ACTION REPLAY

These guys are in the folk/rock vein. This album is only the second ive heard..and ill have to say im not happy with what i hear....ita a live album in a sort of messy sound (the songs arent even that interesting...neither the playing!) and overall it feels like a waste of time....avoid this one...if you like folk/rock try Red Jasper´s " Anagramary" in which you can hear that thes guys actually CAN play. But of course..you could do even better, if you try out: Dando Shaft´s " Dando Shaft"...which is a classic! As is Trees:"on the shore" with beautiful female vocals and superp guitarplaying both electric and acoustic...but thats a hole nother review:

A great classic live album. Played a a furious pace, but with some sublety when required. It is rare that one can feel the energy in a live performance, but here you can almost smell the fastfret, and sense the fully live flavour.

Have to say that their studio efforts are a lot more accomplished, but this album was released at an early stage in the band's career, well worth seeking out

On 26th January 1992 Red Jasper took to the stage at the Fleece & Firkin in Bristol with the intention of recording the gig for posterity. This was the second time of asking as the equipment had failed during the originally planned recording at the end of 1991, so this was the 'action replay'. At this time the band didn't have a recording contract, although their previous release 'Sting In The Tale' had been well received, so they felt that a quick way to get more product out was to release a live set. The line-up had also changed, with Davey Dodds (vocals, mandolin etc), Robin Harrison (guitars) and DC (drums) being joined by bassist Jon Thornton. But they felt that they ought to expand the sound again (previously having sax and keys etc), so roped in keyboard player Lloyd George (of Just) to guest for this night only.

The result is an album that has really stood the test of time and is still as lively and vibrant 20 years down the line as it was on that night. There was/is a very Englishness about this band that was matched by very few in the prog scene, and probably their only real contemporaries in the underground was Grace, but these guys really knew how to put the 'rock' into prog rock. The band have been compared to many others, but really they had no comparison. Of course people who haven't heard them do need a pag on which to hang their musical hat so to speak, so let's say that they had the folk and balls of Horslips, as well as the whistle and keyboards (and even perform 'The King Of The Fairies') yet at times come across as a metallic Jethro Tull. There is a venom in Davey's vocals that provide a harsh edge to proceedings; the folk/punk ethic combining strongly.

It is great that this album has now been made available on CD at long last. No bonus songs, but there is an incredibly well-written booklet''

Land fit for heroes

This reviewer is very happy indeed that Red Jasper's entire back catalogue has now been remastered and released on CD (and a brand new studio album in in the pipeline). The remastered series includes all four of the band's previous studio albums (with all the tracks from the 1989 EP Pull That Thumb (Off The Top Of Your Head) added as bonus tracks to the Sting In The Tale remaster) as well as this live album. Unfortunately, Action Replay is not very representative of the greatness of the band. This has everything to do with the fact that it was recorded very early in their career, before their masterpiece album A Midsummer Night's Dream that constituted the band's first mature release. Still, there are some hints here of what was to come.

The brilliant and distinctive lead vocals of Davey Dodds were already present here, as well as the lovely electric mandolins and tin whistles that makes the sound of Red Jasper so unique and wonderful. However, at this early stage in their career they still suffered from a certain do-it-yourself-mentality and slightly "punky" attitude. There is little of the refined subtlety, and nothing of the sonic excellence that would characterise A Midsummer Night's Dream and subsequent albums. The tasteful Neo-Prog sounds that would come to influence A Midsummer Night's Dream (and then go on to dominate Anagramary) had not yet made its mark on the band at this point.

Oddly, the majority of the songs on this live album never appeared on any studio album. This fact makes this album essential for hard core fans, but it detracts from the album's status as representative of the band (to say nothing of the best of the band). Surprisingly, only a couple of songs from their studio debut - the only album they had under their belts at the time of this live recording - appear here. Not one song performed here ended up on A Midsummer Night's Dream that was only a single year away at the time of this album's release. Interestingly, one of the songs later appeared on A Winter's Tale.

The best tracks here are Englands Green & Pleasant Land?, Second Coming, The Shaman's Song, and the traditional King Of The Fairies. These songs are indeed nothing short of brilliant, and these are also the ones that most strongly point toward the great future of the band. But the first three of these these songs are all available elsewhere in even better versions (studio versions). Overall, there are just too many throw-away songs here to make a solid live record.

Red Jasper is a very underrated and highly recommended band, but Action Replay is recommended primarily for fans and collectors. Beginners should check out the band's studio albums first, especially the fantastic duo of A Midsummer Night's Dream and A Winter's Tale.

The sole live album from Red Jasper is a fascinating document, since it doesn't quite reflect any particular phase of their studio work. Recorded in early 1992, after an attempt to record a late 1991 gig was foiled by technical difficulties. Given that we're dealing with a lean, hungry group here who hadn't achieved much in the way of commercial success, working with temperamental equipment, a caveat has to be added here: the sound quality of this isn't amazing. It's good enough that you can tell what they are playing and certainly better than bootleg quality, but you'd never mistake this for anything particularly pristine. Fortunately, the band at this stage were playing in a somewhat rough and ready style which can arguably be enhanced by slightly fuzzy recording quality, but at the same time it's a shame that the best live document we have of them pre-hiatus is a little murky in places.

Notably, Action Replay has only a light smattering of songs from the band's studio efforts. Specifically, Go For It and Come and By are from the England's Green and Pleasant Land demo album, England's Green and Pleasant Land is from the Pull That Thumb EP, and Old Jack, Second Coming, and The Magpie all come from the Sting In the Tale album. Add to that an early version of The Shamen's Song - eventually released on the Winter's Tale album - and you've only accounted for seven of the fifteen tracks here; the remaining eight are exclusive to this release.

Perhaps this reflects the way the band's evolution was continuing rapidly at this point in time - the product in part of significant line-up changes, with only frontman, whistle-blower, and mandolin wrangler Davey Dodds, lead guitarist Robin Harrison, and drummer Dave Clifford remaining from the Sting In the Tale lineup. Jonathan Thornton joined on bass and Lloyd George joined on keyboards, and the band simply did without a dedicated fiddle-player or saxophonist.

The early Red Jasper sound found the group bouncing between punk, folk rock, and neo-prog - imagine Jethro Tull infused with the more politically angry moments of early Marillion or Twelfth Night, then have a punk group play what you just imagined, and you might end up somewhere in the right ballpark. The harder edges of the group would fade away around this point in time, yielding a neoprog-folk mixture which would be showcased on their next studio albums, but the old style is still evident here and there on Action Replay.

It's notable, in fact, that the punkier songs - Hostage To Fortune, Go For It, and Come and Buy - are clustered towards the start (and two of those three are from their demo album), the band perhaps deciding to put their simpler material earlier in the setlist to prompt the audience to sit up and take notice. The progressive quotient starts gently increasing with World Turned Upside Down, a song named for an old-style broadside ballad from Civil War days (though lyrically it is original to Red Jasper), whilst by the end of the running order they are covering the odd folk standard like The King of the Fairies.

Listening, it's evident that there's been edits here and there to the album - some of Davey Dodds' between-song banter has been faded out here and there. This was presumably necessary to cram down the material to a CD running length, but it does mean that it's hard to assess whether this reflects the full setlist, either in terms of the balance of the material or the running order. The running order we get does capture the band in the process of saying farewell to their perhaps slightly unfocused past and pointing the way towards their future direction.

At the same time, it is a bit of a shame we don't get the full, uncut concert here, complete with between-songs patter, because it's evident from the snippets we get here that Davey Dodds was a fine frontman with a good rapport with his audience - comparable in that respect to Fish, to take an example from the same general scene that Dodds seems to have been at least somewhat influenced by in terms of his delivery. Indeed, shortly after this release Red Jasper would end up playing support to Fish himself - a good pairing, considering how the big man was working elements of Celtic folk into his own music at the time, whilst Red Jasper's approach to doing so had just the right mixture of similarities and differences to complement what he was doing without being overly derivative.

It was on the strength of this release that Red Jasper ended up signing with SI Music - first to distribute Action Replay, then to record some studio albums. Red Jasper were one of a clutch of UK groups of the era who'd release material through that Dutch label only for their hard work to become outright hard to track down in their home country in the wake of the label's collapse. Fortunately, the Angel Air label has rereleased the backbone of the Red Jasper discography, including this release, and listening to it in the present it's evident why SI chose to take on the group off the back of this one.

Whilst much of the SI stable ended up playing very straight-down-the-line neo-prog, Red Jasper were serving up something much more original here, and it's a shame that they've ended up one of the more overlooked groups of the UK prog scene - having the bad luck to rise too late to ride the original neo-prog wave and too early to get much of a boost from the coalescing online prog fanbase. The addition of traditional folk to a neo-prog ethos was as fresh in the early 1990s as the addition of folk ideas to a classic prog style was when Jethro Tull did it back in the 1970s, after all. A tip of the hat to Angel Air, for rescuing this gem and others from the vaults!