ERRORS THREAD Report Errors and Omissions Here

http://www.progarchives.com/artist.asp?id=4349

Edited by NotAProghead - January 09 2016 at 11:38

NotAProghead wrote: Quinino wrote: Let me ask E&O team opinion before I do something foolish: The Wiki article on The Doors is so well documented (90 plus sources, including books & articles)  and so much detailed that I use its album credits for my personal DB, merely out of trust on its authors. Do you fancy me posting them here, attending I didn't go through all the sources to check the info and I dare to suppose you wouldn't too ? (Nevertheless I read some and always confirmed the accuracy of citations) Thanks I don't know whether it's worth the time and effort. In general it's a hell lot of a job - stereo and mono versions, 40th anniversary mixes, surround mixes, guest musicians.  If you'd like to do the job, please use only the info you can confirm. For example, Wiki article about the Doors debut album (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Doors_(album)) reads: Additional musicians Larry Knechtel (uncredited) – bass guitar on "Light My Fire", "Soul Kitchen", "Twentieth Century Fox", "Back Door Man", "I Looked At You" and "Take It as It Comes" Before adding this I prefer to know where this info is taken from. Another example, "Strange Days" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strange_Days_(album)): Jim Morrison – vocals, percussion, Moog synthesizer on track 1 Looks like a bullsh*t. Jim Morrison was whatever but a Moog player. I remember in his book "Light My Fire" Ray Manzarek wrote that they invited some guy with Moog to recording sessions, but because then, in 1967, Moog synths had no memory it was almost impossible to reproduce sounds the band liked. So very little of Moog was used for the album and Moog parts were not played by Jim. Thus, even if "the Wiki article on The Doors is so well documented", not all its points can be trusted.

Thanks for the feedback, insightful as always, that's why I keep bothering you
Now seriously, in the light of you comment gonna put this in the projects drawer (folder, these days) and see if the future brings the time and will to do it properly (some reading and research clearly needed).

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=7192

1. Aurore (5:42)
2. Camara (9:25)
3. Ma Vie Dégénère (2:58)
4. Daisy (7:04)
5. Jungle's Jingle (6:32)
6. Confluence (4:46)

Total time 36:27

Musea 2007 CD release Bonus Tracks recorded in 1980 for the never released 4th album

...
7. Rouge Champs (4:03)
8. ES Blues (4:23)
9. Open It Up (4:50)
10. Babylone (7:15)
11. Time Will Make It Better (6:19)

Total time 63:37



– Marius  "Mimi" Lorenzini / guitar, keyboards, vocals
– Ann Ballester /   keyboards, vocals
– Mireille Bauer /   vibraphone, marimba, percussion
– Francois Grillot / bass (1-6)
– Alain Gouillard / drums (1-6)
- Thierry Tamain / Fender Rhodes, clavinet (7-11)
- Emmanuel Binet / bass (7-11)
- Frank Raholison / drums (7-11)
- Fernand "Titi" Pena / vocals (7-11)

http://www.discogs.com/Edition-Sp%C3%A9ciale-Horizon-Digital/release/2927153

You'll have to also check the booklet to confirm it all (namely the keys)


Edited by NotAProghead - January 09 2016 at 17:06

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=1870

1. Promenade (1:57)
2. The Gnome (4:16)
3. Promenade (1:23)
4. The Sage (4:40)
5. The Old Castle (2:31)
6. Blues Variation (4:14)
7. Promenade (1:28)
8. The Hut Of Baba Yaga (1:12)
9. The Curse Of Baba Yaga (4:09)
10. The Hut Of Baba Yaga (1:06)
11. The Great Gates Of Kiev (6:27)
12. Nutrocker (4:33)

Total time 37:56

Bonus Track

13. Pictures At An Exhibition (15:28) *

Total time 53:24


- Keith Emerson / Hammond C3 & L100 organs, Moog synth, Harrison & Harrison pipe organ (1), clavinet (12)
- Greg Lake / vocals, bass, acoustic guitar (4)
- Carl Palmer / drums, chimes (11), percussion

1-12 Recorded live at Newcastle City Hall on 26 March 1971.

* Track 13 is from a partial studio re-recording with orchestra in 1993 (omitting The Old Castle,Blues Variation, The Curse of Baba Yaga & Nutrocker tracks) first released in the 1993 boxset "Return to the Manticore" and from then on as bonus track in several reeditions of the original live album.

http://www.discogs.com/Emerson-Lake-Palmer-Pictures-At-An-Exhibition/release/1562585

http://https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pictures_at_an_Exhibition_%28Emerson,_Lake_%26_Palmer_album%29#Personnel

http://https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keith_Emerson

And see the video & hear the record

E&O Team: Thanks, done.

Edited by NotAProghead - January 12 2016 at 12:08

Edited by NotAProghead - January 12 2016 at 12:50

With:
- Clare Lowther / cello (3)
- Bruce Lacey / noises from his mechanical machines (2)
- Kingsley Abbott / coins (4), backing vocals (11)
- Paul Ghosh / backing vocals (11)
- Andrew Horvitch / backing vocals (11)
- Marc Ellington / backing vocals (11)
- Pete Ross / harmonica (13)
 

Track 4 recorded Live at St Peter's church, Westbourne Grove.

Track 14 recorded Live for BBC Radio's Symonds On Sunday Show (9th February 1969).

 

Tricky one, you'll have to go through several sources to get it right: mandolin is doubtful; the fun credits coins & footsteps is up to you; the sitar can briefly but clearly be heard and RT explicitely acknowledges its use in an interview

 

http://archive.richardthompson-music.com/QAgeartunings.asp (the sitar situation, also on Wiki)

 

http://www.discogs.com/Fairport-Convention-What-We-Did-On-Our-Holidays/release/426151

 

http://www.discogs.com/Fairport-Convention-What-We-Did-On-Our-Holidays/release/5448270

E&O Team: Thanks, done.

If mandolin is doubtful, its absence is no less doubtful too, so I didn't delete it.

Edited by NotAProghead - January 12 2016 at 22:08

I have checked Manifesto from Rivendel and I haven´t seen it corrected . How long does it take the correction to be public?

http://www.progarchives.com/artist.asp?id=1519

BTW in french would be "Édition Spéciale" but the band name on the covers is always Edition Speciale, so we have to choose, halfway makes no sense

You don't agree?
Maybe I'm becoming too obssessed with this kind of precisions, you just let me know if it's the case, OK?


Edited by NotAProghead - January 12 2016 at 09:04

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=10074

Poor info display, should at least look like this, I suppose

Tracks listing of 2001 expanded/remastered release

1. Walk A While (3:59)
2. Doctor Of Physick (3:33)
3. Dirty Linen (4:12)
4. Sloth (9:14)
5. Sir Patrick Spens (3:30)
6. Flatback Caper (6:24)
7. Poor Will And The Jolly Hangman (5:31) *
8. Flowers Of The Forest (3:58)
9. Now Be Thankful (Mono) (2:24) *
10. Sir B. McKenzies Daughter's Lament For The 77th Mounted Lancers Retreat From The Straits Of Loch Knombe, In The Year Of Our Lord 1727, On The Occasion Of The Announcement Of Her Marriage To The Laird Of Kinleakie (2:52) *
11. Bonny Bunch Of Roses (10:48) *
12. Now Be Thankful (New Stereo Mix) (2:24) *

Total time 58:49

* Five non-consecutive bonus tracks

Track 7 was originally scheduled for inclusion on the original 1970 LP
Track 11 recorded at Gold Star Studios, Hollywood, CA, May 1970

http://www.discogs.com/Fairport-Convention-Full-House/release/480536


Edited by Quinino - March 18 2016 at 06:46

http://www.progarchives.com/album.asp?id=10186

Sh*tty inclusion; should look like this, I guess

1. The Chase (2:14)
2. Mellowing Grey (2:48)
3. Never Like This (2:17)
4. Me My Friend (2:01)
5. Variation On A Theme Of Hey Mr. Policeman (0:23)
6. Winter (2:25)
7. Old Songs, New Songs (4:17)
8. Variation On A Theme Of The Breeze (0:40)
9. Hey Mr. Policeman (3:13)
10. See Through Windows (3:43)
11. Variation On A Theme Of Me And My Friend (0:22)
12. Peace Of Mind (2:21)
13. Voyage (3:35)
14. The Breeze (2:50)
15. 3xTime (3:48)

Total time 36:57

Bonus Tracks (Pucka 2012 reissue; originally A/B single Sept 1967)

16. Scene Through The Eye Of A Lens (2:52)
17. Gypsy Woman (3:25)

Total time 43:14

- Roger Chapman / lead vocals, harmonica, tenor saxophone
- John 'Charlie' Whitney / lead & steel guitar
- Jim King / tenor & soprano saxophones, harmonica, vocals
- Rick Grech / bass, violin, cello, vocals
- Rob Townsend / drums, percussion

NOTE: Mellotron, trumpet, etc (uncredited)

http://www.discogs.com/Family-Music-In-A-Dolls-House/release/4678797

http://www.familybandstand.com/discography/albums/music-in-a-dolls-house#personnel
read the production notes under Trivia

http://www.familybandstand.com/discography/singles#8220scene-through-the-eye-of-a-lens-gypsy-woman8221

E&O Team: Thanks, done.



Edited by Quinino - March 18 2016 at 08:29