Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


Electric Sandwich


From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Electric Sandwich Electric Sandwich album cover
3.41 | 52 ratings | 9 reviews | 19% 5 stars

Good, but non-essential

Write a review

from partners
Studio Album, released in 1972

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. China (8:07)
2. Devil's Dream (6:20)
3. Nervous Creek (5:07)
4. It's No Use to Run (4:03)
5. I Want You (5:27)
6. Archie's Blues (4:55)
7. Material Darkness (5:04)
8. On My Mind (3:24)

Total Time 42:27

Bonus track on CD release:
9. China (single edit) (3:05)

Line-up / Musicians

- Jörg Ohlert / guitar, organ, keyboards
- Klaus Lormann / bass
- Jochen Carthaus / saxophone, harmonica
- Wolf Fabian / drum

Releases information

RR7051 Repertoire Records

Thanks to Philippe Blache for the addition
and to projeKct for the last updates
Edit this entry

Buy ELECTRIC SANDWICH Electric Sandwich Music

ELECTRIC SANDWICH Electric Sandwich ratings distribution

(52 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(19%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(46%)
Good, but non-essential (25%)
Collectors/fans only (10%)
Poor. Only for completionists (0%)

ELECTRIC SANDWICH Electric Sandwich reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by Prog-jester
3 stars Enjoyable and melodical Hard-Blues-Rock from Germany with English lyrics (good singer!) . Really not much Kraut here, and that's probably why I like it ;) Only the opener is Kraut/Space/Psych-related...

It has some LED ZEPPELIN ("Archie's Blues")/BLACK SABBATH-like bits, with good saxes solo (great "I want you" ballad) and this fine-sounding Hammond organ. Songs are well progressing with themes and moods changing frequently.ELECTRIC SANDWICH reminded me more of SPOOKY TOOTH, THIN LIZZY and TEN YEARS AFTER. Prog- related/Heavy Blues English bands - the same atmosphere and attitude. A good example for 70s Art Rock lovers and a good one for collectors too. 2.5 stars really, and also the version I have is of 9 songs (including GNIDROLOG-like "Material Darkness", "China"'s shortened version and simple rocky "On my Mind"). Recommended despite its obvious "collectors mainly" character

Review by Mellotron Storm
4 stars This album was released in 1971 and it really blends that Blues rock style with Jazz to amazing results. The guitarist adds a little organ and mellotron to this recording, but make no mistake this is a guitar / drum led album with some excellent sax added to the mix. Sadly the band broke up while working on their second record because the guitarist wanted to go into a more Jazz direction while the drummer wanted to go into a more Rock vein. This was recorded at Dieter Dirks famous studio in Germany of course.

"China" is simply pure Krautrock. It opens with a gong before we get this hypnotic, trippy beat while the psychedelic guitar does it's thing. Just a pleasure to listen to. Some chaos to end it. "Devil's Dream" has a 60's vibe in the intro and outro as the guitar cries out while vocals come and go. It gets jazzy 2 minutes in as sax, relentless bass and light drums take over. Great sound 4 minutes in when the guitar comes back. "Nervous Creek" rocks out pretty good. Vocals and drums lead the way. It changes to a jazzy flavour 3 minutes in. Love the guitar after 4 minutes as the intro melody comes back.

"It's No Use To Run" again kills me with the guitar. It just sounds so good that's all. Vocals come in as drums pound. Harmonica 1 1/2 minutes in. The guitar rips it up after 3 minutes. "I Want You" opens with guitar and harp. Cool sound. Drums and vocals take over. Ballad-like until sax and then some killer guitar arrive. Sax sounds great 3 minutes in. Some excellent bass and organ follow. Sax ends it. "Archie's Blues" is named after the lead singer. This is a straight up Blues track. The vocals and guitar are very much in that style. He says "Check this guitar boys" as the guitarist then makes his guitar cry the blues. "Material Darkness" opens with heavy bass, sax, guitar and drums. Really good sound to this part. Vocals a minute in. Check out the chunky bass after 1 1/2 minutes. Mellotron after 2 1/2 minutes. Nice. The tempo continues to change and it kicks back into gear after 4 minutes.

This was such a blast for me. A solid 4 stars !

Review by stefro
4 stars A one-off Krautrock gem, ELECTRIC SANDWICH's eponymously-titled debut - which proved to be their only full-length offering - is a rocking, jazzy, psychedelic treat. Combining elements of Neu!, Jane, Hendrix, Jefferson Airplane, Miles Davies and Embryo, the album kicks of in full-throttle mode with the pulsating, eight-minute-plus, driving kraut-psyche-blues epic 'China', and rarely lets up from then on, with Wolf Fabian's intense drumming driving the four-piece forward into hitherto uncharted psychdelic blues territory, complete with squawking sax, rumbling bass and screeching, angular guitar-sounds that all make for a heady, spacey-brew of styles and genre's. The similarities with Embryo(particularly their 'Rocksession' LP), are evident, but instead of being just another overlong jam band, ES manage to cook up a well-balanced blend of solid rock sounds and far-out cosmic crooning. Their failure(??), meant this was it, and considering the success of a whole host of similarly-themed Krautrock bands, it's hard to fathom why it all went so quiet. Brain Records excellent remastering job brings out their music in all it's far-out glory, and read the liner notes carefully(circa 2004), because, apparently, those Electric Sandwich boys are at it again, have reformed, played a few gigs, and now want to get another(very belated) LP out there. Who knows if it will actually happen, and who knows what it'll be like(this reviewer doesn't listen to any prog/Krautrock post 1977), but I imagine a few aficianado's will be waiting with breath baited. Despite their sadly truncated career, ES still managed to leave behind an eclectic and engergetic album filled with top-notch krautrock sounds and brimming with the stylistic invention that made the era of it's conception so fresh and exciting. Great stuff. STEFAN TURNER, LONDON, 2009
Review by Bonnek
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
2 stars Heavy rock album from Germany, rooted in 60s blues-rock, soul, brass-rock and on occasion a bit of jazz. It's overall enjoyable but can't escape an overwhelming sensation of deja-vu.

The album starts off with the best song 'China', an 8 minute jam-based instrumental with lots of percussion, entrancing psychedelica, bluesy guitars, noise experiments and hints of jazz. A strong kraut rock gem this one. Unfortunately, the album is schizoid in nature and after it's progressive opener, it mainly shifts to nice but pedestrian blues rock with those typical heavy soul/blues vocals of the 60s / early 70s (think Coverdale and Hughes in Deep Purple in 1974). On occasion the saxophone leads the band into a looser jazzy vibe that is mostly enjoyable. Examples are 'Nervous Creek', 'I want You' and 'Material Darkness'. But their stuffy 70s hardrock influences never go away for long, and on the closing 'On My Mind' they even sound like Steppenwolf.

'Electric Sandwich' is an album that's starts overwhelmingly with a state of the art krautrock jam, but it quickly strays from the path into 70s heavy rock cliches. Not bad at all, and a record that was probably right for its time, but it now sounds very old-school 70s rock with little that reminds of Prog. 2.5 stars, with 8 redeeming minutes of excellence.

Review by Guldbamsen
3 stars Split decision

I really dig music like this. Whilst drawing heavily on the late 60s vibe - incorporating both blues, jazz and hard rock into the tunes, there are moments such as the opening cut, that take you directly to Krautrock land. Just like previous reviewers have mentioned, there is indeed a shift after this one, and the sound is suddenly much more hippie rock mixed with blues than what one could expect from this wild and adventurous "genre".

China however starts out with a blast, and I just love the dirty gritty Santana like flavour it has. You get fuzzy wah wah guitar that ploughs through the airwaves like a regular pair of chewing gum scissors. It's so hazy and wobbly that everything around it transforms accordingly: the drums slow down to a heavy, yet highly sluggish beat. The bass shimmers like a black propulsive tarmac, and then these two rhythmic protagonists converge and are as one. Ornamenting this earthy foundation are the Latin inspired conga drums that add a wonderful flow to the track. This is how I'd imagine Santana would sound like after a bottle of scotch and a sheet of acid. It's rawkous, psychedelic, brutal and hazy like a dirty but highly seductive Ferrari off-roader. I would happily cross vast oceans to hear music like this.

Then the transformation steps in, and it's not that I have any complains about the music, but it seems rather sudden and uncalled for. I mean, if you want to make a Krautrock album, then by all means go right ahead - eat some wild berries and find an open field to trip out and jam, but if you feel slightly more into the whole notion of structured late 60s blues rock, then why don't stick with the program? I don't have any problems with multifaceted albums. Those that sport a new sound with every new track, and here I am not talking about the famous Exile on Main street by The Stones, that made it big because of this conundrum (because let's face it: We've all heard of albums more fluctuating in sound and scope than that;-), but those that implement all kinds of approaches, genres and instruments to make one big hefty pile of unadulterated musical gew. Electric Sandwich's sole outing doesn't sound like it made this distinction in sound on purpose, but rather because they changed their tastes, approach, brand of tea in the process of recording the album. Some kind of fluke.

The rest of the album, and especially the second track, is a smashing rendition of what made the end of the 60s vibrant and organic. It is a celebration of the blues rock merging with the harder edges of the guitar, although here spiced up with small snippets of jazz kindly submitted by the occasional saxophone. The guitars sound like melodic stairways to heaven with great big reverb and the solos to go with such things. Oh yes this is music for driving down south, and even the vocals reflect a distinctive southern charisma - it grips you by the coldness of your exceedingly technical prog heart and gives you pure emotion and warm thundering rock music. I find it to be a welcome antidote for when things turn too enigmatic and confusing, and it's as safe and well-known as the ringing bells from the ice-cream truck outside your window.

Personally I rate this album very highly, but I can't honestly give it more than a 3.5 rating on a progressive rock site, but to those of you who find such labels as prog, neo-metal, post-office-fusion and experimental salsa increasingly futile and besides the point of what music is and should be - you my friends should definitely try this on for size. It's pure soul and gasoline.

Review by Sean Trane
3 stars 3.5 stars really!!!

Sole album from a sax-singer dominated quartet band that was born out some jam sessions, ES is one of UFO that made Germany's early 70's scene so special that even such an obscure band can still be cited by an international magazine (RS in this case) over three decades later, and get a spot on an important Krautrock compilation. Signed in 72 by the legendary Brain label, their eponymous album was produced by the no-less legendary Dieter Dierks.

Indeed, the band's raw and relatively loose soundscape are reminiscent of Guru Guru's early works (the opening 8-mins China sounds like a track from GG's UFO album), but sometimes as well the excellent Out Of Focus (the 6-mins Devil's Dream) or some fuzzed-out heavy/rough blues rock ala Ten Years After (Nervous Creek). The flipside is centred on the same Carthaus- penned dominated psychy-blues standardier-song-formatted sonics. But overall the flipside doesn't match the A-side's material, despite being still quite charming to the proghead's eardrums.

The band would go on to promote their album (apparently a few radio broadcasts were done), even touring with Uriah Heep, but would fail to finish their second album due to the eternal "musical divergence" factor and broke up in 75, even if a last single would be released the following year, but it isn't included on the album's Brain reissue. Neither is their first single, which included a shorter version of China and the non-album track On My Mind. A bit of a shame, really. recommended anyway!!

Review by siLLy puPPy
4 stars Despite the wild name, this is one of the tamer Krautrock releases i've encountered. In fact i'm not sure if this is Krautrock at all with the exception of the fantastic first track 'China.' The rest of the album is more jazz-fusion with progressive blues rock. It kinda reminds me of what Cream might have sounded like if they continued on into the 70s and added some mellotron and saxophone. It makes me think of a hippie heavy psych band that suddenly went into jazz-fusion territory with some progressive surprises here and there.

These guys only put out one album before disbanding on account of their record company demanding they take on a jazzier sound. The album was a grower for me as upon first listening I only liked the first track and thought they sounded a little too derivative of any blues rock band of the day. The progressiveness is in the subtleties and I have to say that after repeated listens I like this a lot. I'm not sure if it's the remastering or what but the production is so crisp and clean and full that it sounds like it was recorded in modern times.

Review by Aussie-Byrd-Brother
SPECIAL COLLABORATOR Honorary Collaborator
4 stars German band Electric Sandwich's self-titled debut from 1972 appeared on the legendary Brain Records label and was produced by German rock notable Dieter Dierks, but any suggestions that it has connections to Krautrock are pretty much completely inaccurate. However, the terrific English language album has much to recommend about it, having far more in common with psychedelic, soul, blues, R&B and horn-based rock with a touch of jazz here and there, with traces of Hendrix, Ten Years After, Santana band, Nosferatu, Message and even Out of Focus popping up throughout.

Eight-minute opener `China' certainly comes the closest to the Krautrock tag, an acid-rock instrumental with stormy washes of drifting distortion, exotic percussion and Jörg Ohlert's fuzzy electric-guitar soloing. `Devil's Dream' is a smouldering vocal rocker (not a trace of an accent in sax/harmonica player Jochen Carthaus's voice, though!) with bluesy guitar soloing weaving around Wolf Fabian's nimble drumming throughout an extended lightly jazzy improvised middle, and just listen to the way the distorted sax melts and bleeds from about the 3:47 minute mark! Side one closer `Nervous Creek' then jumps between the frantic and mysterious passages of fellow German band Message's first two albums `The Dawn Anew is Coming' and `From Books and Dreams', but also adds in a splash of wild Hendrix-flavoured rock.

There's more bluesy rock on `It's No Use to Run' with a rough n' raspy vocal, spirited harmonica and plenty of slow-burn electric guitar licks, and `I Want You' is purring and dreamy with tougher bursts of relentless harder-edged guitars, tasty Out of Focus-like sax wafting and whirling Hammond organ. `Archie's Blues' is unsurprisingly a bluesy meander that's a real showcase for guitarist Ohlert and his killer strangled electric guitar slinging, and `Material Darkness' closes the album with drowsy chiming guitars and almost whispered vocals that are punctuated with dirty sax blasts, trickles of pristine Mellotron veils and Klaus Lormann's thick bass. It's definitely one of the more ambitious moments of the album, although it proves to be a little anti-climactic with not much in the way of a big ending.

The CD reissue includes a short infectious bonus track of exclusive 1973 single `On My Mind', a cool and confident pop/rocker with strident electric guitar around a raw lead vocal, as well as its b-side, a three minute remix/edit of the album opener `China'.

Although it's far too structured and `clean' to be considered a Krautrock album, `Electric Sandwich' is endlessly melodic with strong song-structures that still allows for plenty of jamming and improvised instrumentation that the talented young musicians deliver with exceptional skill. It's a damn shame that the band dissolved in the same year this album was released, but it's nice that their legacy is preserved with this one cracking bluesy psychedelic stunner.

Four stars.

Latest members reviews

2 stars I really wanted to vouch for this album. I discovered it because it was on the famous german Brain label (which has basically the who's who of krautrock and even Berlin school electronic music). As you'll get from other reviews, this is only krautrock for one song, the opening track China. It's ... (read more)

Report this review (#2632810) | Posted by mental_hygiene | Wednesday, November 10, 2021 | Review Permanlink

Post a review of ELECTRIC SANDWICH "Electric Sandwich"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives

Donate monthly and keep PA fast-loading and ad-free forever.