What are you Listening to Right Now? Febus XIII

Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version Translate Topic

 Catcher10 wrote:

 Mirror Image wrote:

 Catcher10 wrote:

^ I hear ya MI.....it took me awhile to semi-enjoy this album, along with H to the He to the Helium , they are the two I can listen to without pulling my hair out to PH vocals.

Very inventive and experimental music for sure...people complain about Geddy Lee, but PH is the pits.

From Permanent Waves through Hold Your Fire is when Lee's voice really sounded the best to me. I don't like early Rush and I don't like late Rush, but their middle period is just solid gold IMHO and Lee's vocal work is has much more more nuance, subtlety, and yet it still retained a passion that's just infectious. Peter Hammill has never been a taste I acquired and I certainly wouldn't want to waste any more of my own time trying to get into his vocals when I know I'll just never appreciate them.

Essentially for me in my musical life I grew up with Geddy Lee, so I never had any problems with his vocals. Now 99% of the flack he got was from Rolling Stone reviewers, and I never read RS, all the other rock, metal mags I read in my teen years never slammed Geddy...Now RS is trying to redeem themselves and trying to join the Rush party.

I understand about Hammill, but I pay little attention to his vocals, at least I try. Grant it I have made myself listen to those two albums, which I like....I have not tried others in serious.

Only the clueless would give a damn what the Rolling Stone said about a progressive rock band or, well, any rock band for that matter.  I've tried to tune Hammill out but it's certainly a difficult task. 