Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Bad Salad - Puzzled CD (album) cover


Bad Salad

Progressive Metal

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
Second Life Syndrome
4 stars What do you do after you release an incredible debut album? Well, Bad Salad has gone and done the correct thing: They've released a follow-up EP that will make sure we remember them while they write their next album. Yes, "Puzzled" is Bad Salad's EP follow- up to "Uncivilized", a really grower if I do say so myself.

Their style of progressive metal is back in full force, as we still get the incredibly complex guitar work, the awesome but never overbearing drums, the pulsating bass lines, and the ethereal and atmospheric keys. This time there is a bit more to the formula, however, as I feel these guys decided to experiment a little bit. Indeed, there are some spacey synth breaks, some islandic passages, and some awesome bass solos that really break through the wall of normal that most progressive metal bands usually decide to erect. Vocalist Denis is also part of this, as he is pretty darn dynamic. His voice is strong with a bit of rasp to it, and that is fine. There are no caterwaulings or pretentiously overbearing highs. In fact, I love this guy's voice, and it is so different than what I've heard.

I think this EP gets better with each track. It opens with the epic "Pain that Binds Us", which is as technical and metal as expected. Next, "Moonlight" reveals the softer, ballad side of the band with a beautifully executed melody. Lastly, "Deep Roots" wows. It is complex in its variety, and also very low key at points. There is nothing normal about it. They experiment, and I think they succeed.

But, now, I want to write a personal note to the band. Dear Bad Salad, Do not be afraid to try new things. I can tell that you did, and you probably wanted to even more. I know how notoriously picky metal fans can be, and how fearful of change and eclecticism they can be. Don't fear them. There are several points during the EP where I could tell certain aspects were held back a bit. At one point, there is some almost wild west style piano, but it gets lost in the mix. Now, I really enjoyed it, but I know metal fans that would think it is dumb. Don't be afraid to bring that to the forefront. That change---that willingness to evolve---is exactly what will keep you on my radar for a long time. That is the attitude that will keep you from becoming another Dream Theater. Sincerely, Jason.

Hold your breath. This small EP is BETTER than all of Dream Theater's new album. Yep. I hope the guys appreciate this comment because it's true. Bad Salad shows more energy and more willingness to experiment. I applaud these guys for an excellent showing, and I'm really looking forward to their next full album.

Report this review (#1072093)
Posted Monday, November 4, 2013 | Review Permalink
5 stars This is actually first music I ever tried buying from I-Tunes. But then I realized that I never bothered not only to remember the password (which is easily recoverable), but username as well. So, this shows that even though I may not necessarily love bad salad (and who does?), at least I am interested in them as a band.

This 3-song EP follows quickly in the footsteps of their debut album. Yes, Bad Salad are Dream Theater worshipers, but clone the good things and will appeal to those nostalgic for old DT sound before they became stale and boring - very long, but catchy and high-energy songs with diverse parts, moods and lengthy unpredictable instrumental jams, giving everybody a chance to shine. Its also funny how nowadays bands commanding million-dollar budgets can suck at production, but DIY-groups are able to create a balanced sound very pleasant to the ears.

Even if this were a LP, but only those songs were keepers, it would still be an album deserving my well-earned cash. Pity they haven't been heard from since.

Report this review (#1074248)
Posted Friday, November 8, 2013 | Review Permalink

BAD SALAD Puzzled ratings only

chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of BAD SALAD Puzzled

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives