Progarchives, the progressive rock ultimate discography
Various Artists (Tributes) - Easy Star All-Stars: Dub Side Of The Moon (Pink Floyd) CD (album) cover


Various Artists (Tributes)


Various Genres

3.14 | 25 ratings

From, the ultimate progressive rock music website

Special Collaborator
Honorary Collaborator
3 stars Time is the master, and time can be a disaster

I was put off, I don't mind confessing by the "Easy Star All-Stars" name attributed to the artists. No good can come from that, I thought.

If you don't remember "Stars on 45", or worse, Jive Bunny, then you're very lucky...

However, this is an incredibly polished and affectionate tribute to one of the best- selling and groundbreaking albums of all time; completely true to the spirit, yet only occasionally sinking to direct imitation.

There is something as magically timeless about this release as there is about the original - but you do have to appreciate that there is good in dub reggae and drum and bass, as well as the tiresomely boring; on this release, it's mostly the good stuff - although somewhat toned down to suit the conservative nature of the album.

Almost as soon as the familiar heartbeat has kicked the album off, the All-Stars add a percussive dub vibe. The familiar opening vocals are re-interpreted by Sluggy Ranks, Rasta style; "I and I always been mad...", and for some inexplicable reason, there appears to be an asthmatic cough mixed in as part of the rhythmic texture...

"Breathe" starts familiarly - with an absolutely perfect reggae groove, and remarkable restrained percussion combines with a spot-on rhythm section. When the opening lines "Breathe, breathe in th' air" hit you, a capella, it's a perfect moment, recreated in dub, the slightly hoarse vocals of Sluggy Ranks providing the perfect counterpart to Gilmour.

"On The Run" is supported by the same synth sound - in fact it sounds like the actual synth track from the Floyd original - with a couple of subtle twists before it dives headlong into a less subtle drum and bass section that I find a very tasteful re- interpretation. A few new effects are mixed over the top of this confection, which amazingly seems to retain the flavours of the original, whilst moving it on, musically speaking, a couple of decades.

The All Stars clearly had fun with the alarm clocks that begin "Time" - as well as the original bell alarm, there's a bugle call, an electronic alarm and a cock crowing. I actually prefer this to the Floyd version, as it evokes images of wake up calls over different periods of history.

Corey Harris and Ranking Joe have a tough act to follow, and the opening bars of "Time" seem somewhat tentative - are we going to go with the original, or branch into something new? I rather feel that there was a bit of dithering here, so when the song per se starts, the impact of the reggae stylee is lost. It's not until the break that it really kicks in, and a new style really imposes itself with any authority - but when it does, it's good (if you like that sort of style - which I do...although I do find the repetition of "Time is the master..." incredibly irritating after the 3rd time.). Not quite what it shows potential to have been - it nonetheless shows moments of dazzling inspiration - such as the "Home, home again" section, which is creamy, dreamy dub that provides the perfect setup to Kirsty Rocks' big moment;

"The Great Gig In The Sky" doesn't suffer from the same hesitatancy as "Time" - the build-up to the vocal section sets expectations perfectly, and Kirsty Rock delivers the vocal improv with aplomb and perfect tone, if not imagination or creativity. For a vocal- driven piece, however, it falls far short of the original, and misses vast swathes of development; the accompaniment and arrangement fares much better, as do the overdubbed vocalisations - this wasn't done in a single take, and the only tears are in the listener's eyes...

"Money" only really kicks in around 3:00, until which point it's a passable reggae version of the orignal. After this point, it's wilder, more free-form, and an exuberant and enjoyable excursion into dub, spoiled only by the re-entry into the song, which sounds tightly reined in and tame by comparison.

"Us and Them", by complete contrast, is a beautiful interpretation, replete with sax solo, with painstaking attention to detail - my only criticism being that the vocals are on the "precious" side in places. They're much more soulful in the chorus sections, however - and as the verses continue, the constructions in dub get more and more inventive, until the near-miraculous instrumental section that perfectly deconstructs and beautifuly implies the original, seguing equally perfectly into a wonderful, if slightly cheesey rendition of "Any Colour You Like".

"Brain Damage" is a real highlight and lowlight; Dr Israel's echoing voice and Victor Axelrod's insane keyboards realising the body of the piece in style. The arrangement of the chorus eerily echoes The Wailers' style, and is deeply engaging - but "Eclipse" catches you out. The styling just seems wrong, and what should have been a great ending to a superb interpretation of a great album ends up a damp squib.

The Bonus tracks appear to be of the same high quality, and make for a good reprise;

"Time Version [*]" is an instrumental in the style of Augustus Pablo - you only have to hear the slightly de-tuned sound of the harmonium to think of that early dub pioneer, and the arrangement, as ever, is spot-on.

"Great Dub in the Sky" is a King Tubby's special - with strong Scientist overtones and hints of Sly and Robbie. In itself, and taken as a missing Scientist piece, this is quite wonderful - a very special piece of dub - but I'd still like to hear the female vocalist let rip and give us the vocal improv to die for that the original demands - hence this piece is not as satisfying as it has the potential to be.

"Step It Pon The Rastaman Scene" has a great vibe - but it's quite difficult to see as anything other than derivative filler. It doesn't add anything to the experience of this album - despite being a nice slice of dub, and an interesting interpretation of "Any Colour You Like".

"Any Dub You Like" closes the package - but is merely a continuation of the previous track, despite being tastefully mixed in a style resembling early Aswad.

So a somewhat disappointing ending to a highly competent and engagingly produced album that is much more than a simple reggae version of the original - on the whole, it's actually a re-interpretation.

It might not sit easily in many rock collections - but many Pink Floyd fans I've known have also been dub fans - and with good reason.

So if you're already a Floyd and Dub fan, this is for you - and if you're not yet a fan of dub, this would be a great "gateway" album.

Non-essential for Prog collectors - but an extremely well-made and interesting curio.

Certif1ed | 3/5 |


As a registered member (register here if not), you can post rating/reviews (& edit later), comments reviews and submit new albums.

You are not logged, please complete authentication before continuing (use forum credentials).

Forum user
Forum password


Social review comments () BETA

Review related links

Copyright Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise | RSS + syndications

Other sites in the MAC network: — jazz music reviews and archives | — metal music reviews and archives