| More Top Prog lists and filters
![]() 4.30 | 263 ratings STILL LIFE Opeth |
![]() 4.22 | 297 ratings GHOST REVERIES Opeth |
![]() 4.38 | 78 ratings IN A FLESH AQUARIUM Unexpect |
![]() 4.22 | 253 ratings BLACKWATER PARK Opeth |
![]() 4.57 | 35 ratings SOL NIGER WITHIN Thordendal's Special Defects |
![]() 4.47 | 42 ratings BACK TO TIMES OF SPLENDOR Disillusion |
![]() 4.58 | 32 ratings ELEMENTS Atheist |
![]() 4.22 | 108 ratings FOCUS Cynic |
![]() 4.53 | 35 ratings CRIMSON Edge of Sanity |
![]() 4.62 | 29 ratings OM Negura Bunget |
![]() 4.37 | 51 ratings THE SHAM MIRRORS Arcturus |
![]() 4.27 | 73 ratings SYMBOLIC Death |
![]() 4.26 | 62 ratings THE SOUND OF PERSEVERANCE Death |
![]() 4.17 | 97 ratings TRACED IN AIR Cynic |
![]() 4.26 | 58 ratings UNQUESTIONABLE PRESENCE Atheist |
![]() 4.12 | 116 ratings CRACK THE SKYE Mastodon |
![]() 4.60 | 23 ratings ISA Enslaved |
![]() 4.32 | 42 ratings NOTHINGFACE Voivod |
![]() 4.27 | 47 ratings LA MASQUERADE INFERNALE Arcturus |
![]() 4.09 | 105 ratings COLORS Between The Buried And Me |

EXPRESSIONISTBeltane |
WARRING FACTIONSAnsur |
WINTERSUNWintersun |
SHEDDINGApokatastasia |
Open player in a new window
Review by Lezaza
When I saw the amount of reviews on this record I must say I was surprised. I mean, haven't
"Silhouettes" and Textures been around for quite some time now? I remember when "Drawing Circles"
was released, it was all the rage in most metal magazines I read at the time(not that many, I
admit). But the few here on progarchives who give "extreme"(God, I hate that title so much) metal a
proper glance and review it seem to be more focused on the older, classic acts of tech and
progressive metal. The newcomers somehow elude the spotlight.Then again, is "Silhouettes" really an album to sing praises for? Unlike their previous record "Drawing Circles" this one takes an even bigger step in the direction of Meshuggah's poly rhythmical metal, bordering on what is bearable at times. Now this is coming from someone who generally dislikes this brand of metal, so if you love the style of Meshuggah or similar acts I definitely think that you should give Textures a spin or two.
They have branded their musical style poly rhythmical metal and unlike "Drawing Circles" where it was intertwined in the music, serving obvious musical purposes, on "Silhouettes" I get the impression they are smearing the poly rhythms there for show, because I cannot for the life of me see how the drumming makes sense on most of the songs("Laments of an Icarus" is a perfect example).
But when the band shines they do so brightly indeed. There are some truly brilliant songs and moments on the album, so while it does not win any extra points for originality and taste it sure does make up for it in spades with either musicianship, power or melody.
Something well worth noting as well is that Textures features one of my favorite voices in metal at the moment, so if you're looking for a great vocalist or are a vocalist yourself who is looking for inspiration, listening to Kalsbeek's will not leave you disappointed.
Silhouettes is a lot like sequels tend to be; it follows one of the better extreme(ugh) metal albums of the early millennium and is bigger, faster and more complex than its predecessor. Yet bigger is not always better and the album looses a lot of soul and passion in its choice to put further emphasis on its progressive and technical side.
A great album for fans of the genre! 3/5
Review by sbooth
This is truly one of the most interesting albums I have heard. Intense, dissonant, and unsettling,
it is certainly unique. The band rips through blistering hardcore sections, eerie electronic noises,
and even eerier Avant-Jazz with incredible musicianship and skill. I think this album is a concept
album of some sort, something to do with an artist going insane it seems. Ephel Duath's use of
angular melodies and disonance create an intense, deranged, atmosphere that is very unique. Tracks
like "Praha", and "The Passage" (along with any part of the album with that killer trumpet player)
demonstrate this perfectly.However, I do have a few qualms with this album. The vocals, especially the clean ones, are very weak. I'm a bit ignorant when it comes to "Hardcore" vocals, so i can't really tell if Luciano George Lorusso's screams are particularly good ones, but the clean vocals really stand out as being underdeveloped. Honestly, any suburban teenager singing with his garage band could probably do as good.
One of my biggest dissapointments with this album was the fact that none of the tracks are as good as the opener, which is really too bad because the rest of them are generally longer. "Praha" was amazing, as well as a few sections of other songs, but sometimes a poor structure of lack of melodic development makes me itch for the skip button.
Also, it doesn't sound so much like Ephel Duath are fusing two genres, and more sort of just... alternating between them really fast. It gets to the point where you can hear "METALCORE METALCORE METALCO-- doodley-bee doo wop be doodle wop --METALMETALMETALMETAL...". It's not so much fusion as it is just... mashing sh*t together. Like they're just flipping a switch that makes everything all fast 'n' angry at regular intervals. For the most part, this is not a true fusion of Jazz and Metal; It's just a band that can play both really, really well.
And that's sort of the redeeming quality with this album. Both styles are played to perfection, with stunning technicality and musicianship. Heck, occasionally they even overlap gracefully, and we get a few blissful minutes of perfectly structured, balanced, and awesome-as-hell fusion metal.
Certainly not perfect, but the unique aesthetic, stunning musicianship, and energy make-up for its shortcomings. 3 stars!!
Review by birdwithteeth11
Man, I honestly don't know how I missed these guys for so long. Don't think that I've only just
heard of Voivod recently. Back when I was younger and bands like Metallica and Iron Maiden were a
healthy staple of my musical diet, I at least knew who Voivod was. Except at the time they were
"weird" or "too different" from any metal band I'd heard, so it was difficult to pigeonhole them.
Not to mention that the sci-fi concepts went a little bit over my head, and still do quite honestly.Voivod mixes a blend of hardcore punk, thrash metal, and progressive metal to create a really unique sound. They are fairly technical without being overly technical, and draw on many themes from Cold-War era politics to science fiction. Rush and Pink Floyd are drawn upon almost as much as early hardcore punk is on this album. To many metal fans who were lucky enough to be growing up in the late 80s and early 90s, Voivod were something of a band with a massive cult following. And many of them who were into the band talk about some of the members on this album as being legends. I wish I had been around then so I could understand what those feelings were like, but I digress. What stand out most on this album for me is how Blacky manages to fill a ridiculous amount of space in the music without shoving the other band members out of the way, and Snake's vocals are quite distinct, which is partially due to the French-Canadian accent in my opinion. When I first heard this album many years ago, I dismissed it after a few listens as being way too out there. Now that I have a more expanded music ear, I'm surprised I couldn't see how original this album was. Quite honestly, I still think it's pretty original. I especially love the Pink Floyd cover of Astronomy Domine. Like UMUR, I heard this version before I heard the Pink Floyd version. And I do think I prefer this one a little more.
While Nothingface definitely isn't a masterpiece in my opinion, it is certainly light years ahead of its time. Even today it still sounds pretty original. I'll give it 4 stars, and I'm so glad I gave it another chance. I may have to upgrade it to 5 stars eventually though because it's so close to masterpiece status.
Review by
Bonnek
Prog Reviewer
Sometimes it is interesting to see how your appreciation of an album can change over the course of a
couple of listens. By way of demonstrating that change, I kept my review in its original state,
which I took down after the first few listens.
As you will see it does not correspond with my rating at all. Not because I'm schizophrenic (I'd
rather say this album is totally schizoid) but because I've changed opinion. A human right I often
claim. I must also admit that a second reason why I didn't rewrite the review is simply because I'm
lazy. Another human trait that is not entirely strange to me.Between the Buried and Me combine old school death metal and aggressive hardcore with prog
indulgences to create a burst of anger that leaves little room for things to develop. I like
well-dosed aggression in music but after being slapped around the ears with it for 5 minutes, I sort
of get the point and I'm ready to move on towards more interesting expressions of our mental state. That doesn't happen enough here, there are scattered occasions where BTBAM tempt us with what they
could achieve if they would stop hammering down their one point so continuously. Yes we've got it:
you're young, angry and very angry. (Well I admit, that's 3 points they're making) But it's not just that, my main issue is that the aggressive parts themselves are not good enough:
it is known hardcore and thrash metal riffs pasted together with monotonous hardcore shouts and a
hyperkinetic Mars Volta-on-speed approach to prog. But don't have your hopes up with this last
reference. Never do they reach the level of excellence and creativity that we know that band for. It's only when they open up their neurotic attack for some more laidback playing that it gets more
interesting. Examples can be found around the 5 minute mark into "Obfuscation" or 2 minutes into
"Diseas, Injury, Madness". But all too soon, the overstressed metal riffs kick in again and we're
submerged under a wall of thrash metal again. BTBAM has a lot of potential and I'd guess that many youngsters will devour this. For me, less
predictable songs would have enhanced it a lot. Another option would be to do karaoke versions of
their music. Without vocals this would work a lot better.
Given the poor state and creative standstill that the metal scene has suffered from in the last few
years, it is no wonder that this album comes floating to the top of all year-lists.
Actually this is a fun hodgepodge of an album! Approach with care though, maybe some of my intitial criticism will still be valid for you. 4 stars. Subject to change...
Review by
UMUR
Special Collaborator Progressive Metal Team
The Scattering of Ashes is the fourth full-length studio album by Canadian progressive
extreme metal act Into Eternity. None of the preceeding albums have impressed me
much and I´m beginning to think that Into Eternity will have to make a utopian perfect
album to convince me. Yet again my curiosity got the better of me and I´ve had this album on
loan for the last couple of months.The music on the album is a kind of modern melodic death metal with progressive metal elements.The vocal style on the album is not far from the vocal style on the last couple of albums by 3 Inches of Blood. One snarling vocal type, one Rob Halford ( Judas Priest) high pitched vocal type and some melodic clean singing ( well the latter can´t really be compared to 3 Inches of Blood). The clean sung vocal lines are really melodic, but like on all earlier releases by Into Eternity, the vocal lines are not very memorable and after a couple of songs it all kinda sounds the same to me. It´s the same with the music. It´s very melodic and quite powerful most of the time, but after a couple of tracks the songs become forgettable and sounds too much the same. This music seriously lack hooks. While the music is very well executed, the production is top notch and the music as such is pretty well written to, I just can´t get excited about The Scattering of Ashes. And while I probably should give the album 3 stars because of the above mentioned qualities I can´t give something like this more than a 2.5 star rating. Fans of melodic death metal with progressive sensibilities might enjoy this more than I do.
Review by birdwithteeth11
Well, as the saying goes, you have to start somewhere. And while Between the Buried and Me are one
of the leaders in this day and age in progressive metal, this album is not a good showcasing of
that. It does however have its moments from time to time.There are two things I must point out about Between the Buried and Me. As much as I enjoy them, they are not a band for everyone. They are relentlessly brutal most of the time, the music is ridiculously heavy during these moments, and they drew much of their early influence from metalcore (they still do, but it isn't as apparent in their music anymore) which is quite apparent on this release. The second is that they are a band who I honestly don't think can truly disappoint me with whatever kind of music they decide to make. And while their self-titled debut is my least favorite effort by the band so far, I've heard much worse than this. This album is quite good for the right mood, which is a mood where I just want to hardcore dance and/or break stuff by jumping around and running into it. This album for the most part either takes lots of influences from other bands (Pantera is one that comes to mind) or is relentlessly heavy. While BtBaM would later learn to add variation through more clean parts as well as mixing around the heaviness in different ways, this is for the most part fairly technical metalcore with a few progressive tendencies here and there. The best example of this is of course in the final 9:24 track "Shevanel Cut a Flip". The song is so heavy, but incredibly progressive and much more similar to what Between the Buried and Me would do on The Silent Circus and Alaska, two albums in which they would greatly refine their sound. The ending part does drag on a bit for me, but otherwise it's a very good song. The rest are for the most part slightly above yout average metalcore song.
I could stretch it and say this is a 3.5 star album for me, but the production does suffer a bit here. Like most of the music, it's not bad, but it's nothing to be proud of either. So I can't rate this any higher than 3 stars. Good if you want to check out how far Between the Buried and Me have come in the last decade, but not good for much else.
Review by Priamus
Opeth's most outstanding albumI'm sitting in my room, a whisky glas by my side and outside there you can see the colourful leafes of the autumn. And the most important thing, I'm listening to this monolith of modern music.
Still Life might be the album you are looking for an evening like this. It transports the feelings of the autumn like melancholy, depression, hate and satisfaction.
According to the artwork it shows a sad woman, standing in front of a cross and a quite bleak countryside. It is painted in red colours and it fits totally in the whole context. But an artwort can be as good as anything, if the music is bad. I can advise to you that the music is stunning and overwhelming. The album starts with "The Moor", a typical song of Opeth. We have the parts in which Mikael Akerfeld growls like a beast and the parts, which are the most beautiful acoustic experiences I have ever made. By the way, "The Moor" ist the best song by Opeth for me because Opeth perfected their style here. Godhead's Lament is a similar song but not as good as The Moor. The next song is another highlight. "Benighted" is an acoustic ballad, which Opeth quite often does, but it was never so good again. The riffs are stunning, especial the Intro-Riff. Face of Melinda is a similar song but it gets heavy after a few minutes. Not so heavy with growls like the long songs but it has a few heavy distortioned riffs. The last two songs are again some really great songs, which come almost close to "The Moor"
The album ends, my whisky glas is empty, my soul is satisfied with great music. If you are a bit open minded towards Death Metal, you definately should check this album out and make the same experience like me.
Review by Diego I
The frenchs Pablo, Armand, Mathieu and Ben is the 1980 band, who decided to baptize his rod
(product 2007) likewise, Math Rock, Post Rock, Extreme Metal, Jazz Metal, Avantgarde and
many more qualifiers to this album you can give ... what matters ultimately is the music and
what her project ... Purely instrumental moments this project advocates for radical sound of
Buckethead, Russian Circles and Meshugahh, dramatic tunes with heavy sounds ... achieved
a very good mix of sounds and melodies, elements of metal, jazz, funk, etc.., merge to give life
to a furious and energetic album, at times quiet and moving, a perfect blend of madness and
passion.
Review by floydispink
Ghost Reveries was my first Opeth album, and I really can't imagine a better way to get into the music of Opeth. This album is much
more melodic than the previous releases of Opeth. Many melodic passages can be heard throughout the album. Also, Ghost
Reveries combines the heavy growls and death metal riffs with softer music, which clearly is influenced by the 70's prog bands. This
album might as well be Opeth's most progressive up to date. The album starts out with the heavy growls of "Ghost Of Perdition", a very diverse and progressive song. The sng takes us through many changes and passages, and really is a brilliant piece of music. The second song on the album, "The Baying Of The Hounds" starts out, just like the opener, very loud. Heavy growls and distorted riffs make this song one of the most striking songs I know. The song has a softer middle section though, but after about six minutes becomes just as powerful as the way it starts. "The Grand Conjuration" is another heavy song, though it is much less good than the previous two. It still is very enjoyable though.
The album has several softer songs, like Hours Of Wealth and Isolation years. The songs give the album some nice atmosphere, and make the album a very diverse thing. Another soft, atmospheric song is Atonement, of which the final minute is called "Reverie". Though the final minute is included in track 4, your CD player will tell you it's track 5 already. "Harlequin Forest" is probably my favorite Opeth track ever. The song starts out hauntingly powerful, though nowhere as loud as "Ghost Of Perdition". The second half is much more melodic though, and really is brilliant. Another great song is "Beneath The Mire". It opens with an eastern riff, but soon turns into a heavy masterpiece in the vein of "Baying Of The Hounds".
Ghost Reveries is a brilliant album, but I don't think it really is a masterpiece. The album definitely is worth four stars, but it just comes a very slight bit short to get five stars. Songs like "Baying Of The Hounds" and "Reverie/Harlequin Forest" are among the very best of Opeth though.
Review by
b_olariu
Prog Reviewer
Atrox is an tech/extreme progressive band from Norway releasing 5 albums 'till present. This
is their second one from 2000 named Contentum. This norwegian band gathered around the
impressive female vocalist Monika Edvardsen is full of talent and full of unexpected great
ideas. No wonder, because the often comapration between them and The 3rd And The Mortal
are fond, because Monika is the sister of Ann Mari the femal vocalist of the lastest. Musicaly
speaking Atrox can carry you in a great atmospheric and hypnotic journey, all album is full of
great and inventiv passages. Toying with avand garde in places Atrox really knew how to make
a solid album with brilliant passages and absolutly amazing vocal arrangements. This album
is the one you love it or hate it, no middle way, for sure. Contentum is an album where nothing
seems planned yet in some magical way it all seems to flow with intensity, and the listner is
very pleased in the end, like I am. About the instrumental passages are very carefull done, with
a lot of atmospheric keyboards made by Monika, very well interlude with the rest of the
instruments, the guitar is heavy in places sounds very doomy, as I like to hear on this kind of
music, the drums are aswell very doom in places, only very rare they speed up, but the result
is awesome. Now about the hypnotic and haunting voice of Monika and in same time
emotional tone, who is one of the best I ever heared on this kind of music, very talented girl,
with an impressive range, from falsetto moments,, theatrical up and downs and above all
some jaw dropping high pitched vocals, sometimes she remind me in places of her sister
from The 3rd And The Mortal and even of Diamanda Galas, but not a copy of both for sure.I tell you, you won't listen
every day such complex voice and such powerfull combinations of operatic and chaotic
vocals. All pieces are excellent, specially the second track Unsummoned, this is the perfect
example how must sound this genre in this decade, excellent pieces with atmospheric
keyboards and doomy guitars, Letters To Earth and Gather in Me no More, the rest are also
brilliant. I will give 4 stars, one of the best albums in this subgenre and one of the best from
Scandinavia and Europe aswell, recommended for sure. Imagine that you combine the progressive elements of Dream Theater for ex with the doomy atmosphere of My Dying Bride and you got Atrox.
Copyright © Prog Archives, All rights reserved. | Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Advertise
| GeoIP Services by MaxMind