Author |
Topic Search Topic Options
|
beterdedthnred4
Forum Senior Member
Joined: March 28 2005
Status: Offline
Points: 225
|
Topic: THE WORD IS LIVE Posted: August 29 2005 at 23:09 |
I bought this the day it came out, and have been listening to it near continulously since then....I just love it!
The liner notes are a pleasure in and of themselves, but here are some
observations I'm using to entice you to bring 50 bucks to your nearest
cd emporium:
- "Then" sounds much meaner without the orchestra, but not necessarily better than the Time and A Word vers"ion.
- "For Everyone" has only been released in their early BBC
recordings cd, many of the pressings of which erroneously contain two
disc ones. As this was on disc two, I am hearing it for the first
time. To my infinite surprise the middle section would be turned into
Disillusion in Starship Trooper a year and a lineup change later.
- "Astral Traveller" was a minor classic of the Banks' era that I
found slightly overrated, but here you can feel the excitement of the
concert hall in this energetic warts and all rendition.
- On "Yours is No Discgrace" you feel like you are in your 10th row
seat as you watch Bruford and Squire make floor shake and Kaye rock the
organ like it was going out of style. It is very very different
from the version with Wakeman and White on Yessongs.
- This version of "All Good People" is perhaps the best I've ever
heard, especially due to Bruford's hyperactive drumming and Kaye's
increased organ presence.
- The live version of "America" is much less pristine and 4 minutes
longer, but just as satisfying as the Yesterdays version. The
biggest difference is more raunchy and bar band feel Kaye's dirty organ
gives the piece.
- The Moraz portion of the set is led off by a sinister
"Apocalypse" shorn from the "And You and I" suite that struggles to be
heard over the audience, not becuase it is a bootleg, but because the
audience is so loud.
- "Siberian Khatru" gets the Relayer treatment, with a fender
rhodes replacing the harpsichord and more up-front synths in the outro.
- "Soundchaser" speaks for itself as the most hyperactive and
complex piece in Yes' repotoire, and here Moraz and Howe fly by the
seat of their pants trying to outplay eachother.
- "Sweet Dreams" has sound quality of lesser quality than most of
the other songs on the second disc, and is very loose and different
than the original version. Unfortunately, Anderson's vocals get a
little off key towards the end.
- "Future Times/Rejoice" was my favorite song off of the underrated
Tormato, and they pull off a great version here that should have been
on Yesshows.
- "The Circus of Heaven" isn't that great, but it isn't as bad as
some make it out to be. Howe's guitar is as inventive as he ever
was and Squire's bass pattern at the end is addictively sinister as to
seem out of place.
- "The Big Medley" is worth the price of admission; 28 minutes of
pure bliss. An infinitely better version of Time and a Word
segues with a fast and complex version of Long Distance Run Around
where Wakeman rocks the synth rather than the pussy electric piano he
used on Yessongs. Then The Fish, The Ancient, and Survival mix
and come in and out of focus until the band breaks into Perpetual
Change with a vengeance. Finally, the outro of the battle
sequence and Soon are played, and you thank heaven once again for yes.
- "Hello Chicago" is a simple jam similar to the one before Ritual on Yesshows.
- The '78 version of Roundabout was as fast as raucus as this song
got, before the band found it necessary to take off a couple of minutes
or bastardize it into a blues shuffle (not bad on the Songs from
Tsongas dvd, just not my cup of tea).
- The '78 rendition of "Heart of the Sunrise" was much more
precise, yet less brutal than the one on Yessongs. I prefer the
Yessongs version due to pure shock value as you drive in a parking
garage with the, to quote eminem, "windows down and the system up".
- I always thought "Awaken"'s gentle waves of sound were more
suited for a studio environment, but this song does more than enough
justice to the piece.
- "Go Through This" appeared as a bonus track on the remastered
Drama, but here is much more with an actual vocal melody. It
strikes me as Yes' take on punk, but in the best possible way, with
Squire's bassline pumping up Madison Square Garden and Horn's quick
fire verses.
- "We Can Fly From Here" was written, but failed to appear on
Drama. It is more melodic in a Buggles sort of way than the other
Drama songs, but also includes interesting instrumental interplay.
- "Tempus Fugit" is brilliant: ass-kicking tight concise prog.
- The last tracks are okay versions of okay songs from the Big
Generator tour. I loved the version of Rhythm of Love on Songs
from Tsongas, but this one just seems flat. I don't really
appreciate the Rabin era that much, so I won't speak to sour those who
do. Lets just say that once I had "House of Yes," which has
versions of Hearts and Cinema, I've never played 90125.
Now go out and buy it!
|
 |
margaret
Forum Senior Member
Joined: May 29 2005
Status: Offline
Points: 139
|
Posted: August 29 2005 at 23:34 |
Nice breakdown, just got it today. Hasn't left the player except for a couple of VDGG songs earlier. Did you feel as I did, that the Tormato songs came off much better live than they did on the album (agree about Tormato being underrated, could have been one of Yes's great albums but for all the problems in studio). Hopefully this is but the first of several of these, would love to hear more of Tormato live, and would love to hear some more Tales live.
Enjoyed the C.P. version of Yours is No Disgrace more than the Yessongs version, figured I would have since I liked the German T.V. (71) version better as well. It's Love was a real treat as well. Another that really stood out was Go Through This from the Drama show. Thankfully I have a couple of hours in the car tomorrow to continue to digest this one  First impressions, a must have. The liner notes (all the 'testimonies') and the PICTURES! were just the icing on the cake. Get it now, got mine for a reduced price at F.Y.E. for $39.95 So far, worth every penny.
|
 |
beterdedthnred4
Forum Senior Member
Joined: March 28 2005
Status: Offline
Points: 225
|
Posted: August 29 2005 at 23:44 |
Wish list for the Volume Two that probably will never happen:
- South Side of the Sky with Moraz, when Gryphon was their
supporting act. Supposedly on the last couple dates of the tour,
both bands jammed to this song as the encore.
- I know many love to hate Tales, but I would love any of the 4
sides of that, especially Remembering with Moraz, which was played only
a couple times.
- To Be Over. One of my favorite Yes songs, a pure angelic
wall of sound, and I want to hear how the boys did it one stage.
I'd also like to hear the early versions of Awaken this lineup did.
- Arriving UFO, Release Release, or On the Silent Wings of Freedom,
the first two of which weren't played much due to their difficulty of
pulling off live, but they all supposedly sounded FANTASTIC and better
than their studio counterparts.
- Anything else from the Drama shows: I for one loved Drama,
and anything to help yes fans re-assess this hidden gem is fine by me.
|
 |
Eetu Pellonpaa
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: June 17 2005
Location: Finland
Status: Offline
Points: 4828
|
Posted: August 30 2005 at 00:35 |
Sounds like an interesting release! I'll have to check that out...
|
 |
gok22us
Forum Senior Member
Joined: March 19 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 219
|
Posted: August 30 2005 at 00:41 |
You know whats nuts? i found a Yes bootleg, and the sound quality is FAR superior to Yessongs.
i need to check out this boxset though.
|
 |
chopper
Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
Joined: July 13 2005
Location: Essex, UK
Status: Offline
Points: 20047
|
Posted: August 30 2005 at 07:53 |
That's for the info - am looking forward to getting it. Just need to persuade the wife that I really need another Yes box set.
|
 |
Chipiron
Forum Senior Member
Joined: April 05 2005
Location: Spain
Status: Offline
Points: 780
|
Posted: August 30 2005 at 08:09 |
|
 |
Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.