Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Deerhoof - Milk Man CD (album) cover



Crossover Prog

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Bookmark and Share
4 stars Pretty good album, and pretty odd for the 2004 release by the Indie/Crossover Prog band Deerhoof.

In my opinion, this is one of Deerhoof's best and highest-quality albums. Lets get to the review:

Milkman: One of my favorite songs on this album. It starts with a good bassline and then gets going on the main riff for most of the piece. Good track. 4/5

Giga Dance: I really enjoy this track quite a bit. It is very odd and has intresting drums for the song. The I would even go as far as to say that the beginning sounds like a metal song even though very unusual. Great track! 4/5

Disaperecere: It's okay, but I would not listen to it often. It just seems a little uninspired with the soft piano for the rest of the album. 3/5

Rainbow Sillouette of the Milky Rain: Very good track. I listen to this song a lot when I listen to Deerhoof. It starts out as very loud and abrupt, until it gets to softer and more dynamic portions. It has an intresting stop go stop go theme to it. 4/5

Dog on the Sidewalk: Boring track. It just makes a bunch of ambient electronic sounds. It doesn't even sound like a bridge to C, just a filler. 1/5

C: Okay song, just a little boring for me. It just doesn't seem like a very strong track. 2/5

MIlking: Best song on the album. It really is a strong track, beginning with the drums again. It could actually be considered a metal song, even for Deerhoof. Very good prog song. 5/5

Dream Wanderer's Tune: Very light song after Milking. It is a good transitional song. 3/5

Song of Sorn: Very intresting Indie song. It starts out with paino sounds, and then goes into an odd rock song. It's pretty good. 3/5

Big Orange Sun Run Over Speed Light: Average Deerhoof song. Nothing too special. 2/5

New Sneakers: Okay ending, but pretty average too. 2/5

Overall, this captures the height of Deerhoof's career in their music. I think they are definitely one of the best indie rock bands out there. Album rating: 4/5

Report this review (#187604)
Posted Saturday, November 1, 2008 | Review Permalink
2 stars I was not really thrilled (to say the least) with ''Deerhoof'' production so far (this is my fourth review from their work).

The first major problem being the song writing and the second one is definitely the role as a lead singer from Satomi Matsuzaki who has been quite disastrous. Needless to say that the very short length of their albums so far is another of the weak ingredients (although I was quite keen on their short works bearing in mind the weak level).

This album shows some better stuff though. No grandiose tracks, but some decent ones like ''Giga Dance''. Their global style is not much different than in previous release and might be of the likeness of some ''avant-garde'' freaks, but I have never been one of those.

Most of the time (''Desapareceré''), the music is too loose, without direction. The nadir being the sometimes punkish like during ''Rainbow Silhouette''. There is really no wonder to expect form this album. The band is very confidential because his music is very confidential and unlikely bound to appeal the masses.

There are truly unbearable tracks in here (''Dog On The Sidewalk'') and I am quite uncomfortable with their inclusion on this site. Anyway, there are so few reviews for this band that I am quite comforted with my opinion. This is below average experimental music, no more.

Tracks are a bit more achieved this time: a bit more lengthy than usual (three minutes average instead of two or so, although the last four tracks are quite short) but there is little new under the blood red sky. No passion, no feeling and no originality.

''Milk Man'' won't propel this band in the Walhalla of prog music, that's for sure. Slightly better than their earlier works. two stars is my maximum rating for such an album.

Report this review (#214529)
Posted Saturday, May 9, 2009 | Review Permalink

DEERHOOF Milk Man ratings only

chronological order | showing rating only

Post a review of DEERHOOF Milk Man

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives