HATS OFF GENTLEMEN IT'S ADEQUATE

I was blown away by the last album from HOGIA, 2023's 'The Light of Ancient Mistakes', as even though it was their seventh album it was a major step change in what had come before ? think the difference in Big Big Train after 'Bard'. But whereas the latter was due in no small part by the change in line-up, HOGIA is still the duo of Malcolm Galloway (lead guitar, synths) and Mark Gatland (bass guitar, additional guitars and synths) while they have again been joined by flautist Kathryn Thomas who has been there since the second album (although just one song this time) and guest singer Ethan Galloway (again just one song). The earlier albums demonstrated hints of what was to come, but it was only with the last one that everything really gelled and I am delighted to say that here we have more of the same.

With a band comprised of two true multi-instrumentalists, the ideas can be driven through as opposed to needing to explain them to others, and with Galloway also a well-known minimalist classical composer they have a very broad approach to their music. There are times when the syncopated runs are almost mathcore in the way they are attacked, others fall into almost symphonic prog, crossover is always present while they also mix in pop (especially Pet Shop Boys) and rock (David Byrne) and art rock. The result is an incredibly well performed and broad release which has a great deal going for it so one never knows quite what is going to happen next. They also release their music physically with detailed booklets containing lyrics and lots of glossy photographs, something not many independent artists do these days, sadly.

Also, we have a full explanation of some of the songs on the album, and the thinking behind the title itself. "Heisenberg's 1927 uncertainty principle overturned that perception. He showed that for the smallest objects we can detect, increasing the knowledge of one aspect of the particle decreases our knowledge of another aspect. This was most famously demonstrated for position and momentum. Although the uncertainty principle was discovered in relation to quite technical aspects relating to measurements of subatomic particles, I think it was part of an uncertainty revolution in human thought. We fundamentally cannot be certain about some aspects of the world around us. As physicists were overturning our assumptions about the nature of matter, Kurt Gödel showed in 1931 that any system of mathematics must have limitations. Psychology showed that our memories and self-perceptions can be wildly inaccurate. And the history of the 20th century is a testament to the dangers of trusting those who are blinded by certainty. Several historical events that combine quantum physics and inter-personal uncertainty are explored in the album. Two of these relate to Werner Heisenberg, the pioneer of the uncertainty principle, and a leader of the German nuclear programme. One focuses on his disputed conversation during the Second World War with his former mentor Niels Bohr. The second relates to Moe Berg, the American spy and former professional baseball player, who was sent to attend a lecture by Heisenberg, at which he was supposed to decide whether to assassinate him. Although quantum theory might seem obscure, academic, and at times almost ridiculous, it nevertheless provides some the most accurate predictions of experiments ever found in science."

If this doesn't capture the overblown thinking of classic prog what does? Yet the music is fresh and very much of today ? definitely worth investigating.

"Certainty" begins latently, ambient; a reverberating vocal imprinting an emotion, a lament with its haunting voice to launch this title. The synth rises and explodes in a second verse where the voice becomes expressive. The prog rock of today is there with reinforcements of catchy keyboards on this crescendo; the Marillionian finale with a terrible guitar solo that sends shivers down the spine. "Everything Changed" on a Steve WILSON ersatz with the vocal phrasing and the pregnant bass; the syncopated drums adding to the research on this incisive rock piece. The Hammond brings warmth while the guitar gives the melting fruitiness; bold and captivating with the air that sticks to the skin; everything changes even this dynamic sound. "The Ultraviolet Catastrophe" continues on the alternative rock air and its incisive guitar, on RUSH for a time then the heavy jazzy Latin air with the frenzied piano behind; A punchy instrumental that's a pleasant contrast. "Copenhagen" returns to a mid-tempo track, melancholy with an electro backdrop for the keyboard and deep bass. The synth riff evolves over Malcolm's voice, eyeing Jeff Buckley. The story of Niels's encounter with Werner is set against a backdrop of a deep, imposing riff. "Cause and Effect (But Not Necessarily in That Order)" is a jazzy rock ballad, with a PINEAPPLE THIEF-style pad; a jerky piano feel with the guitar jamming, like in the days when the joy of playing was emphasized. A new sound with the distinctive Hammond organ, forcing a blend of genres. The solemn, jovial, fresh yet brutal break, the crystalline piano solo à la Joe Jackson brings freshness to this innocuous instrumental, persevering in this new musical style.

"The Uncertainty Principle" begins latently metronomic, Philip Glass-esque, thanks to the driving piano and mysterious flute, before launching into a velvety guitar solo: sometimes I associate music with the execution of a dish. The story is about whether or not to kill a man to avoid thousands of deaths; the magnificent guitar solo between Gilmour and Rothery seals this formidable choice, Malcolm setting the scene with his inimitable and recognizable voice. The piece evolves into a frenzied crescendo of uncertainty, the flute emphasizing the futility of the situation; a hesitant outro with a final Gabriele-esque riff.

"Inside the Atom" is another instrumental with haunting piano, a hypnotic-minimalist variation in soporific progression; the enlightened, plaintive, joyful, melancholic-demonstrative guitar arrives, staging the life of the atom, a whole musical debate, for the moment, a captivating melancholy. yes, modern prog that feels good. "The Think Tank" à la 'Everything' brutal, playful, nervous; game theory or how to win a war with the least damage? An exploration with bass and keyboards predominant à la PORCUPINE TREE with a gripping phrasing and the right hellish rhythm. "One Word that Means The World (Arkhipov)" with a dark wave sound, memory of this officer who dared to say no and saved the world; a Marianne FAITHFULL, SIMPLE MINDS air on their first releases. Malcolm's guitar solo is the highlight of this schizoid title on acceptance or refusal. "Between Two Worlds" solemn piano arpeggio for the bloody rhyme on our destiny, let us remember that Malcolm is closely interested in everything that is physical for our destiny; in short, an intimate title that sends shivers down the spine, and not just in the machine. "Living with Uncertainty" is a soft bluesy, danceable groove, perfect for swaying, as the prog-rocker doesn't always have a cane at his fingertips. Ethan helps out with the vocals for this track, quickly launching into a superb Rothery-esque guitar solo, so you'll get the picture; a languid piece that leaves no room for doubt about its quality.

HATS OFF GENTLEMEN IT'S ADEQUATE dares to create a new kind of album with dynamic music and an avant- garde style, modern sounds that are changing the game of prog rock this decade. (4.5) .

Hats Off To The Uncertainty Principle

Another standout release of 2025, The Uncertainty Principle marks the eighth album by Hats Off Gentlemen It's Adequate (HOGIA), the British duo of Malcolm Galloway and Mark Gatland, joined once again by flautist Kathryn Thomas. This time, they deliver an adventurous, concept-driven record rooted in physics, exploring the strange and fascinating world of quantum mechanics.

The album takes direct inspiration from the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, which states that certain pairs of properties (like position and momentum) cannot be simultaneously measured with perfect accuracy. This idea of uncertainty and paradox isn't just reflected in the lyrics?it also shapes the album's structure and musical approach, creating an experience that shifts between accessibility and complexity.

Before the album's release, the band dropped the Between Two Worlds EP on January 29, 2025, featuring early versions of key tracks. That EP served as a preview of the musical direction taken here, blending progressive rock, ambient textures, and lyrical themes of scientific discovery and existential thought.

Musically, The Uncertainty Principle sits somewhere between the theatrical storytelling and vocals kind of Fish-era Marillion, the emotional depth of Pain of Salvation's recent work, and the textured, experimental side of King Crimson's 2000s output. The sound is immersive, balancing progressive rock elements with moments of soft metal, pop, and cinematic grandeur.

If there's one potential drawback, it's the absence of a live drummer. While the programmed percussion is well-integrated, some tracks might have benefited from the added dynamics of real drums. That said, after a few listens, it's clear that the band's layered approach compensates for this choice, creating a cohesive sonic landscape that doesn't necessarily need traditional drumming.

Beyond the song titles, the album also reflects quantum mechanics in its musical composition: unpredictable shifts, non-linear structures, and layered sounds that suggest multiple interpretations, much like quantum superposition. It's an album that plays with the idea of knowledge, perception, and the limits of human understanding?just as quantum theory challenges our classical view of the universe.

The Uncertainty Principle is an intricate, thought-provoking album that rewards patience. While it may not be an easy listen for those unfamiliar with HOGIA's style, it offers an immersive experience. The band's fusion of progressive rock, ambient textures, and scientific/philosophical concepts makes this a unique and rewarding listen?one that stands out in 2025's progressive landscape.

For the life of me, I can't remember why this album ever made it to my "check-out list". Probably it was just a part that my ear caught because now that I got around to actually check it out, I scratch my head in disbelief and I wonder where my head was when I ticked it. In essence, I have three issues with this album. The first one is the vocals of Malcolm Galloway (it's actually a one-man band since he plays all instruments except the bass and the flute) are very average (he's doing a bit better when he sings in a hushed fashion). The second one is that the guitar work ranks among the worst I have ever heard since the tone is awful and the playing is truly unimaginative. The 90% of the guitars is hitting a chord, allowing it to ring for a whole bar or two, hit it again and so on (the exception to the rule is Defiance and it is the album's less bad song). The third is that the music as a whole is unimaginative. There are some nice parts here and there, but does that say much? Every time (not too many, that is) I was listening to one of them, I kept pushing myself "hey, it can't be so bad" but it is. I listened to the entire album two times, but I gave up on the third. Just one remark: every time I see a one-man band, chances are it won't be a good one. It's kind of hard to be an accomplished songwriter/guitarist/drummer/vocalist/keyboardist all rolled into one. The diversity and versatility which can be achieved by different personalities is excluded with this setup unless we are talking about highly gifted people.

I don't like to use one star as a rating, but even on two-stars albums there are a couple songs that I like. Unfortunately, here this is not the case.

HOGIA are back with their seventh album, with many of the songs this time inspired by books. The duo of Malcolm Galloway (vocals, lead guitar, keyboards, synths, programming, percussion, drums) and Mark Gatland (bass guitar, slide guitars, keyboards, synths, Chapman Stick, backing vocals, percussion, drums) have again been joined by flautist Kathryn Thomas for three tracks. I have heard quite a lot of Malcolm's material over the years, both with his more classical head on and with HOGIA, and what has taken me with this album is not only the sheer diversity of material on offer but the depth, as this an incredibly complex album which still refuses to sit solely within what many people consider to be prog, with far more indie sounds and styles. The full version, which includes radio cuts of some numbers, is more than 80 minutes in length, containing 19 songs, but never feels over long or dragging as one is brought deeply into their world.

The instrumental "Avrana Kern Is Made Of Ants" just belts along and is quite at odds with much of the rest of the album, which goes between space rock and indie, experimental prog and psychedelia, always ensuring the listener needs to pay close attention to what is going on. The centrepiece of the album is 'Walking To Aldebaran', inspired by the science fiction novella of the same name by Adrian Tchaikovsky, moving from prog metal (I love the flute during the introduction where Kathryn almost loses control) to more theatrical elements. Malcolm's vocal style really works well with this over-the-top styling, as he brings something of a David Byrne approach to it. The song is sung from the perspective of an astronaut losing his sanity as he wanders an alien labyrinth, gradually being transformed into a monster, and there is a darkness and menace here, with the strange experimental piano providing a harshness which fits well. One of my favourite science fiction writers growing up was Philip K Dick, and "The Man Who Japed" has its title taken from the novel of the same name, but not every book is science fiction, although that is a common thread.

There are plenty of instrumentals, all working with strong direction which can change with no notice whatsoever as Malcolm and Mark are never keen to rest for too long. The result is a modern progressive album which never feels regressive but is always moving forward in ways which can be quite unexpected yet always melodic and fascinating. This will not be for those who want their music of today to sound as if it were released 50 years ago, but if you enjoy a more modern approach then this is one of HOGIA's most interesting and complete albums yet.

Maybe WE Could Do Better

We'll See

In "The Light of Ancient Mistakes" -UK trio HATS OFF GENTLEMEN IT'S ADEQUATE's seventh album release- we are drawn into a foreboding, disturbing, unsettling world in which we begin to realize we have only ourselves to blame.

But plenty of villains and rascals and demons to go around.

All set to impeccably engineered, mostly-restrained, Floyd-inspired, brooding music with lyrics telling tales of quiet horror and devastation. Malcolm Galloway- lyricist, composer, multi-instrumentalist- draws from a wide-ranging booklist which inspires him to reflect on our current world conditions.

And he doesn't much care for what he sees- so much we could do to improve ourselves and our world, our relationships, our politics, our sense of connectedness- and we don't do those things.

Why?

Consider this album HATS OFF GENTLEMEN IT'S ADEQUATE's response- not an 'answer' because there may be none or at least none most of us wish to acknowledge (cowardice? let someone else take action? hopelessness?)- to the WHY of it all.

Homophobia/AI/Environmental Ruin/Desperation/Alienation

In poetic and musical form, HATS OFF GENTLEMEN IT'S ADEQUATE addresses demagogues we by our inert responses empower, burning of the world, funding the eight hundred years of military madness which may well light the skies with our own demise- and we are confronted time and again whether in music or in lyrical reveries with our own complicity.

It's a Tough Album

Yet it's a powerful- and perhaps overlong- experience, putting on the headphones and hearing "The Light of Ancient. Mistakes". Pondering whether WE can (and will) do better than we have been.

Musically I do frequently hear the mournful and brooding sounds and the Strat-flavored textures of Pink Floyd, but also, notably in my favorite track, "Walking to Aldebaran", some edgy, heavier progressive metal-style passages with complex riffs. Lots of keyboards, with layers of synths and strings and held, foreboding bass lines, grooving and active bass lines, and some tasty drumming.

The vocals are often lamenting and mournful, considering the subject matter mentioned, with occasional use of octaves and harmony to add heft and texture.

Special mention also must be made for "imtiredandeverythinghurts", a deeply self-revelatory song that has personally challenged me to reconsider using the ubiquitous (and quite awkward, it turns out) question, "How are you?" or "How's it going?"

When one is suffering, what is the proper response? Is the question sincere...or is it similar to the meaningless, "What's up?" with which person greets person.

Not a Literary Thesis

I'm often tempted, when faced with an immensity of questions and literary references and Big Ideas, to begin to unpack these. In "The Light of Ancient Mistakes" we find all these and more, as well as impeccably engineered and produced musical greatness.

But forget it. Malcolm has provided a lot of information- with some wonderful illustrations- about the tracks on this album, and I encourage you to take time to read, and to think about these things.

My Conclusions

Quite a heavy and passionate offering from HATS OFF GENTLEMEN IT'S ADEQUATE, brimming with excellent music and thought-provoking lyrics. I want MORE like "Walking to Aldebaran", as this sounds like a promising departure for the band. And maybe the album. is too long overall- but that's so subjective on my part.

Can we humans do better? Will we?

My rating is nine dystopian solar systems out of ten.

I like this band hailing from London. I like their sense of humour and their music. Despite their funny name, they can display a rich melodic prog. This time, the album is a concept one, it's about the perils of overconfidence, excessive certainty leading to the same old errors, including war! The band evokes plagues such as the Holocaust and Covid ('Cygnus'). And even quotes Philip K. Dick ('Perky Pat' and 'World War Terminus' which echoes 'Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?'). 'We keep saying never again, and we keep making the same mistakes ...'. Yes, this album is dealing with the repeated failure to learn from history. Proves that history repeats itself. At least we know the same reasons engender the same consequences. One of the longest track ('Refuge') is an instrumental inspired by the story of a Jewish woman (a great-grand-mother of one of the musician) with Lithuanian origins and living in Paris who is hunt by the Nazis and finally protected by brave and ordinary people (we call them les 'Justes' in France) in the Pyrenees mountains. The combo underlines the language used dehumanises populations at that time and affirms it is still used today. This is the sixth album already by this dynamic duo, Malcolm Galloway and Mark Gatland. They invited Kathryn Thomas for flute parts and backing vocals. And both designed the (beautiful) cover. Vintage (especially Pink Floyd, Kayak, Camel) and modern prog hints come to the mind. This formula of a duo may also remind you of Tears for Fears or Silver Hunter. In a nutshell, they deliver more than of one hour of rich music and meaningful lyrics.

The Name!

Self-Deprecation

Anything But!

Regarding the name: HATS OFF GENTLEMEN IT'S ADEQUATE evokes mind-pictures of the subtle English habit of self- mockery, the gift of self-deprecation that characterizes one who is paradoxically humbly self-assured enough to be modest about what is "Anything But" simply adequate.

"The Confidence Trick" is much more than "adequate". Rather it is also evocative: it evokes ideas and images from earliest times of hubris and narcissism, until the most recent, timely moments in which we now find ourselves.

Set To Understated Musical Pieces

For these thirteen tracks, threaded with instrumental reveries, but mostly working within artfully expressed and poetic lyrics, convey the dangers and difficulties inherent in maintaining one's bearings amidst great odds of pressure and persuasion.

The music, nor the lyrics, are ever heavy-handed. Rather, subtle, suggesting, waiting gently for the rage and ferocity to be teased out, the disgust and revilement of betrayal by the overlords given the task of caring and protecting those most vulnerable...

...and simply too important and too confident to do those caring, protecting things.

Tastes of Symphony, Jazz, Metal, Rock

The music, in all its variety, is quietly, never flashily, sophisticated, melodic, expressive, and germane to the over-riding theme- "The Confidence Trick" in which the narcissist and the beguiled enter into solemn agreement that the status quo of exploitation and murder shall be oh-so-properly and oh-so-mannerly maintained.

Refuge

For me, the actual, literal story of Malcolm's great-grandmother Broni Krom set to music in this track, shines the clearest and most poignant light upon the intent of this album. She survived many "toils and snares" because of her faith and came through threats of death and also great hardship, with courage, optimism, and hope.

The best, and the worst, of human behaviors are shown in this story of surviving and thriving in and through the "Confidence Trick" as it then was slithering through the zeitgeist, revealing that "all empires fall", regardless of how mighty and impregnable they may appear.

Great-grandmother Broni THRIVED and SURVIVED, and she was given aid and comfort by other bright souls, in the face of hatred, prejudice, and murder.

COVID, SMO, Elon Musk Escaping Earth

How many people have died- been murdered- by over-confident/immoral/incompetent people doing or refusing to do simple, straight-forward, scientifically sound things- providing masks. Admitting one is ill-informed. Sharing scientific evidence even with 'enemies'. Working for the greater good. Refusing 'sanctions' that mostly destroy the vulnerable, the poor, and the humble of the earth. Contributing money for heath-care rather than inter-planetary travel so Mars can be colonized...

For Me

The album is thought-provoking, stirring, lovely, troublesome, maddening, literate, suggesting, provoking. It seems to me to be a collection of thoughts and sounds designed to push humans into action based on caring rather than on cashing-in or lording-over.

My rating

4.0 stars, "Excellent addition to any progressive rock music collection".

HATS OFF GENTLEMEN IT'S ADEQUATE releases their 6th album, so far I'm good! A creative musical vehicle with Malcolm Galloway former Doctor suffering from an illness and Mark Gatland helped by Kathryn Thomas his wife on the flute. HOGIA bears various influences on progressive, classic, electronic and metallic rock from which reminiscences come from PINK FLOYD, MARILLION and contemporary cinematic groups in fashion today. Texts on human errors and their exacerbated confidences painted in parables and 5 instrumentals for uncompromising rock art.

'Silence Is a Statement' launches the soundtrack on a melodic tune with synthesized guitars, crystalline voice and metronomic Mark drums, a little OCEANSIZE for the tune. 'Back Where I Started' Kathryn's flute and Malcolm's rocky voice on a time journey that goes wrong, the fluid and scintillating melody coming to pass... the pill of our incapacity. 'End of the Line' with delicate progressive intro and Malcolm that reminds me of Steve MARILLION's daydreams; atmospheric title where the keyboards and guitars are joined again by this melancholy flute, moment when the futile meets musical hypnosis with the hopeless guitar solo. Heady 'Perky Pat'! A reverberating, hypnotic, tortured electronic instrument on a story of oh so schizoid Dick prelude to our weberized life; progressive with the explosive majestic crescendo. 'World War Terminus' story of nuclear conflict and a rhythmic tune with a fast phrasing voice, dark tune then final crystalline keyboard. 'Pretending to Breathe' another melodic, atmospheric and doubtful instrumental, the ambient passage bringing back on a dark SCHULZE; the finale refers to the magic keyboards of the cheerful TANGERINE DREAM, bearers of hope, a long meditative interlude.

'Another Plague' with a floydian intro bringing a syncopated title where the keyboard is king, a title that is worth for its moving guitar flight, for the shoegaze rock melting pot full of hope against the future of our world, the solemn voice in addition. 'Refuge' for the symphonic piano interlude and its small flute in coulis; cinematic soundtrack mixing sweetness with avant-garde dramatic revival, featuring Malcolm's grandmother's escape from the camps, a beautiful tribute in itself; the instrumental aspect itself seems to give words of explanation; a great classico-progressive moment with a grandiloquent finale and a spectral Genesis solo, a magnificent unclassifiable title, you will have understood it. 'Interlude' on a melodic and symphonic neo-prog declination and an aerial solo. 'The Confidence Trick' eponymous title, bluesy guitar solo à la Gilmour, synth à la Wright, it goes up to denounce our way of life, but let's return to the majestic music launched as food here; apart from the metronomic drums the sound pulls on the PINK FLOYD; emphasis piece. 'Lava Lamprey' last jazzy instrumental, swirling with this sinuous synth, parable of a psychogenic dictatorial power, fresh anachronistic title. 'All Empires Fall' targeted verse-chorus title with a muted rapped voice, acerbic criticism of the dictators of this lower world, velvety guitar slide and a nod to GALAHAD. 'Cygnus' for the outro hymn to health personnel vis-à-vis the pandemic and solemn snub to incompetent governments.

HATS OFF GENTLEMEN IT'S ADEQUATE has released a varied album of contemporary progressive alternative music, an astonishing album mixing electronic sounds with moving classical passages, pledge of spleen and other introspection. Be careful not to miss this special group which gives a philosophical message on the world in which we live.

'We keep saying never again, and we keep making the same mistakes ...', this is dealing with the repeated failure to learn from history. Silence is a statement? Really? Sure, while considering the album's context, the lyrics, it gets a valid meaning. Encouragement is required for example, regarding the needed response to racist violence. Now we promptly are within the album entry. The aforementioned message on one hand, well then the composition as such, plus the instrumental implementation, everything is simply priceless. Leaves you wanting more. And indeed, 'The Confidence Trick' album marks the best song collection I've come across so far regarding this band. Just appealing in its entirety. Considering the booklet's fantastic layout respectively illustrations so much the more something for your ears and eyes. It is worth investing some time. A few songs are referencing Sci-Fi novels written by Philip K. Dick, others are inspired by personal experiences.

There is a really charming atmosphere prepared for the listener all over. Malcolm Galloway's voice appears to be unique, for one or two this probably needs getting used to. A trademark in any case, still can be filed under sorta hybrid of singing and speech. Superficially seen you may have the impression that he's pulling the strings right on his own, but as usual Mark Gatland is on his side, the longtime co-partner so to say. And that's nearly all about the current band line up. Oh, finally not to forget the nice flutes occasionally swirling around, provided by Kathryn Thomas, to mention End Of The Line for example. This has a great effect when trying to implement a somewhat silky mood. Electronics are fairly in place overall, even such a song like Perky Pat works well. Hence the drumming must arrive from the console solely. 10 years ago or so I would have complained, but today these things are refined a lot, finally acceptable to a layman like me.

'When it started, who won?' Major powers are becoming increasingly aggressive in trying to divide up the world, this nowadays is concentrated on the Ukraine. I would say World War Terminus is thematically drawing on current issues, especially concerning the threatening nuclear aspect. The extended symphonic excursion Refuge then comes with grandezza pure, context-wise following some adventurous experiences of Galloway's great-grandmother during Word War II. The album's title track shines with extraordinary playful guitars. And I'm always overwhelmed by the mellow jazz tinged Lava Lamprey flow, including some excellent bass lines. 'Armed with applause, but it wasn't enough ...', finally the short piano driven closing track Cygnus is generously dedicated to all those people from the health and social care devotedly fighting against the COVID pandemic. Occasionally reminding me of Tears For Fears and Talking Heads, and accompanied by those well thought out themes and messages, the band delivers more than one hour of entertaining music.