Forum Home Forum Home > Progressive Music Lounges > Prog Polls
  New Posts New Posts RSS Feed - "Some of you are going to die..."
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Events   Register Register  Login Login

Topic Closed"Some of you are going to die..."
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <123
Poll Question: Which version of the Knife do YOU like?
Poll Choice Votes Poll Statistics
34 [56.67%]
24 [40.00%]
0 [0.00%]
2 [3.33%]
This topic is closed, no new votes accepted

Author
Message
  Topic Search Topic Search  Topic Options Topic Options
Zargus View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: May 08 2005
Location: Sweden
Status: Offline
Points: 3491 		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 18 2007 at 12:35
The studio is my favorite, i get bored by the live version dno why.
Back to Top
BaldJean View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer
Avatar

Joined: May 28 2005
Location: Germany
Status: Offline
Points: 10377 		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 18 2007 at 12:51
Originally posted by Zargus Zargus wrote:

The studio is my favorite, i get bored by the live version dno why.

the same happens to me with the studio version lol


A shot of me as High Priestess of Gaia during our fall festival. Ceterum censeo principiis obsta
Back to Top
Chus View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer
Avatar

Joined: October 16 2006
Location: Venezuela
Status: Offline
Points: 1991 		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 18 2007 at 13:04
Originally posted by salmacis salmacis wrote:

I agree with Erik; it's widely perceived that Hackett had the biggest contribution to the band's more symphonic sound, he urged them to buy a mellotron, for example. That symphonic grandeur left with him, despite ATTWT and Duke still being excellent albums.

However, I still prefer the Trespass version. I think Anthony Phillips' guitar solo is brilliant and makes me forgive the weak drumming of John Mayhew.
 
 I think not, they used a lot of mellotron in Trespass... careful if not more than in NC.... and I quite like Anthony Phillips solo a bit more.. Hackett used too much pull-offs and hammer-ons on his that I found unappealing for Genesis
Jesus Gabriel
Back to Top
CryoftheCarrots View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: November 29 2005
Location: Australia
Status: Offline
Points: 674 		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 21 2007 at 21:29
The Live version was the first version I heard of The Knife. The Trespass version just doesn't have the power (edge)that a song about a revolution should have due mainly to Ant and JM's weaker contributions.
"There is a lot in this world to be tense and intense about"

MJK
Back to Top
richardh View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer
Avatar

Joined: February 18 2004
Location: United Kingdom
Status: Offline
Points: 26371 		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 22 2007 at 02:55
Originally posted by BaldJean BaldJean wrote:

I am really surprised the rather half-baked and energy-lacking studio version seems to be winning at the moment (though the margin by which the studio version leads is by no means decisive yet). Hackett's solo is harmonically far more interesting than that of Philips and much more fitting for the song. the few acoustical gimmicks of the studio version are interesting, but not enough to make me vote for it. the live version of "The Knife" is the closest Genesis ever came to metal, by the way.
I would have expected the live version to be a clear winner. my vote definitely goes to it. too bad there are not more votes with explanations though
 
Half baked?Confused
 
The studio version has a much chunkier feel to it...especially the organ sound. Its tremendously atmospheric as well. If anything the live version is overcookedWink
 
Interestingly as a peice of music it was inspired by The Nice 'Rondo'. Similar comparisons can be made between The Nice doing Rondo (more solid) and ELP's later versions (busier/more energetic) .Again I think I prefer the original studio version in that case as well.Big%20smile
Back to Top
sheeves View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member


Joined: October 30 2006
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 101 		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 22 2007 at 17:48
I think the only bad thing Hackett did with Genesis was ruin ANt Philips Guitar solo on the knife and not play it the way ant did when he played live
my favorite guitar solo besides firth of fifth
Back to Top
Mlaen View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: June 28 2005
Location: Croatia
Status: Offline
Points: 377 		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 23 2007 at 13:52
I don't like live albums very much, so "original" for me.
Back to Top
BaldFriede View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer
Avatar

Joined: June 02 2005
Location: Germany
Status: Offline
Points: 10261 		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 23 2007 at 16:07
"The Knife" is about the only live track of Genesis worth listening to; it exceeeds the original by far. I really don`t understand what people find in the Phillips solo; the solo of Hackett is a lot more original and much more fitting for the song.
I am not the biggest fan of  "Trespass" anyway; the drumming is uninspired, in my opinion, and Phillips lead guitar does not convince me either. For me the first real Genesis album is "Nursery Cryme". The only song on "Trespass" I have a weak spot for is "White Mountain". "The Knife" in the studio version shows potential, but this potential was only developed in the live version. I can understand though why people prefer the studio version to the live version; the live version is probably a bit too much on the metal side for a lot of Genesis fans.


Edited by BaldFriede - February 23 2007 at 17:01


BaldJean and I; I am the one in blue.
Back to Top
salmacis View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member

Content Addition

Joined: April 10 2005
Status: Offline
Points: 3928 		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 23 2007 at 16:18
Originally posted by Chus Chus wrote:

Originally posted by salmacis salmacis wrote:

I agree with Erik; it's widely perceived that Hackett had the biggest contribution to the band's more symphonic sound, he urged them to buy a mellotron, for example. That symphonic grandeur left with him, despite ATTWT and Duke still being excellent albums.

However, I still prefer the Trespass version. I think Anthony Phillips' guitar solo is brilliant and makes me forgive the weak drumming of John Mayhew.
 
 I think not, they used a lot of mellotron in Trespass... careful if not more than in NC.... and I quite like Anthony Phillips solo a bit more.. Hackett used too much pull-offs and hammer-ons on his that I found unappealing for Genesis
 
Well then, where? The only songs that spring to mind with mellotron on for Trespass are on Stagnation and Visions Of Angels, which if you had read later on in the thread I had actually said in the first place.Confused
 
On Nursery Cryme it's on Return Of The Giant Hogweed, Seven Stones and The Fountain Of Salmacis...3 songs to 2 songs....that's certainly less, considering Stagnation uses it fleetingly (most prominently in the climax) and Visions Of Angels only in the instrumental section. It's nowhere to be heard on Looking For Someone, White Mountain, Dusk or The Knife that I know of. In what way does that equate to mellotron being used 'more' on Trespass??
 
And for further clarification, read this Wikipedia article on Nursery Cryme- ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nursery_Cryme) it clearly says they BOUGHT THEIR OWN mellotron- again, I had already said in this thread that the one on Trespass may well have been on loan from the studio.Ouch
 
And to add further insult to injury, I said I like Phillips solo more on The Knife too!
 
I'm not sure if it's as simple as the live version being 'more metal'- I'm a big 70s/early 80s metal fan and I still prefer the studio version, despite its flaws. Always have done, but to each their own.Smile
 


Edited by salmacis - February 23 2007 at 16:22
Back to Top
erik neuteboom View Drop Down
Prog Reviewer
Prog Reviewer


Joined: July 27 2005
Location: Netherlands
Status: Offline
Points: 7659 		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 23 2007 at 16:40
Steve Hackett was very inspired by Robert Fripp his agressive guitarwork and he put a lot of that in the The Knife live solo, in my opinion this element upgraded the live version to a superior level in comparison with the studio version. Listening to Anthony Phillips I have always had the idea that he was a good acoustic guitarist who also played some electric guitar while Hackett was a classically trained guitarist who had an amazing development as a electric guitar player, so creative and adventurous Clap
Back to Top
Floydian42 View Drop Down
Forum Senior Member
Forum Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: January 13 2007
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 846 		Direct Link To This Post Posted: February 23 2007 at 16:51
I love the live version, more energy, more natural, IMHO
Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <123

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down



This page was generated in 0.145 seconds.
Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.