Does Prog have an Uncanny Valley?

Does prog have an uncanny valley? The uncanny valley is the notion that an object such as a robot or computer animation that is almost but not quite human-like will evoke feelings of eeriness or revulsion more so than a corresponding object that is less human-like (or more human-like). I'm using the term loosely to describe a parallel notion whereby modern prog that sounds almost but not quite like classic prog may evoke revulsion compared to modern prog that makes little attempt to sound like classic prog. Do you find it irritating when modern prog attempts to recreate the sound of classic prog but for whatever reason doesn't quite sound like it is classic prog?

I personally don't think that prog has an uncanny valley. Although I may consider how close a particular modern album is to the classic sound, I don't judge the album on that criterion. But modern albums that sound similar to the classic sound may lack originality, and that does affect how I view the album, usually negatively.