Rate Pink Floyd (since it’s all the rage)

Piper at the Gates of Dawn - ****
A Saucerful of Secrets - ***
More - ***1/2 (some great moments here , also some bad ones)
Ummagumma - *** Careful with that axe is one of their best moments ever. studio side is weird and      boring.
Atom Heart Mother - ****
Meddle - ****
Obscured By Clouds - ***1/2 
Dark Side of the Moon - ****
Wish You Were Here - ****
Animals - ***** (their peak)
The Wall - ****1/2
The Final Cut - ***1/2
A Momentary Lapse of Reason - ***
The Division Bell - *** (An ok album but my attention always wanders after some time)

Piper at the Gates of Dawn - *****
A Saucerful of Secrets - ***
More - ***
Ummagumma - *** (4 STARS LIVE, 2 STARS STUDIO)
Atom Heart Mother - ****
Meddle - ****1/2
Obscured By Clouds - **1/2 
Dark Side of the Moon - *****
Wish You Were Here - *****
Animals - *****
The Wall - *****
The Final Cut - *
A Momentary Lapse of Reason - ***
The Division Bell - ****

animals to the grave.the best concept album ever-then dark side and the wall just for the insanity aspects.

Oooh, I want to play! Unfortunately I don't have the entire studio back catalogue but for what it's worth, here is how I would rate the records I do have:

Meddle - 8/10 (Can I please resize Echoes to half of its length...? And while I am at it, get rid of Seamus? Having said that, One of These Days is truly great.) 

Obscured by Clouds- 8½/10 (An unassuming, charming record, with songs that flow well together. It's not all that ambitious perhaps but I still get more out of it than Meddle.)

Dark Side of the Moon- 9½/10 (I know it's hard to believe but I was a whopping 32 years of age before I heard this record for the first time -or even anything from it! I was of course aware of its existence and its significance in music history but it just never crossed my path in my childhood or my teens...not even on the radio, at least not to the extenct that I would have any memories or recollections of the music. And the funny thing is, I always had the impression that DSOTM was a 'strange' album, with 'difficult' music, probably because of the theme of the concept and the way people in the media talked about it. Well, when I finally heard it last year, I was slightly disappointed; it wasn't strange at all! lol Still, I quickly grew to love it and I will only reduce half a point due to the disruption of the flow of the record with Money and the overlong sequence of On the Run. Other than that, perfect.)

Wish You Were Here- 10/10 (This record was my introduction to the band, apart from Another Brick in the Wall part II, which I heard from time to time as a teenager. It was instant love and that love has not diminished one bit in these two years that I have had the pleasure to own it. The first time I listened to WYWH, I sat put on my sofa, as if frozen. I *knew* that I had bought something truly special. It really was something of a milestone in my relation and approach to music in general.)     

Animals- 9+/10 (Its bleakeness is what makes it such a powerful and engaging listening experience. By now Pink Floyd had become masters at putting across a certain mood and run with it. It took me awhile to get into this record but now I enjoy it from start to finish...well, apart for some overly streched bits in Dogs. )

The Wall- 9/10 (Right, another PF blockbuster which I had not heard until...two months ago! In some respects I actually count myself lucky as I have never had the possibility to play it to death, lol. I certainly played it a lot in the first three weeks since getting it and found it instantly accessible. Incidentally, the day after I bought it, I witnessed the reunion of the band at Live 8. Absolutely perfect timing. The Wall is a great blend of pure songs and musical ideas that help to hold the piece together. Ach, if only I had had this album in my teens, I would certainly have loved it even then... But as I said, at least I will never grow tired of it now. As an adult one learns to "pace" one's listening habits a bit better! )   

The Division Bell- 7/10 (So I bought it because I wanted to get a taste for the more recent Floyd stuff... And even though I can see how it tries to emulate the structure of WYWH in some ways and go back to that classic PF sound without really pulling it off, I can still enjoy bits of it here and there. Let's just say that it is one the (many) records I am prone to put on whenever my ears need a rest from pure, stellar prog. Ideal background music, really )