BEST PROG/related ALBUM OF 1979

Shakespeare wrote: Logan wrote: Shakespeare wrote: Um...Am I stupid, or was Hemisphres from 79? And if I'm sane, then WHERE THE HELL IS IT? But of those, The Wall. According to this site, it was released in '78. That said, DB didn't include it in the best album of '78 poll either.  Actually, if you look at his various polls (and read through the debates) his 'methodology' and biases become more apparent. Best is subjective anyway (some no doubt do wish for an "other" option).  EDIT: as for me, I have enough favourite albums listed to choose from (though Eskaton won). Incidentally, Hemispheres is my favourite Rush album. Hemispheres is my favourite Rush album, as well.

Shushhhhh ! Some PAers have a different definition of the word "best". And some PAers get pretty PO'd about people not understanding the hidden meaning not intended or meant by the originator of the post. If I've lost you, don't feel bad. If you have a lot of time on your hands, you can go over some of those other polls & see some interesting "reactions". Me, I'm gonna get lost & wait to see if hornets sometimes forget about their nests
P.S. Hemispheres is my favourite Rush album, too. Or in this case, make that Three, Hee Hee Hee
P.P.S. DB has put out some good ones, though. Check out the French & Italian ones, where's he's uploaded each album cover as part of the list. Eye-catching to say the least, & an excellent way to pique your curiosity about what may be an unknown band


Edited by pantacruelgruel - March 22 2007 at 22:37

Shakespeare wrote: Um...Am I stupid, or was Hemisphres from 79? And if I'm sane, then WHERE THE HELL IS IT? But of those, The Wall.

According to this site, it was released in '78. That said, DB didn't include it in the best album of '78 poll either.  Actually, if you look at his various polls (and read through the debates) his 'methodology' and biases become more apparent. Best is subjective anyway (some no doubt do wish for an "other" option).  EDIT: as for me, I have enough favourite albums listed to choose from (though Eskaton won).

Incidentally, Hemispheres is my favourite Rush album.


Edited by Logan - March 22 2007 at 19:27

For me, the first place will come from Tangerine Dream - Force Majeure, Eskaton - 4 Visions, Mezquita - Recuerdos de mi Tierra or Univers Zero - Heresie... The Wall is one of the albums that I dislike more than anything else (even when the movie is very interesting)!!!

So, my vote goes for ESKATON - 4 VISIONS...

I love The Wall but it's not very prog or fantastic in a musical sense.

seamus wrote: King Zappa wrote: Boooo to those perpetuating the myth that The Wall is a good album.... Boooooo ......!!!!!!!!

It is so not a myth, it is the truth. The myth is that it's a great double album. It would make a great single album, though

King Zappa wrote: Boooo to those perpetuating the myth that The Wall is a good album.... Boooooo

......!!!!!!!!



Edited by seamus - March 20 2007 at 15:26

1.      Force Majeure (Tangerine Dream)

2.      Exposed (Mike Oldfield)

3.      Platinum (Mike Oldfield)

4.      The Wall (Pink Floyd)

5.      Stuntman (Edgar Froese)

6.      pH 7 (Peter Hammill)

7.      China (Vangelis)

8.      Stormwatch (Jethro Tull)

9.      Dune (Klaus Schulze)

10.  In Concert (Emerson, Lake & Palmer)

11.  Daphnis Et Chloe (The Ravel Album) (Isao Tomita)

12.  Time Actor (Richard Wahnfried)

13.  Correlations (Ashra)

14.  Exposure (Robert Fripp)

15.  Oasis (Kitaro)

16.  Opera Sauvage (Vangelis)

17.  From The Full Moon Story (Kitaro)

18.  Azure D’Or (Renaissance)

19.  I Can See Your House From Here (Camel)

20.  Trans Harmonic Nights (Peter Baumann)

21.  Rhapsodies (Rick Wakeman)

King Zappa wrote: Boooo to those perpetuating the myth that The Wall is a good album.... Boooooo

some of us think it's more than a myth..

Boooo to those perpetuating the myth that The Wall is a good album.... Boooooo

NO MORE?

Edited by DallasBryan - March 10 2007 at 17:27