LIVE AT HIGH VOLTAGE FESTIVAL

This 2011 live set is more of a merch item than a major release (in fact it was originally advertised as "ready to pick up IMMEDIATELY after the concert and the moshing have finished." Do people really mosh at a Spock's Beard concert?). It offers five songs covering around 15 years of the band's catalogue and showcases some lineup changes.

While this is for the most part a good selection of strong Beard songs, there's little that is particularly revelatory and the performances are not the best available, so it does have an air of 'for completists.' Yet I find it an interesting listen because of the multiple intersection of phases that it represents. Three songs are from Spock's Beard/Morse Era, two are from Post-Morse/Pre-Leonard albums. Jimmy Keegan (here the tour drummer) and Ted Leonard (here guesting on vocals in D'Virgilio's absence) were soon to join the band formally, and Neal Morse returns here to join in for two tracks on vocals. The album therefore offers a concise aural venue for musing about the different versions of the band.

My own sense of the songs is that while A Perfect Day (from Spock's Beard, 2006) is an enjoyable enough song, The Emperor's Clothes (from X, 2010) does not quite hold up against the older material, and the attempts at Gentle Giant vocal moments in the latter song don't quite land in this version. The older songs seem richer, though one must grant that they are cherry-picked highlights (and allow for my general preference for and more time invested in older Beard).

As for the vocals, Leonard and Morse have very different voices, and personal taste weighs heavily. I enjoy Morse's vocal style and tone significantly more than Leonard's (not his fault). Thinking about why that might be as I listen here to Leonard doing covers of Morse, I am struck by how much Neal Morse typically inhabits songs, creating a strong sense of confessional presence and of direct address to the listener. He does more with his voice, and he was often a preacher while singing well before he more literally started preaching in some of his later material; the discontinuity between pre-Christian and Christian Morse is not complete. Leonard (particularly here) can sometimes sound more distant and diffident to me, as if he's performing the tune more than living the song, and his tighter, higher tone feels a less intimate part of the whole to my ears, though it works well enough for the opener and for passages that need some soaring. Of course, Leonard is here stepping into another band's material and can be forgiven for not quite being inside it; there are moments that sound hesitant.

The recording quality is quite acceptable (better than, say, Don't Try This at Home), but with some noticeable issues here and there. As another reviewer notes, A Perfect Day sounds a little muddy, but not massively so. The intro to The Doorway doesn't go well. Most obtrusively, an important keyboard section drops out almost completely (and sounds off key) at the start of The Light, significantly marring the opening passage. The harmonies on June sound a little warbly - there are several better versions. But it's a live show, an instant merch item with no overdubs, and I suspect not recorded on a big budget - I find the sound quite listenable in that context.

I enjoy the way this set invites comparison of the different songs and eras. It's an entertaining enough hour, but not one that I will prioritize over a slew of other Spock's Beard recordings, and no song stands out as having its finest moment here. It's enjoyable, but seems to belong in the "for fans" category, though for fans it's worth the listen.

Social review comments

Review related links

• Send comments to Proggle
• Report this review (#3201969)
• Buy SPOCK'S BEARD music online with PA partners
• Show all SPOCK'S BEARD MP3/Stream
• Go to SPOCK'S BEARD page for videos, full discography with ratings, reviews and much more
• Go to Live at High Voltage Festival page for more details, where to buy and ratings/reviews
• Search the Forum for SPOCK'S BEARD related discussions