader Homunculus Part IV 24:03 1988 - Glass Hammer If The Sun 24:02 2010 If Redemption Something Wicked This Way Comes 24:00 2002 Redemption Rich, Robert Sunyata (Emptiness) 24:00 1981 Sunyata Schulze, Klaus Dungeon 24:00 1972 Irrlicht (remaster) Dream Theater Octavarium 23:59 2005 Octavarium Carmen Remembrances 23:57 1975 Dancing on a Cold Wind tribes of neurot achtwan 23:56 1996 silver blood transmission Apogee The Range Of Matter 23:54 1995 The Border Of Awareness Rich, Robert Cave Paintings 23:54 1983 Trances Amenophis The Last Requiem 23:53 1983 Amenophis Skylark Light 23:53 1997 - Schulze, Klaus Totem 23:52 1975 Picture Music (remaster) Vander, Christian Baba Yaga La Sorcičre 23:52 1996 - Yes Fly from here 23:52 2011 Fly from here Thieves' Kitchen Chovihani Rise 23:50 2003 Shibboleth Schulze, Klaus Chromengel 23:49 1973 Cyborg Latte e Miele Pavana 23:45 1976 Aquiel E Scoiattoli Pink Floyd Atom Heart Mother 23:45 1970 Atom Heart Mother Bradsham Leather, Don Dance of the Goblins 23:42 1972 Distance Between Us John Fahey Fare Forward Voyagers 23:42 1974 Fare Forward Voyagers Versus X Into the vast Unknown 23:41 2008 Primordial ocean Black Boned Angel Supereclipse I 23:40 2003 Supereclipse Morse, Neal A Whole Nother Trip 23:38 1999 Neal Morse Yob Catharsis 23:38 2003 Catharsis moe. Opium 23:37 2001 Dither Elegant Simplicity Capillary Attraction 23:35 2002 Architect Of Light Island Empty Bottles 23:35 1977 Pictures SBB Going Away 23:33 1978 - Strangers On A Train Endzone 23:32 1993 The Key pt II: The Labyrinth abel ganz So far 23:31 2008 Shooting Albatross Pink Floyd Echoes 23:31 1971 Meddle Nadja Now I Am Become Death, the Destroyer of Worlds 23:27 2007 Radiance Of Shadows King Crimson Lizard 23:26 1970 - K2 Chapter 1: Infinite Voyage 23:25 2005 Book of the Dead Anathema Dreaming: The Romance 23:24 1993 Serenades LP Curtis, Anthony Book of the Key 23:24 2005 Book of the Key NOT Epilogo 23:23 2009 The Spaghetti Epic 3 - The Greatest Silence Schulze, Klaus 1. Satz: Ebene 23:23 1972 Irrlicht Taproban Morton 23:23 2004 The Spaghetti Epic: Six Modern Prog Bands For Six Seventies Prog Suites Vanilla Fudge Break Song 23:23 1969 Near The Beginning Nexus La Aventura En El Mar - The Sea Adventure 23:22 2007 Treasure Island Sunn o))) BassAliens 23:22 2004 White2 Solaris Los Angeles 2026 23:21 1980 - Steven Wilson Raider II 23:21 2011 Grace For Drowning alan sorrenti come un vecchio incensiere... 23:17 1973 come un vecchio incensiere... Chick Corea Sometime Ago / La Fiesta 23:17 1972 Return To Forever Godspeed You Black Emperor! Sleep 23:17 2000 Lift Up Your Skinny Hands Like Antennas To Heaven Hillage, Steve Garden of Paradise 23:15 1979 - Magenta Metamorphosis 23:15 2008 Metamorphosis Schulze, Klaus Buddy Laugh (A Rock'n'Roll Bolero) 23:14 1977 Body Love 2 Sinkadus God Of Silence 23:14 2005 The Colossus Of Rhodes Abraham, Lee white 23:12 2010 black and white Bodin, Tomas I 23:12 2005 I AM Martigan Boatman's Vision 23:12 2009 Vision Spock's Beard The Water 23:11 1995 The Light Bass Communion Haze 1402 23:10 2008 Molotov And Haze Dream Theater A Change Of Seasons 23:06 1995 A Change Of Seasons High Wheel High wheel in the sky part 2 23:06 1993 1910 Focus Eruption 23:04 1972 - Van der Graaf Generator A Plague of Lighthouse Keepers 23:04 1971 Pawn Hearts Aksak Maboul Cinema 23:03 1980 Un Peu De L'Âme Des Bandits Ocean Chief Galleons From The Sun 23:02 2006 Tor Camel The Hour Candle (A Song For My Father) 23:00 1996 Harbour of Tears Schulze, Klaus Mental Door 23:00 1975 Picture Music (remaster) Spiral The capital in ruins 22:59 2011 The capital in ruins Genesis Supper's Ready 22:58 1972 Foxtrot Ash Ra Tempel Desire 22:56 1977 Dream & Desire Harper, Roy The Lord's Prayer 22:55 1973 Lifemask big big train the underfall yard 22:54 2009 the underfall yard Nuova Era Pianeta Trasparente 22:53 1989 Dopo L'Infinito Nnecra Packę La Lune 22:49 2002 Paracelse A.C.T Consequences 22:45 2006 Silence Jon & Vangelis Horizon 22:45 1983 - Schulze, Klaus Voices Of Syn 22:45 1974 Blackdance Shadow Gallery First Light 22:45 2001 Legacy Caravan Nine Feet Underground Nigel Blows A Tune Loves A Friend 22:43 1971 In The Land Of Grey And Pink Kraftwerk Autobahn 22:43 1974 Autobahn Mentaur The Last Battle 22:43 1995 The Last Battle Esoteric Ignotum Per Ignotius 22:42 2008 The Maniacal Vale Schulze, Klaus Synphära 22:42 1973 Cyborg Akacia Journal 22:41 2003 An Other Life Tangent, The The Full Gamut 22:41 2008 Not As Good As The Book Asturias Brilliant Streams 22:38 1989 Brilliant Streams Existence In The Kingdom Of Madness 22:38 1998 - Talk Talk The Rainbow 22:38 1988 Spirit Of Eden Teliof Is it? (parts 1-7) 22:38 2008 Is it? Mindflowers Talk With Myself 22:37 2002 Improgressive Cairo Ruins At Avalon's Gates 22:35 1994 Cairo Godspeed You Black Emperor! Static 22:35 2000 Lift Up Your Skinny Hands Like Antennas To Heaven Montfeltro Canto No 1 22:34 19 - Tapobran The Bandits 22:33 2006 The 7 samurai Unitopia The Garden 22:33 2008 The Garden Godspeed You Black Emperor! Storm 22:32 2000 Lift Up Your Skinny Hands Like Antennas To Heaven Parallel Or 90 Degrees The Time Capsule 22:30 1999 The Time Capsule Versus X The Mirror Of Division 22:30 1996 - The Source From The Start 22:28 2007 All Along This Land Steve Unruh Song To The Sky 22:27 2005 Song To The Sky Flairck Gevecht Met de Engel 22:26 1980 Gevecht Met de Engel Theocracy Mirror of Souls 22:26 2008 Mirror of Souls Haken Visions 22:25 2011 Visions Asturias Circle in the forest 22:24 1988 Circle in the forest Gazpacho Tick Tock 22:24 2009 Tick Tock Circus Movin' On 22:23 1977 Movin' On Pythagoras Journey to the vast unknown 22:23 1981 Journey to the vast unknown Silent Memorial Retrospective 22:23 2009 Retrospective Minimum Vital Etranger En Sa Demeure 22:22 2005 Odyssey - The Greatest Tale Schulze, Klaus Lasse Braun 22:22 1977 Body Love (remaster) SBB Follow My Dream 22:21 1978 - Schroder, Robert Harmonic Ascendant 22:16 1979 - Ash Ra Tempel Niemand Lacht Rückwärts 22:15 1998 Sauce Hollandaise C.A.P. Il regno 22:15 2003 Il bianco regno di Dooah Cathedral The Voyage Of Homeless Sapien 22:15 1994 - Pulsar The Strands Of The Future 22:15 1976 - Sithonia La Recita Del Silenzio 22:15 1992 Spettaculo Annullato Tangerine Dream Alpha Centauri 22:12 1971 Alpha Centauri Roz Vitalis Becoming the Poor-in-Spirit (Dead Can Rise 3) 22:11 2003 Lazarus After Crying A Gadarai Megszallott 22:10 1992 Megalázottak és Megszomorítottak Dogma A Season For Unions 22:08 1992 Dogma Jet Chamber Clearing Your Head 22:05 1998 Jet Chamber 4 Epidermis A Speck, A Dream 22:04 1991 Feel Me Dice Follies 22:03 1978 Dice Discipline Into The Dream 22:03 1997 Unfolded Like Staircase Cast El Puente 22:01 2003 Al-bandaluz Collegium Musicum Pf 1972 22:01 1971 - 62 Eulengasse xxxx 22:00 1995 62 Eulengasse Floating State Wild flower 21:59 2003 Thirteen tolls at noon Trace King-bird 21:58 1975 Birds Vangelis Heaven and hell Part I 21:58 1975 Heaven and hell Fates Warning The Ivory Gate of Dreams 21:57 1999 No Exit Iona Sonc Of Ascent 21:57 2001 Open Sky Light Dreams 21:57 1995 - Spock's Beard The Healing Colours Of Sound 21:57 1999 Day For Night Iona Dunes 21:56 2002 The River Flows La Voce Del Vento Harmonica 21:56 2004 The Spaghetti Epic: Six Modern Prog Bands For Six Seventies Prog Suites Shadow Gallery Ghostship 21:56 1995 Carved In Stone Sotos Tango 21:56 1999 Sotos Yes The Gates Of Delirium 21:55 1974 Relayer Ashra Nightdust 21:52 1976 New Age Of Earth Canarios Cuarto Acto 21:52 1974 Ciclos Magma Riah Sahiltaahk 21:51 1971 - Magic Pie Trick of the Mind 21:50 2007 Circus of Life Roz Vitalis Colore Pieno Di Luce 21:50 2004 Das Licht Der Menschen Versus X Cutting The Veil 21:50 2000 - Oldfield, Mike The Wind Chimes 21:49 1987 Islands Tilion Cheyenne 21:49 2004 The Spaghetti Epic: Six Modern Prog Bands For Six Seventies Prog Suites Atoll L'Araignée-Mal 21:48 1975 L'Araignée-Mal Magenta Genetesis 21:48 2001 Revolutions Parallel or 90 degrees Afterlifecycle 21:48 1997 Afterlifecycle Air Sculpture Gloria mundi 21:47 1999 Fjord Transit Pendragon Queen Of Hearts 21:46 1991 The World Kaipa Skenet Bedrar 21:44 1976 Inget nytt under solen Salmon A Second Life With Heart And Soul 21:42 2001 - Ash Ra Tempel Pikant 21:40 2000 Friendship Carpe Diem Couleurs 21:38 1976 - Finsterforst Untergang 21:38 2009 ... Zum Tode Hin Gracious Super Nova 21:38 1971 This is Gracious Randone Jill 21:38 2004 The Spaghetti Epic: Six Modern Prog Bands For Six Seventies Prog Suites Universal Totem Orchestra Saturno 21:38 1999 - Ash Ra Tempel Time 21:37 1973 Seven Up Extreme Everything Under The Sun 21:37 1992 III Sides To Every Story Tractor Peterloo 21:37 1991 Worst Enemies Göttsching, Manuel Pluralis 21:36 1975 Inventions For Electric Guitar IZZ Deafening Silence 21:36 2005 My River Flows Osanna Animale Senza Respiro 21:36 1972 Palepoli Yes Ritual - Nous Sommes Du Soleil 21:35 1973 Tales From Topographic Oceans Rich, Robert Vertigo 21:34 2003 Calling Down The Sky Trespass Morning lights 21:33 2006 Morning lights Aether Chapter IX 21:32 2005 Odyssey - The Greatest Tale Triumvirat Illusions On A Double Dimple 21:31 1973 Mister ten Percent Apogee Swallow The Illusion 21:30 2003 The Garden Of Delights Glass Hammer At The Court Of Alkinoos 21:30 2005 Odyssey - The Greatest Tale Hancock, Herbie Wandering Spirit Song 21:30 1971 Mwandishi Rare Earth Get Ready 21:30 1969 Get Ready Salem Hill Stolen By Ghosts 21:30 2005 Mimi's Magic Moment Sunn o))) Dylan Carlson 21:30 1999 The Grimmrobe Demos Mr Sirius The Nile For A While 21:29 1990 Dirge Steve Roach views beyond 21:29 2007 Arc of Passion Bodin, Tomas A 21:28 2005 I AM Jet Chamber I Miss Green 21:26 2000 Jet Chamber 5 Schulze, Klaus 3. Satz: Exil Sils Maria 21:26 1972 Irrlicht Cast The Rescue 21:25 1996 - Eggs & Dogs Silicone Bimbo Run 21:24 2009 You Are Rich, Robert Starmaker 21:24 1998 Below Zero Yob The Mental Tyrant 21:23 2005 The Unreal Never Lived Godspeed You Black Emperor! Motherf**ker = Redeemer 21:22 2002 yanqui u.x.o. Rebel Wheel, The Diagramma 21:22 2007 Diagramma Triumvirat Mr. Ten Percent 21:22 1973 Illusions on a Double Dimble Flower Kings, The Monsters & Men 21:21 2006 Paradox Hotel Perez, Luis Ipan In Xiktli Metztli 21:21 1981 - Flairck Variaties op een Dame 21:20 1978 Variaties op een Dame Forgotten Suns A Journey 21:20 2000 - Redemption The Fullness of Time 21:20 2005 The Fullness of Time Jet Chamber Dub In 21:19 1997 Jet Chamber 3 Nathan Mahl Heretik Part I 21:19 2000 - No-Man Heaven Taste 21:19 1995 Heaven Taste Thork EA 21:18 2004 Weila Frogg Cafe Waterfall Carnival 21:16 2003 Creatures Vangelis Heaven and hell Part II 21:16 1975 Heaven and hell Mastermind Brainstorm 21:15 1991 Volume II: Brainstorm Crucible An Imp's Tale 21:14 1997 Tall Tales Galleon The Wanderer 21:14 1998 Mind over Matter Ave Rock Pausa en Espacios 21:13 1977 Espacios Kalaban Eyes Of A Seer 21:13 1993 - Tangent, The Four Egos, One War 21:13 2008 Not As Good As The Book Bi Kyo Ran Suite Ran 21:10 1983 - Buccheri, Francesco Journey 21:10 1979 Journey Reverend Bizarre Cirith Ungol 21:10 2002 In the Rectory of the Bizarre Reverend Mathew Parmenter Modern Times 21:09 2004 Astray Kingston Wall Mushrooms 21:08 1992 Kingston Wall Pendragon The Wishing Well 21:07 2005 Believe Froese, Edgar Tropic of Capricorn 21:06 1977 - Arcansiel I'm Still Searching 21:05 1989 Stillsearching Goldie Timeless 21:03 1995 Timeless Hammill, Peter A Headlong Stretch 21:01 1994 - Thieves' Kitchen The Long Fianchetto 21:01 2008 The Water Road Fripp & Eno The Heavenly Music Corporation 21:00 1973 - Godspeed You Black Emperor! Nervous, Sad, Poor... 21:00 1997 F# A# OO Mago de Oz La Cantata del Diablo (Missit Me Dominus) 21:00 2005 Gaia II: La Voz Dormida
AtomicCrimsonRush
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: July 02 2008
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 14256
Posted: April 24 2012 at 05:19
Edit: we should have a list of the long songs on this thread
Edited by AtomicCrimsonRush - April 24 2012 at 05:21
AtomicCrimsonRush
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: July 02 2008
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 14256
Posted: April 24 2012 at 05:18
The only ones are the tracks with heaps of songs within such as
Dream Theater's 80 minute "6 Degrees of Inner Turbulence"
TAAB of course
and I guess The Whirlwind by Transatlantic.
There's got to be others..... full Cd of one song but I dunno off hand
progrules
Prog Reviewer
Joined: September 14 2007
Location: Netherlands
Status: Offline
Points: 958
Posted: April 24 2012 at 05:02
For those who are interested. This is from our fellow proggers DPRP (Dutch progsite). It should be pretty complete:
A day without prog is a wasted day
tamijo
Forum Senior Member
Joined: January 06 2009
Location: Denmark
Status: Offline
Points: 4287
Posted: April 17 2012 at 14:09
Light of Day, Day of Darkness
NB: I hate the idear of long tracks, anything clocking over 8-9 min needs to be extremly potent.
Tull have shown a great song can be that long, but so many have failed trying.
Prog is whatevey you want it to be. So dont diss other peoples prog, and they wont diss yours
irrelevant
Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: March 07 2010
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 13382
Posted: April 17 2012 at 13:41
Song?
irrelevant
Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: March 07 2010
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 13382
Posted: April 17 2012 at 13:41
elder08 wrote: There was this noise band I use to listen to I can't remember the name to save my life. I thought it was Bull of God but I can't find their website. ANYWAYS, they had a song that was 1 month long. If I recall. It blew my mind when I found out about it.
Bull Of Heaven? Yeah they have a song that outlasts the sun.
elder08
Forum Senior Member
Joined: February 25 2010
Location: Russia
Status: Offline
Points: 236
Posted: April 17 2012 at 13:02
There was this noise band I use to listen to I can't remember the name to save my life. I thought it was Bull of God but I can't find their website. ANYWAYS, they had a song that was 1 month long. If I recall. It blew my mind when I found out about it.
"There are people who say we [Pink Floyd] should make room for younger bands. That's not the way it works. They can make their own room."- David Gilmour
Stool Man
Forum Senior Member
Joined: January 30 2007
Location: Anti-Cool (anag
Status: Offline
Points: 2689
Posted: April 17 2012 at 08:48
spookytooth wrote:
SFranke wrote: "Just an Old-Fashioned Schulze Track" from La Vie Electronique 4 ( I believe) is around 75 minutes. The real winner is Cage's "As Slow As Possible."http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/2728595.stm
Yup, Cage's "As Slow As Possible" definitely takes the cake...it won't be completed until about the year 2640. It's slower than drone music!
Jem Finer's
Longplayer is a thousand years long.
PLUS (and I think this detail matters) a few years ago there was a 1000-minute (that's about 17 hours) live performance of part of it, played by 26 people.
I'd say that being able to be performed live is an important part of defining a long piece of music, song, or whatever you wanna call it.
rotten hound of the burnie crew
smartpatrol
Forum Senior Member
Joined: April 15 2012
Location: My Bedroom
Status: Offline
Points: 14169
Posted: April 15 2012 at 14:16
Well, I have a song called Saturday Circus Dreamscape that's 33 minutes long, but it's not prog. The longest prog song I know is Supper's Ready by Genesis.
Sagichim
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: November 29 2006
Location: Israel
Status: Offline
Points: 6632
Posted: April 07 2012 at 15:04
Um Kulthum - classic arab singer. Most of the songs are 60 minutes pieces. Actually very good music but i'm just kidding.
Andy Webb
Special Collaborator
Retired Admin
Joined: June 04 2010
Location: Terria
Status: Offline
Points: 13298
Posted: April 07 2012 at 14:53
psarros wrote: The longest thing I've heard so far is (Ithink) the 66-min long ''The Girl who Was... Death'' by DEVIL DOLL,but this one includes about 27 minutes of silence.
Great album as well.
That reminds me, The Sacrilege of Fatal Arms is a solid 79 minutes, which beats The Whirlwind, or at least the studio version of TW.
Edited by Andy Webb - April 07 2012 at 14:53