Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


Baby Whale

Prog Folk

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Baby Whale The Downhill Climb album cover
3.45 | 9 ratings | 2 reviews | 0% 5 stars

Write a review
from partners
Studio Album, released in 1973

Songs / Tracks Listing

1. The Old Man and the Sea (4:01)
2. The Downhill Climb / The Cuckoo's Nest (4:00)
3. Cornfields / The Cuckoo (7:37)
4. This Time (3:09)
5. Circles and Circuses (3:28)
6. Dependable Spokes (2:40)
7. Things are not Free (3:42)
8. Evening Song (3:52)
9. This Ain't my Life (4:16)
10. Cabin Town (5:17)
11. Easy Feeling (2:16)
12. The Strangler (4:25)

Total time: 48:43

Line-up / Musicians

- Anne Baker / vocals, guitars
- Steve Brooks / vocals, electric guitar
- Nick Barraclough / vocals, bass, harmonium
- Adrian Kendon / vocals, fiddle
- Brian Wren / fiddle
- Lindsey Scott / fiddle

Releases information

CD Kissing Spell KSCD931 UK (2002)

Recorded for DJM Records in 1973 but not officially released until 2002

Thanks to ClemofNazareth for the addition
Edit this entry

Buy BABY WHALE The Downhill Climb Music

Right Now on Ebay (logo)

More places to buy BABY WHALE music online Buy BABY WHALE & Prog Rock Digital Music online:

BABY WHALE The Downhill Climb ratings distribution

(9 ratings)
Essential: a masterpiece of progressive rock music(0%)
Excellent addition to any prog rock music collection(44%)
Good, but non-essential (33%)
Collectors/fans only (22%)
Poor. Only for completionists (0%)

BABY WHALE The Downhill Climb reviews

Showing all collaborators reviews and last reviews preview | Show all reviews/ratings

Collaborators/Experts Reviews

Review by ClemofNazareth
4 stars Here’s an album that hooked me from the very first strands, and even though it wanders wildly among several styles and genres throughout I can say happily that even as the last notes play out at the end I’m still pretty enchanted with these guys.

Baby Whale is one of those groups that would have a tough time making a go of things today, and come to think of it they never really made it when they were active back in the early seventies. But thanks to circumstance and some good connections the band managed to leave behind a fairly impressive résumé in addition to a very good album. According to various things I’ve read about them they managed to play live with some notable and varied acts, including Fairport Convention, Chuck Berry, Curved Air, MC5 and Mud (okay, I’ve never heard of Mud). I’ve also read they got their big break as far as a record label contract after appearing at the 1972 Edinburgh Festival (or maybe the Fringe, not sure), and also that Mike Oldfield’s sister Sally was briefly part of their lineup (although she does not appear on this album). The band’s genesis was a chance meeting of future BBC disc jockey Nick Barraclough and American Anne Baker in Cambridge in 1971. The two enlisted Toby Jug Band guitarist Steve Brooks, fiddle player Lindsey Scott, bassist Adrian Kendon and drummer Brian Wren - and Baby Whale was born.

These tracks come from a couple of recording sessions laid down in 1972 after the group was signed to the ill-fated DJM label. But the record wasn’t meant to be, as the label folded before it could be released. The band lived on for a couple of years with varying lineups before finally splintering, with Ms. Baker moving on to the late Pete Sayers’ country group, and later showing up with Barraclough in the soft-rock act Telephone Bill & the Smooth Operators. Most of the remaining members found work in various other Cambridge-area groups.

There are no fewer than three violinists appearing on this album at various times, along with a banjo and a few acoustic guitars, so you should be able to get a sense of the type of music the band played. In addition there are copious helpings of excellent vocal harmonies throughout, alternately calling to mind the best of the Byrds and Crosby, Stills & Nash. At least one of the violins has an electric pickup attached, giving the music an eerie and almost overwhelmingly sad tone at times. The electric violin and blend of British folk, country, bluegrass and West Coast acid folk combine to remind me an awful lot of any number of neo-country or early alt-country bands that came along a decade or more later: Green on Red, the Knitters, Cowboy Junkies, Clem Snide and even Tarkio (who begat the Decemberists). While Baby Whale came years before any of these guys, the similarities are remarkable.

But the band’s influence on the alt-country movement is doubtful since this record never saw the light of day until Kissing Spell stumbled upon it and released it in 2001. And what a great find!

The opening “Old Man and the Sea”, based on the Hemingway novella, is possibly the finest work on the album. Ms. Baker’s vocals wander into Sandy Denny territory at times, while the mournful violin provides substance and range where the rhythm section lacks that, focusing instead on a pretty simple meter and decidedly lazy folk feel. The next couple of tunes will be inescapably be tied to American country thanks to the violin, harmonica and banjo, this despite the fact they both include snippets of British folk standards (“The Cuckoo’s Nest” and “The Cuckoo”, the latter given a different spin thanks to dual violins instead of traditional cellos). But at the same time the heavy tempo and lumbering bass line give weight to the violin and the multi-part vocals flesh this out into a substantive folk number bordering on acid.

“This Time” combines bluegrass with almost ragtime vocals, and I’m not sure this one needed to be included on the album, while “Circles and Circuses” holds up with any number of female-fronted hippy folk tunes of that day. “Dependable Spokes” jumps headfirst into fast-tempo bluegrass with banjo and violins flailing about wildly and with abandon. Not the sort of thing many progressive music purists will cotton to, but I can imagine a whole lot of toothless Cajuns and Cumerlands hill folk would get off the porch and dance to this one.

The band does a passingly good America imitation on “Things are not Free”, and follows that up with a simple folk tune that is made endearing with great vocal harmonies and just the right touch of percussion to augment persistent banjo and acoustic guitar strumming on “Evening Song”. I do believe there is also a Jew’s harp twanging along in the background of this one as well.

The other track I say stands out is the ahead-of-its-time sounding “This Ain't my Life”, a borderline soft rock tune made better once again with whining violins and the kind of done-me-wrong female vocals that any number of country-rock bands would ‘discover’ nearly twenty years later. Think the Dixie Chicks singing an old Linda Ronstadt tune and you’ll get a bit of an idea.

“Cabin Town” and “Easy Feeling” are a couple more slow, acoustic country/folk tunes that don’t do much to either enhance or detract from the overall package, although again I’ll raise up the violin and Ms. Baker’s vocals as noteworthy.

Finally the album closes with a pure acoustic number, mostly guitar, and layered all over the place with great vocal harmonies. An understated tune but a great closing to a surprisingly strong album.

I’ll be the first to admit this music is not for everyone. Even many folk fans won’t take to it much, and those who are inclined to dismiss American country or bluegrass music out-of-hand should be warned off altogether. But if you want to get a listen to what an open-minded group of journeyman British musicians sound like backing a talented American woman with a pure-folk voice and an acoustic guitar strapped around her neck a few years before such things became mainstream, then this just might be for you. For me this is a solid four star effort and a great and unexpected find. Hopefully there are a few curious souls out there who give it a try and agree.


Review by GruvanDahlman
3 stars Baby Whale is an album I'll keep for the rest of my life. But that's not because of the music's concistency but rather due to part of the albums magnificent content. I feel the album is pulling somewhat in different directions. On one hand there's brilliant folk and folk-rock of the British isles (the first and last three songs) and then there's the middle section of about five or six songs more in the vein of american country styled folk. Now, I do like country folk. It's great but for me it does not mix well on an album. It disturbs me greatly when the magic of the british styled folk (which is a genre I really, and I mean really, love is interrupted by the country styled folk. There is plenty of room for adding elements of styles into the mix (as on the rather countrified but enjoyable Cornfileds, The cuckoo) but on this album it becomes overbearing, disturbing and quite unbearable. I guess hhe country elements grow too powerful on these. I usually skip the mid section when listenening to the album, which I do quite often.

In short I'd say that the purely british styled folk is brilliant stuff indeed. Magical, powerful and intriguing with great vocals and instrumentation. The mid section of the album I'd rather they'd kept away from the album. The reason for me giving three stars is based on this fact, that they kept it on the album and for me it is disrupting. Still, a great buy if you're into british folk of the 70's.

Latest members reviews

No review or rating for the moment | Submit a review

Post a review of BABY WHALE "The Downhill Climb"

You must be a forum member to post a review, please register here if you are not.


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives