Inappropriate review?

Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic

M@X,
This is a mixture of review and sl*gging off another site/reviewer, so I'm not sure if it qualifies as appropriate, although maybe I'm being a bit oversensitive. I agree with Rafael regarding ELP and the album, though. Maybe you could e-mail him and ask him to resubmit without the invective?
 EMERSON LAKE & PALMER (ELP) - Welcome Back, My Friends ...
Review by Rafael In Rio @ 7:17:57 PM EST, 12/22/2004 

  —   Antes de qualquer coisa, minha banda favorita, segundo, esse disco contém versões allucinates de musicas como tarkus, por exemplo. Realmente, eu tenho lido alguns sites RIDÍCULOS, como GROUND AND SKY, sinceramente um animal pra comparar ange com marillion tem que ser muito filha da puta... Essa é a banda mais compentent do planeta, tocando musica alienigenas, musicas alucinantes, é muito muito bom...a qualidade da gravação é boa então, se você gosta de progressivo, bem vindo ao mundo de marlob... elp.
Firstly, my favourite band, secondly, this record contains hallucinatory versions of music such as "Tarkus", for example.  Really, I have read some RIDICULOUS sites, such as GROUND AND SKY, sincerely a creature has to be very much a daughter of a whore to compare ANGE with MARILLION...  This is the most compentent band on the planet, playing alien music, hallucinatory music, it is very very good... the quality of the writing is good so, if you like prog, welcome to the world of marlob... ELP.

Edited by Fitzcarraldo

Author	Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic
Fitzcarraldo Members Profile Send Private Message Find Members Posts Add to Buddy List Reviewer page Special Collaborator Honorary Collaborator Joined: April 30 2004 Location: United Kingdom Status: Offline Points: 1835	Topic: Inappropriate review? Posted: December 23 2004 at 10:02
	M@X, This is a mixture of review and slgging off another site/reviewer, so I'm not sure if it qualifies as appropriate, although maybe I'm being a bit oversensitive. I agree with Rafael regarding ELP and the album, though. Maybe you could e-mail him and ask him to resubmit without the invective? EMERSON LAKE & PALMER (ELP) - Welcome Back, My Friends ...* Review by Rafael In Rio @ 7:17:57 PM EST, 12/22/2004 — Antes de qualquer coisa, minha banda favorita, segundo, esse disco contém versões allucinates de musicas como tarkus, por exemplo. Realmente, eu tenho lido alguns sites RIDÍCULOS, como GROUND AND SKY, sinceramente um animal pra comparar ange com marillion tem que ser muito filha da puta... Essa é a banda mais compentent do planeta, tocando musica alienigenas, musicas alucinantes, é muito muito bom...a qualidade da gravação é boa então, se você gosta de progressivo, bem vindo ao mundo de marlob... elp. Firstly, my favourite band, secondly, this record contains hallucinatory versions of music such as "Tarkus", for example. Really, I have read some RIDICULOUS sites, such as GROUND AND SKY, sincerely a creature has to be very much a daughter of a whore to compare ANGE with MARILLION... This is the most compentent band on the planet, playing alien music, hallucinatory music, it is very very good... the quality of the writing is good so, if you like prog, welcome to the world of marlob... ELP. Edited by Fitzcarraldo