Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Jack O' The Clock - Repetitions of the Old City - II CD (album) cover

REPETITIONS OF THE OLD CITY - II

Jack O' The Clock

Prog Folk


From Progarchives.com, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
BrufordFreak
COLLABORATOR
Honorary Collaborator
4 stars The busy and genius mind of Damon Waitkus and friends follows up the late 2016 release with a new masterpiece of unusual "Prog Folk." This may be my favorite Jack O' The Clock release with some truly memorable songs and the usual level of high quality composition, performance, and recording exceeding all previous levels. My one complaint of Damon's work remains the often "closed" or impenetrable nature of his lyrics due to the extremely personal nature of the subject matter of his stories.

THE BLIZZARD 1. "Damascus Gate" (2:20) a dream-like weave of electric, acoustic, and field recording sounds within which an effected collection of voices is warbling the preface of the story that follows. "What do you remember?" The Blizzard of 1978 must have burned some powerful memories into Mr. Waitkus. (4.5/5)

2. "Miracle Car Wash, 1978" (13:41) a mercurial musical journey used to take us through a chunk of Damon's recounting of a snow storm, the masterfully composed and rendered music, unfortunately, makes the most sense to it's composer, often leaving us out on a lurch, wondering "Why this twist?" "Why this turn?" (8.5/10)

3. "Island Time" (5:26) a song that stands out for it's totally different stylistic approach--both constructively and vocally--from any previous Jack O' The Clock song I've ever heard. The male vocal performance here is amazing. (Damon performing in a more choir-classical style?) (9.5/10)

4. "Errol at Twenty-Three" (3:58) Damon and a guzheng open this as the story of the Blizzard of 1978 continues. Multiple voices join in with several other folk instruments and percussives in a theatric/stage-like fashion. I imagine a stage performance of this song with costumes and fast-moving sets while the music is played from an orchestra pit below. Gorgeous, complex, genius, worthy of a Tony nomination! (9.5/10)

5. "Whiteout" (1:10) a multi-track looping of voices, percussives and electric instruments. Not sure how this concludes the blizzard story. (4/5)

INTERLUDE 6. "Guru On the Road" (5:51) A percussion-led instrumental with lots of string and wind/woodwind instruments playing into the weave. Not unlike a Markus Pajakkala (UTOPIANISTI) song. Beautiful! Even the inclusion of the laugh and studio end comment, "That's such a wild card." (9/10)

ARTIFACTS OF LOVE AND ISOLATION 7. "My Room Before Sleep" (2:10) Damon duet with a hammered dulcimer. (9/10)

8. "Into the Fireplace" (6:55) opens with "tuning" strings and winds before bursting into a thick, heavy, proggy weave at 0:45. What a delicious surprise! The singing versus return to the more sparsely orchestrated opening theme, but the thick wall of sound reappears with enough frequency to keep me on edge. the complexity of the overall weave of many instruments (and many voices) is also quite impressive, engaging, and beautiful. What a masterpiece of composition and collaboration! (10/10)

9. "Unger Reminisces" (1:27) a dreamy soundscape with commensurately dreamy effected vocals from multiple tracks of Damon. (5/5)

10. "I'm Afraid of Fucking the Whole Thing Up" (5:47) a strangely out-of-place story of an insecure, underconfident youth being told to do something useful--like going downtown to get a job. For a while I thought this second half of the album was the continuation of the Blizzard story. Musically this is more straightforward folk rock with a bluegrassy jazziness to it. (8.5/10)

11. "Double Door" (1:32) odd cacophony of instruments, voices, and field recordings. To what purpose? (3/5)

12. "A Sick Boy" (9:44) a song that has trouble hooking us both musically and lyrically--the story, and its accompanying music, are just not that engaging--are too personally projected from Damon's memories. If this is a concept album, then this is a disappointing lowpoint on which to end the album. Too bad! (8/10)

4.5 stars; a near-masterpiece of jazzy progressive folk music; masterful songwriting and performances that somehow keep the listener at an arm's length due to the highly personal nature of the stories they represent. What an awesome display of collaboration from a large and wide variety of instrumentalists in some quite complex compositions!

Report this review (#2024123)
Posted Tuesday, September 11, 2018 | Review Permalink
Mellotron Storm
PROG REVIEWER
4 stars 4.5 stars. JACK O' THE CLOCK had an incredible three album run beginning with 2014's "Night Loops" followed by 2016's "Repetitions Of The Old City I" and this one 2018's "Repetitions Of The Old City II". In my opinion these three albums will tell you everything you need to know about this band led by Damon Waitkus the composer, singer and producer. We get the core seven piece band along with five guests and as usual so many instruments are involved in the making of this record. It's so unusual for a band to have it's two main group of fans come from the Folk and Avant sub genres as these two are usually far apart from one another. Damon is onto something here.

This particular album is broken really into two sections, the first five songs deal with the blizzard of '78 while the final six tracks seem to be random pieces under the sub title of "Artifacts Of Love And Isolation". In between we get the "Interlude" track called "Guru On The Road" which is different, in fact when the track ends we hear laughter and a comment about it being the wildcard and I guess it is in a sense as the stand alone piece.

I can sure relate to any music about a blizzard living here in Canada. I have so many stories but really it's being on the road in a blizzard that takes the cake. You can't possibly turn around let alone pull over but just hope and pray you don't get into an accident. I did rear end a car once that was stopped dead on the road because they couldn't see anything. Neither could I. Beyond stressful. So the music on the closer to this section "Whiteout" seems so appropriate with that haunting atmosphere and samples, but then the opener also touches on these things and it's called "Damascus Gate".

The longest track on the album is "Miracle car Wash, 1978" at over 13 1/2 minutes. It's all over the place but well done with even a jazzy section. "Island Time" I believe is sung by the female bassoon player and it is different from anything I've heard this band do. I like it, there's something about it. "Errol At Twenty- Three" is something special, the way the vocals and mandolin are so in tune with each other to start. Just a wonder really when I hear this then it becomes fuller and so interesting.

"Double Door" is two guys talking and swearing as they do. They speed up that last comment which makes me laugh every time. An avant piece for sure. Love the strings. "Unger Reminisces" reminds me of GENESIS surprisingly. Beautiful is the word. Thankyou! I was also surprised to be reminded of GENTLE GIANT to start "Into The Fireplace" then it kicks into a heavy groove with piano, vocal harmonies and the bass and drums are great too. Back to that folky violin led piece but with vocals this time. Themes are repeated. So good.

And this album is so good, darn near a five star rating but as it is I am so glad I own it. How can something that often sounds so simple be so complex. The arrangements never fail to impress when Damon Waitkus is involved. There's a reason Fred Frith goes on and on about this band.

Report this review (#2964599)
Posted Thursday, October 26, 2023 | Review Permalink

JACK O' THE CLOCK Repetitions of the Old City - II ratings only


chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of JACK O' THE CLOCK Repetitions of the Old City - II


You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.

MEMBERS LOGIN ZONE

As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: JazzMusicArchives.com — jazz music reviews and archives | MetalMusicArchives.com — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.