Author |
Topic Search Topic Options
|
Luna
Forum Senior Member
Joined: July 28 2010
Location: Funky Town
Status: Offline
Points: 12794
|
Posted: September 06 2016 at 11:09 |
Not a huge Camel fan (still like them somewhat!), but I always found Moon In June to be the weakest (and possibly most grating) track on that album. Maybe the other 3 songs will be ranked higher?
|
|
 |
Magnum Vaeltaja
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: July 01 2015
Location: Out East
Status: Offline
Points: 6777
|
Posted: September 06 2016 at 19:41 |
80. Gentle Giant Three Friends
Schooldays

878.8 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 80 Ranked highest by Micky (#16)
"Deceptively quaint, this track features great vocal interplay,
complex time signatures, churning bass, a nice piano break midway, a grooving
vibe solo and finally a revisit of the first melodic theme. Again, it is simply
amazing how much music territory is covered within a short time." Negoba
79. Talk Talk Spirit of Eden The Rainbow

880.0 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 77 Ranked highest by
mechanicalflattery (#24)
"The electric guitar on 'The Rainbow', my favourite track on the
album, is just beautiful (actually, so is Hollis' singing on that track, and
indeed some of the melodic phrases). The parts with ponderous piano or other
instrument playing quietly while Hollis warbles quietly are probably what
please me most throughout the album." Fitzcarraldo
78. Yes Tales From Topographic Oceans The Ancient (Giants Under The
Sun)

881.8 points Appears 3 times Mean rank: 32 Ranked highest by Micky (#4)
"I complained a lot about this loose structured track. That was my
first impression, of course. The more I played it, it grew steadily with me. I
especially love when the vocal starts to roll and also when the acoustic
passage comes into play with stunning acoustic guitar work by Howe combined
with Jon's voice. Oh man ... this is a great offering from the band!!"
Gatot
77. King Crimson Lizard Lizard

883.5 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 98 Ranked highest by Magnum Vaeltaja
(#8)
"The first section of this masterful three-part song cycle features
Jon Anderson of Yes on vocals, providing yet another savory flavour for
LIZARD's exotic musical mιlange. There is less of the jazzy experimentation
which was heard on previous tracks; the direction here is more conventionally
"progressive rock," with grandiose mellotrons, courtly
subject-matter, and classically-oriented arrangements -- at this point almost a
welcome respite from (or counter-balance to) the overt strangeness of the first
half [of the album]." - Peter
76. Can Future Days Bel Air

887.2 points Appears 3 times Mean rank: 32 Ranked highest by Guldbamsen (#2)
"Last up is the crown jewel of this album. The side long Bel Air.
Stirring intro with the crashing waves, sweet guitar and bass. Does it meander
at times.. it may... does it say anything in 20 minutes... no.. not to me at
least. Take it for what it was.. a musical seascape painting and enjoy the
scenery." - Micky (#88)
75. King Crimson Starless and Bible Black Fracture

890.7 points Appears 3 times Mean rank: 26 Ranked highest by Guldbamsen (#19)
"Speaking of superb guitar from Fripp,
Fracture totally takes his playing to the next level. Words cannot describe how
utterly complicated the guitar playing on Fracture is, it's just so,
unbelievably difficult to play those dissonant lines that are played all around
the fretboard in such a quick sequence. Fripp really is one of the greatest
guitarists of all time because he can play songs as complicated as this."
- Cygnus X-2
74. ELP Brain Salad Surgery - Toccata

904.8 points Appears 3 times Mean rank: 24 Ranked highest by The Dark Elf (#14)
"Toccata is the most aggressive and pummeling piece of prog music
ever to hit vinyl...Forget all your metal bands -- ELP are the real deal, and
"Toccata" is their brain buster. This was the piece of music that
turned me on to this album and to ELP in general, and still I've never found
anything that challenges its throne as king destroyer." corbet
73. Van der Graaf Generator Still Life Childlike Faith in
Childhoods End

905.4 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 81 Ranked highest by A_Flower (#29)
"A radiant composition, and some of the best writing Hammill has
done thus far! The whole band shines on this one, the interplay between Banton
and Jackson is superb and wonderfully textured. The song reaches several epic
peaks, musical and emotional splendor, there's really no way else I can
describe it! Hammill belts out this song in an almost prophetic manner, singing
as if these were his last words. Listen for David's solo during the first
climax, intense! The song ends in epic brilliance, almost taking you with the
human race and they are brought to the apex of the universe, naked to all,
preparing for the final day's of human kind." - Con Safo
72. Bubu Anabelas El Cortejo
de Un Dia Amarillo

913.3 points Appears 3 times Mean rank: 23 Ranked highest by Magnum Vaeltaja
(#1)
"As the manic drums fade in at the start on side A we are taken by
surprise by a freakout orgiastic wash of saxophone, violin, relentless bass
lines and a myriad of other sounds, wonderfully juxtaposed into some semblance
of order but chaotic enough to keep any metronome swinging
wildly...Descriptions cannot do it justice as the music takes on a whole new
meaning with each listen and must be experienced and interpreted on a personal
level. The side long track is masterfully executed and shifts from light to
dark textures, occasionally brutal and disturbing to light and upbeat, truly
emotional music. The way the music builds to a crescendo towards the end
transfixes on each listen, and then there is an improv section with cold wah
wah guitar wailing while a sad tortured violin cries. Simply a wonderful
instrumental and one of the best I have heard." AtomicCrimsonRush
71. Camel Moonmadness Lunar Sea

914.9 points Appears 3 times Mean rank: 71 Ranked highest by Zwordser (#23)
"The concluding track
Lunar Sea is a storming piece of music that starts off, as one would imagine,
full of spacey synths courtesy of Bardens. It eventually erupts into a full
throttle Latimer guitar solo, but when the rhythm section starts playing around
with the time signature, Bardens comes back in ... the effect is both
discomforting and enthralling, and puts the exclamation point on an
entertaining album." - Trotsky
|
when i was a kid a doller was worth ten dollers - now a doller couldnt even buy you fifty cents
|
 |
mechanicalflattery
Forum Senior Member
Joined: August 08 2016
Location: Seattle
Status: Offline
Points: 1056
|
Posted: September 06 2016 at 19:58 |
I actually really like all of these 
Actually I haven't listened to any Bubu yet (I know, I KNOW, I'll get around to it).
|
 |
zravkapt
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: October 12 2010
Location: Canada
Status: Offline
Points: 6451
|
Posted: September 07 2016 at 06:42 |
Didn't realize someone else had Bel Air ranked higher than me. I'm going to guess the top ten will consist of:
2-3 Yes 2-3 Genesis 2 Floyd 2 Crimson 1 ELP
|
Magma America Great Make Again
|
 |
Blinkyjoh
Forum Senior Member
Joined: October 10 2015
Location: Toronto
Status: Offline
Points: 125
|
Posted: September 07 2016 at 08:01 |
listening to some of the stuffs you peoples have voted for so far from the top.
I really like Camel's Ice at first and second listen. but the rest of the stuff up there...woah there is a whole different level of prog than i am used to :D
|
 |
mechanicalflattery
Forum Senior Member
Joined: August 08 2016
Location: Seattle
Status: Offline
Points: 1056
|
Posted: September 07 2016 at 08:50 |
zravkapt wrote:
Didn't realize someone else had Bel Air ranked higher than me. I'm going to guess the top ten will consist of:
2-3 Yes 2-3 Genesis 2 Floyd 2 Crimson 1 ELP |
Heart of the Sunrise, Close To The Edge, And You And I Firth of Fifth, Supper's Ready, maybe Dancing With The Moonlit Knight, The Cinema Show, or The Musical Box Atom Heart Mother Suite, Echoes Starless, 21st Century Schizoid Man Tarkus
|
 |
micky
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: October 02 2005
Location: .
Status: Offline
Points: 46843
|
Posted: September 07 2016 at 09:25 |
yeah much like the battle of bands and albums we had last year (reminds me I need to get cracking on the 3rd part of the McTrilogy and get the battle of the songs together). The real interest is not the very top.. the final rounds... the usual suspects rule. It is the preliminary rounds... or lists like this. Those outside the very top.
Even the bobbleheads can't choose every f**king Genesis song or Camel song for their lists... what is interesting are what they like in addition to those soporific moth eaten prog standards..
|
The Pedro and Micky Experience - When one no longer requires psychotropics to trip
|
 |
micky
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: October 02 2005
Location: .
Status: Offline
Points: 46843
|
Posted: September 07 2016 at 09:46 |
Blinkyjoh wrote:
but the rest of the stuff up there...woah there is a whole different level of prog than i am used to :D |
 that is the point of these things isn't it. There is more to prog than f**king Camel or snoring in time to Genesis songs. So which ones in particular floated your boat...
|
The Pedro and Micky Experience - When one no longer requires psychotropics to trip
|
 |
timothy leary
Forum Senior Member
Joined: December 29 2005
Location: Lilliwaup, Wa.
Status: Offline
Points: 5319
|
Posted: September 07 2016 at 09:56 |
|
 |
Blinkyjoh
Forum Senior Member
Joined: October 10 2015
Location: Toronto
Status: Offline
Points: 125
|
Posted: September 07 2016 at 12:18 |
only made it through 300-280ish, and not very thoroughly. everything needs a second listen.
That (camel instrumental) and one of the Tangerine Dream songs..Atem?
Ive always had a bias of ignoring TD cuz it seems they follow(proceed?) the buckethead path of releasing an album every other hour.
not sure what i think of yeti.
chick corea, never ever listened to him before, but really like Return to Forever's ...Jester as well.
Edited by Blinkyjoh - September 09 2016 at 09:05
|
 |
BunBun
Forum Senior Member
Joined: June 20 2014
Location: MN
Status: Offline
Points: 318
|
Posted: September 07 2016 at 16:41 |
|
 |
Magnum Vaeltaja
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: July 01 2015
Location: Out East
Status: Offline
Points: 6777
|
Posted: September 07 2016 at 17:57 |
70. PFM Per Un Amico Appena Un Po

925.7 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 66 Ranked highest by Magnum Vaeltaja
(#29)
"I can feel it from first sounds in Appena Un
Po', that something magical has been crafted here, soft, tender, coming not
through your ear, but skipping your whole hearing system and going right into
your brain, where it blows into a wonderful explosion." - Marty McFly
69. Genesis A Trick of The Tail Dance On A Volcano

948.2 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 67 Ranked highest by The Dark Elf (#24)
"Dance on a Volcano starts out with a very distinctive, explosive
drum and organ riff that paints a sort of sonic picture of the song's lyrical
content. If one had any doubts left as to Phil Collins' skills as a drummer
(however much one can hate him for his later career), his commanding
performance on this song immediately clears the ground - besides, the interplay
between the four band members is nothing short of dazzling." Raff
68. PFM Storia Di Un Minuto La Carrozza Di Hans

951.0 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 77 Ranked highest by Micky (#5)
"[La Carrozza Di Hans] is built up around the amazing guitar work
of Franco Mussida. I dreamt many times to play it properly with my acoustic
guitar and when I was a teenager Franco Mussida seemed to me like a merchant of
musical dreams, but my guitar never turned from a "pumpkin" into a
magnificent carriage like in Cinderella's fairy-tale...By the way, in this
track there's not only amazing guitar technique to be found, but a perfect
interaction between the guitar and the other instruments." Andrea
67. Rush Permanent Waves Jacobs Ladder

951.9 points Appears 5 times Mean rank: 109 Ranked highest by someone_else (#29)
"Jacob's Ladder is a surprising gem, with a very dark, powerful
atmosphere that Rush rarely attempt to build...In the build-up to a massive
crashing section, we get a great decisiveness and a feeling of spontaneity that
Rush often seems to lack. Everyone is on top form, and the atmosphere is very
moving." - TGM: Orb
66. Rush A Farewell To Kings - Xanadu

969.3 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 70 Ranked highest by someone_else (#8)
"This is another track were Rush excels in passing emotions in
their music. Every time I listened to this, I saw Kublai Khan running with his
Mongol tribes through the Steppes - Grandiose." - Sean Trane
65. Magma - άdό Ẁόdό De Futura

969.5 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 63 Ranked highest by Zravkapt (#7)
"De Futura is one of the best tracks in all of Magma's catalogue.
It has a haunting affect much like the other tracks on the album with the
signature sound of Top's bass and Vander's incredible drumming with various
keyboards and effects thrown in. In the end, this track really does the album
justice, making it a must for every Magma or Zeuhl fan." - Zac M
64. Genesis Foxtrot Can-Utility and the Coastliners

976.0 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 65 Ranked highest by The Dark Elf (#4)
"This is a little talked about song, and much underated. This is
one of my favourite Genesis songs of any era. It combines everthing that made
the Genesis formula brilliant and unique, into 6 minutes of excellent music.
The classical guitar intro perfectly sets the scene and gives way to Phil's
crashing drums and Tony's bass pedals. Very dramatic and very melodic."
Blacksword
63. Radiohead OK Computer Paranoid Android

993.7 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 56 Ranked highest by TheLionOfPrague
(#12)
"The beautiful switches between textures and time signatures whilst
maintaining continuity by use of ostinato rather than riffs is utterly
masterful and the texture is well worth dwelling on. By making subtle changes
using different instruments or different sounds on the instruments, and
modifying riffs by a couple of notes, an amazing seamlessness and organic
growth continues. The "Rain Down" coda that ends this piece is
stunning and raises the hairs on the back of my neck due to the pure beauty of
the melodies, and the brilliant vocal harmonies, many of which are quite far
back in the mix - the counter tenor and bass parts are quite staggering, and
put almost every prog band in the archives to shame." - Certif1ed
62. The Moody Blues Days of Future Passed Nights In White Satin

1020.2 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 52 Ranked highest by The Dark Elf (#6)
"Nights in White Satin, probably the most beautiful prog-rock
ballad, is candid and gentle, the sadness of a lonely night is perfectly
understood. The way the song flows is astonishing and exciting and there's
always a background mellotron tune, a kind of registered mark for this
marvelous song. Unique." - Atkingani
61. Renaissance Ashes Are Burning Ashes Are Burning

1020.9 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 52 Ranked highest by Zwordser (#19)
"The album concludes with the masterful "Ashes are
burning", climbing gently from hollow winds like cute little insects
rising to the green shades of trees reaching for heaven. Melodies shift
interestingly between major and minor keys, and the two themes from the
beginning lead to ascending fireworks of instrumental virtuosic displays,
creating a fine emotional passage from sophisticated entwining of piano,
harpsichord and rhythm section instruments, and also dramatic synthesizer
motive over shimmering layers of percussions. The return to fragile vocal lines
and following explosion for the musical heights is also one of the most
affecting musical sensations which I have yet found from the symphonic rock
recordings." - Eetu Pellonpaa
Edited by Magnum Vaeltaja - September 07 2016 at 17:58
|
when i was a kid a doller was worth ten dollers - now a doller couldnt even buy you fifty cents
|
 |
mechanicalflattery
Forum Senior Member
Joined: August 08 2016
Location: Seattle
Status: Offline
Points: 1056
|
Posted: September 07 2016 at 18:06 |
Can-Utility And The Coastliners is above La Carossa Di Hans....
Burn everything, it's over now 
|
 |
Magnum Vaeltaja
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: July 01 2015
Location: Out East
Status: Offline
Points: 6777
|
Posted: September 07 2016 at 23:18 |
60. Genesis The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway The Carpet Crawlers

1024.7 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 50 Ranked highest by A_Flower (#25)
"One of those songs whose vocal presentation of aural poetry serves
as a balm to the ears and the soul. Brilliant song, brilliantly mixed! God that
guy can write and deliver lyrics! Thank god for the musicians' restraint in
setting this one up for Gabe." BrufordFreak
59. Jethro Tull Aqualung Locomotive Breath

1034.4 points Appears 5 times Mean rank: 96 Ranked highest by aglasshouse (#13)
"This song is to JETHRO TULL what SMOKE ON THE WATER is to DEEP
PURPLE: no way, even now, that they will not play these 2 songs each and every
time they are on stage. They are their flags." febus
58. Yes Relayer Sound Chaser

1035.2 points Appears 6 times Mean rank: 122 Ranked highest by DDPascalDD (#29)
"Sound Chaser ratchets up the energy and tension of the band's
sound to an even higher degree. Driven by Chris Squire's busy bass line, Howe
again gets both Rockabilly-on-smart pills solos and atmospheric moments...Complete
with a "cha cha cha" vocal interlude that makes perfect sense in
context, the song is indeed a road race in a sonic candy store. The newcomers
get a chance to stretch out also, and both more than keep stride with the
veterans." - Negoba
57. Genesis Wind & Wuthering Blood On The Rooftops

1056.3 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 48 Ranked highest by BunBun (#1)
"Blood on the Rooftops contains the most beautiful classical guitar
passages that Hackett ever created in Genesis' history: this time, Banks'
multi-keyboards behave perfectly, being but not feeling too abundant, just
creating the proper orchestral textures and moods for Hackett's guitar." -
Cesar Inca
56. Egg The Polite Force A Visit To Newport Hospital

1057.2 points Appears 5 times Mean rank: 97 Ranked highest by ALotOfBottle (#3)
"A Visit To Newport Hospital is a fantastic opening to the album.
Starting out with a Black Sabbath-esque intro on heavily overdriven organ. That
turns into a very smooth, beautiful, nostalgic piece telling about the times
back when Egg played with Steve Hillage in the late sixties, under the name
Uriel. A true sign of lyrical and musical genius from the trio. The track is
kept in a rather jazzy mood, but with a classical sense of musical structure
going through numerous passages and alterations of the theme." -
ALotOfBottle (#3)
55. Renaissance Scheherazade & Other Stories Trip To The Fair

1069.7 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 43 Ranked highest by Zwordser (#29)
"Trip to the Fair opens with beautiful, classical-style grand piano
and it totally caught me off guard. I'm not sure what I was expecting to hear,
exactly, but John Tout's virtuosity on the instrument is stunning. Soon Terence
Sullivan's drums and Jon Camp's bass join in along with what sounds like
operatic witch howls and cackles reverberating in the background. You'd expect
this combo to sound like early ELP but they bear no resemblance to that fabled
trio at all. They produce a unique atmosphere." Chicapah
54. King Crimson Lizard - Cirkus

1074.3 points Appears 5 times Mean rank: 84 Ranked highest by The Dark Elf (#34)
"With the outstanding drumming and brass, [Cirkus] makes for a
powerful opening, and the ominous dark current running through the song ties in
nicely with the feeling on many Crimson albums I've heard, an indescribable and
nagging unease. The outstanding production values must also be noted. Lizard
sounds fabulous with every instrument crisp as hell and with plenty of space
for them to lounge about, allowing the album to age far better than many
contemporaries." Finnforest
53. Colosseum Valentyne Suite Valentyne Suite

1096.1 points Appears 5 times Mean rank: 87 Ranked highest by Micky (#24)
"Focus should be on the "Valentyne Suite" as it is a
master-suite within the master-album. In it lies la crθme de la crθme of Colosseum,
being the most extraordinary piece of their entire discographic repertoire,
without a doubt." - Ricochet
52. King Crimson Larks Tongues In Aspic Larks Tongues In Aspic,
Pt. 2

1114.2 points Appears 5 times Mean rank: 78 Ranked highest by Zravkapt (#19)
"As Hunter S. once said, "Mother of Sweating Jesus!" Just
when ya think this is the perfect album, the band brings it all up to a new
level, and it's not just perfect, it's sublime. Listen to Fripp, Wetton, and
Bruford just pounding away. This is Heavy Metal as it was meant to be composed
and played. It's as if Fripp is issuing an ultimatum, "Screw Led Zep, screw
Black Sabbath, screw all pretenders now and forever, this is the standard
you'll have to meet from here on out!"" jammun
This motherf***er will wake you up in the morning, any day of the week.
Magnum Vaeltaja
51. Yes Tales From Topographic Oceans Ritual (Nous Sommes Du Soleil)

1122.4 points Appears 4 times Mean rank: 38 Ranked highest by DDPascalDD (#14)
"Ritual is a winner, this is Yes at its best, awesome Symphonic
Rock with full-blown Mellotron and synths, great melodies, superb tempo changes
and mood switches and Anderson performing in a confident and convincing way. I
don't know if this the best composition in here actually, but I love the sound
and arrangements, Squire's bass is awesome and White comes as a real monster
behind its kit with his propulsive drumming. And those soft atmospheres and
spiritual soundscapes changing with the emphatic, complex symphonicism is
mind-blowing to say the least." - apps79
|
when i was a kid a doller was worth ten dollers - now a doller couldnt even buy you fifty cents
|
 |
Saperlipopette!
Forum Senior Member
Joined: December 20 2010
Location: Tomorrowland
Status: Online
Points: 13357
|
Posted: September 08 2016 at 00:15 |
Nice! Wish I took notice of this while you were collecting lists, but I think the members have chosen plenty of fantastic tunes even without my contribution (besides I'm becoming less and less able to make all-time lists the older I get).
|
 |
mechanicalflattery
Forum Senior Member
Joined: August 08 2016
Location: Seattle
Status: Offline
Points: 1056
|
Posted: September 08 2016 at 08:45 |
The list is starting to get a little bit blander perhaps but good stuff in this round. I'm really surprised that Trip to the Fair beat Ashes Are Burning, although I love both so it doesn't really matter I suppose. Carpet Crawlers is probably a bit high but let's not nitpick. Only one I haven't heard is Blood on the Rooftops, which I will remedy right now.
|
 |
BunBun
Forum Senior Member
Joined: June 20 2014
Location: MN
Status: Offline
Points: 318
|
Posted: September 08 2016 at 08:48 |
mechanicalflattery wrote:
The list is starting to get a little bit blander perhaps but good stuff in this round. I'm really surprised that Trip to the Fair beat Ashes Are Burning, although I love both so it doesn't really matter I suppose. Carpet Crawlers is probably a bit high but let's not nitpick. Only one I haven't heard is Blood on the Rooftops, which I will remedy right now. |
Yes, you gotta listen to that ASAP!  In fact, I think Ill go listen to it now
|
 |
mechanicalflattery
Forum Senior Member
Joined: August 08 2016
Location: Seattle
Status: Offline
Points: 1056
|
Posted: September 08 2016 at 08:53 |
Phenomenal opening, Hackett is a legend. The rest is decent enough.
|
 |
Lewian
Prog Reviewer
Joined: August 09 2015
Location: Italy
Status: Offline
Points: 15654
|
Posted: September 08 2016 at 11:48 |
Some of these songs like Carpet Crawlers and Never Let Go are difficult to explain... the melody gets you or not and if it doesn't, it's all but hopeless to explain what makes them great. Something in some songs (including these two) resonates deeply with me, and nobody piling up arguments why they're overrated or what not will take this away from those who get the magic.
|
 |
ALotOfBottle
Prog Reviewer
Joined: February 17 2016
Location: Lublin, Poland
Status: Offline
Points: 1990
|
Posted: September 08 2016 at 12:33 |
So glad Egg's "Newport Hospital" made it so high - I'm glad people appreciate the piece together with me. Shoooshh.
|
Categories strain, crack and sometimes break, under their burden - step out of the space provided.
|
 |