Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography


Crossover Prog • United States

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Fair To Midland picture
Fair To Midland biography
Founded in Dallas, Texas in 1998 - Disbanded in 2012

Formed in 1998 by Andrew Darroh SUDDERTH (vocals, banjo and mandolin) and Cliff CAMPBELL (guitar) Texas based FAIR TO MIDLAND self-released their debut album 'The Carbon Copy Silver Lining' in 2001 with Nathin SEALS on bass, percussionist Brett STOWERS and drummer Jason PINTLER. The follow-up, 'inter.funda.stifle', was recorded with Matt LANGLEY who played guest keyboards on the debut now as a fulltime member and STOWERS now occupying the drum throne following PINTLER's departure from the band in 2003. Released in 2004 'inter.funda.stifle' drew the attention of Serj TANKIAN of SYSTEM OF A DOWN who subsequently signed them to his Serjical Strike Records label, six tracks from the album were re-recorded with 5 new tracks to form their third album 'Fables from a Mayfly: What I Tell You Three Times Is True', recorded in 2007 with Jon DICKEN now on bass and produced by David BOTTRILL (famous for producing such artists as FRIPP & SYLVIAN, KING CRIMSON, TOOL, MUSE and COHEED AND CAMBRIA).

Photo by Frank Ockenfels

FAIR TO MIDLAND Videos (YouTube and more)

Showing only random 3 | Search and add more videos to FAIR TO MIDLAND


Drawn & QuarteredDrawn & Quartered
INDIE 2015
$1.79 (used)
Fables From a Mayfly: What I Tell You Three Times is TrueFables From a Mayfly: What I Tell You Three Times is True
Republic 2007
$2.81 (used)
Arrows And AnchorsArrows And Anchors
Metal/Entertainment One 2011
$17.91 (used)
Arrows & Anchors by Fair to Midland (2011-07-12)Arrows & Anchors by Fair to Midland (2011-07-12)
Entertainment One Music
$69.97 (used)
Fair To Midland - Arrows & Anchors [Japan CD] VICP-64993Fair To Midland - Arrows & Anchors [Japan CD] VICP-64993
Victor Japan
$17.95 (used)
Right Now on Ebay (logo)
Arrows & Anchors - Fair To Midland USA CD Sealed NEW Art Rock, Prog Rock #329* USD $7.19 Buy It Now 2 days
Inter. Funda. Stifle by Fair to Midland (CD, Jun-2004, Fair to Midland) USD $0.99 [1 bids]
4 days
V/A Fair To Midland SHINY TOY GUNS Kaiser Chiefs STRAYLIGHT RUN PROMO DVD! no cd USD $5.00 Buy It Now 6 days
The Drawn And Quartered by Fair to Midland (CD, 2006) USD $1.25 Buy It Now 7 days
FAIR TO MIDLAND, DANCE OF THE MANATEE, 377, EX/EX, 3 Track, Promo CD Single, Car USD $3.51 Buy It Now 8 days
FAIR TO MIDLAND Dance of the Manatee RARE EDIT PROMO DJ CD single USA 2007 MINT USD $24.99 Buy It Now 12 days
Fair To Midland : Fables from a Mayfly: What I Tell You Three Times Is True CD USD $4.49 Buy It Now 17 days
(JB38) Fair To Midland, Arrows & Anchors - 2011 DJ CD USD $10.91 Buy It Now 18 days
FAIR TO MIDLAND - Fables From A Mayfly: What I Tell You Three Times Is True - VG USD $16.95 Buy It Now 19 days
FAIR TO MIDLAND - Fables From A Mayfly: CD Brand New USD $64.99 Buy It Now 20 days
Fair To Midland - Fables From a Mayfly: What I Tell... - Fair To Midland CD 14VG USD $23.48 Buy It Now 20 days
Fair to Midland : Fables from a Mayfly: ... CD Expertly Refurbished Product USD $5.31 Buy It Now 21 days
Arrows & Anchors - Fair To Midland USA CD Sealed NEW Art Rock, Prog Rock #AB03 USD $8.99 Buy It Now 22 days
Ryan Adams, Bad Religion, Unkle, Fair to Midland, Carolyn Mark U.S. promo cd USD $3.79 Buy It Now 24 days
Fair To Midland CDs Albums (Fables Mayfly, Arrows Anchors, Drawn Quartered) USD $14.55 Buy It Now 26 days
Fair to Midland : Arrows & Anchors CD Highly Rated eBay Seller, Great Prices USD $15.00 Buy It Now 26 days
Fair to Midland : Fables From a Mayfly: What I Tell You Th CD USD $4.89 Buy It Now 31 days

More places to buy FAIR TO MIDLAND music online Buy FAIR TO MIDLAND & Prog Rock Digital Music online:

FAIR TO MIDLAND discography

Ordered by release date | Showing ratings (top albums) | Help to complete the discography and add albums

FAIR TO MIDLAND top albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

3.15 | 16 ratings
The Carbon Copy Silver Lining
4.12 | 26 ratings
4.13 | 86 ratings
Fables From A Mayfly - What I Tell You Three Times Is True
3.61 | 61 ratings
Arrows & Anchors

FAIR TO MIDLAND Live Albums (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

FAIR TO MIDLAND Videos (DVD, Blu-ray, VHS etc)

FAIR TO MIDLAND Boxset & Compilations (CD, LP, MC, SACD, DVD-A, Digital Media Download)

FAIR TO MIDLAND Official Singles, EPs, Fan Club & Promo (CD, EP/LP, MC, Digital Media Download)

2.26 | 4 ratings
The Drawn and Quartered EP


Showing last 10 reviews only
 Fables From A Mayfly - What I Tell You Three Times Is True by FAIR TO MIDLAND album cover Studio Album, 2007
4.13 | 86 ratings

Fables From A Mayfly - What I Tell You Three Times Is True
Fair To Midland Crossover Prog

Review by progshavedice

5 stars There is something to be said about the importance of this album, this is a piece of art that was refined and cleaned for the purpose of well mixed listening. A few of these songs, such as "Kyla Cries Cologne" are re-recordings from a previous album called Inter.funda.stifle

The album opens with the track that is nothing short of greatness and vocals that will knock your socks off. "Dance of the Manatee" kicks off with good riffing and catchy octaves of guitar, followed by Darroh Sudderth's impeccable voice that catches your attention, once he has your attention; he hits you with his range which is larger than Mount St. Helens. When the song finally reaches Climax, Darroh releases the kraken with a monstrous roar that is very specific to Andrew himself. The song does a good job of give and take with Dynamics.

The second track "Kyla Cries Cologne" is an extremely good choice to put as the second song, With the placement being where it is, it is complemented by the intro that sets up the verse perfectly. All together, this song is a pure example of the talent which they have when it comes to musical structure. This version contains second chorus high-notes that have the ability to leave a listener not only impressed, but with a sense of accomplishment. One thing I have to mention is the work of Matt Langley on keys, which played a great role in this song.

"The Wife, The Kids, and the White Picket Fence" is the ballad of the album that provides lyrical content that is poetic and memorable. such as: "Between you and me from point A to point B, is a fine line that burns at both our good ends." The lyrical content has the ability to make minds go into a deep sense of curiosity that ties a song, to a place in one's heart.

At this point in the album, it is time to point out Brett Stowers, which provides exceptional drum work on the track "April Fools and Eggmen". Folks, these choruses are strong. They are solid and the creativity shows.

"A Seafarers Knot" shows how Darroh ensures that a good vocal melody doesn't need to be rushed. Darroh is very smart when it comes to writing vocal melodies, Which also starts out with the heaviest intro of this album.

"A Wolf Descends Upon the Spanish Sahara" Is an absolute gem. It starts off with a very ominous yet relaxing intro that goes into the beautiful verse provided with gorgeous vocals. The prechorus/bridge provides a great set up for the chorus, which like I've mentioned before, is VERY strong. When the song dies down Darroh let's out a weeping and strong belt that shows great emotion. The layering is awesome.

Let's talk about diversity, "Walls of Jericho" kicks off with an intro by Cliff Campbell which is rhythmically genius. This song is the song that Serj sang with them live on a show. Which does not surprise me given that it has every aspect that is desired in a song. The bass parts which are played by Jon Dicken are absolutely essential in this song

As much as I try not to repeat myself, It's hard not to talk about ANY of these songs without talking about these Choruses, which are the best in prog. In "Tall Tales Taste Like Sour Grapes" Mr Sudderth doesn't give you break from his awesome choruses. And to be honest, I am proud of it.

"Upgrade^Brigade"is another song that was rerecorded, and man am I glad it was, I love every single version of these songs, but the sound being as refined as it is makes it really precise and special.

as we get to the ending "Say When" is a song that speaks as an ending, almost like when a hero saves the day and the credits are rolling.

5 stars is something that isn't easy for me to give, but today I give credit where credit is due. This album is history. Regardless of popularity, this album will be remembered.

Fair to Midland, 5 stars. Thank you

 The Carbon Copy Silver Lining by FAIR TO MIDLAND album cover Studio Album, 2001
3.15 | 16 ratings

The Carbon Copy Silver Lining
Fair To Midland Crossover Prog

Review by b3aut1fuld1rt

5 stars Probably one of the most important albums in my book. This is one of the very few records that doesn't sound like anything else in existence. I have my own copy of this with all member's signatures and it's my most prized possession. It takes an album that no one can possibly fathom due to it's alienation to be truly unique in every form. Like Lizard by King Crimson. Progressive rock is mainstream in comparison to an album like this. Even a fan of underground music wouldn't make it past the first few seconds. Truly extraordinary and a must listen for anyone who hasn't given a one star rating in a while.

Highlights: Informative Timeline, Pen-_-

 Fables From A Mayfly - What I Tell You Three Times Is True by FAIR TO MIDLAND album cover Studio Album, 2007
4.13 | 86 ratings

Fables From A Mayfly - What I Tell You Three Times Is True
Fair To Midland Crossover Prog

Review by TCat
Collaborator Eclectic Team

4 stars This is a very impressive band that play top-notch progressive rock that has quite a variety of influence and sub-genres many time evident in each individual track. Taking a look at this album cover, you think you are in for a nice brand of folk rock or prog-folk. Well.....that's just the very tippity tip of the iceberg here, ladies and gentlemen. If you catch on to the hidden track that's there before the first official track, and hit the back button on your CD player as soon as you put in the disc, you might fall into the mistaken idea that this is a mid-eastern style of folk, but when that first track kicks in, you see how much you were mistaken. Not that that is a fluke, because prog-folk is evident in many places through the album, but it can flow effortlessly into prog-metal as quick as a blink of an eye. And you are left in the world did that just happen?

This band started out by releasing two albums on their own and by pleasing the locals of their home state of Texas. They did so well there, that they decided to try their luck in other parts of the country, but did not fare so well (I'm guessing because their music is quite complex). It got to the point that the band was going to break up and call the whole thing a failure, but right at the last minute, they caught the attention of Serj Tankian (the lead singer from "System of a Down"). He signed them onto his label and was available for advise and became the executive producer for this album. Soon they were opening for bands like Muse, Smashing Pumpkins, Rage Against the Machine and so on.

So, if I was to compare the music to other progressive bands out there, I would have to say this music is as versatile and inventive as dredg at their best. There are not a lot of instrumental breaks or solos here, except on the instrumental interludes. But the band works together flawlessly and flow from so many styles and meters without a hitch. The biggest draw for this band and their biggest thing they have going for them is their versatility and the vocals of Darroh Sudderth. His range matches the versatility of their style point for point. He has a slight warble in his voice when singing softer or more folk style songs that makes him believable in those passages, but he can switch to an amazing falsetto that's just as strong as anything, and still pull off a low guttural heavy rap as good as Serj can and sound just as authentic.

Then there is the feeling of the music. There is so much variety within each song, but each song has it's own feeling and personality. As you listen and become familiar with the tracks, you notice each one does have an overall direction. "Say When" is a beautiful ballad overall with nice harmonies but still has room to put in an amazing guitar hook and solo. The interlude that follows at the end of "April Fools and Eggmen" is a nice sounding instrumental that sounds like something from a rhythmic renaissance style song, then this gives way to the sudden explosive riff that heads off the amazing "The Seafarer's Knot" one of my personal favorites on this album.

This is really good progressive rock to play while on the road. The overall tone is quite heavy, but it changes so much that I think it would be attractive to a wide audience. Really great music, high quality performance especially form the vocalist, but it is obvious that the entire band is talented. This is a band that needs more recognition for sure. This album is definitely an excellent addition to any prog rock collection. 4 strong stars.

 Arrows & Anchors by FAIR TO MIDLAND album cover Studio Album, 2011
3.61 | 61 ratings

Arrows & Anchors
Fair To Midland Crossover Prog

Review by toroddfuglesteg

3 stars The fourth album from this US band is an unexpected meeting.

Jumping out of the speakers like some angry wasps, this album takes no prisoners. The sound is a mix of neo metal with some really waspish angry guitars which has been teamed up in a wall of sound and some more gentle pastoral rock. This is the sound of the post millenium, hard rock style. This is a really hard album and metallic.

The guys does a very good job on their instruments and the vocals are good. The sound is good too. Everything here is good, except from the the lack of some really great tracks here. This album does not really takes off. It just walks around on the tarmac and does some pirouettes. Which is good. Those more into neo hard metallic rock anno post millenium will find this more worthwhile than I do. It is still a good album though in my estimation.

3 stars

 Arrows & Anchors by FAIR TO MIDLAND album cover Studio Album, 2011
3.61 | 61 ratings

Arrows & Anchors
Fair To Midland Crossover Prog

Review by TheLastBaron

4 stars I'm slightly surprised that no one has written a review for this album yet. I first heard of Fair To Midland when they where signed to Serjical Strike records as I'm a fan of System of a Down and had a habit of tracking what the band members where up to when they went on hiatus. The first album I heard from Fair To Midland was Fables from a mayfly ( I'm to lazy to write the rest of the title). I fell in love with the shift in styles, vocals and cryptic and poetic lyrics. I pateintly awaited the release of Arrows and Anchors ever since Fables. Adn though there are some very noticeable differences, I really enjoy this album. Some may be tuned away upon first listen by the fact that this is a heavier album, not just in sound but in production also. Yet the melodic passages, turns of phrase ( I found myself contempleting the philosophical inclanations of short phrases such as " I could be kicking the bucket, but you should know I never had very good aim" " Is shooting for stars like darts in the dark?" and " if failed attempts where a lottery ticket, you could be I'd be raking it in." just to name a few), and stylistic shifts still remain. Fair To Midland has simply taken what makes them so good and expanded the use of keyboards, growls and subtle electronic touches. Just as Good as Fables but different enough, Fair to Midland could've played it safe, instead they take what fans already love about them and try some new tricks.
 The Carbon Copy Silver Lining by FAIR TO MIDLAND album cover Studio Album, 2001
3.15 | 16 ratings

The Carbon Copy Silver Lining
Fair To Midland Crossover Prog

Review by msphelps

1 stars I suppose it was a mistake to listen to this album after hearing "Dance of the Manatee" for the first time. Going back and listening to their earliest release is, in comparison, just embarrassing. The songwriting is relatively mediocre and the pieces in general are tough, if not impossible, to listen to. Not even a focused listen to this album reveals anything rewarding. It's unfortunate that Fair to Midland managed to take a fairly interesting idea (folk/death/prog) and then fail to do anything interesting with it. It's interesting in that it is the beginnings of an otherwise excellent band, but on the whole, anyone looking for anything similar to Fables from a Mayfly and other parts of their later work should run away, very quickly. Carbon Copy isn't an enjoyable listen as much as it is a physical chore.
 The Drawn and Quartered EP by FAIR TO MIDLAND album cover Singles/EPs/Fan Club/Promo, 2006
2.26 | 4 ratings

The Drawn and Quartered EP
Fair To Midland Crossover Prog

Review by ClemofNazareth
Special Collaborator Prog Folk Researcher

2 stars Fair to Midland are an interesting story; five guys coming out of some jerkwater semi-rural northeast Texas town, discovered by System of a Down frontman Serj Tankian and signed to his Serjical Strike label then breaking into the Billboard Top-200 with their major label debut ‘Fables from a Mayfly: What I Tell You Three Times Is True’ including the striking "Dance of the Manatee" and the very musically mature "Walls of Jericho". The band has two previous studio albums to their credit; 2004’s ‘inter.funda.stifle’ which features early versions of several songs later released on ‘Fables’, and the 2001 independent release ‘The Carbon Copy Silver Lining’ which I haven’t heard and is difficult to find but whose artwork and song titles look an awful lot like something a math rock band might put out (“Pen-_-“, “..(i)..”, “-The Beltway-“, “See, Saw”).

This EP was technically their first major label release, also issued on Serjical Strike in 2006 and featuring five songs (four actually, plus a video that includes pieces of live performances, brief interviews and snippets of fan interactions). Two of the audio tracks are demo versions and two are live; all of them are also found in other forms on the ‘inter.funda.stifle’ CD. From a production standpoint I’ve heard better: the studio versions here are somewhat flat, and the band clearly improved their delivery and sound separation skills between when these demos were recorded and the ‘Fables’ release. Lead singer Darroh Sudderth shows promise here, but nothing approaching his tight and soaring shrieks on the 2007 album.

The live versions are even rougher, with plenty of sound dropouts and a muddled, sometimes almost echoing rhythm section. I’m sure these were much better received by the folks actually at the concert in which they were recorded.

The packaging here is a bit strange too; all the audio tracks are in Windows movie format, which will make ripping the thing to your mp3 player a bit challenging depending on what type of software you have to do that. And the liner notes are just as cryptic and nonsensical as those on ‘Fables’ (in other words, random snippets from the various lyric tracks).

As much as I loved ‘Fables’ I’m starting to wonder a bit about the staying power of these guys. In the past five years they’ve released two studio albums and this EP, but two of the songs on this EP ("Kyla Cries Cologne" and “A Seafarer’s Knot”) also appear on both their full-length CDs (albeit different recordings), and the other two songs here (“Orphan Anthem ‘86” and “Abigail”) are also on ‘inter.funda.stifle’. In the case of "Kyla Cries Cologne" not only the arrangement but also the lyrics are slightly different, but its still the same song.

The band is supposed to have a new studio album out in early 2010, and assuming that one doesn’t include outtakes or leftovers from any of these other records then there may be some hope; otherwise I’d say the band may be relegated to the post-grunge and fair circuit before long.

This is a curio for collectors and fans of the band, but certainly not a very good representation of what they are capable of, and definitely not very highly recommended as an introduction to the group. Check out ‘Fables’ first and leave this one to whet your whistle in the inevitable delay between their 2010 release and whatever follows that. Two stars.


 Fables From A Mayfly - What I Tell You Three Times Is True by FAIR TO MIDLAND album cover Studio Album, 2007
4.13 | 86 ratings

Fables From A Mayfly - What I Tell You Three Times Is True
Fair To Midland Crossover Prog

Review by ClemofNazareth
Special Collaborator Prog Folk Researcher

4 stars One of my favorite discoveries in the past few years, and among the best albums of any genre released in 2007 is Fair to Midland and their third studio release ‘Fables from a Mayfly: What I Tell You Three Times is True’. This group’s blend of metal, folk and progressive music was like a sonic explosion of fresh air that summer, and even now two years later this CD still finds its way into my car’s disc player on most of the many treks I make across the Midwestern United States on a regular basis.

I first picked this up at a record store on a whim during a road trip that summer, having never heard of the band but intrigued by the album cover, band and album name, and some of the song titles; all of which suggested a fresh new group whose music was steeped in American folk. That turned out to be sort of true, but the opening blast of “Dance of the Manatee” dispelled any notion this was some sort of rustic, acoustic-strumming, introspective urban folk band. Clifford Campbell opens the first song with a jolt of torrid guitar, then settles down in a fast-paced but controlled tempo just long enough for Darroh Sudderth to warm up his voice before launching into a soaring and explosive vocal rant that fluctuates between heavy folk, metal shrieking and throaty, guttural rap for a fist-pumping rush that returns again and again, offset only by barely-restrained stanzas of freak-out bass, thundering drums and melodic interludes before skidding to an abrupt halt just about the time my blood pressure reaches party stage. An innovative, energetic, and wholly inspiring 4:10 worth of art rock straight out of Nowhereville (aka the lazy burg of Sulphur Springs, a sparsely-populated blip on the map of northeastern Texas).

I have to admit the band doesn’t really stray all that far from this recipe for the rest of the album, but I’m not one to quibble when five guys who are obviously having a blast click so tightly and with such sonic precision. “Kyla Cries Cologne” brings more of the same before the band slows down just a bit to show off their close-up skills on guitar and bare keyboards on “Vice/Versa”, again only for a short while before Campbell and especially Sudderth cut loose again.

The band shows their poetic and rustic side with the galloping American anthem “The Wife, the Kids, and the White Picket Fence”, followed up by a couple more rockers complete with cryptic lyrics in “April Fools and Eggmen” and “A Seafarer's Knot” before showing off their unique heavy folk chops with the tense and melodic “A Wolf Descends Upon the Spanish Sahara”. For another face to their music Sudderth tones down his voice into human range to open “Walls of Jericho”, but he can’t resist showing off his falsetto range on the choruses here either.

"Tall Tales Taste Like Sour Grapes" is the slowest and most restrained tune on the album, but even here Campbell and drummer Brett Stowers can’t restrain themselves completely, and keyboardist Matt Langley plays around with a little nineties new-wave funkiness in between Sudderth’s staccato rants. Like most of the rest of the band’s lyrics I have no idea what Sudderth is singing about, but as the road whizzes by and my ears are filled with the energetic tones I don’t really care either.

Like several other tracks on the album, “Upgrade^Brigade” is a remake off their second album ‘inter.funda.stifle’, but under the tutelage of producers David Bottrill and Serj Tankian this version sounds richer, more densely packed with sound and much tighter than the earlier one.

Finally the band winds down with the spacey, almost ambient “Say When”, belied only by the torpedo voice of Sudderth and Campbell’s whiny guitar chords. A great ending to a thoroughly enjoyable album.

I never cease to wonder at the creativity demonstrated in melding of musical styles more than a half-century after disc jockeys like Alan Freed introduced eager American audiences to that unique blend of Southern blues and rural country known as rock and roll. Fair to Midland are just the latest marvel in that evolution. This is a very highly recommended album from an up-and-coming band, one that should appeal to metal, art rock, progressive folk and just plain rock ‘n roll fans. Four stars.


Thanks to dean for the artist addition. and to Quinino for the last updates

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives