Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Dead Letter Circus - This Is The Warning CD (album) cover

THIS IS THE WARNING

Dead Letter Circus

 

Neo-Prog

3.59 | 47 ratings

From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Gallifrey
5 stars The Search For Big

The problem that most people seem to have with Dead Letter Circus' 2010 debut full length album, This Is The Warning, is that it seems to contain twelve tracks that are more or less the same thing. They're all insanely energetic, they're all insanely catchy, they all have the same sort of riffing and layering technique, using lashings of delay and reverb on the guitar that just sort of meanders, playing notes and little lines of its own as opposed to chords and riffs. They all have stellar drum performances and dynamic bass and they all have Kim Benzie utilizing his fantastic range at the top of his lungs.

And you know, for the first few months, I was a part of that wagon. This album does repeat itself a hell of a lot. It's not as if the melodies or riffs are repeated, it's just that all of them are dished up and served in the same method, making them appear awfully similar. I still get slightly confused. I hear the intro guitar of 'Reaction', and I could just as easily break into singing 'The Space On The Wall' or 'Walk', until the drum beat comes in and reminds me which track it is. But honestly, 28 listens to this album later and a year of memories behind it, I don't care.

I think the simple fact that this is a repetitive album and yet I can play it 28 times and still not get bored of it shows how incredible it is. When trying to justify this album, I'll often say, 'maybe it's just completely my thing', and I'd be correct, but not only that, the album does it in such a flawless way. In fact, the only track that really breaks the mould, the slower ballad track 'The Design' is probably my least favourite here, as much as I can enjoy its chorus hook. Without the energy of the other tracks, it just doesn't rank.

This album had been a long time coming, and I guess you could use that as reasoning behind why it's so damn good, but more often than not highly hyped and delayed albums fail to bring the goods. Dead Letter Circus had released three tracks more than a year before the release of this, 'Next In Line' and 'Reaction' on the Next in Line EP, and 'The Space on the Wall' as a single, but even those aren't nearly the best songs on here, DLC choosing to drop two of the best tracks, 'Big' and 'Cage' just before its release, creating the biggest hype you could imagine. Those two tracks are masterpieces in their own right, so to shorten this review a bit, I've written about them here and here, but there is still a lot more to say about this record.

I've found this is also one of those records that reveals something new each time, maybe because everything being similar smudges it into a blur, so that you don't notice the flourishes of genius until you're familiar with it. It was only a few days ago, over a year after I first heard it, when I realised just how incredible the final instrumental section of 'The Drum' is. Being a band led by a vocalist with such a skill for a great hook, the instrumental parts just sort of become background, especially when it's basically on the same massively intricate mode for 54 minutes. 'The Drum', the longest track on the album, starts with a brooding ambient intro, and it never really builds massively with the vocals. Usually DLC will use Benzie to create their energy, but here the build-up is all instrumental. Benzie pours over it with the atmospheric chorus 'The city is alive, help me to start over'' but as we finish, the song plummets into a fully instrumental section with pounding drums and fantastic sampled guitars everywhere, even starting to get a bit of a noise influence coming in.

I could easily talk for hours about particular moments of this record. I have already done so in my single reviews of Big and Cage, saving plenty of room here, but I don't want to get too tiring with the writing. 'This Long Hour' is probably the only other track I haven't talked about that deserves a mention, as well as opener 'Here We Divide'. One of the few complaints I have in this record, and it's a complaint I've mentioned about them previously, is the weak repetition of the verse during 'This Long Hour'. As a band who pride themselves on energy and keeping things moving, it feels a bit weak to just go and repeat the same verse with the same lyrics, but everything is forgiven when the chorus hits. This is one of the tracks that, due to Benzie's ridiculous voice, I never actually learnt the lyrics too for months, and found myself blurting aimless attempts at them as loud as I could, but that's just how ridiculously catchy this song is.

But there's one more song here that is the undisputed champion, reigning high above everything else this band have ever done, and I've mentioned this in my reviews of Big and Cage, their second and third best songs.

This is the big, enormous, album-wide version of The DLC Build-Up and Release Technique, although not necessarily the same. During Big, I mentioned that the final chorus is just so momentous because they already have an incredible song with incredible energy, and then they just top it, because it the world of Dead Letter Circus, nothing is ever big enough, it can always go bigger. I like to think of 'This Is The Warning' as an enormous, album-wide 'but what if we go bigger'.

Everything about the track, the laughable spoken word sample, the way the drums come in underneath Benzie's opening vocal, the build, the drum breakdown, especially the drum breakdown, all add to the best thing they've done. It's taken me a good twenty listens to finally be able to nail the drumming during the heavy section, which is entirely in 4/4, but it begins part way through a phrase making it sound like an 8 bar repeating pattern. It's the epitome of intensity, smashing a drum at seemingly random intervals, but after a while you realise there's a pretty clear pattern to the drums, which makes it so much better. But the final verse is what gets me. It's pretty similar to the final verse of Cage in that it's an insanely catchy line delivered with unparalleled intensity over a pounding and energetic rhythm section, but this one knocks Cage off the table.

'They've got it all worked out, wish I could leave here now, is there another way, some other path to take? We will figure out, same people brought us down, they are controlling you. These people lead us. I saw them change the truth; they didn't want me to, right there before our eyes. I knew we'd make it. Don't take the easy ride, we're running out of time.'

This is the warning.

SMASH SMASH SMASH SMASH SMASH SMASH SMASH SMASH SMASH SMASH SMASH SMA-SMASH SMASH

I realise how corny it is to simply quote the album when trying to review it, but I honestly don't think I can do this verse any more justice.

Yes, yes, of course This Is The Warning is samey, but after enough listens I've simply stopped caring, especially because this is one of the greatest melodic releases of this decade, and one of my favourite albums of all time. The melodies are epic, the instrumentals are tight, the energy is unfiltered and enormous, this is one of the best records I have ever come to know, and I can't recommend it enough.

9.2/10

Originally written for my Facebook page/blog: www.facebook.com/neoprogisbestprog

Gallifrey | 5/5 |

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Share this DEAD LETTER CIRCUS review

Social review comments () BETA







Review related links

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives