oh a potentially good one here so let's have half of the classic AR team duke it out.. while David and I drink Sarsaparillas  in the near corner.. RICO!!!! 
|
Post Rock/Math rock
4.11 | 423 ratings
|
From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website
Ricochet
Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator
|

The "Godspeed You Black Emperor" ensemble are gods of Sounds,of Vision,of Context and
of Passion that goes everlasting.With just a short current discographic
achievement,they have managed to make wonders and to disturb the general
dynamics.With just three albums,they have the control.Believe me when I say that the
personal fact of awarding every studio album of their work a solid or a close to
solid five stars is totally justifiable.For even though my viewpoint progressive rock
horizon expands to thirty-forty bands at five-six character of it,"Godspeed You Black
Emperor!" impose as something truly unique,remarcable,fantastic and innovating.They
may not be in a visible top (by not being music on everybody's language and
convenience on anybody's option)-and,regarding them,it wouldn't even be of such
importance to be in a visible top-but they are among the top of creation and concepts
regarding high class,keen sharp focus,great perception and understanding,as well as
masterfull strokes of music.In such style,in such times,in such a world,in such
boundaries of reality and imagination,Godspeed You Black Emperor! Breaks the laws of
routing,of compromise and of conformism,of sound spectrum limits and of composition
boundaries.They define that with aplomb and they work their way as giants and as
prolific.What the ensemble does is in the name and in the valuable prestige of
music,of art;as for the fans,the experience of this manifest (of these
manifests,cause I am still speaking at general scales) is a bliss,a shock,a
soul-thrill and a constant "mind-game",a priceless gift.The relation is within divine
chords and fantastic orchestration.The surrealist hard-abstrakt pulse is
exhilarating."Experimental" comes as just a metaforic state of the Godspeed music.In
fact,almost all definitions tend to be simple guidelines.Even this review of mine can
be just a succint expression.For the real definition is the one given by the
listeners' impression.Everything else,in the end,could just be allusions. Every of the three studio albums carries a different message and a different
pulse.Though great similarities and indigo markings can be considered,it is a very
deceiving idea.After the apocalyptic,nebulous F#a# (and the relatively related EP
that followed after),the scenario changes.Now to be honest I did actually set a
reference on the ∞ and expected a continuation of that.But I was not dissapointed at
all by this other side of the Godspeed dimensions."F#a# ∞" remains my favourite
masterliness album,but "Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas To Heaven" is of the
same magnitude and of the same breathless effect as well.Most elcomed and most
prolific is the opened reference,in which the mystery of the sound and the trembling
of the spirit prevails.Godspeed offers a double sized treat in which the enormous
valences stay intact,the arrangement flows in the same gesture,just the themes and
the approach being changed in order to support a new message,a new horizon,a new
universe.The sensation and the emotion also goes directed into specific meadows.
"Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas To Heaven" adpots an opened expression,one not
in the sense of light or easy music,but in the perspective of a spirit
definition.Here is the true contrast with F#a#.While that one stirs in the venom of
its dark reflection and is clustered within the blackening poem (nota bene I am not
describing limitations,but a concentrated essence) this one expands.It's
plurimotivated and diverse in the general scale.The accent is on force and on the
perpetuation of full power.With "routing" forms of compositions (the climaxes,for
example;the everpresent climaxes),of perspective (higher,higher and higher) and of
manifest (living up to their names),they make a presentation not of the doomsday,but
of a world and thought beyond the natural graphics.As a first,the melody is more
pronounced,this besides (or better said alont) with the experimentation of sound
celss and distorted themes.Also the orchestration of movements and the collision of
influences come tad proeminent related to the unitary form (again,these are not
limits,but simple mass substances).The effuzion:the lights;the control!New is:the
mixture of low silent points-which are sublime in construction and claustrophobic-and
the vibrant energic climaxes-which are stretched as definition beyond your wildest
imagination-as well as the fact that these two general movements are opposite polls
to the limit;the motions,the dynamics,the key points of blistering rapid
explosions;the "order" of the Brownian movement;the splendid scale of finding the
unknown;the ascension focus viewpoint;the meadows of a delightful infinity;the spirit
disquised in primordial material;the challenging phases of a sublime
rapture.Unchanged stays:the essence and the ideals of Godspeed You Black Emperor!;the
constant desire to make everything perfect:the splendid sensation of making out of
the world a metaforical state of effect:the untouchable quality;the fruits of furt
and the freeze of the moment:the unimaginable being reached,the unseen being
faced:the flawless motivation;the close combination of Life,Death and Life;the
neverending chimeras windows and the decreptive passion."Lift Your Skinny Fists Like
Antennas To Heaven" is the call towards hopes and disillusions,towards the end of
everything futile,the agony,the thrill,the point.. As much as I would like to elaborate the aspect,the sensation and the meaning of all
four pieces,I will leave that to your subjectivism and your personal moment of
reflection.My explosions of euphoria come on two moments: "Storm" (which is the best
Godspeed You Black Emperor! Ever) and "Sleep" (for a climax of such intensity that
burns your ears:a caution advice by this of course-to explore the Godspeed world with
care,for the extreme climaxes ARE extreme climaxes). Masterpiece.
|
and in the far corner.. the prog goddess herself...  
|
Heavy Prog
4.21 | 1033 ratings
|
From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website
Raff
Special Collaborator RIO/Avant/Zeuhl Team
|

This album was not my first experience with TMV - on the strength of some very
positive reviews, some months before I'd bought "Frances the Mute", which I liked a
lot on first listening, though later on I came to see its shortcomings somewhat more
clearly. However, "Deloused in the Comatorium", the Hispano-American band's debut
full-length album, is quite a different story. This is truly a groundbreaking record
that sets new standards for contemporary prog.
Hate them or love them, it is hard to deny that The Mars Volta (brilliant name for a
prog band, anyway) are progressive in the true sense of the word. Born from the ashes
of emo band At The Drive-in, they are not afraid to take elements from such disparate
genres as prog, punk, metal, jazz and Latin music and blend them together, stamping
their individual seal over the end result in the process. Their display of dazzling
musicianship, left-field lyrical concepts, stunning cover art and no-holds-barred
songwriting are the hallmarks of a first-rate outfit that's ready to take prog - that
stereotypically earnest, stuck-in-a-time-warp musical genre - right into the 21st
century.
Most of the tracks on this album are over the 5-minute mark, with "Cicatriz Esp"
clocking in at over 12 minutes - another statement of intent on the part of the band,
who are unashamed fans of such historic Seventies prog acts as Rush and King Crimson.
However, even if their original punk roots rear their heads every now and then, it
is never in a really obtrusive way. If anything, these punk roots add a measure of
spice to the exotic mixture that is TMV's sound. The musicianship is first-rate
throughout, with a special mention for inventive, powerful drummer Jon Theodore,
whose rythmic sparring partner is on this occasion a very special guest, RHCP's Flea
(one of the best four-stringers on the market, even if you don't like his mother
band). The crisp, clear production values further enhance Theodore's intricate,
occasionally explosive drumming, as it is quite evident right from the very
beginning, in killer opener "Inertiatic ESP" (preceded by the deceptive quiet of "Son
and Lumière).
In my personal opinion, though, the real strength of TMV lies in the supercharged
vocals of Cedric Bixler-Zavala, whose banshee wail interspersed with more reflective,
almost lyrical moments exemplifies what a really expressive singing style is all
about. A richer, fuller version of Geddy Lee, he stamps his mark all over the album,
perfectly complemented by his partner in crime (and former At the Drive In fellow
member) Oscar Rodriguez Lopez's wildly atmospheric guitar playing. Unlike they did in
follow-up "Frances the Mute", here the band keep the use of weird, electronic noises
to a minimum, with epic "Cicatriz ESP" 's middle section being a prime example of how
such noises can be used sparingly to their maximum effect.
With such a strong album, it would be difficult for me to pick any standout tracks,
apart from those I have already mentioned. Haunting ballad "Televators" is a much
better effort in this sense than "The Widow" on FtM; while "Eriatarka", "This
Apparatus Must Be Unearthed" and album closer "Take the Veil, Cerpin Taxt" brim with
energy and freshness, Cedric's brilliant vocals soaring above the band's unleashed
instrumental fury.
I pondered for a long time, and listened to the album twice before writing this
review - but, in the end, I could not help but decide to give this album the highest
rating, as others have done before me. Weird it may be, but nothing short of
wonderful as well - this is prog for the 21st century, a must-listen for all serious
proggers. A wild ride perhaps, but one to enjoy to the fullest.
|
|