Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography



Crossover Prog

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Deerhoof Milk Man album cover
3.30 | 16 ratings | 2 reviews | 31% 5 stars

Write a review

from partners
Studio Album, released in 2004

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. Milk Man (4:23)
2. Giga Dance (2:58)
3. Desapareceré (4:07)
4. Rainbow Silhouette of the Milky Rain (4:16)
5. Dog on the Sidewalk (1:13)
6. C (4:00)
7. Milking (3:36)
8. Dream Wanderer's Tune (2:19)
9. Song of Sorn (2:25)
10. That Big Orange Sun Run Over Speed Light (2:02)
11. New Sneakers (2:14)

Line-up / Musicians

- Chris Cohen / guitars
- John Dieterich / guitars
- Satomi Matsuzaki / vocals, bass
- Greg Saunier / drums, vocals

Releases information

Kill Rock Stars / 5 Rue Christine / ATP Recordings

Thanks to burritounit for the addition
Edit this entry

Buy DEERHOOF Milk Man Music

DEERHOOF Milk Man ratings distribution

(16 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(31%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(44%)
Good, but non-essential (19%)
Collectors/fans only (6%)
Poor. Only for completionists (0%)

DEERHOOF Milk Man reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by ZowieZiggy
2 stars I was not really thrilled (to say the least) with ''Deerhoof'' production so far (this is my fourth review from their work).

The first major problem being the song writing and the second one is definitely the role as a lead singer from Satomi Matsuzaki who has been quite disastrous. Needless to say that the very short length of their albums so far is another of the weak ingredients (although I was quite keen on their short works bearing in mind the weak level).

This album shows some better stuff though. No grandiose tracks, but some decent ones like ''Giga Dance''. Their global style is not much different than in previous release and might be of the likeness of some ''avant-garde'' freaks, but I have never been one of those.

Most of the time (''Desapareceré''), the music is too loose, without direction. The nadir being the sometimes punkish like during ''Rainbow Silhouette''. There is really no wonder to expect form this album. The band is very confidential because his music is very confidential and unlikely bound to appeal the masses.

There are truly unbearable tracks in here (''Dog On The Sidewalk'') and I am quite uncomfortable with their inclusion on this site. Anyway, there are so few reviews for this band that I am quite comforted with my opinion. This is below average experimental music, no more.

Tracks are a bit more achieved this time: a bit more lengthy than usual (three minutes average instead of two or so, although the last four tracks are quite short) but there is little new under the blood red sky. No passion, no feeling and no originality.

''Milk Man'' won't propel this band in the Walhalla of prog music, that's for sure. Slightly better than their earlier works. two stars is my maximum rating for such an album.

Review by Necrotica
4 stars Ever since their inception, Deerhoof have always had the unique ability of combining a whimsical atmosphere with strong punk and noise rock leanings. The way they could switch from one mode to another at the flick of the wrist gave them both an incredibly loyal cult following and a lot of indie cred, but their influence is not just limited to that either. Radiohead, St. Vincent, Foo Fighters, and a whole slew of other musicians have been either influenced by or appreciative of Deerhoof's work, putting them in that King's X-esque category of "bands who aren't mainstream, but influenced the bands who are in the mainstream." On top of that, despite the band's penchant for noisy songs, they're just so easy to listen to! Fast punchy riffs, catchy melodies and lyrics, and short runtimes are the mainstays of the majority of their records; in fact, I'd say the only real idiosyncrasy of the band comes in the form of lead singer and bassist Satomi Matsuzaki. Her high-pitched, childlike vocal delivery is a huge driving force in the band's compelling weirdness - as are the lyrics, of course. So, with this clash of the benign and harsh, I suppose it comes as no surprise that the band eventually released a concept album with the whole "twisted fairytale" approach. In this case, the album is Milkman and the malicious character is the one who bears the same name.

The central conceit of Milkman's tale is that of the titular character seeming innocent and friendly until he starts kidnapping people and trapping them in his lair. There's not much more to say about the story than that, but Deerhoof work off this concept beautifully. Every hard-rocking number sounds so ramshackled and loose that you'd swear the band's instruments were gonna fall apart at any point; just listen to the garage-like drumming of "Giga Dance" or the relentless distorted single-note riffs of the opening title track. But the band never do let that happen, as the softer and more wondrous moments balance them out at just the right moments for a good sense of contrast. Just when that title track threatens to get too loud or too raucous, the verses immediately bring the volume down to soften the blow; they somehow sound both sinister and sweet at the same time. And some songs are just flat-out gorgeous; "Dream Wanderer's Tune" hosts a dizzying array of layered synths and a slow dreamlike tempo, making you feel as if you're literally floating on a cloud as you listen. But even the softer moments maintain a strange dissonance, whether it be some atonal piano chords that populate the electronic beats of "Desaparecere" or even "Dream Wanderer Tune"'s melancholic second half. Basically, the premise of this album in a musical sense is that much of the record sounds comforting, but also just uncomfortable enough that you're always on edge for the next bizarre motif or riff to rear its head.

Honestly, that seems fitting for a concept in which you're trapped in a place that seems inviting. That twisted kind of juxtaposition is communicated well by the music, and once in a while you'll get songs like "Milking" or "Song of Sorn" which merge both the loveliest and darkest elements of the album into a single strange-yet-compelling mixture. Especially noteworthy is the former track, which is perhaps the best song of the entire record. It pretty much captures an entire summary of Deerhoof's storied career into a single song; abrasive, noisy rock passages, a high-energy punk motif, a whimsical bridge, and lots of dynamic and rhythmic variety to top it off. But luckily, the rest of the album doesn't fall far behind. Really, the only track that could have been left off the record is "Dog on the Sidewalk," which is just a pointless afterthought of glitchy effects and boring vocals; at only a minute and a half, it just feels tacked on. But that's really about it as far as "afterthoughts" go, with everything else fitting neatly with the album's fascinating - if creepy - themes. Deerhoof always deserved more than to just be a band for the indie hipsters to enjoy, so make this your first journey with them if you can. It's both a perfect place to start and a beautiful experience in its own right.

Latest members reviews

No review or rating for the moment | Submit a review

Post a review of DEERHOOF "Milk Man"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.