Which 23 (ish) minute song is your favourite?

Supper's Ready

Can't believe this thread has gone on for more than six years and 'Gates of Delirium' has never even been mentioned ...

The first side of Thick as a Brick.

Because there are no Atom Heart Mother, I don´t give my vote.

Damn, I love Prog. These are all wonderful tracks!!!

Modrigue wrote: Where is Pink Floyd's Echoes ?

You're like the fourth person to mention Echoes in this thread.

On page three of this thread (posted almost eight years ago):

DisgruntledPorcupine wrote: idoownu wrote: Gah! No respect for Echoes - Pink Floyd! I mean, many floyd songs lose their initial push over time (not The Wall imo) but this one definatly does not, a mix of uber passionate artistry and ambient super indented music (I don't even know what that means so don't ask me) Echoes is 23:30, and I round up at the halfway point. Sorry, no exceptions.

I actually don't get why some people don't mention their favourite from the list and then say what their actual choice would be if it were listed, nor do I understand the expectation that some people have that something should be on the list. The "Where is..." questions irk me and often come off as complaining and in too many cases people ask questions without reading through a thread before asking (sometimes the question has already been answered).

----------------------------------------

Incidentally, too many threads are being bumped of late for my tastes with insubstantial commentary -- it's hard to carry on a discussion when lots of threads are bumped and can push down newer topics that people might have put lots of effort into. I think if one is to bump a thread, one should at least put some time and effort into the post, otherwise it can seem spammy.

Anyway, there are several that I love on the list, but I vote for "A Plague Of Lighthouse Keepers".


Edited by Logan - March 05 2018 at 11:52

Plague 

Nine Feet Underground... easily... with twenty seven feet to spare...