SI ON AVAIT BESOIN D'UNE CINQUIÈME SAISON

This is an album of immediately likeable, strongly melodic prog. I especially enjoyed the actual songs (as opposed to the final 17-minute instrumental track), which have folk-style vocals that remind me of the great Scottish singer John Martyn (who's also listed om Progarchives), only they're in a charming kind of French I was hitherto unfamiliar with. The compositions themselves are typical of early 1970s folk as well, with this major difference that you get lots of "symphonic prog" elements creeping in, such as dreamy twelve-string guitar arpeggios and majestic mellotron orchestrations. But the 17-minute "Histoires sans paroles" was a major let-down. It contains no captivating melodies, the band merely let one mediocre riff flow into another, some of the riffs (e.g. the waltz towards the end) go on for too long, and the solo playing (particularly the flute) sounds pedestrian.

I simply don't understand how this album could ever end up in our Top-Ten of best-loved Prog albums. Maybe things would have been different if I'd grown up with it, but as things stand I'd never rank it close behind SELLING ENGLAND or CLOSE TO THE EDGE. It also seems less accomplished and far less exciting than certain classic albums which find themselves a great deal lower in our Top-100, such as the best of Robert Wyatt, Gentle Giant or Gong. To make things worse, its sleeve design must be ranked among the greatest kitsch to have come out of the 1970s.

Social review comments

Review related links

• Send comments to fuxi
• Report this review (#260195)
• Buy HARMONIUM music online with PA partners
• Show all HARMONIUM MP3/Stream
• Go to HARMONIUM page for videos, full discography with ratings, reviews and much more
• Go to Si on avait besoin d'une cinquième saison page for more details, where to buy and ratings/reviews
• Search the Forum for HARMONIUM related discussions