ERRORS THREAD Report Errors and Omissions Here - Progressive Rock Music Forum

^ Thanks, done.

Who are you and who am I to say we know the reason why... (D. Gilmour)

^ Thanks, I'll ask admins let it live or die.

Who are you and who am I to say we know the reason why... (D. Gilmour)

^ E&O Team : Thanks, done !

^ In fact it's 34:57 and 38:13, respectively !
It's good to know your maths Wink

E&O Team : Thanks, done !

Edited by Quinino - July 15 2016 at 06:13

^ Good question, I can just try starting to answer saying - it's because the artist (not the album) is classified that way, then all his works get the same tag.

Does this lead to strange situations ?
Yes it does, specially artists/bands with a career spanning somewhat different styles/genres, which then get all classified the same way.

Life is cruel Exclamation

Have fun and enjoy the music (excellent album, BTW) Big smile

Edited by Quinino - July 15 2016 at 08:53

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=51886

Why is it under Singles/EP? It's a regular studio album!

http://morier.bandcamp.com/

Quinino wrote:

^ Please notice that the category mentions also Fan Club/Promo besides Singles / EP...
A link would be helpful (bandcamp page doesn't add much, I'm afraid)

But I suspect you may be right Big smile

Bandcamp is their web site only, it is very strait forward album ONE, album TWO and NOWHERE does it say EP!

Just because no one is only 33 minutes and the other is 72 that doesn't make it EP if it doesn't say so and if it is longer then 30 minutes, unless the band calls it EP it's an album

^^I'll wait for Eugene, then, he's more experienced and surely will be willing to decide and make the move.
Thanks
Edit:
^ What if our friend who made the inclusion (and wrote the Bio) based himself, and reproduced, an initial error of Metal-Archives ?
It wouldn't be the first similar case, here or elsewhere, and at this moment I am more than suspicious of these chain mistakes.

Edited by Quinino - July 15 2016 at 11:16

carlmarx38 wrote:

ANDERSON / STOLT - Invention of KNowledge album is NOT "Prog Related" !

Seems very odd to me, shouldn't this album belong in "Symphonic Prog" or a related Prog Sub-Genre ?

I can quote you probably about a dozen reviews (a couple of them here on your own site) in which the album as referred to as one of the most "Yes-Sounding" releases in years. Obviously your decision to label it "Prog Related" prevents it from being included in the Album Polls. If that was your intention, I am just curious why you would deliberately try to exclude it from the other mainstream Prog releases in that section of your site. The 2016 Album Poll is one of the main places I go to, when checking for new releases, and your categorization of this album outside of any prog sub-genre, blocks it out from inclusion there.

If you're going to keep it out of your regular prog listings, maybe while you're at it, you should just re-

categorize the Flower Kings as "Prog Related" and not Prog !

just trying to keep this Anderson/Stolt issue fresh, because I don't know how long it takes for these things to get changed. My main reason for posting is because it's frustrating to not see this album listed under the listings for the "Best Prog Album of 2016" even though it is showing a healthy 4.16 / 5.0 with 60 ratings posted already.

Have the administrators ever considered including the "Prog Related" albums in the Album Polls ? That would solve my dilemma somewhat, even if the powers that be are unable to see that Anderson/Stolt is very much a "Symphonic Prog" outfit.

historian9 wrote:

^The symphonic team will be considering putting Anderson & Stolt as an separate artist, after that we'll see how it goes.

Thanks for your interest in addressing this.....while you're at it, any chance of addressing my other inquiry on including "Prog Related" bands/albums in the Polls (or of finding a new home for "Jon Anderson".....incidentally, your "Prog Related" Jon was just voted PROG GOD OF 2016 by Prog magazine) ? !!