Magma vs Caravan

pretty close race but in my view Caravan is undoubtedly superior

SuperMetro wrote: Caravan by a lot. How are you supposed to understand a band that makes their own language. I mean, it influenced me that any music even the great PFM and Banco were listenable. But, PFM and Banco are actually speaking a language, not this Kobian ehhh, whatever it is called. Caravan has more melodic music and feels more like rock music than chanting.

How are you at understanding purely instrumental music?

I mostly listen to albums/ works for the music, not for the lyrics. I listen to a lot of instrumental-only music and albums in languages I don't speak and I don't look up the meanings or translations, well, rarely.

Music itself is a kind of language I would say and I can "get" music, or come to own interpretation and appreciation at least, if I feel like I have some understanding of the idiom. What matters to me is that the music connects with me somehow, even if in a very abstract way. I was first into classical works without lyrics. By the way, my Kobaian is not too bad (know a lot of the words) but the language is more about the sound so I treat it like another instrument. And I love chants, and dissonant music, and non rock-music.

Mortte wrote: Really love both, but vote Magma because it has done better albums after seventies.

Really love both, but vote Magma because it has done better albums after seventies.

Too many difficult polls lately! 

gr8dane wrote: I have 35 Caravan songs on my I-Pod, 1 Magma.

The Question is whether you mean M.d.K. with one song or some other very long thing xD

I think Caravan is better but magma is still good

Caravan